Trinity Industries, Inc. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 20, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Industrials Machinery earnings 60 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jessica Greiner

executive
#1

Thanks, Caroline, and hello everybody. I appreciate your participation on Trinity Industries' call about our 2019 fourth-quarter financial results. My name is Jessica Greiner, and I serve as Vice President of Investor Relations and Communications. It's my privilege to introduce Trinity's incoming Chief Executive Officer and President, Jean Savage, who is going to give us a few opening comments on today's call. Eric Marchetto, Senior Vice President and Group President of TrinityRail, will talk about Trinity's operations and share his perspective on the outlook for our markets. Melendy Lovett, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, will walk us through the financial highlights and the 2020 guidance. Once the prepared remarks are finished, we'll move into a Q&A session. Trinity announced strong fourth quarter and full year results for 2019 yesterday, after the market closed. In that press release, we also gave our initial guidance and outlook covering the full year 2020. On this call, we'll be talking about certain non-GAAP measures. You can find definitions and reconciliations for those measures in the tables of the earnings press release, which is posted in the investor relation section of our website, at www.trin.net. At this point, it's my pleasure to hand the call over to Jean.

Jean Savage

executive
#2

Jessica, thanks, and good morning to all of you. It's a real pleasure to be at Trinity, and I'm glad to have this chance to speak with you today. Shortly, Eric and Melendy will walk through how Trinity performed in the fourth quarter and across 2019. Since I've only held my new position for 3 days, I've tried to identify what matters most to you that I can speak to right now; so I intend to cover 3 topics. Who am I? Why do I feel such enthusiasm about being at Trinity? And broadly speaking, what do I intend to do with this company? I bring experience as a transformational executive, having worked across a number of industrial businesses, among them 12 years in rail. Over the course of my career, I've helped transform those businesses so they delivered substantial value, whether a shift was required because of fundamental market shifts or the business cycle, whether a business required better operating structure, or whether change was needed to expand a business through technology and innovative products. I hold a firm belief in listening to customers, employees and all stakeholders, so I can build understanding and knowledge of whatever business I'm stepping into. After that, I combine what I've learned with the information and figures gathered, so I can pinpoint the openings for choices that matter strategically. You'll see too that I have a strong commitment to allocating capital with discipline, and to preparing for the ways that allocation could change across different stages of the business cycle. During my time at Progress Rail Services, I developed deep expertise in rail, which involved building up relationships with customers. Over at Progress Rail, the scope of what we did was broad — leasing rail cars, fixing them through a network of shops, running big modification programs, remanufacturing components, operating wheel shops, building new locomotives, and handling locomotive repairs. Then, during my last several years with Caterpillar, I led the effort to reshape the Surface Mining and Technology business. By applying technology and innovation, we changed the way customers put the equipment we make to use, which had a beneficial impact on how the business ran. That background — and the experience of turning around a variety of businesses — is what led me to Trinity, where I now take on the role of President and CEO. For me, this is the right job at the right point in my career. I'm really looking forward to guiding Trinity into an exciting new chapter. Rail has always been a passion of mine, and in my view, Trinity stands out as the finest platform in that space. People recognize Trinity for building railcars of the highest quality, offering the widest array of services, and holding the strongest strategic ties with its customers. With so much changing across the rail car supply chain, we have a real chance to accelerate Trinity's standing as a leader in the railcar market by delivering creative products and services, which will shift Trinity toward a business model built on higher quality and recurring relationships. I'd add that we see a genuine chance to sharpen our approach and make the organization, its costs, and its capital structure more efficient, so that Trinity's financial results can improve faster. During 2019, Trinity's management achieved quite a lot when it came to raising ROE, bringing down Trinity's cost of capital, simplifying how the organization is set up, cutting expenses, and balancing the capital allocation framework. Even so, both management and the Board expect more when it comes to pushing the platform's performance to higher levels. The Board and the management team stand completely united and determined to make Trinity's integrated collection of businesses as effective as possible, so that the long-term value-creation potential this platform makes possible can be realized. It is still too soon to offer detailed plans or set out a strategic roadmap for the company, but I can describe where I plan to direct my attention. First, I'm eager to establish a strategic framework for the company, complete with specific key performance indicators that we'll share with investors, so our progress can be tracked and measured. Once our plans take clearer shape and particular initiatives have been pinpointed, we'll pass those along to you. What I expect is that at first, our strategy is going to zero in on squeezing more out of how we run the business and how our finances are set up. Like we've mentioned previously, we did some restructuring work toward the end of last year, and beginning in 2020, that's going to keep delivering between $8 million and $10 million in better operating costs. My belief is there's more room to capture here, and Melendy is going to walk through what we're initially expecting when she gives the guidance commentary. On the balance sheet side, we've also been clear about what we're aiming for: we intend to bring leverage into the lease fleet so that Trinity's cost of capital goes down. Trinity's offerings have met with strong demand in the debt markets, and we will definitely keep tapping that market to reduce our cost of capital. A significant amount of capital can be freed up, which leads me to my final point of focus. As I said earlier, I believe strongly in disciplined capital allocation, and that covers deploying capital for growth as well as returning capital to shareholders. We'll build a framework that lets Trinity deploy capital appropriately and consistently, depending on where we sit in the cycle. The Board and management hold the view that the synergies created by Trinity's platform generate strong, predictable cash flows. This allows us to make significant investments in high-return growth opportunities while also giving back a lot of capital to shareholders. What really fuels long-term value creation, more than anything, is Trinity's platform's capacity to generate cash flow. We do think our stock is trading at a meaningful discount to the intrinsic value of our asset, making it an appealing investment opportunity. As part of our goal to optimize the balance sheet, we plan to keep buying back shares. Trinity has built its reputation on delivering premier performance. We owe premier performance to every one of our stakeholders, both inside and outside the company. In my view, this company is prepared and well placed to undertake the necessary adjustments that will lead to better results, and to raise and speed up Trinity's standing as a top-tier supplier of railcar goods and services across North America. The employees of Trinity demonstrate dedication to excellence, a focus centered on customers, and a proven history of execution along with the delivery of high-quality products and services. What I bring is my background along with a feeling of urgency, paired with deliberate and firm action. It will be a pleasure to collaborate with the Trinity team in order to improve our financial results and create value for shareholders, and to devote time to getting acquainted with and listening to you, our investors. At this point I'll hand things over to Eric.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#3

Thanks, Jean, and good morning to all of you. In our first year as a company focused on rail, TrinityRail turned in strong results. We spent 2019 in transition, starting to optimize our rail platform even as we faced outside pressures and shifting market conditions. Our focus across the organization was on running the business for quality rather than quantity, and on taking out costs from our platform, both structural and cyclical. Our owned and managed lease fleet expanded roughly 6.5% compared with a year earlier, reaching 125,000 railcars, with returns that compare favorably to our ROE target. Utilization stayed high, and we closed the year at 96%, with average lease rates higher, and the organization shipped roughly 22,000 railcars at a 9.6% margin. Throughout all of this, I take real satisfaction in the fact that we honored what we promised our customers. In yesterday's press release, we gave segment-level detail on our financial results for the fourth quarter and for the whole of 2019. What I want to do today is highlight a few of the strategic moves we finished or began during the year, moves that drove our results and that we believe will serve as a foundation for our financial performance going forward. It was a highly productive year for our rail products organization. We proceeded with sizable investments in our manufacturing footprint so we could deliver the market state-of-the-art railcar coating capabilities along with additional maintenance shop capacity. These investments will help bring Trinity's manufacturing capacity in line with customer demand and reduce maintenance costs for Trinity's lease fleet, while also expanding our maintenance services business for important industrial customers. We also completed the integration of our trucking and logistics business out of Trinity's diversified industrial business model and into the rail products business, along with other facility maintenance and engineering support functions. I'm pleased with the way these teams collaborated to streamline and strengthen our supply chain operation. On top of that, our product development team kept working to provide differentiated offerings, launching four new product designs and enhancements that serve a range of markets. Our Railcar Leasing business put significant money into technology and systems, launching our TrinityRail customer digital channel, which gives customers access to key information and services anytime, from anywhere, that they need in order to optimize how their railcars are used. This tool lets customers cut down on the friction that comes with managing railcars, while delivering substantial productivity gains to our organization. Beyond that, the money we've put into data and analytics capabilities over the past few years has had a meaningful effect on our commercial strategies. As we look toward 2020, we continue to align our organization to achieve better operational and financial results across the entire railcar market cycle. That said, industry fundamentals will act as a difficult headwind for overall results this year; during 2019, trade disputes and a slowing North American industrial economy weighed negatively on rail traffic volumes, and as a result, demand for railcars fell. That drop in demand produced a growing fleet of underutilized railcar equipment and fewer new railcar orders. We expect some time will pass before recent trade agreements show up in rail traffic volumes. Still, we hold out hope that the latest movement toward settling trade disagreements will bring greater clarity and certainty to the marketplace. Before new orders pick up speed, better railcar loadings must first work through the railcars already in the fleet. Even so, when you look at the global picture, North America's economy remains a comparatively bright spot. Projections for GDP point to moderate expansion, and consumers continue to show strength. For industrial shippers, moving goods by rail is the most cost-effective form of land-based transport. We take some encouragement from the recent message coming out of certain class 1 railroads, which are stressing growth rather than operating ratios. Although PSR programs appear to have boosted train speeds and dwell times at individual railroads, what really matters for the rail supply chain's performance is how fluidly the whole network runs. Over a longer horizon, we see PSR programs as a vital initial move toward better service for industrial shippers. Regaining modal share in North American freight required exactly that. Central to our customer experience strategy is getting the ownership and use of railcar equipment optimized. In light of where demand stands today and what we expect near term, we are adjusting our production capacity to the right size and picking the business we take on with great care. During the fourth quarter, the rail products team delivered a very demanding production schedule for our customers even as it shifted toward reduced output for 2020. Deliveries in our first quarter will fall by about half relative to fourth quarter delivery volumes, and that figure carries costs tied to roughly 20% headcount reductions plus lost efficiencies. Financially, this resizing will act as a substantial drag on how we perform in the first quarter. Even so, taking this step was required to set the right capacity level for our 2020 delivery outlook. Our full-year outlook builds in a reasonably steady production pace, with about 60% of our production schedule already committed in the backlog. Roughly 17% of our lease portfolio comes up for renewal during 2020. Today's market rates sit about 9% under the rates on leases that are expiring, which suggests a 1% to 2% revenue headwind for the leasing segment. We expect new railcars added to the lease fleet to counter that revenue headwind. Our platform keeps proving it can steer successfully through difficult market conditions. Trinity's platform was designed to produce superior results across the railcar cycle; our business model encourages direct engagement with the customer, delivers solutions that optimize lifecycle ownership and use of railcar equipment, and gives our customers one source for everything they need in railcar equipment and services. During 2019, we made excellent strides in strengthening our financial performance. Through 2020, we will keep optimizing our platform so that our financial results reflect the strong commercial and strategic synergies of the business. Our aim is to stand as the premier provider of railcar products and services. At Trinity, the team is hard at work reshaping how we're organized — cutting our total expenses, sharpening attention on serving customers, and chasing new ideas so TrinityRails keeps its standing as the leader in this market. It's a pleasure that Jean has joined us as the new CEO, and I'm confident her impact will be tremendous when it comes to upgrading how we run operations, unlock value, and produce stronger results. At this point I'll hand things to Melendy for a look at our financial results and outlook.

Melendy Lovett

executive
#4

Thanks, Eric. Good morning, everyone. Yesterday, we reported strong gains for our 2019 fourth quarter and full year results. We saw double-digit increases in revenues, adjusted operating profit, and adjusted earnings per share. These were driven by growing our fleet at attractive prices and by more railcar deliveries with a favorable product mix. Our team did more than deliver solid operational results in a challenging market — Trinity's leaders also made substantial progress on strategic and financial objectives in our first full year as a rail-focused company. In 2019, our priorities included optimizing cost and capital structure, investing in value-creating growth, and returning capital to shareholders. In addition, we committed to improving our financial filings and presentation so the value of the lease fleet within the rail platform would be clearer. As Eric mentioned, leadership has focused on simplifying our operations, moving away from Trinity's former multi-business holding company model toward a rail-centric one. Together, those efforts reduced SE&A by more than $30 million for the year. More work lies ahead before our business platform meets the standard we expect, and we are evaluating both cyclical and structural expenses to improve our performance. Another 2019 focus was optimizing our balance sheets. For Trinity's wholly-owned lease fleet, the loan to value ratio increased from 46.6% to 55.1% by the end of 2019, including debt funding from our corporate revolver; that represented meaningful progress toward our goal of reaching a 60% to 65% LTV ratio soon. We expect to hit that LTV target within the next 12 to 18 months. The debt funding we obtained in 2019 came with very attractive interest rates. Thanks to optimization work since the spin off, Trinity has lowered our weighted average cost of capital by about 150 basis points. Stronger balance sheet positioning, along with improved profitability from solid execution and lower costs, meant Trinity's year-over-year pre-tax return on equity increased from 6.3% to 9% in 2019. Early in 2019, Trinity set a three year average pre-tax ROE target of 11% to 13%, in line with our long-term pre-tax ROE objective of mid-teens through the cycle. We are pleased with the strong progress in year one. Weaker railcar demand will create a difficult headwind for 2020 ROE growth, but we are focused on the levers we can control. Under our current guidance, pre-tax ROE would be around 10% to 10.5% for 2020. Trinity also made significant progress in demonstrating how much cash our rail platform can generate. Free cash flow before lease fleet investment reached $423 million for the year, surpassing our 2019 forecast, driven by major improvements in working capital management and railcar deliveries finishing at the high end of our latest guidance. That figure included $50 million of profit from sales of leased railcars from our portfolio. As Jean mentioned earlier, Trinity's rail platform generates cash flow that plays a key role in building long-term value. Management and the Board alike believe this platform can generate strong, dependable cash flows. That gives us room to invest meaningfully in high-return growth opportunities and still return a great deal of capital to shareholders. As an example, during 2019 we invested in expanding our portfolio, adding about $875 million of net lease fleet on a cash basis. That growth was funded with cash on hand plus prudent borrowing. We also directed nearly $100 million toward manufacturing CapEx to grow our railcar maintenance business and paint and lining capacity, which Eric mentioned. Shareholder returns in 2019 totaled $377 million through buybacks and dividends, about 14% of our market cap. We hold roughly $1 billion of liquidity and have ample room to continue adding leverage to the balance sheet; moving on to guidance. Our 2020 capital allocation plan follows a similar framework and shows how our businesses generate value. For 2020, CapEx guidance splits into two components: non-leasing CapEx of about $90 million to $100 million, and net lease fleet investment of approximately $435 million. At 70% loan-to-value, that calls for equity capital below $100 million. Before any lease fleet investment, we expect free cash flow of roughly $600 million to $650 million. That leaves us with ample capacity to return significant capital to shareholders after making the growth investments the business requires. Here is our 2020 financial performance guidance: total revenues, after elimination, of about $2.5 billion to $2.7 billion, and diluted earnings per common share between $1.15 and $1.35. Our guidance for the year incorporates several key financial expectations. We project production of 16,000 railcars, with about 40% of that volume going into the lease fleet. For the rail product segment, we expect a margin near 7%. On leasing, revenue should come in close to $800 million, with a 46% operating margin, plus roughly $15 million of profit from selling lease railcars out of our portfolio. We've also included meaningful cost-saving opportunities for 2020, spanning SE&A and administrative cost of sales, where we target a reduction of about $25 million to $30 million versus 2019. Interest expense should be around $225 million, and we assume a 27% tax rate. As Jean mentioned, we'll actively repurchase shares through the year as we continue optimizing our balance sheet. Our EPS guidance range reflects substantial share repurchases, subject to Board authorization. Items outside normal course of cooperation, such as restructuring activities or pension plan termination charges, are excluded from the 2020 guidance, and we'll report their impact if and when they occur. On EPS cadence, our full year EPS range compares favorably with 2019 fiscal results. That said, our first quarter financial results will face considerable headwinds before recovering over the course of the year. Expanding on Eric's remarks, delivery volumes in the rail products group are set to drop considerably, and during Q1 of '20 the business is absorbing the impact of efficiency losses as well as cost rightsizing. Lease railcar sales and SE&A cost savings rank among the additional items influencing the cadence of our earnings. As things stand, we expect lease railcar sales to fall largely in the latter six months of the year, and those sales include $50 million of profit from offloading leased railcars from our portfolio. SE&A savings will build progressively over the course of the year as we roll out initiatives designed to lower those expenses. You may have seen in yesterday's press release that we are changing the estimated depreciable lives of our railcar lease fleet; versus the previous year, we anticipate this will lift our financial performance by about $27 million to $33 million, or $0.14 to $0.18 in EPS, and that amount is reflected in our guidance. As part of our review, we measured our depreciation policy against extensive company and industry data and analytics. Our findings support lengthening the estimated depreciable lives, in light of how the railcars in our lease fleet have been maintained and have performed, and it moves Trinity nearer to the practices and results of industry peers, even though we stay at the low end of public comps; we further believe the new estimated depreciable lives align our accounting policies more closely with the economics of our leasing operation. Once today's conference call concludes, we will file our Form 10-K for 2019, which features improved disclosures regarding the economics of our business, including a selected consolidated balance sheet for the leasing company. At yearend, total equity for the leasing company came to $2.3 billion. That figure reflects equity as though we operated as a standalone leasing business. Taken altogether, adjusted equity for the leasing group comes to $1.5 billion. The explanation is that we realize a cost benefit by sourcing equipment from our own manufacturing division. That's a genuine, tangible edge derived from our platforms. We've released these disclosures, together with other numbers provided throughout the year — such as the pre-tax ROE target and free cash flow before leasing CapEx — and the aim is to demonstrate how management assesses our company's worth and to spotlight the opportunities Trinity has to generate meaningful shareholder value. Through 2019, we achieved solid progress, showing what our platform can produce, lifting return on equity, lowering the expense associated with our capital, streamlining the organization, cutting costs, and taking a disciplined approach to capital deployment — financing growth while simultaneously returning money to shareholders. Even so, we recognize that more work remains ahead of us. As Jean said, both leadership and the Board anticipate more from us as we push the company's results higher. We get it — during 2020, the job we have is to remake Trinity even as market conditions stay tough. The culture at this company, along with the commitment to performing work the right way, continues to be an enormous strength and belongs to what this organization has inherited. Having Jean come aboard is a prospect that genuinely excites us. For a long time, she has regarded Trinity with real respect, and she recognizes the elements behind our team's strength and our culture. On top of that, she arrives with a history of guiding companies through significant change. Also worth noting, $50 million in profit came from selling leased railcars out of our portfolio. With that, we would now like to turn things over for questions. Operator, could you please give everyone on the line the instructions?

Justin Long

analyst
#5

Questioner, that's Justin Long: Thank you, and good morning. Also, Jean, congratulations, and I'm looking forward to collaborating with you.

Jean Savage

executive
#6

Thank you, Justin.

Justin Long

analyst
#7

So, to kick things off regarding the 2020 revenue guidance, I'm finding it a bit tough to reconcile the $2.5 billion to $2.7 billion on a consolidated basis with some of the assumptions that have been laid out. Is there anything unusual regarding mix or the size of eliminations, or perhaps the railcar sales, all being units that are younger than one year, that are included in that revenue number? I think it would just be helpful to get a little more color on each of the components, that bridge to that total revenue outlook.

Melendy Lovett

executive
#8

Good morning, Justin, this is Melendy. There's not really anything unusual in the $2.5 billion to $2.7 billion consolidated revenue number. Certainly, if you'd like a follow-up call later today, Jessica and I'd be happy to go into the details and help you with anything we can.

Justin Long

analyst
#9

All right. Regarding the number of shares you brought up, you're factoring in a sizable level of repurchases. Could you tell us the figure you're applying for the share count in 2020?

Melendy Lovett

executive
#10

Ever since the spin off, we've said on a steady basis that our intention is to give back capital to shareholders in a meaningful and consistent way. You've watched us carry that out during 2019 via repurchasing shares as well as raising our dividends. We do expect that the cash flow our platform generates will let us keep doing this. The guidance range for 2020 we've provided includes possible share purchases approximately matching those from 2019; and naturally, that depends on Board approval.

Justin Long

analyst
#11

All right, that helps. And last, this might be one for Eric — regarding what's driving demand for railcars, we're nearly 2 months into the year. What are you seeing on the order and inquiry side so far this year, and any initial thoughts on how first quarter orders might shape up versus the fourth quarter?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#12

Sure, Justin, Eric here. As we entered 2020, railcar loadings at the topline remain under pressure; unfavorable year-over-year trends are still showing up. That said, we're seeing recent gains in a number of areas. Certain parts of chemicals are getting better, refined products too. In some farm products and autos, there's improvement as well. If you look at our guidance of 16,000 railcars delivered each year, roughly 60% of those sit in our backlog. That means we still need railcar order activity to come in over the next couple of quarters to hit that 16,000. What we've observed thus far this year, and what we'd anticipate, is a pace similar to what we saw in '20, and for the second half of 2020 <<inaudible>> sic 2019 to carry on through this year, or through the first couple of quarters into this year.

Jean Savage

executive
#13

I think you mean the second-half of 2019.

Melendy Lovett

executive
#14

Nineteen.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#15

Yes, the latter half of 2019, and that carries over into the early portion of 2020; that is essentially what is built into our — what our guidance implies.

Justin Long

analyst
#16

All right, that helps a lot. I won't push further on that. Thanks for your time.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#17

Morning, and thank you. Jean, congratulations — I'm looking forward to collaborating with you. Here's what I want to ask: it seems you're forecasting 5% or 6% growth in leasing revenue for 2020, yet your guidance for railcars built for the lease fleet sits below last year's figure. And with your guidance for sale of railcars, it appears the lease fleet may expand at a rate that trails the revenue growth rate by at least a couple of percentage points. On top of that, renewals will act as a headwind this year. So if all that holds, are you factoring in secondary market purchases that would let you reach that $800 million revenue growth target?

Melendy Lovett

executive
#18

Morning, Matt — this is Melendy. Let me begin addressing what you asked. Our assumption regarding the share of railcars heading into the lease fleet is about the same as in 2019. Keep in mind that eliminations now cover modifications and betterments, in addition to the additions to the lease fleet. So the decline in our deliveries from 2019 is the main factor behind the reduced count of railcars being added to the fleet. As for your question about secondary market sales, we do have a modest level of secondary market sales built into the net lease fleet investment guidance I provided. You're correct that our present forecast for sales of lease railcars, along with the operating profit that comes from it, is below our 2019 results. Part of why that's the case — and this is a reminder — is that we had sales type leases appearing in our car sales numbers for 2019, and that amounted to $160 million. That's the main reason 2019 car sales landed at a higher level than 2020.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#19

All right. However, within the guidance, you aren't doing any kind of secondary market acquisitions for your lease fleet.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#20

Correct. When you look at leasing revenue, the primary factors behind it, like I said during my remarks, include a renewal headwind, which you pointed out, and beyond that there will be fleet expansion — those figures Melendy referenced — regarding additions made to the fleet. The reason you see gaps when it comes to how much fleet growth we anticipate versus the revenue figure: that mostly comes down to when the renewal headwind hits and when deliveries reach the fleet. No significant secondary market purchases are included in that guidance.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#21

So does that mean, Eric, that the new railcars going into the lease fleet are going to show up before most of the renewal pressure hits?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#22

That's what it would suggest, and keep in mind too that the railcars we're putting into the fleet will cost more and carry higher lease rates than the ones already there; so you also get some mix shift in terms of what that revenue looks like.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#23

Understood. And Eric, I have one final item. The previous occasion when you achieved 7%, if I recall correctly, the manufacturing margin stood at 7.4% back in 2018, and I believe deliveries totaled roughly 20,000 cars. At present, you're steering toward 7% with 16,000 cars. Could you explain how, even though a negative mix shift might occur in 2020, you can still reach the identical margin seen in 2018 while delivering fewer vehicles?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#24

The most evident factor is stronger execution, though on top of that, a mix certainly exists. The shift in mix will definitely account for a substantial portion. We regard it as a headwind, with an approximate 30% step down affecting both deliveries across the industry and our production footprint; therefore, I don't truly view it as superior performance in 2016; our aim is to enhance results this year beyond what we've stated, and we'll keep removing costs from our platform while refining our operations.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#25

When you review the prior five or six years, margins, as I recall, reached roughly 21% at the peak of the crude by rail boom, while the trough stood at 27%, close to what you project for 2020. Looking ahead to a normalized mid-cycle margin, considering all the rightsizing and cost reduction underway in the manufacturing segment, how would that shape up?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#26

You genuinely need to strip out some of the elevated margins from the crude cycle, simply because, with the demand elasticity we saw during that period, railcar delivery was never as potent as it was then. And with our guidance, we don't foresee that happening in the near-term. So, when you examine it — if you remove that, our mid-cycle margins will land in the range we're discussing for this year, followed by a high single digits margin percentage, which is our expectation.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#27

Understood. Thanks a lot.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#28

Somewhere between the middle and the upper end, that's probably the correct calculation.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#29

Alright. Thanks, guys.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#30

Thank you.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#31

Hi guys. Good morning.

Melendy Lovett

executive
#32

Good morning.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#33

I'd like to return to, I suppose, those newly manufactured cars you're adding into the lease fleet. Could you provide a bit of color regarding — clearly, utilization sits at 96%, you had certain cars sitting idle, and you definitely have some renewals approaching. Is there a particular end market fueling some of that fresh interest, or that growth compared with what's currently out there in your portfolio? Any insight you can offer on that?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#34

Certainly. Allison, it's Eric here. Of course. If you take a step back and examine demand for new railcars, replacement demand remains the biggest single factor behind new railcar builds. And although we have, as you pointed out, idle at 96% utilization, that suggests railcars are available. Then, looking at the industry fleet, with some underemployed and unemployed railcars in the market, pockets of strength still exist, I think, as I mentioned earlier; we're observing demand within the chemical space, particularly plastics, refined fuels, which would involve considerable tank car demand, plus some of the farm products and autos. So the market is fairly efficient, though not perfectly efficient. We're seeing demand for certain of those markets that have pockets of growth, whether that growth comes in terms of railcar loadings or replacement demand. And replacement demand is going to be mainly around the boxcar fleet.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#35

Understood. Then I'd like to hear your perspective on storage. With all the interest in newer and more efficient vehicles, what do you think the actual storage figure is? How should it appear across a cycle? Clearly, it's high right now because of traffic, but I'd guess a portion of that capacity definitely won't return.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#36

Allison, Eric here. A great deal does get discussed regarding railcars and storage that the AAR publishes. When we examine it, we tend to split it into two groups, as I said before; we have unemployed railcars, which would literally be railcars in storage. After that, there are underemployed railcars, and that AR metric considers railcars that haven't had a revenue movement within 60 days. A sizable share of the fleet doesn't have a revenue movement within 60 days yet remains leased and an active component of the lease fleet. A few instances of that are plastics cars, seasonal fleets, grain cars, fertilizer railcars, pressure tank cars for LPG that carry a seasonal element. Then there are buffer fleets, where shippers keep additional cars to offset some of the volatility in railcar service. So it might not haul a load within 60 days, but it's still an active piece of their fleet. So when you consider it, I believe the more significant figure is the shift that has occurred. If you look across the past year, that figure the AAR publishes has grown by roughly 100,000 railcars. The largest factor was small cube covered hoppers, which we believe have risen by around 30,000 railcars since this time last year within that figure, so that's a major factor; then a few of the other outcomes stem from traffic trends, with pure coal moves having a significant effect. I don't perceive as much of an effect from PSR. I'd say the effect from PSR is likely under a quarter of that growth in the figure that the railing publishes. Is that useful?

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#37

Yes. No, that helps a lot. Thank you. And then just one final thing from me. Regarding the SE&A cost savings you're expecting to achieve this year. Can we think about that as structural versus cyclical, or is it too muddy right now?

Melendy Lovett

executive
#38

As we mentioned, Allison, we're evaluating. We're looking at both the structural and the cyclical sides of our business so that we can get those savings. And I'm not really ready to break out that level of detail at this moment, but what I can tell you when it comes to modeling is, we expect most of those savings to come out of that total SE&A figure that's around $263 million for 2019. Not all of the cost reductions will be SE&A, but we expect most to be.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#39

Great. Thank you.

Melendy Lovett

executive
#40

Thank you.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#41

Yes. Melendy, I think I caught you saying that your outlook presumes buybacks will be about the same in 2020 as they were in 2019, which would definitely imply the authorization has to be renewed fairly soon, since 2.6 million shares are left under it. But I believe you've also noted previously that the size of that authorization was set so we wouldn't run into problems with the IRS Private Letter Ruling tied to the spin off. Could you shed some light on where we might be mistaken, and what the repurchase plans are for investors?

Melendy Lovett

executive
#42

Of course, good morning, Bascome. That's right. What I said was that our 2020 guidance range includes possible share repurchases roughly matching what we completed in 2019, pending Board authorization. And of course, Bascome, tax considerations rank among the key factors we weigh in our share repurchase plan. So they will play a part in when we act.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#43

All right, got it. Let's touch on capital allocation once more. You brought up growth CapEx. Within the coming 12, 18, or 24 months, do acquisitions fit into the Trinity strategy? And more specifically, might you move past putting money into railcar assets and actually bring in nearby service lines or rail-related operations, so the portfolio broadens toward the more recurring revenue stream you mentioned during your prepared remarks? Thanks.

Jean Savage

executive
#44

Bascome, it's Jean here. What I'd say is that we constantly seek the proper moment and the proper chance to deploy capital. As we talked about before, we want to ensure we strike a balance between growth and giving returns back to our shareholders. So, we maintain a list, we'll keep watching it, and we'll see whether we locate the right acquisition, at the right moment.

Melendy Lovett

executive
#45

Bascome, one more thing from my side: as we noted in our remarks, our priority in the near term is getting the most out of our portfolio of businesses and truly pushing the improvement in financial performance. So I completely share what Jean said. We keep searching for the proper opportunity at the proper valuation, with our primary emphasis remaining on making the most of the businesses we already have.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#46

All right. That's my final question. Jean, at what point do you expect your strategic planning work will have advanced sufficiently for you to present that plan to investors — could be through an analyst day, or perhaps in another form? Thanks.

Jean Savage

executive
#47

Regarding when, we're continuing to work on it. For me, this is day three — or actually, day four has begun. So if you could allow me a bit more time, I'll deliver it to you. That said, I intend to hold certain calls soon, and then make sure I'm getting out and speaking with those who invest in us. So I'll do a roadshow of some kind, or visits. I hope that's useful. Beyond that, it's all I'm able to share at this point.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#48

Okay, that's fine. Thanks, I appreciate it.

Gordon Johnson

analyst
#49

Hi everyone, I appreciate you answering our questions.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#50

You're welcome.

Gordon Johnson

analyst
#51

Okay. So I suppose, to start, you mentioned that you need to witness a rise in orders to meet the 2020 guidance you've given. Could you provide some idea of what the lead times might be for those orders? And when do you think we'll begin to see them come in, so you can move toward that 2020 guidance?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#52

Absolutely, Gordon, it's Eric here. I'll address that in broad terms. As I stated, our guidance suggests there is unsold capacity within it amounting to 16,000 railcars. So typically, the timing for those orders will need to fall in the first half of this year if we're going to schedule deliveries. Thus, I'd say, broadly, order activity will probably occur in the first or second quarter, so that delivery can happen in 2020.

Gordon Johnson

analyst
#53

All right, that helps. Then could you folks give me some clarity — it looks to me like the way free cash flow is being defined has shifted, specifically you're counting fleet sales in free cash flow, yet the CapEx tied to that fleet does not get counted in free cash flow. Could you help me figure out how to make sense of that definition?

Jessica Greiner

executive
#54

Hello, Gordon, Jessica here. Like Melendy said, we gave free cash flow prior to lease fleet investment, and that came after our previous conference call — it was a fresh metric we put out, and it appeared in an earnings release. That definition is something we've kept in place. And regarding that non-GAAP measure, we're glad to take you through whatever specific questions you might have about it.

Melendy Lovett

executive
#55

Gordon, Melendy here. Let me just say as well that the rationale behind discussing free cash flow prior to our investments in the lease fleet is that we view those lease fleet investments as discretionary, with marketplace demand being what drives them. And one more reminder: the lease fleet investment we're referring to is on a cash basis — that's the entire amount of cash required for growing our lease fleet. However, we're able to lever those additions to the lease fleet at market value rather than at cost. That represents a genuine advantage for the platform. So this is a significant factor behind why we settled on the definition of free cash flow before lease fleet investment.

Gordon Johnson

analyst
#56

All right, that's useful. And then I have just one more. When we consider the orders relative to the RSI figures that get reported, it appears that you folks typically capture somewhere in the range of 30% to 40% of those RSI orders. So when we think about those figures being released for Q1, presumably within the coming two months, is your guidance embedding a meaningful uptick in industry orders? Or would you say that your visibility into your own orders is such that, regardless of whether industry orders come in weak, you remain confident about still reaching your guidance? Thanks.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#57

Thanks, Gordon, it's Eric here. I'll take that one. I believe I said this before, that what our delivery guidance implies is an order level during this year's first half that will align with what the industry saw in 2019's second half. So it takes into account both industry activity and the orders we ourselves secure. I'm feeling positive about the visibility we currently have based on orders already booked, and there's still more work ahead of us if we're going to reach that delivery target for the year.

Gordon Johnson

analyst
#58

Thanks again, guys. Good luck.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#59

Thank you.

Steve Barger

analyst
#60

Hi, good morning.

Melendy Lovett

executive
#61

Good morning.

Steve Barger

analyst
#62

Steve, my apologies if this was covered already, but regarding those first-quarter headwinds you mentioned stemming from the shift to reduced output and the pressure that puts on 1Q — would that push EPS into the single digits? Alternatively, could you share what portion of EPS you anticipate in the first half compared with the second half?

Melendy Lovett

executive
#63

Morning, Steve. Quarterly guidance isn't something we provide. I just want to make clear that lower deliveries, lost efficiencies, and rightsizing costs are all weighing on our first quarter. Broadly speaking, your thinking falls within the range, though once more, we'd rather not have it become quarterly guidance.

Steve Barger

analyst
#64

Got it. And Jean, welcome to the team. I realize your first day was this week, but given your background at Progress and your time serving on the board, you're aware that PSR was a massive subject during 2019. Do you have any perspective on how you look at that regarding where Trinity stands when it comes to the chances or risks it creates?

Jean Savage

executive
#65

Absolutely. My view is that for the sector as a whole, PSR is going to let us boost how efficiently that method of transport operates, and it opens the door to growth down the road; so when you consider sustainability along with the reality that moving freight by rail is four to six times more sustainable than moving it by truck, I believe you'll witness a shift over time as railroads improve their overall ability to deliver the product on schedule and reliably for their customers. So, I suppose that's my take on PSR. In my view, it benefits us and it benefits the railroad.

Steve Barger

analyst
#66

Understood. And when you consider what you went through, which you mentioned in connection with the Surface Mining operation and then once more at Progress — could you share your initial thinking about where chances exist to introduce technology at Trinity, to assist in optimizing the company, perhaps addressing both internal efforts and outside initiatives?

Jean Savage

executive
#67

Certainly. Let me begin with a portion of the effort I undertook involving Surface Mining and Technology; the entire focus was on delivering the best possible, lowest possible total cost of ownership performance for our customers. Through technology, we helped them see where their machinery was located, the way it was operating, and how to complete maintenance before they encountered either a problem or a failure of that machinery. That same kind of approach is applicable to the railcars in our fleet — tracking the condition of those railcars, ensuring we can arrange to remove those cars from service before a problem arises with a given car, which might otherwise lead to it being bad ordered and possibly sidelined for them. So, when I think about how we pursue improvements, that's one piece. There's also, for tank cars, certain sensors we're able to install on them that let us observe how those tank cars are doing, and ensure that should any new problems or worries appear, we can alert both the shipper and the railroad.

Steve Barger

analyst
#68

I appreciate the additional detail. That wraps up my questions. Eric, I believe you touched on this somewhat, though in 2019 bookings hit their weakest point since 2016. I realize calling turns in the cycle is difficult, yet did you state that you consider this 10,000 run rate for Trinity to be somewhat trough-like?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#69

Those words didn't come from me. What I did say is that over the near term, I anticipate industry orders holding at the pace observed during the third and fourth quarters.

Steve Barger

analyst
#70

All right.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#71

Steve, I don't mean to be clever here, but everything comes back to the situation with railcar loadings. They're still not favorable. Given that the comps are somewhat easier, I would have thought they'd turn around. As of yet, they haven't. So we need to continue monitoring railcar loading activity, and that's what will drive our view of railcar demand.

Steve Barger

analyst
#72

Excellent. Thanks so much.

Douglas Greiner

analyst
#73

About the balance sheet optimization plan — more precisely, going from a 55% LTV on the lease fleet we own entirely to a 60% to 65% target during the coming 12 to 18 months. What steps make up that operational plan, and what are the toughest obstacles you face to pull it off successfully? Thanks.

Melendy Lovett

executive
#74

Morning, Doug. Melendy here. On the particular steps, a portion of that will hinge on our commercial activity and what our railcar investment vehicle partners are up to. Essentially, though, here's how it works: we've established the 60% to 65% goal as a near-term one, and as I said, we anticipate getting there within 12 to 18 months; so essentially, whenever we require capital to expand our business and to give capital back to shareholders, we'll approach the debt markets and assess which debt is appropriate for us to raise, considering the cost of debt and our time horizon and so forth. And when needed, we'll put that debt into our lease fleet to bring that loan to value up to the 60% to 65% level.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#75

Eric here, Doug — one more thing I'd mention: we definitely have the capital markets open to us if we want to issue and bring in additional capital.

Melendy Lovett

executive
#76

When it comes to the difficulties, I'd say they're largely tied to, as I mentioned, factors we can't really influence — so it's a matter of timing. Take this year as an example: we had projected a loan to value of 57%. We closed out the year at roughly 55%, since our working capital management turned out stronger and we didn't have to bring in as much capital.

Jessica Greiner

executive
#77

Alright, thanks Carolina, and thanks to everyone who invests with us. That wraps up the conference call for today. Once it hits 1 o'clock Eastern Standard Time, you'll be able to hear a replay, and it stays available right up until midnight on February 27, 2020. To listen, dial 402 to 220 to 7233. There's also a webcast replay you can find on the events and presentations page of our Investor Relations site, which is at www.trin.net. We can't wait to talk with you again on the next conference call. Thanks for spending your morning with us.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Trinity Industries, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Trinity Industries, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Trinity Industries, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.