Trinity Industries, Inc. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 30, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jessica Greiner
executiveThanks, David, and hello everybody. This is Jessica Greiner, Trinity's Vice President of Investor Relations and Communications. We're glad you could be with us for the conference call on the company's financial results for the first quarter of 2020. Our prepared remarks will start with comments from Jean Savage, Trinity's Chief Executive Officer and President; after that, Melendy Lovett, our Chief Administrative Officer, will speak. Eric Marchetto, who is the company's new Chief Financial Officer, will then give the financial highlights; once the leadership team finishes its prepared remarks, we'll hold a Q&A session. On today's call, we'll walk through a few slides covering the main discussion points. Those supplemental materials are available on our IR website at www.trin.net. You'll find the slides in the Events and Presentations section of the site, together with the event link for the first quarter earnings call. At this point, I'm happy to hand the call over to Jean.
E. Savage
executiveThanks, Jessica, and hello everybody. The way the economy has been behaving and the steps governments have taken because of the coronavirus have no precedent, and I feel tremendous pride in how the people at Trinity have answered. TrinityRail has been classified as an essential business by the North American Federal Authority. My executive leadership colleagues and I want to begin by praising our workforce for what they give us — their service, their dedication to health and safety, to keeping the business running and to keeping vital supply chains moving; we thank you for your efforts, your spirit and your pursuit of excellence, all of which show the strong culture and the heart of Trinity. Our gratitude also goes out to our customers, our suppliers and every business working so that our communities remain safe and retain access to everything we need day to day. Naturally, we wish to convey our profound thanks to everyone on the front lines battling COVID-19; your dedication and service mean a great deal to us. We take pride in the role our people and our railcars play in keeping our communities going. Beyond the fact that rail plays a key part in protecting our planet as the most sustainable form of land-based transport, rail transport is the lifeblood of the North American economy. Nearly every market relies on railcars as a vital link in its supply chain; each day we all count on food, treated water, energy-generating commodities and medical-grade products, and every one of those goods arrives via the rail supply chain. When times are hard, hard people step up. My belief is that Trinity's pursuit of excellence in the rail platform will demonstrate once more that we can weather an economic crisis. In what I've prepared for today, I intend to address 3 principal items: how COVID-19 is affecting our business, and what we are doing about it; the financial resilience of Trinity's railcar platform, our cost structure and liquidity position, plus the strength of Trinity's leadership team when it comes to steering us through this crisis; and the scenario assumptions we are using to guide our business performance and capital allocation choices given market uncertainty. During the first 2 months of the first quarter, Trinity was carrying out a number of optimization efforts that we had already shared with the market. These efforts were meant to enhance our go-forward cost structure and bring down our cost of capital so we could speed up our competitiveness in the marketplace. Some of our COVID-19 response actions, which I'll turn to next, appear in the supplemental materials on Slide 3. As the seriousness of what COVID-19 would mean started to become clear, Trinity's leaders acted decisively to safeguard the health and safety of our employees and to assist the communities where we live and work. We put in place policies and procedures consistent with CDC and WHO guidelines covering social distancing, cleaning and sanitizing, limiting visitors at our manufacturing facilities and setting up work — remote work arrangements for our corporate and services workforce; we curtailed employee travel and have moved the bulk of our customer interactions to virtual methods. Our ongoing operations have been kept up. Up to now, we haven't run into any delays in production when it comes to getting products or services to our customers, and we keep collaborating closely with them to grasp what they need. Potential disruptions in our supply chains have also been watched by procurement teams, and it's a pleasure to report that they've managed to secure continuity of operations so far. The majority of our first tier suppliers sit in North America and have not yet been materially impacted by the constrained movement of goods from other nations. Contingency plans are in place, in case we start to observe significant disruptions within our second and third tier supply network. During our previous conference call, we talked about the rightsizing steps we expected as a result of the industrial slowdown and the drop in railcar demand during 2019. In March, when the effects of COVID-19 started to appear, we took another look at the possibility of reduced railcar volumes and equipment demand over the near term. Consequently, we acted further and cut our manufacturing workforce by an additional 30% compared with year-end, so that it matches our production capacity. Given the backlog visibility we have right now, we feel our manufacturing platform is sized correctly to serve our customers. The second item I wanted to make certain we cover today is our confidence in the financial resiliency of Trinity's business model. While carrying out our COVID-19 preparedness steps, we went through our financial models and assumptions in depth, stress testing our balance sheet and liquidity against a range of scenarios as severe as, or more severe than, those seen amid the financial crisis in 2009 and '10. Later in the prepared remarks, we'll provide more detail on that analysis. When railcar down cycles occur, the long-term character of the contracts within Trinity's leasing business shields the company from short-term market disruptions and is essential to the company's relative stability and cash flow generation. There are countercyclical elements to our operational cash flow as well, coming from working capital release, because our manufacturing business has a highly variable cost structure. An additional source of value creation for our business model is the considerable tax efficiencies that arise from putting our leasing company and our manufacturing business together. As the lease fleet keeps growing, accelerated depreciation of railcars offsets taxable income from our other businesses. The net operating losses that are produced are then usually carried forward in order to lower future taxable income. The CARES Act, which passed recently, further boosts the tax synergies of the rail platform. The tax losses generated in 2018 and '19, mostly from accelerated depreciation tied to our lease fleet investment, will be used by Trinity to recover taxes paid in earlier years at higher tax rates. By year-end, we expect to receive $300 million in tax refunds stemming from the loss carryback provisions in the legislation. I never could have pictured that within my first few months as Trinity's new CEO, I would be guiding this great company through one of the largest financial and economic crises our markets have witnessed. The people leading our company bring substantial expertise when it comes to navigating ups and downs in the rail cycle, and they are ready for what lies ahead. Drawing on what we know right now and our reading of market conditions, we feel confident that Trinity's platform, along with its ability to generate cash, is strong enough to ride out the global pandemic and seize chances for creating value that might come our way. My expectation is that when this is over, we will come through showing a champion spirit and demonstrating that our rail platform was built to deliver: getting essential goods to society; bringing innovative solutions, products and world-class service to our customers; and generating long-term value creation and returns for shareholders. At this point I'll hand the call over to Melendy and Eric so they can walk through our operational and financial remarks in greater detail, and then I'll wrap up with my final point regarding our go-forward business assumption.
Melendy Lovett
executiveThanks, Jean, and hello everybody. The results we posted for the first quarter show how dedicated we've been to carrying out several moves aimed at bringing the company's structure in line with the rail-focused plan we're pursuing and at lifting how the business performs. We understand that today's conditions will make hitting our financial objectives harder, yet our sights remain fixed on the goals we hold for the long haul. As a leadership group, our top aims are safeguarding the well-being and safety of the people who work here, keeping operations running without interruption, and preserving capital. Luckily, the measures we'd already begun in order to streamline the company's cost base came at a good time and worked in our favor, given what the COVID-19 crisis required us to do. On the earnings call for the company's fourth quarter, we told everyone about a target to cut administrative expenses throughout the organization by $25 million to $30 million. During the first quarter, the company moved forward on savings that came to $9 million to $10 million, covering workforce reductions as well as folding our logistics and equipment services businesses into the operations of the Rail Products Group. It further covered the choice to move our corporate campus somewhere more economical and the disposal of a facility that wasn't operational. Those moves produced a restructuring charge of roughly $5.5 million. On top of that, management has pinpointed $15 million to $20 million in savings that we anticipate acting on over the coming few quarters as we reshape our organization and trim administrative support expenses. Once you add in the cost-cutting steps taken across 2019, the overall reductions in SE&A and other administrative costs are approaching $60 million; we're dedicated to speeding up the platform's performance by aligning our organization effectively and efficiently, and we'll share updates on how our cost optimization is progressing as the year goes on. Optimizing our balance sheet by leveraging our lease fleet to bring down our cost of capital has been another top priority for the company. While doing this, we spotted the early redemption of our 2006 securitization, TRL V, as a chance to optimize. That securitization carried a remaining principal balance of about $105 million along with a coupon of 5.9%. At the moment of redemption, the net book value of those assets stood at approximately $303 million. These railcars can now be monetized either by recapitalizing the assets or via transactions in the secondary market. Following this redemption, the weighted average coupon rate on leasing debt we wholly own came in just under 4% when the quarter closed. In the weeks after our fourth quarter conference call, the company also bought roughly 1.9 million shares for $35.4 million. At the close of the first quarter, the company still has about $90 million left under the amended authorization currently in place. Trinity's management has worked side by side and collaborated very closely in establishing the strategic priorities for the company as a rail-focused organization. Serving as Trinity's CFO over the past year and getting to know many of our shareholders and potential investors has been an honor for me. I'm very confident that we're putting our leadership and our organization in the right alignment so we can serve our customers and stakeholders better, and so that Trinity's performance speeds up and shareholder value is unlocked once we come out of the coronavirus pandemic. Throughout his career, Eric has been a crucial leader at this company and in the rail industry. For our team and for our business leaders, this transition has gone smoothly, and to our investors he will also be a familiar face. At this point I'll hand the call to Eric so he can go through our financial performance in more detail.
Eric Marchetto
executiveThanks, Melendy, and good morning to all of you. It's an honor to step into the CFO role following 25 years of service to this company. I'm eager to collaborate with our stakeholders in this capacity as we keep enhancing both how effective and how efficient our platform is, and to pursue improved performance along with opportunities to create value. Since COVID-19 emerged, we've put preventative measures in place, and so far our day-to-day operations haven't been significantly disrupted. Even so, we anticipate adverse financial effects on our business, and we'll make adjustments as needed — we will make those adjustments as needed. Although Trinity's corporate line items and consolidated results for the first quarter contained quite a few moving pieces, operations at the Railcar Leasing and Products businesses performed a bit above what we had expected internally. The Leasing Group saw revenue and profit from operations increase year-over-year, largely driven by a larger lease fleet and higher average lease rates. Our revised depreciation policy also played a part in boosting this segment's profit margin. In the first quarter, we closed a modest portfolio sale with one of our RIV partners, which showed the worth of railcar assets that come with leases attached, even amid heightened disruption in financial markets. The Rail Products Group shipped slightly more than 3,700 railcars during the first quarter, all while cutting production capacity at our manufacturing facilities. As I noted on our February earnings call, we anticipated these margin headwinds stemming from inefficiencies as we slowed production and trimmed our manufacturing capacity and headcount. On the commercial side, we're feeling the effects of evolving uncertainty in the industrial market and weaker North American railcar loadings. Lease fleet utilization fell to 95.4%, and new railcar orders for the quarter came to 1,970 railcars. Based on our analysis, we estimate that roughly 80% of our customers function as essential businesses and infrastructure under definitions set by governmental authorities, and a great many of our remaining customers indirectly serve those businesses in the supply chain. Since public data on railcar loadings — a key indicator for our business — is so widely available, the changed demand environment for railcar equipment shouldn't be surprising. We've observed substantial drops in rail volumes, which in the end leave railcar equipment underutilized. That said, a handful of market sectors stand out as a bright spot for demand in rail equipment. In our view, the strongest near-term opportunity lies in agricultural markets, particularly grains and fertilizers, given the age of the railcar fleet and the relatively high utilization of assets. There isn't a single railcar market; rather, there are multiple railcar markets, and each has its own demand drivers and fleet dynamics. We're keeping a close watch on economic forecasts for recovery across all of our markets. No matter which way the market goes, our management team has plenty of experience handling swift changes in railcar demand. On top of the challenges tied to COVID-19, the sharp fall in crude oil prices during the first quarter has delivered a historic shock to energy markets. So what we did was take out roughly 540 tank cars from what had been in our first quarter backlog. Those are mostly headed into crude service, since the customer's financial situation shifted significantly after those orders were placed. At this point, nothing in our backlog relates to railcars for frac sand or crude oil. That said, within Trinity's lease portfolio, crude oil accounts for about 4% right now, while frac sand makes up around 8%. Both of these markets have gone through a lot of structural change over the last 10 years, and it's no secret that brown sand mining has created difficulties in recent years. Our view is that if shale oil production collapses, the frac sand sector could end up financially exposed, so we're watching market developments carefully and on an ongoing basis in order to reduce our risk and safeguard the return on this investment. A modest share of our customers have asked for financial relief given current conditions as well. In cases where it makes sense, Trinity has put in place specific criteria for granting extended payment terms to customers right now, and we'll keep assessing ways to help our customers. Turning to Trinity's financial position, we think we're beginning from strength. After financial markets deteriorated sharply because of COVID-19, the company ran multiple scenario analyses on our cash flows to assess how solid our balance sheet and liquidity are. Under every assumption we tested, Trinity's platform held up. Slide 4 of the supplemental materials gives a summary of our liquidity and balance sheet. At the close of the first quarter, the company's committed available liquidity stood at $760 million. On top of that, we anticipate getting $300 million in tax refunds during this year thanks to the reinstatement of tax loss carryback provisions under the CARES Act. That cash tax benefit shows just how significant the financial synergies are across our platform. Our lease fleet is diverse and numbers about 130,000 railcars, which gives us visibility into lease and fee income, and it includes $2.5 billion in total committed revenue plus a railcar backlog valued at $1.6 billion. Given how relatively stable the market has been so far for our highway and maintenance businesses, we look for Trinity to produce strong cash flow in 2020 and to hold our liquidity position under our base case scenario. Beyond that, as additional liquidity options, the company holds roughly $1.5 billion in unencumbered assets that could be monetized via leverage or secondary market transactions. Taking into account the company's debt maturity profile along with the extra levers we can pull to free up capital, we're confident our balance sheet and financial strength allow Trinity to get through the COVID-19 pandemic; we'll keep maximizing cash flow from the committed business while drawing on our commercial reach and market knowledge to steer through these unusual times. Because we've shifted priorities toward managing our balance sheet during COVID-19, we expect the company's leverage ratios could come down as the year progresses. We're keeping a close eye on the capital we have on hand and what we need in terms of liquidity, so we can figure out what steps to take and weigh that against our longer-term objective of optimizing the balance sheet. What our platform is showing is that it was designed to perform and to keep performing. At this point I'll hand the call back to Jean for some closing remarks.
E. Savage
executiveThanks, Eric. Our Q1 results show that Trinity is making moves to bring our cost base in line with what demand looks like right now. We're doing that while the market is tough, and it fits with our longer-range plan to speed up Trinity's performance across the cycle. Because the market offers so little visibility thanks to the coronavirus, we aren't issuing financial guidance right now. As many other businesses have said, there's no way for us to forecast today how long COVID-19 will last or how big its impact will be, nor how the steep drop in energy prices will affect our operations, our customers, or our suppliers. Our attention is squarely on scenario analysis, keeping the business running, contingency planning, and protecting and strengthening our liquidity. Luckily, Trinity holds lease contracts with long durations that shield us from market disruption, plus a healthy backlog, and within that we can adjust our capacity to resize for demand. We do expect to share a wider framework for Trinity's strategic road map during our Q3 call in October. Still, in the meantime, we figured it would help to give you some background on the scenario analysis we ran regarding the company's financial position and condition, as a guidepost. Slide 5 in the supplemental materials summarizes the inputs behind this analysis; those scenarios also give us a framework for guiding capital allocation choices in today's market. The base case assumes the economy reopens soon and railcar loadings start getting better at some point in or around Q3. Under those conditions, we'd anticipate lease fleet utilization holding at roughly 95% as our backlog delivers, a modest level of leased railcar portfolio sales getting done, and our SE&A optimization target being met. In our stress case, should COVID-19 keep holding back the market's recovery, we've modeled possible deferrals of our backlog, utilization falling under 90%, and no ability to complete railcar sales on the secondary market; under either scenario, we expect the rail platform's financial synergies to produce positive operating cash flows. The more our financial performance looks like the stress case, the more our capital allocation framework will lean toward preservation. The more our performance tracks the base case, the more capital allocation will support continued, prudent investment in the business. Trinity's present plans for manufacturing and corporate CapEx are largely committed for 2020 because of construction in progress on new maintenance facilities needed to serve our expanding lease fleet; that spending is projected at about $100 million for the year. Even so, manufacturing CapEx for the rail business has historically fallen somewhere between $5 million and $20 million annually during downturns, which shows we can pull that spend in substantially when we need to. Because of leasing customers' railcars sitting in our backlog, plus the chance that secondary market sales come in lower under each of our scenarios, we think net lease fleet investment in 2020 could land somewhere from $350 million to $500 million under either scenario. Fighting the economic fallout of COVID-19 will certainly be a huge undertaking, but Trinity has kept its dividend going throughout its history. Once more, under either scenario, as the slide shows, our belief in how much cash Trinity's platform can generate underpins what we have promised shareholders in terms of returns. The company is paying its 224th quarterly dividend in a row today. Management and the Board of Directors share the same expectation that the rail platform's synergies let us put meaningful money back into the business while still returning substantial capital to shareholders. During my first few months serving as Trinity's CEO, my pride in this team could not be greater — from the welders on the shop floor, to the dedicated men and women serving our customers and business stakeholders, to the seasoned leadership team and the backing of our Board; we keep aligning our organization and operations so that our performance is maximized. Slide 6 in the supplemental material goes over our key financial and operational goals. In chasing our longer-term goals, the coronavirus has put up a difficult hurdle to clear; that said, no matter where we sit in the cycle, the rail platform's synergies and the cash flow it generates are the engine driving Trinity's value creation for shareholders. Our platform was built to deliver, and we believe we can endure today's market conditions and produce long-term value for our shareholders. Operator, we're ready to take questions from our listeners.
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystEric, congratulations on the appointment — well deserved. I'd like to return to what was said about lease rates. During Q1, they looked quite favorable. Was there anything distinctive about those railcars? Also, perhaps you could walk us through how matters are developing as the pandemic, I suppose, speeds up here in the U.S.?
Eric Marchetto
executiveThanks, Allison. Eric here. I'll handle that question. What I'd say is that the rise in our lease rates referred to the average lease rate across our portfolio. That figure is influenced more by additions and removals within our portfolio — specifically what we brought into the fleet and what we disposed of from the fleet. As for lease rates in absolute terms, we remain — as we noted on our previous call — we remain seeing headwinds affecting lease rates. And given how railcar loadings are moving, my expectation is that this pattern will persist in the near term.
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystGot it. Now, regarding the secondary market — you folks have been quite busy making sales there. Obviously, with all the worries coming from the macro side, it appears that trend might be shifting. Do you have anything to share on that? Might we even witness some consolidation among the smaller participants? What are your views?
Eric Marchetto
executiveAbsolutely. Eric here once more. So indeed we had — roughly $110 million in railcars got sold by us during the first quarter. My thinking was — that happened — those were sold by us in March. That was more or less the peak of the uncertainty, particularly the swings in the equity markets. So I felt good that execution was possible for us. Looking ahead, and as Jean brought up in a few of our stress cases, that's a situation we've run stress tests on across many of our scenarios — the capacity to complete transactions. Should it fail to — should conditions not favor sellers, then things could flip into a market favoring buyers. And where those prices that clear the market sit, I simply don't know, in order for — should people decide to offload portfolios. My expectation isn't that distressed portfolios will show up soon. However, the more time passes, perhaps that shifts.
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystFantastic. For my final inquiry, I'd like to grasp the way you think about utilization versus improved lease rates. Clearly, we appreciate both, but given this type of situation, where is Trinity placing its emphasis? Is utilization the bigger priority for you, or are lease rates? In this context, how do you strike that balance?
Eric Marchetto
executiveRight. Eric here once more. What I'd say is that at present, utilization gets more of our attention. Despite the fact that our utilization is declining, our attention remains on utilization when railcars are required. If a customer has no need for the cars, then perhaps no rate can sustain that. We continue to renew railcars. And on leases that expire during this year, we anticipate continuing to renew railcars. Moving ahead, however, there will be a certain amount of rate headwinds.
Justin Long
analystI’d like to begin with a question about returns. I completely get why the 2020 guidance was pulled, but there was a 3-year ROE objective of 11% to 13%. Could you give us an update on where that stands and when it might be reached? And when we consider the assumptions built into arriving at that 11% to 13%, do we need to see lease rates and build rates come back to normal for that to happen? Or are there sufficient company-specific levers available that you could still reach it even if the market is below replacement?
E. Savage
executiveThis is Jean. Thank you for asking, Justin. Although the present conditions mean hitting our long-term goals within the initial timeframe is very difficult, we remain dedicated to reaching those goals eventually. Given how much uncertainty there is in the market at the moment, I would anticipate it taking us somewhat longer to determine whether we have levers that could keep things on track; but I believe the headwinds will delay it somewhat.
Justin Long
analystAll right. Regarding the personnel-related savings you highlighted, between $9 million and $10 million, does that figure fall inside the SE&A cost reduction objective of $25 million to $30 million? And perhaps, when you consider the downturn and the stress case you brought up and had a slide on, can we think about additional expenses you might remove under those circumstances, over and above what was described in that $25 million to $30 million?
Melendy Lovett
executiveHi, Justin, this is Melendy. Yes, the $9 million to $10 million I referenced during my prepared remarks sits within the $25 million to $30 million goal announced during the fourth quarter. And as I stated in my prepared remarks, we have identified and intend to finish that $25 million to $30 million goal this year. As we presented in the stress case, should we observe additional contraction, should the COVID-19 situation be prolonged, we are ready to implement additional cuts.
Justin Long
analystAll right. Perhaps one final brief item regarding the projection for operating cash flow being positive during this year. Might you discuss the working capital movement that is presumed in that projection? And is the $300 million tax benefit you brought up also part of it?
Eric Marchetto
executiveHi, Justin, Eric here. I won't provide you with a particular working capital forecast; however, regarding operating cash flow, as our production volumes go down, we'll capture certain natural working capital gains across the year as our run rates decrease. That's normal; we've seen that during earlier cycles too; and as for the refund, it is included and it is part — it will be part of our operating cash flow. As we've discussed before, even absent the CARES Act, we would anticipate positive operating cash flow for the year. I'd simply add, we're centered on liquidity. We're going to — we intend, as I mentioned in my remarks, we intend to keep our liquidity up all year; and we have levers available to pull to ensure we keep that.
E. Savage
executiveAs I noted in my comments, at present we anticipate somewhere between $350 million and $500 million for possible additions to the lease fleet, $100 million for manufacturing CapEx, and $150 million to $200 million returned to shareholders via dividends along with share repurchases, and we continue to expect that we will preserve our liquidity.
James Bardowski
analystJames Bardowski from GLJ Research, Chief Investment Officer and Managing Director, speaking on behalf of Gordon: I've got a question, and it's first about the Leasing Group's utilization and balance sheet optimization program. The 60% to 65% targeted leverage under that program hinges on how big your fleet is, and also — tell me if I've got this wrong — on how big you expect that fleet to be in the coming years. Last quarter, as I recall, utilization dropped to 95.4%. You mentioned only a slight impact on leasing customers, yet you did concede that loadings are soft and rates are comparatively weaker. So suppose we get no sharper rebound — instead something more L-shaped — and customers begin cancelling orders: how far would you let fleet utilization decline before you act to shrink the fleet, thereby eroding the leverage you'd tied to future fleet growth?
Eric Marchetto
executiveHey, Gordon, it's Eric here. Let me attempt to — James, apologies, I'll take that one. When I think about the stress case, we modeled it — in that stress case environment, we anticipated utilization — we observed our utilization dropping under 90%. And even so, we felt the business did well, or at least did adequately, across the cycle. As for whether we'd begin — I believe your question is whether we'd divest assets so as to protect leverage. Is that what you mean, in the sense of your...
James Bardowski
analystIn one respect, yes.
Eric Marchetto
executiveOkay, agreed. That is definitely a tool available to us, since our lease fleet is so large and unencumbered — as I said, it comes to $1.5 billion — and we think that hands us considerable financial flexibility, whether by selling assets or financing them, so we can keep liquidity steady or grow it. And so — and that's sort of not really centered on utilization.
James Bardowski
analystJames Bardowski (GLJ Research, Chief Investment Officer and Managing Director): All right, that's quite useful. So essentially, there isn't a predetermined threshold at which you'd begin pushing more sales from the lease fleet — say, if it dropped to 88%?
Eric Marchetto
executiveCorrect, there isn't one. It really comes down to conditions in the secondary markets. If chances to sell assets arose, we'd consider that, but should utilization decline to that extent, our assumption is — one thing we built in was that we probably couldn't move many assets given how the market looks; so that dynamic pushes the other way. At least under a stressed scenario.
James Bardowski
analystSo, moving over to the Rail Group real quick. What I saw was that year over year, new orders dropped once more — that's the fifth consecutive quarter of declines. And you pointed out that cancellations have now taken crude oil out of your backlog, though you're still exposed via the fleet you're currently utilizing. So does that mean you basically don't anticipate any further cancellations? Or are there other uncertain spots where we could see another round of cancellations? I know you said agriculture is doing well, but are there other sectors where you see possible growth that could offset things and perhaps give your orders a boost?
Eric Marchetto
executiveSure, James. Let me — it's Eric here again. I'd say over the longer term, and even in this year, replacement demand is still going to be the biggest thing pushing new orders. For new railcar deliveries and new railcar orders, replacement demand is the single largest driver. I don't see that dropping to 0. In other cycles we've observed, it does turn into somewhat of a buying opportunity for customers taking a longer-term view, buying assets at this point in the cycle. So I really don't expect that to occur.
E. Savage
executiveOrders keep coming our way. Just within the last seven days, we've booked several hundred of them. So despite the difficulties we're facing, buyers still require a number of these rail cars.
James Bardowski
analystJames Bardowski (GLJ Research; Chief Investment Officer and Managing Director): All right, that's quite useful. Then, last thing, and after this I'll pass it along. You brought up "inefficiencies" as one factor behind the compression — or the drop, I should say — in your Rail Group margins. If you look back over time, it does appear that your costs tend to lag; with that said, considering the decision to reduce your utilization, how — can you offer us any sort of expectation regarding margins or possible costs in the Rail Group, perhaps partway through the second quarter?
Eric Marchetto
executiveJames, no forward margin guidance is being provided by us. Assuming things stabilize, we expect to provide it on our call next quarter.
James Bardowski
analystOkay, that's useful. And then, just quickly, if you could — of the railcar orders placed in Q1, how many belonged to the Leasing Group?
Eric Marchetto
executiveRoughly — somewhat around half. Slightly over half of those orders went to Leasing.
Matt Elkott
analystFirst, I'd like to ask something about the industry. Eric, I believe this one is directed at you. At present, a substantial quantity of railcars sits unused, and while we have certain details regarding the categories, we lack information on the subcategories. Roughly what share of that parked fleet do you figure will never return, regardless of how much demand recovers? In other words, these could be aging DOT-111 tank cars that simply cannot serve any purpose anymore and are merely awaiting an acceptable scrap price before being removed from the idle pool.
Eric Marchetto
executiveMatt, Eric here. You've really cornered me into offering an opinion, haven't you? Solid data on this is scarce. Even so, we've conducted analysis on our own fleet along with certain other items we've examined. When it comes to railcars and storage figures, as I've noted during earlier calls, they can be somewhat misleading, yet the direction of the trend, in my view, matters more. Were we forced to assign a figure to that extended storage — and my definition of extended storage would be anything unused for 12 months or more, which I'd then consider surplus or headed for scrap — that figure would fall within the 70,000 to 90,000 railcars range. The main car categories composing it, I believe, would include certain larger box cars, a number of older covered hoppers, and then some of the aging coal cars. Hopefully that's useful, though it's just my personal view.
Matt Elkott
analystYeah. No, those figures are workable for us. I appreciate the input. Then on this point — it might be obvious given the name "base case scenario," but I simply want to confirm that the base case you're laying out is the one you believe, with the information available today, has the greater chance of occurring?
E. Savage
executiveMatt, it's Jean here. Let me just note that a number of those served as guardrails; we've modeled a great many situations. Our aim was to give you assurance that we've examined which levers are available for us to use in response to shifting conditions. However, we can't truly offer guidance on what we believe will or won't take place there until the industry settles down and we understand what's coming.
Matt Elkott
analystUnderstood. Then, regarding the backlog—which I believe stands at 13,000 cars—did you mention what share is slated to arrive during this year?
Eric Marchetto
executiveThat figure wasn't provided, though it will appear in our Q. Roughly 10,000 railcars are set to be delivered within this year.
Matt Elkott
analystSo if we're going off the base case scenario, you don't see any risk to that figure, in your view?
Eric Marchetto
executiveGoing off the base case scenario, like we mentioned, that's what gets delivered in our base case.
Matt Elkott
analystAll right, understood. And then, Eric, I believe you provided a few figures regarding utilization — for the lease fleet, specifically crude and frac. From what I recall, crude accounts for 4% of your lease, while frac makes up 8% of the lease fleet.
Eric Marchetto
executiveCorrect. Those weren't utilization figures. What I was referring to was last serve — meaning, out of our fleet, what the most recent service was.
Matt Elkott
analystAll right, so that means it isn't 4% of the fleet that's being utilized?
Eric Marchetto
executiveNo, that's not right. The figure is 4% of the whole fleet we have, and actually that's a solid question, since...
Matt Elkott
analystHow much are those cars being used?
Eric Marchetto
executiveThat figure applies across our entire fleet, all 100% of it; we examined the most recent contents. So, say a car's last cargo was crude and right now it sits unused — that makes it a crude car. If its last cargo was frac sand and it currently sits unused, then it's a frac sand car. We aren't providing utilization figures broken down by each type of car. However, frac sand was the last load for 8% of our fleet, while crude was the last load for 4%.
Matt Elkott
analystAll right, so when we talk about the share of the fleet actually being used, those figures are considerably under 4% and 8%, correct?
Eric Marchetto
executiveLet me see if I've got that right. As for my response — I can't quite track how that calculation works.
Matt Elkott
analystYeah, so from what I understand, your fleet utilization stands at about 95%, is that correct?
Eric Marchetto
executiveThat's correct — 95%.
Matt Elkott
analystYeah. Regarding that utilized group, what if the share that's crude and frac comes in under the 4% and 8% figures you provided?
Eric Marchetto
executiveCorrect. The count — yes, how many cars — yes, exactly. Exactly.
Matt Elkott
analystUnderstood. Understood. That's clear. And only one more item. Could you share any of the underlying assumptions behind the stress case scenario you're relying on, the macro assumptions?
E. Savage
executiveWhat we assumed was that railcar loadings genuinely wouldn't begin recovering until the second half of 2021. So the broader industry's rebound came later.
Bascome Majors
analystRegarding output, I get the hesitation or reluctance to provide any guidance. But look, you cut production rates by 50% — or nearly that much — within just one quarter. Could you tell us what the weekly, biweekly, or monthly run rate looked like as we exited that quarter, so we can get some idea of how things stand at present, prior to any additional changes?
E. Savage
executiveSo when it comes to manufacturing, during the quarter we took the — so between the close of last year and Q1, we saw a 30% decrease. I just want to confirm that was understood regarding the headcount.
Eric Marchetto
executiveHeadcount.
E. Savage
executiveYes.
Eric Marchetto
executiveManufacturing, as he put it.
Bascome Majors
analystRight, my question concerned how fast we're producing and how fast we're delivering.
Eric Marchetto
executiveCorrect, Bascome, my apologies — for competitive reasons and for guidance reasons, we won't discuss run rates, though during the quarter we did take those actions. A lot of the moves we made in Q1 weren't really tied to COVID-19; on our February call we mentioned that we anticipated a drop in production. So if COVID causes additional declines beyond that, those would be subtracted from that figure.
Bascome Majors
analystAlso, are 3 of your main production sites currently being run under their full capacity? Or might there be a chance to combine part of that when the market is weaker?
Eric Marchetto
executiveLooking back across the years, quite a few of our manufacturing assets have already been consolidated. Right now, on the new production side, we are running 3 facilities — major ones. We'll keep seeking ways to optimize that, and it hinges on how things develop regarding whether we want 1, 2 or 3 facilities in operation. Jean, anything you...
E. Savage
executiveNo, nothing there.
Bascome Majors
analystThen a few about leasing, and after that I'll hand it over. Is rail ABS accessible in the market right now if you decided to tap it? Also, any idea what sort of coupon rates and collateral advance rates could be coming our way?
Eric Marchetto
executiveBascome, Eric here once more. My view is that whenever the moment arrives for us to go into the ABS market, we'll get it done successfully. My guess is spreads will run somewhat above those of our most recent deal. Still, given that the broader benchmarks sit low, I suspect the coupon ends up above what we got before. That said, it somewhat hinges on the timing of our market entry. Even so, my belief is they will be open.
Bascome Majors
analystRegarding advance rates — in your recent transactions, I believe those have typically sat up in the high 70s. Is there any wiggle room there too?
Eric Marchetto
executiveIt's possible — it just depends. There's always a trade-off involved. Often, across every market, you've got latitude in terms of how hard you choose to push that advance rate, and whether you structure things differently — these assets naturally lend themselves to being tranched. Should you go with a single transaction — a single tranche — the advance rate might come in slightly lower, though that gets a bit into inside baseball when it comes to securitizations. Still, my expectation would be something comparable to prior years.
Bascome Majors
analystAnd. This will be my final question. I'm grateful that you shared the crude and sand exposure details. My calculation is that it comes to 12% of the car count in your fleet. If we measured it instead as a percentage of book value, or perhaps as a percentage of current or committed revenue, would that figure change significantly? And to add to that, the customer discussions you're having where people ask for financial relief or payment deferrals — do those originate from these end markets? Or do they come from a wider group?
Eric Marchetto
executiveOkay, great. This is Eric. I'll handle that. So regarding — from a book value standpoint, what we gave you was a unit count. From a total book value angle, once you sum them up, it will be quite near that 12%, and the book value — the single one will be — typically, it will land at roughly that figure. As for revenue, I can say that on the frac sand cars, that 8%, if you consider first quarter revenue, it would have represented roughly 4% of our revenue for the quarter. And so — and then the latter portion of your question about lessee discussions. Those are part of that number, but the requests we're receiving come from a wider market than simply frac sand and energy. Many customers across many industries have been impacted. So we are — we are speaking with a large number of our other customers.
Steve Barger
analystI realize you'd rather not discuss guidance, but assuming today's circumstances roughly persist for some time, should the coming few quarters resemble the first quarter when it comes to deliveries and consolidated operating margin? Alternatively, thinking directionally, how ought we to view the back half compared with the front half, simply given what's visible at this point?
E. Savage
executiveMy expectation is that during the second quarter, conditions will prove tougher for us than they were during the first quarter, given the environment in which we're currently operating.
Steve Barger
analystAll right, and when you consider the second half, is there anything you can share?
E. Savage
executiveOnce more, a base case and a stress case are both in play. And keep in mind, under the stress case, my comment was that we did not anticipate rail loadings beginning to bounce back until the latter portion of 2021. So for what we could anticipate, I'd point you back to that stress case.
Steve Barger
analystYeah. We truly value the fact that you gave us both the base case and the stress case. I suppose, when you consider that stress case, if it actually happened, speaking in terms of a range, would operating margins remain in the high-single digits? Or would they drop into the mid-single digits? Any sort of general expectations?
Eric Marchetto
executiveYes. We aren't providing guidance. I would — so right now I won't make any comment on that. Our hope is to provide additional guidance details during the second quarter, in July.
Steve Barger
analystUnderstood. Then just one additional question. I realize the product mix and how many units we run both play a role, but doing some quick back-of-the-envelope math, what's the lowest number of railcars you'd have to build to keep the Rail Group at breakeven — to avoid losing money there?
Eric Marchetto
executiveSteve, it's Eric here. I'd say that figuring out where breakeven falls is going to vary. And it hinges on whether the production cycle is steady — when things run more evenly, that breakeven threshold can sit at a lower level. When things swing around a lot, it'll be at a higher level. Like I said before, one thing that sets our platform apart right now compared with 2009 and 2010 is that we're running a smaller number of plants; and my sense is that within those plants we've got a cost structure that's more variable. So I'd say that on its own ought to push the breakeven threshold down. But life isn't — there's — everything else isn't held constant; so pinning down exactly what run rate gets you to breakeven is tough.
Jessica Greiner
executiveThanks, David. That wraps up the conference call for today. Starting after 1:00 Eastern Standard Time and running until midnight on May 7, 2020, you'll be able to access a replay of today's call. The number to dial in is 402 to 220 to 1111. You can also find a replay of the webcast on the Events and Presentations page of our Investor Relations website; we're looking forward to speaking with you once more on our next conference call. Thanks for being with us this morning.
Operator
operatorThat brings today's session to a close. We appreciate everyone for joining in, and you're free to log off at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Trinity Industries, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Trinity Industries, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Trinity Industries, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.