Trinity Industries, Inc. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 23, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jessica Greiner
executiveThanks, Bree, and welcome, everyone, to this morning's session. My name is Jessica Greiner, and I serve as Vice President of Investor Relations and Communications at Trinity. We're glad you could be with us today for the company's conference call covering financial results for the second quarter of 2020. During our prepared remarks, you'll hear comments from Jean Savage, who is Trinity's Chief Executive Officer and President, as well as from Eric Marchetto, our Chief Financial Officer. Once our leaders finish their prepared remarks, we'll move into a Q&A session. On today's call, we'll be referencing a handful of slides that highlight the key points of our discussions. Those supplemental materials can be found on our IR website, www.trin.net; the slides are available under the Events and Presentations section of the site, together with the event link for the second quarter earnings call. At this point, I'm pleased to hand the call over to Jean.
E. Savage
executiveOkay, thanks Jessica, and good morning to all of you. For Trinity, the pandemic along with economic developments during Q2 made for an extremely tough operating backdrop. What I want to do today is walk you through how Trinity has responded to those difficulties, as well as our more forward-looking initiatives aimed at turning us into a returns-focused business; throughout this hard period, Trinity's leadership team and its employees have stayed committed to doing what's right right now so the company is best positioned for success down the road. Keeping our people healthy and safe is still priority number one, and that covers the protocols we put in place to help stop COVID-19 from spreading in our offices and production facilities, consistent with guidance from the CDC and the WHO. I'd like to express my appreciation to Trinity's workforce for their dedication and their ongoing emphasis on safety. Working together, we're making sure Trinity's high-quality railcars keep moving essential goods throughout North America and around the globe; we saw soft demand for railcars during Q2 because of the economic fallout from the pandemic as well as the sharp drop in energy prices and demand that occurred earlier in the year. During the second quarter, a sharp drop in crude oil prices drove a number of frac sand suppliers into bankruptcy. As a result, Trinity recorded an impairment on the book value of our fleet of small cube covered hoppers held within our lease portfolio. When Eric delivers his prepared remarks, he will provide more detail about the steps we have taken in response. While railcar loadings have improved somewhat in recent weeks, growing COVID-19 case numbers across the U.S. may endanger the rebound in economic and rail market activity. We're monitoring our supply chain very carefully and coordinating closely with our customers, so our production schedules and lease fleet activities remain aligned with what the market needs for railcars and associated services. Industry data indicates that about 32% of the North American railcar fleet is not fully utilized. While that number remains elevated, we expect continued pressure on pricing for rail equipment, whether newly manufactured or already in service; in a market like this, our commercial approach is to maintain utilization throughout our lease fleet and, after that, meet demand for newly built railcars whenever it is sensible for our customers. On the strategic-buyer side, we've recently seen more railcar interest than we did during the previous quarter, and my expectation is that a number of those possibilities will convert into orders or lease agreements in the not-too-distant future. A few transactions closed lately make me proud because they relied on everything our platform can offer. For one strategic customer, for example, we combined railcars already held in our lease portfolio, modification work and brand-new rail equipment — all as part of one deal. That carefully crafted approach provided a distinctive experience, met the customer's business requirements and should create lasting value for our shareholders. As for both new and used equipment, the agricultural sector, from where we sit, holds the strongest short-term potential for a pickup in demand. Agricultural traffic hasn't encountered as many obstacles during the pandemic, relatively speaking, and beyond that, a large portion of the covered hopper fleet currently hauling grain is getting close to the point where it can no longer serve a useful purpose. Looking forward, we expect considerable demand to replace box cars, aggregate open hoppers, and gondolas across the coming years. Working through a downturn is genuinely hard. Even so, our leasing business delivered a solid second quarter. Rate pressure and reduced utilization pushed revenue down, but strict cost management, together with other elements, offset that decline. Within our lease operations team, customer satisfaction has stayed high, which we credit to spending on advanced tools and technology. Those capabilities are really important for the customer experience we're prioritizing and for driving operational efficiencies, and they also help us keep our railcar fleet safe. In our products group, I also want to recognize our plant leaders and team members for the commitment they keep showing to fulfilling production needs safely. Trinity delivered just under 3,000 railcars in Q2, and the rail products segment recorded a 2% margin. Because of what we were dealing with from the coronavirus, volume fell more quickly than we could take out costs. Our ability to align certain expenses with volume levels was undermined when employees at higher risk or potentially exposed stayed home. Competition on price also became more intense. We have trimmed our manufacturing workforce by 35% since the year began, producing close to $40 million in overhead savings. Further steps are in motion to bring our cost structure in line with production levels through the rest of 2020, even as we shift lower value-added fabrication toward the supply base. Doing so lowers our cyclical exposure by cutting the internal labor a cycle demands. For the balance of my comments, I want to address further moves Trinity is making to lift our platform's performance ahead. Our cash flow emphasis amid present conditions, our optimization work to speed up the company's financial results, and our longer-range strategic planning to keep building shareholder value. Trinity's distinctive rail platform, robust balance sheet, and cash generation let us handle the COVID-19 pandemic from strength. The size of our leasing operation and the multiyear character of lease contracts shield the company from near-term market shocks and underpin that relative steadiness. At present, we are intensely concentrated on controlling coronavirus consequences to limit business interruption and boost our cash flow. Committed future lease payments of $2 billion, a products backlog of $1.3 billion, sound liquidity, and roughly $1.6 billion of unencumbered rail assets uphold our financial standing. I would also point to our push to speed the company's longer-range financial results via platform optimization, a central management and Board priority over the past year; we are tackling optimization across every part of our organization, from operations to our balance sheet. Leaders at Trinity have reached tough decisions involving people in recent months. On the organizational side, we've moved the company away from Trinity's old holding company structure and toward an operating model that's more effective and more efficient, organized around our customers and our markets. Combined with the actions we took in Q1, this is going to deliver $30 million in annualized cost reductions overall, split between SG&A and cost of sales, and that brings us to the $25 million to $30 million goal we set back at the start of 2020. Slide 4 in the supplemental materials lays out some of the details about our cost initiatives. While we're mapping out process flows across different production and service functions and rolling out our new organizational models, we're also establishing further structural savings targets that will be a near-term priority for us. Our management teams are taking a look at different parts of how we operate, such as supply chain costs, the carrying costs of idle facilities and assorted service fees. Now, about what we've been doing to optimize the balance sheet: during Q2, we decided to hold off on going to the capital markets, because we wanted the volatility in interest rate spreads tied to the pandemic to ease up first. Once the quarter had closed, we were glad to finish increasing the size of TRL 2017 by issuing another $225 million in promissory notes, carrying an interest rate of LIBOR plus 1.5%. On top of that, we kept our dividend in place throughout the second quarter. That shows how dedicated we are to returning value to shareholders as part of how we allocate capital, and it reflects our confidence in how strongly our platform can generate cash flow. In addition to near-term actions designed to speed up our financial results, we are heavily involved right now in planning for the longer term. We're looking at additional ways to optimize the platform, and also at opportunities for growth. The goals behind these efforts include making our lease fleet perform better, lowering how cyclical our collection of businesses is, keeping up our operational enhancements, and assessing expansion into rail transportation services. We think Trinity's role as a supplier, maintenance provider, and owner of railcar assets puts us in an excellent spot to work with customers on new kinds of products, services, and solutions that make shipping freight by rail more appealing. We're still working through our review, and we plan to present what we've found along with the choices that come out of it during Trinity's Investor Day, which is coming up soon. Our goal is to stand out as the top supplier of rail-related goods and services, and we're eager to get more freight moving over the North American rail network. We view Trinity's mission — transporting goods and commodities by rail to benefit everyone — as central to our dedication to sustainability. Our finances are solid enough to get us through today's difficult economic climate and to let us seize opportunities when appealing offers present themselves. Trinity's rail business exists to accomplish several things: getting vital freight where communities need it, providing our buyers with creative answers and top-tier goods, and generating strong profits along with solid returns for investors as the railcar market moves through its ups and downs. At this point, I'll hand things over to Eric, who will walk through the quarter's particular financial figures.
Eric Marchetto
executiveThanks, Jean, and good morning to all of you. Trinity's results for the second quarter show what we're doing to build up liquidity in the near term while also lifting our returns by allocating capital in a disciplined way. Because of present uncertainty, we aren't offering specific financial guidance, though we do think the company will keep producing substantial cash flow, thanks to how resilient our platform of businesses is and the financial synergies they naturally share. If you turn to Page 5 of the supplemental material, you'll see we're concentrating on getting the most cash flow possible out of the businesses and keeping liquidity at a healthy level. When we wrapped up Q2, we had roughly $710 million in liquidity. On top of that, there's the $225 million in financing that we highlighted in the press release, which pushes our liquidity even higher. We continue to expect that by the time the year ends, we'll receive over $300 million in cash refunds connected to tax losses from previous years, thanks to the tax provisions included in the CARES Act. In addition, our balance sheet as of June 30 reflects an anticipated $150 million more in cash tax refunds that should arrive during 2021, tied to our 2020 tax year — a clear demonstration of how our platform's tax attributes create value. Also, Trinity has about $1.6 billion of unencumbered assets available as dry powder. We could turn those into cash by taking on more leverage or doing secondary market deals. Our balance sheet and financial strength, in our view, allow Trinity to survive the COVID-19 pandemic and grab value-creation chances that might come up. We put in hard work to keep a diversified railcar portfolio, oversee our customers' credit profile, and spread out portfolio expirations, all so risk-adjusted returns are maximized. On our prior call, we discussed the troubles that many of our frac sand customers were dealing with, caused by a one-two punch: structural shifts inside the frac sand supply chain and the steep drop in energy prices, plus extra strain tied to the COVID-19 pandemic. We have been paying close attention to the ways the frac sand market has shifted at a structural level, and we are working hard with our customers, where it makes sense, to rework lease agreements. That way, the cash flows tied to them continue, and these assets keep getting used. Ultimately, in Q2, four of Trinity's frac sand customers went through bankruptcy filings, and additional ones are still in a weak financial position. That altered our expectations for how much cash flow these lease contracts for this type of railcar will bring back. As a result, these filings meant the company had to put a fair value estimate on these railcars. We finished our review by recording a $369 million pretax noncash charge tied to the small cube covered hopper fleet in Trinity's railcar portfolio. That figure came from what we estimate those assets are worth at fair value, using cash flows that have come under strain because lease contracts keep facing pressure, along with what the assets could eventually fetch as salvage value. This impairment charge does not affect — it has no effect on how liquid we are, and it also does not change whether we meet the debt covenants in our rail securitizations. A portion of that impairment landed on railcars held in portfolios we only partially own, so it was assigned to noncontrolling interest on the balance sheet. After that charge, our fleet of small cube covered hoppers makes up 3% of net book value across the owned and partially owned portfolio. In Q2, we offloaded a railcar portfolio to a partner in one of our RIVs. Proceeds came to $74 million on that portfolio, producing a gain of 6%. These assets were high-quality but lower-yielding, and they fit our partner's portfolio well on a risk-adjusted basis. That freed us to put capital into higher-yielding investments while we keep earning fee income from managing those assets; the sale shows how we can leverage our platform to build transactions that benefit both us and our partners, and it reflects our renewed emphasis on a disciplined capital allocation framework aimed at long-term value creation. As we look at future growth of the lease fleet, we're keenly focused on portfolio returns as part of our plan to push company performance toward a mid-teens pretax ROE. We think we're taking the steps needed to set the company up for accelerated performance once the market recovers, with sharper focus on the levers we control. Now to Page 6 of the supplemental materials. Rather than providing formal guidance three months ago, we gave you two sets of numbers — a base case and a stress case — to serve as markers that managers could reference when making decisions about what we do and where we put capital. Because the market remains unpredictable, it's still difficult to say when rail will bounce back, yet the steps we took and the results we posted in Q2 surpassed certain assumptions built into those scenarios. Essentially all of our 2020 production plan is spoken for, and about 41% of the value in backlog is set to be delivered before the year is over. Based on railcar loading patterns across North America and the strength of our railcar renewals this quarter, we believe lease fleet utilization will remain above 90% even under a downside scenario. That modest portfolio divestiture during Q2 means our prior stress-case view on constrained railcar sales would likewise appear stronger at this point. Beyond that, we can see more clearly now that additional, smaller railcar portfolio sales could occur across the remainder of the year. Savings will also come through our cost programs, reaching the goal we established for this year, and further steps are still ahead. Jean cited $70 million of annualized savings actions taken so far this year; roughly $30 million of that is structural and will reduce SG&A along with other overhead-related line items moving forward. Turning to capital allocation, our net investment in the lease fleet should now come in somewhere between $350 million and $450 million, reflecting RIV as well as secondary market activity. We've delayed certain CapEx projects tied to manufacturing. Even so, our plan is still to complete the expansion of the new maintenance facility located in Iowa. For the year, our guidance now accounts for somewhere between $90 million and $100 million in manufacturing CapEx. When it came to the quarter, we opted against repurchasing shares, a move aimed at protecting our cash position and bolstering our financial standing. Even so, that avenue stays available to us as we continue refining our balance sheet. The company declared, in May, its 225th consecutive dividend, keeping the payout at $0.19 per share, equal to an annualized yield of about 3.5% using yesterday's market close. Trinity is right in the midst of a hugely exciting transformation. Even as we battle the economic fallout from the pandemic, we're laying the groundwork for what Trinity will become. We plan to provide detailed perspective on how we'll operate and what we expect for long-term performance at an Investor Day scheduled in the weeks after our third quarter conference call. Please keep an eye out for more information, since we're eager to walk you through these plans before long. To wrap up, management stands united in expecting that the rail platform's financial and commercial synergies allow for both significant investment into the business and a sizable return of capital to shareholders; we're proving this holds true even amid a severe economic slump. Our platform, we believe, can produce positive cash flow even during downturns, and we stay dedicated to putting money into our railcar lease fleet throughout the cycle, keeping returns for the portfolio front of mind. As we navigate the COVID-19 environment, we're dedicated to a careful approach to capital allocation and robust liquidity so we keep our strong position. Through everything, we believe TrinityRail's platform is designed to perform. Operator, we're ready for the Q&A.
Steve Barger
analystTo start, I have a question about the big picture. A rival of yours in leasing mentioned that because deliveries stayed strong for several years, we've ended up with too many cars built, and working that off will require some time since production is now running under replacement levels. With that in mind, how do you view this, first given where you sit as a top OEM, and second through the lens of your role as a lessor?
E. Savage
executiveJean here. Steve, I'll take that one first. Thanks for asking. The way I see it, the answer really differs depending on which market you're in and which kind of car is being used there. Take certain car types — momentum has already started improving. Agriculture is in that group, and flat cars plus vehicular flat and box cars are also on the upswing already. In those, you don't have as large a share of newer equipment, or perhaps an excess supply, that needs to be soaked up. Turning to the segments that got hit harder, energy being the example right now, those will get absorbed too. That process might take somewhat longer to play out. Eventually, though, some of those cars will reach the end of their life and require replacing, or they'll be retired because of an HM-251 or other mandates to bring that car type up to standard.
Steve Barger
analystOK, and then regarding those different vehicle categories, in your prepared comments you noted there are inquiries you anticipate turning into orders or lease agreements. Could you discuss how large any of those might be, in units?
E. Savage
executiveI'm not able to discuss the size, but what I can say is that they're significant — considerably higher than what we saw during the prior quarter.
Steve Barger
analystAll right. And you mentioned that capacity in the second half is pretty much fully booked. For our models, is the second-quarter run rate a sensible basis for thinking about second-half production?
E. Savage
executiveAs we exit Q2, we're keeping some staff on hand for the opportunities ahead of us. Should those wrap up soon, we'll need to begin production during the third and fourth quarters so we can hit the delivery window for the orders that exist out there. So I'd say that if those opportunities don't materialize, we'll face further downsizing in the third and fourth quarters.
Eric Marchetto
executiveSteve, Eric here. Let me just jump in on what I said earlier — I noted that by the time this year wraps up, we anticipate delivering 41% of the value in our backlog. That should shed a bit more light for you on run rates.
Steve Barger
analystGreat, and I'll ask just one more before rejoining the queue. This is along the same lines, about how much revenue we get per car. For the second half, do you anticipate a mix comparable to what 2Q delivered where revenue per car is concerned?
Eric Marchetto
executiveAs things slow, our mix will keep shifting. Because of that, I doubt it ends up precisely one-for-one, since the mix will grow somewhat less concentrated in tank cars going forward. That's going to affect the ASP to some degree.
Matt Elkott
analystCould you discuss what you expect for manufacturing margin under both the base case and the stress case? I'm just trying to get a sense of how much additional pressure on operating manufacturing margin we might face as we navigate the current environment?
E. Savage
executiveAbsolutely, Matt. Jean here. I'll handle that question. So when we consider the full year, as I said earlier, given the deals we're in the middle of negotiating, we're retaining certain headcount so that we'd be able to fulfill that production if it becomes necessary. Should those not materialize, there's further optimization or rationalization work we'd need to undertake. There's also effort ahead of us involving the removal of some higher-cost footprint. We'll be cutting back on manufacturing support functions as well as administrative overhead expenses. As you go through all of that, there are bound to be a few bumps and bruises during that transformation before reaching where you need to be over the long term. So my expectation is that as we wrap those up, some pressure could arise. However, if we get those deals closed, you might see some tailwind arrive.
Matt Elkott
analystAll right, that makes sense. And Jean, you brought up possibly examining certain expensive production operations to streamline, switch over, or shut down. From what I recall, over the past few years, the bulk of your vehicles have been built in Mexico. To start with, how did the Mexico versus U.S. breakdown look this year while the pandemic was going on? And if a plant were to be cut, would it be located in Mexico or the U.S.?
E. Savage
executiveSo, the way we see it, we build new cars in both the U.S. and Mexico. And it's our expectation that we'll keep doing so in both places. One thing we shut down not long ago was our wheel shop, which was located here in the U.S., and we moved that work to an outside supplier. We're also reviewing sending out some other lower-value fabrication work, which would allow us, first, to need fewer workers to build a car, and second, to find ways to bring down its total cost; that's where we're going.
Matt Elkott
analystAll right, and I’ve got one additional follow-up regarding that question about order activity picking up. I believe you said there’s been more inquiry recently. Could you help us understand what portion comes from financial buyers seeking cars that have leases attached so they can put capital to work? What share involves shippers with actual freight requirements wanting to lease cars, or perhaps shippers interested in purchasing cars that are being manufactured now?
E. Savage
executiveLet me begin, and then I’ll have Eric chime in on this one; what we’re truly seeing is opportunistic purchasers emerging. At present, we’re in a down cycle. Pricing has become aggressive, and those with older fleets they wish to swap out or with extra demand are stepping forward and pursuing those opportunities. That’s where we’re observing this take place. And Eric, would you like to add anything?
Eric Marchetto
executiveAbsolutely, Matt. In terms of turning inquiries into orders, what we mean isn't portfolios of railcar leases. What we mean is railcar equipment users who have demand; and like we said before, replacement remains a significant driver. And my view is that over the coming several quarters, replacement demand is going to be a bigger driver than growth demand. That's where opportunities are showing up for us, with rail equipment users who have certain discrete replacement opportunities and who want to make the most of the present market.
Matt Elkott
analystUnderstood. Let me ask a brief follow-up regarding the orders. My understanding is that this quarter, or in 2Q, you received 40%, maybe a bit more than 40%, of the industry's orders. That's somewhat higher — actually considerably higher — than your performance over the past several quarters, when it appeared you were becoming less aggressive about taking orders. Should we be reading too much into that? Has your strategy shifted at all? Are you now prepared to accept more — 50 orders in one case, 50 in another — while the downturn continues? Or is this simply an anomaly?
Eric Marchetto
executiveYes, Matt. Those figures were released just as we were getting ready to start this call. As a result, I haven't had the opportunity to review many of them. When you consider quarterly industry orders of 1,900 units, that figure is likely too small to draw meaningful trends from. What I can say is that the orders we booked during the quarter leaned somewhat more toward leasing than had been our recent pattern. They also involved more specialty railcar business. The good thing about specialty railcars is that their margins tend to be somewhat higher than those of certain other railcars. So we're quite pleased with the order volume we achieved. The fact that it represented 44% of the market is more of a result than anything. I wouldn't characterize it as any intentional move on our side.
James Bardowski
analystJames Bardowski, filling in for Gordon, here. I wanted to ask about how you're allocating capital. You didn't repurchase any shares last quarter — the first time that's happened in quite a while. I realize you're sitting on plenty of liquidity, but your price-to-book ratio now sits above others in the leasing group. So in effect, one of your objectives has caught up with another one you had, largely internal of course: your leverage goals. My recollection is that it was 60% to 65% loan-to-value. At 57.1% last quarter, it ought to come in somewhat higher given the $225 million facility you just closed, right? That being the case, you're now even nearer to that 60% to 65% goal, so my question is: should we take the absence of buybacks as the new standard? Or are you lifting your leverage targets?
E. Savage
executiveWhat I'd say is that during the prior quarter, the reason we weren't out there actively purchasing was that we'd said we wanted to make sure our cash and liquidity were in good shape. We were still watching how COVID-19 would unfold and what it would mean both for the market and for what lay ahead. So that's why we paused. Eric noted in his script that $90 million remains available to us for repurchasing stock. That will factor into how we think about capital allocation going forward.
Eric Marchetto
executiveYeah, James, I would simply mention that the financing we recently completed isn't automatically just going to increase leverage. A portion of those proceeds is going to go toward paying down our revolver and our warehouse. But as Jean — when we consider — from a capital allocation standpoint, we're still going to produce a substantial amount of cash flow. And buybacks are among the options we'll evaluate regarding what to do with that cash we're going to produce.
James Bardowski
analystOkay. Jean, Eric, that's really useful. I've just got one very quick follow-up. I believe I noticed a figure of $70 million referenced in the press release, relating to cost savings you currently have in progress. Quickly, what portion of that would you call cyclical or variable, and what portion is fixed? And how does it break down across the segments?
E. Savage
executiveJames, one thing — looking at Slide 4, it does mention that, for what we've executed year-to-date, we have $58 million, with $70 million total identified. On the cyclical side, it shows $38 million executed and $40 million identified. One thing I'd like to point out is that we're examining the possibility of outsourcing certain lower-value fabrication items, which will also shift part of that cyclical reduction into something more permanent. So, regarding your question about the percentages, I'm going to hand that over to Eric. I haven't viewed it in those terms, and I'm not sure we have that information at present.
Eric Marchetto
executiveYes, I think that's enough.
E. Savage
executiveYes. Thanks.
Justin Long
analystI’d like to inquire about the used railcar sector and what you’re observing in it. In what ways has that market moved forward during 2Q, and, I suppose, so far this quarter too? Perhaps you could also address the amount of activity as well as the competitive dynamics you’re encountering on whatever transactions are currently available?
E. Savage
executiveOkay, I’ll begin, then let Eric chime in. Justin, at present, the secondary market remains open. You can access it. It isn’t as deep as it was a year ago, yet purchasers are still seeking attractive opportunities. We are likewise present, and we might act either as a buyer or a seller, based on what we find offered and on how attractive those opportunities are. Eric, would you care to add anything?
Eric Marchetto
executiveI believe that addresses it. Justin, we — it isn't — deals are still out there. A handful of players who would have taken part over the past 2 years may be waiting on the sidelines. Yet by and large, the market remains, and you can still get transactions done, whether you're on the buy side or the sell side.
Justin Long
analystAll right, that's helpful. And regarding what's happening with lease pricing, could you share your observations on how those rates have moved during the recent stretch of months? Obviously it will differ a lot depending on the equipment type, but at a broad level, I'd really like to get a sense of how far things have come down. And when you look ahead at the market, with rail traffic improving somewhat on a sequential basis, do you see a chance for lease pricing to find a floor at some point in the back half of this year? Or is that going to require more time than that?
E. Savage
executiveAll right, Justin, I'll take that question first. When it comes to lease pricing, what we've observed is that the marketplace has grown more competitive. If you stack us up against the LPI that other folks reference, the decline in pricing for us has been nowhere near what they've experienced, yet we're still feeling that pressure. We watch what's happening as new vehicles enter our fleets. Our pricing tends to be higher on those. So while there are some pressures, overall the impact on us hasn't been major. As for when we might see pricing move back upward, our hope is that it happens quite soon. That said, given COVID-19, we genuinely don't know what to anticipate there. Still, you've identified the correct metric — as car loadings keep climbing, our expectation is that lease pricing will begin to increase.
Justin Long
analystAll right. Fantastic; and for the final question, very briefly. Jean, it seems like additional details regarding the strategic plan will come our way following the third quarter. Even so, I wanted to ask, only at a broad level, whether you might discuss your dedication to keeping an integrated platform running? Does management and the Board still back that? Or might there be any willingness to consider strategic alternatives in that area?
E. Savage
executiveAll right. Of course, well, Justin, I'll address that; so the Board and management share the same view regarding the platform we run. We think the greatest value for the company and for our shareholders can be delivered through our rail platform. Among the advantages are cost-advantaged railcar equipment sourcing, tax-advantaged lease fleet investments, offsetting manufacturing taxable income and then the lower relative admin cost. And then on the commercial side, it provides us with direct engagements with the customers over multiple touch points. We obtain actionable rail intelligence through this and valuable sales channels. So having said all that, our path forward involves looking at the platform in total. But as always, as a Board and as a company, when new things arrive, we'll take a look and see if we still have the right perspective or if we need to reevaluate.
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystLet me begin with profitability for rail products, and revisit that earlier question so I'm sure I've got it right. There seem to be 2 parts here. First, it does sound as though you're retaining some additional capacity given the order activity you're observing in the market. With that in mind, should we expect a certain amount of heightened pressure as we move into Q3, depending on when those orders land? And how fast would the shift happen from orders to actual production? Then the second part of that profitability question concerns COVID. I believe you referenced certain costs that sound like they might be more of a 1-quarter nature, hopefully, if we're coming out of this. Did that have an impact — or would I call it material — on the quarter when it comes to the headwind?
E. Savage
executiveI'll take the COVID piece first, Allison, then continue from there. Regarding COVID-19, my estimates put the operational impact for the quarter somewhere between $4 million to $6 million. That stemmed not just from the extra cleaning we needed to perform. It also stemmed from employees in high-risk categories sheltering at home, or those who had been exposed and needed to shelter at home until we could be certain this hadn't affected them. Do I believe it will be that elevated going forward if the COVID-19 positivity rate declines? No, but whether it does really hinges on what unfolds with COVID-19; a significant share of our management's time inside the facilities goes toward making sure people comply with the rules, that they work safely, and that wears on you over time; so our hope is that it will decline, though I can't state with certainty that it will. When it comes to the third and fourth quarter on the production side, we expect to find out soon whether those orders will close; and we'd be in a position to convert and begin producing those quite fast in the third quarter. So we're holding for a brief period. Should they close, we'll launch that operation. As I mentioned, there's some tailwind in it for us. Should they not close, we'll do what's appropriate and make whatever reductions are necessary.
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystGreat. Next, I'd like to return to what was said about orders, and attempt to square those orders with the amount of storage sitting out there; it sounds like some verticals are clearly appealing, which stands to reason; and beyond that, you definitely have some replacement demand across the year. I suppose if we consider that storage figure, and I realize this is a tricky question when it comes to defining what counts as normal storage, it sounds like the majority of these are either indifferent to storage, in other words it's a vertical, or it's simply equipment that would never have returned regardless. Is there any additional detail you could share on that?
E. Savage
executiveSo, regarding the 32% in storage, I'm not able to provide many specifics, but 2 primary markets account for that storage. And Eric, would you like to offer more detail?
Eric Marchetto
executiveAll right, Allison. The small cube covered hopper fleet tied to frac sand is definitely putting a large number of cars into storage. Of that overall figure, I'd put it at 55,000 to 60,000 cars. Then you've got open covered hoppers, coal cars, and some tank cars remain in that count too. Looking at the possibilities out there — first, the number you mentioned, it's hard to pin down. You can still find demand in those categories, since the market isn't fully efficient. But like I said, replacement demand is still going to be the driver. It'll push a lot of ordering over the coming few quarters; and there are still pockets of growth in petrochemicals. We continue to see growth there that you're going to have. So it isn't one railcar market. It's markets of railcars, and you'll keep seeing pockets of demand even when — at times when the macro numbers suggest there shouldn't be any.
Bascome Majors
analystEric, are you able to hear me at all?
Eric Marchetto
executiveYes, we're able to hear you.
Bascome Majors
analystAll right. My apologies — I had muted myself. Seeing an asset write-down from a lessor that's still operating is not something you come across often, especially partway through a year, but what has taken place among frac sand companies — that wave of bankruptcy filings, distress, and everything else — is likewise far from typical in this case. So I was hoping you might shed a bit of light on this: once the covered hopper fleet has been written down, what amount of book value for Trinity is still carried on the books, and was the evaluation you all carried out regarding what was impaired versus not impaired tied only to that fleet? Or did you also look at other areas of comparable size where pressure exists but perhaps isn't quite as severe?
Eric Marchetto
executiveCertainly. Certainly, Bascome. The impairment charge we recorded is not a simple matter, and I'd point you to Page 5 and 14 of our press release so you can see how certain of the mechanics work, how they move through our financials. As for other car types, we constantly watch our fleet for those kinds of circumstances. So it isn't something we only do once a year. We're examining that at all times when it comes to keeping an eye on our fleets. You brought up a few of the atypical shifts and exceptional shifts we saw this quarter that genuinely pushed us — that set off that impairment related to the bankruptcies and related to our view that those cars would stay overbuilt. That industry contains 125,000 small cube covered hoppers. As I said before, I believe 55,000 to 60,000 of them are underutilized. Given our forecast for domestic drilling and, in particular, Wisconsin white sand being used in the Permian, we don't expect that to recover to the extent it once had. And so we truly examined it, and the alteration in the committed cash flows stemming from the bankruptcies set off that impairment; and so with other car types, my belief is that the credit profile across the remainder of our portfolio is considerably stronger than the credit profile of our same customers. And as a result, those committed cash flows stand a far greater chance of being turned into cash. And that truly — the — when we look at the impairment, we don't see it right now in any other place.
Bascome Majors
analystAlso, would you be able to include what the book value amounts to...
Eric Marchetto
executiveYes. Yes. My apologies. And I believe I did bring that up. Roughly 3% — once the write-down was taken, the book value for our small cube covered hopper fleet, and that isn't solely our sand fleet, it's the entire — it's our small cube covered hopper, which would also handle other commodities, comes to approximately 3% of the net book value of our fleet as of the quarter's end.
Bascome Majors
analystI think we touched on this, at least in a directional way, during the prior quarter. But for anyone out there attempting to genuinely gauge book value and what they ought to pay for it, could you remind them how much book value could still remain in a few of the bigger tank cars that have exposure to crude oil and/or the coal market? That's everything from me.
Eric Marchetto
executiveI'd point you toward the investor deck we have, since it contains those breakouts. Sadly, though, once you move into crude oil, that tank car becomes — it's not as if we definitely own crude oil tank cars; what we own are tank cars that haul crude together with other commodities, and those markets can shift. Take, for instance, a sizable deal we recently completed in which we switched crude oil over to other refined products, which we finished right as the quarter ended. Every bit of that involved railcars we already had; still, I'd point you toward the investor deck we have. We're going to refresh it over the next — within the coming days too, and it will include the updated net book value percentages, broken out across all the various categories they list.
Bascome Majors
analystI’m going to go back to something, and yes, I realize I claimed that was my final question; however, Eric, another one came to mind as you were responding to me.
Eric Marchetto
executiveAbsolutely, that’s fine.
Bascome Majors
analystYeah. In the slide deck you mentioned — and I realize the 10-Q will have additional details once it's filed — that you had $1.6 billion in unencumbered railcars. That appears to have risen by $100 million to $150 million from one quarter to the next. Yet that occurred alongside the $370 million write-down and your adding $225 million of debt after the quarter closed. So how is it that the unpledged collateral increased? Could you help us sort that out? And is that figure pro forma or not for the debt you took on after quarter end?
Eric Marchetto
executiveThe debt we added afterward is not reflected in it, and on a follow-up we can cover all the mechanics. But basically, what drove the changes would be additions to our fleet. During the quarter there were no financings that would have impacted that, and then the small cars we divested in the quarter. So those are the pluses and minuses, and we'll gladly take you through it.
Barry Haimes
analystMy question concerns that $350 million to $400 million put into the lease fleet. Do you have a sense of how much of that is essentially replacement? In other words, holding fleet size steady, but some cars need to be scrapped, versus how much actually grows the fleet through new units?
Eric Marchetto
executiveAbsolutely. Thanks, Barry. Given that our fleet averages 9 years old, attrition is not significant across our 130,000 railcars. So when you consider what we add to the fleet — those would be additions — replacement plays a very small part. And those figures are net of any railcars that we — of any assets we sell during the year. Plus, they're all on firmly committed leases with customers. So there's nothing speculative in those — in those figures either.
Barry Haimes
analystAll right, that's clear. Just one more quick question, if that's okay?
Eric Marchetto
executiveOf course.
Barry Haimes
analystThe typical age comes to 9 years. Yet when you examine which group is the most aged, what would you say about the comparatively oldest vehicles within the leasing portfolio?
Eric Marchetto
executiveRather than talking about a few individual vehicles, I'd note that the bulk of what we lease has been written since 1979, the year we began. As a result, the most aged units we have are typically still present in some cases. There isn't a lot in the way of — roughly 0.5% exceed 35 years in age. That makes it quite a tiny figure. It clearly leans toward the bottom portion of the spectrum.
Jessica Greiner
executiveThanks, Bree. That brings an end to this conference call. Starting after 1:00 Eastern Standard Time, a recording of today's session can be heard, and it will remain accessible until midnight on July 30, 2020. To listen, dial (402) 220 to 6088. You can also find a webcast replay posted on the Events and Presentations page of our Investor Relations site, which is at www.trin.net. We can't wait to speak with you once more on our next conference call. Thanks for being with us this morning.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's program. Thanks for joining us, and you're welcome to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Trinity Industries, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Trinity Industries, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Trinity Industries, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.