Trinity Industries, Inc. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 22, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jessica Greiner
executiveThanks, David, and good morning to all of you. My name is Jessica Greiner, and I serve as Vice President of Investor Relations and Communications at Trinity. We're glad you could be with us for the company's conference call covering financial results for the third quarter of 2020. In our prepared remarks, you'll hear from Jean Savage, who is Trinity's Chief Executive Officer and President, as well as from Eric Marchetto, our Chief Financial Officer. Once our leaders finish their prepared remarks, we'll move into a Q&A session. On today's call, we'll walk through a handful of slides that highlight the key points of discussion. You can find those supplemental materials on our IR website, www.trin.net. The slides are located in the Events & Presentations section of the site, together with the event link for the third quarter earnings call. At this point, I'm happy to hand the call over to Jean.
E. Savage
executiveThanks, Jessica, and hello everybody. Over the past year, Trinity has been going through a transformation to realign our business, our people, our cost structure and our purpose so we can deliver superior returns to our shareholders. The COVID-19 outbreak threw off the timing and execution of these initiatives. I'd like to praise our people and our business leaders for their resilience and dedication to clearing the obstacles created by the pandemic, and for their work to build our strategic framework for the future, all while still providing high-quality products and services to our customers. As a significant milestone in our journey, Trinity will hold a virtual Investor Day in 4 weeks. There, the management team will lay out our value proposition and strategic framework for speeding up our financial performance. Today, we want to concentrate on the third quarter results and show how those results and the actions we took during the quarter line up with our goals, which you'll hear more about in the months ahead. The goals of our strategic framework are: one, to optimize the returns of our lease fleet; two, to lessen the impact of cyclicality; and three, to boost the modal advantage of the railcar industry. In Q3, Trinity put its new strategy into place. We expect these strategic shifts to drive operating model performance and produce superior shareholder returns. Our strategy rests on our newly defined purpose of delivering goods for the good of all. This purpose aims to stress for all Trinity stakeholders the essential role that rail transportation plays in our daily lives as we dine with our families, clean our homes, fuel our cars and lead a safe and happy life. Trinity has a rich history, a legacy of strong growth and a reputation for flexibility. With these attributes and our new focus, Trinity's premier railcar products and services will support essential North America supply chains. Moving forward, we'll stress the optimization of our platform and scale new products and service offerings that will make our existing investment more valuable. This strategy will put more emphasis on cash flow and returns. That leads to more disciplined levels of growth through the cycle. Our management team kept making progress in optimizing the cost structure of the business during Q3. Because of the new strategy, we have additional headcount and other administrative cost reductions. We also decided to exit the U.S. trucking and logistics business, and outsourced this service to third parties. Along with that, we have a small impairment charge tied to the trucking fleet that have primarily serviced Trinity's former industrial businesses. Counting the actions from the first half of the year, Trinity has implemented over $80 million worth of reduction in operating costs and other related costs. Please turn to Slide 4 of our supplemental materials. We keep rationalizing our footprint as well. During the quarter, further rightsizing produced a total manufacturing headcount reduction of 47% year-to-date. We think there may be more cuts as we move toward the start of next year; we're looking at what we spend on materials and examining how much goes to direct versus indirect costs so we can bring our breakeven point down. Through a range of cost initiatives, we think the margin in the rail segment has room for meaningful improvement across the cycle. We'll give you further specifics on those initiatives at our Investor Day coming up. As our press release showed, we're likewise focused on optimizing the balance sheet, and Eric will walk you through what we've achieved in the financial overview. On the whole, our results matched what we had expected under the base case scenario we laid out when the COVID-19 pandemic began. Utilization in our Leasing business remains steady at approximately 95%, and we're keeping a tight grip on expenses so that lower lease rates on renewals do the least possible damage. During the third quarter, renewal lease rates came in below the rates they replaced. Even so, pricing was relatively flat quarter over quarter compared with the second quarter. The portion of our portfolio up for renewal across the coming 12 months sits within our usual 15% to 20% average, and we're watching our markets carefully for any signal of improvement. Given where market pricing for renewals has been lately, lease rates on our 2021 expirations will face a far simpler comparison than what this year's expirations faced. We've already seen better conditions in some markets, such as agriculture, which includes grain and intermodal, whereas others, such as energy, keep confronting headwinds. As an operating lessor, our goal is to set our products and services apart through customer experience, turning ownership and use of railcar equipment into something more appealing and more valuable for industrial shippers. Growing the additional services we can offer — ones that draw on our wide platform, our market knowledge, and the analytics from the lease fleets we own and manage — can deliver a premium stream of recurring revenue to the company. Lately, we've been building out the analytics and infrastructure needed to add telematics to railcars, and we've teamed up with other top rail service providers on a new technology platform named Rail Pulse, which we think will help reshape rail shipping going forward. Although that platform and the services that come from it are still early in development, we think these capabilities will be a crucial element in strengthening the rail industry's competitive standing against other forms of transportation over the longer term. Turning back to how we did in the third quarter, we took on start-up costs tied to our new maintenance facility in the Midwest as we brought new employees aboard and welcomed our first customers to the plant. We anticipate that inefficiencies from getting operations underway will weigh on segment margin in the year ahead. That said, we do expect the new facility to add to earnings in 2021. Thanks to the capacity this new facility provides, we think we're able to service and maintain as much as 60% of our lease fleet internally. That tops the goal we established 2 years back when the spinoff happened. We'll keep assessing additional expansion of our maintenance services operation, which includes growing service capabilities in markets that are underserved. As I said, our manufacturing operations kept slowing production as the third quarter went on, with further headcount rationalization; even so, the pace did not match the reduction from the second quarter, and that let us cap how much disruption hit our plant. Under our base case scenario, production plans covering the rest of the year presume complete delivery of our 2020 backlog. That would mean slightly more than 11,000 railcars delivered in 2020. Rail manufacturing booked orders for 2,000 railcars during the third quarter, mostly larger complex transactions that show the strength of Trinity's rail platform and our capacity to tailor solutions for customers. Those orders were largely for 2021 delivery and reflect competitive market pricing. We keep seeing a solid pipeline of inquiries for railcars, both new and existing. As is true for so many others, our business keeps running with an even stronger focus on the health and well-being of our people. Looking ahead across the next few years, we expect the broader economic recovery to drive more rail shipments and equipment demand as business and consumer confidence returns and shippers throughout the continent gain confidence in making long-term capital decisions. Railcar loadings bounced back in the third quarter from the historical declines seen earlier this year. Even so, market uncertainty keeps obscuring near-term demand for railcars, since much of the economy stays under pressure because of the COVID-19 pandemic. We stay cautiously optimistic about the trajectory of demand as we head into next year. With the range of possibilities tied to potential scenarios for the economy, the election and the pandemic, we still operate in a very fluid environment and have chosen not to provide guidance. Even so, we are dedicated to enhancing the financial performance of our platform, and we think much of that improvement lies within our control. A recovery in the cycle, whenever it comes, will serve as an added tailwind. Eric, I'll hand it over to you to talk about some of our financial initiatives.
Eric Marchetto
executiveThanks, Jean, and good morning to all of you. Trinity's platform has shown it can produce substantial cash flow by originating railcar transactions that take advantage of the synergies built into our business model. In our view, the cash generated by this platform, together with our capacity to optimize the balance sheet inside a disciplined capital allocation framework, will deliver long-term shareholder value. In Q3, Trinity produced $129 million of cash flow from operations, which brought adjusted cash flow from operations for the year to date to $596 million. Investments during the quarter included roughly $183 million of net lease investment tied to new railcar additions and fleet modifications, plus $29 million for other enterprise capital expenditures. As Jean mentioned, optimizing the Trinity rail platform has been a central focus for both management and the Board over the past year. We are pursuing optimization across every part of our organization, our operations and our balance sheet. Pairing balance sheet optimization with a disciplined capital allocation framework highlights our commitment to operating as a returns-focused company; we made further progress in Q3, and since the quarter closed, in raising leverage on our lease fleet to bring down our cost of capital. In late July, we finished upsizing our TRL 2017 financing, adding $225 million of debt funded at LIBOR plus 1.50%. Earlier this week, we also redeemed $153 million of secured railcar equipment notes carrying interest at 3.8%, and issued a new $156 million securitization carrying interest just below 2%. We continue to evaluate the capital markets and to seize on an attractive interest rate environment in order to bring down our cost of capital. Trinity is performing in line with the base case scenario we gave investors as a guidepost when the pandemic began. As envisioned in that base case scenario, we have kept our dividend and finished our share repurchase authorization. In Q3, we returned roughly $111 million of capital to shareholders via dividends and completion of our share repurchase authorization. Our returns to shareholders over the last 12 months came to $275 million, approximately 11% of our market cap as of yesterday. Earlier this week, the Board authorized a new share repurchase program after we finished our second such authorization since the spinoff 2 years ago. The new $250 million authorization runs through the end of 2021. Returning capital to shareholders is a key element of our investment story and is made possible by strong cash flows resulting from the synergies of our platform; we are highly focused on maintaining a strong balance sheet, which you will see on Page 5 of the supplemental materials. As of the end of Q3, the company had committed available liquidity of approximately $719 million in the form of cash and cash equivalents and availability under our various credit lines. Right now, we're carrying an income tax receivable of $485 million, and that provides us with stronger visibility into cash flow across the coming quarters. That receivable stems directly from the tax-efficient advantages that exist between our leasing and manufacturing operations, and when those benefits get reinvested under our disciplined capital allocation framework, they ought to create still greater value for shareholders. We continue to hold substantial financial flexibility and stay in close contact with our capital providers. Our committed credit facilities are sufficient, and our RIV partners are eager to take on additional assets through our programs. When the third quarter closed, we had $1.4 billion in unencumbered railcar assets sitting on our balance sheet. Those railcars could be turned into cash via leverage or through secondary market transactions. It's our view that our balance sheet and financial strength allow Trinity to steer through the volatility brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic and to seize opportunities that might arise for creating long-term shareholder value. Because of the uncertainty in the market, we keep evaluating our financial condition and business performance in a very fluid manner, looking at a range of scenarios. Conditions in the railcar industry are getting better, yet headwinds remain that must be addressed before we're on track for a full recovery. Those conditions make it hard to forecast our business and to offer earnings guidance; where we have greater control over our performance, we are dedicated to giving specific financial targets. As 2021 gets underway, we'll take another look at market conditions and, insofar as we're able, share expectations regarding our financial performance and capital allocation; with a strong balance sheet to shield us against ongoing market disruption, we think we're positioned well to react to a swift inflection in market demand if conditions improve. To wrap up, we've established a disciplined capital allocation framework centered on lifting our returns. During our Investor Day, we'll set out what we expect the impact of balance sheet and other optimization efforts to be on our returns. Through aggressive cost control measures, disciplined capital allocation, and selective moves to boost returns from our owned lease portfolio, we believe we'll put Trinity on a path toward accelerating our financial performance. I'll hand the call back to Jean now for closing comments.
E. Savage
executiveThanks, Eric. You know, this is a really thrilling moment for Trinity, for our employees, and I think for our investors too. A lot has been discussed regarding the clear difficulties we faced across 2020, yet this year has brought enormous positive transformation to Trinity. Our efforts have positioned us to make a fresh start, adopt a new perspective, and embrace a new operating model; beyond the chance to sharpen our strategy and operating structure, I noted during my first earnings call as CEO that I see a genuine opportunity to speed up Trinity's standing as an industry leader in the railcar market by way of innovative products and services. We think this strategy will move Trinity toward a business model built on higher quality and recurring relationships. The centerpiece of our strategic framework, which we will present at our Investor Day, will center on these themes: first, to optimize the returns and performance of our fleet; second, to reduce the cyclicality of our business model; and third, to increase the modal advantage of the railcar industry. We're eager to talk through these subjects and more with all of you on November 19; and at this point we'll take some time to respond to your questions regarding our third quarter performance results. Operator, could you please provide our listeners with the instructions for the Q&A session.
Bascome Majors
analystWhen we examine the typical selling price that the backlog suggests, it appears a lower revaluation might have occurred during this quarter. Could you address that? If that's what happened, what's causing it? And perhaps you could share thoughts regarding when and how large additional manufacturing consolidations will be, the ones you hinted at during your prepared comments.
E. Savage
executiveAll right. Regarding the backlog, this was simply a materials cost correction that we observed. So cancellations played no part; it was purely the materials adjustment. On facility rationalization, we noted that production lines must be finished before any modifications become possible. A portion of that involves personnel, and a portion involves the plant itself. When reviewing our sites, we consider which workflow we've dedicated to each. Should we observe that shrinking, or should we decide to relocate that work somewhere else, then we can act — determining, let's say, which sites stay and matter for the business going forward, versus those we'll proceed to shrink or eliminate.
Bascome Majors
analystAlright. Regarding the Leasing segment, the margin came in above its historical level. Part of what you mentioned involves the depreciation decrease stemming from the small cube covered hopper write-down, yet maintenance expense was also a fairly significant contributor there. I'm simply wondering, when it comes to maintenance, what is causing that? And how durable is this reduced run rate as we think ahead toward profitability in that segment?
E. Savage
executiveSo when you take a look at year-to-date, our maintenance expense has declined roughly 15%. A portion of that stems from the reality that people aren't handing back the cars; thus, when you lack the cars, the work cannot be performed. Other portions of that come from our capacity to handle more of that work in-house. And when we're able to perform that work in-house, we can bring down the cost and enhance the turn times. And then the third portion of that involves the AAR expense. The work being performed under AAR billing is reduced. So that would be more along the lines of running repair-type work, rather than the planned repair. So those factors together produce the improvement that you're observing.
Bascome Majors
analystWould you say any portion of that can hold up over time? Or does it simply reflect a bunch of factors converging within one quarter?
E. Savage
executiveMy view is that certain pieces of it can last. When we once more examine what we're able to shift over into health, we have demonstrated yet again that performing that work internally costs us less; and once more, the vehicles cycle faster, meaning they reach our customers sooner. Then when it comes to the AAR, manpower has been cut across their networks by the railroads. In my opinion, that could be exerting a slight effect on what they can handle regarding certain running repairs. Another point — everyone benefits when those kinds of fixes happen either at the start, the origin point, or once those loads are finished. That way, you avoid halting or interfering with traffic movement.
Bascome Majors
analystAll right. That's my final question. I understand you've mentioned a far more substantial update on capital returns is coming in a month at your Investor Day. However, as I remember it, given the character of some of that tax-free spending you carried out, and with the 2-year anniversary approaching, certain restrictions existed on how much you could recapitalize the business. You're nearly at the point of lapping that — does this create a chance for you to act more boldly, maybe through another ASR or by accelerating part of this additional $250 million buyback that was just authorized? And even if that's something you can't address, I'm wondering whether the 2021 end date suggests you're aiming to finish this $250 million before next year is over.
Eric Marchetto
executiveYes, Bascome, Eric here. Regarding an ASR, that capability definitely exists on our end, though nothing has been made public; the thing is, the $250 million authorization carries a somewhat narrower window than what we typically attach, expiring at the close of next year, as you pointed out; and assuming business conditions hold, as we stated in April when releasing our base case and stress case, under our base case we anticipate satisfying our prior authorization, which we did — it was finished this quarter. So should matters keep moving on that path, we'd anticipate getting it done. If the market shifts, we'll make adjustments.
Matt Elkott
analystJean, was that figure of 11,000 deliveries for this year that you mentioned? Did I get that right?
E. Savage
executiveThat's correct — I stated a bit more than 11,000 deliveries for this year. Yes.
Matt Elkott
analystAll right. So the delivery figure for the fourth quarter, I believe, is a little more than 1,700. What I'd like to know is how much margin downside will accompany that reduced delivery figure. In other words, are we heading — to what extent — are we heading into negative territory?
E. Savage
executiveWell, guidance isn't something we're providing, so what that margin will be is not something I can tell you. However, the effort we've put in throughout this year, which we'll discuss in November, involves getting the structure in place. Consequently, even during a typical downturn, negative territory isn't where we'll end up. Some strides have been made on that front. You've observed that in the figures we're presenting to you in the supplemental materials; thus, to assist you, a lot of improvements have been made. Guidance is simply not something I can give.
Matt Elkott
analystAlright, so there's a reasonable chance the margin holds up pretty well in Q4 even with deliveries coming in lower?
E. Savage
executiveYes, that's a reasonable possibility.
Matt Elkott
analystYes? Okay. Then here's another thing, a broader question about the industry. Rail traffic has begun moving the right way, and in all likelihood we'll see growth in rail traffic going forward that hopefully can be sustained. But I believe this will be the first time ever that growth in rail traffic happens while every railroad is rolling out PSR. Are you folks beginning to receive calls from current or prospective customers who are worried about that? Or looking at it from your side — based on what customers tell you, are you picking up any hint of disruption across the rail network?
E. Savage
executiveSo Matt, calls from customers with that worry aren't coming in. At this point, I'd say everybody is just cautiously optimistic that the direction of things is right. 3 consecutive weeks showing year-over-year improvement — in the total rail traffic numbers, that's something we hadn't seen since the start of 2019, and I think it has all of us thinking maybe the direction there is right. And on top of that, 75,000 cars have come out of storage during the last quarter. So that's another strong signal that things could be trending upward, so the bottom may be behind us and the upturn may have begun.
Matt Elkott
analystAnd then, if I could, one final item regarding the guardrail segment. In your release, I saw that a factor behind the SG&A decrease was reduced mitigation risk, and I suppose that might relate to court system disruption from the pandemic. But I believe the broader risk facing you folks is largely behind you on that front; so once this entire litigation matter is fully resolved, might this segment be something you'd consider divesting?
E. Savage
executiveIn the past we've discussed that, at the appropriate time, we would explore potentially selling off the highway business to a suitable partner; so does that remain a possibility? Yes, we would entertain it. We simply need to ensure it makes sense for us within the marketplace. And as you pointed out, the litigation has reached a stage where that could occur.
James Bardowski
analystThis is James Bardowski, sitting in for Gordon. On the subject of optimizing your balance sheet — I recall that in the past, your goal was roughly 60% to 65% leverage. Last quarter, you reported 57.9%. Has that earlier leverage target been modified at all?
Eric Marchetto
executiveJames, it's Eric Marchetto. No, that 60% to 65% target is something we've discussed; no change has been made to it; at present, as you noted, we're sitting at approximately 58%. As I mentioned during my prepared remarks, conditions in the capital markets are highly attractive at the moment. So we will — as I noted, we completed a transaction just earlier this week. And we're — those markets will remain something we continue to assess.
James Bardowski
analystAll right, that's helpful. I also recall that in the second quarter press release, you folks brought this up — you increased the cap on your leverage covenant. Could you give us a quick refresher on what the new target happens to be?
Eric Marchetto
executiveWe never said what that new target was, to be clear. What we did do is make adjustments to our covenants when we released both the base case and the stress case scenario in April. In examining the stress case, we searched for ways to mitigate different items, and one item we were focused on was making certain there was plenty of liquidity available to us. As a result, we went to our corporate revolver banks and got that covenant amended, and it will be in effect through 2021. Our view was that this amounted to a solid, low-cost insurance policy should we find ourselves in a stress environment.
James Bardowski
analystAll right, that's useful. Really useful. You also said this new Midwest facility is probably going to weigh on your margins. I realize this is sort of drifting into guidance territory, but do you have any sense of — or could you share any sense of how big that drag might be, or how long it might stick around?
E. Savage
executiveThis is Jean. During my prepared remarks, I did state that the facility would be accretive in 2021. So it comes down to the fact that you need to ramp up the facility, ensure you obtain the volumes and the training to cover all the cost; and that's likely as far as I can go without providing any guidance.
James Bardowski
analystYeah, that's reasonable, that's reasonable. Then I'll pose just one additional question, after which I'll pass it along. During the prior quarter, roughly 40% of your backlog was anticipated to be recognized in the current year, which aligns pretty much exactly with the 11,000 shipments you just provided guidance on today. So can we safely conclude that the 2,000 orders you booked are meant for next year? Could you briefly discuss the composition of those orders? Earlier you noted that these transactions tend to be more intricate. Yet when examining the order value, it has fallen about 30% compared to the same period last year. So where do you actually see the genuine value?
E. Savage
executiveSo in looking at that, when I describe something as complex, I mean our capacity to collaborate with certain customers and perhaps accept some railcar types they no longer require back into our fleet, which we can then redeploy and lease out, supplying them with a newly built car plus management or possibly maintenance services for those cars; so it involves crafting a deal that goes beyond simply selling a car. That's what I mean by complex. Regarding the 2,000 cars we did secure, much of what we discussed during the second quarter materialized, though there was additionally a combination of other cars.
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystI'd like to focus on where costs can be cut. Your approach to reducing expenses has been quite forceful, and that's understandable. That said, when you consider — and you're weighing, I'd call them additional possibilities — ought we to view those as leaning more toward cyclical factors? Or is it that, simply due to things like falling volumes, some bigger — I suppose, more substantial structural openings are opening up for you? Could you shed any light on that?
E. Savage
executiveWe're examining both angles. On the structural front, though, efforts are underway to guarantee that our plants retain the processes with greater added value, while either outsourcing or turning to our suppliers for a portion of the lesser value add. Once that effort unfolds, it will move out of our plant. For us, that becomes a more structural lowering of costs. Then, when we consider possibly divesting certain nonoperational sites or putting them up for sale, that too represents a structural step for us; so any chance to cut costs that we spot is on our radar, and we're methodically sorting them into what might be structural versus what could be cyclical; we aim to put ourselves in a good position. We've repeatedly mentioned aiming for a reduced breakeven threshold and ensuring that throughout a cycle, our margins can be achieved in a way that's better managed, or within a set band. There will be more discussion of this in November.
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystThat's useful. And I'd add, I realize you plan to cover this a bit further in November regarding production and reducing that inconsistency. Within that, I suppose, are you somewhat tightening what you'd be prepared to construct as a consequence?
E. Savage
executiveWhat we're up to is we continue to have a wide scope. We construct for our own needs and for other companies. We anticipate carrying on with that. It's simply the manner in which we build. Once more, through handling a portion of that outside contracting, we'll require fewer workers to turn out the identical quantity of vehicles we made previously. When we examine our indirect and direct material expenses, or the services we purchase and incorporate those expenses. Every single thing we're reviewing is assisting us in bringing those expenses down and ensuring that when an upturn arrives, we avoid a significant rise in our cost structure to achieve that.
Justin Long
analystI'd like to ask you about the lease fleet eliminations. When you look at the implied margins there, in the prior quarter they came in at roughly 7%, while Rail Group margins were roughly 2%. During Q3, looking at the implied margins on those lease fleet eliminations, they dropped quite a bit, down to 1.6%, which was nearer to what the Rail Group showed us. Did mix alone account for that narrowing gap? And perhaps you could discuss how you see that gap moving ahead — ought those figures come more into line?
Eric Marchetto
executiveJustin, Eric here. The brief response is yes, they ought to. Let me give a bit of detail. Whenever we sell railcars — or whenever railcars get moved from our manufacturing segment over to our leasing segment, those get moved at market. So assuming the mix stays the same, margins ought to look quite alike on the eliminations compared with the rail segment, taking into account — there are other elements feeding into it, lease rates, and so on. Car types, and so on. But broadly, those ought to shift together.
Justin Long
analystAll right. And it seems that as we move ahead, you don't expect big shifts in the blend of what gets delivered to outside customers compared with what goes to the lease fleet internally.
Eric Marchetto
executiveAs we move ahead, no guidance is being given by us, though once more, assuming mix were — if you hold mix constant, those ought to match up — the elimination margin and the segment margin really ought to match up. That segment margin contains additional items, like maintenance services plus other items, yet the bulk would track alongside the rail segment margin.
Justin Long
analystAll right, understood. That helps. There was also some discussion about what to expect for deliveries this year. Still, looking at the backlog right now, can you say how many units are already committed for 2021? And on margins, I realize you aren't providing formal guidance, but looking at those locked-in 2021 deliveries, directionally, could margins improve relative to the last couple of quarters?
E. Savage
executiveWe aren't issuing guidance, so honestly I can't give you a figure for units committed. That said, I'll return to the point that the efforts underway this year—which will carry on, and which we'll discuss in November—are aimed at lowering our overall cost structure. When that cost structure comes down, that ought to let higher margins emerge from it. So if we stay on the course we've been following, and we've been telling you our goals and expectations, then we tell you once we exceed them. Even in the release just issued, we noted that we reached $80 million, which we had said would be $70 million, and we aren't finished. So we'll keep examining ways to enhance those margins—not only near term, not only during the trough of the cycle, but also how we can alter our methods and modes to support performance across the whole cycle.
Justin Long
analystAnd then only one more brief item. You brought up how the quantity of railcars sitting in storage is declining. In your opinion, what does that share of idle cars have to reach before replacement-driven orders for brand-new railcars become more prevalent?
E. Savage
executiveThe thing we've got to accomplish is pushing the active railcar count up to roughly 85%, somewhere in that mid-80s band, 85% to 87%. Once that volume is in service, you'll observe considerably more newly built railcars leaving the shops; and one extra bit of context for you, beyond new units being delivered, some railcars have been scrapped during this year. And via Q3, 40,000 railcars had been scrapped. Should you apply that pace through year-end, that would mean somewhere between 50,000 and 55,000 getting scrapped. And for deliveries this year, per third-party sources, the figure is roughly 31,000. Consequently, we will in fact witness a net shrinkage of the fleet this year, and that kind of contraction hasn't occurred over the past 10 years. So that too helps by removing certain cars from the network and afterward creating the requirement for additional new railcar deliveries.
Steve Barger
analystJean, you mentioned that you anticipate changing how rail shipping works down the road; that sounds like quite a daring claim. Could you expand a bit on rail pulse, or on the way fleet analytics is going to reshape this industry?
E. Savage
executiveOf course. In past conversations we've noted that PSR truly centers on only 1 railroad within its own network and on what that carrier alone can accomplish. To genuinely have an impact on that supply chain, we need coverage spanning the whole system — the entire ecosystem — meaning we have to cross between railroads and among various lessors, so that this information becomes visible and shippers can make well-informed choices and get past certain obstacles that keep them from shifting out of trucking and into rail.
Steve Barger
analystSo really, in that case, you'd be approaching things from the car side, seeking to assist the Class 1s with how smoothly the system flows, or simply with achieving improved use of assets.
E. Savage
executiveThe railroads aren't the only ones involved in this; they certainly have a role to play; what's really happening is support for the shippers. Since when shippers feel sure about their supply chain and know they can keep inventories at a level they can maintain, without stressing over whether product arrives on schedule, so that utilization of assets overall is as high as possible, the stronger position we'll all be in across the industry.
Steve Barger
analystSure. I can guess what folks will want to know, and that's this: if the system becomes more fluid, doesn't that suggest you'd ultimately require fewer units of equipment?
E. Savage
executiveThat's one possible reading. Beyond that, railroads keep sending out their share of the railcars. And should modal share rise, that would be an excellent route to growing how many railcars are required. It's more sustainable; we truly must keep spreading that message. When it comes to transportation modes besides shipping, moving goods across the U.S. by rail ranks as the second most sustainable option; so we really need to ensure people get that, particularly when they're discussing ESG.
Steve Barger
analystYes, got it. So you mentioned the net decrease in fleet size for this year, and during the last several quarters, you've brought up expectations of gaining market share. I'm just wondering how you see the railcar fleet's own path shaping up across the coming years. I suppose, on the present fleet of 1.7 million cars, would you take the over or the under?
E. Savage
executiveWow, that — I haven't given that one any thought. That one might be a bit difficult. What I will say is that I expect, or we are expecting, that for next year you could see a contraction, or more railcars being scrapped than new ones being delivered. Beyond that, I don't know that I'm ready to respond. We might be able to follow up.
Eric Marchetto
executiveSteve, one more thing I'd mention is that if you consider the flammable fleet in light of the rules that have been issued, certain retirements are going to be necessary within that fleet, and those would come somewhat sooner than you'd expect given a car life of 50 years. So there's going to be something of a rightsizing event as those rules — as the deadlines for those rules arrive, meaning 2023 in the case of ethanol, plus 2025 and 2029 for the other flammable products. That's going to bring about somewhat more attrition than would have been typical in the past.
Steve Barger
analystYeah, that's precisely where I was heading — you're going to see certain flammable vehicles come out, and you likely have some sand cars that may be permanently impaired. So to stay flat, you'd need fleet growth in the mid-single digits, and maybe 10% growth to demonstrate real upside; so the question becomes which types of cars might grow enough to offset that sort of reduction we're discussing?
Eric Marchetto
executiveWell, I believe you're still going to have — I mean, everything depends on industrial production and where it expands, and that's what — a few of the items we're examining as North America — as certain things and the onshoring that could occur if that keeps up, then industrial production would rise, and you're going to observe that — we believe rail will be well positioned to serve industrial production, particularly if we can achieve modal share growth. And then you can consider — one strong example there is on — is whether it's agricultural and food type products, and much of that currently moves by truck; and if we can successfully shift more of that to rail then that — there's a chance for growth.
Jessica Greiner
executiveThanks, David. Like Jean said, we can't wait to connect with all of you once more in 4 weeks, at our Investor Day coming up on November 19. You can register now for that webcasted event, and the sign-up link is on the Events & Presentations section of our site. One more thing to keep in mind: we anticipate that Trinity will submit our Form 10-Q sometime in the next week. Should you have any questions about the press release covering the company's quarterly financial results, I'd be glad to follow up with you. After 1:00 Eastern Standard Time, a replay of today's call will be accessible until midnight on October 29, 2020. The number to dial in is 402 to 220 to 1140. You'll also find a webcast replay on the Events & Presentations page of our Investor Relations website, which is at www.trin.net. That wraps up today's conference call. Thanks for being with us this morning.
Operator
operatorThank you for your participation, and you may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Trinity Industries, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Trinity Industries, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Trinity Industries, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.