Trinity Industries, Inc. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 24, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jessica Greiner
executiveThanks, Kate, and hello to all of you this morning. My name is Jessica Greiner, and I serve as Vice President of Investor Relations and Communications at Trinity. We're glad you could be with us for the rescheduled conference call covering the company's fourth quarter 2020 financial results. That rescheduling followed the weather-related events that hit Texas and the surrounding areas last week. During our prepared remarks, you'll hear from Jean Savage, who is Trinity's Chief Executive Officer and President, as well as Eric Marchetto, our Chief Financial Officer. Once our leaders finish their prepared remarks, we'll move into a Q&A session. On today's call, we'll be referencing a few slides that highlight the key points of discussion. You can find the supplemental materials on our IR website at www.trin.net; look for these slides in the Events & Presentations section of the site, where the fourth quarter earnings call event link also appears; they're available live during the webcast as well; at this point, I'm pleased to hand the call over to Jean.
E. Savage
executiveJessica, thank you, and good morning to all of you. I want to begin on Slide 3, picking up from where we stopped at our Investor Day back in November of last year. We presented our plan for Trinity's Rail platform aimed at achieving top-tier financial results and putting capital to work to create value. For Trinity, 2020 brought remarkable transformation, and steering that shift toward becoming a business centered on cash flow and returns while a worldwide pandemic was underway made it even harder. Even so, our team came together and took tough steps that have set Trinity up to speed up its financial results. I'd like to praise our employees for how they've stayed dedicated to the company, to one another, to our customers, and to everyone with a stake in our success. As I begin my comments, I think there are multiple bright spots from what we achieved in the fourth quarter and fiscal year 2020 that leave us well positioned going forward. To start, we've united our business behind a core purpose and set forth our plan for boosting the company's returns. Those strategic efforts centered on refining our business structure and expanding our products and services to grow modal share within the railcar sector. Next, consistent with that plan, during 2020 Trinity finished the great majority of the restructuring work we had scheduled. We additionally moved forward on utilizing Trinity's balance sheet within our intended capital structure; we anticipate further strides in bringing down our total cost structure during 2021. Then, Trinity's rail platform demonstrated its durability through the unmatched market turmoil caused by COVID-19, producing robust cash flow from operations. And last, there's room to give more capital back to shareholders, thanks to the appealing cash flow characteristics of our business and the improved capital allocation framework we introduced at our Investor Day. We're genuinely enthusiastic about what lies ahead and fully anticipate that 2021 will bring execution on our plan to push the company forward. We think we have multiple levers available to us for enhancing our performance, and we'll keep you informed of those results as we go. Now to Slide 4. Let's go through the main financial highlights. What we delivered financially in the fourth quarter mirrors weaker railcar demand, since rail traffic dropped when COVID-19 emerged last spring. Consequently, revenue for the fourth quarter came in at $416 million, a drop of roughly 51% from the prior year. Our fourth quarter GAAP loss of $1.13 mainly captures onetime charges taken during that quarter. Trinity's adjusted EPS of $0.04 was down versus the previous year because of fewer deliveries and weaker railcar pricing. Trinity's team acted swiftly and worked hard to remove cost from the business. Lost efficiency stemming from production cutbacks weighed on our cost structure. Although our leasing operations remained stable through the tough market, reduced lease portfolio sales and railcar deliveries generated an earnings headwind across the full year. Our total GAAP loss for the year of $1.27 was down 217% year-over-year, and 2020 adjusted earnings dropped 71% to $0.37 per share. When it comes to how we performed on earnings in the COVID-19 setting, we're not pleased. Still, significant and steady cash flows keep coming from our platform. Cash flow from continuing operations in the fourth quarter came to $195 million, a drop of only 15% versus the previous year. After all investments and dividends, free cash flow of $64 million fell 51% compared with the fourth quarter of 2019. Now turning to Slide 5 for the full year, operating cash flow reached $652 million, a substantial year-over-year gain. Because we kept a more conservative capital structure through the pandemic, free cash flow of $113 million was down roughly 22%, reflecting greater leasing equity CapEx for the year. In a minute, both Eric and I will walk through the performance factors behind these results; but what matters most from our consolidated fourth quarter and full year metrics is that Trinity's rail platform produced resilient and stable cash flow in a very difficult market, which speaks to the valuable synergies inside the business. Broadly speaking, the market we operate in remains soft yet is getting better. On Slide 6. Rail volumes, which track closely with U.S. economic output, have basically made up the ground lost during the first half of 2020. Agricultural and consumer-related markets show the strongest recovery. For energy-related commodities such as crude and coal, railcar loadings keep trailing the recovery because of the economic shutdown's impact. Industry railcar utilization is improving as well. Since railcars in storage peaked last summer, more than 125,000 railcars have gone back into service or been sent for scrap. Our estimate is that close to 51,000 railcars were scrapped during 2020, producing the first year of an industry fleet contraction in more than a decade. We expect this elevated pace of scrapping to continue so long as higher steel prices incentivize railcar owners to scrap older assets. While the industry railcar storage rate of 24% remains above the 5-year average, the trend is a relevant indicator for the health of the railcar industry. Looking at the bottom 2 charts, specific Trinity's business, we generally see the sector-specific impacts of an industry recovery first within our lease fleet before we see improvements in new railcar demand. During 2020, lease rates declined significantly compared to its filing lease rates as a result of lower demand for railcars. As rail traffic has picked back up, lease fleet utilization is stabilizing; we are also beginning to see early improvement in sequential railcar lease rates with the future lease rate differential, FLRD metric inflecting positively during the fourth quarter. We introduced this metric at our Investor Day to provide investors a sense of headwinds or tailwinds the current pricing environment will have upon Trinity's lease portfolio in the near term. Orders during the fourth quarter were low as expected and, for the year, represents the lowest number of orders since the financial crisis in 2009. This is not surprising given the availability of railcars within the industry and the current projections for a slowly recovering industrial economy. We're experiencing a big year-over-year rise in the volume of inquiries coming from shippers and Class 1 railroads about railcar equipment that's available. It's too early to say when those inquiries will translate into better lease utilization, rates, and new railcar orders, but it's a very encouraging signal for the rail market's recovery. Based on where things stand right now, we anticipate a modest rebound in demand for railcars during the back half of 2021. Trinity's market-leading platform, along with our experience managing through railcar cycles, lets us respond quickly to shifting market dynamics and satisfy customer demand. Even more important, while the railcar market will likely only get to a more normalized or replacement level market in the near term, we're confident in our capacity to execute our strategy and enhance our financial performance. Shifting from the industry to Trinity's results on Slide 7. The worth and steadiness of Trinity's leasing business became readily apparent as the year went on. Our lease fleet utilization dropped initially in the first quarter of the year, then went on to hover around 95% utilization through 2020; we're highly focused on keeping our utilization where it is and are seeing green shoots of improvement across various railcar types.
E. Savage
executiveRoughly 17% of what we owned came due for renewal during 2020, which held down how much falling lease rates could drag on the leasing business's top line. Better lease pricing on railcars we brought into the fleet largely cancelled out the pressure from utilization and reduced renewal rates, and leasing plus management revenue slipped about 1% versus the prior year. As we look at 2021, about 20% of the portfolio is scheduled for renewal, and the pricing headwind should be smaller, as the FLRD metric shows. Our leasing group did an outstanding job holding down maintenance costs to counter the earnings hit from the segment's revenue drop. Segment profit also got a lift from our depreciation policy change, which lengthened asset useful lives and better captures the economics of owning railcars. Several efforts are underway to bring down our total maintenance cost structure by leaning more on our internal network and bringing advanced technologies into our maintenance cleaning processes. Turning to next year, 2021 will bring a heavier compliance load for maintenance events, so making the most of our maintenance platform will be essential. Rail Products had a tough year, since a shrinking backlog forced us to cut production and lay off workers at both our production and maintenance facilities. Weaker pricing and the unabsorbed burdens from reduced deliveries weighed on margin all year long. In the fourth quarter, results were further affected by start-up costs for our new maintenance facility in the Midwest and idling costs at other nonstrategic facilities, which left the segment at breakeven margin. We do expect continued headwinds to segment performance in the first quarter of this year from lower volumes, more headcount reduction and additional maintenance facility start-up costs. We expect our cost savings initiatives to start helping segment performance in the second half of the year and to drive year-over-year improvement in segment margin. Before handing the call to Eric for a deeper look at our financial results, let me wrap up with a Slide 8 update on our efforts to boost Trinity's returns. First, as a reminder, we think we have a number of levers available to lift our pretax ROE performance to a mid-teen level across the cycle. The strategic initiatives fall under 2 focus areas: optimization and growth. As we laid out at our Investor Day, our rail platform holds significant information value, and we are confident we can monetize that value across services, parts and solutions. In 2020, our balance sheet optimization was modest, reflecting a healthy level of near-term liquidity and our choice to keep a more conservative capital structure through the pandemic. Over the year, our net debt rose approximately $135 million. Looking ahead to 2021, we anticipate putting more leverage onto the balance sheet, since we'll have chances to put that capital to work. On the SG&A side, during 2020 we delivered more than $35 million in annualized reductions to administrative costs. We'll keep assessing possibilities for trimming SG&A through better processes and managing vendors, and as we always do, we'll match the cost structure of our support organization to the scale of the whole business. To boost how our manufacturing performs, we're proceeding with supply chain programs aimed at increasing the worth of outsourced fabrication work done at our facilities. Once these are executed, we anticipate that roughly $45 million in cyclical headcount cost savings from 2020 will become structural savings. After the year ended, we also made a small investment to buy a railcar cleaning business that uses sophisticated proprietary robotics. Over the coming few years, we anticipate expanding this technology across our facilities, which will raise the efficiency of our production operations generally and lift margins in the rail segment. Turning to fleet optimization, we plan to invest modestly in moving certain railcars into other commodity service that we think has stronger demand profiles over the longer term. We likewise anticipate finishing a modest amount of portfolio sales out of our lease fleet to financial investment partners whose capital has lower hurdles. Earlier this month, our commercial team felt a great deal of excitement in formally rolling out the new Trinsight digital service offering to customers. Trinsight delivers real-time intelligence regarding the location, condition, and status of railcar equipment, which yields rail transportation efficiency and safety that strengthen rail feed operations for shippers. This product offering fits with our sustainability commitment and stands as a key initiative within our business strategy for improving the rail-mobile supply chain as a whole. Through beta testing of the product, Trinsight is bringing in a modest amount of revenue, and shippers who are interested in the service have responded very positively since the launch. It's certainly early days, but given improving fundamentals and how confident we are in the strategy we've built, looking ahead at Trinity makes for an exciting time. With that, I'll hand the call to Eric now so he can walk through our quarterly results.
Eric Marchetto
executiveThanks, Jean, and good morning to all of you. As Jean mentioned, Trinity's Q4 shows railcar demand continuing to soften because of the COVID-19 pandemic. On top of that, a number of one-time items affected our operating results in the fourth quarter. These adjustments mostly involve the impact of the pension plan settlement, plus later-stage restructuring work, such as write-downs on manufacturing-related assets. We also recorded a benefit tied to our final 2020 income tax provision stemming from tax law changes enacted in 2020. Beginning with the income statement section of Slide 9. Total revenues and adjusted earnings mirror a difficult RevPAR market, with railcar deliveries falling and pricing getting softer. Given these reduced levels of manufacturing earnings, the timing of railcar sales along with swings in lease and operations and legal and administrative expense have produced differing effects on our earnings results. In the fourth quarter, Trinity took 2 impairment charges tied to restructuring efforts and other market-related factors. The first charge was a noncash write-down on existing maintenance facilities that didn't match our operational strategy or cost profile and are now classified as assets held for sale. Our maintenance business has realigned how it operates to concentrate on large, full-service railcar maintenance facilities, which lets us serve trace railcar lease fleet and our strategic customers better and more promptly. The second charge was a write-off tied to an investment in emerging technology for advanced steel materials, where the third party couldn't secure adequate funding and is in the process of liquidating. Turning to our cash flow. Total cash from operations in 2020 rose year-over-year thanks to the cash flow synergies of Trinity's rail platform and the countercyclical effects of working capital from our balance sheet. Trinity produced roughly $652 million in cash flow from operations. With the sequential fourth quarter increase coming mainly from receipt of a $64 million income tax receivable. At year-end, we hold approximately $446 million in income tax receivable tied to the 2019 and 2020 tax years; we now expect the 2019 refund to arrive in the first half of this year. Trinity put about $102 million last year into manufacturing and other company Capex. That included building out our maintenance facility in the Midwest. We also made a net investment of roughly $464 million in our lease fleet. Taking into account the effects of modest leverage on new lease fleet additions and associated debt amortization during the year, our equity CapEx needed for this investment came to $484 million in 2020. Total free cash flow after all investments and dividends paid to investors was $113 million for the fiscal year. Trinity returned a total of $285 million to shareholders in 2020, including dividends of $92 million and an additional $193 million in share repurchases. At year-end, we have approximately $182 million left under our current authorization, which runs through the end of 2021. Also, before proceeding, we'd like to direct investor attention toward a prospective shift in how portfolio sales from our lease fleet are treated. Going forward, every railcar sale out of the lease fleet will be shown as a net gain on disposal of a long-lived asset; our reporting ought to become simpler for investors because of this. Presentation of our cash flow statement and of net investment in new lease fleet additions will be modestly impacted by this change, yet the net effect on our free cash flow metric for segment operating profit will stay the same. Right now, with market uncertainty tied to the economic recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic, we aren't offering specific earnings guidance; even so, significant cash flow comes from our business model, and we remain sharply focused on the value that deploying this capital can create. For 2021, cash flow from operations should land somewhere between $625 million and $675 million. Moving to Slide 10. Our balance sheet is well capitalized, as Jean mentioned, and total liquidity stood at $727 million when the fourth quarter closed. Over the course of the fourth quarter, we brought in more than $526 million of new debt carrying a blended interest rate of 2.4%; we figure Trinity's pretax weighted average cost of capital got better by 130 basis points across 2020, reaching roughly 5%. Rates in the capital markets for railcar securitizations are historically attractive, since ever more investors are taking part in these financings. Having pioneered the railcar securitization market back in the early 2000s, we're glad to witness this response to the asset class and look forward to benefiting further from the market during 2021. In late January, we take pride in the fact that Trinity's leasing company became the first North-American railcar lessor to put a Green Financing Framework in place. Sustainability is a commitment we take seriously at Trinity, including our pledge to lessen environmental impact. TLC's Green Financing Framework throws open Trinity's capital raising to fresh investors whose appetite for green asset investment keeps growing, and the reaction has been positive. Trinity's capital position stays very good, with plenty of liquidity, robust cash flow generation, and roughly $1.4 million in unencumbered assets. Looking at how the business performs over the long term, we feel sure that the changes made during 2020 will place our company on a course toward faster financial performance and toward unlocking shareholder value. At our Investor Day in November, we put forward 4 key long-term key performance indicators, shown here on Slide 11. Value in earnings is inherent in the cash flows from our long duration railcar assets, in platform synergies and growth opportunities, and in a disciplined capital allocation framework centered on shareholder returns. Measured across time, these indicators, we believe, together drive long-term value creation. During 2020, operating cash flow rose year-over-year, as covered earlier, while free cash flow fell modestly. Our return on equity dropped year-over-year amid deteriorating market fundamentals. Still, the business has put in place a structure aimed at lifting our results, and in our view a great number of the levers needed to make that happen sit squarely with management. Trinity followed through on its pledge to produce dividend growth in the double digits, raising the December payout by 11%, which gets paid in January 2021. Measured against 2019, our dividend growth across 2020 came to just about 12% for the year. Book value per share was down slightly versus the prior year, largely because of some one-time items. Before moving off this slide, let me restate that Trinity's strategy for driving returns and cash flows will not follow a straight line from one quarter to the next. Every step we've taken was decided with returns and cash flows in mind. How quickly the economy recovers will shape the timeline for hitting our targets, but I want to be clear that we anticipate making headway on our returns and cash flow objectives no matter what the market does, and we believe Trinity is positioned well to accomplish that. I'll wrap up our comments on Slide 11 — or Slide 12 — by restating the main takeaways from the fourth quarter fiscal year-end and our outlook for 2021. First, we set out a strategy to reposition Trinity's rail platform, boost the returns of the business and unlock shareholder value. Second, we achieved solid progress on our efforts to optimize both process and expenses throughout every part of our rail platform. We take pride in the hard work our people delivered amid the global pandemic to reposition the company for accelerating financial performance. Third, our platform showed it can generate significant cash flow even in a very challenging market environment. And last, our dedication to a capital allocation framework centered on long-term shareholder value. In 2021, we plan to further optimize our manufacturing platform by outsourcing supply chain work and integrating advanced technologies, strengthen our product portfolio through evolutionary products and services for our customers and keep optimizing our balance sheet via additional leverage, fleet modifications and portfolio sales. Uncertainty in the market could act as a financial headwind to how these initiatives land, but we believe they are critical to accelerating the company's performance. We have confidence in our ability to execute and look forward to sharing our results with you throughout the year. Kate, you may now take us to questions from our participants.
Justin Long
analystThank you, and good morning. Jean, perhaps to begin with a point — I think you made a remark regarding Rail Group margins. My understanding is you stated that margins for the second half would be stronger compared to the same period in 2020. First, I just want to confirm I heard that right; and possibly if you could share any further detail on how that plays out quarter by quarter? During the first half, you referenced certain cost pressures, with the cost savings really not taking effect until later in the year. So perhaps you could offer us a view on how margins ought to trend relative to what we observed in the fourth quarter?
E. Savage
executiveCertainly. Thank you, Justin, for asking. So regarding the real product segment, what we've observed is the pressure from highly competitive pricing in the marketplace; and additionally the surplus of railcars that have been sitting in the market ready to be deployed. Keep in mind that we made the shift to prioritizing the use of our current fleet before we bring additional cars into it. What I said during the prepared remarks was that in the first quarter, we anticipate encountering some headwinds, and that includes a continued drop in volumes. We continue to have some workforce reductions taking place. And we still have our Midwest facility ramping up. However, in the latter half of the year, we anticipate seeing the outcomes of the initiatives we currently have in motion, which would put us in positive territory. And as I mentioned, we would anticipate the Rail segment margins improving on a year-over-year basis.
Justin Long
analystAll right, but just so I understand — that applies only to the back half, not the whole year?
E. Savage
executiveNo — across the entire year, our expectation is that margins in the rail segment will get better.
Justin Long
analystAll right, that's great. My next question concerns the guidance for operating cash flow. Eric, perhaps this one's directed at you. Could you give us an update regarding the CARES Act funds you anticipate receiving during 2021? Also, has that been included in the operating cash flow guidance you provided? In addition, could you perhaps discuss what you expect on the working capital side too?
Eric Marchetto
executiveSure, Justin, Eric here. As I stated during my prepared remarks, we got our 2018 return, which came to $62 million. Back at our Investor Day, when we discussed the 2019 return, our expectation was to receive it during 2020. That didn't happen — the amount is roughly $245 million, so it now sits within the cash flow from operations figure I provided. Given how the timing worked out for the 2019 refund, the 2020 refund, roughly $190 million, is not — we aren't putting that into our cash flow projections for 2021. Essentially, there was a slide we had at — we moved 2019 into 2021, and we'll move 2020 into '21 or '22. Now regarding working capital, we saw a sizable benefit from working capital during 2020. I wouldn't anticipate that same kind of gain this year, since the bulk of it already came through in 2020. As a result, we aren't expecting large benefits from working capital.
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystI'd like to pick up on what Justin mentioned — or rather, ask about margins. You've clearly removed a significant amount of structural cost from the business model. As we hopefully begin heading toward a recovery, is there a way to frame how incremental margins should be viewed?
E. Savage
executiveAbsolutely, Allison. I'll take that one. In the investor deck, if you look at Page 18, we discussed the manufacturing margin and our plan to bring the breakeven down by 30%, and you ought to expect that margin improvement across the 3 years to go from 3 to — by 3 to 5.5 basis points. So that's what we're carrying out. When that happens will differ. It's genuinely difficult to pin down on a quarter-over-quarter or year-over-year basis, since the majority of those initiatives were multiyear projects. During 2020, we made a substantial down payment by resetting our overall cost structure, and we'll keep updating you as these initiatives get completed.
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystAll right, that's good. Now, when it comes to your lease rate trends, those have been moving in a positive direction. Clearly, storage levels across the industry have come in — we've all been watching that. Eric, I'm not sure whether this one's for you or for Jean. I'd just like some perspective on how you see that starting to develop. Are there particular areas we ought to keep an eye on when it comes to what will drive demand, at least up to something like replacement level? I suppose what I'm asking is whether you feel we're nearing that true bottom, where a bigger inflection could show up? From what you said, it sounded that way.
E. Savage
executiveSure. I'll take that one, Allison. If you look at North American carloads, on a year-to-date basis, they're off roughly 2.3%. Traffic, meanwhile, is higher by 3.3%. And when you look at those segments where the pricing is, chemicals and agriculture are the strongest for us, or the most accretive. We're still facing some headwinds in petro frac and in the coal markets. Another factor feeding into this, though, is attrition. As I said in the prepared remarks, roughly 51,000 railcars got scrapped during the last year. That's concentrated in the segments with the older or aged fleet — meaning the hoppers and the gondolas, covered hoppers and boxcars. Well, the pace of scrapping picked up as the year progressed. And my sense is that so long as scrap prices stay elevated, you'll keep seeing a greater amount of scrapping.
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystUnderstood; and I suppose what we're picking up on is scrapping, and that figure is declining. I suppose, when it comes to the uptick in orders you're getting, are you beginning to detect any willingness for replacement demand right now?
E. Savage
executiveWell, as I noted once more during the prepared remarks, the number of inquiries we're receiving is significantly higher compared with a year ago; and it's encouraging to witness that. What we still haven't observed is everybody converting those into orders. So inquiries have risen. They're showing up in the markets we referenced. You can examine those characterized by elevated utilization, few cars and storage; and for those experiencing greater scrap rates relative to demand, things are certainly improving.
Eric Marchetto
executiveI want to make sure I understood. What did you say was going down?
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystAlright, so only regarding vehicles sitting unused, that figure for inventory. Clearly, scrappage is occurring, and we're just trying to pinpoint when that turning point for replacements might arrive.
Gordon Johnson
analystLet me jump in with a couple of my own. Could you break down what portion of operating cash flow came from that one-time tax refund, meaning the CARES Act?
Eric Marchetto
executiveSure. Gordon, as I said earlier, during 2020, the amount was $62 million that came in — money that otherwise would have shown up under cash from operations.
Gordon Johnson
analystAll right, my apologies if you mentioned that already. I missed it. I'm sorry about that.
Eric Marchetto
executiveThat's fine. It's really not a problem.
Gordon Johnson
analystTurning to the FLRD, it appears to be a metric we haven't seen before. Why does it matter, and in what way is it weighed against the utilization rate, which I believe dipped somewhat during this quarter?
E. Savage
executiveThat FLRD — we presented it at the Investor Day. Its aim was to offer a glimpse ahead. A few points worth considering regarding the FLRD: first, our comps are improving on a year-over-year basis, which is a positive. Lease rates in the market have stabilized, and we've observed a slight sequential uptick. Should today's market pricing persist, our expectation is that FLRD will get better in 2021, since the renewals in our portfolio for the current year face that simpler comp. Also, we intend to give you the FLRD every quarter. So in our view it will assist you when modeling ahead and anticipating what comes from us, whether tailwinds or headwinds.
Jessica Greiner
executiveGordon, Jessica here. To give you a bit more background: back in Q3 of 2020, we included that future lease rate differential in our supplemental materials for the first time, as part of the 1-year look back we provided, so you're able to see how that metric has moved across the past 12 months.
Gordon Johnson
analystAll right. That is quite useful. Then regarding the backlog, could you provide any sense of the amount you anticipate converting this year? And whether that would be weighted toward the beginning or the end?
E. Savage
executiveCertainly. Let me take that one first, Gordon. As things stand, 60% of the backlog we have now should be delivered during 2021, and we'll find out what additional orders arrive over the course of the year.
Gordon Johnson
analystAll right, 60%. All right. That helps. And then, I suppose, I've got quite a few. Just one more, if that's all right. So this one's broader — more of a general one; it looks like there might possibly be — some views are floating around that we might be heading into something like a long-term commodity super cycle. Perhaps that's accurate, perhaps it isn't. But should that turn out to be accurate, might you gentlemen discuss how that could influence your business during this year and roughly across the coming couple of years?
Eric Marchetto
executiveSure thing. Gordon, it's Eric Marchetto here. So if we are, we're not — allow me — something you observe directly, and we're observing it right now, is elevated steel prices. Pricier steel, clearly, is the major input affecting new railcar prices. So that might bring about — if we — if what you're suggesting holds, and a commodity super cycle arrives, then that would cause, without question, asset prices, new railcars, to rise. Clearly, that could reduce some demand for railcars, yet the railcars and the margin that gets constructed would cost more; that would produce a favorable boost in lease rates, and that would give more of a push to rates on cars already in the fleet, a greater chance for those current car rates to rise; on the — leaning more toward the supply side, should a commodity super cycle occur, plenty of commodities travel by rail, be it for domestic consumption or shipments abroad. And so that would definitely affect the demand side. It sort of hinges on which direction it heads, but, I believe, on the whole, deposit...
Gordon Johnson
analystDoes the shutdown of the Keystone pipeline affect your operations at all? Would that be a benefit or a drawback?
Eric Marchetto
executiveAt this moment, I'd describe it as neutral. There hasn't been a — that pipeline has been in place, so on the margin, demand has existed. It ought to be somewhat favorable, but so far we haven't observed that.
Bascome Majors
analystEric, I'd like to build on what Justin asked and take a closer look at the cash flow guidance. Would you be able to spell out, or perhaps give a range for, the cash interest within that? And are there any other book-to-cash reconciling items that might come in unevenly, apart from the refund quantification?
Eric Marchetto
executiveJust so I understand — when you ask that, I want to be clear: do you mean interest income, interest expense? Sorry?
Bascome Majors
analystYou mentioned interest expense within operating cash flow — I just want to clarify how cash interest is being framed here.
Eric Marchetto
executiveRight, so that line wouldn't be — actually, it would show up in the income statement. Our debt levels have stayed fairly flat, honestly. Because of that, the figure ought to remain pretty consistent. Like we've said, you'll be able to check it yourself in our — once the K gets filed later today. We did get somewhat of a boost from rates coming down, though that gets canceled out by slightly larger debt balances. So compared with a year ago, my expectation is no significant movement in interest income — sorry, I keep mixing that up, I mean interest expense as reported. Anyway, you'll be able to confirm all of that once we — when you go through the K.
Bascome Majors
analystAre there any additional items bridging bookings to cash that might come through unevenly?
Eric Marchetto
executiveSome unevenness is always present in that figure, though the primary drivers will largely consist of depreciation plus amortization, which represents a substantial amount. Then I brought up a bit of modest working capital. And then, from your side, the tax receivable — absolutely that $189 million. That stands as the larger piece relative to depreciation and amortization.
Bascome Majors
analystEarlier, a few remarks were made regarding capturing certain cyclical cost reductions within the manufacturing operation and those becoming more lasting during this year. Could you discuss what the long-term footprint of that operation might look like once we've moved past this challenging cyclical period? Also, how tied is that manufacturing operation anticipated to remain over the longer term to your leasing operation, as opposed to sales made to outside parties? And do you expect that proportion to shift?
E. Savage
executiveCertainly. From our perspective, no alteration to our business model is anticipated. We believe numerous synergies will materialize. During the prior year, we did undertake substantial recalibration of that manufacturing operation to ensure that moving forward, we could achieve the margin enhancements discussed at Investor Day across that cycle. Additional initiatives will keep being pursued by us. Some of those initiatives appear on Page 20 of the investor deck. Page 50 is another place to look. It provides an outline spanning the 3 years. What I'd say is that across the 3-year cycle, changes will be made by us on an overall basis. Implementation of the strategies already established will be something we look at. And as the years pass, you ought to witness those improvements emerge. The precise timing for each individual one simply cannot be provided by me.
Bascome Majors
analystGot it. And maybe as a final point here, I'm not sure whether Jean or Eric would like to take this one, but there does appear to be an appetite among public equity investors for — when they look at backlog or businesses with long-cycle cyclicality, they assess them on mid-cycle earnings and are prepared to assign that kind of valuation even though those conditions aren't necessarily present this year or the next. Do you consider that a helpful lens through which to view Trinity's business, given the shifts you're implementing from a valuation perspective? And would you be willing to sort of sketch out for investors what that hard-to-pin-down, hypothetical mid-cycle might resemble with all the initiatives you currently have underway?
E. Savage
executiveAt Investor Day, we attempted to set out what we would anticipate regarding returns to a cycle on average; and I believe what you truly have to examine as a business is that we are moving toward a lease-focused model, with our new production and our maintenance facility supporting our overall business model. We don't anticipate ceasing to deliver new products to third parties; we believe that will be beneficial for the overall footprint we possess. But once more, our priority is to use the assets we already have, first, and after that we'll add new products into our portfolio, and we'll provide service to those third parties.
Eric Marchetto
executiveOur expectation is that this model is going to deliver. We've issued projections for returns, and given how the platform is set up with these businesses, we believe we can generate returns on equity that are very attractive.
Matt Elkott
analystEric, my understanding is that you mentioned 60% of the backlog we already have is scheduled to be delivered during this year. Given that, plus how orders and inquiries are currently behaving — and honestly, they haven't been turning into actual orders the way anyone would hope — wouldn't it be fair to think that deliveries this year might end up significantly below what we saw last year? Does that sound reasonable?
E. Savage
executiveActually, this is Jean speaking, sorry. When you consider the delivery range we observed this year, it spans from the low 20s up to 40s — that's the spread that's been discussed. Now, looking at the backlog that exists across the industry right now, in realistic terms it's likely sitting closer to 20 or the mid-20s rather than up at 40s. Getting there would require a huge wave of orders arriving extremely fast. That's because once those orders are booked, converting them into production takes 3 to 6 months.
Matt Elkott
analystEven if your deliveries end up being reduced during this year, do you remain assured regarding an increase in the operating — the manufacturing margin?
E. Savage
executiveYes, we do. There are numerous levers within our grasp that we are able to pull. It simply falls to us to carry out those initiatives effectively.
Eric Marchetto
executiveThat's exactly the reason we're working to bring down the breakeven point, isn't it? And it ought to — it will begin to show up as we deliver our results over the course of the year.
Matt Elkott
analystUnderstood. That helps. Eric, could you expand on what you said regarding the railcar securitization market being at levels that are historically favorable? What's driving that, in your view? And what might it mean for your company during this year?
Eric Marchetto
executiveBasically, what I'm saying is that last year we tapped the securitization market to the tune of roughly $500 million, and a lot more of that came in Q4 than earlier. Looking ahead, as additional players have come into this market during this year, those investors want yield, and RevPAR assets give them a risk-adjusted yield that's attractive. So that's pushing spreads lower, combined with benchmarks that are low. That explains the financing activity we're engaged in. As for what it means for us this year: when we go to the markets, my expectation is they'll be favorable, and our cost of capital will keep coming down.
Matt Elkott
analystAll right. And at various points over roughly the last 10 years, financial investors and railcar assets have shown interest, seeking yield first from domestic sources, then from Europe, and then from Japan. So what sort of investor profile are you observing at present? Is it every one of those? Or is there a particular region that stands out, where people might be beginning to consider North American railcar assets?
Eric Marchetto
executiveYeah. I believe that if you look back across about the past 10 years, we have definitely witnessed new participants arriving in the market and seeking to put money into railcars. A number of them have reduced their interest. Others have grown more interested. It somewhat hinges on where their exposures sit; however, we continue to observe interest from investors that have not yet taken part in the market and who want to enter it — for those very same reasons. They appreciate the risk-adjusted yields that come with railcar leases; they appreciate the diversity. They appreciate the potential of these assets as an inflation hedge. And so that appetite among investors is still something we see.
Matt Elkott
analystAll right, understood; and Jean, one final item. You said that interest levels have risen a great deal of late, yet converting that into actual purchases hasn't truly occurred so far. Do you have any explanation or hypothesis about why folks haven't pulled the trigger as of now?
E. Savage
executiveSo, if you examine the situation, it remains simply too soon, plus rising fuel prices are making certain parties hold back. I believe that as you keep observing how available the current fleet of railcars is, appearing or becoming more constrained, that will begin to accelerate. Another factor is doubt — when you consider COVID-19, when you consider the reality that a large number of individuals still must receive vaccinations, and then you consider how manufacturing is recovering economically; we've encountered certain supply problems, with interruptions in that area, particularly within automotive, which has taken place; so every one of those elements is contributing, with people feeling unsure and holding back.
Matt Elkott
analystAlright, and one last thing — did you put a number on how much lease rates got better during Q4?
E. Savage
executiveWell, in that investor deck you've seen, what we shared for Q3 showed a negative 21%. Then Q4 came in at minus 13.6%, so that's the inflection point — it began climbing back. And like I said before, indicators point to further gains continuing through this year.
Steve Barger
analystSo if I take all your comments on chances and challenges and put them together, it seems your view is that profits have room to get better in '21, yet you're not looking for a major jump — as if '21 amounts to a year of settling down. Would that be accurate?
Eric Marchetto
executiveThat's what we're attempting — what we provided was qualitative direction, and turning that into quantitative direction isn't something I want to do; so it's enough to say that improvement is what we foresee. You did hear us say that a big driver of that improvement won't be industry deliveries. What matters more is the self-help cost profile changes we're making. And after that, with any luck, demand will begin to strengthen later in the year.
Steve Barger
analystGot it. When you work through organic lease revenue projections using quarter-over-quarter shifts in traffic and utilization, would you be willing to estimate which quarter in '21 follow RD might turn positive?
E. Savage
executiveNope; that's not something we'll speculate about. As I mentioned, we anticipate continued gains thanks to the encouraging signs already emerging, though we'll give that guidance each quarter, and you'll be able to observe how that trend develops.
Steve Barger
analystAlright, and just a final sort of modeling-type question. Looking at the pipeline, as you book orders for delivery during this year, are you anticipating a favorable shift in mix? Or is the revenue per current backlog you're holding at present a solid basis for thinking about the delivery mix in '21?
E. Savage
executiveWell, during '21, my expectation is that freight cars will recover first. That's the area where demand is currently greater and where fewer cars are on hand, and tank cars, you'd find, would trail behind that rebound.
Steve Barger
analystUnderstood. All right, could you expand a bit on Trinsight? In what way does it bring in money? What does the customer get out of it? And what's the timeline before it starts to matter financially?
E. Savage
executiveDuring our Investor Day, we mentioned that growth is coming in that area; in our view it delivers value for our customers. Revenue is already coming in. There's considerable interest and plenty of conversations happening; it gives them information about the vehicle's location and its condition. It can additionally supply them with details regarding the freight sitting there, plus safety-related considerations. So there are many upsides for them; those conversations are progressing nicely, though within this 3-year planning period we anticipated only modest growth.
Steve Barger
analystSo perhaps I missed something — does Trinsight sit inside Rail Pulse, or are these two distinct offerings? What's the connection between them?
E. Savage
executiveThey're distinct. Rail belongs to the industry initiative, and we're a major participant there. Trinsight, though, is proprietary data generated by our own rail platform, which we leverage to assist our customers more broadly with their supply chains.
Steve Barger
analystSo how does rail pulse differ, then, from the Trinsight stuff you just mentioned — what makes it its own thing?
E. Savage
executiveWell, to begin with, rail pulse was only just getting underway. That means it trails where Trinsight stands for us. Beyond that, when it comes to rail pulse, the industry-wide standards have been established by us. We hold a position in that space, which means we're able to contribute — to take part in those conversations and ensure we have a seat at the table for it..
Jessica Greiner
executiveThanks, Kate. Starting at 10:30 a.m. Eastern Standard Time and running until midnight on March 3, 2021, you'll be able to hear a replay of this call. To access it, dial (877) 344 to 7529 and enter access code 1015136. You can also find a webcast replay on the Events & Presentations page of our Investor Relations site, which is at www.trin.net. We're looking forward to speaking with you once more on our next conference call. Thanks for being with us this morning.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of this call. We appreciate everyone joining us for today's presentation. You're welcome to log off at this time.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Trinity Industries, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Trinity Industries, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Trinity Industries, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.