Trinity Industries, Inc. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 22, 2021

New York Stock Exchange US Industrials Machinery earnings 50 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jessica Greiner

executive
#1

Thanks, Rocco, and good morning to all of you. My name is Jessica Greiner, and I serve as Vice President of Investor Relations and Communications at Trinity; we're glad you could be with us for the conference call covering the company's financial results for the first quarter of 2021. Remarks we've prepared will feature Jean Savage, who is Trinity's Chief Executive Officer and President, along with Eric Marchetto, our Chief Financial Officer; after our leaders deliver those prepared remarks, a Q&A session will take place. Today on this call, we'll refer to slides that highlight key discussion points as well as certain non-GAAP financial metrics. Reconciliations of the non-GAAP metrics appear in the Appendix of our supplemental slides. You can access the supplemental materials on our IR website at www.trin.net. Those slides are located under the Events & Presentations section of the site, together with the event link for the first quarter earnings call. They're also available live during the webcast. At this point, I'm pleased to hand the call over to Jean.

Jean Savage

executive
#2

Thanks, Jessica, and hello everybody on this call. I want to begin on page three and resume from where we stopped during our Investor Day back in November of last year. We presented the approach for Trinity's Rail platform aimed at achieving top-tier financial results and putting capital to work so as to generate value. Appreciate it, Jessica. And a good morning to all of you joining us. I trust you're all in good health and anticipating a better summer in the coming year; we certainly feel that way, and we grow more optimistic about the positive direction of both our company and the broader economy. Although the railcar sector is displaying evidence of a rebound during 2021, our attention remains on carrying out strategic programs that fall more squarely under our own control, so as to ready this company for faster improvement in financial results. A great number of these were explained at Investor Day during the winter as part of a plan spanning three years. Turning to the main points from Q1, Trinity's numbers show the early effects of putting some of these project programs into action, on top of difficult pricing conditions and shrinking volumes, because order activity was lighter during the prior year. On top of that, two major weather occurrences hurt our output during the quarter. One of them is going to continue affecting our operations into Q2. Even with all that, I feel good about how far we've come toward the targets presented at our Investor Day and the extraordinary work our people have delivered. We have strong confidence in the way we're readying the business for a rebound and the value baked into the platform for sustained results. Though profits came in low for the reasons just described, Trinity's Rail platforms nevertheless produced a solid amount of cash during Q1. We further hold the view that the money spent this quarter fits with our approach to allocating capital for building shareholder value over the long haul. Let me now move to Slide 4 to go over our results. As stated at the outset, we think the railcar market is only starting to bounce back from the pandemic-driven difficulties of 2020; nevertheless, our Q1 financials kept revealing the effects of softer demand and price pressure seen in the marketplace across the prior year. Revenue for the first quarter came to $399 million, a 35% decline versus the same period last year, which matched our forecast but still isn't the level we'd prefer. This past quarter represents the toughest year-over-year comparison we will face, since COVID-19 didn't spread more widely across the U.S. until Q2 of last year. Adjusted EPS also took a hit from softer deliveries, landing at $0.07, down from a year earlier. Even with the overall financial performance remaining weak, the Rail segment at Trinity continues to generate robust cash flow compared with the earnings we posted. In Q1, cash flow from operations hit $70 million, and free cash flow — essentially what remains after all investments and dividends — came to $90 million. Eric, we'll get into the specifics of our cash flow numbers in a bit. What's difficult to see in the consolidated figures are the positive internal and external trends we're seeing. I'm glad to report that our operations and our railcar gains have reversed course, heading in a better direction throughout Q1. To start, let's take a quick look at the railcar market. Please go to Slide 5. As I mentioned, the rail market is still weak, but we're seeing some signs of improvement. The largest challenge remains the uncertainty in the market following the COVID-19 pandemic. According to our customers, they continue to adjust their forecasts for the North American economic rebound and what it will mean for their operations. With vaccine distribution expanding and government stimulus programs, their concerns are starting to ease. How confident customers feel and where they think the economy is headed shape the decisions they make about renewing leases, growing their fleets, and replacing assets. Now for rail traffic: severe weather dealt a serious blow to first quarter loadings, though things have started looking up over the past few weeks. On top of that, rail cars have been leaving storage for nine months running, ever since hitting a peak last summer, and because of that, industry utilization is back at levels seen before the pandemic and is hovering near the five-year industry average. For railcar types that make up more than half of the North American fleet, we're seeing encouraging carload and storage trends. Earlier, the biggest opportunities came from fleets tied to agriculture and consumer products, thanks to better carload trends. Now that the industrial economy is showing early signs of bouncing back, along with elevated steel prices, rising steel mill utilization, and the possibility of infrastructure construction, we're also seeing favorable effects on railcars in the construction and metals sectors. Energy markets are still trailing, though certain commodities — coal, crude oil, and ethanol — are recovering somewhat from their pandemic lows, probably tied to the economy reopening nationwide. Within our lease portfolio, utilization and pricing are getting stronger, and railcar inquiries are back to a more typical pace of activity. During Q1, Trinity's FLRD metric slipped a bit, landing at negative 14.8%, which came from tough comparisons and the quarter's aspiring lease rate. Across many markets this year, we anticipate lease rates will level off and perhaps tick up somewhat, since surplus railcar capacity is coming back into service to handle growing carloads. As for what new railcar demand might look like, our present expectation is that industry deliveries will fall short of replacement levels during this year. Even so, we think today's inquiries point to railcar deliveries landing at or marginally above replacement levels in 2022. Let me offer a brief remark about steel prices. With industrial output having fallen over the last several years, the current situation around steel availability—and the extraordinary price increases of the past six to nine months—is both distinctive and fast-changing. Across the year, Trinity typically depends on per-contract purchasing approaches, existing supplier commitments, provisions permitting contractual price escalation, and additional arrangements with our customers, all of which help reduce the impact of steel price volatility on their operating profits. Overall, we believe the industry's capacity is adequate for current production volumes, and that our present production forecast is covered by the contracts already in place. Should steel prices stay at least where they are now or move upward, demand for new rail cars might be constrained. Just as significant, today's steel pricing might generate a profit headwind across certain deliveries we'll make in the near term, while the supply chain scales up to satisfy rising demand. Moving to Slide 6, I want to give a bit more detail on the results for our segments; within the leasing business, lease revenue at Trinity declined slightly versus a year ago, driven by continued softer pricing on lease rates along with marginally lower utilization. The bright spot is that beyond prices strengthening in the market as demand gets better, we're observing encouraging movement in leading indicators, including strong renewal success rates and longer terms; our approach to pricing lease rates remains disciplined. And we think we're getting close to an inflection point, since available rail cars in some markets are nearing full utilization.

Jean Savage

executive
#3

We're keeping a tight watch on expenses too, though we anticipate that upkeep and other operating outlays needed to get the lease fleet ready for rising demand will drag on leasing segment margin throughout the year. As part of our strategic initiatives, we'll keep pushing to raise the share of maintenance and compliance events that our own shops handle. Across the past several years, we've grown our service capacity from about one third to more than half of our maintenance events, hitting a goal we established at the close of 2018. Given our present footprint, we can reach 70%, which will keep lowering the impact of fleet maintenance cost and boost how serviceable the railcars are for our customers. Now, looking at how things stand with our railcar manufacturing, on the surface it's easy to see why rail segment margins remain below what we're aiming for. We're continuing to put in serious effort to get our operations to the right size and to move around our variable and indirect expenses. During Q1, we reduced our manufacturing workforce by an additional 25% so that our production capacity lines up with demand; on top of that, we dealt with two major weather events in the first quarter that threw our operations off course and cost us about $4 million in profit. The first was the severe storms that swept across a large part of the country in the middle of February, which knocked out essential utilities at a number of facilities, and a few buildings took on minor damage. The second came right at the end of the quarter, when a tornado caused damage to our maintenance plant in Cartersville, Georgia. Thankfully, nobody was hurt. The Rail Products Group's second quarter results should only see a small effect from the tornado damage. We feel our insurance is adequate to handle the property damage expenses tied to that event. On top of that, because of the work stoppage, the company might qualify for business interruption proceeds. As we look ahead, we anticipate that our optimization work will get us to roughly breakeven margins in the second quarter, and things should keep getting better as we move through year-end. Of our backlog, about 55% should be delivered within the year, which means deliveries will be lower compared to last year. That said, we do expect our delivery pace to increase over the course of the year so we can satisfy demand from new orders. Turning to Slide 7, let's discuss how our first-quarter initiatives progressed. We delivered on the objectives we set for efficiency as well as for our balance sheet. During those three months, we brought several programs online that aim to boost the worth of the fabrication work we outsource. As I noted earlier, we finished another round of staffing cuts; taken together, we've made substantial headway in bringing down the break-even point for building railcars, and the payoff from that work is now becoming visible. For the rest of this year, our intention is to keep applying lean methods and add more automation across rail operations so that our cost base shrinks further. Across the whole company, we continue looking for ways to save. During Q1, we offloaded a number of properties that had been sitting unused. In addition, across the next two years, we expect to complete a handful of similar transactions as a way to streamline our operating footprint and reduce the expense of keeping those sites. Moving over to the balance sheet: we wrapped up a small railcar divestiture, which forms part of our broader push to improve portfolio yield. While that transaction is just a small step toward the goal, we right now have a number of initiatives in motion designed to shore up our balance sheet. As you might recall from Investor Day, Trinity committed to lowering its cost of capital by raising leverage until it reaches an LTV target between 60% and 65%. Eric will soon go into more detail about how we plan to optimize the balance sheet. Last, here's an update on Trinsight, our real-time digital tracking and fleet data service. Conversations with customers remain encouraging, and we have shifted into an active pilot program with a rising number of them; we're eager to share more later about the revenue opportunity and how much of a market impact this could have. To wrap up, our plans are being executed effectively. With further gains and rail fundamentals, we think our returns and financials will improve incrementally through the up cycle, thanks to the operating and financial leverage we are assembling in the business. Pinpointing precisely when an inflection arrives or how quickly recovery unfolds is never easy, though the momentum visible in both our business and the market gives us encouragement. Eric, over to you for further remarks.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#4

Thanks, Jean. Morning, everybody. I'm going to begin with the financial overview on Slide 8 and add a handful of extra specifics. Trinity's Q1 results reflect both a tough post-pandemic market backdrop and the work we're doing to set the business up for faster financial gains. Even though earnings came in below Q1 of 2020, we think the changes we're putting in place will drive better profitability in 2021, and, as Jean mentioned, we're already seeing green shoots from those efforts inside the business. Jean walked through a number of business drivers behind our financial performance, among them reduced overall deliveries along with difficult lease and new car pricing versus earlier quarters. In the quarter, our earnings took a hit of roughly $4 million in direct costs tied to lost production ton from two separate weather events. Looking ahead through 2021, we anticipate a modest earnings lift next quarter, then more meaningful acceleration during the back half of the year, producing year-over-year earnings improvement in 2021; on cash flow, Q1 cash flow from operations mainly mirrors the reduced level of operating income. Working capital stayed largely flat in the first quarter, which generated $70 million in operating cash flow for the period. For 2021, our expectation for cash flow from operations is still between $625 million and $675 million. Investments this quarter included about $108 million in leasing CapEx for new railcars and betterments plus $9 million in manufacturing CapEx after wrapping up our Midwest maintenance facility. For the full year, our outlook for net leasing CapEx and manufacturing CapEx is unchanged at $300 million to $350 million and $45 million to $60 million, respectively. We expect to finish more portfolio sales from the fleet during 2021 as we carry out our initiative to boost lease fleet returns. Total free cash flow after investments and dividends came to $90 million in Q1. The gain in cash flow from operations stems from the timing and the financing of our leased fleet growth for the order, which offset the equity capital required. Trinity also closed the previously announced purchase of a railcar cleaning technology company for about $17 million; we look to leverage this new technology and building capability as part of our automation efforts in rail maintenance operations. We keep returning meaningful capital to shareholders via dividends and share repurchases, which together came to roughly $60 million in the quarter. Our share repurchase authorization still has $145 million available through the end of the year. As we review our opportunity set for deploying capital, we're committed to a returns-based approach and to doing right by the shareholder. Moving to Slide 9. Trinity continues to hold a strong financial position, with a balance sheet able to deploy opportunistically; we're also making consistent progress on our leverage target goals and bringing down our cost of capital. In the first quarter, Trinity upsized the leasing warehouse. With this larger warehouse, Trinity can bring down total interest costs while also getting exposure to floating-rate debt. At the close of the quarter — the close of Q1 — our liquidity stood at $772 million; we anticipate continuing to seize the opportunity presented by the low rate environment to bring down our overall cost of capital. These maturities coming due soon stem largely from subsidiaries we only partly own, which had been financed under a very different rate backdrop. Rail asset-backed securities keep drawing in fresh investors, which has built a very deep market and an appealing setting for getting new debt deals done. Announcing our green financing framework for at-lease securitizations could also unlock new pools of capital. We're applying discipline by pairing the higher leverage on the balance sheet with the capacity to put that capital to work generating shareholder value. In the near term, our priorities for allocating capital stay the same: a modest investment in growing our lease fleet — in our lease fleet for growth. A normalized level of manufacturing CapEx, which includes rolling out new cleaning technology in our maintenance business, plus small tuck-in acquisitions for both secondary market portfolios, and other services. Loan-to-value finished the first quarter at 61%, leaving us in a position to capitalize on attractive market opportunities, including giving capital back to shareholders; to wrap up, we think the strategic plan we laid out for investors is gaining traction; and although real payoff from our efforts will require time to show up in our financials, we're concentrating on carrying out initiatives that lie more within our control, and that will speed up our financial performance once the market recovers. Following a year of enormous upheaval during a global pandemic, and substantial down payments toward restructuring the company in 2020, the first quarter of 2021 offered yet another instance of our people stepping up to meet a challenge. Our platform keeps demonstrating its resilience, producing a solid level of cash flows despite an otherwise low earnings figure. We stay dedicated to a disciplined method of allocating capital to build long-term shareholder value. We take encouragement from the ongoing favorable trends we're observing throughout the railcar industry and believe that apart from a pandemic setback, we're on the road to recovery. Rocco, you may now take us to questions from our participants.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#5

Hi, good morning. I'd like to discuss the really encouraging remarks regarding railcar production in '22, essentially hitting that replacement threshold; and I realize you aren't providing formal car guidance, but do you have any perspective on how you're thinking about that pace? Should we expect the bigger inflection during the back half of this year? Or does it look more like a steady build in your view? Just broadly, your overall thinking.

Jean Savage

executive
#6

Okay. Well, thank you, Alison. When we consider the patterns emerging as we move into the back half, our belief is they'll persist. It comes down to supply alongside demand. During the prior year, more than 50,000 cars left the industry through trade-outs. And based on what we've seen in the Q1 run-rate, we anticipate 50,000, perhaps slightly above that, trading out during this year. So given those forces, a larger pickup would be the natural expectation. One point I should highlight is that the car type mix during this recovery differs considerably from what happened in the previous one; as a result, freight cars are rebounding far faster than tank cars. That's just a small nuance in terms of what we're observing.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#7

Understood, that's useful. You also brought up that margins and rail products got better as the quarter went on. Is there anything you can share so we can get a handle on that exit rate? And related to that, I think you've kept trimming headcount in that area. Should we expect that to level off from here?

Jean Savage

executive
#8

Absolutely. Thank you, Alison. Starting with headcount — you ought to see it begin to level off, since we've now got staffing set, or nearly set, for the demand we saw in the first part of the year; and we've stated our expectation that demand would rise during the second half; so there could be a slight shift in what happens there. So at the moment it's perhaps essentially flat. On margins, there are a few things worth noting; we've been taking action deliberately. We discussed the gains we intended to achieve in both areas, including sending out some of the less value-added fabrication work, and that is beginning to take effect. We've run some supply chain programs more broadly, cutting input material costs wherever we could, which is where steel prices come in. As you're aware, those are climbing and moving the wrong way. But we've also devoted effort to automation and lean events inside our plants. We're beginning to see that come through as improved efficiencies from the factory. So with all of that paying off, we exited the quarter at a stronger run rate that we believe will hold up across the year.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#9

Great, thanks. I'll share that.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#10

Morning, and thank you. Jean and Eric, could you both explain how you define replacement demand? Would that be 35,000 to 40,000?

Jean Savage

executive
#11

When you consider a range of 40,000 to 50,000 cars, that's what we'd describe as replacement demand.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#12

All right, understood. And, Eric, I believe you brought up that earnings would show a year-over-year gain this year. Could you give us some clarity on just how big that benefit is? Is the gain slight, or is it significant?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#13

All right. Matt, Eric here. Yes, we did state that improvement is coming. We don't attach any additional descriptors to it, other than that there was a year-over-year improvement. However, considering where we landed in the first quarter, clearly it came in low. Jean noted that our expectation is for things to pick up modestly during the second quarter, with the heavier portion really falling toward the back end. So that's our expectation, and that's what you should anticipate seeing from us.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#14

Understood. Then perhaps a broader or more long-range question regarding the right-sizing of the manufacturing footprint. You folks have been at that for some time; and this quarter we did a bit more. And from what I understand, you're not excluding the possibility of additional moves down the road. What portion of this stems from the presently soft conditions? And what portion is strategic over the long haul, meaning perhaps it won't return? And looking out three to five years, what will the overall company resemble from a manufacturing standpoint? Are we discussing a considerably reduced manufacturing footprint that's — largely there to support leasing? Or should we anticipate that you folks will climb back as a share of the manufacturing backlog to the 40% plus that you previously had, as recently as 2 years ago?

Jean Savage

executive
#15

Matt, I'll begin with that; and then will pass it to Eric if he wishes to add anything. So regarding our manufacturing footprint, one thing I want to highlight is that a number of the properties we're selling were not being utilized. So they existed for possible future expansion or other kinds of businesses. We're tidying those up. And we still have many facilities remaining that are in that category. So when we discuss selling those kinds of properties, that's what I mean for the coming few years. When we examine demands in the industry, and what we're preparing for, we truly believe the industry will be at industry or replacement levels through potentially 2024. So we would ensure that we're sizing for that kind of environment and what we think our share is. And then the following piece is, even as we have taken some of our capacity, alter offline, we've also shifted some of the work outside. Those lower value-added fabrications going outside, frees up floor space in existing buildings that would in fact enable us to produce more cars; we would simply be doing more of the high-value add and assembly in our facilities. Hopefully that addresses your question.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#16

That's quite useful. Many thanks.

Gordon Johnson

analyst
#17

Hey, everyone, I appreciate you taking my question. I suppose, regarding operating cash flow, the full-year guidance is somewhat greater than what we observed in Q1. Is there anything beyond — it appears you folks anticipate business improvement during the latter half. Anything else besides that, something you're undertaking that will assist with that cash flow figure we ought to be aware of?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#18

Yes, Gordon; and I didn't mention it today, but I've made the point — this is Eric, have made it before. Keep in mind, we hold a fairly sizable tax receivable on our balance sheet. And we anticipate at minimum the part tied to our 2019 tax year arriving within this year. And that's roughly $245 million; so once that receivable turns into cash, it will move through our operating cash flow figure. So that's the additional component. The other component you'll notice is, clearly as our earnings get better, our cash flow, we'd likewise anticipate our cash flow from operations getting better.

Gordon Johnson

analyst
#19

All right, that's quite useful. Then, we're anticipating that a few of our additional industrial verticals for certain items get better during the latter half, and it appears you folks share that view. Is there a metric we ought to be watching? Possibly a little something unusual, or perhaps a little something usual, that we should check, I suppose, simply to sort of assess how matters are moving relative to what you're expecting?

Jean Savage

executive
#20

Thus, the standard measurements you examine, when it comes to the carloads you're observing. Over time, whatever you're noticing regarding the sector's output levels that are occurring. Broad indications that the economy is reopening, will each contribute to a solid rebound or possible rebound for the rail sector.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#21

Yes. Gordon, when it comes to gauging how well our sector is doing, weekly railcar loadings are an excellent signal. That's what makes it so useful. Each week you receive that up-to-the-minute data; so if I had to name a single metric for you to watch regarding our industry, that would be the one.

Gordon Johnson

analyst
#22

Great. Hello, and many thanks for taking the question, everyone.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#23

Thanks to you as well, Gordon.

Jean Savage

executive
#24

Thank you.

George Sellers

analyst
#25

Hi there, and good morning. George Sellers here, filling in for Justin Long. To begin with your long-term ROE target, it seems the replacement demand levels for railcars that you anticipate hitting within two-years are somewhat below what you might have assumed back when you provided that longer term ROE target. So I'm just curious whether anything has shifted regarding the timeline there.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#26

George, it's Eric here. Let me just — broadly, I'd say that relative to what we communicated last November, at our Investor Day, our view on the industry truly hasn't shifted. It's progressing about how we anticipated. So that longer term goal — that 11%- 13% goal that exists out there — still stands; we described it as being replacement level demand across the cycle. Clearly, this year sits a bit under the replacement cycle, or at least that's what we'd anticipate, before returning to replacement levels. So, without getting into fine details, I'd say the level of — nothing has genuinely changed in our industry outlook for the near term.

George Sellers

analyst
#27

Understood. All right, that helps. Then can you bring us up to speed on the used railcar market — say, where values stand and how much activity is happening?

Jean Savage

executive
#28

The secondary market has improved versus last year and is clearly healthier. We completed a modest transaction in Q1, as you noticed; and keep in mind, we're able to act as either purchaser or vendor here and keep evaluating opportunities. My view is that it's solid and should stay solid across the year.

George Sellers

analyst
#29

All right, that's excellent. I'll wrap up on that note. Thanks, everyone.

Jean Savage

executive
#30

Thanks.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#31

Yeah, I appreciate you fielding this. I'd like to explore the upbeat remarks regarding inquiry activity, along with what appears to be growing confidence that the manufacturing sector will bounce back to mid-cycle volumes in the coming year. You've recently reduced capacity, labor shortages have plagued numerous industries, and costs for materials such as steel, plus broader supply chain snarls, have clogged things up across many sectors too. Could you address that confidence that, once your customers are asking for those vehicles, you'll manage to bring capacity back up by the 50% to 100% required to reach mid-cycle? What gives you assurance that you can produce something like a historical trading margin once you hit that run-rate? Thank you.

Jean Savage

executive
#32

All right, I'll take that one to begin. Looking at our management team, they're exceptionally strong and seasoned, and they've navigated these cycles on numerous occasions. They're truly able to respond extremely fast when demand shifts. And where we closed or idled plants, we're compensating through efficiencies, an improved supply chain, and part of that contracting out of lower value-added fabrication work. That assists us as well. Being able to increase output depends more on bringing in the workforce than on the manufacturing footprint. We're lucky to have highly skilled employees in the facilities, and we run our own welding training programs within our plants. So should we need to recruit newcomers to the trade and prepare them, that's something we can do. Thus we feel fairly at ease about our capacity to scale up to meet demand.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#33

Appreciate that. One final item regarding how we deploy capital. You brought up the returns-focused strategy and the priorities for the near term. Given that the share price sits at 28 to 30 dollars rather than the low-20s, could you share your thinking on how you weigh the buyback against the dividend moving forward? And perhaps further out, we've touched on acquisitions and your main North American railcar market. Might there be a chance to become a railcar owner in certain international markets that could deliver additional growth over the medium term? Thank you.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#34

Thank you, Bascome, Eric here; so regarding capital deployment, clearly, it's fluid. Our stock price has shifted compared to last year, it's risen considerably. That definitely alters the calculation, yet also the returns and all other things we anticipate ahead. Thus, it's an extremely fluid exercise. We evaluate every investment choice. And ultimately, we select whichever offers the greatest return. And considering what lies before us, and where the opportunities are? Should you anticipate acquisitions, dividends, share repurchases, you'll observe a mix of those from us. And ultimately, we will act in the shareholder's best interest.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#35

Regarding the possibility of putting money into railcar markets abroad, like Europe, India, or another location — do you have any views on whether that sits within the set of options you might pursue as you produce more cash down the road?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#36

Absolutely, Bascome. This is Jean speaking, and I'll handle that. We're examining M&A across various regions. Beyond that, we'll seek out markets capable of delivering the returns we require, or that we anticipate for our operations. So has it been evaluated, or will it be evaluated later on? The answer is yes. We simply need, once again, to identify the appropriate market along with the appropriate price point so we can move into a few of those.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#37

Thank you.

Jean Savage

executive
#38

Thanks.

Steve Barger

analyst
#39

Thank you, and good morning. Could we revisit what you said regarding supply chain limitations and steel pricing? Was your point that some margin strain might hit the existing backlog because of steel prices?

Jean Savage

executive
#40

When it comes to steel pricing, my point was that we take many different steps aimed at offsetting those kinds of cost headwinds. An unforeseen issue might arise and create a bit of strain. Still, by and large, for the orders we currently hold, our offsetting measures leave us protected.

Steve Barger

analyst
#41

Even so, in your view, if elevated steel prices stick around, might that wipe out some demand?

Jean Savage

executive
#42

Yes, we believe so. Customers are already putting off certain choices, and our sense is that a number will keep holding back until they feel more certain about their operations and the stage of the rebound. Still, when you consider it, steel prices and our output of new cars — although it varies by vehicle type — have risen 10% to 20% per car. That shifts the dynamics and how decisions get made. So the ones you'll see submitting orders are those whose current vehicles are no longer there for them to take and use; they'll have no choice but to purchase new.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#43

And Steve, when we mentioned that this would boost the appeal of railcars already on the books — well, that’s something we really appreciate about our platform. Demand first flows through the fleet we already own, and after that it moves on to newly built units from manufacturing. So what that does is give our current — it gives assets already in place a bit more breathing room to keep performing, specifically when it comes to higher lease rates, since replacement costs have risen. That’s what we’re seeing. We anticipate seeing more of it going forward, and that’s the reason we feel good about our outlook.

Steve Barger

analyst
#44

That tracks. Regarding the supply chain, I believe he mentioned component pricing. Do you have anything to say about pricing and availability where disruption is concerned?

Jean Savage

executive
#45

This pandemic has treated us quite well, honestly. Supply interruptions have been almost nonexistent for us. The bulk of what we source comes from North America — more than 90% — so the kinds of disruptions other companies might face, we've been dealing with too.

Steve Barger

analyst
#46

Also, when it comes to the parts you buy for building railcars, do you have contractual protection?

Jean Savage

executive
#47

Well, the same way it works in other industries, sometimes escalation clauses are included to handle shifts in what materials cost. That's the context when we discuss our agreements — we push those costs along too, so coverage is assured.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#48

Correct — with respect to especially components, that tends to show up at the point when we invoke scrap surcharges and the agreements that make allowance for them.

Steve Barger

analyst
#49

Understood; that's my final question. You've clearly been placing a lot of emphasis on digital platforms and data analytics; during the Analyst Day, you mentioned a $20 billion to $25 billion addressable market opportunity for those services. Is there any news about how that platform is progressing, or how those commercial initiatives are moving forward? And perhaps any initial insight into trend site?

Jean Savage

executive
#50

I'll take that question. As I noted in my prepared remarks, we're observing growing interest from customers. These days, most of the time, when we discuss their needs with them, the customer is the one raising this topic. Currently, we have roughly 50 customers who are moving toward pilot stages for these. And we've noticed a rise in the number of cars that are already paid, joining that platform. So it remains early days. These are still initial results, yet there's very positive acknowledgment from the customer and demand coming from them.

Steve Barger

analyst
#51

Got it. Thank you.

Jean Savage

executive
#52

Thank you.

Barry Haimes

analyst
#53

Thank you very much. There are a few things I wanted to ask about. First, I believe you said the FLRD fell 14.8% during the quarter, partly because of a difficult comparison involving vehicles returning from lease. Could you explain how that comparison plays out across Q2, Q3 and Q4 as the year progresses? Will that comparison remain at a comparable level, or is it just beginning to become somewhat easier? That's my first question.

Jean Savage

executive
#54

All right. Keep in mind that our FLRD represents the forward-looking rate over the coming 12 months, based on renewals we've completed lately. That said, let me discuss lease rates a bit and see whether that addresses what you asked. As you know, we operate across numerous distinct markets, and each is bouncing back at a different pace. Sequential rate improvements are already occurring in 40% of our markets. In other markets, vehicles and storage remain, along with availability from competing lessors. Rate pressure will persist in those until they return to service. Scrapping matters here too; when you scrap more than 50,000 cars annually, supply and demand dynamics translate into better lease rates. So in our view, every factor supporting that lease rate is moving favorably.

Barry Haimes

analyst
#55

Understood. All right, I want to ask something else that's connected, and hopefully it brings a bit more clarity. Suppose you picked a car type or two — maybe ones that are trying to improve. Could you describe what the lease rate was at year-end versus what it is today? And even more significantly, given steel costing more, what would the lease rate have to be for your company to manufacture a car and place it in the lease fleet? In theory, then, what level must it reach so that newbuilds make sense, so to speak?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#56

Regarding car types where improvement has occurred — broadly speaking, I won't go deep into specifics across various car types. But overall, as slack has gotten tighter on the freight car side, we've seen somewhat more of that, particularly cover hoppers used for grain and agricultural products. Tightening has been a bit more evident there, and less so for certain tank cars — on the tight end, particularly tank cars tied to energy. Too many railcars are still available to serve those markets. Now, to your question about what counts as investable levels: Jean brought up material cost increases of 10% to 20%. Taken alone, with nothing else changing, that would imply lease rates must rise 10% to 20%. I'm not claiming lease rates have actually risen 10% to 20%, but in essence, if you intend to keep the same hurdle rate on your investment, then an increase of that size would be required. That's the reason we believe rates on cars already in service will climb — because the other option is putting money into a new railcar. Frequently, a new railcar sets a cap on lease rates for cars already in service, since their usefulness is comparable. Therefore, as those investment — as capital costs for new railcars rise, lease rates will gain some room to run. And that process requires time. It doesn't — this market isn't perfectly efficient. So it won't occur all at once. The information available in our market is imperfect; thus, once people begin to recognize that across the coming quarter, two quarters, possibly even three quarters, that trend will start to accelerate and carry on.

Barry Haimes

analyst
#57

Thank you; that's quite useful. Just one additional item, very brief. Roughly what portion of cost of goods sold does steel represent for you folks?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#58

We typically don't provide much granularity on that subject. Clearly, if you consider — steel comes in various forms, including plate steel and coil steel, plus every one of our parts. Nearly all our parts are steel, which are your cast items. So these days, when discussing steel in turn, we mean primarily the raw steel that goes into coil and plate. Once you consider the complete — every component within a railcar, then essentially the material expense, or the whole railcar, is steel; therefore, the sole remaining item there is our labor and overhead feat; so once you combine everything, the mix is extremely high. If you focus solely on coil steel and plate steel, then it sits well below — it's likely more — it's far less than that.

Barry Haimes

analyst
#59

Great, thanks very much.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#60

Thank you.

Jessica Greiner

executive
#61

Appreciate that, Rocco. Starting at 10:30 am Eastern Standard Time, a recording of this session can be heard, and it will remain accessible right up until midnight on April 29, 2021. To hear that playback, dial 877 to 344 to 7529 and enter access code 10152017. You can also find a webcast replay posted on the Investor Relations site at www.trin.net, specifically under the Events & Presentation page. We are eager to speak with everyone once more during our upcoming conference call. Thanks for being with us today.

Operator

operator
#62

Appreciation to you, ma'am; that brings us to the end of this conference call. Our thanks to everyone for joining us for today's presentation. You're welcome to disconnect your lines at this point. And enjoy a wonderful day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Trinity Industries, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Trinity Industries, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Trinity Industries, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.