Trinity Industries, Inc. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 21, 2021

New York Stock Exchange US Industrials Machinery earnings 56 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Leigh Anne Mann

executive
#1

Thanks, Riley. Hello, everyone, and good morning. We're glad you could be with us for the conference call covering the company's financial results for the third quarter of 2021. In our prepared remarks, you'll hear from Jean Savage, who serves as Trinity's Chief Executive Officer and President, and from Eric Marchetto, the company's Chief Financial Officer; after our leaders deliver those prepared remarks, a Q&A session will be held. On today's call, we'll refer to slides that highlight the key points of discussion, and also to certain non-GAAP financial metrics. Reconciliations of those non-GAAP metrics to comparable GAAP measures appear in the appendix of our supplemental slides. You can find the supplemental materials on our IR website, www.trin.net. These slides are available under the events and presentations portion of the website, together with the event link for the third quarter earnings conference call. I'm now happy to hand the call over to Jean.

Jean Savage

executive
#2

Thanks, Leigh Anne, and I appreciate everyone joining us here at Trinity. Good morning to all of you. On a consolidated basis, Trinity delivered yet another robust quarter and keeps achieving significant progress when it comes to optimizing returns — something underscored by the joint venture we recently established with Wafra along with our fresh $250 million share repurchase plan, and Eric and I will both discuss those subjects afterward. Broadly speaking, we have plenty of confidence in our capacity to carry out our plans and reach the goals we presented during our Investor Day 1 year ago. Allow me to recap a few central themes from our third quarter. Looking at the industry as a whole, fundamentals keep getting better in a broad but uneven manner. Although industrial production figures have risen and fallen amid supply chain disruptions, industrial production overall is nearing levels seen before the pandemic, and robust economic growth across North America is projected for the coming few years. Given these macroeconomic trends, rail carload volumes are climbing up from the lows of last year. Meanwhile, the number of rail cars sitting in storage is shrinking, thanks to elevated scrapping levels and comparatively slower train speeds. From the vantage point we enjoy, the strengthening recovery in railcar demand will carry on through 2022, which strongly supports fundamentals across both of our rail-focused business lines. Let's examine how these trends affected our consolidated results, which are highlighted on slide four. During the third quarter, Trinity brought in revenue of $504 million, which is 10% higher than a year ago. Our GAAP EPS came in at $0.33, versus an adjusted EPS of $0.29. We'll walk through both businesses shortly, but I believe it's worth emphasizing how strong our diversified platform is. Although results from our Rail Products Group might fluctuate quarter- to- quarter depending on the specific orders we deliver, Trinity produced solid and consistent cash flow growth during the third quarter. Cash flow from operations came to $93 million. Free cash flow, or excess cash remaining after all investments and dividends, was $157 million. Eric will cover this in greater detail. The key point to take away here is that our model is capable of generating considerable value creation via stable cash flow and returning capital to shareholders. To sum up, we continue to be pleased with how we're executing against our returns optimization initiatives and are just as excited to observe ongoing strength in the industry fundamentals that support our future results. Let's move to slide five. Here we can examine the railcar market in its entirety. To begin, railcar loads and traffic keep getting better. Industry car loads now sit at roughly 6.5% above 2020 year- to- date. We are getting nearer to pre-pandemic levels, which were last observed in 2019. Railcars in storage dropped 6% versus a quarter ago, helped along by ongoing scrapping activity and the continued deployment of idle assets in key markets such as boxcars, gondolas, hoppers, and tank cars. Relative to the modest rise in car load levels, slower train speeds are likewise contributing to railcar demand, since the average railcar in North America is achieving fewer turns. With that as the backdrop, Trinity's fundamental key performance indicators are also getting better. Utilization got better versus the prior quarter, reaching 95%, while the future lease rate differential — our FLRD — swung into positive territory, sitting at 1.4% now versus a negative 20.9% only 12 months earlier. Interest in new rail cars has likewise been thrilling. During the quarter, we booked orders for 2,530 new rail cars, which is 27% above the prior-year figure. As mentioned in our prior quarter's remarks, we think strengthened underlying leasing momentum along with elevated car pricing ought to keep lifting our results. In 2022 and 2023, new deliveries will probably move roughly in step with replacement levels. Let me be clear: the pattern might not be linear quarter by quarter, something our rail product segment results demonstrate. Even so, today's industry dynamics leave us quite optimistic. Moving to slide six, let's examine Trinity's segment results for the quarter. Within our leasing business, revenue rose modestly versus the preceding quarter, reflecting a mix of fleet expansion, better utilization rates, and greater servicer fees. That quarterly revenue gain was partly counterbalanced by reduced average lease rates as we work through legacy renewals. To put that effect in context, note that lease rate forward indicators are favorable. More precisely, renewal rates during the quarter came in 7% above expiration, and our outlook on overall lease rate trends stays favorable, as shown by the FLRD trend I referenced before. Margins in leasing and management services were solid too, climbing 340 basis points versus one quarter earlier. Higher servicer fees aided our leasing business during the quarter, partly offset by fleet operating costs. We additionally saw somewhat greater depreciation stemming from our successful Sustainable Conversion Program, which I'll cover afterward in my remarks. Remember what we said earlier this year: these expenses, needed to ready the lease fleet for growing demand, will act as a headwind to leasing segment margin across the year. Still, we view that near-term headwind as a good problem, because rising demand is creating value and, in turn, long-term returns for Trinity. Turning to our Rail Products Group results, margin improvement progress year-to-date was negated by labor shortages and turnover, plus supply chain disruptions. To be specific, operating margins for the Rail Products Group this quarter were negative 0.9%, versus 1.2% in the previous quarter. Given quarter-to-quarter dynamics such as delivery mix, supply chain disruption, and labor shortages, the recovery path in this segment will probably be less linear. Even so, we stay confident, based on two primary indicators for the business. First, demand for rail cars keeps climbing, as utilization, lease rates, and quarterly orders demonstrate. Rail car values are the second key indicator. Sure, while increased costs for things such as steel might act as a short-term obstacle for our deliveries, we have strong confidence that rising costs are going to push rail car values upward and, in the end, margins too, as older orders move through our pipeline. It's worth pointing out that although this quarter presented difficulties, Trinity keeps achieving meaningful strides in our expense optimization initiative within the Rail Products group. Moving to slide seven, I'll give an update on our returns optimization initiatives; we were active and achieved some excellent progress during the quarter. Starting with our balance sheet, Trinity and Wafra, an institutional investor, revealed a joint venture partnership aimed at $1 billion of diversified rail car asset sales across the coming three years. This joint venture represents a major step in our dedication to optimizing Trinity's balance sheet and driving ROE. Trinity additionally renewed our pledge to return capital to shareholders through a fresh $250 million share repurchase authorization. From our perspective, shareholders gain both from the robust free cash flow that Trinity's portfolio produces, and also as we optimize our balance sheet to help generate improved returns on equity for the entire enterprise. Regarding our enterprise cost reduction efforts, Trinity sold off three properties during the quarter for a total of $8 million in proceeds and $3 million of gains on asset disposal.

Jean Savage

executive
#3

When it comes to manufacturing, we keep generating substantial gains, since our Lean work and other cost-cutting efforts have lowered the break-even point for building a railcar. Now, on the lease fleet optimization front, the Wafra portfolio sale stands out as a major development, bringing in $325 million of proceeds. As in the prior quarter, we stayed active on the investment side, directing $112 million of leasing CapEx toward expanding and upgrading our lease fleet over the quarter. As we look toward the fourth quarter, we anticipate a slower pace while we integrate and refine what has been done so far this year. The main point to take away is that fleet returns are better, thanks to both mix and the accretive redeployment of sale proceeds; beyond portfolio deals, Trinity completed a modest $4 million acquisition on the secondary market. During the third quarter, our fleet got better because we doubled the number of sustainable tank car conversions, reaching 242 versus 119 in the previous quarter. As of the close of the third quarter, we have booked orders for more than 1,400 sustainable conversions, spanning a combination of tank and freight cars, made up of internal as well as external orders; these sustainable conversions let us reshape our fleet by converting or upgrading railcars we already own so they better satisfy the tough demands of the market and raise the yield on our fleet. That represents a vital element of our fleet optimization work. Finally, for an update on new products and services, we remain on track with several initiatives. With Trinsight, we have now achieved our 2021 target for customers who pay subscription fees for the service. On top of that, new product development is set to reach our full 2021 goal. To wrap up, Trinity is highly confident in the three-year plan we laid out at our Investor Day last fall, and we still have several initiatives underway to keep improving returns, particularly as railcar fundamentals keep getting better through 2022 and afterward. Before handing the call to Eric, I want to spend a moment on our sustainability focus. Trinity is dedicated to leading the market in advancing and promoting the sustainable environmental advantages of rail transportation. In our view, a more sustainable transportation system begins with moving freight from highway to rail, since rail cuts emissions for moving one ton of freight by 75% relative to highway. That means less congestion and less wear on our vital infrastructure. To encourage this shift, we give priority to product and service concepts that help shippers boost supply chain efficiency, moving more freight using fewer railcars and fewer car loads. We have covered several of our new products that deliver on this forward-looking, more sustainable vision, such as our newest grain car and Trinsight. Trinity has likewise concentrated heavily on using existing assets to satisfy new demand through our sustainable conversion program. In certain markets, this removes the need to build a completely new railcar. At the start of this year, we rolled out a green financing framework—a first for the railcar leasing sector—and by the close of the quarter, roughly $4.3 billion of debt tied to our railcars qualifies under that label. At our facility, a range of initiatives has been put in place aimed at cutting emissions, curbing water consumption, and recycling waste; in fulfilling our mission of delivering goods for the good of all, we work to shrink our environmental footprint while growing the beneficial effect we have on people. Having said that, I'll now pass the call to Eric, who can provide further specifics regarding our results.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#4

Thank you, Jean, and good morning to all of you. I'll kick things off on slide 8 by walking through the quarter. On the whole, as Jean mentioned, Trinity keeps gaining from the gradual strengthening we're seeing in railcar demand along with the strategic efforts we've undertaken. If we look at the income statement first, consolidated revenue for the third quarter came to $504 million, which is close to a 10% increase from the same period last year. The drivers were greater external deliveries within our Rail Products Group, plus ongoing gains in leasing fundamentals over in the highway business. Adjusted earnings per share came in at $0.29, which is up both sequentially from $0.15 and year-over-year from $0.17, thanks to a mix of improved fundamentals, gains from lease portfolio sales, and the share repurchase activity we've been doing. Our third quarter results took a hit from accelerated depreciation tied to our sustainable railcar conversion program. Our adjusted EPS figure leaves out a $0.04 benefit from insurance recoveries connected to tornado damage at our Cartersville facility. As we've discussed, the sale of our joint venture portfolio gave third quarter earnings a boost, producing a gain of $33 million on our $325 million transaction. In that joint venture, Wafra holds 90% of the equity, while Trinity holds the other 10%. Much like the better lease fundamentals, our new RIV transaction serves as another illustration of the expanding market for leased railcar assets. As we look toward the next quarter, we anticipate consolidated fourth quarter margins will be fairly in line with our third quarter results, prior to any impact from lease portfolio sales. Now moving to the cash flow statement. Cash flow from operations on a year-to-date basis came to $428 million. Third quarter cash flow from operations was $93 million, and that figure includes collecting $41 million of our tax receivable. The tax receivable we still have outstanding stands at $192 million, and that amount isn't part of our full year cash flow guidance. During last quarter, we provided guidance for full year cash flow from operations of $600 million-$650 million. Because of higher inventory costs along with working capital changes we intend to make, we're lowering our target. Our updated guidance is now a range of $450 million-$475 million. This move is deliberate, since we're concentrating on strategic sourcing to ease inflationary pressures and shield ourselves against supply chain constraints as we pick up the pace of deliveries. During the quarter, we saw a net reduction in leasing investment of roughly $204 million, made up of $112 million in lease fleet investments that were more than offset by lease portfolio sales. So far this year, proceeds from lease portfolio sales have surpassed our lease fleet investment by $41 million. Trinity's net lease fleet investment for the entire year is now anticipated to land between $40 million-$70 million, as we keep making disciplined investments at appealing returns that back our lease optimization initiative. Manufacturing CapEx for the quarter was $4 million, bringing our year-to-date manufacturing CapEx to $22 million. Our manufacturing CapEx for the full year is now expected to be $30 million and $40 million. Free cash flow, after accounting for investments and dividends, came to $157 million during Q3, lifting the cumulative figure so far this year to $516 million. Jean Savage pointed out that the power of our platform keeps fueling these cash flows and lets Trinity deliver value to shareholders by giving capital back. So far this year, Trinity has handed back close to $0.5 billion to shareholders — $69 million through dividends plus $405 million via share repurchases — amounting to roughly 17% of our market capitalization. Moving to slide nine, let's go over our capitalization. Trinity's financial standing remains very solid, underscored by liquidity at quarter end of $1.1 billion, and that's even after the capital return I just mentioned; such liquidity gives us flexibility as we intend to create further shareholder value via disciplined capital allocation focused on returns. Driving returns rather than asset growth stays our strategy, though we do anticipate investing in our lease fleet to grow, particularly in markets where rising demand can be served, and returning capital remains a commitment. Our actions so far show that robust cash flow lets us pursue both. During this quarter, we finished the earlier $250 million share repurchase program and kicked off a fresh $250 million authorization lasting through 2022. We keep refining our balance sheet and boosting our return on equity, which sits at the heart of our long-term strategy. To wrap up, we're making solid headway on our strategic plan; we take pride in Trinity's continued execution toward our objectives. Trinity isn't shielded from the difficulties of today's operating environment, yet our financial standing demonstrates how resilient our platform is and its capacity to produce returns throughout the cycle. Once the market rebounds, we'll show how our platform can generate appealing risk-adjusted returns. Eileen, please open the line for questions from our participants.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#5

Morning, and thanks for the question. Jean and Eric, Canadian National mentioned that what excites them the most would be those green energy car loads tied to Alberta's expansion in hydrogen energy projects. According to them, the potential there matches the peak of crude by rail, yet is far more sustainable. Could that represent an opportunity for your company?

Jean Savage

executive
#6

Yes, Matt, and I appreciate you asking. Hydrogen is something we've examined, and we keep examining various fuel types that might be moved via rail. It's something we're watching. Some development work is underway on our end, and we'll keep at it, hoping that, on the whole, governments will give approval for hydrogen to move by rail.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#7

All right. Assuming that kind of approval comes through, what sort of lead time ought we to anticipate prior to you having a suitable car ready for it?

Jean Savage

executive
#8

That truly would hinge on circumstances. We already have a design that would suit things quite nicely. What it would hinge on is the testing that various governments or countries would mandate in order to place that onto the rail.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#9

Understood. I have one additional inquiry regarding the guardrail segment. Does this uptick stem from expectations surrounding the infrastructure legislation? Could you speak generally about the degree to which this operation is tied to infrastructure construction, and perhaps also touch on whatever modest litigation exposure still exists at the state level?

Jean Savage

executive
#10

Certainly. Let me begin by noting that our highway business team performed exceptionally well. During the quarter just concluded, they achieved their strongest third quarter in the entire history of that highway operation. The segment is getting better largely due to input costs; we can successfully transfer those, together with freight expenses, onto customers. That shows up in the top line. As for the infrastructure legislation, will it make a difference? Absolutely, though in all likelihood that is a minimum of six months to 12 months away. The legislation still needs to be approved. The programs or the construction must receive approval, and typically the guardrail component gets purchased afterward in the cycle, so nearer to the point when they are prepared to commence that construction. That is what would occur. Regarding litigation, you have noticed modest shifts in our disclosures about what is happening there. We are observing fewer new lawsuits arriving. That figure has been declining across the past few years, and we anticipate that pattern will persist. Matt, I believe that covers everything you asked — or do you have something further?

Matt Elkott

analyst
#11

That sounds right. I realize this had three parts, but when it comes to demand tied to the infrastructure bill, even if a lag of 6 to 12 months occurs before the business feels it, my guess is that confidence will pick up right away once the bill passes, and that might at least generate some inquiry activity. Does that make sense?

Jean Savage

executive
#12

Yes, I'd say so. Some projects might get started early by people, or they might move forward on certain ones, but once it's passed and we see what level of confidence it creates, we'll just have to wait and find out.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#13

Alright. A few years back, when Arcosa was spun off by you guys, the guardrail business was kept as the sole non-railcar operation, which made sense given the litigation then, and that's mostly behind us now. Given that it's an infrastructure play at this point and could be in strong demand, would you consider selling this business if the valuation were right?

Jean Savage

executive
#14

Well, Matt, I've mentioned before that we don't think Trinity would be the best long-term owner of that business, since our focus is increasingly on the rail industry. For us to sell it, the dynamics and the situation would need to be right. It is on the table, and we've discussed that previously.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#15

Thank you very much, Jean.

Jean Savage

executive
#16

Thank you.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#17

Hi, good morning. Good morning.

Jean Savage

executive
#18

Hey, Allison.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#19

I'd like to focus on the manufacturing input cost inflation you highlighted. First, I suppose, are you seeing the most inflation in steel, or is it really in the components? I believe you brought up some older contracts. Can we think about how this plays out, where a portion of these input cost increases begin to be incorporated into contracts moving forward with respect to deliveries? Any insight on that?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#20

Yes, Allison, this is Eric. What I'd say is that during the quarter, it was likely more tied to steel and surcharges rather than specialty components. You also had situations such as industrial gases being disrupted, including oxygen and nitrogen. Because of COVID, all those gases were redirected toward hospital use; that definitely had an effect. On the specialty side, I think there may be some pressure later on regarding specialty components, so that's there. Regarding the backlog and the way it flows through, as Jean mentioned in her remarks, it won't simply be linear — as we move through some of the older contracts, whether fixed price or escalatable, they date back to when demand wasn't as strong as it is today. That will carry through across the coming quarter or two.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#21

Understood. Appreciate it; now onto a broader item. Jean, you spoke about being at ease with deliveries roughly hitting that replacement level. A common objection we hear is that, clearly, railroads aren't running as smoothly as they'd like, simply because of certain network issues where we're not exactly, to some degree, adding capacity to the problem, yet a portion of those railcars might actually turn around or some of that demand. Any insight on how you're viewing that, or is it simply really just confidence in that replacement level sort of continuing ahead with minimal effect from some things kind of going back into storage?

Jean Savage

executive
#22

Absolutely, Allison. If you consider how many cars are being scrapped annually, keep in mind we've scrapped roughly 50,000 over the past two years. We're on track to achieve that and perhaps slightly above it this year. The car types being scrapped, a lot of them are in high demand at present, so those replacement cars will be needed, whether it's box cars or grain cars or others. Our confidence and what we projected for industry demand over the next couple of years of 40,000 to 50,000 is truly founded on replacing the cars being scrapped right now. It's not a big overall demand increase.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#23

All right, that's clear. I appreciate you taking the time.

Jean Savage

executive
#24

Thanks.

James Bardowski

analyst
#25

Hi, everyone. James Bardowski here, filling in for Gordon. I appreciate you taking my questions. My first one, I believe, has to do with the new joint venture. Was it roughly 2,000 railcars, more or less?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#26

No — the figure was 3,600 railcars.

James Bardowski

analyst
#27

3,600.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#28

The figure is 3,600 railcars, and clearly our Q will contain additional specifics. An 8-K we submitted in August also includes many of those particulars.

James Bardowski

analyst
#29

Alright.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#30

The figure stood at 3,600 railcars, with $325 million coming in as proceeds. Let me just move forward and address that a bit — that joint venture, in our view, truly showcases what our platform can do. It addresses quite a few of the initiatives; this is an effort we're pursuing consistent with every initiative we have when it comes to optimizing our lease fleet along with our balance sheet.

James Bardowski

analyst
#31

Understood. All right, that makes sense. Obviously, this has an impact on both the rate at which you're utilizing and your LTV ratio. Would you agree with that?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#32

Yes.

James Bardowski

analyst
#33

And then, if we take that sale out of the picture, where would utilization have landed?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#34

All right. Utilization would take a modest hit and come in somewhat lower. Every one of those 3,600 railcars we divested was in use. Yes, it brings things down — when you dispose of 3% of the portfolio that was running at 100%, the result is a bit lower. I don't have the calculation in front of me to give you the exact figure on the spot, though I suspect you're able to work that out yourself.

James Bardowski

analyst
#35

All right.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#36

When you look at loan-to-value, the $325 million we raised definitely included railcars that had no encumbrance on them. Others were pulled from certain borrowing arrangements of ours. There are many moving pieces involved. Ultimately, on a wholly owned fleet basis, our leverage ticked up a bit during the quarter, landing at roughly 63%.

James Bardowski

analyst
#37

Alright. That falls inside the guidance you gave before. Has anything shifted regarding how you're approaching capital allocation at this point?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#38

Absolutely, James. Yes, that's correct. What we set as our goal was 60%-65%, and at present we're sitting around the middle of that band. For both the near term and the mid-term, that band remains what we're targeting. No adjustments have been made, though we definitely retain the ability to make one. As things stand, that band is still what we're using.

James Bardowski

analyst
#39

All right, excellent. Only two or three left. I'll attempt to move quickly. You said your attention would be on speeding up deliveries. Could you tell us what portion of your backlog you expect to ship during this year?

Jean Savage

executive
#40

I believe we discussed preparing cars so they could reach the market faster. Demand is still robust, and as for the full year, I'm not sure we provided a figure for that percentage.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#41

It's in the Q.

Jean Savage

executive
#42

Okay

Eric Marchetto

executive
#43

When we look at what portion of the orders we've got on the books is going to be handed over during this year, that figure comes to roughly 32% — more precisely, 31.8% is the number that will show up in the Q, representing the share of our deliveries we expect to complete in 2021. And that relates to our deliveries of new railcars.

James Bardowski

analyst
#44

Got it.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#45

In dollars.

James Bardowski

analyst
#46

Since this is quite a loaded question, I'll stop here with one last one. I'm sorry about that. With costs climbing as they are, could you break down what portion of the upward push on lease rates right now comes from better market conditions, and what portion is just lessors handing along their own higher expenses?

Jean Savage

executive
#47

So when-

James Bardowski

analyst
#48

So on that note, thank you both, Jean and Eric, so much.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#49

Sure thing.

Jean Savage

executive
#50

Right, thank you. As for the pricing shifts we're observing, supply and demand explains a great deal of that; in areas where the number of vehicles on hand is lower, prices are definitely climbing. I noted a 7% rise during the quarter for renewal rates compared with expiring rates. And that our forward-looking FLRD came in positive. What that indicates is that for vehicles scheduled to come off lease or reach expiration, we anticipate an overall uptick in those rates. For us, that remains a favorable trend.

James Bardowski

analyst
#51

Alright, that's great. Thanks once more, everyone.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#52

Appreciate it, James.

Jean Savage

executive
#53

Thanks.

George Sellers

analyst
#54

Hey, good morning.

Jean Savage

executive
#55

Morning.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#56

Hi, George.

George Sellers

analyst
#57

Let me start with my first question. You mentioned that railcar valuations are going up. I'm just wondering—I realize pricing differs depending on car type—but could you discuss the percentage gain you've typically observed for new railcars? What portion of that comes from higher commodity prices, and what portion is simply core pricing trends?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#58

George, clearly mix and car types are important, and so is how much steel is involved. We've discussed how, when certain input costs have doubled and tripled compared with a pre-pandemic level, that has led to car prices that are 20%-30% higher. How much of that is steel and input cost? A great deal of it is steel and input cost, and a margin component exists as well, and it likely hinges on your starting point. Margins have gotten better across the last couple of quarters, but I'd say a much larger share of the increase stems from inflationary pressures alone on new railcars. That connects to the fact that, as an owner of 105,000 existing railcars, those 105,000 railcars gain enormously from the higher input costs on the 2,000, 2,500 cars we delivered this quarter; that's truly where we see railcar valuations being affected, because those new railcar prices give the existing railcars more room to run, both regarding lease rates and regarding valuations from a depreciated replacement value level. That's genuinely where we feel excited about the future with the lease fleet.

George Sellers

analyst
#59

All right, that's useful. You mentioned the backlog, but can you tell me what portion of the backlog right now will be delivered to the lease fleet during the fourth quarter?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#60

I didn't cover that, but I need to check that queue. Give me a moment and I'll return with that answer.

George Sellers

analyst
#61

All right.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#62

During Q4, 34% of the deliveries we made were tied to the leasing company.

George Sellers

analyst
#63

Got you.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#64

Yeah.

George Sellers

analyst
#65

All right; that's useful.

Jean Savage

executive
#66

Keep in mind that in earlier times, we mentioned that normally the railroads along with the third-party lessors will step in and purchase new cars initially. That continues to happen at this moment; we do see a bit of secondary market activity or end shippers making purchases, yet most of it remains railroads first, followed by third-party lessors.

George Sellers

analyst
#67

All right, that's genuinely useful. I'll stop here. Thanks to everyone for your time.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#68

Thank you, George.

Jean Savage

executive
#69

Thanks.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#70

Yes, thank you. Morning, and I appreciate you fielding my questions. During spring and also summer, you mentioned being in a truly strong spot regarding manufacturing labor, describing yourselves as a preferred employer in East Texas plus the areas where you operate in Mexico. It appears that situation has grown tougher. Could you break down for us what shifted over the past three months, and perhaps offer a bit of insight into which regions or functions are proving hardest on the labor front, plus how you see that developing as we move further into Q4? Thanks.

Jean Savage

executive
#71

Of course, Bascome. I'm Jean, and I'll handle that one. Early on in the pandemic, we counted ourselves quite lucky to avoid supply chain and labor problems. As time went on, it was only during the most recent quarter that certain issues emerged. A portion of that, we believe, is temporary, and it involves some of the gases Eric mentioned earlier, where supply was briefly interrupted, and then there were certain valves as well. Regarding labor, conditions in Mexico remain quite robust, with turnover extremely low and shortages extremely low. In the U.S., much like any other business dealing with labor, we're seeing elevated turnover as individuals depart for different positions or opt to retire, removing themselves from the workforce. That showed up, once again, mostly in Q3 for us, and it's an area we'll keep addressing, same as everyone else, ensuring we put ourselves in the strongest possible position to meet what the market requires.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#72

In the U.S., have those trouble spots begun to level off? Do they seem to be deteriorating? I'm just wondering where things sit now compared with the unexpected softness you first noticed during the quarter.

Jean Savage

executive
#73

Early in the quarter it was somewhat lower. It climbed, and since then it has largely held steady. Once again, it's simply a matter of our now having the people and equipment available to ensure we keep satisfying every bit of demand.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#74

Thanks. You shared your Future Lease Rate Differential, and it was good to see it turn positive, which I believe is the first instance since you started disclosing that figure.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#75

That's right.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#76

Could you describe how this actually plays out in practice? Is it getting to the stage where the rising prices for new vehicles that you mentioned when answering an earlier question are driving the kind of quicker turn you usually observe during up cycles, when lease rates are able to shift quite fast? Have we arrived there yet? Are we moving toward it? Do you expect it? Any perspective at all on how supply and demand interact with new car price inflation, and what that implies for lease rates over the coming year.

Jean Savage

executive
#77

I'll take that first, and then hand it to Eric. Keep in mind that our fleet reaches expiration at varying points. Roughly 17%-20% of the fleet comes due annually. When you consider how that lease rate changes, it takes many years to get through the entire fleet. We referenced the 7% rise in renewal rates compared with expiring for the quarter, yet the total average lease rate for the quarter continued to face some headwinds, so it remains down somewhat. My sense is that working through it completely will require time, but we're encouraged to see renewals climbing; in markets where the supply-demand measure leans more toward requiring additional supply, that shift will happen faster than in certain other regions. Eric, anything to add?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#78

Bascome, let me piggyback on what Jean said and note that the impact does differ depending on the kind of car. Still, when you look at it in absolute numbers, the cost of newly built rail cars is climbing, and because that pushes new-car lease rates upward, the rates on cars already in the fleet will rise as you reprice them. On top of that, for 15 months now we've watched a consistent flow of rail cars leaving storage — that's the metric in question. The fleet keeps getting tighter, partly through attrition and partly because more rail cars are being loaded. Both of those forces — higher rail car loadings, or simply needing additional rail cars to haul the same freight — are at work. Every one of those elements acts as a tailwind for demand, whether for existing assets or new ones, and ought to create chances to push pricing higher. To my mind, that's among the advantages of our platform: being a big manufacturer and a big leasing company, with our maintenance operations, we have visibility into the market, and we can typically spot these inflection points early and react appropriately.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#79

No, thanks for that. Perhaps, just to wrap up that topic — and I'm sorry if this came up in your prepared comments, since I was switching between calls. Is there a way to think about — I know spot isn't the correct term — something like a current incremental renewal rate and how it's moving quarter-over-quarter or month-over-month? Any indication at all of the sequential improvement you're observing, with the understanding that renewals take place gradually and the portfolio's overall average lease rate needs time to shift. Thank you.

Jean Savage

executive
#80

Absolutely, Bascome, and market activity has definitely been rising, so on a sequential basis it's been extremely, extremely strong for us when it comes to renewal rates or the assignment rates feeding into that. Beyond that, we continue to see plenty of activity around quotes for new cars, and orders keep coming in on that front.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#81

Thank you.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#82

Thanks, Bascome.

Steve Barger

analyst
#83

Thank you, and good morning. Could you put some numbers around the labor and supply chain challenges within the Rail Group? What I'm after is a rough sense of how much of that operating loss came from those factors as opposed to volume and mix.

Jean Savage

executive
#84

Each of those three elements contributed to the outcome we delivered. Take supply chain — the inefficiencies that arise when you don't have the gases required to perform the job, or, to give another instance, a valve that still needs to be installed, feed into the reality that the work can't be completed within the timeframe you had in mind. On top of that, you've got either turnover or a shortage of labor needed to carry out that work. Once you add all of it up, there's definitely an effect. We haven't drilled down to determine whether it's 25% or 30%. With all of them combined, my guess is you'll hear the majority of industries, or industrial companies, discussing that kind of impact for the quarter.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#85

Steve, during the earlier call, we discussed how our view on orders leaned more toward freight cars. That remains true, though I wouldn't describe it as a shift in mix between, let's say, Q2 and Q3. What we're highlighting with labor and the supply chain comes down to the fact that those represent the largest factors.

Steve Barger

analyst
#86

Understood. Eric, I'd like to confirm I've got your point about how 4Q might shape up. Assuming no additional vehicles go to the JV, then roughly speaking 4Q looks as though it will resemble 1Q, because of the hit from the Rail Group, and my sense is the bulk of your EPS this quarter came from the sale gain, correct?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#87

What I said regarding the fourth quarter concerned margins prior to factoring in the effect of car sales, and it dealt with margin percentages. If you simply take our statement that margin percentages would appear comparable once that item is excluded, I believe that's a sound approach for thinking about those figures. Regarding car sales, we completed $325 million of them to Wafra during the third quarter. As we've mentioned, this is more of a programmatic effort across the next three years. I wouldn't expect We have no Wafra transaction planned for the fourth quarter.

Steve Barger

analyst
#88

All right. And what about the opening portion of the coming year?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#89

This is a 3-year arrangement worth $1 billion. If you look at it spread evenly across that period.

Steve Barger

analyst
#90

Understood. Should the rail group perform in Q4 the way it did in Q3, then it won't add anything to operating income for this year. Do you believe Q4 will mark the bottom for rail group margins? With the recent ASPs on new orders in mind, ought we to be lowering our expectations for the OEM business during the early part of 2022?

Jean Savage

executive
#91

Keep in mind what I told you — the path for the Rail Products Group won't be a straight line, so it truly hinges on the mix and the volume moving through it. My expectation is that we'll see improvement. I'm simply noting that the line may not be straight; plenty of the optimization and Lean initiatives remain underway, and they carry on across the entire three-year span we set out at Investor Day. As every one of those wraps up, you'll observe various kinds of gains showing up in our results.

Steve Barger

analyst
#92

Would it be reasonable to state that, in light of the average selling prices you've realized across the past two quarters and the volumes you anticipate, a sharp margin recovery isn't in the cards for the first half of 2022?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#93

My view is that those ASPs are really a reflection of mix rather than of margins. It would be a mistake to draw strong conclusions about the margin profile from the ASP; mix is what drives that, and as I believe I mentioned, we're seeing better margins on the new railcars we're selling, since demand conditions have improved compared with where things stood, let's say, at the peak of the pandemic. On that basis, once backlogs level off and then begin to stretch out, typically in manufacturing you'll also start to observe margins widening. Given everything going on with supply chain problems and labor, and so forth, we simply want to avoid getting ahead of ourselves when it comes to expectations, because the results contain a great deal of noise. Broadly, the demand picture is getting better, and that in turn is pushing the pricing environment higher.

Steve Barger

analyst
#94

Alright, that's my final question. Could you expand a bit on the sustainable railcar conversion initiative? What steps are involved in the conversion to achieve greater sustainability?

Jean Savage

executive
#95

When markets shift, we examine whether a particular car type might serve another market with improved utilization and greater yield. To accomplish that, we're able to perform certain modification tasks — whether that means repainting, installing a different hopper, or similar adjustments — so we can reposition that car, which boosts utilization overall and raises yield.

Steve Barger

analyst
#96

Is this something you're pursuing on spec, or is it because a customer comes to you and says, "I'd like a new rail car, but I don't want to shell out the entire rail car price," and you come up with an inventive approach, saying, "Alright, I can perform some modifications on this car and perhaps render it appropriate for what you need?"

Jean Savage

executive
#97

Excellent question; we keep saying that our preference is to make use of railcars we already have, our current assets, and that's exactly what's happening in this case. Rather than constructing a brand-new car while the older asset just sits there, possibly underutilized, we're opting — when it's financially sensible and makes sense from a return perspective — to modify that car and deploy it into a market that might have either a longer run or a greater need at that moment.

Steve Barger

analyst
#98

Is that something you're doing on your own initiative, or because customers have asked for it?

Jean Savage

executive
#99

Customers have asked for it. We aren't taking that kind of action on our own initiative. Either we've got orders from outside customers, or we've got orders we have to fill from our lease fleet.

Steve Barger

analyst
#100

Steve, just one final question: what portion of your fleet, or of the overall fleet, do you figure is suitable for conversion?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#101

Eric, that will really come down to how the owner sees it, and every fleet owner will weigh different factors. Consider a few of the car types that have lately been weaker, where utilization has been slower or lower — take small cube covered hoppers, where that fleet expanded too quickly as demand shifted and car loadings shifted. Those assets are fairly young, so they qualify. Every owner will reach their own conclusion. The same holds for tank cars, where you've had tank cars. Certain sustainable conversions are options available to you — think retanking tank cars, and so on — all of that matters. It hinges on how old the rail car underneath is.

Jean Savage

executive
#102

This speaks once more to how solid our platform is. Those conversions can be handled right inside our own maintenance shops. That assists us in satisfying what customers need and gives us a product that is more sustainable as a whole.

Steve Barger

analyst
#103

Thanks very much.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#104

Thank you.

Jean Savage

executive
#105

Thanks.

Leigh Anne Mann

executive
#106

Thanks, Riley. Starting at 10:30 A.M. Eastern Time, a recording of this call can be heard until midnight on October 28th, 2021. To listen, dial 877 to 344 to 7529 and enter access code 10152033. You can also find a webcast replay on the Events and Presentations page of our investor relations site, www.trin.net. We hope to speak with you once more during our upcoming conference call. Thanks for being with us today.

Operator

operator
#107

That brings today's call to a close. We appreciate you joining this presentation. You're welcome to hang up at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Trinity Industries, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Trinity Industries, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Trinity Industries, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.