Trinity Industries, Inc. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 17, 2022

New York Stock Exchange US Industrials Machinery earnings 61 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Leigh Anne Mann

executive
#1

Thanks, operator. Hello, everyone, and thanks for being with us on this call covering the Company's Q4 and full-year 2021 financial results. Jean Savage, Trinity's Chief Executive Officer and President, and Eric Marchetto, the company's Chief Financial Officer, will each give prepared comments. After our leaders' prepared remarks, we'll open things up for a Q&A session. Today we'll be pointing to slides that call out key discussion points, and also to certain non-GAAP financial metrics. You can find reconciliations of those non-GAAP metrics against comparable GAAP measures in the appendix of the supplemental slides. The Supplemental Materials live on our IR website at www.trin.net; look for these slides in the Events and Presentations section of the site, together with the fourth quarter Earnings Conference Call Events link. After 10:30 A.M. Eastern Time today, a replay will be accessible through midnight on February 24th, 2022. To hear the replay, dial 877 to 344 to 7529 and enter access code 5826703. You'll also be able to find a webcast replay on the Events and Presentations page of our investor relations website. With that, I'm happy to hand the call over to Jean.

Jean Savage

executive
#2

Thanks, Leigh Anne, and good morning to all of you. I hope everyone has had a safe and healthy beginning to 2022. The close of the year was busy and successful for us, with the standout being the sale of our Highway Products Business completed on December 31st, and we're eager about what lies ahead this year. Supply chain challenges and labor pressures throughout the industrial economy didn't stop our optimization work, and our commercial team stayed active hunting for fresh opportunities with current products and services while also looking at ways to broaden what we offer. We feel the toughest part of the cycle is behind us, and the metrics are strong enough to back growth in both our Rail Products segment and our Railcar leasing and management segment. On top of that, given the favorable industry backdrop along with our Internal Business Optimization efforts, our management team and board are confident that we're heading into 2022 set up for significant growth; we're now in year two of the three-year plan we rolled out at our Investor Day in late 2020, and we're on pace to hit the targets we laid out back then. Obviously, we're thrilled to carry that momentum forward into 2022 as we look to speed up our growth. The moment for that acceleration looks like a good one. Simply put, we anticipate that 2022 will be a solid year. Let me walk through a few main themes from our fourth quarter and the full year. Please go to slide three. We continue to feel good about the macro trends affecting our business, and we anticipate the North American economy will keep recovering from the pandemic through 2022. A distinctive feature of this recovery has been how quickly inflation has risen for both Consumers and Producers. Our business holds up well when inflation is running, since we can reprice our lease assets and stay ahead of rising prices. Inflation may also make the rail cars we already have more appealing to our end users, because new equipment prices typically climb faster. When steel prices rise, older assets also become more valuable as scrap, and the substantial retirement levels seen over recent years, particularly in major freight car markets such as Boxcars, Gondolas, and Grain-Covered Hoppers, bolster demand for new rail cars. We believe 2022 rail traffic will be led by Agriculture, Chemicals, and Construction Materials, making it a freight car-led recovery. What sets this cycle apart from earlier ones is that no single rail car is driving the uptick in rail traffic, which opens up more chances for lease fleet utilization and for higher deliveries. In line with our peers and the broader industry, we expect railcar production in 2022 to land at or just above replacement levels, and we're projecting annual industry deliveries of 40,000 to 50,000. Slides four and five highlight some key points from our consolidated results for the quarter and the full year. One quick note: our Highway Products Business has been retroactively folded into Discontinued Operations, so it no longer appears in our continuing operations. During Q4, Trinity brought in $472 million in revenue, which marked a 31% increase compared with the fourth quarter of 2020. GAAP EPS from continuing operations came to $0.16 for the quarter, while Adjusted EPS stood at $0.08; across the full year, GAAP EPS was $0.38, and Adjusted EPS of $0.34 represented a rise of 0.18 versus full year 2020. In a few minutes, Eric will cover how the Highway Products Business affected things. Cash flow from continuing operations reached $197 million in the quarter and 616 million across the full year. After investments and dividends, free cash flow for the full year totaled $539 million. Such results demonstrate that our optimization efforts have succeeded. We've shown our business can produce sizable, steady cash, affording us room to further optimize the balance sheet and boost shareholder value via accretive capital allocation. Moving to slide six, let's examine the railcar market overall and our current position as a company. Rail traffic during 2021 improved noticeably compared with the lows seen in 2020. That said, as this year began, rail traffic has dropped versus 2021, chiefly because the Omicron wave of the pandemic caused labor disruptions across the United States, along with winter weather in Canada. Once these short-term disruptions clear up, we anticipate improvement. The number of railcars in storage kept shrinking, and in December the storage rate dropped under 20% for the first time since summer 2019. Quarter-over-quarter, storage rates are presently down 7.4% sequentially. For Trinity, these favorable market conditions are feeding into stronger business fundamentals too. Fleet utilization sits at 95.7%, returning to pre-pandemic levels last seen two years ago. What's more, after turning positive last quarter for the first time since we launched the metric, our FLRD rose once more in Q4, reaching a positive 2.2%, meaning today's lease rates exceed the expiring rates Trinity will face over the next 12 months. We favor this metric since it looks ahead and relates specifically to leases that are expiring. It's also worth noting that the FLRD is positive even after accounting for some tough comps on select car types, like pressure cars and general Service Tank Cars. Renewal rates climbed by 12.8%, backing the upward rate trends seen in the fourth quarter. On Rail Products, I mentioned our optimism that orders and deliveries would improve in 2022 and beyond; during the fourth quarter, orders came in at 5,360 railcars, 358% above a year earlier, while deliveries of 2,805 railcars were 26% higher. The commercial team's capacity to maintain traditional market share levels while pursuing a more aggressive pricing strategy stands as another testament to our optimization efforts. Even though this recovery is freight car-driven, the lower margin on freight cars will be more than offset by volume improvement. Delays in the supply chain are affecting when certain near-term deliveries will occur, yet durable demand trends are fueling confidence about 2022 and probably past that point too; it should also be noted that during 2022, absenteeism tied to COVID has created labor shortages across North America. Although this has represented a headwind affecting 10%-15% of the workforce at certain of our sites, case rates falling from the most recent COVID-19 wave leave us hopeful that staffing can get back to normal productivity levels within the next few weeks. Turning to slide seven, let's look at Trinity's segment results for the quarter; within our leasing business, Revenue and Operating Profit came in slightly lower than the prior quarter. Renewal rates and the FLRD, as noted earlier, each showed improvement in the quarter, which signals revenue and margin growth ahead in 2022. Our capacity to renew contracts nearing expiration strengthened over the year, reaching a 2021 renewal rate of 79%, the strongest figure since 2014; moving on to the Rail Products Group, both revenue and margin rose compared with last quarter, and book-to-bill for the quarter stood at 1.9 x.

Jean Savage

executive
#3

Like I said before, even though the supply chain problems and staffing challenges that came up during the previous quarter are still with us, we've achieved considerable headway — particularly when it comes to supply chain — on the path to better outcomes. The Rail Products Group posted operating margins of 3.3%, which is an improvement over the -0.9% we saw the quarter before. On a year-over-year basis, full-year new railcar deliveries dropped 23%. The main reasons for this are an order that had to be delivered at the start of this year, a supply chain problem that caused certain deliveries to slip into 2022, and soft demand for Tank Cars. Let's turn to slide eight, where I'll give you an update on the returns optimization initiative. From an enterprise optimization standpoint, the standout event of the quarter was selling off our Highway Products Business. I want to spend a moment walking you through that deal. During the quarter, Trinity closed the sale of Trinity Highway Products to Monomoy Capital Partners, a private equity fund, at an aggregate purchase price of $375 million. We booked a net gain of $131 million from the sale, which shows up in Discontinued Operations. We've noted before that we weren't the right long-term owner and that this business wasn't core to Trinity. Completing this deal allowed us to achieve what we set out to do: become a business wholly concentrated on the rail sector. The terms of the sale struck us as favorable, and we moved quickly to return the $375 million in proceeds to our shareholders using two methods. First, we acquired $250 million worth of shares — 8.8 million of them — from ValueAct Capital in a transaction that was privately negotiated. Next, we allocated the leftover $125 million from the proceeds toward an Accelerated Share Repurchase, also known as an ASR, agreement. Because the ASR is covered by the authorization we already have in place, after it wraps up — and factoring in shares bought back previously — approximately $73 million will still be left under that authorization, which we expect to buy back before it expires at year-end. Overall, the team performed exceptionally well in closing this deal and putting the proceeds to work right away and efficiently. When we look back at 2021 in its entirety, we moved significantly closer to achieving our strategic goals. The Canadian Association of Railway Suppliers honored our Trinsight development with its Innovation of the Year award, and regarding Trinsight, we remain on schedule with respect to cars online. Our program for converting railcars sustainably keeps expanding, with 1,150 cars sitting in our backlog and 650 handed over across the full year. During the fourth quarter, we retanked roughly 80 cars and finished a heavy rebody on 210 cars. To give you some context on our conversion work: depending on which railcar is supplying the parts, we can salvage different amounts of components. Typically, somewhere between 10,000 lbs and 25,000 lbs of material per railcar can be reused, and that represents a substantial way for us to cut down on waste. Beyond that, the Wafra transaction that was completed in Q3 strikes us as an important step in making our lease fleet more efficient, and that partnership is off to a tremendous start. Over the full year, we returned $895 million to shareholders, with $807 million of that delivered via Share Repurchases. Prior to turning it over to Eric, I'd like to repeat our purpose statement: delivering goods for the good of all. Everyone has learned a great deal from the difficulties of recent years. From where we sit at Trinity, the supply chain problems and the worldwide knock-on effects that followed represent a strong chance to reconsider greater reliance on rail within an integrated supply chain. Through efforts such as RailPulse, we keep working alongside Railroads and shippers to find methods of making rail better for the benefit of the wider supply chain and the North American economy as a whole. Our pricing leaves us in a stronger position, we have achieved significant progress on bringing costs down, and strong returns remain our focus. In our view, rail's sustainability relative to other transportation modes creates a distinctive opening as customers consider decarbonization. We likewise remain dedicated to making rail more efficient and take a careful, intentional approach to developing new products. Typically, we invest roughly $10 million each year in new product development, and we intend to do the same in 2022. Among our 2021 new products was a horizontal side seam large covered hopper serving the agricultural market, which maximizes the railcar's clearance envelope by using corrugated sides for strength and efficiency. What results is a rail car offering greater capacity that is 5 ft shorter than a standard covered hopper; this translates into more rail cars per train and reduced fuel per unit of commodity. In addition, we developed a brand-new composite floor aimed at the refrigerated box car sector, which allows a seamless transition between fresh food and frozen food service and boosts how versatile and well-utilized this type of car can be. It's our view that the rail sector is positioned for expansion, and opportunities to increase efficiency and remove friction can be found across the supply chain. We continue looking for ways to grow Trinity's involvement in the supply chain, whether through organic means or acquisitions. We acknowledge that rail has room to improve regarding predictability and efficiency, but Trinity is committed to contributing to the solution. Having said that, I'll hand things over to Eric, who will provide further details about our results.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#4

Thanks, Jean, and good morning to all of you. The past two years have presented a tough operating backdrop, but at Trinity we still achieved meaningful progress during 2021. We closed on financing transactions totaling roughly $1.6 billion, done in line with our Green Financing Framework and benefiting from interest rates near historic lows, which brought down our overall cost of borrowing by about 100 basis points. We started a joint venture program alongside Wafra, aimed at as much as $1 billion of investments in railcar leases. We sold off our highway business, increased our Quarterly Dividend, and gave back $895 million to shareholders via buybacks and dividends. In sum, our strategic initiatives have advanced considerably, and we are positioned to leverage the operating leverage inherent in our business. Jean discussed how the market is getting better. Key industry metrics clearly reflect this. Orders have climbed, backlog has grown, and scrapping is still robust. Lease rates are moving higher, and we expect the pressures from supply chain and labor disruptions to lessen in upcoming quarters; these market metrics are favorable, yet I also want to underscore my confidence that Trinity in particular is set up well to benefit from these market dynamics. Following the fourth quarter sale of our Highway Products Business and all the efforts to strengthen our balance sheet, our attention is on maximizing returns within our business. I'll start on slide nine with a recap of the quarter. Beginning with the income statement. Fourth quarter consolidated revenue from continuing operations came to $472 million. For the quarter, GAAP earnings per share came in at $0.16. Adjusted earnings per share of $0.08 were lower sequentially, largely because of the gain on the Wafra sale in the third quarter, yet they improved from -$0.02 versus a year ago. Full year Adjusted Earnings Per Share from continued operations reached $0.34, up against full year 2020 Adjusted EPS of $0.16. Now to the cash flow statement. Full year cash flow from continued operations reached $616 million, with 197 million coming in the fourth quarter; during the fourth quarter we collected $189 million of our income tax receivable tied to the CARES Act, which had been left out of our guidance of $450 million-475 million. Our cash flow came in a bit below what we expected since we chose to build up our working capital. That higher working capital leaves us better able to soften some effects of supply chain disruptions. During the quarter, we put $183 million into our lease fleet, taking us to a full year figure of $547 million. Once proceeds from car sales are counted, our net lease fleet investment for the year came to $93 million. Manufacturing CapEx for the quarter was $7 million, bringing our full year manufacturing CapEx to $24 million. Total free cash flow after investments and dividends was $28 million in the fourth quarter, bringing the full year total to $539 million. Like Jean mentioned, we gave back $895 million to shareholders during this year via Share Repurchases and dividends, and in the fourth quarter we raised our Quarterly Dividend by $0.02, which works out to roughly 10%. On the final day of the year, we closed the sale of Trinity Highway Products, and we shifted its financial results — which made up most of what we used to call the All Other segment — into Discontinued Operations. Now we report operating results across two reportable segments: the Railcar Leasing and Management Services Group and the Rail Products Group. Those results are now kept out of continuing operations for both the current and prior periods. Everything I talk about today, along with any forward-looking statements, will leave out Highway Products unless I say otherwise. Historical financials, recasts and our reportable segments can be found in the 10-K we will file today. That 10-K also lays out an accrual we recorded in the fourth quarter related to the Highway Missouri Class Action Lawsuit; our focus is on steering clear of the uncertainty and added cost of this lawsuit and getting the highway litigation behind us. To make things clear and help you stack today's numbers against what we reported before, slide 10 gives the 2021 view with Highway Products included. Highway Products earnings per share, once you exclude the gain on sale and the Missouri class action litigation charge, came to $0.05 in the fourth quarter and $0.28 for the full year. So if you add Trinity Highway Products Adjusted EPS to our Adjusted EPS from continued operations, you get 2021 EPS of $0.13 in the fourth quarter and $0.62 for the full year, which is the comparison to past results. Future results, including the 2022 guidance we're giving today, will be compared to the $0.34 that represents 2021 Adjusted EPS from continued operations. Now on slide 11, let's go through our capitalization. We finished the year with liquidity of $782 million. Looking ahead, we intend to keep prioritizing returns, while also making disciplined investment in our business, whether that's through lease fleet investment or acquisitions. Our cash flow provides us the flexibility and the capability to invest in the business; we think the work we've done to optimize our capital structure gives us the right to grow, and the opportunities we see have us excited. I wanted to give some high level guidance for 2022 on slide 12. As Jean said, we're projecting industry deliveries of 40,000 to 50,000 railcars in 2022, and we expect Trinity to hold a market share of railcar orders and deliveries similar to what we've had historically; Sustainable Railcar Conversions are not included in our industry delivery projections. We expect net lease fleet investment for the year of $450 million to $550 million, which is significantly higher than 2021. That figure includes sales from our lease fleet into our RIV program in the secondary market. Fleet investments and proceeds from these transactions are expected through the year as we actively optimize our fleet. For Trinity's manufacturing capital expenditures, our expectation is a range of $35 million to $45 million, covering investments across Safety, Efficiency and Automation. With improved clarity regarding our operations and a more stable operating backdrop, we're offering EPS guidance for continued operations of $0.85 to 1.05, reflecting roughly 179% growth at the midpoint compared with 2021 Adjusted EPS of $0.34. Throughout the year, we anticipate our earnings will strengthen. The bulk of the improvement compared to last year ought to occur within Rail Products, driven by robust orders and deliveries, plus recovery from disruptions in labor and supply chain; on the leasing side, a rising FLRD means projections of growing revenue across the year, with remarketing rates exceeding expiring rates. On top of that, we keep proactively managing our lease fleet so as to optimize returns; we're bullish on the coming year given the positive momentum we observe across the industry, while also recognizing remaining uncertainty related to COVID-19, supply chain disruption and labor impacts. What's more, we're currently delivering orders that were placed when the cycle was at its lowest point, which we expect will weigh on our margins during the first half of the year. In spite of the extraordinary difficulties of recent years, Trinity has managed to use its platform to generate returns even when the cycle was at its trough; as market conditions get better, we're eager to keep showing the strength of our platform and our capacity to build and maintain value over the long run. As ever, we appreciate your support. Operator, please open the line for questions from our participants.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#5

Morning, and thanks for taking my question. So if I use the middle of your industry delivery guidance and apply the same share of the market we had in 2021, I get roughly 13,600 cars. Jean, Eric, is that the delivery level you anticipate for this year?

Jean Savage

executive
#6

Okay, I'll begin by saying we think industry deliveries will land nearer the top end of our 40,000 to 50,000 range. I should point out that figure excludes our sustainable conversions, and for the industry we anticipate that being between 6,000 and 7,000 cars this year. Then, if you consider it, we expect to be within our historical market share range. I hope that answers it.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#7

Yeah. That is quite useful. Could you share a little more about where you anticipate the margin heading? I realize the first half is going to be somewhat weaker as a result of those low price cars, but what kind of gap should we expect between the first half and the second half, and where do you figure the margin will land for the full year in manufacturing?

Jean Savage

executive
#8

You nailed it exactly. During the first half, we will be delivering some of those cars we picked up when the market was at its bottom, so improvement is what we'd look for in the second half. Let me bring you back to our Investor Day, when we were projecting mid- to high-single digits, and my expectation is that it falls within that range.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#9

Understood. Jean, I have one final follow-up question. If deliveries turn out stronger than the 13,600 figure I brought up, since you sit at the upper end of the range for the industry, plus you have those other cars and a pretty solid margin, then honestly the guidance looks somewhat conservative to me.

Jean Savage

executive
#10

Is there anything I'm overlooking regarding the— Jean Savage: Well, there's still—

Matt Elkott

analyst
#11

What about guidance on earnings?

Jean Savage

executive
#12

Absolutely. A number of challenges remain, and there's still uncertainty about how the year unfolds. Where we have confidence, we want to provide you with as much guidance as possible.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#13

Matt, one more thing from my side, Matt. If you turn to slide 10 of the earnings deck, once you take out the Discontinued Operations as well as the highway business divestiture — that's the Trinity business — the go-forward figure came to $0.34 for 2021. Should you simply use the midpoint from the guidance range I referenced in our script, that works out to a 179% gain compared with a year earlier. Considering the volume, this really shows how much operating leverage exists in this business. It won't be a steady climb, I'll grant you, yet we have confidence that improvement will come through across the year.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#14

Yeah. No. That logic tracks. I mean, I certainly, you know. It's hard to tell how many consensus estimates count the highway business in or leave it out, so comparing them gets a little difficult. Eric, only one more thing on the leasing side. Even though fleet size and utilization went up, your lease revenue fell from one quarter to the next. How much of that might relate to when the utilization and fleet size increases landed? That alone can't account for all of it. Was there a drop in management and services revenue?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#15

Matt, I believe I can address that for you. If you simply look back across the year, starting at Q4 of 2020 and moving quarter by quarter, keep in mind, during the early portion of 2021 our lease rates were still a drag, and they only flipped positive in Q3. We mentioned late in Q2 that renewal activity had begun pushing lease rates upward. What you've got in Q4 is, you know, two or three quarters of lease rate declines, you know, balanced out by two quarters of gains; then comes the timing of the fleet additions we completed. We did some secondary market buying. Those purchases landed very much at the tail end of Q4, so they barely moved revenue at all. As for services, there's a small amount of services revenue, but honestly, when it comes to the drop in Q4 versus Q3 of last year, I'd really chalk it up to shifts in renewal rates and when fleets were added. You know, we completed a big sale in Q3, and that would have dragged on revenue in Q4.

Matt Elkott

analyst
#16

Got it. Thanks very much.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#17

Yep.

Jean Savage

executive
#18

Thanks.

Justin Long

analyst
#19

Thank you, and good morning to everyone.

Jean Savage

executive
#20

Good morning.

Justin Long

analyst
#21

Going back to that margin question—when we look at the opening six months, do you expect the Rail Products Group's margins to decline on a sequential basis compared with the 3.3% you just reported for Q4? Then, in the back half, we're moving toward that mid to high single digit range. I simply wanted to confirm that my thinking on this was correct.

Jean Savage

executive
#22

To start with, Justin, quarterly guidance isn't something we're going to provide. What we're attempting to do is give you an annual figure; we're trying to assist you somewhat by noting that orders taken when the market was at its lowest are still working their way out during Q1 and Q2. Whether we'll go much further into detail than that, I'm not sure—other than, as we've stated, by the time the year ends, my expectation is that we'll land within the range shared with you at Investor Day.

Justin Long

analyst
#23

Alright. Regarding that remark you made as the year wrapped up, you're basically saying the exit rate is going to land somewhere in the mid- to high-single-digits%. Did you mean that for all of 2022, we'd see something in that mid- to high-single-digit range?

Jean Savage

executive
#24

What I'm telling you is the exit rates are going to fall within that mid to high single digit range.

Justin Long

analyst
#25

Understood, that's useful. Regarding gains from selling railcars during this year and the sales themselves, is there anything you can tell us about what's being assumed? Perhaps we could also discuss the share count and the level at which you finished the year, since my assumption is that a fairly significant decline will occur in Q1.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#26

Sure, concerning the fleet sales portion of what you asked, we anticipate greater investment into the lease fleet; we mentioned $450 million-550 million in net fleet investment, which comes after the car sales. That compares with roughly $90 million during 2021. This does, as you know, indicate that we're pointing to considerably more investment. As for activity around car sales, we intend to keep pursuing our Wafra transaction, which began in Q3 of last year. During my script, I noted that the fleet's additions along with its sales will occur across the year. We anticipate less lumpiness, and it will happen throughout the year because it's simply part of our operations. I'll stop there. Does that address what you were looking for regarding fleet additions?

Justin Long

analyst
#27

That sounds excellent. Perhaps we could briefly address the number of shares outstanding.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#28

Sure. Regarding the share count, much of the capital return we completed, as we noted, took place on the final day of the year. It had minimal effect on our average share count during the fourth quarter. In our 10-K, which we will submit later today, you will find a share count of roughly 83 million shares — 83.3, to be precise; that is essentially the figure we are carrying into the year.

Justin Long

analyst
#29

All right. That assumes you also carry out the remaining portion of the buyback authorization.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#30

Correct.

Justin Long

analyst
#31

That's assumed in the guidance.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#32

Yeah. Yeah.

Jean Savage

executive
#33

Yeah.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#34

Within that number for shares, the ASR's effect is included — you know, three quarters of it showed up in what we reported for 2021; beyond that, roughly $73 million comes into play once the ASR wraps up. As for when that ASR finishes, our expectation is that it happens during this year's third quarter.

Justin Long

analyst
#35

All right. That's useful. Thanks for making time for this.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#36

Sure. Thanks.

Jean Savage

executive
#37

Thanks.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#38

Hello, good morning.

Jean Savage

executive
#39

Good morning.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#40

Let's go back to those supply chain and labor issues — obviously not something only Trinity is dealing with. Could you help us get a handle on what you had planned for Q4 that you couldn't carry out because of those problems, meaning it basically got moved into this year? And then the other piece is supply chain. I know Eric talked about boosting working capital to help even some of that out, but have you begun reaching beyond the supply chain or the people you already work with in order to, given all the difficulties out there right now, lock things down more firmly? Any thoughts on that would be helpful.

Jean Savage

executive
#41

Sure. Looking at it, a few different things happened with the deliveries at the end of the year that ended up moving into this year. There was a big order that had to go out in January, right at the start of the year, so we had to get those built and then keep them on hand until January; we also had hatch covers where a supply chain problem was happening in the third quarter, and we're still dealing with that today, which made us push back delivery of some cars from the fourth quarter into the first quarter of this year. Looking at the supply chain as a whole, for certain items where we were running into trouble — hatch covers, valves, a few others — we made the decision to try going a bit longer on some of them, so we could be sure we had them and avoid disrupting the line during the year. I won't claim everything is fully taken care of. Things appear to be getting better, but we'll keep working to remain ahead of it.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#42

Understood, that's useful. Then regarding those Sustainable Railcar Conversions, the backlog came to slightly more than 1,000. Do we expect those to be delivered within this year, or does it stretch across multiple years? I'm simply attempting to grasp the timing pattern there.

Jean Savage

executive
#43

All right. When I mentioned the industry figure for this year, it was 6,000 to 7,000 units that would be delivered during this year.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#44

Related to our backlog, those will get delivered this year, Allison.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#45

They're going to. All right, that's great. Only one more item from me. A great deal of rationalization took place, as you're aware, during the most recent geographic slump. As we consider the sector returning to replacement demand levels inside your regions, is there any need, I'd ask, to bring plants back online, or are you able to absorb that added volume using the plants you already have geographically for production as things stand today?

Jean Savage

executive
#46

We have every confidence that our existing production footprint can absorb the recovery up to replacement demand.

Allison Poliniak

analyst
#47

Perfect. Thank you.

Jean Savage

executive
#48

Thank you.

Gordon Johnson

analyst
#49

Hello, everyone. Appreciate you fielding this. I suppose I have a handful of, I suppose, broader-picture items for you. Could you first discuss what's happening with car storage? As I recall, the peak we hit before was 500,000. I didn't catch any mention from you about roughly where things stand at present, or roughly how you see that moving, and then I've got one more thing to ask.

Jean Savage

executive
#50

All right. At present, roughly 312,000 railcars sit in storage. Of that group, around 81% remain in service, which means 19% have not been moved over the past 12 months or so. As for the rest, they are essentially just sitting on the—

Eric Marchetto

executive
#51

60. Over the most recent 60 days.

Jean Savage

executive
#52

My apologies — the most recent 60 days. Which means the rest of them simply come and go. Maintenance has to get done on those units. Their service is being changed over. Additional matters are happening with those as well. We've recorded 19 consecutive months in which storage of rail cars has declined.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#53

One more thing I'd mention: if you consider train velocity and a few of the challenges the railroads have faced, including weather, I believe one development is unmistakable — cars are being pulled from storage to meet that demand, and over the long term that's not a great situation. Ideally, we want the rail network to operate far more efficiently; for now, that's among the factors tightening supply and simultaneously letting lease rates climb. As you know, once the railroads work through certain of their own supply chain bottlenecks, our view is that demand exists for railcar loads to gradually grow into the fleet.

Gordon Johnson

analyst
#54

All right, that's useful. Look, we've had a shortage of truckers for most of the last ten years, but I'd say the railroads never really took full advantage of it. Do you have any plans to tackle that? And finally, I talked not long ago with someone known as one of the bigger doubters in this business, and it caught me off guard when he told me the railcar sector is in the strongest position we've seen in 6 years. Then he added a caveat: he's hoping this year's production doesn't exceed 40,000 cars, which would worsen overbuilding. It sounds like you're hinting — not sure whether 10,000 cars makes a difference — but could you respond to both of those? Appreciate your time, everyone.

Jean Savage

executive
#55

Alright, I'll begin with the second thing you asked about. Over the last 3 years, roughly 150,000 vehicles were scrapped — pulled out of the system entirely. Looking at that, a number of people moved up their scrapping since the scrap rates available on those vehicles were high. That created a need to return to the 40,000 to 50,000 vehicle range. Even at the start of this year, the pace was fairly heavy. Our view is that it will begin to ease, particularly as Eric just said, because locating those vehicles is becoming much harder. Unless the industry gets some replacements, they will need to push back — at minimum, we believe in the second half — push back additional scrapping; in our view it makes a lot of sense to expect the coming few years, 2 or 3 years, to fall within that 40,000 to 50,000 range. That is, at least, how we see things unfolding. A super cycle is not something we foresee.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#56

Gordon, I'd like to build on that point. As a major manufacturer, we also operate a sizable lease fleet. In my view, we enjoy strong insight into commercial activity across the North American market, and we aren't observing much ordering driven by speculation. When we examine our lease fleet, any additions we make—whether bringing in equipment or securing space—must clear our return thresholds, and we carry a substantial residual position. Given where we stand, my expectation is that this market will show greater discipline during the current cycle than it has previously. There is, you know, demand that aligns with the volume we're producing.

Jean Savage

executive
#57

Returning to the first thing you asked, we mentioned during our prepared comments that we aim to play a role in fixing the problems causing inefficiency in rail right now. RailPulse is one avenue we're exploring for that. You're probably familiar with it. Should shippers gain a means to see more clearly where their cars are located, letting them manage their supply chain more effectively, my belief is that a greater share of traffic, or car loads, will shift onto railcars rather than staying on trucks; that represents just a single approach we're taking to operate inside the existing framework and improve things for the entire sector. This isn't solely a Trinity initiative — it's a push involving the whole industry.

Gordon Johnson

analyst
#58

Thanks again for the questions.

Jean Savage

executive
#59

Thank you.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#60

Yes, hello. So, you've already aligned a few of those longer-horizon forecasts with what you're expecting this year regarding industry deliveries and manufacturing margins. I was hoping you might discuss the net portfolio lease investment a bit. My understanding is you'd mentioned somewhere around $500 million to $600 million across three years. This year's figure combined with last year's would put you comfortably inside that band. I'm just wondering whether there's perhaps some caution baked into how sales get modeled before a deal is actually signed, or whether you see that investment climbing past that range. Anything you can offer to help us think through this year and the next would be useful. Thanks.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#61

Hey, Bascom, this is Eric. Great question. Your assumptions are correct — combining our guidance with what we achieved last year essentially gets us to a three-year plan. There's still plenty of activity that needs to unfold. Much of it comes down to timing. My sense is our three-year plan outlook hasn't shifted. With the Wafra transaction, our intention is to divest roughly $1 billion worth of railcars across that three-year span. Based on our projections — which incorporate assumptions regarding what gets leased versus what goes to direct sale — the timing of those additions matters, since you can't simply put a car on lease and sell it that same day. Thinking about it across the three-year period, I'd say I remain at ease with our three-year guide, and it really is a matter of timing. Lease pricing has me feeling encouraged. It has gotten better. As we examine our capital allocation framework, putting money into leasing looks considerably more appealing than it did a year ago, for instance. That's a nice problem to deal with, and we'll keep assessing it. Should our outlook on that change, you'll be the first to know.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#62

Okay, so to put some shape around that, I just want to ask a follow-up, because regarding what Justin said a bit earlier, I think you mentioned something about seeing more consistent gains on sale across both the investment side and the disposition pace when it comes to the lease fleet. Those remarks seem to indicate that there could be some unevenness from one year to the next, and in terms of arriving at that net $500 million-600 million across a year. Could you just-

Eric Marchetto

executive
#63

Yeah

Bascome Majors

analyst
#64

So could you pull those two together and confirm we're getting one coherent story? Thanks.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#65

Right. I'd say the timing of putting a railcar into our fleet, versus possibly selling one off, will vary. Modeling a railcar sale is tough if there's no railcar order in place, particularly when it's tied to a syndication plan. You need to be certain that all deliveries happen and so on. As you mentioned, when you triangulate every one of our assumptions against a one-year assumption, some lumpiness between years is inevitable with respect to those three-year assumptions. I'd say our additions and dispositions should be considerably smoother in 2022 than they were in 2021. In 2021, essentially the bulk of it landed in Q3. Compared with 2021, we'd anticipate 2022 being smoother. It won't be a straight line by any means, but it ought to be smoother.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#66

Alright. I appreciate that. And, you know, finally, you know, you mentioned briefly the operating margin on an exit rate back inside the range you'd guided to. I think it was mid- to high-single digits%. Do you feel more or less confident about where this thing is headed regarding the manufacturing cycle and margins at that so-called mid-cycle, whether that's 2023 or later? Or I'm just wondering, you know, compared with 6, 12 months ago, how do you feel about where the cycle is going right now? Thank you.

Jean Savage

executive
#67

Thanks. I'll handle that one. We feel a lot better about where the cycle is going compared with the last couple years. You know, we just reached the bottom. We turned and began seeing orders in the third quarter of last year. Definitely a different feel. We also did a lot of heavy lifting during that first year and a half, where we were going through and shutting some facilities, making sure we right-sized everything at those facilities. We relocated supply chain. All of it; we installed some automation, some new technology. All of that cost us some money to get that done. We were doing that at the bottom of the cycle. Now what we're looking forward to as the cycle starts to recover, we should see the benefits from that. And that's why we're saying as the volume comes up, it's gonna be better for us and especially if it stabilizes. Hopefully that helps.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#68

Okay, this will be my final question. I'm not going to push for figures that you aren't in a position to guide on. I realize you remain committed to your three-year outlook, and no EPS figure is included in it. That said, what would have to take place before you'd want to sharpen your guidance a bit more regarding the direction of things in year three? In other words, is that truly something for January or February of 2023? Or could there come a moment when, after getting past certain things you hope to see occur during this year, holding something like an Investor Day and offering somewhat greater visibility into year three would make sense? Thank you.

Jean Savage

executive
#69

Thanks for that clarification. As we move nearer to the third year, our expectation is that we'd begin refreshing certain assumptions and could share our view of what will likely unfold, along with where we stand in terms of finishing the three-year plan, while also beginning to discuss the following years within that cycle. Watch for that ahead, and the timing you mentioned seems roughly correct. Thank you.

Bascome Majors

analyst
#70

Thanks.

Steve Barger

analyst
#71

Hello, everybody.

Jean Savage

executive
#72

Good morning.

Steve Barger

analyst
#73

From what you're hearing from customers, should we expect conversion activity to pick up — or, being realistic, do you see yourselves shipping more than 1,150 during this year?

Jean Savage

executive
#74

My sense is that it will pick up speed. Appetite for this has grown considerably now that folks are beginning to watch those units go out, get them running, and recognize how useful that is. It supports getting more out of the assets you already own, and it additionally assists on the whole with certain of the rates.

Steve Barger

analyst
#75

As conversions keep contributing more, how should we be thinking about the revenue and the margin that comes from that?

Jean Savage

executive
#76

Honestly, it lines up quite closely with what we see on new products. Keep in mind, this market is truly driven by freight cars, but when you look at margins for conversions as a whole, they come in very close to what you'd anticipate on a new car.

Steve Barger

analyst
#77

Is it right to view that revenue figure as being equal to half of what a typical new car brings in, or is it 70%?

Jean Savage

executive
#78

That depends on what is going to take place. When a modification is a heavy one, the range is roughly 50%-70%.

Steve Barger

analyst
#79

Okay.

Jean Savage

executive
#80

Yes.

Steve Barger

analyst
#81

Steve, regarding the margin profile you brought up and the net fleet additions you mentioned, how should we think about working capital for this year? And more generally, what's your expectation for operating cash flow in 2022?

Eric Marchetto

executive
#82

Yes, Steve. Like I said, working capital did build during the fourth quarter, and my expectation is that it keeps building through this year as production rates go up. Guidance on operating cash flow wasn't something we provided. Clearly, looking at 2021, significant tax refunds gave us a boost. That's now behind us, so that benefit won't be there. It's going to look more like a typical operating cash flow, and this business will generate significant operating cash. Working capital will act as a headwind, and that affects what we generate in operating cash flow.

Steve Barger

analyst
#83

Correct. Both of those will flip. The tax advantage won't be there, and as the year progresses you'll see working capital increase.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#84

Yes.

Steve Barger

analyst
#85

Relative to 21.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#86

Exactly. Right.

Steve Barger

analyst
#87

I apologize if I overlooked this. For whatever quantity you end up delivering, do you anticipate that the pace of deliveries will be evenly distributed among the quarters?

Jean Savage

executive
#88

No. Looking at it over the course of the year, my expectation is that it will increase from one quarter to the next.

Steve Barger

analyst
#89

All right, only one more from me. So, profits have been fairly tight across the last 4 years, you know. The guidance for 2022 landed under what the consensus was. And going back to 2017, there's been a pretty big drop in the number of shares outstanding. If deliveries rise once more in 2023 and lease rates keep getting better, do you figure earnings could begin to resemble 2017 once again? I suppose, how are you viewing the way this unfolds? Because it really seems like — clearly, industry conditions have been rough — but the recovery has ramped up quite slowly.

Jean Savage

executive
#90

All right, very briefly, I'll kick things off and then let Eric come in and add. Looking at it, back in 2020, when the pandemic hit and orders dropped off, we deliberately decided to push forward with some major shifts inside the company to position it for the recovery. Those moves are still ongoing, though most wrapped up during 2020 and 2021, and that weighs on EPS. Should the market keep bouncing back and we complete every one of the initiatives we've got — and we fully plan to — I believe that gets you into our range, and after that's finished, we'll begin discussing what you ought to expect from EPS on a continuing basis. Keep in mind, the reason for all that effort across 2020 and 2021 was to aid us when the next downturn arrives. Our goal was making sure manufacturing didn't drag things down at the trough of a typical cycle and instead added value as the cycle climbed. Those dynamics are only now beginning to play out. This year, at last, you're going to see volumes begin rising. Once more, we're forecasting volumes to remain at minimum within the 40 to 50 range over the following couple of years. I believe you'll witness how our platform does far better in that sort of setting.

Eric Marchetto

executive
#91

Steve, one thing I'd tack on. Regarding how it stacks up against 2017, I won't go there, but your core argument strikes me as right — there's a great deal of operating leverage in this operation. Once the highway divestiture is behind us, the company becomes far less complicated: it's strictly rail — building railcars, leasing railcars, servicing railcars — and yes, substantial operating leverage exists within it. Looking back across the past several years, since the spin, our share count has fallen quite a bit — roughly 40 million, 45 million, 50 million shares removed. Once earnings begin to move, I believe you'll witness additional leverage when it comes to earnings per share. The arithmetic alone dictates that outcome.

Steve Barger

analyst
#92

Yep. That'll be nice to check out. Appreciate it.

Jean Savage

executive
#93

Thanks.

Jean Savage

executive
#94

Okay, thanks for being with us today. We've entered year two of a plan that spans three years, and we're right where we should be to hit the targets we laid out during Analyst Day toward the end of 2020. At Trinity, 2021 became a period focused on fine-tuning — refining the balance sheet, the lease fleet, and the business as a whole. Given how we've performed so far and what remains under this strategic plan, we believe Trinity is set up to deliver meaningful expansion in the coming years, particularly as the rail car market keeps getting better. Thanks once more, and we're eager to share how things are going on our upcoming conference call.

Operator

operator
#95

That brings us to the end of today's conference, everyone. Thanks so much for joining the presentation. You're welcome to hang up your lines at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Trinity Industries, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Trinity Industries, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Trinity Industries, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.