Trinity Industries, Inc. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 25, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Leigh Anne Mann
executiveThanks, operator. Morning, all. We're glad you could be with us for the company's third quarter 2022 financial results conference call. Jean Savage, Trinity's chief executive officer and president, and Eric Marchetto, the company's chief financial officer, will provide comments in our prepared remarks. After our leaders give those prepared remarks, we'll hold a Q&A session. On today's call, we'll refer to slides that highlight key points of discussion, along with certain non-GAAP financial metrics. Reconciliations of the non-GAAP metrics to comparable GAAP measures appear in the appendix of the supplemental slides, which you can access on our investor relations website at www.trin.net; those slides are located under the Events and Presentations portion of the website, together with the third quarter earnings conference call event link. A replay of today's call will be accessible after 10:30 A.M. Eastern Time through midnight on November 1s, 2022. Replay information can be found under the Events and Presentations page on our investor relations website. I'm now pleased to hand the call over to Jean.
Jean Savage
executiveThanks, Leigh Ann, and hello to everyone on the line this morning. Back in July, the last time we talked, I said we anticipated a meaningful step-up during the second half of the year when it came to building railcars, growing lease rates, and delivering stronger financial performance. Today I'm happy to say we're tracking exactly along the path we described, and momentum keeps building in the markets we serve. Sure, the economy carries plenty of uncertainty right now, but we think both our company and this industry can withstand a minor recession. What supports that view is how much the supply-demand balance for railcars has improved over the last two years. Bottom line: our take on the business has hardly shifted since last quarter. Please turn with me to slide 3, where I'll walk through the key messages from today's call — we'll dig into all of them in more depth later during our prepared remarks. To start, we're posting GAAP EPS of $0.35, along with Adjusted EPS from continuing operations of $0.34 for the third quarter — that's a rise of $0.20 versus last quarter and $0.16 higher than a year ago. As you'll hear in what we say today, the results demonstrate strength throughout our businesses, since greater external deliveries plus gains from yet another successful Wafra transaction lifted our performance. Next, our future lease rate differential, or FLRD, came in at positive 11% for the quarter, which in our view proves the market will keep backing healthy gains in renewal lease rates. The reason is stronger fleet utilization during the quarter — 97.9% for our lease fleet — which shows demand is still elevated while the supply available remains tight. Third, during this quarter we closed on selling 2,678 railcars to our joint venture with Wafra, part of the rail investment vehicle program we announced previously. That sale brought in proceeds of $254 million, and we booked a gain of $25 million within our leasing business. Beyond the Wafra car sale, we disposed of a number of other small portfolios during the quarter, generating total proceeds of $300 million and a gain of $34 million. Last, earlier this month we announced a six-year, 15,000 railcar order, and that pushed our reportable third quarter backlog to an impressive $4.1 billion, while our book-to-bill ratio for the quarter reached five times. This order added $1.8 billion to our backlog. Once again, every one of these sales and orders reflects the visibility we have into demand versus supply for our industry; it's encouraging that so many of our customers keep making long-term investment decisions. Now let's move to slide 4 for a market update. Rail traffic continues to feel the effects of labor shortages and service problems, though we're beginning to see some of that ease. Rail traffic remains under pre-pandemic levels, yet improvements in railroad headcounts keep coming, and we view that as a necessary step toward supporting better rail service. A fast fix doesn't exist here, yet we fully back greater efficiency and better service across the rail sector. Railcars sitting in storage had fallen for 23 straight months, then the storage figure rose a bit during the summer, mostly because seasonal grain cars returned to storage ahead of the fall harvest and tank cars went into storage to get ready for the winter heating season. That pattern flipped, though, in October, when the AAR reported 16.9% of cars as inactive, versus almost 21% one year earlier. That marks the smallest share of inactive cars for any October since 2018, and the smallest absolute count of idle railcars since 2015. Turning to the Trinity-specific figures on the lower portion of the slide, as I noted at the start of this call, our FLRD and fleet utilization are again favorable this quarter, and we think they will lift leasing revenues in the quarters ahead. Our FLRD slipped a little versus last quarter, though that reflects the mix of cars reaching expiration more than any drop in remarketing rates. The firmness in lease rates is widespread; we delivered 3,935 railcars this quarter, which is 57% above the second quarter, even with ongoing railroad service problems and supply chain disruption. During the prior quarter, we said our plan was to roughly double deliveries in the back half of the year relative to the front half. Production pace keeps speeding up, and we still see a clear path to hitting that goal in 2022. Now for orders: besides the 15,000 railcar multi-year order with GATX, we booked orders for another 4,500 railcars during the third quarter, which shows the market's ongoing momentum; in our view, demand is being fueled by the retirement of older assets, so we would anticipate order volumes holding steady near term even with macroeconomic uncertainty. Lessors appear less speculative than in earlier cycles, which keeps demand steadier and more rationalized. As our backlog keeps expanding, Trinity has started accepting orders for production slots in 2024. We remain convinced that supplying railcars to shippers, railroads and other leasing companies gives us the widest perspective on industry trends and dynamics and, in the end, produces strong returns for our shareholders. The multi-year GATX order showcases the strength and the long-standing relationships we have built in this industry. Under this renewed supply agreement, we anticipate delivering a combination of 15,000 newly built tank and freight railcars across a six year span. We're eager to keep this partnership going, since it supplies a baseload of orders through the next 6 years. On to slide 5. Revenue for the quarter came to $497 million, an 18% rise year-over-year, and adjusted earnings per share of $0.34 increased $0.16 year-over-year. Cash flow for the quarter was $9 million, while free cash flow was -$42 million. Eric is going to get into the details of our cash flow, but basically, this was the quarter we anticipated as we keep building up working capital to get ready for a faster cadence of deliveries and reduce supply chain exposure wherever possible. Now let's move to slide 6, where we'll look at results by segment. Leasing revenue came in at $195 million, which was flat versus the prior quarter, and our fleet got a bit smaller by the end; renewals came in above the rates that were expiring during the period, with an 82% success rate on renewals; that marks a fifth straight quarter of positive FLRD, and since we keep repricing the fleet, we anticipate revenue growth in this segment that drops directly to the bottom line. Fleet composition shifts stemming from net lease fleet investment activities also affect revenue. If you set aside car sales, operating profit margins for leasing and management dipped slightly on a sequential basis, driven by greater fleet operating costs and increased depreciation tied to our sustainable railcar conversion program. The overall operating profit margin for that segment got a boost from the $25 million gain on the sale of railcars to Wafra. Gains from selling railcars remain, in our view, a routine and repeating element of what we do.
Jean Savage
executiveWe constantly work on optimizing the fleet. With two levers — production and fleet ownership — we have multiple ways to determine the smartest use of our capital. Turning to rail products, revenue came in at $597 million, which rose 39% from the prior quarter and 76% compared with a year ago, fueled by a significant jump in deliveries during the quarter along with improved pricing dynamics. Our operating margin reached 4.4%, also better sequentially, climbing 120 basis points thanks to stronger pricing dynamics and railcars delivered. During the quarter, we recorded a gain of $1.1 million from insurance recoveries. That amount is left out of our adjusted consolidated results but sits inside the rail products group. If you take out that gain, the operating profit margin for rail products would have been 4.2% for the quarter. Although supply chain challenges have been easing throughout the network, rail service problems and congestion at the U.S.-Mexico border hurt our production and deliveries in the quarter. I take pride in how our operations team has adjusted to this shifting environment to serve our customers' needs; that flexibility carried a cost, reducing operating margins by 300 basis points during the quarter. Lastly, on slide 7, I want to call out a few other actions we took in the quarter that support our longer-term strategic initiatives. We amended and renewed our revolver for a fresh 5-year term and amended both our warehouse and revolver facilities so they are indexed to SOFR, anticipating the upcoming phase-out of LIBOR. We bought back $14 million in shares and have $34 million left under our current authorization. So far this year, our net investment in the lease fleet stands at $176 million, which declined during the quarter because of our sizable portfolio sale to Wafra, which more than offset fleet additions. Our sustainable railcar conversion program keeps producing solid results, and the present conversion backlog totals 2,400 railcars. Last, I'm pleased to share that Trinity held its first ESG roadshow. If you'd like to read about some of the excellent initiatives our team is working on, the presentation is up on our website. I'm struck by Trinity's dedication to better sustainability, for our business and for the industry overall, as we carry out our company's purpose of delivering goods for the good of all. I'll now hand the call to Eric so he can walk through our financial results.
Eric Marchetto
executiveThank you, Jean, and good morning to all of you. I'll begin my remarks by referring to slide 8. If we look first at the income statement, total revenues came in at $497 million, which reflects an increase in external railcar deliveries. Adjusted earnings per share from continuing operations equal $0.34, and that figure leaves out the gain tied to insurance recoveries. As Jean noted, during the quarter we saw a benefit from the $254 million lease portfolio sale to Wafra. Now let's turn to the cash flow statement. Cash from continuing operations totaled $9 million, while free cash flow for the quarter came to -$42 million. The primary reason is a year-to-date working capital increase of $226 million, which stems from several different factors. First, since we are getting ready for more deliveries, we have built up inventories ahead of a faster production pace. Inventories were also impacted by the rail service problems at the border that Jean brought up. And lastly, raw materials cost more in today's environment. Once we deliver the railcars now being produced, we anticipate an improvement in cash flow. Our net lease fleet investment so far this year stands at $176 million. During the third quarter, we added $217 million in new railcar deliveries to our lease fleet, along with a modest secondary market portfolio purchase. Beyond the Wafra car sale, we disposed of additional leased railcars during the quarter, generating total proceeds of $300 million and a gain of 34 million. Secondary market valuations continue to be robust, which mirrors assumptions of increasing lease rates and higher input costs for new railcars. We stay disciplined when it comes to secondary market transactions and regard them as an efficient means of optimizing our fleet and capitalizing on whatever opportunities arise in the market. Picking up our discussion of liquidity, please go to slide nine. At present, our liquidity equals $465 million; with interest rates climbing, our debt profile features a favorable blend of fixed and floating rate debt, comparatively low interest rates, and nothing maturing before 2024. Together with the strength of our lease fleet and a solid manufacturing backlog, this debt profile gives us clear visibility into cash flow across the next several quarters as we keep optimizing the business. Although we are not ready to offer commentary regarding 2023, we believe railcar demand will stay strong, and we look to finish this year with solid momentum and visibility. Please go to slide 10, where I will discuss what we expect for the remainder of 2022. Our thinking remains that industry deliveries this year will land somewhere between 40,000 to 50,000 railcars, driven mostly by replacement demand. Our views have stayed the same as the year has unfolded, even with macroeconomic headwinds. Because of lower internal deliveries and greater railcar sales, we are adjusting our guidance for net lease fleet investment this year to a range of $250 million-$300 million. Taking into account how the broader economy is behaving, we're pacing our investments carefully since certain deliveries have slipped to next year; at the same time, we capitalized on a favorable secondary market, and railcar sales came in above what we'd projected. So far this year, net lease fleet investment stands at $176 million, made up of $532 million in fleet additions — via both internal deliveries and secondary market purchases — plus $159 million in fleet modifications and conversions, less $515 million from railcar sales; our three-year net lease fleet investment forecast remains on target. And now, with nine months behind us, we're reaffirming our Adjusted EPS guidance range of $0.90-$1.10 for continuing operations. Results in our fourth quarter should improve sequentially, driven by greater expected external deliveries. That said, we should recognize that additional rail service problems or other supply chain difficulties could push some deliveries into 2023; we feel we have solid visibility into fourth quarter deliveries and have spent the entire year mitigating supply chain risk. Although higher interest rates don't directly hit us, their effects still reach us. Our full year guidance accounts for interest expense that came in far above what we'd anticipated. Before opening the floor to questions, I wanted to touch briefly on the three-year targets we rolled out in November of 2020. 2023 marks year three of that plan. Even with an operating environment that proved difficult and unforeseen throughout the plan period, we're still positioned to achieve every objective we set except one. Back in 2020, we forecast cash flow from operations of $1.5 billion-$2 billion across those three years. Over seven quarters, we've produced $563 million, and given what we can see for 2023, we're adjusting that target. We now expect three-year cash from operations to land somewhere between $1.2 billion and $1.4 billion. Our original assumption factored in cash flow from our highway business, which this update removes. On top of that, substantially greater working capital in the geography of railcar sales is weighing on our cash flow forecast, partly offset by the timing of cash received from our income tax receivable. We think we're still on course for the remaining three-year targets, even with plenty of unforeseen headwinds in the market, and should our expectations shift over the coming year, we'll keep you informed. Bringing everything together, I want to echo what Jean said at the beginning of this call. We view our third quarter results as evidence that we can deliver on our goals, and we're encouraged by the progress being made. With strong forward-looking metrics, we anticipate closing out 2022 carrying considerable momentum into 2023. Operator, at this point we're ready to take our first question.
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystHello, and good morning. The lease rate figures we're seeing right now are quite strong, obviously, when you consider renewals along with pricing and similar factors. Worries about the macro picture are definitely affecting how people feel at the moment. Could you perhaps provide a bit more detail, purely in absolute terms, regarding what stabilization looks like from your vantage point? Are there any verticals where your concern has ticked up a little more recently? Any additional insight into how we ought to frame that market across the coming months would help. Thank you.
Jean Savage
executiveOf course. As you examine the various markets, Allison, demand really is fairly widespread, which our utilization figures make clear. We do still have a few small areas where tank cars sit idle. Yet when we consider the chance of a mild recession, the markets tied more closely to consumers and their spending likely carry the greatest risk; that means automotive, plus certain goods that travel via intermodal. Turning to chemicals, North America's robust results in that space will likely shield it to some degree. Energy and agriculture generally shift regardless of broader economic conditions. That brings us to construction. Declines in housing will create some strain, though the infrastructure bill that got approved ought to deliver some activity or backing there, particularly for items such as aggregates or asphalt.
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystThanks, that's useful. Regarding rail manufacturing, there's a pretty big headwind coming from the transport side. You brought up the US-Mexico problems, as you're aware. From what I can tell, it looks like deliveries would pick back up in Q2 or Q4. What's the right way to frame that headwind? Does it begin to ease somewhat, or could it actually get worse given how many deliveries you expect over the remainder of the year? Any perspective would help.
Jean Savage
executiveWhat's good, Allison, is that so far this quarter we haven't run into those same headwinds. In the prior quarter, however, we saw a 20% reduction in production days at our largest-volume manufacturing plant, and 10% at the second-largest; the effect was quite significant. We managed to make up for part of it through overtime and weekend shifts, yet it remained a substantial headwind — somewhere between 500 and 1,000 cars during the quarter that were already being built but couldn't be delivered. We have to move beyond that. Once more, things are getting better. Our hope is simply that it continues.
Allison Poliniak-Cusic
analystGreat, thanks. I'll share that.
Justin Long
analystThanks, good morning. I just want to build on what was asked before. Jean, I believe you said the cross-border problems created roughly a 300 basis point hit to margins. I was hoping you could confirm whether you meant the rail product group margins when you said that. For Eric, regarding the net lease fleet investment, the guidance midpoint dropped by $175 million. It seems like that reflects both more rail car sales and less money put into the lease fleet. Could you split out those two pieces and explain what caused that $175 million decrease?
Jean Savage
executiveSure, I'll take the first one, Justin. Yes, the 300 basis points related to the rail products margin I was discussing, and the reason was what I just told Allison or replied to Allison about.
Eric Marchetto
executiveOkay, Justin — Eric here. You've got it right: what's driving the decrease in our net fleet CapEx, or net fleet investment, is really a mix of fewer deliveries. Part of that comes from deliveries that slipped out of this year — the ones Jean just mentioned, which hit the third quarter. A portion of those won't land in the year at all. We're definitely seeing a really robust secondary market at the moment. Given the railcars we've handed over, plus our three-year outlook for net fleet investment, we figure now is a good moment to act on that and therefore sell more cars. The market is there, and when you put those two factors together, that's what produces the net fleet investment figure. It's driven more by deliveries being pushed out than by car sales, but it's a blend of both.
Justin Long
analystUnderstood. For my next question, I'd like to ask more about what you said regarding the secondary market. It appears to remain quite robust at present, though it's clear rates of interest are climbing. What I'd like to know is whether you have any early views on where the secondary market is headed as we go into 2023. As you're aware, rail car sales have been at an elevated level over the past several years. Do you have any perspective on what gains on rail car sales might look like at a normalized level?
Eric Marchetto
executiveI won't provide a normalized figure. I'm not going to give you gains at a normalized level, but what I would say is that activity will take place. How much lease origination activity we complete plays a part in that. Clearly, when lease origination activity rises, a greater amount would pass through the gain line. That depends to some degree on the market and on what our customers decide to do. Turning back to the secondary market specifically, you are correct that rates of interest have risen. What I'd share with you is that based on what we observe and our experience in the secondary market, there is definitely an expectation that lease rates will keep getting better as buyers take on higher lease rates. I touched on this briefly in my script — that this is producing appealing valuations in the secondary market. Even though rates of interest are rising, which does have an impact on funding costs, the revenue line, or the assumptions regarding lease rates, is rising too, in tandem with that, which points to the general tightness in the market and the longer-term outlook for rail.
Justin Long
analystAll right, understood. Thanks.
Matt Elkott
analystMorning. Appreciate it. Going off your projection of doubling shipments during the back half, I believe I get to roughly 6,000 vehicles for Q4. I'm curious whether you could speak to how quickly those deliveries will occur and what the quarterly delivery figure looks like as we move into 2023. Should we expect a step down during the first half, or does that pace hold?
Jean Savage
executiveMatt, we'll return in February next year and provide our 2023 guidance. When we consider Q4, we've by now brought on board every worker required to build the product for this year. That's an encouraging signal. We ought to wrap up speeding up that ramp quite soon, and after that be in a position to handle items such as those I brought up during my prepared remarks. You know, orders for 2024 are already beginning to come in, so that's the single detail I'll share with you, apart from the fact that we'll be back in February.
Matt Elkott
analystGot it.
Jean Savage
executiveNow one-
Matt Elkott
analystYeah. My apologies.
Jean Savage
executiveMy apologies. There's one more item I want to share with you, Matt. Beyond that, when it comes to inquiry levels, they're still tracking where the industry needs them to be for 40,000 to 50,000 railcars to be delivered in the coming year.
Matt Elkott
analystAll right, that's useful. Does the first quarter usually have anything built into it that would make deliveries drop somewhat, or is that not really the case, since you've been adding resources? I'm basically just trying to figure out how uneven things might look during 2023.
Jean Savage
executiveNothing structural exists that would alter anything.
Matt Elkott
analystAll right, understood. I just want to ask something brief regarding lease rates. It's encouraging to observe that the momentum in lease rates keeps building. From what I recall, the sequential gain on a quarter-over-quarter basis has fallen somewhere between the high single digits% and the mid- to high teens% for the industry, and perhaps for you guys as well. Could you describe how large the percentage increase was in the third quarter compared with the fourth quarter? And should we expect that to naturally taper off going forward, considering it has now been happening for two years?
Eric Marchetto
executiveMatt, is your request for us to forecast the FLRD for the fourth quarter? Is that what you're asking me? Is that the nature of your question?
Matt Elkott
analystNo. Eric, to start with Q3 — my question concerned spot rates. Say you look at a cross-section of the fleet; in the spot market, how much did things improve percentage-wise in Q3 compared with Q4?
Eric Marchetto
executiveYeah, getting into every one of those specifics isn't something I plan to do. What I'd say is that on a sequential basis, lease rates keep getting better. Considering interest rates alongside new railcar asset prices, plus how tight the market is, lease rates ought to keep climbing. From where they stood in Q3, we'd anticipate lease rates improving sequentially as we move into Q4 and on into next year. That's about as clear as I can put it.
Matt Elkott
analystYeah, that's useful. So I realize there's a bit of a split between freight cars and tank cars, and my understanding is that a number of tank cars will be due for scheduled maintenance over the next several years. Could you discuss how that will affect the industry's utilization figure for tank cars, both optically and in real terms, if the effect is genuine?
Eric Marchetto
executiveI believe you're pointing to two separate items. The first is the retirement of flammable tank cars, which for ethanol arrives in May of 2023. 2023 is simply a heavier year by nature for tank car compliance, for units built in 2013, 2014, and so on. Each of those will matter. Regarding the retirement, I'd say the industry has managed that transition quite well. The majority of those cars serving ethanol are compliant, and for those that aren't compliant as of today, we have clear visibility that they'll either be modified or swapped out for new tank cars. From that angle, I don't see any sort of sharp supply shifts. We'll observe additional compliance next year and in the years ahead. As you know, that might affect what shows up in the AAR figures, since those tank cars that enter shops won't move for possibly 60 days or more. That might create an effect that makes the number appear artificially low. On the flip side, it's going to place strain on the current tank car fleet. That'll tighten the fleet somewhat; we do believe that's already being accounted for in shippers' fleet planning choices as they head into 2023 and 2024.
Matt Elkott
analystAll right, thanks Eric. And thank you, Jean. I appreciate it.
Jean Savage
executiveThanks.
Bascome Majors
analystAbout the fourth quarter, can you talk a little more about why interest expense is so high, or give us a range for what the guidance assumes? On the $0.40-$0.60 that's implied for this quarter, I understand you won't roll that into next year — you've been very clear on that — but if there are pieces of that guidance or meaningful levers you can see and want to make sure both the sell side and buy side know about, a qualitative walk-through of those pieces would help. Thanks.
Jean Savage
executiveI'll start with the second part, then Eric will cover interest. One of the items I'd point to is that for a while now we've said industry deliveries should come in at 40,000 to 50,000. We said that for this year; we talked about the next couple of years staying at that level. Looking at the whole industry with that kind of stability and the number of cars that have to be delivered, it should help everyone improve their efficiency, because you don't have the ramp up or ramp down that typically happens when you get either a bigger input or a bigger lift in the cycle, or when you're in decline. Those things should help settle what's going on and let companies maximize that efficiency to iron out any problems they've run into during the ramp up. On our fixed to floating rate debt, we're roughly 80% to 20% fixed to floating. I'll pass it to Eric for interest.
Eric Marchetto
executiveBascome Majors, I won't be giving guidance on individual line items, but I will say this: just a reminder that when it comes to our debt, the split between fixed and floating is roughly 80 to 20. That remains the case, and as you're aware, you did observe interest expense rise step by step over the course of the year as the benchmark rates moved higher. With the fleet investment plan we currently have in place, we aren't anticipating any meaningful shifts in either the composition or the amount of debt. What I would say is that the third quarter serves as a fairly solid proxy for the run rate we expect going forward.
Bascome Majors
analystThanks to both of you for those considered responses. Perhaps we could rewind a bit to what was said earlier regarding the cost of capital. Could you discuss, in terms of a new lease you're evaluating now at a cost of capital reflecting current market conditions, what kind of returns you believe you're achieving, how appealing you consider those to be, and if that added lease aligns with your objectives over the long haul? Maybe also touch on Trinity and whatever else you'd like to mention regarding how the market players purchasing this equipment and leases perceive things from your vantage point, and how their underwriting goals or actions have shifted over the past 3 to 6 months. Thank you.
Eric Marchetto
executiveCertainly, Bascome. I'd say that, indeed, our weighted average cost of capital is a major focus for us. Regarding lease originations and how we underwrite, I believe we maintain strong discipline by establishing hurdle rates grounded in the markets we operate in. In terms of lease pricing, despite elevated interest rates and adjustments to our hurdle rates, market lease rates have continued to uphold those greater valuations for new rail cars and to sustain the yields and return objectives for the company that we set out 3 years ago. As we consider the lease originations being brought into our fleet, including those entering the fleet this quarter and those in our lease backlog, we think they will boost our margins in line with our long-term return goals. As for market evolution, I'd say the market has transformed. Different participants have responded in varying ways to elevated interest rates, the strength of the dollar, and inflation. I believe there is far less speculative ordering happening now, which brings about considerably more discipline, and rail cars are less apt to need to locate a home in a frantic manner. From that perspective, I feel quite positive. It appears to be a sensible market, and I think that's a supportive factor, especially where things might become more competitive than the secondary market, since you aren't speculating as heavily. In that case, you're engaging in known deals, and it's somewhat more of an auction process. That could carry a marginally lower hurdle rate compared to certain lease originations we're observing.
Bascome Majors
analystThanks for covering both of those areas. If you're able to provide it, I'd appreciate one point of clarification regarding next year. When we consider the renewal rates along with the inputs for both the current rate and the expiring rate, does that expiring lease rate denominator—given how the portfolio is put together right now—decline once more next year, or is it beginning to level off? Thank you.
Eric Marchetto
executiveWith the FLRD, there's consistently a mix involved when it comes to the changes we add every quarter and the ones we come off every quarter. So I'm not certain I can offer you a solid answer on that in detail. I believe I'll simply have to leave it there.
Bascome Majors
analystI appreciate you making room for this.
Eric Marchetto
executiveWe’re able to pick this back up afterward.
Steve Barger
analystThanks, and good morning. Jean, you're anticipating that the industry will hold up reasonably well even if there's a mild recession, yet ocean freight has been slowing down. I believe some of the trucking companies have offered fairly cautious remarks. Of course, rail car orders and traffic have historically moved with GDP. Could you expand a bit on why you have confidence that the industry can avoid a downturn?
Jean Savage
executiveSure. If you consider the supply and demand balance currently at play in the industry, plus what Eric just said about how, this cycle, everybody has shown far greater discipline with no speculative ordering, that stands out strongly in my reasoning. ESG comes up far more often in discussions, along with the advantages rail offers versus trucks and what that could mean together with the difference in cost. Should service levels on the rails keep getting better, we view that as a chance to at last begin shifting a portion of that modal share away from highway and toward the rails. The final thing I'll mention, I suppose, is that we've discussed already beginning to book orders for 2024, and the fact that our customers are making those long-term commitments and investments, so we continue to think a brief hiccup or shift won't impact that.
Steve Barger
analystAll right. So the low interest rate environment that was around for 10 years drove a lot of lease fleet investment, obviously. Would you expect higher rates to do the reverse — that is, instead of a long stretch of deliveries well above theoretical replacement, we'll see under-investment in the fleet?
Eric Marchetto
executiveSteve, I'd say railcar leasing is still attractive from a capital standpoint, and it's more on a risk-adjusted basis; it's all relative value, and I do think that railcar leasing has relative value. The more we can make it, you know, a stable market that has less cyclicality, the more attractive that will be long term. The return profile on these assets is appealing, and they're built to last. My view is that over the long run, they'll remain a compelling place to put capital.
Steve Barger
analystSure, I realize your attention is on boosting pre-tax ROE, but should we move into a stronger stretch of the cycle, what makes that the correct metric to steer by rather than EPS growth rate or perhaps a metric tied more directly to cash flow that might connect better with investors?
Eric Marchetto
executiveThat's a key question, I'd say. When you consider how we gauge our business, we feel return on equity and economic profit is, over the long term, the finest approach to assess our business and gauge success. Different incentives exist at other companies, and that leads to different behaviors. We trust that the measures we've put in place will generate disciplined long-term value creation that we believe matches up with our shareholders. That's our perspective on it.
Steve Barger
analystYeah, that's my final question. I suppose the, well, the motive I'm asking whether deliveries rise next year is that you ought to get solid earnings leverage, yet growing the lease fleet simultaneously could obscure EPS upside. I suppose, to build on a prior question, what ought we to anticipate when considering how you turn production growth into EPS growth?
Jean Savage
executiveDuring the prepared remarks, Eric noted that among the metrics provided at the November 2020 investor day, just one won't be achieved. Should you revisit those, you'll see our present lease fleet investment and our anticipated position after three years. It also provides ROE, EPS; it supplies the metrics, I believe, required for gauging our direction. Honestly, extremely proud of the team. They've absorbed plenty of headwinds over the past two years, and for most of those metrics, we still foresee a path to achieve them.
Steve Barger
analystOkay, thanks.
Eric Marchetto
executiveThanks, Steve.
Jean Savage
executiveAlright, thank you. I appreciate all of you being here this morning. As has been discussed during today's call, what we saw in the third quarter reflects advancement and betterment across our operations, even with the ongoing pressures affecting the rail network. Our committed team makes me deeply proud, and the way they have handled these unforeseen difficulties has been remarkable. My belief remains strong that Trinity will deliver solid results in the years ahead. Once more, thank you for standing with us.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of this call. We appreciate your joining us for today's presentation. At this point, please feel free to disconnect your lines.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Trinity Industries, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Trinity Industries, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Trinity Industries, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.