Trinity Industries, Inc. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 21, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Leigh Anne Mann
executiveThanks, operator. Hello, everyone, and good morning. We’re glad you could be with us today for the conference call covering the company’s financial results for the fourth quarter of 2022. In our prepared remarks, we’ll hear from Jean Savage, who serves as Trinity’s Chief Executive Officer and President, and from Eric Marchetto, the company’s Chief Financial Officer. Once our leaders finish those prepared remarks, we’ll move into a Q&A session. On today’s call, we’ll be referring to slides that highlight the key points for discussion, as well as certain non-GAAP financial metrics. You can find the reconciliation of those non-GAAP metrics to comparable GAAP measures in the appendix of the supplemental slides, which are available on our Investor Relations website at www.trin.net. Those slides are located in the Events and Presentations section of the website, together with the event link for the fourth quarter earnings conference call. A replay of today’s call will be accessible after 10:30 A.M. Eastern Time through mid-night on February 28, 2023. Replay information can be found under the Events & Presentations page on our Investor Relations website. I’m now pleased to hand the call over to Jean.
Jean Savage
executiveThanks, Leigh, and hello everybody. I trust 2023 has gotten off to a wonderful beginning for all of you. Ahead of diving into our prepared comments, I'd like to pause and recognize what was achieved during 2022 — things that don't necessarily show up on the financial statements yet matter greatly to each of our stakeholders. Our corporate mission involves providing goods for the benefit of everyone, and woven into that mission is our dedication to excellence across environmental, social, and governance matters; we've revised our operating model so that sustainability now appears as a fundamental value, which is further proof that we treat sustainability as a central priority for our organization. During the past year, we kept pushing forward with efforts to expand our ESG programs across the company. That involved appointing a Global Head of ESG for Trinity to drive and direct our ESG work. We turned into the first railcar manufacturer in North America to certify that our current EHS management system complies with the international organization for standardization's environmental standard and its occupational health and safety standard. We brought on a Director to lead DE&I efforts, rolled out nine employee resource groups along with employee networks, and held our initial ESG roadshow with investors. On top of that, within our main business, we continually pursue new product development that backs sustainability goals; this covers raising efficiency in new railcar designs as well as programs such as our sustainable conversion program, which lets us repurpose railcars that already exist and extend how long their parts and components last. So far, our sustainable railcar conversion program has reused more than 54 million pounds of steel. Our ESG work continues, and I'm eager to share updates on our progress as the year goes on. Now please join me at Slide 3, where I'll discuss the key messages from today's call, which we'll go into greater detail on later during our prepared comments. Our fourth quarter GAAP EPS from continuing operations came in at $0.46, while adjusted EPS from continuing operations was $0.44, which is up $0.10 sequentially and $0.36 year-over-year. Across the full year, GAAP EPS reached $1.02, and adjusted EPS of $0.94 rose 176% compared with 2021. Considering the unforeseen labor, supply chain, and rail service difficulties we encountered during 2022, those challenges hurt our capacity to deliver cars as quickly as we had anticipated. We take pride in what we got done and the growth we delivered in 2022. Moreover, as we look forward, we likewise have grounds for optimism. We closed out the year with our future lease rate differential, or FLRD, at 25.1%. We see this as a solid forecaster of upcoming rate growth within the leasing segment, and the elevated FLRD signals ongoing broad-based strength in the railcar leasing market. The FLRD works out the implied shift in lease rates for railcar leases that expire across the coming four quarters, by using the most recently transacted quarterly lease rate for every railcar type. The FLRD additionally factors in current market rates, which stay robust even amid uncertain economic sentiment. What you need to keep in mind is that supply within the industry has gotten tighter, and planning around energy costs and supply chains has made visibility, control, and logistics planning more important for companies. Trinity holds a distinct edge because it both builds railcars and benefits from strong leasing fundamentals. Most of the rest of the industry generally does just one or the other, which can be difficult when the market is volatile. We're rolling out our 2023 EPS guidance of $1.50 to $1.70. At the midpoint, that works out to EPS growth of 70% versus 2022, and it reflects more deliveries, better lease rates, and stronger segment margins. And last, during the fourth quarter we finished buying Holden America, which was our second acquisition of 2022. Eric will go over that acquisition and how we generally see acquisitions going forward. Now let's move to Slide 4 for a market update. Although we still feel the effect of railroad labor shortages on rail service and traffic, rail service metrics have improved somewhat lately, giving us hope that the worst is behind us. Still, the count of operating employees remains a major constraint for carriers as we head into 2023. Absent substantial hiring, holding onto rail service gains will be difficult. Railcar load volumes for 2022 came in level with 2021. Markets such as grain (ph) and automotive brought real momentum into the New Year, yet other markets, including chemical and metals, faced significant headwinds late in 2022. Meanwhile, the quantity of railcars in storage rose modestly, in line with typical seasonal patterns and the ups and downs in carload traffic, though it stayed far under the five year average. We still anticipate that the current railcar fleet will stay tight in 2023 and that replacement requirements will push new railcar demand. Turning to the bottom of the slide, I noted earlier that our FLRD sits above 25%, a big increase from last quarter's level. Lease fleet utilization for the fourth quarter came in flat at 97.9%, matching what we saw before the pandemic and showing that the fleet is tight. We booked orders for 3,015 railcars during the quarter and delivered 4,400. We closed out the year with a backlog of 32,270 railcars worth $3.9 billion. We anticipate delivering roughly 49% of that backlog in 2023. And because of the multi-year order we booked in the third quarter, we expect a portion of this backlog to stretch out as far as 2028. Our backlog and recent inquiry levels reflect replacement level demand, and our customers require these cars for supply chain management, which gives us confidence and visibility into our delivery forecast. Slide 5 presents fourth quarter performance on a year-over-year basis. Quarterly revenue of $591 million rose 25% from a year earlier; fourth quarter adjusted EPS of $0.44 climbed 450%, while cash flow from continuing ops for the quarter of $62 million fell 69%. Adjusted free cash flow came in at $138 million, which marked a 394% increase. On Slide 6, you can see how our full year 2022 results stack up against 2021. Revenue was just under $2 billion, representing a 30% gain versus the prior year, and as I noted earlier, full year adjusted EPS rose by 176%. On top of that, railcar deliveries were up 50% in 2022, and we closed the year with a backlog of $3.9 billion; throughout the full year, cash flow took a hit from elevated working capital tied to larger railcar delivery volumes and ongoing supply chain difficulties. In examining the variance in cash flow between the two years, keep in mind that 2021 had the benefit of $438 million in income tax receivables. Now let's move to Slide 7 for segment results. I already covered the strong FLRD and fleet utilization within the leasing segment. However, I also want to call out our renewal success rate, which reached 85% in the fourth quarter. For the whole year, that rate stood at 82%, something we haven't achieved since 2014; this figure demonstrates that while we're raising rates upon renewal to align with climbing current rates, customers still see the value in keeping the railcar and therefore agree to the higher rates.
Jean Savage
executiveTo put it simply, the railcar fleet remains tight, and on the leasing side of our business we continue to enjoy considerable visibility and stability. Fourth quarter leasing segment revenue came in at $197 million, which mirrors better rates along with net lease fleet investment activities. Our FLRD has been positive for six quarters now, and those improved rates are beginning to show up in our financials. In the fourth quarter, leasing and management operating profit margins reached 38.3%, rising sequentially thanks to net lease fleet investment activities. Compared with a year earlier, margins declined, driven by a broad rise in maintenance, which tends to move in cycles, plus greater depreciation expense, largely tied to our sustainable railcar conversion program. Now for Rail Products: we brought in $656 million in revenue for the quarter, which was up both from the prior quarter and compared to a year ago, driven by more deliveries plus better pricing and a more favorable product mix. As the year progressed, deliveries picked up speed, so we closed out the year at a quicker tempo. We delivered just under 5,000 railcars in the first half of 2022, then that number climbed past 8,000 in the second half. For the Rail Products segment, operating margins came in at 2.8% in Q4 and 2.8% for the full year. During our Q3 call, we spent a lot of time explaining how operational inefficiencies and supply chain challenges were pulling margins down. Sadly, those problems kept weighing on us throughout the fourth quarter. Beyond ongoing rail service disruptions, supplier deliveries failed to match our scheduled requirements, and railcar completion on multiple lines slipped behind. On top of that, capacity at facilities grew more slowly than we had anticipated in order to hit our original production schedule. Labor proved difficult, with elevated attrition forcing more hiring and onboarding than we had planned, a meaningful burden given the added hiring required to support a higher production level, particularly in Mexico. Rail service, supply chain and labor difficulties together cost us more than 400 basis points of efficiency in operating profit. So what we're seeing there is this: if our efficiency had performed the way we expected, the margin for that segment for the quarter would have come in at about 7%, which falls within the high-single digit range we had forecast. Our expectation remains that by the time we finish the planning period, Rail Products margins will be in the high-single digits, because we believe these challenges will let up as 2023 goes on. Now, moving to Slide 8, there are a few other important wins I want to call out. Back in December, we raised the quarterly dividend to $0.26 per share, an increase of about 13%, and that gets us to our three year goal of achieving double-digit dividend growth. On top of that, our Board gave the green light to a fresh share repurchase authorization totaling $250 million with no expiration; that provides us with added flexibility on timing as we weigh different methods of capital deployment. When it comes to our net lease fleet investment, we put $178 million into it this year, which came in a bit under the $250 million to $300 million range we had expected. Two things explain that: the secondary market turned out stronger than we thought, which pushed railcar sales above what we had projected, and we took delivery of fewer cars for the lease fleet because supply chain problems held back our delivery pace. When you look at the full year, our pretax ROE was 10.4%. Our ROE for all of 2021 stood at 3.4%, which means 2022 was a significant and lasting move forward toward the mid-teen ROE we've set as our strategic goal. We've now moved into 2023, and this marks the third year of the three-year plan we introduced at the end of 2020. On our Q3 call, we revised our target for operating cash flow to a range of $1.2 billion to $1.4 billion, which reflects the divestiture of our highway business, higher working capital needs and the geographic locations where railcar sales are taking place. With that single exception, we're still on track to hit those three-year targets, and we continue to work hard to deliver on these metrics. Ahead of passing things over to Eric, I want to address a handful of topics related to our operations. To start, despite challenges with the supply chain and rail service, we continue to see robust inquiry levels and very strong ties with our customers, which leaves us feeling good about near-term order activity. In addition to EPS expansion in 2023, I'd also like to emphasize that significant operating leverage is showing up across our business, and we anticipate that returns will continue climbing — something we regard as a better yardstick for evaluating our business, considering the value of our lease fleet and how much visibility we have into it. We continue to make adjustments to our organization and carry out efforts designed to put our manufacturing and leasing operations in the best position to generate maximum value despite tough conditions outside the company. The Rail Products Group is a strategic holding that provides diversity in revenue along with a competitive edge, yet it is generally more volatile given its near-term exposure to market and labor challenges, and that has clearly played out this year. When you look across several years, however, this business moves with the same railcar fundamentals as the leasing segment, and the return available is substantial. To wrap up, even with an unpredictable macroeconomic environment, I take pride in what our team achieved over the past year. Running a company always brings difficulties, yet because our business model is robust and our people are strong, I believe we can deliver on our three-year targets in 2023. At this point, I'll hand things over to Eric so he can walk through our financial results.
Eric Marchetto
executiveHello, everyone, and good morning. First off, I want to congratulate Jean for receiving the 2022 Railcar Women of the Year honor from the League of Railway Women. I'd also like to add some further detail regarding the Holden deal that Jean brought up. Holden makes industry-leading multi-level securement and protection systems for vehicles, gravity-outlet gates, plus gate accessories used in North American freight rail. The initial price we paid for Holden came to $70 million, with an additional $10 million minimum payable through installments across the coming two years. Our 10-K, which we anticipate filing later today, contains additional details about this acquisition. This deal aligns nicely with our approach of boosting exposure to aftermarket parts that are less cyclical and carry higher margins, which gives us added chances to serve customers and broaden our revenue mix. Beyond that, with automobile preference shifting toward SUVs and heavier electric vehicles, securement systems are going to matter even more, and we're eager to be a market leading shop provider while continuing to deliver the quality and service Holden's customers expect. During 2022 we closed two acquisitions, Quasar and Holden, and both operations are currently being integrated into our platform. We recognize the value in refining our business through strategic acquisitions and keep searching for suitable opportunities, though we stay selective when evaluating possible targets. Turning to Slide 9, I'll begin my remarks with the income statement. Consolidated revenue during the fourth quarter reached $591 million, up both sequentially and year-over-year, thanks to greater external railcar deliveries and better pricing. Adjusted EPS for the quarter came in at $0.44 per share, which also improved sequentially and year-over-year, aided by $236 million in lease portfolio sales that generated a gain of $55 million. Now for the cash flow statement. Cash flow from continuing operations for the full year totaled $9 million, while adjusted free cash flow reached $138 million for the year after investments and dividends. As has been true throughout the year, working capital levels remain elevated to support a production ramp up and to lessen supply chain disruptions. On top of that, higher receivables tied to deliveries late in the year weighed negatively on our operating cash flow. During 2021, free cash flow got a boost from collecting roughly $438 million of income tax receivables. Consistent with our guidance, we closed the year having invested $38 million in manufacturing and general CapEx, and we gave back $154 million to shareholders via repurchases and dividends. Secondary market sales stayed robust throughout the year, and we booked some considerable gains on railcar sales. So long as we keep delivering railcars into our lease fleet, we anticipate completing secondary market sales as part of ordinary business, provided market conditions stay favorable. What happens here is a movement of cash flows away from operating activities and toward investment activities, and that holds true even when deliveries are running high. The reason is that when a railcar goes straight from our manufacturing operation to a buyer, the cash shows up in operations, whereas when the railcar comes out of the lease fleet, that cash lands in investments. Our net lease fleet investment for the year came to $178 million, as Jean noted. During 2022, roughly 36% of the railcars we built went to our lease fleet in order to satisfy customer demand, and that amounted to a gross fleet increase of $929 million. With a strong secondary market helping us, and consistent with our aim of only modest fleet growth, we sold about $751 million in railcars from the fleet, which lets us fine-tune the mix of railcars we hold so we can meet customer demand and keep utilization at a high level. Now go to Slide 10; we closed the year with $398 million of liquidity, which is made up of cash and equivalents, revolver availability and warehouse availability. At year-end, the loan to value on the wholly-owned fleet stood at 65.7%, still within our target LTV range of 60% to 65%. As supply chain conditions get better and deliveries rise, lowering our working capital, we anticipate liquidity will strengthen in 2023. Our loan maturities carry attractive rates given what the market is doing. Turning now to Slide 11, let's discuss a few of the expectations for 2023. Back at the end of 2020, when we established our three-year plan, we said we anticipated industry deliveries holding at a replacement demand level, which we put at roughly 120,000 railcars across the three years. Through the plan's first two years, the industry delivered a bit more than 70,000 railcars. For 2023, we anticipate industry deliveries between 40,000 and 45,000, which puts us finishing a little under the 120,000 we projected at the close of 2020 for that three-year stretch. That figure leaves out sustainable conversions, which have been meaningful during the planning period; where Trinity is concerned, we anticipate delivering at or close to our historical share of industry deliveries. Our view of this build cycle remains that it is rational, and that will serve our lease fleet well throughout the cycle. Our planned net fleet investment over three years was $500 million to $600 million, so to land within the forecasted range we expect net fleet investment of about $250 million to $350 million in 2023. That investment forecast includes new railcar deliveries into the lease fleet along with sustainable railcar conversions and modifications to our existing fleet and secondary market additions, less secondary market sales; it comes in somewhat above what we have put to work in recent years. Even though a lower percentage of the railcars we deliver will enter our lease fleet compared with last year, on an absolute basis we expect internal deliveries to be similar, and we expect higher eliminations in dollar terms because more deliveries are happening at higher prices. Right now, the amount we have committed to leasing for new railcars sits at $459 million. Deliveries won't all happen during 2023, and sales of railcars will partially counterbalance what we hand over to the lease fleet when we calculate net lease fleet investment across the full year. On top of that, we're looking at manufacturing plus other general capital spending somewhere between $40 million and $50 million, which tracks with what we've seen in earlier years. For 2023, we're putting forward preliminary adjusted EPS guidance of $1.50 to $1.70, and that marks considerable growth compared with how 2022 turned out. Yes, we do anticipate that labor, rail service, and supply chain difficulties will ease somewhat during 2023, but those problems won't vanish suddenly, and that's why they're baked into what we're guiding. Deliveries should proceed at a fairly steady rate as the year unfolds, though quarterly consolidated financial results are going to be uneven because of when planned maintenance expense lands and how net lease fleet activity plays out. To wrap up, over the past several years we've made moves to strengthen the balance sheet and boost the operating leverage of our business. Looking ahead into 2023, I have faith in our company's capacity to perform well even in a tough environment, generating cash and achieving better returns, and in the end, greater shareholder value. At this point, operator, let's take our first question.
Allison Poliniak
analystHi. Good morning.
Jean Savage
executiveGood morning.
Allison Poliniak
analystJean, I'd like to return to what you said regarding the leasing side — storage counts remain depressed, though they're gradually rising. Could you give us a bit more detail there? I realize you brought up seasonality, but should we be concerned that we're genuinely observing some added storage tied to certain softness in the market? Also, regarding that rate of successful lease renewals, what figure makes sense to keep in mind for '23? Thanks.
Jean Savage
executiveAll right, and thank you, Allison. Looking at an 85% success rate on renewals, that hasn't happened since 2014. Conditions in the market remain extremely tight. What we're observing entering storage is largely seasonal — not grain cars, or grain cars that aren't required — plus on the consumer side there's a touch of softness, and that sort of car is going in. So our expectation is that the market stays tight, particularly when you consider broadly what's occurring or anticipated regarding attrition, along with new railcars re-entering the system.
Allison Poliniak
analystUnderstood; next, regarding rail manufacturing, you pointed to several margin pressures during the quarter just ended; and I'm just attempting to square this—you anticipate a sequential gain even though deliveries stay flat. Is it that you're capping that capacity growth purely due to the labor situation you're encountering? I'm just trying to figure out what pushes that margin up given the delivery volume you're now guiding to?
Jean Savage
executiveExcellent question. So if you consider it, a few of the lessons from this past year include having a very solid backlog, which gives us solid visibility. We're lengthening the horizon, or the outlook, that we provide to our supply chain so they can see it. We continue to observe—at the close of last year, I believe we mentioned this—that there are fewer rail suppliers furnishing product, and they're still struggling. When we entered Q4 and sought to increase our output, their capacity to deliver promptly declined; thus it moved in the wrong direction. They had settled at the reduced run rate; so at present they have a solid outlook for the year regarding what we require, and we anticipate that as the year progresses they'll improve at delivering promptly. On our side, we implemented certain measures during Q4 regarding labor, and we've observed that actually decline again, so we get somewhat better at our capacity to draw in and then retain or hold onto those workers; so we aren't yet at the headcount required for full-year production, but we're considerably nearer.
Allison Poliniak
analystExcellent. Thanks a lot.
Matt Elkott
analystMorning to you. Appreciate it. So on the surface, it seems as though you might be anticipating fewer deliveries for 2023, yet this is because your delivery guidance for the industry has a high end that's reduced and a low end that's truly beneath the real 2022 figure; however, Eric, from what you said, I believe you noted an expectation that your share would align with 2022, which I think stood at 34%. Therefore, if I use the midpoint of your own — of your industry delivery guidance, I get slightly more than 14,000 vehicles for '23, which represents roughly a 5% increase. Does that calculation hold up?
Eric Marchetto
executiveNo. Matt, my apologies, in case I wasn't clear. I referenced historical market share ranges, meaning within that 30% to 40% bracket. So should you take the 40% to 45% and use a 30% to 40%, you'll arrive at a band. And our deliveries are going to rise beyond what you're — it exceeds what you've computed?
Jean Savage
executiveSo if you think back to last year, in the first half we delivered 5,000 cars, and then 8,000 came in the second half. And as I just mentioned, we don't yet have the headcount required to support production for the entire year, which should give you a bit of a hint about where we think we're headed.
Matt Elkott
analystAll right, understood. That's useful. Now, for my follow-up: I realize you benefited somewhat, I believe, from last year's storm recovery, which gave margins a lift, yet this year you're dealing with supply chain disruptions. Deliveries rose 36% compared with a year earlier, while margin declined. Could you help us break down how much of that was due to the storm recovery benefit versus the supply chain disruption in this quarter?
Eric Marchetto
executiveThe store benefit was something we adjusted out, and that accounts for the significant gap between $0.94 and $1.02. Also, the slides provide additional detail on the rail segment, particularly regarding the quarters when those recoveries came in — you can see it in their calculations. As for the headwinds, they exceeded the storm recoveries by a substantial amount. Jean referenced the 40 basis points in the fourth quarter, and that figure is far greater than the storm recoveries.
Matt Elkott
analystUnderstood. Then I have a single final question tied to the industry. Do you anticipate any possible adjustments regarding the Class II flammable liquid rule as it applies to tank cars, or to other car types comparable to what we witnessed with crude-related rules following Lake Megantic?
Jean Savage
executiveA great deal of conversation is taking place, along with plenty of calls. My view is that we need to hold off until the NTSB releases its conclusions about what took place; even so, I would anticipate some kind of action, whether regarding safety, or how they make certain trains are configured while moving through in manifest sharing and similar matters, though we will simply have to wait and observe. That subject is being talked about by us at this moment.
Matt Elkott
analystGreat. Thank you, Jean. Thanks, Eric.
Jean Savage
executiveThanks.
Justin Long
analystThanks, and good morning. I'd like to ask about the margins for the Rail Product Group. Jean, from what you're saying, it sounds like by the time we finish out this year, you expect to land in that high-single digit range. But could you help us reason through the cadence of margins that's baked into the guidance, and how you anticipate that 400 basis point headwind you flagged fading as the year goes on?
Jean Savage
executiveWe aren't providing quarterly guidance, but what I can tell you is that, as Eric said, those headwinds won't disappear overnight, in our view; we expect them to get better and to go away across the year. So what I'd say is, keep that in mind when you're looking at the year as a whole or at individual quarters.
Justin Long
analystEric, you brought up that profitability would have some unevenness, if I recall. Can you provide any additional detail on that remark when we consider how to model out the quarters in this year?
Eric Marchetto
executiveYes. As Jean — regarding the Rail segment, you observe — Jean talked about the enhancement. The unevenness would largely stem from eliminations and car sales; in this year, a greater or smaller portion of what we deliver will be allocated to the lease fleet, meaning there will be less, the fleet investment falls within that range of $250 million to $350 million; however, the car sales, particularly when considering the Wafra transaction, in past years, that has been completed during the latter half of the year. This marks year three and that agreement covers a three-year program. Consequently, some unevenness will arise from the gains on sale.
Justin Long
analystAll right, and my final question concerned cash flow. I was wondering whether you might provide any outlook regarding 2023. I understand there are certain moving parts involving working capital that you brought up? Additionally, regarding the buyback under the fresh authorization, might you address what is being incorporated into the EPS guidance concerning repurchases?
Eric Marchetto
executiveYes. So, regarding repurchases in particular, we have given back a substantial amount of capital to shareholders across the past several years, most certainly, and we wrapped up our prior authorization and commenced a new one during December. I would describe our share repurchases for this year, based on the earnings guidance, as being more opportunistic and modest concerning how much capital we return through share repurchases. I believe we simply increased the dividend during the fourth quarter to $0.26 per quarter. Thus, a greater portion of our capital to shareholders will be delivered through that channel, at least as things stand right now. And then, my apologies, the initial portion of your question dealt with cash flow.
Justin Long
analystWhat we anticipate for cash flow.
Eric Marchetto
executiveRight. If you look back at the three-year plan from our Investor Day, we brought it down a bit in the last quarter, the cat, and with what occurred in the fourth quarter plus where we stand right now, we remain within that range — perhaps at the lower end, the lower portion of it, yet it appears our cash — this platform is capable of producing a substantial amount of cash, and we anticipate that carrying on through 2023.
Justin Long
analystAll right, that's excellent. I appreciate you taking the time.
Eric Marchetto
executiveYes, thanks to you.
Gordon Johnson
analystHi everyone. Appreciate you taking my question. This might be one for Jean. If we zoom out and consider the U.S. economy — retail sales, which are the motor powering it, have declined in 3 of the last 4 months. Real disposable income had its surplus drop in 2022, the first time that's happened since the Great Depression of the 1930s. Real consumer spending on services stayed flat in December. That's the only monthly figure like that in close to 12 months. Real average weekly earnings have fallen for a record 21 straight months. Auto sales growth decelerated in January, and 2022 was the weakest in almost 10 years, while home sales last year were the lowest since 2014. I realize that's a lot of statistics, but it feels like we're factoring that in, plus Midwest region average truck rates and other delivery rates. Things appear quite negative — not to sound overly gloomy — but is the guidance you're providing weighted toward the back half? And if so, do you perceive any risk there? Then I have a follow-up. Thanks.
Jean Savage
executiveAbsolutely; if you examine manufacturing figures, November and December showed a slight decline, yet they rebounded in January. So we observed a bounce there. Consumer-facing areas are definitely experiencing the greatest softening; intermodal falls into that category. Still, on the whole, we continue to see very high utilization of cars. Traffic is flat versus 2021, and customers keep wanting to ship more via rail; so we believe we can endure — or we would have a — we will be resilient against a mild recession. And when you look at our backlog, we have $3.9 billion in backlog there, providing us with really solid visibility for this year.
Gordon Johnson
analystAppreciate that. And so, finally, regarding free cash flow — I realize someone already raised a question there, but the burn during this quarter, I believe, if we're just taking a look at operating cash flow minus CapEx, comes to approximately $900 million. Are there any capital-related plans in the works? Thanks for the questions.
Eric Marchetto
executiveYes, Gordon. Eric here. If you remove that $900 million, I believe what you're seeing is the entire lease fleet investment, and I would simply point you toward our adjusted cash flow in the disclosure, where we sort of detailed how the fleet investment is definitely — the headline figure is large; however, once you finance it, it doesn't call for much cash. And one more reminder, that's fairly tax-effective capital investment; therefore, from a cash flow perspective, it's a comparatively favorable outcome. And I would just point you toward our disclosure on that.
Gordon Johnson
analystThanks again.
Eric Marchetto
executiveYeah.
Steve Barger
analystthank you. Jean, you mentioned that Trinity is producing solid operating leverage. And regarding that, the incremental margin for 2022 landed at roughly 20%. When you consider the mix for '23, are you expecting the incremental contribution margin to exceed that level?
Eric Marchetto
executiveSteve, if you examine the earnings guidance we provided, plus a bit of the detail regarding fewer car sales and some of the detail regarding deliveries, that would suggest a fairly strong incremental margin; so it partly hinges on which part of the range you fall into; however, the — my expectation is that the incremental margin will be at a very strong pace in 2023, based on where we stand right now. I'm not sure whether we'll provide the specifics, but your calculation is right. If you look at simply the volume we're discussing and the earnings increase of 70%, but you'll — a great deal of that has to come from incremental margin.
Steve Barger
analystRight. And that obviously has to originate from the Rail Group, doesn't it, given the enormous incremental margin you recorded on leasing during 2022?
Eric Marchetto
executiveYes, that's right.
Steve Barger
analystAll right. And you mentioned that on-time delivery declined once you increased production. What caused that? Was material unavailable to them? Do they face their own workforce problems, or are these suppliers spread across various sectors, directing capacity toward other industries instead? What exactly took place within the supply base?
Jean Savage
executiveA large portion of the supply base dealt with workforce problems, same as everybody else across North America; more than 95% of the materials used to build our railcars originate from North America; so first, they became accustomed to the pace — the run rate at which everyone was operating; they determined how to handle that. Then, as we attempted to increase it, they slipped back. So they're addressing it; some gains have appeared, yet pockets still emerge occasionally involving various components. And keep in mind, I believe I said a bit earlier that we're working to provide them with greater visibility into that signal. So normally, you provide 60, 90 days. We're attempting to extend that further, particularly given the backlog we're carrying.
Steve Barger
analystUnderstood; also, since I've been hopping between topics during this call, my apologies if this point already came up. Eric, my impression is that you mentioned a greater emphasis on dividends rather than repurchases for '23. To begin with, did I get that correct? And well, I suppose we can take it from there.
Eric Marchetto
executiveYes. Steve, your understanding is correct; we examined — someone asked before about what level of share repurchases is included in the guidance. And I replied that it was modest, with a larger portion of capital allocation moving toward the dividend.
Steve Barger
analystWill that continue to hold up? You've clearly retired 45% of the shares over roughly the last six years. Should we view this as a change going forward, meaning more cash gets directed toward the dividend?
Eric Marchetto
executiveI'd characterize it as more of a one-off tied to this year; we had our three-year plan and our three-year plan. We discussed meaningful buybacks and dividend growth, and by every measure, we've delivered on that. And when we look ahead toward the coming three years, across the next planning period, we'll share additional details about that, but that's not something we're doing right now.
Steve Barger
analystUnderstood. Okay. Thanks.
Eric Marchetto
executiveThanks.
Jean Savage
executiveAlright, thanks — and once more, I appreciate all of you being here today. We feel we're in a solid place to make 2023 a big year. What we're projecting takes into account increased lease pricing, more deliveries, and gains in efficiency that push margins upward and bring in cash flow. I'd like to express my appreciation to our team for how hard they've worked throughout this year and for getting things done even when conditions were tough. Thanks once more for sticking with us.
Operator
operatorThat brings today's call to a close. We appreciate you joining this presentation. You're free to leave the line at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Trinity Industries, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Trinity Industries, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Trinity Industries, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.