Trinity Industries, Inc. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 2, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Leigh Anne Mann
executiveThanks, operator. Hello, everyone. We're glad you could be with us today for the company's conference call covering financial results for the third quarter of 2023. Remarks we've prepared will feature comments from Jean Savage, who serves as Trinity's Chief Executive Officer and President, along with Eric Marchetto, the Company's Chief Financial Officer. After our leaders deliver those prepared remarks, a Q&A session will take place. On today's call, we'll point to slides that highlight key points of discussion as well as certain non-GAAP financial metrics. Reconciliations of those non-GAAP metrics to comparable GAAP measures appear in the appendix of the supplemental slides, which you can access on our investor relations website at www.trin.net. Those slides sit under the Events and Presentations portion of the website, together with the third quarter earnings conference call event link. A replay of today's call can be heard after 10:30 A.M. Eastern Time until midnight on November 7th, 2023. Details about the replay can be found under the Events and Presentations page on our investor relations website; and now it's my pleasure to hand the call over to Jean.
Jean Savage
executiveThank you, Leigh Anne, and good morning to all of you. I'll begin my prepared remarks on slide three by going over the key messages we want to get across on today's call. Trinity's results for the third quarter show much stronger performance, with revenue up 65% versus the same period last year. We feel we're on a solid track to close out 2023 with favorable financial performance and further improvement. During the quarter, our leasing segment continued to show strength, posting fleet utilization of 98.1%, and we're confident lease rates will keep climbing, supported by our future lease rate differential, or FLRD, of 26.6%, along with ongoing favorable railcar supply fundamentals. We already told you about this: shutdowns at borders and heavy backups led to us delivering 14% fewer units than we had projected for the quarter — 4,325 deliveries in total. Our prepared remarks will get into the fourth quarter a bit later, but because of those missed deliveries tied to border problems, plus other supply chain fallout and efficiency effects, we're lowering the 2023 Adjusted EPS outlook to $1.20-$1.35. Now if you'd go to slide four, we'll walk through market conditions and the commercial picture. Starting at the graph in the upper left, rail traffic overall is improving. You'll recall that intermodal volumes have been the single largest drag on rail traffic during this year, although recent weeks have brought an uptick in those volumes. Year-over-year carload numbers remain higher, since strong results in motor vehicles, minerals, petroleum products, and farm products made up for lower grain volumes. With covered hoppers being used more effectively—largely for grain shipments during this harvest season—the number of railcars sitting in storage across the industry has been going down. Turning to the lower portion of the slide, as I noted earlier, both our FLRD and utilization rates remained healthy during the quarter. A 26.6% FLRD shows we can continue raising rates while keeping fleet utilization high, at 98.1% for the third quarter. In the bottom right section, deliveries during the quarter were affected by the border closure and congestion. Looking at our orders and inquiries, they point to replacement-level demand, which lines up with what we've been expecting for the next several years. Moving on to slide five, let's go over how we did financially this quarter. We brought in $821 million in revenue, a 65% increase compared to the same period last year, thanks to more external deliveries during the quarter. Adjusted EPS came in at $0.26. Keep in mind that during the third quarter of 2022, we closed a sizable railcar sale that gave EPS a boost in that prior year. Gains from lease portfolio sales in the third quarter of 2023 were on the smaller side, though we still expect the fourth quarter to bring larger railcar sales for 2023 and help us hit our net fleet investment goals. During the quarter, continuing operations generated $76 million in cash flow, while adjusted free cash flow came in at negative $31 million. Later on in our prepared remarks, Eric will go into more detail regarding cash. Now, if you could move with me to slide six, we'll discuss our segments, beginning with leasing. Leasing revenue for the quarter reached $223 million, marking a 14% gain over the prior-year comparable period. This improvement was driven by stronger lease rates, increased utilization, and acquisition-related revenues that fall within the current year period. For the quarter, average renewal lease rates were 32.5% above expiring rates, which is very much in line with the FLRD. Because market conditions have been favorable, we've now posted a double-digit FLRD for six quarters in a row, and with more than 30% of our fleet reflecting today's strong lease rate environment, the effect is clearly noticeable. To hold onto these lease rates, we keep extending duration, with an average renewal lease term of 55 months on a year-to-date basis. Despite how strong the lease rate environment is, our renewal success rate for the quarter reached 86%, which is well above average and shows that lessors continue to hold considerable pricing power. Leasing and management operating margin came in at 38.4%. Compared with twelve months earlier, that figure is just a bit above, since improved lease pricing was partially cancelled out by increased costs for maintenance, greater depreciation, and the margin characteristics of businesses purchased in that segment. The higher spending on leasing maintenance is driven largely by a pair of continuing trends in the industry. One is an increase in change of service modifications meant to place railcars where they can capture the strongest opportunities, while the other is a rise in scheduled compliance work throughout the tank car fleet. Moving on to rail products, I want to touch quickly on the border matters that came up during the quarter. On September 20th, U.S. During the quarter, U.S. Customs and Border Protection shut down rail movement across the border into the United States at Eagle Pass, Texas. For us, that location serves as the primary gateway used for delivering railcars from our plants in Mexico. The reason for the stoppage was to assist the U.S. Border Patrol, given the surge of migrants arriving at the border. Rail operations did resume on September 23rd, but problems with congestion and rail traffic continued to shift and develop. As a result, during the third quarter we received 685 fewer railcars than anticipated. Even though we have started moving railcars again, some remain parked in temporary storage and at our own sites, and we continue to review what other options exist for moving goods by rail and by truck between Mexico and the United States. We don't anticipate getting every one of these deliveries done prior to the close of the year. Although quarterly deliveries came in below what we had expected, they leaned strongly toward sales to outside parties, and that provided support to the consolidated financials for the quarter. On top of that, even with the loss of efficiency brought about by the border issues, we still managed to improve operating margin on both a sequential and a year-over-year basis, landing at 5.7%. Gains from insurance recoveries were part of the segment results during the quarter. Strip those gains out, and segment margin comes to 5.2%, which is a sign of substantial gains in labor and efficiency. The peso remained strong over the quarter, averaging an exchange rate of $17.07, yet our hedging program let us reduce additional risk. If we don't run into more major problems with rail service at the border, we're looking at ending the year with an operating margin for the rail products segment between 8% and 9%, and a full-year average between 5% and 6%. Any further congestion or shutdowns would compromise our capacity to move railcars across the border and might require us to reduce speed or halt production for a period. Along with the rail carriers and government agencies, we're working to ensure that rail and truck movements, both inbound and outbound, keep flowing without interruption. When it comes to new railcars, our backlog is valued at $3.6 billion, with another $124 million associated with sustainable railcar conversions, giving us production visibility through 2024 and beyond. Please join me on slide seven, where I'll point out several other notable achievements from the quarter. At present, our Loan-to-Value stands at 64.9%, a level we regard as favorable. So far this year, net investment in our lease fleet totals $238 million, and over the last 12 months our pre-tax ROE came in at 9.6%. Before handing the call over to Eric, I'd like to call attention to one of our sustainability wins. In September of this year, Trinity earned an AA rating from the MSCI ESG Ratings assessment. That score reflects the steady progress we've made across the past four years as well as recognition of how well we handle ESG risk compared with our peers. Nowhere is that more evident than in our focus on employee safety, where our ISO 45001 certified program fuels ongoing improvement, improvement that shows up in our safety incident rates. I want to congratulate our team on this achievement. At Trinity, safety is a core value, and our AA rating signals that the industry recognizes our efforts. At this point, I'll pass the call to Eric, who will walk through the financial statements and discuss the fourth quarter.
Eric Marchetto
executiveGood morning, everyone. On slide eight, I'll begin my remarks by discussing the income and cash flow statements. Our quarterly revenues came to $821 million, which reflected an increase in external railcar deliveries along with better lease rates. GAAP earnings per share stood at $0.29. Once we excluded $3.7 million of insurance recoveries booked during the quarter, adjusted EPS came in at $0.26. It's worth pointing out that gains on lease portfolio sales reached $3 million this quarter. As I mentioned last quarter, we anticipate larger gains in the fourth quarter of the year. Now turning to the cash flow statement. Cash flow from continued operations on a year-to-date basis is $216 million. Adjusted free cash flow comes to $50 million once investments and dividends are accounted for. As Gene noted, adjusted free cash flow for the third quarter was -$31 million. The main drivers were modest railcar sales during the quarter, along with net repayments of debt. Earlier this week, we made our 238th consecutive dividend payment, which represents a meaningful source of capital returns for shareholders. On slide nine, our liquidity of $780 million reflects our cash, revolver, and warehouse positions. Due to the border closure and congestion, we finished the quarter carrying higher inventory levels, driven by railcars parked in finished goods and greater work in process stemming from other supply chain challenges; and now let's move to slide 10 to discuss the final three months of 2023; we still anticipate industry deliveries of roughly 45,000 railcars, implying fourth quarter deliveries about in line with the third quarter. We anticipate net fleet investment between $250 million and $350 million in 2023, and expect to finish the three-year planning period inside our target range of $500 million-$600 million. Year-to-date, investment totals $238 million, and in the fourth quarter, we anticipate a more traditional mix of internal and external deliveries. We anticipate manufacturing and general CapEx of $40 million-$50 million. We have invested $29 million year-to-date; we anticipate a similar run rate in the fourth quarter to what we have achieved this year. As Jean said at the top of the call, we are reducing our 2023 EPS guidance to a range of $1.20-$1.35 to reflect the lost deliveries in the third quarter, as well as related supply chain and efficiency challenges caused by the border closure and congestion. This target represents significant growth in the fourth quarter and depends on continuing strength in our leasing results, a large lease portfolio sale, and improved revenue and margins in the rail product segment. We're working hard to get as many deliveries across the border as quickly and efficiently as we can, but any additional congestion or closures would hurt our results in the fourth quarter. And finally, in the third quarter of 2022, we set a revised three-year cash flow from operations target of $1.2 billion-$1.4 billion for the three-year period, 2021 through 2023, to reflect changes in our operating environment. Even though things keep getting better, we're changing that cash flow goal to somewhere between $1 billion and $1.2 billion. That's because working capital has stayed high from border problems, supply chain difficulties, and weaker efficiency and margins than we'd anticipated in the first half of 2023. Keep in mind that railcar sales don't show up in cash from operations, yet they're a major source of cash for Trinity. I feel proud of how hard our team has worked to get through the border challenge. Assuming no additional disruptions, I'm sure we can finish the year with robust financial results, dependable operations, and the capacity to leverage the considerable operating leverage in our business. We're eager to share those results with you in 2024; and now, operator, we're ready for our first question.
Allison Poliniak
analystHi there, and good morning. To start things off, I'd like to ask about leasing. On the maintenance front, I realize you mentioned that it remains at a high level. Can we look at it quarter by quarter and tell whether things have settled down? What are your expectations regarding how this will develop as we head toward 2024? Any detail would help.
Jean Savage
executiveThanks so much for raising that, Allison. As you know, over the past few years, we have talked about the elevated number of tank car compliance events that will be necessary, stemming from the robust production period of 2013 to 2015, during which more than 100,000 new tank cars were manufactured by the industry. I do want to stress that the HM-251 modification work is a separate matter. What we're addressing here is simply the mandatory 10-year compliance requirement for every tank car, and that surge is happening at this very moment.
Allison Poliniak
analystAll right. So from what I'm gathering, given the figures that had been established during those years, we clearly anticipated that it would continue into 2024?
Jean Savage
executiveThat's correct.
Allison Poliniak
analystAll right, and regarding production, you know, there have been ongoing difficulties down in Mexico. Could you perhaps discuss how flexible your manufacturing operations are? In other words, is it possible to shift a portion of that output back to the United States, or do the expenses still not justify doing so? And whatever insights you have on that would be helpful.
Jean Savage
executiveAll right. So a number of new cars are made by us here in the U.S., at Longview, Texas, and that work is ongoing. As for the cars currently being assembled in Mexico, from a cost perspective and given the need to stay competitive within the industry, relocating every one of them back would not be feasible. That said, our confidence in the Mexico team is strong, and border problems like these are not typical. We've implemented certain measures aimed at reducing future disruptions. You know, when it comes to transporting materials across the border into Mexico for assembly purposes, we now have various routes and various entry points available to bring that product in. After that, we're studying ways to return our completed rail cars to the U.S. via alternative entry points. We're exploring how to lessen this going forward, so that we avoid experiencing the same impact we saw in the third quarter.
Allison Poliniak
analystGreat. Thank you.
Jean Savage
executiveThank you.
Justin Long
analystThank you, and good morning. Jean, I believe you mentioned at some point that margins for rail products would exit at 8%-9%. I just want to confirm that this is your expectation for the entire fourth quarter. Also, is there a way to measure the headwind you experienced from Eagle Pass as it affects rail product margins during the quarter?
Jean Savage
executiveWell, thank you, Justin. Regarding the exit rate for the quarter, we do anticipate it will be 8%-9%. And looking at it, this applies to the whole quarter. As for some of the headwinds, we aren't providing a breakdown in basis points regarding the impact, but allow me to explain what occurs when the border closes. To start, any railcars already parked there remain. Any railcars that were traveling there proceed to park. Thus, it takes some time for that congestion to clear. At our current production levels, we're producing roughly 400 cars, so considering that, 400 each week, if they aren't removing cars from the plant site and putting them into storage, we would very soon have to halt a plant. A significant amount of congestion accumulated quite rapidly during the third quarter; we began to observe it easing throughout the first half of October, and currently we see operations that are more typical taking place.
Justin Long
analystAll right, understood. Appreciate it. Now, moving to my second point, which is likely directed at Eric: we have observed considerable swings when it comes to railcar sales. Looking back at Q2, the effect on operating income stood at roughly $30 million; by Q3, that figure had fallen to $3 million. I realize a sizable lease portfolio is set to be sold during Q4, but could you provide any further detail regarding what range of outcomes we might expect for its impact in the fourth quarter?
Eric Marchetto
executiveJustin, thanks for that. You're correct that earnings do show some variability. During our discussion last quarter, we indicated that rail car sales would land in Q4; in Q3, our sales were truly quite limited. What I'd add is that, to reach the guidance, a car sale figure is definitely baked in. We addressed this before — both arriving at the net fleet investment and having eliminations return to a more typical level; so what you'll see, what we'll see, is car sales running at heightened levels, though nothing beyond what has already occurred.
Justin Long
analystAll right. So should we anticipate something nearer to what we saw in 2Q?
Eric Marchetto
executiveAs I mentioned, those figures are going to come in higher. They will be bigger, yet nothing outside what has already occurred in our experience.
Justin Long
analystGot it. Thanks for the time.
Jean Savage
executiveThank you.
Bascome Majors
analystMorning. When we turn our attention to the coming year and consider the momentum in lease rates that's obviously there, plus the FLRD sitting at 27% and the way that metric ought to keep behaving going forward, is there something unusual regarding how many cars are expiring now compared with the following year, or perhaps a mix problem that FLRD doesn't pick up? Anything at all that could give us directional help in working out how much lease momentum carries into next year from this, given present conditions. Thank you.
Jean Savage
executiveThank you, Bascome. Look, guidance for next year won't come until our Q4 call, scheduled for February; however, I can tell you that in a normal year, between a fifth and a sixth of our fleet reaches expiration and requires renewal. We don't see any meaningful shifts on that front; and an FLRD of 26.6% points toward substantial lease rate gains across the coming four quarters.
Bascome Majors
analystThanks for that. And to revisit what Justin asked, perhaps from a different angle — for companies similar to yours, folks like us tend to annualize whatever happened in the latest quarter, especially when seasonality isn't significant. We recognize that the $0.70-$0.75 you've guided to for Q4 benefits from gains that came in much bigger than in a couple of quarters this year. But aside from that gains figure, is there anything else we ought to consider as atypical when thinking about the Q4 run rate, you know, looking ahead for the business? And definitely in terms of direction, not necessarily precise figures here. Thank you.
Jean Savage
executiveSure. So if you consider where Trinity stood when the third quarter wrapped up, roughly 50% of the industry backlog was ours, which gives us solid visibility into 2024 and beyond. As we look at Q4, changeovers are down; labor has stabilized better, meaning lower turnover. Employee tenure is going up, and that's assisting our efficiency, plus there's some volume during the quarter. Supply chain disruptions are appearing less often, and the FX headwind is milder than we'd expected. So when you put all of that together, it gives us confidence. The team has been prepared. Sadly, during Q3, headwinds emerged and hit us, so we're positioned and prepared to move forward in Q4.
Bascome Majors
analystSo can we say that the fourth quarter is one in which certain factors that might have been holding you back from reaching your potential — things you've noticed the whole time — are now disappearing, instead of some odd items tilting things upward?
Jean Savage
executiveYou could put it that way, Bascome. Appreciate it.
Bascome Majors
analystOne final question from me, and after that I'll hand things over. At some point you mentioned the possibility of holding a long-term investor update during the fourth quarter or at the start of next year. Could you share where your thinking stands on that? Thanks.
Jean Savage
executiveBascome, we haven't locked in a date for it as of now, though my expectation is that it will happen at some point next year.
Bascome Majors
analystThank you, all.
Eric Marchetto
executiveThanks, Bascome.
Jean Savage
executiveThanks.
Matt Elkott
analystMorning, and thanks. It's encouraging to watch FLRD stay high while utilization edges upward slightly. Could you discuss what absolute market lease rates look like? For instance, how did they change from one quarter to the next during Q3, and do you believe further gains are possible, or would you say absolute lease rates are basically at their ceiling?
Jean Savage
executiveAppreciate it, Matt. My apologies, Matt. Compared with a year earlier, the average lease rate across our consolidated fleet has climbed 8%, and that's beginning to show up in the top line through the revenue figure. When you pair that with market conditions—which, as of now, we don't expect to shift dramatically—and an FLRD of 26.6%, we continue to believe lessors have room to push rates higher.
Matt Elkott
analystAll right. That's useful, Jean. Then when it comes to orders, 3,200 units looks like — I suppose, well, a decent figure, but it strikes me as somewhat soft compared with the broader industry, particularly considering how robust lease rates are and how squeezed certain pockets of railcars have become. I'm simply curious what manufacturing order and inquiry activity looks like at present, and whether any orders have come in since the third quarter.
Jean Savage
executiveIf we examine inquiry volumes, they continue to back our expectation of a 40 to 50,000 car build for the industry, and we anticipate that across the coming few years. As you're aware, Matt, orders tend to be uneven from one quarter to the next, and we currently hold 50% of the industry backlog. Consequently, we believe our visibility into current conditions is quite solid; so far this year, the industry is on track to produce 36,000 cars, so in terms of attrition, and we still anticipate that 40 to 50,000 cars will get built.
Matt Elkott
analystThanks a lot, Jean. I appreciate that.
Jean Savage
executiveYes, thank you.
Christian Zyla
analystGood morning, everybody; Christian Zyla here, filling in for Steve Barger. I appreciate you letting me ask a couple of things. To start, given where demand stands right now and the backlog, could you share your perspective on what a normalized level of deliveries looks like?
Jean Savage
executiveWhen we talk about a normalized delivery level, it will correspond, once again, to our expectation for the industry's build, meaning 40,000 to 50,000 cars annually. From one quarter to the next it can be uneven, depending on circumstances and on the types of cars involved. So if you like, divide that by four, though it shifts somewhat. That's likely the best response I can offer on that topic.
Christian Zyla
analystUnderstood. Next, how much of the backlog is designated for production in 2024? What amount is for 2025, and how much lies past that? Thanks.
Jean Savage
executiveDuring last year's third quarter, we received a sizable multi-year booking from GATX, so at minimum for a portion of those orders, our line of sight extends across the coming five years. As for what we'll hand over in the following year — they are pulling that figure for me at this moment. So next year, 40% of the backlog will be delivered.
Christian Zyla
analystExcellent, thanks very much.
Jean Savage
executiveThanks for being with us today. We feel good about what we delivered in Q3 and the gains showing up across our operations. As we wrap up the year, we anticipate carrying real momentum and healthy financial performance. We're eager to update you on how things are going at that point.
Operator
operatorThat brings this call to a close. We appreciate your joining us for the presentation today. You're free to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Trinity Industries, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Trinity Industries, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Trinity Industries, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.