Trinity Industries, Inc. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 1, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Leigh Anne Mann
executiveThanks, Operator. Morning, everyone. We're glad you could be with us for the company's conference call covering second quarter 2024 financial results. Prepared remarks will feature comments from Jean Savage, Trinity's Chief Executive Officer and President, along with Eric Marchetto, the company's Chief Financial Officer; after our leaders deliver those prepared remarks, we'll take questions in a Q&A session. On today's call, we'll refer to certain non-GAAP financial metrics. Reconciliations of those non-GAAP metrics to comparable GAAP measures appear in the appendix of the quarterly investor slides, which you can access on our investor relations website at www.trin.net; those slides sit under the events and presentations portion of the website, together with the second quarter earnings conference call of webcast link. After 10:30 A.M. Eastern Time through midnight on August 8th, 2024, a replay of today's call will be available. Replay information can be found under the events and presentations page on our investor relations website. Before handing the call to Jean, I wanted to remind you that Trinity completed our 2024 Investor Day on June 25th. A replay of that webcast is likewise available under the events and presentations page on our investor relations website; and now it's my pleasure to turn the call over to Jean.
E. Jean Savage
executiveThanks, Leigh Anne, and hello everyone. Seeing some of you face-to-face at our June Investor Day was a real pleasure. I'd suggest tuning into the webcast, as it details both the longer-term priorities we've set for the coming years and the headway achieved since our previous event in 2020; from where we sit, we possess a rail platform without equal that provides a complete range of customer solutions and ought to ultimately generate stronger returns for shareholders; we rank as a top-tier rail car leasing firm, backed by a platform of integrated rail capabilities that sustains our lease fleet and serves our customers. During Investor Day, one idea we aimed to get across was our ability to maximize returns over the life cycle, made possible by a steadier operating climate and diminished cyclicality throughout our platform. The solid results we delivered in the second quarter underscore that ability and demonstrate substantial gains in both the improvement and the durability of margins across our business. A handful of important items to note before we move into the specifics. To begin, GAAP EPS was $0.67 and adjusted EPS was $0.66, representing an increase of $0.33 quarter-over-quarter and $0.43 year-over-year on an adjusted basis. Next, revenues grew 16% year-over-year, and operating profit increased 43% year-over-year; this mirrors improved lease rates, greater external deliveries, and advances in labor and operational efficiencies. Third, cash flow from continuing operations came to $243 million for the quarter, fueled by increased external deliveries and working capital improvements. Last, as we mentioned at Investor Day, we are moving to a more conventional post-tax ROE definition as a key performance indicator. With this revised metric, Trinity's adjusted ROE over the trailing 12 months stood at 16.8%, reflecting strong operating results and balance sheet positioning. In summary, our team produced solid financial results in the second quarter, and that leaves us confident about the second half of the year. Eric will cover this in his prepared remarks, but we're lifting our annual guidance by $0.20, bringing the 2024 full-year range to $1.55-$1.75, which suggests steady results through the second half. Before we get into Trinity's performance, I want to bring you up to date on the rail car market. Demand for existing rail cars is still strong, and we expect carload volumes to stay steady in the back half of the year. As is typical with normal seasonal patterns, rail cars in storage have risen a bit, yet we see the overall rail car market in a favorable light. The North American rail car fleet has expanded somewhat during the last 18 months, as rail car users seek to optimize scrapping decisions while replacement cars are delivered. During Investor Day, we noted there are still sizable segments of rail cars that are getting older and will require replacement over the next several years. On top of that, train speeds look good and dwell times have come down — a positive indicator for modal share shifting toward rail over the longer term, though it does lower rail car demand in the near term. Carloads are somewhat below where they stood a year ago, driven primarily by weaker coal volumes. Excluding coal, carloads were actually up a little year over year. Over the past few weeks, North American rail originations in construction and metals, agriculture, and downstream and chemical products rose about 9%. All told, those segments' rail cars make up over 75% of the net book value in our fleet. We expect roughly 40,000 rail cars delivered industry-wide in 2024, and 120,000 across the next three years. Manufacturers—Trinity included—are demonstrating solid market discipline, and that keeps the industry fleet both well utilized and diversified. In our view, the rail car build cycle will prove less volatile than prior ones, with peaks that are lower and floors that are higher. Trinity's business is divided into two primary segments: leasing and services, plus rail products. I'll start with leasing and services, the segment that includes our leasing, maintenance, and logistics operations. On the leasing side, we're pleased with how the lease fleet keeps performing and building momentum. Our future lease rate differential, or FLRD, is at plus 28.3%. Market rates have stayed firm, and that measure has held consistently high. Over the nine quarters we've reported this metric in positive double digits, we've repriced approximately 44% of the fleet. Renewals came in at rates 32.5% higher than the expiring ones, and revenues from leasing and management were up roughly 9% versus a year earlier. Renewal success for the quarter reached 72%, with utilization at 96.9%. We look at where our rail cars can perform best in the market, aiming to optimize returns over the long term — and that can mean moving cars to another location once existing contracts expire, so the fleet is set up as well as possible for lasting value. Considering the markets, car types, and customers whose contracts come up this quarter, we're pleased with where the fleet stands today and how it's being used; we closed a portfolio sale of 1,315 railcars along with the associated leases for a total price of roughly $143 million, and across all lease portfolio sales in the secondary market this quarter we recorded gains of $23 million. Our maintenance operations are part of the leasing segment. Since the mix of internal versus external repairs fluctuates, margins in that area tend to swing considerably. Still, having a robust maintenance network and being able to service our own fleet gives us a competitive edge and helps us be a stronger railcar owner and partner. Now, regarding rail products — which backs up our lease fleet and covers railcar manufacturing along with our aftermarket parts business — I'm happy with the considerable headway we've achieved, especially on labor and operational efficiencies. The 7.9% operating margin we posted in the second quarter represents a big gain both sequentially and year-over-year, and lands at the top end of the 6%-8% full-year guidance we provided. During the quarter, we received orders totaling 2,495 rail cars and handed over 4,755 rail cars. Replacement-level demand remains supported by incoming inquiries, and our customers continue to put deliveries into service without delay. Because our rail car build cycle is now tighter, we're able to run operations with greater consistency and to plan labor and supply chain work more smoothly. Even in the absence of near-term volume growth, that should help this business maintain margins that are steady or slightly better. Before I close, I should note that at the end of June we issued an interim update to our corporate social responsibility report, which is available on our website. I'd encourage you to review that report for a current look at our company's sustainability efforts. Now I'll hand things over to Eric, who will go over the financial statements and refresh our outlook for the remainder of the year.
Eric Marchetto
executiveThank you, Jean, and good morning to all of you. I'd like to go through a few highlights from our financial statements, and after that I'll wrap up with some thoughts regarding what we expect for the remainder of 2024. To begin with the income statement, revenues for the quarter came in at $841 million, which reflects more external rail car deliveries and better lease rates. GAAP earnings per share from continuing operations was $0.67, while adjusted EPS came to $0.66. As Jean pointed out, that amounts to substantial growth on both a sequential and a year-over-year basis. During the quarter we gained from lower eliminations as well as from sales in the lease portfolio. In addition, we saw consistently stronger performance across our business and improved operating margins in both of our segments. Turning to the cash flow statement, we produced cash flow from continuing operations of $243 million for the quarter and $300 million year to date. As you may recall, we finished 2023 with a higher working capital balance, which was driven by year-end issues at the border. Those rail cars have since been delivered and turned into cash, which shows up in our reduced working capital balance of $699 million, roughly $92 million lower than in the first quarter. Combining $163 million in lease rail car sales with fewer deliveries to the lease fleet during the quarter gives us a net fleet investment of negative $77 million. Our guidance range for net fleet investment across the full year is still unchanged, since secondary market activity tends to be lumpy, and we anticipate net investment rising in the back half of the year as more deliveries enter the lease fleet and fewer rail cars are sold on the secondary market. The RIV sale during the second quarter fulfills our original program agreement. We expect to keep selling leased rail cars to our RIV partners. At present our liquidity stands at $985 million. For the wholly owned lease portfolio, our loan-to-value is 68.3%, which sits inside our new target range of 60%-70%; during the second quarter, two significant debt and capital market transactions bolstered our balance sheet and optimized our loan-to-value. First, in May, we issued $432 million of green secured rail car equipment notes, the TRL 2024 notes. We used the proceeds from that issuance to repay warehouse borrowings and to redeem the outstanding ABS debt of TRL 2017. Second, in June, we issued an additional $200 million of principal on our unsecured senior notes, bringing the aggregate principal amount to $600 million. With the proceeds from this transaction plus cash on hand, we repaid our Trinity unsecured 2024 senior notes. Now let's discuss what we anticipate in the second half of 2024. As Jean mentioned, we still expect roughly 40,000 industry rail car deliveries in 2024, which would support replacement-level demand. On a net basis, we expect to invest between $300-$400 million in our fleet. Our operating and administrative capital expenditures of $50-$60 million a year, which cover investments in automation, technology, and modernization of facilities and processes, are unchanged from prior guidance. To wrap up, as Jean said, we're raising our full-year EPS outlook to a range of $1.55-$1.75 for 2024. As we look ahead to the coming six months, I'd like to give a bit more detail on that guidance. First, as anticipated, we completed a sizable rail car sale during the quarter. So far this year, gains from rail car sales total $25 million. We said before that we expect gains to come in at roughly half the 2023 level. That implies gains from secondary-market sales will be smaller in the back half of the year. Second, on our fourth quarter 2023 call, we noted that for 2024 we expect roughly 20%-25% of deliveries to be allocated to the lease fleet. In the second quarter, that figure was about 10%, reflecting the timing and planning of our manufacturing and delivery schedule. That helped second-quarter earnings, since revenue and profit eliminations were lower. We anticipate a greater share of deliveries heading into our lease fleet during the second half of the year. This supports our fleet investment objectives and our confidence in the returns we'll earn by leasing these rail cars rather than selling them new. Whenever a rail car joins our fleet, the related manufacturing revenue and profit are eliminated. So a larger share of rail cars going to our fleet at the same delivery count will lower quarterly earnings per share, yet it will produce stronger long-term returns on the rail car and give us multi-year visibility into forward cash flow through lease contracts. As we've discussed around our Investor Day, we expect 2024 operating margins of 38% to 41% in our leasing segment and 6% to 8% in our rail product segment. While we expect margins to average at those rates across the years, there can be some variability through the year. Leasing segment operating margins can shift with secondary market activity, maintenance volume, and mix. Rail product margins can shift with product mix, line changeovers, and production efficiency. We're proud of how we performed in the second quarter and feel increasingly confident in our visibility for the remainder of the year, as reflected in our raised EPS guidance. In our leasing segment, a consistently high FLRD has pushed lease rates higher, and the revenue growth from those higher lease rates flows through to the bottom line. Our maintenance and digital services businesses are also doing well, giving customers a broader offering and a better experience. In the rail products group, our higher operating margin reflects steady, disciplined work on labor and operational efficiency. Our legacy parts and heads businesses are performing well and are reducing the segment's overall cyclicality. In summary, our full suite of products and services is performing well, improving our business's returns and driving shareholder value. Operator, we're now ready for our first question.
Bascom Majors
analystGood morning. Starting with a bit of framing, you laid out very clearly the split between internal and external sales and what that means for the back half. Could you speak a little to how margins are trending, given how strong they've been for a number of consecutive quarters? And on the OE side, if that continues to climb, it could put us toward the upper end of your range by the time the year closes. But we also get that there could be some absorption challenges as more of that revenue and profit gets eliminated, and how do you reconcile the underlying trend against the accounting side of it? Thank you.
E. Jean Savage
executiveWell, Bascom, that was a very good summary. So as we think about the second half in the products group, as Eric said during his prepared remarks, a lot hinges on the mix of vehicles we're building, how many line changeovers happen in that window, and then the efficiencies. Each car type carries its own efficiency profile. So the group will keep pushing on all the initiatives. Among the early wins we've had are things in supply chain and procurement, plus some of the changeover efforts they've been working on. So we anticipate carrying that forward, but we're still maintaining the full-year guidance of 6%-8% for products margins. Keep in mind that moves higher next year, and the range we've given for that is 7%-9%.
Bascom Majors
analystThat ties directly into what I had in mind to ask. Next year reflects a slight increase, and then your longer-range guidance turns into something closer to a jump to 9 to 11 in 2026. Could we go through that — I realize it was discussed at the Investor Day a few weeks back, but could we take another look at it? Why caution for next year, with visibility or hope for a more meaningful increase the year after — is that essentially just some cyclical cushioning, or does the mix and backlog give you visibility suggesting a bigger leap should really appear 18 months out rather than 6 months out? Thank you.
E. Jean Savage
executiveSure, Bascom. So the mix isn't the issue. What we're looking at is the initiatives. Remember, we said we're working on workforce staffing, retention and development, standardizing product offerings and complexity reduction, enhancing our production planning capabilities, advanced supply chain processes, and strategic sourcing, and then technology and automation. Every one of those items needs time before it reaches the bottom line, and that goes past the supply chain — so the real issue is the timing of completing them and bringing them in. At the Investor Day, we told you that for 2024 through 2026, industry deliveries should total 120,000. That means a reasonably steady environment on the whole. You might see some unevenness from one year to the next, but it is reasonably steady. As a result, these initiatives will need to come through for that margin to keep improving.
Bascom Majors
analystThis is my final question. Could you expand a bit on something — I believe you mentioned that 44% of your fleet has been repriced since lease rates really climbed a few years back. How long is the runway before we reach 100%? I think the general assumption out there has been roughly 15% per year as a rough guide. But assuming lease rates hold steady in absolute terms, how much runway remains to reprice the existing fleet at meaningfully improved returns as we work through that, without requiring sequential strengthening or absolute increases in lease rates? Thank you.
E. Jean Savage
executiveBascom, I'll take that one, and Eric can chime in if needed. Given the tight market we're operating in — really a balanced, supply-driven market — discipline has been maintained within it. So with just 44% of our fleet repriced — and you're right, we've been repricing about 15% of our fleet annually — we still see headroom ahead. Keep in mind, during the quarter our renewal rates came in 32.5% above expiring rates. So strength remains evident there. Any shifts in that will show up in our FLRD down the road, but an FLRD of 28.3% is still quite strong.
Bascom Majors
analystThank you both.
E. Jean Savage
executiveThanks.
Jacob Moore
analystHello, and good morning. Jacob Moore here, standing in for Steve today. I appreciate you taking our questions. A few of them overlap with what Bascom raised, though I might frame them a bit differently. So, first off for me: this appears to be among the weaker revenue-per-car quarters going back to 4Q21, and I'm not fully certain how the segment reclassification plays into that. So I suppose my initial question is whether you could discuss what's happening with mix and how mix should shape up in the second half? It seemed as though there was a negative call out on the manufacturing revenue line.
Eric Marchetto
executiveYes, Jacob, Eric here. Thank you. On the mix question, the market continues to be driven more by freight cars, and freight cars typically carry a lower average selling price compared with tank cars; and inside that, mix fluctuates quite widely; so I'd say that's fairly. I wouldn't read too much into it. Looking ahead, we anticipate somewhat of a modest pickup in tank car deliveries, which ought to support that average selling price. Our attention is more on margins across all of those rail cars, and we therefore feel good about the overall pricing environment pretty much across the board for every car type.
Jacob Moore
analystAll right, understood. Appreciate that. This is my second question. In the first half, your orders averaged 2,200 each quarter, while deliveries averaged more than double that figure, at 4,700. So what I want to ask is: if that trend continues through the second half, by my calculation backlog would finish at roughly 16,000 cars. Are you considering reducing production, or do you have firm delivery schedules for everything currently in the backlog?
E. Jean Savage
executiveI'll handle that question. Looking at order entry, the builders are becoming faster at delivering cars. Previously, when the supply chain had problems, orders would come in earlier since everything filled up more quickly. We're essentially sold out for 2024. Looking at the composition of those orders, as Eric said, freight cars still lead the way. Tank cars are beginning to improve. We're not particularly worried. Order entry can be uneven. Keep in mind, we received a large multi-year order. Roughly 46% of the industry backlog sits on our books. As you mentioned, we've delivered 40%+ of deliveries over the last four quarters. On the whole, it's really the unevenness in quarterly entry, plus the backlog we already hold.
Jacob Moore
analystAll right, understood. And that sort of flows right into my final question, if you don't mind. Should deliveries come in lower next year, would you be able to hold manufacturing margin around the 8% level? Or put another way, what is the lowest delivery schedule needed to hit your target manufacturing margin?
Eric Marchetto
executiveWell, Jacob, regarding 2025, we held our Investor Day just a few weeks back, and we laid out fairly solid indications of activity and margin guidance covering 2024, 2025, and 2026. That is as far as we will go today with respect to 2025. Yet, as Jean said a moment ago, we anticipate 120,000 rail cars across the coming three years, matching the figure from the prior three years; so things ought to run fairly smoothly. It won't be 40,000 each year, but we are roughly on pace for about 40,000 this year; so there isn't much variation to be had from that. And on the margin profile, what we know about our margin profile for 2025 is captured in the comments we made at our Investor Day.
Jacob Moore
analystGot it—that clears things up nicely. Thanks, Eric. And thanks to both of you for fielding questions.
Leigh Anne Mann
executiveThank you, Jacob.
E. Jean Savage
executiveThanks.
Bascom Majors
analystEric, with all the accounting detail showing up in your numbers — at times involving the eliminations and that sort of thing — could you walk us through the $0.20 lift to EPS guidance, so we can get a clearer picture of what's accounting and what could be upside surprises in the core performance of the business? Thanks.
Eric Marchetto
executiveYeah. Thanks, Bascom. I mean, I think the way you frame your question is kind of accurate. First, I'd say the second quarter activity — we're really pleased with how the activity turned out. And we did see solid performance in both of our segments. Relative to the outlook we gave for the year when we last spoke in late April or early May, the second quarter is showing stronger results than we had anticipated then. Our present forecast also points to improved performance during the latter half of the year. As I mentioned in my prepared remarks, we were aware of how the gains would be timed — a larger share has landed in the first half rather than the second, and I believe I was fairly explicit about that. And as you noted, the eliminations are definitely weighted toward the back end this year; that simply reflects how the production schedule worked out. Part of that showed up in our second-quarter beat. Eliminations came in lower. We saw slightly bigger gains than anticipated because one deal closed during Q2; even so, we're keeping our full-year GAAP outlook unchanged. Our full-year elimination outlook remains the same as before, so all in all we feel really good about it. One more thing worth noting: remember those deliveries that got stuck at the border during the fourth quarter? They've all now been delivered and turned into cash. That gave us the benefit of about 1,000 units in the first half, and we won't get that in the second half.
Bascom Majors
analystOn what you said about being pleased with results that beat our expectations in Q2 and that continuing into the back half — if we dig into that, is it mainly manufacturing efficiency and margin? Or, I mean, which one or two items would you highlight where you did better than you had assumed versus the April budget? Thanks.
Eric Marchetto
executiveYeah. I'd point to Rail Group margins, and in particular the border deliveries, plus how our supply chain flowed through — all of that produced better efficiencies. That gives us considerable confidence going forward; on leasing, with an FLRD of 28%, versus 32% last quarter, we expect lease rates to keep rising. And we're confident that through the back half of the year we'll keep repricing assets upward; so that's another area where we have confidence.
Bascom Majors
analystThank you.
Eric Marchetto
executiveThanks.
E. Jean Savage
executiveWell, I appreciate you taking the time to join us today. What makes the Trinity platform strong is the steady emphasis we place on safeguarding and boosting the returns from our lease fleet. We feel good about what we delivered in the second quarter, and we think we're set up well to keep making further gains in the returns of our business.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's conference call and presentation, ladies and gentlemen. Thank you for being with us. You can disconnect your lines at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Trinity Industries, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Trinity Industries, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Trinity Industries, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.