United Utilities Group PLC (UU) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 25, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood morning or good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the United Utilities Group plc Half Year Results covering the 6 months ending September 2020. I'm Adam, and I'll be operating this call. <<operator_script>> At this point I'll pass things over to Steve Mogford to get us started. Steve, over to you.
Steve Mogford
executiveThank you so much, Adam, and good morning everyone, and welcome to the United Utilities Half Year Results Presentation for the Financial Year 2020/2021. Because of COVID-19 restrictions, we again aren't able to meet in person, but I really hope this presentation, along with the Q&A afterward, will provide a sense of the excellent progress we've made on our AMP7 plans. It's been an unusual beginning to a new regulatory period, having to adjust to the operating conditions required to safeguard customers, employees, and supply chain partners. The EU team has performed brilliantly, and I feel tremendous pride and appreciation for the adaptability and commitment demonstrated by everyone throughout the business. Despite these difficulties, we stayed strongly focused on achieving our AMP7 objectives. So these are the main points this morning. To begin, we deliver an essential service to customers 365 days a year, 24 hours a day, and access to water for sanitation has never mattered more to customers than during this pandemic. With roughly 60% of our employees working from home and the remainder at our COVID secure sites, our services have held up well in meeting the greater water demand we've seen. The Northwest is among the regions hit hardest by COVID, and it includes the areas that were first to face the strictest Tier 3 restrictions because of high infection rates before the second lockdown.
Steve Mogford
executiveOn top of that, we serve some of England's most socioeconomically deprived communities, which can be especially vulnerable to COVID and the lockdown restrictions that come with it. So continuing to support those customers who are facing difficulties during these times has been one of our key priorities. A lot of the communities where we operate are struggling, and we've done our part to try to help. I'll say more about this shortly. Second, we were well prepared for AMP7. With fast track status and our early investment in the final year of AMP6, we had a supply stop against our AMP7 targets, and we're performing well. We've accelerated our capital investment plans, spending more over the next couple of years than in our original PR19 business plan so that improvements come earlier in the period for customers and the environment, together with the accompanying ODI rewards, and contributing to the green recovery in our region. Third, and Phil will walk you through the numbers, our financial performance has again been strong across the first 6 months of this year. Revenues have held up well, cash collection has been good, and our balance sheet and pensions position remains strong. And finally, dividend policy — again, Phil will give you more color — but we now have a clear understanding of the impact of COVID on our business, which remains robust and supported by a strong balance sheet.
Steve Mogford
executiveThat, combined with a more settled outlook for inflation, is why we feel able to reaffirm the AMP7 dividend policy announced earlier this year — growth in line with CPIH inflation. Let me now walk through some of the detail, beginning with how we performed operationally across the last 6 months. As I said, our services have held up well against the unusual patterns of demand we've seen. In the first half, net demand for water came in 3% higher, as domestic demand outweighed the fall in business consumption. During the hot, dry spring, demand at its peak rose 22%. Domestic retail cash collections stayed strong, thanks to a tremendous effort from our cash team in helping customers who are in difficulty and collecting from those who can pay. As a result, domestic bad debt has been held at 1.8% of revenue across the first half. With COVID restrictions continuing, we're seeing businesses make more redundancies, which could affect customers' ability to pay. As things stand, though, we're comfortable with the GBP 17 million additional bad debt provision we took at the end of last year. Our confidence is strengthened by the agreement we secured earlier this year to widen the scope of our social tariff. That has the capacity to extend support to as many as an additional 45,000 customers who are struggling to pay their bill.
Steve Mogford
executiveConditions for retailers are still tough, yet the liquidity assistance given to them throughout the pandemic—our joint venture Water Plus included—has been enormously valuable. That support will taper off gradually by the end of the year. Retailers are now starting to rebuild the accounts whose billing had been paused. Ofwat is presently consulting on how much bad debt relief retailers might receive above 2% of revenues, and we are waiting to hear how those discussions conclude. I take great pride in the dedication and empathy our customer-facing teams have displayed through these extraordinary times. We offer a broad selection of schemes designed to assist customers, and in the year to date these have reached over 3x as many customers as they did in the equivalent period a year earlier. Altogether, roughly 142,000 customers are presently receiving help with their bills, which works out at about 5% of our domestic customer base. We made a commitment to deliver GBP 71 million of financial support to customers across AMP7, and this year we have sped up payments so that help arrives where it is badly needed. We have also tried to do our bit to help the communities we serve come through the pandemic. A few illustrations: while schools were closed, our education team built a home learning hub that gave teachers and children throughout the region materials for schooling at home.
Steve Mogford
executiveMore than 7,000 users accessed those resources, and our reach stretched as far as schools in Italy. We held the sector's first Social Mobility Summit, where over 100 organizations joined us to launch our opportunity action plan, setting out our commitment to the Social Mobility Pledge. Apprentice and graduate recruitment has carried on without interruption, as has our youth program, which helps young people and employees — this includes our backing of the Kickstart program, providing training and meaningful work placements for an initial 250 young people, with room to grow further next year. And last, our continuing charitable support, among it the Board's voluntary salary reduction, has given welcome help to local communities. A donation of ours to the FareShare charity helped it deliver 600,000 meals to half press families through local food banks. Our investment in skills has carried on right through the pandemic. Established in 2014, our Technical Training Academy has so far given skills development and certification to roughly 2,500 employees, and it includes programs for people who are not in education, employment or training. As I said earlier, we are lucky to have a workforce that has demonstrated flexibility and commitment in maintaining customer services. In surveys, we consistently find ourselves among U.K.
Steve Mogford
executiveWe rank among top performers when it comes to employee engagement. Even so, our people are not shielded from the difficulties that have affected so many households across our region, so we set up a staff outreach program offering financial help to those whose families are facing money troubles directly because of the pandemic. As with numerous other firms, the pandemic has sped up our digital strategy, and I don't foresee a return to how we operated before COVID, and we are giving careful thought to what our new normal should look like. I'm really encouraged by how we've begun AMP7. As I said earlier, gaining fast track status in PR19 gave us early certainty about our targets and the time to make a flying start to the new regulatory period. We put about GBP 130 million into the final year of AMP6, in projects that enhanced customer or environmental outcomes and the chance to outperform our ODIs. During AMP6, we sped up capital expenditure across the first 2 years so schemes could be delivered early, and we're taking the same approach in AMP7, with roughly GBP 500 million of our total expenditure pulled forward, mostly into this year and next. Our AMP7 scope has grown thanks to the upgrade of our wastewater treatment facility in Bolton, along with work on our critical Vyrnwy Aqueduct, amounting to around GBP 150 million in AMP7.
Steve Mogford
executiveOn operational performance, the first half showed yet another improvement versus a year earlier, and customer satisfaction is still high and on course to earn a first-year reward under the new C-MeX incentive mechanism. We've kept up our sector-leading performance, with no serious pollution incidents recorded so far this year, and we remain on track for industry-leading 4-star environmental performance for 2020. I'm also pleased to report that we've successfully finished replacing the Hallbank section of our Haweswater Aqueduct. That work began in AMP6, was funded from AMP6 outperformance, came in on time and within budget, and replaces the portion of the Aqueduct judged most at risk of failure based on surveys carried out in AMP5 and 6. Ofwat assessed our AMP7 business plan as among the most efficient in the sector, and I'm glad to say that, thanks to the action we took during AMP6, we enter AMP7 at the target totex run rate. So we're confident of delivering our AMP7 scope within our final determination totex allowance. Our plans also have us delivering the committed outcomes, investing to drive further efficiencies, and delivering ODI outperformance. While our aim is to deliver totex outperformance, we will invest totex where we're confident that doing so can deliver greater ODI performance through improved customer or environmental outcomes.
Steve Mogford
executiveThe way AMP7 differs from AMP6 is that our ODIs get measured each year and lead to a revenue adjustment 2 years afterward. At present, we are on course for a net ODI reward in AMP7's first year. As you're aware, we have 46 ODIs altogether, though this slide indicates where we presently forecast we will land at year-end, for the biggest contributors by way of a net ODI reward. The biggest rewards are anticipated for how we perform on lowering hydraulic internal flooding risk, pollution and cutting the count of void properties. On certain of our harder ODI targets, we expect to be in penalty, even though system thinking is central to lifting our performance in those areas. We will say more about plans at our Capital Markets Day in the new year. Right now, we anticipate earning a net reward of roughly GBP 10 million this year. Plainly, our total outcome will hinge on second-half performance, and we awaited to get through, but there is also scope for us to do better. Over AMP7 as a whole, we are aiming for a net ODI reward above the GBP 44 million delivered in AMP6. And finally, AMP7 dividend policy.
Steve Mogford
executivePhil will go into more detail during his part, but at this point we have a solid grasp of how COVID has affected our business, which is still resilient and backed by a healthy balance sheet. Along with a more settled inflation picture, that gives us the assurance to restate the AMP7 dividend policy we set out earlier this year — growth in line with CPIH inflation. Phil, over to you.
Philip Aspin
executiveThank you, Steve, and good morning to all of you. I've had the chance to meet a lot of you during my time as Group Controller and, before that, as Group Treasurer, so it's a real pleasure to bring you my first results presentation today in my role as CFO. In this session, I plan to draw attention to how well we've performed financially and to set out the key financial matters linked to COVID-19. Since COVID-19 has become a diminishing part of daily life, no adjustment has been applied for its effect on the non-GAAP financial measures we're reporting today. After that, I'll turn to the strength of our balance sheet, starting with where we stand on customer receivables and then moving onto territory you'll know well—RCV gearing and, naturally, pensions. Once I've gone through our strong financial results and resilient balance sheet, I plan to explain in more depth why the Board feels confident enough to reaffirm our AMP7 dividend policy as of today. And finally, I'll share some top-level guidance looking ahead to the full year. These are the main financial highlights for the half year. Revenue came in at GBP 894 million, a decline of 4.4%, which mainly mirrors the price reduction we already knew about in this, the opening year of the new regulatory period. Household bad debt stands at 1.8% of regulated revenue, in line with the pre-COVID level seen in the same half a year earlier.
Philip Aspin
executiveUnderlying operating profit came in at GBP 319 million, an 18.5% decline driven by lower revenues and the planned increase in infrastructure renewals expenditure. Consequently, underlying EPS stands at 25.5p per share, a drop of 16.1%. We continue to hold one of the sector's strongest balance sheets, with low customer debtor risk, RCV gearing at 63%, and a pension scheme that is fully funded on a low dependency basis — all of which underpin the stabilized A3 credit rating from Moody's. Let me now walk through these points in more detail. On the left-hand side of this slide, we show a bridge of revenue from the first half of last year to the first half of this year. To summarise, revenue of GBP 894 million is GBP 41 million lower, mainly reflecting a no price reduction in this, the first year of the new regulatory period. Turning now to each of the components in the bridge. Revenue in the first half of last year was reduced by GBP 6 million because of the impact of the wholesale revenue forecasting incentive mechanism, which does not apply in the current year. In this first year of the new regulatory period, we had a known reduction in the revenue cap, which in the first half is GBP 40 million, representing a 6.6% reduction in average household bills and a 1.5% increase in CPIH.
Philip Aspin
executiveWhen it comes to the nonhousehold market, revenue is down GBP 40 million, which reflects lower consumption as well as businesses that were classified as temporarily vacant during the first COVID lockdown. Conversely, in the household market, revenue is up GBP 26 million — initially because people were locked down at home while the weather was warm in late spring, and then because many of them kept working from home over the longer term. The right-hand side of the slide shows our market guidance for full year revenue to March '21. For the second half of the year, we expect the effect on nonhousehold revenue to be broadly consistent with the first half, whereas the household revenue impact is likely to be smaller since we won't get the benefit of the higher consumption driven by warm weather. Our current guidance is that full year revenue to March '21 will be GBP 60 million to GBP 110 million lower than the prior year, with the volume impact estimated at GBP 10 million to GBP 60 million. Under the revenue cap, that volume impact can be recovered in 2 years' time. I'll now walk through 3 key points on household cash collection and bad debt.
Philip Aspin
executiveFirst, cash collections stayed strong across the opening six months of the year, and cash relative to current-year charges matched last year's level. The assistance the government has given the job market has helped. And while some uncertainty inevitably persists into the second half of the year, as the second lockdown has shown, government policy is still to supply whatever support is needed to safeguard jobs. In recent years, we have concentrated on making progress with better data quality, business processes and systems, so that we can pursue payments accurately in an efficient and timely way. I was therefore delighted that the 2020 Credit Awards recognised this, with our customer team taking the Best Use of Technology Award for their work on the new debt management system. Second, although cash relative to prior-year charges is slightly lower than last year, that decrease is smaller than we anticipated when we received the GBP 17 million incremental provision in March '20, which also prudently assumes that the low level of cash flow continued into future years. As such, we remain confident that the balance sheet is adequately provisioned — more on this shortly.
Philip Aspin
executiveWhen there's an obvious affordability problem for customers trying to pay their bills, we can provide the broadest selection of affordability plans in the industry. And, as Steve mentioned earlier, those were expanded during this year by adding a third social tariff, which gives GBP 15 million per annum to help customers who are struggling because of COVID-19. The third key point is that our household bad debt charge for the first half of the year has stayed at 1.8% of regulated revenue. That matches where we were in the first half of last year and the underlying position for the full year to March '20. During the current year, we have also strengthened our credit reference sharing process by bringing in another agency with a stronger high street focus. This will broaden our footprint even more and enhance our collections activity. That is only one illustration of our comprehensive approach to collections activity, which underpins our ability to collect cash from customers who are able to pay but try to avoid doing so. In today's climate, it is entirely reassuring that the customer team's comprehensive approach to collections activity was recognized further when it won the headline award for Utilities & Telecoms Team of the Year in the 2020 Credit Awards.
Philip Aspin
executiveThose factors make us confident we can keep performing well as the employment situation and joblessness numbers change. On this slide, we show a bridge from underlying operating profit in last year's first half to the first half of this year. Underlying operating profit of GBP 319 million is lower by GBP 73 million. The main reasons are a GBP 41 million drop in revenue and a GBP 15 million rise in infrastructure renewal spending, reflecting continuing efforts to optimize how our network performs, and that figure also takes in GBP 3 million of expenditure tied to adverse weather. Property rates have gone up, largely because of a GBP 8 million rates refund received in last year's first half. Employee costs are GBP 5 million higher, partly because of a margin reduction in capitalized costs, with just 45% of employment-related costs charged through the capital programs. Having finished AMP6 with the required totex run rate for AMP7, we are confident we can keep our cost to live within the AMP7 final totex. Finally, we have incurred GBP 3 million of additional COVID-related costs, and those, together with the GBP 3 million of adverse weather-related expenditure I mentioned earlier, have been absorbed within our cost base.
Philip Aspin
executiveAll told, that comes to GBP 6 million of spending, and we haven't counted it as an adjusted item when working out our underlying operating profit. Turning now to the other main lines on the income statement. Our underlying net finance expense stands at GBP 109 million, and that's GBP 34 million below the first half of last year, mainly because of lower inflation being applied to our investment debt. Our share of joint venture profits is GBP 3 million, largely tied to our current JV. Because of our share of Water Plus losses in the prior year, we cut the group's net investment in Water Plus down to 0 at March '20. As a result, our GBP 6 million share of Water Plus losses for the first half of this year isn't recognized in the income statement. Our underlying tax charge for the first half of the year is GBP 39 million, which works out at 18% of underlying operating profit -- that's underlying profit, and it leaves out the deferred tax impact, all of which gives us underlying profit after tax of GBP 174 million and an underlying EPS of 25.5p per share. Now let's look a bit more closely at financing performance. Over at AMP7, we have roughly GBP 2.4 billion of financing to raise.
Philip Aspin
executiveFrom May, when we reported our full-year results, we've brought in approximately GBP 600 million, capitalizing on favorable rates and pushing our liquidity out to September 2022. During this stretch, central bank stimulus has given considerable support to solid investment-grade firms such as ours, and we anticipate that will remain the situation, giving us efficient entry to debt capital markets going forward. This chart presents our projected debt balance throughout the AMP, along with the rates we've locked in. Those rates have become favorable relative to the cost assumed for AMP7. In August, we completed our inaugural CPIH swap, creating GBP 50 million of debt that is now tied to CPIH and, as a result, an ideal fit with the regulatory regime; we believe this will be among the first CPIH swaps and represents the initial move toward growing our CPIH linkage within the debt portfolio. And last, on financing. Yesterday, we released a new sustainable finance framework, enabling us to raise financing founded on our robust ESG credentials. A sizable share of funding has consistently supported environmental projects, and historically the European Investment Bank provided this. After Brexit, whatever is raised via our sustainable finance framework will take the place of our green EIB funding and will sit alongside our conventional issuance.
Philip Aspin
executiveMoving on now to where we stand with customer receivables. Because of the uncertainty that COVID has brought about, we expect there will be close attention paid to how comparable household debtors are. As we mentioned before, this is something we have focused on heavily for most of the past decade. This chart illustrates where our household net debt stood across the last 5 years. That position has been managed soundly, and our strong performance shows up in the balance falling from GBP 115 million in 2016 to GBP 78 million in 2020. At March '20, our net debt balance of GBP 78 million was the lowest it had been in 5 years, and it ranks among the best managed customer receivables positions in the sector. Our policy for provisioning bad debt makes sure that debt older than 3 years is fully provided for, since we believe that covers the extent of any credible recovery period. And as you can see, the balance sheet exposure to debt more than 1 year old is only GBP 17 million. Knowing that our customer receivables position was well-managed going into the pandemic crisis gives us added confidence as we look to navigate the challenges ahead. This slide bridges the net debt from March '20 to September '20.
Philip Aspin
executiveNet debt stands at GBP 7.4 billion, which is GBP 35 million higher than in March '20. That figure reflects a change in how we define it, so that it leaves out the effect of derivatives that aren't hedging particular debt instruments — which means it gives a clearer picture of the debt balances we're contractually required to repay. Our revised method now aligns more closely with the one credit rating agencies use and captures the regulatory economics more accurately. Under this new definition, net debt at September '20 comes down by GBP 178 million, versus GBP 135 million at March '20. You'll find a complete explanation of these adjustments in the appendices to this presentation. This bridge sets out the normal movements in net debt. Credit rating agencies additionally adjust for any IFRS pension deficit, and that isn't applicable to United Utilities, since we're in an IFRS pension surplus position. Turning now to pensions in more detail. As we're aware, pensions can be a nice progress. Although attention tends to fall on the IFRS deficit that's visible, the true scale of the pensions problem, when measured on a low dependency basis, sits unobserved beneath the waterline. If we go back to 2010, we really did have a pensions iceberg, with an iceberg deficit of slightly below GBP 300 million.
Philip Aspin
executiveOfwat has just wrapped up the PR09 <<inaudible>> and set a boundary regarding how pension deficits will be funded going forward, past the 60% support for the deficit as it stood at that moment. With that in mind, we set up a joint working group alongside the pension trustee so that pension risk could be handled collaboratively, staying inside acceptable envelopes for risk and affordability. This creative way of working with government is one more illustration of ESG being put into practice at United Utilities, generating long-term value for every stakeholder by means of responsible strategic financial management. You can see the effect in the middle of the slide. Looking at how the acquisition has recently evolved, at September '20 our IAS 19 surplus stood at slightly above GBP 650 million, and the short-lived jump in credit spreads brought about by COVID that we saw in March '20 has for the most part reversed. That compares with a fully funded position on a low dependency basis, meaning no further pension deficit contributions are payable. On top of that, since the pension schemes are fully hedged against interest rates and inflation, we would not expect the pension scheme position to be -- to be rise -- we expect the pension scheme position to be largely shielded from market volatility. Our robust pension position aligns with the fast track classification the pension regulator has proposed, and we do not anticipate that any further action will be needed as the pension regulator's approach develops in parallel with the present consultation.
Philip Aspin
executiveAt a moment when having a strong balance sheet matters more than it ever has, it's reassuring that with United Utilities we have no pension icebergs to deal with. Now I'll go into more detail about why we feel confident today in reaffirming our AMP7 dividend policy. Back in May, the unsolicited COVID had clearly created a significant degree of uncertainty. There was a risk that low inflation would persist over a 3 to 5-year period. The government and Central Bank response was still in its infant state, and the ongoing impact on our business was unclear. Since then, monetary and fiscal policy has been deployed extensively and persistently to support the economy. The Bank of England retained the capacity to act more and to provide more support, and has been clear that in times of uncertainty, it is better to act aggressively. While the lease care authorities more generally committed to maintaining support to the economy as long as it is necessary to do. So although we're now in the second national lockdown, the picture is very different today even in May. Most businesses continue to operate and COVID secure ways of working are normal. Policymakers have repeatedly shown they are prepared to act and provide -- they're prepared to act, most recently in November, with further monetary and fiscal policy support.
Philip Aspin
executiveThe consensus for medium-term inflation has gone back to levels we saw before the pandemic, and the risks around those forecasts are increasingly tilted to the upside. That whole set of developments, together with a growing probability that vaccines will be rolled out on a mass scale, continues to lend support to the economy and, crucially, to inflation over the medium term. It is this constructive inflation picture, combined with our expert operational delivery and our robust balance sheet, that gives the Board the confidence today to reaffirm our AMP7 dividend policy. This slide lays out our outlook for the full year. As we have already covered, we would anticipate full year revenue of between GBP 1.75 billion and GBP 1.8 billion, which reflects the known year 1 bill reduction and the net effect of COVID on both household and nonhousehold consumption. We expect underlying operating costs to be higher year-on-year, reflecting modest inflation increases feeding through into core costs, together with higher IRE to maximize the performance of our network. Having closed out AMP6, we need totex runway for AMP7, and we remain confident that we can deliver the AMP7 scope within the final determination totex allowance. Underlying finance expense should be lower year-on-year, since the reduction driven by low inflation in the first half of the current year is expected to carry on into the second half.
Philip Aspin
executiveFor the year, CapEx is anticipated to land between GBP 590 million and GBP 640 million, which reflects the acceleration of our AMP7 program. And while it does hinge on how we perform in the second half, we would expect an ODI reward of roughly GBP 10 million for the year. So to sum up, we've turned in another strong financial performance during the first half of the year. Cash collection and our bad debt position have stayed robust. We've locked in some debt at low rates versus positive assumptions and have kept good access to credit markets, which means we're well placed for AMP7. We benefit from having one of the strongest balance sheets in the sector, with a leading pensions position and a low level of customer debt at risk. And finally, inflation forecasts have stabilized, supported by Central Bank stimulus and government intervention. That, alongside our excellent operational performance and our strong balance sheet position, gives us confidence today to reaffirm our AMP7 dividend policy. Thank you, and I'll now hand back to Steve.
Steve Mogford
executiveThanks, Phil. Before I wrap up, there are just a couple of areas I wanted to give you an update on. First, the sector has been helping the government do its part in the green economic recovery after COVID, specifically through infrastructure investment that benefits the environment and creates more jobs than would currently be the case under AMP7. There are 4 components to this request. The first is that companies should be on track with their current AMP7 commitments, and we are. The second is that companies are encouraged to speed up existing AMP7 investment plans, and we are, to the tune of around GBP 500 million, as mentioned previously. And the third is that companies should convert potential AMP7 enhancement projects into commitments through engagement with quality regulators, and we have, with around GBP 150 million of additional investment now planned in AMP7. And finally, companies may propose accelerating schemes that might otherwise feature in AMP8 within companies' PR24 business plans. We're in dialogue with Defra, the Environment Agency and Ofwat regarding proposals in the fourth category, and there's much to resolve in terms of scope, cost and funding, but this presents an opportunity to supplement what we're already doing to contribute to the green recovery, creating jobs in regions hard pressed as a consequence of the pandemic.
Steve Mogford
executiveWe'll share more on that next time we get together. Last thing: a quick reminder of how strongly we've performed across the various ESG indices. Our stance on ESG has been consistent and long-standing. And with COVID's challenges, acting responsibly in how we back customers, colleagues and communities matters more today than it ever has. Earlier this month, we were glad to once again reach world-class status on the Dow Jones Sustainability Index — a status we've now kept for 14 consecutive years, which shows our long-term dedication to ESG. That same level of performance carries across the wide set of industries you see on the slide, many of which investors use. Some of you will have come across the investor guide to our ESG approach that we put out in September, and we hope it proved useful. And as Phil mentioned earlier, we're drawing on our strong potential here through our sustainable finance framework to raise debt and replace the green EIB funding that's no longer available. So to sum up, I'm enormously proud of how the UU team is keeping services running and giving support to struggling customers, employees and communities in a region that COVID hit hard.
Steve Mogford
executiveIncreased household usage is compensating for the decline in commercial income, and from a bad-debt standpoint we are in a strong position. Our AMP7 launch went very smoothly, since we had the benefit of roughly GBP 130 million of investment made before the period began, along with the certainty that came from fast track status in PR19. We are generating value for every stakeholder group. On customer satisfaction we are setting the pace, we are on course for a 4-star environment status that leads the industry, and we anticipate delivering outperformance in year 1 of the AMP. Lastly, we are restating our AMP7 dividend policy: growth year-on-year by CPIH through 2025. Thank you for listening, and we will now gladly take any questions.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Today's initial question is from Dominic Nash at Barclays.
Dominic Nash
analystNice work on those results. I have a couple of questions, if I may. First, regarding ODIs and how they relate to totex: I believe your point is essentially that within this AMP, ODIs will come in above where they were in the prior AMP. The previous AMP figure was GBP 43.9 million — could you confirm that? And does that imply we should expect this kind of run rate across the entire 5-year period? It also appears fairly dependent on the flooding ODI — will that dependence change over the course of the 5-year review? Then, on totex versus the ODI, you mentioned a trade-off where some totex might be given up in favour of ODIs. How do you assess the returns and payback on that? And finally, would you also put the sustainability of the ODIs going forward against the cost of the totex, please?
Steve Mogford
executiveAlright, Dominic, let me follow up on that point. I believe you're right about ODIs. Yes — we're aiming for stronger improvement — apologies, stronger results on ODIs during AMP7 than what we delivered in AMP6. And I think the figure you mentioned regarding top performance for AMP6 is accurate. So yes, our goal is to do better than that. And clearly, a positive result in the first year is a great position to be in — a strong start. As you noted, many different factors feed into ODIs, some positive and some negative, as we're currently observing. Part of the challenge ahead of us — and this is where we really examined some of our early investments, both during the final year of AMP6 and also what we're funding right now — involves those areas where, in particular, we're seeing ourselves rise into penalty performance, so areas such as supply interruptions and internal sewer flooding. So what we're doing is investing at present, and we have pilot teams running in the first year, essentially focused on reducing the downside risk that the targets we hold in those areas present. If we simply continued on our current path, we would find ourselves in penalty territory.
Steve Mogford
executivePart of what we're doing with our investment strategy is to lift performance in areas where we essentially face a penalty regime — a substantial penalty regime. One example of that is internal sewer flooding. What we intend to do — we don't have the time this morning — but we can walk you through more of that at Capital Markets Day and get into the specifics there. On the trade-off question, you're absolutely right, and you've picked up the tone of what we said. If you look at the underlying position on totex in AMP7, at this early stage we're looking to deliver an outcome not dissimilar to AMP6 when it comes to meeting our FD commitments with a totex efficiency. On the trade-off, here's another way to see it: clearly, if you're looking at totex expenditure, you'd be looking at an ODI return, and that return on the investment would be better in the sense that the ODI return you'd get would be greater than the totex cost to shareholders. So what we're doing, in essence, is encouraging our teams across the board to seek out opportunities that improve outcomes on ODIs — which clearly benefits either customers or the environment — and that we're delivering a better service to customers or better environmental performance as a result.
Steve Mogford
executiveHowever, we're pushing our teams to seek out opportunities. So basically, if there's a chance to invest more and get a stronger return, then please bring those forward. So instead of just accepting the — our FD predictive performance is precisely what we want to do, we actually want to see improvement. And I think the other area for that, of course, is that when you look at areas where we're already at the frontier of our own performance, like on pollution, for example, where we're a frontier performer, clearly it's an area where we want to maintain frontier, but we've also got an eye to AMP8 and to — an expectation as we go into AMP8, we want to be as close to upper quartile as possible because you can only expect that as you go into AMP8, you're going to get further challenge. So I think you've picked up. Where we do see opportunity to earn, we will because essentially it's value-creating when you look at the return on investment that you make.
Philip Aspin
executiveAnd Dominic, just to add to what Steve laid out there — I mean, this really comes down to maintaining that performance over the medium term.
Dominic Nash
analystSo does that mean you believe that AMP8 ODIs and performance will look a lot like AMP7? I mean, you'll need to look at whether the measures themselves are sustainable.
Steve Mogford
executiveHonestly, no one can say for sure. It's basically guesswork, right? What has stood out to me is that, when you examine the CMA's review of the sector, they haven't really gone back to take a fundamental look at either the econometric models or the incentive regime in any meaningful way. So within that specific area of challenge, that subject hasn't been reopened, regardless of where the appellants stand on it. And I think that if you were assuming the train has already left the station when it comes to upper quartile performance, and that the sector is being pushed toward upper quartile, you still have to keep watching what that actually means. What we have consistently done as a business, really, is aim to deliver sustainable performance from the investment we've made, rather than essentially chasing short-term targets. Our goal would be to deliver something that holds up and is resilient for the future.
Operator
operatorMartin Young from Investec has our next question.
Martin Young
analystI trust everyone is doing well. If I may, I have 3 questions. The first concerns what you've said about how COVID could affect volumes across the full year. I understand that, up to a point, this is like trying to nail a jelly to a wall. With that minus GBP 14 million in the first half of the year, plus those comments about stability on the nonhousehold side — or stability in line with the first half of the year, I should say — but perhaps a smaller pickup on the household side, I just wondered, when you flesh out that narrative, how do you arrive at minus GBP 10 million at the bottom end of your range? Surely we ought to be looking at something a bit tighter. My second question is about the GBP 150 million of additional totex that you mentioned. Is that on top of your final determination? And if it is, where can we see this set out? I assume through a revised final determination showing how it flows through to revenue over the AMP. And then the last question, a bigger-picture one, concerns the CMA and its provisional determination with regard to the forward talents.
Martin Young
analystClearly, that’s something that doesn’t have a particularly big effect on you this year, but it could matter more over the longer term. I just wanted to ask whether you could share your thinking on what that might mean for you and for the sector over the longer term if the CMA does not shift much from where it ended up in those provisional determinations?
Steve Mogford
executiveYes. Martin, I’ll take questions 2 and 3, and then pass things to Phil regarding the revenue impact, if that works. So the GBP 150 million of additional totex is mainly 2 projects. One relates to the treatment work at Bolton, and the other relates to one of our main aqueducts, where we are carrying out relining. Both of those sit on top of our final determination. And basically, one of the mechanisms in AMP7 is that if you obtain an environmental scheme — Bolton is one, and it has essentially been converted to green status, in other words approved — then essentially you get reimbursed. So for both projects, we will have full cost recovery. The mechanism means we are likely to see the revenue impact of that land in AMP8. So we will deliver those projects, not entirely, but in large part during AMP7, yet we won’t see a revenue uplift in our AMP7 income, though we will see an adjustment, a full adjustment, once we reach AMP8. So we will see full cost recovery. On the other one, CMA: I think you’re right. For companies that are not appellants, the impact of CMA is 0 in terms of expectation.
Steve Mogford
executiveLooking at this over the long term — and I mentioned this earlier when answering Dominic — if you examine what the CMA actually did, they clearly reviewed the cost of capital for the appellants and granted a higher allowance. That allowance still falls inside what people regarded as a roughly reasonable range. Ofwat's — well, maybe reasonable isn't quite the right word, but inside a range one could predict, and Ofwat sat at the bottom of it, obviously, with the CMA higher. Does that affect investment and the thinking that goes into decisions ahead? Once we reach AMP8, nobody can really say, though there's clearly a feeling that we have to bring investors in. Broadly, though, when you look across the board, areas such as econometric modeling — several of the methodologies and approaches in use — have gone unchallenged. So saying what the impact will be is genuinely hard. One thing that I believe has emerged from the CMA's review is the need to make sure resilience holds going forward, and for the sector overall I think that's a fundamental issue.
Steve Mogford
executiveAnd in a way that, for the energy sector perhaps, being able to adapt to the use of renewables and to electric vehicles — with the government now having set very firm time scales for those — is like a call to action for the energy industry. And I think if you actually spoke to anybody in the water sector, climate change adaptation and population growth are a call for action as far as that sector is concerned, in terms of having resilience to the very, very evident impact of climate change. And I think that, to me, was something that came through in the CMA consideration and in some of the points the company made. So I think — and it's anybody's guess what will happen in AMP8 — but I think those are the 2 probably key issues: both attractive returns for investors and being resilient, I think, are 2 key features that will be subjects. I'm sure we'll talk about them, again, as we get into PR24. Do you want to — Phil, do you want to pick up on the revenue point that Martin made?
Philip Aspin
executiveMartin. Yeah, regarding revenue, let me break that into volume and non-volume pieces. To start with, what you're seeing in the first half on the non-volume side is a GBP 40 million price cap effect. That works out to roughly GBP 80 million across the whole year. Mechanism rewards and other items come to about GBP 12 million. So on this roughly GBP 30 million for the full year, it's effectively a net GBP 50 million cut versus the prior year. And that explains the gap between the revenue guidance and the volume effect. On volume itself, in half 1, as you mentioned, nonhousehold gives us a GBP 40 million hit, and the GBP 26 million favorable household position offsets it, leaving GBP 14 million adverse. We expect that to be a bit worse in half 2. That's what produces the volume range of roughly GBP 10 million to GBP 60 million. I think it matters to flag that estimation uncertainty in half 1 is relatively high. One difficulty the entire sector has faced is being able to obtain meter reads. As you'd expect, especially during lockdown, reading meters simply wasn't really feasible.
Philip Aspin
executiveYou'll see that in the back of the announcement, within our financial account, we've followed the FRC's best practice for giving guidance on revenue sensitivities. So that's what we're pointing out there. On the household side, for instance, 25% of meter reads have been used to help estimate household revenue, and just 17.5% of meter reads for the nonhousehold position. So these are all steps that look at the facts, back to the facts in the accounts. But I think it does highlight that there's a fairly high degree of uncertainty in the overall position. And then, looking ahead, as you put it in your question, it's a bit like crystal ball gazing when it comes to half 2 and understanding how the economy will perform. So that's our best estimate as of today, and I think it's a reasonable range to guide you to. And the last thing to flag, as you all know, is that the revenue cap has recovered the volume impact, effectively 2 years later.
Operator
operatorJames Brand from Deutsche Bank has our next question.
James Brand
analystI had 3 questions, please. The first one follows on from Dom's question, and it's just asking about the kinds of trade-offs and how you think about totex versus ODI outperformance? And you mentioned that you obviously think about how much you could get out of the ODIs versus how much you're spending on totex. I was just wondering on that, are you thinking, when you make that judgment on what you can deliver on the ODIs in the current period? So you're thinking if we spend GBP 50 million in totex, we might be looking to generate an extra GBP 25 million in ODI outperformance, that kind of calculation? Or are you thinking multiple periods? Like if we invest in this today, we might be able to eke out a little bit extra on ODIs over the next -- over this period, the next period, a period after that. And it becomes a kind of NPV of multiple periods of potential ODI outperformance, in which case, a much longer payoff? That's the first question. Second question is on ODIs directly. I was just wondering whether it gets harder or easier to deliver on the ODIs as we go through the period.
James Brand
analystNaturally, those goals become more demanding as time passes, though occasionally you get a step change in year 1, after which it could get somewhat easier or somewhat harder across the period? Second question. And third, something for Phil, since this is his first results presentation as the new finance director. Previously — back with Russ — the company set a net debt to RAV target of between 55% and 65%, with a broad aim of sitting around the midpoint, even though that has always been fairly conservative relative to other businesses in the sector, since plenty of water companies carry higher gearing. So I was wondering whether your thinking on gearing has shifted at all? Does that target still stand, the 55% to 65%? And if so, why do you want to operate with lower gearing than some of your peers might?
Steve Mogford
executiveYeah. Thanks, James, and good morning. I think I’ll take the first couple and leave the question for Phil, since you went back to him directly. I think when it comes to trade-offs on ODIs, we do tend to think about it mainly as an AMP issue. So we’re looking at AMP7 ODI targets and investment in totex to hit AMP7, so that we see a, if you like, this AMP return on a totex that we might spend. I think the point I made to Dominic about AMP8 and beyond is that, clearly, we do have an eye to what upper quartile performance might look like in the sector. And therefore, the potential for further targets or even tougher targets as we go into AMP8, from where we might end AMP8. So improvement in AMP7 will give us a better launch platform is the way we tend to think about it. If you are looking longer term, then we will be looking for a very robust position. But there is -- undoubtedly, there is benefit for a pound of totex, a pound of ODI, it’s worth more in a way that you actually see performance. And of course, it means you’re delivering better service to customers and the environment as a consequence.
Steve Mogford
executiveYeah, so in-period is definitely how we usually think about it. When it comes to ODIs, I'd say it's quite a mixed picture depending on where you look. I mean, some of those ODIs tie to investment we've already made. On leakage, for instance, I've mentioned before everything we're doing there, whether it's technology, docks, satellite, sensors. We'll likely end up with one of the largest networks of sensors and loggers. We're running some pilots in our water network. This year we're actually performing well against our leakage target. And that clearly helps going forward. In other areas, as you can see with internal sewer flooding, that's been a difficult one for us. We actually proposed a 10-year improvement program for what they said to do in 5. So that gets hard as you work through it, which is why we're stepping up funding again in how we manage our sewer network so we can deliver faster performance improvement, because simply spending more on cleaning and responding to flooding won't get us there. So honestly, I'd call it a mixed bag.
Steve Mogford
executiveBut broadly speaking, as you're aware, ODI goals do become more demanding across that period, since you're progressing toward upper quartile status. Would you like to address…
Philip Aspin
executiveYes. Regarding the debt-to-RCV position, James, I'd say the position is — the group's policy is unchanged. That means our position and our target credit ratings — we set our target credit recognition back to the color on that. I think it's probably important to acknowledge that this very much plays a part in financing the performance we're able to deliver and the good market access we have. And I think as we look at this, and we've discussed how we're speeding up totex expenditure to deliver performance. So what you'll see and observe is that ratio rising and then falling toward the back end of the AMP to really effectively. When we look at it — if we're viewing it through the cycle and making sure we're comfortable it sits in a sustainable place.
Operator
operatorThe next person to ask a question is Mark Freshney from Crédit Suisse.
Mark Freshney
analystCould I ask a question about Water Plus? From what I understand, there were 2 issues. The first concerned basic business processes, which required time to refine after the creation. My question is, how are those performing? And second, clearly, there are COVID-19 collection issues. I think you referred to the 17.5% meter readings and voids, et cetera, accounting for the write-down. So I understand that you've written off the equity. Why would you not begin to write off some of the intercompany loans that you've made to that joint venture?
Steve Mogford
executiveRight, I'll take the first part, and Phil will handle the second. On the basic business side — yes, at the start of this year we very clearly began a pretty radical overhaul of Water Plus: how it approached the market, how it assessed returns across different market segments, and how its underlying processes worked. So we've had a program of fundamental improvement running throughout the year — understanding where the business will earn the best return, examining basic processes, examining systems. And I think we're confident now that as we get past COVID, we'll have a business that returns to profitability. So I'd say we're much, much happier with the business — its performance and its potential. Obviously, the issue now is getting ourselves through the COVID period. When we took the provision at the beginning — the additional provision — we could see ourselves being, in our view, adequately provided for bad debt. But I'll let Phil talk you through where we stand on those.
Philip Aspin
executiveAll right, so I suppose I'll start with the COVID-19 aspect as it relates to our business. Mark, you'd have picked up from the full-year position that we obviously wrote down the equity value of the net investment in Water Cost, and we also booked a GBP 5 million expected credit loss charge tied to the loans to Water Cost. So that was reflected in the numbers back in March '20. And that credit charge was predicated on how the business was forecast to perform at that point. Now, 6 months on, the business is actually performing, and it's doing marginally better than those forecasts from that time, which explains why there's no additional impact today when it comes to the expected credit loss. The second half is clearly still going to be challenging. But as Steve said, the processes and the turnaround are beginning to come through, and we'd expect the second half, in effect, to be a consolidation period leading into FY '22, when we would expect the business to return to profitability.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Ajay Patel from Goldman Sachs has our next question.
Ajay Patel
analystThis is really just a simple, granular question more than anything else. I'm just looking at the IRE, and you had a fairly strong set-up in the first half — is there any kind of indication you can give us about how the IRE profile will look across the 5 years? Will it be weighted more toward the front end than perhaps the back end? Or, even looking at this year, would it be fair simply to double the number for the half or for the full year? Or would that be overstating it? I just wondered whether any sort of guidance or direction you could offer would be really helpful.
Steve Mogford
executiveAjay, at a broader level, you're spot on. I think I'd view the profile as pretty much flat across this year, effectively into double for the full-year assessment. I suppose, as we go through the remainder of AMP, the profile will likely continue along much the same guidance. Is that fine?
Ajay Patel
analystSorry, did I hear you right? You're saying it's roughly that same level for the remainder of AMP — is that right?
Steve Mogford
executiveThat's right. That's right. Yes.
Operator
operatorChris Laybutt from Morgan Stanley has a question for us.
Chris Laybutt
executiveI had 2 questions. First, regarding the incremental CapEx projects that you announced today: will the spending you announced that you incur in AMP7 be part of the shadow RCV you report, so that we can keep track of it? And second, on governance: you pointed out your pension risk issues back in 2010. I'm just wondering whether you might be able to comment on where you see the biggest risk today from a governance standpoint, and any commentary you might have on that theme would be very helpful?
Steve Mogford
executiveRight, yes — incremental CapEx and shadow RCV. Phil, is that shadow RCV?
Philip Aspin
executiveYeah, I think that's likely the case. One thing to keep very much in mind is that the shadow RCV doesn't fully reflect what the actual worth of that will be in the next AMP, because in effect a portion of that value simply returns through revenue compensation in the following AMP too. So we'll probably aim to give more detail on that going forward, really.
Steve Mogford
executiveYeah. I think regarding—interesting question, Chris, regarding risk and what we consider sort of the key governance risk. I mean, clearly, we've got nothing of scale on pensions in the organization in terms of the things we do. I think what you probably find—and obviously, prior to the election, we were also talking about the potential for renationalization. And I think, again, that is largely, I think, gone certainly for this period. And it appears, even with the current labor policy, unlikely to come back in the same guys. So I think in that sense, as far as a principal governance risk. In most of the issues that we talk about around the Board now from a risk perspective, are all around ability to meet your statutory obligations. So if you think about it up fundamentally, our obligation is to provide water 24/7, 365 days and take away into wastewater. So it's largely around that capacity. And I think, as I mentioned before, that whole challenge of resilience to climate change and population growth. So if you look at us, for example, a lot of activity associated with having sufficient raw water available to us, I mean because we are an organization that relies heavily on surface water supplies, there's very little ground water because of the geology of our area.
Steve Mogford
executiveSo with sufficiency in those areas, plus how our treatment performs, I brought up Haweswater Aqueduct as something that needs replacing. From a governance standpoint, what you usually see is very little at the scale of pensions in that sense — it's much more about individual, more granular risk tied to our operations and the key assets and capabilities we rely on. So that's the — that tends to be the case. And you'll see it. If you go to the RNS and look at the back section, and begin going through the risk section, you'll find those sorts of things showing up, rather than any bigger macro issue. And I think with COVID, obviously — I mean, COVID has been a huge issue for all of us, if you like. But because of key worker status and the nature of the service we provide, actually, I think we've risen to that challenge in a way that makes me hugely proud of the organization and what people have done. So I think, yes, when you go through our risk reports now, you'll see it's largely operational stuff that we tend to worry about.
Steve Mogford
executiveAll right. Adam, does anyone else have something?
Operator
operatorWe've got time for one more question from the audio line, and that comes from Ahmed Farman at Jefferies.
Ahmed Farman
analystI have just a quick question from my side. On Slide 21, I believe, when you discuss the dividend and your inflation forecast — that you're more comfortable with it — I wanted to see whether you could elaborate: when you last gave an update, which inflation scenarios were you considering? And what are you seeing now that has added visibility and helped you reaffirm the AMP7 dividend policy?
Steve Mogford
executiveYes. Ahmed, I’ll ask Phil to address that one specifically, but speaking as a Board back in May, I think at the point when we were debating this matter, we were right in the thick of it, so to speak, with COVID during the first lockdown, working out what it meant for the business and for our customers more broadly across the region. So there are, I think, several considerations: what effect would COVID have on operations? What cost would be involved? What would it mean from the customer standpoint? Certainly, when you observe how not only we but the sector and utilities — service providers more widely across the country — have responded, I’d say utilities have done a superb job in keeping service going right through this period. And then you look at what has been achieved in the health service, et cetera. So I think the fact that we now live with COVID daily yet keep operating gives the Board far greater confidence in our capacity to handle the pandemic going forward. Of course, we’ve had the vaccine news, which is fantastic in the sense that there now seems to be a light at the end of the tunnel on that front.
Steve Mogford
executiveOf course, the other element — and this is likely the largest economic effect on us — was inflation. And back then, we were running quite a few scenarios, which were actually being handled at a sector level through some work we had underway, and those gave an extremely wide range of possible outcomes. And Phil, would you like to explain how that has developed?
Philip Aspin
executiveSure, Steve. I’ll come back to that shortly. I think it probably makes sense to also point to Slide 48, where the path included the HMT survey and the inflation forecast that we publish each quarter to obtain the most recent economic guidance from analysts and others. As Steve mentioned, back in May the Board was right to <<inaudible>> address the difficulties that sustainable inflation creates for the business model, along with the more evident and immediate operational difficulties. And in May, as the chart shows, inflation risk was heavily skewed to the downside. Our forecast had medium-term rates moving lower. And really, there was no clarity about what would happen next or where all of this would ultimately lead. By contrast, I think today the world looks very different. Operationally, we are doing well. But from the perspective of the U.K. authorities, I suppose, they responded with sustained and persistent support through monetary and fiscal policy. And it is interesting that at the end of October the IMF issued its annual surveillance decision and praised the U.K. for its massive approach, acknowledging that the policy interventions were probably among the best anywhere in the world.
Philip Aspin
executiveAnd the U.K. authorities are still committed to taking whatever steps are needed to back the economy and jobs. And third, they have the policy response to do that. So I suppose all of that ties into what the Bank of England is doing and the chance of activity in terms of supporting the economy. And I think, today, you look at the HMT surveys, November, and you can see the sort of bounce back, we're looking at medium-term inflation book prepandemic levels, and I would probably characterize the risk very much to the upside today.
Operator
operatorMark Freshney from Crédit Suisse has a follow-up question for us.
Mark Freshney
analystRegarding that GBP 150 million that you expect to enter the asset base because it qualifies as a green scheme, roughly how much will be spent between this AMP and the following AMP? And, further to that, I assume there will be a true-up on an NPV-neutral basis, reflecting the fact that you are carrying it within this price control while not receiving a cash return on it. Is that a fair assumption?
Steve Mogford
executiveI'm not really certain, to be honest. I think we'll need to take that away and check whether we get a full true-up, which is often how it works. But I'll have Rob follow up on that point, Mark, and get back to you. As for the GBP 150 million, the thing is I can't give you that figure entirely off the top of my head. My rough guess would be that around 75% of it is this AMP's expenditure, because part of the project does in fact run into AMP8. If you look at the Vyrnwy program, that one does run over into AMP8. But I'll have Rob verify the exact numbers — though 75%, 80% is my guess, just from knowing the program durations, as to what that spend will be. Rob will come back with the detail, Mark.
Operator
operatorAnd we have another question, this time from Dominic Nash at Barclays.
Dominic Nash
analystThis one should be pretty fast. I believe the totex involved in this review came to roughly GBP 6 billion. During the presentation, you mentioned that in this review you'd be exploring things like increasing spending and generating jobs in the Northwest, and so on and so forth. Have you already kind of figured out the sort of scale you might be able to carry over into AMP7 from AMP8 projects? I mean, could we see an additional GBP 1 billion, for instance? Or is that…
Steve Mogford
executiveYes. We’ll — yes, and we’re going to turn to you for the depth on that, <<inaudible>>. No, I think — I mean, it’s a genuinely interesting market. There’s a great deal we can do when it comes to bringing stuff forward. So we’ve — one of the things we’re examining is areas such as our meter reading strategy, where we can see clear benefit on consumption — on helping manage consumption demand, helping customers manage bills by moving into a metering strategy, which effectively is not compulsory metering, but essentially, it says there is a meter if customers want to use it because we’ve been moving — we’ve been trialing what essentially is the lowest bill guarantee. So if you’re a big family, you can go on a fixed charge. If you’re a small family, a couple or an individual living in a property, you might want to go on a meter charge. So that’s an area we’ve been looking at. A topical issue at the moment is combined sewer outfall. So this is where your sewer system is effectively inundated largely for us with surface water, all the rainfall that we now get through climate change. There’s a drive by government to try and reduce the number of spills into the environment in those circumstances.
Steve Mogford
executiveThat's a space where a significant amount of opportunity exists for us to do work. We're engaged in some genuinely innovative efforts around catchment management. There's an entire spectrum of possibilities, and it could range from tens to literally hundreds of millions in opportunity, which is precisely why we're in discussions with government about it and attempting to grasp how it operates. So first of all, if you perform the work, will you be remunerated? Will remuneration come this time or will it come next time? If payment doesn't arrive this time, will you receive essentially a full correction for value for the work if it's funded in AMP8, for example. I think the other issue essentially is what impact does it have on customer bills? I mean if it's a capital expenditure, then it will tend to have a relatively small impact on customer bills. But is this going to be a bad way to going into AMP8, how are we going to deal with it? I think the other aspect is, what does it do from a shareholder perspective as well in the sense of, if you're doing this work and not getting reimbursed in AMP8, then essentially what you're doing is -- it's reducing, it's diluting the return that shareholders are getting during AMP7.
Steve Mogford
executiveSo then ultimately, you have to ask yourself: if you aren't getting paid, where does the cash come from in AMP7? And what does that mean for debt to RCV? What does it mean for your credit metrics? And what effect does that have? If we were downgraded 1 notch, what would that cost us in terms of debt going forward? And how does that tie back to customer bills? So there's an enormous amount of conversation happening right now. But the reality is that if all of those issues can be resolved through the discussions we're having, then there's a great deal we can do that could ultimately add up to the hundreds of millions. And as I said, all of the things that we're doing. We're on track with AMP7. So as a company, we qualify. We've already brought forward GBP 500 million of our AMP7 investment. We have roughly GBP 1 billion of environmental programs underway in AMP7, which we're speeding up. So we're already playing a major role in green recovery. Yes, we'd like to bring things forward, but we want to be in a position to answer all of those questions.
Steve Mogford
executiveAnd I'd say every one of those options is on the table right now. So the list of potential schemes is extremely long. And honestly, Dominic, you could pick any cutoff point you like, depending on how you interpret what each one might imply. But as you're aware, we protect our credit metrics fiercely. And we're equally unambiguous that we want to make sure shareholders receive value. We've put in long, hard work to reach the position we're in today, and at this point we're confident that we can deliver that value. What we genuinely don't want to do is water things down for shareholders before we know what the upside will be. Are there any further questions?
Operator
operatorYes, we do. And now we'll take the following question from Fraser McLaren at Bank of America.
Fraser McLaren
analystI hope everyone's doing well. I've just got a couple of questions, if I may. First, could I ask about whether you could create value by bringing your systems and your thinking to other businesses that aren't performing as strongly? So do you believe that kind of merger is bound to work, and in what situations would it appeal to you? And second, may I also ask how strategically important the stake in Tallinn is, please?
Steve Mogford
executiveYes, Fraser. Thank you. We're doing well, and I trust you and your family are too. Yes, if you think about systems thinking — those of us who began with it, when I first came into the sector and was observing how it functioned, we had experience from other industries, from the use of technology and how it delivered management information. It's been a major enabler for us, and one that keeps accelerating. We'll share a great deal more at the Capital Markets Day, but robotics and machine intelligence — I mean, the team has devised a clever little trick, for instance. And if you recall, some time back, we'd find individuals roaming our field searching for a Pokémon that was apparently standing right in the middle of it, and they had to capture it. What we've done is take that kind of gaming technology, and we now have the team, the lads, using it out in the field, which basically means it matches your GPS location against our database to determine whether there's a void property at that spot.
Steve Mogford
executiveSo basically, through your handheld device, on this app, you can see what we call a void property. And you can ask: does it appear occupied? Is there a business there that seems to be operating? That helps us spot and capture properties that aren't truly vacant. So it's a bit like a game concept. You can picture how thrilled we all are to spend a weekend driving around with this app hunting for void properties while we're out shopping or visiting mom or whatever else. There are all kinds of opportunities. For me, that's a somewhat amusing example of the sorts of things we're doing, but it represents a massive use of technology and machine intelligence to give us a better understanding of what we're doing. We've always approached it on the basis that we know it scales. So you could apply this to anyone's business, and there would be some investment in sensing. In other areas, though, not. You could still apply it. So yes, we do believe it's applicable. What we've actually found is that a number of companies have approached us asking, what are you doing?
Steve Mogford
executiveAnd could you talk about that? It's a strong sector where we do share, yet we're also competing. So to some degree there's an intellectual property element and a competitive element to systems thinking that we protect generously. But those companies are really struggling, and you know who they are within the sector—we actively share with them to try to lift them up. And actually, some of the folks who have helped us are now helping them. There's a question that came in from Verity about M&A, regarding where we see the potential for M&A. And we definitely believe that bringing systems thinking to another company will produce a very significant improvement in performance and in the cost of delivering that performance. So yes, we do think that would help with synergy benefit beyond the more obvious ones of 2 headquarters to customer teams, et cetera, et cetera. More broadly, just addressing Verity's question on M&A—we constantly keep it in mind. I think we've always felt you'd look at the scenario post the CMA. Some of the prices paid for businesses have been very racy more recently.
Steve Mogford
executiveWe could, however, end up seeing quite a few owners in distress. Some were already looking to exit the sector before PR19, and given how PR19 turned out, I'm sure those owners are still looking to leave — and there could be additional ones. So we'll bear that in mind. That said, yes, systems thinking definitely has wider applicability. Oh, right — Tallinn. Sorry, Phil just reminded me that I was <<inaudible>>. I got so carried away with systems thinking that I forgot. Tallinn — strategic? No. Clearly, as an investment it has performed well over the years, despite some of the difficulties we've encountered with Tallinn and with Estonia. It's been a solid investment with a good return. For us, I think it falls into the category of things where you view reserve as a value opportunity. Should the right deal come along, we might have an interest. But in effect, it's — certainly, no, it isn't strategic, and we have no other forays into overseas plans at this point in time. Okay, Fraser?
Fraser McLaren
analystThat’s great. Many thanks.
Steve Mogford
executiveOkay. Anyone else, Adam? If not, we’ll move on to the webcast.
Operator
operatorThere aren't any further audio questions, so I'll let you go ahead.
Steve Mogford
executiveOkay, thank you very much, Adam, and thanks to all of you. Just a quick note on the webcast. Mark Freshney raised the question of savings or ODI benefits that could show up later in the price control as a result of accelerating totex. I believe I've already addressed a few of those points. But to give somewhat more concrete examples, one of the things we're doing by accelerating is installing a full network of sensors across our water network. If you look at the areas where we see ODI penalties and where we're trying to mitigate them, that includes things such as supply interruptions and, clearly, leakage. So that's an area where, by speeding up investment, we can see it will lift our performance on that — on a number of the ODIs tied to it. On wastewater and sewers? Basically, the way the sector frequently runs, it's largely blind to what's going on in its wastewater network. So one of the things we're examining right now as a means of reducing penalties and reaching upper quartile more quickly is how we can be more proactive in how we manage it, which entirely flips how we manage on its head. That's an area where, once again, we'll — we are accelerating investment in our wastewater area.
Steve Mogford
executiveThere's also a further advantage to speeding up CapEx — it ties into our capital program and lets us de-risk quite a few of our capital schemes, and if we failed to deliver those on schedule, we'd again incur penalties. So there's a broad set of benefits we gain from that acceleration. Mark had another question. Given that lots of businesses will be pushing back CapEx — local authorities, big infrastructure projects that got delayed because of COVID — are we noticing any softening in supply chain pricing? Clearly, we aren't running into resource constraints as a result of that. And through the tendering we're carrying out, we're hitting our target efficiencies on the capital program. We generally don't operate through alliancing. We do have a number of capital partners, but in how we run things we lean toward more competitive tendering rather than partnering, and definitely not alliancing, which in my view can be rather inefficient. So we're beginning to see some benefit emerge through pricing there, which is enabling certain targets. One thing we're picking up on in a couple of areas is overhead growth, as we observe businesses grappling with lower volumes, though it isn't significant relative to the programs we're driving.
Steve Mogford
executiveMark also asked over the phone for a comment on how the underlying business is performing within Water Plus. That one's been handled. Could we walk through AMP8 acceleration? Where do we stand, and which is Verity? I believe Dominic covered that during the call. To give you some background on this whole green recovery matter: a couple of months ago now, the combined Defra family of regulators, along with Defra themselves, made a point of inviting companies to say how they might contribute to the government's green recovery. Proposals need to be submitted. A number of discussions — I mean, a number of discussions — have taken place and will take place with government on this, covering its size and shape, to understand how it would operate. Our understanding is that companies must have their proposals in by the end of January. So what we'd expect is that by the end of January, this may at least firm up where scope is concerned. Whether further discussion on terms follows after that, we're not certain. Systems thinking? I think I've mentioned that one.
Steve Mogford
executiveAnd could you elaborate a bit more on that GBP 150 million expansion of scope? What portion will be carried by shareholders as opposed to customers? Basically, what we’re looking at is full recovery. So our expectation is that this gets fully recovered through customer bills. It doesn’t run through the totex sharing mechanism — that menu arrangement that’s roughly 50-50 for us. This one will be recovered in full via bills, and we’ll see that during AMP8. Okay. I believe that covers every question. May I just wrap up by thanking all of you for taking the time to listen to the presentation and for all the questions we received? I look forward to seeing everyone at the full year, where it’s very much my hope that we can report continued good progress on AMP7. And let’s hope that by then, 1 or 2 of us will have had a vaccine as well. So thank you very much, everyone, and goodbye.
Philip Aspin
executiveAppreciate it, everybody. Take care.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, that brings us to the end of today's call. Thank you so much for being with us. You can go ahead and disconnect your lines now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete United Utilities Group PLC transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to United Utilities Group PLC earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in United Utilities Group PLC or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.