United Utilities Group PLC (UU) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 26, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David Higgins
executiveGood morning, everyone, and welcome to United Utilities' presentation of our full year results. Since I joined the company, I've appreciated the chance to talk with many of you, and I'm looking forward to carrying on those conversations, ideally face to face at some point this year. Board succession is one of the subjects investors have raised with me, and I'm glad to report that we've carried out an orderly process, just as you would expect from us. On the non-executive director side, in July this year, you'll note that Mark Clare, our SID, along with Stephen Carter, who chairs our corporate responsibility committee, will both step down from the board. Each of them made an enormous contribution to the company's success over the years, and I want to express my thanks for their support. Their succession is covered by a clear plan: we brought Liam Butterworth onto the board in January, and one more non-exec appointment is planned for this year. Turning to our executive directors, Phil Aspin took over as CFO almost two years ago, and the board is very pleased with what Phil keeps delivering. You will undoubtedly have seen that Steve intends to retire early next year, and that Louise Beardmore has been named as his successor. Louise has spent more than 25 years with United Utilities, and she brings extensive utility experience.
David Higgins
executiveShe has been central to the company's shift toward becoming a top performer in customer service, operational delivery, and employee engagement, and she stood out as the exceptional candidate in a rigorous selection process that included both internal and external applicants. The board is pleased to make this appointment, and it once more shows the strong management team that Steve has built. During his 11 years with United Utilities, Steve has driven the business's transformation into one of the U.K.'s best-performing water and wastewater companies. As this morning's presentation will show you, performance across this last year has kept improving under the leadership of Steve and his management team. In recognition of this, the board proposes a 0.6% increase in the final dividend, which is consistent with our policy. That brings the total dividend for the year to GBP 0.435 per share. Thank you, and I'll now pass things over to Steve.
Steve Mogford
executiveThanks, David. Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the United Utilities full year results presentation for 2021/2022. Once again we built on strong foundations this year, delivering value through high levels of customer satisfaction and operational performance that improved further. Inflation and the cost of living are significant issues right now, and via our extensive affordability support schemes, we have kept playing our part in helping those struggling most. Keeping control of our cost base in this environment has been a key focus area for us, as has responsibly using outperformance. Our anticipated AMP7 outperformance is expected to be significantly higher than previously predicted, and we believe a responsible approach is to share our success for the benefit of all of our stakeholders. We will therefore be investing an additional GBP 400 million to deliver even greater improvements in services for customers and the environment, bringing the total investment beyond the scope of our final determination to GBP 765 million. Systems thinking is embedded across the business, supporting our transformation to a digital utility, and we are seeing the benefit of accelerated investment on performance, both in this regulatory period and in expectations for future periods. Recent developments in environmental legislation are very substantial, and the government targets currently subject to consultation could represent significant growth in the investment contained within our business plans for PR24 and beyond.
Steve Mogford
executiveNow, the year's highlights. Our industry-leading support package — valued at roughly GBP 280 million across AMP7 — delivers vital financial help to households in the North West that are struggling. We've maintained strong operational performance, and that, combined with elevated inflation, helped produce a return on regulated equity of 7.9% along with an annual net ODI reward of GBP 25 million. Underlying operational performance, strengthened by targeted incremental investment, gives us confidence to raise our total AMP7 ODI target to GBP 200 million — a third more than prior guidance. Since our AMP7 outperformance is now anticipated to come in significantly above earlier forecasts, we're sharing that success responsibly by investing an additional GBP 400 million. Together with investment already announced, this pushes our total AMP7 investment outside the FD scope to GBP 765 million, supporting sustainable performance and adding to nominal RCV growth of 21% over the AMP. At the heart of this sits investment in our Better Rivers plan, which will get us started early on provisions tied to the Environment Act and help cut recorded spills by at least a third. Altogether, we've set out four pledges to deliver across the coming three years, and through them we'll set a river revival in motion ahead of AMP8.
Steve Mogford
executiveWe play a key part in helping customers who find it hard to pay their bills. If you look at bill rises throughout the sector for FY23, we're among the minority of companies expecting no increase in the average household bill in our region. We've pledged a substantial support package for households in difficulty, valued at roughly GBP 280 million across this AMP. Via our broad selection of affordability schemes, we're right now assisting more than 200,000 households, and we're setting the pace in the utility sector on open banking, which has allowed us to provide even better customer service. It shrinks a process that once might have stretched over weeks down to only a few minutes, so we can quickly identify the most suitable support scheme for customers. In 2019, we collaborated with the advice sector to create the North West Hardship Hub, a central repository giving access to every one of the very latest affordability schemes on offer. It has shown itself to be an invaluable resource, especially through the pandemic, and it will keep being so as households feel the effects of today's challenging environment. There is always more we would like to do, and we're leading. We're a leading backer of the Consumer Council for Water's push to bring in a national social tariff.
Steve Mogford
executiveThat would support a fairer distribution of support nationwide, ensuring help reaches those in need no matter their location. Moving now to how we've been operating. As I've mentioned before, we concentrate on putting money into operational performance that can be sustained, and that is exactly what we're delivering. Customers are getting better service, and we've once again done well on Ofwat's C-MEX measure, securing a reward for the year. In wastewater, we remain at the sector frontier, with low pollution levels, having cut overall pollution by a third since the AMP began. Compliance at our treatment works stays strong, and we anticipate remaining green on that measure in the Environment Agency's annual performance assessment for 2021. In water, we keep enhancing both quality and resilience of supply. Ofwat's latest service delivery report bears this out — see the chart at the bottom of the slide — where we're flagged as an industry top performer for cutting water supply interruptions and for reducing pollution incidents. In both areas, the benefits of targeted investment from AMP6 are now coming through. Ofwat's assessment places us at or above target on most measures, though three specific areas came in below target.
Steve Mogford
executiveHousehold water use is one of those areas, and the industry targets established at PR19 have been heavily affected by the shift to working from home throughout the COVID pandemic. Targeted investment is concentrated on the remaining two areas, and I'll now explain what we're doing in each of them. Internal sewer flooding and water quality — chiefly appearance — are the 2 measures where we missed our target for the year. Both are areas of focus and incremental investment. I've talked before about our Dynamic Network Management program. It's our pioneering GBP 100 million systems thinking network, the first of its kind anywhere in the world. Over 10,000 sensors were fitted across our sewer network and connected to an innovative artificial intelligence platform. Thanks to the data this system generates, we're identifying and resolving problems in the sewer network before an incident occurs. As a result, over the last year customers have experienced a reduction in internal flooding of a third year on year, and our performance is well ahead of the original target we set ourselves. We're also putting GBP 100 million into our water networks to cut down on incidents of discoloration that customers experience. Progress so far has again been good: in the first four months of this year, customer reports of taste, smell, and appearance issues fell by more than 26% compared with last year.
Steve Mogford
executiveBuilding on the wider evaluation of drinking water quality, in the prior year we achieved a 44% gain on the measure capturing the effect of water quality incidents across that period. Investment across both of these areas is helping drive better ODI guidance for AMP7 and will strengthen our overall AMP8 outlook. I'd like to explain how strong execution combined with capital outlay converts into ODIs. During AMP7 our approach has centered on putting operating performance first and securing ODI rewards via efficient TotEx spending. In the year just reported, on 80% of our ODIs we hit or surpassed the goals we set. We expect ODI targets to become more demanding once more in AMP8, so extracting maximum performance in this AMP gives us the best possible launch point for the next one. We project our net ODI reward for the year at roughly GBP 25 million — our biggest reward in any single year — and above the target we set at the outset. Results so far, together with focused spending on areas needing improvement, give us confidence to raise our total AMP7 ODI guidance by a third, to GBP 200 million. I'd like to examine in more detail how we are fairly distributing to every one of our stakeholders the gains from our steadily rising operational performance and from higher inflation.
Steve Mogford
executiveWith inflation running high right now, the broad affordability help we offer matters a great deal, and many customers who are feeling heavy inflationary pressure on their other household bills will welcome the news that the average bill in our region will not rise for 2022 to 2023. Better operational performance on our side, combined with elevated inflation, is lifting our expectations for outperformance in AMP7, so we are responsibly passing those benefits on through GBP 400 million of extra investment in two particular areas that would otherwise sit inside our AMP8 business plan. To start, GBP 250 million will support stronger environmental outcomes by letting us begin implementing the government's new Environment Act ahead of schedule, which includes delivering the commitments laid out in our Better Rivers plan. Next, GBP 150 million is going into additional base and business case-driven projects. That spending will speed up service improvements for customers, boost ODI performance, and takes in roughly GBP 100 million aimed at better drinking water quality, which I mentioned earlier. What we invest today will not just lift service and ODI performance during this AMP — it will also build a foundation for markedly stronger ODI performance in AMP8 and beyond, which means added benefit that the company keeps.
Steve Mogford
executiveI want to use this moment to put that GBP 400 million of fresh investment into perspective against the broader investment we're undertaking outside our final determination. That figure now totals GBP 765 million. On this slide, you can see the GBP 765 million of total incremental investment split into three main groups. The first group is GBP 265 million of approved incremental base investment, which is permitted under the regulatory mechanisms set at PR19, along with our Green Recovery investment. The second group is GBP 250 million tied to business case-supported investment, which delivers better customer performance and ODIs. That supports our raised ODI guidance for AMP7 and substantially strengthens our ODI outlook in future AMPs. The remaining GBP 250 million concerns investment aimed at speeding up environmental improvements, which I mentioned on the prior slide. Our expected outperformance, combined with our financial strength and balance sheet headroom, lets us fund this investment while staying within our target capital structure and AMP7 dividend policy. By doing so, we are responsibly accelerating environmental improvements and enhancing customer service, while also creating shareholder value, with the entire GBP 765 million subject to the regulatory mechanisms currently in place.
Steve Mogford
executiveAs a sector leader when it comes to environmental performance, we are deeply concerned about how we affect the environment. We are always trying to lift our standards of performance, and we remain actively involved with EA and Ofwat in the joint investigation they are running into how the sector complies with wastewater discharge permits. We are set on keeping our sector-leading position on environmental performance, building on the legacy we have by tackling elements of new and emerging environmental requirements early in AMP7. To show our continued commitment to protecting and enhancing the environment, we have launched our Better Rivers: Better North West program, aimed at kickstarting a river revival across our region over the next three years. It is a four-point plan, with the high-level aim shown on the left-hand side of the slide and some of the detailed targets on the right-hand side. Our AMP7 final determination included GBP 230 million of investment in environmental improvement, and as I said earlier, we are putting in an additional GBP 250 million to get an early start on what the Environment Act requires. We have got off to a great start against our targets, achieving a 28% reduction in spills between 2020 and 2021. I will now pass you to Phil, who will take you through the numbers.
Phil Aspin
executiveThanks, Steve, and good morning, everyone. In today's presentation, I'll walk you through our strong financial performance. First, I'll summarize where we stand on RoRE, before turning to how we're weathering the current inflationary environment and giving you more detail on how we approach power hedging. After that, I'll look at how our additional investment, alongside higher inflation, is set to deliver higher RCV growth. To wrap up, I'll offer some high-level guidance for the full year to March 2023. These are the key financial highlights for the year. Our performance, together with higher inflation, has helped to deliver a reported RoRE of 7.9%, double our base return. Revenue of GBP 1.86 billion is up 3.1%, largely reflecting higher consumption from businesses as activity has returned to pre-pandemic levels. Household bad debt has returned to 1.8% of regulated revenue, consistent with the rate we were achieving pre-COVID. An underlying operating profit of GBP 610 million reflects the increase in revenue, partly offset by inflationary increases in our core costs, including increased power costs. Like many companies, we've experienced inflationary cost pressures on a range of input costs, and as power is a significant cost for our business, we have a progressive policy of hedging to minimize short-term volatility.
Phil Aspin
executiveThat’s helped soften part of the inflation hit and leaves us in a comparatively solid spot for next year, since we’ve hedged more than 90% of the commodity price risk. Underlying EPS comes to 53.8 pence per share, and the total dividend per share is 43.5 pence, consistent with our policy. Lastly, our balance sheet is still among the strongest in the sector, with low customer debtor risk, RCV gearing of 61%, and a pension scheme that is not only fully funded on a low dependency basis but also fully hedged for inflation — an important feature in today’s environment. All of that underpins a stable A3 credit rating from Moody’s. I’ll now go through these points in more detail. First, let’s turn to RORI, with the chart here showing our reported RORI for the year of 7.9% on a real basis. That reflects strong performance on tax, where we’ve optimized government tax incentives, and on financing, where we benefit from the higher inflation and rates that we’ve locked in on our debt portfolio. Our ODI performance reflects the GBP 25 million net reward for the year, and TotEx performance is a consequence of the investment we are making beyond the scope of the FD, primarily on dynamic network management.
Phil Aspin
executiveLater on, the gains from better ODIs stemming from this investment come through into RORI. The underlying RORI is 7.7%, adjusted for how we assess the tax impact, though it will be subject to the tax sharing mechanism. Customers will keep the benefit from capital allowance super-deductions on the FD CapEx profile, as well as green recovery spend. In contrast, shareholders will keep the benefit of company decisions to speed up capital investment, together with investment beyond the FD scope. Underlying operating profit came in at GBP 610 million, an increase of GBP 8 million, mainly reflecting a GBP 55 million rise in revenue that was largely offset by inflationary increases in our core costs. Revenue is GBP 55 million above last year, chiefly reflecting higher non-household revenue, since business activity has been stronger than expected during the year. That was partly offset by a decline in household revenue, in line with expectations, as fewer people work from home. In the prior year, GBP 8 million of additional one-off costs were incurred in adapting our operations, which allowed us to operate through the pandemic. As we keep pushing for better outcomes for customers and the environment, we have taken on an additional GBP 17 million of costs, aimed at improving performance against specific customer ODIs, such as the spend associated with Dynamic Network Management.
Phil Aspin
executiveAs with numerous other businesses, we have felt the impact of inflation on costs for inputs including electricity, chemicals, contracted services, and staffing, which has produced a rise of GBP 33 million in core costs. Additionally, a recent decision by the IFRS interpretations committee concerning configuration costs tied to software as a service means that GBP 6 million of costs in the current year are now classified as operating costs, whereas in the past these would have been recorded as additions to fixed assets. Steve has already described the substantial support we give to customers facing an affordability difficulty. I'll now explain how we handle cash collection from households across the wider customer base, along with our bad debt results. More than 80% of our customers are on direct debit or alternative payment arrangements — one of the highest shares among our peers. That provides a solid foundation for our collection efforts and delivers a high degree of certainty across a significant portion of our revenue. When customers are able to pay yet decide not to, we apply a thorough, data-driven collections strategy that lets us pursue payment accurately, efficiently, and promptly. We employ several methods, among them prompting late payers via email or text message, drawing on multiple credit reference agencies to build a financial footprint, and in the end, using credit reporting — something only a small handful of water and sewage companies do.
Phil Aspin
executiveWhen it comes to collections, our top method keeps getting outside validation — we recently picked up five external credit awards, judged against peers in credit, banking, and utility companies. The way we innovate with data and technology helps direct financial assistance toward the people who need it the most, and together with progress in open banking, it keeps being seen as best in class. Last, as I said before, you need to view the bad debt charge alongside the risk that sits on the balance sheet. A year ago, I pointed to how strong our customer debtor position is — among the best managed in the industry — and thanks to our sturdy collections approach, balance sheet risk is still low today, with just GBP 4 million of our net household debtors aged over one year old. That is a very strong place to be, given the pressures customers are under in a highly challenging setting of rising inflation. All of this underpins our lowest household bad debt level, at 1.8% of regulated revenue. Now let's turn to how inflation affects our business. Under the regulatory model, inflation comes through indexation of the TotEx allowance and the RCV, and for every 1% rise in inflation across the AMP, our TotEx allowance goes up by around GBP 150 million and our RCV by around GBP 600 million.
Phil Aspin
executiveLet's begin by examining where we stand on TotEx and what we're doing to handle inflation's effects. Regarding OpEx, we've finalized our pay agreement for FY 2023, which is roughly consistent with inflation as of last November. For FY 2023, more than 90% of our power is hedged, and I'll go into that in greater detail in a moment. Chemicals make up a fairly small share of our cost base, but in FY 2023 we could see those costs climb substantially beyond CPIH, driven by pressure from elevated energy costs and the disruption stemming from the war in Ukraine. Turning to the capital program, more than 90% of the AMP7 base program is already contracted under target price arrangements. That gives us stronger certainty of supply in a heated construction market and makes sure both sides have an incentive to keep cost pressures in check. In summary, we keep actively managing how inflation affects our cost base, with indexation of our TotEx allowance offering additional mitigation. Now let's turn to our capital structure and interest costs. Debt accounts for around 60% of the RCV, with the other 40% made up of equity. As you're aware, our hedging policy aims for 50% of our debt to be inflation-linked, which means 30% of the RCV is hedged against inflation, while equity gains from inflation exposure on the 70% of the RCV made up of equity and nominal debt.
Phil Aspin
executiveSo because of that, equity is leveraged 1.75x to inflation. Consequently, inflation matches the indexation charge index on our inflation-linked debt, along with the inflation return on 30% of the RCV — even though that inflation return on the RCV doesn't show up in the P&L. Hedging is a long-term policy for us, and it has served the company well, delivering a significant share of the financing outperformance we've achieved in the past. It remains a core pillar of AMP7 outperformance and gives greater certainty in a world that's uncertain. Let's now examine power more closely. This chart displays our present estimate of power consumption across the AMP, breaking out the share of total consumption that carries a fixed price versus the portion we still need to buy. Thanks to our progressive hedging policy, we had locked in the cost for most of our FY 2022 consumption ahead of the recent price rises, securing an average rate of GBP 65 per MWh across the year. That compares favorably with the current market rate of GBP 238 per MWh for FY 2023, and it has been fundamental in letting us minimize the impact on our cost base. Our hedging policy underpins this position through the remaining years of the AMP.
Phil Aspin
executiveLooking ahead to FY 2023, we anticipate total consumption will stay pretty much flat compared with the prior year, at roughly 800 GWh. Thanks to self-generation and how we apply our hedging policy, we still have about 8% — or just under 70 GWh — of our expected consumption left to purchase, which means we have certainty on pricing for more than 90% of what we expect to consume in FY 2023. That leaves us in a strong position, with the vast majority of our FY 2023 consumption locked in at a rate that is a quarter of the current market price. So we anticipate power costs rising only slightly year-on-year. We do still have a proportion of our energy consumption across the remainder of the AMP exposed to today's unprecedented volatility in energy prices, but because our hedging policy is progressive, we're in a strong position, with two-thirds locked in at prices that compare favorably to current market rates. Turning now to the other lines on the income statement. Our underlying net finance expense is GBP 306 million, made up of GBP 118 million of cash interest, with a balance largely reflecting indexation. The 173 million increase in the overall expense versus last year largely reflects the significantly higher inflation applied to the non-cash indexation of our index-linked debt.
Phil Aspin
executiveAfter making the most of the research and development tax allowances available for innovation in capital investment across every open prior-year tax position, and also applying the capital allowance super-deduction in the current tax year, we end up with an underlying tax credit of GBP 65 million for the year. That figure leaves out all deferred tax effects, among them a one-off deferred tax charge of GBP 403 million tied to the rise in the headline corporation tax rate to 25% starting April 2023. Taken together, all of this gives us an underlying profit after tax of GBP 367 million, along with an underlying EPS of GBP 0.538 per share. Turning now to look in more detail at financing performance. Across AMP7, we have roughly GBP 2.7 billion of financing to raise, and of that amount we have already raised GBP 1.4 billion, seizing attractive rates and pushing our liquidity position out to February 2025. Our effective interest rate for the year is 5.1% nominal. The chart on the right-hand side sets out our average locked-in rates across the AMP7 period against Ofwat's allowance for embedded debt. As you can see, our rates compare favorably and help to show the degree of financing outperformance we expect to deliver this AMP.
Phil Aspin
executiveLet me step back and take a wider view of shareholder value, with particular attention on the value we are generating at present, which will only show up in RCV and revenues during AMP8. Because of how we performed relative to our AMP7 final determination, along with the GBP 765 million of extra TotEx investment that Steve mentioned previously, we anticipate an RCV uplift and roughly GBP 750 million of additional revenues in AMP8. This slide lays out the breakdown of the biggest components tied to that additional TotEx — both the investment that is subject to customer sharing and the fully recoverable investment that falls under existing regulatory mechanisms set at PR19 and Green Recovery. Our target for net customer ODI rewards in AMP7 is approximately GBP 200 million, and we expect about GBP 125 million of those rewards to be earned in the final two years of this AMP and carried forward into the next AMP. On top of that, there is a blind year adjustment reflecting the true-up of the PR19 final determination position for performance in the last year of AMP6. Finally, there are numerous other adjustments, such as a tax true-up resulting from changes in tax rates. Altogether, these amount to roughly GBP 50 million of net adjustment into AMP8.
Phil Aspin
executiveThe GBP 750 million of value that we expect to carry forward in total is going to boost our AMP8 RCV and help support AMP8 revenues. Now I'd like to focus specifically on how our additional investment and the higher inflation environment affect the profile of our AMP7 RCV. As you can see from the chart, on a nominal basis, our final determination, shown by the green line, sets an expected RCV growth over the period of 5.8%. The blue line takes the FD RCV profile and adds in the GBP 750 million carry forward value that I just discussed. Lastly, the black line shows RCV growth of 21.4% and includes this carry forward value plus the latest consensus view of inflation. So we now expect RCV growth 15% higher than was expected at the beginning of the AMP. This slide bridges the net debt position from March 2021-March 2022. Net debt of GBP 7.6 billion has risen GBP 264 million since March 2021, with the usual underlying movement shown in the bridge. Our net debt position gives us RCV gearing of 61%, within our target range of 55%-65%, which supports a stable A3 credit rating with Moody's. The credit rating agencies also make an adjustment for an IFRS pension deficit position, which, as I've mentioned before, is not relevant for United Utilities given our IFRS pension surplus position.
Phil Aspin
executiveTurning now to a quick look at pensions. At March 2022, our IFRS pension surplus stood at roughly GBP 1 billion, and on a low dependency basis we remain fully funded. As I mentioned at earlier results presentations, that funding position reflects the fact that the IFRS measurement basis isn't as robust as the low dependency basis, which the pensions regulator expects schemes to target. On the low dependency basis we continue to be fully funded, with no ongoing pension scheme deficit contributions due. Funding valuations apply to the schemes every three years, and the latest valuation, as at March 2021, is now finalized. That valuation confirms the strength of our pensions position, and we're now looking at further de-risking options, for example a buy-in that would transfer some or all of the risk to an insurance company. We've covered inflation extensively today, so it's also worth considering it in the pensions context. With DB pension liabilities of about GBP 3 billion, similar in order of magnitude to our index-linked debt, it's reassuring in today's high inflation environment that our pension schemes are fully hedged for inflation risk. This slide now sets out our outlook for the year to March 2023.
Phil Aspin
executiveWe anticipate revenue coming in roughly 1% up compared with a year earlier, mainly driven by the 4.6% CPIH rise and the 1.5% uplift from the ODI reward earned in FY 2021, partially offset by the negative K factor of -1.3% and by rebasing revenues to reflect over-recovery in FY 2022 stemming from higher business consumption. Underlying operating costs should rise by approximately GBP 100 million. About half of that rise comes from the FY 2023 OpEx effect of the GBP 765 million of extra investment already covered, while the other half comes from inflationary pressure on labor, power, chemicals, and other contract costs. Elevated inflation will affect our index-linked debt as well, and on our present inflation forecast we expect the underlying finance expense to be roughly GBP 150 million greater. Our index-linked debt portfolio stood at GBP 4.3 billion as at March 2022, meaning each 1% rise in inflation translates into an interest charge about GBP 43 million higher. As noted previously, cash interest in FY 2022 was GBP 118 million, and we expect it to be broadly unchanged in FY 2023, with the total increase in underlying net finance expense mostly tied to non-cash indexation of our index-linked debt.
Phil Aspin
executiveSo our cash metrics are still solid, and as we went through before, the higher inflation will apply to our RCV as well — 70% of that is exposed to the upside from higher inflation, which gives shareholders roughly 1.75x leverage to inflation. We expect underlying tax to be a small tax charge for the year, as we keep optimizing how we use capital allowance super deductions. CapEx for the year should land in the range of GBP 640 million-GBP 690 million, and that includes the FY 2023 element of the incremental CapEx tied to the additional GBP 765 million investment beyond the scope of the FD allowance. We're targeting a customer ODI reward of around GBP 30 million, consistent with our updated investment plans and our AMP guidance on ODIs. Lastly, our dividend policy is unchanged, and we expect dividends in FY 2023 to be in line with our AMP7 dividends growth year-on-year by CPIH. To wrap up, we've delivered another strong financial performance through what has been a challenging year for businesses. We've doubled our base returns on RoRE with strong financing, tax, and customer ODI performance. Our affordability schemes and the way we manage cash collection have meant that household cash collection has stayed strong, with our bad debt position returning to 1.8%.
Phil Aspin
executiveInflation has pushed our costs up this year, but it has also produced larger TotEx allowances and better financing outperformance, and along with the extra investment we've announced beyond our final determination, that will help drive greater RCV growth across this AMP. Lastly, we gain from holding one of the sector's strongest balance sheets, with low customer debtor risk and a leading pensions position. Thank you — I'll now return things to Steve.
Steve Mogford
executiveThanks, Phil. Before I go through today's presentation, I'd like to spend a moment on how things are shaping up for AMP8 and past that. As you're aware, public health and the environment matter enormously to us, and that shows in the transformation we've delivered over recent years in water quality and environmental performance. I feel we've reached an inflection point here in the UK, with the environmental agenda moving to center stage. The government's recent Environment Act is a reflection of that. We strongly share that ambition, and our original AMP7 plans deliver meaningful environmental improvement by 2025. The extra investment announced today brings even more forward ahead of AMP8 by deploying outperformance in a responsible and wise way. Specific AMP8 targets are being discussed with government and our regulators, but one thing is already clear: our shared ambition is to deliver fundamental change in how our wastewater systems were originally configured. That means fewer discharges to the environment, less phosphate and water release from our treatment works, and an improved nutrient balance in our rivers and coastline. The capital expenditure tied to these changes will be significant for the water sector, but it's a particular issue for the North West. For many decades, a much higher proportion of our sewers have been combined sewers, carrying both foul and surface water at 54% compared to an average of 33% across England.
Steve Mogford
executiveTake Liverpool’s system: roughly 80% of it carries combined foul and surface water, so meeting the targets now being discussed would require re-engineering it completely. Together with government and regulators, we are examining how that ambition could be achieved and what timetable is realistic, bearing in mind that the speed of change has to reflect what customers can afford. It is a bold ambition, and an exciting one, and we are eager to do our part in delivering it. In summary, this has been another good year, with good performance again. We know customers are under cost of living pressure, and we have committed to a substantial support package for struggling households, valued at about GBP 280 million across this AMP. Customer satisfaction has stayed high, supported by operational performance that keeps improving. At GBP 25 million, ODI rewards are up year on year, and our five-year forecast has risen by a third, to GBP 200 million. Better performance and higher inflation helped produce a reported RoRE of 7.9% for the year, double the base return. We are handling inflationary cost pressures well, with another year of strong financial performance supported by a robust balance sheet and a healthy pension position. We are investing our performance responsibly and sharing our success for the benefit of all our stakeholders.
Steve Mogford
executiveAs we look forward, we anticipate that business plans will mirror the goals tied to environmental legislation. Thanks for tuning in, and at this point we'll open it up for questions. I've got a chance here to field questions either online—where folks are sending them in writing—or actually via Teams or phone. We'll blend those together as we proceed. All right, the first one that's come in is from Mark Freshney at Credit Suisse. So, Mark?
Mark Freshney
analystHi there, am I coming through clearly?
Steve Mogford
executiveAbsolutely, Mark. We’re able to do that — thank you.
Mark Freshney
analystPerfect. Two questions from me. First, Phil, I was quite interested when you brought up the pension buy-in you're considering. Could you shed a bit more light on it? What portion of the overall pension funds would be involved? Would you potentially need to inject cash into it, or might you even get paid for transferring the pensions, or the liability, to someone else? Second, on tax. The tax outperformance is fairly significant at 2.7%. Obviously, tax is always a huge gray area, I suppose, especially where regulators are concerned. What I want to know is, how likely is it that Ofwat lets you retain that? Presumably, items such as super-deduction and optimization are, you know, extremely sensitive as far as Ofwat is concerned. Thank you.
Steve Mogford
executiveAlright, Phil, those two seem to be directed at you. Would you like to take them?
Phil Aspin
executiveMorning, Mark, and thanks for the questions. First, on pensions — as many of you probably know, our scheme is now fully funded on a low dependency basis. Effectively, that means it sits at roughly that buyout level in terms of position. We're hedged against inflation, and we're hedged against interest rates. Mortality isn't something we're hedged for, since that risk tends to evolve more slowly. Going forward, what we intend to do is effectively test the insurance market and get a sense of what insurance buyout pricing might look like. We feel now is probably a good moment for that. We'll need to evaluate it as results come back in. On the scheme's size — typically you'd look at a buy-in, buyout arrangement covering your deferreds and pensioners. That's probably around about half of the overall position. I certainly wouldn't expect to have to put cash into the pension scheme to support it, because as I say, it's fully funded on that low dependency basis. That's where things stand on pensions.
Phil Aspin
executiveOn the tax side, this year really has two elements to it, the 2.7% of RoRE. Of that, 1.7% relates to the prior year position, and that is an area where we've been genuinely effective at optimizing tax allowances around innovation. Some of you will have attended our capital markets day in March, when we went up to the West Cumbria system, which is the first sort of widescale implementation of systems thinking across the whole drinking water catchment. That's quite innovative and qualifies for sort of extra tax deductions, as do other schemes such as our Nereda plant at Blackburn, which is Europe's largest implementation of Nereda. It's really great to be able to optimize the tax benefits coming out of those capital programs. In the context of the sort of how that will work out from a shareholder/customer perspective, you know, those are innovations that we've put in place as our sort of decisions. On that basis, effectively that benefit will flow back to shareholders and be retained by the company. You're quite right about the capital allowance super-deduction. As I touched on in the script, the further 1% of the 2.7% tax is in relation to capital allowance super-deduction and also the tax shield effect on our index-linked debt.
Phil Aspin
executiveWe have a greater charge tied to index-linked debt, so we also gain from the tax shield benefit on it. Regarding the capital allowance super-deduction, as I more or less mentioned, under the way the Ofwat model operates for the tax true-up mechanism, essentially they re-run their model when a price control period ends, using in effect the updated tax rates then in force. The upshot is that for the base FD CapEx profile plus any Green Recovery spend they have permitted, the tax advantages flow back to customers. By contrast, when it comes to the capital acceleration that Steve and I put in place across the last couple of years, we invested roughly GBP 600 million of CapEx this year versus GBP 400 million under the base FD profile, speeding up and pulling forward the base spend. The company keeps that benefit. That is how the mechanism functions, and in the script I pointed out the estimate of what returns to customers, namely the 20 basis points I mentioned in the narrative.
Steve Mogford
executiveAll right. Thank you, Mark. Are there any further questions? All right, then we have James Brand from Deutsche Bank. Good morning, James. James, I believe your line is muted.
James Brand
analystIs this coming through clearly now?
Steve Mogford
executiveSure, I can do that. Thanks.
James Brand
analystOh, is this coming through now?
Steve Mogford
executiveYes, we can. Thank you. Is the audio coming through okay for you?
James Brand
analystThank you. Apologies for that. I can. Sorry. So, two questions if I may. Thanks for the presentation. First, regarding power hedging, you provided a cost per megawatt-hour of GBP 60/MWh for the hedging you've put in place for the year we've just entered. For the volumes you've hedged for full year 2024 and full year 2025, should we expect a comparable price, or could you offer any guidance on either what that price is or perhaps when those hedges were put in place, so that we can, you know, check the price and attempt to figure it out ourselves? Second, a somewhat broader question about incentives. It appears that in this regulatory period, clearly it's a little unusual given the inflation backdrop, and many companies are going to have considerable financing outperformance during this regulatory period. But when you look specifically at the incentives, the ODIs and the TotEx, many companies seem to be underperforming, and you're doing relatively well compared with the rest of the sector. But the vast majority of companies are underperforming, and I was just wondering whether you thought that was sustainable going into the next regulatory period, because it seems very, very tough for so many, you know, to have a fairly tough assessment on the cost of capital and for the vast majority of companies to be underperforming on incentives.
James Brand
analystIs there an argument that the regulator might recognize things have been somewhat difficult and show a little more generosity regarding incentives in the upcoming regulatory period? Are you sensing anything along those lines, or perhaps not? Thank you.
Steve Mogford
executiveWould you like to take the hedging, and I'll handle the other part?
Phil Aspin
executiveMorning, James. On power hedging, we've provided quite explicit guidance for FY 2023. As for the two-thirds hedged for FY 2024 and 2025, it's roughly at a comparable kind of level, though I won't be putting a number on the table today. Still, it's a similar sort of pricing level.
Steve Mogford
executiveOn incentives, James, I believe you're spot on. In fact, only a small number — two or three businesses — currently sit in positive ODI territory. Naturally, we'll see how things look once full-year results come in. Many firms, as you know, are missing their target achievements. When you consider it, having some individuals earning while others don't is probably appropriate, since that reveals something about the targets themselves. It reveals something about overall performance. The purpose of ODIs, really, is to push everyone toward delivering incremental gains measured against a sector benchmark. So it likely is the case that if everyone were earning, or if everyone were losing, you'd begin to ask whether the targets have been set correctly. For me, the crucial point looking ahead is this: I genuinely believe incentives work for the sector. Consider what has happened in customer service, for instance — we've witnessed notable gains there thanks to the SIM measure we used for many years and, more recently, CMEX. I think we're observing the same across other performance areas. In my view, they're a positive thing whether you're a customer or you're the environment, in terms of moving the industry in that direction.
Steve Mogford
executiveFor me, the main problem is establishing targets when the funding isn't there. When I look at AMP8 and consider how much further companies are being pushed on performance, you can't reach that higher level without the money required to do so. That, I'd say, is the central point — having a discussion about how that performance gain will be paid for, and making sure the financing is sufficient. It's still too early to know where things will land on AMP8 methodology. We expect to receive that in the summer. My sense is we'll likely keep ODIs, and we'll see what incremental improvement is being asked for. If improvement is wanted, it has to be funded — that's how I see it. How exactly is that going to work? That's a significant consideration as we head into the AMP8 business plans and the discussions around them. Okay, next one. We have Martin Young from Investec. Good morning, Martin. Over to you.
Martin Young
analystGood morning, everyone. Just a couple of quick items. First, a clarification on the incremental investment you've mentioned. Looking at the green box on slide 10, with the GBP 250 million you're putting in from performance, am I right that the TotEx sharing mechanism effectively returns half of that, meaning shareholders are funding the other half? Second, and there may not be an answer right now, but could you give an update on where things stand with the Environment Agency and Ofwat investigations regarding flow to full and combined sewer overflows? Thanks.
Steve Mogford
executiveYes, thank you very much. I’ll address both of those points. First, regarding regulatory mechanisms — we do reference them — we would anticipate that regulatory mechanisms would come into play, and so the menu mechanism that effectively applies in our case, which is roughly 50/50 sharing between customers and shareholders. Yes, Martin, you’re right. You would expect that mechanism to apply to the green box. Regarding the investigation, we clearly had a first output tied to it, and among what was identified there are additional questions and further detail to be obtained from five companies in the sector, so five of the 10 wastewater companies in the sector. That doesn’t necessarily mean, as they’ve said, that they don’t have further questions for others, but at the moment, that isn’t the case. The Environment Agency, I think, has indicated that, given the data they’ve requested, and the volume of data and the scale of the work required, they’re probably not likely to come back until 2023 with any initial conclusions. I think this may well be a relatively long-run issue for companies to address. Given the amount of data they’ve got, I’m sure we’ll get supplementary questions as we go through.
Steve Mogford
executiveMy guess is that it will likely be next year before any conclusions start emerging—at minimum, preliminary conclusions from the EA regarding that work. Naturally, we are collaborating with both Ofwat and the EA concerning the data they seek or require for that investigation. So it's difficult to predict where that will lead. At the same time, naturally, we have our Better Rivers plan. I believe our focus has been heavily on the first part of the investigation, which is termed flow to full treatment. That is an area we have been addressing for a great many years, we are very mindful of it, and we have been steadily resolving problems where we identified risk in those areas. As you can see in our Better Rivers plan, this year we cut CSO spills by 28%. It is somewhat of a shifting target since we are putting in additional monitors. We anticipate having monitors fully installed by next year. I believe that's a solid beginning in cutting the number of spills we have. Yeah. It remains an evolving situation, but I don't believe it's one that will fail fast. I believe considerable effort is needed to grasp where everyone stands.
Steve Mogford
executiveAll right. Moving on, our next question comes from Ahmed Farman at Jefferies. Good morning.
Ahmed Farman
analystMorning, and thanks for taking my questions. I'd like to begin with the operating cost base, and thank you for all the granularity you've given us today. My question is this: as you look ahead to the next 12 months, what portion of your operating cost base will be rebased to reflect the current inflationary environment? And how much still needs to be adjusted over time if we keep seeing the current commodity price environment? That's my first question. The second one concerns the additional investments you've outlined to get yourselves, I guess, prepared ahead of what you believe are some of the priorities for PR25. Should we treat that number as a comprehensive figure that you're now quite happy with? Or is it an ongoing process where we could see that number rise if opportunities arise and there's capacity to fund them? My final question is a bit about the DPS and EPS profile. Of what you're outlining today, there is going to.
Ahmed Farman
analystTo me, there looks to be a fairly large gap between the way EPS shifts and the way your DPS moves, and I realize part of that involves non-cash items and, you know, RCV indexation not being captured. So my question is this: does management consider that an important KPI? Thank you.
Steve Mogford
executiveAll right, I think we'll get going again. Phil, if you have anything to add, please go ahead. Regarding the cost base, we've been examining it going forward in light of what we regard as consensus inflation trends. Obviously, there's a degree of uncertainty about where the economy is headed. Are we going to enter a recession? Where do we think inflation may end up? But right now, all of our projections are being done within the framework of what we consider a consensus forecast. Clearly, we view things very much through the five-year lens, and we assess that against what we see for our determination allowance. At this moment, despite the pressures, we do believe we can stay within the allowance we have in the FD for delivering our FD scope. Of course, beyond that, we've discussed the enhanced investment we've made in specific areas. Right now, we do feel we can manage within the numbers. Our main cost drivers are labor, and you've seen what we've done this year in largely managing within inflation.
Steve Mogford
executiveChemicals — Phil covered that. Power — Phil covered that too. The remaining pieces are the capital program. The infrastructure sector is clearly extremely busy right now — you could even call it overheated — when it comes to how much infrastructure development is being demanded. Because of that, we consider ourselves quite lucky that approximately 80% of our overall capital program for the period is already under contract. That alone puts us in a strong position, since plenty of companies in the utility sector are having a hard time securing capacity. The second point, as Phil noted, is that we typically structure our contracts around a target cost arrangement with a share line. Both our partners and ourselves have incentives to keep costs within those share lines. We collaborate very diligently to achieve that. At this moment, I'm not sure whether that answers your question, Ahmed, but from a cost base standpoint, we're certainly clear. Phil, would you like to add anything?
Phil Aspin
executiveMorning, Ahmed. I'd like to follow up on one item — I believe we already went over it on slide 17, but I just want to make sure you notice it. On slide 17 there, we've essentially indicated that for every 1% rise in inflation across a full five-year AMP period, our TotEx allowance goes up by GBP 150 million. In practice, we face the difficulty of handling how inflation affects our cost base, yet we do receive that TotEx allowance with inflation built in, which gives you some context for gauging the scale of that impact.
Steve Mogford
executiveAlright, thank you. Regarding further investment, we’ve really examined this AMP and the start of AMP8. Phil and I have essentially told the wider organization, “Don’t come knocking at our door again,” as we head toward the conclusion of this five-year regulatory cycle. I’d always say this, Ahmed: if someone brought me a genuinely strong proposal with excellent returns, you would consider it. At this moment, we believe the industrial investment we have is enough to accomplish what we intend for the remainder of this AMP and to prepare for AMP8. So, no. This isn’t a situation where we’d want to return annually and add more, unless some brilliant plan is presented, and then we always evaluate those. I think we’ve largely scoured the organization for the best ideas at this stage. Would you like to address the DPS and EPS?
Phil Aspin
executiveSure. That's a genuinely interesting question, and honestly, the analyst community already knows the answer here, I think — namely that our businesses aren't valued through an EPS-driven process. The valuation happens on an RCV basis, and it centers on, in effect, the level of RoRE financing across our performance ODIs and TotEx positions. That is the real driver, and that is what truly matters. As for the overall guidance I provided for the year, we've indicated that interest costs will rise by roughly GBP 150 million. Next year our interest charge will come in at around GBP 450 million, and GBP 120 million of that is cash, while the remaining GBP 330 million is indexation. I've laid out fairly detailed guidance for you because I'm aware the current environment is volatile and uncertain, so you're able to see the inflation levels being applied to the indexation on the index-linked debt. The crucial point is really the 8% inflation on CPI as of January 2023, and that is what's pushing that indexation allowance higher. For context, I'd say that with a GBP 12 billion RCV, 8% CPI on the RCV comes to just under GBP 1 billion of indexation on the RCV, which is partly offset by that GBP 330 million of indexation running through the P&L interest line, and the remainder then effectively contributes to performance for the business.
Steve Mogford
executiveAll right, thank you, Ahmed. Up next we have Dominic Nash with Barclays. Good morning, Dominic.
Dominic Nash
analystMorning. Am I coming through clearly?
Steve Mogford
executiveYeah.
Phil Aspin
executiveYeah.
Steve Mogford
executiveYes, I can — thanks.
Dominic Nash
analystGreat, thanks. I have a couple of questions, please. First, regarding underlying RoRE for TotEx, since you've obviously cited a -0.8%, and I'm mindful that you're spending above your baseline here, as I believe you noted in your presentation. Could you give us a sense of what your underlying performance would be on an RoRE basis for TotEx if we removed everything, and where do we stand in terms of quartile benchmarking performance as we move toward AMP8 on an underlying basis? My second question returns to inflation. I may have missed this, but could you remind me what actual inflation figure you used to calculate your financing outperformance, please? If it's that 8% I think Phil mentioned earlier regarding CPIH, is there a risk of some kind of windfall or another sharing mechanism, or is Ofwat discussing with you whether this is an unearned number that, particularly given the cost of living crisis, might need to be returned? Then just a very quick one here.
Dominic Nash
analystJust to double-check on that 1.8% bad debt figure — is that the provision you're booking against revenue based on last year's numbers? And if a cost of living squeeze or recession does hit next year, what bad debt level should we be factoring in on a guidance outlook basis? Thank you.
Steve Mogford
executiveAlright, a lot of that is really for Phil. But if I just touch on what you might describe as the general mood music from Ofwat regarding inflation — Dominic, you'll have picked up on this just as much as we have — basically, Ofwat is very mindful of where inflation stands right now, and there are really a couple of points here: what that means for a customer's capacity to pay, and really pushing companies to do everything they can to support customers who are finding things tough. As you saw this morning, I think we as a company have by far the biggest commitment when it comes to company contribution. If you look at what we're doing — the GBP 71 million we've put in, plus the matching arrangement we've put alongside it — there's over GBP 140 million of company money going toward supporting customers within that overall GBP 280 million. We're doing a great deal in that space, and we've committed to doing so across the five-year period. I think the other side of it is: what does this do to the outperformance potential for companies? Naturally, it won't be uniform right across the sector.
Steve Mogford
executiveThat is the basis for our choice to share outperformance and essentially get ahead of AMP8 by carrying out work that customers would otherwise be charged for during AMP8. We have formed our own view on that and made our own decision on it. Each company has to decide what it does. That, in essence, is our approach to what we regard as responsible behavior, and we have done this before. In that sense, there is no specific guidance, no specific requests, and no direction in that area. We have chosen to do this because it is what we do. It is how we act toward customers as we achieve success. Phil, do you want to take the others?
Phil Aspin
executiveOkay, let me take the first one, and Dominic, on the underlying RoRE position and TotEx, just to give a bit of context around the scaling. I guess you can see the 0.5% customer ODI performance, which comes to GBP 25 million of ODIs in the current year. The -0.8% on TotEx works out to roughly GBP 40 million, and that relates to DNM investment we're making — additional investment flowing through the TotEx sharing mechanism and supporting delivery of future ODIs. That's the story on the TotEx position. On inflation, I think it's a really interesting point you raise. The 8% isn't what's driving financing performance in the current year, because that's really a look forward into the outlook for next year. Just to unpack the 1.6% financing outperformance we've earned this year, there's a technical mismatch occurring there that's dragging the financing outperformance down a little, because the way the calculation works is that an average CPI is used for the allowance over the year, and as we know, we've come through a year of rapidly escalating inflation, so that average CPI for the year is only 3.7%.
Phil Aspin
executiveNow, if you examine our index-linked debt, it's mostly tied to a January CPI figure, and that figure came in at 5.4%. In effect, in an environment where inflation is rising, you have a technical mismatch, and that mismatch is holding back the financing outperformance in the current year. As you move upward and things level off and then begin to decline again along that downward path for inflation, you get the pickup, because in effect the average is lagging the cost of the index-linked debt. I hope that helps clarify. That lag is probably worth roughly 1.5% on the financing outperformance that will show up in later periods. Finally, on your question about bad debt and the 1.8%: I suppose if you ran a prudent organization, you might attempt to make the case for provisioning against future bad debts, but that isn't something you can do. You have to provision for what sits on the balance sheet on the day, and for your expectation of collecting that debt. Looking ahead, our best view right now is that cash collection is holding up very well—remarkably well—and I think that reflects all the hard work that goes into the cash collection activity as well as all the support schemes we have in place.
Phil Aspin
executiveWe offer a wide range of targeted support programs for customers. That's roughly GBP 280 million in a package across the AMP period, and it genuinely assists those facing real affordability challenges. As I mentioned during the presentation, our entire strategy around data and analytics for cash collection is delivering strong returns. Going forward, it's difficult to predict what conditions will look like over the next 12 months, though at this point we certainly don't anticipate any major issue.
Steve Mogford
executiveTo build on that point, I believe what really helps us is the approach we take to the entire customer relationship — being able to spot issues and act fast to give customers support, so they avoid falling into debt and know what options exist for them. You know, I mentioned the schemes we basically make available. I mentioned the hub we've set up, which basically serves as a reference point for all the various debt advisors out there in the community who are advising and assisting people. I think the credit referencing we have allows us to grasp a customer's circumstances, because inevitably when they're struggling, we're not the only one they're not paying. I think the newest innovation is excellent, because by basically using open banking instead of having to complete forms, which is often rather hard in itself and can take time — you know, people are actually pursuing applications that previously might have taken weeks at a moment when they're very stressed and very worried about accumulating debt. Within minutes we're able literally to speak with them, to share their banking picture with their agreement, and then to actually give them the best advice on which kind of scheme could help, which ultimately might be that we'd recommend you go and speak to the trust fund that has been established, which effectively, independently of us, disperses funds for people who are really in need.
Steve Mogford
executiveI'd say it comes down to really deep engagement with the community, across multiple channels, and being able to grasp the customer's financial picture, then very quickly getting them onto a scheme that helps. That's genuinely something we've built over years, and it has contributed to the bad debt level we've got. To have just GBP 4 million of bad debt aged over a year is really remarkable. I think so — as well-positioned as anybody to deal with what we might see as we go forward over the next year or so. Okay.
Dominic Nash
analystUm, uh, Ris—
Steve Mogford
executiveMy apologies.
Dominic Nash
analystFollow-up, sorry. Those initiatives look really, really solid, but let me just ask a follow-on: if that lag is factored in — I believe you mentioned 1.6% — and then inflation next year runs at 8% or whatever the average turns out to be, you might be showing a financing outperformance of maybe 6%-7% within 12 months' time. Is it fair to assume that, as a responsible corporation and as someone invested in your company, some of that would likely be voluntarily directed toward helping the more vulnerable customers in your area? Or do you think that figure can sustainably be passed through to shareholders as planned?
Phil Aspin
executiveMaybe I can just touch on that quickly, Dominic. As Steve mentioned, there's the reinvestment we're making through today's announcement — the GBP 250 million. What we're really doing there is concentrating on advancing that environmental agenda and delivering improvements, partly by using some of the financing outperformance. We're putting it to work to drive the right kinds of activity in the environmental space. When it comes to customers, we're very aware that, you know, they'll be finding things very challenging, but we do have the sector-leading package of support measures that Steve described. 280 million over the AMP, very targeted and focused on those facing the biggest affordability challenges. With that package in place, I think it's right for us to pay attention to the environment and to support the environmental investment we announced today.
Dominic Nash
analystThanks.
Steve Mogford
executiveAll right, thanks, Dominic. Next up on the line is Chris Laybutt from Morgan Stanley. Good morning, Chris.
Chris Laybutt
executiveGood morning, everyone. Thanks so much for taking my questions. I really just had one question, and it goes back to your earlier comments about how 1% inflation across five years would improve your TotEx budget by GBP 150 million. Is the message here that the inflation you've seen coming through so far offsets the effect of the higher costs that are coming? Is that basically the message? Maybe a question that's more strategic in nature. When I think about you, I think about digitization, machine learning, innovation, untapped efficiency potentials — or potential, rather. Once again, we're seeing reinvestment, and we can see the benefits of that, particularly politically and also when it comes to asset performance. At what point do we start to see that sort of potential within the organization really shine through?
Steve Mogford
executiveI think so. Do you want to take the inflation point first?
Phil Aspin
executiveYeah. If I take Chris's question first — good morning, Chris. The short answer is yes. I think, as Steve more or less said, our base TotEx program is aimed at coming in within our allowance. That allowance is subject to inflation. We have inflation with cost pressures flowing through, and we still expect to land within that base allowance. Yes.
Steve Mogford
executiveYeah. I think when you really step back and consider all the drivers we have via systems thinking and other approaches, what we probably don't explicitly discuss is the efficiencies that are baked into our plan, right from the very beginning of our determination. I think among the key elements we had as part of securing fast-track for our final determination at PR19 was that we had very significant efficiencies built into our underlying TotEx, principally the OpEx line, tied to savings coming through from efficiencies delivered via different ways of working. Those efficiency targets effectively sit there and must be delivered in order to hit our overall FD numbers. While we don't discuss it as, effectively, an explicit set of figures, I can assure you, Chris, that in order to hit the efficiency curves, which secured us fast-track and secured what was an FD that, you know, compared to what happened across the sector at PR19 was a largely undisturbed plan, we were baking in efficiencies that were being delivered through our different innovations, both in use of technology, AI, et cetera. We'll see that benefit coming through. The other areas you're seeing is in things like ODIs.
Steve Mogford
executiveIf you recall where we stood when PR19 began, we discussed an ODI level that was not especially far from what we had earned during AMP6—roughly GBP 50 million. Our projection for this period is now 4 times that amount. We are in fact seeing that benefit show up as value across several different areas, in how it supports our plan. Okay. Verity? Verity Mitchell from HSBC. Good morning. I believe your line may be muted, Verity.
Verity Mitchell
analystGood morning.
Steve Mogford
executiveGood morning, everyone.
Phil Aspin
executiveGood morning, Verity.
Verity Mitchell
analystThanks so much for the presentation. Slide 11 really caught my attention. You mentioned that a 28% reduction in spills has already been achieved between 2020 and 2031, and since your target is 33, you're nearly there. Are you being ambitious enough on that front? Following up on your earlier comment, how much of those spills is actually being monitored now? I have a question about slide 23. Could you tell us what your revised RCV growth is on a real basis? I ask because I see inflationary assumptions included there. That would be really helpful. Just a quick third one, building on Mark's earlier comments regarding tax. Do you expect the super deductions to mean that your ODI outperformance on tax is going to be lower in subsequent years? Thank you.
Steve Mogford
executiveAll right, thank you. I'll take the first two, which is ambition. As I said before, we're essentially aiming at a target that keeps shifting, because roughly just over 80% — in the mid-80% area — of our CSOs are equipped with what we call an event duration monitor. They have a sensor installed. We will finish that, as we stated in our pledges for Better Rivers, we will finish that by 2023. That 28% is measured against the lower figure. Yes, you're completely right. It's a strong achievement in year one, but next year we'll have a larger number to think about when it comes to spills. I think we're reasonably comfortable with the one-third, and if we can beat it, we will. Right now, it's a moving target against which we're measuring ourselves. Do you want to take tax, et cetera?
Phil Aspin
executiveYeah. Starting with the RCV profile, I'd say the added effect from the carry forward value comes to roughly 6% real across the overall RCV profile. As you know, we had a negative real position on the RCV over the five years in the final determination. I think this brings us out at around 2% real overall growth across the five-year period. Verity, on the tax point, maybe remind me again. I didn't quite follow the link you mentioned from the tax allowance to the ODIs.
Verity Mitchell
analystI mean, you've just gotten an advantage from super-deductions. Setting aside the fact that you'll have to give this back to customers, when the tax regime changes, that number is going to be lower in subsequent years, isn't it?
Phil Aspin
executiveYes. Regarding the tax piece, that's correct. The 20 basis points I flagged represents the amount going back to customers. Whatever remains is kept by shareholders and the company. Obviously, the super-deduction figure is worth roughly GBP 40 million this year. Next year, the value of super-deductions should be around the same order of magnitude. The tax adjustment mechanism will then take effect and reverse things over the two years after that, since the 25% corporation tax rate will be in force — meaning money value will flow back to the company from customers, because essentially there's a shortfall in the tax allowance that has to be made up to reach 25%. That's how the mechanism operates. The roughly 1% current K value in RPI for today, this year — I'd expect something similar in magnitude next year.
Verity Mitchell
analystSure.
Steve Mogford
executiveAlright. Thanks. I believe — yes — Bartek Kubicki from Société Générale has joined us at this point. Good morning, Bartek.
Bartek Kubicki
analystMorning, and thanks for the opportunity to ask. There are three things I'd like to go through, if that's alright. First, going back to the extra investments you announced today: my understanding is that you were weighing two options. In one, you put money in now, you take TotEx underperformance, but you receive more on ODIs. In the other, you invest in AMP8, you're fully funded, there's no TotEx underperformance, but fewer ODIs. Comparing those two, you clearly went with the first. When it comes to creating IRR, NAV, or ROE, how do the two stack up — can you put numbers on each — and what made you pick the first over the second, that is, over investing in AMP8? Second, regarding the GBP 280 million customer support scheme, will that affect earnings, ROE, underperformance, outperformance, and so on? Is it funded in some way within your allowances, or not really? Third, on procurement for your capital program, you said 80% is already procured for AMP7. I'm wondering whether your suppliers are giving any signals that they'd like to renegotiate those contracts, or want out of them, because inflationary pressure is simply too high to keep the contract conditions in place.
Bartek Kubicki
analystI appreciate that.
Phil Aspin
executiveMay I start with the first question?
Steve Mogford
executiveIf you'd like, sure.
Phil Aspin
executiveYeah. Okay. I guess I’ll just take the first question about TotEx investment — why now instead of later? I suppose what’s driving it at this point is the push for sustainable long-term performance, so that spending on DNM and on taste, smell, appearance, and water quality is in fact driving performance in ODIs within this AMP, which effectively pays back through the TotEx mechanism, but also then positions us to have stronger ODI earning potential going forward into the next AMP. It’s really about getting it done early so we can drive that kind of progressive performance into AMP8.
Steve Mogford
executiveI think the other thing, Bartek, is whether you feel sure that you'd secure the funding in AMP8. I think you're in a position — and I'll probably just give you a single illustration, which is DNM, an investment we're making in sewers. I think across PR14 and PR19, we had put forward what we believed was a persuasive case for putting money into our sewer network. As I mentioned earlier, we have roughly 54% combined sewers. Rainfall where we are is far greater than in other regions of the country. We believed there was a solid case for spending on that sewer system. We did not prevail in that argument. I'm not certain that even at this point we would prevail again when we get to PR24. I think, you know, DNM presents a chance to transform how we perform in this area, but in a manner where, when you consider things such as menu sharing mechanisms, when you consider ODIs, you can genuinely see a return on investment so far as the shareholder is concerned. If you didn't, what you would probably simply do is just keep going along as you are, and be penalized very heavily via ODIs in this AMP and the ones that follow. I think when you really examine it, there is a question of whether, if you assumed you were going to get an AMP8, yes, there's a question about timing, and there's a question about the ODI benefit that one might receive.
Steve Mogford
executiveThere's also, I think, a moral case here — namely that we're gaining quite substantially from outperformance. Given the conditions today, considering the strain customers are facing, why wouldn't you do it? We are doing it. In AMP7, customers don't have to pay for these items, so we're providing the benefits customers will experience, yet it isn't affecting the prices they'll face during AMP7. Several factors come into play on that. Regarding the procurement question you raised, I think it's undeniable that the construction supply chain is encountering a whole array of cost pressures. That tends to show up in what you'd regard as both the direct costs of any rises in material prices — and anyone who's actually done building at home knows how far things like wood, steel, and concrete costs have shifted — and the indirect costs tied to a very buoyant market in which companies perhaps aren't ready to take the competitive risk they would have taken in a less active market. Fortunately, our supply chain partners were on framework agreements that would basically fix the pricing basis we'd work on.
Steve Mogford
executiveTo reiterate what I mentioned earlier, the majority of these are structured around a target cost setup. Yes, I do believe pricing pressure is going to exist, and yes, on quite a few occasions we've spoken with companies regarding whether they can stick to the arrangement they entered into. As I noted previously, I think the fact that we have them under contract is a massive advantage first and foremost, since we have access to resources, and looking ahead, factoring in those discussions, we're confident we can meet our commitments inside our FD number. That involves an enormous amount of effort between ourselves and our contractor partners — examining scope, examining additional efficiencies. You know, how do you truly deliver against the budget we have? Right now, we look solid for AMP7. Was there another question that I missed?
Phil Aspin
executiveYeah, that GBP 280 million related to customer support and what it does to earnings — should I handle that one?
Steve Mogford
executiveYeah.
Phil Aspin
executiveRight. I mean, Bartek, that GBP 280 million for customer support isn't a fresh development. We've had that in place across the entirety of this AMP. In practice, the figures we're reporting today already reflect this year's portions of that expense. To put it briefly, as we move ahead, there's no effect on our EPS, since it's already baked into where our earnings stand today. We'll simply continue moving forward through the remaining three years of this AMP.
Steve Mogford
executiveAll right, then. Thank you. I believe there are no more questions coming in through Teams, nor any written ones arriving. Oh, wait—there's one question, isn't there? Just one more. Is it coming through? Oh, Chris. Chris. That isn't Chris.
Chris Laybutt
executiveMorning. Apologies — my line dropped before. I have one quick follow-up, if I may. On that additional GBP 400 million of investment, is that number stated in real terms or nominal terms? That's just a point of clarification. One thing people are talking about today, I think, since the share price reaction has been fairly substantial, is the inflation assumptions you've now built into your fiscal 2023 guidance. If those were included and carried forward into your revenue, what revenue uplift would that give in 2024 and 2025 purely from the inflationary effect?
Steve Mogford
executiveRight. That extra investment is the figure we'd anticipate laying out. In that respect, I'd call it nominal, I guess. Yeah?
Chris Laybutt
executiveSure.
Steve Mogford
executivePhil, would you like to take on the question about the outlook?
Phil Aspin
executiveRegarding revenue for the next year — and we're getting a bit ahead of ourselves here, Chris — CPI is anticipated to stay fairly flat across the coming 12 months. The January figure I have on the outlook slide for index-linked debt is essentially 8%, I'd note. As you're aware, it's the CPI position at November that drives revenue for FY 2024. I would probably anticipate that to amount to roughly an 8% uplift, in effect.
Steve Mogford
executiveAlright.
Chris Laybutt
executiveI appreciate it. Thanks so much.
Steve Mogford
executiveOkay, I thought I caught a brief glimpse of Mark Freshney there. So does that mean he has a question, or not? Fine, Mark, you're off the hook. All right. Many thanks to all of you. Appreciate you being with us, and we really appreciate your questions.
Phil Aspin
executiveAll right, thanks to all of you.
Steve Mogford
executiveThanks. Goodbye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete United Utilities Group PLC transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to United Utilities Group PLC earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in United Utilities Group PLC or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.