United Utilities Group PLC (UU) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 16, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Chris Laybutt
executiveGood morning, everyone. I'm Chris Laybutt, the IR and Clean Energy Strategy Director at United Utilities. Welcome to all of you for our interim results presentation this morning. As usual, please take note of the cautionary statement at the start of the presentation. And consistent with prior events, today's format will feature a brief presentation from our CEO, Lou Beardmore, and CFO, Phil Aspin. After that main presentation, we'll have some Q&A. That Q&A will take place live. <<operator_script>>. Great. With that, I'll hand over to Lou in the studio.
Louise Beardmore
executiveThank you, Chris, and good morning to everyone, and I appreciate you being with us today and giving us the chance to discuss our business plan. What we want to do is walk you through the specifics of the half-year results, and also to have a conversation about the actual plan we handed in at the beginning of the year. I'm very aware that the last time we spoke with you was in October, so we will try our very best to keep this short and — but above all, since we want to leave a bit of time, we can hold a Q&A and give you the chance to raise any questions you might have for us. So first, and I suppose since I have a captive audience this morning, I wanted to spend a moment covering some of the highlights from the business plan, because as you know it has been an enormous effort, and that plan was submitted on the 2nd of October. Looking at the detail, we genuinely believe this plan delivers on what matters most: the county-based approach we have applied to its design, its planning and its engagement has made sure we have a plan that delivers customers for communities and for regulators.
Louise Beardmore
executiveThis is a GBP 13.7 billion totex plan, and through it we're going to achieve 37% real RCV growth — giving investors strong year-on-year returns in a way that AMP6 and AMP7 never managed. Our balance sheet is strong, with 59% gearing and a credit rating of A3/A-. Looking ahead, we have financing flexibility: 65% average gearing across the AMP period, based on Ofwat's early view WACC and the current scope, and that requires no recourse to equity at all. This plan can be delivered. Even more than that, we've already begun delivering on it. The GBP 1.2 billion of early investment has let us start making progress on our store-made flow reduction plan. We've put money into our in-house CSO rainwater management and modeling team, and it's now up and running. We've also expanded our delivery partners from 5 to 50 to underpin delivery in each of those 5 counties. Even though ours is one of the biggest plans in the sector, our 25% bill increase sits in the midpoint of the range set out by regulators. At the same time, we have an affordability package worth GBP 525 million, and you'll see us able to support 1 in 6 customers here in the North West through it.
Louise Beardmore
executiveBut the key point is that this plan produces a step change in performance, especially regarding combined 0 overflows, with spills falling 60% versus the baseline. As for what follows, this timeline will look familiar. We presented it to you back in October. What you can see here, though, are the specifics along with some of the top-level milestones we've laid out. As you're aware, Ofwat is looking at issuing an early assessment during March, and then draft determinations will come in May and June, which might, if things go our way, land around the same time as our full year results. Regardless, I think we all know May and June will be extremely busy, for you as well as for us, as everyone digests the detail. So let me now walk you through operational performance for the first half of the year. It's been a solid first half, and I hope that, as I take you through the next couple of slides, you'll see that we haven't only been working hard to deliver great performance for customers and communities. We've also been concentrating on developing new capabilities. Those capabilities will leave us really well positioned to deliver AMP8 and the step change we've proposed in our plan.
Louise Beardmore
executiveSo again, we've turned in solid operational results even with the weather causing us difficulties. I had to smile when I heard the music that was playing before you all joined — Mr. Blue Sky by ELO. It may be a real favorite, but it doesn't seem like we've seen a lot of blue sky. And with Storm Debi arriving this week, that makes 3 named storms within this many weeks. Because of that, I'm happy to report that water resources are in strong shape and a healthy position, and as we head into winter and then spring, things look very positive on that front. We're still ahead of our target and glide path when it comes to cutting water quality contacts through our investment and our focus on water quality, which is delivering visible improvements for customers. And our leakage was again on track for strong performance, hitting our leakage targets and expecting to earn a customer ODI reward for the year. Now I'll move to how our wastewater side performed. Under the EA's EPA assessment, our teams are working hard to deliver strong performance. And we're glad that we're currently on track to reach 4-star status this year. Unfortunately, we have seen a performance impact caused by the wetter weather across the summer and the storms we've had, especially regarding sewer flooding.
Louise Beardmore
executiveBut when it comes to storm overflow performance, even with more rain and the expanded monitoring — which, incidentally, remains on schedule to reach our goal of 100% monitoring by year-end — we still anticipate delivering additional reductions in average bills this year. The faster investment has enabled us to begin the work, and we are already seeing early gains from the new team and the solutions we are beginning to roll out across the North West. That should take us from 59 spills per overflow in 2020 to roughly 30 spills per overflow in 2023, which is strong progress toward the 2030 goal of 20 spills per overflow that we laid out in our business plan. Moving on to customer service. Our customer service metrics remain strong. The Institute of Customer Service has just ranked us as the #1 WaSC and, more significantly in my view, fourth among 30 utilities nationwide for customer service. We recognize many families are struggling at present. More than 370,000 households are on our priority services register, and in AMP7 we have assisted over 350,000 customers with affordability support to date.
Louise Beardmore
executiveThe programs we offer, together with credit collection practices that lead the industry and smart use of technology like open banking, have allowed us to post our strongest ever cash collection performance for the current year, along with a stable debt charge of 1.8% of household revenue. That's a really solid result given the headwinds created by the current cost of living crisis. Moving now to how we're doing on ESG. On the environmental side, we're pleased that we remain on track right now to reach 4-star EPA. We're also backing the development of an exciting new carbon capture facility at our head office here in Warrington, which gives us a great opportunity to decarbonize the footprint of our head office. On the social side, I'm glad to tell you that we've been named Water Industry Skills Employer of the Year. With an investment program in AMP8 that will demand great skills and talent, that's a great springboard for success going forward. All of this not only delivers for our customers and our communities, but from our standpoint on water poverty, I'm also happy to report that we have lifted 100,000 customers out of water poverty so far this AMP. It's real testimony to all the hard work under way to help with customer affordability. And we keep our focus on strong governance, with Ofwat's monitoring financial resilience report once again placing us in the highest financial resilience status.
Louise Beardmore
executiveMoving on to ODIs now. Last year was our strongest ever, with 83% of our performance commitments delivered — the best in the sector. This year, we're on course to deliver net customer ODI reward of over GBP 50 million, which is more than double what we earned last year. And the AMP guidance stays the same at GBP 200 million. To sum up, then, it's been a strong first half on operational performance. Water quality performance has been really strong. We're currently on track for the 4-star EPA rating. The accelerated infrastructure delivery project is genuinely helping us deliver further reductions in average spills per overflow, despite the rain levels and the increased monitoring. We've supported over 350,000 customers with affordability support so far in AMP7, and we're continuing our track record on ESG. We expect to hit record ODI levels and, as I've said, we're really pleased to be able to double the ODI rewards from last year. Finally, as I mentioned at the start, we've submitted what we believe is a really strong and ambitious AMP8 plan. It delivers on the things that matter to customers, it's transferrable and it's deliverable. I'll now hand you over to Phil, and we'll take you through some of the financial highlights.
Philip Aspin
executiveThanks, Lou, and good morning, everyone. So here are the main financial points for the first half of the year. Revenue came in at GBP 982 million, up 7%, mostly because of the allowed inflation increase, partly offset by a small K factor adjustment, as set out in our PR19 final determination. Underlying operating profit was GBP 271 million, an increase of 5%, mainly reflecting higher revenue, offset slightly by the effect of inflation on our core costs. Now in June, we had a fractured outlook pipe at our Fleetwood wastewater treatment works. We installed a temporary bypass of 2 kilometers and 5 lanes to bring full operations back to the site. And during that period, we supplemented site treatment with an extensive tankering operation to minimize any potential environmental impact. And this led to GBP 30 million of additional OpEx and IRE in the first half which, given it's a typical nature, we've adjusted for in our underlying measures. As a result, our reported operating profit is lower, at GBP 241 million. Underlying EPS of 13.2p per share reflects the improved underlying operating profit, and we reduced net finance expense thanks to the lower inflation charge on our index-linked debt. Finally, in line with policy, the interim dividend per share is 16.59p, and our gearing rose slightly to 59%, reflecting ongoing investment.
Philip Aspin
executiveBefore we go into the specifics of the first-half results, let me take you back to the AMP7 financial framework we laid out at the full-year results. That framework is the same today as it was in May. After updating for performance expectations and inflation, our RoRE guidance for the AMP is still in the range of 6% to 8% real, which delivers strong returns. We also still expect the compound annual growth rate of the RCV over the regulatory period to average between 4% and 5% per annum. Our dividend policy calls for growth in line with CPIH inflation, and our strong balance sheet continues to serve us well, with gearing targeted in the range of 55% to 65%, which results in an A3/A- rating at the world company level. As we move further through the PR24 process, we'll be able to update you on what this means for our framework into AMP8. So let's now turn to underlying operating profit. Underlying operating profit of GBP 271 million is up 5% on the prior half year. The driver is inflation, with regulatory adjustments to revenue of around GBP 50 million higher than the prior half year, which more than offsets the inflation impact of higher OpEx.
Philip Aspin
executiveAs we look toward the whole year, guidance for revenue and OpEx stays as it was. The OpEx run rate is a bit ahead in the first half versus what we've historically seen, but that comes from some timing effects and from power and chemical costs being split more evenly across Half 1 and Half 2. Finally, since our asset base is expanding, depreciation is up by GBP 7 million, and that rounds things out. Moving on to underlying tax and interest. Underlying net finance expense came in at GBP 180 million for the half year, which is GBP 87 million below the first half of last year, mainly because of lower inflation being applied to our index-linked debt. It won't surprise anyone that cash interest went up GBP 6 million as higher interest rates take hold, yet we keep delivering financing outperformance. As you're aware, we front-loaded the CapEx program in AMP7, meaning we funded a proportionately larger share of our AMP7 capital requirements while interest rates were low, which adds to further outperformance versus regulatory assumptions. As we look toward the whole year, we still expect net finance expense to be down at least GBP 150 million. On underlying tax, we recognized no current tax charge for the first half, consistent with our guidance, as we benefit from full expensing.
Philip Aspin
executiveWe still expect that to hold in the second half, which means no current tax charge for the full year. All of this produces underlying profit of GBP 90 million and EPS of 13.2p per share. Moving now to our strong balance sheet. At 59%, our gearing is among the lowest in the sector. That figure rests on an RCV of GBP 14.4 billion, up from GBP 14 billion at the end of March, and net debt of GBP 8.5 billion. In the half year, we finished a GBP 1.8 billion pension scheme buy-in transaction with Legal & General, covering around 2/3 of our liabilities. That marks a very significant milestone in our derisking journey. We raised around GBP 750 million of funding during the first 6 months of the year, and with our AMP7 financing requirements fully funded, we are now funding our AMP8 investment program. As such, our liquidity position remains robust and cash coverage into 2026. So to summarize, once again, it's a robust half year for us here at UU. As you know, we benefit from higher inflation for RCV near-term impacts to manage and we're pleased to deliver a solid set of financial results with our full year guidance unchanged.
Philip Aspin
executiveThe strength of our balance sheet still ranks among the best in the sector. That means we're in a solid position to finance the growth investments tied to last month's regulatory submission. In addition, our progressive dividend keeps rising in step with inflation. So thank you — and with that, I'll hand things back to Lou.
Louise Beardmore
executiveThanks, Phil. Before we move into Q&A, I want to lay out the key points from the first half of the year. We've put forward a plan to the regulator that is ambitious and of high quality — one that is affordable, financeable and deliverable — and that plan rests on a strong track record and on delivering for our stakeholders. As we've demonstrated today, we keep drawing benefit from our strong balance sheet, which gives us flexibility going forward. We're delivering in AMP7. And even more importantly, we're positioning ourselves to succeed in AMP8. Alongside that, we continue to support our customers in the North West with affordability support that leads the sector. Finally, and I believe this matters most, we are waiting in AMP8 to deliver on what matters to our stakeholders. We're already tackling storm overflows, and the accelerated investment Ofwat permitted earlier this year has helped with that. Thank you for your time today. Phil and I would now be happy to take any questions you may have.
Chris Laybutt
executiveGreat, thanks so much, Lou, and thanks, Phil. So kicking off the Q&A session today, we have James Brand. Mr. Brand, please unmute yourself and go right ahead. Thank you.
James Brand
analystActually, I only have a single question. A bit more than a month back, when your business plan came out, you received some fairly robust backing from mayors in the area. Since then, clearly, there has been considerably more opportunity for the plan to be absorbed and for you to talk with stakeholders. So I was wondering how that process has played out regarding reactions you have received after the plan from political figures, and whether you can say anything on the Ofwat side.
Louise Beardmore
executiveThanks, James, for that question. Yes, we received really strong backing. As you know, I think, when we submitted the plan, we took a very different approach to how we constructed it. So essentially, we used a country-based model, meaning we have a plan that is specific to each of the 5 counties here in the North West, and that's because we have very different stakeholders with very different needs and drivers. And as you know, as I said, when we put the plan in, we've had great support from both Steve Rotheram in Merseyside and Andy Burnham in Manchester, and that support has actually continued to strengthen since the plan's gone in. And I think what's really important is the context of how many people we've managed to talk to about the plan since its submission on the 2nd of October. So just to put some sort of quantification against that. We've engaged with over 550,000 customers since the plan has gone in, over the 400 stakeholder meetings. So fantastic regional support and engagement. What's more important, we're already now up and working with Andy and the regional team in terms of Greater Manchester and the combined authority starting to deliver against those commitments.
Louise Beardmore
executiveThe political and local backing we have secured keeps building genuine speed and momentum. Regarding what we've heard back from Ofwat, as you're aware, we are clearly in a formal process at this point. You can usually gauge these matters by the volume of questions and queries that come your way. I'm genuinely pleased to report that, judging from the data and insight in front of us, we sit right at the bottom end of the queries being returned, which is exactly where I want us to be. What we're being asked about is truly constructive, and these are subjects we'd genuinely like to engage on. We're still having very positive discussions concerning adaptive planning and the plan as a whole. So ever since the plan was submitted, engagement has kept on intensifying and it has been genuinely positive.
Chris Laybutt
executiveAll right. Thank you, James. Following next is Sarah Lester. Please proceed.
Sarah Lester
analystApologies, no video — IT has been somewhat troublesome this week. I have 2 questions, please. First, regarding the business plan and specifically your base regulatory dividend assumption: could you remind us how that base rate dividend assumption — return on equity minus the 1% — fits with Ofwat's suggestion in "4% assumption for non-growth companies and close to 2% for high growth"? My second question is fairly high level, and I do appreciate you may be limited in what you can say. I'm just curious: here in the U.K., we have 2 regulators whose sectors face a really meaningful step-up in investment, with one regulator showing encouraging signs of being proactive, nimble, and adaptable to that. Presumably this presents an opportunity for some cross-sector learning. So I suppose the question is twofold. What would you ideally like to see from the water regulator? And I'm not drawing you into a public debate on return allowance — this is just more general. Then the second part of the question: do you think the door is open to at least evolution, if not revolution, at Ofwat?
Louise Beardmore
executiveThanks, Sarah. We’ll take the questions in 2 parts. I’ll have Phil address the dividend first, and then I’ll return to the regulatory question.
Philip Aspin
executiveYes. Thank you, Sarah. Regarding where we stand on the dividend, I'd say we feel very, very at ease with the policy we set out in the plan. It's a plan that's both highly ambitious and of high quality. On your particular question, the fact that it sits 1% below the rest of equity is offset by our starting point. We haven't taken a position when it comes to the robust capital position at UU Water and the reality that it isn't exposed to -- to the drags affecting its cash flows, so to speak. For instance, we discussed earlier today the pension scheme derisking transaction. So the long-tail cash flow risk in that area is gradually eroding the debt position, in a manner of speaking. So a very, very solid capital position, in a manner of speaking, along with a dividend policy that retains equity. That proportion is the correct one. And you need to view this within the wider picture of what you're seeing unfold in terms of adaptive planning and the shifts that WACC will bring about. So given that the WACC is about to be updated, we know it will be going up by, in all likelihood, a minimum of roughly 40 to 50 basis points. And I think if you consider what we laid out at the October business plan submission event, so to speak, when we discussed the Ofwat position and the Frontier Economics position, in a manner of speaking.
Philip Aspin
executiveIf we ran those figures today, we'd likely be seeing roughly an additional GBP 500 million to GBP 1 billion in cash flow moving through the plan. So there are still plenty of moving parts to work through. And with all of that in mind, we have strong confidence that our dividend policy represents both a high-quality and ambitious approach to the plan.
Louise Beardmore
executiveAnd Sarah, on your second question, you're absolutely right. I don't really want to get pulled into a kind of debate about that. But what I'd say, I suppose, is that I'm seeing that evolution coming through from Ofwat. So I think the way they're engaging with the plan is really positive, and broader regulators as well, in terms of the Environment Agency, Defra and Natural England. Those are really great, constructive conversations, and I think that's really important. But what I'd also say is that we are seeing some movement. And I think we've already seen evidence too with the accelerated investment that we saw last year and our ability to be able to maximize that. That was an opportunity that was put forward which, as you know, United Utilities sort of ceased. And we took the opportunity in terms of how we could advance that investment from AMP8, AMP7 so we could get started. So I think we're seeing more and more of those types of -- that type of thinking and that sense of actually how can we get going early on some of these programs. So I think it's really encouraging signs that we're seeing, and we're at the heart of trying to have those conversations and present those solutions.
Chris Laybutt
executiveAll right, thanks, Sarah. I see you're keeping us on our toes. Moving on, Martin Young is next. Go ahead, Martin.
Martin Young
analystI've got a couple of questions about the business plans. As you mentioned, the plan you have is quite large and quite ambitious. If I were to ask what the single biggest risk to that plan is — whether it's internal or external to the group — what would you say it is? And then second, you clearly have a team that has gone through the business plans of the rest of the sector in great detail. Based on that analysis, where do you think you stand out as being well positioned compared with the peer group? And on the flip side, where would you say you currently fall short of best-in-class?
Louise Beardmore
executiveThanks, Martin, for both of those questions. I'm quite clear about where I see the biggest risk. It's actually — if you think about the level of infrastructure we're delivering — it's how do we get through the sort of planning departments that exist in relation to the positions we need. And we've already started on how we mitigate that risk. That's the real benefit of building a plan based on 5 counties, because we've already been able to engage with local authorities, MPs, stakeholders, Post Councils and everybody else and construct and build that plan so we can enable delivery. So actually, that smooth run through, if you like, of getting those permissions is key. So all the work we've been doing on what we've called early mobilization, both in terms of ground conditions and planning, is designed specifically to deal with that particular risk. In addition to that, you asked me a question about where I thought we were well positioned. When we put the plan in and we talked to you about it in October, we said we were backing ourselves as a team to deliver. And we very much are, particularly in the space of around ODI.
Louise Beardmore
executiveThe mood, if you will, has shifted from bespoke to common ODIs, and certainly that holds at United Utilities too. I believe we showed this morning that we've done well — the strongest performer in the sector when it comes to the ODIs we've delivered. And as you can see from the most recent data Ofwat published, only 3 water and sewage companies are in fact earning rewards. That's mostly driven by bespoke. But when we look at how we do on the common ODIs, we've performed well, and we're not as resilient — reliant, if you will, on those bespoke ODIs. One of the key points in that, therefore, is our confidence as we move into AMP8 regarding delivering those rewards. Conversely, we've looked around at everyone else regarding whether there's anything that worries us. Some features of the North West pose a challenge, and the volume of rainfall is one of them. And I suppose, particularly on sewer flooding — so if I look at where we sit on sewer flooding relative to others, then that is Mid-Pac. But that is a feature, if you will, of the environment in which we operate.
Louise Beardmore
executiveStill, that fits into the wider picture with ODIs. So once more, I'll return to my earlier point. Given the targets we've set out and where we believe we'll land and deliver relative to them, we feel our position is genuinely strong and we're confident.
Chris Laybutt
executiveGreat. Our next question comes from Pavan Mahbubani. Go right ahead.
Pavan Mahbubani
analystSure, quickly then. First off, you said you're confident about securing a 4-star EPA rating. Could you elaborate a little on that confidence, particularly since you dropped to 3-star for 2022? Second, regarding your A- credit rating, can you remind us whether that sits at the group level or at the water company level? And related to that, when it comes to your guidance about funding your AMP8 plans without recourse to equity, does that mean a downgrade would be required? And if so, are you prepared to accept one? Then my last question concerns ODI performance this year compared with last year. Can you give us some detail on which metrics have performed especially well?
Louise Beardmore
executiveAlright, Pavan, thank you for that question. I’ll take the 4-star and ODI strength piece first, and then I’ll pass things over to Phil, and we’ll cover that point regarding credit metrics and equity in a broader sense. It’s November now, and the EPA measure runs on a calendar-year basis. At present, 6 weeks remain. With 6 weeks left, we’re exactly where we would want to be. We’re moving into what you might call the riskier stretch when it comes to weather and the challenges weather brings. So fingers are crossed. The team is working very hard, and at this point we’re exactly where we would want to be. But those next 6 weeks are still in front of us. And when I look at how the team has responded, the areas we’ve concentrated on heavily have delivered benefits for us in terms of performance across this year. We’re intensely focused on performance over the next 6 weeks. On ODIs and ODI strength, and on what has contributed this year, if you like, to the improvement we’ve seen and to the doubling of the ODI rewards — that is particularly down to improvements in water quality.
Louise Beardmore
executiveThat gives you a picture, if you will, of the water quality gains and the infrastructure that has been brought in, along with the improved resilience that has delivered those gains in relation to the ODI rewards we discussed this morning.
Philip Aspin
executiveAll right, thank you, Lou. And you're absolutely correct, Pavan. That A- rating applies to the water company. Every bit of our debt gets issued through the water company. So in terms of debt issuance, that rating matters. Regarding the plan we discussed last October, we clearly laid out the pathway there to position. On the no equity — no recourse to equity plan, that would mean average gearing of 63% across the AMP period. That rested on the adaptive planning scenario of GBP 1 billion that we've been discussing this morning. And once again, that has been received very positively by Ofwat and government more broadly. So that was one factor. The second factor was the WACC position. And we showed the Frontier Economics WACC at 3.9%. Interestingly, updating it today, that WACC position now sits at more like 4.2%. And so that, again, just keeps pushing down our overall average leverage in the AMP period. And that aligns with the A- rating we currently hold for UU Water.
Chris Laybutt
executiveGreat. Mr. Nash, thanks for waiting so patiently. The floor is yours.
Dominic Nash
analystI've got three questions if that's alright. First, I believe the autumn statement is due on the 22nd, and there are these proposals that could extend the capital allowances for tax. Obviously, capital allowances have delivered a significant benefit to your investment programme in AMP7. What I really want to understand is what effect extending these capital allowances would have, both on AMP7 and on your business plans as you head toward AMP8? Do you expect there might be a new iteration of this? My second question concerns the early assessment you mentioned in March. How likely do you see it that Ofwat allows it to be fast-tracked? And if that happened, do you think you'd be among those selected? Finally, I wanted to raise another risk probability. You said a moment ago that your WACC stands at 4.2% today. Could you walk me through how you arrive at that figure from your cost of equity number, and how it connects to your sensitivity number? I believe you land at 5.32%, which personally strikes me as somewhat low.
Louise Beardmore
executiveDominic, thank you for those questions. I’ll have Phil take the ones concerning the autumn statement and the WACC build. Regarding your 2 points on early assessment and where I believe Ofwat will land: I think we know what you know right now about that timeline and when we anticipate some early indication. The methodology Ofwat set out this time as we entered the AMP was very clear. They want companies to submit the strongest possible plan from the outset. And we believe that is exactly what we have done. We are very focused on securing those additional 30 basis points—we have submitted a plan that is ambitious, financeable, deliverable and, more importantly, affordable for customers as well. So we believe we are very well positioned in that respect. And we are obviously just as eager as you are to get a view so that we can begin work as quickly as possible. So I think all of us will keep pushing for some clarity on that date and for any early indication of when we might learn more.
Louise Beardmore
executiveStill, I believe there's a broad feeling — politically and on the regulatory side alike — that getting these settlements resolved quickly genuinely serves everyone's interests, so that we — every water company — can actually deliver the improvements customers and stakeholders are looking for. So yes, I'm quite hopeful that things will proceed quickly and with momentum. Phil, would you like to take the 2 questions?
Philip Aspin
executiveYes. Good to see you, Dominic. So, 2 questions regarding tax. First, the autumn statement — I think that's a great question. At present, full expensing continues through to FY '26. And I believe all of us are hopeful and anticipate that it could potentially be extended. Were it extended across the full AMP period, that would provide us with GBP 120 million in cash tax benefit relative to what we submitted in our plan. So clearly that is a fairly material figure. It would also assist in terms of the broader context of the plan. Obviously, as you're aware, a tax adjustment mechanism exists. So once that change occurs, it will ultimately be passed back to customers in any event. It is simply a matter of whether it gets factored into the base calculations or treated as an exposed adjustment. Regarding the WACC — the WACC position as it stands today — clearly, we presented the Ofwat early view to you, and we presented the Frontier Economics WACC back in October. If we were updating most today, my best estimate today would be — the Ofwat position would be roughly 40 basis points higher, and the Frontier Economics position would be approximately 30 basis points higher.
Philip Aspin
executiveAnd really, as you're aware, the bulk of that comes from the cost of equity. From where I sit, the cost of equity would be closer to 4.7% under the Ofwat position, while Frontier Economics puts it nearer 5.6%. If you'd like, we can follow up afterward and go through it in more detail.
Chris Laybutt
executiveGreat, thanks Dom. Now we’ll hear from Hannah Avory. Hannah, the floor is yours.
Hannah Avory
analystHannah Avory from BNP Exane. I've got questions about the finance charge and net debt. Clearly, strong results this morning on finance dispensed, with the inflation indexation component declining. Obviously, right now you carry a fairly high share of index-linked debt compared with listed peers in Ofwat guidance. I was just wondering whether you could remind us what the plan is here for your net debt in terms of the proportion of debt linked versus tax, sort of going forward in the short term and also into the next.
Philip Aspin
executiveRight, Hannah, thanks. So on net debt — roughly around about 50%, just over 50% of it is index linked. Looking ahead, we don't plan to issue any more index-linked debt in the near term, and that position will unwind gradually over time. Though, as you likely know, most of those instruments are very long-dated, so effectively it runs out quite a long way.
Chris Laybutt
executiveAll right, thank you. Wonderful. And our final question comes from John at BMO.
John Musk
analystI'd like to return to the subject of outcome delivery incentives. If I've got this right, your full year guidance for this year is GBP 50 million. And from my calculations, that seems a bit conservative, since you have GBP 200 million cumulative across the whole AMP, which would suggest something closer to GBP 60 million for the full years 2024 and 2025 in order to hit that guidance, based on how you're currently performing. Or maybe I'm overlooking some kind of end of period AMP7 adjustments that would produce a meaningfully larger ODI award in full year 2025? So any clarity on this would be useful.
Louise Beardmore
executiveJohn, thanks for asking that. Yes, it's really the ODIs that are coming in. So at the start I mentioned water quality and the improvements. This concerns some infrastructure delivery, and that comes in over the course of next year. So they aren't even when it comes to how they're spread across each of them — you're seeing the variation. So we've put its default in place. And once again, we expect additional ODI benefits to arrive next year, more of that infrastructure delivery — delivered in connection with those programs.
Chris Laybutt
executiveGreat. A few people joining late. Excellent. Nice to see you both. Bartek, the floor is yours.
Bartlomiej Kubicki
analystOnly 2 quick questions. First, regarding your carbon capture project: what impact does it have on your P&L? And what does it mean for your potential totex ODI outperformance — is it just nice to have, or does it carry any financial impact? And second, looking at your costs. Naturally, costs will rise in FY '24, as your guidance indicates. For FY '25, are you expecting some of that increase to reverse? I'm specifically asking about the cost of electricity here.
Philip Aspin
executiveAlright, I'll take up both of those points, Lou. So what I mean is, the carbon capture initiative is a modest-sized project that's being carried out at the site. It's genuinely quite exciting and innovative. So I think the main thing is really about sort of observing that and grasping the advantages. It won't create any meaningful near-term financial effect on our statements, though. When it comes to sort of expenses heading into FY '24 and, in particular, in power, we'll provide full guidance in May next year, which is when we sort of typically come out and sort of lay out what's happening in the year ahead. So that's -- actually power has been sort of pretty much fully hedged. So we have a full hedging position. So that's averaging things out. So we won't all of a sudden discover we've got a sort of big one-off gain or that prices have dropped. Because it's a smoother profile.
Chris Laybutt
executiveThanks, Bartek. Alex, the floor is yours.
Alexander Wheeler
analystPhil, I’ve just got one quick question for you. Regarding net debt, could you give us a sense of what you anticipate for the run rate in the second half, and do you expect it to follow the same kind of pattern you saw in H1?
Philip Aspin
executiveYeah. There's likely a quite brief response to that, Alex, and it largely hinges on inflation and what we expect inflation to do during that second half. Since that's clearly been a fairly significant factor behind the indexation applied to the net debt figure. So in the second half, that's probably the piece that will be volatile, so to speak.
Chris Laybutt
executiveGreat. We’ll take one final question, and it’s Dominic Nash. Welcome back.
Dominic Nash
analystI had 3 questions ready, and then Phil's answer made me swap one out. So let me put the question I held back to you. Could you remind me once more what your CSO target for 2030 is? And given what the labor policies seem to have settled on around their party conference — which I see as a meaningful step-up in CSO cleanup — could you tell me how you think that would affect your 2030 target? And is meeting that faster pace actually simpler in practical terms when it comes to supply chain constraints and spending constraints, please?
Louise Beardmore
executiveThanks, Dominic. I'll take those questions. I believe we included that chart in the presentation, so you can see exactly where combined sewer overflow spills began and where they now stand. If I take you back to 2020, the average was 59 spills. But consider what we expect to report at the close of this year — roughly 28 to 30, depending on rainfall. So we'll keep demonstrating a year-on-year decrease in combined sewer overflow spills regardless of how much rain we get. And as I mentioned, that reflects all the effort under way. On 2030 and the target, that takes us to 20 spills by the plan's end. We've had extensive discussions with Ofwat regarding that spill target, and you'll see the representation we've submitted in our business plan. Because when we set our targets, the context of where we operate matters. So as you're aware, here in the North West, rainfall is 28% higher, and more than 54% of our sewers are combined, against a national average of 30%. And if I take you back to work Stantec did about 2 years ago, they said hitting the CSO targets across England and Wales would cost GBP 56 billion, with GBP 20 billion of that in the North West.
Louise Beardmore
executiveI think one thing that's genuinely, genuinely positive, within the debate around CSOs, is that people now grasp far better what it will actually take in practical terms to achieve that step change in performance. So what matters a great deal, I think, and in the discussions we've had with the regulators, is that their aim is to create incentives for reductions. And so I'm aware there's been a lot packaged together around targets. But equally, I don't know any regulator who would want to commit to handing companies targets they were already hitting at that performance level. So I think in the plan we've set out a very strong proposition, which basically states that this will deliver the biggest step change in CSO spills nationally and that we are committed to delivering it. On your point about labor, I think that's really well put. There were discussions at the outset, roughly 18 months ago, about fast-tracking CSO reductions. I think there is a great -- well, I don't merely think it, I know it, that there is now far more understanding of what is physically required to achieve that scale of reduction. And the fact that a 2030 target, while all of us want to see the improvement, is simply physically impossible.
Louise Beardmore
executiveAnd it's not solely due to the infrastructure we'll need to construct, Dominic — there's another reason too, and I believe this matters a great deal: we must keep providing the service. Our plan involves addressing 420 overflows, yet at no stage do we kind of switch off those treatment works, kind of cease actually treating sewage. So there's a physical limiting element, so to speak, simply because we're working on infrastructure that already exists and we have to keep the service running. It's comparable to constructing a road — I can't really close it down while I carry out the upgrade. I think engagement with labor is progressing well. This afternoon at 3:00 I'm on the session with Steve Rotheram. And I think they're really eager to engage with this sector. Because I think they also believe — all parties are coming to realize — that these plans create opportunities for jobs, and that's something we've genuinely built on here in the North West, and for growth. So I think there's a chance, in many people's manifestos once those get published, to draw that link and welcome the investment.
Chris Laybutt
executiveGreat, thanks. Dom, anything else you wanted to ask? The mic is yours.
Dominic Nash
analystYes. So I think you brought up that, like probably every water company in the U.K., you're eager to secure an extra 30 basis points of allowed return on equity from Ofwat. This is sort of, I suppose, the quasi-early view, which might arrive in March, I think, as you said. Are you aware that only one company in the sector can actually reach up to that 30 basis points? Because I think the range was between plus 10 and plus 30. And presumably, you believe you're the best positioned. But do you know whether it's only one company or could several companies, additional?
Louise Beardmore
executiveDefinitely not restricted to a single company. And I believe they have laid out quite clear criteria. We think the plan we have presented meets those criteria. But to be clear, more than 1 company can earn the gold medal, that is certain.
Chris Laybutt
executiveGreat, that's quite a few questions. All right, one final chance for questions. Does anybody have a follow-up? No. I believe we've reached the end. So thanks so much. That brings our Q&A session to a close. Lou, Phil, over to you.
Louise Beardmore
executiveThanks, Chris. Look, I really appreciate the chance to speak with you this morning. And thanks as well to the many of you we've had the chance to see. Since handing in the business plan, we've been very eager to keep engaging with you and to address whatever questions you might have. But I'm very grateful for your time today and for the chance to discuss with you how we performed across the first half of the year.
Philip Aspin
executiveThanks.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete United Utilities Group PLC transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to United Utilities Group PLC earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in United Utilities Group PLC or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.