United Utilities Group PLC (UU) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 16, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Chris Laybutt
executiveMorning, everyone. I'm Chris Laybutt, Head of Investor Relations at United Utilities, as I'm sure you're all aware. Welcome to the presentation of our Fiscal 2024 results. The format is unchanged today. Our chair, David Higgins, will say a few words. After that, Lou and Phil will give a brief presentation, and then we'll open up Q&A. For Q&A, please raise your hand, as usual. Make sure your name is in the box so we can see who you are. That'll be terrific. Okay, I think we're ready to go. David, over to you.
David Higgins
executiveThanks, Chris, and welcome everybody, and I appreciate you being with us today. Although media scrutiny of our industries carries on, at United Utilities we stay firmly dedicated to delivering both now and over the long term for our customers. The team led by Lou has delivered another strong year, and as Lou and Phil will walk you through this morning, we keep performing well against our regulatory commitments despite what has been a very volatile year where the weather is concerned, and that represents a fantastic outcome for the whole organization. The coming 12 months will be extremely busy, with the general election approaching here, and of course the finalization of our regulatory determination, yet the board looks forward to moving into what will be a transformative period for our business. We understand how important dividend payments are as a key element of shareholder returns, and the board has proposed a final dividend of GBP 0.3319 per share, which brings our total dividend for the year to just under GBP 0.50. That aligns with our policy of growing the dividend at CPIH plus inflation. I'm now glad to hand things over to you, Lou.
Louise Beardmore
executiveThank you, David, and good morning everyone. It's wonderful to have all of you joining us today. As usual, our CFO, Phil Aspin, is here with me. We'll begin with a brief update on the price review, then move into our operational and financial results for the year. Naturally, we've set aside some time for questions, and both Phil and I will be glad to take them. Before we dive into the details, I'd like to offer a quick picture of where things stand. We keep delivering on both the operational and financial fronts, and the results we're announcing today are strong. We're strengthening our capabilities to drive future growth, and through accelerated investment we've already made improvements in priority areas. Our finances are strong and flexible, with low levels of gearing. Above all, we have a solid track record, so we're very well placed to deliver more improvements for customers and strong returns as we move into AMP8. As a quick reminder, here's the AMP8 timeline, and I know you're all, just like us, watching the 12th of June date, when Ofwat will publish their draft determination.
Louise Beardmore
executiveBy that point, we'll understand much better the costs, the scope, and how they intend to handle the adaptive plan we've proposed. Then in August, we will submit and publish the response we send back on that draft determination. Dialogue and discussion, though, will carry on through the autumn and on into December, when the final determination comes to us. Once we have the FD, we anticipate being in a position at that stage to set out our updated financial framework, dividend policy included, in early 2025. The plan makes me genuinely excited and proud, and I'm sure you recall that it is a substantial plan — one that features a seven-fold increase in environmental investment — and we are very well prepared. It is a financeable plan, and a strong financial position today underpins our capacity to fund the growth. It is an affordable plan, with one of the lowest bill increases in the sector, backed by our proposals to assist more than one in six customers through GBP 525 million worth of affordability support. And thirdly, and most importantly, it is a deliverable plan — one that sees us drive change in the things that matter most for our customers and the environment: improving water quality and sufficiency, reducing storm overflow spills, and reducing pollution and sewer flooding.
Louise Beardmore
executiveWhat genuinely excites us at this moment is that work is already underway throughout our five great counties—mobilizing the supply chain, developing that internal capability, and putting faster solutions in place to address spills. As you'd anticipate, we're having very constructive, open conversations with regulators and government regarding how we meet these challenges. Our statutory obligations aren't really in dispute, but there's plenty of productive discussion around phasing and the best delivery points, along with the kinds of engineering solutions we're proposing to deploy. We've had genuinely encouraging talks about the adaptive planning scenarios we submitted in the plan, since we believe that approach delivers the best value for customers. You'll undoubtedly have many questions about this, and Phil and I will both be glad to address them once we reach Q&A. Yet this isn't solely about AMP8. Several long-term investment drivers exist, and those can be broadly placed into, I'd say, three main buckets. First, shifting expectations regarding environmental performance—and rightly so. Second, asset replacement and resource adequacy. The focus throughout is on creating long-term resilience in our network.
Louise Beardmore
executiveAlso, thirdly, climate change affects us daily in ways we can feel and see, so building the appropriate infrastructure to react is essential. That won't be accomplished within a single AMP. As we go forward, we're envisaging a program of investment spanning multiple AMPs. Being on track with AMP7 capital delivery is something we're genuinely pleased about, and we have delivered 100% of our capital program commitments. That delivery matters a great deal, since it builds stakeholder confidence in how well we can complete projects and programs on schedule. Mobilization for AMP8 is happening at pace. We're in dialogue with our supply chain partners, and several contracts have already been awarded. Our AMP8 programs are already underway, and roughly GBP 400 million of investment has been accelerated into this AMP, which helps us speed up CSO improvements so work gets going immediately. Thanks to the accelerated infrastructure program, we were able to begin that really important work early. In our plan we propose tackling 420 CSOs, and through the accelerated funding we secured agreement in April of last year to start work on 150 projects in AMP7. On top of that, progress is really strong. That includes fast-tracking solutions at Windermere, where every scheme enters construction this calendar year.
Louise Beardmore
executiveBeyond that, we keep examining ways to innovate so that delivery can be improved, and work is already moving forward on projects at several of our high-spilling overflows. I'd like to use this moment to give you a quick case study. The overflow that spilled the most during 2022 was located at Cargo, a wastewater treatment facility situated just outside Carlisle. Rather than holding off, and drawing on the new team of 500 people now in place, both within the company and throughout our supply chain, we could act immediately to put a modular solution in place, which has delivered more storage and treatment. The solution developed at Cargo has cut spills by 90%, and it offers a prototype that we are now applying across this region at our smaller, more rural CSOs, with several key sites under construction and due for delivery by September of this year. What the accelerated CSO investment has taught us so far is that no single approach suits every situation when it comes to the solutions required. A number of our much bigger projects will involve huge new underground storage tanks being built, followed by modifications to treatment works, yet for others like Cargo, an accelerated solution delivered in the best possible way can have a very large impact and, more crucially, achieve that impact fast.
Louise Beardmore
executiveImproving the well-being of our rivers is among our strategic priorities, and we want to deliver a step change there. Based on the EA's published figures from the beginning of the AMP, we accounted for approximately 18% of the attributable reasons why rivers in the Northwest fail to reach good ecological status. A plan is in place that will cut our footprint considerably, and we aim to bring that figure to under 5% by the close of AMP8, measured against the same baseline. Alongside that, we are collaborating with local government as well as partners in agriculture and rural land management to do more for the health of our waterways — something shown by the partnership approach within the Cumbria River Restoration Programme, which picked up a European Riverprize recently and is now on the shortlist for a global award. Our hope is that by leading the way, we will prompt others — whether voluntarily or via legislation — to make the major step change in practices that they also need to make. Coming together and working jointly will be essential if we are to drive the improvements required at a societal level to enhance river health. Let's move on now to how we performed operationally.
Louise Beardmore
executiveThis year has been a solid one in terms of the performance turned in by every one of my colleagues at United Utilities, hitting roughly 80% of the commitments we set ourselves. There are, of course, areas where we can still do better, but even so, this shows genuinely strong delivery on the things customers value most. On top of that, the gains were achieved against a set of targets that had been made even tougher, and the upshot is a customer ODI reward for this year of GBP 34 million — the highest we have ever recorded. While that is our best-ever reward, the weather has done us damage, and when we entered the winter period we had been expecting a bigger ODI reward for this year. As you saw in the trading update we issued in February, rainfall across the North West has been extraordinarily heavy — the wettest year in 69 years, with 14 named storms, every one of them striking our region. You will have noticed the effects not just on us as water companies but on farming, on construction, and on the building of new power infrastructure. As with those other sectors, the consequences for us have been considerable, and my colleagues have responded heroically to the substantial impacts generated by storm activity: flooding, power interruptions — all of them factors that have hit us here in the North West.
Louise Beardmore
executiveThat has affected where we stand on ODI, and we've seen roughly a GBP 30 million hit to reward compared with what we had forecast to achieve as we entered the winter months, which brings the post-tax reward down to GBP 34 million. Even so, in spite of these difficulties, we have still been able to turn in a strong performance overall. We won't have certainty until July, when our final EPA rating comes through, and I would never want to second-guess or assume, but for the last 12 years we have been a solid three- or four-star, and we believe we are on course for four-star this year. A great many measures feed into the EPA, and I am glad to report that, notwithstanding the weather, we have been green on the EA's assessment of serious pollutions for 12 years — the only company to achieve that. Despite the progress we are making with accelerated solutions, looking at storm overflows, we did see a 40% rise in their activation owing to weather and because more monitors are now in the ground, with 100% of our CSOs monitored. At the start of May, we launched our real-time map, which lets anyone see what is happening at overflow locations and gives customers the ability to make informed decisions based on live and accurate data.
Louise Beardmore
executiveAlthough the accelerated infrastructure delivery project has let us begin work earlier, and we're already starting to see advantages from the new team and the solutions we're beginning to deploy, the implementation and construction we need to put in the ground is going to take time, and that will take time to show up in the benefits in our numbers. On water, we've hit our leakage target for the 18th year, delivering over a 7% reduction in leakage in AMP7, and our Water Quality First program has been hugely impactful and, as a result, supported a 27% reduction in drinking water complaints so far this AMP. We've also been improving our assets by cleaning over 15,000 kilometers of water mains as we continue to focus on delivering high-quality water to our customers every day. For the second time, I'm really pleased to say that we've been named as the number one water and sewage company in the Institute of Customer Service UKCSI Index, and we've maintained our position within the top five for the entire utility industry out of 36. An excellent result, especially as this metric is seen as a good industry cross-comparison of service.
Louise Beardmore
executiveService matters, and it always will, but the next AMP brings a greater number of customer service measures. We believe we're in a strong position to make the most of those opportunities, having earned rewards on every MEX measure in each year of AMP7 to date. The count of customers gaining from our wide-ranging affordability support has risen again. Through our schemes, we now assist over 375,000 customers in this AMP, which matters enormously to customers given today's economic conditions. Thanks to the stronger support and the investment we've put into both technology processes and colleague capability, our cash performance keeps delivering excellent results, and our bad debt charge has fallen to 1.6% this year. The future opportunities genuinely excite me, and our people and our talent will be what helps us reach our future goals. Seeing such strong engagement from our colleagues this year has been terrific, with engagement levels of 81% meeting U.K. high-performance benchmarks. We're delighted to be named the Water Industry Skills Employer of the Year for 2023, and having the right talent and capability to deliver is vital to our future success.
Louise Beardmore
executiveBeyond that, we keep nurturing the young talent of tomorrow as well. You might recall that when we all met in person last year, I brought along our full-year result, Sam, who had won the U.K. Apprentice of the Year, and it gives me real pride to share that you have another award winner in your ranks. Yesterday, Amelia Swain was given a Young Engineer Award for outstanding achievement. That's a great result for her and for our apprentice team, who now have so many excellent role models, and it stands as genuine proof of the calibre of colleagues here at UU and of how well we draw in and grow great people. Last, on ESG performance, we keep making solid progress on our six carbon pledges and have already gone past our 2030 goal for peatland improvement. That brings carbon benefits, and it also assists in lowering flood risk, enhancing water quality, and boosting biodiversity. When it comes to delivering our environmental programme, we hit 100% of our WINEP outputs on schedule for AMP7, which, as I mentioned, matters greatly — not only for the environmental outcomes it produces, but also for showing we can deliver for customers, communities, and regulators. We are out in front across the sector on vulnerability assistance, with more than 400,000 customers now on our priority services register.
Louise Beardmore
executiveOnce more we put in a solid showing on the ShareAction workforce disclosure, and our 89% score came in 18% above the U.K. average and 31% above the utilities average. Then, on top of all that, we hold strong positions across a variety of ESG indices: we've kept our CDP climate disclosure score at A minus, we're rated world-class in the Dow Jones Sustainability Index, and we've had our Fair Tax Mark accreditation for the fifth year in a row. With that, I'll pass things to Phil, who will walk you through some of the financials.
Phil Aspin
executiveThanks, Lou, and good morning, everyone. To start with, I'll cover the financial highlights. We're putting in a strong performance, with cumulative ROI at 7.9% real. Consistent with guidance, revenue rose by roughly 8%, mainly because of the inflation rate increase to tariffs. Underlying operating profit grew to GBP 518 million, with underlying EPS of GBP 0.333. As expected, dividend per share has gone up in line with our policy to GBP 0.4978, and lastly, our gearing remains in the lower half of our target range at 59%. As a reminder, here is our financial framework for this AMP. It stays unchanged. Our ROI guidance for the AMP is between 6%-8% real. We continue to forecast an RCV growth rate of 4%-5% per annum, and as I just said, our dividend policy is for growth in line with CPIH inflation. Lastly, we continue to benefit from our strong balance sheet, with gearing targeted in the range of 55%-65%, resulting in an A3, A-rating at the water company level. After we receive a final determination in December, we'll provide an update on our financial framework going forward. So now let's turn to ROI. On the left-hand side, we have presented the ROI progression chart for AMP6 and AMP7 to date.
Phil Aspin
executiveAs you can see, during the current year we delivered a solid return of 8.5%, which is 4.5% above the base return. As I said earlier, our AMP7 guidance for ROI is still in the 6%-8% real range. Over on the right-hand side, we show our cumulative ROI. As you can see, financing has been the main driver of outperformance, with tax and ODIs partly offset by TOTEX and retail. That produces a cumulative ROI of 7.9%. Moving next to the underlying profits bridge. Operating profit of GBP 518 million is up GBP 77 million versus the prior year. That reflects inflation increases to revenue, which more than offset the effect of inflation in giving higher OPEX. Revenue rose by GBP 145 million, reflecting the inflation increase permitted under our revenue cap as well as consumption increases compared with last year. Underlying operating costs went up by GBP 41 million. The biggest inflationary increases here were in power and labor costs. Other costs have been tightly controlled, partly mitigating the inflationary increases and leaving operating costs slightly better than guidance. Underlying net finance expense for the year came in at GBP 293 million, GBP 182 million lower than last year, largely reflecting lower inflation applied to our index-linked debt.
Phil Aspin
executiveCash interest went up by GBP 23 million as interest rates climbed, yet we kept comfortably beating the iBoxx index. Turning to FY25, we anticipate the underlying net finance expense will be roughly flat versus the prior year. On underlying tax, we're recognizing the small credit this year, and we expect full expensing to keep benefiting us going forward, which means no current tax charge for FY25. All of this gives us an underlying profit of GBP 227 million and EPS of 33.3 pence. Our balance sheet keeps showing financial strength. Gearing at 59% is among the lowest levels in the sector. RCV has risen to GBP 14.7 billion, up GBP 700 million from last year, and net debt stood at GBP 8.8 billion. You might recall that during the summer, we finished a GBP 1.8 billion pension scheme buy-in deal with Legal & General. That covered two-thirds of our liabilities, greatly cutting balance sheet risk and any possible future funding needs. Lou already noted this morning how we're operationally preparing ourselves for AMP8. With our AMP7 financing requirements fully funded, we're now well along in funding our AMP8 programme and have raised roughly GBP 1.6 billion this year.
Phil Aspin
executiveSo because of that, our liquidity is solid — more than GBP 2 billion, which funds us through 2026. On the funding side, we've raised roughly GBP 1.7 billion to date under our sustainable finance framework, and investor engagement has been at really encouraging levels. In February, following an absence of nearly 20 years, we returned to the public Eurobond market. The deal was received very well — the order book was 3.8 times oversubscribed — which let us both increase the size of the transaction and bring pricing in to roughly our sterling benchmark yields. Going forward, we anticipate being an active issuer under our sustainable finance framework, supported by our strong green credentials and our sizable environmental investment program. Taxonomy disclosures will come with our FY25 year-end reporting, and until then we'll keep using our existing framework as we gear up for AMP8. So, before I wrap up, here's our technical guidance for FY25. Revenue should rise by about 10%, with roughly 3% from inflation, offset by K-factor, and 7% from timing. Underlying operating costs should climb above inflation owing to higher business rates, regulatory charges, and IRE. Depreciation should go up by GBP 30 million-GBP 40 million, reflecting growth in the underlying asset base.
Phil Aspin
executiveWe anticipate that underlying finance expense will stay level, given full expensing, and no tax payment is expected in the coming year. As we prepare for AMP8, capital investment should step up, and the top end of that range reflects an early launch of AMP8 projects. ODIs are forecast to rise once more this year, with a reward at minimum matching the GBP 34 million we booked into FY2024. Lastly, our progressive dividend keeps rising in step with inflation, and our policy points to an FY2025 dividend per share of GBP 0.5187. To sum up, we are producing robust returns, with cumulative ROI of 7.9% and RCV growth tracking at 4%-5% per annum. A strong balance sheet leaves us well placed for what lies ahead, and we have already begun funding our AMP8 investment program. The total dividend per share for the year came to GBP 0.4978, consistent with our policy and with growth in line with CPIH. Thank you, and I will now hand back to Lou.
Louise Beardmore
executiveAlright, thank you, Phil. Before we take questions, I want to highlight a few key points. Even with the weather and all those named storms, we're doing well on both the operational and financial fronts. There's more work ahead to push further improvements, and we've put forward some truly ambitious plans — and more importantly, plans centered on what matters to our stakeholders. On the financial side, as Phil has told you, we're in a very strong position, and we aren't sitting idle. We've already begun. And finally, most importantly, I want to thank the team here at UU. We have some incredible, engaged, and talented colleagues who, just like me, are deeply committed and determined to deliver the step change that everyone, including us, wants to see. Thank you very much for your time today, and we'll now open it up to questions.
Chris Laybutt
executiveGreat, thanks a lot, Lou. And thank you, Phil. Now, Jenny Ping, I believe you were the first one in the queue. Go right ahead.
Jenny Ping
analystExcellent. Morning, all. Two questions, if I may. Lou, first off, I'd like to get a sense of the kinds of talks you're involved in, or that you understand Ofwat is having with Defra and the EA, concerning TOTEX phasing, since clearly there's still a degree of debate about when a portion of that CapEx has to be deployed. So I was just wondering what conversations are underway there. Tied to that, I suppose, is what kind of discussion is on the table regarding this gateway mechanism, in terms of the uncertainty element that might only emerge much later in the AMP? Any commentary on that would be great. And then finally, I just want to understand some of the press coverage about assets that have gone unmapped and undetected in the water industry, and get a sense from you as to whether this has any bearing on UU. Thank you.
Louise Beardmore
executiveOkay, thanks Jenny, and good morning everyone. First off, you'll notice in that chart we discussed our adaptive plan, and I think you'll recall that we essentially filed a plan which said, "Look, we understand these are regulatory and statutory drivers, but we believe there's a better approach to delivering some of these projects and programs." And that led us to file a plan that basically said, "This is the 13.7, but there's a GBP 12.7 billion plan here," acknowledging there's a GBP 1 billion that we had which essentially constituted this adaptive plan. Those discussions have gone exceptionally well with the E.A., Ofwat and Defra, and there were certain specific schemes, particularly involving Davyhulme and similar locations, and we included them in the case, put the case study in, if you recall, into the business plan itself. So those plans have been — those conversations, I should say, have gone extremely well, and we remain in dialogue with regulators, and we would anticipate seeing that reflected in the position on the 12th of June. So that's the first part. The second part, and I think it's a really important point that you've raised, concerns the gateway mechanism.
Louise Beardmore
executiveFrom Ofwat's perspective, one difficulty in reviewing the plan is that comparing base costs is far simpler for regulators, yet with enhancement costs—where you have many projects and programs—those vary enormously from one another. Assessing them from a cost standpoint poses a real challenge, and likewise, as you correctly point out, there is the uncertainty mechanism, given that you are pricing projects and programs today for construction work that will occur at some future point. I believe we may well witness—and Ofwat themselves seem to have begun hinting at this—some type of gated mechanism, possibly even applying to certain of the bigger projects and programs. That is something we at UU would welcome, since anything offering a chance to examine, or giving us the ability to examine, uncertainty mechanisms, along with the opportunity to confirm that costs and solutions are right, matters for customers as well. So I think come the 12th of June, we will see both of those elements: their view of our adaptive plan, and second, the mechanism regarding those gateways.
Louise Beardmore
executiveOn your other question, I believe it concerned assets that are unmapped — unmapped with regard to the wastewater network, that is. If you recall, we took on private pumping stations and networks of that kind, so those transferred from local authorities over to water companies, and they keep being updated and refreshed as we achieve that wider integration of those assets. So it isn't really a UU-specific matter; it's an industry-wide matter that all of us are watching.
Chris Laybutt
executiveAlright, wonderful. Many thanks, Jenny. Sarah Lister, the floor is yours.
Analyst
analystThank you. Chris, I feel as though I cut in front there, but I'll accept it. Good morning. Lou, I have two questions at quite a high level, if I may. The first concerns dividend policies, and I want to emphasize that I am not at all attempting to pull you into a discussion about your own dividend policy. What interests me is how you view the wider, longer-term development of dividends within that investment proposition framework. In the regulated utility sector, many of these companies are moving strongly toward a growth narrative. So certain people argue that perhaps, with regulated equity expanding, you ought to be distributing more. Others might argue that you should be putting that capital to work for growth. So I am simply curious about your perspective, how you think about this in a very broad, longer-term sector sense. And then second, just to move away from Jenny's question, Lou, you mentioned this in your presentation. Yesterday the regulator again discussed how important it is to take that longer-term view of investment. Could you say a bit more about how significant the wall of CapEx arriving behind AMP8 that you have in your LTDS is, how that shaped your AMP8 submission, and to what extent do you believe the regulator will actually examine it?
Analyst
analystI guess what I'm saying is, the amount you're spending on AMP9 enhancements seems to be even larger than AMP8. To what extent do you expect they will take that into account? Thanks.
Louise Beardmore
executiveYeah. Great. Thanks, Sarah. Good to see you this morning. So I guess there are two questions. There's a lot of talk out there about dividend policy, as you'd expect. I mean, we've said, "Look, we're not going to confirm anything until we've got the final determination," and you wouldn't expect us to do so. And there are plenty of competing narratives. Is it a growth trajectory? What's the importance of that return more broadly? As you know, this isn't just a one-AMP position in terms of growth for United Utilities. In fact, far from it. It continues to grow quite significantly. So I'll let Phil pick up the question more broadly on dividend in a second. But in terms of our AMP8, AMP9 submission, I think what's really important is the way that we built our AMP8 plan was we understood what were the statutory obligations that we needed to deliver. Just as a reminder, 93% of those enhancement programmes are actually statutory obligations. Then we then looked at the sequencing of that plan. We didn't start with it or start with the development with a plan that was in any way CapEx constrained. What we started to understand was what are our legal obligations, what makes sense to deliver in what sequence, and how do we do that?
Louise Beardmore
executiveAs you correctly point out, AMP9 and AMP10 appear to be even larger than AMP8. Another highly significant element matters when it comes to constructing these plans. One aspect is whether you can deliver them, but another is whether you can sequence and manage your organisation too. A major consideration I frequently mention involves being able to sequence outages and the delivery of this plan. This isn't a case where I'm building a new asset that can be done behind the scenes and simply unveiled. It's infrastructure that must be integrated with the assets we currently have, so there is a limit on what can actually be delivered while running an operation and continuing to meet your service obligations. So there are a number of factors you take into account, but I think the important thing is the 93% in this year's or in this AMP that relates to statutory obligations. Phil, would you like to take the question on dividend?
Phil Aspin
executiveOkay, thanks, Sarah. A few things I’d like to note here. First off, we fully recognize how much dividends matter to our shareholders and to a number of our investors. A dividend policy really does need to be sustainable over the long term — that’s essential. So that’s going to be one of the things we weigh. It also matters that we’re giving investors a fair return. And taking all of that together, I think you then circle back to consider, I suppose, the choices available around things like dividend reinvestment options, so shareholders can make their own selections as part of that process too. All of that will factor into the consideration as we work through the capital structure and the approach that comes out of the FD, though we’re still very far away from that point right now.
Chris Laybutt
executiveAll right. Thanks a lot, Sarah. Mr. Freshney, I believe you're the next one.
Mark Freshney
analystHi there. Thanks, Chris. Two questions from me. First, regarding the ODIs — it looks like today is when you officially abandoned the GBP 200 million ODI target for this AMP. That was a five-year goal, and you appear to be suggesting it was really a one-year thing, but I don't believe that's right, since it's a five-year plan. So which specific areas fell short of your expectations, and where did you struggle? I'd assume there were several, because if you set a 200 target, you'd have intended to hit it fairly comfortably. Second, a question for you, Phil. If it wasn't clear to all of us back in October, it certainly should be clear now that the risk environment for these kinds of businesses means you almost certainly wouldn't want to sit at the top end of your 55%-65% net debt to RAB range, since you'd lack flexibility to do things in an AMP. And your business plan, even under the adaptive planning scenario, brings us to the top of that range. And I suppose developments like what's happening with HoldCo debt elsewhere will only reinforce that.
Mark Freshney
analystSo how at ease are you with bankrolling that business plan seven or eight months after it was filed?
Louise Beardmore
executiveAlright, thanks Mark. I'll take the first question, and then pass things over to Phil. So yes, it's me — the new Chief Executive, so to speak, taking a look at where we stand on ODI. Previously, GBP 200 million was on the table. Weather has hit us hard, Mark, when it comes to the performance we've seen on sewer flooding, customer minutes lost, and some of those activities affected by the weather. But that's actually not the issue. It's the knock-on effect. We had certain deliverables tied to project delivery that we simply couldn't get to on the ground because of ground conditions. So a number of factors are at play there. What matters, though, Mark, I think, is that we are delivering ODI returns. Only a few companies do, and the ODI returns we're delivering have risen year-over-year. So this is about building that capability year-over-year, and that's basically what we've been doing and where my focus lies in building that capability within the organization. I've noticed some remarks this morning about it being a very conservative number that we've put out there this morning, but the bottom line is we're very mindful, and I'm a year — well, a quarter in, in terms of some measurement, and in fact we've had a very wet start.
Louise Beardmore
executiveWe feel good about the 34, and we're pressing harder to get more, given the context of the ODIs we're really pursuing. Still, that's a solid result. It comes on top of year-over-year gains in delivery, and you can be sure we're very focused on it. Phil, would you like to take the funding question?
Phil Aspin
executiveSure, absolutely. And Mark, I think you laid out the situation from October pretty well, and as you mentioned, under that adaptive planning scenario, our gearing progressively moves toward the top end of our range as we approach the end of the AMP. So that lands in 2029, 2030. That's fairly far off in the future from that standpoint. I think there's still a great deal for us to grasp regarding where the determination ultimately comes out, since the adaptive plan we set out included nothing for quality or award assessment—meaning how Ofwat evaluates our plans. It also had nothing regarding ODI performance and returns. We're a top quartile performer in the sector, and we'd anticipate being in positive territory as we move into the next AMP on those factors too. We'll need to consider all of it together to see how it shapes our decision. We begin from a position of having one of the strongest balance sheets in the sector, if not the strongest. We're well placed to handle the growth that lies ahead of us.
Louise Beardmore
executiveMark, one thing worth adding specifically about ODIs: that guidance reflects a post-tax position, which matters for your models. So in terms of the ODIs, that guidance number is post-tax.
Chris Laybutt
executiveThanks. All right, many thanks, Mark. Ollie, the floor is yours.
Analyst
analystThank you very much. I have two questions, if I may. First, at the half-year results you offered a view on how the draft determinations might turn out. So any updated thinking from you on that—especially regarding the allowed term—would be helpful, to whatever extent you're able to discuss it. Second, turning to the CapEx plan you've submitted, what portion of it do you expect to be approved? What's your current thinking on that? Thank you.
Louise Beardmore
executiveThanks, Ollie. I'll likely address your most recent question first. That's a great question. We're looking forward to 12 June 2022 with regard to the TOTEX plan. What matters, I think, is that the 12.7 adaptive plan will, I believe, keep being received very positively. So I suspect that will be where we start. Discussion will carry on. Way back at the start, when I talked with Jenny about how we'd probably see these kinds of gated mechanisms around TOTEX, we would genuinely welcome that. I return to the point that 93% of these projects and programs are in fact regulatory requirements, so they aren't, you know, nice-to-haves, if that makes sense. So I think we wait with keen anticipation for what emerges on 12 June 2022. So it's not a figure I'd guide to beyond the 12.7 we've discussed this morning. And on the draft determination more broadly, we clearly expect at that stage guidance on what we'll see concerning the quality assessment. That is, Ofwat's judgment of the plan's quality, and bear in mind those outstanding plans have a 30 basis points uplift, and that range concerning the quality of what you've actually submitted.
Louise Beardmore
executiveWe would anticipate getting clarity regarding the WACC, and also on the actual reward spread along with the TOTEX position in a wider sense. So when those announcements are released, I believe it's genuinely important for us to examine it both as a whole and to gain a sense of what lies beneath the headline figures too. Phil?
Phil Aspin
executiveOkay, so I suppose I'll start by touching on the WACC and a few of those return points as well, Ollie. I guess the WACC is going to be the headline figure that everybody zeros in on right away. Just to remind everyone, in Ofwat's final methodology, what was it? Effectively 3.3%, with a cost of equity of 4.1%. And I think at the time, we published our Frontier Economics report in which we discussed the 3.9% WACC that featured in our adaptive planning scenario. We've since updated that and rolled it forward. And I think if you take the mathematical roll-forward of Ofwat's position, you land at roughly a 3.6% cost of capital and a 4.6% cost of equity. We've refreshed our Frontier Economics work, and that gives a cost of capital range that, in our view, is more balanced at 3.9% to 4.2%. That implies a cost of equity of 5.4% to 6%, effectively, in real terms. I think the really key thing to bear in mind here is that people frequently treat this as a purely mathematical exercise, and it is. But you do need to think about the look-back period, especially for things like beta, given that we've been through a highly atypical five-year stretch.
Phil Aspin
executiveTo start, COVID came first, and then a high-inflation setting followed—both of those have had an effect on beta. Looking ahead, we have a substantial investment profile, and as Mark kind of pointed out, a growing amount of risk in the sector that has to be managed. Each of those factors will have a somewhat atypical influence on beta. So my view is that this pushes it strongly toward the top end of the range I mentioned. That 4.2% cost of capital works out to roughly a 6% cost of equity. Now, I realize that when you examine cross-checks and try to see how this compares more widely, we have done analysis looking at hybrid debt. I know Ofgem and the RIIO-3 price control are considering hybrid debt options as a cross-check there, and that would place your cost of equity up at that 6% or above. And I'm not sure whether Dominic is on the call today, but I know Dominic carried out a fairly extensive investor survey on investor requirements and what they seek in terms of investability following a price review process. Their requirements there, I believe, with over 80 investors surveyed, point to a cost of equity of 5.8% or higher.
Phil Aspin
executiveAll of that is fairly mutually reinforcing in terms of where we land on the WACC position. I think it's probably important just to emphasize that it isn't only WACC, though. Plenty of other factors matter a great deal and need to be taken into account. So ODIs are going to be really, really important — understanding both where performance commitment levels get set and also the incentive rates, plus how powerful ODIs are. As a top-performing company, we would expect to have, sort of, ODI earning opportunities as we look ahead into AMP 8. And then, sort of, on cost allowances — cost allowances will be key, understanding how that gets set and also how Ofwat sets price control deliverables within that context. In particular, I'll be looking to make sure that any approach to price control deliverables is symmetric and permits portfolio management of the overall delivery of the TOTEX program. If it isn't, that will be, again, a further risk and a further challenge to manage through. Those are the sort of broad return issues that I'm, sort of, looking at and how I'm thinking about the price review process.
Analyst
analystMuch appreciated.
Chris Laybutt
executiveAll right, thanks, Ollie. Pervin Mayburmani, you're up last — but certainly not least. Go ahead.
Analyst
analystThanks, Chris. Good morning, everyone. Appreciate you taking my questions. I've got two, please. Could you give us a bit more detail on the conversations you've had with Ofwat, with the EA, and perhaps with Defra, if those have been happening, regarding your business plan submission — and where you think, based on the queries or any other discussions, how your plan stands and how that shapes your thinking on the draft? Then my second question concerns the recent BBC headlines about the incident in Windermere. I was wondering whether you could provide any further detail on what happened there from a UU perspective, and any lessons learned, if there are any. Thank you.
Louise Beardmore
executiveOkay, thanks, Perv. I appreciate both questions. Let me start with the second one, then circle back.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete United Utilities Group PLC transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to United Utilities Group PLC earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in United Utilities Group PLC or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.