Verbio SE (VBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 9, 2023

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Energy Oil, Gas and Consumable Fuels earnings 82 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Just a note that this session is being recorded. This call comes after the release of the half-year figures for 2022 and 2023, and they'll be presented by CEO Claus Sauter along with Alina Köhler from Investor Relations. Once the presentation wraps up, the floor will open for questions. With that said, Mr. Sauter, over to you.

Claus Sauter

executive
#2

Thanks so much. Good morning, everyone — ladies and gentlemen — and welcome to our quarterly call. I'm here in the United States, so good morning to you. I'd like to begin with our presentation. The agenda: we want to show you the new segment reporting, which will begin in the next business year. The key highlights in the first half and in Q2 2022 to 2023. Our financial results, segment results, and finally an update and an outlook for the rest of the year and the coming year. Regarding the new reporting system. Next year, we want to change how we report on the business drivers, and this is first generation, second generation, and specialties. In the first-generation, biofuels and first-generation biofuels are biofuels based on arable feedstocks, like non-food grade grains and oil seeds, rapeseed oil. This is rapeseed oil methyl ester and bioethanol. The second segment is advanced second-generation biofuels, and these are biofuels based on waste and residues. For example, corn stover here in the United States, wheat straw, rice paddy in India. These kind of agriculture residues. The product is mainly RNG, so renewable natural gas, and a portion of about 10% of our biodiesel production, which is advanced biodiesel.

Claus Sauter

executive
#3

When distinguishing first-generation from second-generation biofuel, the feedstock is what matters. The product isn't the deciding factor—it's the feedstock. Last, the third segment is specialties, and that segment covers high-quality pharma glycerine, sterols, and down the road chemical feedstocks, plus proteins. All of these come as co-products out of our current output, where we add value along the chain and pull out valuable components from the feedstock we don't need for the biofuel definition. Within this specialties segment, we serve a range of markets, such as pharma and chemical applications. For the most part, these specialties don't end up in biofuel uses. Now that we have a stable framework for second-generation biofuel in Germany and across Europe, we raised the volume of second-generation biofuel. That is squarely our focus, and roughly 40% of our CO2 savings come from advanced second-generation biofuels. During the first half of the business year, we delivered around 1.5 million tons of CO2 savings to the biofuel industry. We posted record RNG output in the first half of the business year, particularly in Q2 2022/2023. RNG production keeps rising. As I mentioned, Verbio delivered 1.5 million tons of CO2 savings in the first half.

Claus Sauter

executive
#4

Folks are abandoning their round trips between Paris and New York. Roughly 40% of the CO2 reductions come from advanced second generation biofuels, and we reaffirm our guidance for the business year. Now, turning to RNG production. RNG output rose 22% year-over-year, driven by added capacity in Germany along with the ramp up in the United States and in India. For biodiesel and ethanol production, capacity utilization stood at 96%. In the chart, you can see biodiesel production, which totaled 158,000 tons, 71,000 tons of ethanol and 261 GWh of RNG. EBIT-EBITDA declined from EUR 147 million to EUR 48.9 million, mainly because of falling sales prices, in particular for bioethanol. We'll get into the details later when we show you the margin situation, along with higher raw material prices and a sharp rise in energy costs — especially energy costs, with natural gas and electricity up 400% compared to Q2 of the last business year. Our net cash position from during the last quarter fell by 32% to EUR 177.5 million. Higher RNG inventories and investments in PP&E, PPE for future growth, as well as tax payments, offset the cash inflow.

Claus Sauter

executive
#5

Now, moving into the details, I'll pass things over to Alina, who leads our IR. I skipped one slide — the equity ratios. The equity ratio rose to 74%, which demonstrates that our financial stability is still strong. Alina, over to you now.

Alina Köhler

executive
#6

Thank you. Yes. Hello, everyone. I’ll dive straight in. Even with the ethanol market challenges we encountered during the last quarter, we achieved EUR 48.9 million in EBITDA, which was really powered by the biodiesel segment and confirms what a strong benefit it is for us to have a wide product portfolio. The greater sales in biodiesel effectively more than offset the weaker sales in bioethanol. That said, we still did not succeed in holding EBITDA at the prior-year level, as the slide shows. In the same quarter last year, we posted EUR 147 million in EBITDA, and this year, as I mentioned, it is near EUR 50 million, since EBITDA was weighed down by several factors. First, as Claus already noted, material costs were higher, and energy costs were also higher, up more than 400% year-over-year, along with a rise in personal expenses. Personal expenses increased by roughly EUR 6 million year-over-year, because we are expanding our workforce here in line with our strategic growth plans. We also paid inflation bonuses during the last quarter, so that contributed a small amount to the increase in personal expenses.

Alina Köhler

executive
#7

We also saw some adverse currency movements on a year-over-year basis, and that created a drag of EUR 12 million. That isn't cash relevant, however, so it simply flowed through the P&L and is tied to our U.S. dollar cash. Moving to the next slide and digging a bit deeper into the biodiesel segment, the chart shows that in biodiesel as well — not only renewable natural gas but biodiesel too — we hit record production levels. That's largely because of very strong utilization in Canada as well, which also lifted our sales, and our revenue rose thanks to higher biodiesel prices in North America along with higher sales prices for the high value glycerine we make from rapeseed oil. As I mentioned earlier, the higher sales level didn't really carry through to the bottom line because higher input costs weighed on EBITDA. What's really worth noting is that we remain well above the long-term average. And last year's figure of EUR 96 million EBITDA was in fact affected by attractive rapeseed oil prices, which we also communicated last year. Truly, the year-over-year comparison is a bit difficult here.

Alina Köhler

executive
#8

Turning to the market on the following slide, there are two charts for you. The green line on the left shows this year's spread; the gray line shows the spread from last year. So what's the takeaway from that chart? In the quarter just reported — Q2, the one we're reporting right now — one thing you'll notice is that, looking purely at market prices (which don't necessarily mirror what we pay or what we sell at), biodiesel spreads came in considerably lower than they did a year ago. The chart beside it shows both selling prices and purchase prices for rapeseed oil. There you can see how sale prices fell, along with rapeseed oil prices. Another point: we do anticipate spreads normalizing during the second half of the year, and they remain attractive. Moving on to bioethanol, we've said a few times already that we hit yet another record level of RNG production. The key thing, though, is that the full earnings benefit from RNG won't show up until future periods, since a large portion of the RNG is currently being stored in the grid.

Alina Köhler

executive
#9

Claus will get into this in a moment. What matters on revenues — that's the light green bar on the chart — is that although ethanol prices fell very sharply, by 20%, we came close to offsetting that through greater ethanol sales volumes and GHG premiums. Still, the big jump in the cost burden, tied mostly to material costs but of course to energy too, hit our EBITDA hard, so we were able to post a positive result. Even so, versus last year it was a sizable decline. We achieved EUR 1.7 billion of EBITDA in the ethanol segment. As I said earlier, RNG is largely stored, so the earnings benefit will show up once our downstream business is online. Now I'll hand it back to you, Claus, since you'd like to dig a bit deeper into that.

Claus Sauter

executive
#10

Thanks, Alina. Turning to the biomethane and bioethanol biomethane segment: through our downstream investment, we aim to boost the margins — the highly attractive margins — on renewable natural gas. The fact of bringing RNG to market: in the past, the primary channel was sales via CNG filling stations. At CNG filling stations, the main customers are cars — natural gas cars — and since 2018 we've been seeing a growing fleet of mainly LNG trucks. That's why we began investing in a liquefaction unit and building our own LNG filling stations. These investments are on track, and the focus is on supplying those LNG filling stations with Bio-LNG and capturing the full margin that's available for renewable natural gas. Renewable natural gas is no longer a niche when it comes to CO2 reduction in transport. Its importance keeps growing, as shown by the acquisitions big oil majors have made in this segment over the last months. Verbio here continues to pursue the strategy of growing its biomethane inventory so it can capture the entire product margin through its own Bio-CNG and Bio-LNG infrastructure. If you look closely at our results, you can see that inventories are growing, and that growth comes mainly from RNG.

Claus Sauter

executive
#11

Roughly 700 GWh went into the grid on our side. That represents around 2/3 of what we produce. When we take the standard route to market via CNG filling stations — which cities and grid operators control — a meaningful share of our margin has to be handed over. As things stand, 100% of CNG at German filling stations is already renewable natural gas. That makes it appealing. It's the lower-cost product, particularly following last year's sharp rise in natural gas prices. Look at pricing at CNG filling stations and you'd notice that CNG as a fuel, in particular, stayed very stable last year as well. The reason is that 100% of the output was renewable natural gas. We anticipate our downstream business kicking off substantially in the coming quarter — so Q4, 2022, 2023. Our target is unambiguous here: we intend to bring the entirety of our RNG production — national RNG production — and going forward the international RNG production too, to market via our own downstream business. As I mentioned, renewable natural gas isn't a niche anymore. It's a highly appealing product. It's the least expensive route to decarbonize transport.

Claus Sauter

executive
#12

The fact that every bit of our output is second generation—advanced renewable natural gas—also matters for our margin, and for this segment we receive the top prices for CO₂ savings. Alina already walked through how the biodiesel market has developed, and what I'm showing you here is that same slide, but for ethanol. As you can see, in this quarter—Q2—ethanol prices dropped considerably. Traditional ethanol margins during the last quarter were more or less negative. Europe's traditional ethanol industry in particular is under a great deal of pressure because of flooding ethanol imports, chiefly from Brazil and the United States. On the other hand, because of the war in Europe, bioethanol—wheat prices also rose considerably. Over the last few months prices have also fallen considerably, and we are far from the level seen in past years. Here, Verbio responds by changing feedstock. As you know, for ethanol production we have a big variety. We can use any kind of grain, and when we see wheat costing more than corn or rye, we switch to a different feedstock.

Claus Sauter

executive
#13

So why are we able to do this? The reason is that we produce it from the co-product, from the silage. We aren't producing feed, where quality standards have to be met. What we're producing is renewable natural gas. It makes no difference to our bacteria whether that residue comes from wheat ethanol, corn ethanol, or rye ethanol. Particularly in times such as these, our technology demonstrates its competitive edge. And I can tell you this isn't only the case in Europe — it's the same in the United States. Thanks to our combination, here in the United States as well, we earn a significantly higher margin than our competitors in the traditional ethanol industry do. Now, on the outlook and the investment programs: our investments are fully on track. In the United States, a 160 GWh straw-based RNG plant is operational. Utilization stands at about 50%. Over the first half of 2023 now, we're aiming to reach full utilization. The Nevada biorefinery rollout is underway. Mechanical completion of the biorefinery is now expected in spring. We'll start the plant up during the summertime, and at that point our renewable natural gas production capacity in the United States will rise from 20 GW — 80 GW, 20 MW -80 MW.

Claus Sauter

executive
#14

Our additional renewable natural gas capacity can be tripled. In India, we also have 20 GW, 20 MW of capacity for renewable natural gas, equal to 160 GWh annually. The plant is operational, with low capacity utilization. The focus here is on ramping up production and improving profitability. The liquefaction plant in Germany should be operational by end of summer 2023. As I mentioned already, it is very important that we can produce the LNG for our LNG filling stations and monetize the full margin on renewable natural gas. Bioenergy, Bio-CNG stations — we are going to build 20 gas stations. That is the plan. Locations are secured. Roll-out is running. Ramp up in the first half, in the second half of this business year. As I said, we will start delivering Bio-LNG to filling stations during Q4. The ethanolysis, the entrance to chemical applications based on our biodiesel. Here the plant location is secured. Approval process for the ethanolysis plant is pending. Verbio protein — initial production volumes of feed-grade proteins achieved. Expansion for production of food-grade proteins is ongoing. The guidance is fully on track.

Claus Sauter

executive
#15

For this business year, our guidance was EUR 300 million EBITDA, along with EUR 30 million net cash at year-end. Looking at the half-year results, it's clear we're on track. For the first half of 2022/2023, that came in at EUR 170 million EBITDA, and net cash stood at EUR 177.5 million. Our investments are going to be accelerated, primarily in advanced biofuels, and we'll keep globalizing and diversifying our end markets. Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much for listening to our presentation. I'll now hand things over to the operator so your questions can be presented. Let's move to the Q&A session.

Operator

operator
#16

Thanks a lot, first of all, Mr. Sauter, and naturally, Ms. Köhler, for the presentation you gave. You have two ways to send in your questions: by audio line — for that, just raise your virtual hand — or, as an alternative, through the chat. Your questions will be read aloud by us on your behalf. Our first questions come from Adrien Piere. Please go ahead.

Analyst

analyst
#17

Yes. Hello, and good afternoon. I'm hoping I come through clearly on your end.

Alina Köhler

executive
#18

Yes, we’re able to hear you clearly.

Analyst

analyst
#19

Okay, perfect. Hi, everyone. Just a couple of quick admin questions to start. I noticed that the personal expense line in biodiesel came in a little higher than I had anticipated. I mean, you obviously already mentioned during your presentation the one-off bonus that has been paid, but also the headcount actually came down somewhat. I was wondering whether there are some special effects at play. Then, on the bioethanol side, I saw that headcount actually declined fairly substantially. Is there a specific reason for that, or what were the effects there? My third admin question is about the amount of methane stored in the grid, which you said is now around 700. I mean, given that you may have continued to store rather 2/3 of the production in the quarter in the grid, shouldn't we be closer to something like 770,000? I might have some longer-term strategic follow-up questions. Maybe take those three admin questions first.

Claus Sauter

executive
#20

Thanks a lot. To start with, Verbio's headcount is going up considerably.

Analyst

analyst
#21

Mm-hmm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#22

You may have heard about the structure program we launched — we refer to it as Mustang.

Analyst

analyst
#23

Mm-hmm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#24

Because of our green horse. Headcount is going up, but we have a new organization. We now have a new unit like EPC. All the engineering team, all the processes for building plants. In the past, these engineers were counted within the segments. The engineers who build new plants and improve the technologies were in the biodiesel segment, the same for ethanol, and now it's a new structure. We have ambitious targets for building new plants to increase our capacities, and that was the reason we have to ramp up our engineers, our technical teams, because the know-how is in Germany, mainly in Leipzig. For all the investments we are doing in India and also in the United States, the engineering comes from Germany. It's not that the heads are going down, heads are going up. Also, the costs for personnel. This is, as I said, due to the new structure. There is a new, let's say, Zuordnung, and it is significant. We at least hired about 80 new engineers. It's not only engineers for technical applications, so to build the plant. Also IT is increasing, accounting is increasing. We recognized that, during the first phase of the expansion, when we made Nevada in the United States, when we made India, we stressed our organization, so there was a lack of enough capacities, and that is the reason.

Claus Sauter

executive
#25

Heads aren't dipping—they're rising. Turning to your methane question: we currently have production in Germany, the United States, and India. You're correct that if we stored across all of that output, the 2/3 going into the grid would come to roughly 800. In the United States the rules differ, the market conditions differ, and the same holds in India. That product typically heads to market and gets monetized. As for German production, it's as I said—two-thirds stays in the grid. We cut the volume of renewable natural gas, or methane, as you put it. We lower the quantity sold via traditional CNG filling stations, since otherwise we'd be leaving too much margin on the table. Right now, if you want to move more RNG into the transport market, there simply aren't the capacities to do more—you'd have to push someone else out of the market, and that's only achievable through a thinner margin. I believe this demonstrates that our strategy of moving downstream and investing in our own filling station network was the correct call. Soon, over the coming months, it will let us capture the full margin.

Claus Sauter

executive
#26

It's not the U.S., and it's not India, but I can say we're working on strategies here as well to capture more margin in those markets—through new customers and new approaches for bringing the product to market. We're fairly young in the U.S. market. At first we concentrated on upstream to lock in the feedstock, then on investment to build the plants and handle training for new employees here. Our technology is quite sophisticated. That was the focus; sales mostly run through progress in the U.S. and in India too. The next step, as in Germany, is for us to do the downstream ourselves. That's the reason, and that's the answer to your questions.

Analyst

analyst
#27

Okay, no—appreciate that. Yeah, I did notice that group headcount clearly rose, so we ought to locate the extra staff to some degree, obviously as well in the other segment, or the holding structure, or however you'd like to describe it. Actually, a question about the spreads you helpfully laid out in your presentation—thanks for that. Clearly, on the ethanol side, you anticipate spreads coming back on the positive side. I was just wondering, what are you seeing in the market right now? Is that pressure on ethanol still elevated going forward regarding imports from the United States and Brazil? Do you expect spreads to return, not necessarily because this is easing somewhat, but owing to other factors—a bit of an outlook on this segment? Last thing from me, before I go back into the queue, two somewhat longer-term strategic questions, if you will. Obviously, we've discussed India in your near-term plans and also the US side. First, could you remind us of the CapEx budget—is it unchanged in your guidance? Should we expect additional CapEx emerging in the second half?

Analyst

analyst
#28

Looking further out, I realize you haven't provided longer-term CapEx or revenue guidance, but just thinking about the concept, clearly the plan would be replicating the facilities you already operate over the coming couple of years, and expanding production in biorefinery and methane in India. How should we frame it regarding the pace at which you can move? I know in India this is obviously a regulatory matter, or discussions with the government, and so on. How are things progressing broadly? What about the CapEx figure — in the sense of whether we should prepare ourselves for magnitudes similar to what you have envisioned for 2023? Will it be significantly lower as you move along a learning curve here? Just to hear your overall thinking on the expansion — let's say the rather medium and longer term — in these markets, that would be helpful. Thank you.

Claus Sauter

executive
#29

Alright. That brings us right up to—

Analyst

analyst
#30

Right, I realize that, and I apologize.

Claus Sauter

executive
#31

All right. The second part is clear — strategy and all of that is fine. Now, what was the first—?

Alina Köhler

executive
#32

The first one concerned ethanol. Regarding the price of ethanol—

Claus Sauter

executive
#33

And turning to our outlook — okay.

Analyst

analyst
#34

Regarding the outlook, there's competition from, you know.

Claus Sauter

executive
#35

Yes.

Analyst

analyst
#36

My apologies. Yes.

Claus Sauter

executive
#37

Alright, thanks a lot for asking that — it's really useful. Ethanol is a commodity business, and it operates globally. The US and Brazil are the largest producers. As this chart shows, we saw enormous spreads through what was, shall we say, a tough year — 2022. October, November, December, you know...

Analyst

analyst
#38

Okay.

Claus Sauter

executive
#39

We generated substantial profits. The market is in backwardation.

Analyst

analyst
#40

Mm-hmm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#41

The traders are looking at the curve, particularly 2022, and even with the backwardation—with a significant backwardation—that opened up the arbitrage for imports. These guys managed to secure their imports on the curve. We saw significant imports. Brazil increased by 400%, and the same for the United States. Europe was simply too attractive. They now imported so much ethanol that they put the price under a lot of pressure. At the level, especially what we saw in December, which was for a short period, even below EUR 700/cu m.

Analyst

analyst
#42

Mm-hmm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#43

No one among Europe's established ethanol makers—so ethanol plus DDGS, the feed co-product—can turn a profit, particularly given today's steep energy costs. For the ethanol sector, conditions came together as a perfect storm. The opportunity emerged over the summer through backwardation on the curve. Right now, that arbitrage has shut. Incidentally, a key driver behind our push to go global was that we spotted this arbitrage too. Ultimately, no one could gauge how much volume would actually arrive, yet it was obvious margins wouldn't remain so elevated, since the ethanol molecule is identical whether made in Brazil or the United States. An open arbitrage is essential, because once you begin importing, you need a minimum of two or three months. The current message is that the arbitrage is very much closed. Deals for the imports now arriving were struck in late summer and fall. Today we're seeing imports decline while margins, or prices, climb. Nearly every day now brings a price increase. We stand at EUR 820, EUR 830. The curve hasn't shown traditional backwardation. It carries a carry.

Claus Sauter

executive
#44

Margins are recovering now, and that's needed. What I referred to here applies to ethanol producers, including the traditional ones, and I brought it up while giving my explanation. This is where our setup's competitive edge shows, since right now we're earning on the gas. Gas is the product, it's what's working today. As I said, the market has to recover. Every European producer saw volumes decline because they're losing money — even the ones that are most competitive. Another thing that's hard to foresee was national intervention, such as caps on gas prices and caps on electricity prices. In the U.K., a cap is already in place. In Germany, the cap is supposed to arrive over the coming months, but we won't need it by then, because gas and electricity have fallen. 2022 was truly an insane year. Many unexpected developments. I believe we got a lot right, though not all of it. Ethanol in particular is now heading toward a more profitable situation. Turning to your second point on CapEx and our strategy: the biofuel business — the way it developed over the last 20 years was quite weak, owing to political weaknesses.

Claus Sauter

executive
#45

What we're witnessing over the past three to four years—particularly following the ESG regulations—is that companies are increasingly seeking to cut their CO2 footprint. No longer is the primary force political choices; it's largely emanating from the corporate sphere. One thing that surprises me greatly, though I can simply offer an illustration. Right here in the United States, we're encountering growing appetite for our renewable natural gas coming from a voluntary market. Despite there being no mandates within the chemical sector, the steel sector, or other sectors, firms reach out to us saying, "Could we purchase renewable natural gas from you?" Pricing levels resemble those in the transport segment, where a mandate exists. That's a fascinating evolution. I'd argue that the absence of investment certainty—something we spent recent years grumbling about—grows more pronounced daily. I've spent 25 years in this industry, and on numerous occasions I observed that even elected officials would inform us they needed to ramp up efforts toward lowering CO2 emissions across society. Then policy choices moved in the opposite direction. They cut quotas or pushed them back. Such delays or outright cuts did tremendous, tremendous damage to our progress.

Claus Sauter

executive
#46

We’re cautious. Now we need to recognize that a new phase is beginning. In prior years, we only issued guidance covering the coming 12 months. At present, Alina, Olaf, and I are developing a plan with a longer horizon. A longer-horizon plan means, yes, more CapEx, but as you can see, our balance sheet is solid, with a 72% or 75% equity ratio. There’s substantial room for CapEx. As I mentioned, we’re cautious. The second element is that we also aim to strengthen our capabilities for these trading options. That’s a key component of our strategy to become an international company. In the years ahead, we want to be in a position to use arbitrage across different products, not just ethanol. Arbitrage also exists in biodiesel, arbitrage exists in RNG, and we are advancing those efforts. My final point is the IRA, the investment reduction. The inflation. I say investment, but it’s the Inflation Reduction Act. To us, it’s an investment act. The U.S. government is backing the renewable energy industry with enormous sums. There are many opportunities for us, particularly given our technology, bioethanol and biomethane, because no one is cutting CO2 emissions per ton of corn more than we are.

Claus Sauter

executive
#47

Corn goes into that.

Analyst

analyst
#48

Mm-hmm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#49

The only thing that leaves is energy. And when we discuss renewable energy, the primary aim of this Inflation Reduction Act, let's say, is its emphasis on cutting CO2. For our renewable natural gas expansion—with the goal of producing synthetic gas—we'll manage to finance 30% to 50% of our CapEx. Through renewable hydrogen, we can obtain 30% to 50% of the CapEx from the government. At present, we're studying the law. We're studying how the market stands, but the momentum here, particularly in the United States, is, well, it's wild. That now lets us be a little bit mutiger, a little more ambitious, to scale up our plans, our CapEx plans, and also to examine opportunities in the market and set up a trading unit. One final point: India. The talks we're holding in India are extremely, extremely constructive. India is a third world country, so energy has to be cheap. India can't afford to spend as much money as the first world does to shrink their CO₂ footprint. They're very keen to do it. You know, if you look at India, and at the area where our investment sits, we're not just talking about CO₂ reduction—the far bigger problem is what's called stubble burning.

Analyst

analyst
#50

Mm-hmm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#51

When the straw—whether from paddy or wheat—isn't collected out of the fields, farmers set it on fire, and that's visible across the entire continent. The haze drifts from the Himalaya toward the south and southwest, covering the whole nation. Halting stubble burning sits at the top of the Indian government's priorities. That's why our conversations with them are highly constructive. India's energy sector doesn't operate as freely as ours does. When oil or gas prices climb, the Indian government provides subsidies for the energy that end consumers use. They hadn't recognized the environmental and regulatory picture, which in certain instances works against our business. Take Punjab's farmers, for instance—those growing rye and wheat get electricity for irrigation at no charge. Agricultural fertilizer likewise costs them nothing. On top of that, even when they keep burning rice straw, which is prohibited, there are no repercussions.

Analyst

analyst
#52

Mm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#53

The subsidies in the traditional fuel sector in particular are hurting us. They're damaging our renewables business too. Our message to the government has been: "Sorry, but by subsidizing fossil products under your strategy, you're damaging our business." Farmers aren't keen on purchasing our fertilizer, which contributes revenue, since they receive state-owned fertilizer at no cost. One point is that if this strategy continues, we want an equivalent sum of money, and the state must pay it. In the end, there are many minor matters. No single one is a major problem, but above all, you need to reach the right people—those with authority to make such decisions. I've often said our technology and investment in India create a win-win-win-win situation for the country. To start, we end stubble burning. Next, we deliver investment, we deliver jobs, and we deliver value in rural areas. We intend to compensate the farmer for the rice straw. We create jobs there—jobs in our production and jobs in agriculture. The last win, number four, is local production of renewable natural gas. Finally, natural gas. Last year India was importing LNG from Qatar and from everywhere around the globe for enormous sums.

Analyst

analyst
#54

Okay.

Claus Sauter

executive
#55

The shortfall absolutely exploded. India has more to gain here than Verbio does. Should they choose—and they do want us to deploy our technology—a handful of issues need resolving. That's where I'd say we're making solid progress. First, as you know, you must capture attention. Second, what exactly are the tasks we need to tackle? Last week the Indian government announced its intention to enact legislation requiring that 5% of natural gas in India be renewable natural gas. A market has to be built there. The proper conditions have to be put in place. It strikes me as somewhat contradictory that the government subsidizes fossil energy—fossil oil and fossil gas—while we, as someone delivering added value to India, must struggle against artificially cheap energy prices.

Analyst

analyst
#56

Mm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#57

That doesn’t add up at all.

Analyst

analyst
#58

You know, after the last question there's always a very final one, and that one is actually about India, to get a slightly better understanding of it. I completely share your view, and obviously it has to be a win-win situation for both sides. The thing is, given the current prerequisites that you see there in the market, and, you know, just assuming you'd put all your CapEx into India as of tomorrow, nothing for the rest, would that in principle mean a dilution for your methane margin today? Since.

Claus Sauter

executive
#59

Sure.

Analyst

analyst
#60

That isn't the system for this quarter, so it has to be that way, correct?

Claus Sauter

executive
#61

Absolutely. That's a huge amount of dilution.

Analyst

analyst
#62

Okay. Even though the input material you receive there has to be almost free or something, right? I mean, that's a problem.

Claus Sauter

executive
#63

Yes. I mean, you don't pay for it. You get the input at no cost, though gathering it is something we have to do.

Analyst

analyst
#64

Yeah.

Claus Sauter

executive
#65

Material cost isn't the biggest piece.

Analyst

analyst
#66

Mm-hmm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#67

You’ve got to dry it. You’ve got to gather it, bale it, keep it stored, and feed it into production. Those steps come with costs. In places such as the United States or Europe, those expenses are much lower, but conversely, there’s no regulatory framework covering the molecules. At this moment, in India, we’re up against natural gas—whether we’re going into the conventional natural gas market, or competing with LPG or diesel at the filling station.

Analyst

analyst
#68

Understood.

Claus Sauter

executive
#69

For many, many years, that was our business model in Germany. We’re not afraid. You know, when the Indian government subsidizes diesel and LPG at the filling station, that harms our business. In India, especially during the last year, we would be extremely competitive with natural gas, with LNG from Qatar or the United States at these price levels.

Analyst

analyst
#70

Mm-hmm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#71

The Indian government was providing a very large subsidy for it.

Analyst

analyst
#72

Understood.

Claus Sauter

executive
#73

We're working on it — we've made our first investment there. India has enormous potential. We talk about 500 million tons of agricultural residues. It's a tropical and subtropical region. Crops grow 3 to 5 times faster than in North America or Central Europe. There's a huge amount of unused biomass. That's why farmers burn it. What else should they do with it? They have to get rid of it. That material is the feedstock for our production.

Analyst

analyst
#74

Right. The farms are really small, so getting everything done is quite complicated. I appreciate your help.

Claus Sauter

executive
#75

Yeah.

Analyst

analyst
#76

Yeah.

Claus Sauter

executive
#77

You know, that's not a bad thing.

Analyst

analyst
#78

Alright.

Claus Sauter

executive
#79

When you've got plenty of farmers near your facility, your purchasing leverage ends up larger than if just 2 or 3 large farmers sit right around it, since on the farmer side they're all the same size.

Analyst

analyst
#80

Mm-hmm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#81

The situation is quite different. Here in the United States, a farm typically covers 2,000 acres. Over in India, to work 2,000 acres, it takes 500 farmers.

Analyst

analyst
#82

All right.

Claus Sauter

executive
#83

Right? The landscape has changed, yet significant opportunity exists. We put money into a single project. One facility was constructed so we could demonstrate to the Indian government our capability and that the technology is ours. So now, once the market conditions get sorted out, we'll expand it.

Analyst

analyst
#84

Understood — that’s quite useful. Thanks.

Claus Sauter

executive
#85

Thanks, Mr. Piere.

Operator

operator
#86

Thanks for those questions, Mr. Piere. Next up, we have more questions coming from Joma Emerson. Go right ahead.

Analyst

analyst
#87

Hello there. Is my voice coming through?

Alina Köhler

executive
#88

Yeah, we’ve got you loud and clear.

Claus Sauter

executive
#89

Received you loud and clear.

Analyst

analyst
#90

Great. Yeah. First off, congratulations. I’ve just got two quick questions. The first one has to do with possibly buying your next plant in the U.S., correct? I mean, conditions look favorable. Could you shed a bit more light on that, and also on how the Inflation Reduction Act could assist you with it? For my second question, could you go into a little more detail about biodiesel’s specific advantage in North America? I believe Alina brought up Canada. Maybe just walk through, you know, the precise reason that happened to be the situation.

Claus Sauter

executive
#91

My apologies, Joma. On the Canada biodiesel topic — I didn’t catch what the question was.

Analyst

analyst
#92

Could you walk us through that?

Claus Sauter

executive
#93

So, how are things going?

Analyst

analyst
#94

On the whole, North America — why biodiesel has gained from North America. I believe that was on one of your opening slides.

Alina Köhler

executive
#95

Right. That happened simply because prices were quite elevated during the last quarter relative to the prior year.

Analyst

analyst
#96

What's the reason for that? Is it simply—

Alina Köhler

executive
#97

Market development.

Analyst

analyst
#98

That's a fair point.

Claus Sauter

executive
#99

Alright. Alright, it's a bit more involved than that. On the first part of your question, acquisitions: we've said that's clearly our focus. All of that was before the IRA. Our clear focus is boosting capacity in North America — a more stable framework, a larger market, greater feedstock possibilities. We're working on acquisitions. There's nothing we can announce as of yet, but we are working on it. The main impact now comes from the IRA, and I've said this already. The focus in particular is CO2 reduction and implementing a hydrogen infrastructure. That's exactly what we're doing. The IRA is a set of activities and opportunities around investment tax credits — and even for our existing investment in Nevada, thanks to that, we're not on schedule with our commissioning, because even for this investment, for the second part, we'll be able to obtain what you might call subsidies or support. For the new projects, we need to dig deeper into the IRA. That's what we're doing right now, and looking at where the real benefit lies, because we see room for new business ideas that differ from the period before the IRA. New business models means we see opportunities with lower CapEx, even to speed up our expansion of the availability of the right molecules.

Claus Sauter

executive
#100

It's a bit early for that. As I mentioned, the emphasis under the IRA is on cutting CO₂ emissions substantially within the ethanol sector, and in the U.S. ethanol sector, all of it is first generation. The complaint was that, well, there isn't much of a CO₂ reduction, since the majority of plants — most ethanol plants — generate their power from coal. It's somewhat contradictory, you know. You've got a coal-fired power plant while you're making biofuels. Now the IRA provides backing across the ethanol sector to concentrate on achieving better CO₂ reduction. That's something we've been doing over the past 10 years. This notion of focusing on how biofuel genuinely delivers something for society and for the country — if the emphasis shifts to CO₂ reduction, that aligns with our strategy. There's plenty of money available. That's one piece. The second piece concerns building out a hydrogen infrastructure. As you know, Europe has been continuously debating for 2 years already where the electricity for electrolysis could come from. Everyone talks about excess renewable electricity, particularly in Germany, which we already have.

Claus Sauter

executive
#101

When you actually examine the surplus, it amounted to roughly 200 or 300 hours during the previous year. If all you have is 200 or 300 hours annually, running an electrolyzer isn't feasible. A year contains 8,760 hours. With only that small quantity of extra electricity, no one is going to put money into this sector, and no one can genuinely establish an infrastructure. I have been following these discussions for two years now. In the United States, it is entirely different. They are not concerned about where the electricity originates. Here in the United States, an electrolyzer can be operated for 8,760 hours. That represents the initial step. Certainly, the primary support for hydrogen, which stands at $3 per kg, is obtained when you use renewable electricity. The thinking from the U.S. government is that first of all, this hydrogen infrastructure has to be built up. Whether the electricity comes from nuclear or even coal makes no difference. A hydrogen infrastructure is what we need. The following step, then, is that support must increase. Doing it with renewable energy, with power from solar and wind, has to become more attractive. The state with the greatest amount of wind power utilization in the United States is Iowa, which is where we are located.

Claus Sauter

executive
#102

The point I'm making, though, is where the emphasis lies. In the US, the emphasis is more pragmatic, and when it comes to infrastructure—hydrogen infrastructure—the message is clear and so is the decision, and meeting the requirements is comparatively simple. I believe I've said this a few times already: we have a technology. The CO₂ from our bacteriums, from our yeast in production—we can use that CO₂ to produce synthetic CH4. Combining the two—reducing CO₂ emissions from the ethanol industry while building up a hydrogen infrastructure—means we have backing from both sides, since once the CO₂ from our process is used to make synthetic CH₄, we further boost the CO₂ efficiency of our ethanol plant. And second, we get a new molecule that is ultimately the same molecule as our renewable natural gas. All the infrastructure we have at our site in Nevada can likewise be used for synthetic methane.

Analyst

analyst
#103

Mm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#104

The IRA creates fresh opportunities for us and gives our technical approach even more backing. Now let's see what we can work out. Last, it means that on new investments, we'll be able to cut our own CapEx contribution by 30%-50%.

Analyst

analyst
#105

That's great.

Claus Sauter

executive
#106

All right, Canada — I always leave Canada out, my apologies. Just so you get a sense of it: renewable diesel capacity keeps expanding across the United States, and many oil companies are putting money into renewable diesel. A number of plants have already begun operating, and they're enormous facilities. Enormous. Several are already coming online, and they require feedstock. North America, the U.S. included, also has sustainability rules in place. Anything made in North America counts as sustainable. These new renewable diesel plants are aimed primarily at North American soybean oil and North American canola oil. Canola is comparable to rapeseed oil. Right now, vegetable oil produced in the U.S. carries a 30% premium over the rest of the world. You can't sell European rapeseed methyl ester or European biodiesel into the U.S. market, because... it's a sort of, well, America First approach. Under U.S. regulation, the European rate doesn't qualify as sustainable.

Analyst

analyst
#107

Alright.

Claus Sauter

executive
#108

In the US, prices rose, which puts our Canadian plant in an interesting margin position. We've secured some margin so that, say for 2023, output is covered and the margin is locked in. That said, it doesn't change the fact that, let's say, I'm not especially bullish on biodiesel in North America — similar to how I feel about ethanol and renewable natural gas.

Analyst

analyst
#109

Mm-hmm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#110

There's just too much happening right now. With soybean prices at the level we're seeing today, my sense is that the new renewable diesel capacity is genuinely having a hard time earning a margin. They certainly need to work their way down the learning curve. We won't be making any decision at this point on further investment in our biodiesel plant, and that investment would be required unless we get a clear picture of how this develops. To give you a sense of it, the announced renewable diesel capacity — which mainly goes as road, as transport diesel, and sustainable air fuels into California — covers 140% of California's diesel consumption.

Analyst

analyst
#111

All right.

Claus Sauter

executive
#112

Right? It takes more than that to make California fully green when it comes to diesel. The Low Carbon Fuel Standard in California — 18 months back, California was paying $220 for each ton of CO2 savings. Today that price has fallen to 60. That completely changes the economics. We'll watch how things develop. Perhaps California will step up its efforts and move faster toward CO2 neutrality. Perhaps the IRA will also foster conditions in other states to concentrate much more heavily on cutting CO2, so that a market for our CO2 savings will emerge in other states too. Those are many questions I don't yet have answers to. While I lack answers and a clear picture, no investment decision will be made by us.

Analyst

analyst
#113

Okay, that sounds good.

Claus Sauter

executive
#114

All right?

Analyst

analyst
#115

Yeah. That was excellent. Thanks. I appreciate your feedback.

Claus Sauter

executive
#116

I appreciate you asking that.

Operator

operator
#117

Appreciate the question. On timing, we’ve still got a few questions coming in through the chat.

Claus Sauter

executive
#118

Yes, please go ahead.

Operator

operator
#119

Let me go through those quickly too so we cover them. The first one is more of an understanding question. You generated 522 MWh of biomethane in the first half of the year. How many tons of Bio-LNG does that let you produce?

Claus Sauter

executive
#120

All right, that figure is 520 GWh rather than 520 MWh.

Operator

operator
#121

Okay, that works.

Claus Sauter

executive
#122

Alright, that one's fairly straightforward. A single kilogram of LNG equals 15 kWh. Since 500 GWh works out to 500 million kWh, dividing that by 15 gives you the kilograms, and from there you can work out the tonnage. I don't have that figure on hand right now — it's pretty simple to get. One kilogram of LNG is 15 kWh, and we're dealing with 500 GWh. That comes to roughly-

Alina Köhler

executive
#123

The figure ought to fall somewhere in the range of 30,000 to 40,000 tons.

Claus Sauter

executive
#124

Yes. That’s 35,000 tons of LNG. Thanks, Alina. Thanks so much.

Alina Köhler

executive
#125

I appreciate that.

Claus Sauter

executive
#126

Alright.

Operator

operator
#127

This is a follow-up question. In roughly 3 to 5 years, how many GWh of biomethane are you producing, or do you plan to produce?

Claus Sauter

executive
#128

That’s a good question.

Alina Köhler

executive
#129

The target we've publicly stated is getting the biorefinery to 2 TWh across the United States, India, and Germany. We do have plans to expand past that, though we haven't yet shared the figures for it.

Claus Sauter

executive
#130

Right. So we'll have 2 TWh in the next business year.

Operator

operator
#131

Mm-hmm.

Claus Sauter

executive
#132

So, what's the plan for getting up to 5 TWh? No, that was the question. Three to five years. I think it lands somewhere between 5 TWh and 10 TWh. That's the plan.

Operator

operator
#133

Okay, that actually addresses another question too. Now, on the German politicians who’ve raised that old subject once more — the phase-out of first-generation biofuels — what’s your view?

Claus Sauter

executive
#134

Look, it doesn’t mean we would have to halt output of the first generation. If Germany passed a law saying first‑generation biofuel there gives no contribution toward the CO₂ reduction obligation — if that political decision came — no company in Germany would have a bigger advantage than Verbio, because we’re already the largest producer of advanced biofuels. Finally, if it really happened, which I can’t imagine, since 90% of the CO₂ reduction today in Germany comes from the first generation — but I don’t care. That would mean we keep producing, but we wouldn’t sell it in Germany. We’d export it to other European countries. If you follow the press, there’s no idea in France, in UK, in Italy, in all of Eastern Europe to phase out first‑generation biofuel. It’s the other way around. Ethanol demand in Europe is increasing. We see it in the imports, it is increasing. Just another example. Germany now decided for 2022, if you use biodiesel from palm oil, it doesn’t count for the quota. Does that mean global production of biodiesel from palm oil stops?

Claus Sauter

executive
#135

No, since you can still take it into France, Italy, Poland, Hungary, and the U.K. There's still a market there. That's why I'm entirely at ease. Honestly, if it actually happens, I'll throw a party, because we'd earn higher margins — far, far higher margins on our advanced biofuel. To me, that would be more interesting. You see, the requirement for cutting greenhouse gases in transport in 2022 stands at 8%. Of that 8%, 90% is first generation. I'd argue the Minister of Environment and of Agriculture ought to examine how they intend to take that 92% down to zero between 2024 and 2045, a span of 22 years. Worth considering how to phase out the largest portion of what we already have. Let's watch what unfolds. We're entirely at ease.

Operator

operator
#136

Okay, thanks. From what I understand, Schwedt is currently operating at just 50% to 70% utilization. How does that affect you?

Claus Sauter

executive
#137

On our end, we're sending additional output from the PCK refinery out to other refineries, and those refineries are selling their products into the very market PCK used to serve. Where the diesel or gasoline originates doesn't really matter to us, provided consumption stays at the same level. It's simpler for us to just pump our products on the other side into the refinery and have blending done there. If we're forced to take it out, our logistics costs go up. Right now, from a logistics standpoint, we have no issues at the PCK refinery, because yes, it's only running at 50%, but that also means rail tracks are free and rail cars are free. Getting rid of our material from the PCK refinery poses no problem for us.

Operator

operator
#138

Thanks a lot. Since this is our final question, could you provide a rough estimate of how much lower energy costs should affect EBITDA in the second half of 2022 to 2023?

Claus Sauter

executive
#139

Alright, I can give you a rough idea. Back in the summer, when we did our planning, gas and electricity prices were extremely high, and we said that would add roughly EUR 100 million in extra production costs. Costs have since come back down, though not to where they were before. For the full year, I'd say it isn't EUR 100 million more — it's around EUR 75 million. EUR 70 million to EUR 75 million. Compared with our planning, I think energy costs will come in approximately EUR 30 million lower than when we put the guidance together.

Operator

operator
#140

Thanks.

Claus Sauter

executive
#141

I’m not claiming we’ll generate an extra EUR 30 million in EBITDA, since those market distortions are visible. We’re keeping our guidance, and items such as reduced energy costs are helping us toward the goal of EUR 300 million EBITDA.

Operator

operator
#142

Okay, great. Thank you. Mr. Sauter, Miss Köhler, many thanks once more for making time for us and for taking the questions as well. And to everyone on the call, thank you so much for your interest. Mr. Sauter, I'll turn things over to you now for a few closing remarks before we wrap up.

Claus Sauter

executive
#143

All right. Thanks so much to everyone who tuned in. Thanks to the operator. And thank you, Alina. I really am eager — genuinely eager — for the call we'll hold next time, and with luck we'll be able to walk you through additional specifics about the IRA. Many thanks. Enjoy the rest of your day.

Alina Köhler

executive
#144

I appreciate everyone joining. Take care, and goodbye.

Operator

operator
#145

Thank you. Goodbye. The recording-

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Verbio SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Verbio SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Verbio SE or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.