Verbio SE (VBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 11, 2023

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Energy Oil, Gas and Consumable Fuels earnings 77 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good morning, everyone. On behalf of Montega, I'd like to welcome you to VERBIO's earnings call after the release of the Q3 figures for 2022, 2023. In just a moment, CEO Claus Sauter and Alina Köhler from Investor Relations will present the results to you, and after that presentation the floor will open for the questions that follow. With that said, Mr. Sauter, over to you.

Claus Sauter

executive
#2

Thanks a lot, operator. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the presentation of the Q3 results for business year 2022, 2023, on behalf of myself and the Board, and together with Alina, our Head of IR. So we have put a presentation together. To begin with, we'll report on the group financials, the segment financials, the acquisition of our new site in the United States, in South Bend Ethanol, and then an update and outlook. And of course, for this discussion, one of the main topics will be the development in biodiesel, especially the imports from China. But let's get started — Alina, please go ahead. Okay. So first of all, an overview of production and the key figures for Q3. So on production, finally, we are very much in line. We raised biodiesel production 10% year-on-year thanks to higher utilization in Canada. Ethanol production is stable year-on-year, and RNG production, renewable natural gas, is 14% plus year-on-year thanks to capacity expansion. EBITDA minus 66% compared to the previous quarter last year. So the decrease is primarily due to a decline in sales prices, in particular for biodiesel. We have a big margin squeeze in biodiesel imports, but therefore, we have prepared a later slide about the Chinese imports, and at the same time, higher purchase prices for feedstocks.

Claus Sauter

executive
#3

Net cash came in at EUR 121 million, down 32% from EUR 177.5 million. That movement reflects EBITDA and working capital, and beyond that we put money to work mainly on growth investments, adding new capacity and funding our other activities in Germany, along with tax payments and the dividend payout. The equity ratio held steady at 73.8%. Our balance sheet is therefore strong, and financial stability is still high. At this point, though, I'd like to pass things over to you for the details.

Alina Köhler

executive
#4

Thanks a lot, and good morning to everybody from me as well. So, as Claus mentioned earlier, EBITDA in Q3 came in at EUR 43 million. That falls short of the EUR 128 million we posted a year ago, which was clearly helped by the favorable procurement we did on rapeseed oil, and on weed too. So the figures aren't really comparable — you can't just line up the numbers. What we also present on this slide is that during the previous quarter, EBITDA stood at roughly EUR 49 million. As you can see, the mix has shifted enormously. The bioethanol segment rebounded quite strongly, while biodiesel came down for the reasons Claus already noted, in particular imports of Chinese biodiesel, which we'll get to in a moment. Still, for biodiesel, as I said, comparability with last year is low. That said, you can see that in green light cars, our sales rose compared with a year ago. We noted that the biodiesel price did come down. In North America, though, we achieved better utilization at the Canadian plant, and that drove the improvement, along with stronger biodiesel prices.

Alina Köhler

executive
#5

Yes. That said, EBITDA took a hit from weaker European biodiesel prices, and those lower prices came alongside fairly high purchasing costs, while attractively priced GHG premiums kept our results steady here. So ultimately, we posted EUR 25 million in EBITDA for the biodiesel segment in the Q3 figures — our Q3 EBITDA — and that's a very good outcome given the imports we've seen from China. But I'll hand it back to you.

Claus Sauter

executive
#6

Yes. So one major issue right now, I have to say, is biodiesel imports from China that are wrongly labeled. And on this chart, we just want to show you how the market developed. So the gray chart is the situation last year, 2021, 2022. And for biodiesel, you can see that between September and August and January, margins were very attractive — EUR 500, EUR 600 per tonne of margin. Then it went down in February, March. And the actual business here now shows that margins are now at a level of below EUR 100 per metric ton. The whole commodity on the right hand, on the right chart, the whole commodity market went down dramatically. So when rapeseed oil was EUR 2,200 last year in July, then we are at the moment at EUR 900 per tonne. Finally, there is a possibility to hedge the feedstock costs. But — we are in a position where we say for vegetable oil, we are bullish because in the United States, 10 million tonnes of new capacities for high-grade vegetable oil is coming up. So the distortion of the Chinese imports, which are finally palm oil methyl ester, some blended with other components, is really distorting the mark heavily.

Claus Sauter

executive
#7

And that's — what I'd say is that this isn't merely a gimmick. On April 24, an announcement came out regarding Chinese imports into the U.S. that were labeled as used cooking oil. In New Orleans, we halted 2 ships. The Environmental Protection Agency and the beauty control took samples. And in the end, it turned out to be palm oil that had been labeled as used cooking oil. So we now have more and more signs that what is heading there is truly a big deal. And on the next slide, I want to show you the amounts we're talking about. So Chinese biodiesel was always coming into Europe or being exported. Capacity in China stands at roughly 2.4 million tonnes of biodiesel — and the total volume we need in Europe is around 9 million tonnes, just so you get a feeling. So that's about 25% of China's capacity. Most of those exports in earlier years arrived as used cooking oil methyl ester. And if we look at January through the first quarter of last year — January, February, March 2022 — exports were approximately 50,000 to 100,000 tonnes, but it was labeled as used cooking oil methyl ester.

Claus Sauter

executive
#8

Relative to that, Chinese exports are up twofold versus a year earlier. Plus, the bulk of this product carries an incorrect label of advanced biofuel together with an appealing greenhouse gas quota. What matters is that used cooking methyl ester has also been limited since January 2023 to 1.9%. Well, these imports, particularly those going from China into Europe, get labeled as advanced biofuel under Annex 9A. That therefore means, for the German market as well as the U.K. market for advanced biofuel, biodiesel, it looks very appealing, since the quota gets counted twice. So on the chart, measured in tons of CO2 reduction, the majority of the product is imported through Rotterdam, yet we estimate that most of this biodiesel carrying the advanced label ends up in Germany. And you can see it isn't merely that these volumes reach the market and get blended by the oil companies into diesel under double counting, with the quota doubling. That therefore means, for instance, when back in 2022, 100,000 tonnes of biodiesel arrived on the European or German market, in Germany it was counted once for the quota. So 100,000 tonnes counted as 100,000 tonnes toward the quota. Now, labeled as advanced and ultimately, much of it based on palm oil, which is prohibited in any case, with a multiplier, 250,000 tons of biodiesel are arriving in Europe.

Claus Sauter

executive
#9

A large share goes to Germany, since that's the market that draws the most interest. At 250,000 tonnes, you receive 500,000 tonnes of quota. Take used cooking methyl ester imports in January of last year—100,000 tonnes, which equals 100,000 tonnes of quota—and now 250,000 tonnes are arriving, which translates into 500,000 tonnes of quota. That illustrates just how badly the market has been disrupted. The distortion is enormous, and it simply can't be that every bit of this product shipped in from China is genuinely advanced, because the feedstock—to start with, that feedstock isn't available. And second, a plant designed for used cooking oil methyl ester production is unable to process the advanced feedstock needed for advanced biofuel. We know this from the conversations we're having. We too intend to expand our current advanced biofuel capacity, but for that reason we're putting up an entirely new plant. So right now, solutions at both EU and national level are in development to tackle biodiesel mislabeling. We're aware that Berlin and Brussels are both at work on this. And in the United States—I brought this up on April 24—they have just halted the imports. ISCC, among the most significant certifiers across the biofuel sector, has already pulled 5 certificates from Chinese exporters over the past couple of weeks.

Claus Sauter

executive
#10

And luckily, luckily at this point, the first oil majors have ceased using mislabeled time oil-based biodiesel from China. Last week there was a clear announcement from Total — anything containing Chinese components will not be accepted in Germany for German refined Total refinery or refineries. So action is being taken, but at a minimum these significant fraudulent imports from China are distorting the entire market. Even what I mentioned earlier, that rapeseed oil fell from EUR 2,200 to EUR 900. So the whole market has shaped up because the volume of imports is simply so huge. 250,000 tonnes per month, which equals 3 million tonnes per year, counting double, so you are creating 6 million tonnes of CO2 savings in a market environment where biodiesel use is 9 million tonnes, you can see it's more than 50%. All of the products coming from China, a huge distortion, which is not only affecting biodiesel, it also has an effect on bioethanol because when it's now easy for the oil companies to fill their obligation with these kinds of biofuel they also decide to take less ethanol because there is no pressure at the moment. So what we are asking the government is, first of all, to stop the imports; and secondly, to investigate how much volume came from these companies where the certificates were withdrawn and finally, to go back because it was all fraudulent.

Claus Sauter

executive
#11

So let's see what we can accomplish here. But in the end, it's a massive scandal, and Big Oil is involved in it too. Okay. Thanks a lot. Alina, please go on.

Alina Köhler

executive
#12

Yeah. So turning to the ethanol segment. Compared with a year earlier, we saw a decline as well. Even so, there was a robust recovery from one quarter to the next. If we look at sales — again, that's the green light in the chart — you can actually see revenues holding steady versus a year ago, while our production stayed broadly flat. That's mainly thanks to extra GHG quota we sold, even though ethanol prices came down. So that's what explains why revenues in fact stayed largely flat. And although the GHG quota carries a very appealing margin, the drop you see in EBITDA was still caused by the heavy pressure on our input costs tied to feedstock, and on energy cost as well. On top of that, last year we had positive one-off effects worth flagging. And that too explains the gap you can see. It's also worth noting that we made initial bio-LNG sales in the last quarter. And we held on to the quota. So we are clearly waiting to sell, since potato prices are once again at a very attractive level for us. That said, we are making very good progress at the center, and Claus will give an overview of our gas network near the end of the call, because we already have 5 gas stations online right now among our own gas stations.

Alina Köhler

executive
#13

Turning now to the market, on the left-hand side of the chart you can see the spreads — the green line shows the current spreads we are observing, and they have recovered strongly over the quarter, which is also driving the results, and they remain largely stable; they came down a bit also because of the biodiesel imports, as Claus was explaining a little bit earlier, that this also has an effect on directional demand. So that is basically what you are seeing in the chart. On the right side, it is the comparison between bioethanol prices and weak prices, both per tonne of bioethanol, which basically just gives you the calculation for the spreads on the left-hand side... Moving on to our acquisition.

Claus Sauter

executive
#14

Regarding China — we were just discussing the U.S. market and our recent acquisition, South and ethanol. South Bend Ethanol is located in Indiana. What we've put together here is a demonstration of how our technology stacks up competitively against U.S. technology. Let me walk you through it: in the United States, corn enters as a feedstock and what comes out is ethanol plus end feed, known as DDGS feed — animal feed for chickens, cattle, and pigs. Those are the 2 primary products. The major distinction with our technologies is that corn goes in and ethanol comes out, but we don't make animal feed — we produce renewable natural gas. That's the key difference between conventional U.S. technology — which all of the 220 ethanol plants across the Midwest are using, as I mentioned — and what VERBIO is now bringing: a combination of ethanol and RNG. RNG can be sold as a biofuel in the U.S. So we end up with ethanol, like a traditional corn ethanol plant, which is a D6 RIN, plus our renewable natural gas, which is a D5 RIN. When we compare these 2 technologies, we therefore hold a competitive advantage looking ahead over the coming months of roughly EUR 0.50 per gallon.

Claus Sauter

executive
#15

Now, regarding the South Bend example — that’s an 85 million gallon ethanol plant — our competitive advantage of roughly $0.50 per gallon works out to USD 42 million per year. That’s the competitive advantage. So, as you can guess, you’re not making money on ethanol. What gives us USD 42 million is solely our competitive advantage, achieved only by combining ethanol and renewable natural gas, compared with ethanol DDGs. This is the first time we’re showing this slide. And this slide is pre-IRA; it has nothing to do with the IRA. So on the deal rationale, what will we do? We will convert the traditional bioethanol plant into a VERBIO bio-refinery with 85 million gallons and 850 gigawatt hours per annum of renewable natural gas, with a strong competitive advantage. Estimated CapEx is EUR 230 million. The project will be financed from freely available cash credit lines and cash flow. And as I said, these competitive advantages are pre-IRA. So when we look at the IRA, then for this location, the IRA provides an investment tax credit of between 30% and 50%. At this location there in Indiana, we will receive a tax credit of 30%. So 30% of the investment will be granted by the state as an investment tax credit, which ultimately is the equity.

Claus Sauter

executive
#16

Beyond the ITC — the investment tax credit — we're also setting up production tax credits. What production tax credits mean is that when the carbon intensity of our biofuels, ethanol and renewable natural gas, falls under the 50 kilogram CO2 per MMBTU threshold, we receive $0.2 per gallon for every kilogram we are below that threshold. Take an example: if the CI for ethanol and for renewable natural gas sits at 40, then we are 10 points under 50. That gives us $0.02 per gallon in production tax credits over 5 years, which works out to another 20 USD 5 million versus a traditional producer. Why 25 with 85 million gallons? Because it's granted on the ethanol. So at 85 million gallons, EUR 0.02 at 40 CI, we're talking about 70 million. Then we produce renewable natural gas, where the same logic applies — there too we get $0.02. Provided all the product stays in the U.S.; if we export, since there are certainly more attractive markets abroad, we don't generate the production tax credit. Still, at a minimum, this is the baseline. That baseline, with our technology, once completed, post IRA, amounts to a competitive advantage of 70% to 75% per gallon.

Claus Sauter

executive
#17

So I believe that's a compelling point, and it demonstrates these — yes, the benefits our technology offers over conventional ones. We've now been working on the South Bend acquisition for over 1 year. The closing took place on May 2. So we're already running that plant. Our engineering staff was on site already. So although it's a traditional ethanol facility right now, we've already spotted some easy wins for boosting efficiency. And the following stage is that once Nevada is commissioned, which will happen in late summer this year, we'll begin right away with South Bend, given how appealing our business model is, even for the U.S. market. And with the tremendous support of the IRA, we're continuing to look at what additional targets exist in the market. Okay. Next slide. So at minimum, through this new investment in South Bend, the growth in capacity for liquid biofuels and for renewable natural gas as well will keep going. So I notice there's an error here. So our current estimate was for 2023, 2024: 710,000 tonnes of biodiesel, of which 100,000 is advanced biofuel, 800,000 tonnes of ethanol and roughly 2 terawatt hours of gas — and with the South Bend acquisition, and there, there's a mistake, 2026, 2027.

Claus Sauter

executive
#18

Ethanol will also go up. At that point we'll be at roughly 1.1 million tonnes, and gas will rise to about 3 terawatt hours, all right?

Alina Köhler

executive
#19

That $800 million figure already accounts for 250,000 to...

Claus Sauter

executive
#20

You're right about that...

Alina Köhler

executive
#21

Since we’ve already...

Claus Sauter

executive
#22

We already make ethanol — I'm not sure, hold on. Okay, okay. Sorry about that. The figures are correct. So, 800,000 tonnes of ethanol, roughly 3 terawatt hours. And once we've acquired South Bend, our ethanol gas unit over in the United States is already considerably larger than what we have in Germany. All of that gas, those 3 terawatt hours, count as advanced biofuel in the United States, and they also qualify as advanced biofuel under Annex 9A for the European market. So to wrap up, we had to revise our guidance down from EUR 300 million EBITDA to EUR 240 million EBITDA. But I've explained the reason behind it. It's a market distortion. Our net cash remains positive. And looking at this market distortion and the effect — what you want to do against fraud. So when I look at the actual market situation and I see what's happening with our competitors. And I have to say the results we're presenting are extraordinary, because a lot of competitors are already shutting down. So versus last year, it's less EBITDA, for sure, but last year was extraordinary. And under the actual circumstances, it's really, really a great job with everybody in VERBIO made.

Claus Sauter

executive
#23

There's just a bit to add here. So regarding the expansion in Germany, we're a little ahead of schedule. In the United States, the 160 gigawatt hours straw-based RNG plant is up and running at roughly 50% utilization. Additional capacity will come onstream. The -- the Nevada Biorefinery rollout is underway. Mechanical completion of the biorefinery should happen by summer -- late summer. So we'll be starting up the plant. And the reason for only 50% capacity utilization on the straw-based gas has partly to do with feedstock quality, but it's mainly that once the biorefinery is complete, the straw-based RNG production has to be integrated into the biorefinery. Here too we're constrained on production. So this summer, the entire biorefinery, everything will be implemented, and then we can start it up, and at that point we're talking about 800 gigawatt hours of yearly gas production, and everything is progressing. On our downstream business, our own network of bio LNG and bio CNG filling stations, so 20 gas stations are planned, locations secured, rollout is underway, and 5 gas stations are already online. We've already been producing bio-LNG since January. And yes, we're now going to increase these amounts, but it's already working.

Claus Sauter

executive
#24

Also, we have third parties—filling stations and other companies—that were putting money into LNG filling stations, and those are now being supplied with bio-LNG from us. Ethenolysis is the gateway into the chemical industry. So the plant site has been secured. Finding the right location proved harder than we anticipated, but the plant site has been secured. The approval processes for the ethanol uses plant are still pending. And from the government, we'll receive an investment subsidy—not as attractive as what's offered in the United States, but it comes to roughly 25% of the investment. So thank you very much, ladies and gentlemen. Thank you, Alina, for presenting the numbers. And at this point the floor is open for a Q&A session.

Operator

operator
#25

Thank you so much, and to begin with, Mr. Sauter and Ms. Köhler, I really appreciate the presentation the two of you gave. <<operator_script>>. Our first questions come from Jonah Emerson. Jonah, the floor is yours.

Jonah Emerson

analyst
#26

Great. Are you able to hear me?

Claus Sauter

executive
#27

Got it, very clear.

Jonah Emerson

analyst
#28

Okay, great. Yes, I'll begin with two questions from my side. First, what amount of quota credits do you have started at present? And do you anticipate carrying any of that over into the following fiscal year? Then for my second question, what size are your renewable natural gas reserves at the moment? Of this product, how much has been sold compared with how much has been stored? And what does that picture look like in Q4?

Alina Köhler

executive
#29

For competitive reasons, we aren't disclosing how much quota we hold on our balance sheet. The gas we began with on the balance sheet comes to roughly 750 gigawatt hours. As we mentioned earlier during this call, we've already begun supplying bio-LNG. So the growth in gas reserves is already easing somewhat.

Jonah Emerson

analyst
#30

May I also pose an additional question related to that?

Alina Köhler

executive
#31

Absolutely.

Claus Sauter

executive
#32

Perhaps I should just add one thing. We sold quite a lot of our quota in February as well. That was before the major slump arrived and quota prices dropped from 460 to 200. It has since bounced back to 270, 300. However, at these levels we aren't selling right now. So more — we now have the flexibility to take it and store it. As I said, we sold a substantial volume, yet nobody is forcing us to sell our quota at current price levels. That is another considerable benefit. With biodiesel, the quota is tied to the molecule, and when biodiesel prices are that low, we cannot retain the quotas. For the gas business, though, we are now boosting our sales of the molecules straight into transport. We are capturing the CO2 savings and holding on to it. Okay. Go ahead, Jonah...

Jonah Emerson

analyst
#33

Right, so at that point we're consigning cap along with renewable natural gas reserves. The level sits at 750 right now. Your initial go back in the day was roughly 1,000. Yeah, so what's it going to look like in Q4, right? How much — I mean, you've probably already — if you add all of it up, you've probably already hit 1,000. Could you maybe give a little more insight into Q2, on how much you're actually planning to sell from your renewable natural gas?

Alina Köhler

executive
#34

That hinges on how quickly our gas stations ramp up. So we can't comment on that yet. Depending on how much we can already sell through those stations, we won't store a significant amount that we can deliver directly to the transport sector right away.

Jonah Emerson

analyst
#35

That’s great. Thank you...

Claus Sauter

executive
#36

Our expectation is that it holds steady right there, meaning you won't see any additional rise beyond that.

Jonah Emerson

analyst
#37

Alright.

Claus Sauter

executive
#38

It's somewhat tied to this, though as Alina mentioned, it hinges on how quickly the filling stations ramp up. Still, the fact that we can already deliver bio-LNG came about faster than we had anticipated. So we're assuming it will remain at that level, around 750 gigawatts. Okay?

Operator

operator
#39

Appreciate the questions, Jonah. <<operator_script>>. It looks like you haven't unmuted yourself just yet. <<operator_script>>

Niklas Becker

analyst
#40

Yes. Good morning, Mr. Sauter and Ms. Alina — this is Niklas Becker calling from Deutsche Bank. I have a few questions as well, and I'd like to go through them one at a time. My first one concerns the European biodiesel market. What's your own take on where things stand? Do you think it will get resolved? Or, based on your experience, what outcome seems most likely? And beyond that, do you see this becoming a structural issue down the road — with oversupply, and with customers able to source the biofuel from cheaper alternatives? Also, could you shed some light again on the unannounced audits by the ISCC and give us some context on the 5 withdrawn certificates? How many are there in total?

Claus Sauter

executive
#41

Apologies — you asked for one question at a time, and now there's a lot looming. Alright, regarding competition from cheaply sourced biodiesel: this isn't the advanced biodiesel that's arriving here. The fact that everything is simply pouring in from China — you can smell it, you can literally smell it. And the fact that the first oil companies have now begun saying, sorry, no, we won't accept it anymore. I think it's already a scandal that it was possible to bring these huge volumes into Europe, into Germany, because all these products are suddenly arriving from China now. So you can smell it. At least we expected something along these lines. During the process when this law that we're currently implementing was being drafted, we said publicly in hearings that the entire system is fragile. And it was only a matter of time before something like this would happen. And finally, fraudulent imports have been coming for already 5 years. But the volumes were low — 50,000 per month, 30,000 — and then it was spreading everywhere across Europe. Now at 250,000, that has a dimension that is truly dramatic. And to your question about what we expect: we expect that it will go away sooner.

Claus Sauter

executive
#42

In the short term, it's going to disappear, since legal proceedings have been launched from Berlin and from Brussels, though that will require time. The stronger argument now is that since all of this has already become public—and is growing more public—at least it's the oil industry that is getting around things with a fraudulent product, one that isn't advanced. If you keep pursuing this notion of committing fraud, why use biodiesel at all? Just do it with diesel. So the key issue now is that this product will simply be shut out by the oil industry. Everyone is aware there's an enormous question mark. Massive volumes are coming, all of it solely from China. All at once, everything gets labeled as advanced. That simply isn't possible. From our perspective, we anticipate it will vanish quickly—and that's also why we're fighting for biodiesel from these sources, as far as equipment goes, to be canceled retroactively, to be canceled, because it's simply too blatant. Then let's see how things unfold, but the market distortion—we expect it will be gone in the short term. Yet, as I mentioned, we also want the volumes that have already been blended to be canceled, because the oil industry, in Germany for instance, is sitting on roughly 2 million, 3 million tonnes of CO2 savings—if they were heavily using these kinds of biofuels now, they could even scale it up.

Claus Sauter

executive
#43

It just can't be that something like this is going on. So all right, those are the key points. Could you say again whatever I haven't answered yet, please?

Niklas Becker

analyst
#44

Yes, that was quite clear. Perhaps just a single follow-up regarding the Wistron certificates. Could you provide some context around the fight withdrawn certificates that you brought up? Are you aware of how many there are in total in China?

Claus Sauter

executive
#45

Apologies, but you'll need to take a look at what we have lined up for <<inaudible>>.

Niklas Becker

analyst
#46

<<foreign_lang>>

Claus Sauter

executive
#47

All right. Well, there are at least 43 producers, with 2.4 million tonnes of capacity. And up until 2022, everything—or most of it—was labeled as used cooking oil methyl ester. So the first point is that technically, using advanced feedstock in this technology doesn't work—that's number one. As for your question—these are just estimations. But right now, the German market is the most attractive one for this product. So when we look at January, 250,000 tonnes, and most of it should have come to Germany, then 250,000 tonnes creates about 500,000 tons of CO2 savings, because 1 ton of biodiesel makes 2 tons of CO2 savings. So 250,000 tons, 500,000 tonnes of CO2 savings—and this 500,000 tonnes, if it is really advanced, is creating 1 million tonne of CO2 savings. So for 2023, the overall target for CO2 savings is 16 million tonnes. So you see, from China alone, this amount of CO2 savings is huge—in January only. So at least if we continue with these Chinese imports without doing something, 60%, 70% of the German quota can be fulfilled with this product—dramatic. So under lease situation, if you see our results under these spots—but then we did a really great job.

Niklas Becker

analyst
#48

All right, that's quite clear. Now for my second question, given that we're already in Q4. As we look toward next year, with major events and profit drivers set to come on stream — including, on one side, the downstream expansion, and on the other, the North American capacity starting up. Yet at the same time, pricing-related headwinds remain. At present, consensus has EBITDA at roughly EUR 320 million for the coming financial year. How do you view that figure? In the current environment, would you call it ambitious, or is it achievable? And perhaps you could give that number some context.

Claus Sauter

executive
#49

All right, a question back to you: what exactly do you mean by pricing headwinds?

Niklas Becker

analyst
#50

Given how pricing is behaving right now, and the pressure we're seeing on the spread side.

Claus Sauter

executive
#51

Okay, so the margin pressure stems from fraud, and fraud isn’t just hitting Europe and Germany—Chinese used cooking oil imports are also damaging the U.S. market. The U.S. authorities, though, move much faster and act more decisively than their European counterparts, yet the U.S. market is still affected. In a normal situation there’s no pricing headwind, because—as I mentioned—for vegetable oil across the entire vegetable oil segment, mainly rapeseed oil and soybean in the U.S., we’re bullish, but prices are declining since there’s no demand for biodiesel, or it’s difficult for our competitors to earn a margin. That’s the reason. Our plants continue running at full capacity. However, if you want to sell rapeseed from the most recent harvest today to a European oil mill, they’re full. They won’t take it because vegetable oil demand—especially rapeseed oil demand—is weak. So that explains why prices have been falling. At least once the fraud is resolved, we expect vegetable oil to rise again, because at that price level farmers can’t make money.

Claus Sauter

executive
#52

We aren’t seeing those headwinds. To return to the question you raised specifically: for the new business year, EUR 320 million EBITDA — that’s a bit too early. Right now we’re in the middle of planning the new business year. And this year, as usual, we provide guidance only for the next 12 months. We’ll keep doing that, but we also want to give an implication for the next 2 or 3 years, because at this point we have a clear view. Our strategy is clear. IRA in the U.S. is clear. So we’re able to look somewhat further ahead, okay? But as for EUR 320 million, it’s a little too early. We need to do our planning. We’ll come out with it in September.

Niklas Becker

analyst
#53

All right. And maybe just a final question regarding the South Bend acquisition. Could you share a bit of insight into the EBITDA contribution and how we should think about the phasing going forward...

Claus Sauter

executive
#54

Ethanol pricing in the U.S. is quite volatile, yet typically at a facility such as South Bend right now, you can generate a margin of between $0.10 and $0.20 per gallon from traditional ethanol output. So in normal circumstances — at full production, that is — we'd put it at roughly EUR 10 million to EUR 20 million of EBITDA, if we simply operated the plant. However, we intend to begin our investment as quickly as we can, and that investment is going to affect how the plant runs. So, to keep it brief, the contribution from South Bend while our technology is being installed — this is fanatic — won't be very large and may even turn negative.

Operator

operator
#55

Appreciate the questions. A few also came in through chat. Let's begin with the first one. Is there a chance that low or negative spreads could force you to slow down or halt biodiesel output for a period in Germany? And when do you anticipate the fourth Chinese imports will wrap up?

Claus Sauter

executive
#56

I believe I've already addressed that. Our expectation is that the Chinese will halt in the short term, since it's simply too obvious. And no — we still have some margin on biodiesel. I think we made that clear in the slides. At the moment we don't foresee any risk that negative margins would force us to cut biodiesel output in Germany. Our margin is positive — not from biodiesel production itself, but once co-products are factored in, we do generate a positive margin. And I think you could see that our EBITDA margin came in at 25.8% last year. Right now it stands at EUR 7.9 million, which is disappointing for us, but at least the margin remains positive.

Operator

operator
#57

Okay, let's take the next question. We've gotten a few additional inquiries about the South plant. Could you shed a bit more light on the key risks around where your R&D breakeven sits? Also, do you have the right people in place there, and what's the situation with the procurement contracts?

Claus Sauter

executive
#58

Alright. On this slide here I’ve laid out what gives us our competitive edge — meaning that even when ethanol earns no margin at all, we still get EUR 0.50 per gallon. That’s what the competitive advantage looks like. The plant runs at full capacity. So there’s a team in place, and we took over that entire team. As I mentioned, our engineers were on site. On May 2, we presented our concept to them. And yes, the response was extremely, extremely favorable. Finally, I’m pleased with the team there. These are seasoned people from the former owner’s side; their chances to enhance the plant and contribute their ideas had been constrained, since the former owner, Mercuria, is essentially a trading house. They don’t have those kinds of engineers. So yes, it’s quite encouraging. We’ve got a team, and everything looks very promising. So, feedstock. Feedstock is short term on both counts. So we don’t have there — it’s the same situation in the U.S. as in Europe: no long-term contracts exist. We’re carrying on, doing business the usual way. Corn gets purchased at the market, 1 to a maximum of 3 months forward, and we have to watch what market conditions look like. The question about RNG — what’s your breakeven? Look, corn comes in, ethanol and RNG go out.

Claus Sauter

executive
#59

Think of it as a refinery: crude oil comes in, and out comes diesel, gasoline, and chat fuel. So if you're at breakeven on your diesel, and we look at how the market has been over the last 12 months, when diesel was far pricier than gasoline, then you can see it. You might even take a loss on gasoline, because you're earning a super margin on the diesel. That's our business model as well. I can't give you a figure at which RNG is profitable. The 2 main products that are going out have to give us a margin base on a bushel of corn. So that's the point. Feedstock goes in, 2 main products go out, and they get priced differently by the market. Natural gas in the United States also has a lot of volatility. That -- but at least renewable natural gas in the United States is far cheaper than in Europe, which makes it more competitive, which also makes it more interesting for so-called voluntary markets. So in the U.S., we see more and more demand coming from Maritime. So big cruises with LNG engines, they ask for renewable natural gas, bio-LNG. So there's a lot of development, a lot of movement.

Claus Sauter

executive
#60

And on that slide, what we presented is important — our edge over the conventional ethanol plant comes to roughly $0.50 per gallon...

Operator

operator
#61

Okay, thanks a lot for going into detail on that. And could you kindly remind us about the potential in the U.S. market for selling biomethane as fuel?

Claus Sauter

executive
#62

Like I mentioned, renewable natural gas is used for transport. Demand in the market is strong. In California it tended to be extremely high. In California, virtually all of the natural gas that's used for fu— for fuel is already renewable natural gas. In other states — Texas, Illinois, all across the Midwest — there's demand for filling stations. And set against diesel, RNG is the most appealing fuel. So demand is sufficient. And as I said just now, voluntary demand is picking up, <<inaudible>>, when I speak about transport, but also the chemical industry, methanol production, the steel industry — everyone is requesting renewable natural gas. So demand is extremely, extremely high and it's rising very quickly. We have more inquiries for RNG than here in Europe, and large volumes, truly large volumes. So it's fairly positive. That's the first thing. The second thing is that with the ability to liquefy renewable natural gas, it's also interesting to supply U.S. RNG to the German or the European market. And then, let's say, after some pause in natural gas heavy-duty transport, the market is returning, because compared with diesel it is very appealing. That pause stemmed from the extremely high natural gas prices last year.

Claus Sauter

executive
#63

So a few of the full years were taken aback. But now, with the ability to provide their bio-LNG, we can promise them a steady price, and we can promise them a discount relative to facilities. So this bio LNG is a game changer when it comes to price stability for the hauliers, and second, for decarbonizing transport. Next question, please.

Operator

operator
#64

Yes. The upcoming questions concern the request for a comment on the recent Indian activities, where things currently stand, the time planning, the business volume, and also the utilization and profitability of the plant.

Claus Sauter

executive
#65

Alright, India isn't generating profit right now. The EBITDA there runs roughly negative EUR 2 million annually, at minimum. It remains quite modest in scale. That said, we're currently collaborating with the Ministry of Oil & Gas on what's needed to strengthen the business case. Last year India was heavily occupied with elevated oil and gas prices, since the Indian government — specifically the oil ministry — provides subsidies for oil and gas, and that ultimately hurt our business. So we managed to bring our expectations straight to Hardeep Puri, the Minister of Oil & Gas. We held multiple meetings. And at present we're pursuing legal amendments that are required for us to raise our capacity in India. However, right now India is a startup — it holds enormous potential, yet at the stage we're in today, we're essentially doing classic first-mover work. First, the legal framework has to be sorted out. Then, as a second step, we can consider expanding our capacities. But per our timeline, the plan is unmistakably to make India profitable, with a positive EBITDA contribution in the next year, the next business year.

Operator

operator
#66

Okay, thanks a lot. You also said you're prepared to make additional acquisitions in the U.S. — so what further plans do you have, or how much additional firepower is available to you here?

Claus Sauter

executive
#67

I don’t get that question. What does firepower mean… As always…

Operator

operator
#68

What additional plants do you intend to...

Claus Sauter

executive
#69

Additional expansion goes hand in hand with how we finance it. At present, our equity ratio remains at 75%. We need to observe how that will play out. So my sense is there's room for 2 more acquisitions — within the South Bend range. Roughly that kind of thing ought to be feasible. And from a financing standpoint, that's why I brought up the 30% investment tax credit, which represents the equity. With the IRA, there are also opportunities for new financing structures thanks to U.S. projects, since typically the banks finance the ITC as well. So we need to examine that now; South Bend was funded through equity. Raising their money wasn't required. But at this point we're exploring which options, in light of the IRA, could let us do more. As of now, I'd say through the end of 2024, it should be feasible to complete 2 additional projects.

Operator

operator
#70

Much appreciated. Jonah sent us one more question to address...

Jonah Emerson

analyst
#71

Yes. Thanks for taking my question once more. So essentially, regarding what you just said — right, so 2 acquisitions through the end of 2024 — does that mean we could potentially maybe even expect one more acquisition still within the rest of this year? Or would you expect both of them to arrive during next year? How far along are you even when discussing that side?

Claus Sauter

executive
#72

I assume you're referring to the calendar year rather than the business — because within the business, for you, it's 1 month...

Jonah Emerson

analyst
#73

I’d like to make one remark.

Claus Sauter

executive
#74

No, no, Jonah, it's too early right now. Like I said, at this point we aren't focused on anything in particular, and South Bend required 1 year. So we have to — so not before the end of 2024. Perhaps something could come faster. I doubt it will be faster, since ethanol in the U.S. faced some pressure, margin pressure, and margins have recovered now. So almost everyone is profitable at the moment. That means acquisitions will cost more and be harder to do as well. So we're still scanning the market. We're trying to find something you can put into your model right now.

Jonah Emerson

analyst
#75

All right. Great. Thanks — that was actually what I wanted to ask. I appreciate it. And thanks for your time.

Claus Sauter

executive
#76

Yes. Perhaps just a bit to add on that, Jonah... Obviously, we're sticking with our plan to expand production capacity. For a few years now, we've been saying that the U.S. market is the preferred one. And those statements came before the IRA. So the IRA acts like a toolbar — a double turbo boost for our business. In any case, we need to examine our firepower, what we're truly capable of doing. By firepower, I mean not just having capital available; we also need staff available. That's very good in South Bend, where we managed to bring on an already experienced team. In Nevada, for instance, we really have to build everything from scratch. So — but what I want to say here as this call wraps up is that we're still carrying on with our strategy. We intend to grow our capacities. We intend to grow our trading activities, trading these volumes, and to keep advancing with our main molecules — methyl ester, ethanol and methane — into chemical applications. Nothing has changed.

Operator

operator
#77

Thanks, Jonah. Mr. Salta, would you be able to share some detail with us about what's planned for the trading desk and Stanford?

Claus Sauter

executive
#78

Trading volumes aren’t meaningful at this point. We’ve got the team in place right now. And with the type of trading operation we run, there’s groundwork to do—we need to build out logistics. In our business—and this is visible here with the Chinese fraud situation—the entire logistics system and the whole operation must be certified. So at present, we’re going through that process. As I mentioned, the traded amounts aren’t significant. There’s a positive contribution in the single-digit millions to the business, but it isn’t significant. And I believe we’ll be in a position to scale up trading volumes and also to move the molecules by the end of 2023. So what we’re planning now is to import bio LNG by the end of 2023—significant volumes into Europe—or the U.S. angle is to export it from the United States.

Operator

operator
#79

Okay, thank you. And since we’re now at the point of taking the final question, could you give us some indication of how much revenue currently comes from the first product and how much comes from the second-generation product?

Claus Sauter

executive
#80

That's a really good question.

Operator

operator
#81

That's the reason our segmentation is being changed -- so that when we get to next year, we'll provide you an answer on that for the following financial year.

Claus Sauter

executive
#82

Yes. That’s an interesting question, because Europe’s definition of advanced biofuel differs from the one used in the U.S. So I understand where the question is headed — it concerns advanced biofuel for the German market within the European business. But allow me to add a note on this point. When we discuss VERBIO as a company, our strategy, and where we intend to go, we shouldn’t focus so heavily on German and European legislation. Ours is a global business, and the feedstock is biomass. That is also why the best pricing exists, and it explains why all the Chinese are bringing their proud product into the European or German market. Right now, in Germany, it is advanced biofuel. That product is the most profitable, but it will disappear as well. And we have — when we discuss our strategy, a broader perspective is needed, because many of the definitions, particularly regarding scientific fuels, the European definition indicates there will be no investment since it is too complicated. Germany and Europe will have an obligation for renewable fuels of nonbiologic origin, but no production capacity will exist.

Claus Sauter

executive
#83

And that matters. So a lot of what we make — IO diesel, for instance — is entirely advanced biofuel destined for the U.S. market. Under U.S. legislation, biodiesel on its own counts as advanced biofuel. In Germany, by contrast, if it's produced from rapeseed oil, that's first generation. So, to be more precise. But returning to your question and to what Alina said, yes, our reporting will change, and it will make clear what is first generation and what qualifies as advanced biofuel under European regulation. Right now we don't have those figures clearly, because we're in the process of changing our accounting and preparing everything so that we have genuinely clear figures. At the moment, I'd say it's roughly 30% of our production. It's all of our guess, it's a type of biodiesel, but it's around 25%, 30%.

Operator

operator
#84

Okay, thanks a lot. Well, this brings us now to the conclusion of today’s earnings call. Once again, many thanks to Mr. Sauter and Ms. Köhler for making time and sharing all those fascinating specifics. Thanks as well to everyone who joined and to those who submitted questions. Mr. Sauter, I’ll turn things over to you for a few closing words before we wrap up.

Claus Sauter

executive
#85

Alright. Thanks a lot to everyone listening. There’s nothing further I can add. We’ve covered it all. Alina, perhaps you have something?

Alina Köhler

executive
#86

No. Thanks a lot.

Claus Sauter

executive
#87

Thanks a lot. Alright, so we're looking ahead to the next call, and we're confident that we'll be able to share more encouraging news, and that in particular the China situation will be finished. And what matters even more to us is that this will now carry real consequences — for instance, volumes already blended in January and February will be canceled. That is, right now, especially my job to speak with the ministries, because first of all, it was anticipated. We informed them that they needed to take action. And now we have it, and now it has to produce consequences, since at least big oil also knew that it simply isn't possible for all this type of product to be arriving from China at this point. Many thanks, ladies and gentlemen. I hope you have a pleasant day. And as I mentioned, we're looking ahead to the next call. Have a good day. Goodbye.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Verbio SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Verbio SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Verbio SE or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.