Verbio SE (VBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
September 26, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood afternoon, everyone. Montega welcomes you to this Verbio Vereinigte BioEnergie AG earnings call, held after the annual report for the 2022, 2023 financial year was released. Claus Sauter, our CEO, along with Olaf Tröber, our CFO, will present the results to you shortly, and after that presentation the floor will open for any questions you may have. We're eager to hear those results, and with that, I'll turn things over to Mr. Sauter.
Claus Sauter
executiveThanks a lot, Mrs. Volz. Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to today's presentation. Joining me today is Olaf Tröber, our CFO. It's wonderful to have you with us on this call. We'll be covering our Q4 and full year 2022, 2023 results. In addition, we'll share some thoughts on what to expect for the current year. The strategic update covering the midterm will come at our Capital Markets Day in Schwedt on Thursday. For those of you who have registered and plan to attend, we're looking forward to meeting you in person. I'm particularly excited that every one of my fellow board members will be present and will offer you more detailed insights into our business. Now shifting attention to the actual business year, 2022, 2023, I'm personally in awe of what the Verbio team delivered over the past year. Throughout what have been somewhat uncertain times, there are three highlights I'd like to point out. First, we achieved our second-best EBITDA in Verbio's history. Second, we generated 3.4 million tons of CO2 savings worldwide. 40% stems from advanced second-generation biofuels. That's a significant increase and represents 20% growth year-on-year on CO2 savings, while production volumes measured in GWh increased by 8%, underpinning the increased share of high-saving second-generation fuels.
Claus Sauter
executiveSo we're well on track to hit our 8 million tons CO2 saving targets in 2026. Third, we're doubling down on our strategy. Our Nevada plant in Iowa is complete, and we'll be commissioning the combined ethanol and RNG plant shortly. Construction has already begun in South Bend, and we're very excited about the opportunities in North America. We're investing in expanding our retail gas station network, with nine gas stations already operational. And we've commenced construction of our ethenolysis plant in Bitterfeld and the catalyst factory in Hungary so we can bring our green solutions to the chemical industry. Let me give you a quick overview of our 2022, 2023 key figures. We achieved record production volumes for all of our main products. Biodiesel production volumes rose 8% year-on-year, mostly driven by better utilization in Canada. Bioethanol volumes were up 20% year-on-year, mainly due to the acquisition of the South Bend plant in May. Our RNG production grew 22% organically. Our EBITDA for 2022, 2023 was EUR 240.3 million, and while the results don't meet our initial expectations of EUR 300 million due to unexpected and fraudulent Chinese biodiesel imports, we are in line with our most recent guidance of EUR 240 million EBITDA.
Claus Sauter
executiveBy the end of the year, our net cash had fallen to EUR 57.4 million, mainly because of growth investments exceeding EUR 250 million. At year-end, the equity ratio was 70.3%, staying largely stable. Now I'll pass things to Olaf so he can walk us through the Q4 results. Over to you, Olaf.
Olaf Tröber
executiveCould I have the mouse, Claus? Thanks. Key figures. Here we go. Thanks, Claus, and good afternoon — or good morning, everyone, depending on where you're located. Moving to our Q4. For Q4, we reported an EBITDA of EUR 26.8 million, in line with expectations. Last year isn't a suitable comparison point, since we had a favorable long position in feedstocks, as you may remember, which gave us the most successful quarter in the company's history. We'll go into more detail shortly, but as the graph shows, our ethanol and biomethane segment more than offset the negative result in the biodiesel segment and delivered the best quarterly result of the past financial year. Once again, this demonstrates the resilience of our unique product portfolio. No. Yep. Although we ran at nearly full capacity in Europe and overseas, European biodiesel prices fell sharply, year-on-year, by as much as EUR 1,000. You may recall that biodiesel prices spiked by roughly EUR 2,400 a year ago. And quarter-on-quarter, we saw a downward trend in biodiesel prices of EUR 400 per ton on average, driven by Asian biodiesel imports. Claus will address that in a minute.
Olaf Tröber
executiveSo sales also declined, reaching EUR 266.4 million. That, combined with less favorable purchasing costs, resulted in a gross margin close to break-even, and therefore a negative EBITDA. Although the imports are not fully resolved, fundamentals have begun to recover, so market spreads—and in particular our production margins—look much better now. As I mentioned, prices deteriorated strongly, or I would say temporarily, during our Q4, which you can see in the right chart. It shows how European FAME minus ten biodiesel prices and rapeseed oil prices developed. Since we purchase our feedstock two to three months ahead, it becomes quite clear that our valuable by-products, as well as the greenhouse gas premium for higher CO2 reduction, held up our gross margin close to break-even. On the right chart, you can see how the corresponding market spreads developed. We have been very outspoken about the reason for declining biodiesel prices, and Claus will quickly give you an update on the Asian biodiesel imports.
Claus Sauter
executiveAlright. Thanks, Olaf. So what's the current situation with biodiesel coming in from China, which is probably made from Indonesian palm oil yet is mislabeled as advanced biofuels? On the chart here, you can see the trend, and although Chinese export volumes have come down from their January peak, as the graph on the slide shows, those volumes are still higher than in prior years, while on the feedstock side, we have both feedstock exports from China and product exports, and the product here is the biodiesel. So feedstocks have stayed just as high. But in mid-August 2023, the EU at last opened an investigation into the widespread fraud in biodiesel supply chains running from Southeast Asia to Europe. The sums involved are enormous. We're talking billions of euros. That investigation concerns tariff and tax evasion, since that is simpler than probing environmental fraud, but it beats having no investigation at all, and right now we are waiting to see the customs data for September. We know the European Commission had already begun on-site investigations at other plants. But just to give you some sense of the timeline, which all of you are of course interested in, in the next phase, a delegation from DG TREN visited facilities in Belgium on September fifteenth.
Claus Sauter
executiveAnd while they were there, the goal was to collect information on process technology and the market situation for advanced biofuels, plus what larger import volumes would mean. After that, an assessment of Chinese producers is going to be carried out, and the whole thing has to wrap up in nine months. Hi — tight, tight. One moment. So beyond what it does to biodiesel prices, this also affects the greenhouse gas quota. One second, please. Where's that chart? Biodiesel imports and ethanol. All right, so it affects quota prices, since suddenly there's so much more — and still questionable — high greenhouse gas reduction on offer, which pushes prices down. Notably, we only delivered CO₂ reduction quota contracts that were still closed at a time when prices sat above 300 metric, 300 EUR per metric ton. Quota prices matter for both the biodiesel segment and the ethanol biomethane segment. With that, I'll hand it back to Olaf.
Olaf Tröber
executiveThanks, Claus. The next slide is actually the one we're on right now — bioethanol, with a strong quarter-over-quarter recovery. Within the bioethanol segment, you can see a steep rise in bioethanol production volumes, driven by our South Bend acquisition, along with a fully organic gain in RNG production volumes. Combined with higher ethanol prices, that pushed revenues up quarter-over-quarter. As Claus mentioned earlier, we built only the greenhouse gas reduction volumes that had already been sold, while the rest sits on our balance sheet at production costs. We're pleased to have delivered EUR 336.2 million in EBITDA — the segment's best quarterly result in the past year. That's a gain of more than 100% quarter-over-quarter, helped by additional RNG volumes and greenhouse gas reduction volumes being sold. South Bend has also contributed a positive result already. Organic growth came in at 89% quarter-over-quarter. Year-over-year, much lower ethanol spreads could not be offset, even with additional RNG volumes and considerable amounts of Bio-LNG volumes being sold. Let's take a quick look at price and spread development for bioethanol. After spreads fell due to larger bioethanol imports from Brazil, they are holding at an attractive level. Arbitrage remains closed in all regions, which bodes well for the European bioethanol market.
Olaf Tröber
executiveOn South Bend, we remain very enthusiastic about the SBE acquisition, and May and June results this year have positively surprised us, but additional optimization steps are still needed so that production stays stable. In fact, if SBE had been included from the beginning of our financial year, it would have added roughly EUR 5.5 million in losses to our EBT. For the current year, we anticipate break even or a small positive EBITDA, depending on margins in the United States. We have, however, already begun initial construction work on our RNG plant. DDGS production will be phased out when our LNG production starts. I will now provide an outlook for our current financial year. Yeah, here we are. We expect EBITDA of EUR 200 million-EUR 250 million. We decided to provide a range given the uncertainties we face this year from Asian biodiesel imports. Let me quickly give you an overview of our assumptions. We expect high utilization in the biodiesel segment, I would say, as always. By doubling capacities for advanced biodiesel, the annual total capacity for fiscal year 2023 to 2024 will be adjusted to a whopping 710,000 metric tons from previously 660,000 metric tons.
Olaf Tröber
executiveIn Canada, we have agreements in place that deliver a satisfactory margin for the current financial year. Beyond the extra ethanol capacity of 250,000 metric tons in South Bend, the ethanol plant in Nevada is already fully included in our annual total capacity of 800,000 metric tons of bioethanol. Previously, that capacity stood at 342,000 metric tons. However, the Nevada plant will only hit full capacity in the fiscal year 2024 to 2025. We're facing a ramp-up phase this financial year. The same holds true for the biomethane plant in Nevada that was recently commissioned, and therefore, that unit will be loss-making in the financial year 2023 to 2024. In Germany, annual biomethane capacity is being adjusted upwards thanks to efficiency measures. Altogether, this will bring annual production capacity to 1,980GWh. I think it's fair to say, let's keep the 2,000GWh in mind. For the fiscal year 2023 to 2024, previously 1,300GWh, a moderate utilization rate is expected despite a significant growth in production quantities. In addition, to ensure full utilization of Verbio's proprietary fuel station infrastructure here in Germany, the board currently anticipates a further build-up of biomethane value volumes in inventory. As always, we base our price assumptions on prevailing forward curves.
Olaf Tröber
executiveWhen it comes to greenhouse gas quota prices, though, we're expecting pricing to come in a bit above what brokers are showing at the moment. By year-end, we expect a negative net cash position of EUR 150 million to EUR 110 million. Beyond our EBITDA forecast, that also takes into account CapEx of roughly EUR 300 million. Within that CapEx number are investments in the capacity expansions we've announced and in building out the ethenolysis plant here in Germany, plus some other projects in our pipeline aimed at capitalizing on the defossilization of our economies. Now, back to Claus, who will update you on our new segmentation plans.
Claus Sauter
executiveWe're quite conscious that all of you have a strong interest in seeing second generation and first generation economics broken out separately, and that interest is shared by us — that's the reason we originally intended to revise our reporting segments starting with our Q1 reporting. Our team has put in very diligent effort on this. That said, as you're aware, we operate biorefineries, and separating second generation from first generation calls for internal cross-charging plus complicated methods of cost allocation. In the end, our feeling was that we would be removing transparency instead of adding the extra transparency we had initially expected. We'll keep working on it and test it internally, and we will return to you with an update. With that, I'll pass things to Mrs. Volz for the Q&A session.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot for that presentation. Now we’ll move into the Q&A portion. To keep the conversation lively, we ask that you pose your question yourself over the audio line. To do that, click the Raise Your Hand button. If you joined by phone, please use the key combination star nine, then star six. If you aren’t able to speak openly, you can also put your question in our chat box. We’ve already got the first question through the audio line. Please go ahead, Adrian Pehl. You can unmute yourself now.
Adrian Pehl
analystOkay, can you hear me?
Operator
operatorYes.
Claus Sauter
executiveComing through loud and clear.
Adrian Pehl
analystOkay, thank you very much for having me. On the guidance question, Mr. Tröber, you also said that a somewhat higher greenhouse gas quota price has been factored in. I was just curious whether you could disclose what level you are assuming for that. And you also noted, of course, that the guidance is based on prevailing forward prices. On the other hand, we are already a bit further along now, at the end of September. I was just thinking that our spreads must actually have been quite reasonable and quite good in the first quarter. So what is the underlying base? Is it more the end of June that you look at, and then forward for the fiscal year, or is it rather the end of September? And lastly, on the guidance, are there any other factors we should take into account? Of course, that explains the guidance range at the lower end and at the upper end, so EUR 200-EUR 250. Let's take it here, and then I actually have some questions on the filling stations and biomethane.
Claus Sauter
executiveAll right, let's begin with this. First, on our assumption for greenhouse gas savings, what we're expecting is a recovery to EUR 250 per metric ton.
Adrian Pehl
analystMm-hmm.
Claus Sauter
executiveAlso, as usual, our guidance sits on the forward curves. Those forward curves are inverted, meaning that the further out we look, the thinner the margins become. That's the basis for our planning and the way we mirror the market. Typically, as we approach the delivery month, it picks up. The curves are nearly always inverted. What about Q1? You noticed that margins have returned for RME, rapeseed methyl ester. In the end, that backs up what I just told you. During the month, we're seeing fairly reasonable margins for RME. On ethanol, prices have also recovered there, and as Olaf said, the arbitrage between the US and Brazil is shut. Farmers in Germany had a very poor harvest, so quality is low, which means for us there's ample feedstock at sensible prices. On the chart I'm showing you here right now, this is ethanol versus wheat. You're aware that we have the flexibility to use any type of grain?
Adrian Pehl
analystCorrect.
Claus Sauter
executiveSo we go with the least expensive option. Right now, we're still getting direct inflows from agriculture of that low-quality grain. And at this point we're seeing a lot of corn arriving from Ukraine. That puts significant pressure on the feedstock market. So as far as Q1 and Q2 go, things look pretty favorable. That said, there's uncertainty around how things develop with China, and we see, or we have seen, that imports were declining. And, you know, when I read the press, our situation right now is merely one illustration of what's currently taking place with Chinese exports into Europe. So ultimately, once it emerges that China is being used to get around the anti-dumping duty from Indonesia, China must be blocked too. I'd also like to share something extra that you haven't asked about yet. Between 2022 and 2023, the quota in Germany rose by 1%. It moved from 7% to 8%. That 1% equals 1.5 million tons of CO2 savings. In 2024, the quota will rise by 2%, so it will move from 8% to 10%, which translates into an additional three million tons of CO2 savings.
Claus Sauter
executiveSo moving from 8%-10% represents an increase of at least 25%. The market is therefore expanding, and demand is going to rise. If we can handle that, the Chinese and the — I still hold the view that this is fraudulent, not the entirety of it, but the lion's share. Since at those factories, where normal biodiesel was being produced, you cannot process the feedstocks that are applicable for advanced biofuel. No, we have a separate technology for this, and a separate new plant had to be built. At least, it took us two and a half years to get that on stream, and the Chinese are doing it in six months. That is simply not possible. So reducing the import volumes from China, combined with the quota increase next year, ought to produce a more positive outcome. Still, that positive effect isn't reflected in the forward curve, and for that reason it also isn't reflected in our guidance. But uncertainty exists, and we don't like to build Luftschlösser. We prefer to stay down on earth, and for the first and second quarter, we will be quite positive. Did I answer all your questions?
Adrian Pehl
analystYes.
Claus Sauter
executiveAlright.
Adrian Pehl
analystAnd along with that,
Claus Sauter
executiveSo then go on.
Adrian Pehl
analystMoving to biomethane, I have a question. First, I wanted to determine the volume of biomethane and quota you're holding on the balance sheet. Perhaps the report contained a note on this that I overlooked, but could you provide the number? Then, more broadly—since these matters are clearly interconnected—how are things progressing with the filling stations? It seems to be moving somewhat more slowly than initially expected. And based on your comments in the report, it sounds as though during the current fiscal year you will be net storing additional biomethane rather than net selling from the stockpile of stored biomethane. Is that accurate?
Claus Sauter
executiveYes. Okay, honestly, I don’t have the breakdown between renewable natural gas that’s in the grid and the CO2 quota volume — that’s where RNG, as we’ll call it, comes in. I prefer the English term rather than biomethane; in my view, “renewable natural gas” is a much better English word. So we’re discussing RNG. That means RNG sitting in the grid, plus RNG already introduced into transport, which is delivering the CO2 savings — but we can give you that figure. Coming back to your assumption, well, two significant changes are underway. At present, quota prices are under pressure, and we have the advantage of being able to store the gas in the grid along with the CO2 savings. On this point — let’s say the pressure on quotas tied to Chinese imports — at this price level we can sell every day, so we don’t believe it will remain that way, and we expect a recovery, at the latest once a decision is made on the Chinese imports. Second, we have the filling stations, yes, LNG. Nine are already in operation, and each month, one and two are being added there. And I think everyone now grasps the rationale behind that move downstream, because the limiting effect — the limiting factor — will now be the gate to the client.
Claus Sauter
executiveWhat does the regulatory change involve? It means that green attributes can now be transferred from compressed natural gas in the grid to fossil LNG at a terminal. That is entirely new. The European grid is open at this point. So as a German producer, we previously couldn't, since Germany lacks a liquefaction terminal or an LNG terminal. Now we're able to swap the molecules to Spain, France, Belgium, even Poland, and bring the LNG — the liquefied molecules — to our filling stations. And that's the reason. You know, it was only decided recently, two to three weeks ago. A little administration still needs doing, but I, or we at Verbio, have been working 10 years on this, on this mass balancing. So that's the point. And with every LNG operation that's online, plus the fact that we have plenty of molecules in the grid, we can now monetize the green attributes at our own LNG filling stations. The LNG filling stations are now gradually becoming the limiting factor. The second major change is, perhaps you noticed the bankruptcy of bmp greengas.
Claus Sauter
executiveIt's a subsidiary of EnBW. An article came out in Handelsblatt not long ago, and they were selling large volumes of renewable natural gas to many municipalities. That piece mentioned a loss of EUR 750 million. What we're seeing at present, then, is extra demand from cities that previously held contracts with bmp greengas, and we've already signed a first small volume at sensible prices, which sit far below the sales prices bmp greengas had. I have to say, you know, bmp greengas was, yeah, growing larger and larger, and in the end, they were running a questionable business model. So long as sufficient renewable natural gas existed on the market, it worked. Yet ultimately they failed, because they sold a great deal, and then conditions shifted, since more and more renewable natural gas now goes to transport for greenhouse gas reduction, and prices tripled compared with the earlier situation. That means, yeah, it's now simpler to produce LNG, Bio-LNG from renewable natural gas. That's the first point. The second is that a new market is opening up now at sensible prices, one that lies outside the transport segment. So keeping the gas in the grid was not the wrong call.
Claus Sauter
executiveIn the end, we had no alternative, since we weren't willing to hand over that much margin to the operators of fuel stations for CNG. So I believe that was a sound call, and at this point I think we are stepping up how quickly we monetize the molecules, while at the same time we keep watching how quota prices develop. As I said, 25% more volume next year, for Germany alone, and if we can pair that with fewer volumes arriving from China, the market will see a very rapid shortage and the quotas will recover. As I already mentioned, our assumption is that it will return very quickly to 250 EUR per metric ton of CO2 savings. Okay?
Adrian Pehl
analystYes. Okay, here we go. All right.
Claus Sauter
executiveAny other questions?
Adrian Pehl
analystNope, I'm good. I'm getting back in line.
Claus Sauter
executiveAlright, thanks a lot, Mr. Pehl.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot for sending those in, and now we'll go ahead and take Constantin Hesse's questions. Mr. Hesse, you're able to unmute at this point.
Constantin Hesse
analystThanks a lot. OK, I have a few questions, mainly around M&A. I believe earlier there were some remarks regarding possible acquisitions in the US, and I think we're discussing a figure somewhere between 2 and potentially the close of the next financial year. So perhaps you could comment on anything regarding M&A — what you're seeing, or any — is there even a possibility of M&A during this financial year? And tied to that, given your cash position of EUR 170 million and EUR 300 million in CapEx, are there any potential cash needs you'd have to bring in from outside?
Claus Sauter
executiveAll right. The South Bend acquisition in Indiana was an M&A deal. So we're permanently on the lookout for new targets, because that also takes time, but acquiring 2 to 5 sites by the next business year is absolutely impossible. At the moment we're commissioning the plant in Iowa, so that it becomes profitable, so that we have positive cash flows from it. And Olaf mentioned that the contribution from the US on an EBITDA basis will be negative. That's correct, but if you take the IRA into account, and we're also getting an investment tax credit for the Iowa investment, then on a cash basis, the US is already positive, on a cash basis. So right now, the pure focus, and we have a big team in Iowa at the moment, is commissioning the plant and bringing it on stream as fast as possible. Second, well, I've mentioned it, we're going to start South Bend. South Bend is an ethanol plant that is operational, but we also have to invest there and install our renewable natural gas technology facility there. It's $230 million. So, and right now, with these projects, yeah, our team is busy. So going everywhere, not just with the projects, but the team as well.
Claus Sauter
executiveWhat we do technologically isn't that straightforward. Part of it is, you know, the question of how you construct the plant. So we're bringing people on board, and I imagine I don't need to remind you that recruiting engineers right now is tough in Europe, and it's the same story in the US. That means our primary focus right now isn't snapping up the next ethanol plant, and perhaps the one after that won't come until the following business year. What we're mainly concentrating on at present is getting the people in, teaching them — you know, I want the US to turn into a cash cow sooner rather than later. That's where our attention sits. That's what we're zeroing in on, and at the same time, we're thinking through ways to scale up our business model, though nothing can be shared on that front right now. It should be obvious that Verbio is expanding, that we're putting money into the future. The IRAs — with the investment tax credit alongside the production tax credit — give us the ideal conditions. It amounts to a double turbo, but we take it one step at a time.
Constantin Hesse
analystGot it. Thanks a lot.
Claus Sauter
executiveThanks to you too, Mr. Hesse.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot for that question. We've got another one coming in through Audionet from Jonah Emerson. Go ahead — you can unmute yourself at this point.
Jonah Emerson
analystHi there, and thanks for taking my question. I have another one about our guidance — more specifically, the bottom end of it, that EUR 200 million. Does that figure also factor in a quota price of EUR 250, which would mean the large gap between EUR 200 and EUR 250 comes mainly from the spreads?
Claus Sauter
executiveNo, no. Hey — the lower end, so you're saying that lower end is based on EUR 250?
Jonah Emerson
analystYeah.
Claus Sauter
executiveNo. I really just need to defer to Olaf here, since he handled the planning. No, it isn't EUR 250. In fact, we're expecting an even lower price there. I believe it ought to be the EUR 180 that we currently have.
Jonah Emerson
analystAlright, that's interesting — interesting. Good to know. And then when it comes to the spreads, probably lower than where they sit right now as well, or?
Claus Sauter
executiveYes. Sorry—could you say that again? No, no, one more time.
Jonah Emerson
analystSo then you’ve got the biofuel spreads—biodiesel and bioethanol. Do those sit at the same level, or would you also expect the spreads to improve toward the lower end of guidance?
Claus Sauter
executiveAs you’re aware.
Jonah Emerson
analystAlright.
Claus Sauter
executiveThe margins between rapeseed oil and biodiesel are determined by the forward curve.
Jonah Emerson
analystAlright.
Claus Sauter
executiveSo then there's no need for us to make an assumption, and it's the same story with ethanol. The one area where an assumption truly is required is the quota price. At present, we're sitting at roughly EUR 180, or nearly EUR 200 — it varies. And on that, our expectation is that it will reach at least EUR 250.
Jonah Emerson
analystPerfect, thanks. And then, yes, about the chemicals business — you brought it up a few times. When do you expect the first revenues from that chemical business to come in?
Claus Sauter
executiveIt won't happen before 2026 or 2027.
Jonah Emerson
analystAll right.
Claus Sauter
executiveGot it?
Jonah Emerson
analystOkay, got it.
Claus Sauter
executiveBut look, don't set your expectations too high at the outset. This is an investment in the future. It's an investment that demonstrates Verbio isn't reliant on the transport sector—here, we're a first mover. So my expectation, I'd say, is that through 2030 we won't be earning margins above those in transport. Through 2030, transport is quite attractive right now. Next year, in 2024, we'll have a 10% greenhouse gas quota, and it will rise to 25%. So for the remaining six years, there's annual growth of roughly 2.5% per year. So transport will dominate our business, but starting now, ethanol use—and we have similar ideas for ethanol—is adding value through the fact that our molecules carry green carbon. As I always say, you can't decarbonize chemistry; you can only defossilize it. I think at this point, something else I want to mention, though it wasn't your question: Verbio is now becoming a global company—or we already are global—with North America, India, which has huge potential, India, and two weeks ago I was in Brazil, so South America.
Claus Sauter
executiveIf we're discussing sustainable feedstock, we need to examine the local market. In Europe, sustainable feedstock means only residues and waste. In the Midwest of the United States, biodiesel produced from vegetable oil—soybean oil or canola—qualifies as an advanced biofuel there. Corn grown in the Midwest counts as a sustainable feedstock. In Brazil, every feedstock they use, and ethanol output there is always tied to sugar production. They use sugarcane, but a certain portion of polysaccharide cannot become sugar for human consumption. That residue, then, is directed into ethanol production. So the details matter a great deal. Take India—undoubtedly there are hundreds of millions of tons of genuine residues, and the fact that in the coming weeks India will again be burning and haze will blanket the continent. So undoubtedly 100 million tons of paddy, of rice straw, is available. But I think at this point, as a global player in this business and on this call as well, I believe the majority of participants on that call are European.
Claus Sauter
executiveWe need to consider the definitions, and we can't approach every market through a European lens. And I believe that's what makes our business model appealing right now: with a global network, we'll be able to supply the right molecules depending on the regulation and the market we intend to serve. And that delivers extra profitability. So I think at present I don't see anyone pursuing that path the way Verbio is, and at this stage where we find ourselves, North America isn't generating real money. We simply have to get the first plant started up. But during this business year and the one after, we'll come forward with reasonable figures from the US. That's just something I wanted to mention. Taking our European glasses everywhere around the world isn't a good idea.
Jonah Emerson
analystOkay, got it. Perhaps just one last question?
Claus Sauter
executiveRight.
Jonah Emerson
analystOn the reserves question — I get that you've already touched on this somewhat, but just as a very, very rough estimate: right now, how many GWh of renewable natural gas sit in the reserves? Are you able to share that?
Claus Sauter
executiveAnd what about the inventories?
Jonah Emerson
analystYeah.
Claus Sauter
executiveMy recollection is that the prior figure was 750GWh. I don't have the exact number in front of me at the moment, but it is higher than that.
Jonah Emerson
analystAlright.
Claus Sauter
executiveAlthough it comes in at less than 1 TB/hr.
Jonah Emerson
analystGreat, that's exactly what I needed.
Claus Sauter
executiveAll right, I believe — yeah, let’s take a look. That figure can be given to you. Olaf will handle it.
Jonah Emerson
analystOkay, thanks — I appreciate that.
Operator
operatorI appreciate it.
Claus Sauter
executiveHey Jonah, we’ve got that figure — 820GWh.
Jonah Emerson
analystThat's even better. Thanks.
Claus Sauter
executiveAll right, thanks.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot, Mr. Emerson, for that question. Mr. Adrian Pehl sent in a follow-up, so we'll take that now. Mr. Pehl, go ahead and unmute yourself, please.
Adrian Pehl
analystIs my voice coming through?
Operator
operatorYes, we can hear you now.
Adrian Pehl
analystOh, okay. Now, obviously. Thanks for taking my question. I just want to be sure about the guidance, both regarding the IRA effects, obviously.
Claus Sauter
executiveThat isn't part of it.
Adrian Pehl
analystRight, OK. So probably the option is, let's say, to sell a substantial stake in ITC, so to speak, which should help you fund the $300 million CapEx — but that isn't factored in either. So that comes on top.
Claus Sauter
executiveYes.
Adrian Pehl
analystRegarding what you mentioned about the financial guidance, correct?
Claus Sauter
executiveYes.
Adrian Pehl
analystI just want to be sure of that.
Claus Sauter
executiveYes.
Adrian Pehl
analystThat’s great.
Claus Sauter
executiveYes. And, you know, at present there is demand for investment tax credits, but that will hinge on — if we end up having to accept too much, a discount that is too high, then it comes down to the discount, how and when we monetize it. At the moment, with our investment plan covering the coming 12 months, even if we go down to net debt minus EUR 100, we are not nervous, because I think our balance sheet, the equity ratio will still be at 60%-70%, which is a reasonable figure. Okay, but I think we have far, far more questions. I see five questions in the chat. Please continue, Mrs.
Operator
operatorAnd we also have a question coming in through the audio line from Niklas Yannik Becker. Go ahead, Mr. Becker — you're able to unmute yourself at this point.
Niklas Becker
analystGood afternoon. Is my voice coming through clearly?
Claus Sauter
executiveReceived you loud and clear.
Niklas Becker
analystGreat, thanks, and good afternoon everyone. I’ve got two questions. First, regarding the customer negotiations for 2024 that you normally wrap up by November or early December — I imagine those talks will get going shortly, if they aren’t underway already. In prior years you locked in meaningful levels above EUR 300 per ton of CO2, so what’s your expectation for this round? Do you plan to lock in portions of your GHG quotas, or would you rather keep those contracts floating?
Claus Sauter
executiveTalks have already begun, which answers the first part of what you asked. Yes, we're in negotiations over next year's contracts. As for the quota level, at present we favor floating contracts tied to the quotation.
Niklas Becker
analystGot it. And then just a quick second question, also about the quota market. I believe when we last spoke, you said the quota market had essentially dried up, and that was one factor behind the quota price sitting at roughly EUR 250 per ton since March. In your view, what's behind the price more recently climbing below EUR 200 per ton? Is it forced sellers coming into the market, or is there something else you've picked up from the industry?
Claus Sauter
executiveLately, the primary sellers of quota — and this has been announced — were Shell and BP. So what's their reason for offloading quota? New negotiations are approaching, and certainly during this negotiation stage, they're aiming to show us where quota pricing stands right now. That means there's pressure in the market. There are buyers and sellers. A few of them may hold too much, though as I noted, we'll require an extra three million tons of CO2 savings next year. So certainly, previously we entered into fixed contracts for CO2 savings, but we say, "Hey, at that price, what we're seeing right now." And, you know, you can see production declining. Many European producers can't supply biofuel at the level we currently have. If you look at Chinese imports, you know, logistics costs run around $250 per metric ton. Against current prices, that's a margin of 15%-16%. So it's only the added costs — feedstock stays the same — so it's simply not possible. But there's the quota price. The market is quite narrow, not particularly liquid, so when you put certain volumes into this market, you create a big impact.
Claus Sauter
executiveSo really, the question is how much volume actually sits behind the prices we’re seeing right now. And Verbio is a major player in that market. I’d say the volumes backing it aren’t that large, because in the end, most producers simply can’t supply quotas at 170 or 180 EUR per metric ton. I think that’s just part of the game.
Niklas Becker
analystAll right, thanks.
Claus Sauter
executiveMr. Becker?
Operator
operatorThanks a lot, Mr. Becker, for those questions. A few came in through our chat, and I believe Marcus Kobach has already addressed the first one, but I'll go ahead and read it aloud. How long have you been holding THG quota? At what point are you ready to sell them? And there's one more question from Mr.
Claus Sauter
executiveHold on, hold on, hold on, hold on. I'll take that one. You know, those CO2 savings can just sit on our balance sheet forever, as far as we're concerned. And yes, we'll sell them once a reasonable price comes along. As for the price we're seeing right now, from where we stand, it isn't reasonable.
Operator
operatorAll right, that's helpful. And for the reporting segment, what does the timeline look like now?
Claus Sauter
executiveFor this year, we'll keep using that same type of reporting. As I said in my presentation, the primary factor is the conversations we had with investors. A few months ago we did our first roadshow over in the United States. Really interesting meetings. And the clear takeaway was that we're going to take transparency away. So for that reason, Alina was particularly recommending and saying, "Hey, we wanted to bring more transparency into the market," but we can't ensure this, and that's why we say, "Okay, let's stay in this reporting system." Our clear target is to bring more transparency, so we'll give additional information the way we're doing it at the moment. So 40% of our biofuel production is now advanced, and for the German markets, that means the double quota. So everybody can make his model and have a good estimation. We also see it from our analysts that, let's say, the estimations are getting better and better, so it makes sense to leave it like this. But as I know that we are on the consensus at the moment, but please, you have to take into account that there is a distortion in the market, and you can do nothing against fraud.
Claus Sauter
executiveWhen it comes to fraud, there is nothing we can do as a company. That really is a black swan event, and the responsibility lies with the government or customs authorities in Europe and also in Germany to try to regain control. Then, as you know, market demand is growing very rapidly. We have everything required to monetize the molecules. We have our own downstream business. So now, with the market growing and accelerating, being able to supply the quantity of molecules needed to keep up with this demand is significant. And building additional capacities and bringing more capacity on stream, particularly in Europe, will take time. At present, I am not aware of any large projects in Europe that would provide additional big capacities for advanced biofuels. So regaining control over the Chinese imports is very important. And lastly, we factor that uncertainty into our conservative guidance.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot. A handful of questions came in about India. Are the results there falling short of what we expected, and what kind of timeline are we looking at before it turns EBITDA positive?
Claus Sauter
executiveAt 40% utilization, we're already EBITDA positive. That said, there's still a distance to travel. Profitability hasn't come in the way we expected. The facility we have in India is 20MW. So at 30% or 40% utilization, we're discussing 80GWh, which isn't a large figure. The Lehragaga plant serves as the blueprint for that continent. If you set India beside Brazil and consider Brazil's power, meaning biofuel, India holds comparable possibilities, yet nothing exists there. So the potential is substantial, but regulatory changes are needed. Fifteen months back, we went to the government. We presented four changes that we required. Three have already been implemented, and once we have a sensible business case along with the profitability we anticipate — and as I mentioned, on EBITDA we're already positive — then we want to roll it out. However that rollout takes shape, but our intention was never to go to India and construct their single renewable natural gas plant. Incidentally, we are by far the largest producer of renewable natural gas in India, at 20 megawatt, which is ridiculous. Still, we are by far the largest producer, and we maintain a good relationship with the Ministry for Oil and Gas India, and perhaps you noticed from the G20 meeting that Modi established the Global Biofuel Alliance there with India, with Brazil, and with the United States.
Claus Sauter
executiveAnd we could also put out our, yeah, let's call it, white paper. So we got word that this would take place. So we really have a solid line there, though minor items need to be handled, and I believe that next year we'll manage to develop the truly big plans. What does rolling it out mean if we do it on our own or alongside a partner? But we want to monetize our first mover pain.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot. Does the EUR 70 million EBIT scenario still hold?
Claus Sauter
executivePardon me, could you repeat that?
Operator
operatorThe question was whether the EUR 70 million EBIT scenario from Mr. Andres Guyom is still valid.
Claus Sauter
executiveHold on, hold on, hold on. From what I understand, the India results came in below what was expected, is that right? Does the scenario of EUR seven million EBIT still hold? What does seven million refer to? Is it INR seven million or EUR seven million? And EUR 70 million is a long way off. So right now EBIT is negative, but EBITDA is positive, and.
Operator
operatorThat’s the one you just fixed — it should be Indiana, not India.
Claus Sauter
executiveAh, ooh.
Operator
operatorIndiana, you have the floor.
Claus Sauter
executiveRight, right, right, right, right, right. Yes? It's related in Indiana. Okay, yeah, it's written there. Okay. Where these can come out for today. Okay, that's written correctly. It's Indiana. Yes. Regarding our competitive edge from renewable natural gas, along with the production tax credit, we're talking about a EUR 70 million EBITDA advantage. But at this moment in the US, ethanol margins are quite reasonable, so margins would be even better. So here too in the United States, we had a bumper corn harvest. A lot of corn came in, the weather was perfect. Corn prices dropped from $6.20 per bushel to $4.50. So it's a good year for everybody producing ethanol in the Midwest.
Operator
operatorAll right, and one final question before we wrap up today's earnings call, and this one comes from Mr. Thomas Schiessle: is the Canada business sustainable EBITDA positive, and not just across full year 2023 to 2024?
Claus Sauter
executiveI'm not sure what he intends by "sustainable," but Canada is EBITDA positive — mid, so not double digit, in millions of US dollars, single digit, yet positive nonetheless. Regarding biodiesel in North America, I should mention that there's an enormous number of announcements about what they intend to produce in HVO, hydrotreated vegetable oil. Massive announcements exist — millions of tons — particularly on the West Coast, but, well, throughout the United States as well. At present, we're reluctant to put substantial capital into Welland. We do have a business case there that looks quite appealing to us, and it certainly can proceed so long as no regulatory change occurs. However, investing money in Welland would be required to raise that plant to the standard of our European operations. So we're not yet at a point of having a feel for where the US biodiesel market is headed. HVO is a distinct technology. It sits closer to diesel, and producing sustainable aviation fuels from it is simpler, which is a plus, but the CapEx involved is far, far greater. Conversely, with biodiesel production, you gain the ability to create high-value co-products such as pharma glycerine and sterol.
Claus Sauter
executiveSo, Welland, we'll keep going the way we're operating right now for as long as we can, for as long as our read on where the market is headed feels right. Right now, the industry is undergoing a big shift. There are plenty of assets—biodiesel assets—for sale all over the US. Let's watch how things unfold over the next 12 months. As of now, we don't intend to put more money into Valent, but utilization is good. We're running at a margin, and let's see what comes next.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot.
Claus Sauter
executiveAnd there's another question I have as well. I see it right there — hold on, hold on, hold on.
Operator
operatorYes, we just got one final question from Mr. Ralph Lucow. He’s enthusiastic about the biomethane business segment, and he points to Jefferies’ forecast for 2022, 2023, and 2026 — for biomethane, EBITDA above EUR 175 million. Is that realistic?
Claus Sauter
executiveWhat's your expected TWh output for 2025 and 2026? Regarding the planning, I'm not sure what assumption Jefferies is using, but for 2025 and 2026, we should have 2 TWh of production — production capacity. RNG production still requires some time to ramp up. In any case, in 2025 and 2026 we will have 2 TWh of capacity.
Olaf Tröber
executiveAnd on top of that, capacity is nearly 90%.
Claus Sauter
executiveYeah. Regarding that EUR 175 million EBITDA — sorry, I can't put that question forward at the moment. Perhaps he could return to Alina, and then we'll look into it.
Operator
operatorAnd yeah, since we're at the forward point, that brings us to the close of today's earnings call, and we'd kindly ask Mr. Ralph Lucow to reach out to Mrs. Köhler. As was mentioned already, if any further question comes up at a later time, or your questions haven't been answered, please don't hesitate to get in touch with Mrs. Köhler, and I'd now hand things over to Mr. Sauter for some final remarks.
Claus Sauter
executiveYes, but let me finish this question first.
Operator
operatorAlright.
Claus Sauter
executiveDo you actually see a genuine opportunity to hit, or even beat, your best result over the medium term? Well, my view is that the last business year, 2021, 2022, was extraordinary. But we also know that, once again, it was the first time — I don't know — that war returned to Europe. Ukraine is a major player in the agriculture market, and so are the Russians. So there were plenty of distortions, and we handled them well. But the EUR 240 million we're making this year, under those circumstances, with Chinese imports, holds even greater value for me than the last business year did. So Verbio is growing, and demand for CO2 savings is simply enormous. We announced now that this year we had 3.4 million tons of CO2 savings, and that is, let's say, a good benchmark. By 2026, we want to move from 3.4 million tons of CO2 savings to eight million tons of CO2 savings. So we are more than doubling, and that is not a very ambitious target. It is a realistic target, and then we want to keep going. Just remember, we are talking about 50 billion tons of CO2 emissions globally, 50 billion tons, and Verbio is going from 3.4 million to eight million tons.
Claus Sauter
executiveEventually the moment will arrive when we surpass even last year's results, and that's our explicit priority — grow, baby, grow. Yet growth has to happen everywhere, which also means we require the staff and the organization in place. And whether we're doing one plant in the US, or doing two or ten plants in the US, then it's simply on the side. Still, our clear message is grow, baby, grow. We're on a good path, and that's the goal for the years ahead. Luckily, we're in a market where demand is rising everywhere around the globe, and the challenge is simply enormous. So, Mrs. Volz, I'm now finished, and I think, yeah, time is up. Anyone who couldn't get their questions addressed — anyway, I covered everything I wanted to cover on this call, so I don't know what would be left over. But if you have questions and couldn't raise them here, please feel free to call Alina Köhler. In any case, I believe some of the people on the call now we'll be able to welcome in two days for our Capital Markets Day in Schwedt.
Claus Sauter
executiveThanks a lot to everyone who joined. And thank you, Mrs. Volz, for putting the call together. You did a great job, and I’m looking forward to our next call. Many thanks.
Operator
operatorThanks so much for tuning in, and we hope everyone has a wonderful week. Take care.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Verbio SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Verbio SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Verbio SE or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.