Verbio SE (VBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 14, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood afternoon, everyone, and welcome to today's earnings call for VERBIO SE, held after the release of the 9 months and Q3 figures for 2023, 2024. We're very glad to have with us CEO Claus Sauter and CFO Olaf Troeber, who will be speaking shortly and walking us through the presentation and the results. After that, we'll transition to our Q&A session, where you'll be able to put your questions to them directly. With that said, Mr. Sauter, the floor is yours.
Claus Sauter
executiveThanks so much, Mrs. Malok. Good afternoon — or good morning, in my case — and I really appreciate you all joining today's earnings call. Olaf Troeber, our CFO, is here with me on the call today. Right now I'm in the United States, at our headquarters in Stamford, Connecticut. Things are moving along well here in South Bend, in Nevada, at the ethanol plants, and also in Valent and in Europe. Our strategy holds firm, even with the renewable market as dynamic as it is. We're now 10, almost 11 months into our financial year. And as we anticipated with our guidance cut in January for the actual financial year, the renewables market posed more of a challenge in the third quarter. But first, let me walk you quickly through our key figures for the first 9 months. As you can see, in good VERBIO fashion, we keep delivering strong production volumes, with output rising across all key products. The year-on-year biodiesel volume increase came mainly from the acquisition of South Bend ethanol in the U.S. — the plant we bought in May 2023 — and from the ramp-up we did over the last month. At South Bend, ethanol, we've managed to push production above the nominal capacity, which represents a 30% increase from just a few months ago.
Claus Sauter
executiveWe made technical adjustments, but the changes were mostly operational. So even with higher volumes, group EBITDA for the 9 months of 2023 and 2024 came to EUR 82 million, which is down year-on-year from EUR 214 million. The primary cause is pretty much the same as what we observed across the first 6 months. Let me restate that briefly. During the financial year 2022 and 2023, we were still enjoying the exceptional contribution from the biodiesel segment. Our biodiesel generated more than EUR 90 million in the first quarter by itself. At the same time, we are gearing up for additional growth, and that produced extra fixed costs year-on-year. Given that our European operations must still carry all growth investments and that we face near-term headwinds in the European biofuel market, these results are broadly in line with our own expectations. Net debt is EUR 55 million, with our investments in growth projects of close to EUR 130 million in particular weighing against our positive operating cash flow. Even so, our equity ratio, at a level of 68.4%, declined slightly. And now I would like to hand things over to Olaf Troeber, our CFO.
Olaf Troeber
executiveThank you, Claus, and a warm welcome from me as well. I'm joining you today with a bit of assistance as we hold our crown frigging ceremony for the Ethanol Schwedt plant. But first, let me turn to our Q3 results before we dive deeper into our strategic update. The chart displays the EBITDA bridge from Q3 '22, '23 to Q3 '23-'24 from left to right and gives you an overview of how both segments have developed. Once again, the biodiesel segment safeguards our earnings while the ethanol segment covers all the costs related to the U.S. expansion. The decline in the biodiesel segment year-over-year is mostly due to unrealized changes in the fair value of open commodity derivatives. Excluding this effect, the biodiesel segment result would have stood at EUR 21.1 million, close to the level in the previous year. Overall, we posted an EBITDA of EUR 7.3 million in Q3, '23, '24, down from EUR 43.2 million in Q2 last year and from EUR 26.1 million sequentially, but let us dive a bit deeper and look at the key drivers. While our sales volumes were roughly stable year-over-year, sales came down by 29% year-over-year. The main reason for the sales development in biodiesel segment, where the lower biodiesel and greenhouse gas quota sales prices in Europe compared to the same quarter of the previous year.
Olaf Troeber
executiveAlso, shifts in how sales revenues in Canada are presented resulted in a substantial decrease in revenues. What is the meaning of that? As of December 23, contracts covering production volumes in Canada are accounted for as storing contracts. This reporting change has no effect on our EBITDA. Nevertheless, the unrealized movements in fair value of open commodity 2. As you are aware, we hedge only opportunistically, and given that the Q4 forward spread stood at appealing levels while we operate in volatile markets, we chose to take a position. Including that effect, our Q3 reported EBITDA came in at EUR 11.44 million. On this chart, you can observe how market spreads in this case — biodiesel price per ton minus rapeseed oil price per ton — have evolved over the past 2 years and particularly during our Q3. This year's market spreads, depicted by the dark green line, sat below prior-year spreads yet stayed broadly stable across the quarter. Given that we purchase our rapeseed oil roughly 2 to 3 months ahead, we were unable to lock into spreads in financial year '22, '23. During the first quarter of the year 2024, which is our third quarter, biodiesel prices and rapeseed oil prices rose slightly.
Olaf Troeber
executiveDemand held steady, but biodiesel prices climbed as raw material costs rose and fossil markets priced higher. Turning now to ethanol and biomethane, or RNG. Production and sales volumes rose, largely because of the South Bend Ethanol acquisition in May last year, where we made big efficiency gains, as Claus mentioned earlier. As a result, revenues grew even though sales prices in Europe were lower. Grain prices also fell, but the lower greenhouse gas premiums in contracts starting January 2024 hurt overall margins. On top of that, of course, came U.S. expansion costs. And last year we earned roughly EUR 10 million more from additional quota sales than in Q3 this year. All told, we posted negative EUR 5 million EBITDA, which includes a positive effect from unrealized commodity futures. As you can probably see in the chart, average quarterly market spreads were about flat both quarter-over-quarter and year-over-year. Spreads widened during the quarter. And in the chart on the right, you can see the reason. Ethanol prices bounced back while prices kept trending down. Lower imports, especially from Brazil, cut ethanol stocks in water dam from 2023 thanks to higher blending mandates and the rollout of E10 in Poland and other places.
Olaf Troeber
executiveDemand for spot volumes was solid. The persistent backwardation is complicating ethanol imports and ought to support an upward price movement. In Germany, though, weak greenhouse gas quota prices keep holding back E10 expansion. The incentive that would grow the market share of fuels containing a larger share of biofuels is still constrained over the near term. Still, the antidumping probes underway at the European level, along with the media focus — especially on fraud cases tied to upstream emission reducers — leave us optimistic that the absent control mechanism will be put in place and that fair market conditions will return going forward. Claus will now bring you up to date on that and share the latest developments.
Claus Sauter
executiveThank you, Olaf. Yes, let me return to Main and the fair market situation shortly, in the near term. So as you can now see on that slide, the quota prices have been developing. Quota prices are still under pressure. But once more, we're seeing a new narrative around Chinese product. That new narrative is UER. The first thing visible on the chart is that starting in January 23, quota prices fell from EUR 400 per metric ton to 100, 120. And I believe what the chart shows us is that we've hit bottom, and that makes sense, since at this level — EUR 100 million, EUR 120, EUR 150 per metric ton of CO2 savings — even product from China, labeled as advanced biofuel, doesn't make sense. But now, what about UER? So UER is upstream emission reduction. A few reports came out recently on television and in newspapers. Upstream emission reduction is another way to satisfy the German regulation on greenhouse gas reduction. It was implemented in 2020. And it is capped at a maximum of 1.2%. So for instance, if there is a greenhouse gas reduction quota of 10%, then out of that 10%, 1.2% can be met through upstream emission reduction, which means 8.8% must be achieved via biofuels or renewable electricity.
Claus Sauter
executiveSo that's a significant point. We're discussing 1.5 million tonnes of CO2 savings annually that come from UER. And UER, for instance, refers to measuring greenhouse gas reductions at oil rigs and gas rigs. So anywhere globally where emissions originate from fossil crude and fossil gas upstream, all those measurements taken to cut these emissions count toward greenhouse gas reduction in Germany and several other European countries — though not every one of them. So what emerged is that with this UER project, we already have 95% located in China, where similar frauds exist as with imports of fate biodiesel. So it turns out at least 10 projects don't exist or aren't eligible. So some of these projects simply don't exist. They aren't there, even though they've been certified. And the certification body is the Deutsche Bundes-Immissionsschutzgesetz, which is part of Deutsche Bundesstiftung Umwelt. And since fraud could be demonstrated easily, the German government quickly put forward an amendment to the 36 Bundes-Immissionsschutzgesetz. So the draft and the accounting of upstream emission reduction certificates toward the greenhouse gas quota in 2024. But that's 2 years earlier than originally planned. And at least what pleases me is that this marks the first occasion the German government, in relation to Chinese proud, has truly reacted fast.
Claus Sauter
executiveThe announcement, therefore, produced a modest rise in greenhouse gas quota prices off their lows. Now, let me walk through the particular consequence shown on the next slide. As I said, UER were first put in place in 2020. In 2020, then, the greenhouse gas reduction quota stood at 6%. Of that 6%, 1.2% was UER. So at least relative to 2019, when the greenhouse gas quota was 4%, moving to 2020 at 6%, but with UER, the increase was at least only 1% between 2019 and 2020. So if we now compare and look at the chart, the chart displays the annual growth in market size of greenhouse gas savings in biofuel and e-mobility. Without the UER, that is only biofuels and e-mobility. We can see that in 2020, it actually declined — biofuel use was minus 0.2% — and then it rose again in 2022 by 1.9% and in 2023 by 2%. That is the reasoning behind that chart. And since the greenhouse gas quota was introduced in 2015. The sad increase of 1.25% plus the removal of the UER as a compliance option results in the largest increase ever, roughly 5 million tonnes of CO2 savings year-on-year.
Claus Sauter
executiveSo with upstream emission reduction going away at the close of 2024, you've got demand for liquid biofuels and e-mobility. The greenhouse gas reduction that must come from that segment is going to rise to roughly, or perhaps even past, 5 million tonnes. That's enormous. So this brings the overall renewable fuels market size to over 21 million tonnes of CO2 equivalent. Taken together, that means the CO2 savings cushion the oil majors carry on their balance sheets ought to weaken, ultimately triggering a buying spree and lifting prices once more. On top of that comes the drop in Chinese imports. That gives extra upside to every other renewable fuels and e-mobility market participant, and it's being driven by the EU antidumping investigation. So factoring in fewer imports from China of advanced biofuels, the EU investigation capped with no more UER, and the additional rise in obligation in 2025, we should see meaningfully greater demand for biofuels and greenhouse gas reduction in 2025. What about the investigation? So as of now, there's no retroactive cancellation of a quota plant, but the industry, naturally, and our associations continue to fight for that. So we've had particular interest from shareholders who want to back the fight against green product fraud.
Claus Sauter
executiveAlina and I have included several sources in the appendix, so you can check those links after the call if you're interested. I believe VERBIO was among the earliest firms to make that point quite forcefully on that path 1, 1.5 years ago. Today it's present everywhere. It showed up across Europe, and politicians at the European Commission came to see that ambitious greenhouse gas targets combined with an open market lacking oversight simply won't work. So let's now move to what I believe is the final slide, covering our guidance. Guidance stayed the same, pinned to the lower end. So let's turn to our guidance. The guidance we updated in January for the present financial year is unchanged. As of now, we expect, or rather we do expect, to land at the lower end of the EBITDA guidance given the current market environment. That still means a very strong year-over-year and quarter-over-quarter rise in EBITDA for Q4. Beyond the improved biodiesel spread, which we can capture only in part because of certain hedged volumes, this is driven in particular by South Bend Ethanol's better performance. On top of that come biodiesel production volumes with greater CO2 efficiency, since we have successfully commissioned our advanced biodiesel capacity in suite.
Claus Sauter
executiveBy doing this, we're doubling the total capacity we have for second-generation biodiesel production, taking it to 100,000 tonnes. So those, at any rate, are the outcomes of the investment program we launched in Europe roughly 2 years back. That said, I'll move on to the strategic update. At Nevada, renewable natural gas output was commissioned successfully back in March and is presently operating at roughly 30% of capacity. Starting up ethanol production comes next. We're working on that right now, with the aim of having the first meaningful ethanol volumes by the end of May. As you can likely gather, this indicates we managed to fix the sulfur separate container. Plenty of small issues needed to be cleared away over the last month, yet our team did a really good job there. Full capacity utilization at the Nevada biorefinery should therefore arrive in 6 to 9 months from now. On top of that, the biomethane plant qualifies for an investment tax credit under the IRA in the inflation reduction, covering 30% of the investment cost — though only for the portion tied to the RNG plant, and not the ethanol part.
Claus Sauter
executiveAt this moment, VERBIO North America is in the last stages of talks to sell the ITC for roughly USD 40 million, and our goal is to wrap up that process ahead of the close of the present financial year. To be honest, it has been easier than I expected both to generate the ITC and to locate a buyer willing to purchase an ITC. A higher single-digit percentage discount is required on our side. That is not a major issue, and measured against the prevailing inflation rate, it is genuinely modest. Still, it has been a fascinating lesson for me in how the United States funds its renewable investments. With that knowledge now, I believe Germany has much it could learn from this approach. The rules are straightforward, and the market handles moving the tax credit to other companies. Returning to Nevada specifically, the imminent launch of full commercial output at the Nevada refinery, together with progress at South Bend Ethanol, shows that we are prepared for the following phase. That following phase involves starting the build-out toward combined bioethanol and biomethane output at South Bend. A formal groundbreaking ceremony with certain politicians is set for May 23.
Claus Sauter
executiveMay has been an interesting month for us and a successful one in the 2024 business year. So with that, let me hand things back to Olaf, and he'll bring you up to speed on what's happening with our European activities. Olaf, over to you.
Olaf Troeber
executiveOkay, thank you. And on the subject of groundbreaking events — as I mentioned at the start of this call, the ceremonial shovels for the Ichnusa Plant are going in today, roughly half an hour from now, I believe. So allow me to recap the project details once more. We're stepping up our commitment in the chemicals business to secure a position in the world's third-largest industry. The hurdles facing green chemistry are massive. Green chemistry isn't merely a matter of protecting the environment. It's an economic imperative too — after all, markets are shifting, and consumers, the public and legacy laters keep raising their expectations for environmentally friendly products. Since 2019, we've run a pilot facility in Hungary where we make centers in quite small quantities. There we keep refining this innovative process. Now we're moving to the next stage. We're putting money into the world's first Ichnusa Plant at industrial scale. What does that look like in numbers? VERBIO is committing a total of EUR 80 million to EUR 100 million to the new Ichnusa plant at a better health side, and we'll get a double-digit investment trend of approximately 20%. Our plant's nominal capacity will come in at 32,000 tonnes per year of 9 Dame and 17,000 tonnes per year of Deca.
Olaf Troeber
executiveAt this facility, we intend to make 60,000 tons annually of renewable product for the chemical sector. The goal is to bring the Ichnusa plant into service in 2025, next year. After that, we'd like to begin regular output in 2026, the year after. With that, we'd like to wrap up today's prepared remarks and move into the Q&A session. Thank you.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot for that presentation, Mr. Sauter and Mr. Troeber. At this point we'll transition into our Q&A session. To keep the discussion lively, we'd appreciate it if you'd pose your questions in person over the audio line. <<operator_script>>. We'll begin with questions from Niklas Becker. Please go ahead and ask.
Niklas Becker
analystYes, this is Nicholas at Deutsche Bank. I appreciate you taking the call, and many thanks for the update — particularly the details on Chinese biodiesel flows alongside the German greenhouse gas quota. One question from me about quota prices. Does the market remain as illiquid as it was during the second quarter? And where do you expect greenhouse gas quota prices to go in 2025?
Claus Sauter
executiveSure, that's a good question. When you're looking at pure greenhouse gas quotas, only a handful of participants exist and liquidity is thin. However, as you're aware, the majority of the greenhouse gas reductions we generate get sold into the market tied to our liquid molecules. So on the second piece — the quota prices — we still don't have clarity on the volume of greenhouse gas savings the oil companies actually carry on their books. Our estimate puts it somewhere in the range of 6 million to 7 million tonnes, a substantial figure relative to the 2023 obligation. Yet as UER comes in and imports from China decline — I believe I touched on this earlier in the call — those volumes are moving quickly into that period. As a result, we believe a sound CO2 price ought to sit around EUR 250 per metric ton of CO2 savings. That's the level at which extra investments — further capital for expanding production capacity — become necessary, particularly as we approach 2030, since the obligation curve is a hockey stick and rises sharply across 2026, 2027, '28, and '29. So toward the far end of that curve, more investment is required, and that's why we at VERBIO state that CO2 prices need to be roughly EUR 250 per metric ton.
Claus Sauter
executiveAt that level, it’s going to draw in more investment that’s needed for new capacity. But whether we get there in 2025 or in 2026 — that 250 million level — we don’t know that, and it depends heavily on how much CO2 savings oil companies are carrying on their books.
Niklas Becker
analystThat's really useful. Perhaps a follow-up tied to it. During your prepared comments, you noted that continuing to ship Chinese biodiesel into the European Union isn't economically appealing at the current greenhouse gas quota prices. Would you expand on the thinking there? As I understand it, we've still observed considerable volumes coming from China into the European Union during the first quarter of 2024.
Claus Sauter
executiveYes, imports are visible, but compared with what we saw 1 year ago, this is nothing. So it has now come down to a more reasonable level. But if you are generating the double amount of CO2 savings, and if we are right and most of it is coming from Proud, then what are the 2 effects. The first effect is that palm oil is about $100 per metric ton 150 depends on the market situation, cheaper than rapeseed oil. And on the other side, you have higher logistic costs. So logistic cost is it has to come from Indonesia to China, go through a tank, go on the boat again, go to Europe, come in. So if you just get for your CO2 savings, EUR 100 or EUR 120 per metric ton, then you are close that this additional money will not cover your cost anymore. And because of this, I say, it was attractive when the CO2 saving was at EUR 400 per metric ton because you make about 5 tonnes of CO2 savings with double counting on 1 ton of biodiesel. So that was about if we talk about EUR 400, we were about EUR 2,000 additional money per metric ton just from the greenhouse gas savings.
Claus Sauter
executiveNow, when we're looking at EUR 120 million, that's only EUR 600 million. And then, on the other hand, you've got to subtract your extra cost. So at EUR 400 per metric tonic, it was considerably more appealing to also take on the added logistics costs at 120 — at that point it just isn't as much anymore. Got it.
Niklas Becker
analystRight, that's clear. Before I rejoin the queue, a final question about your biodiesel hedging. Could you give a bit more detail on those hedging initiatives? Specifically, how much of your biodiesel sales volumes for the fourth quarter have you secured, and at what prices — in other words, what EBITDA tailwind should we expect from those hedges in Q4, since you ought to have visibility on the rapeseed oil prices you've already locked in?
Claus Sauter
executiveAll right. I believe those figures—the in-depth ones—Olaf will cover, particularly regarding what underpins the strategy. In recent calls, we kept bringing up the uncertainty in Europe and what's arriving from China. So we observed decent margins, above all for biodiesel derived from rapeseed oil, and that was one item where we decided, fine, let's undertake some hedging. Figures are now going to come from Olaf. And it's somewhat ironic. I remarked that margins looked strong for rapeseed biodiesel—we were taken aback by that. Yet the majority of imports arriving out of China fail to meet spec. So they don't satisfy the spec, the specification. The finest biodiesel available in the market is biodiesel produced from rapeseed oil, and in particular from VERBIO, since most of what we make is distilled. Thus the market requires biodiesel from rapeseed oil—a high-quality product—to blend with the off-spec import from China. So it's somewhat ironic that above all the first generation biodiesel, biodiesel made from rapeseed oil, is benefiting from it. So Olaf, might you give further details regarding Q4?
Olaf Troeber
executiveYes. On biodiesel, we hedged close to 50% of our European production in Q4. The reason, which we already disclosed, is simply to give us some protection against the higher volatility expected in the market. On prices, we achieved a good margin, and good means healthy and good enough that we expect to reach the lower end of our financial year '23, '24 guidance. Just to give you a bit more color, we had a negative volume value from these derivatives of a little bit more. I think it was EUR 11 million. So I mean that's a result already given in the fourth quarter. And that means, in turn, we have to achieve a little bit less than a EUR 10 million EBITDA in each month in the fourth quarter, which should be achievable. And that's also why we said we will come in at the lower end of our guidance.
Niklas Becker
analystI just want to make sure I understand — at the low end of your guidance, is biodiesel the only contributor you're assuming? Or does ethanol also factor into that number?
Olaf Troeber
executiveRight. And to reach the lower end — the EUR 120 million for the full financial year — some contribution from the ethanol segment is also required. That said, at present we're seeing fairly good margins — not especially healthy, but good. Ethanol pricing is sitting at roughly EUR 680 to EUR 690 per cubic. And for the majority of what we need in Q4 of this financial year, we've already locked in raw material prices. So visibility is good. With commodity markets this volatile, you never know, but as of now visibility is good.
Claus Sauter
executiveYes. And at this point we're fairly confident about ethanol as well. For single counting, the import arbitrage into Brazil and into the United States — ethanol is closed at the level Olaf referenced, EUR 690 to EUR 700 per cubic meter. On the other hand, what I can report from the U.S. is that we had — and I brought this up in our presentation — we achieved meaningful progress in South Bend. Production volumes there rose 30%. That changes the entire economics: you get larger volumes spread over an unchanged fixed cost base. Which means the drag, the negative contribution hitting our ethanol segment over recent quarters, is shrinking. So the U.S. is not yet profitable, but we are now moving toward lowering costs. That said, our European ethanol business was never negative — it has always been profitable — however, the expense of expanding capacity in the United States, along with all those investment projects, sits inside our ethanol and RNG segment. So European ethanol and RNG production must carry all of those costs. That is the reason. So, as Olaf noted, in the most recent quarter we saw improved and stable margins in Europe, which we had already locked in — the point he was referring to.
Claus Sauter
executiveAnd on the flip side, the cost contribution for the U.S. expansion is coming down. And I'd say, yes, we've made it through the valley. At this point we're in a position to grow our profitability, and given all the arguments and facts surrounding higher quotas in 2025, we're quite confident that we can return to genuinely attractive profitability. So now someone else should step in and ask questions. Niklas, thank you very much. But there are more questions from other parties.
Operator
operatorYes, definitely. At this point, we’ll turn things over to questions from Adrian Pehl.
Adrian Pehl
analystSo, starting with the first one, since we were just discussing hedging on the floor. Just so I'm clear on what you did: is it basically hedging on the input side, so being rapeseed in wheat? Or are you also hedging the appetite? That's my first question. The second one is, I'm still wondering whether — I mean, obviously, you had negative EBITDA contributions from hedging. And on the other hand, is it fair to assume that if you hadn't done that, your guidance would rather look for, let's say, the midpoint? I mean, on the other hand, you're probably sacrificing some stability in Q4. But any thoughts and clarification on that would be helpful.
Claus Sauter
executiveAlright. On the second question — first, you're correct. It would be even better without hedging. But Olaf brought it up; we didn't hedge all the volumes. Half of it was hedged. Still, margins improved further. That's why the hedging position at the end of March was negative, at minus 11%. But you also saw margins come back. So that hedging too — for Q4 it now sits on a more positive side. But you're right, without hedging we'd be closer to the middle of our guidance rather than the lower end, but <<foreign_lang>>. Okay. So second, input. How does the hedging work? When we discuss hedging, we mean sales hedging, because normally our input is priced at a fixed price. That means the wheat — or, let's say, the serial, not wheat, the cereals, since it's a bunch of different cereals — the cereals for ethanol production are purchased fixed, and we don't need additional amounts now until the new harvest 2024. So with cereals, we're more or less done. Same with the rapeseed oil. And then on the sales side, we hedged to secure our sales prices.
Claus Sauter
executiveRegarding biodiesel—and yes, ethanol too—we're handling things in much the same manner via our trading department. So all of that is progressing well.
Adrian Pehl
analystThen, on the second question—as usual, we're quite interested in learning how much biomethane remains on the balance sheet, since at first glance it seems to me—though I haven't gone through everything—that you sold more biomethane in Q3. Is that right?
Claus Sauter
executiveThat's right.
Adrian Pehl
analystCan you give us a figure on where we are with stored methane?
Claus Sauter
executiveWell, we aren't giving out that figure in detail, but you're heading in the right direction. So I think you've got a sense of it. So we were selling some greenhouse gas reduction. What we have to sell amounts from 2023. And yes, we also sold more biomethane, even into different markets like transport, but we aren't disclosing the volumes.
Adrian Pehl
analystThat's unfortunate, though I'll accept it as it stands. My following question, actually, is that I was taken aback to see that headcount in the ethanol business had actually eased somewhat from the peak we saw in the prior quarter. So what's the story behind that?
Claus Sauter
executiveOkay, so at the end of — in October and November in the United States, that's the season when we're finishing up harvesting the corn. So that's seasonal work. So we had to bring on some truck drivers and baler drivers there. And once the season ends in our third quarter — so the first quarter of 2024 — we let those people go. So it's just that seasonal piece. On the other side, what it means for the team in production, South Bend as well as Nevada, we're still hiring people. We've already done a lot, but a small amount. So there will be a further increase in the yearly average. We're investing in people there. We saw that the former owner, especially in South Bend, was running the plant really at the lower end of what's necessary, really, in terms of employees and especially blue collars, to run such a plant. So our strategy is different. We're more technically driven, and Oliver with his team is now building up a team there. And I think the results are great — more or less with the same team and 30%. Over the last 10 years, the plant didn't make as much ethanol as we're doing now since February, and there's further room to go up.
Claus Sauter
executiveSo the actual goal for that plant is to hit 100 million gallons of ethanol, which works out to roughly 385,000 cubic meters.
Adrian Pehl
analystJust 2 really fast questions. First, can you give us the actual figure for your U.S. ethanol output? And the second is about the CapEx timing. I mean, my assumption is that Q4 will show a fair amount of CapEx compared with earlier quarters. Is that a reasonable assumption? Or are you trending lower when it comes to CapEx?
Claus Sauter
executiveAlright, so at the moment ethanol is only in South Bend. These days we’re running at nearly 8 million gallons each month, which reflects the real capacity. So the goal for 2024 and 2025 is 90 million gallons. The year before we took over that plant, it stood at 65, EUR 65 million gallons. For this business, I don’t have the exact figures in my head for the first 6 months of the business year, but my guess is we’ll land at 75 million to 80 million gallons for the operation here. The first half was <<foreign_lang>> not enough. Still, as I mentioned, since February we’ve been making solid progress. Overall, I think we should end up in the 70%, 75%, 80% range. For the next business year it’s 90% — let’s see whether we can actually even hit 100 million gallons. As for CapEx, maybe Olaf can put more detail on that. But I’m not expecting much CapEx now in the final quarter. Yes, we’re doing groundbreaking in Bitterfeld and groundbreaking in South Bend, though that doesn’t carry much cost.
Claus Sauter
executiveThe actual expenses will hit in 2025, when you're placing orders for equipment, destilations, all of that. But Olaf, would you confirm what I just said?
Olaf Troeber
executiveRight, so the plan actually calls for us to make extra investments in Q4 amounting to roughly EUR 60 million. That said, from what I've seen, that figure sits at the very top of what we've planned for. My own expectation would be more like EUR 40 million, EUR 45 million for Q4 of this financial year.
Adrian Pehl
analystRight, that's what I figured. So for the whole year, it's definitely under EUR 200 million, correct?
Olaf Troeber
executiveRight. For the full year, it will definitely come in under EUR 200 million.
Operator
operatorThanks, Adrian. At this point, only one question remains in the chatbox, and we don’t want Camia to go without an answer. That question is whether the guidance also includes sales of U.S. IRA tax credits, or whether that is on top.
Olaf Troeber
executiveRight, that isn't a contribution. It's a tax credit, and that credit has to be written down across the next 16 years. So roughly, on an EBITDA basis, that works out to about USD 2.5 million annually. That said, only a couple of weeks remain, so there will be no contribution of any kind for the current financial year.
Claus Sauter
executiveSo to give you a straightforward response: yes, it sits on top. This is a tax credit. It never runs through our P&L. It is a tax credit. As a result, its worth is actually greater than that of a plain subsidy. And indeed, the cash arrives on top. As for the remaining value of our assets, the tax credit does not affect it right away. So it really is a highly appealing and favorable tool for funding all renewable investments — a very clever system here in the United States. All right. I believe that wraps us up.
Operator
operatorYes, I suppose we should just return to Nicholas with a very, very brief follow-up question.
Niklas Becker
analystI have just one more question about the ramp-up costs in Nevada. Earlier, you anticipated roughly EUR 20 million of headwinds during this financial year. Does that assumption still hold? And for the following financial year, how much extra, if anything, should we expect?
Claus Sauter
executiveOkay, overall — and I think we touched on this as well — the cost of our U.S. expansion, excluding investment, came to roughly EUR 30 million, not just 20 million; it was EUR 30 million. South Bend, though, is part of that figure. So at this point we're commissioning, and we're beginning the ramp-up phase. Olaf can provide you with further detail here. The one thing I do want to note is that, based on our current planning, we anticipate full utilization, let's say, in the first quarter of 2025. So, as I said, we need those 6 to 9 months for the ramp-up phase. We'll see whether it moves faster — what's very helpful right now is that corn prices in the United States are very low. Farmers had a good harvest in 2023. So corn prices have fallen from $8.50 per bushel to $4.50 as of now, so nearly 50%, which is huge. And that also brings down our commissioning costs, because the gas — and I mentioned this during my speech — the gas we're producing right now isn't sold to the transport sector. It goes to the voluntary market, and that is more or less at a very much fixed price.
Claus Sauter
executiveOlaf, at this point, do you have any sense of what the actual commissioning costs for 2025 will be in Nevada?
Olaf Troeber
executiveLet me start by addressing the past. So we're discussing roughly the midpoint for the Nevada EBITDA increase, somewhere between EUR 20 million and as much as EUR 30 million — so more like EUR 25 million, give or take, on an EBITDA basis. As for the next financial year, well, that's a bit tough to pin down. Our plan assumes at minimum a positive figure, let's say EBITDA of plus EUR 5 million, with South Bend included. But bear in mind, first of all, this is a ramp-up period, and there could be one uncertainty or another that comes up. That's the downside. The upside, though, is — well, yes, that isn't on the table at the moment. But as production volumes rise at South Bend, combined with healthier margins in the United States and the approaching — or really the driving season — we therefore also have considerable upside potential when it comes to EBITDA for the next financial year, stemming from our U.S. ethanol operations. Then again, it is a ramp-up phase. So don't count on very, very strong figures right at the start of the year. Yes, it's more of a line heading upward. So breakeven plus 6.
Claus Sauter
executiveAs Olaf said, this is a ramp-up phase. Once production is operating the way it does in Europe, our visibility improves considerably. So please keep in touch with Alina. She'll keep you informed and provide short-term guidance information. I really believe that's the right approach for the next 12 months — all of the analysts staying in close contact with Alina.
Operator
operatorThank you so much. That answer wraps up our Q&A session, which brings us to the conclusion of today's earnings call. Thank you, everyone, for participating and for showing interest in VERBIO. If any additional questions come up later on, please don't hesitate to reach out to Investor Relations. And Mr. Sauter and Mr. Troeber, a big thank you as well for the presentation and for the time you gave us today. From my side, I wish all of you a lovely rest of the day and hand things back to you, Mr. Sauter, for some closing remarks.
Claus Sauter
executiveYes. That covers everything. Many thanks to everyone who joined the call and added to the discussion — Olaf, myself, and Alina are all looking forward to our next call, when we'll report on the successful close of 2023 and 2024, a year that was quite challenging, I have to say. Okay. Thanks again so much. Have a great day and enjoy. We look forward to our next call. Goodbye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Verbio SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Verbio SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Verbio SE or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.