Verbio SE (VBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

September 26, 2024

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Energy Oil, Gas and Consumable Fuels earnings 70 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good afternoon, everyone, and a very warm welcome. Thank you for being here on the VERBIO Q4 fiscal year '23, '24 earnings call. It's a real honor for me to be joined by VERBIO SE's management: Mr. Claus Sauter, our CEO, and Mr. Olaf Troeber, our CFO. The two of them will host the call and present the results. Today's agenda has a presentation first, with a Q&A afterward. Kindly type your questions into the chat box located in the lower right-hand corner. Once the presentation wraps up, we'll take them up during the Q&A. I'm eager for some interesting insights, and with that I'll gladly turn things over to Mr. Sauter and Mr. Troeber.

Claus Sauter

executive
#2

Thank you so much. Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to today's earnings call. Joining me are Olaf Troeber, our CFO, and Alina Köhler, our Investor Relations Manager. It's great to have you with us on the call. We'll cover our fourth quarter and full year 2023, 2024 results. Despite the challenging market environment, I am pleased that we were able to post a good set of results for the full year and in Q4 especially. In line with our latest expectations that we shared in our Q3 earnings call in May. We will go into more details later, but now let me first reiterate some of our highlights from the past year. At the end of the call, we will give you an idea of what to expect for the running business year. First of all, the group highlights. Turning now to focus on our delivery for 2023, 2024. We were able to make significant progress and with this implemented the elements of the strategy presented at the Capital Market Day in September, 2023. First, we have achieved record production volumes exceeding 1 million tons of liquid biofuels for the first time. We also grew our RNG production to a new record of 1.1 terawatt hours.

Claus Sauter

executive
#3

Through these products, along with any trading products, we boosted the CO2 savings our customers can achieve via our offerings by 1 million tons, bringing it to 4.4 million tons of CO2 savings. Secondly, we made strong headway in scaling our own technology overseas. After some early hiccups and delays, we've announced that Nevada is now operating on small volumes. Back in March, we had launched the second RNG production line using corn as a feedstock. Having begun commercial ethanol production this summer, we've now switched over to stillage for making RNG. In the meantime, we succeeded in raising production availability at South Bend, Indiana, South Bend ethanol by roughly 20% in 2024 compared with 2023, something none of the prior owners were able to accomplish. We've also kicked off construction of the RNG facility and are applying all our learnings from Nevada to make sure the journey at South Bend ethanol goes more smoothly. Over in Europe, we held our groundbreaking ceremony for the specialty chemicals facility in Bitterfeld, which will use our biodiesel made from rapeseed oil as its input. That's a major step for us too, since we'll be entering a new and highly promising market going forward.

Claus Sauter

executive
#4

Finally, I'd like to draw attention to the creation of a trading operation headquartered in Geneva, Switzerland. This is meant to help us chart the worldwide movement of goods, products, and feedstocks more effectively, and to foresee those flows faster. Let's now move on to the headline numbers for the financial year. I'll give you a brief rundown of our key figures for 2023, 2024. As I noted, we hit record production volumes across all our primary products. Year-on-year, our biodiesel output rose 4%, largely on the strength of improved utilization in Canada. Bioethanol volumes climbed 64% compared with a year earlier, chiefly because of the South Bend acquisition in May, along with a certain amount of production growth in Europe. EBITDA for 2023, 2024 came to EUR121.6 million. Although the results fell short of our original target of EUR200 million to EUR250 million, owing to persistent pressure from fraudulent Chinese biodiesel imports and the supposed CO2 reduction tied to them, we are aligned with our latest guidance. Do bear in mind that in 2023, 2024, our European business had to absorb both the market distortion in Europe and the expense of our growth investments in the United States, which came to roughly EUR25 million. Net debt at year-end climbed to EUR32.9 million, driven primarily by growth investments exceeding EUR180 million.

Claus Sauter

executive
#5

Also significant is how much better we did on generating cash. At year-end, the equity ratio came in at 67.4% and was broadly unchanged. The investment tax credit tied to our Nevada RNG facility, which we sold successfully in Q4, had a negative effect on that ratio, since it gets recorded as an investment grant and therefore pushes liabilities higher. At this point I'll pass things to my colleague Olaf, who will walk you through the Q4 results.

Olaf Troeber

executive
#6

Thanks, Claus, and good afternoon, everyone. Moving on to our fourth quarter. During Q4, we posted EBITDA of EUR39.5 million, which matched expectations. That marks a strong gain both year-over-year and quarter-on-quarter, driven mainly by wider biodiesel spreads. Bioethanol spreads in Europe and North America likewise added to the positive momentum versus the prior quarter. Even though sales prices rose sharply and volumes sold were slightly higher as well, sales fell year-over-year to EUR197 million, for two reasons. First, permanent accounting changes in how trading revenues are recognized — now shown net within results from commodity forward contracts — produced a correction in revenues and cost of materials of EUR74 million and EUR72 million respectively for the nine-month period 2023, ‘24. Please note this hit both segments but had no impact on the EBITDA level. Second, as we also mentioned on our last earnings call, Canada currently operates via processing contracts, which lowers revenues and material costs alike and therefore clearly raises our EBITDA margin. EBITDA improved significantly to EUR28.5 million from a negative EUR10 million a year earlier, thanks to a higher biodiesel sales price in Europe and advantageous rate seed oil procurement.

Olaf Troeber

executive
#7

Cheaper greenhouse gas quota prices and premiums hurt earnings versus the same quarter a year earlier. As I mentioned, prices came back strongly during our fourth quarter, and you can see that in the chart on the right, which shows how FAME minus 10 biodiesel prices and rapeseed oil prices developed. Since we purchase our feedstock roughly 2 months to 3 months ahead of time, it is fairly obvious that our own spreads beat the market spreads displayed on the left. That same dynamic accounts for our quarter-on-quarter EBITDA improvements. The reason behind the firming price levels was higher raw material prices together with falling import volumes from China. On top of that, demand for biodiesel made from rapeseed oil remains strong in particular, since product quality from China fails to meet European specifications for blending purposes and therefore has to be upgraded. Now let me move to the bioethanol, biomethane segment. Higher sales volumes nearly offset the drop in ethanol and greenhouse gas quota prices relative to the same quarter of the prior year. Even so, VERBIO did post lower revenues because of the trading related correction I described earlier.

Olaf Troeber

executive
#8

EBITDA declined compared with a year earlier, going from EUR36 million down to EUR10 million, since improved ethanol spreads were insufficient to counterbalance the drop in greenhouse gas quarter prices and premiums along with the ramp-up costs in the United States. In comparison with the prior quarter, though, there was a notable effect coming especially from the attractive margin situation in Europe and also in North America. Consequently, the bioethanol, biomethane segment produced the strongest segment result of the 2023, '24 financial year in Q4. Let's take a quick look at how prices and spreads for bioethanol developed. Those spreads stayed at an attractive level. This was thanks in particular to bioethanol prices, as the top light green line in the chart on the right-hand side shows. The price recovery in Q3, or form, can be explained by lower imports in Q1 of 2024, mainly from Brazil, which caused a decline in ethanol inventory volumes in Rotterdam. Rising demand provided additional support, which meant better spreads both year-over-year and quarter-on-quarter. Well, as was explained earlier, the greenhouse gas quota surplus caused a sharp price decline.

Olaf Troeber

executive
#9

The price for greenhouse gas quotas—according to market information, in mid-2023 it was still at EUR250 per ton of CO2 savings—had most recently fallen to well below EUR100 for the 2024 quota. That covers the past, so let's now turn to our guidance, which we had already published in a talk release on September 10th. We expect an EBITDA of EUR120 million to EUR160 million. At the midpoint, this implies 15% grow year-over-year. To bridge last year's result with this year's guidance, we need to take into account our key drivers. While we expect to post a slightly positive EBITDA result in North America, part of these gains will be offset by a negative impact from the greenhouse gas quota. Please keep in mind that the entire calendar year 2023 and also our first half of 2023, 2024. We were still benefiting from very attractive locked in prices, which are at much lower levels in calendar year 2024, and while we do foresee a recovery of market prices in the future. As Claus will address in a minute, the timing is difficult to forecast. In detail in the bioethanol and biomethane segment, the ramp-up of the planned Nevada, Iowa and the increased production in South Bend, Indiana will have a positive effect on earnings compared to the previous year.

Olaf Troeber

executive
#10

Considering the appealing—and I'd call it highly appealing—margin picture in North America. Turning to Europe again, we anticipate rising plant capacity utilization supported by steady ethanol margins, and it's worth noting that our RNG output should climb further as well, meaning the 1-terawatt hour threshold will be surpassed in Europe for the first time ever. Regarding biodiesel in Europe, we foresee capacity utilization staying elevated through the 2024 ‘25 financial year, which has already started. Average margins are expected to decline versus the prior year because of the tight vegetable oil situation. Contracts ensuring a solid margin are secured for Canadian biodiesel output during the current calendar year 2024. On the whole, we anticipate a net debt position of no more than EUR190 million at year end. CapEx will concentrate on our key projects for the South Bend Ethanol and the Ethanol user spend here at the bid of health side, but now back to Claus, who will provide an overview of where the greenhouse gas quota market currently stands and will have some kind of growth on the strategy execution.

Claus Sauter

executive
#11

All right, thanks a lot, Olaf. Now let's take a bit of a look ahead. Constraints on the supply side plus demand that keeps climbing are setting the stage for a surge in the greenhouse gas quarter market — and here's why we think so. A great deal has happened over the past few weeks that ought to give the greenhouse gas market support as we move forward. Let's turn to supply first. During our last earnings call, we talked about removing upstream emission reduction as a compliance option for 2025. What's new is that, per the German Bundestag, projects delivering roughly 4 million tons of CO2 savings could be canceled retroactively as well. How that will actually be carried out, we aren't sure. I have no clue, but clearly this step is necessary. The mere consideration of it represents a great success and may tie back to the work of the initiative against climate fraud, IKS, where we are actively collaborating with 70 others — partners, companies, associations — to fight fake climate protection. Anyone who is here in Germany should be aware of this TV report about UERs. And, yeah, this is, let's say, very impressive, what happened there. So, the picture comes from CDF, Frontale investigation.

Claus Sauter

executive
#12

At this site, you really ought to be able to look at a new ER project that delivers CO2 savings. What you actually see, though, is a picture of an empty chicken coop — one that is worth EUR80 million in CO2 savings. Beyond the political readiness to cancel quotas retroactively, certain players have made their own choice to abandon these projects. Rosneft issued an announcement not long ago, and Rosneft, as an example, has scrapped 500,000 tons of CO2 savings, which at today's prices would be worth close to EUR50 million. On top of that, as the chart shows, monthly exports out of China have fallen sharply, and along with that, the share heading to Europe. Over the last few months, we have likewise observed investment freezes, halted projects, and installment fees in the biofuel space reported across the media, which ought to give support to prices going forward. It also makes plain that the market for greenhouse gas quotas has to recover, since rising quota prices are necessary to make sure that investments in climate protection and the transport sector are economically feasible. Still, every one of these measures and constraints can only really take effect once control measures exist, so that the moment we enter a higher price environment, no incorrectly declared product can enter anymore.

Claus Sauter

executive
#13

We need effective barriers, and those should be put in place alongside RED III. On the demand side, the yearly increase in the mandate, together with a phase-out of UER, produces the largest rise in required CO2 savings in 2025 — the biggest since 2020, when the greenhouse gas quota began, or when UER began. Also, last week the Ministry of Environment — the German Ministry of Environment — proposed suspending the rollover option, so that greenhouse gas quotas generated in the past could not be used to meet the obligation in 2025 and 2026. Some implementation details still have to be clarified for the industry, but on the whole, it is encouraging to at last see a response to the critical issues. Finally, implementing RED III also carries potential on the demand side, and beyond that, road and rain shipping and air traffic are to be included. In the meantime, we keep focusing on our core projects. These include bringing Nevada to full utilization levels within this financial year. We continue our building works at South Bend Ethanol and the Specialty Chemical facility in Bitterfeld, Germany. And now we are open for the Q&A session. Thank you very much.

Operator

operator
#14

I appreciate those insights very much, Mr. Sauter and Mr. Troeber. There are a few questions we have, and I'd like to go through them one at a time. The first set comes from Mister Quadrado at Kepler Cheuvreux. In fact, it's four questions combined into one, so I'd like to take them in turn. The first: a year ago, you pointed out that the US business was still dilutive to group margins. What's the picture for the new fiscal year, given that Nevada — the Nevada plan — is ramping up and South Bend continues to improve?

Claus Sauter

executive
#15

All right, Olaf, that segment is yours.

Olaf Tröber

executive
#16

As Claus mentioned, we anticipate that South Bend will keep getting better thanks to the higher output. Our technicians have therefore done an excellent job. We're running at greater capacity utilization, and as you're aware, having a high capacity utilization rate matters a great deal for any bioethanol plant. Regarding Nevada, I believe you noted earlier as well that across the financial year we expect an EBITDA of zero, which is back end loaded — that means we begin with a negative EBITDA in the first and second quarter, then shift toward a positive EBITDA in the second and particularly the third, and above all the fourth quarter.

Operator

operator
#17

Okay, thanks a lot. Let's move on to question number two. Would you be able to tell us what the main assumptions are — and this is a bit more granular — regarding ethanol biodiesel spreads, greenhouse gas quota prices in Germany, and natural gas prices in Europe at the midpoint of your EBITDA guidance?

Olaf Tröber

executive
#18

Okay. Particularly in the US, we have healthy bioethanol margins right now, and we're relying on those margins, or market spreads. So we're factoring in stronger margins during the driving season and weaker ones outside it. Outside the driving seasons, that would be December and, yeah, the window season and, roughly, spring. In Canada, as we noted, we have a merchant contract in place. So we simply work with the margin rather than the spread. And regarding biodiesel in Europe, I already mentioned that we included the high margins, or healthy margins, we currently see, and we took a somewhat cautious, a more cautious approach for Q3 and Q4, where we said, okay. We're planning with a lower margin for the biodiesel segment. Then coming back to bioethanol in Europe, we basically assumed stable margins. That means slightly higher ethanol prices than we see at present. Prices came down over the last couple of weeks, but we expect them to rise again, and crane prices more or less stable. As for the greenhouse gas quota, we already anticipated a price increase, a slight increase in the greenhouse gas quota price from a level of EUR120, but I'd prefer to hand over to Claus, because when it comes to the greenhouse gas quota, a lot is happening and it's somewhat difficult to put this into figures for planning purposes.

Claus Sauter

executive
#19

Thank you, Olaf. With this legal draft from Friday, there's now a major shift. At present, we're in negotiations over the new 2025 contracts with the obligated parties, and through last Thursday they were fairly relaxed, since their balance sheets carry a lot of CO2 savings. Since Friday, though, the game has changed, should they be unable to carry 2024 quotas forward into 2025 and 2026. As we already pointed out, demand is rising substantially. Yes, this will be an entirely different shift, and we're already seeing the 2025 CO2 quota climb, so it's much too early to make any adjustment to our planning. Still, I believe that with our assumptions of a rising quota price, we are entirely on the correct side, not only because of the arguments we raised — that it has to grow given insolvencies and the postponement of other investments. Since Friday this really is a game changer, but as I said, far too early to adjust anything. And lastly, we must wait until this new legislation is actually passed. Even so, the market situation for 2025 and 2026 as well is quite promising. Honestly, we were surprised by Friday's announcement, and it looks a bit like a firefight mode, with the German ministry now seeing that there is a lot of fraud.

Claus Sauter

executive
#20

And you'll recall I flagged this a year and a half ago. So it's now reality, but they need to figure out a way to cancel CO2 savings, which we ultimately didn't deliver, though that will take far longer than until the start of 2025. So this is a quick fix that will help for 2025 and 2026. But the specifics, the actual date specifics as well regarding canceling the CO2 savings on out to 2030. Putting in place clear rules to prevent frauds of this kind down the road will take somewhat longer, but they'll be implemented through RED III. Okay. That's it on this question, next one please.

Operator

operator
#21

This next question also comes from Kepler Cheuvreux. Could you perhaps bring us up to date on any negotiations currently underway regarding enhanced certification for diesel imports into the EU from Asia? And is that a workable scenario for preventing additional fraudulent volumes?

Claus Sauter

executive
#22

I believe I've already covered these questions. Something will definitely come up. But working out the specifics, how to put it together, and what the consequences would be if fraud were to occur again — all of that has to be discussed thoroughly in spring 2025. So for that reason, I'm very grateful for Friday's draft, since it helps us now that we aren't dealing with this surplus from 2024 into 2025 and 2026. So, we're on a good path.

Operator

operator
#23

Thanks. And one final question: what level of CapEx are you assuming for the new year in order to hit the net debt guidance you’ve set for the new fiscal year?

Claus Sauter

executive
#24

Olaf?

Olaf Tröber

executive
#25

As you already noted, the average over the coming 3 years is going to be roughly EUR140 million. For this year, we had estimated as much as EUR200 million of investments, but the real shame is, when it comes to all those prepayments we must make for the large equipment in South Bend — whether you pay on the final day, in June, or on the first day of July, you always end up with this cash or liquidity tied up for creations — so we chose not to provide a bend. Instead, we gave you the figure of max, or up to minus, a net debt of EUR190 million.

Operator

operator
#26

Thanks. Now we’ll take questions from Leon Muhlenbruch at MWB. His first one concerns the EU tariffs on biodiesel. What do you expect there? Will they come under pressure? Do you think they’ll remain in place for a while? And how do you view the effect of that?

Claus Sauter

executive
#27

So, the antidumping duties that the European Union announced are comparable to the draft we saw on Friday. It doesn't solve the problem. That isn't the solution. What the solution has to be is that we need mechanisms for controlling imports and for controlling feedstock streams. That isn't our job. It's the regulator's job. And we have nothing against biodiesel imports. They can come from China or anywhere else, as long as it's fair. Incidentally, our strategy also has us focused on a global business. And a global business means the availability, or the possibility, of importing product, but what we need is to make sure the biodiesel being imported is genuinely made from the feedstock that's written on the certificate. A lot of product is coming into Europe — ethanol from the US, from South America. The big problem with China was always that there was no possibility of going there and controlling the streams, and that has to be stopped. We aren't focusing on the antidumping duties, because that doesn't solve the problem. It helps, and we see that it helps, because imports are going down. We're at a lower level now with our own port than in 2021 — it helps, but it doesn't solve the problem.

Claus Sauter

executive
#28

So until that issue gets resolved, there won't be any further investment coming into Europe. That's why, above all, we need regulation that's clear. What's actually going on? When it isn't possible to verify control of the feedstocks in the nation where the product originates, then my view is that accepting it isn't possible. And on top of that, this doesn't just hit us — it hits renewable hydrogen, CO2 efficient steel, all of that. So we need stable regulation on this. Second, there has to be a consequence for the companies purchasing this product. More emphasis is needed on compliance. At the moment, obligated parties are able to trust 100% in the paperwork they receive; there's no requirement to trace the value chain. No requirement to do extra analysis. In the United States, things work entirely differently. If you buy a RIN with no product behind it, the obligated party must sort it out on their own, and it costs money, since you end up paying twice. So we need a system of that kind in Europe as well. And I'm fairly confident it will eventually arrive, after our announcements where we said, guys, look, China is cheating — that turned out to be true.

Claus Sauter

executive
#29

We were headed in the right direction. We weren't pointing fingers at anyone. There's nothing there. We were headed in the right direction. And now everyone has to acknowledge it, both from the government and from the ministries as well.

Operator

operator
#30

Thanks. This is a broader question regarding how margins are developing, and margins overall in Europe compared with the US. The question asks: why do you anticipate margins that are so much greater from the US market, or correspondingly, margins that are lower in Europe by comparison?

Claus Sauter

executive
#31

Like I mentioned, over in Europe—particularly given the oversupply situation—we were careful about setting a sensible margin, but Friday brought a new game. Margins in the United States were quite healthy. What's the reason? A record corn harvest is expected, and it starts next week. So yields are very high, the weather in the Midwest was perfect, and corn production is a record. And cheap corn translates into cheap ethanol. So right now, U.S. ethanol is far and away the cheapest ethanol anywhere in the world. And the reason prices moved so favorably and margins did too over the last month was that export figures came in at double or triple what had been estimated. So the U.S. is exporting ethanol, the world is being fed with U.S. ethanol, and that will keep going as long as corn stays cheap. Cheap corn translates into cheap ethanol, and cheap ethanol—if it's the cheapest anywhere in the world—will speed up export figures. And at minimum, we expect that to last until the new seeding in spring 2025.

Operator

operator
#32

Thanks. Let's pick up on the items that shifted last Friday, and we have a question from Marcus Kuvesh <<inaudible>> at Lupus IFA. There are actually two questions, though the first one ties directly into what you were just saying. What timing do you expect for the draft that came out last Friday?

Claus Sauter

executive
#33

Stakeholders such as businesses and trade groups have until Monday of next week, October 1, to respond or submit their views on that draft. As you can see, the pace here is extremely fast, since the goal is for this new regulation to take effect on January 1, 2025. That's right. So our expectation for the schedule is as follows. We have gathered some input from the industry as well as from our own side, and we are getting that ready. Once we send these to the ministry, negotiations will follow. My expectation, then, is that in November it will clear the German parliament so that it can apply starting January 1, 2025. So I am — or rather we are — fairly confident that this timeline will hold.

Operator

operator
#34

Great, thanks. I’d like to dig a bit deeper into the greenhouse quotas and the write-offs on unfinished goods. Marcus Kuvesh also asked about the fact that there have again been substantial write-offs of unfinished goods, which leaves them at roughly EUR214 million. If you have a figure, what is the per-ton assumption for the greenhouse gas quota still held in stock?

Olaf Tröber

executive
#35

To start with, the drop in stocks as well as in raw materials and finished goods isn’t caused just by a write-down; lower prices play a part too, and please understand that we won’t be giving that figure here. Some interested parties may also be on this call, and yes, please accept that. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#36

Thank you. Our next question is from Roland Federer at Praxis Partners, if I have that right, and it concerns the carryover of greenhouse gas quotas—or the fact that no carryover may be possible. The question is as follows: the German government, as you mentioned earlier, has proposed legislation to pause the rollover of greenhouse gas certificates for 2025 and 2026. In your view, how probable is it that this law will take effect, and should it take effect, what impact do you anticipate on the industry and on VERBIO, and equally important, might that potentially lead to an upgrade of your guidance for the coming financial year?

Claus Sauter

executive
#37

Like I said, it's much too soon. We're sure it's going to happen — the industry needs it — but at minimum, if I put it at 90% or 95%, there remains a 5% or 10% chance of uncertainty. Until the parliament has passed it. We don't have that knowledge yet, though the effects are already visible. I brought up the 2025 CO2 price signal, since at present no one holds CO2 quotas for 2025. That is really going to lift the entire market. But please, give us time to work it out. We issued our guidance. We don't wish to revise it at this point over a draft, yet just to give you a sense, with no more UER and the standard quota step-up in 2025, that's roughly 4.5 million tons of CO2 savings. That's substantial alongside a simultaneous drop in Chinese imports, which since 2020 have made up a significant portion of the whole system. So yes, I believe the talks — what we're doing with the oil companies right now — will take on a completely different spin in the coming weeks. As you're aware, VERBIO is very strong in low greenhouse gas biofuels. So our biofuels deliver high greenhouse gas savings, and the share of advanced biofuels volume has gone up in recent years.

Claus Sauter

executive
#38

So if it appears that greenhouse gas prices are going to rise — and I don't anticipate levels like the EUR450 we saw two years ago — I do see the price coming in significantly above where it sits today and above what our planning assumes. Once our new contracts are in place and once there's clarity on whether the draft gets through parliament, we can run a fresh calculation. And if that shows we're too far off with the guidance we currently have, we'll correct it.

Operator

operator
#39

Thanks. There are three questions I have, and all three concern the U.S. — all three come from Pamela Stenger at Tiedtke. Let me begin with the first one. Could you give us a bit more detail and color on that tax credit sale in the US?

Claus Sauter

executive
#40

Okay, on the detail: the tax credit came to roughly $40 million, and we had to offer a discount — I'd rather not say what it was, but it was single digit. And yes, the process went smoothly and was quite straightforward, considerably easier than I'd anticipated, and the funds are now in our account. So everything's fine.

Operator

operator
#41

Everything's fine.

Claus Sauter

executive
#42

Everything's fine. It's the US. Not as complicated as Europe. Pretty easygoing.

Operator

operator
#43

Thanks, that's helpful. Nevada — could you give us a bit more detail on how you expect production to ramp up, and what Nevada is expected to contribute to results in fiscal year 2024 and in 2025?

Claus Sauter

executive
#44

Okay, so Olaf brought that up. We're currently in the ramp-up stage. Our intention is to reach full utilization by the close of the business year. At the moment, things are moving slowly, but we'll pick up speed no later than spring. Honestly, it isn't exactly straightforward. For the operators over there, this is a new technology — a new company, a new technology, a new product, renewable natural gas produced from Stellish <<inaudible>> destined for the U.S. market, where our primary focus is the voluntary market. So we're essentially establishing a fresh market for a fresh product. Bio-fertilizer will be part of the picture too. That's another novel item as well — recycled fertilizer for the Midwest. We're likewise in discussions with DC, with the EPA, the Environmental Protection Agency, to secure additional support there. Currently we're applying for a grant tied to a program that centers on what we're doing here. So we'll see what comes of it. But as I mentioned, it's a new technology, new teams, a new product — not just the RNG, but the bio-fertilizer as well. So the goal is to be EBITDA neutral by the end of the business year. South Bend is coming along very nicely.

Claus Sauter

executive
#45

That was a plant that already made ethanol, so compared with Nevada it was fairly easy. I hope none of our engineers are listening in. So it was fairly easy. We raised capacity by 20%. We cut costs. And that really turned out to be a very nice success. South Bend is profitable. And now we move to the next step, which is starting the investment there. That is also where our focus sits at the moment. So first comes the proof of concept with Nevada, and the second one is South Bend. Beyond that, we have no plans right now to really roll it out. Rolling out will happen once we demonstrate the competitive advantage of Nevada against the rest of the U.S. in the U.S. ethanol industry.

Operator

operator
#46

Thanks a lot. The final question about the U.S. — and I'm certain this comes up in every single conversation with whatever company you're having it with — concerns the political climate in the U.S. and what would follow from a victory by either the Democrats or the Republicans in an election. Do you think the result of that election would affect your business, and what's your view on it at the moment?

Claus Sauter

executive
#47

No, I don’t see any effect at all. The major backing for our efforts across the Midwest comes from the IRA — the Inflation Reduction Act. And we’ve already discussed this. It was enacted by the Democrats, yet the party that benefits most from the IRA is the Midwest, and historically those are Republican-leaning states. Ultimately, why would the Trump administration take action that is harmful and would damage corn farmers in the Midwest? So, I just don’t see it. In any case, I was referring to a competitive edge. So, if the U.S. ethanol sector does take a hit from thinner margins, our technology holds an advantage, since we don’t produce ethanol and feed — we produce ethanol and RNG. Once you have that, the technology is more profitable than merely making feed. No, I don’t anticipate any adverse effect from the November election.

Operator

operator
#48

Thanks a lot. And this final question shouldn't consume too much of your time. It has to do with possible pricing trends, price hikes, and naturally the effect on your forecast. As written, if I'm understanding Mr. Sauter correctly, price increases are more probable in 2025 and beyond. And should that occur, what would that imply for your guidance or your business outlook?

Claus Sauter

executive
#49

It's hard to predict, honestly. As I mentioned, starting Friday we've already seen the 2025 quota climb by 50%. But looking at this draft as it stands, nobody holds a 2025 quota right now. Because if there's no way to carry 2024 into 2025, then no one has one. So we'll see. It's all speculation at this point, though I'd say there's a reasonable chance quota prices rise once more above EUR300 per metric ton. We'll find out. At the moment, I'd describe the industry—particularly the obligated parties—as shocked. During our initial talks on 2025 and 2026 biofuels, they were quite relaxed. But since Friday they're in shock, since they had counted on using their surplus across the next 2 years, and it very much appears that's finished. Still, it's hard to say—let's wait. It hasn't even been one week.

Operator

operator
#50

Okay, a brief note on India — the question itself was pretty short, though it's definitely an interesting one. So, what's the situation with India?

Claus Sauter

executive
#51

So, India — we have our plant there. Unfortunately, utilization is only running at 50%, 60%, since demand in that region isn't large enough. Two weeks ago — I'll be in India in two weeks — and we'll be speaking with the Ministry of Petroleum and Gas, Mr. Hardeep Puri, who gives us a great deal of support. Indian Oil, for instance — the Indian Oil Company is our biggest customer, but that isn't sufficient. My sense is they never anticipated that we could ramp up that plant, that we could operate or make renewable natural gas from rice straw, from PEDI <<inaudible>> as they call it, since right now we're the only company — plenty of companies are examining that market, the big Adani's and Ambani's announcement of 50 and the 100 plants over there in India, biogas plants. And they've already begun investing as well. Yet the sole company actually producing is VERBIO. So I'm confident, though India always takes longer than we expect. But we have a plant there, we are producing, we are EBITDA neutral — that wasn't the reason we went to India, though.

Claus Sauter

executive
#52

So let's see how things go. But first of all, that plant has to be profitable, and after that we can consider what comes next. What I can tell you, though, is that in India, when it comes to biofuel, there's a lot in the market right now — E10, so 10% ethanol, was recently implemented. Nearly 80% of the sugar plants are now producing ethanol as well. So there's a lot of movement in the market, and with biogas too, it's accelerating. But let's see. As I said earlier, first of all I want to see the proof of concept, and then we can go further.

Operator

operator
#53

We have two final questions. The second to last one is from Marcus Kubishegan, Lupus Ifa <<inaudible>>. When are you going to sell the greenhouse gas quota stock that sits on your balance sheet? And what does the timing of that depend on?

Claus Sauter

executive
#54

The price is what matters here. We’re after a fair price. We’re not in a rush to sell our greenhouse gas savings at just any price, particularly when the pricing isn’t fair. That’s why we put so much effort and so much energy into joining this initiative, for example—but stop it. So it looks like keeping it on the books was the right strategy for us. So we can carry it forward to 2025, and there’s a high probability that we’ll get a much better price in 2025 and 2024. Yes, we need the clear effects of the draft from Friday. We already see some effects, and yes, profit maximization is our target, and I think even if it’s on our balance sheet and we need working capital for it, it was a good decision.

Operator

operator
#55

Thanks. Now we come to the final question, and since it's quite precise, I'll read it out loud. What is VERBIO's position regarding the contested shipments of unrefined liquid dextrose, ultra-filtration, and rein-based ethanol coming from the US into Europe?

Claus Sauter

executive
#56

Nope.

Operator

operator
#57

That is a really brief and quite specific response. Thanks a lot.

Claus Sauter

executive
#58

That's a quite particular question, and whoever is asking it knows the subject very well. No, that stream isn't available to us at this point. So, that's all the questions.

Operator

operator
#59

That wraps up the question portion. We've done well on time—an hour and five minutes. I'd like to use this moment to express appreciation to both of you, naturally Mr. Souter and Mr. Troeber, for the time you gave us, your insights, and the way you walked us through the fiscal year ‘23, ‘24 figures. Also, thank you to the entire VERBIO IR team, including you, for assembling all of this. We look forward to hearing more, particularly about that draft that was developed on Friday, and to seeing how it evolves. A short feedback form will go out to everyone who participated in this call, and naturally, from our side, a big thank you to every single participant—not just for attending, but for posing questions and making this such a lively call. Thank you so much. Yes.

Claus Sauter

executive
#60

Thanks a lot, and maybe I’ll close with a final remark from my side. What I’d like to stress is this: yes, the figures from this business, set against what we had already delivered, are somewhat disappointing — but when you factor in the environment, the circumstances under which we managed to produce that result, then I have to say it is an extraordinary result, since we were genuinely up against difficult market conditions. So, finally, I look forward to what has happened recently. I look forward to 2025, 2026, 2027, when demand for biofuel will continue to rise. Many thanks to everyone who joined that call, to the shareholders who are invested in VERBIO — under these circumstances we did a good job. We truly did a good job. Measured against earlier years, we are still there. It remains a good result, and I believe many of the decisions we took, including pulling back from certain investments, certain investments, certain opportunities, were the right call. So even if it doesn’t sound that way, I am quite positive about the years ahead. I look forward to being involved in the discussions on RED III implementation and to being part of it.

Claus Sauter

executive
#61

I believe our government — the Ministry of Environment — has to acknowledge that they committed some crazy mistakes. We're talking about billions in lost money due to fraud. And that's solely their fault, no one else's; they failed to check properly the paperwork put before them. So it was hard to get through those times, even though we were raising these issues — insufficient control, fraud, things of that sort. So a situation like this had to happen. Unfortunately, some companies went bankrupt. Unfortunately, some companies were forced into enormous write-downs and had to halt projects. But we keep moving along our path, though not at the pace we had hoped. Let me return to our Investor Day in Shreve in the fall of last year. Still, we stay the course, and it appears that most of the challenges and problems we've dealt with over the last 2 years are nearing an end. So, many thanks, Mr. Nas, for leading that call. Many thanks to Olaf. Many thanks to Alina. Many thanks to everyone who joined that call. And let's see how quickly we can come out with an adjustment to our guidance.

Claus Sauter

executive
#62

Thanks a lot. Have a good day.

Operator

operator
#63

I appreciate that.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Verbio SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Verbio SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Verbio SE or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.