Verbio SE (VBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 12, 2024

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Energy Oil, Gas and Consumable Fuels earnings 65 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Holger Nass

operator
#1

Good day, everyone, and thank you for being here for Verbio's Q1 earnings call for fiscal year 2024/2025. It's a real pleasure to be joined by the leadership of Verbio SE: Mr. Claus Sauter, our CEO, and Alina Köhler, Head of Investor Relations — the two of them will walk us through the results today. After the presentation, we'll open things up for a question-and-answer session. One note: sell-side analysts can pose their questions through their microphones, and further instructions will be given to you at the close of the presentation. Everyone else should use the chat box located in the lower right-hand corner of the system. So that your question can be considered, we'd ask that you kindly provide your company name along with your own full name so we can qualify it. Many thanks. I'm now looking forward to hearing some interesting insights from Mr. Sauter and Ms. Köhler, so I'll hand the presentation over to you.

Claus Sauter

executive
#2

Many thanks, Mr. Nass. Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to today's earnings call. Joining me is Alina Köhler, our Head of Investor Relations. It's wonderful to have all of you with us on the call. We'll go over our first quarter results for the July through September period. Following that, as was already noted, we'll have time for questions. Our current performance is not satisfactory, and we'll get into the reasons for that shortly. But first, let's keep our focus on the big picture. The shift to a green economy is essential for the world's future. Even big oil urges Mr. Trump to keep the IRA, so that their green investments remain viable. You've also heard about the big transaction three weeks ago, which is a strong signal of confidence in the European biofuels market and its returns. While the journey will not be linear, we are operating in a growth sector and Verbio is in a prime position to capitalize on them. So now let's look at the figures for Q1. On a positive side, our production volumes increased year-over-year, as you can see in the chart on the far left. The increase in ethanol volumes, the light green bars, was driven by better utilization in all regions, including small volumes at our Nevada plant in Iowa.

Claus Sauter

executive
#3

RNG output went up as well for us. Even so, EBITDA fell sharply, landing at minus EUR 6.6 million. So the tough market environment shows up quite plainly in our first quarter numbers. Net debt after the first quarter came to EUR63 million, since we kept putting money into our main projects. Those are chiefly South Bend ethanol, the Indiana plant, and our specialty chemicals facility in Germany. We're still investing, though we're doing so carefully and staying focused on keeping the balance sheet strong. The equity ratio came in at 65% and was broadly unchanged. As I noted when we reported Q4 figures, the investment tax credit tied to the IRA for our Nevada RNG facility — which we sold successfully in Q4 — weighs on that equity ratio, because it's treated as an investment grant and therefore raises the liability. I'll now turn things over to Alina, who can walk you through the figures in a bit more detail. Alina, over to you.

Alina Köhler

executive
#4

Thanks, Claus, and good afternoon from me as well. This slide shows, from left to right, the main drivers behind the swing in our EBITDA between Q1 of last year and Q1 of this year. What you can see is that the gross margin is the real force behind the decline. It is falling mainly because sales pricing has come down, and because the GHG quota market has been challenging. Both segments have in fact been hit by this — Biodiesel and Bioethanol/Biomethane. In Q1 of last year, we were still benefiting from attractive GHG credits that were locked in. So of course that makes for a tough comparison for us. And something else you can see right beside the gross margin decline is that FX effects and commodity forward contracts had a negative impact on our results. Consequently, the earnings from our European activities were not enough to cover the costs of our North American endeavors. But I am really pleased to report that in North America we have in fact delivered a better performance than the prior year, which comes thanks to better utilization despite a lower spread, as you will find out when we get to markets a bit later. But let's move on now to the more detailed split by segment.

Alina Köhler

executive
#5

You've likely seen this chart before; it's probably familiar to you. What it does is show how the makeup of our EBITDA changed, and it also sets the prior quarter against this year's quarter. As you can tell, the drop in the two segments has been quite comparable. That said, the Biodiesel segment's decline came entirely from the gross margin, while the Bioethanol decrease stemmed from the FX effects and commodity forward contracts we mentioned earlier, along with the gross margin. Let me now turn to the Biodiesel segment and walk you through a little more detail. In Biodiesel, Verbio brought in revenues of almost EUR 200 million, which you can see in the chart on the left. That figure came down from roughly EUR 323 million in the same quarter a year ago. What really stands out is that production volumes, and sales volumes too, stayed largely flat. So the downward revenue trend came entirely from lower biodiesel prices, and also from lower GHG quota sales, and as we mentioned on our Q4 and Q3 call in the last financial year, Canada has been operating through processing contracts starting December 2023, which basically means revenues and material costs get reduced, but when it comes to EBITDA, there's no change to that.

Alina Köhler

executive
#6

So obviously, if we look now at the chart on the right side of the slide, weaker spreads along with reduced GHG quota prices hurt our results relative to Q1 of last year. As I said, market spreads narrowed. That's shown here in the chart on the left. The market spread means the gap in price between biodiesel and rapeseed oil, calculated per ton of biodiesel. It fell in the third quarter versus a year earlier. The dark green line actually captures this, representing the present financial year, while the lighter green line shows the prior financial year. Over in the right-hand chart, you can see those spread declines were caused by biodiesel prices coming down. What also stands out, though, is that right now both biodiesel and rapeseed oil prices are climbing, pushed by the veg oil complex and mainly palm oil, in fact. That's genuinely good news for our second quarter, since a rising price backdrop tends to benefit us given that we purchase feedstock 2 to 3 months ahead. But let me now share a little more detail on biomethane and bioethanol in our first quarter.

Alina Köhler

executive
#7

Sales are essentially flat year over year at EUR 160 million, despite higher production volumes. The bar chart's far-left column shows revenues, and right beside it you'll find production volumes for RNG and bioethanol. So the added volume didn't lift sales. The reason, once again, is weaker bioethanol prices along with GHG prices. Those softer selling prices, with feedstock prices down only slightly, passed straight through to the bottom line, which took a further hit — as I noted earlier — from FX effects and from the change in value of commodity forward contracts. Consequently, for the Bioethanol/Biomethane segment we ended up posting negative EBITDA of EUR 21.5 million. Incidentally, the FX effect and the open commodity forwards ought to work in our favor in Q2, since the dollar and ethanol prices are both rising at present. And on the topic of ethanol prices, let's turn to how the market has been developing. The spreads, again displayed on the left of the slide, narrowed as the quarter drew to a close. That narrowing came mainly from weaker bioethanol prices. Alongside those low bioethanol prices, the lead prices were low as well.

Alina Köhler

executive
#8

They've only just risen toward the quarter's close, which you can see with the dark green line — that's actually driven by US corn, and we'll get to that in a moment. And I mentioned earlier that bioethanol prices declined. That was in fact mainly driven by lower stocks in Europe. But as I just said, we're now turning to the US, which we've included here for the first time. Like I said, corn is the price maker at the moment, and the good crop in the United States keeps the corn level low, as you can see in the chart on the right. Right now we're talking about bioethanol at 150 per ton of corn, or EUR 450, as you can see on the slide, for 1 ton of ethanol for the corn you need for that. In the United States, though, bioethanol prices also declined, given that producers are maximizing their production. Also, what shows up very clearly on this slide is that if you look at the chart on the left side now, we really saw seasonality in the United States. We've discussed the drier season before, and you can see that during the winter months, usually the margin is very low, whereas in the summer months, the margin comes up again.

Alina Köhler

executive
#9

And with that, I'll turn things over to Claus, who's going to bring you up to speed on the GHG quota and what's going on with that.

Claus Sauter

executive
#10

Thanks, Alina. So, as Alina said, quota prices kept falling in our first quarter, and that hurt our results. The draft amendment that the German Federal Ministry of the Environment published on September 20 also played a part in pushing prices down. So what does the draft contain? I refer to this draft as notverordnung since it is plainly a response to the market distortions we have been dealing with for nearly two years now. So the draft proposes suspending, for 2025 and 2026, the ability to carry forward extra greenhouse gas reduction from one year to the next. The Ministry of Environment's aim is to lift demand for quota options and prop up greenhouse gas quota prices in those years. So that idea appears explicitly in the draft. That is the goal. But ever since the draft was released, we have seen demand for 2024 quotas almost come to a halt, which immediately weighed on the market. So although prices have bounced back a little, that is happening only on the back of very small volumes. What is also interesting, though, is that quotas for 2025, which cannot even be delivered yet, since nobody holds 2025 quota, are already beginning to gain value. And that is probably only the start.

Claus Sauter

executive
#11

Now let's consider what's going to take place in 2025. As I mentioned regarding the draft from the Ministry of Environment paper, market participants who have quota obligations will no longer have the option to use CO2 savings achieved in 2024 for offsetting purposes in 2025. So what does that imply for demand? We have the set quota mandate, which the dark blue line represents. In the 2024 quota year, the carryover or carry-in from 2023 is expected to reach roughly 6 million tons of CO2 savings. That's the light blue bar. In 2025, no carry-in will exist, even though it certainly has been generated and will be moved to 2027. At the same time, the transition from RED 2 into RED 3 will occur, which offers another possibility to adjust further growth in greenhouse gas savings. So in 2025, real-time CO2 offset needs to fill this gap. Eliminating upstream emission reductions, UERs, as a compliance option starting in 2025 also requires compensation of around 2 million tons of CO2 savings through other options, such as more liquid and gaseous biofuels as far as electricity. Combined with the planned increase in the greenhouse gas quota, these effects produce the largest annual rise in greenhouse gas savings to date, to around 10 million tons, which must be achieved within the same year.

Claus Sauter

executive
#12

That's a substantial rise — 10 million tons — and it's going to have an impact on greenhouse gas prices. But as I've said previously, and I'll repeat it, every one of these measures and constraints really only works once control measures exist, so that when we're in a stable, higher-price environment, no wrongly declared product can enter anymore. We need barriers that actually function. That's the reason the initiative against climate fraud calls for a register system, which could be put in place ahead of RED 3 implementation. In fact, the current situation in the fight against fraud is being helped — and Alina already brought this up — by very high palm oil prices, meaning that right now, using palm oil, even when it's fraudulent, doesn't pay economically. So there's more potential here given the likely cancellation of fraudulent UER projects. And on our previous call, I already noted that clear fraud exists and that we anticipate a response from the government. So during our last earnings call, I mentioned that projects covering roughly 4 million tons of CO2 might be cancelled retroactively. So exactly how this will be handled is still unknown to us. Now the German environmental agency, Umweltbundesamt, is stating that project leaders will have to supply new valid upstream emission reduction certificates to take the place of the fake ones.

Claus Sauter

executive
#13

That said, this simply isn't realistic. It doesn't hold up in practice. The volume of counterfeit certificates greatly exceeds the supply of legitimate ones on the market, even when you include new projects. Given that, our view is that these cancelled certificates ought to be permitted to be offset through any compliance options that are available, which would push demand up even further. Moving to the next slide, Alina. Thank you. So our guidance stays as it was. As a result, we still anticipate EBITDA of between EUR 120 million and EUR 160 million. Net debt at the close of our financial year is projected to rise to no more than EUR 190 million. As I mentioned before, the draft proposal from the Ministry of Environment should have a favorable impact during the second half of the financial year, driven by considerably greater sales volumes of greenhouse gas quotas. There is, though, uncertainty over whether an impairment of the carrying values of greenhouse gas quota inventories will have to be recognized by year-end, contingent on how greenhouse gas quota prices develop further in 2024. A possible impairment write-down, assuming greenhouse gas quota prices rise going forward, would lead to unrecognized reserves being established, and that would produce future earnings potentially generated starting in 2027.

Claus Sauter

executive
#14

Thanks so much for hearing us out on that explanation. Now then, let’s move into the Q&A portion. So we have no questions at all?

Holger Nass

operator
#15

…we’ve got a technical problem at the moment. We’re working on getting it resolved. Please bear with us for just one second.

Claus Sauter

executive
#16

It seems we're running into a few technical problems. I can see that some questions have already come in through the chat. So should we begin with those questions that are in the chat? I think, then, that we'll start with the questions in the chat.

Alina Köhler

executive
#17

Perhaps we could begin with the question from Cornelis? He's asking whether you could give us some additional clarity regarding the potential impairment as well as the profit contribution.

Claus Sauter

executive
#18

I believe we should just go through the questions one at a time, Alina. All right, we'll begin with the question from Cornelius Kick <<inaudible>>. Could you give us more clarity on the potential impairment as well as the profit contribution? Well, it very much depends on where the quota price ends up at the end of the year. So there's a lot of movement. And ultimately, the question is how things will develop for the 2025 quota. As of right now, we don't anticipate a major issue with the impairment, but it could be maybe low. It's a single or perhaps a low double-digit million euro amount. And I'll start at the beginning here with Sven. At the current price, Verbio has a lower market valuation and the company is financially healthy. Are there currently no parties interested in acquiring the company? Could you share your views on this? Well, no, there are no parties interested in acquiring the company. So ultimately, I think the low market valuation at the moment is very much tied to the fact that we have a clear regulation. But regulation was not properly controlled by the government and the institutions. And I think all these concerns about fraudulent product, and I was reporting about it already two years ago, now it is clear that there is fraud.

Claus Sauter

executive
#19

Once that's behind us, I believe our results will bounce back, and after that the market will bounce back too, and then we'll see how things unfold. The next question was — on your prior call, also from Sven — on your prior call you sounded fairly optimistic about the year ahead. How come the results are so much weaker than the expectations you laid out? Well, in the end, we issued our guidance on September 19. And we didn't anticipate that a day later, the government would come out with this notverordnung. So I think that sends a clear message. And as I mentioned earlier, it's stated in the draft itself that the government must do something so that greenhouse gas prices are recovering. So I think it's a clear statement, a fast reaction. So the impact now on the first two quarters will be that, since obligated parties won't be able to use their CO2 savings in 2025, they have to carry it over to 2027. So oil companies, obligated parties, cut back their use of biofuels to take as much of their CO2 savings as possible in 2024. So this is some change, an unexpected change, yes, but in the end it's a great signal into 2025, because the overall demand, or the overall target, for 2025 is approximately 21 million tons of CO2 savings.

Claus Sauter

executive
#20

So taking all of those factors together — the absence of carry-in, no UERs, and the standard quota increase, which translates into 10 million tons of additional CO2 savings, and that accounts for 50% of the extra volume — that was something we hadn't anticipated. So I remain optimistic for 2025 and for 2026 as well. There's an opportunity for the market to bounce back. It's widely acknowledged that current greenhouse gas prices are much too low. And as for the question of what should be done about the fraudulent volumes — the 4 million tons I referred to — I believe that's a discussion we'll be holding with the Ministry of Environment as RED 3 is implemented. There has to be some consequence as well. So I think the government has come to understand how important it is to have unambiguous rules and to police them, so that fraud on the scale we witnessed — millions of tons of CO2 savings that were never actually delivered — cannot recur.

Holger Nass

operator
#21

Cornelis Kick has a few more questions, and unless you've already covered them, I think we should go ahead with those. One of them is: could you give us more clarity and quantify the ramp-up costs in the US?

Claus Sauter

executive
#22

Okay, regarding US ramp-up costs — we're in the middle of ramping up right now. So the plan for the full year is that ramp-up costs will be there, in the single-digit million euro amount, though at this point it's a bit too early to say. That's what we're planning. But we expect EBITDA of between zero and under EUR 10 million. Let's see how things continue. I'm in the US right now. We're making great progress here in Nevada. And yes, the plant — we have a shutdown at the moment to fix some things. But since September, we've been running at up to 50% utilization. So it's moving forward.

Holger Nass

operator
#23

Cornelius also asked whether we anticipate the revaluation impacts along with the FX and commodity contracts reversing in Q2, assuming the dollar strengthens potentially.

Alina Köhler

executive
#24

Yeah, absolutely — I mentioned that in the presentation too. Ethanol prices are rising and the dollar is gaining strength, and that clearly works in our favor for the second quarter.

Claus Sauter

executive
#25

Yeah, margins are down, as they were in the last business year, but they recovered everywhere. And we had some effects—what Alina mentioned during the presentation—that are also shifting now. So the second quarter should be much better than the first quarter. Next question.

Holger Nass

operator
#26

And on the US as well, when do you expect the expansion there to be finished — meaning the capacity ramp-up? When do you think that will be complete?

Claus Sauter

executive
#27

At the moment, our primary focus is getting the Nevada plant fully ramped up. As I mentioned, we were running at 50% utilization. So the plan is to bring that plant up to full capacity by the end of the business year. Then, ethanol in Indiana — in South Bend — is already running, so that one is at full capacity. After that, the next step is to implement RNG production there in Indiana, in South Bend. But for that, we have to make the investment. Groundbreaking started in May this year. Right now, we're building digesters. However, during this commissioning in Nevada, we learned that US corn differs from European corn. So it appears that producing renewable natural gas from US corn spillage is less complicated than in Europe. As a result, we expect to be able to lower the investment cost for Indiana. The original plan was $230 million. But I think we can manage it. Some components of our technology that we need in our German plants aren't needed here in the US. So we're learning a lot. We're gaining interesting learnings and experience. So I think we'll be able to bring the Indiana investment below $200 million.

Claus Sauter

executive
#28

So that’s the plan. Through the end of the business year, Nevada will run at full capacity on ethanol and at full capacity on renewable natural gas, which is right here on that slide that’s still up on the screen. And then we’ll keep investing in RNG in Indiana, which from today will take at least another two years, but in any case, that Indiana investment is very closely tied to how our company performs, so that the market is recovering and we can deliver the guidance we expect. And Indiana is also something where we have the ability to adjust the investment and the cost somewhat. I think another important point is that the Indiana investment also qualifies for the IRA. So there will be an investment tax credit when we invest $200 million, and that will come to roughly $60 million, 30% of it.

Holger Nass

operator
#29

Our following question comes from Jocelyn <<inaudible>>. At present, in the BD and RD EU market during Q2, with every RD refinery offline, are you seeing a supply crunch, and in what ways might that impact you? Also, do you carry any exposure, or some exposure, to the French spot market in Q2?

Claus Sauter

executive
#30

That's quite a few questions rolled into a single one. Could you say it again for me?

Holger Nass

operator
#31

Absolutely, happy to take that. At present, are you seeing any supply tightness in the BD/RD EU market during Q2, given that all the RD refineries are offline? And in what ways might that impact you?

Claus Sauter

executive
#32

Look, first, there's the growing demand and the question of how those extra 10 million tons of CO2 savings get achieved, and just in the German market. So as things stand, China is off the table. There's no business case at the moment because palm oil prices are high. And then particularly in Germany, we need 10 million tons of additional CO2 savings. We've mentioned this. That has to happen through liquid or gaseous molecules. But in certain areas, we have blending walls. So even when the molecules exist, getting them blended into diesel and gasoline is a challenge. That isn't our problem. It will be the oil industry's problem. But it is a challenge. And in my view, gaseous molecules can deliver the biggest effect, since no blending is involved. It's 100% pure biofuels. So we're talking bio-LNG or bio-CNG. And I think we'll see more demand there emerging over the course of 2025. And just the possibility of meeting the target by blending this additional volume, even if the molecules are available, bringing it to market will be a challenge. And what I'm seeing is, first of all, more demand coming from gaseous molecules, renewable natural gas, which is what Verbio is doing.

Claus Sauter

executive
#33

Also, my second point: I'd expect the oil sector to shell out premium prices for biofuels that deliver large greenhouse gas reductions. The reason being that with blending — we've got E10, meaning 10% ethanol is the ceiling. When it comes to biodiesel, blending it is the least expensive option, yet a 7% blending wall applies there. So you're able to push somewhat more renewable diesel this way. Still, what matters most to the oil industry, I believe, is simply the cost of blending as such. That translates into stronger demand for biofuels with high greenhouse gas savings. And that's another thing Verbio is capable of. We offer top-grade biodiesel, and on the volume that gets blended we can achieve substantial greenhouse gas savings. So at present, let's watch how 2025 unfolds, though the crucial factor isn't just molecule availability — it's likewise the route for getting it to market.

Holger Nass

operator
#34

What was our exposure to the French spot market in Q2?

Alina Köhler

executive
#35

Typically, we sell all of our volumes, and we always carry exposure to prices—to spot prices—since that is the basis on which our contracts are structured, tied to the average spot prices within a month, if that answers your question.

Claus Sauter

executive
#36

Yeah, I believe that's right. We're pretty much sold out, so the volume's booked. Utilization is going to be near 95%, 97%. Like Alina said, our exposure comes from how market prices develop.

Holger Nass

operator
#37

Marcus Kubasch <<inaudible>> has a question — he's asking, given the political environment, what the odds are that the draft of the law we discussed earlier will actually become law by the end of the year.

Claus Sauter

executive
#38

This isn’t a law—it’s just a regulation. That means it doesn’t need to go through the government. So a majority isn’t required. So as things stand, the fact that our government is a minority government has no bearing on this regulation, because the regulation only has to go through the cabinet. Well, before all these changes in Germany, the date to decide on that regulation should have been tomorrow, so November 13. Right now, I don’t know if this date is still valid. But it’s a clear message. And you know the regulation is coming from the Greens. And as I said, it doesn’t have to go through the Parliament, it’s just a regulation so it is decided from the Cabinet.

Holger Nass

operator
#39

Before we get to the final questions, if anyone else has something to ask, go ahead and put it in the chat. We'd be glad to respond. And if you can, please include your company name along with your full name, so we can qualify the questions properly. Now let's go to a question from Ms. Stenger-Tiedtke. Her company is Renewable Energy Research, and she asks: how do you currently assess political risk in the USA? Could you give more detail on sales of US production volumes?

Claus Sauter

executive
#40

Thank you, Alina. Perhaps you can see it up on the screen — a strong oil lobby defending the IRA. Big oil is pressing Trump not to dismantle Biden's climate law. So that's my first point. Well, my first argument concerns our business: most of the US states impacted by the IRA and by what Verbio does are Midwest states, and those are Republican states. The second point is what Alina just put on the screen — it's no longer only companies such as Verbio, a pure biofuel company. No, particularly over the last two, three years here in the United States, Big Oil has been investing. A few of the firms are named here. Phillips 66, which converted a large mineral oil refinery into a renewable diesel refinery, ExxonMobil invested in Occidental Petroleum. So all of these oil companies have begun enormous investments in renewable diesel, or they are doing CO2 sequestration. So it's not just companies like Verbio anymore — it's also Big Oil, which has realized that the package surrounding the IRA is economically very attractive and a good opportunity to make money. I just mentioned the so-called 45Q. So if you sequester a ton of CO2 savings in the United States, you generate an $85 tax credit per metric ton of CO2.

Claus Sauter

executive
#41

So that's a massive business here — investments in the multi-billion dollar range. And even if the IRA disappears, the choice we made to come to the United States happened well before the IRA existed. Call it a windfall gain for us on the investment here in Nevada. So we have zero concern that something is going to happen, and it will keep going. But even if something does happen, then investments will definitely slow down and they'll proceed on a calmer footing, but no one is going to halt that movement here in the United States.

Holger Nass

operator
#42

I just want to confirm — since the system dropped me — that Cornelius Kick's question about clarity on the possible impairment and the profit contribution has already been addressed, I take it.

Claus Sauter

executive
#43

That question's already been addressed.

Holger Nass

operator
#44

It seems, from where we sit — hold on, another question is arriving, and it comes from Conrad Leder <<inaudible>>. Could you share insights — and I believe we've touched on this briefly already. Could you share insights regarding industry capacity adjustments? I think to some degree we've already covered that.

Claus Sauter

executive
#45

No, that’s something we haven’t tackled yet. Well, I can’t say for sure, and we don’t know which producers are running and which aren’t. What we do hear from the market, though, is that a substantial amount of European biodiesel capacity has gone offline. There are two main reasons, which I mentioned: the margins were poor, and now demand is poor as well, since oil companies aren’t purchasing extra biodiesel volumes because they’re drawing on their surplus of CO2 savings. But I think everyone is getting ready now, and you can already see it. European rapeseed prices climbed by, let’s say, 20% over the past two months. So the market is gearing up to bring those capacities online in 2025 and to produce more European-based biodiesel. Palm oil isn’t an option — it’s too expensive. But as I said in response to that other question, it isn’t just about whether molecules are available. Those molecules also have to be brought to market. And I think that’s the biggest challenge. So it’s not simply a matter of producing biodiesel; it’s about producing the right biodiesel and the right biofuels. So limitations exist everywhere. And in 2025, the real goal is to reach the volume of 21 million tons of CO2 savings.

Claus Sauter

executive
#46

I think that's separate from just having the molecules available. Renewable diesel is one possibility, though it's the priciest one.

Holger Nass

operator
#47

Roland Federer from Praxis has one more question for me — I think that's how it came through. You reaffirmed the guidance for this year. That guidance was originally put out before the proposed regulatory change. Would it still stand if no change in regulation happens? And would there be upside should the proposed regulation be passed? Could you give any sense of how large that potential upside, or the downside, might be?

Claus Sauter

executive
#48

Yes, that question was correct. Our guidance had already been completed beforehand. But this effect — well, looking at our Q1 results, this effect whereby obligated parties reacted right away by cutting volumes. To blend it in 2024. There is room for additional biofuels in 2024, yet they no longer use that room. And that is impacting our Q1 figures. We were adjusting now, let's say, our response for Q2. So as I mentioned earlier, we anticipate Q2 being better than Q1. But at this point it will shift everything into 2025. So the key question is how quickly the market recovers, particularly the quota market. And in my view, the quota market will be crucial for hitting the 2025 target. We still have some options there to raise our volumes, to produce more and bring it to market. And it's genuinely difficult right now to say whether there is additional upside. We must wait until January 2025. At present we are negotiating the new contract for 2025. We need to see how much of a premium obligated parties will pay for biofuels with high greenhouse gas savings. But there is too much uncertainty at this moment at that point to comment on how the business here will develop further.

Claus Sauter

executive
#49

There's one more thing, Sven. One question remains. How is utilization at the plants in America — Nevada and South Bend — progressing? I notice production in Q4 is the same as in Q1. Yeah, that's correct. At South Bend, we're making some adjustments, some deep bottlenecking, to raise production reliability to a different level. So right now, overall, Q4 and Q1 look very similar. But Nevada was producing at, as I mentioned, roughly 50%, though at the very end of Q1 — so you'll mostly see that figure in Q2 — and South Bend came down a little bit. So the real effect will show up in Q2. Then I have one more question here from Valle <<inaudible>>. How is development in India going? Still hopeful? Yes. Well, development in India is interesting. And maybe some of you saw that three weeks ago, I spent one week in India. So what's the status quo there? We built a plant — a 20 megawatt renewable natural gas plant in Punjab — and our feedstock there is rice straw. In India, it's called paddy straw. So the plant is running at 50% utilization. And the gas is sold as a transport fuel in bottles at the surrounding filling stations.

Claus Sauter

executive
#50

The reason for my trip to India was primarily this: I told the government, look, we have a way to combat stubble burning. What's happening at present, with the rice harvest, is that 20 million tons of paddy straw are being set on fire by farmers. 20 million tons — the situation right now is terrible. In Punjab, and over in Pakistan as well, it's getting worse by the day. So people remain indoors, unable to go to work. That's our key objective. We arrived in India seven years ago. We observed what was happening there. And at this point we've built a plant as well as a value chain so that collection becomes possible. Currently we're gathering 60,000 tons of paddy straw — 60,000 tons that won't get burned. But a viable business case is needed. And that's the ongoing conversation with the Indian government, where we tell them we possess a technology capable of halting stubble burning and putting an end to that terrible situation each year, across the 10 weeks from October through December. And we're the only player, and the largest. So that's an entirely different story, since the primary product there isn't renewable natural gas as yet.

Claus Sauter

executive
#51

It's a renewable energy source that replaces fossil fuels. But the key thing is that we can take that paddy straw and turn it into another product. And we're now close to some regulatory changes in India that will make for a very compelling business case. During my visit to India, we signed a contract with GAIL. GAIL is the state-owned operator of the trans-India natural gas grid. It's a multi-billion dollar company, and we signed an MoU to build another 10 plants in India. We would build those plants jointly with GAIL. We would run them, and GAIL would take 100% offtake of all the renewable natural gas produced. Now, with Verbio India, we reached a point where we could show the government that what Verbio is doing works. And at this moment, as I said, we are the only option to stop that stubble burning, because the farmer himself has no way to do anything with that paddy straw since there's simply too much of it. The soil can't digest these enormous volumes of paddy straw. And after the rice harvest, December 10, the wheat has to already be sowed in the soil. So there's only a short window to do something with the paddy straw.

Claus Sauter

executive
#52

And for the farmer, the only real choice is simply to burn it. So yeah, those are interesting developments over in India. We'll see how things keep going from here. I think at that point I can share a fresh update when the Q2 numbers come out. But we're making really substantial progress in India.

Holger Nass

operator
#53

Great. Thank you very much. It seems our time is nearly up, though I believe we've covered every question from investors and sell-side analysts. So I'd like to use this moment to warmly thank everyone who joined us, and of course especially you, Mr. Sauter, and you, Alina, for the insights you shared. I'm looking forward to what happens in Q2, and I wish everyone a wonderful afternoon. Many thanks for being with us. And apologies on my end for the brief technical glitch. I'm still not sure what caused it, but I'm back now.

Claus Sauter

executive
#54

Yes. All right. Yeah. Thanks also from me. Many thanks to everyone for joining. Yes, as I mentioned at the start, the Q1 results are not satisfactory, but I believe the outlook now looks even better — much better for 2025. I also very much appreciate that our government finally responded and that our concerns regarding fraud proved correct. We weren't pointing fingers at anyone. So I look forward to speaking with you again when we present the Q2 numbers. And have a nice day. Thank you all very much. Thank you.

Alina Köhler

executive
#55

Thanks.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Verbio SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Verbio SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Verbio SE or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.