Verbio SE (VBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 12, 2025
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood afternoon, everyone, and a warm welcome to the Verbio earnings call covering the first half of fiscal year 2024 to 2025. Joining us today are Claus Sauter, Verbio's CEO, and Olaf Tröber, the company's CFO. They'll take us through how the business performed during the first half of the fiscal year, covering key milestones, market trends, and strategic initiatives. Before we dive in, though, a quick housekeeping note: this conference is being recorded, and all participants are in a listen-only mode. Should you have questions, please submit them via the chat box, and we'll address them during the Q&A session following the presentation. Please make sure to preface each question with your name and the name of your company in order to be considered. And without further ado, I'll hand it over to Mr. Sauter and Mr. Tröber. The floor is yours.
Claus Sauter
executiveThanks a lot, Harry. Good afternoon, everybody, and thank you for joining us on the call for the second quarter of 2024 to 2025 and our half-year earnings. With me today is Olaf Tröber, our CFO. When we look back over the last six months, we have achieved solid progress on our biggest growth project, the ethenolysis plant located in Bitterfeld. Starting in 2026, we will make the first quantities of renewable molecules for the chemical industry at our Bitterfeld site. These specialty chemicals serve as essential ingredients in detergents, cleaning products, high-performance lubricants, and plastics. Through this, we are advancing the shift in the chemical sector from fossil-based raw materials to renewable ones. At the same time, the ethanol plant startup in Nevada has not proceeded as smoothly as we had expected, because of equipment malfunctions. We are working at full capacity to fix these quality issues and to ramp up operations. The technology and the process in Nevada are proven and reliable. As a result, our long-term outlook stays fully intact. Turning to our operating results, the recovery of the greenhouse gas market is not occurring as fast as we anticipated. Operating conditions in the German greenhouse gas quota market remain challenging because of the huge oversupply of greenhouse gas credits generated from fraudulent products. Fortunately, things are stabilizing, thanks to national and international measures, and we expect significant improvement in the region in calendar year 2025.
Claus Sauter
executiveEven with those difficulties, we had a solid second quarter, largely because of how our biodiesel segment performed. Verbio stayed focused on running operations excellently, and that produced better gross margin in the segment both quarter over quarter and year over year, even though spot market spreads were lower. So with that, I want to hand things to Olaf so he can walk us through some of the financials, and after that I'll return with my views on 2025. Olaf, over to you.
Olaf Tröber
executiveThanks, Claus, and good afternoon, everyone. I'll begin with a review of the first half of 2024 to 2025, and then I'll get into Q2. So, the first slide — key figures. Once again, we can report record production volumes. The year-over-year rise in ethanol volumes — those are the light green bars in the chart on the far left — came from better utilization across all regions, and in particular at the South Bend plant. Now, the previous owner of this ethanol plant did manage to produce volumes like that over the past 20 years. Our RNG production volumes also went up, thanks to better utilization at our plants in Nevada and India. Yet our EBITDA declined to EUR 14.3 million, mostly on the back of a weak first quarter. Average product margins in the first half of the year were much lower than in the same period last year. This was largely due to an oversupply of greenhouse gas reductions caused by the fraud in the German market. Notably, in the first half of 2023 to 2024, Verbio was still benefiting from higher contractually fixed greenhouse gas premiums, which makes last year's comparison basis quite tough. Our net debt at the end of December stood at roughly EUR 97 million, as we continued to invest into our key projects.
Olaf Tröber
executiveThese mainly comprise South Bend Ethanol and our specialty chemicals facility in Germany, which Claus mentioned earlier. Although we keep investing, we do so cautiously, maintaining our attention on the strength of our balance sheet. Capital expenditures came to EUR 36 million in the second quarter and EUR 62 million across the first half of 2024 to 2025. At the same time, operating cash flow stayed positive and, well, fairly strong. The equity ratio remained near 65% and was largely stable. That said, I'll move on to Q2. Looking at Q2 2024 to 2025 overall, as Claus already noted, the second quarter was satisfactory on the whole, given challenging markets and the continuing burden from our North American operations. As anticipated, we saw a strong recovery in the second quarter of 2024 to 2025 relative to the first quarter of the current financial year. EBITDA in the second quarter came in at EUR 20.8 million, versus -EUR 6.6 million in the first quarter and EUR 26 million in the same period a year earlier. On a quarter-over-quarter basis, both main segments — biodiesel and the combined bioethanol/biomethane segment — posted a significant EBITDA improvement. Within the biodiesel segment by itself, EBITDA more than doubled. This significant recovery stems from attractive production margins, helped by favorable rapeseed oil purchases relative to the spot market.
Olaf Tröber
executiveCompared with the prior quarter, the rebound in bioethanol/biomethane is mostly attributable to how changes in the value of financial assets and commodity futures played out. Moving to the next slide. Biodiesel segment. I'll now provide a little more detail on how each part of this segment performed year over year. The chart on the left shows revenues were broadly flat at EUR 242 million, with production and sales volumes comparable. Average biodiesel prices being higher in the quarter were partly offset by reduced greenhouse gas premiums, along with the fact that from December 2023 through November 2024 — November of last year — our Canadian plant ran under processing contracts, which basically translates into lower revenues and raw material costs. Even though greenhouse gas premiums were more attractive last year, we succeeded in raising EBITDA by 25% year over year, reflecting our emphasis on spread, or margin, management. We took advantage of higher biodiesel prices through favorable rapeseed oil purchases. Next slide, please. Now, an update here. Speaking of Canada, in much the same way as many of our biodiesel peers across North America, we have cut production volumes at Welland because of the difficult margin environment. It's worth noting that our initial guidance had conservatively anticipated this, given expected challenges tied to the shift in incentive schemes from the Blenders Tax Credit BTC to the Production Tax Credit PTC.
Olaf Tröber
executiveThe BTC is feedstock agnostic, so qualifying parties get $1 per gallon — that works out to about EUR 280 per ton — while the PTC rewards low carbon intensity and yields a different value depending on the feedstock. We plan to ramp the plant back up in March, since the recent PTC guidance ought to help us. So why does this matter? Leaving canola oil out of the PTC disadvantages American producers. Canola oil, which largely originates in Canada, does not qualify for the PTC. Because of that, we can make biodiesel roughly EUR 35 per ton more cheaply than a U.S. player choosing soybean oil, which is sourced in the U.S. Biodiesel market development in Europe. On to the next slide. Returning to how we operated in the second quarter. Our margin management shows up clearly in the chart on the left. Spot spreads averaged nearly EUR 30 per ton of biodiesel lower in the fourth calendar quarter than a year earlier. Contract greenhouse gas premiums came in lower this year, yet we still improved product margins year-over-year. Biodiesel demand was weaker than in the same period last year, driven mainly by macroeconomic factors and fewer miles driven.
Olaf Tröber
executiveAlso, because quota transfers were halted, parties that have quota obligations had moderately restored blending by the close of 2024. Consequently, the drop in biodiesel imports coming from China provided only partial support to biodiesel spreads. When you look now, you'll see the spread between biodiesel and rapeseed oil stood significantly below the prior year. Still, it should be noted that prices for both biodiesel and rapeseed oil did climb over the reporting period, largely because of developments in the vegetable oil market. Moving to the next slide, Alina, bioethanol. Thanks. Within the bioethanol biomethane segment, sales fell to EUR 147 million, as the far left bar shows for Q2 2024 to 2025. That happened even though production volumes went up. The sales trend reflected lower selling prices and, in particular, lower greenhouse gas premiums. And earnings dropping to -EUR 15.3 million came mainly from a lower gross margin, partly offset by reduced personal expenses and favorable fair value changes on commodity forward contracts plus FX effects. Now, well, it's also worth noting that dollar cash holdings were raised ahead of the upcoming payments at South Bend Ethanol to safeguard the ITC, the Investment Tax Credit for the investment.
Olaf Tröber
executiveThe overall strategy hasn't changed, though: we optimize while keeping exposure as low as possible so we don't ramp up sensitivity needlessly. On bioethanol market development: higher blending mandates and Poland's introduction of E10 created strong ethanol demand. Beyond that, ethanol stayed a cheap blending component. So we expect parties with quota obligations in Germany to cut blending only marginally by the end of 2024. They therefore keep accumulating a greenhouse gas quota surplus that, because of regulatory changes, won't be usable until 2027. The relatively lower bioethanol spreads this quarter versus last year can partly be tied to imports from the U.S. Now to the U.S. There, a good harvest and low corn prices pushed bioethanol prices down during the summer months, as the chart on the right shows. Meanwhile, manufacturers ran production flat out, which squeezed margins relative to last year, as shown on the left. Seasonal demand patterns also came into play. Summer brought more driving and thus higher bioethanol demand, yet margins typically fall in winter, when demand declines during the colder months.
Olaf Tröber
executiveNow I’ll turn it back to Claus, who can give you more insight into the quota and what’s happening there.
Claus Sauter
executiveThank you, Olaf. The amendment to the 38th Ordinance stabilized greenhouse gas quota prices. In our second quarter, on November 13th, the German Federal Cabinet approved the draft amendment to the 38th regulation on implementation of the Federal Immission Protection Act, which was put forward by the Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation, Nuclear Safety and Consumer Protection, BMUV. This is — this was an emergency measure. It's firefighting. In the preamble to the greenhouse gas emergency amendment, the BMUV writes that the measure is designed to raise demand and prices for greenhouse gas quotas going forward. Under the amendment to the 38th <<foreign_lang>>, obligated parties lose the option to use their surplus CO2 savings — where a lot is fraudulent — for offsetting purposes in 2025 and 2026. Since the draft was published, demand for greenhouse gas quotas for 2024 has almost come to a standstill. That makes sense, because there will now be a delay until 2027 before the 2024 surplus quotas can be used again. Even the 2025 surplus, if there is a surplus, has to be pushed into 2027. So why would anyone buy them? As a result, prices for 2024 have fallen sharply in the short term.
Claus Sauter
executiveAt the same time, 2025 quota prices have begun rising, which you can see on the slide before you. Regrettably, the rebound is coming more slowly than we anticipated. There are two principal causes we see. First, some sellers currently in the market are motivated purely by liquidity needs, a situation that benefits big oil, though transaction volumes ought to be fairly low. On top of that, greenhouse gas balances for 2024 stay open through the end of March. So attention has not yet turned much to anything past that point. Once the 2024 quota year wraps up, focus is likely to move to 2025. In the meantime, the emphasis is on maximizing blending of low carbon intensity fuels, since any unblended ton of fuel would represent a lost opportunity. Meeting the 2025 targets will be a challenge for the obligated parties. But the recovery is slower than expected. New guidance was hit by market and technical issues at the Nevada plant. So the spot greenhouse gas quota price recovery coming in slower than first expected, the greenhouse gas quota prices contracted below plan to minimize risk, and the technical issues at Nevada prompted us on January 15th to lower our EBITDA guidance for the current financial year. We now expect an EBITDA result in the mid double-digit million range, compared with EUR 120 million to EUR 160 million previously.
Claus Sauter
executiveOur forecast for net financial debt at the close of the financial year is still the same — a maximum of EUR 190 million. Now I'll walk you through a few more specifics on Nevada. Regrettably, during the startup phase, quality problems with equipment at the ethanol production facility came to light. That equipment sits in the old DuPont plant, which we acquired a number of years back. Minor items, yes, but fixing them will take a while and push back our ramp-up. Take rust in valves that were installed originally in the existing facility — those now have to be swapped out one at a time. That comes to roughly about 200 valves. In the winter season, with the bitter cold, it's tough, yet we are making headway. As I mentioned at the start of this call, the EBITDA effect is a shift in timing rather than a structural problem. The slower ramp-up in Nevada pushes the anticipated positive EBITDA contribution out further, and the repairs bring a single-digit million EUR amount in costs. Even so, in spite of the revised timeline, our long-term outlook is still intact. We stay fully committed to executing Nevada successfully. We now expect to give a revised completion schedule alongside our Q3 results in May.
Claus Sauter
executiveKeeping a bioethanol facility profitable really hinges on running it at full utilization. To lessen the effect, we're operating at maximum capacity and making sure every required upgrade hits the performance standards we've set. Our CTO, Professor Dr. Lüdtke — a colleague of mine — is there on site, actively overseeing the process, and we're keeping utilization low, under 25%. So at this point let me turn things back to Olaf, who'll go over the net debt guidance. Olaf?
Olaf Tröber
executiveThanks, Claus. So, as Claus pointed out, even though EBITDA came in lower, our net debt expectations haven't changed. We do have a degree of flexibility when it comes to managing CapEx, especially regarding South Bend. The investment pace is in the process of being adjusted. Managing financial assets is among the additional liquidity measures. On top of that, we're optimizing working capital, so that by year-end the strategic inventory build-up tied to the new quota regulations — which wasn't initially planned — is expected to be offset. Next slide, please. Thank you. Now, moving from our guidance to what lies ahead, our focus is on growing free cash flow. Following a stretch of heavy investment and against the backdrop of a demanding market environment, we're now concentrating on optimizing existing assets via plant modernization and cost-out investments, and all of our strategic growth projects are under review. Construction of the ethenolysis plant is proceeding at full speed, and we recently issued a press release about reaching a construction milestone — specifically, installation of the distillation column. In the meantime, the investment at South Bend Ethanol aimed at transforming that plant into a state-of-the-art facility combining ethanol production with RNG will be phased. Each construction phase will be taken one at a time.
Olaf Tröber
executiveIn addition, the money we're putting into the CNG and LNG fueling station network is going to be wrapped up during this fiscal year, and because of that, we expect to secure the rent within the biomethane value chain. It's also worth pointing out that we're reviewing any opportunistic growth initiatives. Claus will now bring us up to speed on market expectations, which we also see as supportive of cash flow moving ahead. Claus?
Claus Sauter
executiveYeah, yeah, yeah. I had myself on mute there. My apologies. Thank you. All right. So yes, our outlook is optimistic. What you're seeing is the greenhouse gas quota accelerating, which was ultimately what that measurement from the German regulator targeted. So the recovery in the greenhouse gas quota is accelerating, and for the German market as well as the European market it is imminent. We're optimistic about calendar year 2025 and 2026. As we get close to the end of the 2024 quota year in March, focus in the quota market will probably move to 2025. So with the greenhouse gas quota mandate rising to 10.6% in 2025, demand is expected to increase significantly. At the same time, supply should get tighter because of several key developments. First, UER projects — most of them from China, most of them fraudulent. So UER projects are being phased out, and the possibility to carry quotas over into 2025 and 2026 has been removed. So the 1.2% UER options are gone, and that volume now has to be met by physical molecules. More demand. On top of that, anti-dumping duties on Chinese biodiesel are putting added pressure on supply. Also, China itself has scrapped the 13% export tax rebate on used cooking oil, which effectively amounted to a subsidy of roughly $120-$150 per ton.
Claus Sauter
executiveWhen you export used cooking oil from China, there's a subsidy of $130-$150 per ton. The purpose is to support biofuels production within the country. Beyond that, Indonesia is putting stricter controls in place on palm oil derivatives such as POME, HAPOR, and used cooking oil, which tightens exports even more. Taken together, all these things ought to make the market for CO2 savings tighter, and that should have a substantial effect on the market as we move ahead. So Indonesia acts on an indication of fraud, and that supports German greenhouse gas markets. On slide 16, you can see the announcement. So what exactly took place? Indonesia's exports of POME and HAPOR — which is finally palm oil and which serves as feedstock for producing advanced biofuels under European regulation — have climbed sharply, overtaking crude palm oil exports. This article says that POME and HAPOR exports hit 3.4 million tons, whereas crude palm oil exports came to just 2.7 million tons. So across the past five years, POME and HAPOR exports rose by almost 21% each year, while crude palm oil exports fell by nearly 20% annually. I believe anyone who examines these figures will quickly grasp what is going to happen. So the Indonesian trade minister noted that these exports have gone well beyond reasonable limits, since normally it's only around 300,000 tons, not 3.5 million.
Claus Sauter
executiveYou know, 300,000 tons of those residues ought to be shipped abroad. What that tells us is that crude palm oil is getting blended with POME or HAPOR, which drives up the export figures. Since the tax only applies to crude palm oil shipments, Indonesia is bleeding a lot of revenue, given that POME escapes the export levy — so the government responded by rolling out a new rule in January 2025 that puts tighter restrictions on overseas sales of palm oil derivatives such as POME, HAPOR, and used cooking oil. That's where I'll leave it — back to the operator, and let's get the Q&A going.
Operator
operatorThanks for the insights up to this point. Now we'll shift to the Q&A portion. A few questions have already come in, though as a reminder, kindly submit yours through the chat function and be sure to include your name along with the company name. I'll go through them individually. We'll aim to get through as many as we can given the time available, beginning with sell-side analysts, then buy-side analysts and investors, so let's get started. The initial questions came in from Pablo at Kepler Cheuvreux. He has 4 questions, so perhaps we'll begin with the first one. Could you perhaps help spell out what annual negative EBITDA is expected in connection with the operational problem at the U.S. bio plants caused by the equipment failure?
Claus Sauter
executiveI think, huh?
Olaf Tröber
executiveSo, should I go ahead?
Claus Sauter
executiveOkay, yeah, go ahead. My impression is we handled these one at a time rather than covering all of them. So go ahead and answer. All right. Yes, Olaf, go ahead.
Olaf Tröber
executiveIn Q1, the impact came to about -EUR 5 million, and during the second quarter it was approximately -EUR 9 million. If you annualize that, you'd land at more or less -EUR 30 million. That said, this is only a calculation. It depends heavily on the ramp-up and on how that ramp-up unfolds. As we laid out earlier, we'll share more details at the start of May, when we release our nine-month figures. Please bear with us.
Claus Sauter
executiveWhat I’d like to add is this: the real question is whether this is tied only to the ramp-up delay and the equipment failure. What Olaf referred to is the ethanol result overall. So the EUR 9 million for Q2 isn’t caused solely by our slower ramp-up. It’s also that ethanol margins in the U.S. are under pressure at the moment, and margins are traditionally lower over the wintertime, you know, so that will recover, and we expect recovery from March onwards. So it isn’t just the failure; it’s also weak ethanol margins in the U.S. right now. Okay. Next question, please.
Operator
operatorYes. On the U.S. plant, perhaps we could bring in Mr. Mühlenbruch from MWB Research. Could the fallout from that technical problem in the U.S. create further significant difficulties, financial ones included? You already touched on that with the EBITDA. When do you expect that facility to be fully operational, and at what point will it reach full capacity?
Olaf Tröber
executiveThe plan as it stands is that once winter ends, we’ll ramp up fast. We expect the plant can be at, let’s say, 80%/90% capacity when the new financial year begins. We won’t be able to manage that right now until that business year is over. June would be a bit too early, but we expect that during summertime we can reach full capacity for ethanol and gas production.
Operator
operatorJust a quick follow-up: what utilization rate gets us to break-even in Nevada?
Claus Sauter
executiveIt really hinges on ethanol and what prices are doing, but typically a plant like that needs to operate at somewhere between 90% and 100% utilization, and at that point you're profitable.
Operator
operatorGreat, I appreciate that context. Turning away from the U.S., could you give us your perspective on how RED III is being implemented in Germany — both on timing and on what it means for the business?
Claus Sauter
executiveThe expectation is that implementation of RED III will wrap up by the end of May 2025. That is the timeline the European Union has set out. Right, a new government is coming in now. It's going to take some time. Implementation of RED III ought to happen within the first half of 2025. Our main hope isn't that volumes go up further. The rules in place at present are genuinely ambitious. What we're after is clarity on how the government intends to handle fraudulent CO2 savings originating from UER, and those are substantial. Several million tons of CO2 savings are at issue, and in the end they were never delivered. The question becomes how we, together with the government, can add these improper CO2 savings through 2030 on top of the curve that already exists. That's the challenge we face. Lastly, there's the matter of which steps will be taken so fraud doesn't happen again. Stricter rules so that not just anyone can deliver into the European market, plus more checks on the feedstock side. And last, which matters most, the capacity of European and German regulators to verify production and where feedstock supply originates. Higher targets are not really our focus.
Claus Sauter
executiveOur main focus right now is making the targets we already have safer.
Operator
operatorAppreciate the insight. Pablo has another question. When compared with the H1 performance, do you see it as feasible to keep up a similar performance in the biodiesel segment?
Claus Sauter
executiveIt's difficult to predict at this point. We had anticipated a quicker rise in greenhouse gas prices by now, and here we are at the start of February. That hasn't materialized. We also anticipate more profitable biodiesel margins and biodiesel results. But whether it will land in the same range as Q2, it's too soon to tell. The market moves very quickly. We witnessed that particularly with ethanol last week, when ethanol prices were bouncing up and down. So the market is quite jittery right now, and margins can rise very quickly and can fall just as fast at the same time. So at this moment, I think the obligated parties are still mainly focused on 2024. So as I mentioned, I'm surprised that quota prices remain so low, because meeting the obligation for 2025 is a huge challenge. We're talking about an additional 10 million tons of CO2 savings. And at present, I don't know how they intend to get these molecules into the fossil fuels, because everywhere — with ethanol and also with biodiesel — we have blending wars.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our final question comes from Pablo at Kepler Cheuvreux. Have you noticed any shift in the way demand for RNG has been behaving over the past month in the countries where you operate?
Claus Sauter
executiveNo. Demand for RNG is quite steady. And for a year or a year and a half now, the focus is no longer just on Germany. For the past 18 months, renewable natural gas can be moved across all of Europe. And our export volumes have gone up considerably. So demand for RNG in Europe keeps growing. So we aren't seeing anything. And I believe the key thing at this point — and this is our outlook — is how greenhouse gas quota prices will rise. And if they do rise and the situation becomes more profitable, then we still have options to grow our volumes and, using the same quantity of molecules we sell, to achieve greater greenhouse gas savings. But at this point everything hinges on what happens with the quota price. And we are highly flexible in that regard. As for our molecules, our books are full for the calendar year. So the volumes are locked in. And there we have some flexibility to generate more or fewer greenhouse gas savings. From a technical standpoint, we are extremely flexible there, but there has to be a business case. In the end, time is on our side. We are not under pressure. The volumes are sold.
Claus Sauter
executiveMargins, particularly in Europe, are sensible. Yes, in the U.S. we've got those technical problems there, but the move from the Blenders Tax Credit over to the Production Tax Credit is entirely logical as well. The Biden administration failed to release the regulatory details on schedule. That's why ethanol margins are currently weak. Biodiesel flow has been disrupted too. Things will shift very shortly, though. The market will gain more clarity. So I'm confident margins will bounce back everywhere and turn more profitable. And as I mentioned, we're not under pressure. We're in a position to watch the market and hold out until margins recover. We can generate greater greenhouse gas savings, or, if the pricing isn't adequate, we simply won't proceed. There needs to be some sort of premium, let's say, for high greenhouse gas creation, and I don't see that at present. We'll see how things unfold. 2025 is going to be a very interesting year.
Operator
operatorOur next question is from Mr. Hesse at Jefferies. Should we expect the improved rapeseed oil prices to keep providing a benefit over the rest of the quarters? It looks like the biodiesel spread is narrowing quite a bit once again in Q3 and Q4.
Claus Sauter
executiveRapeseed oil prices had already risen substantially by that point. One thing that stands out is this: in our presentation, we noted that canola oil from Canada is at a disadvantage next to U.S. soybean oil. Canadian farmers aren't cultivating soybean — what they grow is canola, which is essentially rapeseed. The entire canola oil output went into biodiesel that was shipped to the U.S., where the blenders' tax credit applied. That's finished now. Going forward, a U.S. producer eligible for a production tax credit will find soybean oil the more attractive option. As a result, canola oil already trades at a discount to soybean oil. Increasingly, canola — both as rapeseed and as canola oil — is arriving in Europe. I concur that growing demand ought to push rapeseed oil prices higher. Yet given what's now unfolding in North America, canola is capping how far rapeseed oil prices can climb. In short, I don't anticipate higher rapeseed oil prices before the new harvest. Canadian canola is the constraint.
Operator
operatorThanks. We have another question from Mr. Hesse. Regarding the guidance reduction, how much came from the U.S. versus the revised expectation for GHG certificate prices? And why has net debt stayed the same? Is that because of lower CapEx?
Claus Sauter
executiveOkay, it's a mix of both. But I can't provide you with an actual number for how much of the effect came from the U.S. and how much came from, say, greenhouse gas or from the postponement of greenhouse gas price increases. Still, we ran a sensitivity analysis, and in the end we reached the conclusion that the market contains a great deal of uncertainty. So we need to revise our guidance, since there isn't much time remaining before June 13th. On the net debt question, as I've said previously, we aren't under pressure. Our European business, our German biofuel business, remains profitable. We are earning money. And with that money, we are funding our growth projects. So if the cash flow doesn't materialize, we can adjust our investment projects. That means that's what we're doing. We are adjusting investment projects. We're placing a stronger emphasis on cash flow management. Olaf brought it up. And I believe that's also how we intend it. This is our cap, this EUR 190 million, and we're keeping an eye on it. It could shift again should the market recover more quickly. But our clear priority is cash management.
Claus Sauter
executiveAs a result, we can tweak and move investment projects somewhat further out into the future.
Operator
operatorSwitching back to the U.S., when do you expect the U.S. to start contributing positively again?
Claus Sauter
executiveThe positive contribution, then, won't land in this business year. What we're concentrating on now is having that positive contribution arrive in the following business year — 2025, 2026. That's where the focus sits. And we're quite confident that we can get there.
Operator
operatorNext, we have a balance sheet question from Mr. Hesse. How much is still available on the credit lines? Do you foresee any risk of extra equipment needs over the next two years? And what does the CapEx plan look like, or how much CapEx remains for fiscal years 2025 and 2026?
Claus Sauter
executiveCould you say that again, please? That was a lot to take in. I think we ought to break it down somehow.
Operator
operatorYes, we break it down into segments, and we begin with the first one. What credit lines are still available?
Claus Sauter
executiveThat’s a detail we aren’t making public.
Operator
operatorAll right. But in the coming 2 years, do you see any risk of needing more equipment?
Claus Sauter
executiveI'd say it's the equipment—we need to swap out some of the equipment at our operating plants, that kind of thing. No.
Operator
operatorRight. And then to get the U.S. completely up to capacity?
Claus Sauter
executiveNo. The Nevada investment is finished. The focus now is ramping it up. There will be a few small extra costs. I brought this up during the presentation, but the bulk of the investment is behind us. Now we need to ramp it up. South Bend is an existing ethanol plant that produces ethanol and feed. Our focus there is getting it back up to nameplate capacity. And Welland, the biodiesel plant, was operating. Everywhere, particularly at South Bend and Welland, we have ideas and opportunities to implement the technologies we use at our plants in Germany. But nothing has to be done. So that's what I mean. We can adjust and delay investment ideas. The big investments are done. And our German sites are operating. They are always near 100% full capacity. And it was important that we installed our filling stations, because with the filling stations, we can now bring more molecules into the market to create more greenhouse gas savings if we can make money. So this investment is done as well. So what remains is ethanolysis. So ethenolysis is an investment for the future, where the rapeseed methyl ester that we still sell right now as biodiesel will be the feedstock.
Claus Sauter
executiveAs a result, we anticipate entering new markets and achieving better margins. On the investment front, though, we're quite at ease, and given our cash flow position, we have the flexibility to adjust it.
Operator
operatorPerfect, thanks. Coming back to the GHG certificate prices — what price are you assuming in today's guidance?
Claus Sauter
executiveOlaf, that's something we won't be disclosing either, I think.
Olaf Tröber
executiveNo. But it's pretty much in line with where the market is right now, roughly speaking. Just so you have a sense of it.
Claus Sauter
executiveAlright.
Operator
operatorAlright. And on how pricing has been moving — it's clear why you think the GHG price ought to come back, but why is there no improvement showing up yet? And when do you expect things to get better?
Claus Sauter
executiveLike I mentioned, the oil companies and obligated parties are, I believe, focused on the 2024 obligation at this moment. So they're in the process of finalizing their books, and they have until the end of March to do so. Once that's completed, we expect prices to begin rising during March. And yeah, we'll see where it goes. Personally, I expect it to exceed EUR 200 per metric ton of CO2 savings. But we'll see. That's the reason, though. The obligation and the challenge for 2025 are extraordinary. And our expectation is that — or rather, let's say, we believe their focus right now is mainly on wrapping up the 2024 balance sheet. After that, they'll turn their attention to 2025.
Operator
operatorGreat. We got a few questions from Hauck & Aufhäuser, from analyst Wunderlich. So here too I'll break the questions down a bit. Will biodiesel deliver another strong EBITDA contribution in Q3? And what's the situation with rapeseed oil prices?
Claus Sauter
executiveWell, same answer there. Yeah, biodiesel consistently produces really strong results. That's already in the past now. Like I mentioned, I don't see rapeseed oil prices going up any further. My view is they'll hold around that level, since there's a cap on it from the fact that Canadian canola oil trades at a discount. A steady business. We keep our margins. If the greenhouse gas quota prices bounce back as things recover, then margins on ethanol and biodiesel will need to bounce back too. If it stays where it was in Q2, I'm not sure.
Operator
operatorAll right. That might be the next thing to ask too. Should we expect the bioethanol and RNG segment's EBITDA to keep getting better step by step in the quarters ahead?
Claus Sauter
executiveYes. We do expect a substantial improvement there. Biodiesel and ethanol differ, you know. With biodiesel, we hold the molecule and sell it; the greenhouse gas savings embedded in it get blended. Ethanol gas works differently. We have ethanol, which is blended too, but gas is delivered to filling stations, so the CO2 savings and greenhouse gas quotas are generated at those stations. If we aren't receiving adequate money, we can lower the greenhouse gas quota rate and nudge the market somewhat, so should greenhouse gas quota prices fail to rise, our renewable natural gas will be directed to other markets. We have no obligation to bring it into the transport sector and generate greenhouse gas savings.
Operator
operatorTim has another question, this time for the U.S. What was the size of the negative EBITDA impact from South Bend and Nevada in Q2?
Claus Sauter
executiveWe already brought this up. Olaf mentioned it. During Q1, the U.S. ethanol segment dragged results down by -EUR 5 million, and for the second quarter, that figure came to -EUR 9 million.
Operator
operatorWhat positive EBITDA swing, in EUR million, would we see when Nevada goes from 25% capacity utilization up to 90%?
Claus Sauter
executiveSo, regarding what we anticipate from ethanol overall—and that covers not just Nevada but South Bend as well, the two of them together—our expectation, once we're at full utilization, is an EBITDA contribution of EUR 30 million to EUR 35 million.
Operator
operatorThanks, that's great. What kind of impact are the U.S. tariffs going to have on your operations in Canada?
Claus Sauter
executiveAll right. At this moment, no tariffs are in place. In any case, Canadian biodiesel is not going to keep flowing into the U.S., and that's because of the switch from the Blenders Tax Credit to the Production Tax Credit. That simply doesn't make sense. In the past, Canada's biodiesel mandate was met using U.S. biodiesel that carried subsidies. That situation is finished, and it has nothing to do with tariffs. Should a tariff arrive — and we already have a plan in place — it won't affect us, since Canadian canola and Canadian biodiesel will now remain in Canada regardless. Canadian obligated parties are now required to source their biodiesel from producers in Canada. That part is clear. On the other side, the tariffs going into the U.S. don't affect us. We are a U.S. producer. Perhaps Europe will then put a 25% tariff on ethanol imports from the U.S. — I don't know. There is a local market, and there is an export market. In any event, once we have more clarity on tariffs and how they will look, within one quarter we can adjust our business.
Operator
operatorIf the CDU wins the election in Germany, what would that mean for biofuel regulation, looking at it from the U.S. and Canada?
Claus Sauter
executiveI’m not sure. Let’s take a look. All I can really say is that, during that UER fraud, there was considerable backing from the CDU. In the end, they were pushing—yes—the <<foreign_lang>> so that everything was brought into the spotlight, so, as I said, we already have a regulation in place and the targets in it are fine. They are ambitious as they stand, and the next stage is going to be putting RED III into practice, and on that point, as I mentioned before, that was where our attention was focused. We need additional controls. We need greater assurance that something like what happened—the distortion of ticket prices, and the fact that it is odd—does not occur. There is a European regulation that aims to prohibit palm oil through 2030, and yet under the regulation now in force, more palm oil has never entered the European market as derivatives than at any earlier point, which demonstrates how feeble that regulation is when there is no control over it. Still, in the end, it is good that this occurred at this point. For many years we had been making that argument. And I believe the CDU has, shall we say, ears that are more open to hearing our arguments and the measures that must be adopted in any case. If not, every investment connected with renewables—and that means not only biofuels—is at risk.
Claus Sauter
executiveChemistry will follow the same pattern. Steel and aluminum will too. When there’s no control over where the product originates, fraud occurs. Okay. Please continue.
Operator
operatorAlright, I'll go ahead. And actually, there's one final question coming in from the sell-side analysts. But just as a reminder, if analysts have follow-up questions, please don't hesitate to post them. So we have a follow-up from Mr. Wunderlich, since he says he actually missed this information. What will the total negative EBITDA contribution from the U.S. be in fiscal year 2024/2025, including the need to replace the valves?
Claus Sauter
executiveOlaf already brought that up. We stated that in Q1 we had -EUR 5 million. Now in Q2, we're at -EUR 9 million. So for the first half combined, that comes to roughly EUR 15 million. And a further -EUR 15 million from this contribution in the second half is the maximum we're expecting.
Operator
operatorAll right. That's great.
Claus Sauter
executiveAll right. So the final figure should land below EUR 30 million, if all goes well — but it won't exceed EUR 30 million.
Operator
operatorAll right, let me just verify when the third question came in. There are indeed additional questions. That said, time is basically up for us. So any remaining questions will be gathered, passed along to Verbio to finish, and we'll make certain they get answered afterward. We're slightly past our limit — already over the allotted time. I simply want to thank you for that thoughtful question, and a big thank-you as well to Mr. Sauter and Mr. Tröber. To everyone on the call, we value the time and interest you've given to Verbio. It would mean a lot if you'd share your feedback both with Verbio and with our research team. With that in mind, a brief email is already waiting in your inbox. I have just posted a link to a short survey. At this point, from my end, have a wonderful day. We hope to see you again next time. To do that, please take a look at our Research Hub at research-hub.de. Goodbye and take care.
Claus Sauter
executiveYes, though I’d like to offer one last remark. Harry, many thanks for organizing every one of the questions. In my view, that was the finest call we’ve had. You made it excellent. Thank you so much. We managed — and it’s clear now too that a few questions are being repeated — and the remainder ought to go to Alina. The single point I’d like to add in closing is that I hope we succeeded in conveying the messages. The message regarding supply and the one regarding demand are complete. There is this regulation that was introduced in November last year. China is taking action. Indonesia is taking action, so really nothing more is needed at this point to return to a sensible market. All we require is a little time now for all these measures to take effect, and with that said, many thanks to everyone who joined the call. Thank you again, Harry, on your behalf. Should you require further information, please reach out to Alina, and she will gladly assist you. Thank you so much. Have a wonderful day. Looking forward to hearing you again on our Q3 call. Bye-bye.
Operator
operatorThat’s our hope. Take care, and goodbye.
Olaf Tröber
executiveAppreciate it.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Verbio SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Verbio SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Verbio SE or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.