Wheaton Precious Metals Corp. (WPM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
March 12, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorMorning, everyone, and thanks for holding. You're listening to the conference call on Wheaton Precious Metals' results for the fourth quarter and the full year. Every line has been muted so background noise doesn't come through. Following the speaker's comments, we'll open things up for questions and answers. To ask something at that point, just hit star and then one on your phone's keypad. Should you wish to pull your question, that's the pound key. Many thanks. A quick note that this call is being recorded today, March 12, 2020, at 11:00 A.M. Eastern Time. I'll hand things over now to Mr. Patrick Drouin, our Senior Vice President of Investor Relations. Over to you.
Patrick Drouin
executiveThanks, operator. Good morning, everyone, and I appreciate your joining the call today. With me this morning are Randy Smallwood, President and Chief Executive Officer of Wheaton Precious Metals; Gary Brown, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer; and Haytham Hodaly, Senior Vice President, Corporate Development. I want to draw your attention to the fact that certain commentary on this call may include forward-looking statements. There is no guarantee that forward-looking statements will turn out to be accurate, since actual results and future events could differ materially from those anticipated in such statements. Beyond our cautionary note on financial results relating to forward-looking statements, please see the section titled Description of the Business Risk Factors in Wheaton's annual information form, as well as the risks identified under Risks and Uncertainty in Management's Discussion and Analysis for the year ended December 31st, 2020, both of which are available on SEDAR, and in Wheaton's Form 40-F and Wheaton's Form 6-K, both available on EDGAR. Those documents, together with last night's press release, lay out the material assumptions and risk factors that could cause actual results to differ, including, among others, fluctuations in the price of commodities and impacts on Wheaton or on the mining operations from which Wheaton purchases precious metals as a result of an epidemic.
Patrick Drouin
executiveThere are hazards tied to the mining activities that supply Wheaton with precious metals, the ongoing capacity of Wheaton's counterparties to meet their commitments under precious metal purchase agreements, and the effect of any audits CRA is currently conducting. Please note that every figure mentioned on this call is stated in US dollars, except where indicated otherwise. At this point I'll hand the call over to Randy Smallwood, our President and Chief Executive Officer.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThank you, Patrick. Good morning, everyone. We appreciate your time today as we review Wheaton's results for the fourth quarter and the full year of 2020. I truly hope all of you have stayed healthy and safe since our previous quarterly call. With the one-year anniversary of the COVID-19 pandemic approaching, Wheaton's highest priority continues to be the well-being of our employees, our mining partners, and the communities where we operate. Even with the difficulties this pandemic has created, 2020 proved to be a highly productive year. We succeeded in returning value to shareholders across numerous fronts. It is my pleasure to report that during 2020, Wheaton's high-quality asset portfolio produced revenue exceeding $1 billion and operating cash flow surpassing $765 million, with both figures setting records for the company. Thanks to Wheaton's innovative dividend policy, that robust cash flow has translated into a 30% increase in our minimum quarterly dividend compared with last year. We were also glad to advance our growth strategy, disclosing two accretive transactions in 2020 involving the Marmato mine in Colombia and the Cozamin mine in Mexico. Our confidence in delivering continued long-term organic growth from our portfolio has additionally prompted us to introduce 10-year production guidance for the first time, alongside our customary one and five-year forecasts.
Randy Smallwood
executiveI'll share more about how our growth looks a bit later in this call, but first let me hand things over to Gary Brown, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, who will go into more detail on our results. Gary?
Gary Brown
executiveThanks, Randy, and good morning everyone. In Q4 2020, our precious metals operations generated 178,800 gold equivalent ounces, consisting of 93,100 ounces of gold, 6.5 million ounces of silver, and 5,700 ounces of palladium. Compared with the fourth quarter a year earlier, that was a 4% decline on a gold-equivalent basis, as reduced output at Salobo and 777 — where operations were temporarily suspended at both sites — was partly offset by higher-grade material mined at Antamina. Sales volumes on a gold-equivalent basis fell 3%, tracking the lower production. As of December 31st, 2020, produced but not delivered ounces, or PBND, stood at roughly 133,000 gold equivalent payable ounces, equal to about 2.2 months of payable production. That PBND figure aligns with the average balance of approximately 139,000 gold equivalent ounces across the previous fourth quarters. Fourth-quarter 2020 revenue came in at $286 million, up 28% versus Q4 2019, mainly driven by a 33% rise in the average realized gold equivalent price, partly offset by the 3% drop in sales volumes. Within that revenue, gold accounted for 57%, silver for 39%, and palladium for 4%.
Gary Brown
executiveFor the fourth quarter of 2020, gross margin rose 69%, reaching $162 million, which again underscores how our business model benefits from rising precious metal prices. Cash-based G&A expenses came to $8 million in Q4 2020, down $2 million from Q4 2019, mainly because of lower accrued costs tied to performance share units, or PSUs, partly offset by greater charitable donations, as the company gave close to $1 million toward the previously announced $5 million Community Support and Response Fund connected to the COVID-19 Pandemic. Interest costs in the fourth quarter of 2020 were $1 million, producing an effective interest rate of 1.2% on outstanding debt, versus $8 million in interest costs at an effective rate of 3.62% in Q4 2019, while the average outstanding debt balance fell 39% in the most recently completed quarter and stood 63% below its fourth-quarter 2019 level. Net earnings in the fourth quarter of 2020 were $157 million, over twice what was generated in Q4 2019. Basic adjusted earnings per share climbed 101% to $0.33, up from $0.17 per share a year earlier.
Gary Brown
executiveFor the fourth quarter of 2020, operating cash flow came in at $208 million, which works out to $0.46 per share, versus $132 million, or $0.29 per share, a year earlier — that's a 57% rise on a per-share basis. In line with the company's dividend policy, the board has declared a dividend of $0.13 per share, which is 8% higher than the previous quarter, payable to shareholders of record on March 26, 2021. Through the dividend reinvestment plan, the board has chosen to give shareholders the option to have their dividends reinvested in newly issued common shares of the company at a 1% discount to market. Looking at 2021, the company is setting the dividend floor at $0.13 per share, which is a 30% increase over the floor established for 2020, underscoring the continued strength of the company's operating cash flows and the advantages of its unique dividend policy, under which dividend distributions are targeted at 30% of operating cash flow. In the fourth quarter of 2020, the company repaid $293 million on the revolving facility and paid dividends of $47 million, and these cash outflows were partly offset by proceeds of $113 million from the sale of First Majestic shares.
Gary Brown
executiveAll told, net cash outflows came to $17 million during Q4 2020, which left cash and cash equivalents standing at $193 million as of December 31st. Taken together with the $195 million still outstanding under the revolving facility, that produced a net debt position of just $2 million at December 31st. Across the year that ended December 31st, 2020, output measured on a gold equivalent basis landed within the company's revised guidance and came in within 2% of the original guidance, even with the assorted shutdowns experienced in the second quarter because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Even in the face of the pandemic, sales volumes ended up virtually unchanged compared with 2019, chiefly because of relative shifts in the ounces produced but not delivered. Revenue over the year reached a record $1.1 billion — the first occasion in the company's history that we have crossed the $1 billion mark. Breaking that revenue down, 60% came from gold sales, 36% from silver, and 4% from palladium. Measured on a gold equivalent basis, average realized commodity prices climbed 28% in 2020, which drove a 69% increase in gross margin. Cash based G&A expenses for 2020 totaled $60 million, an increase of $11 million versus 2019, with that rise mainly tied to higher accrued costs associated with the PSUs as well as higher charitable donations.
Gary Brown
executiveLooking at 2021, the company projects that non-stock based G&A expenses — leaving out costs tied to the value of stock options and PSUs — will come in at $42 million-$45 million. Interest costs for 2020 were $12 million, down $33 million from 2019, which works out to an effective interest rate on outstanding debt of 2.03%. Basic adjusted earnings per share rose 106% to $1.12, up from $0.54 per share in the prior year. Cash flow from operations came to $765 million, up 53% as compared to 2019, mainly because of higher commodity prices. That translated into operating cash flow per share of $1.71 versus $1.12 in 2019. With 2020 having ended in a neutral net debt position, the capacity provided by the $2 billion revolving credit facility, together with the strong forecast operating cash flows, positions the company very well to satisfy its funding commitments and sustain its dividend policy, while at the same time having the flexibility to consummate additional accretive precious metal purchase agreements. That concludes the financial summary, and with that, I turn the call back over to Randy.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThanks, Gary. We're glad to reaffirm the production guidance for 2021 and the longer term that we put out in February. For 2021, Wheaton's forecast attributable output should land in a range of 370,000 to 400,000 ounces of gold, 22 million to 24 million ounces of silver, and 40,000 to 45,000 gold equivalent ounces of cobalt and palladium — which adds up to roughly 720,000 to 780,000 ounces in total gold equivalent production. Gold output in 2021 is expected to rise, largely on the back of growth at Salobo, San Dimas, and Constancia. Silver production should also climb, since we expect extra ounces out of Cozamin and Keno Hill. Cobalt production from the Voisey's Bay mine is a first for us, and we already took delivery of our initial shipments in February. Going forward, we see steady organic growth accumulating across the coming five years, with gold equivalent production averaging 810,000 ounces annually and rising to 830,000 ounces annually across a 10-year horizon. We expect average output over both the next five years and the next 10 years to rise, mainly because of continued growth at Salobo, Constancia, Penasquito, and Stillwater, plus incremental ounces from the Marmato, Cozamin, and Voisey's Bay streams. Hudbay's progress at the Rosemont project looks encouraging, but Rosemont output isn't part of Wheaton's five-year guidance — it does show up in the 10-year forecast.
Randy Smallwood
executiveFinally, even though Barrick keeps moving forward with an in-depth evaluation of Pascua Lama and Pan American keeps progressing with talks regarding Navidad, since there is no timing framework in place, Wheaton right now factors no output from either project into its long-range projections. Turning to corporate development, in spite of travel restrictions, our people were more active than at any point during 2020, announcing 2 fresh streaming deals and examining many additional opportunities. We adjusted rapidly to the changed circumstances and created different approaches to due diligence, which let us keep conducting thorough assessments of prospective new acquisitions. We were delighted to bring 2 top-quality assets into our portfolio — a silver and gold stream on the Marmato project in Colombia, plus a silver stream on the Cozamin mine in Mexico, which is returning to our asset base following the conclusion of our prior Cozamin stream in 2017. In our view, both projects show considerable upside potential and will give our shareholders additional chances for organic growth. Going forward, we will stay focused on securing accretive precious metal streams that fit well with our top-quality portfolio. The significance of creating shareholder value while limiting our impacts and backing our local communities has never been clearer than it was in 2020.
Randy Smallwood
executiveFor a streaming business like ours, the healthier our partners become, the healthier we become too. To back our mining partners and the communities around them, we set up a $5 million fund aimed at tackling and easing the effects of this pandemic — an amount that more than doubled what we had already budgeted for community investment. By the close of 2020, over $3 million from that fund had been put to work on initiatives alongside our mining partners and frontline organizations, among them food banks, shelters, and hospitals. In the precious metal streaming space, Wheaton has always aimed to lead on sustainability. This year we broadened our ESG risk management disclosure considerably by publishing our inaugural sustainability report. Several ESG rating providers honored us for our performance in this area, giving us sector-leading scores. Most recently, Sustainalytics ranked Wheaton as the number one precious metals company and, perhaps even more impressively, placed us in the global top 50 among more than 12,000 companies spanning all sectors. Looking ahead, this area of our work will only become more important. We are proud of the steps taken so far, yet we know sustainability is a journey, and our commitment to constant and continual improvement — and to leaving a positive impact — is as strong as ever.
Randy Smallwood
executiveTo sum up, even with the extraordinary difficulties we faced this year, Wheaton has come out of it in a stronger position than before, with a durable base and a highly promising outlook. We hit record levels for both revenue and cash flow, and for the ninth year in a row we came in above the midpoint of our production guidance. We also issued 10-year production guidance for the first time, which shows the confidence we have in the steady, long-term organic growth we expect from our portfolio. We listed on the London Stock Exchange so that we could widen our investment base to those seeking exposure to precious metals, and to give internationally based shareholders another entry point for investing in Wheaton. Through our value-creating business model, our commitment to operating responsibly, and our focus on high-quality assets, we keep offering investors what we regard as the best vehicle for investing into precious metals. Lastly, against the backdrop of global uncertainty, I see it as our privilege and our responsibility as good corporate citizens to keep giving support where it is needed most. In times like these, helping those who are most vulnerable matters more than anything. It is simply the right thing to do. With that, I would like to open the call for questions.
Randy Smallwood
executiveAre you there, operator?
Operator
operatorThanks. At this point, ladies and gentlemen, we're going to move into a question-and-answer session. Our first question is from Tyler Langton at JPMorgan. Go ahead, please.
Tyler Langton
analystMorning, and thanks for the question. I suppose I'll begin with Salobo — I know you said you expect output to be higher this year. Could you talk a bit about the profile you're anticipating for this year and the next couple of years, perhaps relative to the more normal levels we saw in 2019?
Randy Smallwood
executiveAbsolutely, Tyler. Thanks once more for taking on coverage of Wheaton Precious Metals. We're glad to have you with us and part of the team, or the family. Salobo — what we're seeing there over the coming years is really exciting. As I understand it, they were roughly 68% mechanically complete, mid-60% at year-end, on the phase III expansion. The expectation is that they'll flip the switches at some point in 2022. They're hoping to have the completion test satisfied on that third phase of expansion by the end of 2022. As I mentioned, that's a 50% increase in throughput. What the mine site does today is stockpile lower grade material — common across many of the larger open pit copper and gold mines globally. They stockpile the lower grade material and concentrate on running higher grade material through the mill. That's the current practice. No final decision has been made yet on their approach once phase III opens up. From an economic standpoint, a stockpiled approach makes sense, and in fact we've put some incentives in place to continue to hopefully push Vale down that path toward continuing the stockpiling approach. That decision hasn't been made yet, so giving an accurate forecast over the next few years on how phase III will impact production is a little bit tough for us.
Randy Smallwood
executiveWhat we've built into both our strategy and our production guidance is the assumption that no stockpiling will occur—that material will keep moving through. We view that as a fairly cautious stance. In our view, it adds a conservative element to our own output projection for 2022 and later years, since from an economic standpoint we genuinely believe it makes sense for them to keep up the stockpiling practice—putting lower grade material to one side while running higher grade material through the mill. Beyond all that, what's especially exciting is that Vale once more announced the phase IV expansion back in December. That was the first occasion they had spoken about it in public. We've clearly held extensive talks with them on the matter, but they have now disclosed it publicly, and it would mean a further increase—an equivalent capacity increase—taking the operation from 90,000 tons per day to 120,000 tons per day. The expectation is that this would be operational by 2027. There's a great deal happening at Salobo, a great deal of growth at Salobo. On the resource side, we have published our updated figures, and the growth there is visible. This deposit just keeps on delivering for us.
Tyler Langton
analystGood. No, that helps. Moving over to M&A, you said the pipeline is still robust. Could you speak a bit about what kinds of deals you're seeing when it comes to size, and whether it's mainly base metal producers wanting precious metal streams, or more on the precious metal side — any detail there would be great.
Randy Smallwood
executiveTyler, that question is best handled by Haytham. He’s in charge of our Corporate Development function. Haytham, you’re on the call.
Haytham Hodaly
executiveOf course. Appreciate it, Randy, and morning to you, Tyler. How's it going?
Tyler Langton
analystYeah, good morning.
Haytham Hodaly
executiveTo give everyone a quick picture, things have been quite active since the start of the new year. There are plenty of fresh opportunities to evaluate. Most of them are development stage opportunities, and they suit many of our early deposit structures, which we have completed a few times before — that is where we take precious metals as a byproduct from a base metal mine. Streaming, of course, delivers the most value in these kinds of opportunities. We are also seeing some opportunities centered on balance sheet repair, plus a few expansion stage opportunities, and in those cases streaming can actually help fund part of the expansion. The reality that streaming is being weighed across all of these areas really underscores how competitive the cost of capital is that streams offer. Some royalty packages have come across our desk in the past, but I can tell you that nothing has made sense from a Wheaton perspective, largely due to their size or because they carry a substantial amount of non-precious metal revenues. Our focus will remain on the larger development stage and expansion stage opportunities that we are seeing at present.
Tyler Langton
analystExcellent. Thank you very much. My apologies—please continue.
Randy Smallwood
executiveI'd simply add that we're observing considerable expansion in base metals. With copper prices and other base metals ticking upward, plenty of base metal firms are now considering reinvesting in exploration, so that's likely the most significant shift. Naturally, many of those assets include precious metal byproduct streams, which will offer a solid, competitive source of capital to support those companies' growth.
Tyler Langton
analystPerfect — I really appreciate it.
Haytham Hodaly
executiveThanks, Tyler.
Operator
operatorThe following question is from Ralph Profiti at Eight Capital. You have the floor.
Ralph Profiti
analystMorning, all. Appreciate you giving me the chance to ask a few things.
Randy Smallwood
executiveHey there, Ralph.
Ralph Profiti
analystRandy, I had one question, and I wanted to return to Salobo and what phase IV might hold. Should we view that as more of an underground operation, maybe even a move to a block cave? Or is it simply a systematic additional 12 million tons per annum being added on? I suppose the second question is, when you consider that incremental investment Wheaton would be inclined to pursue, should we just take the old agreement, which would come in at around, say, a $900 million contribution?
Randy Smallwood
executiveI honestly think there's potential for a block cave down the road. Let me tell you about the reserves we hold in the open pit at Salobo. Phase IV expansion would involve expanding open pit operations. It wouldn't have anything to do with a block cave site. There's no question that underground operations at Salobo have long-term potential. It's just that we still have, I believe, more than 20, more than 30 years of reserves ahead of us, even at the expanded throughput. I think it will remain an open pit for a very long time, and phase IV concerns open pit production. Sorry, what was the second part of the question?
Ralph Profiti
analystThat additional investment.
Gary Brown
executiveRalph, the fact is that Vale gets just a single chance to come to us requesting payment. Our expectation is that the request would arrive once phase III is complete. Assuming they meet the completion test in 2022, that payment would land somewhere around $570 million to $670 million. Of our contingent payments tied to Salobo, that one is the final piece. Should they move ahead with phase IV, Wheaton would not be making any further payment.
Randy Smallwood
executiveTo restate that, Vale holds a single-time right to receive an expansion payment. Whether they take it when phase III concludes or hold it back until phase IV ends is up to them. Naturally, that payment grows larger as scale rises, yet it shrinks as time passes. Our expectation is that they will use that one-time option once the phase wraps up, as soon as they meet the completion test for phase III.
Ralph Profiti
analystMuch clearer to me at this point. All right, many thanks.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThanks a lot, Ralph — appreciate it.
Operator
operatorJosh Wolfson from RBC Capital Markets has the next question. Go ahead, please.
Randy Smallwood
executiveHi there, Josh.
Josh Wolfson
analystThanks. Hey, good morning. Staying with the Salobo theme here, regarding this next opportunity around stockpiling, can you give us any kind of timeline for when an update might be expected? And just from a technical standpoint, is there anything that would stop the company from making that decision at a later date rather than before the expansion is complete?
Randy Smallwood
executiveFrom a critical timeline standpoint, the sole meaningful change at the site would involve some surface preparation, though the size of the mobile equipment fleet is what would need adjusting. Based on my experience, that only requires a single 800 Caterpillar or Komatsu. They will figure out how to secure one. Adjusting the mobile fleet's size doesn't consume much time. Naturally, a somewhat bigger mobile fleet is needed if they intend to stockpile part of the material rather than sending all of it to the mill. It simply means additional material gets moved each day. That represents the critical path approaching from the opposite direction. We now have the updated resource, which is public at this point, yet the updated reserve isn't available because no final decision has been made regarding which plan will proceed. Since the resource is already there, it truly comes down to their engineering teams, their technical teams, and the whole group reaching that decision. We are, naturally, hopeful it occurs at some point, and the sooner it does, the better, simply because it provides us with considerably more clarity going forward.
Randy Smallwood
executiveWe have certainly put incentives in place through the variance in the expansion payments we provide. Our hope is that it happens at some point during the first half of this year. We are confident it will occur at some point this year, though it ought to fall within the first half of this year.
Josh Wolfson
analystAll right, that's good to hear. And regarding Vale's other operations, specifically Voisey's Bay, could you give us an update on how that operation is expected to ramp up, or what it will look like, across this year, given that you'll be getting some of the open pit material while the underground is ramping up? As a follow-on to that, one of the opportunities historically cited has perhaps been cobalt marketing, given the jurisdiction in which the asset operates. If you have any views on that today, with production commencing, that would be of interest.
Randy Smallwood
executiveAll right, let's begin with the asset itself. You're right that the underground start was pushed back, and the main cause was production stoppages at the site last year tied to the pandemic. Oddly enough, that works somewhat in our favor, since material that would have been mined last year got deferred into this year. The underground start has been delayed. From our standpoint, it isn't really a ramp-up, because output levels hold fairly steady whether the material comes from the open pit or the underground. We're already seeing solid production flows out of the open pit. It all counts as of January 1st, no matter whether it originates from the open pit or the underground. Once the underground comes online, it will clearly offset, and the open pit sits there as a dampening device so we can be sure of steady, reliable production from the pit. Things look good on that front. On the marketing side, I can report that we ran a product marketing request for proposals, and interest in our product was very strong. In the end we chose a marketing agent, which is now working through.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThis product has strong name recognition. It has been made for many years, so demand for cobalt from Voisey's Bay is very high. We're quite pleased with what we've observed so far — we've now made our first sales, and we're quite pleased with how that's being handled. Recent cobalt pricing movement, along with some of the difficulties seen elsewhere around the world from other production, has really timed itself very well for us to begin receiving our cobalt production here. This is a new product for us, and it's a new marketing approach for us in terms of it being a bulk product rather than doré or precious metals. We're really viewing these first couple of years as a chance to learn more about this market and see whether there are ways we can further optimize it.
Josh Wolfson
analystPerfect. Thanks so much.
Randy Smallwood
executiveAppreciate it, Josh.
Operator
operatorCosmos Chiu from CIBC has the next question. Go ahead, please.
Cosmos Chiu
analystHello there. Randy, Gary, and the team, thank you — it's really good to see the dividend raised. My questions concern the two recent acquisitions. Perhaps starting with Marmato: I notice the initial payment comes to $34 million and the second one is $4 million, and neither has been paid as yet. I'm curious about the timing of those payments, and also when production from that asset would begin flowing to you. Does that happen once the first payment is made? I'll follow up with those other questions afterward.
Randy Smallwood
executiveAppreciate you keeping the question list manageable. No, the payments still haven’t gone out, since a few tenure matters down there needed clarification, and that’s being worked through now. It seems like it will occur very shortly, right around now. Yes, we’ll receive some output from the upper zone, which is producing at present. It goes back to — I can’t recall the exact date — but it goes back to last year. Once that payment is completed, we’ll pick up a modest amount of accumulated production inventory from that period. The real — sorry, please continue, Haytham.
Haytham Hodaly
executiveIts starting point is July 1st.
Randy Smallwood
executiveIt was July 1st. Right, so the starting point is July 1st, which means we'll see a decent little lift. But that isn't why we're involved in Marmato. Our involvement in Marmato comes down to that deeper lower zone, and you only need to take a solid look at the drilling results this company has delivered there. That geological potential has us genuinely enthusiastic, along with where we believe that project is capable of going. Considering the fresh management team arriving with Aris, who bring a lengthy track record of building from projects of this kind, we're quite enthusiastic about that project.
Patrick Drouin
executiveCosmos, I just want to make sure you're aware that no production has been booked yet. Although it accrues back to July 1st, we haven't booked any production in 2020 for Marmato, and we haven't for Cozamin either. Both of those will be trued up in Q1 once payments are made.
Cosmos Chiu
analystAll right. Yeah, that was actually the next thing I was going to ask about — the timing. Is it in Q1 that we'll see somewhat greater output at both Marmato and Cozamin, probably? Because with Cozamin, you've already made that payment in full, so it lands in Q1. And Marmato — possibly Q1 too?
Patrick Drouin
executiveProvided that payment goes through. We do expect it — and I can say we're fully ready on our end to send it. It's only a matter of finishing the last details, crossing the final T's and dotting the I's. If that gets done within the coming few weeks, then yes. Cozamin was accrued as of December 1st, so the period is shorter.
Cosmos Chiu
analystAbsolutely, of course. I don't believe I came across that in the MD&A, but then again, it doesn't seem significant to me, Randy — however, how much have you roughly incorporated into the 2021 guidance regarding these two assets? Or might that be something you're able to share with us?
Patrick Drouin
executiveBoth of those are already accounted for. Marmato was included. As Randy mentioned, Marmato remains quite small until we reach the deep zone. With Cozamin, we definitely had it — we announced that acquisition in December, and it would certainly be part of 2021. That said, I can tell you we took a conservative approach. We do believe Capstone will increase production, perhaps not in 2021 but further out. We think there is definite upside there in the five- and 10-year guidance. It is reflected in our current guidance.
Randy Smallwood
executiveA number of the initiatives Capstone has set in motion at Cozamin are certainly going to lift output figures at that operation. We anticipate that showing up across the coming 2 years.
Cosmos Chiu
analystRandy, on the deep zone at Marmato — could you remind us about the timing? What's the potential timing there?
Randy Smallwood
executiveMy understanding is that was 2023. Haytham, your line is open. Can you provide that?
Haytham Hodaly
executiveAbsolutely. My sense is that the expected timing falls around late 2023 to early 2024.
Cosmos Chiu
analystThanks. Turning to another stream, Keno Hill: I see commissioning of the mill began in November 2020. Given the timing and the concentrate situation, when should we expect that stream to start contributing? And as far as you know, how is the startup progressing?
Randy Smallwood
executiveThe startup faced some difficulties, largely due to COVID-19 risk management. In October and November, the second wave arrived, so restrictions went up, and that clearly made things hard for the startup when it came to bringing staff on site safely and ensuring strong risk management protocols were maintained. That clearly made it somewhat harder for them to get operations running smoothly. They did succeed in achieving first production. For us, it's a concentrate that gets shipped out. We're hopeful that, as we appear to be emerging from this second wave, conditions will ease somewhat for Alexco when it comes to reaching full speed. They are obtaining some good, very impressive grades from the underground. Things look very promising on that front. We fully expect that, by spring, they should be getting closer to full production levels.
Patrick Drouin
executiveRight. Cosmos, we didn’t record any output for Keno Hill during 2020, though you should see it begin building production, likely in Q1. I can’t think of any reason we wouldn’t be producing in the first quarter.
Cosmos Chiu
analystAppreciate it, Patrick. Perhaps one additional question at this point. Typically in Q4, producers prefer to bring sales in line with production. I suppose that didn't really materialize in Q4 2020 this year, perhaps because of the COVID-19 impact. Do you have any insight regarding when that could flip, with sales surpassing production in some later quarter? Would that be Q1 or Q2? Is there any insight of that kind you're aware of right now?
Randy Smallwood
executiveYou're right about that. Last year, the suspensions during the second quarter—and in some locations stretching into part of the third quarter—sorry, in some places it was the first quarter running into the second—created a somewhat unusual effect on those units normally produced but not yet sold. In our view, the figures aren't too far from what we typically average each quarter, so we do anticipate a return to normal. Our experience has consistently shown that the fourth quarter is when sales get pushed, since everybody tightens the inventory pipeline to try to lift year-end results. That's generally the motivation behind it, and it's among the reasons we usually observe that pattern in the fourth quarter. My guess would be that after we return to normal levels—which I believe we're quite close to at this moment—it likely won't be until the fourth quarter once more that we see anything like that, Cosmos. Again, probably the drive to simply make the year-end results appear somewhat better is an ongoing objective, correct?
Cosmos Chiu
analystAppreciate it again, Randy, Gary, Patrick, and Haytham. That covers everything I wanted to ask. Hope all of you stay safe out there, and enjoy the weekend.
Operator
operatorBrian MacArthur from Raymond James has the next question. Go ahead, please.
Brian MacArthur
analystMorning, everyone.
Randy Smallwood
executiveHey there, Brian.
Gary Brown
executiveHi there, Brian.
Brian MacArthur
analystMorning. There's plenty of industry chatter right now about returns on streams going forward. With your sell-down of First Majestic, I'm curious how you view the rate of return on what I'd term the San Dimas May 2018 deal, because when I look at it, you laid out $220 million. Assuming my math is right — and tell me if it isn't — you've already received $94 back in cash. You've also sold roughly 151 million shares of First Majestic, with more still to come, and you retain the stream. When you run those rate of return calculations, do you factor in that First Majestic sale? Given how significant the First Majestic position is, I'm just curious how you think about that philosophically.
Randy Smallwood
executiveHonestly, from a philosophical standpoint, I see it this way: we had a chance to carry out the stream at Cozamin alongside Capstone, and one route to funding it involved selling off our First Majestic shares and essentially redirecting that capital into silver still in the ground at Cozamin, which is a solid, long-life asset. We back First Majestic strongly and support what they're doing at San Dimas. In our view, that asset fits First Majestic perfectly. I believe a number of the initiatives they have going will only make that asset stronger than it is today. They've got a solid, strong emphasis on, first of all, getting drill holes into the ground, which is always the initial requirement when it comes to ensuring you have the exploration potential and the resources that convert into reserves. Beyond that, there's ongoing optimization of the mill, plus gains in throughput and recovery rates and reinvestment into it. Even as of this morning, San Dimas remains First Majestic's flagship, and it will always be a central focus of their investment. We were content shareholders and supportive ones, we spotted a chance to remain focused as well, and we're also quite bullish on silver.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThat works well for us. Gary, on the return rate side?
Gary Brown
executiveYeah. Look, Brian, you need to keep in mind that we see the San Dimas restructuring we completed back in 2018 as a highly successful transaction—a genuine win-win—one that has benefited First Majestic, which has done a wonderful job with the asset and had exploration success. The original stream, we received the current stream. The current stream, we modified the stream so that we were getting about 60% of what we were previously getting. For the 40% that we gave up, we received $151 million of First Majestic shares. You have to take that into account, right? We got $370 million, and then the Goldcorp gave us $10 million to get rid of their guarantee relative to that asset. We received $380 million for the original stream. We've received $156 million so far as at December 31st, 2020, in proceeds from selling the First Majestic shares, and we had about $100 million of First Majestic shares at year-end. Let's call it $260 million relative to our original valuation of $151 million. We've generated as at December 31st, 2020, about a 70% return on the First Majestic shares. That's reflective of the fantastic job that First Majestic has done with San Dimas.
Gary Brown
executiveAnd keep in mind, when we closed that transaction, gold was trading at roughly $1,200. Since then, gold has climbed more than 40%, and those two factors together have produced a very substantial return. Under the amended stream, we've collected more than $94 million so far. Thanks to the exploration success First Majestic has achieved, the mine life there has been extended considerably. I'd call that a highly successful restructuring, and we're quite pleased with how that asset is performing.
Brian MacArthur
analystThanks. Perhaps one more question. Regarding the Voisey's Bay transaction, from a technical standpoint, and given all this discussion about marketing, and as you noted, it is a premium product. What exactly is the reference price for cobalt that you will receive after marketing? If a situation arose in which there was a two-tiered market or something similar, I simply cannot recall — is it technically specified to reference a particular price, or is there some possibility?
Randy Smallwood
executiveYeah, Brian, right now we’ve got an agency agreement under which we sell at block prices across the period, correct? Clearly, we keep an eye on spot market prices, but every block sold gets a price assigned when that transaction occurs, on a go-forward basis. There are various different reference points or reference prices out there. Obviously, we watch that, and our agent watches it too in terms of how it moves forward. It isn’t directly tied to those agency prices. It’s simply there for reference.
Gary Brown
executiveBrian, this is going to be tough, because the reference that applied best used to be Fastmarkets MB—though I believe they might have rebranded. LME really isn't a solid substitute. If you check the LME price, what you'll get is movement that's proportional or directional. Take a look at LME, and you can observe that prices there have climbed from the mid-teens all the way into the mid-20s. That happened over the past period, into late 2020. Right around when we began selling our initial product and completed our first sale, pricing had improved considerably. When it comes to a precise figure, forecasting anything beyond a directional shift from LME is going to be hard, unfortunately.
Brian MacArthur
analystOkay, let me make sure I understand this clearly. There's a philosophical debate in the market about whether cobalt sourced from Canada could be worth more than cobalt from, say, certain locations in Africa. That would be something negotiated, and if customers were willing to pay extra for material from Canada, then it would be a negotiated price handled through your agency — and in theory, you would capture a premium if you were able to arrange that, and if that situation actually existed in the market. It isn't as though this is a fixed, unchanging reference point for anything.
Randy Smallwood
executiveRight. It’s a distinctive product that originates from Voisey’s Bay, and it is available in the market. It is widely recognized in the market. There are people who genuinely favor this product, and those are the ones now coming forward. Our initial sale went to a buyer that had been using Voisey’s Bay cobalt for quite some time, and it fetched a solid price.
Brian MacArthur
analystExcellent. I appreciate everyone taking the time to respond to each of my questions.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThanks, Brian.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Richard Hatch at Berenberg. You have the floor.
Richard Hatch
analystYeah, thanks a lot. Morning to the management team and <<inaudible>>, congratulations on a really strong set of numbers. I have a few questions. The first is just regarding Salobo. I was wondering whether you could add a bit more detail about what you might potentially achieve on production levels, specifically across the different mills. I understand it's rather difficult and you may not have the complete picture there, but could you give us some kind of guidance on the three and four expansion — what might that lift production levels to?
Randy Smallwood
executiveOkay, what I can share with you is how many tons each of those expansion projects involves. Right now, the mine operates at a capacity of roughly 60,000 tons per day. With phase III, that figure goes from 60,000 up to 90,000 tons per day. As for phase IV — the proposed phase IV — it is not definite at this point by any means, but it certainly appears to be taking shape, and it would add another 30,000 tons per day. In the end, that takes the mine from the current 60,000 tons per day to 120,000 tons per day. And that still, if you look at copper mines across the globe, the large open pit copper mines worldwide, is not the biggest in the world by any means. It is a fairly typical operating rate and, in fact, quite similar to what we see at Penasquito, where strip ratios are even higher. Now the question becomes: what grade did they select when stockpiling? That is very difficult. We know that at present, they are stockpiling material of lower grade. They have done so ever since the mine started up back in 2012, setting the lower grade material aside and building up a low-grade stockpile, which ultimately, at the very end of the mine life, will be processed through the mill.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThey're already doing that. The stockpiling approach is more or less reflected in current production levels. It's easy for us to forecast, we know that, and as a matter of fact, our long-term forward forecasts have incorporated the assumption that all ore mined gets processed through the mill and that stockpiling doesn't stop. That, in our view, is a very conservative base case, and we believe there's definitely upside beyond it. That said, when it comes to how much material they stockpile, if current practices continue, you'd imply a possible 50% increase this time around. It simply won't play out that way. Usually, as you scale up capacity throughputs, any crossover grades for stockpiling will decline somewhat as you adapt to that higher capacity through the mill. The range of possible outcomes is very broad, and it's hard for us to offer more guidance than this: we're confident it will be higher than what our forward forecast contains. How much higher really depends on the quantity of material they choose to set aside in the stockpiling campaign and the quantity they choose to move through the mill.
Randy Smallwood
executiveIt's really a whole range of outcomes, and they have a lot of flexibility on their end. What I can do again is stress the point that beyond our belief that continuing to stockpile makes economic sense for them, there's also a fairly strong incentive. As Gary said earlier, there's an incentive of about $100 million on top of their expansion payment if they commit to a continuous stockpiling program and focus on higher grade materials through the mill. With stronger economics combined with that incentive, we're certainly hoping they'll make that decision. Ultimately, how they approach it is Vale's decision. I only wish I could offer you more guidance than that, but I can't.
Richard Hatch
analystNo, that's alright. That's really useful. Just one quick thing about Rosemont. You said you moved that into your long-term guidance. When does it come online in your figures?
Randy Smallwood
executiveSo, it's roughly six years away from arriving. We genuinely believe Hudbay is progressing well with its talks regarding the appeal of that ruling. As a matter of fact, Hudbay's own guidance indicates they anticipate announcing, or ideally reaching, a decision point at some stage within the next—I believe it's a few months, actually. Definitely before this year is out. With that in mind, construction takes around two and a half to three years on it, and there's a fair likelihood they could proceed. Should their appeal of the latest ruling fail, they still have the option to attempt relocating the operations onto land that is privately held and to keep moving ahead. That would be an operation at a smaller scale. It truly doesn't make sense, yet at times you're compelled to do things that don't make sense so you can work around these obstacles. They are certainly making solid headway on that front, and we're confident they will succeed. In such a case, we believe there's a fairly strong likelihood it lands inside our five-year guidance. We simply thought, once more, that it's better to stay on the conservative side. We're confident they'll get there. Even if it fell within the five years, we probably wouldn't see it until that guidance's fifth year.
Randy Smallwood
executiveIt's genuinely something that's going to arrive, and I'd say there's a solid chance it lands six years out, maybe seven years out. We've essentially got it contributing to production during years six through 10 of that 10-year guidance.
Richard Hatch
analystCool. Okay, quick one on the dividends. It's really good to see the dividend raised once more and the yield going up. I guess your balance sheet is set to turn into net cash in Q1. Where's your thinking when it comes to a meaningful increase? If I look at my figures, we're at a 5%-6% free cash flow yield and 1.5% on dividend yield. There may be room to push it a little harder. Do you reckon you hold off another year or two and see how the deals play out, just to keep that extra firepower for yourself? Do you think we might see dividends lifted somewhat higher looking 12 months out?
Randy Smallwood
executiveOkay, so one thing to remember is that our dividend is averaged across the prior four quarters of cash flow. Given the organic growth we just talked about over the coming few years, we recognize that this dividend will face upward pressure simply because we tie it to our cash flows. Should precious metal prices show renewed strength, that would create additional upward pressure on the dividend as well. That's just naturally going to happen. Richard, I can tell you we're focused on trying to grow our portfolio. If we succeed, well, we only do so when it's accretive and when it's high quality. We're extremely selective. I can tell you our hit rate runs at roughly one in 100 when it comes to projects we review versus those we actually close on. So we are very selective about what we put money into, but our goal is to keep growing the company with ounces in the ground. If we don't succeed, then you're right. This year, we're going to accumulate an incredibly strong cash balance on the balance sheet, and that's not where I'd want to be.
Randy Smallwood
executiveSo what that really means is, if we get to the end of this year and we haven't done any other major acquisitions in terms of putting money back into the ground, then we'll certainly be looking at the possibility of raising the payout ratio from 30% to maybe as high as 40% or 50%. I don't see it going all the way to 50. The next logical step would be 40%, but that's only going to happen when we've got the cash to give back to our shareholders. We're not going to borrow money to give back to our shareholders. We will borrow to acquire ounces in the ground. Our focus is on growing the company. If we can't see good opportunities to grow the company, then the money will come back to our shareholders.
Richard Hatch
analystSo, are you factoring in a special dividend or not?
Randy Smallwood
executiveI doubt it, though we'll see how things play out. Should our balance sheet grow excessively and we end up holding an excessive amount of cash, those options could come into play. This year, that's improbable.
Richard Hatch
analystAlright, thanks. And my final question is really just for Haytham. If you looked at the deal pipeline right now — and I think one of the others mentioned this a bit earlier — but taking the pipeline as it stands today, how confident are you that some of these are at the point where the pen is hovering over the paper, or is it more that there's still a fair amount of work left before we get any news flow on deals?
Haytham Hodaly
executiveTo respond to that, Richard, I'd say there are likely 10 to 12 opportunities worth $100 million-$300 million in the pipeline that we keep reviewing constantly, and we hope to manage getting a couple of those completed. How confident am I? I believe we'll do everything possible to ensure we carry out accretive transactions, and I'm fairly confident we'll succeed in 2021.
Richard Hatch
analystThat’s really useful. I appreciate you all taking the time — thank you very much.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThanks, Richard. If I could, just one more question.
Operator
operatorTrevor Turnbull from Scotiabank has the final question — go ahead, please.
Randy Smallwood
executiveTrevor, it's great to hear from you.
Trevor Turnbull
analystOkay, thank you, Randy. I hope you'll excuse one final question about Salobo. Would you mind giving us a quick overview of how copper and gold relate to each other here, and if copper prices stay higher for a sustained period, does that push Vale toward a decision one way or the other on stockpiling as it relates to the expansion?
Randy Smallwood
executiveWell, that certainly plays a role, without question, since they receive all of the copper revenue and roughly a quarter of the gold revenue. Stronger copper prices are absolutely going to give them a reason to move that ahead. Looking more broadly at the corporate level down there, Vale — every single time you see them present, they keep emphasizing growth in base metals. They carry substantial iron ore exposure, and the message comes through repeatedly that they aim to try to double what the base metals division of Vale contributes. Salobo and Salobo IV come up again and again. Earlier this week I attended a panel discussion at the PDAC where it was mentioned. Our view is that even stronger copper prices give them added incentive to pursue this course and to try to capture some of the gains from today's copper prices.
Trevor Turnbull
analystApologies — at the most basic level, when copper grades come in higher, gold grades tend to be higher as well, so everything moves the same way.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThat's a lovely thing, isn't it? Yes, precisely.
Trevor Turnbull
analystOkay, thank you, Randy.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThanks, Trevor, and thanks to all of you. To wrap up, we genuinely believe Wheaton is positioned very well to keep delivering value to our shareholders, and there are a number of reasons for that. First, our costs are low and predictable, which gives us some of the highest margins anywhere in the precious metal space and produces very strong operating cash flows. Second, we have a steady organic growth profile along with a proven track record of accretive, quality acquisitions. Third, our portfolio of long-life, low-cost assets gives shareholders exposure to some of the highest quality mines in the world. And last, we are a leader among precious metal streamers in sustainability, through initiatives like our CSR fund and our strong support of our partners and the communities where we live and operate. I'm looking forward to speaking with all of you again soon. Stay healthy. Stay safe. Thank you.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's conference call. We appreciate everyone joining in. You may now disconnect your lines.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Wheaton Precious Metals Corp. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Wheaton Precious Metals Corp. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Wheaton Precious Metals Corp. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.