Wheaton Precious Metals Corp. (WPM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 12, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorMorning, everyone, and thanks for joining us today. You're listening to the Wheaton Precious Metals 2022 Second Quarter Conference Call. To keep background noise out, every line has been muted. Following the speaker's remarks, we'll open things up for a question-and-answer session. During that time, if you'd like to ask something, just press star followed by the number one on your phone's keypad, or you can type your question into the webinar's Q&A box. Should you wish to withdraw your question, press star and then the number two. Thank you. I'd also like to note for everyone that this call is being recorded on Friday, August 12th, 2022, at 11:00 A.M. Eastern Time. At this point I'll hand the conference over to Mr. Patrick Drouin, Senior Vice President of Investor Relations and Sustainability. Please go ahead, sir.
Patrick Drouin
executiveThank you, operator. Good morning, everyone, and thanks for joining us on today's call. With me this morning are Randy Smallwood, President and Chief Executive Officer of Wheaton Precious Metals; Gary Brown, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer; Haytham Hodaly, Senior Vice President, Corporate Development; and Wes Carson, Vice President, Mining Operations. For anyone who isn't on the webcast right now, the slide deck that goes with this conference call can be found in PDF form on the presentation page of the Wheaton Precious Metals website. I want to draw your attention to the fact that certain commentary on today's call may include forward-looking statements, and I'd ask everyone to look at slide two of the presentation, where you'll find important cautionary notes about forward-looking statements. Please note that unless otherwise indicated, every figure mentioned on today's call is stated in U.S. dollars. Also, when we refer to Wheaton or Wheaton Precious Metals on this call, that includes Wheaton Precious Metals Corp. and its wholly owned subsidiaries, as applicable. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Randy Smallwood, our President and Chief Executive Officer.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThanks, Patrick, and good morning to all of you. We appreciate you being with us today as we go over Wheaton's results for the second quarter of 2022. I'm happy to report that our portfolio once more generated strong revenue, earnings and cash flow during the first half of 2022, which Gary will walk through later. That strong showing speaks to how resilient the streaming model is when faced with the inflationary pressures being felt throughout the global economy, and particularly among the traditional miners. As a matter of fact, our average cash cost for each gold equivalent ounce went down in the first half of 2022 compared with the first half of 2021. Although we kept actively chasing a number of new opportunities during the second quarter, we also demonstrated our readiness to strategically pinpoint opportunities both within and beyond our portfolio that generate value for shareholders. Along those lines, during the quarter we announced the proposed termination of the Keno Hill stream for $135 million, which once completed will ultimately produce an absolute return on our Keno Hill investment of more than 300%. That said, terminating the stream, together with severe weather events at Stillwater and throughput from Salobo that came in below expectations, means Wheaton has had to reduce its 2022 production guidance.
Randy Smallwood
executiveWes is going to share further details afterward on this call. Even so, because of the solid liquidity on our balance sheet that is available for investment, the output increases at our main producing assets, and our varied development portfolio, we remain on course to deliver sustained long-term production and robust growth across the coming four years. Finally, we showed our leadership once more in sustainability and in creating value for all stakeholders by releasing our third annual sustainability report and by announcing a sustainability-linked element tied to the renewal of our existing undrawn $2 billion revolving credit facility. At this point I'd like to hand the call over to Gary Brown, our Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, who will give you more detail on our results.
Gary Brown
executiveThanks, Randy, and good morning, everyone. In the second quarter of 2022, our precious metals interest turned out 163,000 gold equivalent ounces, or GEOs, made up of 68,000 ounces of gold, 6.5 million ounces of silver, 3,900 ounces of palladium, and 136,000 pounds of cobalt. Compared with the same quarter a year earlier, that was a 15% drop on a gold equivalent basis, mainly because of weaker output at Salobo. Sales volumes on a gold equivalent basis came in just 3% below Q2 2021, as shifts in ounces produced but not delivered, or PBND, largely made up for the reduced production. At June 30th, 2022, roughly 123,000 GEOs sat in PBND, plus cobalt inventory of 10,700 GEOs, and together that 133,000 GEOs came to about 2.4 months of payable production. That figure is about 24,000 GEOs below the average for the four quarters before it. Revenue in the second quarter of 2022 reached $303 million, an 8% decline from Q2 2021, driven by a 5% fall in the average realized gold equivalent price along with the softer sales volumes. Breaking that revenue down, 52% came from gold sales, 43% from silver, 2% from palladium, and 3% from cobalt.
Gary Brown
executiveLower realized prices and sales volumes drove gross margin down 11% to $162 million for the second quarter of 2022. Still, one thing worth noting is that average cash cost per GEO fell 1%, which shows how resilient our business model is to the inflationary pressures the mining industry is experiencing across the board. G&A expenses came to $10 million in the second quarter of 2022, and donations and community investment expenses added another $1 million, for a combined $11 million that was virtually unchanged from Q2 2021. For 2022, the company still estimates G&A expenses will come to $41 million-$42 million, while donations and community investments are estimated to add $6 million-$7 million. Stock-based compensation was $2 million in the second quarter of 2022, a decrease of $6 million relative to the comparable quarter of the prior year, mainly because of differences in accrued costs associated with the PSUs. Net earnings came to $149 million in the second quarter of 2022, compared to $166 million in Q2 2021. Basic adjusted earnings per share fell 8% to $0.33, compared to $0.36 per share in the prior year. Operating cash flow for the second quarter of 2022 was $206 million, or $0.46 per share, compared to $216 million, or $0.48 per share, in the prior year, a 5% decrease on a per share basis.
Gary Brown
executiveIn line with the company's dividend policy, the board has declared a payout of $0.15 per share for holders of record as of August 26th, 2022. Through the dividend reinvestment plan, the board chose to give shareholders the choice to have their dividends reinvested into newly issued common shares of the company at a 1% discount to market. In the second quarter of 2022, the company paid dividends related to the previous two quarters totaling $117 million, invested $15 million related to Marmato, and picked up $3 million in long-term equity investments. All told, net cash inflows came to $72 million in Q2 2022, leaving cash and cash equivalents of $449 million at June 30th. Recently, the company introduced a sustainability-linked element into its revolving credit facility, which highlights the company's dedication to ESG initiatives. Additionally, the revolving facility's term was pushed out to July 18th, 2027. The capacity from the undrawn $2 billion revolving credit facility, together with strong forecasted operating cash flows, puts the company in a very good position to meet its funding commitments and maintain its dividend policy, while also retaining the flexibility to complete additional accretive precious metal purchase agreements. That wraps up the financial summary.
Wes Carson
executiveThanks, Gary. Good morning to everyone. On the whole, output during the second quarter fell short of what we had anticipated, as Salobo and Stillwater both delivered weaker results than expected; that shortfall was partly made up for by better-than-expected output at Constancia, Peñasquito, and Antamina. At Salobo, attributable gold production for the second quarter totaled 34,000 ounces, roughly 39% below the level seen in the second quarter of 2021, which reflected reduced throughput and lower grades. Mine movements kept improving as the quarter went on. Even so, concentrate output took a hit from how the process plant performed, owing to slower-than-planned ramp-up following a scheduled maintenance shutdown along with extra corrective maintenance work. Vale anticipates that additional maintenance will carry on through the second half of 2022, centered on lifting overall operational performance at the mine and at the process plant alike, which should ultimately bring better production over the rest of the year. Vale also said physical completion of the Salobo three mine expansion stood at 95% as of the close of the second quarter. Beyond that, commissioning work got under way during the quarter at the primary crushing and stockpile areas. Over in the second quarter, Stillwater Mine turned out 2,200 ounces of attributable gold together with 3,900 ounces of attributable palladium, which works out to declines of roughly 27% for gold and 26% for palladium compared with the second quarter of 2021.
Wes Carson
executiveFlooding across the region hit the Stillwater operations on June 13th, 2022, causing damage to several bridges as well as the access road leading to the Stillwater Mine. The East Boulder Mine and the Columbus Metallurgical facilities were not cut off, and both kept running at full capacity throughout the flooding events. The Stillwater Mine, responsible for 60% of mine production from the Stillwater operations, restarted production on July 29th, 2022, after safe access to the site was reestablished. Output at the Stillwater Mine should be back to normal levels by the fourth quarter. In the quarter, the Voisey's Bay Mine turned out 136,000 pounds of attributable cobalt, roughly 64% lower than the second quarter of 2021, mainly because of lower grades during the ongoing transitional period between depletion of the Ovoid open pit and the ramp-up to full production at the Voisey's Bay underground project. The Voisey's Bay underground mine extension, encompassing development of two new underground mines, Reid Brook and Eastern Deeps, stood at 74% physical completion as the second quarter ended. Reid Brook underground carried on ore production for development during the quarter, and Vale has said Eastern Deeps should start up in the second half of 2022.
Wes Carson
executiveWith the planned divestiture of the Keno Hill PMPA, reduced output at Stillwater because of harsh weather, and Salobo coming in below expectations, Wheaton is cutting its production guidance. Estimated attributable production for 2022 is now projected at 300,000 to 320,000 ounces of gold, 22.5 to 24 million ounces of silver, and 35,000 to 40,000 gold equivalent ounces from other metals, which works out to roughly 640,000 to 680,000 gold equivalent ounces. Over the five-year span through 2026, the company now projects average production of 820,000 gold equivalent ounces. Across the ten-year span through 2031, average annual production is now expected to reach 870,000 gold equivalent ounces. That wraps up the operations overview. I'll now hand the call back to Randy.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThanks, Wes, and thanks, Gary. To sum up, although there were some difficulties, Wheaton posted a strong quarter marked by a number of important highlights. We delivered robust revenue, earnings, and cash flow for the quarter, and we declared a quarterly dividend of $0.15. We strengthened our financial flexibility, which puts us in a good position for accretive growth going forward. Finally, we demonstrated our sustainability leadership once more by putting a sustainability credit facility in place and by earning recognition from Corporate Knights as one of the best 50 corporate citizens in Canada. With that, I'd like to open the line for questions. Operator?
Operator
operatorThank you. At this point, ladies and gentlemen, we're going to move into a question and answer session. Should you wish to pose a question, please press Star and then the number one on your telephone keypad. To pull your question back, press the star followed by the number two. We'll take a brief pause while we put together the Q&A roster. Our first question is from Trevor Turnbull at Scotiabank. Please go ahead.
Trevor Turnbull
analystYeah, thanks, Randy. I was just wondering whether you might speak a bit about what changed with the 5- and 10-year guidance. I get that those shifts are fairly minor in the bigger picture and partly tied to the adjustment from ending that Alexco Stream, plus the mine changes that just came out here at Sibanye-Stillwater. I was curious if any other factors played a role in your decision to revise those longer-term outlooks.
Randy Smallwood
executiveOkay, I'll hand it over to Wes for more specifics, but let me begin by noting that at Salobo, the production decline this year also carries significant weight once you spread it across the 5- and 10-year averages. Remember that 2022 falls within that 5- and 10-year average, correct? Without question, that affected production. Then, as you mentioned, there's the Keno divestiture and the revised mine plan from Sibanye-Stillwater. Another element I'd point to is that we're now beginning to see the configuration of Copper World and Rosemont, along with the lower expected output in the initial years — despite substantial growth in total ounces to be received from Rosemont, it will begin at the Copper World area, so production is clearly below what the original Rosemont plans contained. That too contributes to lowering the long-term forecast. Across the board, Wes, anything you'd like to add?
Wes Carson
executiveYes. The only two other smaller items were a modification at Toroparu as well — and how that aligns with the production profile and the fresh plan they devised — and then Phoenix also being deferred; those were the only two other smaller items. On the whole, really, I mean, the key item was the adjustment to this year, and then the Keno Hill stream were the two big ones.
Trevor Turnbull
analystAll right, that’s really helpful context. I hadn’t considered how this year’s Salobo figures would affect things, but I appreciate the explanation—and thank you.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThanks, Trevor. That’s great.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from KeyBanc's Adam Josephson. You may proceed.
Adam Josephson
analystMorning, Randy and everybody. Appreciate you taking my questions. Wes, I just have one follow-up to what you said in response to the previous one. Could you quantify how much of that 5- and 10-year cut comes specifically from this year's production versus the other factors you brought up?
Wes Carson
executiveYeah, roughly 30% of that would probably land this year.
Adam Josephson
analystOver that five-year period.
Wes Carson
executiveYes, across that 5-year span. And for the 10-year period, correct, it comes to 50% of that figure.
Adam Josephson
analystFifty percent of that amount.
Wes Carson
executiveYeah. That's right. Precisely.
Adam Josephson
analystUnderstood. Alright. This year, it appears Salobo accounted for a. Out of that 70,000-ounce decrease, Salobo looks like it was roughly 50. Randy, does that sound about right, or am I overlooking something there?
Randy Smallwood
executiveThat's roughly the right figure. What I was going to mention is that, as you're aware, output at Stillwater has clearly declined because of the flooding they experienced there, so that will leave a mark. Underground transition at Voisey's Bay has fallen somewhat behind, which means we're getting somewhat reduced cobalt from Voisey's and the like. Silver, I should say, remains fairly well on schedule, yet gold has been affected at both Stillwater and Salobo, and then, as you know, cobalt from — plus palladium and cobalt from, naturally, Stillwater and Voisey's Bay.
Wes Carson
executiveYeah, that’s actually true.
Adam Josephson
analystOkay.
Wes Carson
executiveThe figure coming from Salobo is a bit more than 40,000. We're looking for improvement around Q3 and Q4. Q2 was fairly tough.
Adam Josephson
analystWhat was the amount? Thanks. Salobo accounted for 40 out of roughly 70. What does Stillwater come to?
Wes Carson
executiveAllow me to verify something at this point.
Randy Smallwood
executiveI mean, out of those 70, somewhere between 40 — let's say roughly 15 to 20.
Wes Carson
executiveYes. Yes, that sounds roughly correct.
Adam Josephson
analystTo 20.
Wes Carson
executiveSure.
Adam Josephson
analystAnd regarding the ten-year outlook, Randy or Wes, how significant would you characterize Stillwater's contribution as being? Could you elaborate further on the revised mine plan and what effect that is exerting on how you see long-term production?
Wes Carson
executiveLooking at Stillwater, it's fairly small over the long term. We're really only talking about roughly a couple thousand ounces from each of the 5-year and 10-year figures. They still intend to ramp up during the coming few years, and that does happen. I mean, the Blitz ramp-up has some effect, but in the bigger picture it isn't significant.
Randy Smallwood
executiveYes. One figure in that 10-year guidance does get affected, and naturally it's Rosemont moving across to Copper World. For the first five years, that genuinely makes a fairly meaningful difference.
Wes Carson
executiveSure.
Randy Smallwood
executiveOnce more, this is a positive development, since every one of those ounces fell outside what we had initially planned, so that output will show up. We have confidence that Rosemont will eventually be constructed in full and will be operated. Given the fresh guidance we've observed through our talks with Hudbay as they advance that project, it actually carries a fairly substantial effect on our 10-year guidance. Not so much on our five-year guidance, because, you know, it only arrives close to the conclusion of that five-year guidance. For the 10-year guidance, it's actually among the largest contributors to the shift in the 10-year guidance.
Wes Carson
executiveYes. Without a doubt.
Adam Josephson
analystUnderstood, thanks, Randy. Regarding Salobo, what level of confidence do you have that Salobo three will begin operating in the fourth quarter, as you currently anticipate? And more generally on Salobo, how confident are you at this stage that they at least have a solid understanding of what the issues are and what must be done to resolve them, compared with what has occurred there really from the time the pandemic began?
Randy Smallwood
executiveOkay, I’ll hand it over to Wes to add some more color and detail here. What I’ll say is that we recently went down for our first site visit in a number of years, and I really can’t overstate how much more valuable it is to actually be there in person rather than doing virtual mine tours — both for getting a feel for how operations are running and for gaining confidence in their capability. I’ll let Wes give a bit of color. I’ll tell you that one reason we put money into the most profitable mines anywhere in the world is that Vale has a very strong incentive to get it fixed as well. I know there have been a lot of management changes down there aimed at resolving these issues. That said, we can’t overlook the pandemic’s impact and the effort to manage through it. Brazil was among the countries hit hardest on the planet in terms of how COVID affected operations. Many of the measures taken to try to limit the impact at the site itself also affected productivity and how we move forward.
Randy Smallwood
executiveWes, would you like to add some more detail?
Wes Carson
executiveYeah, absolutely. Early in June I was out at the site with a technical team — that visit was arranged quite recently, and it really gave us added confidence for the remainder of this year and for the Salobo 3 ramp-up. All told, we spent 4 days there and came away with a solid review of the whole site. Our relationship with Vale, our biggest partner, is excellent, and they are always extremely transparent with us when walking through precisely where the challenges lie. As Randy mentioned, quite a few changes have taken place at the site. They understand what the maintenance-related problems are — problems to which COVID has especially contributed, and also going all the way back to the fatalities in 2020. Through that stretch, getting things back on track has genuinely been a struggle for them. There is very strong confidence now that they have sorted things out. Salobo 3, I think, looks excellent. Walking around the site, you could definitely see it — the 95% completion is right there. They will have it running by the end of this year. Ramping it up, though, and actually reaching full capacity is going to take some time, and I think the mine is in great shape to feed all 3 lines into next year.
Randy Smallwood
executiveOne thing to keep in mind is that phase one, when the mine was first starting up, needed roughly 24 months to hit full capacity on that initial line. The second line required about 18 months to reach full capacity. Obviously, as they keep moving along this path, things ought to get better, so our hope is that we should see full capacity without much trouble by the end of 2023 to 2024.
Wes Carson
executiveSure.
Randy Smallwood
executiveWe’re looking at the early part of 2024.
Wes Carson
executiveWhen you tour the Salobo 3 project, one standout is simply every enhancement they implemented, drawing on lessons from Salobo 1 and 2. They have built in many more forms of redundancy to support availability. A great deal of effort went into ensuring that the Salobo 3 line is as good as it can possibly be. Also worth pointing out: it is an entirely standalone line, starting at the primary crusher and running all the way through, so Salobo 1 and 2 experience no effect on how they operate once Salobo 3 starts up. There are no tie-ins or anything of that sort required. In fact, it is a fully separate line.
Adam Josephson
analystThanks to both of you for that. Wes, I just want to clear up one point regarding how Salobo affects your long-term guidance. Setting aside the reduced output you're expecting for this year, have your longer-term Salobo production forecasts shifted at all because of the issues they've encountered, or do they remain unchanged from before—with the sole effect on the 5- and 10-year outlook being roughly 40 thousand fewer ounces this year?
Wes Carson
executiveYes, the only change is that production for this year has been reduced. Our confidence remains very strong regarding the long-term guidance the company has and that we provided before.
Adam Josephson
analystThanks. Randy, one final question about jurisdictional matters, specifically in South America. How, if at all, has your view shifted regarding your readiness or hesitation to put money into a lot of those nations, for reasons that are perhaps obvious?
Randy Smallwood
executiveSure. Political risk is definitely a challenge. Getting it right is tough — take a country like Chile, which for decades has ranked among the world's best jurisdictions for investment, and all at once it's become very difficult, with a number of permits rejected of late under the new government there. I know that ultimately this is going to affect foreign investment in the mining industry there. All you have to do is look at their state miner Codelco and the lack of capital it has when it comes to building and advancing its own projects. That's going to have a real negative impact on Chile. What you try to do is find assets strong enough to withstand any changes in taxation, because we see it everywhere in the world. Even here in Canada, we see increases in taxation all the time, and so on. Again, I reiterate how important it is to look for first and second quartile assets and to focus on assets that deliver high profitability to all the stakeholders, including the recipient governments for taxes and the recipient communities for income and stuff.
Randy Smallwood
executiveWe need to make sure we concentrate on these, since they're the ones best able to withstand such pressures — whether that's higher taxation, higher royalties, or bigger difficulties around permitting and the added costs that come with it. It really just underscores how important it is that we concentrate on assets capable of handling all that while still getting their essential products to society.
Adam Josephson
analystYeah, I’m with you there. Just one final question. When it comes to the discount rate you’d use for a country such as Chile, could you give us a rough idea of how it may have shifted given what has occurred over roughly the last year?
Randy Smallwood
executiveYeah. It's a bit greater than it used to be. That figure is quite fluid. We've got a group that evaluates political risk, so it's a very changeable number. So whatever number I give you today would be different tomorrow and would have been different yesterday. It's a fluid figure — anytime we're assessing a project, we try to evaluate not just where a country stands, but we also examine the vectors in terms of where we think it's headed. One thing about the streaming sector is that these are life of mine investments. Unless somebody comes along and offers a really attractive price for an existing stream, they're life of mine investments. Political risk matters enormously to us. We put a great deal of effort into it. I can tell you that, yeah, Chilean political risk has added to our risk profile, and we aren't prepared to pay as much for Chilean opportunities as we were a year ago, two years ago.
Adam Josephson
analystYes, thank you very much, Randy.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThanks, Adam.
Operator
operatorThank you. Our following question is from Ralph Profiti at Eight Capital. You have the floor.
Ralph Profiti
analystMorning to you. Randy, I appreciate you fielding my questions.
Randy Smallwood
executiveSure.
Ralph Profiti
analystRandy, staying with Chile for a moment — are you part of some kind of mitigation plan at Phoenix together with Rio2, the partner there? I ask because your ESG expertise keeps growing and that's become a real focus for the company. And would you be open to being part of their strategy, which involves looking for alternative financing, whether that comes through a renegotiated stream or through other means of capital investment?
Randy Smallwood
executiveSure, we are absolutely in contact with them. I’ll let Haytham give a little more detail here. Obviously, this is an asset we like. In our view, it is an asset with solid optionality and strong growth potential. At the end of the day, it first has to get up and running. There is no question that we are in discussions with Rio2 about that one. Haytham, I don’t know whether you’d like to add some detail.
Haytham Hodaly
executiveAbsolutely, and thanks for asking, Ralph. On Phoenix specifically, we're currently in talks with them. We're working to determine what kind of capital will be needed over the near term and looking at ways to collaborate with them in order to meet those capital requirements. Broadly speaking, whenever any of our partners encounters difficulties, we're always present. We're constantly working out how best to assist them and what the appropriate route forward would be for them in this situation, in a politically driven decision down in Chile. You have to move carefully here and work out how you can endure this regime, at least for the coming couple of years.
Ralph Profiti
analystYes. That's fair enough, and I appreciate it. Gary, may I ask you something about the sustainability-linked facility? Specifically, whether this leaves you exposed to third-party ESG scores. Does the potential rate on drawn amounts go past emissions targets and the parity goals, and do you run the risk of environmental stewardship on matters that may be somewhat outside your total control?
Gary Brown
executiveOkay, so three components, three KPIs, sit behind the sustainability-linked piece of our revolver. The biggest swing in drawn pricing, whether we hit those targets or miss them, comes to plus or minus 5 basis points. One of those goals, you know, has to do with how our partners have committed to cutting greenhouse gas emissions. Take that 5 basis points, split it three ways, and you land at roughly 1.6 basis points. That said, we do expect our baseline KPIs to improve on that front. This downside risk, honestly, is pretty negligible. And we definitely think there's a stronger likelihood that we'll bring down our borrowing costs in this area. Patrick?
Patrick Drouin
executiveRight, I’ll just add this: the sole KPI linking us to an outside rating agency is the one tied to our S&P rating. In the most recent sustainability report we published, we included extra disclosure — we were actually putting numbers on our scope three investment GHG emissions and similar items, plus various other targets we set in that report — and we firmly expect that score to rise substantially. It doesn’t worry us much, since, again, given the efforts underway and the additional disclosure we’ve already implemented, S&P’s next scoring cycle ought to capture that.
Randy Smallwood
executiveRalph, let me just tack on one more point. We can't use our partners as cover, you know. A lot of companies in this space have done exactly that for years, but the investments we make and the partners we work with are our responsibility. Obviously, we don't control them, but we have to do everything, and we have to take ownership of the fact that going forward, they're our partners. We do everything we can to try to help them improve. I think that focus on the relationship is one of the things that really sets streaming apart.
Ralph Profiti
analystUnderstood. Yes, that was well put. I appreciate the responses. Thanks.
Randy Smallwood
executiveAppreciate it, Ralph.
Operator
operatorThanks. We’ll take our next question from Charlie Rothbarth at Berenberg Bank. You have the floor.
Charlie Rothbarth
analystMorning — nice work on the results, and thanks a lot for taking my question.
Randy Smallwood
executiveCharlie, good evening to you.
Charlie Rothbarth
analystYes. Good evening from London, where it is just 4:30 P.M.
Randy Smallwood
executiveOh, all right then.
Charlie Rothbarth
analystYou pointed out in your presentation the kind of capital you have available. Given how pricing stands right now, could you add just a bit of commentary on how you're thinking about deals and streams, and on whether you're finding them more available to you at the moment?
Randy Smallwood
executiveHaytham is the right person to take that question.
Haytham Hodaly
executiveAbsolutely, and I appreciate the question, Charlie. What we keep observing is a range of smaller streaming possibilities, with the majority sitting below the $300 million mark. These are largely development stage prospects, quite similar to those you've witnessed across the past couple of years. My team right now is moving through several due diligence efforts. To give you a sense of scale, at any moment we tend to be reviewing somewhere around 10 to 12 opportunities. With luck, over the coming 12 months we can whittle that list down to one or two high quality assets that fit what we require, assuming everything goes smoothly. Also, bear in mind that our organic growth remains strong, particularly in light of how well we've done with these streaming transactions entered into during the last 24 months. We'll be in a position to direct some cash toward that, though we'll keep seeking ways to deploy our cash. It needs to be accretive over the near term.
Randy Smallwood
executiveYeah. I'd add this: you know, I mean, any businesses out there with operations already up and running have fared pretty well when it comes to commodity prices — and so, too, with cash flow, their own internal cash flows, with little requirement for capital from outside for those that already have operations going. There's certainly solid demand for that.
Charlie Rothbarth
analystGot it — thanks a lot. I may have missed this, so would you mind reminding me? For your forward-looking assumptions on commodity prices, do they differ materially from those you used for this year? I'm thinking in particular about the cobalt sell-off right now and your $33 per pound assumption for 2022.
Randy Smallwood
executiveApologies. Are you referring to the production forecast in terms of gold equivalent ounces, or something else? Yeah, we—
Charlie Rothbarth
analystCorrect, that's right.
Randy Smallwood
executiveWe deliberately held those unchanged so the comparison would be truly apples to apples. For the forecast, the conversion to gold equivalent ounces is precisely the same as it was when this year began.
Haytham Hodaly
executiveJust so we're clear—when we look at new opportunities, we assess them using the current spot price.
Randy Smallwood
executiveYes. Again, that figure moves around a lot. You know, by now I've spent more than 30 years in this industry, and honestly, I still couldn't say where gold prices will be tomorrow. It's extremely fluid. It always comes down to a function. Any time we evaluate new opportunities, everything always hinges on that day's spot price. That, you know, is what drives valuations.
Charlie Rothbarth
analystAlright, got it. Just so I’m clear — the price you applied for this year is identical for both the 5-year and the 10-year GEO calculation?
Haytham Hodaly
executiveThat's right.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThat's right. Yes. Yeah.
Haytham Hodaly
executiveThose figures get established annually, purely to keep them consistent — they're basically locked in around the time we release our initial guidance, and we leave them unchanged for the rest of the year.
Charlie Rothbarth
analystAll right. That’s great. I’ve got it. Thanks so much.
Randy Smallwood
executiveAppreciate that, Charlie.
Operator
operatorThanks. We’ll take the next question from Lawson Winder at Bank of America Securities. You have the floor.
Lawson Winder
analystMorning, gentlemen. Thanks for the update today. Appreciate the detail you've given us so far on the update and the long-term guidance—very helpful. On Stillwater, I was hoping you might be able to add a bit more detail around yesterday's news from Sibanye-Stillwater than what we have, especially on the gold side. When you originally did that stream, the expectation was roughly 14,000 ounces of gold per year once it reached its run rate. Do you have a sense of how materially that has changed?
Randy Smallwood
executiveRight. On the whole, there hasn't been much of a shift. What I mean is that it does step up once the Blitz project kicks in. The main effect really lands across the coming year or two, given that the project has been slowed down a little. For gold specifically, the impact isn't significant. It's genuinely across the next couple of years.
Lawson Winder
analystThat's right.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThe Blitz project, you know, along with the other enhancements, is simply requiring more time to put in place, and without question those efforts have been further complicated by the flood events that occurred there this year.
Lawson Winder
analystSure, absolutely. All right. Appreciate that context. Regarding cobalt, within the other metals segment, has anything shifted in the longer-term outlook for cobalt?
Randy Smallwood
executiveCobalt's longer-term forecast came down slightly, and that's really tied to Voisey's Bay — some of the difficulties we're facing there with the project and bringing those underground operations into service. The main factor is that 2023 came in a bit lower, and that carried through to the other metals across both the 5- and 10-year views.
Lawson Winder
analystAlright, that really helps a lot. Thanks, Haytham. Now I’m just working to reconcile my model for Copper World Rosemont. Under the guidance you gave before, which year had you assumed for Rosemont’s startup? And with the guidance you’re giving now, which year are you assuming for startup at Copper World?
Randy Smallwood
executiveAt the tail end of the 5-year guidance, we have a very small quantity of output from Copper World. We anticipate it will land in that range. As you know, on the Hudbay side they are still tightening things up, so we are still waiting for greater clarity. This is only our best estimate, given that any production is more than 4 years away, but the amount is extremely small. Where we see it arriving is really in the years — I suppose 6 to 10 is Copper World. Should they achieve some success on permitting, this could also, on the federal side, with respect to the Rosemont portion of the project, immediately trigger a change in that mining plan to bring on that extra production from Rosemont. As you know, the plan is highly fluid. Hudbay is firming things up right now, but we simply saw enough of a shift in the indication regarding early production from Rosemont that it justified taking it out of the ten-year guidance.
Lawson Winder
analystThat's roughly comparable to the situation in the earlier guidance we issued this year. When it happens hasn't shifted. What did shift is really the volumes, and that's due to the fresh plan they've released. Okay, understood. No, that's excellent. Appreciate the assistance on that. Last thing, I'd like to touch on Keno Hill. Thanks for giving us the IRR. 335% is quite striking and difficult to dispute, though I recognize that was an asset you were enthusiastic about. Now that a far better capitalized operator is stepping in, I'd be interested in your view on whether the potential return from getting that asset to fully ramp up and generate at its full capability was even close, compared with the return you achieved by selling it.
Randy Smallwood
executiveYou see, once again, I believe the situation called for it. This is one of those cases in which you must weigh keeping the stream in place against deciding if the investment would have proceeded on the project as it stood, or whether to exit. Our view was simply that although we have supported that project for more than 10 years—roughly 14 years, I think, since we struck the original deal—it has just not been able to perform. The jurisdiction is a difficult one. We are aware that Hecla possesses, as you know, stronger capabilities. They have operating teams at Greens Creek, in Alaska, essentially right next door, so to speak. That is quite a distance, yet relatively speaking it is right next door. We simply believed that this was the finest route for that project to advance. As for the price offered, we held many discussions about ways to keep streaming on it and so forth, but ultimately we had to consider where we believed the best return lay. Extracting $135 million from that project would have taken us a very long time.
Randy Smallwood
executiveWe simply thought the moment had come for us to step away from it and let Hecla take a shot at it.
Lawson Winder
analystExcellent. That's clear, and I completely understand. Many thanks, Randy, and thanks to you as well.
Randy Smallwood
executiveYeah, thanks, Lawson.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Brian MacArthur at Raymond James. Go ahead, please.
Brian MacArthur
analystGood morning. I want to revisit the Salobo outlook from another angle. I notice your expected payment for next year hasn't changed, yet you provide guidance of 550 to 650 to reach 36 million tons. So my first question is whether you still anticipate making that payment next year. Second, do you believe the ramp-up will be slower, meaning you'd pay at the lower end of that range simply because of the new Salobo outlook? Or third, could you walk through how it scales up once more — the trade-off across the 90 days, what you need to achieve versus what you must pay, and what the scaling of your payment looks like?
Randy Smallwood
executiveWell, Brian, that's an excellent question, since it's obvious Vale still has work to do. That expansion payment gets calculated from the site's overall performance, not from line three alone. I think that point deserves remembering. As we've observed and as we're reporting right now, lines one and two are not performing to spec. They have considerable work ahead of them before reaching the full payment. As you know, and I believe nearly everyone knows, it's a matrix tied to time and throughput levels — total throughput levels. Not the throughput of line three, but total throughput levels. You know, I remain hopeful. Nothing would please me more than paying that full amount, because that would mean they're up and running across the board on lines one, two, and three. Still, there's some work for Vale to do on this front. You're right. I think that's probably fairly conservative. Given that, as I said, line one needed two years to reach full level. Line two needed 18 months. Since it's a 90-day completion test, that means you have to add on a quarter.
Randy Smallwood
executiveOnce you kick off that test, roughly a whole quarter of production goes toward meeting it, in a manner of speaking. My sense is there's a decent likelihood the expansion payment won't happen until 2024. We hope it gets made next year, but you know, at the same time, they have to get that line up and running and bring it to those levels. The test is based on — I believe it's 90% of throughput capacity. You know, it's going to be a challenge for them. You know, they're still working toward that. I don't know whether you'd like to add anything.
Wes Carson
executiveThat's a bit above 90% for that item. To reach that, they actually need to reach 35 million.
Randy Smallwood
executiveOkay, that's right.
Wes Carson
executiveA total throughput of 35 million.
Randy Smallwood
executiveRight, my apologies — 35 million, to illustrate the 36 million capacity.
Wes Carson
executiveAbsolutely.
Brian MacArthur
analystSorry, just on that point—if it were 35 out of the 36, that would set off that matrix, and I assume it works the same way all the way up. Let's say they only reached, you know, next year—if they hit the 32, they could actually choose to elect. If they ran it and got that result, you'd simply pay them at 32. But is there a scenario in which they're better off now waiting and trying to push it up to, you know.
Randy Smallwood
executiveRight. 38, and moving ahead roughly a couple of years, so you wouldn't be paying even two years from today, or something like that? It's a single, one-off trigger. They are the party that decides when they wish to start the test. We sit tight across the coming 90-day window and observe what comes out of it. Then, once that concludes, we compensate them according to how they performed during those 90 days. It's a single, one-off trigger. They get just a single opportunity to exercise this. One of the other scenarios that could play out is that they hold off. We're aware there has been talk regarding Salobo Four. On Vale's side, nothing has been committed on Salobo. Another scenario available to them would be to wait, finish Salobo Four, and bring it to that stage. Well, that is easily several years away. With greater throughput capacity, the numbers would rise. It's their call to pick whenever they wish to exercise it. Our best estimate remains that they manage to satisfy it at some point next year. There's likely a bit of conservatism baked into that. I'd say there's a genuine risk it slips into 2024. As I mentioned, I would be glad to make this payment, since that would mean they've sorted out these issues and Salobo is once again the top asset in our portfolio.
Brian MacArthur
analystThat’s great, Randy — I really appreciate the extra detail.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThanks, Brian.
Operator
operatorThank you. Our following question is from Adam Josephson at KeyBanc. You have the floor.
Randy Smallwood
executiveAdam, good to have you here again.
Adam Josephson
analystThank you all, and thank you, Randy. Clearly, I didn’t ask you enough questions earlier. Haytham, would you be willing to walk me through where most of your opportunities are coming from? Are they primarily precious metals mines, or base metals mines? And have you noticed any recent shift along those lines?
Randy Smallwood
executiveSo, look, most of the chances we're seeing have come from precious metals out of base metal mines. There are a few development projects out there that lean more toward precious metals but carry very, very strong margins, and those are looking at precious metal streams too. You know, there are also opportunities, if we were open to it, to take precious metal streams along with a tiny bit of base if that helps a bid. You know, at this point in time, everything we're looking at is focused on precious metals.
Adam Josephson
analystSure, I follow you there. Randy, I believe in earlier months or years you expressed a view — and this ties back to a question asked before regarding your outlook on commodity prices, recognizing that nobody can predict where these prices will head — that silver and gold might decouple, given all the presumed secular opportunities for silver. Clearly, that hasn't occurred. Have you altered your thinking at all on that front? Do you still anticipate silver decoupling from gold at some stage? Any perspective on that would be great.
Randy Smallwood
executiveWell, the basics remain the same. As a precious metal, silver serves as a store of value and a measure of value just like gold, but silver does far more than that. Silver is also used in, you know, high-efficiency electronics, which in the world today are incredibly important — and growing more important constantly. No other noble metal conducts electricity as well as silver does. If your goal is to maximize battery life, to maximize efficiency, processing power, or solar power generation on solar panels, silver is a must. Silver possesses antibacterial properties beyond those of any other noble metal. Again, water purification systems, health applications, you know, silver simply offers so many other things, you know. To me, when you look around the world and consider the challenges society faces in terms of trying to be more efficient and less wasteful, that simply means silver will play a larger role in making sure we use the energy we have as efficiently as we can. That hasn't changed. On that basis, I think silver has the same attributes as a precious metal. Obviously it's not anywhere near as widely accepted as gold, but it carries the same attributes.
Randy Smallwood
executiveA big chunk of society views it like a precious metal and a store of value, yet there's also growing industrial demand that's becoming more vital to society daily. I really do think it'll happen at some point. It has lagged behind gold. The flip side, you know, is that most silver output originates from lead-zinc mines, and I definitely don't see many lead-zinc mines being constructed these days.
Adam Josephson
analystOkay.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThat's a factor that's going to affect overall silver output, you know. There's pressure when it comes to supply, and demand keeps rising on the other side. I think every metric lines up far too neatly for us to overlook it.
Adam Josephson
analystThanks for that. Just one final question, Randy. Regarding the guidance you provide, obviously you give the current year, a 5-year figure, and a 10-year average. Some of your peers provide 5-year and current year. Others provide only the current year and nothing beyond that, and I think Dave said, "Look, we only have so much visibility into the future, so we just don't necessarily think giving 10-year average guidance is appropriate given the visibility we have or don't have." Given all these projects that have been moving around, delayed, et cetera, have you considered perhaps just giving, I don't know, current year and 3-year or current year and 5-year, rather than going out as far as you do, given whatever visibility you have?
Randy Smallwood
executiveAdam, you know, I think data measured at a single point in time matters. Vectors matter too, in my view. By providing 10-year guidance, what we're emphasizing is that this is a continuous uptrend — that we have strength for the next 10 years ahead. You know, I think it's the vector we're discussing, and that vector hasn't changed, right? What we're seeing now is a drop in terms of the overall. The vector — the slope of that vector, the slope of that growth — hasn't changed from where it stood a year ago or six months ago when we put together our prior guidance. You know, that's a key attribute of our portfolio that I think it's important to make sure the investing public grasps. I know our shareholders get it. I mean, it's one of the attributes we have: good long 10-year growth in our portfolio. We've got assets, you know, I think it's close to 40 years of proven and probable reserves and measured and indicated resources. Another, I think it's 19 years of inferred resources after that. There's not another portfolio out there that has that.
Randy Smallwood
executiveI believe it's worth highlighting this regarding our own output projection. We're confident we'll be there. Of course, it will shift. I hope so, you know. I know it will shift, since we're going to make acquisitions over the next 10 years, so without a doubt it will shift. What matters, I think, is demonstrating that our 10-year average guidance exceeds our 5-year guidance. That hasn't changed. That vector remains as strong as it has ever been, and that's the key aspect of ensuring we provide that 10-year guidance. I think if you look across the precious metals industry overall, for many reasons, many companies don't give 10-year guidance because the vector points the wrong way. They have gaps they must fill either through acquisitions or by spending aggressively on organic growth. That's among the reasons it isn't embraced. In our portfolio, we don't see that. You know, I must stress again, one advantage of the streaming business model is that we give precious metal investors access to long-life base-metal operations by investing in and purchasing the non-core byproduct precious metals.
Randy Smallwood
executiveWithin the precious metals space, having a portfolio with such extended life—long reserve life and long resource life—and returning that value is quite unusual. That 10-year guidance is something we feel good about. We believe it matters a great deal that investors out there are aware of it.
Adam Josephson
analystThank you very much, Randy. I truly value the responses you gave to everything I asked.
Randy Smallwood
executiveThanks, Adam, and thanks to everyone for joining us today. To wrap up, we feel we're in a strong position to keep creating value for all our stakeholders, for several reasons. First, our costs are low and predictable, and combined with exposure to rising commodity prices, that gives us some of the best margins anywhere in the precious metals sector. Second, shareholders gain exposure to our diversified portfolio of long-life, low-cost assets, along with the robust organic growth built into it. Third, we return value to shareholders via our distinctive dividend policy tied to cash flow. Finally, we lead among precious metal streamers when it comes to sustainability — by backing our partners and the communities where we live and work. I'm looking forward to talking with all of you again before long. In the meantime, please stay healthy and stay safe. Thank you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Wheaton Precious Metals Corp. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Wheaton Precious Metals Corp. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Wheaton Precious Metals Corp. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.