5E Advanced Materials, Inc. (FEAM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 30, 2023

NASDAQ US Materials Metals and Mining earnings 51 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Davis Snyder

executive
#1

Good afternoon, and thanks for being with us on today's call covering 5E Advanced Materials' fiscal fourth quarter and year-end 2023 results. On this call, management will walk through the earnings press release and a webcast presentation, both of which are available in the investor relations portion of our site. Should you require the press release or the supplemental presentation, reach out to Alpha IR Group at feam@alpha-ir.com. Kindly move to slide two, where our legal disclaimers appear. I'd like to remind everyone that what we say today will include forward-looking statements, such as expectations regarding future results, costs, production, capacity, market dynamics, liquidity, cash spending, and other matters. Actual results could differ materially and adversely from what those forward-looking statements project or discuss. Details about factors that might cause results to differ materially and adversely from these forward-looking statements can be found in the press release issued earlier today, along with disclosures in our public filings with the SEC. The company assumes no obligation to update these forward-looking statements. Today's call might also address non-GAAP financial measures, as defined under Regulation G. Non-GAAP financial measures shouldn't be viewed on their own or as a replacement for financial information presented in accordance with GAAP. Hosting this afternoon's call are 5E's Chief Executive Officer, Susan Brennan; Chief Financial Officer, Paul Weibel; Chief Marketing Officer, J.T. Starzecki; and VP of Operations, Chris Knight. Management will begin with some prepared remarks, and after that, we'll take your questions. At this point, please go to slide three of the PowerPoint, and I'll hand things over to Susan Brennan. Susan?

Susan Brennan

executive
#2

Thanks, Davis, and I appreciate all of you being here with us today. We just wrapped up our 2023 fiscal year. Over the past year, we achieved meaningful strides toward our objectives and continue to stay sharply concentrated on pushing forward the corporate and commercial sides of our 5E Boron Americas project. Looking ahead to fiscal year 2024, we determined it mattered to establish a consistent rhythm of communication with investors worldwide, so this marks our first quarterly earnings call. Today, we'll talk about our current position on the project development timeline. We'll bring you up to speed on our guideposts and walk through the long-term opportunity once more for anyone who is new to 5E and/or thinking about putting money into the company. To start, although I've spoken with a few of you, plenty of faces I haven't met yet. I stepped into the CEO role in late April of this year. Across the bulk of my thirty-year career, I've worked in leadership roles at global organizations spanning the materials, clean tech, and automotive sectors. That wraps up the CEO roles I've held most recently in the battery and EV technology space — Romeo Power, which Nikola Motors picked up last year — and prior to that, I spent eight years as COO at Bloom Energy, a company that leads in fuel cell technology. Going back further, I held a number of operational roles at Ford and Nissan, and early on in my career I was a research assistant at Hercules working on chemical process development. So, as you can see, I have a solid understanding of our end market. I know how to run an early-stage business, and I can build an organization that operates globally. During my first few months, I've met with key personnel, our talented operators and staff, and brought our team into alignment around shared objectives. I can state with certainty that we're on a carefully mapped route to success, and we're putting in the effort to place our company so it generates significant value for our shareholders and stakeholders, both in the coming year and beyond. One question I've frequently heard since starting this role is, what drew me to take the helm here? 5E is a genuinely distinctive project, offering a pure-play opportunity in boric acid along with lithium carbonate in an environmentally responsible manner. Looking at boric acid, the demand picture is very favorable whether you're thinking near term or further out, because this product sits right where a number of fast-growing sectors overlap—sectors that are going to be essential as the world shifts its energy systems. Many of you have been following our story for a long time, so I'd like to bring you up to speed on where our attention is focused at the moment. You already know that two issues in the near term have pushed back some of our timelines: one is the final set of conditions still to come under our EPA permit, and the other is a disagreement over a contract with the firm that had been leading the build-out of our small scale boron facility, or SSBF, which is situated in Newberry Springs, California. To start, our engagement with the EPA remains active, and we'll keep collaborating with them until everything is wrapped up. Under the terms of the EPA permit, we've put in four monitoring wells for water up-gradient and five down-gradient at the initial mining block, plus four injection recovery wells. On top of that, the permit obligated us to plug and abandon every unused, existing, open historic well sitting inside the permit area of review boundary. That work is done, and in October 2022 we sent the EPA all required reports, well completion reports included; a reply on those reports came back to us in May 2023. The EPA's May 2023 reply contained a number of inquiries regarding temperature monitoring at the injection recovery wells, the sealing and closure of old wells, and the legacy Duval boreholes plus the possible impact they could have on groundwater below. In June 2023 we submitted our answer to that EPA correspondence, and we believe all of their remarks have been resolved at this point. Analytical data was used to put together the alert level report mandated by the permit, which establishes alert thresholds for each water monitoring well. That report was delivered to EPA in October 2022 as documentation supporting the authorization to inject process. After the reference submittals are complete and have gone through review, we expect to receive the go-ahead for water injection, which is what we call step-rate testing. It's our understanding that step-rate testing represents the last remaining permit requirement standing between us and completion of the injection approval process. This testing will serve to confirm two things: the porosity of the ore body, along with the formation fracture pressure. With step-rate testing behind us, we look forward to being cleared to inject acid, and that's the point at which mining can get underway. Right now, our attention remains fixed on business fundamentals, and we're advancing the work streams that are within our control. Consider the unfinished final plant commissioning work that the third-party contractor walked away from — a portion of that has been taken on by us; beyond that, our optimization efforts have been moved in-house, and we've held the line on both headcount additions and total spending, which allows us to keep costs under disciplined control and protect our cash position. Paul is going to share additional detail on that in a moment, but I genuinely don't think I could be more proud of how everyone here has come together around prioritizing capital and reducing expenses. And last, we are positioning ourselves for what lies ahead through a wide range of commercial, capital, and other strategic initiatives. During today's call, we'll take you through each of those work streams and give you a clearer picture of the milestones we'll be targeting going forward. Before we dive in, I'd like to recognize that this call includes people who've been with us for a while, folks who've just come aboard, and others who are simply exploring. With that in mind, let's pull back and walk through the core of why we think this is a compelling investment, along with the significant upside ahead of us. I believe the most logical place to begin is with the refreshed images of our small-scale, fully integrated boron plant, which appear on slide 4. As you can see, what we're looking at is an actual operation that's close to being finished — an asset that has generated output before. During the 1980s, three distinct pilot testing initiatives demonstrated that the deposit was leachable. Those efforts yielded several hundred tons of boric acid. Then, in 2017, bench testing confirmed that lithium chloride is recoverable. If you're looking at U.S. production of boric acid and lithium carbonate, the 5E Boron Americas project stands out as the biggest near-term growth opportunity around. Our S-K 1300 Technical Report Summary, which we wrapped up at the start of this year, demonstrates that we own an uncommon boron and lithium resource — and that we're capable of extracting, building out, and turning a profit on it through a sizable commercial-scale operation. On top of that, we've shown both the value and our capacity to bring advanced technology into our operations, especially In Situ Mining/Leaching, which avoids the surface disruption associated with open-pit mining. Our first-mover advantage in the U.S. is underscored on slide five. We're still waiting on the EPA's approval, which is what we need before we can start operations, but all of our required permits are already secured. A lot of you are aware that getting those permits is a major undertaking, and having them is something that shouldn't be taken lightly or undervalued. Beyond holding the permits we need, the 5E Boron Americas project stands apart from what competitors are doing, because our plant is already built and sits on a mineral deposit that has been mined in the past. That puts us in a very strong spot to make our vision a reality soon. We've got the underpinnings of a strong enterprise established, plus a massive chance ahead of us. On top of that, we're pursuing a staged rollout approach across three modules, which once finished will allow us to produce as much as 450,000 short tons of boric acid along with 5,500 short tons of lithium carbonate. Paul will now walk you through that roadmap and share some additional updates. Paul?

Paul Weibel

executive
#3

Thanks, Susan. For the next few minutes, I want to discuss the current status of our 5E Boron Americas project at Fort Cady and the strides we've taken to turn that vision into something real. After that, I'll address what we expect the capital scope to look like as this project moves forward through its modular, multi-phased structure; and last, I'll walk through the specifics of the capital solution strategy we're putting into action so we can secure the funding required to properly finance the project as we scale up production and grow. Let's move to slide 6. As Susan mentioned, when it comes to building our Small Scale Boron Facility at the 5E Boron Americas complex, we've managed to get past the near-term construction difficulties that the prior contractor left behind, and the facility now stands ready to go the moment the EPA grants us authorization to inject. Not long ago, we engaged a new construction contractor to handle the final stretch of construction work and fix any workmanship deficiencies that had been flagged; our local team deserves tremendous credit, since we handled quite a few of the smaller jobs in-house to trim additional costs. What matters most here is that despite the setbacks, we're moving along a path that will get the required construction finished, which lets us fire up the plant as soon as the EPA gives us the necessary clearance. Under our present budget, we expect an additional $5 million will go toward the small-scale facility, with final mechanical completion targeted for mid-October. There are five sections within the small-scale facility: well field, utilities, PLS, boric acid, and gypsum. The well field, utilities, and PLS are set to run. Based on historical data, conditioning the wells in the well field should require 30 to 60 days. The moment EPA authorization to inject arrives, we'll start conditioning the well field with acid right away. After we've built up sufficient PLS, we'll run the back end of the plant — the sections responsible for producing boric acid and gypsum. If authorization to inject comes through, and keeping in mind the historical timeframe needed to condition the well field, we'll be in a strong position to produce boric acid, lithium carbonate, and gypsum. As Susan noted, every permit we need is already in hand, and ours is the sole project in the industry to have entered the construction phase. In fact, we hold the only permitted boron deposit with a commercially viable resource that we expect to come online at some point within the next five-seven years. The progress we've achieved so far reinforces a clear route toward becoming a top boric acid and lithium supplier in North America. This complex has gone from being land and an idle mineral deposit to what will shortly become the first commercial-scale boric acid producer in decades; we've invested more than two years and logged hundreds of thousands of work hours with zero 5E lost time injuries. We are transforming the 5E Boron Americas site from a project into an operating business. Back in May, we hit a major milestone for our project development schedule when we updated the Technical Report Summary. What that report shows is a world-class mineral deposit, with revised resource estimates for boric acid and lithium carbonate, and it also features a thorough economic analysis backed by a multi-phased strategy for scaling up output at the commercial facility. To help shape our capital estimates, we brought in two prominent EPC firms. The technical report summary lays out a timeline and metrics we intend to hit, and the project economics show highly appealing return targets and IRRs tied to the resource and the plan. A phased approach is laid out in the report. That approach gives the company the means to scale production in a modular, de-risked way. Altogether, the report shows a multi-generational asset with a 31-year mine life plus a future exploration target for expansion that will underpin substantial boric acid and lithium output. On slide 6, you can see that our staged, multi-phase business model offers modular optionality. Our execution plan is realistic, and the approach lets us make economic decisions and fine-tune our timeline, schedule, cost structure, and capital deployment. Since we think we're on the verge of being able to run the small-scale facility, and given our inherently conservative stance on risk, we'll keep most of this discussion focused on financing phase one of the commercial project. Under the phase one plan as it stands, we'll aim for production of 90,000 short tons of Boric Acid and 1,100 short tons of Lithium Carbonate. Phase one development carries an estimated capital requirement of about $389 million, all in. Once again, those costs are distributed across a planned three-year period. What's more, out of that $389 million, our expected first-year needs in phase one come to just over $37 million, which is a much smaller figure compared with the total capital scope mentioned in our report. In addition, we intend to further refine the report once FEL 2 engineering is finished, and that work is set to begin in February, assuming we get the final clearance from the EPA soon. That initial $37 million covers development work including expanding infrastructure, optimizing cost data for FEL 2 engineering following operation of the small scale facility, expansion of our water supply wells, and initial down payments on long lead item equipment once we refresh the technical report summary. On the economics side, the technical report summary reveals that the 90,000 short tons of boric acid production and 1,100 short tons of lithium carbonate should produce more than $101 million of EBITDA each year. Those projected results point to very appealing returns on a standalone basis, with EBITDA margins above 62%. In short, we believe our production activities will be highly profitable and that we'll be able to partially self-fund future expansions. Please turn to slide 7 for an update on our cash position and cost plans. At the close of the quarter, our cash stood at $20.3 million on June 30, 2023. As Susan mentioned, we've implemented measures that substantially lowered our cash burn during the fourth quarter of the fiscal year's end, and that has carried over into the first quarter of the new fiscal year. While we wait to satisfy the EPA's last remaining condition, we're still actively holding discussions with our investment partners and other possible funding sources to secure more capital. Slide 8 provides a summary of this, showing an illustrative capital structure and model for funding phase one of our project development; our aim is to draw on a blended mix of capital sources optimized for both size and cost; that blended mix covers equity investment, debt capital, and non-dilutive equity, as reflected in mineral rights, royalty schemes, and prepayments. Our strategy has us chasing several buckets of capital. Tapping traditional equity capital markets is part of our capital plan, and for phase one we've conservatively set aside roughly 25% for equity financing. We expect to combine any equity financing with non-dilutive financing, including mineral royalties and customer prepayments. A royalty is especially appealing because it's inherently non-dilutive and permits the funding risk to shift to the capital provider itself once commercial production begins; when it comes to customer-led funding solutions, we think the overall value proposition is compelling enough for those who view our boric acid and lithium carbonate production as material and important to their own strategic business needs. That would let 5E capture value upfront and apply a prepayment of funds toward last construction activities, in return for either prepaid volume or an upfront investment to lock in allocations of our production volume. The remaining bucket consists of debt capital from government agencies and/or project finance, and our preference is to seek loans through government agencies, which J.T. will cover in more detail. With a potential model of 50% government and/or project finance, 25% equity, and 25% non-dilutive options, this model would produce highly attractive returns for all of our stakeholders. With that, I'll hand the call over to J.T. Starzecki, our Chief Marketing Officer, to highlight a few recent developments. J.T.?

J.T. Starzecki

executive
#4

Thanks, Paul. Let's move to slide 9. In the next several minutes, I want to discuss the unified approach we're pursuing — one that brings together commercial buyers, the U.S. Government's Loan Programs Office, the Department of Defense's DPA Title III program, and our capital markets effort — all aimed at reaching a favorable result: securing the funds needed to build the 5E Boron Americas Complex commercially. The opening piece of this approach concerns the way we're tackling our commercial prospects and shifts in the market. Once our small-scale boron plant is up and running, we'll be able to hold far more substantive talks with prospective offtake buyers. For any commercial relationship we establish, product validation matters most, and when boric acid comes straight from our own ore body, produced to rigorous technical specifications, we stand on equal footing with our rivals; it also lets us enter offtake contract negotiations from a position of strength instead of merely pointing to a hypothetical future product; it puts us squarely in the present as the newest domestic maker of boric acid. As Susan noted before, several commercial LOIs are already in place, giving us a foundation, and we keep holding discussions with a range of potential partners whose focus is pushing our long-term material strategy forward. Our government affairs approach, backed by our allies in Washington, D.C., centers on creating and widening chances for 5E to work with agencies through major defense and clean energy funding programs — specifically the Departments of Defense, Interior, and Energy. Thanks to recent talks with agency leadership, among them a 5E site visit that drew more than a dozen senior DoD and DOE staff members, we've pinpointed priority areas for advocacy and for federal partnership. Since the Department of Defense classifies boron as a strategic and critical material for the defense industrial base, we see substantial room to team up with the DoD on locking in a new domestic boron supply chain. Though timelines and due diligence processes always bind us, we're genuinely enthusiastic about what's possible with the Department of Defense in the near term to lessen our defense industrial base's reliance on suppliers abroad. That leads us to the Department of Energy and its Loans Program Office, or LPO. The LPO has, in essence, three stages: pre-application, technical eligibility, and project readiness. Every stage carries a different level of due diligence and assessment against strict criteria. As an organization, we grasp each of the three stages very clearly and intend to work our way through this process. We're firmly convinced that our base case for eligibility satisfies the required criteria, and we're strategically engaging and sitting down with stakeholders to talk over our project, prepare white papers, and get our application underway. Now let's turn to today's market for boron and boron derivatives, and to how we anticipate that market will grow quickly. Please go to slide 10. The chart on the left makes clear that the traditional boron markets have been strong, with well-established opportunities across multiple glass types, micronutrients, and advanced ceramics. On top of that, developing opportunities exist in permanent magnets, wind, and solar technologies. That said, as the world increasingly focuses on sustainable solutions, we expect the boron market to speed up even more. Taking everything together, and according to the International Energy Agency report, this should generate no less than 1.6 million tons of additional demand within the coming several years. At present, a Turkish government-owned entity controls roughly 65% of global supply. With the U.S. government emphasizing onshoring of critical infrastructure and materials, you can see the tremendous opportunity before us to become one of the leading domestic U.S. suppliers. Slide 11 puts this opportunity into even broader context. Looking at the macro picture, the gap between current boric acid supply and product demand keeps growing quarter over quarter; that imbalance between supply and demand is shown further across the coming five years in the chart on the right. Since no major new projects besides 5E are expected to come online in the near term, this ecosystem will remain under strain for decades ahead; alongside our boric acid production, we will also be able to demonstrate our DLE technology to the market and deliver lithium carbonate to customers for validation and commercial discussions. Given how parabolically the price of lithium has risen over the last few years, this turns into a highly meaningful revenue stream for our company. As an organization, we are lucky to be introducing to the market two key strategic materials that are required in a variety of applications across the battery technology, defense, energy, and food security sectors. Because so many boron applications exist already, we see a path forward to push our commercial agenda ahead by seizing on the demand for additional decarbonization technologies. Turning next to the EV space, growth in boric acid demand is expected to speed up since these vehicles need touchscreens, fiberglass for the body, and permanent magnets for the motors, to name just a few examples; furthermore, our co-product stream of lithium carbonate is badly needed as another domestic source of critical mineral. As I mentioned, boron is likewise essential to permanent magnets, which serve a broad range of applications, though most notably in wind turbines and electric vehicles. Neodymium permanent magnets, the type most commonly used and produced in today's clean energy space, are made up of rare earth elements and ferroboron. Beyond clean energy uses, permanent magnets are also vital to the U.S. defense industrial base. The fiscal year 2021 and fiscal year 2023 National Defense Authorization Acts, a national defense bill passed each year, contained magnet sourcing requirements for the Department of Defense. Under the fiscal year 2021 bill, DoD is barred from procuring permanent magnet materials, understood to include ferroboron, from China, Iran, North Korea, or Russia. In the previous year, Congress expanded upon that ban and put in place a fresh mandate for Department of Defense contractors to reveal the province and thorough supply networks for materials contained in permanent magnets, which is interpreted as covering the obligation to report the location where boron within a magnet obtained by the DoD is extracted, processed, and turned into the magnet. Such regulations reflect rising apprehension among Congress and the Defense Department regarding permanent magnet supply networks as well as Ferroboron supply networks. That said, this represents merely a single illustration of how boron is utilized in defense-related goods... Boron serves as a component in things such as sophisticated ceramics employed by the aerospace industry, and also Boron Carbide in goods such as body and tank armor. As we ready our supply to serve these market possibilities, it brings us to an ideal transition into our government affairs initiative and the funding possibilities connected to it. Thus, as you can observe, the market for boron and sophisticated boron derivatives is diverse at present and is anticipated to expand at a quicker rate in the years ahead. One thing I have not yet addressed is the enormous applications for boron derivatives in defense-related goods. Boron is a component in things such as sophisticated ceramics employed by the aerospace industry, boron carbide in goods such as body and tank armor, extending all the way to fuel and rocket propulsion technologies. Having said that, I will hand it back to Susan for some closing comments.

Susan Brennan

executive
#5

We appreciate you joining us on this earnings call. On slide 12, you'll see the same project milestone chart that we provided when the technical report came out, which covers both the SSBF and the engineering design for the phase I commercial plant. I want to unpack that a bit more by walking through the phase I commercial plant specifics on slide 13. That covers making boric acid and lithium carbonate, moving commercial talks forward once those two products are being produced and have been qualified, advancing the initial stage of the commercial engineering design, and strengthening our technical group, which unlocks the following stage of commercial funding. Let's wrap up our prepared comments with a brief look at our main investment highlights on slide 14. To start, we hold a distinctive and scarce asset that gives exposure to the critical minerals boron and lithium. Those materials are set to matter greatly for U.S. reshoring, decarbonization, and the homegrown output needed by the clean energy economy. The 5E Boron Americas project already has a completely built plant sitting on a mineral deposit with a history of operation, and the U.S. government has labeled it critical infrastructure. The initial facility was constructed to support both near-term and long-term production capability. On top of that, our multi-staged execution model hands us meaningful optionality across the project life cycle, which lets us fine-tune our decisions as we move through our timeline. And last, 5E is positioned to become a major global business, with anticipated yearly EBITDA of $682 million at the point full production capacity is achieved. As I always do, I want to express gratitude to the whole team at 5E Advanced Materials for their dedication and efforts as we work to create long-term value for our shareholders. With that said, we'll now take your questions. Operator?

Matt Summerville

analyst
#6

Thank you. I have a few things to ask. To start, could you perhaps refresh our memory on which pricing assumptions underlie the EBITDA forecasts you laid out for each stage? After that, could you discuss when the market is anticipated to move into a tight and more or less lasting — at least for now — shortage situation when it comes to boric acid? Then I have one more question. Thanks.

Susan Brennan

executive
#7

All right. Thanks, Matt. I'll — Paul, would you like to handle that one, and J.T., you can speak to the market.

Paul Weibel

executive
#8

Yeah, thanks. So for that initial complete year, the price comes to roughly $1,700 a ton, and, you know, from that point we expect it to climb, pushed along by the shortage in supply. And after that, J.T., would you like to move on to-

J.T. Starzecki

executive
#9

Yeah

Paul Weibel

executive
#10

... the deficit?

J.T. Starzecki

executive
#11

Yeah. Thanks for joining us, Matt. We truly appreciate it. So when you look at it through the lens of a market shortfall, what we actually observed during quarter 3 and quarter 4 of the prior year was that every bit of supply reaching the market had already been claimed. That identical pattern showed up in quarter 1 and quarter 2; so as we keep introducing more and more technologies, we find ourselves, we find ourselves sitting at that tipping point as of today; so just a minor bump upward in demand will be enough for demand to overtake production or capacity. So we are, we are basically standing at that precipice at this very moment.

Matt Summerville

analyst
#12

Understood. Thanks for that. Then, as a quick follow-up, could you explain what goes into your choice between selling SSBF output to prospective buyers and using that same output to begin advancing your advanced material strategy?

J.T. Starzecki

executive
#13

Yes, of course, Matt. Let's begin with the output itself. As we've said publicly, we've discussed the 2,000 tons that SSBF will initially produce; we've also stated publicly that we plan to raise that output to a somewhat larger scale, which is going to give us a few different opportunities. First, the first product leaving the plant will be used for product qualification to solidify all our talks regarding offtake, tonnage, and pricing; so that's the first product going out. As Chris and his team begin scaling production and we raise the run rate, we'll then be able to take that product and sell it on the spot market and potentially even serve some offtake customers early. Our intention is to take the product, complete qualification with our identified customer base, and then put the remaining product into the market as a sellable product.

Matt Summerville

analyst
#14

Matt, as a brief follow-up on that point: if you consider the timeline, so to speak, how much time passes between when you start getting good material from the back end of the process and when the product becomes qualified? And how long is needed to push SSBF output up to the point where you're starting to sell into the spot market?

Susan Brennan

executive
#15

Sure, Matt — I'll let Chris handle that one.

Chris Knight

executive
#16

Yes, thanks, Matt. So we figure we'll likely need roughly 60 days before that plant is operational; we recognize there are certain unique hurdles, just like every startup encounters. Those will come our way, and we'll have to resolve them. We've already reached out to a number of key clients—the ones holding LOIs with us—and we've had conversations with them; their expected qualification timeline runs somewhere from three to six months, and that applies to achieving full commercial qualification. Once we reach that stage, we can begin putting product out into the marketplace and truly figuring out those supply chains.

Matt Summerville

analyst
#17

Understood. Thank you, guys.

J.T. Starzecki

executive
#18

Thanks, Matt.

Susan Brennan

executive
#19

Yes, thanks.

Ben Kallo

analyst
#20

Hi there — I appreciate everyone letting me ask something, and I'm grateful for this call. So, to start with, it does seem as though demand exists, and one thing is that, given Turkey ranks as the largest producer, in what ways have you noticed any shifts when you talk with customers? I'd assume folks grasp the shortfall that's approaching, as you explain it step by step. But how exactly does that alter the conversations customers have with you?

Susan Brennan

executive
#21

Right — J.T., could you handle that one and perhaps also address what it means on the government side as well?

J.T. Starzecki

executive
#22

Absolutely. It's great to speak with you, Ben. And thanks once more for being here. When it comes to how customers are evolving, what we're seeing are really unmistakable indications that the customers we're talking with want to spread their sourcing across more suppliers. So there are certain issues — we'd describe them as product quality concerns — that arise simply from transportation, from a delivery standpoint, depending on which part of the world the product originates in. But one unmistakable indication from everyone we've had conversations with, and those conversations are very much continuing, is that they need to diversify, to avoid being locked in with a single supplier or even a pair of suppliers, because of the risk that naturally comes with both product availability and pricing. So that, I'd say, is the one clearest defining feature we've observed across these commercial discussions during this year so far.

Ben Kallo

analyst
#23

Ben, thanks, and Christie, thank you too. Regarding how we handle our cash position, this multi-part approach—Susan, since you were at Romeo, you witnessed everyone making deposits for cells during those really tight periods. Could we potentially set up an arrangement with a partner in which they contribute capital?

Susan Brennan

executive
#24

Absolutely, Ben, that's a great observation. Given what we've discussed about the shortfall, the straightforward response would be affirmative, and the chance to sell in advance, much like that selling pattern, is certainly something we are looking into.

Ben Kallo

analyst
#25

All right. And last thing from me — you mentioned having every permit required, yet Susan, I believe you noted there's a certain EPA approval needed regarding the injection wells. Would you mind clearing that up? Thanks so much, everyone.

Susan Brennan

executive
#26

Yes, so — and I appreciate you raising it, since this comes up a lot, and I want us to be truly clear on it. A permit exists; attached to it are conditions, and since this ore body, as we've mentioned, saw experimental activity previously, we have — those conditions cover efforts we've completed along with wrapping up work left from before. So the EPA's conditions must be satisfied by us, and after the data and assurances have been provided to them, we can proceed. So what we're working on isn't the permit itself; it's actually getting the conditions lifted from it.

Ben Kallo

analyst
#27

... Okay, thanks.

Susan Brennan

executive
#28

Thank you for the question.

Matthew Key

analyst
#29

Hi, thanks for fielding my questions. I was hoping maybe you could provide a bit more specifics regarding when the government financing path might move forward. And if all goes well with that, perhaps you could also tell us something about how much you might be able to get from the DPA Title III program, in particular?

Susan Brennan

executive
#30

Yeah. J.T., do you want to handle that one?

J.T. Starzecki

executive
#31

Absolutely, it's great to speak with you, Matt, and I appreciate you being on the call. I believe the cleanest approach is to divide this into a couple of categories; and just as you correctly pointed out, there genuinely are — you have the DPA Title III Act, which falls under the Department of Defense. So I'll begin there. The central instrument in that case is really an attachment to different components that feed into either military technology or the supply chains involved in producing that technology. With the DOD, applying for funding initiatives is somewhat more direct. Basically, you prepare a white paper, then you work through a number of conversations directly with the Department of Defense. Once you've presented your case, you submit your request for funds, and that request gets incorporated into an appropriations bill; that bill is currently being negotiated for next year and happens on a yearly cycle. So the DPA Title III and the DoD represent what we'd describe as a nearer-term route to funding; after that, once you're dealing with the Department of Energy and their loan program office, there's a multi-step process, which I referenced during my opening remarks, that involves roughly three phases. As you progress through those phases, the level of due diligence you undergo changes, correct? You're discussing the project itself, the detailed engineering, the construction schedule; and because of that, the project or program requires somewhat more time. Published DOE reports show an average of roughly 12 months to complete something, and most likely that could run a bit longer. Even so, the amount of capital accessible through that program is substantial. So in terms of how we intend to structure the capital, I'd say the Department of Defense moves faster toward funding, but the- The bigger share of the funding will probably come through the Loans Program Office.

Matthew Key

analyst
#32

Understood. That is genuinely useful, Paul or J.T. — I appreciate it. And I suppose I have just one additional question. During your prepared remarks, you noted that certain actions have been taken to lower overhead expenses. For fiscal year 2024, what would be a reasonable assumption regarding cash burn each quarter? Clearly, that excludes the $37 million of CapEx spending, which is of course an estimate.

Susan Brennan

executive
#33

Yeah. I will begin, and then, Paul, if you would like to jump in at the end. First, let me reframe things. When I arrived back in May, we made the company's scope narrower, and we remain an advanced material company, but, you know, what I refer to as the order of operations. We cut back so that today we spend only on items that will bring boric acid out of the ground. Going forward, once boric acid starts coming, some of our spending actually will need to rise, because at that point we must purchase certain materials that we are not purchasing today. So this is a grade, and it was sort of a... If you were looking at a graph, we moved from one level down to a lower level; we will stay at that lower level, and then, since we have aligned the work Chris and his team are doing in operations with what we believe the EPA timing is, so that everything comes together at once, and then we start, and then we ramp up. So, Paul, would you like to add anything more-

Paul Weibel

executive
#34

Yeah.

Susan Brennan

executive
#35

Context to that?

Paul Weibel

executive
#36

Thanks for asking that. To echo what Susan mentioned, after she joined, the leadership team assembled and basically pinpointed, “Alright, which items are essential and which ones can be cut?” Over the past 2 months, we’ve made a significant reduction in our administrative spend, and that same rate will continue going forward. From an internal standpoint, our target for pure G&A is roughly $1.5 per month. Then, once we gain clarity on the permit, we can adjust and retain the flexibility to scale up or down.

Matthew Key

analyst
#37

Understood — that clears things up nicely. That's all I had. Thanks so much for your time, and best of luck from here on.

Susan Brennan

executive
#38

Thanks.

Paul Weibel

executive
#39

Thank you.

Tate Sullivan

analyst
#40

Hello, and thanks. Good afternoon. So, regarding what you brought up — I believe you referred to an extra $5 million in CapEx tied to the SSBF. Could you walk us through where that money is headed? We'd appreciate a bit more specifics on it.

Susan Brennan

executive
#41

Alright, let's hand it over to you, Chris. Thanks, Tate, for asking that.

Chris Knight

executive
#42

Okay, sure. Thanks, Tate. So here's where things stand for us right now, Tate. We discussed those five separate areas. In PLS and in our utility areas, we're mechanically complete and commissioned. On the well field, we're wrapping up. We basically just took that apart to get ready for step-rate testing, and after that we'll put it back together. So really only small dollars there. Most of the cost is going toward just finishing the piping and the electrical work that's needed in the boric acid and the gypsum areas... and some continuing spend, you know, cranes, you know, welding machines, some leased equipment that we're using to finish that construction.

Tate Sullivan

analyst
#43

Thanks, Betsy. And on that same note, I mean, is there anything like an unpaid balance or something along those lines from the continuing disagreement with Matrix that we ought to factor in?

Susan Brennan

executive
#44

Yeah, and I... Yeah, we aren't going to take any questions, but, you know, since this is active litigation, we can't answer anything on that subject right now.

Tate Sullivan

analyst
#45

Got it. Then regarding SSBF output — Jason, you touched on this before — that goal of 9,000 short tons of boric acid. Has some approximate share of that already been discussed when it comes to quality testing and possible off-take?

Chris Knight

executive
#46

Right. So a portion of that will be allocated toward qualifications. And a number of the prospects we're engaged with, as you know, operate multiple locations. Every one of those locations will need commercial-scale volumes — you know, complete shipments of material to process through their facility; but from an overall testing standpoint, that really won't represent a significant amount. So after we get that material tested, and we keep moving forward with that production, once it's been cleared, at that point we ought to have volume ready for sales.

Tate Sullivan

analyst
#47

Alright, thanks everybody.

Susan Brennan

executive
#48

Thanks for asking that, Tate.

Susan Brennan

executive
#49

Thanks, every-

Susan Brennan

executive
#50

Thanks, all of you, for giving us your time and attention regarding 5E Advanced Materials, Inc. Ahead of us sits an enormous chance for us to turn into the world's most recent producers of boric acid and lithium. With our go-forward team working on the ground and getting things done each day, we possess the culture, execution, and leadership. Our asset is proven, and we have a plan to grow it in a modular way across the coming several years. All of us are eager to take you along on this journey.

Operator

operator
#51

Appreciate it. That wraps up the call for today. At this point you're free to hang up your phones. Thanks for joining us.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete 5E Advanced Materials, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to 5E Advanced Materials, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in 5E Advanced Materials, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.