5E Advanced Materials, Inc. (FEAM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 21, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Joseph Caminiti
executiveGood afternoon, everyone, and thanks for being with us on this call for the 5E Advanced Materials Fiscal First Quarter 2025 Shareholder Update. On today's call, management will be referring to a press release and a presentation, both available in the investor relations area of our site; if you'd like a copy of that release or the supplemental deck, reach out to Alpha IR Group at feam@alpha-ir.com, or simply visit the investor relations page on our website. Kindly navigate to slide 2 in the presentation, where our legal disclaimers appear. Just a reminder that what we say on this call today will include forward-looking statements, among them our expectations regarding future results, future operational initiatives, costs and cost savings, production capacity, capital expenditures and capital savings, market dynamics, liquidity, cash spending, and other items. Actual results could differ materially or adversely from what these forward-looking statements project or discuss. Further details about factors that might cause results to differ materially or adversely from these forward-looking statements can be found in our annual report on Form 10-K filed with the SEC on September 9th, 2024, and as updated periodically in our other public filings with the SEC. The company has no obligation to update forward-looking statements. This afternoon's call is being hosted by Paul Weibel, 5E's Chief Executive Officer, Rod McLean, Vice President of Engineering and Construction, and Mark Zamek, Vice President of Commercial Products. Management will begin with some prepared remarks, and after that, we'll open things up for your questions. At this point, please go to slide 3 in the presentation for a corporate update. I'll now hand things over to Paul. Paul?
Paul Weibel
executiveThanks, Joe. And thanks to all of you for being here today. A bit more than 2 months back, when we last had this conversation, we shared a roadmap for the strategic moves coming next — one that would establish foundations in 2 essential areas: our initial commercial engineering phase, along with our approach to customer commitments. I'm happy to report that since that prior update, we at 5E feel we've achieved substantial headway on quite a few of the main focus areas capable of continuing to propel our success in those 2 essential areas. We're moving nearer to bringing key project-advancing catalysts to fruition, and we're positioned strongly to meet our near-term and longer-term objectives while building the base for ongoing shareholder value creation. We'd like to take this moment to make sure we provide prompt updates to our investors, stakeholders, and the wider market as we get ready for the calendar year that lies ahead and aim toward a financial investment decision at the close of calendar year 2025. On this quarterly update call, I'm delighted to have with me 2 of 5E's senior leaders who are assisting in moving the company along its strategic roadmap. Today, you'll have an opportunity to hear from Rod McLean, our Vice President of Engineering and Construction, and also Mark Zamek, our Vice President of Commercial Products. Rod and Mark both hold essential roles in 5E's development, and we're thrilled for the chance to acquaint our shareholders and wider stakeholders with what they're achieving currently and going forward. Each of them will offer some prepared remarks regarding their respective focus areas within our operational and commercial strategies, and both will be with me to take further questions during our live Q&A session. To start, on slide 4, I want to give the market a quick state of the union regarding our 5E Boron Americas project and the company overall. Today I'll walk through three things: where we stand at our small-scale facility, the first stage of commercial engineering, and our commercial activities. When we spoke last month, we noted that we'd made meaningful progress on the plant operations side. The strongest proof of that is the plant team hitting consistent operating rates while achieving much higher purity in boric acid output and doing away with calcium and other metal salts in a sustainable way. The maintenance challenges we faced earlier in the prior quarter, along with the difficulties that come with starting up a new facility, are now behind us, thanks to operations leadership applying serious focus and operational discipline to deliver stronger and steadier run rates. More specifically, our operations team concentrated on improving the full production process. They did this by reworking and upgrading the facility's conveyor systems, which in the past had created bottlenecks. They also optimized the FEED rates for the boric acid belt filter after trying out different approaches to boost purity and yield. They programmed our crystallization unit so that distillation happens continuously. And they added new spray nozzles to our belt filter, which allowed us to optimize flow and keep sulfur rates under 100 ppm. These were key steps because they enhanced boric acid consistency and overall product quality, and also helped make sure we can consistently surpass the specifications that our prospective customers require. Just last week, that effort culminated in a major corporate achievement: we shipped our initial full truckload of super sacks containing boric acid to a buyer out in the Western United States. Per what we shared in our press release, we're now reliably turning out one short ton of boric acid each day. We chose that production pace on purpose, since it struck the best balance between two things we really needed. For one, running at that level yields sufficient sample material for 5E to keep backing our customer qualification work as it moves forward. And up to now, the response we've gotten from companies that are interested or potentially buying has only gotten better. Additionally, we believe this output level strikes the right equilibrium between what we spend to operate and the liquidity we currently hold, so that our cash gets deployed as efficiently as possible while we keep building out the data we need for our commercial approach. Our attention has been squarely on refining how the organization is structured, finding a reasonable middle ground between growing the business and squeezing the greatest return from the funds we have available. We've worked hard to cut away expenses that serve no purpose, along with any overhead weight that doesn't truly fit what this company requires. Along those lines, we've just carried out a strategic workforce reduction. The goals were to streamline our team, cut both fixed and variable operating expenses, and achieve better efficiency given where production currently stands. Our estimate is that this move may generate roughly $2.2 million in savings on operating expenditures during the next calendar year. That leads into what I first raised regarding how we make decisions and plan ahead when it comes to our byproduct strategy. From the time I stepped into the CEO position in June, we've kept examining different byproducts through economic, technical, and operational perspectives. The two byproducts we've concentrated on most are gypsum and calcium chloride. We've now chosen to move forward with a calcium chloride byproduct, fold it into the commercial foundation of our design, and aim for partnerships and offtake agreements with several strategic parties. Taken as a whole, this strikes us as a sound move both strategically and in terms of synergy, for the reasons we'll lay out in a moment. With that, I'll hand things over to Rod, who will walk through why we made this call and bring everyone up to date on where we stand on the path to FID.
Rod McLean
executivePaul, thank you, and good afternoon, everyone. Please open to slide six, since that's where I'll begin my comments. In our review of calcium chloride, we compared it with gypsum using the pillars of technical and operational ease, logistics, commercial factors, and economic variables. After setting out the advantages and disadvantages, we are convinced that proceeding with our calcium chloride represents the best path forward for the company. Our commercial basis of design now incorporates calcium chloride. At commercial scale, our goal is to sell 38% calcium chloride in solution, which reflects market feedback along with initial samples given to customers. We've found through our market studies that there's strong demand across the Southwestern United States, since that region serves a range of industrial and agricultural sectors. Fundamentally, calcium chloride plays a role in controlling dust, melting ice on roads, and it's a staple in oil and gas operations, plus it shows up in numerous food-related and farming uses. Speaking more technically, handling and distributing calcium chloride in its solution form is a more straightforward undertaking than the work required to purify a high-grade gypsum. From an operations standpoint, concentrating on calcium chloride should let us cut staffing once we reach commercial volumes, simplify things by no longer needing to make two high-purity solid products at large scale, make the workplace safer since sulfuric acid would no longer be part of the process, and bring about lower upkeep expenses and fewer maintenance demands. But what matters even more here is that we expect to cut commercial CapEx by roughly 15%, since this approach could shrink how much solids-handling machinery is needed for gypsum production and make our design less complex. Those projected savings on capital and costs, combined with a commercial market we see as robust enough to push cash costs down to levels that can compete with gypsum, are what backed our strategic choice to proceed with calcium chloride. Now, please turn to slide seven, where I want to spend a moment covering where we stand on the commercial design, plus the key upcoming steps and the timeline we expect over the next 12 months as we work toward reaching FID. We're making solid headway in the initial commercial engineering stage, and we've put key project documents in place — things like our project management system, the project charter, our strategy for the project, a thorough risk register, and a plan for executing the project. Now, since we intend to define the scope, optimize it, and bring CapEx down by adding calcium chloride to our basis of design, we expect Fluor to deliver our capital estimate by spring 2025 at the latest. Once we have that capital estimate, it will trigger an update to our technical report before we move through the stage gate into FEL-3, which is also referred to as FEED engineering; we expect that FEED engineering work to take seven to eight months, which puts us in position to aim for a financial investment decision in the latter part of calendar year 2025. I'm going to hand things over to Mark now so he can walk us through how our commercial efforts are going and what our strategy looks like. Mark.
Mark Zamek
executiveThank you, Rod. To start, I want to say how thrilled I am to join this organization as someone who has spent a long career in the Boron Value Chain, and I see 5E as a newcomer to the market that is positioned quite well. My comments will start on slide eight. Like Paul said, we reached a significant milestone last week when we made our initial delivery of a full truckload of product to a buyer in the Western United States. That initial truckload sale consisted of 22 super sacks and will serve as an offset against the operating costs of our small-scale facility. In addition, we managed to send one super sack to a sizable domestic producer of cellulose insulation so they could test it. When we consider how we are developing our commercial approach, our plan is to concentrate on segmenting customers by going after those with high margin profiles and low cost to serve. During commercial phase one, we have just 90,000 tons of production, and that level of output gives us greater optionality since we can be extremely selective about where we direct those initial 90,000 tons. The customers we intend to serve will support sectors such as wind energy, LCD glass, insulation, traditional oil and gas, cellulose insulation, and construction. Boric acid is essential in so many industries, and we feel we have the luxury of being selective. Not long ago, we brought on Kenneth Hu as Vice President of Commercial Products Asia. Kenneth will act as my counterpart, concentrating specifically on the Asia-Pacific market. Kenneth also brings multiple decades of substantial and direct experience in global sales and marketing of borates, working with both producers and consumers. We feel that adding Kenneth to our team fits directly with our broadened commercial strategy. By also going after the APAC region, we can perform an additional layer of strategic market segmentation for our volumes, which ensures we maintain a solid balance of diversification across consistently growing demand and a strong pricing profile. This fits well with our strategic aim of targeting customers that have high margins and low overall cost to serve, both in APAC and here at home. As a West Coast project with a logistical edge when it comes to California ports, the plan to serve the APAC region matches 5E's objectives; for context, Asia represents the biggest center for global borates demand, and we think that market is rich with opportunity, with numerous potential buyers and targeted industries. Achieving success there can open expanded pathways to significant long-term returns for our business. Although up to now our commercial focus has mostly been directed at customers based in the U.S., our wider strategy and vision envisions 5E becoming a global leader, and that requires making sure we take part everywhere there is solid demand for what we can produce. Kenneth and I together mean that 5E can now reach, geographically speaking, over 80% of worldwide borate demand; that's going to be a major strategic driver, and the speed of the success we've had so far has us excited; with a solid plan in place for going after customers, our focus shifts to Heads of Agreement and offtake agreements so we can lock in our pipeline with bankable customers; right now we can see a path to offtake for the initial 25%-50% of our 90,000 tons, and our goal is to have tonnage committed for the entirety of phase two by spring of 2025. Holding agreements like these will reinforce and bring a higher level of predictability to 5E's forward economics, which in turn boosts our capacity to secure the capital needed to fund the project. Our view is that offtake agreements and HOAs extending beyond that initial 90,000 tons will bolster 5E's legitimacy in the market as a global operator, show the confidence customers place in our business, and highlight the need for 5E to come online at commercial scale; in turn, we expect that executing successfully on this front can cement a pathway toward long-term shareholder value creation, reduce the risk across the overall corporate profile, and further reinforce 5E's legitimacy as an investable entity in the global capital markets. I'm eager to keep our shareholders and stakeholders informed about our commercial progress as we move ahead, and with that, I'll hand the presentation back to Paul.
Paul Weibel
executiveThanks, Mark. So moving on to slide 8, I want to take a short while to talk about how we're approaching capital and funding. On our prior earnings call back in September, we mentioned that 5E had filed its first application with the Export-Import Bank of the United States, seeking a guarantee tied to a loan for financing project debt. Over the quarter, we got a non-binding letter of intent laying out the possibility of establishing a facility worth $285 million in debt, which would serve as a backstop for either a private sector loan or a capital commitment under EXIM's Made in America initiative. If we secure that potential guarantee on the debt funding, it should cover a large share of what we need in development capital for phase one of our commercial project. Getting this LOI from EXIM represents a highly significant milestone on the path to financing the project on the most favorable terms. On top of that, the LOI could improve our credit profile, offering a potential route to obtaining the capital required to build a commercial facility, and it puts us in position for our objective of producing for customers and generating cash flow at phase one commercial. To capitalize on this positive EXIM progress, our next move involves submitting the official application to EXIM. We expect that submission to occur shortly after the company wraps up phase one of its commercial engineering design in early 2025. While this represents meaningful forward momentum in how we fund the business, it's important to recognize that this is just one avenue we're pursuing. Our broader strategy—tapping federal funding programs, exploring non-dilutive royalty arrangements, and securing extra private capital for both immediate and future needs—remains in play and ongoing. We continue to chase various funding sources through our outstanding applications to the U.S. government, especially with the U.S. Department of Defense in connection with the DPA, plus pending applications we've submitted to the U.S. Department of Energy. As we wait for more clarity regarding where those funding applications stand, we keep advocating for congressional support and its backing of boron produced domestically and its derivative products. We're also continuing to work alongside our partners in Washington to boost the chances that boron gets added to the USGS's critical minerals list, which would further enhance 5E's capacity to access federal funding and to finance 5E for commercial production. I'll finish my prepared remarks by giving a summary here. Over just a handful of months, 5E has made solid headway on multiple key pieces of our strategy and forward-looking plan. At our small-scale plant, boric acid output has settled into a steady, consistent pattern, and that's matched by improved quality across the board. The volumes we're generating are tuned to what our customer qualification process—both current and progressing—calls for, and to the liquidity position we have today. Given the distinctive characteristics of our ore body, we'll now fold calcium chloride, as a byproduct, into the design basis for the first phase of commercial engineering. This ought to simplify operations and reduce our capital expenditures, and because of that, we anticipate an improved IRR profile for the business. Commercially, things are moving along well, and improved output along with better-quality product has let us develop a customer pipeline that's stronger and more robust. Larger quantities of boric acid are now going out to a broader set of interested potential purchasers, and we're reliably meeting their required specifications — plus we've completed our initial sale of a full truckload of super sacks. We've completed the process of finalizing how we'll segment our customers, and solid progress is being made when it comes to locking in offtake deals with a set of buyers whose respective industries offer considerable expansion opportunities along with robust projections for demand over the long haul. Two very capable experts have joined our commercial group, and each of them brings several decades of work in the worldwide borates sector; the industry connections they possess will assist us in carrying out our commercial plan successfully and in getting the most economic value out of what we're able to produce. Our commercial attention now reaches into APAC, a region responsible for about 60% of demand worldwide, and when you combine the U.S. with APAC, we're addressing roughly 80% of demand across the globe. Demand is holding up well from U.S. Federal agencies as well as from American buyers of boron and its specialty derivatives, and at the same time we're focused on being present in whatever markets give our products and capabilities the highest worth. Our business is going to span the globe, which means 5E will go after demand worldwide that delivers the strongest profit outcome and, at the same time, supports ongoing creation of shareholder value. For roughly 25%-50% of our initial 90,000 tons, we can already see a path to offtake agreements, and by the spring of 2025 we aim to have tonnage committed for phase two; last of all, our capital funding strategy has been moving forward on several fronts. The money we raised in our last financing has been going toward moving our top-priority operational and commercial efforts forward, and toward getting the company ready to complete pre-FEED engineering work plus a refreshed PFS during 2025. We also managed to secure an LOI from EXIM, which has the potential to supply credit enhancement backing for a substantial project debt facility — one that would fund a sizable share of the CapEx needed on the commercial side. Looking at what's coming up soon, the catalysts we anticipate include wrapping up the first offtake arrangements along with Heads of Agreements covering boric acid as well as calcium chloride. Also coming up: we're sending 18 tons of boric acid over the Pacific, which will go through tank testing at a major worldwide specialty glass producer, and that opens the door to more offtake deals with customers moving forward in our pipeline. Then finally, there's the 2025 CapEx estimate, and we anticipate it will come in substantially below what our earlier technical report projected. The strides we've made in only a few months have us energized, and we intend to keep the market updated on what's ahead and on the catalysts that should unlock near-term value. I want to express my appreciation, as I always do, to everyone at 5E Advanced Materials for the effort and the contributions they put in while we work toward creating value for our shareholders over the long term. Having said that, we're going to turn the call over to your questions now. Operator?
Tate Sullivan
analystThanks. Regarding that initial shipment containing 22 super sacks — what you described as the first sale, does that mean the first revenue lands in the quarter we're in right now? Is that right?
Paul Weibel
executiveYes, that's right, Tate. 22 super sacks, and for the moment we won't be disclosing the revenue. In the end it will serve as a credit against the production costs tied to the small-scale facility, and as is visible this quarter, we've begun separating fixed and operating OpEx onto a single line within the income statement.
Tate Sullivan
analystSo what's the mechanism there? Even so, don't you receive payment from the party you delivered it to? And on the books, isn't it simply applied as a credit offsetting that cost? Is that right?
Paul Weibel
executiveThat's right. Yes, indeed, those super sacks do get monetized. And as was hinted at during the previous call, 22 super sacks are available to you; thus, on a monthly basis, we're able to switch production rates back and forth. However, when output isn't being shipped out specifically for qualification by our customer, we continue operating anyway. So we'll aim to make sales strategically at the best prices and capture that value.
Tate Sullivan
analystThen you brought up possible catalysts ahead, that 18-ton shipment for tank testing. Does that count as customer qualification rather than a sale?
Paul Weibel
executiveThat's right; it will be customer qualification, and in that case, that customer, we clearly are going to supply the product. Ideally, offtake follows that, and that customer then handles the freight.
Tate Sullivan
analystAt this small-scale plant right now, are you making calcium chloride — is that what you said — or does that lean more toward engineering work ahead for phase one?
Paul Weibel
executiveWell, we have in fact made it, at smaller volumes, in our laboratory. After the calcium gets isolated and the metal salts are taken out, all that would be needed is putting in additional HCl. The small-scale facility, though, as it stands today, was built with gypsum in mind, and gypsum is what comes out of it now.
Tate Sullivan
analystAll right. And regarding that final item — the FEED engineering study's 7-to-8-month schedule — does that line up with how you'd been thinking about FEED over these past 2 years, schedule-wise?
Paul Weibel
executiveYes. Look, we had to nail down our byproducts. We had to determine whether it's gypsum or calcium chloride, and after we sort of removed that uncertainty and completed the market study along with weighing the advantages and drawbacks, at that moment, it felt like we could genuinely, fully move forward; we'd already been progressing on the boric acid side, though this alters the design somewhat now, yet I'd say, looking at the big picture, we anticipated a reasonable CapEx decrease, and so once you're able to stage gate and your PFDs and P&IDs are fully finalized, with no changes to follow, then you stage gate into FEL-3, you cut down any change orders, and you allow Fluor and our owners' team to genuinely take the lead.
Tate Sullivan
analystThanks, Paul.
Tate Sullivan
analystAll right, appreciate it. When you mention being able to serve 80% of borate demand, what exactly did you mean by that? Is it that you have customer contacts worldwide that represent that 80%?
Paul Weibel
executiveMark, do you want to handle this question?
Mark Zamek
executiveRight, absolutely, Paul. The Asia-Pacific region leads the borate market, with China making up a significant share, along with the U.S. market. So, when we claim coverage of 80% of the worldwide borates market, we've got a representative brought on board a couple of weeks back — Kenneth Hu — who brings 17 years of experience from Rio Tinto, and he's taking care of the Asia market on our behalf. That accounts for 60% of global borates offtake. Meanwhile, I handle the U.S. market, which represents 20% of worldwide borates offtake. So, together, the two of us will have, yeah, points of contact and customer relationships spanning those two geographic regions, adding up to 80% of the entire global borate market. And the rationale behind concentrating our resources this way is that these aren't just high-demand markets — they're also low-cost-to-serve and high-margin markets. Places like Europe come with very high cost-to-serve, heavy regulatory pathways for getting product in, and very low price points. That's why Europe isn't our focus. Same goes for South America. So we've decided essentially to fine-tune our strategy to cover APAC and the U.S., maximizing shareholder value for 5E.
Tate Sullivan
analystAll right, that's helpful. Then, Paul, regarding the financials ahead, when it comes to the operating costs for the small-scale facility in 3Q, should we treat that as a typical run rate? You mentioned that from this point, there would be reductions at that operating cost level, or is that line item going to hold steady given the one-ton per day, one-ton output?
Paul Weibel
executiveYes. So it will hold steady relative to what you saw in Q1; though clearly, we carried out the strategic reduction, sort of fine-tuned how the team is sized in terms of operators per shift, plus some maintenance personnel. Now that we're six months in, we've simply become more efficient. And so that ought to be sort of comparable to slightly lower. And then any product sales as we move forward would be credited against that. So that's what it'll be. It should get better sort of quarter over quarter.
Tate Sullivan
analystGot it; and I've got a few more questions about the modeling. Approximately how many pounds of boric acid go into each sack?
Paul Weibel
executiveThat's a good question, since we've been sort of figuring out what the right super sack should be. You're pretty much correct; these were around 1,700 to 1,800. Of course, it's 2,000. Ideally we want it to be exactly 2,000 pounds, which equals one short ton in the U.S. We've now sort of found a super sack that's pretty much ideal. So each day the plant can reach that one ton. So 2,000 should be the ideal goal, but this first one came in at roughly 1,750, which would probably be your average.
Tate Sullivan
analystAll right, thanks. And this might be a bit premature, since the FEED package will include the calcium chloride integration. But approximately, for one ton of boric acid output, what could the potential calcium chloride yield be? That still has to be pinned down on a volume basis.
Paul Weibel
executiveNo, I can address that immediately, and our mass balances are already giving us a sense of it. On a pure basis — call it 100% calcium chloride — you get slightly under a one-to-one ratio. Probably, and I tend to view this against the 90,000 figure, for each 90,000 tons of boric acid, roughly 75,000 tons of pure calcium chloride at 100% would be produced. Then, of course, that isn't the form in which it's sold. It's sold at 38%, diluted with water. So at commercial scale, you're looking at approximately 190,000 on a tonnage basis. That's something we'll evaluate. With plant design for gypsum, our inclination is to concentrate on the boron. But later on, we're going to examine whether we can extract the calcium chloride from that small-scale facility. And if that proves to be the case, at a ton per day, you'd likely get perhaps two tons in solution, more or less, on the calcium chloride side.
Tate Sullivan
analystAlright, that's everything. Thanks for taking all my questions. Have a good night.
Paul Weibel
executiveYou're welcome.
Paul Weibel
executiveI appreciate all of you taking the time to join us and for your interest in 5E Advanced Materials, Inc. As the world's most recent producer of boric acid, we have an enormous opportunity ahead of us; our asset is proven, and we have a plan to grow it in a modular fashion across the coming years. Both our commercial and operational approaches are moving forward, and we are gaining increasing backing from regulators and the government, which ought to open up further avenues for low-cost financing. We can't wait to take all of you along on this journey during the quarters ahead. Thanks, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete 5E Advanced Materials, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to 5E Advanced Materials, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in 5E Advanced Materials, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.