AMCIL Limited (AMH) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 31, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, and thank you for joining us for the AMCIL full-year financial results briefing. Right now, everyone is in listen-only mode. We'll have a presentation, and after that a question-and-answer session. Questions will be taken through the webcast. Should you wish to ask something when that time comes, please type your question into the Ask a Question box located at the bottom of the webcast window. I'll now pass things over to Mark Freeman, AMCIL's Managing Director. Over to you.
Mark Freeman
executiveAll right, good afternoon, everyone, and thanks for joining us for this full-year results briefing. First, I want to recognize the traditional owners and custodians of the lands where we're meeting today, and to pay my respects to their elders past, present, and emerging. With me today on the webinar are Jaye Guy and Gilbert Battistella from the investment team, Andrew Porter, our CFO, Matthew Rowe, our Company Secretary, and Geoff Driver, our General Manager of Business Development. Before we begin the presentation, a few housekeeping notes about the webinar. This briefing draws on material available on the company's website. If you're accessing the presentation through the webcast on your computer, the slides will advance automatically. Lastly, please be aware that after the presentation there will be time for questions and answers. You can submit a question through the webcast using the tab at the bottom of the screen. Moving to the slide, Slide two, the disclaimer — just to note that we're here to discuss what we're doing in the company, and we're not providing any advice as such. To get the presentation started, I'll hand over to Andrew, our CFO, to discuss the results.
Andrew Porter
executiveThanks, Mark, and good afternoon, everyone. We're on slide four of the presentation, and if you look at the upper left corner, you'll see profit for the year came in at AUD 7.5 million, a slight decline from AUD 7.6 million in the prior year. The main reason for that was lower dividends, primarily from resource stocks. Take BHP, for example: on its own, we got AUD 700,000 less during the year just ended, the year to June 2024, than we did in earlier years. And plenty of shareholders holding BHP, Woodside, and similar names would have experienced the same. Even so, we consider it a pretty good result. That's despite other companies, banks and so on, raising their dividends. That resulted in a final dividend of AUD 0.025 plus a special dividend of AUD 0.005. So including the interim dividend, that comes to AUD 0.04 in total for the year. Capital gains were low this year, since we had brought-forward losses from the prior year that had to be used up before we could realize any taxable capital gains, which is what generates franking credits. The portfolio returned 20.5%, well ahead of the market's 13.5% for the year, and we'll cover portfolio performance in more detail later.
Andrew Porter
executiveThe management expense ratio came in at 0.56%, compared with 0.66% a year earlier. In other words, it's AUD 0.56 for each AUD 100. The main thing that moves a management expense ratio is how much it costs to operate the company expressed as a proportion of the average portfolio value. So portfolio movement is really what drives the management expense ratio. Even so, as we talked about at the AGM and the shareholder briefings last year, the company's actual running costs did fall year-on-year, and a big part of that came from the underperformance in the prior year. What that meant was that AMCIL essentially received a refund, or a credit note, covering some of those costs this year, which helped push it lower. We went through the detail of how that works last year. So AUD 0.56, compared with AUD 0.66. Given how AMCIL has performed this year, I'd expect the actual cost will probably rise this year, 2024, 2025. To repeat, portfolio performance is really what drives the management expense ratio. Slide five, the next slide, simply shows the premium discount chart. This is worth drawing shareholders' attention to, because it asks: are you purchasing the underlying assets for more than they were worth, or are you purchasing the underlying assets for less than they were worth? As at 30 June 2024, the NTA was AUD 1.26 and the share price was AUD 1.10.
Andrew Porter
executiveThus, had you purchased it at AUD 1.10, you would have gotten a 13% discount to the NTA. Right now, many LICs are trading at deeper discounts than usual. We suspect this is partly because numerous asset managers are telling people that fixed interest can now deliver a decent yield if you move out of equities, or out of a portion of your equities, and into fixed interest. We think that is having some effect. The market overall has risen roughly 4% this month, so you would anticipate the AMCIL NTA to have climbed around 4% as well, and the share price sits at $1.15. What that tells you is that AMCIL shares remain available at a fairly attractive discount to their underlying value. With that, I'll hand things over to Mark.
Mark Freeman
executiveAll right, thank you, Andrew. Now we turn to the longer-term performance figures, which are on slide 7. Andrew already covered the one-year numbers and walked everyone through them. Over the longer term — five years — and compared with the index over 10 years, we're roughly in line, though the performance we display reflects the franking credits we have actually distributed. We still hold franking credits within the company. Had we paid all of those out straight away, AMCIL's performance figures would be higher than the ones you're looking at. So our tendency is to present a conservative picture of the company's performance numbers. Let's go to the following slide, where we'll discuss a few of AMCIL's characteristics. It's a focused portfolio. The screen we apply is a desire to invest in quality companies. Index weightings don't necessarily determine how large our holdings are. There's a strong alignment of interest. AMCIL carries a low management cost relative to other funds of the kind we call higher-conviction. No performance fees apply, and directors and staff hold a significant equity stake in AMCIL. So for the directors and staff, seeing AMCIL perform over the long term is in our interest.
Mark Freeman
executiveOur portfolio turnover is still kept on the low side, we try to do that. We're aware that plenty of other funds that are managed more actively in the market are able to churn their portfolios heavily. With a high-conviction fund, some turnover is inevitable, but we're never after letting it get excessive, since that simply creates tax at the end of the day. At AMCIL, our attention is on a specific framework we're progressing toward, and that's on the following slide, slide nine. It's the filter we apply to our stocks, and we'd describe it as a very accurate reflection of the team's investment process — or our process — namely seeking out businesses possessing unique assets that are difficult to replicate. Put another way, that means companies holding an industry leadership position, or one that's developing, along with a sustainable competitive advantage. We're mindful of companies where external factors are able to affect the business. The balance sheet matters a great deal, so companies carrying too much debt are not ones we want to own. Our preference is for companies whose earning streams are consistent, and the people running the business is critical. So we want companies run by genuinely good management teams, and we hold a strong bias toward what we term owner-driver businesses, or ownership alignment, or founder-led companies, where the people who started the business, who started running it, are running the company.
Mark Freeman
executiveWe've had a lot of success with numerous of those businesses, and looking across AMCIL's portfolio, it's packed with owner-driver companies, something we're quite happy about. So putting those factors together means you're effectively taking a stance on sustainable competitive advantage. Firms possessing it typically earn a higher return on capital, and that means you produce more cash that can be reinvested into the business to fuel growth. That lets you seize opportunities and in the end delivers shareholder value by growing profits. In the end, our aim is to establish a framework that lets us grasp which companies stand the best chance of growing earnings and profits, since ultimately share prices track earnings per share. We then seek to purchase those companies when value appears, and when companies fall short on any of these traits, we tend to be sellers, and frequently we'll exit the business. Turning to the following slide, on diversification, you'll see the portfolio is spread across sectors, with a fairly even split between what I'd call the really large-cap stocks, above AUD 50 billion, and more of the mid-cap style stocks, between AUD 5 billion and AUD 15 billion, at 24%, plus another 37% in stocks smaller than that.
Mark Freeman
executiveWe're comfortable holding stocks of any size — small, mid, or large cap. All of them are open to us. We go where we believe the strongest opportunity lies, and given how we build the portfolio, we're usually more selective about which large-cap names we hold. That can mean bigger weights in those positions at times, though we generally own fewer of them. Once you move down into smaller-cap stocks, we usually spread things more widely, since the goal there is to find the future winners, which naturally means smaller position sizes. So we pick the best out of the large caps and keep a wider spread across the smaller companies showing the traits our experience says are most likely to produce a good business over the long term. Turning to recent activity more broadly, a few names we've sold: we've exited Santos and Computershare. With Computershare, we'd basically added it a little while back more as a trade, and since we'd booked some profits, we moved on. The stock has kept trading higher, but that was the reason we held it. With Santos, at the margin, I think we're beginning to see some better buying opportunities in Woodside.
Mark Freeman
executiveAltium came about through a takeover. So anyone who's been on these webinars over the last 18 months will recall us including it. The situation is that Altium was a stock that matched up very well with the framework, so we purchased it, and it's probably no shock that a sizable takeover offer emerged, so that turned out to be a highly successful investment. ASX is a business we chose to exit. It still possesses plenty of the traits we seek in terms of its market position. There appear to be a range of problems the company is grappling with. We'd like to see those problems resolved before we re-enter the stock. And IPD Group was another owner-driver stock. It was a small position that we held, and we'd generated some profit from it, so we exited, but nothing, no genuine worries regarding the business itself. It remains of interest to us, but it was a small holding that we stepped away from. And then a few of the stocks we've trimmed, you can see NAB, Commonwealth Bank. Banks have been tremendously strong in the market, and we're beginning to have difficulty with the valuation metrics. The P/Es these businesses are trading on are extreme when you look back through history.
Mark Freeman
executiveSo when pricing gets extreme, we're glad to pull some capital out of those companies. Same story with Wesfarmers. We still hold a sizable position in Wesfarmers. We also continue to hold positions in CBA and NAB. But once again, the multiples look quite expensive, and with Netwealth, Rio Tinto, Reece, and CSL, we trimmed just a small amount based on valuation metrics, though they remain large holdings in the portfolio. Then on the other side, from cutting back NAB and CBA, those businesses pay us great franked dividends, and we've directed some funds into Telstra, which we view as more fairly valued. It provides us with franked dividends, and Woodside is one we've been gradually moving into. Once again, that will generate solid franked dividends. So we're simply trying to go where we see a bit more value among the companies that produce yield for us. We've observed persistent weakness in IDP, so we've kept adding small amounts to that. Woolworths went through a stretch of rather negative news. Again, if you looked at those results probably 12 months ago, we had cut our Woolworths position quite significantly in the high 38, around $38. It looked really expensive. Then it went through a period of really bad news.
Mark Freeman
executiveThe stock fell to around 31 or 32, so we moved in the opposite direction and bought some back. Then there are a few of our smaller holdings. These are owner-driver businesses. Objective Corporation had a stretch where it got sold off. A big seller in the market wanted out. That gave us a great chance to add to that position. Macquarie Technology Group — sorry — they did a capital raising to fund development of a data center at a very attractive price, so we were glad to participate. Min Resources, we've been accumulating bits and pieces along the way. So those last three stocks are all owner-driver or founder-led businesses that we're happy to buy when value shows up. And then on to the new stocks, as I mentioned, we touched on Telstra. Jaye will cover that shortly. Then Tech One, Block, Redox, and PWR. Again, Gilbert and Jaye will speak to those shortly. And then we've taken a small position in NEXTDC because we find their growth in data centers interesting, but it's only a very small position. And similarly, SEEK — we believe people are steering clear of the market in anticipation of a cyclical downturn, so we're taking a very small position there.
Mark Freeman
executiveWe would build up those two stocks only if we saw better value in the market. Now moving on to a few slides, just walking through some of those acquisitions, and I think we'll begin by talking about Tech One and Block.
Gilbert Battistella
executiveThank you, Mark. I'll begin with TechnologyOne. This company delivers ERP software, with a focus on the local government and higher education sectors across Australia, New Zealand, and the U.K. Tech One's software is what customers rely on to operate their businesses. Thanks to the strong ties Tech One has built with its customers, it has maintained a world-class retention level of 99% per annum across the last 10 years. Those same customers also generally raise their spending with Tech One as time goes on, and the driver behind that is growing breadth in how customers adopt Tech One's products and modules. This customer base is highly resilient economically, since more than 90% of revenues are recurring, and that lets Tech One keep growing right through the economic cycle. Block is a fintech conglomerate. Its key assets are Cash App, a peer-to-peer money transfer app with 57 million U.S. customers; Square, an integrated payment offering made up of payment terminals, software, and financial services used primarily by small businesses; and Afterpay, which they acquired at the wrong point in the cycle but which is now a small component of the total Block business. We opened a position in Block because we were seeing Block win market share in the large markets that they serve, combined with improving cost discipline, which is driving a material improvement in earnings.
Gilbert Battistella
executiveBlock additionally holds a substantial net cash position, and owner-driver CEO Jack Dorsey leads it. Because this investment carries a higher risk profile, it represents the smaller holding in the portfolio. Moving to the next slide, PWR Holdings. PWR Holdings designs and produces advanced cooling solutions that are used in high-performance automotive and industrial applications. With motorsports as its grassroots foundation, PWR is expanding by applying its advanced cooling IP and expertise to the aerospace and defense markets. The key characteristics that attract us to PWR are owner-driver CEO Kees Weel, strong margins, a high return on equity, a net cash balance sheet, significant R&D investment, and unique IP in advanced cooling technology. I'll hand over to Jaye to discuss Redox now.
Jaye Guy
executiveThanks, Gilbert. Now moving along to Slide 13, we're putting the spotlight on Redox. It isn't really a name most households would recognize, though chances are you'll have some link to everyday products you pick up, for instance, at the supermarket. Basically, Redox is a top distributor of chemicals and ingredients. The company holds a very strong market position in Australia and is building an expanding presence in the United States. It serves as a crucial bridge connecting suppliers of chemicals and ingredients with buyers like manufacturing companies that produce items used in our daily routines, shampoo being one example. Redox was founded in 1965, and after the IPO in mid-2023 the founding family is still deeply involved in the business. They hold a meaningful presence on both the management team and the board, and as shareholders they're aligned with us, holding a substantial stake in the business. Raimond, Redox's CEO, joined the company at age 18, so he clearly brings plenty of experience in the industry and the space. The company has a strong growth record — across the last 30 years, sales have grown at a 12% compound annual growth rate. We see leverage on the balance sheet. Redox pays a solid dividend yield and produces an attractive return on capital.
Jaye Guy
executiveNow turning to Slide 14 — as Mark pointed out, we've also begun building and added to stakes in bigger businesses where we identify value. The charts on these slides show what we've been buying in those two companies. So, Telstra — plenty of people listening will know the business. It's a top telecommunications provider in Australia. In our view, it's well placed to gain from growing data usage and society's rising need to be digitally connected. We believe Telstra is well positioned to produce sustainable earnings growth plus an attractive, growing, fully franked dividend. Management has a carefully thought-out plan for improving returns over the years ahead, and the character of Telstra's business means it throws off defensive cash flows that are fairly predictable, and it also carries a solid balance sheet. Turning to Woodside — over the period we grew that position. That gives us more exposure to a globally unique portfolio of hard-to-replace, high-quality liquefied natural gas and oil assets. These low-cost assets support strong free cash flows going forward, which in our view the market underappreciates. On top of that, Woodside carries a strong balance sheet, giving it optionality — recently demonstrated by the announced acquisition of New York Stock Exchange-listed Tellurian at book value, which strengthens the company's production profile and lifts its LNG exposure.
Jaye Guy
executiveMark already mentioned that the company offers a solid dividend yield as well. At this point I'll hand things back over to Mark, and he'll walk everyone through the outlook portion.
Mark Freeman
executiveAll right, thank you, Jaye and Gilbert. Turning now to the outlook, we began with the portfolio, and it follows the same framework we've applied at the past two meetings for thinking about the companies we own. We hold quite a broad spread of growth companies, and as I mentioned, several of these are smaller businesses, which makes us more willing to own a larger number of them. As I noted, doing so is intended to improve our chances of capturing the winners in structural compounding. Beyond that come our more stalwart businesses, followed by income companies. So beginning with income companies, as I said before, the banks strike us as fairly expensive. They offer attractive franked dividends, but when it comes to sourcing franked dividends, Telstra and Woodside look like better value at current prices. On stalwart companies, these are businesses we're comfortable owning over the long term, meaning companies we believe hold privileged positions in the markets where they operate. Then there are growth stocks. I'll attempt to identify the founder-led businesses, and I might miss some, but it's notable how much attention we give them — going through this chart, Macquarie Technology, Netwealth, ARB, Reece, and Breville all show those traits via the current CEO, while TechnologyOne is essentially a second-generation founder-led business.
Mark Freeman
executiveGoodman Group — Beamtree shares the same traits as Temple & Webster, WiseTech, Min Resources; Gentrack has those kinds of characteristics thanks to where the CEO sits. Netwealth, Mainfreight, Objective, PWR, ResMed, EGL — Xero is basically what you'd call third generation now, and Block fits that too. So quite a few companies carry that trait, and as I mentioned, we believe this raises our odds of succeeding with our investments. Moving on to the outlook remarks: our take is that the markets — I nearly said in the U.S., but these days here in Australia — have responded really warmly to the possibility of rate cuts. So even today in the Australian market, with inflation readings and some weaker retail sales figures, the market is getting enthusiastic that there won't be further rate hikes. They could stay flat, and that pushed the market sky-high. But I think the market at times loses sight of why that is — because certain parts of the economy are soft, and that ultimately hits profits. Sentiment regarding China has been soft too, and that has weighed heavily on commodity markets. So we have the market trading at record highs, and that's not something we have any issue with.
Mark Freeman
executiveOver the long run, markets rise. Resources have been trailing. Our one caveat, though, is that valuations look very elevated. So when you examine price to sales, price to book or PE for the Australian market and the U.S. market, we're at what I'd describe as upper levels — so beyond one standard deviation. At times there are explanations for that. Either profits sit at a low point and are set to recover. We don't believe we're there. Maybe the market's structure is different. There are more tech stocks that earn higher returns and are better. Perhaps some of that is in play, but on the whole, when we observe these kinds of levels, we simply carry a tone of caution. So as a result, despite the portfolio's strong performance, we actually hold a nice allocation to cash right now. So if we head into reporting season, we actually do find some opportunities. We have the ability to act on that. So we've got good stock, we've got some cash, and we've still delivered the performance. So just to return to what we look for, when we review our portfolio, we always want to be able to say we hold good companies that have aligned management teams, the ability to grow earnings over the long term, and have strong and resilient balance sheets.
Mark Freeman
executiveThat brings the formal presentation to a close. At this point, we would like to open the floor for questions.
Jaye Guy
executiveOkay, so Mark, I’ll try to kind of moderate the questions. So once again, just as a reminder to everyone, there’s an opportunity to actually put questions to the team. So the first one I have here is — I think you may have already addressed this — but given that CBA is at a historic high, would AMCIL swap it out for Macquarie Group in the portfolio?
Mark Freeman
executiveYeah, so the PE on CBA is far higher than anything I've witnessed across my whole career. So like we've mentioned, it stands to reason that we've been reducing that holding. We consider it a wonderful company. It's an exceptional business. It generates solid return on equity, but everything has its price. And when we look at the dividend yield, it's currently sitting at roughly 3.3% fully franked. Once you include the franking credits, that could take you to 4.5%. So you'd need fairly strong earnings growth for it to make sense as an investment from this point. That could well happen, but we remain quite cautious. So it's ended up as a fairly small stock within the portfolio. Macquarie is already a big position. You always have to add more if the price is right, but it's a pretty solid position, and that's likely the reason it didn't show up in the buying list this time. We've simply found other things to put money into. So we're hopeful that Macquarie can keep performing over the long run, since we hold a lot of it.
Andrew Porter
executiveWithin the portfolio, Macquarie is in fact bigger than CBA.
Mark Freeman
executiveWow, that's quite a bit larger. Yeah.
Jaye Guy
executiveThe biggest thing I'd point to — and Andrew will likely touch on this too — is whether that meaningful drop in the management expense ratio is something we should expect to stick around, or whether it simply reflects circumstances unique to this year.
Andrew Porter
executiveIn dollar terms, I’d expect the actual costs to be a little higher this year, for the reasons I walked through. But as we discussed, the ratio itself will hinge on how the portfolio performs. If the portfolio rises by more than the dollar cost increases, then the MER would decline. But obviously, the reverse applies if it doesn’t grow by as much.
Jaye Guy
executiveAlright, thank you, Andrew. I'll offer a remark on that. A number of firms out there assert that investments in private credit deliver returns similar to equity. How does AMCIL view the opportunity for investment in that space?
Andrew Porter
executiveYeah, well, yeah, we're an equity investor. That's our core strength. That's what we do. We're not credit analysts. That's really a different field. It requires a different skill set and a different way of looking at a company. And we would certainly never put ourselves out as to be an expert on credit. So therefore, it's not for us. There are much better managers out there, people interested in investing in funds that specialize in private equity. I get the point, though. There is some private credit that can get returns like equity or better, but that's all an outcome of risk. The more risk you take on private equity, you'd expect to get a better return. And likewise, equity, a high-risk equity, you want a high return. A low-risk equity, you might expect a lower return. But it's just not our area of expertise, so.
Jaye Guy
executiveHere's a question: I believe this relates to our putting money into gold stocks, but if the gold price keeps getting better, won't those gold companies see their earnings improve?
Andrew Porter
executiveSure, they will. We actually examined a gold stock not long ago. Predicting the gold price always struck us as difficult. In fact, looking back through history, if gold interests you, the surest route to profit is to own gold itself rather than the equities. That said, it doesn't follow that those equities rise whenever commodity prices rise. The way we've built our portfolio, I'd say, is more about directing money into businesses where we can see more clearly why their profits should grow over time. To my mind, with gold companies, you're essentially taking a view on the gold price. That's just something we find really hard to do. So it's a step we haven't taken as yet.
Jaye Guy
executiveThere's a question here about whether we can talk through weight limits for individual companies. So I suppose the question is, at what point do you start to feel uneasy about how much of the portfolio sits in any single company? And also the AMCIL dividend policy, plus how many retained franking credits we hold that are available.
Mark Freeman
executiveOkay, I'll start with the first weight, then hand it over to Andrew regarding our franking balance. Look, there’s no formal cap in place, but CSL is currently our largest holding. It makes up roughly 8.8% of the portfolio. We believe there’s some value in it, though the index weight is likely around 7%, high six. So we assess weightings both on an absolute basis and against the index, since that shows how our portfolio stacks up versus the benchmark. I’d say the CSL position is probably a touch elevated right now, because we feel the stock has been undervalued. So I’d characterise that as moving us closer to our upper limit. There have been periods when a single stock reached 10%, but that was likely the exception rather than the rule. So even CSL at 8.9% is probably a bit more than we’d prefer. We’d probably want a somewhat wider spread. So Andrew, over to Andrew on the franking.
Andrew Porter
executiveWhen it comes to dividend policy, the board determines the dividend each year. I don't believe they'd claim to have a specific dividend policy as such. Regarding franking credits, once we've paid the final dividend we announced along with the special dividend, we'll essentially have just over AUD 0.04 per share of franked dividend left in reserve. The company holds sufficient reserves to cover just over one full year's ordinary dividends.
Mark Freeman
executiveCorrect.
Andrew Porter
executiveRegarding the dividend policy you brought up, we definitely understand that shareholders value fully franked dividends, and of course we're eager to distribute those as effectively as we can. Andrew, I'll follow up with you. You noted that AMCIL needed to accelerate capital losses, which lowered the tax payable for this year. Did any single position account for those realized capital losses? That was handled in the prior year, and we don't disclose the capital gains tax position for any specific investment. What I can tell you, though, is that in 2022/23 — and shareholders can reach their own conclusions — the biggest sales were in Iress and PEXA Group, and we exited both of those positions during the 2022/2023 year.
Jaye Guy
executiveAll right, thank you. I've got a question about Mineral Resources. Since the company has such heavy exposure to lithium and iron ore — and prices for both are dropping — what makes them appealing to you?
Andrew Porter
executiveThanks, Jess. Turning to Mineral Resources, we see several appealing traits there. The company was started by Chris Ellison, and he still runs it today. He owns a meaningful stake in the business, so his interests line up with ours as shareholders. The company operates several divisions. One is a mining services division with an excellent history of volume growth and clients including the big major miners. They also have an iron ore division, lithium, and a developing energy division. We recognize that lithium and iron ore prices affect them and sit outside their control. Still, in our view they are expanding output from their assets, and we regard those assets as high quality and positioned well on the cost curve. So earnings growth for them does not depend solely on resource prices. They can achieve it by growing production in a disciplined way. In our view, the market probably does not appreciate the earnings profile of the mining services business as fully as it should, and that business delivers solid, steady earnings growth for the company. With that in mind, since commodity prices lie beyond the company's control, we factored that into how we sized, and positioned, our holding in the stock.
Andrew Porter
executiveThat's a somewhat smaller holding for the portfolio, and we certainly bear in mind, I suppose, how cyclical this business is going forward.
Mark Freeman
executiveYeah, I think the other thing worth mentioning is that our stake is roughly 0.7%. So it's one of those smaller positions. And given how the business works, it's probably never going to be one we take a really big holding in. But with those characteristics, it's enough for us to say we're comfortable having some shareholders' money alongside those founder-led companies like what we see in Min Resources. And from an iron ore standpoint, we're also significantly underweight BHP.
Jaye Guy
executiveThere's a question about Realestate.com, or REA Group as I should now refer to it. How would you size up the potential of REA's India business, which is currently loss-making, as it feeds into the valuation for REA?
Mark Freeman
executiveHonestly, it's genuinely hard to pin down a valuation. I actually went on a tour — they ran an analyst tour of their operations. So I travelled over to New Delhi last year, I believe that was the timing. And yes, it was well worth doing. Right now they're in a fight with two other big competitors over who leads the market. That's exactly where the company is concentrating its effort — trying to break away from those rivals. That's the plan. With these online businesses, that's invariably the plan: you do usually take some losses, but reaching the number one spot matters. And once you're at number one, you begin collecting all the benefits that come with a big market position. And in the end, some of them can begin to command better pricing and generate better returns. We've watched that happen with REA in Australia, and Carsales shows the same thing overseas. So that's where they stand. India is an extremely large market, though obviously it's less developed. I suspect REA would likely tell you it perhaps resembles Australia 15 years ago. They hold a solid position, and it isn't one they're willing to surrender.
Mark Freeman
executiveWith that market expanding, I'd say it's a solid choice for the company. And should it pan out, who can say what it might be worth over the long run. But it doesn't contribute much to how we view near-term value for the business, though it does contribute somewhat to how we think about holding that stock over a 10-year horizon. And if that really begins to materialize, it will contribute a great deal of value in time.
Jaye Guy
executiveThanks, Mark. So, on this question—bearing in mind that we brought in an interim dividend a couple of years back now—what it really comes down to is whether there's a way to even out the interim and final payments to some degree.
Mark Freeman
executiveYeah, well, look, I'd say there's probably an intent behind that, though it could take some time. But we do acknowledge that we hear that question from all our LICs — that some shareholders would prefer a more even split. So all I can say right now is that it's probably something we're conscious of, and we try to work toward it.
Jaye Guy
executiveAll right, thank you, Mark. I've got a question: in what way are you putting money into that new investment abroad? I believe that may tie in more with.
Mark Freeman
executiveWell, look, I think when we've discussed another one of our funds, AFIC, we've mentioned that it holds a somewhat international portfolio. Through AMCIL, we don't invest in that. But never say never — that's something that could potentially be open to us. When I say could, I mean that we have an investment team examining international stocks. At what stage would we say, well, if that team produces a high conviction call, might it go into the AMCIL portfolio? And certainly, a few stocks in that portfolio are ones I know pretty well and that actually would have performed very well in this portfolio. So these were, again, companies of the founder-led, owner-driver kind that appear to have a special niche, plenty of opportunity to grow market share. They've got to keep doing what they're doing. I can see a couple of stocks they've held that would suit AMCIL. So it could be something we contemplate and consider at some point and would be another point of difference for AMCIL. But we'd really need conviction on that. Still, I think it's something we really should be thinking about.
Jaye Guy
executiveThanks, Mark. So, on the question of whether there’s any interest in the coal stocks, given that some of them are offering attractive dividends?
Mark Freeman
executiveYeah, well, that's visible. But I suppose when coal stocks go through our screen and our frameworks, it really has a hard time. And we have to stay faithful to how we do things, which means we won't capture everything. So if dividend yield is what we're after, we'd lean toward names like Telstra or Woodside here. So yeah, it likely just doesn't pass certain of our frameworks, though that's really a result of the frameworks themselves, and we have to remain committed to them.
Jaye Guy
executiveYeah, thanks, Mark. My question is about HMC Capital, an alternative asset manager listed on the ASX. It appears to have the traits we've been discussing, though I suppose at the end of the day we aren't major investors in other asset managers. I'll leave it with you.
Mark Freeman
executiveNo, no, no. What we're doing, I think, is choosing companies on our own. What I'd likely tell you is that this may be one for individuals to examine on their own. Still, you should never say never if they happen to be truly excellent at what they do. That said, it hasn't been on our radar up to now, though I'm quite glad to go away and take a look at it.
Jaye Guy
executiveThis question probably concerns a person we're familiar with who has more interest in other healthcare sector stocks, ones that might look appealing to you.
Mark Freeman
executiveSure, we have solid exposure in that area, and I'd say names of higher quality such as Cochlear and Fisher & Paykel, which we're quite fond of, come with very high valuations. So those aren't large positions for us. As I mentioned, we've found some value in CSL. That's a significant holding in the portfolio. ResMed has had a bit of a roller coaster ride, but we still believe that one looks okay. As for the others, well, we do examine Sonic. We've been looking at Ramsay. We don't hold them right now. But I'd say both of those are dealing with some issues. And our preference leans toward what I'd describe as cleaner stories. So we're watching for perhaps moments when they become cleaner, but that's where our focus lies.
Jaye Guy
executiveAnd beyond this sector, there are quite a few opportunities open to us too. So, I mean.
Mark Freeman
executiveCorrect. We’re never looking to concentrate excessively within any single sector; diversification is what we aim for. As a result, we hold solid exposure across healthcare more broadly.
Jaye Guy
executiveHow do you respond to the view held by several analysts that small caps tend to be undervalued and are poised for better P/E ratings relative to large caps?
Mark Freeman
executiveSure, I get that feedback. I think the situation differs because much of that discussion has come from the U.S. When people in the U.S. say small caps are undervalued, they mean their own small caps. They'd probably view our large caps as attractive. So those are very large, established companies that get classified as small caps in the U.S. Still, they're good businesses, solid businesses, and you've watched their P/Es come down. When we talk about small caps in the Australian market, it's a completely different picture. These are frequently businesses facing more difficulties, ones that are attempting to grow. You'll find plenty of resource stocks in the small cap space, many emerging businesses that might not be profitable. So yes, I can see that the P/Es have fallen. I'd guess there's likely some value in a number of them, but you need to be quite cautious about which ones you pick. Our small caps look very different from US small caps.
Jaye Guy
executiveThanks, Mark. So, kind of questions. If any of you have questions, please send them in now. But we’re sort of nearing the end of the ones we have in front of us. Given the comment on international stock, would AMCIL be interested in Berkshire Hathaway?
Mark Freeman
executiveWell, look, you never want to rule anything out. I believe it would come down to price, valuation, and everything else we weigh when we back a team of people. So if you were buying into the stock today, one question on your mind would be who will be leading that business. Our horizon is long term — that's how we approach it. As a result, you need to think about the coming five to 10 years as the story unfolds. Do we perceive value there? Certainly, it has certain traits that appeal to us strongly. If the price were right and we felt good about who would be running that company over the longer term, then yes, it could happen.
Jaye Guy
executiveAll right, so here's a question about what we're actually doing — I suppose, what's the plan? What steps are we really taking to shrink that discount the share price is attempting to?
Mark Freeman
executiveYeah, look, that's frustrating for us. We think over the year, the performance has been sound. We're increasing dividends. We think for an actively managed fund, the MER is very low, no performance fees. We try and be transparent. You can see the stocks we've got. And as Andrew's pointing out, the share price around AUD 1.15, you can see what the market's done and add that to AUD 1.26. There's a very, very large discount. So it seems like people are happy to pay. If you go into an ETF, you're paying the market value, yet we're at this large discount. But I guess some might say that provides opportunity. We have seen there is longer-term cyclicality to share price premiums or discounts. We've had periods where it had a premium. So this is a period where it had a discount. And for a number of factors Andrew's touched on, we do introduce some of the shareholders we traditionally had are happy to be more fixed interest. We've seen in the past when markets are hot, people want to pick the eyes out of the market and perhaps are less interested in LICs. So there's probably a few we think over the last 10 years, there's been a lot of LICs come onto the market.
Mark Freeman
executiveA number of those have not worked out particularly well. So several factors likely converge and produce a certain softness. That said, it may present an opening for other players. Still, my view is that we simply need to continue engaging with the markets.
Jaye Guy
executiveWe're giving quite a few presentations aimed at getting brokers and financial advisors interested. That's keeping us busy too.
Mark Freeman
executiveYes, so a great deal of that effort is aimed simply at spreading the word.
Jaye Guy
executiveYeah — would Soul Patts ever be something we'd look at as an investment?
Mark Freeman
executiveRight, absolutely. I mean, we're quite familiar with those folks. We understand they invest for the long haul and how they operate. At the end of the day, it would likely come back to value. When we last took a look, it seemed somewhat pricey in our view, though it wouldn't exactly be a name we'd remove from our list.
Jaye Guy
executiveAlright, thanks, Mark. Look, I believe I'll finish up with him. There are no questions on my end, though I'll add one remark at the close. As a foundation shareholder, we're quite eager to see a modest exposure that's suitable for overseas stocks. The ASX is becoming more constrained when it comes to business exposures. More companies are being taken over and delisted. That overseas exposure might have an effect on income, but over the long term, this could be outweighed.
Mark Freeman
executiveYeah, well, look, that's a really good recap. I mean, the way I'd frame it exactly is that at times the Australian market does feel somewhat crowded. And with some involvement in the international portfolio — the team runs it, but I can see the stocks — you do come across certain ones and think, yeah, there's something special about that company. That would probably make a good candidate. Sure, you don't get the same dividends, but at AMCIL we're more focused on total returns and growth. I mean, we can always pay some dividends out of capital gains. So I think that's a well-made point, and it probably aligns with how we think.
Jaye Guy
executiveMark, is there anything else—any further questions? If not, we’ll bring this to a close here.
Mark Freeman
executiveAll right, thanks to all of you for tuning in. I believe our next point of contact — our meeting — comes in October. That one will be webcast. Once again, we'll provide an update on the portfolio as well as our performance and how things are going. And obviously, likely next week, we'll be putting out our NTA.
Jaye Guy
executiveYes, that other NTA.
Mark Freeman
executiveYeah, at the close of July. So I'd really urge all of you to watch for that and check how the share price compares with the NTA. And I'm quite glad we've had some solid questions along the way. So thanks once more, everybody.
Operator
operatorThanks. That brings us to the end of today's conference call. We appreciate everyone joining us. You're free to disconnect at this point. Speakers, please remain on the line.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete AMCIL Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to AMCIL Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in AMCIL Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.