American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. (AII) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 11, 2026

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Insurance earnings 37 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Bob Ritchie

executive
#1

Thank you, and good morning, everyone. Before I talk about how we performed, I want to recognize the families and communities hit by Hurricane Isaias. Insurance is a promise made long before it gets tested, and after the storm our team moved fast to the panhandle inside 48 hours, meeting policyholders in person and helping them get the claims process and the recovery underway. I want to thank all of our employees, our agents, and our claims partners for carrying out that important work. What they did reflects the purpose American Integrity was built for. Now to our results. This quarter says a lot about the company we have built across the past 20 years. Our voluntary business continues to expand. We're retaining a larger share of the economics we generate, and equally significant, we're maintaining underwriting discipline in a marketplace that has grown more competitive. Net income for the third quarter reached $28.4 million, more than double what it was a year earlier. Net premiums earned climbed approximately 95%, hitting $101.2 million. Revenue increased 83% compared with the prior year. The combined ratio stood at 70.6%, while annualized return on equity was 29.8%. What matters even more is that these figures demonstrate how our operating strategy is converting into exceptionally strong financial performance. Within those numbers, the continued expansion of our voluntary business is highly encouraging; roughly 41,000 new voluntary policies were written by us during the quarter. That figure represents a 57% increase over the same quarter last year, following record output during Q2. The number of policies we hold overall has climbed 18.6%, surpassing 481,000, while in-force premium gained 17.4% to reach nearly $1.1 billion compared with the equivalent period a year earlier. Even as we expand and add scale, our attention has remained fixed on disciplined risk selection. Simply boosting policy counts is not our goal. What we pursue is business that we are confident we can underwrite prudently and support effectively. Let me highlight two segments where growth is happening. Tri-County stands as an illustration of an area offering potential for ongoing expansion. In the past, our presence there was limited, but at this point we possess substantial underwriting expertise in that area along with enduring ties to the agents operating there. Better market conditions have allowed us to broaden our appetite and apply that expertise. We think we can grow our footprint in Tri-County by serving as a reliable partner to agents while choosing risks that satisfy our underwriting standards. Middle-aged homes make up the next segment. As we've discussed, this offers us an additional opportunity to leverage capabilities we already possess; prior to Florida's litigation crisis altering the economics of this line, it was a central piece of our business, which caused us to scale back our involvement throughout the crisis. That is no longer the case. Because the reform is so robust and the operating environment has gotten better, we're growing in that market once more. That track record is important since we know this segment well, and we've demonstrated that we'll adjust how much we participate as conditions shift and improve. Whatever we choose now must mirror the properties we are underwriting and the returns we anticipate from them. Collectively, these opportunities provide greater latitude regarding where we write business, and we're leveraging that latitude to construct a portfolio that delivers results over time. Jon Ritchie will cover the production, the underwriting factors, and the rationale for that strategy. Being able to capitalize on these opportunities comes down to the independent agency relationships we've built — a competitive edge that took years to establish and, honestly, isn't something you can duplicate simply by spending money. Florida agents clearly have options, and those options keep growing. Earning their recommendations is something we must do every day, through our underwriting appetite, consistency, responsiveness, and claim service. Those kinds of relationships help us spot opportunities, and it's disciplined execution that determines whether we turn them into profitable business. A while back, we gathered roughly 50 of our top agents for an event called the Power of Partnership. We took time to talk about their businesses, the needs they're seeing in their communities, and how our changing appetite can support them in serving customers; those conversations matter because they connect the opportunities agents see with the business we're looking to write. We've put 20 years into building these relationships. Our agents are familiar with our people, they understand how we underwrite, and they know what service to expect from us. And we, in turn, understand their businesses. Our goal is for that familiarity to turn into confidence when an agent puts American Integrity in front of a homeowner. The effort behind a relationship doesn't stop once a policy is issued—especially when a customer files a claim. We believe that by showing up consistently in that partnership, we can win a bigger share of the business our agent partners send our way over time. Those partnerships matter especially now, as Florida's property insurance market is growing healthier and, yes, more competitive. Availability has expanded, prices have come down, and new capital has entered the market, which is good for homeowners. At the same time, it raises the bar for every insurer, including us. Looking ahead, success will depend increasingly on how well we judge risk, the relationships we hold across distribution, how efficiently we operate, and our ability to adapt—not just on where the market cycle sits; we're ready for that. One thing worth noting: across our portfolio, the typical premium for each policy is roughly unchanged from twelve months ago. That figure mirrors changes in the mix of business as well as pricing. Growth in the tri-county area and in middle-aged residences is helping offset some of the modest, sensible rate reductions we've applied elsewhere in our book. While rates are easing, our inflation guard adjustment provides additional support. We'll continue to evaluate pricing against the true cost of the risk we assume. Portfolio averages offer helpful context, but they can't take the place of that assessment at the level of individual products and markets. The legislative reforms in Florida keep delivering benefits for us — less litigation, favorable loss cost trends, and greater availability of insurance; those gains have drawn additional businesses to write and let more carriers serve homeowners. That is genuinely a good thing. In this environment, it's a very responsible and healthy approach. A stable operating climate matters for customers who need coverage and for the capital that must be available to provide it. We'll continue pushing for policies that encourage a healthy, competitive insurance marketplace. I'd also like to extend congratulations to Florida's newly elected officials following last week's vote, and we're eager to work with the incoming administration and state leaders. As we see it, the outcome of this election backs the continuation of those reforms, and we'll go on advocating for a stable, competitive market serving Florida homeowners. Our opportunity isn't limited to any one quarter or to a single region of Florida. We believe there's still opportunity to reach more homeowners in South Florida, particularly in the middle-aged home segments we understand thoroughly, and on a selective basis throughout the Southeast. Even so, the core principle stays consistent across every market: we'll expand wherever risk-adjusted returns warrant the capital we put to work. Keeping a larger share of our underwriting economics increases both the opportunity for our shareholders and our obligation to manage risk prudently. Jon will now explain how we're carrying out these decisions. I'll turn the call over to Jon.

Jon Ritchie

executive
#2

Thanks, Bob, and good morning, everyone. I'll cover production across our growth initiatives, underwriting performance, and reinsurance. I'll also bring you up to date on Hurricane Isaias, which happened after the third quarter closed. Gross premiums written rose 22.7% to $293.3 million, mainly because voluntary business grew. Retention came in better at 84.9%, up from 84.4% in the second quarter and 82.8% a year ago; we're bringing in new business while keeping a larger share of the customers we already have. Both things help us build the portfolio, and as competition heats up we'll keep evaluating retention together with pricing and loss performance. Florida holds substantial opportunities in market segments where our participation today is still fairly small. Market size tells us where to focus. Our underwriting standards determine which opportunities we pursue. In Tri-County, we wrote about 8,000 voluntary new business policies, compared with just over 200 a year earlier and roughly 7,600 in the second quarter. That sequential increase is encouraging, since the second quarter is typically our strongest seasonal period for new business. Importantly, as of September 30, Tri-County accounts for approximately 28% of Florida households and 10% of our Florida policies in force; that comparison helps illustrate how relatively small our presence is and what future growth opportunity exists. It does not dictate our eventual mix. Beyond Tri-County, we recorded roughly 8,600 voluntary new business policies covering middle-aged homes, compared with under 600 annually a year earlier. In 2016, prior to our pullback amid the litigation crisis, this segment represented approximately three-quarters of our HO-3 policies in force. That track record provides a base for our expansion efforts. Rather than attempting to rebuild a portfolio mix from the past, we apply those lessons to current property attributes, pricing, and loss circumstances. In growing, we evaluate each property as well as its contribution to total exposure. Selection at the individual policy level is aided by eligibility criteria, roof condition, and inspections. Portfolio considerations also include geographic concentration and catastrophe exposure. We take all of those considerations into account jointly, ensuring that an appealing production opportunity remains aligned with the level of risk we are willing to accept. Across Georgia, South Carolina, and North Carolina, voluntary new business policies rose 20% compared with the prior year. As of quarter end, those states accounted for 6.9% of our voluntary in-force premium. We believe there is room to expand this business over time by leveraging builder and agency relationships that are already in place. Those partners are familiar with American Integrity and the way we conduct business, giving us a base from which to introduce further products. Our plan is to expand what we offer in those states during 2027, adding dwelling fire coverage among other things—agents have informed us that demand for it is robust—and we are currently preparing the necessary product filings and approvals. That contribution remains relatively modest, yet we think expanding these relationships can continue to extend our business past Florida as the portfolio grows. Now, regarding Florida's commercial residential market, that segment is still very competitive, and although we identify select opportunities, we do not anticipate this business becoming a primary growth engine. As of September 30, we had 283 commercial residential policies in force, and in-force premium came to $16.7 million. As previously noted, we write only business meeting our underwriting and return criteria. Lastly, we did not participate in a Citizens take-out this quarter, as the policies presented to us did not satisfy our underwriting standards and targeted profitability standards. Even so, we'll keep assessing opportunities going forward. As you can see, having several sources of voluntary growth gives us options regarding where to deploy capacity. How we handled Citizens, along with our selective approach to commercial residential business, shows how we apply that flexibility. We'll keep evaluating those opportunities while steering our efforts toward business that satisfies our underwriting and return objectives. Our gross underlying loss ratio came in at 18.9%, versus 19.3% a year earlier. That consistency encourages us as production grows and the portfolio mix evolves, and we'll keep evaluating the emerging loss experience of newer business as it matures. That overall ratio is a meaningful metric, and how the portfolio itself performs will guide any changes we make to our participation. Moving on to Hurricane Isaias — that occurred in the fourth quarter and stands apart from the catastrophe losses reflected in our third-quarter results. Based on what we know today, we view it as a loss event we can handle. Our preliminary figure is a loss of as much as $35 million. Keep in mind that our catastrophe excess of loss program has an attachment point of $35 million. Claims handling remains at an early stage, and our estimate may shift as claims develop. Right now, we view a loss of as much as $35 million as a cautious figure, and we'll update you when fourth-quarter results are reported. From our current understanding, Isaias isn't expected to significantly alter our view regarding the June 1, 2027 reinsurance renewal. We continue to expect favorable pricing, though we acknowledge that terms will hinge on industry loss experience, capacity that is available, and conditions at the time of renewal. The third quarter represented the first complete quarter under the catastrophe reinsurance treaty renewed on June 1, 2026. Our ceded catastrophe excess of loss premium ratio fell to 42.7% from 48% a year earlier, mainly reflecting better risk-adjusted pricing. For the treaty period, we still anticipate program costs in the range of $430 million to $440 million. That said, I'll hand things over to Brian, who will walk through our financial results in greater detail.

Brian Foley

executive
#3

Thanks, Jon. Our net income came in at $28.4 million, equal to $1.44 per diluted share, versus $13.2 million, or $0.67 per diluted share, in the same period last year. Adjusted net income stood at $28.3 million, or $1.44 per diluted share. Income before taxes rose 111% to $39.6 million, up from $18.8 million in the prior year period. I will take you through the premium growth underneath, how our reinsurance decisions played out, and the expense comparisons, since these shed light on the strong year-over-year growth. Gross premiums written rose 22.7% to $293.3 million, up from $239.1 million, mainly driven by voluntary business growth. Gross premiums earned grew 14.9% to $255 million, up from $221.9 million. Ceded premiums earned fell to $153.9 million from $170 million, chiefly because of the cut in our non-catastrophe quota share cession from 40% to 25%, effective January 1, 2026. Net premiums earned climbed 94.5% to $101.2 million, up from $52 million in the prior year period. Growth in our net earned premium mirrors both the expansion of our underlying business and our choice to keep a larger portion of it. Effective January 1, we lowered our non-catastrophe quota share cession from 40% to 25%. What that means is that more premiums stay with American Integrity. It also means we hold on to more losses and get less ceding commission income to offset expenses. On top of that, better catastrophe reinsurance pricing is working in our favor economically. These items matter for understanding the improvement in our earnings. Net investment income rose 21.9% to $8.4 million from $6.9 million, driven by redeploying roughly $200 million of cash into fixed income securities at the start of the quarter, and to a lesser degree by higher interest rates. Loss and loss adjustment expenses grew to $38.3 million from $29.7 million, mainly due to business growth and the larger share of losses we keep after the quota share reduction. Our net loss ratio improved to 36.6% from 54.1%, while our net underlying loss ratio improved to 31.7% from 49.9%. The higher prior year net loss ratio came from the timing of reinsurance costs ahead of anticipated earned premium growth. Catastrophe losses in the third quarter were $5.1 million, stemming from severe convective storms, versus none in the prior year period. As Jon mentioned, the gross underlying loss ratio was 18.9% against 19.3% a year ago; that ratio shows the underlying loss experience before reinsurance. The bigger shift in our net underlying loss ratio mainly comes from our reinsurance structure, where added costs of our cat tower started hitting our financial statements in the third quarter of 2025, before the anticipated growth showed up in earned premiums. That distinction matters when judging how much of the improvement stems from underlying loss experience and how much stems from the economics of the reinsurance program. Policy acquisition expenses rose to $18 million from $6.3 million, reflecting greater new business production and reduced ceding commission income after the quota share reduction. Ceding commission offset allocated to policy acquisition expenses was about $15 million this quarter, compared with $20 million in the prior year quarter. The comparison to the prior year was helped as well by the Citizens take-out business, since that business comes with very little in the way of upfront acquisition costs. G&A expenses rose to $17.6 million, up from $7.3 million. Within that $10.3 million increase, roughly $8 million comes from lower ceding commission offsets tied to the step-down in the quota share. The other approximately $2 million came from growth in our gross G&A expenses; we think this explanation matters so you can separate the cost of running the business from changes in the quota share. Our expense ratio went up to 34% from 24.8%. This comparison was affected by higher production, business mix, and lower ceding commission offsets, along with the absence of Citizens take-out windfalls. Our combined ratio came in at 70.6%, better than 78.9%, which is an improvement of 8.3 percentage points. That shows strong reported underwriting profitability for the quarter, while the underlying measures and the reinsurance explanation give context for the year-over-year comparison. Annualized return on equity was 29.8%, versus 17% a year ago. Annualized adjusted return on equity was 29.8% as well, versus 18.1% a year ago. Shareholders' equity grew to $391.2 million at September 30th, up from $337 million at year-end. Book value per share came to $19.96, which is up 23.7% year-over-year and 5.8% since June 30th, 2026. Book value growth offers shareholders one more measure of the value building up in the company as we execute. We also repaid all of our outstanding surplus note debt in the quarter and finished the period with no debt. With that, I'll hand the call back to the operator so we can open the line for questions.

Tommy McJoynt

analyst
#4

Hey, good morning, everyone. Appreciate you taking our questions, and congratulations on a strong quarter. My first question actually concerns the Citizens take-out opportunity. Although the policy count at Citizens in Florida sits at a multi-decade low, it's notable that roughly 170,000 policy take-outs have occurred year to date. American Integrity, I believe, took maybe 1,000 of those earlier this year. Still, when you're reviewing the data room of what's available at Citizens, what do you believe drives your conclusion that none of these policies satisfy your underwriting or profitability standards? Yet evidently other carriers doing take-outs do see an opportunity there. So what might cause such a divergence in how that opportunity gets evaluated?

Bob Ritchie

executive
#5

Tommy, it's Bob Ritchie here. Thank you for your kind words. This is how I feel about it. Citizens Property Insurance Corporation currently has 216,000 risks in its policy count; that's too low. The previous time this happened, it wound up around 400,000. My reason for saying that is Florida has no assigned risk program. There are plenty of non-standard risks for a state with 23 million people and 8 million rooftops. We don't believe it's responsible, nor do the underwriting characteristics match what we're looking for. Now, I'm not here to criticize anyone who perhaps has done that, but for us, it doesn't make sense. Beyond that, Jon's going to explain why we don't need them. Go ahead, Jon.

Jon Ritchie

executive
#6

Right, Tommy, to build on that point, because of how we've grown our distribution organically, we're able to draw in the kind of risk that we consider profitable and appealing to us organically via the voluntary marketplace. As far as we're concerned, the Citizens take-out has always been additive rather than central to our overall production strategy.

Tommy McJoynt

analyst
#7

Understood. That's clear. Now, turning to another topic, I realize the next 6/1 reinsurance renewals are still quite a distance off, but I'd like a refresher on the way you think through and eventually negotiate your retention levels. In this cycle, the retention was a $35 million first event loss, yet since you're growing at a healthy pace, possibly lowering your quota share, and producing really robust earnings, as you consider where that $35 million figure might go next cycle, do you aim for a particular percentage of income, a percentage of equity, or some other factors? Thanks.

Jon Ritchie

executive
#8

Yes, Tommy, when we look ahead to next year's renewal, given the portfolio and exposure growth, that $35 million exhaustion point for the insurance company and captive will rise in proportion to the portfolio's growth; we will start negotiating that very soon as our conversations begin, especially for our cat bond issuance, which comes earlier than the traditional program on June 1st. But you should expect that $35 million exhaustion point of our retention to go up at next year's renewal.

Mitchell Rubin

analyst
#9

Morning, everyone. Mitch here, filling in for Greg. Nice work on the quarter.

Bob Ritchie

executive
#10

Morning.

Mitchell Rubin

analyst
#11

After your latest events with top agents, what feedback did you get regarding the competitive landscape that is influencing your voluntary growth projections for 2027?

Jon Ritchie

executive
#12

Sure, our discussions with agency partners remain extremely positive regarding Q4 of this year and our growth prospects looking toward 2027, especially as we keep advancing the strategic initiatives of expanding in South Florida and also middle-aged homes, segments where we are underweighted both geographically and by risk characteristic. There is substantial opportunity for us with existing distribution and, particularly in South Florida, as we bring on additional distribution. American Integrity has participated in this market for 20 years, and our relationships go back 20 years to when we founded the company. The competitive marketplace has definitely intensified with new entrants and the overall risk appetite of incumbents. Still, we are confident that our capacity to deliver on our 2027 new business plan will succeed with our existing agency plans and as we keep growing that under Dick Dowd, who heads our sales and marketing team.

Mitchell Rubin

analyst
#13

Thank you. I appreciate that additional detail. Could you share more about what is behind the ongoing gains in retention given this market that keeps getting more competitive, and perhaps how you see that developing as we move into 2027?

Jon Ritchie

executive
#14

Yeah, that's a good question. Part of it is simply that, across the last 2 renewal cycles, consumers have started getting renewal invoices that are flat, or even somewhat below the premium they paid for the earlier term. As a result, they are shopping their policy less often. And of course, the support and partnership from our agency partners that I mentioned a moment ago plays a role, along with the American Integrity brand, American Integrity's ability to pay claims, and our company's 20-year track record; all of those things together are what have let us achieve a really strong return when it comes to growth in overall policyholder retention.

Mitchell Rubin

analyst
#15

Thank you for taking my questions.

Paul Newsome

analyst
#16

Good morning. I was wondering if you could spend a little time on the move into dwelling fire and how that could alter some of the metrics we track for the portfolio as a whole, correct? What I have in mind is things like average premium issues, margins, and changes in the expense ratio relative to the loss ratio. In what way does the shift toward dwelling fire affect those things?

Bob Ritchie

executive
#17

Good morning, Paul; this is Bob. It is good to hear from you. In Florida we are a market leader for dwelling fire, and have been for decades. It represents a natural extension of both the relationship and the business opportunity, and it comes with characteristics that, in some cases, carry lower loss costs. Jon, would you elaborate?

Jon Ritchie

executive
#18

Sure, Paul — I'd say that when you look at us bringing that into the expansion states beyond Florida, the loss experience from that line of business won't differ in any hugely material way. Average premium might vary a bit versus the HO-3 line in some cases, though not all; but really, what we're after is adding a line of business our agency partners request and have been requesting, so they can handle landlord-type business — something along those lines. That's the natural evolution for us, and it's what we did here in Florida when we launched the company. Naturally, we began with an HO-3 line of business, but we added complementary lines of business quite quickly, dwelling fire among them.

Paul Newsome

analyst
#19

Beyond dwelling fire, do you have any plans to expand into some of these other related products? There are competitors out there doing data commercial, doing some other things. I'm just curious whether you had

Jon Ritchie

executive
#20

What could

Paul Newsome

analyst
#21

when you take a longer-term view.

Jon Ritchie

executive
#22

Yeah, beyond dwelling fire in those expansion states, we don't have any other immediate plans for 2027; but of course, speaking in broad terms, we'll keep assessing which products we currently offer in Florida, like boat owners, might be a natural line of business we'd want to add in some of those states. As for commercial in those states, we're watching the marketplace. We're checking whether an opportunity exists. It's still a bit too soon for us to make that determination, but everything you asked about is certainly among the opportunities on the table when we take a longer-term view.

Paul Newsome

analyst
#23

All right, I appreciate the assistance. Many thanks.

Bob Ritchie

executive
#24

Thanks.

Bob Ritchie

executive
#25

Thanks, and I appreciate everyone's questions and the attention you've given the company. To close, I'd like to lay out why I believe American Integrity stands out as a compelling long-term investment. Our strength comes from three capabilities developed across twenty years that reinforce one another. First, underwriting know-how in complicated property markets. Second, lasting ties with independent agencies and other partners. Third, the financial self-discipline to retain a greater share of the value we generate. This quarter's results demonstrate both what that combination can achieve and what it realistically delivers. We are dedicated to carrying out that strategy steadily — selecting risks wisely, setting proper prices for them, supporting policyholders when losses happen, and protecting the capital placed in our trust. Our approach to expansion is to chase opportunities only where the financials make sense, and to decline those that do not. That kind of discipline is just as important to where we're headed as hitting any output target. With close to five hundred thousand policies now active, I'm mindful of what that figure carries with it, since behind every policy sits a household that depends on us. It also means an agent who has staked their good name and their income right next to ours. And it means shareholders — every one of you — placing confidence in us to choose wisely; all three of those trusts must be re-earned daily. That is the business we've constructed, and it's the way we're running it. I'd like to extend particular appreciation to the whole American Integrity team—350 people strong—who show up each day determined to improve our company and boost its profitability as we expand; what we're reporting stems from the discernment, the attentiveness, and the sense of responsibility our staff deliver in their daily work, all the way from choosing and pricing risks to backing our agents and assisting policyholders at the moments they need us most. This team makes me extremely proud, and I'm thankful for the dedication that produced these results. And to our agency partners, policyholders, reinsurers, and shareholders: thank you for the trust and partnership you keep giving us. This quarter's results make us happy, yet we won't halt at this point—our attention stays fixed on gaining that confidence by delivering steady results across time. Thanks for being with us; enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#26

This concludes today's call. Thank you so much for attending. You may now disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.