Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 3, 2024

Euronext Paris FR Financials Banks earnings 63 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good afternoon, everyone. I'm the conference operator speaking. We appreciate your participation in Crédit Agricole's First Quarter 2024 Results Conference Call, and welcome to it. Please be aware that everyone attending is in listen-only mode for this session. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'll hand things over to Mr. Jerome Grivet, Deputy Chief Executive Officer of Crédit Agricole S.A., who oversees Steering and Control. Sir, the floor is yours.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#2

Good afternoon, everyone. I'm glad to be here to walk you through these results today. I'll begin straight away with the presentation, on Page 4, where we set out the key messages for the quarter. The first item, obviously, that's on all our minds is that we're reporting our highest first quarter results ever. The second thing I also want to stress is that this very strong level of results stems, of course, from the end of the contribution to the single resolution fund, but also — and this has held true for many, many quarters now — from further enhancement in the operational parameters, with revenues up and very good cost control. Because of that, naturally, we still enjoy a very solid capital and liquidity position, and we've been able to keep developing our strategic operations during the quarter — here you have a list of the various operations mentioned on this page. And we've also kept working, of course, on the energy transition program that we launched two years ago. Moving to Page 5, where you'll find the main figures for the group and for Crédit Agricole S.A.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#3

I won't go through every one of these figures, naturally, but let me point out just a handful. Starting with the group, what we observe is simultaneously a strong movement in the top line — plus 6.7% — a substantial gain in gross operating income excluding the contribution to the single resolution fund of plus 8%, and above 30% when last year's single resolution fund contribution is factored in. On top of that, net income group share improved to €2.4 billion, up 42% — 43% if we set aside the contribution to the SRF — and up 6% excluding that contribution. Turning to Crédit Agricole S.A., those same indicators also show a marked improvement. Top line, gross operating income and net profit, both with and of course without the contribution to the single resolution fund: net profit of €1.9 billion, plus 13.3% and plus 55%, and top line up 11% at €6.8 billion. Perhaps just one or two further figures I'd like to stress on this page: the cost income ratio for Crédit Agricole S.A. has moved further down, to 53.7%.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#4

That figure is down 40 bps versus Q1 2023, and return on tangible equity for this quarter exceeds 16% — 16.3%. On the next page, we wanted to give a bit of a preview of what this year will bring, given the very strong results we're reporting for the first quarter and based on the reassessments we've been carrying out regarding our potential development over the remainder of the year. And we're happy to report that we plan to hit every target in the medium-term plan for 2025 as early as this year. That was already true for the cost-income ratio and for return on tangible equity, where we came in under 58% and over 12% last year. And naturally we'll keep that up this year as well, but it wasn't entirely the case for net profit. And we now expect to deliver net profit above €6 billion for the full year of 2024 rather than 2025. This is also a good moment to point out that since 2016, we will have nearly doubled net profit at Crédit Agricole S.A. across those eight years.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#5

Moving to the next page, we'd like to use this results presentation as a chance to bring you up to speed on our energy transition program. First, a quick reminder of the three pillars of our strategy: it rests first on permanently speeding up the growth of our financing and investment in renewable and low carbon energy sources. And here are some numbers demonstrating that we keep accelerating quickly along this path. The second element: we keep assisting our customers — every category, corporate, SMEs and households — in their transition, and we've developed a number of initiatives to help them make it. And third, which follows from the first two elements, we will keep lowering our own carbon footprint, I would say, targeting our net zero trajectories by 2030, consistent with the various targets we've already published. Those targets are recalled on the next page, Page 8, where we update the results of the first five trajectories we had announced back in December 2022. And as you can see, across all of those trajectories we are very much on track toward the objectives we set for 2030. And we have added, as you know, three new trajectories at the end of last year, which are recalled here on the right-hand side of this page.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#6

Also, for these 3 additional sectors, we will begin supplying figures and data at the start of next year, so we can verify that across these 3 sectors as well we remain on track toward the 2030 target. Beyond that, let us recall that we keep substantially lowering our exposure to hydrocarbon extraction, which now stands at approximately $1 billion, with all financing of new fossil fuel extraction projects brought to an end. Let me move to Page 10 now and share some details about the activity we recorded this quarter. Again, as I would put it, this naturally continues the same strategy and the same growth engines we have pursued for many, many years now. There are 2 elements I want to highlight here. The first is that our universal retail banking model keeps expanding, with several indicators reflecting this favorable development. Customer capture momentum remains good. Net inflows of customer deposits at our banks keep rising. Insurance activity has been very strong, both in life insurance, where we are reporting record inflows this quarter, and in non-life insurance, where the equipment rate of our customers keeps climbing across the different services we offer them.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#7

We also saw strong and well-balanced asset management inflows at Amundi. And finally — and this isn't something we should keep in mind when gauging how active our retail banks are — it's true that new loan production, particularly home loans, has slowed. That's a very direct result of monetary policy normalization. I'd even say that monetary policy normalization is aimed precisely at this decline in new loan production. But again, this shows it isn't sufficient to characterize a drop in overall activity at our retail banks. On the contrary, activity is developing well at our retail banks in France and across the rest of Europe. Turning to the large customer division, we are posting this quarter a record level of activity and a record level of revenues, both for the CIB and for the custody activities, with a sharp rise in assets under custody and under administration for CACEIS. Let me now go to Page 11, where we show some precise indication of how this overall financial performance was generated, starting with revenues. Revenues are up 11.2% for CASA this quarter.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#8

As you can see on this page, every business division is contributing to the rise in that overall top line. The Asset Gathering division gained at once from solid commercial momentum and from favorable market effects. Within the Large Customers divisions, CACEIS again set a record for revenue level, surpassing the record we posted in Q1 2023. And CACEIS, which is reaping the benefits of integrating RBC's European activities, both of those entities are delivering a steep rise in their top line. Turning to the specialized financial services division, here too we gain from the full integration of Crédit Agricole Auto Bank, which was carried out only in the second quarter last year and was not in our scope of activities at 100% back in Q1 2023. In Retail Banking activities, we see a top line increase, both for LCL, French Retail and for the international retail banking activities. And finally, in the Corporate Center, we have a rise in the top line, driven mainly by the valuation of the Banco BPM shares that we bought back in 2022. So all in all, a steep increase in the top line.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#9

And on the right side of this page, it's clear that this top-line growth has been building steadily since at least 2017 — quite consistently, and it seems to be speeding up lately, combining organic and inorganic growth. Perhaps one final point on this page: naturally, there's the scope effect benefit in this quarter, but integrating the acquisitions we made — sorry — last year accounts for under half, specifically 40%, of the top-line increase. Moving to the next page on costs, the overall cost base is rising more slowly than the top line, at plus 10.2%. So for the quarter, we have a positive jaws effect. And in assessing where that cost increase sat, it's evident the scope effect is the main driver, since the bulk of the cost-base increase shows up in the large customer divisions and in the SFS division. Within large customers, that's naturally the RBC integration, and in the SFS business division, it's the full consolidation of Crédit Agricole Auto Bank.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#10

If you set aside the scope effect, the total rise in our cost base would have come in at only about 5%, driven primarily by HR expenses, reflecting the full-year impact of the general salary raises made in the middle of 2023, along with the individual salary increases implemented at the start of this year, which is something we do on a regular basis. Moving to Page 13, here's our overall assessment of the cost of risk. In this quarter, it is roughly flat versus the first quarter of 2023, and it is coming down somewhat relative to the average for the fourth quarter of 2023. It is somewhat lower, particularly when compared with Q4 2023. As was true last year, the cost of risk is concentrated in the specialized financial services division. That means mainly consumer credit along with retail banking activities. We even recorded a loan loss provision reversal at the level of CACIB within the large customers division, and the same applies to CACF, meaning the consumer credit business. Naturally, a scope effect also plays a role, since back in Q1 2023 we had no cost of risk arising from Crédit Agricole Auto Bank, whereas now we do. Looking at how the cost of risk evolves division by division each quarter, what stands out is that it is roughly stable or even edging slightly lower, which is notably true for the consumer credit division specifically.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#11

Moving to Page 14 now, for a broad view of how Crédit Agricole SA's global P&L has evolved. Starting on the left side of that page, you'll notice every business division added positively to the rise in the bottom line. That bottom-line growth comes to plus 55%, which of course includes the benefits from the end of the contribution to the Single Resolution Fund, yet it is still plus 13.3% once you strip out the benefit from that contribution ending. And what the right-hand side of the page indeed shows is that gross operating income, excluding the contribution to the Single Resolution Fund, gained from the sharp rise in the top line — close to €700 million in additional revenues. Bearing in mind one more element we forgot. But in Q1 last year, we were still benefiting from the remuneration of the mandatory reserves at the ECB, which is no longer the case now. And against this increase of close to €700 million in revenues, under €350 million of additional costs produced a significant rise in gross operating income, excluding Single Resolution Fund, of plus 12.3%.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#12

The remaining item is smaller, and that's what produces this pronounced rise in net income group share, up 13.3%, excluding Single Resolution Fund. Solvency is on Page 15. Beginning with Crédit Agricole SA, solvency appears stable at 11.8% at quarter-end, matching where it stood at the end of last year. This reflects both a substantial amount of retained earnings and a fairly large lift in organic growth of the business lines' RWAs. Still, I'd like to highlight two things about that movement. First, as in each quarter, whenever Crédit Agricole Assurances does not distribute its results to Crédit Agricole SA, the equity accounted value — the carrying value — of Crédit Agricole Assurances goes up, which raises RWA consumption by 1.8 billion, or 1.7 billion of additional RWA. So naturally, each time we upstream a dividend, that will come down. Second, at CASA, for a number of technical reasons, we are seeing a peak in RWA consumption that will be largely reversed over the quarters ahead. Then there are various bits and pieces, among which we have the last — or rather not the last, since we still have another one coming back next year.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#13

There's an additional layer of IFRS 9 phasing in that costs us five bps. We also have a few other technical items. So solvency at CASA stays stable at a level that sits very comfortably above the 11% target. At the group level, we also see stability, with the same factors producing this steady 17.5% CET1 ratio, a high level of retained earnings, meaningful organic growth in RWAs — including the CASA points I just raised — plus some smaller bits and pieces. Beyond this very high core Tier 1 solvency, which exceeds the requirement by 780 bps, our leverage ratio, TLAC ratio and MREL ratio all stand very significantly above every requirement. Finally, on liquidity, our position remains very solid, with LCR ratios very significantly above 100% and even very significantly above our 110% target. We've seen a new and further increase in the level of liquidity reserves. Even though we repaid €21 billion of TLTROs this quarter — it's almost the end of the TLTRO — we still have less than six additional billion to go.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#14

And every element tied to how stable our customer deposits are, along with how solid our liquidity positions remain, keeps performing in a very favorable way. I'll pause at this point so that you have adequate time to pose your questions. Still, to wrap up all of these elements, I simply wanted to sum things up by restating that we are delivering an outstanding quarter where results go, with the very same trends observed across recent quarters and indeed across recent years, a steady expansion both organic and inorganic, robust operational efficiency, and very strong asset quality. And that is therefore bringing us, notwithstanding all the uncertainty in the environment, to anticipate that we will hit by 2024 every target we had originally established for 2025. So I'll conclude here and hand you now the floor for your questions.

Operator

operator
#15

This is the conference operator speaking. The question-and-answer session is starting now. <<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Azzurra Guelfi at Citi. You may proceed.

Azzurra Guelfi

analyst
#16

Good afternoon, and I’m genuinely pleased to be back with a couple of questions. First, regarding the profitability target you’ve set: you’ve already delivered nearly €2 billion of net profit in the first quarter, your cost income is very strong, and you have the benefit of the acquisition beginning to materialize in the second part of the year. I know you’ve said above €2 billion, but given all these moving parts, doesn’t that appear a little conservative? And perhaps you could also comment on French retail NII as a second point, since I see you still anticipate some pressure on margin and on the level of lending. It still isn’t increasing — owing to monetary policy developments. So I’ll leave it at those two. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#17

Apologies, Azzurra — the connection wasn't great. So I'm inferring what you asked, though I believe I caught the gist. Your first question concerns the targeted net profit. You appear to believe that €6 billion is overly cautious. What I'd say is that we're making progress here, since until now we've held to the position that the sole pledge we made was hitting €6 billion in 2025. What we're telling you now is that we will already exceed €6 billion in 2024. So please don't push us to advance too quickly on too many fronts simultaneously. We'll stay with the notion of running one year ahead on targets that were established two years back. Consequently, I can't say precisely what the number will be at the close of 2024 — we shall see. Three quarters remain. And we're aware there could be certain headwinds that may offset the tailwinds you brought up. So headwinds exist. We're aware the climate is uncertain. We're aware that pressure on net interest margin may persist, particularly in French retail.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#18

That brings us to your second question. There will also be certain integration costs, since every one of these operations we're discussing will indeed bring in extra revenues. Yet at the outset, we must also bear some integration costs. So on balance, we consider it reasonable — perhaps conservative, though I'll let you decide whether that label fits — to simply accept that we will hit the €6 billion plus as early as 2024. And that figure we will not change. Turning to French retail and net interest income, what we observe is that Q1 versus Q1, the net interest margin is roughly stable. It does decline slightly in Q1 compared with Q4. That's true. This reflects a mix of different factors. The average yield of the loan book at LCL is absolutely stable. So the loan book sits at the same level in Q1 2024 and Q4 2023. And it isn't improving, chiefly because new loan production — which is meant to gradually lift the loan book's average yield — was very, very subdued this quarter. So new loan production was at only a very low level, and thus it made no significant contribution to improving the yield.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#19

At the same time, the average cost of customer liabilities rose slightly between Q4 2023 and Q1 2024 — again, by just a few bps. That reflects the ongoing shift from site deposits into term deposits, which costs a little more. Then there's another factor, a technical one, but it amounts to nothing: Q1 2024 had one day fewer than Q4 2023. And a final point is that within net interest income you also have some odds and ends that aren't directly tied to customer deposits, customer liabilities and hedging, but instead relate to portfolio revenues and similar items. It happens that we saw a fairly high level in Q4 2023 and a lower one in Q1 2024. So all of that explains why we see this slight decrease between the two quarters. And looking ahead at what may unfold over the remainder of the year, we still believe the average yield on the loan book ought to rise. We very much hope that production of new loans will progressively speed up. We keep hoping that the largest portion of the swings — or the switches within the shifts in customer liabilities — is now behind us.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#20

But we keep watching this situation very closely, since it all comes down to how customers behave, and that isn't something that's completely scientific. So all these elements tend to lead us to be prudent on the future revolution of NII at LCL. But I will end with this comment, which I made several time already. We are talking about 7% of the total revenues at CASA.

Operator

operator
#21

Our next question comes from Giulia Aurora Miotto at Morgan Stanley. Please go ahead.

Jean-François Balaÿ

unknown
#22

Hi there, Giulia.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#23

Hello there. Good afternoon, and thanks for taking my questions. So I'd like to ask — you're discussing the <<inaudible>>, and the division that performed especially strongly is large customers, and asset servicing within that. So I'm curious: how do you see the remainder of the year unfolding here, particularly once rates begin to decline? Should revenues expand, given that assets under administration and custody are growing, or will there actually be some margin compression as rates come down? And then second, on capital, may I just ask whether you could remind us, for the rest of the year, what impacts are coming? I believe I have the consolidation of the growth and €4 billion of trim. Is there anything else we should keep on the radar? Thank you.

Jean-François Balaÿ

unknown
#24

Thank you, Giulia. Regarding your first question about large customers, there are two separate aspects here. CACIB and CACEIS. With CACIB, everyone is aware that Q1 tends to be the strongest quarter of the year. So we're all aware we shouldn't annualize it by multiplying further to try to best estimate what the full-year results level would be. CACIB will keep benefiting from its strong positioning with its customers and from its very, very resilient business model. Still, we can't precisely predict what revenue level would be. And that isn't so closely tied to the interest rate level. As for CACEIS, it's true that net interest margin matters for CACEIS, particularly given that CACEIS generates on average close to €100 billion of cash that we can deploy across different maturities. So assessing what yield this cash could produce is very important. But CACEIS is also a fee-generating business, and those fees are computed based on assets under custody and assets under administration. And we hope this will keep growing as RBC is progressively integrated within our setup.

Jean-François Balaÿ

unknown
#25

The legal mergers will occur during Q2, and after that the remainder of the year will be focused on IT migrations. As those IT migrations happen and customers move progressively onto CACEIS platforms, we'll be able first to begin work on the cost base, and the benefits of the cost synergies will progressively become visible. Second, naturally, we anticipate some extra revenues from those customers, since once they're migrated onto our IT platforms we'll be in a position to improve the range of products and services we offer them. So looking ahead, for CACEIS we expect profitability to keep improving over time. On capital and capital headwinds, yes, indeed, the Degroof integration is going to happen. That's roughly 25 to 30 bps that probably will need to be booked at the end of Q2 or the start of Q3. It isn't entirely clear yet when the closing of the operation can be carried out, but it's around that.

Jean-François Balaÿ

unknown
#26

Then there’s trim, which you correctly brought up. Once more, apologies if I’m not being especially exact, but that could happen either during this year or perhaps — and this is our aim, what we hope to accomplish — in 2025 together with the remainder of the Basel IV transition. Also in 2025, we have a further 5 bps from the phase-out of IFRS 9. There’s Amundi’s acquisition of Alpha Associates, which closed at the start of Q2, and at the Kaza level that will cost us roughly 6 bps of solvency. That’s about everything. And again, I want to stress that, on the whole, our best assumption as of today is that once we enter Basel IV at the beginning of 2025, it will be broadly neutral for Crédit Agricole S.A. — meaning the negative items, such as consolidating the leasing businesses that aren’t prudentially consolidated at present, will be absorbed inside the overall neutral impact of the Basel IV transition.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#27

Thanks. That's very clear. And just to confirm, the trim will also be included in the neutral and Basel IV impact.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#28

Alright.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#29

Alright. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#30

Guillaume Tiberghien from BNP Paribas has the next question. You have the floor.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#31

Yes, good afternoon. The first question concerns your target. I realize there won’t be additional information for 2024, but clearly your 2025 figure is outdated at this point. So what can you give us to help us better understand 2025? The second question relates to international retail excluding Italy. That business appears to have been especially strong in this quarter. I’m therefore trying to work out whether this represents a new normal or something lumpy in nature? And just one clarification regarding the earlier question: did you state that trim is part of the zero impact for Basel IV? And does that also cover the onsite inspections? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#32

So to reiterate, trim sits inside the neutral Basel IV effect. That means either we absorb it during 2024 — which would raise RWA consumption that year and then bring it down in 2025 — or it gets folded straight into the Basel IV transition in 2025, in which case there's no impact at all. Once more, this is a rough assumption that the result will be neutral, but at the global level that's how it should land. On the 2025 target — I'm afraid I'll let you down slightly here. My view is that we won't be setting any target for 2025. My best guess is that at some point — I can't tell you precisely when — we'll need to establish fresh targets over a longer horizon, most likely 2027 or 2028. That should happen sometime between now and, let's say, one year from now. One last point on international retail excluding Italy: it is indeed particularly strong. Still, there's nothing exceptional in itself there. What is exceptional is the fourfold increase in net profit, since a year ago the profit level was low. But when it comes to overall profitability, within those three entities — which differ greatly from one another yet share a common feature, namely very high interest rates across those three countries and a very strong liquidity position at our banks in those three countries — it's absolutely normal for us to produce a high level of profitability under those conditions.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#33

So again, given where rates are and how much liquidity those three banks have, there’s nothing out of the ordinary about the profitability level we’re seeing right now.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#34

Thanks, Jerome.

Operator

operator
#35

Our next question comes from Stefan Stalmann at Autonomous Research. You have the floor.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#36

Yes. Hi there, Stefan.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#37

Good afternoon, Jerome. Hello. I have a couple of questions, if you don't mind. The first concerns Slide 6, where you reference a NIM ceiling for CA Italia. Would you be able to clarify what that term means? My second question relates to Slide 13. When I examine how the cost of risk has developed at LCL, it appears to be drifting somewhat higher — not by a large amount, but moving from 15 basis points to 21 basis points — whereas at the regional banks it has stayed notably steady at roughly 19 basis points. Is there something worth noting in that? Does a reason exist for that divergence? Or is it simply randomness inside a fairly narrow band of outcomes? Thank you so much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#38

Let me begin with your second question, Stefan. There is indeed a rise in the cost of risk at LCL this quarter, but it is very, very closely tied to what you mentioned, namely some random effect on a smaller basis rather than the aggregation of all regional banks. And perhaps one more factor plays a minor part as well: generally, the regional banks carry a much higher level of IFRS 9 provisions and maybe have more capacity to absorb the cost of incurred losses by writing back some IFRS 9 provisions, whereas at LCL we hold a very, very decent level of IFRS 9 provisions, though not of the same magnitude as the Regional Banks. So nothing significant at LCL, a few specific files this quarter, which show no characteristics of being systematic or systemic. And some differences between the Regional Banks and LCL regarding the historical capacity to build up IFRS 9 provisions. Then, turning to Crédit Agricole Italia and what we anticipate for the evolution of the net interest margin, what we are saying is that even if our retail activities in Italy are not exactly similar to those of the other Italian banks, because we have partially, I would say, injected into the commercial policies of Crédit Agricole Italia some of the characteristics that we use in France when it comes to providing some loans, fixed rate loans, to our customers.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#39

Even so, we're aware that Italy's market is far more driven by where rates go than France's is, for instance. And if we expect — which we do — that the ECB will begin lowering rates in June and likely keep going in the fall, then that will definitely affect the net interest margin at Crédit Agricole Italia, with everything else held constant, by gradually bringing down the return on the loan book somewhat. That's what we're conveying with this point.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#40

Perfect — that’s very clear. Thanks so much, Jean.

Operator

operator
#41

Moving on to our next question, which comes from Jacques-Henri Gaulard at Kepler Cheuvreux. The floor is yours.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#42

Good afternoon, and thank you. I have a couple of questions. First, it's pretty clear by now that over the past several quarters you've seen a step change in profitability, which is great. So is there not a temptation, or at least a possibility, for the Regional Banks to trim their stake in CASA, given that, all else being equal, they'd likely receive the same dividend amount, and that would strengthen your liquidity considering that two of your competitors in France aren't in the best shape at the moment? That's my first question. Second, on acquisitions — obviously you've done a lot of them. So I was wondering whether you feel you have some integration work ahead. It's true that you do. And given the distraction that always comes with it, will you pause a little on doing them? Or, if an opportunity comes along, will you keep — are you going to keep doing them? Sorry. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#43

Right now, Regional Banks lean more toward buying than selling. You might have noticed that back in 2022, they announced a plan to purchase €1 billion in shares, and they followed through. They took the same position again at the end of 2023, and in the next few days they'll likely report the outcome of that second buyback. So nothing I'm hearing suggests to me that they'd be sellers of shares. That said, it's definitely a question worth putting to them. In this matter, we're merely the object. On the acquisition front, it's true we've done a fair amount of buying lately, and we're extremely cautious about the integration risk you mention. What we monitor closely is whether each business line can properly absorb what it acquires. That means we try to keep the same management team from being tied up in too many integrations simultaneously. Naturally, not every management team has the same degree of experience in this respect. Take Amundi, for instance: over the past 15 years they've carried out a string of acquisitions that were integrated properly.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#44

So we're confident they have the ability to keep making acquisitions. Beyond that, they're acquiring Alpha Associates, but regarding the deal they've announced in the U.S., Amundi won't be on the front line for integration. It's Victory Capital that will need to fold Amundi U.S. operations into its own setup. So I'd say Amundi is relatively unencumbered and has plenty of capacity to take on new operations should any come up. And on the other businesses, it's true that when we approve an acquisition at our level at Crédit Agricole S.A., we factor in the business's actual ability to integrate properly.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#45

Thanks a lot.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#46

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#47

Sharath Kumar from Deutsche Bank, your next question — please go ahead.

Sharath Kumar

analyst
#48

I appreciate you taking my questions, and congratulations on a really strong set of numbers. I have a couple, and the first is about specialized financial services. I'd like to understand the reasons behind the weakness in a bit more detail. As of today, your ROE sits at 10%, and you're hoping for a step up to greater than 15% in the near term. So I wanted to understand how much of this is inched on rate cuts and recovery in loan demand. That's the first one. And second, just a couple of very small clarifications. First, on Amundi acquiring a minority stake in Victory Capital, would this also be have a penalizing impact from a capital standpoint, given that Amundi is only acquiring a 26% stake? And the second follow-up is on corporate center? Do we expect a continuous volatility for revaluing your minority stakes in Banco BPM and Worldline going forward? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#49

Thanks for those questions — they're obviously very relevant. To begin with the specialized financial services division, it's clear that over the last four or five quarters, we've seen the average margin level on outstandings decline. That comes from a combination of a rise — a sharp rise — in refinancing costs, along with only a gradual ability to pass those costs on to customers. This rise in refinancing costs reflects either regulatory factors, such as the usury rate in France, or competitive factors, like the fact that we operate in competitive markets and need to adjust gradually, only when we must raise rates for new customer loans. The good news is that for at least two quarters now, margins on new production have been rising sharply, and we've provided some figures on page 25 of the deck. The average customer rate went up by 23 bps between Q4 and Q1. And given that refinancing costs fell significantly over the same period, production margin actually improved by more than 50 bps. So naturally, this will feed into the P&L only gradually, because we need to see new loans replacing old ones.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#50

But this is definitely going to have some positive effects on CACF's net interest income in the second quarter — and definitely in the second half of this year. So I'm quite optimistic about CACF's capacity to improve its revenue level in the second half of the year. Victory Capital — for the time being, it's not very clear what the impact will be in terms of solvency for Crédit Agricole S.A., but it's definitely going to be very, very tiny, very limited. So we aren't able to disclose precisely what is going to happen, but definitely at our level it's not going to have a significant impact. And last point when it comes to the corporate center and the impact of the revaluation of Banco BPM stakes. Well, for many reasons this equity stake is accounted for through fair value against the P&L. And this is a choice that we made in the beginning, and this is not a choice that can be modified. So of course, this may trigger some volatility. As of now, we do not think that we are exposed to any risk of a sharp decrease in the stock price. And in addition to that, we have understood that BPM intends to be quite generous in terms of dividend.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#51

And naturally, whenever a dividend gets paid out, that gives us an additional revenue component, and it declines in the same proportion as the reference price. So to this point, even though there could potentially be some volatility, we aren't seeing any significant risks on our side arising from this stage.

Sharath Kumar

analyst
#52

I appreciate that.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#53

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#54

And our next question comes from Pierre Chedeville, who is with CIC. Pierre, you have the floor.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#55

Yes, good afternoon, Jerome.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#56

Yes. Hi there.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#57

I have a couple of questions. First, on the protection figures — which are really impressive both for individuals and for companies — I was wondering whether that impressive premium growth, 15%, 22%, if I recall correctly, came from something specific in the global market, or whether it came from specific commercial actions on your side, because those figures are really impressive compared to competitors. My second question concerns the cost of risk. I was wondering whether the cost of risk this quarter has been impacted by some specific Pfizer, as some other banks mention, or whether it's a day-to-day, I would say a casual cost of risk this quarter. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#58

Thanks, Pierre. Regarding protection, we've been pursuing this strategy for a great many years now. In our view, both individual protection policies — death and disability — and group protection policies genuinely belong to the range of products we aim to offer our customers. That's why these products and services are available from us on a permanent basis. And I'd say the numbers you're looking at — 15% for individual policies and 22% for group policies — reflect all the commercial work we're devoting to this area. Where group policies are concerned, bear in mind that this line is fairly recent next to individual policies, since it was introduced back in 2015. So we're still in the process of building up the portfolio, and we keep growing the business through a gradual widening of the distribution network. So this is entirely normal — there's nothing unusual about it from that standpoint. On cost of risk for this quarter, it's evident, and I believe we've mentioned this somewhere, that we've been exposed, like certain other banks, to a few, let's say, specific files that we won't identify by name, and that's simply part of the life of a large banking group such as ours.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#59

We can therefore envision that the expense tied to risk might come down over the next several quarters...

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#60

Since, I suppose, you've got a...

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#61

It really hinges on how asset quality develops, though you can see, for instance, with CACF, the peak came back in Q2 2023, and since then it's been coming down steadily. So further improvement is possible. That said, the cost of risk at quarter-end is exactly where it ought to be given what occurred during the quarter.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#62

Yes.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#63

Alright, thanks, Pierre.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#64

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#65

Moving on, our next question comes from Sam Moran-Smyth at Barclays. Sam, you have the floor.

Sam Moran-Smyth

analyst
#66

Good afternoon, and thanks for taking my questions. I have two questions about the demand outlook, please. Slide 63, which shows average production over time, is really helpful. Q1 was a historical low for both LCL and the regional banks, so my first question is when you might expect that curve to begin turning around, and I'm wondering how to think about any lasting effects of the usury rate caps from the start of last year. Is there pent-up demand from consumers who were previously shut out of the market, or are customers perhaps still just normalizing to the high rates that eventually came through? And then my second question concerns another business impacted by usury rates. I'm just wondering when you expect the consumer credit business to see a full recovery. I understand P&L is growing anyway from scope effects, but when would you expect those underlying numbers to pick up again? Thanks very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#67

Regarding retail activities, the usury rate is no longer affecting us. In fact, the significant rise in customer rates happened back in 2023, and throughout that entire year, month after month, we were straining to hold out until the following month so we could adjust pricing on new loans to a higher usury rate level. But from the start of this year, that has stopped being the situation, and in fact we are observing to some degree a modest decline in market rate levels for new loans. So the usury rate is no longer a problem. What is a problem when it comes to production of new loans is simply that customers are in a wait-and-see mode — initially set off by monetary policy and by the steep rate increase, but which has now shifted somewhat, I would say, toward certain expectations of a further drop in property prices. And in fact, if you are ready to purchase a property but you anticipate that waiting another three months might bring a lower price, that could cause you to hold off for another quarter.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#68

This is where things stand right now, particularly in France. That's why we haven't yet seen new loan production pick up. Our expectation, though, is that it will happen, probably around the middle of this year, and we're already seeing some green shoots — very tiny ones — as more customers reach out to ask what rate we'd be able to give them if they went ahead with a loan. The second point concerns consumer credit: as I mentioned, we anticipate the margin improvement on new loans to start showing up in H2 of this year. So Q2 will likely again be somewhat subdued when it comes to overall margin on the outstanding's, but gradually, and potentially during H2 this year, we'll begin to see the first gains from higher margins on new loans.

Sam Moran-Smyth

analyst
#69

Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#70

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#71

Anke Reingen from RBC has the next question. Go right ahead.

Anke Reingen

analyst
#72

Yes. Thanks a lot. I just had one question about wealth management. You mention on the slides that you delivered the highest quarter ever. And I'm just trying to get a sense of whether this is kind of just market driven, or whether any structural changes are driving it. And now with the Petercam coming in during the course of the year, Degroof Petercam — is that sort of a bolt-on idea, opportunistic, given the asset was on, given an asset was available? Or is this an area where we could kind of think about you're going to expand further and build out and look for opportunities? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#73

Alright. So revenue-wise, it was a really strong quarter. To start with, commercially speaking, the quarter went well. And then, as you can see, inflows came in at a meaningful level — close to €1.5 billion in net new money — along with a very favorable market impact. So taking everything together, the base off which we earned commissions in wealth management during this quarter was considerably higher. Secondly, customer activity was also at a healthy level, which produced a solid amount of transaction fees. But the point of departure is that, on the commercial side, we had a good quarter. As for possible further acquisitions in this business division, just bear in mind that Degroof Petercam still has to be integrated properly. So, I think for the time being, we won't be seeing meaningful acquisitions in this business division, because, once again, they need to be devoted to integrating properly the very important acquisition that was signed last year. And on Page 22 of our documents, you can see that this will generate some considerable costs through the end of this year, around €50 million. However, we are aiming for a very, very substantial improvement in the division's net profit, since we are targeting an additional €150 million to €200 million of additional profits.

Anke Reingen

analyst
#74

Appreciate it.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#75

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#76

Chris Hallam from Goldman Sachs has the final question. Go ahead, please.

Chris Hallam

analyst
#77

Yes, only one question remains from me, and apologies, Jerome. It concerns that 7% of group revenues again, though specifically home loan production during the quarter. Regarding the negative momentum you mentioned, how does that stack up against the market? It appears you might be reducing production to a greater degree than the market, yet simultaneously you are raising group profit guidance for this year. So I am simply curious whether CASA has made a deliberate choice to favour pricing above volume, essentially since the strong momentum elsewhere in the group means there is no need to pursue mortgage demand. I just wondered whether Jerome could comment on that.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#78

Absolutely not — and certainly inside the group, the notion that we would intentionally reduce how much commercial business we do for what I'd call purely financial motives really isn't something we do. So I think that comparison works a bit against us when it comes to the evolution, Q1 versus Q1, simply because in Q1 2023 the other banks outside the group had nearly halted, and in particular a number of large national networks had nearly halted when it came to distributing new home loans. And so for them the comparison, their basis of comparison, isn't very demanding, whereas in our case we actually kept lending throughout 2023. And so the basis for comparison is more demanding. But if you look at the market shares of the various groups, you could see that at the end of Q1 this year, Crédit Agricole Group's global market share is probably at its peak when it comes to home loans, outstanding home loans. So definitely no arbitrage on our side.

Chris Hallam

analyst
#79

Understood. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#80

Alright, since I realize that was the final question, I appreciate everyone joining. Enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#81

Ladies and gentlemen. Thank you for joining. The conference is now over. You may disconnect your telephones.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.