Better Home & Finance Holding Company (BETR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 13, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Hana Khosla
executiveGood morning, and thanks for joining us for Better Home & Finance Holding Company's Q3 2024 earnings conference call. I'm Hana Khosla, Vice President of Corporate Finance and Investor Relations here at Better. With me today are Vishal Garg, our Founder and Chief Executive Officer, and Kevin Ryan, our Chief Financial Officer. Along with this call, I'd ask you to take a look at our third quarter earnings release, which you can find on our Investor Relations website. An investor presentation is posted there as well. Some of what we say today may be forward-looking statements under federal securities laws, built on current expectations and assumptions. Those expectations and assumptions carry risks, uncertainties and other factors — we discuss these further in our SEC filings — that could make our actual results differ materially from our historical results. We take on no obligation to update forward-looking statements except as the law requires. During today's discussion, management will talk about certain non-GAAP financial measures, which we believe matter for assessing the company's financial performance. These non-GAAP financial measures shouldn't be viewed as substitutes for our GAAP results and should be read alongside them. You'll find reconciliations of these non-GAAP financial measures to GAAP financial measures in today's earnings release and investor presentation, both of which are on the Investor Relations section of Better's website and, when filed, in our quarterly report on Form 10-Q filed with the SEC. Figures described as of and for the quarter ended September 30, 2024, are a preliminary estimate as of the date of this earnings release and may be revised once we file our quarterly report on Form 10-Q with the SEC. Additional information as of and for the quarter ended September 30, 2024 will be provided upon filing our quarterly report on Form 10-Q with the SEC. I'll now hand the call over to Vishal.
Vishal Garg
executiveThanks, Hana, and hello everyone joining our Q3 2024 earnings call. We're grateful you're here today and for the support you keep showing as we pursue our goal of making homeownership better, faster, and easier for our customers by creating a technology platform that transforms what it's like to become and to be a homeowner. Toward that vision — where each customer can buy, sell, refinance, insure, and improve their home digitally online instantly without friction — we keep making solid strides. Let me begin by calling out several of the key wins from the quarter. We're still leaning into growth to push volume higher, balanced against continued efficiency gains, broader distribution channels, and management of corporate costs, with the aim of hitting profitability over the medium term. Put simply, even with a market still facing historically poor housing affordability and mortgage rates that stay persistently elevated, we keep advancing along the roadmap we laid out when the year began; during Q3, funded loan volume rose to $1.035 billion, which is a 42% year-over-year gain and an 8% sequential gain, surpassing the $1 billion funded loan volume guidance we gave last quarter. Because several significant 1x financial items tied to closing the de-SPAC transaction affected Q3 2023, alongside our year-over-year comparisons, we'll also call out the quarter-over-quarter shifts versus last quarter. Revenue for Q3 came in at $29 million, versus $32 million last quarter and $5 million in Q3 of last year. Keep in mind that last quarter's revenue also contained certain non-recurring benefits from a positive mark-to-market impact on our lock pipeline totaling roughly $5.5 million, which ought to be removed when looking at quarters sequentially. Once that benefit is excluded, our revenue grew about 8% quarter-over-quarter. We keep carrying out strategies to lift conversion via added products and services, and to boost sales efficiency so more customers pull through. We likewise keep raising revenue per loan through pricing and marketing channel optimization, which produced a year-over-year gain on sale margin improvement, from 1.58% in Q3 last year to 2.08% in Q3 this year. As we mentioned on the prior earnings call, I want to restate our strategic priorities for 2024. Priority one is thoughtfully leaning into growth, and we demonstrated continued progress on that this quarter. The year-over-year funded loan volume growth came from gains across all three product categories — purchase, refi, and home equity loans — with home equity products and refinance loans serving as the biggest growth drivers this past quarter. Purchase loan volume climbed 13%, home equity loan volume climbed 493%, and refinance loan volume climbed 177% year-over-year. Despite some of the temporary rate relief seen in Q3, this quarter ended with 30-year fixed mortgage rates comfortably above 7%, which keeps pressure on our customers dealing with a high cost of living and affordability challenges. With our home equity offerings, customers can tap into the value tied up in their properties, even when refinancing an existing mortgage doesn't make financial sense given where rates stand today. We're still eager to seize the chance to expand our seasoned loan officer ranks, bring on more marketing and brand advertising channels for our D2C operation, and introduce fresh products and services — like the streamlined refinance option aimed at FHA and VA borrowers, which we introduced just last week — so that we're properly positioned to grab a bigger slice of the market once consumer demand picks back up. Priority number two for us is boosting operational efficiency, making loan production costs more variable, and squeezing out maximum operating efficiency while the macro backdrop remains extremely difficult. During Q3, overall expenses rose by roughly $9.5 million versus the prior quarter, reflecting our ongoing push into particular growth-related costs like marketing, loan origination expenses, and compensation for bigger loan production teams needed to generate greater volumes, plus the fact that certain one-time expense benefits recorded in the previous quarter were absent. To put a finer point on it, marketing and advertising costs came in at $12 million in Q3, up from $9 million in Q2. We keep assessing what we get back from every additional dollar devoted to marketing, and we anticipate that spending will decelerate as the market enters a seasonally quieter stretch while our marketing approaches grow more efficient; those growth-related costs were partly balanced out by reduced general and administrative expenses and lower corporate compensation costs. Although compensation for our loan production team went up in Q3 owing to greater funds and the hiring of more loan officers, we remain convinced that our production cost is far more efficient than what the industry typically sees. Drawing on what we've learned from benchmarking ourselves against the industry, we figure that selling and processing a mortgage across the United States costs close to $9,000 per loan on average. Thanks to Tinman's capabilities, we've managed to automate the time-consuming, labor-heavy parts of the mortgage process and bring that cost down by more than 35% relative to the industry average; we're confident that our ongoing technology investments will push our costs down substantially further, delivering better operating efficiency and a superior customer experience. Following up on what we discussed last quarter regarding our AI investments, we're excited to unveil Betsy, the U.S. mortgage sector's first voice-based AI loan assistant. Betsy represents our newest innovation, created via Tinman, our proprietary loan origination platform, designed to boost the operational efficiency of our loan teams and elevate customer experience by delivering accurate, immediate answers to detailed questions and efficiently helping with pending tasks — all with the aim of achieving quicker service times, stronger self-service options, deeper customer engagement, and greater sales efficiency. With Betsy, loan officers can devote their time to talking through interest rate specifics with customers and handling other more complex licensed activities, rather than collecting data or carrying out routine verification work. She employs artificial intelligence and large language models to speed up a customer's whole mortgage process, all the way from the beginning of pre-approval through to closing the loan, and she is built to speak with customers out loud in order to respond to questions about mortgage applications and to gather and confirm application details that are still missing. Since Tinman's centralized, context-rich data setting is arranged in a hierarchical, tree-like format, it is simple for LLMs such as Betsy to comprehend. That stands in contrast to conventional mortgage industry software, in which information sits scattered among numerous fragmented systems and datasets, for example the point of sale system, the CRM system, the loan origination system, the document management system, and the pricing engine. Our belief is that Betsy will assist in driving our growth throughout the years ahead, and we are just starting to see how AI will upend the traditional mortgage industry, while our technology is establishing the benchmark for providing maximum value, savings and service to American homeowners; we are eager to show you today a demonstration of how Betsy is able to engage with a customer on a call, and we'll play this clip to help illustrate the power of this technology. <<presentation>> We are extremely enthusiastic about what Betsy may become down the road as we continue integrating Betsy into Tinman and assist consumers through even larger parts of their application across the whole mortgage process.
Vishal Garg
executiveWrapping up with priority number three — broadening where and how we distribute by expanding our B2B operations — we keep encountering appetite for both our tech and our origination skills among new partners that have well-known brands. These partners want to provide mortgages to their own customers without breaking the bank, or they want to make their current mortgage operations more efficient in fulfillment. Along those lines, I'm happy to share news of NEO Home Loans, a top distributed retail mortgage platform started by Danny Horanyi, Ryan Grant, and Chris Ledlie, whose aim is to give customers throughout the U.S. the finest service imaginable and genuinely change their lives before, throughout, and following a mortgage transaction. Much like those of us at Better, they've consistently maintained a goal of transforming the mortgage sector and treating their customers fairly. We're delighted to have brought on Danny and Ryan along with a handful of other people from the NEO team, with the aim of growing Better's premier technology platform and digital lead funnel so NEO's local loan officers can be empowered. For anyone who isn't as acquainted with how the various mortgage industry channels differ, there used to be a split separating lenders built around local branches from those operating digitally online. In the past, digital lenders were seen as tech-savvy, speedy, simple, and inexpensive, while branch-based lenders rely on advice and guidance, offering customers highly personalized education and analysis, though they may move more slowly and depend on outdated technology. We're eager to overturn those assumptions by launching NEO Home Loans powered by Better. The NEO group has only just come aboard, so we're still in the early stages, yet we can't wait to bring their more than 50 loan officer branches, which serve customers in 48 states, together with Better so that, jointly, we can alter how customers experience their path to homeownership. In my view, NEO Powered by Better represents an ideal blend of NEO's proven history of outstanding customer service and solid standing in the communities they work in, plus our AI powered Tinman technology, which we hope will eliminate friction from their fulfillment workflow and grow their ability to assist additional customers. Since we've barely begun, I should note that providing volume or financial guidance for NEO powered by Better is just not possible yet. However, because of the time it takes to bring branches onto our system, we don't anticipate any meaningful effect on our volume in the near term; we'll make certain to keep you informed as that onboarding moves forward and as the team remains intensely focused on completing the technology integrations; in our view, this chance to bring Tinman into the distributed retail channel opens up a crucial portion of the market that online originators have historically struggled to reach, particularly on the purchase side, where borrowers depend more heavily on advice and guidance from their trusted local loan officer; as background, the direct-to-consumer segment, where we have traditionally operated, expanded enormously during the COVID refi boom but has since leveled off at roughly 20% of all mortgage originations in the United States, while from 2021 to 2023 the distributed retail channel accounted for approximately 40% to 45% of the market. Based on those figures, this opportunity could nearly triple the addressable universe of customers we are able to serve. Looking past 2024, the medium term opportunity for Better remains very exciting. We stay focused on strengthening our go to market, with growth as our North Star, while maintaining disciplined expense management and channel diversification. We will keep investing in Tinman Automation and AI to improve the customer experience and further drive down labor costs, making our platform more efficient and scalable. With that, let me now hand things over to Kevin Ryan, our Chief Financial Officer, who will discuss the quarterly performance and our financial Kevin?
Kevin Ryan
executiveThanks, Vishal. Although conditions in the market stayed tough, during this quarter we kept pushing toward expansion, generating funded loan volume that rose both versus a year ago and versus the prior quarter, matching the outlook we gave three months ago of hitting $1 billion in volume in Q3; likewise, as we talked about three months ago, we kept spending heavily on particular growth items, such as compensation and marketing. During Q3, we additionally ended the lease on our New York office, and from that we anticipate saving roughly $10 million fully loaded from now through 2030, when the original lease was set to end. Now moving to third quarter financial results; funded loan volume came to $1.035 billion, revenue was roughly $29 million, and adjusted EBITDA loss was about $39 million. GAAP net loss in total for Q3 was around $54 million. Of the funded loan volume in Q3, 75% came via our D2C channel while 25% came via our B2B partner channel. By dollar volume, 71% was purchase, 16% was HELOC, which includes home equity lines of credit and closed end second lien loans, and the rest was refinanced; now let me briefly address our balance sheet and capital position. We closed the third quarter of 2024 holding $480 million of cash, restricted cash, short-term investments and self-funded loans. Our view is that we remain well capitalized to grow, with the liquidity needed to keep carrying out our vision and corporate objectives. We keep strong ties with our financing counterparties, holding three warehouse facilities totaling $425 million of capacity as of September 30, 2024. During the quarter just past, we also finished a reverse stock split of Better's common stock, at a ratio of 1 post-split share for every 50 presplit shares. Because of that reverse stock split, Better has returned to compliance with the minimum bid price requirements needed to stay listed on the NASDAQ global market. Following the reverse stock split, as of September 30, we had roughly 15.1 million shares outstanding across Classes A, B and C shares. Now shifting to our outlook for the rest of 2024. With mortgage interest rates having recently moved higher and with us entering a seasonally slower stretch of the year, offset by the ongoing growth initiatives we've covered on this call, we anticipate fourth quarter funded loan volume will be roughly in-line with third quarter volume; we stay focused on producing operating leverage via ongoing investments in efficiency, corporate cost management and broadening our distribution channels, aiming at profitability over the medium-term. I'll now hand it back to the operator for Q&A.
Analyst
analystHi there. I really appreciate you fielding this. Vishal, I'd like to ask about Betsy, the AI loan assistant you recently rolled out; it definitely seems promising, and the demo was quite striking; but from your perspective, what sets Betsy apart from other AI tools being used in lending? Could you go into more detail on that?
Vishal Garg
executiveAbsolutely. Thanks. That's a wonderful question. In my view, Betsy is quite sophisticated compared with certain things we've observed in the AI arena among mortgage firms. Much of the AI that mortgage companies—our publicly traded competitors included—have implemented really pertains to the back office side of things, processing or underwriting, where OCR has been used, which essentially means extracting data from a document. So you'd look at income information on a pay stub and generate the nearest estimate of what that income could be. That capability has existed in our Tinman system for a long time. Much of the other AI people discuss involves decisioning AI, in which essentially the machine makes the call instead of a person making the call to push the loan file ahead. Once again, that's been inside Tinman for a long time. We created that one day mortgage in which most of the work of taking a mortgage from a lock to a commitment letter happens automatically; and then the final piece we've observed at other mortgage companies as well is chatbots, meaning chat based customer support delivered online. And should you have actually tried those chatbots, you'd notice a massive delay and the chatbots can't truly advance the customer beyond essentially serving as an interactive FAQ, or frequently asked questions list. What we've accomplished with Betsy is actively embedding Betsy within our platform, Tinman. And as the call made clear, Betsy could, first, figure out which items were absent from the consumer's loan file, could absorb that data, and then attach it into Tinman itself and push the process forward and establish that the following step would be a rate quote, which would need a human based loan officer and then effectively hand that off to a human based loan officer. So we're discussing essentially substituting for the work that a typical loan assistant or SDA, sales development assistant, would have performed, and doing it better here. Now, for context, back in 2021 when our volume was $58 billion, we had more than 1,500 SDAs and loan assistants. And I'd estimate the overall spend on them exceeded $100 million annually. And Betsy can essentially carry out the function of these loan assistants and let us scale up. At this point, Betsy handles every one of the inbound phone calls we receive, which frees our loan officers to concentrate on assisting consumers once those consumers are prepared to lock in a rate, talk through different products, or engage in similar tasks that count as licensable activities. So we believe the technology behind Betsy, and the manner in which we built Tinman, which is essentially a decisioning engine sitting on a tree based data structure within something known as a JSON blob, is something LLMs can grasp quite easily and then process at a speed that truly has no equal. We have not observed anybody who can match the speed of response time, which, as you witnessed, felt nearly natural at roughly 800 milliseconds, compared with the 3 second response time typical of chatbots or voicebots across the industry. No one has really managed to engineer that the way we have, and that is why we felt at ease bringing it to market commercially and have now expanded it so that 100% of inbound calls are actively handled by Betsy; and so I think we have put in a great deal of work on this and we are only beginning. As of today, Betsy is the worst it will ever be. It improves week after week, and we are extremely, extremely enthusiastic about what we will be able to accomplish for our cost structure going forward.
Analyst
analystThat sounds great. If I may squeeze in one short follow-up — obviously, I realize this business started out digital-first; that's essentially baked into who you are. Still, I'd like to know how the two of you are thinking about the TAM as it stands today, and how that compares with the size the addressable market might ultimately reach.
Vishal Garg
executiveYeah. That's yet another fantastic question, in my view. As I believe we mentioned during the earnings call, the TAM today for consumer direct mortgage lenders within purchase mortgages sits at roughly 10% to 15%, correct? So even though our company's market share isn't especially large, our share is fairly substantial when you look at the proportion of purchase loans originated consumer direct. Through what we're now doing with NEO Home Loans, we're moving into a purchase market that's 4x larger and genuinely expanding the overall TAM beyond simply those consumers seeking to buy online — roughly 10% to 15% — to those engaged in the conventional loan officer and realtor referral relationship, which accounts for somewhere around 40% to 45%. And so, by taking Betsy and Tinman and arming local lenders with our technology, we believe we'll be able to reach a market roughly 4x larger than the one we've managed to reach up to now.
Kevin Ryan
executiveOkay, okay, this is Kevin, and I'll kick things off. Vishal might want to add something. Look, I mean, I figure all of us have been observing the market side by side, correct? We're sitting at about 4.40 on the 10-year. We released rates this morning, same as we do each morning; we're a bit above 7%. So I believe — and the MBA and other folks have somewhat reduced their projection for 25 compared with where they might have stood a few months back. So I think we're anticipating ongoing gains in the market backdrop. I mean, our refinance volume increased from a modest base, granted, yet it rose enormously during Q3. We've noticed that other firms did too, at least the ones that are public and have already reported. And so our base case assumes a gradual decline in mortgage rates across 2025, and we're preparing with that in mind. You've observed us raise marketing spend. You've observed us push toward expansion; we retreat when it fails; we press forward when it succeeds; and so I think our take on the operating environment looks largely the same for the coming year, though with slight gains across 2025. Probably not in a straight line — that's typically not how capital markets behave. But we anticipate that on this call in November of 2025, we'll be in a somewhat improved operating environment, and we're managing the company with that expectation.
Vishal Garg
executiveRight. So, at this same point 3 years back, when rates initially began climbing, purchased loans made up 5% of the volume we handled, while refinances accounted for 95%. The last couple of years have been challenging, yet we've shifted the company's direction extremely aggressively. Today, purchase mortgages represent 71% of what we do — pardon me — and I believe that share exceeds what most of our direct-to-consumer online competitors achieve. So we've discovered how to handle purchase mortgages digitally; we keep making further progress and gaining more insights from certain partnerships we'll soon establish with local retail operations in various markets. I think that will only improve us. Therefore, should conditions in the market remain tough, I expect you'll simply keep witnessing better execution from us in purchase lending and ongoing expansion fueled by stronger customer acquisition economics, stronger manufacturing expenses, reduced production costs, plus enhanced efficiency and client assistance via the work we're doing with Betsy.
Kevin Ryan
executiveRight, so this matters quite a bit. Neo Specialty involves purchase activity, and our position in purchase is, we believe, improving. In this country there's substantial demand that's been held back when it comes to buying homes, correct? We're aware of every factor behind why it has taken so long to gain traction — affordability issues, which include both interest rates and the cost of housing. Still, our sense is that we're placing the finest technology available in the industry with these local experts, and that ought to strengthen our capacity to make further inroads into purchase even while refi volumes remain low.
Vishal Garg
executiveWe’re grateful you could be with us on this earnings call for Q3. Your backing of what we’re trying to do—and of our goal to improve homeownership for every American—means a great deal to us, and we can’t wait to be with you again in the months to come for our Q4 call. Thanks.
Operator
operatorThis concludes today's conference call. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Better Home & Finance Holding Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Better Home & Finance Holding Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Better Home & Finance Holding Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.