Better Home & Finance Holding Company (BETR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

March 19, 2025

NASDAQ US Financials Financial Services earnings 76 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Hana Khosla

executive
#1

Good day, and thanks for joining the fourth quarter and full year 2024 earnings conference call for Better Home & Finance Holding Company. I'm Hana Khosla, Vice President of Corporate Finance and Investor Relations here at Better. With me on the call today are Vishal Garg, our Founder & Chief Executive Officer; Kevin Ryan, our Chief Financial Officer; and Ryan Grant, Co-Founder & President of Retail Lending at NEO Home Loans. Along with this call, I'd ask you to take a look at our earnings release for the fourth quarter and full year, which you can find on our Investor Relations website; an investor presentation is posted there as well. Some of what we say today may be forward-looking statements under federal securities laws, built on our current expectations and assumptions. Those expectations and assumptions carry risks, uncertainties, and other factors — described further in our SEC filings — that might make our actual results come out materially different from our historical results. Except where the law requires it, we take on no obligation to update forward-looking statements. During today's discussion, management will talk about certain non-GAAP financial measures that we think are relevant when evaluating the company's financial performance. You shouldn't treat these non-GAAP financial measures as substitutes for our GAAP results, and you should read them alongside those results. Reconciliations of these non-GAAP financial measures to GAAP financial measures appear in today's earnings release and investor presentation, both of which are available in the Investor Relations section of Better's website and, once filed, in our Annual Report on Form 10-K filed with the SEC. Additional information as of and for the period ended December 31, 2024 will be provided when we file our quarterly report on Form 10-K with the SEC. I'll now hand the call over to Vishal.

Vishal Garg

executive
#2

Thank you, Hana, and I appreciate all of you being on this call about our fourth-quarter and full-year 2024 results. Your presence means a lot, and so does the continued backing you give us as we work toward our goal of improving, speeding up, and simplifying home ownership through a technology platform that reshapes the entire experience. Our vision continues to advance: a future in which every customer can handle buying, selling, refinancing, insuring, and upgrading their home digitally, over the internet, right away, with no friction. I'll start with several important accomplishments; when 2024 began, our plan was to prioritize growth and AI to boost volume and revenue, all while maintaining our momentum on efficiency improvements, broadening our distribution channel mix, and reducing corporate expenses. Those objectives were met: funded loan volume for the full year rose 19% versus a year earlier, revenue climbed 50% year-over-year, and adjusted EBITDA losses shrank 26% year-over-year. We placed some big bets on Tinman AI and started a distributed retail channel called NEO Powered by Better, and both are showing encouraging momentum early on. Despite a market that stayed difficult, with housing affordability at historic lows and mortgage rates stubbornly elevated, we still advanced in 2024 along the roadmap laid out when the year began; for the full year 2024, funded loan volume came to 3.6 billion, revenue reached 108 million, and adjusted EBITDA loss was $121 million. In Q4, we funded 936 million in loans, which is a 77% increase compared to the same period last year, driven by growth across all three core product types: purchase, refinance, and second lien loans. Looking at it quarter over quarter, our funded loan volume dropped by about 10%, which is in line with the typical seasonal dip we see in the fourth-quarter purchase market. Revenue for Q4 was 25 million, compared to 18 million in last year's fourth quarter and 29 million in the prior quarter. We're continuing to focus on ways to improve conversion by adding products and services, while also refining our sales efficiency to increase customer pull through. During 2024, we consistently boosted the revenue we earned on each loan by refining our pricing strategies and optimizing the marketing channels we use. As a result, our gain on sale margin improved when compared to the prior year, climbing from 1.95% in 2023 to 2.17% in 2024. As we look toward 2025 and the years that follow, the strategic priorities we laid out on previous earnings calls remain essentially unchanged. The first priority involves continuing to pursue growth in a deliberate and thoughtful manner, and our performance during 2024 showed we made headway on that front. When comparing the fourth quarter to the same period a year earlier, funded loan volume grew, driven by gains in each of our three primary product categories, with home equity products and refinance loans serving as the strongest contributors to that expansion. Compared to the same period a year earlier, purchase loan volume increased by 25%, and refinance loan volume surged 611%, though that growth began from a quarter at the close of 2023 that was unusually low both for seasonal reasons and historically. For HELOC and home equity loans, our volume in the fourth quarter of 2024 was up 416% year over year. Fresh data from TransUnion indicates total HELOC and HELON originations grew 10% in the third quarter, and during that same quarter Better's origination volume increased 619%. So if HELOC market patterns remain stable or possibly improve in Q4, we believe the triple-digit growth we are experiencing will continue to outpace the industry in the fourth quarter, because our stronger product offering is fueling gains in market share. If you compare quarter over quarter, moving from Q3 into Q4, refinance volume jumped 34%. We saw a 3% gain in home equity loan volume, while purchase loan volume dropped 10%, largely due to the seasonal slowdown in home buying during the fourth quarter. Even though the mortgage market was better in Q4 than it was during the same period in 2023, 30-year fixed rate mortgage rates remained somewhere between the high sixes and low 7% range, and that continues to weigh on mortgage demand. We anticipate that rates will remain elevated in the near term, which should keep demand strong for our Home Equity products. Keeping expenses down and improving operational efficiency is our second priority, and our goal is to achieve profitability over the medium term. Total expenses in the fourth quarter came in roughly flat compared to Q3. Even so, those numbers contained about 17 million in restructuring costs that won't repeat, largely from shutting down our operations in the UK, along with roughly 4 million for ending some leases. If you set aside those one-time items, overall costs dropped around 24% from the prior quarter, which we achieved through cost-control efforts in every major spending category. On top of that, we reduced adjusted EBITDA losses by about 11 million, a 28% improvement, comparing Q4 with Q3, despite bringing in less revenue during a quarter that's typically slower. Here's the thing — we brought down what we spend on originating loans by 28%. We trimmed compensation-related costs by 21%. Marketing and advertising came down 27%. Meanwhile, volume only dropped 10%. That gap tells you exactly what our AI and automation work has delivered when it comes to operating leverage. With Tinman's capabilities in the mix, we've taken the time-heavy, labor-heavy pieces of the mortgage process and automated them, and that's gotten our cost to originate more than 35% below the industry average. We think the money we keep putting into technology and AI is going to drive those costs meaningfully lower still, which means better operating efficiency and a better experience for customers. To build on the updates we shared across the last two quarters about the money we're putting into AI, we're now realizing benefits as we keep growing Betsy. She's the mortgage sector's first voice-driven loan assistant here in the U.S., and she relies on large language models to walk a customer through pre-approval. On top of that, she now handles rate quotes and rate locks without human involvement. Through Betsy's program, she talks with consumers out loud to address their mortgage application questions, and she gathers and confirms any application details still missing. These are tasks sales staff have historically handled, and the aim is to deliver quicker service, stronger self-service options, deeper customer involvement, and better sales productivity. When it comes to hard figures, Betsy handled about 5,000 customer interactions back in June of 2024, and by February of 2025 it was completing over 115,000 consumer interactions. That works out to growth of more than 20x, and all the while we kept adding to what Betsy can do. On our last quarterly call, we shared a brief early video of Betsy talking with a customer on a call. Today we're excited to show a demo in which Betsy walks a customer through the whole mortgage rate lock process — previously, that meant speaking separately with up to three sales team members and going through multiple rounds of manual data entry. Thanks to Tinman technology, this whole process can now be handled 100% autonomously by AI, around the clock, every day. Wherever and whenever customers want, Betsy is there for them. <<presentation>> Let me point out what sets Betsy apart from the other AI bots you may have encountered in financial services; this isn't merely an SAQ bot or a tool for scheduling appointments, which is what we've seen other mortgage companies rely on. Typically those bots handle just one task and only engage users through chat, unlike bots. The cause of these shortcomings at other mortgage companies is that they connect to just one software system, whereas most mortgage companies generally use seven to eight systems. On top of that, the majority of these legacy systems for origination and servicing run on architecture from the 1980s, which severely restricts what AI tools can do.

Vishal Garg

executive
#3

Betsy runs on Tinman. Tinman pulls a full point of sale setup, a CRM, tools for pricing and eligibility, a loan origination system, an insurance engine, an appraisal management platform, a QC system, and a closing platform together into one package. Anything a customer or someone on our loan teams does is captured there, and all information about the customer or the property lives in one centralized fax graph. That way an LLM can quickly pull the full picture and move forward or backward through any step of the mortgage journey alongside the consumer, just like a human would. If a typical mortgage lender attempted to put a complete AI agent stack into production, the round trips of data between that agent and all the connected systems would create massive delays. Those delays would be bad enough that most borrowers would just walk away. Because Tinman gives us an end-to-end platform, Betsy can take a customer from that very first question, through the rate lock, and right up to funding, all inside a single interface. We've also been growing another AI application: using our Tinman AI to perform work that an underwriter would normally do. More precisely, that means qualifying income, assets, and credit so a decision can be prepared and underwritten. You probably remember that we've automated big chunks of gathering documents, pulling out data, and running underwriting math. Thanks to that, our one day mortgage product now accounts for over 70% of the mortgage volume we do, and the typical stretch from lock to commitment letter is eight hours — something revolutionary in mortgage lending, especially when getting a commitment letter elsewhere can stretch to 45 days. Last quarter, we began applying AI review, which in certain situations shortened things to under a minute. It's pretty amazing: with AI, we're going from one day mortgage to less than one minute mortgage. By the close of 2025, we intend to push AI-driven underwriting review past the 75% mark of our locks, which should cut fulfillment labor expense per loan considerably and clear a choke point in a vital part of the mortgage workflow. Intelligent routing of appraisal requirements, along with AI underwriting for title insurance, represents a third mortgage underwriting domain where we've made solid headway. By refining how we handle this, we've begun to offer instant title and appraisal on a modest share of our locks, and we're aiming to expand that in the coming months. We think it won't be long before a buyer can be completely underwritten for a mortgage—covering credit, income, assets, title, and appraisal—within minutes of signing a contract on a home. The key point: we're leaning even harder into what we see as a massive edge we have with AI agents in our Tinman platform, because of the changes we're seeing in how regulators are behaving. Over the past few months, we've noticed a significant increase in regulators' willingness to embrace AI. On the AI front, we've removed the limits. A month ago, we launched Betsy to serve as the primary customer-facing contact for refinance lending in one state, while a human loan officer stays available as a backstop. Our estimate is that Betsy may lower sales costs by $2,000 for each fund and operations costs by $1,400 for each fund, positioning us well below what the industry typically spends. This is just the start. As we close out on priority number three — broadening how we distribute by growing the B2B side of things — we continue to see interest in our tech platform coming from fresh partners that have strong brands and are looking to provide mortgages to their own customers affordably, or to make their current mortgage operations more efficient in fulfillment. To get started, I'd like to share where things stand with Ally Bank, our partner. The mortgage collaboration between Better and Ally has lasted over five years, and we feel proud of what both organizations created jointly to transform white label mortgage technology offerings. In late 2024, Ally chose as a strategic move to fully depart the mortgage sector, so during Q4 we began reducing our Ally volume; our expectation is a complete exit by the close of this year's second quarter. Along with seasonal winter effects, that reduction is a factor in fourth-quarter volume coming in below the level seen in Q3 of 2024. On the growth side, during the prior quarter we shared news about NEO Home Loans Powered by Better going live. I'm pleased to say we're seeing encouraging results right out of the gate as we pursue our aims of broadening better's distribution channels and using Tinman to support neighborhood loan officers — cutting down on fulfillment headaches while boosting how many borrowers they can serve. Better's AI capabilities and digital lead pipeline will also be put to work for NEO Powered by Better, giving extra firepower to NEO's loan officer groups, whose members have proven themselves in delivering top-tier customer service and enjoy solid standing in the areas where they work. At NEO, Betsy is given its own branding for every retail loan officer. On top of that, early stage purchase customers coming from better D2C channels get routed to leads, since a loan officer located in their neighborhood can serve them more effectively. This should sharply boost efficiency and produce conversion improvements in both D2C and our retail distribution channel. Production started in January 2025, and since then we've brought on roughly 110 NEO loan officers spanning 53 branches. So far, about 220 families have been served through NEO Powered by Better, which works out to $95 million in funded loan bonds. When it comes to NEO Home Loans, the gain on sale margin we're averaging is roughly 365 basis points, while our better.com figure for 2024 came in at 217 basis points. The thing that genuinely excites me about NEO is the unique opportunity to unlock significant market segments that online lenders without a strong local footprint have historically found hard to serve — especially in purchase mortgages and for certain loan types like FHA, VA, down payment assistance products, and buy down programs. Ryan Grant is here with me — he's Co-Founder and President of Retail Lending at NEO Home Loans — and he wants to share what makes him excited about what's ahead for us with NEO Powered by Better.

Ryan Grant

executive
#4

Thanks for that, Joel. There's nobody on the NEO Home Loans team who isn't absolutely delighted to be Powered by Better now. This isn't merely a partnership — it's a real transformation of how mortgages work. As we see it, we're jointly creating the most valuable mortgage platform out there, serving not just our clients and business partners but every mortgage professional across America. NEO Home Loans was founded on one straightforward but mighty concept: reshaping what people should expect from a mortgage company. For many decades, this industry has been about pushing debt, and that has left plenty of professionals wondering whether the value they bring is genuine. Our goal was to accomplish more — providing solid guidance to customers prior to a home purchase, and continuing to offer proactive assistance for many years afterward, which helps them accumulate wealth over the long term. Even so, we encounter considerable obstacles from a deeply established sector. Processes became inefficient because of antiquated technology, while scaling up proved expensive and constrained. We had difficulty getting our messaging seen by a sufficient number of customers and by mortgage specialists working locally. A lack of financial clarity across the industry resulted in priorities that did not align. Every one of these stood as a serious hurdle, yet the NEO Powered by Better partnership is resolving each of them. This is why we take such pride in this chance, since it puts us in a position to genuinely reshape the industry. For a long time in the mortgage business, our success came about even though technology was working against us rather than helping us. When we went to Better's headquarters, we got a look at Tinman, we met Betsy, and we were amazed. The technology Better created delivers performance on par with what people can do across many mortgage tasks — nobody in our field had ever witnessed anything like that. Thanks to this infrastructure driven by AI, NEO is now able to bring together the strongest parts of each approach: clients get the speed, efficiency, and automation they're asking for, along with the advice, strategy, and lasting dedication of a local mortgage advisor that they both need and deserve. This changes everything. Our approach at NEO Powered by Better rests on three central beliefs. To start, we're going to slash the expenses tied to loans and make our team members far more scalable — something that's a huge headache for nearly everyone in mortgage lending. Thanks to Tinman and Betsy, our people can serve additional families efficiently, delivering greater value at a significantly reduced expense, and that lets us go head-to-head with discount lenders while keeping value intact. Our second core conviction is this: we're able to offset costs for the neighborhood mortgage expert through lead generation, which has grown considerably more difficult over the last several years. Conditions in the market have changed, and that makes locating clients who require assistance tougher for mortgage advisors. Once we found out that about 30,000 individuals each month were reaching out to Better about buying a property, we realized our staff of extensively coached advisors was capable of turning a larger share of those interested leads into real homeowners. Therefore, beginning in April, we will scale up lead routing, and the short-term goal is a 10% conversion rate — an improvement of approximately 500% over our current figure — plus improved experiences across Better's B2C channels. We're also thrilled about the ability to link these home buyers up with the top real estate agents nationwide and to assist more of their clients too; and through higher lead conversion plus collaboration with additional top agents in our local markets, we anticipate that the expense of bringing on a client can be cut dramatically. Our third core conviction, then, is that through building the industry's first genuinely transparent partnership lending model, we can give local mortgage professionals the confidence, knowledge, and financial understanding needed to perform at far higher levels; and in doing so, NEO Powered by Better is establishing a natural alignment of interests among every team member in the organization, rather than the misaligned priorities mortgage professionals have contended with for decades before; and finally, we're eager to reveal more regarding NEO Home Loans Powered by Better to local mortgage professionals throughout the country; we anticipate that once they witness and begin to grasp this blend of technology, efficiency, scalability, and growth via lead generation and referral partnerships, the best and brightest will want to join us in our push to wholly transform and enhance the mortgage industry. In 2024, roughly $2 billion in mortgage volume was funded by our NEO team, and we did so while remaining profitable. Now, with Powered by Better behind us, we're positioned to grow at a faster pace, deliver improved profitability, and create a bigger impact. We're reimagining mortgage lending together, and we're just getting started. Thanks. With that, I'll turn things back over to you, Vishal.

Vishal Garg

executive
#5

Thanks, Ryan. Having the NEO team join us on the platform and as partners as we shake up the mortgage business together has us really fired up. As we look ahead to 2025 and past that, the medium-term opportunity is incredibly exciting. Our focus stays on strengthening how we go to market, with growth serving as our North Star, along with ongoing expense discipline and diversification across channels. We'll keep putting money into Tinman AI so the customer experience gets better and labor costs come down further, which makes our platform more efficient and scalable and moves the business toward profitability over the medium term. With all that said, I'll hand things over now to Kevin Ryan, our Chief Financial Officer, who will talk through the quarterly performance and our financial strategy. Kevin?

Kevin Ryan

executive
#6

Thanks, Vishal. In 2024, despite a market that stayed tough, we made solid headway on our objectives: pushing higher volume and revenue while keeping a handle on expenses and getting more efficient. During Q4 of 2024, funded loan volume came in at 936 million, revenue reached 25 million, and adjusted EBITDA showed a loss of $28 million. GAAP net loss totaled roughly $59 million. Looking at that fourth quarter, 81% of funded loan volume came via our D2C channel, while 19% arrived through B2B partners, and by dollar volume the mix was 62% purchase, 18% home equity loans, with the rest being refinanced. On top of that, our UK bank — the Bank of Birmingham — is seeing early wins, with scaled loan originations jumping over 10-fold between December 2023 and December 2024 as we rolled out our technology there. We anticipate UK bank originations will more than double once again in 2025 as we bring in AI, aiming to create the top AI-driven specialist mortgage bank in the United Kingdom. Now, on to our full year 2025 outlook. We're still aiming to manage toward midterm profitability, and we plan to fuel growth via efficiency from Tinman AI, broadening distribution channels, and smarter marketing, all while offsetting those growth costs with additional cuts to corporate expenses. For Q1 2025, funded loan volume should decline roughly 10% to 15% versus Q4 2024. With ongoing seasonal softness and the winding down of our businesses — which, as a reminder, accounted for 29% of full year 2024 volume and 19% of Q4 2024 volume, and we expect them to be just low double digits percent of Q1 volume before fully winding down sometime in the second quarter — we're especially thrilled that NEO funded loan volume is running ahead of schedule, and we expect over 90 million in NEO originations for March by itself, following February as the first complete month of NEO on our platform. As one more reference point to frame our trends against the broader industry, the Fannie Mae February housing forecast shows overall Q1 market volumes dropping 24% quarter-over-quarter, which highlights how Better is outperforming the overall market in Q1; for all of 2025, we anticipate funded loan volume growth in the low to mid double digits percent year-over-year, powered by tailwinds from growth efforts like NEO Powered by Better, though offset by lingering macro headwinds and the loss of the Ally business — a headwind of roughly $900 million. That growth should show up especially in Q2 and Q3, when we expect NEO to be more fully ramped and to gain from better seasonal tailwinds. We also anticipate further shrinking our adjusted EBITDA losses in 2025 relative to 2024, thanks to a mix of efficiency improvements and ongoing corporate cost reductions. Finally, we're working on getting out of our non-core UK assets, even as we keep our attention on expanding the bank. We anticipate that leaving 3 smaller non-core UK businesses behind will begin helping our adjusted EBITDA losses during the second half of 2025, thanks to their disposition. So with that, I'll hand things back to the operator for Q&A.

Eric Hagen

analyst
#7

That AI demo was genuinely fascinating. In what ways do the AI system and underwriting process account for how expensive and hard to get property insurance has become? Can the technology make any sort of adjustment for that, and might that even open up a chance, given that people are reaching you through the internet and there are simply more efficient methods to complete such a loan? Thanks.

Vishal Garg

executive
#8

That's honestly an excellent question. What you just watched isn't some kind of form-filling engine. We had more than 15 separate data forks plus API calls, which passed through 45 investors and were narrowed down to five HELOC investors, and we ran every permutation involving credit, DTI, LTV, cash out amount, and even insurance quotes and closing costs throughout 3,600 U.S. counties. There's an insurance component we've built right into the platform, so when someone is in the middle of a refinance, a HELOC, or a cash-out refi, they can get homeowners insurance instantly. These are tasks that previously required a whole lot of manpower. To put it in perspective, if we assume the 10-year treasury could return to where it sat in 2019 — back then we grew from $85 million in revenue to more than $850 million in 2020, with over $250 million of EBITDA — yet that operation was only about 50% automated. Today, Betsy handles essentially every task those refi salespeople performed in 2020, and does it at zero or near-zero marginal cost. What that means is we can skip bringing on 3,000 sales staff, avoid adding 5,000 people for processing and underwriting, and no longer need 1,000 insurance agents like we once did. So the product now carries a tremendous amount of built-in scale, Betsy is handling all of it, and honestly we're sitting in a far stronger position than we have in a long time to handle any shift in the broader economy — including the scenario you described, where homeowner insurance rates climb.

Eric Hagen

analyst
#9

That's great to hear, and quite interesting. If profitability keeps trending favorably, how might that influence the level of risk you're willing to assume, and how do you gauge the risk you're taking during a given timeframe — even down to how you'd set pricing upfront?

Kevin Ryan

executive
#10

Excellent question. What often gets overlooked when people compare us with other fintechs is that ours is a pure marketplace operation. We don't keep loans on our balance sheet that haven't already been promised for sale to someone else. On our platform, 45 institutional investors purchase our loans and our HELOCs daily. So essentially, we won't originate a loan without a buyer ready. Once you lock in that loan with us, we already know its destination, and that's how Tinman meets the specific underwriting standards for that investor to deliver the loan to them. So the route to profitability we're discussing isn't based on accepting additional marginal risk units. It's really centered on — well, we basically lost around $9 million each month last quarter, correct? Shutting down the UK operations accounts for about a million monthly. Enhancing the bank's profitability should add another million per month, we believe. With AI reducing operational expenses, we could expand and save an additional 3.5 million monthly. We have numerous compliance and legal expenses stemming from the DSPAC, the highly aggressive CFPB period, and similar matters. We can trim that by a million each month, I think. We still have several legacy contracts from ’21 and ’22 — for instance, we just exited our New York office space of about 45,000 square feet, reduced it by 80%, and relocated to a less expensive spot. That's another 2 million per month. Then, factor in some volume increase, better margin, plus profits from the NEO channel, and you reach breakeven. Thus, we foresee a route to breakeven again, founded on efficiency, on shedding many legacy costs from the ’21 and ’22 era, on leaving behind legacy businesses, and on enhancing margins as we've been consistently doing. And once more, all without assuming additional credit risk.

Ryan Grant

executive
#11

Well, Eric, I'd like to build on what Kevin and Vishal mentioned. In my view, every single loan originated during the quarter had already been committed to investors before we made it. If it wasn't all of them, it was 99%, correct? That means we're basically not exposed to any risk. The sole lens through which we consider risk is whether we should push harder on marketing this month or hold off until the next one, based on what the market is doing — but that's a decision made tactically, right in the moment. Turning to costs: comparing Q3 with Q4 alone, we removed $11 million in expenses, core expenses. They appear about level because we recorded a $16 million charge tied to disposing of the UK assets; that was a one-time, non-cash item; once you exclude it, we brought expenses down roughly $11 million to $12 million over a quarter, which works out to $4 million per month. So we are — and across every major category, I believe, as Vishal noted during the prepared remarks, we declined, with corporate expenses falling substantially. Marketing came down somewhat. Thus, we certainly eliminated a great deal of expense during Q4 and are still doing that in Q1.

Eric Hagen

analyst
#12

This is genuinely impressive work, everyone. We're grateful for it. Thanks so much.

Vishal Garg

executive
#13

Thank you, Eric.

Jake Kooyman

analyst
#14

Hello, and thanks so much for taking the questions. This is Jake Kooyman sitting in for Raina Kumar. Could you take us through the savings that come from Tinman applying AI, and also how that plays into things? Thanks a lot.

Vishal Garg

executive
#15

Absolutely, so the way I see it, savings show up when you consider what a conventional loan officer and their assistant actually do, correct? Most of their hours, especially on the D2C side, go toward helping borrowers who arrive through the online channel, pursuing those borrowers in the purchase market, pursuing the realtor those borrowers have chosen, so enormous energy goes into outbound calls, and then enormous energy goes into chasing the inbound calls you weren't able to pick up since you were already on the line with somebody else. Now, sure, you can add headcount, you can run a 10,000 person call center to catch every one of those calls and place all those outbound calls the way other mortgage companies do, making 400 outbound dials a day. That is extremely inefficient and it truly wears down the workforce; we've got Betsy handling every inbound call during nights and evenings, so not one call gets missed. Previously we would miss something like 40% of calls coming in, because nobody was free to meet their loan officer, since borrowers were calling at 9:00 PM, in the evening once the kids were in bed. And they're reviewing what they'll do about buying a home that upcoming weekend, or they're calling us on the weekend right before going into contract on their home, wanting to confirm the rate quotes is still good and wanting to refine the purchase amount; we did have these tools online, yet Betsy truly cuts the cost dramatically, and even more importantly lifts the customer experience, since it never sleeps, and so I'd say that has been a game changer, and I'd say there's room to pick up $2,000 per funded loan in sales costs once Betsy is fully implemented in the sales funnel, correct? So we're doing close to 1,000 loans a month, correct, and we're working to scale that higher. With NEO it's beyond that, so we're getting there, correct, that's meaningful savings each month that we can produce as we roll this out not only for ourselves, but for our B2B partners. On the automation side, we continue to push forward. If you look in the earnings supplement, you will see the percentage of locked loans that are AI underwritten, and that's increased about 40%. When it comes to loans that get underwritten by AI, there's as much as $1,400 in savings on each one, correct? And once more, if you combine those two factors, the production cost we're discussing is already over 35% below what the rest of the industry sees, and then for loans that are fully driven by AI, you're looking at an additional $3,500 in savings per loan. All of that is going to flow into margin, since we already have — some of the lowest gain on sale, and because of that, the lowest price to the consumer available in the market. So every one of those AI improvements will essentially land in the bottom line. I hope that gives a bit of context.

Alex Bond

analyst
#16

Hello, everyone, good morning. This is Alex Bond here, filling in for Bose. Thanks for letting us ask our questions. To begin, since we're nearly through the first quarter, I was hoping you could update us on where gain on sale margins stand, quarter to date versus 4Q, given how rates have fallen during the quarter; and also, as you noted in the prepared remarks, the gain on sale margin on NEO loans has been stronger so far than the 2024 company-wide margin, and you said there's potential to perhaps push this even further as efficiencies improve. Does that come mainly from AI and other tech-related improvements, or are there other components that could also be made more efficient? Any extra detail would be helpful. Thanks.

Ryan Grant

executive
#17

Okay. Kevin, I'll begin and unpack that. I think there are a few sub-questions in there, and Vishal, you probably want to chime in. So on gain on sale in Q1, the trend is upward. I believe we disclosed 90 million in yield loans already in Q1; they really only just onboarded in February. As of this morning we crossed 100 million. So we're past 100 million loans, and they're running far higher — 150 basis points higher on average for gain on sale than a direct to consumer business. That's something we anticipated going in, expected, and we'd have been disappointed if they weren't running a higher gain on sale, simply given their boots on the ground operation, their expertise, and so on. So our aggregate gain on sale ought to trend upward as NEO becomes a larger share of our production, correct? I mean, in practice we're swapping out a billion dollars a year of Ally volume for, say, 2 billion in NEO, let's just say this year. And that will carry a much higher gain on sale than what we'd have reported on our Ally, so; and then regarding the D2C business, I'll start, and I'm sure Vishal will want to jump in. Yeah. Betsy and the AI let us — we've steadily raised our gain on sale in the direct to consumer business, right? We were below 2%, and now we're above 2%. We're not at the 3.5% that NEO's at, but the business isn't structured that way, right? It's an online business. As Vishal said, we have some of the lowest rates out there, but thanks to our improvements and a better customer experience through the AI, we've been able to gradually increase gain on sale. And then the rate decline we've seen, you know, we're roughly around 6.75% now on rate, right, has definitely helped with bid as well. We're not at the 3.5% that NEO's at.

Vishal Garg

executive
#18

Sure, I can explain what's behind the improvement in margin. When someone is online and fills out what amounts to a lead, they're comparing options—they're visiting our website while keeping a competitor's page open in another tab. They may also be using a comparison shopping platform, and usually a lead would come in and it would take our team over five minutes to respond, correct? To phone them and attempt to connect, and by then they might have moved on; as a result, our marketing wasn't working as well, plus they're evaluating other choices. With Betsy, we've cut that five minutes down to 800 milliseconds, universally, which represents a 400x gain in speed, so now we reach the customer more quickly than anyone else; we reach them before they can leave, look at other options, and we can inform them about our closing guarantee. We can inform them about the better price guarantee. We can address their questions, we can turn them from a lead into a application. We can approve them, we can accomplish all of this that previously, with only a human-staffed call center, was essentially almost impossible, and consequently you wind up competing far more on rate than on speed and surface, and I believe that, once again, it allowed us to keep improving margin while still preserving our value proposition for the consumer.

Alex Bond

analyst
#19

Excellent. That's all clear to me. Thanks for answering our questions.

Reggie Smith

analyst
#20

The information you provided regarding possible savings from, I suppose, many of your cost programs is quite heartening. Here's what I want to know, and I don't know whether you have separated this out or if you even consider the company in these terms, but could contribution profit for each loan, or loan economics, be framed that way? You mentioned certain savings possibilities in the press release, I realize, yet I'm interested in how you view this and how we ought to view things such as loan-level economics; for instance, income for each loan versus costs, can marketing or overhead be assigned in some manner to the loan origination process? And I have something else to ask. Thanks.

Kevin Ryan

executive
#21

Right, this is Kevin, so let me offer a couple of thoughts. Naturally, that isn't visible within the GAAP financials. Our operation is managed using a contribution margin approach, and within the mortgage segment that margin has been getting notably better over the most recent couple of months; I believe we'll remove that and separate it out next quarter so you can sort of follow it back into the GAAP financials; this is a topic we discuss constantly. Still, I can say that because of these savings plus the gain on sale improvement, the expense reductions achieved through AI, our production's contribution margin keeps strengthening and remains so into Q1. That's an area where we are fiercely focused, correct, since although corporate costs are being reduced by us more quickly than costs within the mortgage segment, we likewise must bring down mortgage segment costs if we're truly going to generate contribution profit that can then be used to cover what is good. Some fixed overhead will always exist; therefore we consider this constantly.

Vishal Garg

executive
#22

Reggie, 2024 brought plenty of shifts. Our model changed from paying loan officers and processors a salary to one built on incentives, with a modest base and strong incentive component. We began bringing on experienced loan officers, and those people needed training on Tinman. Anyone who couldn't grasp it or produce results through Tinman had to be released, which created some expenses. That covers 2024, and afterward we ran NEO late in the year. And finally, we'd been counting on that rate reduction in September to bring rates down, and it simply didn't happen. As a result, a good chunk of our marketing dollars went to waste, since we purchase leads and consumers believe they'll land a 6.5% rate, yet when they reach the lock stage they're actually offered 7.25%, correct? That borrower no longer qualifies financially, or that borrower can't move forward and will hold off instead. So 2024 handed us many difficulties. We achieved a great deal, an enormous amount of progress. Yet what we concluded as '24 wrapped up was this: we will direct our focus obsessively toward growth that delivers positive contribution margin, and we'll keep widening that positive contribution margin even when it requires projecting a somewhat slower growth rate. Now I believe we can reach rapid growth alongside better contribution margin, and that becomes achievable not through a human-centric business model but through an AI-centric one, and I think that's precisely what we're pushing into with tremendous intensity. So with luck, that provides some background for what lies ahead. And naturally, we'll accept the guidance that we need to get out there and simplify your work by breaking out contribution margin next quarter.

Reggie Smith

analyst
#23

I wasn't certain whether that had slipped past me or not, and as I mentioned, we don't have any model for you folks, so that was simply a thing I was hoping to find. Therefore I didn't know whether I could squeeze in a couple more questions really fast. First, I really like the demo that you folks showed, or walked through, while on the call. I was wondering how it's landing with customers, and my hunch, though I could be way off, is that for younger folks it's likely a more intuitive method of getting things done. I was wondering what feedback or insights you've received regarding whether younger folks are using the automated system more effectively than older people? And how frequently people choose to opt out and ask for a representative or something similar? Then my final question, you mentioned, I believe, approving a loan within one day. I was wondering how fast you folks can fund a loan. That's a thing I've grown to value over the last month. I'm attempting to sell my condo in Brooklyn, so folks who are able to close quickly make a difference. I was wondering whether you had any edge there too. Thank you.

Vishal Garg

executive
#24

Yeah, no, that's a great question. So, generally speaking, we're seeing quite high adoption of Betsy. During the process, approximately 18% of consumers ask to be transferred to a human loan officer, right? They encounter it, realize it's an AI, and want to switch to a person. So yeah, we're going to try to bring that number down, and we need to make the voices sound more human. There's a lot of work ahead to keep adding functionality. So I'd say it's still early days. Betsy's initial release came just a handful of months back, as you may recall. What that means is we're clearly adding more capabilities and more lifelike behavior, and things will keep getting better. The strongest adoption has come from those in the 20-to-35 bracket, and then, to be honest, quite unexpectedly from the 55-plus group — the reason being they don't mind a somewhat slower pace of speech as long as the enunciation is clear, so we've observed some encouraging figures there. Once more, it's still very early, and we'll find out how everything settles, though without question younger users appreciate being able to have a conversation whenever they want. You're able to send texts to it, and you've got a loan officer available whenever you need one. So that's something we're really focusing on. Then, on the topic of how long closings take — in New York, I believe we can typically close a loan, and let me pull the actual figures, considerably quicker than what competitors manage. Hold on a moment while I look that up; for New York, the average closing timeline for the whole industry is 46 days, whereas we come in at 32 days. Sure, there's naturally quite a bit of lag involved, since folks need to sort out things like relocating and everything along those lines, but in New York State in particular, we come in roughly 40% ahead of our rivals.

Reggie Smith

analyst
#25

Yeah, that's great, and honestly I didn't really get it until I actually went through it on my own. So it's good to know that's such a big deal for buyers; and I'll say this, speaking just for me, I can't stand AI, but it's one of those things I've just got to accept when it comes to automation. I'm in that 18 percent that pushes back the moment I realize a machine is handling it. But yeah, no, it's, watching how that changes down the road should be interesting. Nice work on the quarter, and best of luck, everyone.

Vishal Garg

executive
#26

Reggi, should you come across a buyer in Brooklyn, point them toward Better.com, and we'll get them preapproved within a couple of minutes.

Reggie Smith

analyst
#27

Will do.

Michael Kaye

analyst
#28

When I look at adjusted net income and adjusted EBITDA for Q4, profitability didn't get any better compared with the same period a year earlier, even though volumes rose 76% versus the prior year. Could you explain why the increased volumes year over year and the cost programs implemented during the past year aren't showing up as improved profitability? Perhaps just take us through some of what's going on and whether there's something I'm overlooking.

Kevin Ryan

executive
#29

What you're doing is a year-over-year comparison, correct?

Michael Kaye

analyst
#30

Right, a $38 million loss — that's adjusted net loss for Q4.

Kevin Ryan

executive
#31

Yeah, like Vishal mentioned, on the marketing side we increased our spend there, and that accounted for the largest swing, plus we brought on additional staff too — as Vishal noted earlier, we added more headcount anticipating a rate environment that would decline during the back half of 2024, and frankly that bet didn't work out, so we've scaled back somewhat; that explains part of the distortion you're noticing. Volume hit its lowest level in Q4 of '23. Staffing also bottomed out then in the mortgage division — the mortgage factory. So every other corporate expense and such has dropped sharply from Q4 '23 onward, yet marketing costs ran higher in Q4 '24, same with sales and ops labor. With Betsy ramping up, those will keep declining per unit, which ties into what Reggie asked, and we intend to try to break that out.

Vishal Garg

executive
#32

Right, so in Q4, our headcount was higher than needed. Once Betsy was put in place, we managed to cut roughly 250 positions within the mortgage factory.

Michael Kaye

analyst
#33

All right. Switching topics. What's your degree of confidence regarding the spring season for buying homes? Mortgage rates sit near 6.75%, there's more housing supply on the market at present, likely some accumulated buyer demand, even if affordability challenges exist. So just share your perspective on the spring home purchasing period.

Vishal Garg

executive
#34

The number of pre-approvals relative to each dollar we put into marketing has kept climbing sharply. And I'd say that serves as a solid forward-looking signal, correct, for how many individuals are rushing out and beginning to shop. We'll find out how many among them ultimately manage to secure a property. Yet up to this point, it appears the count of preapprovals for every marketing dollar spent keeps rising quite significantly. So our outlook is positive regarding what will occur. And look, once more, the chatter coming out of Washington concerns deregulation and bringing the tenure down, so you place your bets on whether they'll be able to achieve that. Should you think that's achievable, my view is we could be headed toward a pleasant upside this spring and summer home purchasing period.

James Friedman

analyst
#35

That was a fascinating presentation, and the demonstration was genuinely useful. I had most of my questions answered already. I just wanted to ask about the macro picture — specifically, how would you describe the way supply and demand are interacting in the end market? In your view, where do we sit along that spectrum, and what do you expect, if anything, looking toward the coming year?

Vishal Garg

executive
#36

What we tend to say at Better these days is that, sadly, our track record on forecasting the macro backdrop over the last three years has not been good. At our core we're optimists — as any technologist would confirm, optimism is mandatory, since without it, what would you possibly believe in? Our view is that the mismatch between housing supply and demand will be corrected within the coming 1 or 2 years. Tariffs clearly play a role here, though the flip side is that the properties currently listed for sale represent something of a steal should those tariffs indeed persist and the cost of raw materials for constructing a home rises sharply. So my expectation is that older homes will move faster. Demand for the HELOC product is truly surging on our end, since homeowners must renovate — boomer-era properties, for instance, require modernization before they can be sold to millennial purchasers — and as a result we're witnessing enormous appetite for renovation financing through the HELOC product. Whether people are preparing to list their home or simply remaining where they are, we expanded our HELOC by 400% over the last year, making us the fastest-growing HELOC lender in the market, and we believe we can scale it up once more quite substantially in the current year. We've essentially gone from zero to ranking among the top HELOC lenders nationwide. So my thinking is that we're working to assemble a well-balanced mix of loan categories, which lets us prosper regardless of whatever macro conditions arise.

Ryan Grant

executive
#37

Yes, I believe, as Vishal mentioned, forecasting the macro environment has proven genuinely difficult, and tuning into earnings calls this quarter—we're near the end of that period—you'll hear the term uncertainty repeated roughly 20 times per call. That's simply the climate we're operating in today. It affects every business, and especially our sector, that matters. We understand that. Still, we firmly believe we're far ahead of this shift, and the certainty that technology will upend the traditional mortgage workflow in America is perhaps unfolding somewhat slower than anticipated, yet the movement persists, and we're confident we're squarely aligned with it, and it will unfold gradually. No matter what happens with rates, and February's starts figures look fairly solid, though afterward folks claim consumer confidence has weakened. So how should we interpret that for the spring period? We take all of it in and attempt to incorporate it, and it certainly shapes our market choices daily, yet it has zero effect on our technology roadmap. We already know what needs to be constructed.

Vishal Garg

executive
#38

Sure, I'll include that. We've got more than 2 million pre-approvals issued across the last couple of years where those folks never ended up finding a property. So when the dam breaks, we don't know the timing, but once it does, our position will be strong. Each month, the count of people who visit better.com and receive a pre-approval represents percentage points of market share when you look at how many individuals are out shopping for a home. Meanwhile, the count who actually convert is basis points of market share. A great deal of that comes down to homes being available. So if rates, home affordability, or availability shift, our hope is that we can serve that demand just as we served refi demand in 2020, yet without the staffing expenses we took on in 2020. That, I believe, explains why you keep seeing us push so aggressively into AI.

Will Brunemann

analyst
#39

I'd like to know how much time you expect before NEO returns to the volume run rate it had previously, once Tinman is fully ramped up, and you brought up Betsy driving cost efficiencies down the road. At what point do you expect most of those additional cost efficiencies to be completely achieved? Then I've got just one additional brief question.

Vishal Garg

executive
#40

Sure. My sense is that within the coming couple of months, we expect NEO to return to its initial volume.

Ryan Grant

executive
#41

Right, so in Q3, they'd return to their previous level, and then in Q4, ideally things would improve beyond that earlier point.

Vishal Garg

executive
#42

And, you know, when we made the NEO announcement, we were attending a few industry conferences and showing off Betsy, and the amount of loan officers who have big retail books reaching out to me on LinkedIn asking, hey, can I come aboard, plus the number of folks contacting Ryan, Chris, and Danny, who were the principals over at NEO, is quite large. So we're just making certain we can expand completely the product sets contained within Tinman. We're ensuring we can serve every one of those loan officers fully; we're assisting them in moving from something like driving a Ford Tauras on the infrastructure and mortgage lending they currently use to driving a Ferrari, and we simply need to ensure they're capable of doing that, and after that they're off to the races. In just a few months, NEO is going to return to the loan volume it had originally, and after that we intend to expand it significantly. As for the other side of Betsy, we'll continue updating you on the proportion of customers, and the proportion of customers interacting with Betsy, which lets us cut expenses substantially in sales. We'll also keep you posted on what percentage of loans Tinman is underwriting, and from that figure alone you can work out the savings. Any loans left over are still running on the previous cost structure. We'll make sure to keep all of you updated on that. Even so, the expense reductions are pretty substantial, and they're starting to show up. You'll see them in the current quarter, again in the following quarter, and once more in the net third quarter. Like I mentioned, our expectation is that by the close of 2025, Tinman AI will handle underwriting for 75% of loans. Turning to Betsy, we currently have a single state that's fully on Betsy. So you take that, and then we need to reach all 50 states running entirely on Betsy.

Will Brunemann

analyst
#43

All right. That's excellent. So for my final question, where do you see growth possibilities opening up inside the wider distribution retail channel, such as NEO?

Vishal Garg

executive
#44

I'd say the potential there is enormous. A lot of folks are approaching us wanting to expand with us. Consider this — in direct-to-consumer, our competitors are some fairly advanced companies. Rocket is one we go up against. loanDepot is another. Beyond that, there are plenty of others who've put money into technology. When it comes to the retail channel, our rivals are essentially loan officer staffing platforms, or mortgage broker platforms, that gained an advantage because nobody in that world had any real technological sophistication, and my view is those platforms impose a fairly substantial tax on the loan officer already in place, and I believe we're able to liberate them from it. The nearest comparison I can offer is what took place with RIAs, correct, as opposed to tying yourself to an old wirehouse and receiving a percentage, a modest slice of revenue. You had the option of joining RIA platforms that understand technology and are private labeled, which hand you essentially everything while letting you retain a bigger share of what you earn. That, in my view, is the disruption headed for retail, and I believe we'll be the ones driving it.

Will Brunemann

analyst
#45

That's fantastic. Thanks, folks, for fielding my questions.

Brendan McCarthy

analyst
#46

Excellent, thank you, and good morning to everybody, and I appreciate you answering my questions here. I'd like to begin with the corporate cost cutting angle. I believe you said — yes, you said that corporate cost reductions were a benefit to ‘24. I'm just wondering where you anticipate the largest chance for additional cuts during 2025.

Ryan Grant

executive
#47

Absolutely; so a few places exist where we'll keep going on compensation and benefits at this point, and regarding the GAAP line item, correct, all of it gets merged, whether that's corporate or sales UK, all of it is going to merge, so we can, we will, we'll separate it out moving forward. You're going to keep seeing gains in that area; right now we're located in an office building that is 20% the size of the one we occupied during the prior earnings call. By relocating offices, we're saving $10 million in lease expense across the next couple of years. So you're going to begin to, we're heavily renegotiating agreements with vendors. A number of them we finished during the second half of ‘24. So a full year benefit will appear in ‘25. A number of them will be finished throughout ‘25, so a full year benefit will appear in ‘26. And so it truly applies to all, and it applies to every area. Looking at even G&A alone, year over year it was down 70%, and G&A quarter-over-quarter declined $2 million from Q3 to Q4; so professional fees would be the other one for us. Those represent roughly the four major areas. Clearly compensation and benefits is the largest area. G&A, a portion of that sits in technology expense, a portion of that sits in G&A with the vendors, and then clearly you're, the majority of the lease work has already been completed, but you're going to begin to see the run rate benefits this year.

Brendan McCarthy

analyst
#48

Great, that's helpful. Considering how robust your company's growing technology stack is, what opportunities do you foresee for additional B2B partnerships in the marketplace?

Vishal Garg

executive
#49

Sure, I'll give you one example. Three examples; Betsy launched in October. During the past few months, the CEO of a top-five servicer called us and said I want to build a recapture business that's completely AI-driven, would you private label Betsy for me, and also private label Tinman for me, and help me with that? So we're currently in term sheet discussions with them. One of the three biggest lead generation firms in financial services — the CEO reached out again and told us he had a board meeting coming up in four weeks. He needed to demonstrate to them that AI had to be put into place, and he asked what we could possibly do. Our response was that we'd be glad to take that on. We plan to bring their offering to market, and it will be operational and exclusive to our company. We also have a sizable community bank that wishes to accomplish something similar, structuring it around non-QM loans, bank statement loans, and non-conforming loans—areas that, once again, traditional mortgage software struggles greatly to handle. We're currently in advanced talks with them. On the business-to-business front, growth has taken off to a degree we hadn't witnessed since roughly 2018 through 2019, back when customers approached us seeking assistance in standing up refinance engines to handle that refinance wave. That said, we aren't limiting ourselves to the largest players, which was more or less the approach we took following Ally, Amex and the other companies that had joined the platform. The tech we originally developed for Ally and Amex is now letting a B2B partner go live in just three weeks, which is quicker than even the time it takes to sign a sales contract with established industry names such as Ellie Mae, Black Knight, or similar companies. So we're going after that hard, and hopefully you'll see us share some major announcements over the next few months.

Brendan McCarthy

analyst
#50

Understood. Thanks. For my final question, what sort of effect do you anticipate from the Ally business going away? How would you measure that effect, roughly? And what steps are being taken to eventually make up for that loss across the whole business?

Kevin Ryan

executive
#51

Sure. If I examine — well, two main metrics. Let me begin with a pair, then tell me whether you'd like more detail. Regarding volume, it's just under $1 billion that appeared in last year's figures and won't appear in this year's figures. Some Ally volume will show up in Q1, though it drops off sharply once this quarter ends. NEO does more than make up for it, and we've guided toward low to mid-double digits volume growth for this year. So even with that $1 billion gone, volume will still increase. We have confidence in that, and clearly NEO plays a major role. As for EBITDA, this is essentially a neutral occurrence. All things considered, the fee arrangement we'd set up with Ally performed very strongly during a favorable low rate period. Yet you have a set number of staff required for a sizable B2B partnership of that kind, and when their volume declined alongside the broader industries, they reduced marketing spending, and so on; we fully grasp their reasoning, you were essentially operating a business neutral to EBITDA, meaning there's no adverse effect on EBITDA since we've clearly handled the costs tied to Ally as those revenues diminish.

Brendan McCarthy

analyst
#52

Thank you, everyone. Yes, definitely; that helps a lot. Nice work on the momentum.

Vishal Garg

executive
#53

We appreciate every one of your excellent questions, and we appreciate you sticking with us while we create the top AI mortgage platform in America. By doing that, we assist customers in obtaining a mortgage, securing a superior rate, and enjoying an improved process, which allows them to have a nicer home in a nicer school district with a nicer commute and a nicer backyard; and we're — this adventure began for us 8 years ago, and the last 3 years have proven extremely challenging for us, but we're attacking once more and attacking aggressively, and we can't wait to grow the business and to be able to bring you more encouraging updates in the upcoming quarters. Many thanks, and thanks for having faith in us.

Operator

operator
#54

This concludes today's conference call. Thank you for joining. You may now disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Better Home & Finance Holding Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Better Home & Finance Holding Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Better Home & Finance Holding Company or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.