BOK Financial Corporation (BOKF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 22, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Steven Nell
executiveHello, everyone, and thank you for being with us this morning. Our Chief Executive Officer, Steve Bradshaw, is going to start things off with some opening remarks. After that, Stacy Kymes, who serves as Executive Vice President of Corporate Banking, will walk through our loan portfolio along with our credit metrics. Following him, I will share a number of specifics about the items on our income statement for the fourth quarter, and I'll also give high level guidance for 2020. Once the call wraps up, Scott Grauer, Executive Vice President of Wealth Management, and Marc Maun, Executive Vice President and Chief Credit Officer, will both be on hand to take questions. You can find a PDF of the slide presentation and the fourth quarter press release on our website, bokf.com. Please take note of the disclaimers shown on Slide 2, since they apply to any forward-looking statements that we make on this call. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Steve Bradshaw.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveGood morning, and thank you for being here as we go over the financial results for our fourth quarter and for the full year 2019. With the fourth quarter behind us, BOK Financial has now posted a second straight record year, measured both by net income and by earnings per share. Net income for the full year came to $501 million, which represents growth of more than 12% versus 2018. For 2019, diluted earnings per share reached $7.03, compared with $6.63 in the prior year. Each year during 2019 rested on a broad base, with considerable expansion across our fee businesses, continued strengthening of our specialty lending channels, and also faster growth during the quarter in our core deposit franchise. On top of that, during 2019 we met our business integration and financial objectives related to the CoBiz acquisition, and that will help generate momentum in two of our most critical high-growth markets as we move ahead. If we zero in on the fourth quarter, net income equaled $110.4 million, or $1.56 per diluted share, which is below our record third quarter yet 2% above the same quarter one year earlier. As a reminder, we completed the CoBiz closing at the beginning of the fourth quarter of 2018, so comparing against that light quarter makes sense. Fee and commission revenue rose 12% year-over-year, while seasonal slowdowns along with mortgage volumes and somewhat weaker consumer service charges pushed our fee and commission revenue down 4% versus the prior quarter. We continue to manage expenses prudently, although expenses climbed 3% this quarter because of elevated severance costs as we right-size our business units going into 2020, combined with our annual charitable contribution to the BOK Foundation, which supports many non-profit partners in the communities we serve. Our loan loss provision for this quarter was $19 million, driven by some migration in our energy portfolio, and Stacy will go through that in greater detail shortly. If you turn to Slide 5, average loans stood at $22.2 billion, an increase of 3% year-over-year, though lower than last quarter because of general pay downs in energy and commercial real estate plus two anticipated large year-end pay downs in our CI portfolio. That said, we feel good about our pipeline opportunity as 2020 gets underway. Average deposits grew 8% compared with the previous year, and more than 5% on a linked-quarter basis. Despite such strong growth this quarter, we managed to lower overall interest-bearing deposit costs from 1.17% in the third quarter to 1.09% in the fourth quarter. Expanding deposits to fund loan growth was a major area of emphasis for BOKF in 2019, and our results reflect that. This focus will carry into 2020, letting us fund future loan growth. Assets under management or in custody increased more than 2% for the quarter and over 8% year-over-year, with strong sales activity combined with favorable equity markets serving as the key drivers behind that expansion. Additionally, during this quarter we identified a chance to put more money into our business at an attractive valuation, repurchasing 280,000 BOKF shares through open-market transactions at $81.59 apiece. Once our remarks wrap up, I'll share some further context regarding the results, though at this point Stacy Kymes is going to walk through the loan portfolio and credit in greater depth. At this time I'll hand the call over to Stacy.
Stacy Kymes
executiveAppreciate it, Steve. If you look at Slide 7, you'll see that loans at period-end came in at $21.8 billion, which represents a decline of over 2% during the quarter, and pay downs also had an effect on our quarter-end figures. From a lending standpoint, 2019 was a year of growth for BOKF, rising 3% on average compared to the prior year. Total C&I grew by almost 3% in 2019, but pay downs within our two biggest growth drivers, energy and healthcare, resulted in total C&I being down 2.7% on a linked-quarter basis. Energy experienced a tremendous 2019, with growth of nearly 11%, even as the segment declined by $141 million for the quarter; the industry trends we've talked about still hold, and pipelines are still full. I anticipate energy growth will get back to positive territory as we move into 2020. Our healthcare channel likewise delivered an outstanding 2019, with growth exceeding 8%. While the quarter was flat, consistent growth, commitment levels, and our expertise in senior housing point toward another strong year for healthcare in 2020. It appears that a deceleration in general C&I reflects growing caution among the broader middle market business community. Tariffs, trade disputes, and uncertainty as we approach a new election cycle appear to have given some of our clients reason to pause. Greater clarity regarding regulatory trade matters and the economic backdrop ought to help reinvigorate the middle market segment. Ongoing discipline regarding concentration limits in commercial real estate, along with late-quarter pay downs, resulted in the segment declining 4.2% for the quarter. Commitment volume in that space remains solid, and we'll keep high grading via rigorous customer selection as we oversee the portfolio. Turning to Slide 8, you'll observe that credit quality on the whole is still sound. Non-accruing loans rose $8.5 million in the quarter, mostly driven by a $6.6 million increase in one non-accruing community development credit. Net charge-offs totaled $12.5 million, or 22 basis points annualized, compared with $10.6 million, or 19 basis points, in the prior quarter — all fairly in line with what we've observed across the last 18 months. Potential problem loans — defined as performing loans that, based on known information, raise management concern about the borrower's capacity to keep performing — came to $160 million as of December 31st, up from $143 million as of September the 30th; much of that rise stems from the energy portfolio, since the capital markets environment is requiring certain customers to address their liquidity needs. This could result in further non-accruals and some impairments. That said, as we've noted before, our senior secured collateral position ought to shield us from material loss content. After assessing all credit factors — including shifts in non-accruing and potential problem loans, plus specific impairments on two shared national energy credits, one of which we are not the lead agent on — the company concluded that a $19 million provision for credit losses was suitable for the fourth quarter of 2019. I'll hand the call over to Steven Nell, who will walk through the income statement in greater detail. Steven?
Steven Nell
executiveOkay, Stacy, thank you. On Slide 10 you'll see that net interest income came in at $270.2 million for the quarter, which is $8.8 million lower than the third quarter, because the last two Federal Reserve interest rate cuts were fully realized during this period. Net interest margin stood at 2.88%, compared with 3.01% in the prior quarter, and I've included a roll-forward on the slide to point out the significant items that affected how NIM was calculated. Number one, accretion levels came in $5.1 million lower this quarter because of fewer CoBiz loan payoffs, and that reduced NIM by 6 basis points. Number two, loan fees were higher in the fourth quarter, which boosted NIM by 3 basis points. Number three, our non interest-bearing funding profile saw a 9 basis point decline, with demand deposits decreasing and receivables from our trading activity increasing. Beyond that, our earning asset yield fell, and excluding accretion and fees that 29 basis point drop was essentially offset by a 28 basis point decrease in funding costs. Even though net interest income and margin have declined across the last several quarters, the flat interest rate environment projected for 2020 ought to permit some stability as we move ahead. Now on Slide 11, fees and commissions reached $179.4 million, which is a 12% increase both quarterly and year-over-year, driven mostly by the strength of our brokerage and trading business. Brokerage and trading rose more than 56% versus the same quarter last year, while on a quarterly basis overall brokerage and trading was roughly flat — trading revenue grew by $5.6 million, but lower customer hedging revenue and loan syndication fees offset that gain. Mortgage banking revenue declined 16% amid an anticipated seasonal slowdown; even so, 2019 proved to be an excellent year for the mortgage channel, since the favorable rate environment let us expand that business 16% relative to 2018. Looking toward 2020, our confidence in our origination capabilities remains intact, even with rates expected to stay flat. Fiduciary and asset management revenue rose more than 3% linked-quarter and year-over-year, as strong sales gathering activities and favorable equity markets drove steady growth. Other revenue declined because of the variable nature of repossessed asset revenues tied to certain oil and gas properties that sit within that line item. Moving to Slide 12, total operating expenses rose $9.5 million, reaching $288.8 million. Personnel expense was up $5.8 million for the quarter; incentive compensation climbed $2.6 million linked quarter, reflecting an increase in cash based incentive compensation mainly from sales activity in wealth management and commercial banking. Regular compensation rose $3 million, primarily because of severance costs tied to a realignment of personnel ahead of the 2020 operating environment. Non-personnel expense was $3.7 million higher than the third quarter, mostly because of our typical year-end charitable contribution of $2 million to the BOKF Foundation. The pressure I mentioned on net interest revenues pushed our efficiency ratio back above 60% this quarter. A 60% or lower efficiency ratio remains our long-term goal, though the revenue mix going forward will have an influence on it. On slide 13, you'll find what we presently anticipate for 2020. Security balances on average should stay in line with where they are now, since we're steering toward a fairly neutral position on interest rate risk. Loans should grow on average somewhere in the 3% to 4% range, with energy showing less expansion than in 2019. For the whole year, deposit averages ought to fund that loan growth. Net interest revenue should hold roughly level versus 2019, reflecting the generally lower rates throughout the year. The net interest margin should stay steady at today's level, and could lean slightly better should the broader rate picture stay unchanged. Fee revenues should rise in the mid-single digits, driven by ongoing gains in brokerage and trading as well as assets under management and wealth. The efficiency ratio should come in a bit above 60%, because fee revenues are climbing faster than net interest revenue. Provision levels under Day 2 CECL will support loan growth and will respond to shifts in the economic outlook. We don't anticipate any significant movement in the historic loss rates that feed our models during 2020. Taxes should run at about 21% of pre-tax income; we'll keep supplying ample capital for loan and balance sheet expansion, a competitive dividend payment and a modest amount of optimistic — share repurchases. Capital ratios ought to strengthen somewhat as 2020 progresses. Finally, I'd like to discuss the revised CECL transition impact we anticipate recording on day 1. Following numerous test runs, we project the pre-tax transition adjustment will fall somewhere between $60 million and $65 million, which sits in the middle of the range we gave last quarter. We've chosen to phase in the CECL transition's effect on regulatory capital across a three-year period. I'll hand the call back to Steve Bradshaw now for closing commentary.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveThanks, Steven. For our company, 2019 turned out to be a remarkable 12 months, and it really shows how varied our sources of revenue are. Compared with 2018, the broader sector had a tougher time in 2019, since we ran into rather major top-line obstacles once interest rates began dropping around the middle of the year. Although pressure like that usually shrinks what regional banks can earn, we experienced a sharp jump in income from our fee-based divisions, which tend to do very well whenever rates fall. None of that happened by chance. We deliberately design the business so it can succeed through every kind of economic cycle. We also stay hopeful about our capacity to keep expanding the business in 2020, though the drag from cheaper money and the economic doubt that always gets blown out of proportion during a national election year could still make things difficult. Even so, our method for creating shareholder value has always been oriented toward the long run, and that priority will keep shaping how and where we put money into the company as we move ahead. With all that said, we're happy to open the floor for your questions. Operator?
Ken Zerbe
analystGreat, thanks. Good morning.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveGood morning.
Steven Nell
executiveGood morning.
Stacy Kymes
executiveGood morning Ken.
Ken Zerbe
analystI'd like to begin with expenses — hopefully we can get somewhat more clarity on, say, the $1 figure for expenses, since it appears this quarter came in well above what was anticipated, even after removing the severance and the charitable contribution. And I realize your guidance says it will exceed 60% on the efficiency ratio, but could you offer a bit more direction regarding, for instance, which dollar amount is the correct one to have in mind here?
Steven Nell
executiveWell, I believe that when you consider 2020 and the sort of revenue we expect to generate in the fee businesses, that is among the reasons I sense the efficiency ratio will run somewhat above 60% — since growth in our fee business revenue will outpace growth in our net interest income. And when fee revenue grows, it brings along a somewhat larger expense base, commissions and other activities there that simply produce a slightly higher efficiency business as far as the percentage goes; and so, I think a level — you know, you want me to name the precise dollar level. I think it is, you know, adding 2020 will be nearer to, you know, where we stand at this one $288.8 million, somewhere, you know, plus or minus around that figure I think moving forward for 2020 is likely a pretty solid expense level to adopt.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveOkay, and Ken — Steve Bradshaw here. Something that tends to be somewhat unusual when it comes to the fourth quarter is that we currently have quite a few folks, both within the fee businesses and across many of our lending areas, who have annual incentive targets. While we accrue for those over the course of the year as we monitor them, by the time we reach the fourth quarter it grows more definite. That means there's always a bit of unevenness where incentive comp is concerned as we accrue toward year-end bonuses. So I won't argue with how Steven described it, though I believe there's invariably some added incentive comp expense sitting in Q4.
Ken Zerbe
analystAll right, that makes sense. Now I have a couple of very fast questions. First, whenever you say those capital ratios should get better, from whose point of view is that? In other words, do they rise or fall as the year goes on?
Steven Nell
executiveSure, so what we're aiming for, I'd say, is only a slight enhancement in those ratios, all right —
Ken Zerbe
analystMeaning that you’ll go higher?
Steven Nell
executiveThey go higher.
Ken Zerbe
analystAll right.
Steven Nell
executiveThose percentages tick up only marginally — you know, we're not discussing any significant buildup of capital in this case, you know. As I said, my expectation is that we keep on paying a solid, highly competitive dividend, and whenever the market gives us the chance, we'll act on it opportunistically along with stock buybacks. Still, I'd want to see that ratio rise only a touch across the —
Ken Zerbe
analystAlright, that’s great. And then only one final short thing: regarding energy credits, what share of your energy portfolio are you not the lead on, especially when it comes to the SNCs?
Stacy Kymes
executiveOn the SNC portfolio, roughly 65% is where we aren’t the agent.
Ken Zerbe
analystAnd what portion of the total do SNCs represent?
Stacy Kymes
executiveRelative to total energy, that figure is going to be fairly high.
Steven Nell
executive49%.
Stacy Kymes
executiveYeah, half.
Ken Zerbe
analystGreat. All right, thanks a lot.
Brady Gailey
analystHi there, good morning, everyone.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveMorning.
Steven Nell
executiveGood morning.
Stacy Kymes
executiveGood morning Ken.
Brady Gailey
analystRegarding your 2020 outlook, you mention NIM holding steady compared to where it stands now — I take that to mean NIM staying flat versus the $288 million figure from the fourth quarter. Is that the right interpretation?
Steven Nell
executiveYes, that's right — that's our view.
Brady Gailey
analystAll right, and then whenever you take a look at accretable yield levels — the $5.8 million during Q4 was the smallest amount you saw throughout all of ‘19. I realize it's a bucket that keeps shrinking, but what's your expectation for how yield accretion will move in 2020?
Steven Nell
executiveHonestly, that $5.8 million came in a bit under what I had anticipated. My real sense is that 2020 is going to land somewhere within roughly $25 million to $30 million for accretable yield. I can't tell you how it'll break down quarter by quarter, but that's probably the figure you ought to be looking for.
Brady Gailey
analystAll right, and last thing here regarding what we pay on deposits. When we talked 90 days back, I recall you both indicating that deposit cost might stay level, or possibly tick up slightly. In Q4, deposit costs came down. Could you discuss the possibility of pushing deposit costs even lower from this point, or do you believe that they have essentially reached a floor around this 4Q mark?
Stacy Kymes
executiveStacy here. If you consider our Q4 activity, we grew deposits by roughly $1.5 billion, and even so brought the total expense of deposits lower, which as you pointed out, strikes me as a major victory for us when it comes to keeping deposit costs on a downward path going forward. My view remains that you will see chances to bring deposit costs down further. LIBOR responded right away when the Fed acted, whereas deposit costs are slow to react; they trail on the way up and will trail on the way down. That hands us an opening as we enter 2020 to keep enhancing our deposit costs within our funding mix, and ideally that shows up as NIM improvement as we enter 2020 too.
Brady Gailey
analystUnderstood, thank you fellas.
Michael Rose
analystHi there, everyone. I just wanted to ask about the outlook for loan growth; it appears to be 3% to 4% for the full year on an average basis. I suppose I'm attempting to square that with how the period-end balance differs from the quarterly average balance — it seems like there may have been certain pay downs or perhaps charge-offs at year-end. And trying to square that with a few of the remarks concerning, you know, some softness in the middle market and, you know, energy not expanding as much going forward. So if you could help me make sense of that, I'd appreciate it. Thank you.
Stacy Kymes
executiveSure. So loan growth was pretty healthy throughout the quarter overall — it was really just the last two weeks or so when we saw paydowns hit both energy and commercial real estate. Early in January we've seen a nice bounce back in outstanding balances, so our hope is that some of those paydowns you noticed are the revolving kind and will come back. As for where growth came from last year, well, energy was up 11%; going forward, we're definitely not projecting that same pace for energy. Quarter-over-quarter expansion may be uneven at times, much like what we saw in earlier stretches. Even so, when you consider growth over the long haul landing somewhere between 3% and 4%, that's a result we're quite confident in. In our view, nothing about Q4 represented a lasting pattern. When we examined what drove those decreases, part of it came down to normal seasonal effects. Certain operations within our C&I segment typically draw down funding midyear and then settle those balances as the year closes. Energy reduced its borrowings, and we also saw paydowns in commercial real estate. We don't believe that reflects what lies ahead for us, and though it's admittedly very early in this new year, that assessment has certainly proven accurate so far. I'd say the outlook we've given — the 3% to 4% range — is something I'm quite confident in, and as of right now, nothing suggests to me that hitting it isn't possible.
Michael Rose
analystAll right, I appreciate the additional detail. Let me shift topics over to energy, and this might be for Marc. Could you provide a bit more insight into what might have driven some of the problems with those two energy SNCs? My guess is it likely ties back to the borrower running low on liquidity. If you could shed some light on that, and also whether these were tied to gas or to oil? And then, has your perspective shifted at all when it comes to lending in the energy space as we look ahead at it as an asset class? Thank you.
Marc Maun
executiveSure. Starting with how we track energy as a category, honestly nothing has really shifted in terms of our approach. What the market is showing us is that there's genuinely an effect coming from the capital markets and the A&D market being somewhat shut in certain situations, plus natural gas prices and NGL prices are currently depressed. That's creating challenges for certain credits. That said, we keep being 78% E&P first lien secured deals; from a gas price standpoint, 95% of our customers carry some form of hedging. We don't truly evaluate it at a portfolio level, but we're glad to see our customer base embracing hedging as a means of safeguarding their downside risk. When it comes to a specific credit, we sort of watch those individually and don't get too granular about what's happening on particular deals. And I can share that we feel very confident that our workout team, in certain situations, is taking every step required to reduce whatever exposure we have and reduce the amount of loss, such that we genuinely believe that as we go into 2020, we'll keep having our 12-month loss within the 20 basis points to 25 basis points range, which lines up with what we've experienced before. It might be a little uneven in the first quarter, but looking ahead, we don't expect it to deviate from what we've seen historically.
Michael Rose
analystAll right, I appreciate you fielding my questions.
Peter Winter
analystHello there.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveHello, Peter.
Peter Winter
analystI'd like to ask whether you could discuss what's behind that 3% to 4% average loan growth figure, since energy in particular — the key force in 2019 — is set to decelerate, and there seems to be a bit of hesitation in the middle market generally?
Stacy Kymes
executivePeter, it's Stacy. Energy is definitely going to remain one of our drivers. I really don't want to suggest that growth won't happen there next year; we believe opportunities will exist, we posted 11% growth, I doubt we'll repeat 11%, but I believe mid-to-high single digits is achievable within energy, which is clearly a big portfolio for us. We've got plenty of capacity remaining under our commercial real estate limits to keep expanding there. Our people in that area keep finding opportunities that we view as favorable and sensible from a credit risk standpoint at this stage of the cycle. So growth there seems likely to us. Healthcare is a segment where we keep expanding and putting money in, and we see — you see solid growth in healthcare for the year, we hold high expectations for that team in 2020 and believe growth will continue there. The softness shows up perhaps at the smaller end of C&I, where a sole proprietor or single business owner tends to be somewhat more wary about the macro environment. Still, we believe that clearly, considering what we've accomplished on the wealth side, we expanded our lending side in the wealth space, you know, at a strong double-digit pace last year and we expect that to serve as a growth driver for us in 2020 too. So when you put the pieces together and carry that into 2020, we definitely feel quite confident that something within the 3% to 4% range is very achievable for us.
Peter Winter
analystAll right. Turning to fee income, you mentioned brokerage, trading, and wealth. I wanted to ask, Steven, if you could share what you expect for mortgage banking during 2020?
Steven Nell
executiveSure. Across the areas we serve, our origination capabilities are solid, and when it comes to the purchase market, we have strong confidence both in it and in our capacity to meet its needs. Therefore, for the full year of 2020, I do expect a somewhat smaller total, though I believe our approach is excellent, our process is sound, our pricing is quite competitive, and our discipline is strong. As a result, I am confident we can deliver fairly strong results in mortgage, even if revenue may fall short of what we reached in 2019, because of the shift in the rate environment, you know. Still, I feel quite positive about that sector's ongoing expansion.
Peter Winter
analystAlright, and for my final question, I realize the Bank has put substantial effort into lowering costs. I'm curious, given a more challenging revenue landscape, do chances remain to trim the Bank's expenses?
Steve Bradshaw
executiveYes, Peter, Steve here; we truly got down to serious work on that push back in the fall, once it turned clear we'd face additional rate reductions and greater strain on net interest revenue in ‘20, and you observed us absorb slightly more than $2 million in severance charges during the fourth quarter. That step was mainly about pinpointing where we believed possibilities existed throughout the organization; we're likewise scaling back some growth of new roles across the Bank too. So while possibilities always exist and we constantly look for ways to boost efficiency. We're taking care not to achieve that by cutting our technology investment commitment, which matters to us competitively and where we keep making progress, yet without a doubt we'll maintain an intense focus on expenses all through 2020.
Peter Winter
analystOkay. Thanks for taking my questions.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveYeah.
Steven Nell
executiveI appreciate that, Peter.
Gary Tenner
analystThank you. Hello, everyone, and good morning.
Stacy Kymes
executiveMorning to you as well.
Gary Tenner
analystHi there, I've got a couple of things to ask. First, regarding deposits — Steven, you obviously provided the quarter-over-quarter movement in deposit costs. Might you share any mid-quarter detail about what deposit costs looked like during December?
Steven Nell
executiveNot really — I don't have the exact December figures available right now. All I can say is that, as Stacy noted earlier, the blended deposit costs for the quarter came in, and we were glad to watch that figure decline from 1.17% to 1.09%. Like he said, I believe there's room to push that lower somewhat; and — beyond that point, I don't think I'd say anything more.
Gary Tenner
analystAll right. And now, stepping back to look at the wider Oklahoma economy — we've been hearing that things might be slowing a bit there, with reduced tax collections and, I believe, some layoffs at a few of the bigger energy firms in the state. Could you share your thoughts on what the outlook looks like for Oklahoma's economy overall?
Stacy Kymes
executiveOklahoma's performing nicely. In my view, the drop in tax receipts mostly comes from lower growth production taxes, since drilling activity has decreased in the scoop and the stack right here in Oklahoma, yet corporate taxes and personnel income taxes have remained quite solid and are in fact up just a touch. So my sense is that Oklahoma's economy is in good shape. We really aren't detecting any softness — it appears the economy can take in those job cuts within a sensible timeframe; thus we aren't observing any underlying fragility there, recognizing that dislocation does occur now and then at particular companies, but job growth exists here as well and can soak that up, and the state is performing well.
Gary Tenner
analystAll right, thank you.
Steve Nell
executiveThank you.
Matt Olney
analystHey, thanks. Good morning guys.
Stacy Kymes
executiveGood morning, Matt.
Matt Olney
analystLet me circle back to what I believe was Peter's opening question regarding what will drive loan growth in 2020. And Stacy, it seems like energy is going to be a fairly meaningful piece of that driver, and my understanding is energy currently makes up roughly 18% of loans outstanding. Could you remind us of the internal limits you have on that asset class? And given the elevated charge-offs we saw from energy this quarter, is there any hesitation or worry about expanding this book going forward? Thanks.
Stacy Kymes
executiveAbsolutely. We have plenty of headroom within our concentration limits; nothing appears to stand in the way of our capacity to grow it, aside from simply finding good deals. When you look at actual net charge-offs, we've been running in that $10 million to $12 million per quarter range for some time now, and from that standpoint I don't view the fourth quarter as an outlier — actually I think it's quite consistent, if you look back at the fourth quarter of last year, net charge-offs fourth quarter-over-fourth quarter were nearly identical. So, as Marc mentioned, we're essentially offering some guidance that we expect net charge-offs to land in that 20 basis point to 25 basis point range next year for the full calendar year. Some of that could be front loaded earlier in the year as certain near-term issues work themselves through the process. But we still feel very good about this space. Regarding net charge-offs in energy this year, they came in higher than last year; they're at roughly 91 basis points or so in the E&P space, but if you consider the sector as a whole, we're earning 100 basis points to 125 basis points of additional spread on those loans, and we think we'll keep seeing some opportunity to improve that in 2020, as others reconsider their exposure here, but we like this business through the cycle, we recognize that this has been a longer-term ebb and flow in this industry than we've seen in a while, but we have a great team. The credit teams in the line are working great together. We have a great engineering staff. We think that we're well positioned to be able to manage through this and do it in a way that is good for the shareholders and good for us. I think we've talked about there will be some happiness and criticized and classified and non-accruals and you see that a little bit, but even with all that our non-accrual loans are less at the end of the fourth quarter than they were at the end of the second quarter. So there's a little bit where we're going to go out, there's a little bit where we're going to go down, but it will ebb and flow and it's at a level that we believe is very manageable. And so, when we look at the entire year, we expect charge-offs of 21 basis points for the company, and in our view that will stack up quite well against our peer group. So it's an asset class that obviously gets a lot of media attention, and there are problems with liquidity in that space, largely speaking, but we are working our way through it and believe we're in a very strong position to handle it. We remain as energized, so to speak, about energy as we have ever been, since we believe it's a key element of our DNA as a company, and we keep wanting to stress that as a core product offering for BOK Financial.
Matt Olney
analystAlright, I appreciate the additional detail there, Stacy; and following up on what we were just talking about. According to the press release, non-accrual loans did rise, and I believe it pointed to an increase of $7 million tied to a multifamily community development credit. Could you share more details on that credit, and does it fall within the senior housing portfolio?
Stacy Kymes
executiveThat credit is not within the senior housing portfolio. It's a low income housing tax credit deal we entered into as part of our investment in the communities we serve; some weakness has shown up, and leasing has been slower to ramp, though leasing is now underway — it's simply progressing at a slower pace. We don't see any truly significant loss. I won't claim zero loss, but definitely nothing of that magnitude tied to that new non-accrual loan in the fourth quarter.
Matt Olney
analystOkay, guys, thank you.
Steven Nell
executiveThank you.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveI appreciate it.
Jon Arfstrom
analystThank you, and good morning to everyone.
Steven Nell
executiveMorning to you.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveSteve Bradshaw speaking.
Jon Arfstrom
analystJon Arfstrom here — two quick follow-ups, and Steven, this first one's probably for you. Earlier, regarding NIM, you mentioned it reflected the last 2 cuts being fully realized. We touched on deposit pricing a bit, but I'm curious: are you indicating that the pressure on earning asset yields from last quarter has basically played out? Is that what you're telling us?
Steven Nell
executiveYeah, I'd say a good chunk of it has. Consider how many of our loans tied to LIBOR have already effectively re-priced — the bulk of that is captured in the figures.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAll right, that's helpful. And Stacy or Steve, this might be one for either of you. That broader deceleration on the C&I side that came up, and I believe the word you used was pause, and it could be tied to confidence. Clearly, 3 months back the mood was perhaps somewhat more downbeat, while today it's somewhat more upbeat. Over the past 3 months, have you noticed any of that improved confidence showing up, or is it basically unchanged?
Stacy Kymes
executiveMy sense is that conditions in the middle market and the lower end of the middle market on the C&I side have stayed fairly steady across the last few months. As greater clarity emerges around some of these matters, I believe you'll keep seeing chances for businesses to put money into their operations, purchase a new piece of equipment, bring on an additional line, and grow and expand, but as of today that hasn't been an area where we've observed much growth, definitely not growth running ahead of GDP. You know, for a number of years we discussed being in a position to exceed GDP growth, and you can manage that a little, but not by much and not on a consistent basis, and if you do, then, you know, be careful. So I think what we're seeing is essentially slow and steady expansion, not, you know, growth in the high single digit range in that space.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAlright, sounds good. You mentioned a couple of significant anticipated paydowns at year-end — could you help us understand how big those were, how material?
Stacy Kymes
executiveNo, that wasn't the case. We saw paydowns pretty widely across — actually in three segments: energy, commercial real estate, and our wholesale retail sector. These were just portfolio paydowns, not big credits. You know, part of that is the cyclical pattern where one of those, in wholesale retail, typically funds up during summer as they work through what's essentially their Christmas selling period, buying inventory, and then they sell down when cash flow comes in over that stretch. Energy and commercial real estate were, you know, simply the character of the business, nothing out of the ordinary there especially, but looking at the early portion of 2020, I notice a decent rebound there, so I'm definitely optimistic as we head into 2020 that this wasn't a trend, just sort of a late fourth quarter oddity — sometimes you get those types of things, Jon, and I'm not sure whether it's, you know, balance sheet dressing for a few of those companies or not dressing, but we'll observe that and generally don't respond to it very strongly given what we see late in the fourth quarter as we go forward.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAll right, understood. Perhaps I didn't catch that correctly — but it's useful. Then, for the final one, it seems you still — there's a fair amount of capacity on the commercial real estate side, yet you brought up concentration limits on a few occasions. Could you remind us what the themes are and, in a sense, what guardrails apply there?
Stacy Kymes
executiveWell, commercial real estate is a 100% — the limits for both energy and commercial real estate are determined by committed rather than outstanding balances; for commercial real estate, that figure is 175% of tier 1 capital and reserves, while for energy it stands at 225% of the joint capital reserves, meaning we possess plenty of room to expand in line with the guidance we gave for both of those areas. Therefore, we aren't — we hold no significant worries that our internal concentration guidelines would meaningfully restrict growth in those segments during 2020.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAll right, understood. Thanks so much.
Timur Braziler
analystHello there, and good morning. I'm Timur Braziler, sitting in today for Jared. For my first question, I'd like to revisit a few of the remarks regarding energy. What I'm curious about is whether the softness we're seeing in the energy sector is showing up in other industries as well. And if that's the case, to what extent is it contributing to what's been said about the sluggishness in middle market C&I?
Stacy Kymes
executiveAre you referring to a wider spillover impact across the broader economies of Colorado, Texas and Oklahoma?
Timur Braziler
analystRight.
Stacy Kymes
executiveWell, when you look at that, jumping to that kind of explanation is understandable. At this point, though, I wouldn't say it's clear to me that this is the message we're sending. From where I sit, this resembles the story of that first slump, which took place during 2015 and 2016. My sense is that things were sharper back then. These days, in my view, it isn't anywhere near as sharp, and from that angle it's somewhat more of a steady state. I'm not really — it's a fair question, but right now I'm not really drawing a straight line between the broader C&I deceleration and the softness — some softness that has shown up <<inaudible>> I believe that stood out more plainly and was stronger, you know, a number of years back, yet now that we've settled into this sort of $55 to $60 oil price, especially across the markets in our footprint, I'd say that matters less.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right. Perhaps shifting topics now to how deposits grew during this quarter. Quite noteworthy. Did that simply represent everything coming together from efforts underway that all landed in Q4? And I suppose, considering certain programs already in motion, what's left to do, plus how ought we to view deposit expansion as we move toward 2020?
Stacy Kymes
executiveWell, deposit growth, as Steve told everyone, is a key priority meant to help finance loan growth throughout 2019. Going through such a process, though, isn't easy — it resembles a vessel that won't pivot right away. Cultivating and spotting chances demands considerable time and work. Looking at Q4, Scott Grauer from our wealth group truly performed remarkably, securing excellent deposits at sensible pricing; those proved a major catalyst behind deposit gains during that quarter. Still, the commercial sides also performed admirably on this front. Essentially it came about thanks to sustained dedication — the payoff of labor underway for some time regarding pushing deposit figures higher. Turning to 2020, our genuine aim involves expanding sensibly on pricing; we wish to keep growing so as to keep financing loan growth, yet we remain highly conscious of watching what those deposits cost and doing all possible to limit any damage to our net interest margin when contemplating deposit expansion in 2020.
Timur Braziler
analystAlright, and one final item from my side — when we compare mortgage banking revenue against expense, and that gap this quarter, is it a matter of timing, or was it genuinely an incentive tied to such a robust year?
Steven Nell
executiveYes, so on the revenue side, commitment levels are what matter most, while on the expense side, things are linked far more closely to loan fundings. Now, loan fundings have stayed fairly flat. As a result, the effort required to complete those loan fundings shows up in the mortgage banking costs line item, yet the revenue side responds more to where commitment levels stood at year-end, and those fell off. That, essentially, explains the mismatch — it comes down to timing.
Timur Braziler
analystThanks a lot for that.
Steven Nell
executiveAlright, so we're glad you all could be here with us today. We truly value each of the questions you've raised and the attention you've shown toward BOK Financial. Should anything else come up, feel free to reach me by phone at 918 to 595 to 3030, or send a message to <<email_hidden>>. Enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's call. At this point, you're free to hang up your phones. We appreciate you joining us, and have a wonderful day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete BOK Financial Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to BOK Financial Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in BOK Financial Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.