BOK Financial Corporation (BOKF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 22, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Steven Nell
executiveMorning, everyone, and thank you for being with us. In light of the extraordinary circumstances we're facing right now, we thought it was important for you to hear from a number of leaders throughout our organization. To begin, Steve Bradshaw, our CEO, is going to give some opening remarks. After that, Marty Grunst, who serves as our Chief Risk Officer, will bring you up to speed on how our business resiliency operations are handling the coronavirus pandemic. You're also going to hear from Norm Bagwell, Executive Vice President of our Regional Banking division, and he'll talk about how we're responding to what customers need throughout our region, which includes the considerable work being done to extend loans through the Paycheck Protection Program; Stacy Kymes, Executive Vice President of Corporate Banking, is going to walk through our portfolios in energy, health care and commercial real estate; and Marc Maun, our Chief Credit Officer, will be with us as well to go over the remaining loan portfolios, our credit metrics and what our CECL implementation has meant. Finally, I will share the first quarter specifics on net interest income, net interest margin, fee revenues, expenses and where our balance sheet stands overall when it comes to liquidity and capital. You can find a PDF of the slide presentation along with the first quarter press release on our website, bokf.com. Please take note of the disclaimers on Slide 2, which apply to any forward-looking statements we may make on this call. At this point, I'll hand things over to Steve Bradshaw.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveHello, everyone, and thank you for being here as we go over our results for the first quarter of 2020. Before anything else, I'd like to share that everyone affected by the coronavirus pandemic is in our thoughts. For our company, our region, and our country, this is an event unlike anything we've faced before. We know our clients and communities are counting on us today more than they ever have. As a company playing an essential part in the economies where we operate, we witness directly how this crisis touches individuals and businesses, and we're still dedicated to supporting our clients through these difficult days; and although today's call will cover our first quarter results, we'll devote considerable time to talking about how this new economic landscape is affecting our company. Just as Steven said, we have quite an agenda today, one that should shed light on how we're responding and what we see ahead when it comes to COVID-19. On the first quarter, BOK Financial posted net income of $62.1 million, along with diluted earnings per share of $0.88. Results for this quarter took a dramatic hit from an economic outlook that was shifting and oil prices that were falling, which pushed up our loan loss provision substantially under the newly adopted CECL accounting standard — something Marc Maun will cover thoroughly in a little while. Without downplaying expected credit losses, if you look at pre-provision net revenue against prior quarters, the numbers were truly strong. Pre-provision net revenue came to $173.1 million this quarter, compared with $160 million the quarter before and $148.2 million in the first quarter a year ago, which highlights what our diversified mix of business revenues contributes. Net interest revenue fell $8.9 million, landing at $261.4 million this quarter. Even with several rate cuts during the latter half of 2019 and 150 basis points of emergency cuts in March of 2020, LIBOR has stayed fairly elevated. That factor, together with our capacity to bring deposit costs down, has kept a substantial share of our margin intact. Steven will later discuss the steps we've taken to position the balance sheet and push deposit costs even lower. Our brokerage and trading and mortgage banking revenues keep outperforming, powered by strong mortgage-backed securities trading and mortgage loan production volumes. Fees and commissions revenue rose more than 7% from the prior quarter, extending the momentum built over the previous year, while mortgage banking revenues climbed over 46% on a linked-quarter basis. As you might expect, growth in this area sped up during the final month of the first quarter and will likely keep leading in the quarters ahead. Expense management was outstanding this quarter too, with expenses dropping 7% versus the prior quarter. Although lower incentive compensation was the primary factor this quarter, we also made several moves involving delays in filling open positions and cuts to discretionary spending, which we'll detail later on the call, and those should aid expense levels through the rest of this year. Moving to Slide 5. At the close of the period, loans totaled $22.5 billion, which represents a rise of more than 3% versus the prior quarter. Although that was a favorable development for the organization as a whole, a meaningful share of it stemmed from larger draws, especially within our commercial and industrial portfolio. Deposits at period-end climbed almost 6% on a linked-quarter basis and rose more than 15% compared with a year earlier, extending the momentum we showed in 2019. Despite that considerable deposit expansion, we managed to lower total interest-bearing deposit costs from 1.09% during the fourth quarter to 0.98% in this quarter, since we could reprice what we pay on exception price deposits in our commercial portfolio far faster than anticipated. Assets under management or in custody declined for the quarter, which is understandable given that equity markets pressured asset prices; even so, sensible diversification across our clients' assets allowed us to perform comparatively better than the broad market sell-off. Furthermore, this quarter presented a chance to put more money into our own company, as we repurchased 442,000 BOKF shares at $75.52 per share on the open market. Once the prepared remarks are finished, I'll share further perspective on the results. For now, though, I'll hand things to Marty Grunst, our Chief Risk Officer, so he can discuss our business resiliency and employee safety response to the coronavirus pandemic. Marty and his team played a key role in ensuring we could react swiftly while keeping business continuity intact across our footprint. Marty?
Martin Grunst
executiveAppreciate that, Steve. Let me walk through what we've done since we put our business continuity plan into action. Right at the start, our Chief Human Resources Officer and I set a two-part objective: keep employees as safe as possible and keep service running without interruption. From there, we built and rolled out a range of tactics aimed at hitting those targets. That includes remote work for 70% of our workforce — the people whose roles allow them to do their jobs from home. For staff still in the office, we put in place a variety of social distancing measures, among them spreading work teams across several locations. We went further with split shifts to create more separation, and we assigned specific entry and exit doors, break rooms and similar spaces to each team. Banking centers shifted to drive-through and appointment-only service, and after that we trimmed hours somewhat and temporarily shuttered a number of banking centers so we could rotate shifts more easily. All of our locations now follow enhanced cleaning protocols. Because our call center faced greater demand, and mortgage and SBA lending volumes climbed, we temporarily moved employees out of banking centers and other departments throughout the company and into those high-demand areas. And above all, we introduced a set of employee support programs in light of how the environment has changed for our staff. Those include as much as 5 days of extra paid time off, added financial help for employee child care, co-pays waived for using our telemedicine service, and premium pay for certain nonexempt employees who must stay in the office. Whatever environment we end up operating in, our team stands ready to support operations. Finally, I want to express my gratitude to the many employees who have worked tirelessly over these past several weeks to make sure we show up for one another, for our customers and for our communities. I'll now hand the call to Norm Bagwell, who will cover how we're responding to customer needs. Norm?
Norman Bagwell
executiveAppreciate that, Marty. Across the country, the toll COVID-19 has taken on a lot of small and midsize companies is unlike anything we've seen. The social distancing measures that became necessary didn't just hurt companies heavily dependent on gatherings — the knock-on consequences are rippling through all of our markets. Our customers need us more today than they ever have; as a result, we've concentrated on putting together a strong bridge to them while the majority of our bankers shifted to remote work. We've brought clients into thorough portfolio management conversations centered on how their businesses are doing and on steering through deferral requests and renewals. Beyond that, we're partnering with clients to right-size their interest costs by tweaking earning credit rates and deposit interest rates given the changed rate landscape. Where it made sense, we've brought back interest rate floors. Conversations about interest rate swaps are happening actively too, and a number of our clients are capitalizing on the favorable rate climate. Fresh business keeps getting booked, since we've managed to pull pipeline items through during this period. Meanwhile, we're continuously risk rating our portfolio across the cycle. In wealth management, we've been extremely proactive with clients as well. Lately, active management and hands-on client service have fallen out of fashion, yet moments like this let us show why BOK Financial's wealth management know-how stands apart from competitors. Our staff are guiding thousands of clients — everything from counseling individuals on steering personal assets through difficult markets to assisting corporate clients in repositioning their balance sheets. Although phone and email remain the primary channels for our hands-on service, we're noticing these clients embracing our technology more heavily. Month-over-month, digital logins for our private wealth and retail brokerage rose 16% and 6.5%, respectively. On top of that, participants in our institutional wealth offerings have boosted digital transactions by 32%. Usage of our digital account performance monitoring tools has jumped dramatically too, with certain wealth management areas recording performance login growth of up to 65% between February and March; given how quickly all this adoption is happening, keeping continuous digital dialogue with clients about the wider economic forces in play has proven truly essential. More recently, our conversations with clients have zeroed in on the CARES Act, which is designed to deliver close to $350 billion in loans to small businesses through the Small Business Administration's Paycheck Protection Program, or PPP. As a certified SBA lender, BOKF started accepting PPP business the very day the program launched, Friday, April 3. Hundreds of our employees got reassigned from their usual positions in commercial banking and consumer banking, working around the clock to take applications and set aside funding for their clients. The response from our clients regarding how well we've handled things has been overwhelmingly favorable and has clearly set us apart from our peers. I feel a great deal of pride in what we've done to support our customers and the communities around us as they navigate this period of economic uncertainty. At BOK Financial, we've worked through roughly 4,700 PPP applications to completion, and SBA approvals totaling $1.8 billion have come through. We'd call our swift response on behalf of clients a win, though it certainly came with difficulties; that brief 10-day window for funding created something of an operational strain, yet we managed to rise to the occasion. On top of that, the sheer number of applications our credit services team handled in so little time this year was difficult, to put it mildly, but our credit team's resilience and adaptability have been demonstrated; in fact, tighter quality control measures were introduced throughout this period to guarantee the accuracy and viability of each application. Having said that, I'll hand things over to Stacy, who will walk through our energy, health care and commercial real estate portfolios. Stacy?
Stacy Kymes
executiveThank you, Norm. If you turn to Slide 11, you'll see that loans at period-end came to $22.5 billion, which represents a gain of over 3% during the quarter. Commercial real estate was mostly unchanged in this quarter, but C&I grew by more than 5% versus the prior quarter, driven mainly by the general business, energy and health care portfolios. Broadly speaking, growth in the traditional C&I portfolio stemmed from a mix of seasonal patterns and how customers reacted to the COVID-19 pandemic. Such revolving lines of credit are typically secured and subject to a borrowing base. Moreover, in numerous instances, what customers drew down was put back on deposit with the bank. When it comes to our specialized lines business, we saw very few draw requests, which was a reaction to the macro environment right now. Borrowing against credit lines has leveled off, and things have remained pretty steady ever since March came to a close. As we finished up the first quarter, the amount of energy loans on our books was $4.1 billion, which works out to 18% of all loans. The energy exposure we carry has caused our share price to swing around, but supporting the energy sector has been something that has defined this firm for over a hundred years. If you turn to Slide 12, you'll see that the bulk of this portfolio is made up of first lien, senior secured reserve-based lending to oil and gas producers — and from where we sit, that's the least risky form of energy lending. During this earnings call, we discussed how the pandemic-related slump in energy usage, along with the dispute over output among OPEC+ nations, pushed down crude prices in both spot and futures markets. About 62% of the production loans we have committed are backed by assets whose primary output is oil. The remaining 38% are secured by holdings that chiefly yield natural gas, a commodity that the recent events have not significantly impacted. Most borrowers hold a blend of oil and gas in what they produce. As we have said in the past, we view how long the downturn in crude prices lasts as a bigger factor in results than the actual price. If these declines turn out to be temporary—meaning they last less than a year—the portfolio losses we're anticipating shouldn't hit the company disproportionately hard. One thing that gives us a real edge during this slump is the hedging our customers already have locked in. Of the energy customers we put through stress testing, who make up 92% of production loans outstanding, 95% have at least some hedging in place covering the next 12 months, and a good number of them have positions stretching out to 24 months. Our thinking is that combining the underwriting discipline we've always applied with where our customers stand on hedges will carry us through this downturn, the same way it did in previous ones. Health care sector loan balances climbed by $131 million to $3.2 billion, which equals 14% of total loans. Slide 13 shows that senior housing and care facilities — $2.4 billion of the total — make up the bulk of these health care loans, spanning independent living, assisted living and skilled nursing. Our borrowers usually own portfolios containing several facilities, and that structure helps spread the risk associated with any one facility. A limited group of properties has seen a small number of COVID-19 cases. Even so, the response from our health care operators has so far kept any major effects in check. The rest of our health care portfolio consists of hospitals and other medical service providers, and they too have felt the effects of elective procedures being postponed so that enough protective equipment and ventilators are available for those delivering acute care to virus patients. It's worth noting as well that the CARES Act includes several measures to boost revenue for hospitals and skilled nursing facilities alike as they work through the virus risk; our confidence in the long-term outlook for this space is unchanged, and we expect it to keep leading growth once health and economic conditions shift toward something closer to normal. Balances on commercial real estate loans were mostly flat versus the prior quarter, making up 20% of total loans. Digging a bit further into this segment on Slide 14, loans backed by office buildings and other properties rose by a total of $141 million this quarter. That gain was mostly offset by a $128 million decline in loans backed by industrial facilities. Multifamily residential loans represent our biggest slice of commercial real estate lending, at $1.3 billion at quarter end. Loans backed by retail facilities stood at $774 million at March 31. When we consider real estate in a broader sense, we're entering this downturn from a relatively strong position. For a long time now, we've followed a rule that holds commercial real estate to no more than 175% of Tier 1 capital, and we also apply sub-limits broken out by category, construction, tenant and state. As of March 31, every one of those limits and sub-limits was still above where our legacy commercial real estate portfolio stood. Clearly, the retail portion of this portfolio carries the biggest exposure to extended stay-at-home and shelter-in-place orders. That portfolio divides about evenly between goods and services. At the close of 2019, the retail CRE segment's weighted average regulatory loan-to-value came in at 58%, and its weighted average debt service coverage was just under 1.5x. Similar to what we see with oil, how much retail revenue disappears will depend largely on how long government mandates stay in place and how shoppers change their habits once those mandates end. Office and multifamily properties will certainly feel some effects, but over time we think our geographic reach gives us an advantage in those categories, thanks to consistent population gains. That said, no one can sidestep every broad economic credit problem hitting banks and lenders. Our track record shows we have always underwritten credit carefully, and the previous downturn made that clear. We also feel good about how our underwriting standards will hold up during the current downturn. I'll hand things over to Marc Maun, who will cover the remaining loan portfolios, our credit metrics, and what CECL implementation means for us. Marc?
Marc Maun
executiveThanks, Stacy. Turning now to Slide 16. Here we've grouped together certain loan categories that we think face heightened risk from the economic slump brought on by the social distancing measures now in effect to combat the coronavirus. The segments you see listed — entertainment and recreation, retail, hotels, churches, airline travel, and higher education, all of which depend on large gatherings to remain profitable — account for roughly 7.7% of our overall portfolio. That lending group is highly diversified, spanning over 550 loans with an average size of less than $3 million. Some of those borrowers are going to enroll in the Paycheck Protection Program, and that ought to bring them a certain amount of relief from whatever pressure they're feeling. Clearly, we'll keep a close eye on those exposures as the coming months unfold. Speaking briefly from my vantage point as Chief Credit Officer about the energy book Stacy brought up a moment ago: when it comes to energy, the spring borrowing base redetermination window is now open, and over the second quarter we'll be calculating what our customers' reserves are worth. Beyond that, each quarter we apply a stress test to energy borrowers whose lines of credit carry over 50% funding, looking across all criticized loans, and we use a price deck with a 20% discount, which helps us identify possible trouble. When we ran the most recent stress test, incorporating customer hedges, nothing unexpected came up. Turning to Slide 17, credit quality has obviously remained solid up to this point. Even so, given the current economic environment, we anticipate migration in nonaccrual and potential problem loans. On top of that, requests for loan modifications have been handled one at a time, individually. Typically, what people ask for is 90 days of principal and potentially interest, and then at the close of that period we consider whether to extend for an additional 90 days. Based on what regulators recently told us, those loans don't get classified as troubled debt restructures as long as they were current on March 1, 2020. We saw nonaccruing loans decline by $17.8 million during the quarter, and that was mostly because nonaccruing commercial real estate loans went down by $19 million. Meanwhile, nonaccruing energy loans increased by $4.7 million in Q1. We recognized $30 million in new nonaccruing loans during the first quarter, which was offset by $9 million in payments we received and $19 million in charge-offs. Potential problem loans stood at $293 million on March 31, compared with $160 million on December 31; much of that growth stems from the energy portfolio, since the recent drop in oil prices, combined with a capital markets environment that requires certain customers to address their liquidity needs, pressured some energy borrowers. This could result in further nonaccruals and certain impairments. As Steve mentioned in his opening remarks, the company adopted CECL effective January 1, 2020; and since 12/31 we have raised total reserves by $131.5 million. Slide 18 illustrates what drove the increase in our allowance for credit losses and provision under CECL. The day 1 adjustment reflects a $49.4 million increase in ACL reserves. The day 1 adjustment in total includes another $12 million from mortgage banking activities and HTM securities, bringing it to $61.4 million overall — that matches what we told you last quarter — and this quarter that figure hit capital rather than earnings. For the first quarter, the day 2 provision for credit losses under CECL came to $93.8 million. Two things weighed most heavily on the CECL calculations during the first quarter: a worsening macroeconomic outlook tied to the COVID-19 pandemic, and declines in oil prices. In making those calculations, the company relied on base case, downside and upside economic scenarios, incorporating key economic indicators like gross domestic product, unemployment and oil prices. During Q2 2020, those scenarios rely on GDP ranging from minus 10% down to minus 30%, unemployment between 6% and just under 10%, and oil priced from $19 up to $27. Looking ahead, the economy is expected to pick up somewhat across the rest of 2020. Other economic inputs incorporated into the models include credit spreads, home price indexes and vacancy rates. Additional specifics supporting sensitivity analysis of these variables in relation to our total portfolio will be provided in our first quarter 10-Q. Shifts in loan balances, agent mix and credit quality make up portfolio changes, which contributed $16 million to the ACL. During the first quarter, we also recorded $17.2 million of provision expense tied to net charge-off activity. Once we accounted for the day 1 and day 2 first quarter provision, our allowance for loan losses came to $315 million, with an additional $28.5 million placed in other liabilities for unfunded loan commitments. While the full reserve for loan losses can be applied to losses in any portfolio, $100 million of it is assigned to our outstanding energy portfolio. At this point I'll hand the call over to Steven Nell. Steven?
Steven Nell
executiveAppreciate it, Marc. As we show on Slide 20, net interest revenue came in at $261 million for the quarter, which is $8.9 million lower than what we saw in the fourth quarter. Our net interest margin landed at 2.80%, a decline of just 8 basis points versus the prior quarter, since LIBOR has stayed high compared with how it has historically related to other short-term market interest rates. That factor, combined with our capacity to bring interest-bearing deposit costs down by 11 basis points, has let us hold onto a substantial share of our margin. In March, the Fed cut rates by 150 basis points, and that clearly had an effect on both net interest revenue and net interest margin, though the full picture won't become clear until we get into the second quarter. When it comes to the portions of net interest revenue and net interest margin that are most within our control, deposit costs are where we have the most leverage. With rates sitting at nearly zero, we're working hand in hand with our depositors to secure and retain balances while making sure the pricing on those balances is appropriate. Our interest-bearing deposit cost came down to 79 basis points in March, and looking ahead, we're confident that we can continue driving our costs even lower in the coming months. Now moving to Slide 21, fees and commissions came in at $193 million. That's an increase of 7.4% from the prior quarter and a 20% rise on a year-over-year quarterly basis, and it's still primarily powered by strong performance in our brokerage and trading and mortgage operations. In our trading and derivative businesses, we achieved record revenues this quarter, and combined brokerage and trading revenues exceeded $50 million. The bulk of that stemmed from trading activity tied to mortgages, with MBS/TBA trading revenue for the first quarter reaching $31.7 million, which represents a 40% gain over the linked quarter and a 212% jump compared with the same quarter last year. Even though those growth rates stand out, there's something even more notable: gains from mortgage trading were partially canceled out by declining fair value on asset-backed and municipal securities as spreads widened. As rates fell and mortgage market volatility increased, our traders did an outstanding job helping clients manage and reposition their investment and hedging portfolios. This quarter brought a significant surge in mortgage banking production revenue, up $11.8 million, which is over 46% higher than last quarter and almost 56% above the same period last year. Mortgage production volume overall reached beyond $1 billion, and refinances accounted for 57% of that total. On top of that, we boosted our gain on sale margins by 62 basis points relative to last quarter. One more bright spot this quarter involves how we hedge our mortgage servicing rights. Because of how quickly and how far mortgage rates fell, the fair value of our mortgage servicing rights dropped $88.5 million in the first quarter; even so, our securities and derivative contracts held as an economic hedge covered $86.8 million of that drop. The securities held as hedges also produced net interest revenue of $4.6 million. Thus, net MSR activity gave us a $2.6 million benefit in the quarter, which is a remarkable result given the conditions. Fiduciary and asset management revenue slipped just over 1% in the quarter, which could catch some off guard, considering how market-sensitive this segment is perceived to be. The truth is that only about 1/3 of those assets carry equity exposure right now, and that has brought added resilience throughout the cycle. Solid sales work, paired with this sensible diversification, showed up in relative outperformance. Quite a few of our fee businesses have plainly gotten off to a strong start in 2020 and, once again, underscore how important the revenue diversity our company possesses truly is. Moving to Slide 22. Total operating expenses fell a little more than $20 million, a 7% decline from the fourth quarter. Personnel expense dropped $12.2 million in the quarter, mostly because of a $2.2 million reduction in both deferred compensation and regular compensation combined. On top of that, the fourth quarter had roughly $2 million of severance costs tied to a realignment of personnel that did not repeat. Employee benefits rose $3.6 million as a seasonal bump in payroll taxes and retirement plan expenses was partly offset by lower employee health care costs. Non-personnel expense also came down, falling $7.9 million versus the fourth quarter. Mortgage banking costs declined $3.7 million, mostly from lower MSR amortization expense. Business promotion expense fell $2.6 million because of a seasonal drop in advertising costs along with reduced travel costs stemming from the current pandemic. Also, during Q4 we made a $2 million donation to the BOKF Foundation, and that item is absent from the current quarter. As Steve mentioned before, steps have been taken so that costs stay down through the remainder of 2020. To start, no new hires will be made under existing plans, and each vacancy gets reviewed carefully prior to filling it. Next, with so many employees working from home right now, we expect to save money on business promotion, fees paid to professional consultants, and costs tied to occupancy. Last, given these unfavorable business conditions, we decided to delay every IT project and other initiative that isn't essential. We'll continue funding efforts that face clients and enhance their overall experience, along with other key projects that keep our infrastructure running. Focusing on the most important work and letting less essential efforts move forward more slowly is a reasonable approach for now, at least until we can see the economy with greater clarity. Our liquidity position remains solid, but given how severely the pandemic has disrupted the capital markets, we've put several defensive measures in place to preserve that strength. Those measures include watching our liquidity on a daily basis more closely by monitoring the deposits coming in and going out for each customer, reviewing loan advances broken down by segment, making the most of what we can borrow from the Federal Home Loan Bank, and increasing the collateral we hold at the Federal Reserve discount window, along with other steps. As we mentioned before, our deposit balances remain robust, and so does our ability to bring in more deposits. On Slide 23, you'll see that our secured borrowing capacity stands at more than $12 billion, while unsecured and contingent liquidity capacity exceeds $7 billion, which supports the company's liquidity needs. On top of that, we can now fund PPP loans totaling $1.8 billion through the Fed Reserve PPP liquidity facility. Our capital position is strong as well — in fact, it was a cited factor when BOKF NA, which serves as the primary source of holding company liquidity, recently had its A rating reaffirmed by both S&P and Moody's. Our common equity Tier 1 ratio stands at 10.9%, which puts us well above the minimum of our internal operating range and 390 basis points higher than what regulators require — so we're in a solid position. In addition, we will take advantage of the OCC's capital phase-in plan as it relates to CECL implementation. Last, just a brief note on guidance. Because there's so much uncertainty about how long the pandemic will last and how severe it will be, as well as how it will affect the wider economy, we are not going to give the more formal guidance that we've offered in the past, but we do want to share a few thoughts that could be useful. On top of the $751 million in loan advances we've already made and the $1.8 billion in PPP fundings, we don't expect any loan growth for the foreseeable future. Given where pricing stands today, it's unlikely we'll complete any energy transactions. Most health care possibilities are on hold as a result of the pandemic, and there won't be much happening in our CRE and C&I portfolios. Mortgage loan origination will continue, though only a small portion will make its way into our permanent portfolio. We'll continue reducing deposit costs and ensure our deposits carry appropriate pricing in light of rates being close to zero, all while keeping overall funding requirements in mind. During the first quarter, we took advantage of mortgage spreads widening dramatically and pre-invested several months of expected cash flows from our available-for-sale securities portfolio at spreads that were considerably favorable. After we collect the cash flows we expect, we'll go back to putting money into mortgage-backed securities that have the right spreads along with prepayment and extension traits we can manage. The variety of fees we bring in ought to keep softening the hit to earnings that our spread businesses are taking. We'll stay strict about keeping personnel and non-personnel expenses in check. Nothing we currently offer or do is slated for elimination. We may put less important projects on a slower track, but money will keep flowing toward enhancing how clients experience us and our tech foundations. We're heading into this slump with solid capital, and the dividends we pay aren't in jeopardy. Buybacks remain something we look at when conditions are favorable, though never in a way that would weaken our solid capital standing. Steve Bradshaw, over to you for your closing remarks.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveAppreciate it, Steven. As we mentioned, there are some favorable operating outcomes in the first quarter. Without question, the day 2 CECL provision mattered a great deal, and at this stage we cannot forecast what lies ahead in later quarters. We haven't yet been through an entire quarter this year under conditions near 0 rates, so we absolutely anticipate that will pressure our spread businesses moving forward; that factor, combined with a deliberate economic pullback aimed at slowing the virus's transmission, will restrain expansion for every financial institution during 2020. Even so, a number of encouraging elements exist, particularly at BOKF — specifically within our wealth management and mortgage operations, which have every chance to exceed expectations in 2020. As we always do, we're applying a disciplined, careful method to every choice we make. We're taking in the effect of significantly reduced asset rates while searching out the finest cost options and funding sources ahead. Our liquidity and capital are robust, which affords us the freedom to make well-considered adjustments that won't hamper our chances for growth once this climate stabilizes, as it certainly will; until then, we'll keep working to control costs wherever we can, shelving certain projects and reducing hiring growth along with other steps, until demand shows clear signs of recovery. I'd note that our outlook has picked up a somewhat negative tilt since the quarter closed, as we try to grasp the lengthy path before us for meaningful economic activity to come back. It's possible to imagine second-quarter GDP contraction and joblessness levels worse than what we projected when the quarter ended. Still, none of us has traveled this territory before; therefore we'll act for our customers' sake in whatever way needed, doing all we can to help them, no matter what the economy does in the short term. And we stay certain that this company was constructed to deliver results even under severe economic strain; our leadership team is deeply seasoned, and that leaves me completely confident in our capacity to steer through this obstacle just as we've done with so many others. At BOK Financial, our perspective generally stretches further out than most, and I firmly believe we'll stand out once the record of this economic trial is complete. With that, we're happy to answer your questions. Operator?
Ken Zerbe
analystGreat. I figured we'd kick things off by talking about energy. You mentioned that 95% of your customers have a certain amount of hedging in place. So with any luck, I'd like to learn how much hedging. But what I really want to ask is whether you can discuss the credit quality of the energy loans and the borrowers who either have no hedging whatsoever or fall within that 95% but on the portion of their production that isn't hedged. Does that carry substantially more risk?
Stacy Kymes
executiveThis is Stacy. I'll address customer hedging. More than three-quarters of our present low-weighted commitments are hedged at a minimum of 50% for 2020, at an average price above $55. So we feel quite good regarding the hedging level present across our customer base. And truly, that ranks among the most remarkable mitigants against the downside. And although we keep emphasizing that the time horizon represents the greater risk rather than the commodity's absolute price. Obviously, entering this cycle, we did so with a reasonably solid book; we had particular customers showing a certain degree of weakness; but when we examine that as we head into this, we feel quite good about it; and I believe that as we prepare ourselves for the time horizon, we're going to be in a condition that's quite manageable for us. Just to remind everyone, since we get terribly fixated on the spot price and whatever is moving on the daily ticker, oil prices collapsed in '08 and '09, falling from $141 a barrel to $34 a barrel within a brief span. In 2014, we witnessed yet another oil price collapse, going from $105 a barrel to $26 a barrel over a fairly short stretch. Throughout that span, natural gas likewise faced a considerable amount of pressure. In the 5-year period concluding at the close of 2019, our cumulative losses stemming from the previous collapse across a 5-year period totaled $89 million; we don't know how long this cycle will last, but we do know that historically we've done a solid job underwriting energy credits; and so we feel quite confident in our capacity to work through and manage this. But our emphasis isn't on short-term pricing but rather on the long-term curve, since we believe that better indicates how our customers will perform over time.
Marc Maun
executiveMarc Maun here, Ken. Let me quickly tack on one more point: when we look at the forward curve right now, we have to remember how steep the contango is. So regardless of what customers have seen over these past few days, when you glance at the remainder of this year and on into '21, the prices you're finding are hitting $30 a barrel, or even beyond that. That means there's a chance with those customers who haven't hedged — an opening for us to collaborate with them and figure out approaches to improve the general quality of their cash flow, by examining hedging possibilities and partnering with them along those lines.
Ken Zerbe
analystUnderstood. All right, that's useful. So perhaps one more item. Clearly, you said LIBOR has been a major factor behind the reason your NIMs have stayed as strong as they have. Should LIBOR ever begin moving back toward normal levels versus Fed funds, could you assist us in putting a number on just how significant that is for your portfolio? More or less, what does that do to margin? For instance, how much is tied to LIBOR as opposed to prime?
Steven Nell
executiveCertainly, Ken. Steven Nell here. Indeed, LIBOR has maintained an advantage of roughly 40 to 45 basis points compared with its historical relationships; over the past week it has actually narrowed by about 10 or 15 basis points. That matters to some degree since, as you're aware, approximately 75% of our loan book is variable. And I'd say most of that is based on LIBOR. So that spread has given us some benefit. Our view is that over time it will narrow. And absent providing a particular dollar figure or percentage effect, should it return to a position closer to historical norms, there will be a certain compressing effect on our margin ahead.
Stacy Kymes
executiveStacy speaking here. One additional point I'd make: the gradual decline in LIBOR has definitely worked in our favor. It has essentially bought us room within our deposit base to concentrate on accounts carrying higher rates and to steer things accordingly. Looking at it — roughly $4 billion falls into what we refer to as exception price deposits, meaning those priced above our usual levels; since the close of February up through mid-April, we've brought that figure down by more than 90 basis points. So when we consider where the margin heads from here, that equation has several sides to it. Without question, LIBOR has been a tailwind for us. Yet because its descent has been gradual, we've had the opportunity to properly adjust pricing across our wider deposit base, and we believe that serves as a helpful offset.
Jared Shaw
analystStaying on the topic of credit for a moment — could you tell us how much deferral activity you've seen, particularly within those at-risk portfolios like energy, health care, and CRE? Those fall under the COVID umbrella but aren't currently classified as TDRs, right?
Marc Maun
executiveSure, Marc Maun here, happy to address that. When it comes to energy, we've had zero deferrals so far. Across the commercial side overall, deferrals sit at roughly 3.7%, and health care accounts for the biggest chunk of that. For commercial real estate, the figure is approximately 8.2% of total dollars — that's dollars outstanding. And from what I've seen in peer group surveys, our percentage of dollars deferred across all those categories ranks toward the lower end to date.
Jared Shaw
analystAll right. So focusing specifically on energy, what do you expect for crude prices when you're setting this reserve right now? Once that 12-month window has passed, what price level are you assuming for oil? And looking back at Q1 of 2016, the allowance stood at 3.1%. I'm a bit puzzled as to why the allowance would come in lower today, considering the wider shift and what CECL does.
Marc Maun
executiveLet me offer a few remarks regarding the price forecast. We track the forward curve from the price deck that gets published regularly. On day one of every month, we establish our price deck using the latest price movements — or the price deck from the 5 days before that month starts. Then, throughout the month, we evaluate whether declines in price are large enough to warrant lowering that deck mid-month. Right now, our April price deck lines up well except for spot price, which isn't our focus; what we focus on is discarding month one and examining the deck past that point. Our April deck matches the forward curve as of this morning. So we still see it as roughly $28 during the opening year, then rising to somewhere around $40 by 2023. Your second question dealt with the energy reserve size. That $100 million figure, as Stacy mentioned, stacks up quite well against our net charge-offs over the last 5 years. It's risen $52 million since 12/31. Back in 2016 it reached a peak of $101 million. Midstream now represents a somewhat larger portion of it, and midstream carries a slightly smaller reserve allocation than was the case in 2016. Meanwhile, it's April, and this was done as of March 31 using what we knew then. I can't rule out chances to add to reserves down the road as we monitor our market, our customers, and energy prices broadly. Still, on the whole, 2 or 3 weeks after the OPEC+ shifts, that reserve level was justified. Given our track record, we feel fine with where it stands now, and we'll keep assessing it ahead of time and set proper reserve expectations in Q2.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveSure, I’ll add a couple of things. Right now, the percentage for our energy reserve is at its peak, and that happened because we saw very large pay-downs in that portfolio. Over $600 million came down, and on top of that, we kept the allowance in place while not using it as much as we had originally provided for, so in effect the denominator got smaller and that lifted the percentage. Because of that, I think the absolute dollar amount Marc mentioned is a better way to compare things. Marc raised this too, but clearly trying to project expected losses ahead of time for any portfolio—particularly energy—is very difficult, and we’ll continue to review it over time. The key thing for us to keep in mind is that our fee revenue mix is very strong, and our pretax pre-provision revenue is at a very high level, so 280 gives us the ability to keep adding to the reserve in fairly meaningful amounts without ever putting capital at risk; that leaves us well positioned ahead, though we’ll keep reassessing as conditions change to ensure our provision remains appropriate.
Jared Shaw
analystAll right. Then, last thing from my side — regarding capital in the prior quarter, you mentioned wanting to strengthen capital levels. Clearly, Q1 saw some major, dramatic shifts. That said, how long would you remain at ease running an elevated overall capital return ratio before, I suppose, we start considering other capital measures aimed at building capital?
Steven Nell
executiveYeah, Steven Nell here. At 2.98%, our common equity Tier 1 level sits at a point I'm quite comfortable with. Stacked against a lot of peers, that's considerably better. So I'd say we enjoy solid capital flexibility. Like I said during my remarks, at this moment I see no danger whatsoever to our dividend. And I believe we'll remain opportunistic. I'm not going to declare today that we'd halt any buybacks. Staying opportunistic is what I want, though always within the frame of that robust capital standing. So let's allow some time to pass and observe what happens. Stacy's points ring true to me. Our pre-provision, or net revenue, generation is enormous. Revenue diversity is solid. That means our earnings power gives us ample strength. Our reserves are more than sufficient, and our capital standing is extremely solid. So I'd say we have a fine chance there to keep paying dividends while staying opportunistic with buybacks going forward.
Michael Rose
analystI'd like to return to the energy portfolio for a moment. What I believe you're telling me is that, given our current knowledge — since your downside scenario actually sits above the 12-month strip as of today — you're indicating that, if we finish the quarter around these levels, and with borrowing base redeterminations underway, and the borrowing base clearly set to decline, then we should anticipate an additional reserve build for the energy book in Q2. Is that how we ought to frame it, Marc?
Marc Maun
executiveYes, I believe that's right; the hedging piece also has to be taken into account during borrowing base redetermination season, and our hedge book is substantial. But definitely, at present, the forward curve is what we'll use, and the price deck we apply will be tied to that forward curve. And it will probably push borrowing bases lower. Roughly 25% to date has been completed. So once the spring determination season wraps up, we'll assess what the suitable reserve level should be.
Michael Rose
analystAnd on that 25%, what sort of average reduction in the borrowing base have you achieved so far?
Marc Maun
executiveRight now, I'd say we're sitting somewhere between 10% and 20%.
Michael Rose
analystAll right, that's useful. So perhaps, to wrap up the discussion of energy and tied-up capital, how does this current energy slump differ from what we saw between '14 and '16, and also from the '09 stretch? From an outsider's vantage point, it looks like E&Ps could face greater danger this time around, simply because of liquidity limits and the fact that, apart from bank lines, capital is extremely hard to obtain. So could you walk through the pluses and minuses of how the situation differs now?
Steve Bradshaw
executiveSure — in my view, the most notable difference lies in how much hedging is in place. The volume is substantial; based on what we've examined, and as Marc noted, roughly 1/4 of these, the extent of hedging has been quite striking, and it has helped keep the borrowing base afloat. We're also seeing customers act far faster when it comes to output and drilling choices this time, even shutting in wells to a degree, moving much more rapidly than has been the case in past cycles. That should produce a sizable effect on supply, though some time will be needed before it fully shows up. Obviously, the demand shock caused by COVID-19 is the unknown factor here. At what point does the economy start to bounce back? At what point do aircraft — big consumers of oil via jet fuel — get back into the skies? At what point does demand come back? For me, right now, this is genuinely a demand problem rather than a supply problem. My sense is that supply will decline, and decline fairly fast; yet the unknown element, as I see it, is the demand side — how soon it returns. You also had demand troubles during the '08, '09 price drop, driven by the wider recession. So ultimately, supply and demand imbalances must be resolved. I believe the market will resolve them, as it has done throughout history, but that process requires time. Typically, it takes 12 to 18 months to reach some form of equilibrium, which is exactly why we keep concentrating on that horizon rather than on the absolute numbers in front of us today; still, we believe the markets have reacted as they should, though in our view the main risk going forward centers on the demand effect and how fast it can bounce back once business activity of some sort resumes.
Peter Winter
analystSteven, I was hoping you might give us some insight into what the second quarter could look like for a few of those fee income operations. You posted fantastic results — in brokerage, trading, and mortgage. So I'm curious whether that pace can hold up. And might you also touch on a few of the other segments?
Steven Nell
executiveSure thing, Peter, happy to. On whether it holds up — the climate right now is genuinely unusual, so predicting is tough. In the somewhat narrow guidance we provided, I believe I indicated that in my view brokerage, trading, and mortgage will plainly be tailwinds and contribute additional revenue, which should counterbalance part of the strain coming from net interest income and net interest margin. So my sense is they'll remain robust. This climate — it's choppy. On the trading side, it hands us chances to assist clients in setting up hedges and arranging their investment portfolios. As for mortgage activity, right now it's still extremely, extremely robust; I think we did a genuinely strong job of lifting margins in mortgage, which rose 61 basis points, if I recall correctly. That should keep going. So I expect they'll be quite helpful in the second quarter, just as they were in the first. As for exactly how much, I'm not — I won't speculate on that. But I'm confident they'll be quite helpful.
Peter Winter
analystThen there are a few of the other areas, such as payments and wealth management.
Steven Nell
executiveOn the transfer and payment businesses, I could let Stacy take that one.
Stacy Kymes
executiveAbsolutely. When you look at the payments side of things, heading into April, we definitely observed a drop in ATM and debit activity tied to that segment. More lately, though, we've noticed activity picking up now that those stimulus checks have come in. I wouldn't call it a dramatic slowdown—more like a modest one on the payments side as we look ahead. That business tends to be quite steady whether times are good or bad. Still, on a relative basis, I think the effect of consumers spending less overall will show up in our payments business during the second quarter.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveAbsolutely, Peter — Steve Bradshaw here. When it comes to wealth management, our expectation is that flows will show some improvement. Certain operations of ours, corporate trust among them, ought to expand under the conditions we're in right now. Beyond that, we're witnessing money coming in on the equity side, since it appears people have concluded that in numerous instances a bottom has formed. As a result, some movement is occurring as funds shift away from cash and toward equity. And clearly, a great deal of repositioning is taking place within fixed income. During the first quarter, that served as a significant catalyst. Nothing we can observe at this moment points to that having slowed down at all; therefore, in line with what Steven mentioned, my expectation is that this segment will stay robust and present chances for growth despite the difficult environment we face.
Peter Winter
analystThen, turning to credit in health care, especially senior housing, could you go a bit further into what the COVID effect looks like from a credit quality perspective?
Stacy Kymes
executiveAbsolutely, Peter. It's Stacy, and I'm happy to take that one. In health care, I'd say 3 sectors are affected. With hospitals — if you're a rural hospital right now, this could hit you very hard, potentially devastatingly so. Our portfolio doesn't include rural hospitals, particularly within our footprint, where most states by and large haven't opted into the affordable CARES Act. Rural hospitals were already facing heavy strain, and that's never been a business development priority for us. Regarding the hospital systems we do have, several factors have hit them: elective procedures being delayed, which is a higher-margin line of business for them, plus, honestly, people avoiding the facilities in some instances when they need care, out of fear of being around COVID-positive individuals and catching it; these are very sophisticated hospital health systems. They hold large endowments and can ride this out; we absolutely anticipate greater liquidity demands from that hospital systems group, since they probably won't want to liquidate endowment holdings while securities pricing is depressed; instead, they'll more likely draw on lines of credit and similar arrangements. So we anticipate some growth from that portfolio. Still, we see no material credit risk whatsoever within that hospital systems group. At the time we bought CoBiz, they possessed a very strong and robust medical and physicians large practice group. That's where we've received the biggest volume of health care deferral requests. The reason is that these specialty-style practices have taken the heaviest hit from elective procedures being postponed. So our thinking is that we'd view this as fairly temporary. Typically, these involve doctors — individual doctors who back the facility alongside the corporate entity; therefore, there could be some timing effects, and some classification shifts over time once we receive financial statements. I don't view that as a meaningful loss risk at present, though if a lengthy stretch passes without access to those kinds of facilities, that could certainly shift; in senior housing, that's definitely where attention has centered regarding credit risk and potential loss. I believe it's key to recognize that we have more than 350 skilled nursing facilities within our portfolio; as we mentioned in our earlier remarks, we favor multi facility operators given the diversification. Roughly 5% of the skilled nursing facilities we hold have reported a minimum of 1 COVID case. So when you look at the bigger picture, that's a fairly modest number. That said, a substantial amount of government assistance is headed toward both the health systems and skilled nursing, including Medicare and Medicaid enhancements, plus extra funding to support these heightened infection-control measures and money for buying more protective equipment, and so on. That portfolio is performing solidly. It's going to be — it's going to take time; we won't know today precisely what the effect looks like; some time will be required. Obviously, we're talking with our borrowers, getting a sense of how they're being affected and what steps they're taking. But as I mentioned, about 5% of the facilities in our portfolio have reported a case. So we fully recognize that could shift as time goes on. But as conditions start to settle, I feel quite good about the skilled nursing portfolio. It won't be flawless, but I don't — I'm not especially worried about it.
Brady Gailey
analystI wanted to ask about hedging on energy. This week the energy market has behaved in such a strange way, and the price for the May 4 contracts turned negative. So I'm curious whether that affects in any way the hedges held by your energy companies. Do they actually use those 4 contracts for hedging, and is there basis risk involved? Are those hedges failing to function as intended, or do they hedge through different methods?
Stacy Kymes
executiveStacy here. Well, that's among the chatter that tends to circulate, with everyone monitoring the spot price as if we could have taken advantage of it. I believe folks throughout Texas and Oklahoma would have topped off their pools with crude just to receive payment for doing so. For the borrowers, hedging really operates on something like a daily average basis across the 20 trading days leading up to the contract's closing. So that oddity we witnessed when the May contract closed had no real significant effect on the hedging. Sure, it generates noise and plenty of headlines, yet it doesn't matter when it comes to how these hedges actually settle.
Brady Gailey
analystAlright, and moving over to expenses, you saw a nice reduction, and that was in compensation costs. I know you've mentioned that a portion of this ties back to incentive comp. That said, fees performed quite strongly while comp declined. Usually, those two tend to go hand in hand. Perhaps you could — just give us a sense of the size. In other words, how do you — when we think about the second quarter, what's your expectation for how that comp line moves? Should we treat 1Q as a solid baseline? Or was a meaningful chunk of it essentially a one-off gain coming from the lower incentive comp?
Steven Nell
executiveYeah, Brady, Steven here. I'd estimate about $8 million of that reduction came from deferred compensation, which flows through that line item. And my expectation is that it won't happen again. So that's a decrease this — during the first quarter that is not going to repeat. As for the rest, I'd say it's fairly solid. We did bring down somewhat our personnel costs, meaning our standard and part-time wages. I believe that trend will persist given certain actions we're undertaking around adding to staff as well as definitely vacant roles and backfilling roles, plus we're slowing a few of our project expenses and — bringing them down somewhat. So I'd say when it comes to the outlook, that single item of roughly $8 million is something I would not view as recurring.
Brady Gailey
analystAll right. Then my final item here concerns the net interest margin. Steven, according to you, the complete effect won't show up until the second quarter. Do you have any sense of how big the decline in margin might be for 2Q? In 1Q, as I recall, it dropped 7 or 8 basis points. What kind of drop do you expect for 2Q?
Steven Nell
executiveHonestly, I believe there are simply too many variables in play. You have sizable growth in your loan portfolio, some of which is tied to COVID. You have PPP loans sitting on the balance sheet at present. You have funding costs tied to those. You have large volumes of deposits flowing in; telling you the precise size of what the NIM will be is not possible. That said, I will say this, and I will repeat what Stacy mentioned before, the most important thing we can possibly do is truly keep our deposit costs under control. And we are putting in a tremendous amount of effort. He provided an illustration involving roughly $4 billion of exception price deposits that we have brought down considerably. Our March interest-bearing deposit cost, I believe, came in at 79 basis points, and I anticipate that figure will move substantially lower across the quarters ahead; so that should serve as a solid positive to help bolster net interest margin. Even so, obviously, given the drop in — the enormous drop in rates that occurred around the early to middle portion of March, NIM will feel an effect. And there are simply numerous variables to weigh; so I won't go out and declare it will be x number of basis points, but it will come in below the 2.80% that showed up in the first quarter.
Jennifer Demba
analystI'd like to return to the topic of energy loans. Investors might be making a particular comparison, and I was hoping you could help us put it in context. Comerica came out with its results yesterday, and they said their energy reserve right now sits at roughly 10%, while yours is at 2.4% to 2.5%. Could you give us your take on that? Also, would you explain the way you stress tested the energy book, especially when it comes to a longer duration for this scenario of lower oil demand?
Marc Maun
executiveJennifer, Marc Maun here. I'll address the comparison with Comerica. Honestly, I'm not familiar with their portfolio, so it's hard for me to judge how they arrived at those specific figures. That said, during the 2015 through 2017 slump, several banks came out early on with sizable energy reserves. Along with certain other institutions that are quite active in energy, we usually found ourselves toward the smaller end. Our energy reserve figure is driven by the traits we observe within our own portfolio. From what we're able to determine by looking at how their engineering is put together — our team includes 16 engineers and technicians — we believe our analysis is quite robust, covering not just how the price deck factors in, but also a clear picture of how those wells will produce and perform once completed through that engineering work. Beyond that, we keep returning to the hedging piece, since it offers price protection that lets us look past whatever the current price deck happens to be. So we bring all of that together when we evaluate. Looking at how things have played out historically, our track record shows we've maintained adequate—actually more than adequate—loss reserves to handle the ultimate claims that come with energy cycles. As we've mentioned previously, we'll keep assessing things continuously to make sure the reserve level is right. On the stress test front, our practice is to use roughly a 20% discount to the price deck we're currently using—that's what I noted before. For crude oil, that discount started at 23% in early 2020 and eventually reached a peak of about 33% or slightly above. Natural gas was at $1.52, and that figure rises to approximately $1.92 across a 5-year span. That stress test is run on a — without hedging basis. Like I mentioned before, at this point, that stress test still reflects what the forward curve is. It's well below what the — it's still at the 20% below, roughly where the forward curve is today. So we take a look at that, take a look at the hedging that's associated with the individual customers. Determine where our highest risks are. We had a very small number of customers that continue to not have sufficient hedging. And those are the ones we've identified. As for the remainder, we'd already flagged those as criticized loans and are actively engaging on them. So what we saw wasn't a big jump in the count of customers we consider to carry elevated risk, and that's the lens we applied to the stress test.
Stacy Kymes
executiveI won't get into naming any particular counterparty, but in general terms, when it comes to our energy relationships, we hold the control position in 69% of them — whether that means serving as the lead, acting as syndicating agent, or perhaps being the sole bank on a facility. Still, my sense is that this really works in our favor as we move through all of this, letting us help steer and resolve whatever problems might arise in the current climate.
Jennifer Demba
analystThat's really useful. Regarding the industries you flagged as more exposed to the pandemic — casinos, restaurants, hotels, and so on — what sort of deferral rate are you observing across that group?
Marc Maun
executiveHonestly, I'm not sure I can give you that level of detail split out by industry. What I'd come back to is that nearly all of those sit inside our C&I portfolio. On total dollars, we're at roughly 3.8%. I do know we've received a few deferral requests tied to the casinos, since those properties are entirely closed. Most of them, though, are tribal casinos — practically all, in fact — and they hold fairly sizeable liquidity reserves. In many instances they're also keeping their staff employed, and that's part of why they're seeking modifications. In convenience stores, specialty stores, hotels, colleges and universities, or airlines, we haven't really seen anything yet that would be worth mentioning or that's material. On the restaurant side, we've seen some — a meaningful share of that is franchisee-financed. That said, we're dealing with very large brands, very recognizable names. So even though we're told sales have fallen 20% to 30%, we know they can still operate drive-through, curbside, and delivery. And in many cases the franchisor is backing those brand names, offering longer-term support if this stretches on further.
Stacy Kymes
executiveWell, Jennifer, as you're aware, at BOK Financial we deliberately kept our exposure light in these sorts of areas for a really extended stretch of time, and businesses like these tend to struggle more when a downturn hits. That's why, looking back, we've never been a major player on the lending side here. Then there's another spot where our weighting has been notably light, and that's leverage lending of any type. Marc, along with his credit team, has handled that quite well, since a big chunk of what we hold relies solely on cash flow for repayment. So when it comes to those riskier portions of the spectrum, we're feeling fairly confident.
Jennifer Demba
analystAll right. Could you describe what makes that casino portfolio—specifically the one involving Indian casinos—distinct? Also, what's the worst-case magnitude of losses? And in what manner does recourse function for credits of that kind?
Marc Maun
executiveSure, I'll explain how these are put together. They're direct—they go to the gaming operations of each individual tribe. As you're aware, mortgages on casinos generally aren't something we can take, owing to assessments by sovereign nations. Yet every nation provides methods to address immunity here, and recourse would operate by us assuming control of the cash flow tied to the casino. Like I mentioned, at present these casinos are closed. Even so, their liquidity is robust, and their cash balances are sizable. Consequently, we anticipate no meaningful chance of loss, since we'd expect these properties to start operating again once the economy reopens. Assessing this is difficult—it hinges, once more, on the duration until reopening. For the bulk—the bigger—most of this portfolio, we're at ease that cash reserves exist to carry it across a sensible shutdown span.
Stacy Kymes
executiveJennifer, one intriguing footnote to that: once those stimulus checks started going out, we also noticed a significant jump in the gaming portion of our debit card. So it's tough to gauge. Some offsets are going to show up there; these are extremely robust gaming operations, and the tribes backing them are strong. So it ought to be a really solid portfolio.
Matt Olney
analystLet's return to what we were saying about hedges on the energy side. After we get past that 12-month window, could you help us understand — or provide a bit more clarity on — the amount by which that hedged output falls?
Marc Maun
executiveSure, Marc here; roughly — among our customer base, around 1/3 of the customers weighted toward oil have over 50% of their average price — their portfolio hedged at an average price of $52 into — through 2021; and for gas it's somewhat bigger, closer to 36% hedged at an average price of $2.63. What I'd point out is that we continue to observe folks ramping up their hedging activity into 2021 given where prices sit now, particularly a couple of weeks ago when you were still looking at $40-plus oil in 2021. So our expectation is that hedge activity will begin rising during the latter half of this year and also into that 2021 year.
Stacy Kymes
executiveWhat's more, during the past 14 days or so, we've observed considerable hedging activity that these figures don't capture. As of 8:00 this morning, you're able to hedge 2021 at $33 per barrel, and 2022 at $36 per barrel; therefore, plenty of room remains to layer in hedges. Many of these firms will typically run rolling hedge programs of perhaps 18 months, along those lines. So my view is that the 2021 figure will keep getting better as the year goes on.
Marc Maun
executiveAlso, one more point worth making: with prices sitting where they are now, these businesses don't require a rebound to $50 — or even $40 — for their cash flow to improve substantially, particularly given that they're winding down their drilling operations. Should we get an uptick of just a couple of dollars, thanks to the operating expense leverage they have in conditions like these, their overall cash flow would rise dramatically, and the chance of losses tied to those specific loans in this portfolio would drop considerably. The reason is that they no longer bear the cost of drawing on existing production to fund CapEx. That picture would shift if drilling were to pick up. Yet as things stand right now, in the present environment, we don't expect any meaningful drilling activity.
Matt Olney
analystAll right, that's useful. Could you expand a bit on the counterparty exposure inside those hedges? Do these hedges clear through BOK, or is it another party? I'm just attempting to determine which entity sits on the losing side of that hedge?
Stacy Kymes
executiveSure, these are executed against the — many of them go through an exchange. As a result, you have the exchange counterparties, who hold post margin, and the credit risk associated with those exchanges is in fact quite minimal; a certain count of our hedges are executed with individual counterparties that carry high investment-grade ratings, though with quite small bilateral credit lines. Consequently, cash moves back and forth each day to square up whatever gaps arise between the credit line extended and price movements over that span of time; so a limited degree of counterparty exposure exists there, yet it remains quite minor right now, vastly, vastly unlike the situation during '08 and '09, when the bulk of such trading was executed with individual counterparties at credit limits far above those we rely on presently.
Gary Tenner
analystThere were two things I wanted to ask about. To start, regarding the retail commercial real estate book of roughly $775 million, you point to approximately $605 million of it on that slide covering COVID-19 effects. Could you walk us through perhaps which portions weren't put on that slide?
Marc Maun
executiveAll right, I'll have Stacy address the CRE side with you, though let me make one thing plain: on that COVID-19 slide, the retail involved sits within our C&I portfolio. It does not belong to the CRE retail portfolio.
Gary Tenner
analystDoes that figure come from the retail trade portfolio?
Stacy Kymes
executiveYes, that's right.
Marc Maun
executiveYeah.
Stacy Kymes
executiveThe retail CRE portfolio, meanwhile, sits in a really solid spot. I referenced earlier that average debt service coverage figure for that portfolio at the close of 2019. What I didn't say is that the 1.5x came from a stress scenario we run — here, a 6.25 rate over a 25-year AM. So the real debt service is going to look considerably stronger than that. Still, we examine it that way — aiming to smooth out rates and similar factors when we review that portfolio.
Gary Tenner
analystAlright, then. You brought up that the retail portion comes out of the wholesale/retail trade portfolio, so within that $2 billion segment, does the remaining $1.4 billion consist entirely of wholesale trade? Or do other retail pieces sit inside it as well?
Marc Maun
executiveNo — that $605 million represents the entire size of our retail exposure. Everything else falls on the wholesale side.
Gary Tenner
analystAll right. Then let me pose just one additional question regarding energy. I'm attempting to reconcile what happened in the E&P sector during the prior year, when crude traded above $50 for most of that period, yet bankruptcy filings continued to climb. So as we move into this year and beyond, even though part of the production is hedged at $52, clearly the portion that isn't hedged lowers the weighted average price per barrel producers receive. And if you hedge going forward at $30 or in the low 30s across the coming couple of years, that appears as though it would create even greater exposure for reserve-based producers or borrowers compared with the commodity price we observed last year. Could you help me reconcile that once more?
Stacy Kymes
executiveSure. What I believe you're overlooking is total debt. The key factor behind the rising bankruptcies is mostly unsecured capital market style debt that borrowers are unable to roll or refinance, and much less so the senior secured lending tied to the revolver. We have borrowers either in or considering bankruptcy whom we would anticipate being able to keep on accrual, since the problem isn't the bank debt — the problem is the unsecured bond debt, or obligations outside the bank facility, that they cannot refinance or repay. As a result, a restructuring occurs in which those bondholders become the equity holders, and a bankruptcy process is required to accomplish that. That, I believe, is the connection that your analysis isn't capturing as much as it likely ought to.
Steven Nell
executiveAppreciate it. Once more, I want to thank all of you for being with us on this call. Should anything else come to mind, feel free to reach me by phone at (918) 595 to 3030, or send a message to ir@bokf.com. Enjoy the rest of your day. Thanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. That wraps up what we had scheduled for everyone today. You’re welcome to hang up now, and we appreciate your joining us.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete BOK Financial Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to BOK Financial Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in BOK Financial Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.