BOK Financial Corporation (BOKF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 22, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Steven Nell
executiveHello, everyone, and thank you for being with us today. First up, our CEO, Steve Bradshaw, is going to give some opening remarks. After that, Stacy Kymes, who serves as Executive Vice President of Corporate Banking, will walk through our loan portfolio, with specifics on the energy, healthcare and commercial real estate portfolios. Our Chief Credit Officer, Marc Maun, will then discuss credit metrics. Next, Scott Grauer, Executive Vice President of Wealth Management, will talk about the fantastic results his team delivered this quarter. Finally, I'll go over second quarter details covering net interest income, net interest margin, additional fee revenues, expenses, and where our overall balance sheet stands from a liquidity and capital standpoint. On top of that, I'll share a few thoughts about what we expect in future quarters. You can find PDFs of the slide presentation and the second quarter press release on our website at bokf.com. Please see the disclaimers on Slide 2, which apply to any forward-looking statements we make on this call. With that, I'll hand the call over to Steve Bradshaw.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveHello, everyone, and thank you for being here as we go over what we achieved financially in the second quarter of 2020. It's our pleasure to share that BOK Financial delivered a record quarter when it comes to pre-provision net revenue, and that happened even with all the economic difficulties created by COVID-19. On Slide 4, you can see that net income for the second quarter reached $64.7 million, which works out to $0.92 for each diluted share — a 4% gain over the prior quarter, and that's with yet another quarter of heightened provision for credit losses. What really lifted earnings this quarter was $214 million coming in from our fee businesses, since our Wealth Management and Mortgage teams kept up their momentum and delivered record quarters for the company at the same time. When we look at pre-provision net revenue, the big advantage we create for our company through our longstanding dedication to balanced revenue and the wide range of our business capabilities becomes very clear. Pre-provision net revenue hit $216 million this quarter — the greatest amount ever recorded in our company's history. Given the conditions we're facing right now, that's genuinely an outstanding result, and every one of our talented, high-performing employees ought to feel proud of it. Fee and commission revenue climbed close to 11% versus the prior quarter, and an astonishing 21% on a quarterly year-over-year basis, driven by continued strong Wealth Management and Mortgage revenues. Fee revenue now makes up 43% of total revenue, compared with 38% in the same quarter one year earlier; this again shows an important quality that sets BOK Financial apart. For a long time we've maintained a diverse revenue mix that acts as an earnings buffer and helps during economic downturns, thanks to the countercyclical nature of certain fee revenue streams. We've stayed prudent with expense management, with an efficiency ratio under 60% for the quarter, even as the revenue mix shifted toward fee income. It's also worth noting that we made a $3 million unplanned contribution to our foundation, which included an extra $1 million during the second quarter to help people in our communities dealing with food insecurity, while also creating much needed jobs for restaurant workers who had been displaced. Our loan loss provision came to $135 million this quarter, driven by a mix of changes in our reasonable and supportable forecast of macroeconomic variables, plus some credit migration that Marc will go through in greater detail shortly. Even as we build a reserve once more this quarter, we think the material reserve build should be mostly finished, assuming our economic forecast stays on track moving forward. Net interest revenue rose $16.7 million to $278 million this quarter. Even with the continuing effect of the 150 basis points of emergency rate cuts in March, our capacity to lower deposit costs and the relatively elevated nature of LIBOR early in the quarter helped us keep a large portion of our margin. Steven will walk through the underlying components in greater detail later on the call. Now to Slide 5. Average loans grew $2.2 billion to surpass $24 billion this quarter. While that was positive for the company overall, $1.7 billion of it came from the small business administration's PPP program. Deposits averaged almost 16% higher than the prior quarter and close to 30% above the year-earlier quarter. This robust expansion, in our view, stems from ongoing momentum in our deposit gathering efforts, together with PPP loan deposits and government stimulus payments. Despite that considerable deposit increase, we managed to reduce total interest-bearing costs from 98 basis points in the last quarter to 34 basis points in this one, since we could adjust the rates we pay on interest-bearing deposits thanks to our proactive management amid an unprecedented Fed move during the first quarter. Assets under management or in custody rose almost 5% this quarter. Given strong sales efforts and gains in the equity markets over the quarter, we think part of the asset growth reflects market volatility, which has truly highlighted the value a professional adviser delivers to individual and corporate investors in periods of extreme uncertainty. I'll offer further perspective on the results when the prepared remarks conclude, but now Stacy Kymes will go through the loan portfolio in greater detail. I'll hand the call to Stacy.
Stacy Kymes
executiveAppreciate it, Steve. If you look at Slide 7, you'll see that loans at period end came to $24.2 billion, which is an increase of $1.7 billion for the quarter. Our portfolio got a $2.1 billion boost from PPP loans, so growth did occur in certain specialty areas we have. Once you strip out PPP, though, the portfolio actually shrank this quarter because of broad paydowns throughout our core commercial and industrial loan book. Part of that reflected repayment of the more defensive draws taken in the first quarter, while another part stemmed from the natural drop in economic activity. Energy loans shrank 3.3% over the quarter, since commodity prices made it hard to source new deals in today's environment. At this point in the cycle, energy borrowers are paying down debt in order to lower leverage. Energy commitments dropped $360 million versus the first quarter of 2020 and $630 million since the year ended. Those commitment reductions come directly from the redetermination of borrowing bases that took place in the second quarter. Even with all of this, we're still open for business and we keep supporting our customers in the energy industry. Lending to energy sits at the core of our DNA, and what we've been through in past commodity cycles shows this can be a profitable business when you approach it consistently and with discipline. This business goes beyond lending activities, which the record quarter we posted of $5.4 million in energy derivatives revenue demonstrates, as customers keep managing their commodity risks aggressively; taking that long-term view has worked in our favor. And as of today, we're well positioned in the industry, with a complete service offering, world-class energy bankers, and an enviable customer base; over the next several years, we expect great opportunity for our energy franchise, since other banks have retransformed this space entirely or in part. Marc will go over the credit specifics of the energy portfolio in a moment. But as we've said previously, our view is that how long the oil price decline lasts matters more for performance than what the price levels are. Balances in our healthcare sector loans rose $124 million to $3.3 billion, or nearly 4%, for the quarter, mainly because balances grew from our hospital system clients, who show a strong credit profile. This client segment has taken a hit from deferrals of elective procedures and from the need to build up inventory of supplies and protective equipment. That being said, the CARES Act contains multiple revenue enhancement measures for hospitals and skilled nursing facilities alike as they manage through the risk of the virus. Multiple clients have benefited from this, and it should help mitigate the credit risk in the healthcare portfolio. Though it's still early, so far we haven't realized any material credit migration or deterioration in this portfolio. Commercial real estate loan balances rose 2.3% versus the prior quarter, mostly because of the lowest level of paydowns we've seen in many years, driven by friction in the permanent financing market. PPP loans certainly contributed to the pickup in overall loan growth for the second quarter, but how much lending grows over the remainder of the year will mostly come down to how quickly and in what form the wider economy recovers. I'll hand things over to Marc Maun, who will walk us through our credit metrics. Marc?
Marc Maun
executiveThanks, Stacy. Moving on to Slide 9. Once more, we have put together a set of loan categories that we view as having greater susceptibility to the pandemic's economic effects. As you can see, our exposure to entertainment and recreation, which takes in gaming within our Native American specialty portfolio that carries a strong credit profile, retail, hotels, churches, airline travel and higher education that rely on large social gatherings to stay profitable at present, accounts for under 7% of our overall portfolio. This loan group is very well diversified, consisting of more than 550 loans, with an average size below $3 million. A number of these borrowers have taken part in the Paycheck Protection Program, which has delivered a certain amount of relief. Clearly, we will keep watching these exposures closely over the months ahead. Credit quality has stayed manageable, and — yet there has been some movement in nonaccrual and potential problem loans because of the present economic climate, mainly within our energy portfolio, which resulted in a bigger provision for credit losses in the second quarter. Slide 10 lays out our provision actions for this quarter. The total provision came to $135.3 million, with $138.8 million tied to lending activities. Shifts in our reasonable and supportable forecast of macroeconomic variables, chiefly from the expected impact of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, along with another assumption, necessitated a provision of $54.6 million. All other changes came to $84.2 million, which consisted of $14.4 million mainly from greater specific impairment of energy loans and portfolio changes of $55.7 million chiefly from shifts in risk grades tied to energy loans. The $84.2 million was partly offset by the effect of a decline in loan balances and net charge-offs of $14.1 million, which brought net portfolio change adjustments to $70.1 million for the quarter. Provision tied to lending activities was partly offset by a $3.6 million reduction in the accrual for expected credit losses from mortgage banking activities. Our base case reasonable and supportable forecast incorporates an 18% rise in GDP and an 8.4% civilian unemployment rate in the third quarter of 2020, as adjusted for the effect of government stimulus programs. Our forward 12-month forecast through the second quarter of 2021 presumes a 5% rise in GDP and an 8.5% civilian unemployment rate. WTI oil prices are expected to broadly track the NYMEX forward curve that stood at the end of June 2020, $38.99 per barrel for delivery in the third quarter of 2020 and climbing to $40.13 per barrel in the second quarter of 2021. Our downside, reasonable and supportable forecast captures a more severe and extended disruption in economic activity than the base case. It incorporates a 6% rise in GDP and a 9.7% adjusted civilian unemployment rate in the third quarter of 2020. Our forward 12-month forecast through the second quarter of '21 presumes a 6% rise in GDP and a 10% adjusted civilian unemployment rate. For WTI crude, the forecast range is $33.99 a barrel for Q3 2020 delivery up to $34.63 a barrel for Q2 2021 delivery. Let's move to Slide 11. Non-accruing loans rose $92 million during the quarter, driven mostly by a $67 million climb in non-accruing energy loans along with a $13 million rise in non-accruing services loans. As we've noted previously, our view is that the danger of migration into potential problem or non-accruing status is greater than the danger of loss within the energy portfolio. Potential problem loans came to $626 million at quarter end, compared with $293 million on March 31. That increase stems largely from the energy portfolio, since the recent drop in oil prices, combined with a capital markets environment that forced certain customers to address their liquidity needs, pressured some energy borrowers. Commodity prices, oil especially, stayed depressed through the bulk of the second quarter, though they bounced back somewhat during June. As we mentioned last quarter, had prices continued to be depressed as we moved through the spring borrowing base redetermination process, we would have expected ongoing credit quality problems in this portfolio. We saw that migration materialize as we finished most of our redeterminations across April and May. Prices have since gotten better, yet they remain fragile and tightly linked to the ongoing economic recovery. If current price levels persist into the fall, we would expect positive credit quality migration in this portfolio. The allowance for loan losses came to $436 million, or 1.8% of outstanding loans, as of June 30, 2020. Leaving out PPP loans, the allowance for loan losses stood at 1.97% of outstanding loans, and the combined allowance for loan losses plus the accrual for off-balance sheet credit risk from unfunded loan commitments was 2.12%. Fiscal stimulus has helped credit quality through PPP loans, SBA support and other CARES Act programs; even so, we got a number of deferral or forbearance requests early in the quarter, but very few new ones after April. Every request was reviewed on a case-by-case basis, and we have granted $1.2 billion in forbearance requests from customers as of June 30, including $704 million, or about 5%, of commercial loans, mainly in the small business and healthcare portfolios, $398 million, or roughly 9%, of commercial real estate loans, and $143 million, or roughly 4%, of loans to individuals. We are only now beginning to hit the expiration of the first 90 days. And so far, over 60% of the deferred loans are returning to regular payments. While retail commercial real estate does make up over 40% of our commercial real estate deferrals, we have not seen any material credit issues to date, largely because of stimulus programs. Clearly, the retail portion of this portfolio is the most exposed to sustained stay-at-home and shelter-in-place directives. As with oil, the loss content in retail will be closely correlated with how long the various governmental orders last and how consumer behavior adjusts once those orders are lifted. Although office and multifamily properties are going to feel some effects here, we think our geographic footprint is going to be a benefit to us in those segments over the long run, given the strong in-migration we've seen over time. How quality migration plays out in commercial real estate in the near term is going to hinge on economic recovery as well as what fiscal stimulus does. Now I'll hand the call over to Scott Grauer, who will go over the Wealth Management fee revenue contribution for this quarter. Scott?
Scott Grauer
executiveThanks, Marc. Moving to Slide 13, you can see the key points from Wealth Management's financial results for the second quarter. Our investors are aware that this is a business BOK Financial has dedicated itself to for more than 100 years, offering a wide array of products and services — institutional and personal wealth management, trust services for individuals as well as corporations and institutions, private banking services, retail and institutional brokerage, investment banking, and financial risk management, plus several others. Revenue in Wealth Management rose 14%, reaching $134 million versus the prior quarter, and climbed 18% on a quarterly year-over-year basis. That figure encompasses the fee income lines investors observe in our corporate income statement — brokerage and trading and fiduciary asset management — while also capturing net interest income from loans and deposits within our private wealth group and our trading portfolio. BOKF has kept growing its hedging pipeline risk and supplying liquidity to mortgage originators, reinforcing its standing as a market leader and market maker in that area. Broadly speaking, mortgage issuance grew, propelled by reduced rates as the Fed intervened to deliver market stability, and GSE policy changes concerning forbearance opened a chance for BOKF to supply more liquidity to the housing market amid a stretch of record volumes, lifting the trading portfolio 27% and producing a record quarter for our trading and derivatives business. Total brokerage and trading revenues produced within the Wealth Management division rose 61% compared with the same quarter one year earlier, surpassing $54 million. Most of that came from mortgage-related trading activity, with second quarter total MBS, TBA trading-related revenue hitting $48 million. That marks a 21% gain over the linked quarter and a 220% gain versus the same quarter one year ago. Net direct contribution — operating income before corporate allocations — increased a robust 37% for the quarter; this stemmed from prudent expense management, since total operating expenses for the division before corporate allocations rose only 3% versus last quarter and 16% versus the same quarter one year ago, even with the exceptional revenue growth; that produced considerable and meaningful earnings leverage for the division. Turning to net interest revenue, Wealth Management loans increased modestly while deposits grew 10%, respectively, this quarter — evidence of our capacity to add value to the company in numerous ways. In fact, Wealth Management deposits now make up 26% of total company deposits, as our efforts in that area have grown relative to the rest of the company. Possibly most significant, the groundwork is laid for further growth in the Wealth Management division. Near term, reduced interest rates and the resulting stimulation of the mortgage industry point toward continued performance in our brokerage and trading segment. Looking further out, one of the strongest demographic forces affecting the wealth management business is the baby boomers leaving the workforce and close to $6 trillion in wealth passing to their heirs; with a broad range of offerings and services aimed at what the next generation requires, we think our position sets us up to gain. At this point I'll hand things over to Steven Nell. Steve?
Steven Nell
executiveAppreciate that, Scott. As we point out on Slide 15, net interest income came in at $278 million for the quarter, which is an increase of almost $17 million versus the first quarter, although $13.6 million of that figure stemmed from PPP loan activity. Net interest margin stood at 2.83% versus 2.80% in the prior quarter. A dramatic drop in deposit costs of 64 basis points, falling all the way to 34 basis points, LIBOR spreads that stayed elevated during the early part of the second quarter, and the strategic positioning of our balance sheet all worked together to ease margin pressure during this quarter. If you set aside the effect of PPP loans, net interest margin came to 2.82% versus 2.80% in the prior quarter, which speaks to the actions we have taken. Average earning assets rose $1.9 billion from the prior quarter, while average loan balances grew $2.2 billion, mostly driven by the wave of PPP loans received in the second quarter. Available-for-sale securities rose $816 million as we repositioned our balance sheet for today's rate environment. Fair value option securities, which we hold as an economic hedge against changes in the fair value of mortgage servicing rights, fell $1 billion. On top of that, receivables from unsettled security sales, chiefly tied to our mortgage-backed trading operations, grew $1.6 billion. The expansion in average earning assets and noninterest-bearing receivables was mostly funded by a $2.2 billion rise in interest-bearing deposits. Over $2 billion of PPP loans still outstanding when the quarter closed were funded through the Federal Reserve's PPP liquidity facility; turning to Slide 16, fees and commissions totaled $213.7 million, which is up almost 11% from the prior quarter and up 21% on a quarterly year-over-year basis. The main driver was strength in our brokerage and trading business that Scott just walked through, along with a record quarter from our mortgage banking activities. Mortgage banking experienced a major jump in production revenue this quarter, rising $17.6 million, or over 81%, versus the prior quarter and nearly 230% versus the same quarter last year. Even though volumes climbed, what powered this result was a 159 basis point increase in gain on sale margins relative to the prior quarter. At present, the industry faces capacity constraints, which is softening pricing competition and lifting margins. Refinances made up 71% of total originations, since low rates fueled a large portion of the demand. Although we view the second quarter as peak seasonality for this area, we absolutely expect to capture our share of purchase and refinance activity for as long as these opportunities last. Service charges fell $4.1 million, mainly because of shelter-in-place effects, combined with voluntary fee waivers we extended to our customers as a courtesy during the pandemic. One more bright spot this quarter involves the hedging of our mortgage servicing rights. During this quarter, net MSR activity produced a $9.3 million benefit, driven by favorable net hedging results, slight assumption revisions, and an economic gain tied to the sale of roughly $1.6 billion in unpaid principal balance of Ginnie Mae servicing rights outside our footprint — a remarkable result given that rates continue to be volatile. A number of our fee-based operations are plainly powering the company's broader success, which again underscores how much our revenue diversity matters. Moving to Slide 17. Total operating expenses rose $26.8 million, reaching $295.4 million. Personnel expense grew $20 million this quarter, mostly because incentive-based compensation climbed $22.3 million, divided between cash-based and deferred compensation. The $11 million cash-based piece came from higher trading and mortgage activity, while $11.6 million of deferred compensation was tied largely to the broader equity market recovery. That deferred compensation expense recognition is offset by an $11.7 million gain on the associated deferred compensation assets, so there was no earnings impact this quarter. Other elements included a $1.5 million rise in regular compensation and a $2.1 million seasonal payroll tax reduction in employee benefits. Non-personnel expense was up $6.7 million this quarter. Mortgage banking costs rose $5.1 million, with $1.7 million attributable to MSR amortization expense and $2.8 million from shifts in our portfolio and loan counts, delinquency levels, plus additional accruals connected to loan losses and forbearance. Occupancy and equipment expense grew $4.6 million because of impairment on 2 leases. We also contributed $3 million to the BOKF Foundation as a charitable donation in the second quarter. Partially offsetting these increases was a $4.3 million drop in business promotion costs, mostly from lower travel and entertainment spending due to the pandemic. Our liquidity position is still very strong, thanks to the extraordinary inflow of deposit balances. Our loan-to-deposit ratio now stands at 71%, versus 77% at March 31, giving us substantial on-balance sheet liquidity to serve future customer needs. On top of that, we hold $14.6 billion of secured borrowing capacity and more than $6.5 billion of unsecured and contingent liquidity capacities to back the company's liquidity needs. Our capital levels are still strong, with a common equity Tier 1 ratio of 11.4%, better than 10.98% last quarter, comfortably above our internal operating range minimums, and a full 440 basis points higher than regulatory minimums. Our internal stress tests have made us confident in supporting our customer base and maintaining our current dividend level. While we have no set plans or commitments to repurchase stock in the near term, our capital levels would permit that opportunity. At present, we see no need to bolster holding company or bank level capital through any capital raising actions. Because the pandemic's seriousness and how long it will last remain unclear, along with the effects on the wider economy, giving the kind of precise outlook we provided when conditions were more typical is hard, yet I'll offer several remarks regarding Slide 19 that could be useful. For the foreseeable future, soft loan growth is what we anticipate; at today's prices, most energy deals probably won't get completed; because of the pandemic, many healthcare opportunities will stay paused; and in our CRE and C&I portfolios, there will be minimal activity; a very small volume of mortgage loans will keep being originated by us, with only a limited portion landing in our permanent portfolio. During the second quarter, our available-for-sale securities portfolio, composed mostly of agency mortgage-backed securities, produced a yield of 2.29%. With rates staying low for a sustained period, prepayments might hit more than $700 million each quarter. At prevailing rates of roughly 90 to 100 basis points, we anticipate reinvesting those cash flows. As we mentioned, we achieved success in the second quarter by pushing deposit costs down considerably; in our view, some additional room exists for lowering deposit costs, though they probably won't fall much under 30 basis points, a figure similar to the low point for our deposit cost during the prior period of rates near 0. Pressure on asset yields combined with limited ability to cut deposit costs will create some strain on net interest margin in the upcoming quarter. Some offsetting effect on the overall earnings pressure felt in our spread businesses should keep coming from our varied portfolio of fee revenue streams; elevated levels of brokerage and trading activity ought to persist, we believe, thanks to our products and capabilities in mortgage-backed trading. Solid performance should continue in our mortgage origination and servicing business, though it will probably ease somewhat as refinance opportunities diminish and seasonal patterns cause a slowdown later in the year. Our careful method of managing personnel and non-personnel expenses will carry on; reducing staff or eliminating current capabilities or products is not something we intend to do. As BOKF and nearly all other banks have demonstrated, substantial loan loss reserve building occurred in the first and second quarters. Even though a great deal of uncertainty persists in the economic climate, we think the period of building loan loss reserves is mostly over. As I said a moment ago, our capital strength is something we feel good about. The present amount of quarterly cash dividends will be kept, and as the year goes on, we'll assess share buybacks. Now, for closing commentary, I'll hand the call back to Steve Bradshaw.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveThank you, Steven. What we achieved during this quarter stems from a strategy built for the long haul — one that serves customers comprehensively while giving shareholders the advantages of steadier profits and stronger protection against risk, since none of our lending operations carry any urge to chase expansion by taking on added exposure. Anyone who has followed us for some time will recall the prior period of rate movements, when earnings potential tied to net interest revenue shrank at the majority of financial companies. Back then, just as now, BOK Financial came out ahead thanks to a distinctive model weighted heavily toward fees, which delivered value to our shareholders throughout that difficult stretch. No 2 slumps look alike, yet a number of unmistakable bright spots are proving themselves at BOKF right now — specifically within our Wealth Management arm and our Mortgage arm. Even so, the biggest prospect ahead involves a secure return to completely normal economic conditions nationwide. In the end, we prosper whenever our customers and the places we serve prosper. Because of that, we keep our outlook measured while the route toward a sounder broader economy becomes clearer. Before then, we will keep doing all we can to support our customers, no matter how quickly or in what form the economy rebounds. Achieving more together is something you'll frequently hear around BOKF, and nowhere is that truer than right now. Once COVID-19 started putting our communities at risk, we joined forces, making hard choices to lower infection danger for our customers and for one another. Remaining connected while physically apart brings its own difficulties, but we keep gaining insight from working virtually, and we are coordinating and defining how we'll handle parts of our operations moving ahead. The resilience I witness among people throughout our company makes me just as proud as the financial results it is producing. Our approach and our workforce at BOK Financial are plainly unlike those of similarly sized competitors. And I believe our capacity to go head-to-head successfully with the large national banks and investment houses plays a major role in what we generated this quarter. With that, we're happy to answer your questions. Operator?
Ken Zerbe
analystGreat. Maybe I'll just ask something fairly wide-ranging regarding energy. I recall that at the outset of the pandemic, your team provided some careful remarks essentially noting that the length and scale of the pandemic might result in fairly significant losses should it persist. What's the situation now — it has been 3 months since the previous earnings report — how have energy sector trends actually come in relative to what you had expected when this cycle kicked off?
Stacy Kymes
executiveSure. Ken, it's Stacy here. From where we sit, the bounce back came faster than we'd have expected at the start. Neither the market nor we, I believe, predicted how much production would be shut in and what else would occur to reduce supply under these conditions. Once prices dropped so sharply, the response from the industry was extremely robust. The industry has a long history of healing itself, as we often mention; typically it takes 6 months to 18 months before a fresh equilibrium price emerges; yet the price rebound witnessed over roughly the last 30 days, especially for oil, has truly been heartening. And at these price levels, we definitely feel far, far more comfortable regarding potential future losses than was previously the case. Using the strip average rather than spot, on that strip average, we sit about $12 per barrel above where things stood at our earnings call during the prior quarter, which matters considerably for our outlook and for what we regard as possible loss content there. I believe Marc referenced in his remarks that should prices remain at this point, we'd anticipate favorable credit results from a credit migration standpoint as we progress through the third and fourth quarters. Keep in mind that we don't lower ratings across the entire portfolio. When prices shift, that happens only as we reach them via the semiannual redetermination process. And those prices weren't good ones during the redetermination. By the same token, though, we don't raise ratings for the whole portfolio when a price rebound occurs. So when we reach those credits late in the third quarter and into the fourth, provided prices stay at these levels, we'd anticipate seeing quite favorable migration within that book.
Ken Zerbe
analystOkay, that's great, perfect. Then moving to my second question. Your press release contained a statement indicating that, out of the deposit growth you saw, $2.7 billion came from CARES Act funding. My understanding is that you had $2.1 billion in PPP loans. Could you clarify this for us? Did you tap the federal government's facility in order to fund those PPP loans? Is that included in the deposit growth?
Steven Nell
executiveKen, it's Steven here. No — what we saw was simply an inflow coming from PPP and also from every other type of CARES Act initiative, and those together produced that deposit growth. So PPP wasn't the only source; additional CARES Act stimulus also made its way into our customers' accounts. We therefore went back and attempted to determine what portion of our $4.5 billion in deposit growth could be tied to CARES or to other stimulus programs, and we arrived at approximately $2.7 billion of that growth originating from those areas. Everything else was simply ordinary growth coming from our core customer base.
Ken Zerbe
analystGot it. Alright, so suppose those PPP loans get repaid — or, to put it another way, if both PPP and the other loans are repaid — then it's possible that $2.7 billion in debt funding disappears, or the deposits disappear; yet after that, you're indicating that the remaining amount, roughly $2 billion in deposits, consists simply of core deposits that could prove more durable as time goes on?
Steven Nell
executiveYes, that's right.
Gary Tenner
analystMarc, thanks for that detail regarding the economic outlook. In the slide deck, I believe you mentioned the build — the build rests on 3 scenarios that you also pointed out. Am I right to assume the third one is an even more adverse scenario? Or would it be some sort of upward scenario? And could you perhaps share how the 3 scenarios were weighted in your analysis?
Marc Maun
executiveCertainly. The base case scenarios we pointed to there received a 50% weighting from us. An upside case and a downside case are also run by us, with each of those getting 25%. That mirrors the weighting we applied back in the first quarter. Once again, the economy is shifting so fast and transforming so quickly that we believed an even base weighting across those scenarios — 50%, 25%, 25% — helped capture that potential volatility.
Gary Tenner
analystAll right. So when you consider how the fee component of the PPP loans gets recognized, plus what's baked into net interest revenue for this quarter from that, did you simply use a 24-month average life as the basis? Or did you make additional changes assuming a shorter average life when it comes to recognizing revenue?
Steven Nell
executiveYeah, Steve here. That's right. We estimated a benefit of roughly $13.6 million, as I recall, to our net interest income from PPP — split — but approximately $10 million or slightly above that came from the fee recognition portion, with another $3 million or so purely from net interest income on PPP loans. Our weighting assumes those loans start being forgiven more during the fourth quarter than in any other period. So you'll see some extra in the third, but a larger amount in the fourth quarter, since we expect many of them will start reaching forgiveness status; and after that a tail will remain as those loans stay on the books for 24 months. That's how we've staged it.
Brady Gailey
analystLet me begin with fee income. Another fresh high this quarter, I mean, coming on the heels of another record in the prior quarter. Yet from what you've said, it seems brokerage and trading might hold around this level, mortgage may decline somewhat, but fee income, as it sounds, is going to stay near this elevated point through the remainder of the year. Is that how we should be thinking about the strength in fee income?
Steven Nell
executiveSo perhaps you handle the brokerage and trading part, and then I'll offer a few remarks regarding mortgage.
Scott Grauer
executiveAll right, absolutely. This is Scott Grauer speaking. When it comes to Wealth Management, there are several factors behind our confidence in the momentum, and that goes beyond just the mortgage-backed securities volume and activity, which clearly was very strong in Q1 and Q2. We expect to keep up those robust levels, both in our TBA hedging activity and in the overall volumes within the mortgage-backed securities product mix. That said, we have solid momentum and have delivered strong results in our financial institutions group, which provides taxable and tax-exempt securities across the range to downstream banks, as those banks seek to position their securities portfolios amid somewhat waning loan demand. So that activity has been quite strong. When it comes to our corporate trust business and our retirement plans business, we have observed very good activity and fairly healthy pipelines. In fact, in our defaulted debt space and our corporate trust piece, where we have typically dealt with 1 or 2 well-known names, we currently have 8 defaulted debt assignments. So that gives us good opportunities. Our investment banking activity in Q2 was very strong, both in the municipal piece — financial advisory and underwriting — and in our corporate deals, where we saw a surprisingly high number of capital market transactions for energy names. So if you look at overall trust fees, we truly moved from a period of decline, if you looked from the end of '19 through the end of March. And then into April, the trust fee revenue rate had dropped roughly 17% from peak to bottom, and we have now recovered that and are back at year-end trust fees overall starting in June. So we feel we have pretty good activity and a reason to be confident about sustaining the momentum.
Steven Nell
executiveAlright Brady, regarding the mortgage business, we've now seen 2 consecutive quarters where production volume exceeded $1 billion. What I believe set this quarter apart was the margin — gain on sale margin rose from 206% in Q1 to 365% in Q2. That's really what accounted for most of the lift in mortgage revenue. And I expect we'll remain strong in that area throughout the year. That said, I do believe seasonality plays a role here, especially considering Q2 was 71% refi. Those refinances won't continue indefinitely. I think that will taper off at some point. So while I expect mortgage to remain solid, I'm hesitant to claim it will reach the same level as Q2, given those unusually high margins. The other fee businesses are performing fairly well. Take the TransFund network and its activity — though there is some weakness in consumer service charges. You're seeing that industry-wide because of the pandemic, and we'll find out whether it bounces back over time. Still, our fee businesses should be a fairly substantial contributor, in my view, over the coming several quarters compared to our other operations in the bank.
Brady Gailey
analystOkay, that's useful. And finally, from my side, when you examine potential problem loans, they dropped by a fairly significant amount this quarter. My understanding is they moved from approximately $300 million up to around $600 million. I believe you mentioned energy as a major factor. Is there anything else you can share about why potential problem loans rose during the quarter?
Marc Maun
executiveThis is Marc. So far, energy has truly been the primary cause. The borrowing base redetermination period fell mainly during April and May, right when oil prices hit their lowest point. That is what drove the shift in those potential problem loans, and our hope is — as Stacy said before — if prices remain at current levels, they will move in a positive direction as we head into the fall. Up to now, we haven't observed any meaningful migration in other portfolios. Nothing has struck us as unusually large compared to a typical cycle; we are keeping an eye on our portfolios everywhere, have conducted many more deep dives into segments we view as higher risk, and we are concentrating on those. So we will watch them carefully and assess them going forward, but no substantial migration has appeared as of yet.
Stacy Kymes
executiveAlso, my expectation is that this will get better in a way similar to how we've watched commodity prices recover. Beyond that, within that bucket we label potential problem loans, that's where we've placed those revolving credits and energy names that have been through bankruptcy — usually the revolver itself is fine, yet what's getting cleaned up and turned into equity is the sub-debt, or the unsecured debt from the capital markets; we've relied on that potential problem loan bucket to essentially hold those while that process plays out. So once they start to come out of it, you could see some favorable credit migration emerging from that angle too.
Brandon King
analystBrandon King here, filling in for Jennifer. I saw that churches and colleges show up in your impact areas table, so I was hoping you could give some color on what trends you're seeing in those portfolios.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveOn those portfolios, to this point we have not encountered anything meaningful on the college and university side. Obviously it's summertime right now, and we're watching to see what those schools decide about reopening and getting students back on campus. In our conversations with them, we believe those loans look fine as of today, though we are keeping a close eye on them. Turning to churches, that's a wide-ranging portfolio made up of many smaller loans, and we have run into trouble with 2 or 3 of them. Still, on the whole, no migration has shown up so far. That said, it's a far broader base. You won't find sizable large loans in there; the loans are generally quite small, so we're fairly at ease that the risk tied to that portfolio is something we can handle.
Brandon King
analystAll right. On top of that, when it comes to those impact areas, where are you noticing the greatest strain? Which ones seem to have the least strain?
Steve Bradshaw
executiveLet me narrow it down a bit — the casino segment is likely where we're seeing the least pressure. Nearly all of those are native American and tribal casinos, exclusively. Around 70% of what we have outstanding is backed by cash that's on hand either at the casino locations or with the tribes. So even though they were fully closed for a couple of months, they're beginning to open back up; given the tribes' liquidity and similar factors, we're feeling fairly at ease. There were hardly any PPP loan applications tied to the casinos, or loan deferrals tied to the casinos. So that's likely held up well. We have a modest hotel portfolio that came to us through our CoBiz acquisition, since that's not something we go after or have ever gone after in an active way; that portfolio is fairly small, but among the loans listed on that slide, it's likely to be the one facing the most difficulty.
Jon Arfstrom
analystI've got a few cleanup and follow-up questions, I suppose. Regarding the energy NPLs, Stacy or Marc, could you describe what drove the increase? It might be clear already, but help us understand what's behind it.
Marc Maun
executiveSure, here's what happens — let me frame it that way. The rise in non-performings came mainly out of the borrowing base redetermination process that took place during April and May; our price deck, as Stacy pointed out, was $10 to $12 lower. Given that, when discounting back to cash flow, the collateral support level fell below what the loan level was in certain cases, and would need to be — a shortfall requiring attention. The collateral base's overall quality was sufficiently strong that we remained covered and anticipated no meaningful losses, yet it did generate a stressed situation for those borrowers. That, in turn, produced a higher level of nonperforming loans. Now, looking ahead — the wonderful aspect of the energy lending portfolio is that whenever we resize our loans, we reassess them on a 6-month cycle using the prevailing price deck. So were we to examine these loans during the fall, we expect they'll migrate in a more positive direction, since price availability has risen considerably. I mean, it matters to point out that repayment doesn't depend on drilling; what we depend on is production from the existing borrowing base for the existing collateral set at the given price levels. Let me also mention one additional item. I believe it's valuable to make this clear: our portfolio holds a substantial amount of hedging. It remains quite robust. 77% of our oil commitments are hedged at greater than 50% at $52 for the rest of 2020 and 41% are hedged more than 50% at $52.20 in — throughout 2021; so the hedging profile of both our oil and gas portfolio is going to help sustain them through this process as the economy reopens and the price deck improves.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveSteve here, Jon. You can also observe that an allowance for energy is sitting there at 4.4% plus, which is significantly higher than where it stood at the peak of the prior cycle. Our thinking is that we're looking to tackle this right now in a proactive way through CECL, so you essentially have all of it reserved for. Whenever we examine those NPLs, each one gets assessed for impairment. Therefore, my sense is that we hold reserves for that; circumstances will keep being evaluated, yet we believe that portfolio is well reserved and adequately reserved as we go forward.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAlright, that's useful. It sort of leads into my next point, which has 2 parts. I attempted to insert "abate" into the loan loss provision line of my model, and it failed. So I could use some clarification on what "abate" signifies regarding building reserves? That was supposed to be a joke, incidentally. But are you indicating that you do anticipate some reserve growth, while not expecting much in the way of losses? And clearly, you gave a fairly unambiguous signal about loan balances. So does the takeaway suggest a significant pullback in the provision going forward?
Marc Maun
executiveI would...
Steven Nell
executivePlease continue, Marc.
Marc Maun
executiveAll right. I'm not going to claim a significant pullback is coming. What I'd put forward is this: with CECL structured so that reserves get built sooner within the cycle, the economic projections released, combined with how we've assessed our loan book, have produced a fairly substantial reserve build up to now. Should our base case projection materialize, no further reserve build would be required on our part. That isn't to say we'd begin trimming it, unless credit quality improved or we stopped seeing the kind of credit deterioration that could come along if — it depends on how the economy unfolds. Our energy portfolio is something we feel quite positive about. Stimulus measures have continued to provide support for retail along with certain industries hit by COVID. And over the coming several quarters, we need to watch how those develop. That said, if things unfold perhaps into '21, you could see us get the chance to revisit that reserve level.
Stacy Kymes
executiveJon, what we mean by reserve build is when provisions exceed charge-offs. And of course, that hinges on the credit migration we observe as this virus plays out. The point we're trying to signal is that we believe the heavy provisioning and reserve accumulation from the first and second quarter is mostly in the rearview. And going forward, we'd react more to real charge-off levels rather than keep adding to reserves, assuming our economic forecast pans out.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAlright. Alright. I might circle back on that point, though the way I see it, since your potential issues could be declining, you aren't exactly sending a strong signal that there's much credit stress ahead. That said, I can revisit it later. My final question concerns the buyback. What would it take for you folks to have the — perhaps courage is too strong a term, but the comfort or the nerve to consider turning the repurchase program back on? That's everything I had.
Steven Nell
executiveSo, Steven here. What I'd probably say is this: we view the price as appealing, and we'll need to observe how the environment shapes up. Our capital is substantial. I'm genuinely pleased with where our capital stands. In fact, it increased during this quarter. So I'm not pledging anything specific about buying back or not buying back. Still, I do believe it's something we talk about opportunistically here at the bank, and we'll reach a decision. It isn't automatically ruled out, unlike what you've witnessed from plenty of banks announcing no further buybacks this year. I mean — we won't find ourselves in that spot; we'll assess it as the year progresses and, having done quite well, repurchase some shares. Just no hard commitment.
Timur Braziler
analystThis is Timur Braziler, actually, in for Jared. I want to piggyback on the credit question that the earlier caller raised. The allowance increase this quarter appeared highly sensitive to credit migration. Based on everything you've been saying, it sounds as though better pricing, combined with other factors, could produce some potentially significant favorable credit migration as soon as Q3. So what would stop that same degree of allowance sensitivity from reversing as migration gets better in upcoming quarters, the way the allowance grew when migration deteriorated in Q2?
Steve Bradshaw
executiveWell, I think that's just how CECL works. Our models incorporate a factor for risk grade migration, and we experienced that. As Marc and Stacy mentioned, the risk grade for those energy customers gets determined when we do our borrowing base determinations. We observed negative migration, and that flows into the probability of loss, or probability of default, calculations within our CECL model. So to your point, if those grades improve in Q3 or Q4 when we redo the borrowing bases — hopefully at these prices, which have recovered substantially in June — then we'd anticipate risk grade migration going the opposite way, which would obviously have a strongly favorable effect on our CECL calculation. The way that calculation works is that if we believe reserves should come down, we'll remove them — we'll take those reserves off. We simply need to see where things land in Q3 and Q4. But that's our understanding of how it functions.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right, that's useful. Then one final item from my side. The release includes a line about buying loans back from Ginnie Mae once specific delinquency thresholds are triggered. When those thresholds are hit, do you have to take them back out of those pools, or can you choose whether to do so? And any additional detail you could share on that would be great.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveSure. It isn't required — the choice is ours. However, you forfeit "sale," meaning essentially you hold the controls and are able to repurchase them. That puts them back onto your balance sheet, though it merely inflates the balance sheet. So in reality you aren't buying them, yet the loans come back and you get a matching liability on the opposite side. So it isn't required. Still, we did, historically, buy a number of those outright and picked up some benefit from doing so as time went on, but that's how the accounting treatment functions in this case.
Gary Tenner
analystOne fast follow-up from me; regarding the $1.6 billion in COVID-19 impact area loans shown on Slide 9, how much of that has gone into forbearance or modification since the pandemic began?
Marc Maun
executiveYes, Marc here. How much has been deferred? Our deferral figure actually comes to roughly 5.6% of all our loans. However, 70% of the loans appearing on that slide got PPP instead of requesting a deferral. So on that specific slide, we haven't seen any meaningful rise in deferrals compared with any other portion of the portfolio, since they were primary beneficiaries from PPP, which led a number of them to avoid taking deferrals.
Gary Tenner
analystAll right, that slide mentions PPP loans for those categories totaling $240 million, compared with $1.6 billion, so that works out to roughly 15%, correct?
Marc Maun
executiveYes, 15% of those loans get PPP, though 70% of customers received a PPP loan. In fact, looking at it by account rather than by dollars, it's higher, yes.
Steven Nell
executiveAll right. Since there are no more questions, we truly thank each of you for being with us today. Should anything else come up, don't hesitate to reach me by phone at (918) 595 to 3030, or send a message to ir@bokf.com. Have a wonderful day, everybody. Thanks.
Operator
operatorThanks so much, everyone, for being here. That wraps up what we had for today. At this point, feel free to drop off the call or sign out of the webcast, and we hope the rest of your day is great.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete BOK Financial Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to BOK Financial Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in BOK Financial Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.