BOK Financial Corporation (BOKF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 20, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Steven Nell
executiveHello, everyone, and thank you for being with us this morning. Steve Bradshaw, our CEO, is going to start things off with some opening remarks. After that, Stacy Kymes, who serves as Executive Vice President of Corporate Banking, will walk through our loan portfolio along with our credit metrics. Then I'll wrap up with specifics on net interest income, net interest margin, fee revenues, expenses, and where we stand overall on the balance sheet when it comes to liquidity and capital. For the Q&A portion, we have Marc Maun, our Chief Credit Officer, with us — he can field in-depth questions about credit metrics. We're also joined by Scott Grauer, Executive Vice President of Wealth Management, who can speak further about our wealth management capabilities, which delivered yet another fantastic quarter for the company. You can find PDFs of both the slide presentation and the fourth quarter press release on our website, bokf.com. Please take note of the disclaimers shown on Slide 2, which apply to any forward-looking statements made on this call. At this point, I'll hand things over to Steve Bradshaw.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveGood morning, and thank you for being with us as we go over the financial results for the fourth quarter and the full year 2020. To sum up, although the year brought plenty of obstacles, it's hard to exaggerate how much adaptability and determination our company showed throughout it. A record $786.4 million in pretax pre-provision revenue for 2020 once again confirmed the strength of our diversified revenue strategy and the steadiness it offers when the economy is under stress. Even more significant, it highlights how broad our service capabilities are and the value we deliver to our customers. Beginning on Slide 4. Full year net income came to $435 million, or $6.19 per diluted share. Turning to the fourth quarter specifically, net income reached a record $154.2 million, or $2.21 per diluted share, which works out to EPS growth of 1% on a linked-quarter basis and an increase of more than 40% versus the same quarter last year. The main factors behind our success this quarter began with yet another excellent broad-based earnings quarter from our wealth management business, along with continued elevated production from our mortgage team, though that came in lower than the last 2 quarters as seasonality and modest margin compression appeared after the summer's mortgage boom, yet mortgage margins stayed strong compared with the first half of 2020. No credit loss provision was required this quarter. In fact, the improving economic outlook, together with improving credit trends, let us release $6.5 million of our reserve. And finally, the proactive steps we took to keep expense levels in check when the pandemic began in March paid off in the fourth quarter, just as they did throughout all of 2020. Moving to Slide 5. Loan growth stayed a challenge this quarter, since our borrowers quite understandably lowered leverage amid the difficult economic environment. Stacy will go into this in more detail shortly, but we do expect growth opportunities to return in 2021 as the economy keeps rebounding. Deposit growth continues to be excellent, rising over 3% linked quarter and over 30% versus the same quarter a year ago. Those figures exclude the second wave of stimulus enacted late in 2020, so we expect this trend to persist in the near term. Assets under management or in custody rose over 11% for the quarter, exceeding $90 billion for the first time in our company's history, driven by very strong new client sales and favorable market impact. We'll take a somewhat deeper look at the record year our wealth management team delivered in 2020, as well as a shift of some brokerage and trading fee revenue into net interest revenue stemming from an increase in trading securities balances and settlement timing in the fourth quarter. It goes without saying that we are incredibly proud of our Wealth Management division. I'll offer some additional perspective on the results before we begin the Q&A session, but now Stacy Kymes will review the loan portfolio and our credit metrics in more detail. I'll hand the call over to Stacy.
Stacy Kymes
executiveAppreciate that, Steve. Moving over to Slide 7. Within our core loan portfolio, period-end loans came in at $21.3 billion, a decline of 1.8% across the quarter. Like Steve said, when the economy is uncertain, quality borrowers tend to bring down leverage, and that's exactly what we saw from our borrowers once again this quarter. Now onto the energy portfolio. Balances shrank 6.7% during the quarter and 12.7% over the year. Although commodity prices have come up quite a bit in recent months, finding enough new deals to make up for paydowns in today's environment is still difficult, since existing borrowers keep paying down debt in order to reduce leverage. Even with all of that, we stay optimistic about lending and energy-related revenue growth as we head into the new year, and we'll keep supporting our customers in this space. Keep in mind that our diversified revenue strategy lets us view clients holistically, and the energy business involves far more than lending alone, as this year's record level of energy hedging revenue shows. Treasury, retirement plan services and personal wealth management are all businesses that keep expanding and serving our energy client base. Healthcare balances dipped slightly this quarter, since growth in senior housing loans got offset by a decrease in hospital system loans; for the year, however, healthcare loans rose 9% year-over-year, mainly driven by growth in balances from our hospital systems clients, who demonstrate a strong credit profile. Going forward, we stay confident in our healthcare portfolio's long-term growth and credit outlook, and we expect to be a growth leader once again after health and economic conditions move toward a more normal state. In the near term, it's worth noting that the second stimulus bill passed last month, much like the original CARES Act, contains multiple revenue enhancement measures for hospitals and skilled nursing facilities alike as they navigate the current environment. Paycheck Protection Program, or PPP, balances fell nearly 20%, with just over $470 million of balances forgiven during the quarter. At the start of PPP in April of 2020, the forgiveness process turned out to be more complex than we had believed. That said, additional guidance from the Small Business Administration, or SBA, clarifying our requirements, along with continued refinement of our processes, has cut down significantly on the time required per application. The biggest hurdle in recent months has been clients' reluctance to apply for forgiveness, since they were hopeful of legislative action that would relax the requirements. The recent Economic Aid Act will deliver substantial forgiveness process relief, especially for those clients with existing PPP loans of less than $150,000, which represents more than 70% of our total PPP volume. We will take part in the newest round of PPP with largely the same strategy of focusing on our existing client base; this will allow us to leverage additional resource capacity to meet our existing clients' needs in an extremely timely manner, thereby increasing client engagement, loyalty and retention. Looking ahead, we are optimistic in our outlook for loan growth for 2021. How quickly and in what form the wider economic rebound takes hold will decide when lending activity picks back up. Even so, our position is strong when it comes to serving customers, and we feel sure that capital investment will come back during 2021. Moving to Slide 8, there's a refreshed picture of where things stand with loan deferrals throughout the BOKF portfolio. Only 0.6% of all loans are still under deferral of any kind, which is half of the 1.2% figure from the prior quarter. Among those still deferred, a tiny number — 12 loans worth $24 million in total — sit in extended deferral. We keep a close watch on this shrinking set of loans, and in the near term, credit quality has kept moving in a favorable direction. What happens over the longer haul hinges on how fast the economy recovers and what further fiscal stimulus does. Also on Slide 8, we start pulling together the roster of loan segments that the markets initially viewed as more exposed to persistent economic headwinds tied to the pandemic. This collection of loans is widely diversified, numbering more than 550 with an average size under $3 million. At present, the $574 million retail piece of this portfolio is the most at risk, and we will keep tracking those exposures carefully. Even so, the retail slice of our loan book has proven more durable than anticipated, since our borrowers have shown resilience. Several chunks of this list that were first deemed more vulnerable are doing quite well, among them gaming, convenience stores, religious organizations and colleges. On Slide 9, credit quality is clearly much stronger than it was in the first half of 2020. We could not only free up part of the loan loss reserve, we also recorded substantial credit quality gains in our energy portfolio after finishing the borrowing base redetermination process during the quarter. Firmer commodity prices in the near term brought down criticized and potential problem loan figures, as well as the reserve allocation we needed for energy loans. Net charge-offs fell to $16.7 million, or 28 basis points annualized, this quarter, compared with $22.4 million, or 37 basis points annualized, in the third quarter. For all of 2020, net charge-offs came to 32 basis points, comfortably inside our company's historical loss experience. The combined allowance for loan losses stood at $389 million, or 2% of outstanding loans, at quarter end, excluding PPP loans. As of December 31, the combined allowance for loan losses tied to energy was 3.61% of outstanding energy loans. Non-accruing loans rose modestly, by $14 million, this quarter, mostly because non-accruing commercial real estate loans increased. Potential problem loans came to $478 million at quarter end, a sharp drop from $623 million on September 30. From a credit standpoint, plenty of uncertainty remains in today's environment, so forecasting very far ahead is still hard. Having said that, taking into account our current knowledge and presuming that our economic projection holds true as we move forward, we anticipate that net charge-offs for 2021 will stay toward the lower portion of the 30 to 50 basis point span that represents our historical average. As has always been our practice, we will keep setting our reserve at the suitable amount. Our overall view of the credit picture for 2021 is favorable, which permits us to start a reserve release during this quarter. After we gain greater clarity regarding how quickly COVID-19 case counts decline, how vaccines are distributed, and a wide return to normal economic activity during 2021, we might possibly find further chances to release reserves within this year. At this point I'll hand the call over to Steven so he can discuss our NIM dynamics, fee revenues and the key balance sheet items for the quarter. Steven?
Steven Nell
executiveAppreciate that, Stacy. This marks our second quarter in a row of record net income, and our diversified revenue strategy is plainly delivering a differentiated result against this low rate backdrop. Big contributions from the wealth management team, along with careful expense control, drove our success this quarter and offset the effects of today's low rate environment. Moving to Slide 11. Net interest revenue for the fourth quarter came in at $297 million, which is an increase of over $25 million versus the prior quarter. That gain is mostly tied to net interest revenue generated from a $5.1 billion rise in trading securities stemming from our brokerage and trading customer transactions. In a moment I'll cover how net interest revenue shifted away from fee revenue in our brokerage and trading business during this quarter. Net interest margin landed at 2.72%, a decline of 9 basis points quarter over quarter. On the slide I've laid out a roll forward of net interest margin and net interest revenue covering the third to fourth quarter, calling out the more notable items. PPP fees came in higher during the fourth quarter as additional loans were forgiven. And COBZ discount accretion dropped this quarter relative to an elevated figure in the third quarter. This quarter's migration of brokerage and trading customer transaction revenue out of fees and into net interest revenue diluted net interest margin while raising the dollars booked in net interest revenue. The slide also flags other infrequently occurring loan fees and interest recoveries to stress a core net interest margin of 2.67%. We kept reinvesting cash flows from our available-for-sale securities portfolio, and the portfolio yield fell 13 basis points to 1.98%. Beyond that, we're still succeeding at pushing interest-bearing deposit costs lower, from 26 basis points in the last quarter to 19 basis points in this one. Although plenty of moving parts remain, among them ongoing recognition of PPP interest and fees, the mix of continued repricing in the AFS portfolio plus limited remaining room to cut interest-bearing deposit costs further will weigh on net interest margin going forward. Now on Slide 12, you can observe the effect of that brokerage and trading fee revenue conversion into net interest revenue I referenced earlier. This stems mainly from record volume and the settlement timing of mortgage-backed trading securities, which meant customer transaction revenue was earned and recorded as interest rather than fees. On top of that, energy hedging fees, despite setting a record for the year, fell $5 million versus the third quarter's record amount. Taken as a whole, our wealth management team delivered yet another excellent quarter, posting total revenue of $131.5 million, a slight dip from the third quarter yet still the third best quarter ever, and across the full year, total revenue exceeded $500 million for the first time. Transaction card revenue declined 6.7% this quarter, mainly because of lower transaction volumes caused by consumers spending less. Even so, 2020 was an outstanding year for our TransFund team when it came to signing new contracts with financial institution customers, and that ought to offset some of the drop we experienced this quarter. Conversion timelines run long, but we anticipate a recovery in 2021 that aligns with better economic conditions. Fiduciary and asset management revenue rose $1.9 million in the quarter, mostly because of higher fair value of assets under management tied to both sales activity and favorable markets. Deposit service charges held steady for the quarter, but they fell $15.7 million across the year since we are waiving certain fees during the pandemic. Mortgage banking revenue declined $12.7 million versus the prior quarter, the result of both fourth quarter seasonality and some margin compression after elevated margins caused by industry capacity constraints over the past few quarters; even so, it remained a top 10 quarter ever for our mortgage business, which matters given the usual seasonal drop-offs in the year's final quarter; altogether, 2020 mortgage banking revenue set a company record, up $74.8 million compared with last year and providing a major offset to margin pressure from the prolonged low rate environment. Even though it isn't shown on Slide 12, I want to mention that net economic changes in fair value of mortgage servicing rights and related economic hedges came in at positive $6.5 million for the quarter. Fees and commissions did fall this quarter, partly because revenue geography shifted on the income statement, but keep in mind the unprecedented production levels our fee businesses delivered over the past few quarters. Those businesses running at record levels have plainly been essential to the success we achieved this year. We will keep directing capital and reskilled employee resources toward key fee areas so we can maximize our revenue opportunities. Moving to Slide 13. We remain prudent on expense management, with total expenses roughly flat versus the prior quarter. Total expenses did rise 4% year-over-year, yet it's worth noting that higher incentive compensation tied to record annual production in our wealth management and mortgage businesses more than explains the entire expense increase this year. Personnel expense fell just over 2% from the prior quarter. Incentive compensation dropped $2.1 million, as a $5.3 million rise in combined cash-based and deferred compensation was more than offset by a $7.4 million decline in stock-based incentive compensation from last quarter's elevated level. In addition, employee benefit expense fell $1.4 million because of the usual seasonal decrease in retirement costs and payroll taxes. Non-personnel expense rose 2.5% from the third quarter. We contributed $6 million to the BOKF Foundation as a charitable donation this quarter, reflecting our continued focus on the communities we serve and the extreme needs the pandemic has created. Business promotion expense grew by just over $1 million, mainly from higher advertising expense, while other expense rose $3.3 million because of loss contingencies and recruiting expenses. Net losses and expenses tied to repossessed assets fell by $5.1 million, driven mostly by write-downs taken during the third quarter on a group of oil and gas properties along with retail commercial real estate properties. There was also a $1.8 million decline in insurance expense, and mortgage banking costs came down by $1 million; turning to Slide 14, our liquidity position stays very strong thanks to deposit balances that keep flowing in. At present our loan-to-deposit ratio sits at 64%, versus 68% at the close of the prior quarter, which gives us substantial on balance sheet liquidity to serve customer needs going forward. Over the near term, we anticipate that customer deposits will keep flowing in, since the stimulus measures enacted at the end of the year were not captured in the deposit figures for December 31. Our capital levels are likewise in healthy shape, with a common equity Tier 1 ratio of 12%, which is comfortably above our internal operating range. Given capital levels this strong, we were active once again with share repurchase, buying back 665,000 shares opportunistically in the open market at an average price of $63.82 per share. On top of that, we authorized a raise in our quarterly cash dividend during the fourth quarter, bringing it to $0.52; for the company this marks the 15th consecutive year of dividend increases, as we keep rewarding our shareholders across varying types of economic environments.
Steven Nell
executiveTurning to Slide 15, I want to share a broad view of what we expect in the near and midterm as we head into 2021. Our expectation is that loan growth will gradually pick up alongside the wider economic rebound during this year. Though it will be weighted mostly toward the third and fourth quarters, we think we can expand loans within the low single-digit range across the entirety of 2021, setting aside any effects from PPP activity. Our available-for-sale securities portfolio, composed mostly of agency mortgage-backed securities, produced a yield of 1.98% in the fourth quarter. With rates staying low for a sustained period, prepayments may run at roughly $800 million each quarter. Right now, we are able to put those cash flows back to work at yields of about 75 to 85 basis points. As we mentioned, we made progress this quarter in pushing deposit costs down further, and they sit well beneath the trough REITs experienced during the previous environment of rates near 0. In our view, there may be some additional room to nudge deposit costs down, though we sense we are close to the floor. Lower-rate securities reinvestment combined with very little space to cut deposit costs further will weigh on net interest margin over the next several quarters. Our varied set of fee revenue streams ought to keep offering a partial offset to the revenue strain our spread businesses are experiencing. We anticipate modest expansion across most fee revenue categories in 2021, apart from brokerage and trading along with mortgage businesses, since the record-setting 2020 in those segments will be hard to match. We will stay disciplined about managing both personnel and non-personnel costs, with growth planned in the low single digits for 2021. Our aim is to hold the line on expenses we can manage without giving up multiyear technology commitments that enhance customer service and our competitive standing. Should the economy keep strengthening and oil prices become more stable in 2021, a further release of loan loss reserves is possible. As I said a moment ago, we take confidence in our capital strength. We will keep pursuing share buyback opportunities and will hold our quarterly cash dividend at its present level. I will now hand the call back to Steve Bradshaw for closing commentary.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveThanks, Steven. Something we say a lot is that BOK Financial was deliberately designed so that downside risk and swings in earnings during uncertain economic periods get softened. Doing credit underwriting the right way no matter where we are in the cycle, plus putting money into expanding our fee-based lines of business, has been something our company has taken real pride in for a long stretch of years. That approach faced its biggest test ever in 2020. A year that tough would normally hurt how much most regional financial institutions can earn, so I take a lot of pride in telling you we produced a result that stood apart for our customers, our communities, our employees and our shareholders. As we look toward 2021, we believe that approach will keep producing strong results; we see a chance to grow our market share in chosen fee business segments, and lending opportunities should come back too, since our clients' confidence is recovering alongside an economy spurred on by renewed capital investment. 2020 showed us how quickly an economic forecast made early in the year can shift, yet it also demonstrated what our diversified revenue model is worth, as well as the expertise and leadership our management team brings, while we navigate the difficulties the pandemic created. With that, we're happy to take your questions. Operator?
Ken Zerbe
analystOkay. My goal here was simply to confirm that I grasped exactly what took place regarding those extra trading securities showing up in the NII line. So, did you folks start this yourselves? And going forward — I suppose what I'm really asking is whether this represents the appropriate run rate, both for brokerage and for NII? I'm just attempting to work through how all of these pieces fit together.
Steven Nell
executiveRight. Ken, Steven here. My take is that market dynamics drove it. We saw unprecedented trading volume in Ginnie Mae securities stemming from everything that happened over the summer, and we helped our clients execute those trades; those securities then landed on our balance sheet, to a greater degree than certain earlier securities we had traded on behalf of clients; as a result, we booked that transaction revenue through net interest income rather than through fee revenue. So for the most part it amounted to a shift in market dynamics, with our trading securities averaging more than $5 billion higher in earning assets during the quarter. I can't say — Scott might have a view on what happens later, but my suspicion is that many of those trading securities will continue to be held in a similar manner, at minimum through the early portion of this year.
Ken Zerbe
analystUnderstood. Alright, then — and I suppose, strictly speaking, all of us should — so if that's what's keeping your NII up, does it follow that we ought to figure brokerage and trading revenues remain at this considerably weaker level during the first quarter? And then it seems like you indicated that because it's only happening in the first quarter, perhaps activity returns to normal in the second and third. Is that simply the correct approach to understanding how this works?
Steven Nell
executiveHonestly, I do believe the fee revenues are going to remain depressed at that level. I genuinely believe client trading activity is going to appear more in — at minimum during this — during this quarter within NII; however, the way we handle brokerage and trading is to examine the whole revenue stream as one. It doesn't really matter to us whether a transaction gets booked as net interest income or as fees. And during this specific quarter, it leaned more toward the NII side. And that could be what happens, I'd guess, at least through the early portion of the year, possibly extending into 2021; we simply track how it works out with our clients and how we record it in whichever bucket.
Ken Zerbe
analystUnderstood. All right, that seems reasonable. Then, only one more item from my side. If we leave out every trading security, correct, clearly the net interest margin you're steering toward is reduced; it sounds as though you anticipate quite slight loan expansion, perhaps strengthening during the latter half of the year. Typically, it sounds as though NII, excluding trading, ought to face a rather considerable degree of strain. Could you possibly put a figure on how much those elements affect NII?
Steven Nell
executiveFine, let me begin by offering something closer to a core NIM figure for the year. On that chart, we placed it at roughly 2 67%. Once more, predicting how far it will drift lower is difficult. I believe it will, though, owing to the repricing within our available-for-sale securities portfolio. I mean, when you look at the chart we've supplied, a rather steady reduction in AFS securities yields is visible. A couple of quarters back, I believe it was 18 basis points, then 13 basis points during this quarter; that roll-down is going to keep going. Now, once again during this quarter we've managed quite well at forcing our interest-bearing deposit costs lower. As a matter of fact, the average for this quarter came to 19 basis points, and I believe December's figure had fallen to roughly 17 basis points. Is further downward pressure possible? Maybe so, yet I don't believe there's much room available to counteract part of the AFS securities repricing. Thus, in my view, net interest margin will simply drift lower in a natural way. Naturally, our attention rests more heavily on net interest revenue than on anything else; and as you mentioned, loans starting to expand, we're hoping, at some point during 2021, especially in the year's second half, will certainly assist in steadying the margin and pulling it back up.
Brady Gailey
analystI just want to ask something more about the trading securities inventory. So I mean, right now we're at $7 billion — if you look back across the past couple of years, it's been somewhere between $1.5 billion and $2 billion, and today we're sitting at $7 billion. So it seems like it will remain near $7 billion for the near term. But over the longer term, does it go back to that roughly $2 billion level? Or is this permanent?
Scott Grauer
executiveScott here. So I would say — if you examine how things trended through 2020, it grew from $4.6 billion at the end of Q1 to $6.2 billion — that $6.2 billion at the close of Q3 and then slightly above $7 billion during Q4. So we expect it to stay elevated. That will clearly hinge on overall volume and flow within the mortgage markets, but we don't see it returning, like you mentioned, to those low levels you're talking about.
Brady Gailey
analystAll right. Okay. That helps. Then when you examine loan balances, excluding PPP, it appears that for roughly the past 3 quarters, those core loan balances have declined somewhere between 5% and 8% annualized. This quarter, I believe, was down 8% linked-quarter annualized. So what makes you confident that you'll see a reversal from that shrinkage toward some modest loan growth from here?
Stacy Kymes
executiveWell, I'd say the largest part of that is when you look at annualized energy loans, which represent one of our biggest lending segments, they're down nearly 13% year-over-year. And on a linked-quarter annualized basis, they fell 6.7% — so not annualized, just linked quarter. So if those energy balances stabilize, which we believe we're near, you'll see some paydowns. Perhaps we see a bit more runoff during the first quarter; then hopefully we start to plateau and grow from there. We are seeing new deals in that area, but that's simply not exceeding the pace of deleveraging or paydowns occurring in that book. Still, a lot of solid activity has come from the work we did surrounding the PPP program, and we think we're well positioned there. But I think you see — you need economic growth, and I think you also need some of this liquidity to come off the balance sheet before you truly reach core loan growth. But I think the figures we provided regarding low single-digit loan growth for the year, back weighted to the second half of the year, I think we feel very confident about those, assuming we get stability and then growth in the energy book.
Brady Gailey
analystOkay, that's useful. So last thing from my side: plenty of folks anticipate that 2021 will be a pretty busy year when it comes to M&A in banking. I realize BOKF has picked up banks and fee income businesses here and there across the years. What's your take — do you figure BOKF will be doing deals this year?
Steve Bradshaw
executiveOkay, Steve here. I'd say your read is right that more M&A chances are going to show up. If you look back, whenever you've got a low rate setting plus pressure on revenue, that clearly makes some sellers willing to have those talks. So we see that chance arriving too, and we'll keep evaluating chosen possibilities that might come along during '21, with priority mostly on things located inside the footprint.
Peter Winter
analystYou folks are clearly performing very strongly when it comes to credit; and as the economic picture improves, might the reserve-to-loan ratio return to where it stood on January 1, roughly 1.2%? Could it be moving in that direction by the close of this year?
Marc Maun
executivePeter, Marc Maun here. When I look at that, what I observe is this: assuming you continue to see betterment and the economic outlook gets stronger, you witness pandemic cases falling sharply and vaccine outcomes delivered, plus energy prices staying steady, as they have in recent months, and basically, you get back to a January 2020 outlook. Our day 1 adjustment figure was 1.2%, and that appears probable should all of those things happen. Naturally, quite a few ifs remain within that projection.
Peter Winter
analystAll right. And so, Steven, should that loan growth come through in the back half of the year, do you figure that would contribute to a steadier margin as we get nearer to the latter part of this year?
Steven Nell
executiveYeah, it would. For sure, as you shift the mix of your earning assets out of securities or — and toward loan balances instead, that's definitely going to provide support for NIM down the road.
Peter Winter
analystAlright, maybe I can slip in a final question here. This year was a record one for mortgage banking. A slight drop is anticipated, though mortgage should remain solid. When we think about the years further out, is it fair to say you've picked up share in this business, meaning growth ought to stay above something like the 2019 mark, even as mortgage banking cools off?
Steve Bradshaw
executiveYeah. Peter, Steve here. My sense is that in '21, mortgage sits in more of a steady state. Q4 is likely a decent stand-in, though we'll probably get more refi volume in quarter 1, which is typical for us, and then the purchase market picks up somewhat more strongly afterward. I do believe we've gained share, since we've put more money to work beyond Oklahoma. Our bench of producers is far deeper across Colorado, Texas, Arizona, New Mexico, and so on — plus Kansas City — and that has genuinely delivered for us. That's where we've expanded. To me, it mirrors the broader company, in that our share is fairly modest with solid potential across each of those markets. And I'd say mortgage shows that reality better now than it likely did 3 to 5 years back.
Jared Shaw
analystStaying on the topic of the provision reserve level, I suppose: what kinds of qualitative overlays got applied this quarter, either on the energy book or across the book generally? And did that genuinely assist in, I suppose, slowing down the releases? And as the year unfolds, we ought to simply anticipate that those qualitative overlays shrink in order to return to that lower allowance level.
Marc Maun
executiveYes. Once more, this is Marc Maun. Yes. We examined the qualitative overlays quite closely where our reserves are concerned; we definitely did consider more reallocation than reduction in specific areas. Energy clearly got better, and that reserve was brought down by us to 3.4% from 4.2%, which is where it stood last quarter. Yet we continue to have worries in several other areas where stimulus played a key role across a number of areas, especially in CRE and in smaller businesses. That might or might not have concealed some problems that could arise, and so we want to be sure we're thoughtful regarding how we view the credit's performance over the short term and then assess them quarter by quarter, based on how economic activity develops.
Stacy Kymes
executiveEven so, your broad argument holds up. And as I see it, our position was that because of the stage we've reached in the cycle, going beyond what we already did would have been jumping the gun. That said, if we start to get a clearer picture of the economic rebound, of how quickly shots are going into arms, of falling infection numbers, and of stronger business activity, then our stance might shift.
Jared Shaw
analystAll right, that's helpful detail. Now when you look at the energy book, do you actually — is it your view that energy prices have to rise from where they are now for more growth to come? Or is it mostly just soaking up the liquidity that's already sitting out there? And after that gets soaked up, that's when organic growth can begin.
Stacy Kymes
executiveWe're — I'd say we're in a pretty good place right now. Take oil specifically: something in the $50 to $55 band isn't a bad place to sit, in terms of stability; and in the Permian especially, that's somewhere companies can keep expanding and still make money doing it. From where we sit, though, this is a price range where we — as soon as a stable point can be found, I believe growth becomes possible from there. New transactions are getting signed. We're signing them. We're the lead on a lot of them, so we see solid opportunity in that. It's simply that eventually, energy borrowers will deleverage at a slower pace, and then all the effort our energy team is putting in to expand that will truly become visible; and I believe we'll witness it. Whether that lands in the first quarter or the second quarter, I can't say, but my expectation is that we'll witness it in 2020 to 2021.
Jared Shaw
analystAlright. So last thing from my side: PPP's second round is now underway. What's the right way to frame the possible scale of that for you folks, and also perhaps the typical loan amount versus what the initial round looked like?
Stacy Kymes
executiveWell, simply given how it's built, it will come in smaller. I mean, I believe the cap on loan size, broadly speaking, sits at roughly $2 million, with exceptions tied to revenue drops and similar matters. So it won't reach the magnitude that the first PPP effort had. We definitely intend to take part actively, striving hard to assist our clients who are able to make use of it so they can join in, yet we don't expect it to match the original program's scale, largely owing to limits on loan amounts as much as other considerations.
Jared Shaw
analystSo should we be considering, if you were just above $2 billion at first, something like $1 billion, or is that premature?
Stacy Kymes
executiveThat's premature. I mean, we are — and only yesterday, fresh regulations are being issued that control the program from the SBA. So I believe it's extremely difficult to forecast with any degree of certainty right now.
Jon Arfstrom
analystLet me ask you something, Stacy. You mentioned on Slide 7 that loan growth could accelerate later this year, and energy seems to be a major driver behind that. Could you elaborate a bit more — looking ahead 12 months, which other loan categories do you expect to contribute most to growth?
Stacy Kymes
executiveHonestly, I'd say every category. If you look forward 12 months and assume commodity prices hold steady, energy should grow mid-single digits, possibly a touch higher. Our healthcare book is performing really well. I'm very proud of that team. You noticed we ticked up just slightly this quarter, but that was largely due to some sizable paydowns and health systems loans, which, considering their liquidity position at the time, really obscured some strong growth we're seeing in senior housing; and our C&I businesses, I believe, are set up to perform very well. One of the genuine advantages we gained from the original PPP is how effectively we executed it; and because of that, we've been able to convert it into new Treasury relationships. And we think that once the market returns to some semblance of normal, that will truly open up opportunities for us on the C&I side, given how well we executed and the capacity to reach a banker and have that relationship when you need it and have someone you can contact to assist you. So we're hopeful that once things normalize, growing at roughly 2 to 3x GDP, if you will, which is essentially how we've measured it over a long time frame, is quite achievable for us given the business mix we have. We also have an excellent footprint. I mean, we're not — we operate in several footprint states that will expand more rapidly than the rest of the United States. Consider Texas, Arizona, and Colorado — we're well positioned geographically to benefit disproportionately from growth as those core state economies are likely to outpace the national economy.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveOne additional point, and this comes specifically from the commercial and industrial side: lower utilization was clearly a major factor behind the drop in economic activity. Should that pick up, our expectation is that utilization of credit lines and similar facilities will rise, and that will feed into it.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAlright. You took care of a few of my questions already, which I appreciate. But broadly speaking, leaving energy aside, are there any encouraging signals you're picking up across the footprint? My hunch is yes, especially in certain stronger markets. Still, are you noticing those first hints of confidence returning and pipelines starting to grow?
Stacy Kymes
executiveI'd say — well, my view is that unless we start drawing down some of that liquidity, I just don't see significant C&I loan growth ahead; we are getting a bit in health care, particularly around senior housing. Yet honestly, until some of that excess liquidity sitting with our borrowers gets used up, it's going to be tough to see that happen anytime soon. So for me, it feels too early to call. From where we sit, we haven't yet observed any kind of pickup in economic activity that would convince us meaningful C&I loan growth is right around the corner.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAll right. Then only one brief item regarding credit. Those energy NPLs shown on Slide 9 — how do you expect them to get resolved, especially given the bottom end of the charge-off range you anticipate for the entire year?
Stacy Kymes
executiveEach of those will resolve on its own as we work through them. A couple of points, I suppose, are what I'd say. First, the net charge-off guidance we've given, which sits around the low end of that historical range, is something we feel quite good about. Consider what we charged off during 2020 — that's a reasonable yardstick to attempt to beat in '21. Another distinction is that commodity prices on those energy loans are climbing; so attempting to resolve and work out an energy loan when prices are stable and rising is an entirely different situation compared with when they keep dropping. Thus we're fairly hopeful that, as we work through them, the guidance we gave you will be something we can definitely hit. And our hope, certainly, is to do better than that, since the environment, I think, is giving us something of a chance to work some of them out in a manner that benefits us. Losses will arise from those nonperforming loans. But the real question is whether a stable and even slightly rising price environment will genuinely help soften those? And on that, I'd say we're optimistic.
Matt Olney
analystYeah. I'd like to inquire about operating expenses, and that guidance you folks released sounds quite favorable, aiming to hold that down to low single-digit growth during 2021. Could you share anything further regarding how you plan to pull that off? Also, I want to confirm we're comparing equivalent figures on the correct base point. I see $1.166 billion in operating expenses for 2020. Is that accurate?
Steve Bradshaw
executiveYeah; so — Steve here; we simply put in a lot of effort, I believe, during our budgeting process through the autumn and particularly in November, collaborating with every business line and attempting to figure out the appropriate amount of expense and how we can keep it under control given a somewhat tougher revenue landscape; and it spans everything. It's — it touches personnel. It touches business promotion. We intend to keep IT spending since we need to preserve our competitive edge with the products and services we deliver to our customers. But it's simply a great deal of meticulous effort to preserve that cost discipline.
Matt Olney
analystAll right, and moving to the buyback, I'd like to know how much appetite there is for repurchasing shares given that the stock is now trading well above the prices where you bought back in Q3 — or Q4, rather, my mistake.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveYeah. What I'd say is, our execution during Q4 was something we felt good about. The shares were purchased by us at roughly a 25% discount compared to where the market sits today. This is something we'll monitor closely. Putting out a specific price point — saying we'd purchase at this level and wouldn't below or above it — isn't something I'll do. So my view is we evaluate it against our capital position, against where capital can be deployed. And — even so, my belief is that appetite remains, and we possess the capital strength to act throughout the market when attractive chances arise.
Matt Olney
analystAll right. Then regarding the PPP, you provided disclosures, but I just didn't catch it. How much did you recognize in PPP fees during the fourth quarter? And how much is left in fees still to be recognized going forward?
Steve Bradshaw
executiveYeah. During the fourth quarter, we recognized $3.3 million of net interest revenue from PPP along with $13.5 million in fees, which comes to $16.8 million total on the fee side; and roughly $25 million still remains on the fee side.
Gary Tenner
analystMost of those questions got addressed already. Still, on the topic of loan growth, I get it — clearly, if the energy book settles down, that would definitely help loan growth in the coming year, or even this one. Regarding business overall — and I believe this came up and was partly covered — are pipelines picking up at all in your view? Do certain regions show more momentum than elsewhere?
Stacy Kymes
executiveNothing stands out. Not right now. I'd go back to what Marc said before, and I believe it's the strongest point regarding the C&I portfolio: remember that the bulk of that portfolio is driven by borrowing base — meaning receivables, inventory, items along those lines — so our utilization there is actually quite low, especially when measured against where things stood before the pandemic. That leaves room to expand organically, simply through better utilization as those receivable and inventory balances start rising again while people grow once more — that's an organic growth opening. Beyond that, as I said before, the efforts we made alongside our borrowers and with others holding several banking relationships in connection with PPP have created a genuinely promising pipeline for broad expansion too. So my sense is we're positioned well to grow that core C&I portfolio once the economy starts improving.
Gary Tenner
analystAlright, and only quickly regarding the energy book, you mentioned there are fresh deals available that you're either taking part in or heading up. Could you help us understand, for that segment during the quarter, how originations compared with paydowns?
Stacy Kymes
executiveThat figure isn't available from me right now. Without a doubt, paydowns went well beyond the new originations. Still, during the fourth quarter we completed more than a handful of transactions that were new to the marketplace, and a lot of those were led by us, which brought in fee revenue tied to them. So we're feeling optimistic. The real issue, I believe, is timing the bottom of the deleveraging process. And my sense is we're near it. Whether that lands in the first quarter or the second quarter, I simply can't say, though it feels visible from where we stand.
Steven Nell
executiveAll right. Once more, thank you all for being with us today. We're grateful for your interest in BOK Financial. Should you have additional questions, give us a ring at (918) 595 to 3030, or send a message to ir@bokf.com. Enjoy the rest of your day. Thanks.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's call, everyone. We appreciate your joining us. You're free to hang up now, and we hope the rest of your day is great.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete BOK Financial Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to BOK Financial Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in BOK Financial Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.