BOK Financial Corporation (BOKF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 21, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Steven Nell
executiveHello, everyone, and thank you for being with us this morning. To start things off, Steve Bradshaw, our CEO, is going to give some opening remarks. After that, Stacy Kymes, who serves as our Chief Operating Officer, will walk through our Loan Portfolio, Credit Metrics and Fee Income businesses. Then it's my turn — I'll go over net interest income, net interest margin, expenses, and where our overall balance sheet stands when it comes to liquidity and capital. For the Q&A portion, we're joined by Marc Maun, our Chief Credit Officer, who can field in-depth questions about Credit Metrics, along with Scott Grauer, Executive Vice President of Wealth Management, who's here to speak further about what we're doing in wealth management. You can find a PDF of the slide presentation and the first quarter press release on our website, bokf.com. Please take note of the disclaimers on Slide 2, which apply to any forward-looking statements we make on this call. With that, I'll hand things over to Steve Bradshaw.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveGood morning, and thank you for being here as we go over our financial results for the first quarter of 2021. Before I begin, though, I'd like to share a few thoughts about the announcement earlier this month concerning my intention to retire on March 31 of next year. Having spent 3 decades at BOK Financial and served over 7 years as President and CEO, this was, needless to say, not a simple choice. Leading what I consider the finest regional financial institution in the nation—one sharply dedicated to long-term shareholder value—fills me with enormous pride. That said, I have every confidence that BOKF has never been in a stronger position to handle this change. The way we performed during the pandemic, along with my leadership team's resilience and unity across 2020, showcased knowledge and teamwork rooted in what truly defines our organization: experience and collaboration. During the year ahead, my attention will be on making sure the transition goes smoothly for whoever succeeds me, once the Board formally names that person in the months to come. Anyone who knows our company understands that leadership choices at BOKF are made with great deliberation. We manage this company with a long-term view, and that involves considerable effort spent cultivating talent from within. I have complete expectation that the Board will select an internal candidate to take over as CEO when the right moment arrives. We're in a strong position to make that selection shortly, and I can assure you the incoming leader will carry forward the very same deliberate, long-term shareholder emphasis we're recognized for. Meanwhile, I'll be concentrating on the set of goals and objectives we laid out for 2021, which will keep enhancing our competitive standing and our prospects for growth in 2022 and beyond. With that said, let's turn to the latest quarterly numbers. As you can see on Slide 4, net income for the first quarter came to $146.1 million, or $2.10 per diluted share. That's a modest decline from the record earnings we posted last quarter, yet the contrast between the first quarter of 2021 and the same period in 2020 is about as sharp as it gets. Several key items shaped this quarter: yet another exceptional earnings performance from our mortgage business, since activity stayed elevated this quarter even with rates climbing; the contribution from our Wealth Management team remains something that sets us apart, even though results fell short of the back-to-back record quarters in late 2020, just as we had anticipated. The brightening economic picture, together with better credit trends, let us release $25 million from our loan loss reserve; and finally, expense management is still excellent, as it has been really through the whole past year. Now to Slide 5. Loan growth remained difficult this quarter, since our commercial and commercial real estate clients keep paying down debt. Our borrowers are understandably continuing to lower leverage amid a tough economic environment, but we think we're set up for growth opportunities during the latter half of 2021 as the economy keeps recovering. We're still seeing fantastic deposit expansion — close to 3% higher than the prior quarter, and roughly 30% above the comparable period 12 months earlier, since the latest round of stimulus started showing up toward the end of the quarter. In Wealth Management, the assets we manage or hold in custody keep rising, because rates staying low for so long pushes yield-hungry clients toward the market. Equities now make up 40% of all assets under management or in custody, an increase of about $2 billion since year-end, which puts us in position to grow fees substantially in our Fiduciary and Asset Management business. Before we open things up to questions, I'll share a bit more context on the results, but right now Stacy Kymes is going to walk through the loan portfolio, our credit metrics and our main fee businesses in greater depth. Stacy, over to you.
Stacy Kymes
executiveAppreciate that, Steve. Turning now to Slide 7. Looking at our core loan portfolio, we finished the period with $20.7 billion in loans, which represents a 3% decrease quarter over quarter, as borrowers continue deleveraging in the way we had expected at the start of 2021. For the portfolio as a whole, utilization of lines came in at 62% when the first quarter of this year ended, down from 68% prior to COVID, with the steepest declines occurring in Energy, Healthcare and General C&I, where line utilization on a cumulative basis is now 58%, compared to 65% before the pandemic. As economic reopening proceeds, we have confidence that line utilizations will normalize and that our positive outlook for loan growth will materialize in the latter part of this year. Over the long-term, our loans have consistently grown at 2 to 3x the typical rate of GDP growth. And we think our competitive position will keep benefiting us once macroeconomic factors settle down. Turning to the Energy portfolio, balances shrank 7.7% for the quarter. Although commodity prices keep getting better and more stable, finding enough new deals to make up for paydowns in today's environment is still difficult, since existing borrowers keep deleveraging. Even with these factors, we stay optimistic about lending and energy-related revenue opportunities as we keep supporting our customers in this space; this industry vertical is a great illustration of how we run the bank for long-term economic outcomes rather than short-term optics. During Q1, we recorded a $14 million gain from selling energy properties, which stemmed from an equity stake we acquired via a workout during the latest downturn. We've consistently stated that we're prepared to retain foreclosed assets. While this raised nonperforming levels in the short term, we held onto those assets until market conditions improved, which means we're set to achieve a complete economic recovery on that loan. Healthcare balances stayed largely unchanged this quarter, as an increase in senior housing loans was canceled out by a decrease in hospital system loans. Looking ahead, we have strong confidence in the credit quality and growth potential of our Healthcare portfolio over the long run. As health and economic conditions move back toward normal later this year, we expect that portfolio to once again become a leading driver of growth for us. Balances on PPP loans increased by $166 million, up almost 10%, and now represent 8% of total loans. During the quarter, we originated $544 million in new PPP loans, remaining committed to our approach of focusing on our existing client base, which lets us meet those clients' needs promptly. Paydowns from the first round of loans partly offset the growth we saw from new originations this quarter. During Q4, we saw less forgiveness activity tied to prior PPP rounds than we'd projected. That created roughly a $10 million shortfall in net interest revenue versus our expectations, though it ought to just roll into later periods as forgiveness occurs. Going forward, we remain hopeful about loan growth during this year's back half, after today's extraordinary liquidity conditions settle back to usual. Given how quickly vaccines are getting distributed and the wider economic recovery underway, we believe confidence—plus the related capital investment—will return to the U.S. economy before the year is out. Let's turn to Slide 8. BOKF's credit quality is still a standout, as is evident. Throughout the loan portfolio as a whole, we saw substantial credit quality gains in the quarter, since charge-offs and criticized asset levels landed under our projections. Given that, along with commodity prices holding steady in the near term and economic metrics improving sharply, we decided to release $25 million in reserves during the quarter. Net charge-offs went from $16.7 million, or 31 basis points annualized net of PPP loans, in the fourth quarter, down to $14.5 million, or 28 basis points annualized net of PPP loans, in this quarter. If you look back across the past four quarters, net charge-offs—once you strip out PPP loans—were 31 basis points, putting us at the low end of the range where we've historically seen losses. When the quarter closed, our combined allowance for loan losses totaled $385 million, which works out to 1.86% of outstanding loans once PPP loans are excluded. On March 31, the portion of the combined allowance for credit losses tied to energy amounted to 3.29% of outstanding energy loans. Nonaccruing loans dropped substantially—down $19 million from the prior quarter—with the main driver being fewer nonaccruing energy loans. Potential problem loans ended the quarter at $422 million, a meaningful decrease from the $478 million recorded on December 31. Almost all categories of loans with possible issues declined compared with the previous quarter, with potential problem energy loans and general business loans driving that improvement. When we consider credit going forward, a certain amount of uncertainty remains in today's conditions, which makes forecasting hard. Even so, using the information available to us now, and if our economic projections prove accurate going forward, we expect net charge-offs for 2021 to remain in line with the past 12 months. We will, as we always do, maintain our reserve at the right level. Overall, we feel good about the credit picture for the remainder of the year, and that lets us keep releasing this quarter. If the path of the virus becomes clearer, with fewer cases, vaccines reaching people, and a wider return to normal economic conditions during 2021, then there may be room for us to free up more reserves in the months ahead. Turning to Slide 9. As the slide shows, brokerage and trading fee revenue declined versus the prior quarter. Looking at the brokerage and trading operation in total — both its fee income and its net interest income — results fell roughly $15 million from one quarter to the next. That drop stems mostly from activity pulling back after the record-breaking third and fourth quarters, along with tighter margins in the mortgage business, which pushed trading margins down by roughly 70 basis points versus the preceding quarter. Also, we saw a $2.1 million drop in customer hedging revenue. That was mostly because energy customers did less hedging activity than they had in a record fourth quarter. Investment banking revenue was down $2.1 million too, largely driven by the timing of loan syndication activity. At our enhanced mortgage trading desk, net interest revenue and trading revenue both declined from the record highs of 2020, and that's exactly what we expected. All the same, it's still a major reason this company performs well as a whole, and compared with the same quarter a year ago, it's still up more than 15%. On a linked quarter basis, mortgage banking revenue declined roughly $2.2 million, but it remained solid despite scarce housing inventory nationwide and rising interest rates. Margins have narrowed compared with the historic levels seen in the summer of 2020, but they are still approximately 45% higher than in March of 2020. Production volume on a total basis for this quarter was in line with what we saw in prior quarters. Going forward, limited inventory may keep supporting the idea that these elevated production levels can be sustained, since meaningful improvement in inventory will take some time. This quarter, other revenue rose $2.1 million, driven by greater revenue from repossessed oil and gas properties. Although it isn't visible on slide 9, I'd also like to note that positive $4.7 million was recorded for the quarter from net economic changes in the fair value of mortgage servicing rights and related economic hedges. I'll now pass things over to Steven, who will go through our NIM dynamics and the main balance sheet items for the quarter. Steven?
Steven Nell
executiveThanks, Stacy. Moving on to Slide 11. Our net interest revenue for the first quarter came in at $280 million, which represents a decline of roughly $17 million versus the prior quarter. Although core yields within our loan portfolio held fairly steady, a drop in average loan volumes along with the timing of loan fees — among them a $2 million decrease in PPP fees on a linked-quarter basis — weighed on net interest revenue during this quarter. Net interest margin stood at 2.62%, a decrease of 10 basis points compared to the quarter before. Reduced average outstanding loan balances, combined with reinvestment of cash flows from our available for sale securities portfolio, kept pressuring net interest margin, as the portfolio yield fell 14 basis points to 1.84%. On top of that, though we did manage to push interest-bearing deposit costs down modestly to 17 basis points, the pace of that decline was slower than in prior quarters. There are numerous moving pieces to take into account — among them continued recognition of PPP interest and fees — but the ongoing repricing of the AFS portfolio together with the shrinking room to lower interest-bearing deposit costs further will keep weighing on net interest margin in upcoming quarters. Now to Slide 12. Our approach to expense management stays disciplined, as total expenses fell 6% on a linked-quarter basis. Personnel expense declined $3.2 million, or just under 2%, this quarter. Cash-based incentive compensation was lower by $8.2 million, mostly reflecting the reduced brokerage activity referenced earlier. Deferred compensation — which is largely offset by a decline in the value of related investments recorded in other gains and losses — dropped $3.4 million. Employee benefits rose $6.4 million, largely driven by a seasonal uptick in payroll taxes and retirement plan expenses. Overall, we're quite pleased with how we've preserved the personnel cost efficiencies achieved during the pandemic, even as medical expenses climbed $1.7 million year-over-year now that employees are pursuing wellness and other treatments they put off in 2020. Non-personnel expense dropped almost $15 million, or 12%, versus the fourth quarter. A $14.1 million gain on the sale of an equity interest received through the workout of a defaulted energy loan accounted for half of that reduction, partly offset by additional expense and write-down of a set of oil and gas properties during the first quarter. The rest of the decrease in non-personnel expense came from a $1.6 million reduction in business promotion expense, a $2.3 million decrease in professional fees and services, a $1.6 million decline in recruiting expense and a $1.2 million drop in occupancy and equipment, partly offset by $2.4 million more spent on ongoing technology projects. In addition, we contributed $4 million to the BOKF Foundation during the quarter, as we remain focused on the communities we serve and the extreme needs the pandemic has created. On Slide 13, our liquidity position is still very strong, supported by continued inflows of deposit balances. Our loan-to-deposit ratio now sits below 60%, versus nearly 64% at year-end, which gives us substantial on balance sheet liquidity to address future customer needs. We also have robust capital, with a common equity Tier 1 ratio at 12.1%, which is comfortably above the minimum of our internal operating range. Given this solid capital position, we were active again in repurchasing shares, taking advantage of market conditions to buy back 260,000 shares in the open market at an average price of $77.20 each. Turning to Slide 14, I want to share a broad outlook for both the near term and the mid term. Excluding PPP effects, we think loan growth net activity will gradually pick up pace alongside the wider economic rebound this year. Our available for sale securities portfolio, mostly composed of agency mortgage-backed securities, had a yield of 1.84% in the first quarter. With rates staying low for a while, prepayments might hit about $700 million each quarter. Right now, we can put those cash flows back to work at yields of roughly 95 to 105 basis points. At 17 basis points, our view is that deposit pricing is nearing its floor. Because we are reinvesting securities at reduced rates and have little space left to cut deposit costs further, net interest margin will decline over the next several quarters. Our varied mix of fee revenue sources ought to keep offering some offset to the revenue squeeze we are experiencing in our spread businesses. We anticipate modest growth in most fee revenue categories during 2021, except for brokerage and trading and mortgage businesses, since matching the record-setting 2020 in those segments will be tough, as we noted at the end of last year. We will stick with our rigorous method of managing personnel and nonpersonnel expenses, with growth planned at low single digits for 2021. Our aim is to keep expenses in check while still honoring multiyear technology investments designed to enhance customer service and sharpen our competitive edge. Should the economy keep strengthening and oil prices become more stable this year, we could release additional loan loss reserves. As I said earlier, we are confident in our capital generation. We will keep seeking chances to buy back shares, and we will hold our quarterly cash dividend at its present level; we plan to have all staff return to the office by the close of the second quarter, thanks to better health metrics and broad vaccine availability. Now I will hand the call back to Steve Bradshaw for his closing remarks.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveThanks, Steven. On the whole, BOK Financial delivered a strong quarter. Although our Mortgage and Wealth Management units declined versus the prior quarter, they keep providing a meaningful cushion given the weak loan demand that weighed on the entire industry, and they deliver differentiated shareholder value for our company. The credit quality results we saw this quarter demonstrate not just how effectively we've navigated the continuing crisis, but even more so our capacity to stay disciplined about credit decisions during the more favorable stretches of the cycle; we share the view of most forecasters that we're at the edge of a stretch of swift economic expansion as we move toward the back half of this year, and we think that will turn into loan growth — an area where BOKF has never been positioned better than it is right now to capitalize. Looking at the short term, as Steven said when giving his outlook, we plan to have every employee back in the office before the second quarter ends, thanks to improving health metrics and broad vaccine availability; we recognize that we're better together and expect this to serve as one more positive catalyst for our work to build relationships and bring in new ones during the second half of this year. Having said that, we're happy to take your questions. Operator?
Peter Winter
analystI want to ask a question about the pipeline for loans. Could you give us some additional color on the tailwind that you're expecting, based only on the discussions that you're having with customers? And after that, how about the amount of excess liquidity that's sitting on our balance sheets, and how that influences their ability and willingness to borrow?
Stacy Kymes
executiveSure. I'll take the loan pipeline, and then I'll pass it over to Steven for the excess liquidities. I think if you — we're seeing opportunities, and pipelines are growing really across the lending segment. But the level of liquidity that exists on our clients' balance sheets is still very high. When you examine why our loan book didn't expand this quarter, two areas that usually drive our growth stand out. Energy and commercial real estate both declined more sharply than we'd typically expect. On the fourth quarter call, I mentioned that we expected energy might be nearing a bottom or an inflection point. We hoped it would happen in the first quarter, though we figured the second quarter was more probable. Today I'm more confident that energy will reach that inflection point in the second quarter as payoffs start working through. Energy prices during the first quarter were quite strong. A lot of those people take the additional cash flow and use it to reduce what they owe; in commercial real estate we saw a few oddities, with paydowns running at a higher level during the first quarter. That segment will expand at a healthy pace; so my sense is that after things settle down and it starts posting growth once more, it's essentially hiding some solid activity we're looking forward to. And our hopes remain for the back half of the year. We feel quite confident that you'll start to observe meaningful loan growth emerging from that portfolio, and that's the reason we called out utilization in what we said. A significant portion of our growth will come naturally from improved utilization of existing credit lines, especially within our C&I portfolio. So when core economic activity comes back, I believe we'll see meaningful upticks in line usage that, on top of bringing in new customers, will support loan growth during the back half of the year. That gives us confidence. Obviously, forecasting this is difficult. Your customers are sitting on plenty of liquidity, yet there's substantial stimulus already in play, and additional stimulus has been put forward. Our expectation is that this will drive more economic activity, which should naturally boost lending volume. Still, our confidence in this is high, and we're equally confident in the caliber of the loans we're bringing on. Our attention stays on areas that can last and that fit within our credit parameters over the long haul. So we're not going to chase lending volume merely to meet market expectations; rather, we'll stay dedicated to that foundational lending expansion that has served us remarkably well over a very long period. At this point, I'll turn it over to Steven to cover the surplus liquidity.
Steven Nell
executiveAbsolutely, Peter. If I compare where our average deposits stood just 12 months earlier, the increase comes to $8.3 billion, or 29%, and $4.2 billion of that sits within our commercial portfolios, meaning commercial clients, which works out to a 35% rise. So it's obvious, exactly as you noted, that there's a substantial amount of liquidity sitting on balance sheets. As for how that factors in — when it actually gets put to work, and whether a portion of it gets deployed ahead of the loan growth Stacy feels quite confident about, that's possible, though none of us has that answer; so yes, considerable liquidity, and it very well could contribute to some of it being drawn down before we see any line utilization pick up; we simply can't say how much.
Stacy Kymes
executiveYet when you look closely at that liquidity, a good chunk of it simply reflects how solid our franchise is at its core. Even as the expense tied to interest-bearing deposits keeps falling each quarter relative to the one before, we're still bringing in top-tier customers along with their deposits. What we've achieved on that front across the past 12 months is genuinely impressive; despite the reality that we aren't compensating at an elevated rate for those deposits, we'll keep drawing them in, which truly highlights the underlying franchise worth of BOK Financial.
Peter Winter
analystCould I ask one more thing, specifically about the utilization of these lines? Stacy, you noted that utilization on the core portfolio has moved from 65% down to 58% as of today. For each single percentage point of improvement in line utilization, what's the effect on commercial loans? And by the time we reach year-end, how far do you believe it might climb?
Stacy Kymes
executiveBroadly speaking, $150 million corresponds to 1%, give or take around that figure. From that point you can run the numbers yourself and form your own view. Pre-COVID serves as our benchmark of sorts; we considered that stretch to be a fair representation for line utilization. Should economic activity come in stronger than what existed pre-COVID, which is probably likely, line utilization will then be higher and will surpass where we stood pre-COVID.
Will Jones
analystThis is Bill Jones, filling in for Brady Gailey. I'll just build on the loan growth discussion for a moment. When I think about loans overall, I recognize energy has really been a significant drag recently. Do you think balances right now are at a low point for the entire portfolio? Or do you think additional contraction might still be ahead?
Stacy Kymes
executiveWell, I'd say if you examine what we refer to as the core loan portfolio — on Slide 7, where we separate out the Paycheck Protection Program — I believe those loans will run their course. So if you look at that, it could create some headwind going forward as they get forgiven and roll off. But within the core portfolio, energy has clearly been the headwind. During this quarter, real estate was a headwind as well, which is — which historically is a segment we've grown fairly steadily over time. The inflection point, I believe, comes in the second quarter, whether that's April, May or June, I'm not sure. But I do think we'll hit the inflection point where we kind of bottom out in the second quarter at some point. And then from that level, we begin to grow back. We're seeing opportunities in Energy. I think even the rise in commodity prices, in my view, in the first quarter led to — resulted in a higher level of paydown activity than even what we were anticipating and forecasting, because those borrowers weren't using that cash flow for CapEx. They were using it to continue paying down revolver. So I think we're within a quarter here of reaching that inflection point, and then you'll begin to see loans begin to grow back. As we've pointed to now for 2 quarters, second half of '21 is really when we're expecting the core loan growth to return.
Will Jones
analystExcellent; that's fantastic context. And it's truly encouraging to hear that positive outlook regarding Energy. I hope it comes to fruition. And this is my final one. I simply wanted to shift to — just considering M&A. I realize BOKF has traditionally been quite discerning when it comes to pricing deals and picking targets, but there's been a tremendous amount of activity already in this year, such as Cadence and BancorpSouth, which was — I mean, quite literally right in your own region. I'm just wondering what you think about a deal of that scale — would BOK ever have interest in something like that? And speaking more generally, how busy do you believe BOK might be with M&A during this year?
Steve Bradshaw
executiveYes. This is Steve Bradshaw. I'll handle that question. We definitely recognize what is happening across the financial industry when it comes to consolidation. In fact, it appears somewhat more intense among banks of comparable size to BOKF, such as those 2 you referenced; and I believe — from my perspective, there are 2 primary reasons for that, one being the chance or the wish to extend the cost structure across a wider base. And that will interest us. And in our latest deals, that has been a crucial component for us too. The second reason is genuinely technology investment, and you hear that brought up repeatedly. I'll say that we don't experience that same sense of competitive pressure since we haven't paused at all. We've kept putting money into technology as a growing share of our revenues, really over the past 5 or 6 years and beyond; and we like our competitive standing and believe we are where we should be and can compete with large investment firms as well as national banks in the upmarket segment; so that isn't as strong a driver for us; so we essentially return to our fundamental conviction about M&A. We truly want to find banks mostly inside our footprint that are top quality, have excellent staff and leadership teams, and possess a wide business foundation. Now we don't anticipate them having an identical base to ours since we're distinctive even compared with our peers. But we want to see more than just a big real estate book, honestly. Because we will need to — once we achieve those energy — not energy, rather expense synergies, we must expand it moving forward; and so our approach is essentially that we treat revenue as the benchmark for our acquisitions — can we bring in a target that we believe would contribute to revenue going forward. Your — the other portion of your question concerned size, really. Yes, at the size we stand today, it would need to be a more substantial deal for us than anything we've completed previously. Our latest purchase came in at roughly $4 billion of assets, and for anything to genuinely shift the needle on cost savings and top-line growth—and justify the cultural disruption that comes with folding one company into another—the size would have to exceed that figure. That's a long reply to a brief question, yet I realize it's top of mind for everyone, given how much activity we've witnessed and the deals announced, including some just this week. Still, that captures our thinking. Looking ahead, we'd anticipate having a chance to take part in acquisitions; however, the kind of bank I just outlined probably isn't a seller in the current economic climate. My sense is we'll need to observe economic expansion and sustainability before banks sitting squarely in our sweet spot conclude that merging makes good sense.
Brett Rabatin
analystSteven, congratulations on the retirement you have planned.
Steve Bradshaw
executiveThanks. I appreciate that.
Brett Rabatin
analystI guess my first question is about the reserve, and specifically how you're thinking about releasing reserves going forward. Before CECL, your reserve had dropped under 1%. So I'm curious — in this new CECL environment, where could that reserve ultimately land, if the economy turns into something like a roaring 20s scenario where conditions are really strong? How do you see the reserve potentially declining from where it stands now?
Marc Maun
executiveYes, Marc Maun here. Let me start by reminding everyone that when CECL took effect, a day 1 adjustment to the reserve was required. So prior to the pandemic's impact and everything else affecting our reserve, we had built it up to 1.2% — meaning it rose above that sub-1% mark. After that, we added further reserves tied to the economic downturn and the pandemic. As we look at where the reserve goes from here, we'll factor in economic conditions and our credit quality metrics — both of which, in our view, should keep getting better over the course of this year — and loan growth will be the other piece. Given how that plays in, we want to be certain we're keeping it at the right level to handle it. With all of that combined, our hope is it comes back down to that 1.2% mark, though it will depend on a mix of funding loan growth and possible releases tied to credit quality and the economic outlook.
Brett Rabatin
analystAlright, that's reasonable. Now moving to fee income — the guidance, or whatever you'd prefer to label it — suggests those categories will see modest growth, apart from brokerage and trading plus mortgage. Could you share any perspective on mortgage going forward? Are gain on sale margins likely to keep shrinking, or did 1Q basically capture all the strain coming from the volume levels we had before? Then second, regarding brokerage and trading, we've clearly had volatility across the past 2 quarters. Maybe give us some sense of how that unfolds? Does volatility also drive flows in that business?
Stacy Kymes
executiveSure. Stacy here. Scott Grauer is also with us, and he can add color on the wealth side too. As far as mortgage goes, I'd say our outlook entering the second quarter is positive. Mortgage activity has a seasonal pattern, with the second and third quarters typically being fairly strong from an activity standpoint. That gives us a bit of a tailwind. Gain on sale margins have thinned somewhat, yet relative to what's typical for this business, they remain quite healthy. So that's still a very good position to be in. Despite the decline, they're still quite robust. Some pressure could emerge, but at least based on what we see right now, it doesn't look like we're heading back to pre-COVID levels, so to speak, in terms of where that stands. So we — regarding mortgage, I'm optimistic about the coming couple of quarters. I'm very optimistic about growth in our Wealth business, brokerage and trading revenue more broadly, and everything taking place there. What you witnessed in the first quarter genuinely strikes us as a number we can perform really well with and perhaps even beat as we move into the second quarter — especially since it's a sustainable figure and one we believe we can grow modestly from, as Steven mentioned during his prepared remarks. So in both of those businesses, we're pleased with our positioning. They are volatile. Looking at it, the overall Wealth business, Brokerage and Trading — both the NIR and the Brokerage and Trading fee revenue component, meaning total revenue for that business — is up 15% first quarter over first quarter. So you face that difficult comparison against the fourth quarter, which was simply a record. And I don't want to overlook the reality that this core business has expanded considerably. We keep dedicating capital to it as well. Our capital commitment to the Wealth business has risen over 50% versus this time a year ago, and we'll keep backing it, since we genuinely like that business.
Jon Rau
analystThis is Jon Rau, filling in for Jared. I suppose, staying with the Wealth segment, if we look at assets under management and administration, it was more or less flat versus the prior quarter. And you brought up the $2 billion gain in equity balances as well. Could you provide any detail on, I suppose, what the gap between inflows or outflows and market value movements was that drove that balance?
Scott Grauer
executiveCertainly. This is Scott Grauer speaking. And if you look at our total AUMA, we were in fact quite happy with net inflows during the first quarter. Throughout the first quarter, we had very sizable planned distributions of assets, much of that within our Corporate Trust group. As a result, we had total disbursements of more than $11 billion in the first quarter. And so we recorded net sales — new sales — of more than $10 billion. So there really was, kind of, a modest market increase in that total AUMA.
Stacy Kymes
executiveIt appears that Q1 typically represents the peak period in terms of those distributions. That's really the main driver behind it.
Jon Rau
analystAll right, that's useful. Then, I suppose, if we're discussing the equity buildup within that segment — is this more of a long-term thing? Or would you prefer it lean more heavily toward equities, perhaps to shield the margin somewhat better, at a high level, I mean? What's your thinking there?
Scott Grauer
executiveYeah. So in fact, we're — our allocation and how it's distributed across asset classes suits us; we've kept observing, just as broader markets have, that with fixed income offering these nominal yields and real yields, equities clearly carry stronger momentum when it comes to asset flows. Looking at the close of the first quarter, we were — simply to share the allocation, we stood at 12% cash, 42% fixed income, 38% equities, plus roughly 8% in alternatives. And that mix holds steady; the mix we're seeing reflects the assets and aligns with our target allocations. So that distribution feels right to us for weathering and growing no matter how rates and equity markets perform; so we're comfortable with it; we'll always pursue efforts aimed at expanding our equity inflows, since that's where flows broadly end up positive across the whole market.
Matt Olney
analystThanks. I'd like to return to what we discussed regarding loan growth, and you addressed the energy subject quite thoroughly. What I wanted to inquire about is commercial real estate. At this bank it isn't especially big, yet we observed a fairly sizable drop during the first quarter. Could you shed light on what caused that decrease? Also, how do you see commercial real estate going forward?
Stacy Kymes
executiveNo. Our feelings about the portfolio are positive. What I mean is, you'd want — from our standpoint at least, you'd want a commercial real estate portfolio containing a certain amount of churn, which signals that deals are doing well and are able to be refinanced over the long term in the permanent financing market, be that Lifeco, CMBS, or something else. During 2020, owing to the pandemic, we witnessed the smallest amount of payoffs stemming from movement into the permanent financing market that we've observed across the past 10 years, without question; therefore what you noticed in the first quarter was actually more of a going back to normal in terms of typical paydowns, where things are shifting. Perhaps the level was somewhat greater because there was some accumulated opportunity sitting there. With commercial real estate, growth as well as paydowns have a tendency to be uneven, and it's best to examine them across a 12-month horizon rather than something like linked quarter annualized. Things will be fine for us there. We believe we'll see solid growth in commercial real estate during this year. There will simply be some unevenness between quarters as those advances occur; after that, the refi's moving into the permanent financing market — nonrecourse, long-term Lifeco style arrangements — will exit the portfolio; and in our eyes, that indicates a healthy portfolio. That's how we see it.
Matt Olney
analystAll right. Stacy, moving to the Healthcare segment — I believe balances overall stayed fairly flat during Q1, though there was something of a composition change, with gains in senior housing alongside paydowns and hospital. Could you share anything further? And does that represent some sort of turning point we witnessed in the first quarter?
Stacy Kymes
executiveYeah. My view is that it does represent the turning point. A number of hospital systems had drawn up ahead of COVID, along with the costs tied to that. I believe we observed something like the tail end of that during Q1, when those balances were paid back down, and after that you started to see core growth in senior housing return. We are genuinely seeing strong metrics emerge from our portfolios within senior housing. We can track them weekly. We're observing occupancy climbing back at a pace of nearly 1% each month across our core senior housing portfolio; so as soon as that portfolio truly starts to stabilize, we do believe there is a certain amount of pent-up acquisition activity waiting to occur there, which would drive loan growth within the Healthcare segment. Our team is excellent. We're positioned well for that. And my expectation is that this keeps being a growth driver for BOK Financial.
Gary Tenner
analystI'd like to ask how you're approaching the management of the balance sheet in general across this year. You're pretty much fully invested. In the securities portfolio, it appears you hold a certain amount of excess balances, though not close to the — perhaps the extreme some other banks have of several billion in cash. And I'm simply curious how you're weighing the possibility of some change in deposit flows across this year, as your customers draw on their liquidity and deploy it, particularly given the low rates you mentioned when it comes to reinvestment?
Steven Nell
executiveYes. This is Steven. If you look at the full year, our available for sale securities portfolio ended up $1.8 billion larger. That works out to about 15%, so in a way we put some of the liquidity that came in to work across the year; during the first quarter specifically, we added $400 million. Going forward, my expectation is that we'll reinvest cash flows. Still, with the yield curve being steep — or a bit steeper — I don't think you'll see us push that securities portfolio much further through leverage, so to speak. Where the balance sheet stands now is something I'm fairly comfortable with. We don't take that risk; in past periods, we never moved toward being asset-sensitive. If you consider a 100 basis point instantaneous move, we'd be roughly 2.5% asset sensitive on a forward basis, and honestly that's a solid position for us. We feel good about it. So when we think about the securities portfolio — which serves as the main tool we use to control interest rate risk at this bank — that's really the consideration. And we aim to keep it fairly steady by putting cash flows back to work, and those flows are actually somewhat stronger than what we saw a quarter ago. It seems our cash flow pace has eased a little. On top of that, the rates we're reinvesting at are somewhat better than they were during the prior quarter, which also helps.
Stacy Kymes
executiveOne more item — it's Stacy here — that I might address, especially as all of you are considering and discussing this: you begin to anticipate greater asset sensitivity. If you examine the different disclosures on that subject, a whole set of assumptions feeds into that sensitivity analysis. And getting true apples-to-apples comparisons throughout the regional bank landscape, in terms of precisely how people approach that, is extremely difficult. However, I would urge the analyst community to instead examine the actual results from the most recent period when rates rose. I mean, consider it — we had a recent pre-COVID cycle during which rates were climbing, and you could genuinely observe how folks' balance sheets performed because of it. In many respects, I believe that serves as a superior indicator compared with what people will project through their Q and K regarding asset sensitivity as we look ahead.
Gary Tenner
analystSteven, let me return to what I asked at the start — sorry if my wording wasn't clear. What I meant to get at, I think, is this: since your balance sheet doesn't carry as much excess liquidity, do you have — are there — no real worries on your end about customer deposits draining away as some stimulus gets used up, when other banks are sitting on far more excess liquidity? So I'm basically asking how you view that situation.
Steven Nell
executiveNo, that isn't quite it. I don't believe we do. What I touched on before was how those balances grew. In Scott's area, Wealth, there's been a rise of a couple of billion. Some of that could leave down the road if people locate other spots to put their money. Still, I don't think we're overly worried about it all disappearing in the near term.
Gary Tenner
analystAll right, that sounds good. Then, to build a bit on what Stacy mentioned, Steven, could you give us a brief rundown of how BOKF sits within the loan portfolio when it comes to variable versus fixed rate loans, and also what effect floors might have as rates move higher?
Steven Nell
executiveSure, I can address that. Roughly 70% of our loans are variable, or they reprice inside a year. So that should give you a sense of it. Out of the $22 billion loan portfolio, around $3.8 billion — maybe $3.4 billion — has floors built in. Those floors are providing us roughly $18 million to $20 million on an annualized basis, and they're helping NIM by about 4 basis points.
Gary Tenner
analystOkay, one final item, and I'll try to fit in 1 more question. Regarding PPP, now that the second round has been added, could you share how much in total fees has not yet been recognized through that line?
Steven Nell
executiveSure, I can address that. For the initial 2020 fundings under PPP, which came to $2.3 billion, the related fees were roughly $59 million; regarding the first quarter 2021 fundings in this latest round, there are fees of approximately $23 million tied to it. That adds up to roughly $82 million. In 2020, we recognized $36 million. We expect to recognize approximately $30 million during 2021; after that, we'll observe how the remaining amount plays out, though probably the bulk of that leftover balance lands in 2022.
Gary Tenner
analystAll right. And out of the $30 million that you're anticipating for '21, what portion got recognized during the first quarter?
Steven Nell
executiveRoughly $11 million, and that's only the fees. Then there's the interest, plus naturally the cost of funds tied to it — tied to that 1%. So altogether, the first quarter's total PPP NIR benefit came to roughly $14 million, a slight decrease versus the fourth quarter. That's among the factors behind our NIM dropping somewhat more than we had anticipated, purely as a result of that PPP activity; though that's likely just a timing shift into upcoming quarters.
Jennifer Demba
analystOver the coming several years, what's your thinking on competition in energy lending? Some of your rivals have sort of pulled back from that area, indicating they might have reduced appetite there, particularly in the near term. What's your expectation for how this unfolds?
Stacy Kymes
executiveWe believe the outcome favors us. When you consider it, energy loans currently make up roughly 13% of our portfolio, I suppose. At one point we reached 22%. We're ready to deploy substantial capital into this area. Looking ahead, I believe that opens up opportunity for us. We've frequently discussed what we appreciate about Energy: capturing the complete wallet share of clients. That means we handle derivatives trading. We serve the executive team through the private bank business. We manage their 401(k); we handle their deposit business. Plus, we achieve strong risk-adjusted spreads in that segment too; so we're fond of — as we peer ahead across the next 2, 3, 4, 5 years, we're quite positive on this business's profile and the chance to expand it, since as you pointed out, you've got certain smaller competitors exiting it. What will be fascinating to observe is that it's simple to exit that business when commodity prices are tough and executives must address asset quality during an earnings call. Once you generate solid results in this business moving forward, you might find some people re-entering the business, especially within our footprint; but we're genuinely thrilled about our current positioning. Consider our standing in the league tables compared to production in this business — we compete effectively with the biggest national banks in this space. So as this sector starts to recover, and I've seen some information just in the past week discussing global storage levels being at pre-COVID levels now. However, demand levels aren't at pre-COVID levels; so if you simply follow that logic through, I believe there might be additional tailwind for certain prices in the short-term, which would be beneficial; but I think we truly favor the business. We appreciate our position within the business. In my view, there's no superior energy team anywhere in the country compared to BOK Financial. So we're eager to expand the business.
Steven Nell
executiveAll right. Once more, I want to thank each of you for being with us on this call. We’re grateful for the interest you’ve shown in BOK Financial. Should anything else come to mind, feel free to reach out by phone at (918) 595 to 3030, or send a message to ir@bokf.com. I hope the rest of your day goes well. Thanks so much.
Operator
operatorThanks. That wraps up the call for today. At this point, you're free to hang up your lines. We appreciate you taking part.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete BOK Financial Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to BOK Financial Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in BOK Financial Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.