BOK Financial Corporation (BOKF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 20, 2021

NASDAQ US Financials Banks earnings 50 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Steven Nell

executive
#1

Hello, everyone, and thank you for being with us this morning. Our Chief Executive Officer, Steve Bradshaw, is going to start things off with some opening remarks, and then Stacy Kymes, who serves as our Chief Operating Officer, will walk through the loan portfolio, credit metrics, and fee income businesses. After that, I will share specifics on net interest income, net interest margin, expenses, and where we stand overall on the balance sheet when it comes to liquidity and capital. For the Q&A portion, we have Marc Maun, our Chief Credit Officer, with us, and he can address detailed questions about credit metrics, along with Scott Grauer, Executive Vice President of Wealth Management, who can speak further about our wealth management activities. You can find PDFs of both the slide presentation and the third quarter press release on our website, bokf.com. Please take note of the disclaimers on slide two, which apply to any forward-looking statements we make on this call. At this point, I'll hand things over to Steve Bradshaw.

Steve Bradshaw

executive
#2

Good morning, and thank you for being here as we go over our financial results for the third quarter of 2021. Once again this quarter, our strategy of diversifying revenue streams proved to be a major advantage, as pre-tax, pre-provision earnings rose 22% from the prior quarter and net income surpassed $180 million for the first time ever in our company's history. As you can see on slide four, net income for the third quarter reached a record $188.3 million, or $2.74 per diluted share; this marks a 13% increase over the record we set in the previous quarter, reflecting our longstanding dedication to a balanced earnings model and the wide range of our business capabilities. Several key factors drove our success this quarter: first, our fee-based business units kept delivering strong results, with total fees and commissions climbing $21 million, or 12%, compared to last quarter. Our wealth management team's contribution keeps expanding and influencing our results, setting a new quarterly record for total revenues at $153 million this quarter. That represents 30% of the company's total revenues and 51% of total fees and commissions for the quarter. Mortgage fees also rose $5.1 million, or 24%, quarter over quarter, largely because our reported margins rebounded from the lows we saw last quarter. Net interest revenue stayed the same versus the prior quarter, with a modest gain in loan fees, mainly from non-use fees tied to low utilization levels, and our cost of funds on interest-bearing deposits dropped another 1 basis point this quarter. We're still seeing some yield compression in our available for sale portfolio. However, that was more than made up for by better yields in our trading portfolio. Improved market conditions and credit trends let us release $23 million from our loan loss reserve this quarter, and $83 million for the year. Our expense management remains outstanding. Total expense held steady from the prior quarter. We've kept expense growth to just a bit over 2% across the last two trailing 12-month periods, even with substantial investments in technology and cyber, which shows our disciplined approach. Now looking at slide five, total loans declined $1.1 billion this quarter, though PPP loan forgiveness makes up $586 million of that decrease. Core loan growth stayed difficult this quarter, since our energy and commercial real estate clients keep paying down debt or refinancing in the long-term markets. Loans tied to our wealth segment increased $32 million this quarter, pushing them past $2 billion in outstanding balances for the first time. Our core C&I book shrank at a rate comparable to last quarter, as overall line utilization levels sit at five-year lows. We think this sets us up for growth once the economy keeps rebounding and supply chain disruptions get resolved. Average deposits rose another $344 million this quarter and stand 9% above the same quarter last year. Custody accounts hold our assets under management, and during the quarter our wealth management operation expanded 2.3% versus the prior quarter, reaching $98.8 billion, getting close to the $100 billion milestone, driven mostly by acquiring new business and supportive market movement in that period. Before we begin the question-and-answer portion, I'll share a bit more context regarding these results. At this point, Stacy Kymes is going to walk through the loan portfolio, our credit metrics, and the fee businesses in greater depth. Over to you, Stacy.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#3

Thank you, Steve. If you’ll move with me to slide seven, loans at period-end within our core portfolio came to $19.8 billion, a decline of just over 2% quarter over quarter, since we keep observing borrowers in certain specialty lending segments further cutting back on leverage. On the whole, utilization levels for commercial and specialized lending lines dropped once more this quarter, marking their lowest point in more than five years, and the one exception to that pattern is our private wealth area, which expanded at a 6% annualized rate compared with the linked quarter and 12% over the trailing 12 months. Energy balances shrank during the third quarter, because energy borrowers hold substantial liquidity given today’s oil and natural gas prices and have mostly been paying down what they owe; we keep adding new customers in this area, yet repayments have been exceeding new originations. Our present view is that the fourth quarter will mark the inflection point, and we anticipate growth from this segment in 2022. If drilling activity were to rise materially, the company is positioned well to achieve strong growth in this sector, thanks to our long-standing expertise and our ongoing strong commitment to the energy sector. For this segment, fee revenue hit an all-time high this quarter thanks to ancillary operations tied to customer hedging, investment banking, and treasury — coming in 9% above the prior record set in Q3 of last year. On a linked quarter basis, healthcare balances slipped a bit, down $34 million, or 1%, driven largely by our senior housing assisted living business. Looking ahead, we remain highly confident about our ability to deliver on growth as well as credit within this portfolio, given that it continues to be a leader for us. As for core middle market C&I, utilization now stands at its lowest point across any period we've measured since March 2015, dipping under 50% for the first time. We have a lot of room to grow when demand comes back, and we don't need to bring on new customers to do it. If utilization simply returns to more normal levels, that alone would produce about $600 million in core C&I loans organically, on top of what we anticipate from the specialty businesses. Balances fell again this quarter, but overall the C&I book is beginning to level out, which makes us feel encouraged going into next year. On commercial real estate, balances were down 3% for the quarter; borrowers continue to refinance into the long-term fixed rate non-recourse market to take advantage of low rates. Portfolio turnover in 2020 was one of the worst years real estate has seen, because a lot of the permanent markets remained hesitant. With those markets now open again, there's some catch-up happening — that's naturally a good sign for a healthy portfolio, but it does keep creating swings from quarter to quarter. I expect balances to level off in Q4 and get back to a more typical growth trajectory in 2022. Once again this quarter, PPP loan forgiveness came in at a substantial level — $586 million was forgiven, cutting the portfolio down by 52%. Of the PPP balances still outstanding, only 4% of the 2020 vintage remains, along with 66% of the 2021 vintage. We anticipate that the pace of forgiveness on the balances that remain will drop off quite a bit. Looking forward into 2022, we feel we're in a strong position for a loan growth cycle that's more normal. Once the constraints in the supply chain loosen and the full effect of fiscal stimulus comes through, we think BOKF will be positioned well for loan growth that accelerates. If you turn to slide eight, it's clear that credit quality keeps getting better as we put more distance between ourselves and the pandemic. Across the wider loan portfolio, we keep seeing meaningful gains in credit quality, with non-performing assets and potential problem loans each falling substantially once again in this quarter. If you look at total commitments, this is the first time we've dropped back below where we stood in the fourth quarter of 2019, before the pandemic, for total criticized assets tied to lending activities. Those items, combined with commodity prices that keep holding up well and an economic outlook that remains positive for both GDP and the labor markets, led us to free up $23 million of reserves in the quarter. Net charge-offs totaled $7.8 million, which works out to 16 basis points annualized once PPP loans are excluded for the third quarter. That compares with $15.4 million, or 30 basis points annualized, during the prior quarter. Across the last four quarters, average net charge-offs have declined to 26 basis points, a figure that falls within the bottom portion of our historical loss range. Looking ahead to the coming quarter, we anticipate that net charge-offs will land in that same lower part of our historical range. Our total allowance for loan losses stood at $306 million, equivalent to 1.54% of loans outstanding at quarter end, once Triple P loans are excluded. Non-accruing loans decreased by $38 million versus the prior quarter, driven primarily by a decline in non-accruing energy loans. As of quarter end, potential problem loans totaled $333 million, a substantial drop from $384 million on June the 30th. Looking at loans, we saw quarter-over-quarter declines across energy, services, and general business categories. Moving to slide nine, the standout item there is the exceptional third quarter turned in by our Wealth Management group — it was a record. For the quarter, total revenues in Wealth Management came in at $153 million, which is an increase of almost 17% versus the linked quarter and 14% higher than the prior record, which was established in the third quarter of 2020. That figure covers the fee income lines visible to investors on our corporate income statement — brokerage and trading, plus fiduciary and asset management — along with net interest income derived from loans and deposits within our Private Wealth Group, and net interest income produced through the Brokerage and Institutional Trading Group. One area that really stands out is the banking products and services we offer to Private Wealth clients. This quarter, the total loan portfolio went past $2 billion in balances, which is a 12% increase, or $221 million, over the same quarter last year. Our deposit portfolio finished the quarter at $3.9 billion, rising 3% from the prior quarter and 12% versus the same quarter a year ago. Total net interest income keeps climbing, posting a 3% gain linked quarter. On the brokerage and trading side, revenues overall were $15.4 million higher, amounting to 25% on a linked-quarter basis. The main driver here is a change we made to product strategy back in the second quarter within our institutional trading and sales business, along with the addition of new financial institution clients. That supports what we told you last quarter — namely, that this repositioning of product focus together with a broader customer base can be sustained. We have confidence that a healthy pace of activity and revenue generation will continue across our MBS operations company-wide. In this segment, we expect our capital commitment to stay fairly level for the foreseeable future; separately, over in wealth management, fiduciary and asset management fees rose nearly 1% on a linked-quarter basis and 13% versus the same quarter last year; worth keeping in mind is that the second quarter carries the annual tax preparation fees, so growth layered on top of that matters, and it ties to our strong expansion in assets under management, which now stand at $98.8 billion. Although favorable equity markets have clearly lifted customer account balances, sales activity in this area also continues to be robust. The present composition of our assets under management is 41% fixed income, 39% equities, 12% cash, and 8% alternatives.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#4

The way we do business, built around relationships, fits exactly with what clients require right now, since we keep witnessing both institutions and individuals holding on to the greater value they place on financial guidance that they picked up over the last 18 months. Revenue from transaction cards barely moved in this quarter, yet it rose 5% versus the identical quarter a year ago. That's mostly attributable to stimulus programs along with the wider reopening of the U.S. economy. Fees for deposit services climbed $1.6 million, which is 6%, during this quarter, since we've seen better customer spending behavior. Revenue from mortgage banking went up $5.1 million, meaning 24% on a linked-quarter basis, chiefly because our mortgage commitments were valued more favorably quarter over quarter. On the whole, mortgage commitment volumes stayed fairly steady during the third quarter, though valuations looked better than those of the second quarter, which had been pushed down mostly by falling industry refinance production volumes. Even with that shift in the unrealized mark to market from one quarter to the next, settlement margins in reality have slipped somewhat — a pattern we've observed throughout the year and anticipate continuing into the fourth quarter. Constraints on housing inventory across the industry keep weighing on the market. There was a bit of encouraging news regarding housing, since Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac each flipped their stance on preferred stock purchase agreement delivery limits for second homes and investment properties, something that ought to help us in our Colorado and Arizona markets. Other revenue fell $4.3 million on a linked-quarter basis, which came from selling a repossessed asset tied to oil and gas properties. Though it isn't shown on slide nine, I'd like to point out that net economic changes in the fair value of mortgage servicing rights along with related economic hedges came to a positive $7.3 million for the quarter. Within our total other operating revenue, yet absent from slide nine, sits a $31 million net gain stemming from what our alternative investment group did; that group's focus is supplying equity and debt capital to businesses that are growing, a number of which have been solid BOK Financial customers; this business is extremely long-term, and its portfolio has expanded to $75 million invested across 11 portfolio companies. We anticipate that this area will add to earnings in the future, even if it does so in a rather intermittent fashion. At this point I'll hand the call to Steven so he can discuss our NIM dynamics and the key balance sheet items for the quarter. Steven?

Steven Nell

executive
#5

Appreciate that, Stacy. Turning to slide 11, net interest revenue landed at $280 million in Q3, essentially unchanged from the quarter before. Compared with Q2, average earning assets fell $892 million, and average loan balances were lower by $1.3 billion, with PPP balances accounting for $875 million of that drop. Average core loan balances decreased $443 million. On the other side, average available for sale securities climbed $203 million, because we continue to plow most of the quarterly cash flows from that portfolio back in. Average trading securities increased $187 million, which supports our brokerage and trading business. Average total deposits grew $344 million, while non-interest deposits were up $480 million in the quarter, and that provides a lift to net interest income. This quarter, we were able to pay off the $150 million in subordinated debt, which will reduce interest costs by about $8 million each year. Our net interest margin was 2.66%, an increase of 6 basis points compared to the previous quarter, primarily because of PPP forgiveness activity in Q2 and Q3. In Q2, PPP loans contributed 2 basis points to net interest margin, and in Q3 they added 7 basis points. Removing the entire PPP effect from the margins would bring net interest margin to roughly 2.58% for both quarters. Average yields fell 5 basis points on a linked quarter basis, largely as a result of reinvesting cash flows from our available for sale securities portfolio. Beyond that, we continued to successfully lower the cost of interest bearing deposits by an additional 1 basis point, bringing the quarterly average to 13 basis points. In our view, the core margin has stabilized, and the coming quarter will reflect a complete period of benefit from the sub-debt call made last quarter. Taking that into account, and setting aside any PPP effects, our net interest margin projection is approximately 2.6%. We see no movement higher in net interest margin before rates begin to climb once more. Looking ahead, it's possible we'll see rate increases within roughly the next twelve months, so it's worth recalling our performance in the prior cycle of hikes, 2015 through 2019, when we landed in the upper or top quartile among regional banks. We can't promise a repeat of that outcome, but little suggests to us that things would play out in a materially different way; as a matter of fact, today's system holds even more liquidity than it did ahead of that earlier cycle of increases, which ought to lessen the pressure on the market to raise rates rapidly. If you'll turn to slide 12, you'll see that our approach to managing expenses stays prudent, since total expenses came in flat versus the linked quarter and fell 2% from the same quarter a year ago. On a linked-quarter basis, personnel costs came in $3.8 million higher, a 2% rise. The main driver was compensation tied to sales, though that was more than made up for by the overall strength of revenue gains. Another factor pushing costs down was the usual seasonal drop in payroll taxes. Regular compensation expense held steady. Taking everything into account, we're quite pleased that we've been able to preserve the personnel cost efficiencies we achieved during the pandemic, and we anticipate maintaining them moving forward. Non-personnel expense declined by $3.7 million in the quarter. Expenses associated with repossessed real estate fell $6 million this quarter, as we sold off the oil and gas holdings responsible for those charges. Mortgage banking expenses came down by $2.2 million, reflecting fewer prepayments along with reduced accruals for default servicing and loss mitigation work on loans we service for other parties. Spending on data processing and communication rose by $2 million, driven by a range of project investments. Turning to slide 13, our liquidity standing is still quite robust. The loan-to-deposit ratio went from 57% in the prior quarter to slightly under 53% as of September 30th, mainly because PPP balances shrank considerably once again this quarter. This sizable amount of on-balance sheet liquidity means we are well prepared to serve customer needs going forward. We're in a really strong spot when it comes to capital — our common equity Tier 1 ratio sits at 12.3%, which gives us plenty of room above the range we target internally. Because our capital position is so healthy, we went ahead and repurchased shares again, picking up 478,000 of them in the open market when the opportunity looked good, at an average of $85 apiece. Now if you turn to slide 14, I want to offer some thoughts as we head into the 2022 budgeting process; we're expecting net activity and loan growth to improve, and we believe our company is positioned for positive growth once borrower demand returns and utilization on our lines gets back to normal levels; we also expect the total loan loss reserve as a share of loan balances to continue drifting back toward where it stood before the pandemic. Core net interest margin has leveled off. We could encounter mild downward pressure as our available-for-sale securities portfolio keeps repricing, yet the considerable strain on net interest margin over the past year is mostly behind us. Our varied portfolio of fee revenue streams should stay solid and will keep offering strong support to total revenue. We will maintain our disciplined approach to managing personnel and non-personnel costs, with total expense levels anticipated to be similar to what we saw over the past few quarters. Our emphasis will be on holding the line on manageable expenses without giving up multi-year technology commitments aimed at improving customer service and our competitive position. Like I mentioned earlier, our capital position is something we're pleased with. We'll continue looking for chances to repurchase shares and plan to maintain the same quarterly cash dividend. At this point, I'll turn things over to Steve Bradshaw for some final remarks.

Steve Bradshaw

executive
#6

Thanks, Steven. Like I said when the call began, BOK Financial just had a record quarter; we keep doing the right things the right way for our long-term investors, building shareholder value while not sacrificing credit discipline or skipping investment that could hold back the company's future. Our credit results show it, along with the gains from our alternative investment strategy and the record contribution from Wealth Management this quarter — we keep doing this prudently and in a diversified manner. This quarter was again driven by what our fee-based businesses delivered, but the greatly improving growth outlook in our footprint as we come out of the pandemic is boosting customer confidence in a way we haven't seen in a long while. Supply chain and workforce disruptions may be hurting certain areas in the near term, yet economic indicators are still strong, and that bodes well going forward. We're cautiously optimistic about the restart of some of the biggest growth drivers in the company; with that, we're happy to take your questions. Operator?

Will Jones

analyst
#7

Will Jones here, filling in for Brady. Morning, everyone.

Steve Bradshaw

executive
#8

Morning.

Steven Nell

executive
#9

Morning.

Will Jones

analyst
#10

Hey, sounds good. I'd like to begin with the topic of loan growth. I realize loans declined somewhat once more during this quarter, though an inflection point had been anticipated for 3Q. I understand the optimism you're expressing about the coming quarter and about 2022. Could you take us through a few of the factors behind that confidence regarding your growth outlook? It sort of seems as though a growth rate in the low single digits might be within reach for you next year. Would that be a reasonable way to characterize it?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#11

Yeah. At this moment we aren't prepared to discuss our 2022 projections, though I can definitely explain why we'd feel optimistic regarding stronger loan growth as we head into next year. Looking at the major factors behind this quarter's decline, the PPP paydowns were obviously one. Roughly 80% of those we originated have been paid down year-to-date. The two other categories that truly produced the largest decreases this quarter are energy and commercial real estate, and those are the two categories about which we likely have the fewest worries when it comes to their growth in 2022. Energy is positioned quite well. Owing to our ongoing dedication to that space, we brought in more than 40 new customers along with nearly $1 billion of commitments tied to them during 2021. We have strong confidence that growth will appear there as we enter next year. The same holds for commercial real estate. There's genuinely an oddity at play. Thanks to the ongoing conditions created by the pandemic, certain borrowers chose not to refinance. During 2020 we lacked the portfolio turnover we normally experience, so this year you somewhat got a doubling up of that. A bit of that could persist into the fourth quarter. Our commercial real estate team has clearly done an excellent job of steadily adding commitments to the book, and we anticipate that will be a growth area. The two largest categories behind this quarter's decline within our core portfolio are the two where our confidence is greatest as we head into 2022. I believe that's a significant piece of it. Our healthcare sector, without question, keeps performing quite well. Solid growth there. It has been quite strong and steady over an extended stretch. Core C&I is genuinely the unanswered question. It truly hinges on when line utilizations start rising. Numerous factors come into play there. We've made reference to the supply chain problems that affect some of it. The liquidity present in the market plays a role too; we're positioned very well. There's solid activity in our pipelines on the commercial and corporate banking side; we stay quite optimistic about that.

Will Jones

analyst
#12

Great. That's all really useful. Perhaps if we focus only on energy for a moment. Thinking over a longer horizon regarding that portfolio, how we've observed a solid rebound in energy prices and demand as it ultimately comes back. What's the final expectation for where energy loans, as a share of your entire portfolio, are headed? I understand historically it's been in that 18%-20% range and is nearer to 14% now. How do you view your total energy exposure over the longer term relative to the whole portfolio? Do you manage it toward a specific capital level, or is it a particular loan concentration?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#13

Yeah. We track it using two different yardsticks: capital percentage and loan portfolio percentage. On both of those, we currently have plenty of room to expand that portfolio. Neither measurement comes anywhere close to being a constraint that could hold back growth in that area; our optimism about expansion there clearly hasn't changed. As we move into next year, assuming prices stay where they are, our hope is that drilling picks up, which would without question boost borrowing demand and, naturally, the loan demand tied to it. That sector has us genuinely enthusiastic. We see it as somewhere our know-how runs deep and where our track record of bringing offerings to market stays steady. The clients we brought on board over the past year have given us recognition on that front. As a matter of fact, when the league tables came out for Q3, we ranked first among originators in energy for deal sizes that align with our sweet spot — those under $500 million in total loan size. Our standing there feels promising, and we expect it will keep fueling us far ahead. Another thing worth noting: we tend to fixate heavily on just the lending side of that operation. I brought this up earlier in my remarks, and I want to touch on it once more. That segment also posted its best-ever quarter for fees, spanning treasury income, investment banking income, and derivatives income. Those components are central to what that relationship actually is — it isn't merely a credit arrangement. It's a comprehensive, multifaceted relationship with additional revenue-generating dimensions that matter greatly both to the bank and to our shareholders.

Will Jones

analyst
#14

Great, that's really useful. One final thing from me, more of an administrative question. Could you refresh our memory on where utilization stands right now? I apologize if that figure came up earlier in your prepared comments and I didn't catch it.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#15

Sure. Looking across the entire portfolio, pinning down an exact figure is difficult. We're sitting at roughly 64% overall, though that may not be the ideal lens through which to view it, since certain commitments, such as those in energy, are able to expand and contract based on pricing over time. Within our core C&I, roughly our corporate C&I segment, we've dropped under 50% for the first time in recent memory. In that specific segment, we think simply getting back to a more typical pace of loan growth would lift loan balances by roughly $600 million. That applies only to that more corporate C&I group. It has no effect on the specialty areas and others, which would likewise stand to gain from growth and higher utilization too.

Will Jones

analyst
#16

That covers everything on my end. I appreciate you answering my questions.

Matt Olney

analyst
#17

Hi there, and thanks. Morning, everyone.

Steve Bradshaw

executive
#18

Morning.

Matt Olney

analyst
#19

Continuing with a few of the energy-related questions. Stacy, I believe you noted that 40 new customers were added to that business during this year. That's useful. What are current energy customers telling you about their strong cash flows resulting from higher commodity prices? Are they talking about additional drilling activity, or do they still intend to pay down more debt? Thanks.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#20

The discussion is modest. Consider, as an energy producer, what they've experienced over the last 18 months; they witnessed a day when oil price went negative and natural gas was clearly depressed, and now oil sits above $75 and natural gas at one point reached $6 an MCF. That's a very different environment, and they've encountered a great deal of volatility tied to it. They're far more disciplined about hedging, and far more focused on it. I'd say the largest conversations today center on free cash flow. Having cash flow available to show returns to their investors, I believe, matters a great deal to them. What we're learning from the early discussions, I think, is that at this point, drilling activity is probably far more modest than you'd anticipate, considering the substantial run-up in commodity prices over roughly the last six months. That isn't to say it won't shift. We're sort of in capital budgeting season for those energy customers. We'll find out more as we go through this quarter. My expectation, certainly, is modest rather than significant — but modest — growth in drilling activity as we head into next year. That certainly could shift based on many factors, among them whether commodity prices keep climbing.

Matt Olney

analyst
#21

All right. That's quite useful, Stacy. I believe the other figure you provided involved energy commitments rising roughly $1 billion thus far in the current year, coming from those more recent clients. I'm attempting to grasp what baseline sits beneath that figure. Are you able to share total energy commitment levels held at the bank, or even just a rough figure?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#22

As of the close of September, looking at energy commitments, the figure stood near $5.4 billion; that amount fluctuates more than likely any other committed total, since borrowing bases grow and shrink twice a year. Utilization there is also beneath where it has sat historically. It sits in the low 50% utilization. Combined with that, I think we will witness commitment growth there, plus hopefully greater utilization as we move into the following year.

Matt Olney

analyst
#23

All right, that's great. My final question is about PPP. Could you share the figure for fees booked during Q3? And how much smaller do you anticipate the amounts recognized will be across the coming quarters? Thanks.

Steven Nell

executive
#24

Sure, Matt, Steven here. For the third quarter, fee recognition came to $12.7 million. Compared with Q2's $11.1 million, that represents a modest increase. There's still $15 million remaining to be recognized, though the bulk of it relates to loans from the 2021 vintage, so we anticipate that will be recognized across a more extended timeframe. Fee recognition during Q4 and into the early portion of 2022 won't reach the levels you've observed up to now, since the 2020 vintage is nearly exhausted.

Matt Olney

analyst
#25

Okay. Thanks, guys.

Steven Nell

executive
#26

Thank you.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#27

Hey, thanks. Good morning.

Steven Nell

executive
#28

Hi, good morning.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#29

Stacy, could you say something about the balances in commercial real estate? Would you anticipate that shift into the permanent market picking up speed, or is it more of a persistent issue that will remain for some time and perhaps ease at some point?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#30

We definitely anticipate a slowdown. That really started picking up speed, we observed, in Q2 or Q3. Before I declare we've hit the bottom, I think I would want to see things settle down somewhat. In my view, that probably happens in Q4. There was no activity at all toward the permanent market during the prior year. Given how our portfolios are structured, they typically progress through construction and stabilization, after which they refinance into a non-recourse permanent financing source. So you've essentially got a couple of years where things are overlapping. My expectation is that will settle down, probably in Q4. It might extend into Q1 of next year, though my best guess is it happens late in Q4 of this year; from that point we would be in a strong position to expand.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#31

All right, sounds good. Regarding loan growth — yes, I realize you'd rather not discuss 2022 — but only one or two points. You mention stronger demand from borrowers and line utilization getting back to typical levels. Steven Bradshaw, I believe you brought up growth drivers starting up again. Does it seem as though we're only at the beginning of what you might call growth in the economy that isn't driven by stimulus? If that comes across clearly. It simply seems as if conditions are falling into place for improved growth, and that's before even mentioning the energy component. So, I suppose, do you feel optimistic? Are you increasingly optimistic about growth during Q4 of 2022?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#32

Our optimism is very strong. There are many reasons for that. We are positioned to gain disproportionately as commodity prices climb. We have an energy book that stands to gain from a growth standpoint; we have a footprint that stands to gain, one that is expanding. Steven and I spent the last couple of weeks in Texas, and man, you can't go anywhere there without noticing the tremendous in-migration. I've been in Phoenix, and there's a great deal happening in Phoenix and Denver. I mean, the in-migration coming from coastal areas is substantial. Our footprint fits that perfectly. I believe borrower sentiment has come across as exceptionally strong. There are certain economic headwinds — be it supply chain or labor shortages — that will work themselves out to some degree, I think, within the next quarter or two. The majority of stimulus dollars have been allocated to states, and local governments haven't even spent them yet. I think an enormous amount of growth is sort of pent up, and I think we are at the very early stages of starting to witness it.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#33

Yeah. All right. So it's kind of curious — feels like we bypassed the credit cycle, and at this point we're coming out of it ready to grow. That positions things fairly nicely. One additional item regarding deposit flows. I believe you described them as easing somewhat, though they remain quite robust. Are you expecting a slowdown, with deposit growth continuing to decelerate, and what do you figure might ultimately turn that growth around and perhaps cause deposits to begin declining?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#34

When we started having some internal conversations about what our approach should be looking toward next year, from the level we're at right now, we honestly aren't observing meaningful decreases. Significant drops in deposit levels aren't part of our forecast. Our view is that the liquidity present in the market will remain, since even if today's liquidity gets drawn down, more liquidity that hasn't yet moved through the system will take its place. For roughly the next 12 months that we can reasonably see, we believe today's deposit levels probably fall within the range of what lies ahead. Another thing that tends to come up in connection with this: if there's that much liquidity sitting in the system, how is loan growth possible? That's a reasonable question. We examined this going back to 2008, 2009, and 2010 — the most recent period when a major downturn occurred followed by a recovery. Loan growth can happen while liquidity in the system stays elevated. Frequently it shows up across varying sectors. Overall there may be abundant liquidity, yet sectors expand at differing rates, which generates demand for loans. Those two things don't exclude each other; they're connected, but they don't rule each other out.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#35

Yeah. Okay, sounds good. Appreciate the assistance with those items.

Gary Tenner

analyst
#36

Thank you. Morning to everyone. I have two questions to go through. Regarding gain on sale from mortgages, like you mentioned, it came in significantly above the prior quarter's figure. From what I gathered, that happened because commitment levels more or less settled down following a sharp decline in 2Q. I'm curious whether you might share your perspective on where gain on sale is heading, since it remains far higher than the levels seen before 2020.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#37

Sure. Rather than getting into specifics about gain on sale, if we step back and look at the entire business, our expectation is that what the mortgage segment delivers in the fourth quarter on the revenue line will land pretty much in line with the mortgage revenue figure from the second quarter. There could be a few chances on the cost side tied to MSR amortization that might help us somewhat more during the fourth quarter. As for mortgage's total contribution, we'd anticipate it matching the second quarter, perhaps slightly improved when considering pre-tax contribution from mortgage. On the revenue side, our view is it will align much more closely with the second quarter's numbers.

Gary Tenner

analyst
#38

All right, thanks. So, Steven, you said earlier that you anticipate PPP forgiveness will be drawn out going forward. Could you please remind everyone how much in PPP fees is still left to be recognized?

Steven Nell

executive
#39

Sure, we have $15 million remaining. The remaining balance on the PPP loans, I believe, is around $580 million, roughly. As I said, this is the second round, or the 2021 vintage, and forgiveness will take place across a longer stretch than what happened with the first round. That's the reason we expect the $15 million to be recognized across a number of future quarters.

Gary Tenner

analyst
#40

Yes. Okay, that's good. I appreciate you taking my questions.

Matt Olney

analyst
#41

Yeah. Hi, everyone, just a handful more on the follow-up front. Looking at the average balance sheet, investment securities balances now sit at roughly 50% of average earning assets, and my sense is that's the highest we can locate going back a number of years at this bank. Do you have any desire to push that up in the near term while we're waiting on loan growth, or would you say it has peaked now?

Steven Nell

executive
#42

Yeah, my view is it's largely peaked. That breaks into two pieces. Roughly $13 billion, I'd say, is AFS, and for our trading portfolio we have the remaining $7 billion or so. On the $13 billion AFS, my sense is that's fairly near the level we'd like. It rose a couple of hundred million during this quarter. Driving it up isn't something we really have initiatives for. Not when we expect rates will ultimately be rising, hopefully before 2022 ends. Our interest rate risk position feels pretty comfortable to us, and that AFS portfolio, at least as we think about it today, I'd say sits at the right level.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#43

Matt, when you consider how we're set up to take advantage of higher rates, I'd point to how we did during the most recent period of rate increases — from that angle, we ranked among the top-quartile banks. And of course, what we've been hearing from the Fed and its various governors across the past month or so has been far more suggestive of tightening than of the easy money policy continuing; at present, our projection puts the first hike in December of next year. My sense is there's likely additional pressure building that will arrive sooner rather than later. We are extremely well-positioned to gain from rising rates, and we'd want to hold that strong position should it happen sooner rather than later.

Matt Olney

analyst
#44

Yeah, that’s a great point, Stacy. Thanks for bringing that up. I guess, what about on the loan floor side? What's the level of loan floors you have at this point? How many rate increases do you have to see to get above some of those floors?

Steven Nell

executive
#45

There's just shy of $4 billion of our loans have floors embedded in them. Right now, it's supporting net interest income about $20 million a year; it supports NIM about 5 basis points; that kind of give you an idea of what you would have to push through in the support that we're getting there now.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#46

That's going to phase out. On the competitive side, the number of floors we can secure in deals right now is lower than it was 12 months back. Assuming something like a three year roll-off there, then 12 months from now there will definitely be fewer than what we have today.

Matt Olney

analyst
#47

Yeah. Returning to that AFS securities portfolio, it seems like yields might face somewhat more downward pressure, though we're nearing a floor. Is that accurate, Steven?

Steven Nell

executive
#48

Yeah. When you examine the portfolio yield, it stands at 180. I checked this morning. We purchased some securities, actually yesterday, at 135. Those carry a duration of 4 to 5 years. There's still capacity for further repricing downward. That's the reason I brought it up. I don't view it as a massive overall weight on net interest margin. My genuine belief is that we've largely gotten the margin stabilized quite well. A bit remains there should rates remain low, both from the portfolio yield and from what we're putting to work with the cash flow coming back to us and being reinvested.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#49

As Steven hinted, we took care of the sub-debt during Q3. That had only a partial effect; when we get to Q4, there will still be an entire quarter's worth of impact amounting to roughly $2 million. On the whole, that ought to help the margin too.

Steven Nell

executive
#50

Yes.

Matt Olney

analyst
#51

All right. Regarding loan yields, we're attempting to isolate the effect of PPP and examine only the underlying yield. I believe you brought up 2 lending segments where you feel highly confident about expansion in the coming year: energy, and then commercial real estate. Did I understand that correctly? Would it be reasonable to state that, on average, those 2 segments generate greater yields than most other portions of the bank's portfolio?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#52

That is an accurate statement.

Matt Olney

analyst
#53

Stacy, when you look at energy loan spreads right now, how do they stack up both against history and against the remainder of the portfolio? Do they continue to sit comparatively high?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#54

Yes, they do. With various players having chosen to exit that area, the spreads in it have obviously remained quite steady. Today there are fewer rivals competing there, and we continue to receive spreads that fit the risk we assume in that area.

Matt Olney

analyst
#55

Okay, great. That's it from me, everyone. On brokerage and trading, you all knocked it out of the park this quarter. It appears the bulk came from trading, plus customer hedging. I realize forecasting this from one quarter to the next is difficult, but could you say more about whether these levels can hold up in the third quarter?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#56

Sure. I'll address a few points, and then I'll turn it to Scott to see whether he'd like to chime in. Our wealth group makes us extremely proud; we're sitting at exactly $100 billion in assets under management. At times, things like energy over on the lending side, or the trading operations over on the wealth side, can divert attention from what's taking place at the core of this company. Obviously, volatility comes with the trading operations, yet looking at wealth revenues as a whole, volatility does occur within a quarter, but we've increased wealth total revenue compared with the prior year for more than 10 straight years at this point. The wealth revenue CAGR stands above 9%. Some of these trading operations do swing around, but genuine core expansion is underway that, in my view, the market is overlooking within our wealth business. When we look ahead to the fourth quarter, we expect the trading portion of that business to land probably somewhere in between what showed up in the second quarter and the third quarter. Likely not as robust as the third quarter, and likely perhaps somewhat stronger than what showed up in the second quarter. Considering the business and how we view it, total wealth revenue has served as a major engine for our company, and that isn't solely the trading operation. It's the assets under management for which we offer guidance to our customers and to institutions. Normally you'd observe managed assets amounting to half the size of the core bank. Ours exceed twice the size of the core bank and come to nearly $100 billion; that business makes us proud, and we're enthusiastic about our accomplishments on the trading side, yet the core wealth business has functioned as a crucial growth engine for our company for quite some time. Scott, is there anything you'd like to add?

Scott Grauer

executive
#57

Stacy framed that well, I think. Outside of institutional trading, where the numbers can be more volatile quarter to quarter, we have also managed — fairly quietly — to grow retail brokerage revenues at a healthy clip, both sequentially and versus a year ago. And then our investment banking operation has come through extremely strongly, exactly as Stacy mentioned earlier during prepared remarks. Add to that the continuing momentum in mortgage-backed securities — that's the sizable component — along with investment banking, retail brokerage, and our hedging operations, not just the ones linked to energy, but also in our FX business and our interest rate derivative work. Each of those pieces, as we see it, sits in a very strong position for further momentum, running in the 1.35% to 1.80% range.

Matt Olney

analyst
#58

Okay. Great stuff, guys. Thanks again.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#59

Thank you.

Scott Grauer

executive
#60

Appreciate it, Matt.

Steven Nell

executive
#61

All right, and once more, thanks to all of you for being here with us. Should anything else come up that you'd like to ask about, feel free to reach me by phone at 918-595-3030, or send a message to ir@bokf.com. Enjoy the rest of your day. Thanks so much.

Operator

operator
#62

Thanks. That wraps up the call for today. At this point you're free to hang up. We appreciate you joining us.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete BOK Financial Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to BOK Financial Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in BOK Financial Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.