BOK Financial Corporation (BOKF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 27, 2022

NASDAQ US Financials Banks earnings 58 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Steven Nell

executive
#1

Hello, everyone, and thank you for being with us this morning. Our President and CEO, Stacy Kymes, is going to start things off with some opening remarks. After that, Marc Maun, who serves as Executive Vice President for Regional Banking, will walk through the loan portfolio and the credit metrics tied to it. Scott Grauer, Executive Vice President of Wealth Management, will then discuss the results we generate from fees. Following that, I will share the specifics on net interest income, net interest margin, expenses, and where our balance sheet stands when it comes to liquidity and capital. You can find a PDF of the slide presentation along with the first quarter press release on our website, bokf.com. Please take note of the disclaimers on Slide 2, which apply to any forward-looking statements made on this call. At this point, I'll hand things over to Stacy Kymes.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#2

Hello, everyone, and thank you for being here as we go over BOK Financial's results for the first quarter. I'll begin on Slide 4. We posted net income of $62 million, which works out to $0.91 per diluted share — that's down $55 million versus the prior quarter. The first quarter brought sweeping shifts in both the economy and geopolitics, and those shifts produced severe swings in interest rates. Our mortgage-related operations, and particularly our mortgage trading efforts, took a hit from that turbulence; measured on a pretax basis, the net contribution from our institutional trading group fell $43 million from the previous quarter. With investors responding to rate swings and unsettled markets, appetite was limited for lower coupon U.S. government agency residential mortgage-backed securities. Rate swings also hurt what we saw from hedging our mortgage servicing rights, which meant a $13 million pretax drop in performance relative to the fourth quarter. And lastly, another significant piece behind the quarter-over-quarter decrease was the $17 million pretax reserve release we took in the prior quarter. What stands out most about this quarter is how much our loans grew. If you set aside PPP loans, our core loan portfolio rose $608 million, or 3%, from the prior quarter. Credit quality across our loan book remains excellent. We concluded that the reserve for loan losses at its present level was right, so there was no reserve release this quarter. Commodity prices staying strong along with better credit metrics were enough to counter both this quarter's loan growth and shifts in the economic outlook. Our projections for GDP growth and unemployment, though in line with pre-pandemic figures, are more restrained than they were a quarter ago. Now to Slide 5. Total loans were up $469 million, or 2.3%, from the prior quarter. Keep in mind, though, that this is net of another $139 million of PPP loan forgiveness during the first quarter. Core C&I loan balances have risen 12% annualized. C&I commitments also increased, and the core utilization rate was fairly flat, which leaves us in a strong position with ample capacity to grow as the economy keeps recovering. As we anticipated, our Commercial Real Estate Group got back to positive growth this quarter, with period-end commercial real estate balances climbing $270 million. Loans tied to our Wealth segment came in materially in line with the fourth quarter. Average deposits rose $560 million this quarter. Period-end balances, though, dropped $1.8 billion; during the fourth quarter we saw a large seasonal deposit inflow in our Commercial and Wealth business lines, and by the close of the first quarter more than 65% of that increase had moved off the balance sheet. Relative to March 31, 2021, period-end balances now stand $1.6 billion, or 4.2%, above where they were a year ago. Assets under management or in custody within our Wealth Management dipped modestly this quarter, slipping 3.7% to $101.1 billion. Market value accounted for more than half of that movement. Relative to March 31, 2021, assets under management or in custody have grown $9.1 billion, or nearly 10%. I'll share a bit more perspective on these results before we open the Q&A, but first Marc Maun will walk through the loan portfolio and our credit metrics in greater detail. Marc, the call is yours now.

Marc Maun

executive
#3

Appreciate it, Stacy. Now moving to Slide 7. Within our core loan portfolio, period-end loans came in at $20.5 billion, which marks a linked quarter rise of $608 million. That figure stands as our biggest linked quarter balance increase going all the way back to the first quarter of 2020. Total C&I loans expanded by $377 million, or 3% linked quarter, with the bulk of that growth coming from general C&I along with energy. As we had anticipated, the payoff trend in real estate slowed down, which produced commercial real estate growth of $270 million, or 7% linked quarter. Loans to individuals shrank by $39 million linked quarter, and most of that decrease traces to the resale of loans that had previously been sold into Ginnie Mae mortgage pools and that the company repurchased once certain delinquency criteria were satisfied. We keep seeing loans that were repurchased during the pandemic getting cured and then meeting the resale qualifications. Loans in the energy space posted back-to-back quarters, with period-end outstandings rising $191 million in the first quarter after last quarter's $193 million increase. Commitments this quarter grew a bit less than outstanding balances did, so utilization levels ticked up, but they stay low relative to pre-pandemic levels. If utilization on our existing customer base returned to those levels, that would deliver an additional $300 million in outstanding balances. Ancillary business from customer hedging, investment banking and treasury for this segment set yet another new record for fee revenue this quarter, surpassing last quarter's previous high, with linked quarter growth just under 14%. Healthcare balances also rose, up $27 million, or 0.8% linked quarter, mainly driven by our acute care and specialty hospital sector. Health care line utilization levels matched what we saw last quarter. Going forward, we stay very confident in our capacity to deliver from both a growth and credit standpoint in our health care portfolio, since it remains a leader for us. Leaving out energy and health care, core middle market C&I achieved positive growth once more this quarter, with linked quarter growth of $159 million, or 2.6%. C&I utilization levels are still running at historic lows, though they did edge up slightly this quarter. With utilization levels that low, we still hold significant capacity to raise outstanding loan balances as demand keeps coming back online, and that doesn't depend on acquiring any new customers. A return to more normal utilization levels organically contributes roughly $500 million of core C&I loans, separate from the growth we expect in the specialty areas. Given fourth quarter lending trends, we felt optimistic going into the first quarter, and the results did not disappoint. We stay confident in our ability to generate solid growth through the rest of this year; we're optimistic that the payoff trend we've seen since the fourth quarter of 2020 in commercial real estate balances has at last reversed this quarter, as period-end balances grew $270 million, or 7% linked quarter. Industrial, multifamily and office were the segments that drove this quarter's results. We expect those balances to keep growing through the year, since we have plenty of capital allocated for this space to grow in 2022 and beyond. Forgiveness on PPP loans came to $139 million during this quarter, which brought outstandings down to just $137 million. Looking at what's left in PPP balances, under $24 million — that's 1% — comes from the 2020 vintage. We keep working alongside our clients as they go through forgiveness, and we anticipate that whatever balances remain later will be minimal. We think the momentum from the first quarter can be leveraged and that trend extended, yielding a more typical loan growth cycle as 2022 unfolds. Moving to Slide 8. As we get further past the pandemic, you can see credit quality keeps getting substantially better. We're still seeing meaningful improvement in credit quality throughout the wider loan portfolio; and when loans guaranteed by U.S. government agencies are excluded, nonperforming assets came to $13 million on a linked quarter basis versus $132 million. Compared with 12 months ago, nonperforming assets have fallen $147 million, or 53%. Asset quality overall now exceeds pre-pandemic levels. Our credit quality metrics broadly, together with ongoing strength in commodity prices and an outlook calling for moderate GDP and labor market growth, gave us a favorable offset to the substantial loan growth seen this quarter, meaning no boost to the reserve for loan losses was needed; net charge-offs of $6 million were realized in the first quarter, up $6.7 million against just $714,000 in net recoveries during the fourth quarter. If PPP loans are excluded, net charge-offs have averaged 14 basis points across the past 4 trailing quarters, below our historic loss range. Looking ahead to next quarter, we anticipate net charge-offs will stay at or under the low end of our historical range. With PPP loans excluded, the combined allowance for loan losses was $283 million, or 1.38% of outstanding loans and unfunded commitments at quarter end. Now that the pandemic is behind us, the allowance is shifting toward our post-CECL level of 1.2% from early first quarter 2020. Non-accruing loans fell $9.8 million versus last quarter, largely because of a decline in non-accruing general business and energy loans. Potential problem loans stood at $169 million at quarter end, lower than $222 million on December 31. Potential problem energy, commercial real estate and service loans each declined versus the prior quarter; with that, I'll hand the call to Scott Grauer.

Scott Grauer

executive
#4

Thanks, Marc. Moving on to Slide 10. Fees and commissions came in at $98 million during Q1, which represents a $49 million drop versus Q4. As Stacy mentioned previously, during the first quarter there was turmoil in fixed income markets, driven by a mix of things including climbing inflation, the latest bump in the federal funds rate, anticipation of additional hikes, and the war in Ukraine. Those developments significantly reshaped the MBS trading landscape, cutting into appetite for our short duration, low coupon U.S. government agency residual mortgage-backed securities. Consequently, pretax contribution from our institutional trading group fell $43 million quarter over quarter. Outside of institutional trading activity, every other brokerage and trading revenue line slipped $1.3 million from the prior quarter, mostly because of the record Q4 we had in syndication deals inside our Commercial segment, which tend to be uneven. When it comes to our MBS trading operations, we anticipate balance sheet usage will ease over the coming several quarters as the mortgage origination market responds to elevated interest rates and an ongoing lack of housing supply. Trading volumes and the revenues tied to them will respond to those market conditions, and we expect margins to stay under pressure. Fiduciary and asset management fees came in roughly unchanged from the prior quarter, yet they climbed 12.3% versus the same period 1 year ago. Even with a drop in market valuations, assets under management ended the quarter at $101 billion, a decline of only 3.7% quarter over quarter. Against this point last year, assets under management are up $9.1 billion, or 9.9%. Although favorable equity markets have helped lift customer account balances over the last year, sales activity in this area continues to be robust. The present composition of our assets under management breaks down as 41% fixed income, 38% equities, 13% cash and 8% alternatives. Our relationship-driven business model aligns perfectly with what clients need right now as we navigate this new stretch of market volatility. To illustrate, our Cavanal Hill Investment Management mutual funds were just ranked #26 on Barron's Best Fund Families of 2021. That places us among 849 asset managers in the Lipper database. We think the trust and appreciation for financial advice that we gained throughout the pandemic from both institutions and individuals puts us in a strong position to support our clients during this time of market uncertainty. Transaction card revenue fell 3.1% from the prior quarter, as seasonal patterns affected the quarter-over-quarter comparison. Relative to Q1 of 2021, card revenues have risen 8%. That mostly reflects stimulus measures along with the wider reopening of The U.S. economy. Deposit service charges rose $286,000 in the quarter, with that growth split evenly across our Commercial and Consumer segments. Versus the first quarter of last year, total service charges have increased $2.8 million, or 11.5%. Roughly 23% of deposit service charge fees during Q1 came from consumer-related NSF fees; we keep watching the current regulatory environment in this area, assessing a range of options as we determine our strategy moving forward. Revenue from mortgage banking fell by $4.6 million, which works out to 21.8% compared with the prior quarter, driven mainly by smaller production volumes along with tighter margins. The volume of mortgage production dropped by $93 million, landing at $408 million, since the industry keeps confronting not just limits on housing inventory but also mortgage rates that are climbing. Other revenue was down $1.1 million, a 9.8% decline from the previous quarter, largely because of lower fees from domestic letters of credit and diminished revenues from repossessions. At this point I'll hand the call to Steven so he can walk through our net interest margin dynamics and the key balance sheet items for the quarter. Steven?

Steven Nell

executive
#5

Thanks, Scott. Now moving to Slide 12. Net interest revenue for the first quarter came in at $268 million, which is down $8.7 million versus the prior quarter. The main driver there was an $8.9 million quarter-over-quarter drop in loan fees, and $3.8 million of that was tied directly to PPP fee recognition. Nonuse fees within our business lines declined $2.3 million on a linked quarter basis, mostly because utilization levels were higher. On top of that, Q4 included a seasonal boost of $2.8 million in fees from selling transferable tax credits, something that mostly happens in the fourth quarter every year. Income from our trading securities dropped $3.5 million, as the effective yield declined 18 basis points from the prior quarter. That drop in trading securities interest income was largely offset by higher interest from our available-for-sale securities portfolio, where the average yield rose 5 basis points. Average earning assets were down $744 million from last quarter, driven mostly by a $723 million reduction in the trading securities portfolio that supports our brokerage and trading operations. Average loans rose $221 million linked quarter. If you set aside the $194 million linked quarter decrease in PPP loans, average balances were up $415 million. Interest-bearing cash declined $158 million. Average total deposits increased $560 million, with noninterest-bearing balances rising $243 million and interest-bearing balances rising $317 million during the quarter. Net interest margin came in at 2.44%, a decline of 8 basis points from the prior quarter, and that drop was largely caused by the linked quarter reduction in loan fees. If you exclude loan fees, core loan yields were up 4 basis points, as we started to see benefits from rising short-term interest rates. The average cost of our interest-bearing deposits stayed flat at 12 basis points for the quarter. In our view, the core margin has reached a low point. This quarter we saw better yields on both our available-for-sale securities portfolio and our loan portfolio as short-term rates started moving up. Given our current asset-sensitive position, we're set up to benefit, since we anticipate the Fed will move short-term rates higher aggressively through 2022. Now to Slide 13. Let me quickly walk through where our asset sensitivity stands today, which we went over in detail last quarter; we remain asset-sensitive on the balance sheet and expect our results in a rising rate environment to look similar to what we saw during the last rate hike cycle, from 2015 to 2019. Under our standard modeling, if we assume a parallel shift up of 200 basis points phased in gradually over 12 months, net interest revenue would rise 7.5%, or roughly $85 million. Over the next 12 months, the total benefit increase reaches 16%, or $196 million; if the yield curve turns out flatter than that parallel shift up scenario, our estimates for up 200 basis points would come in at about half those levels. I'll give you more detail shortly when I discuss our specific forward guidance for net interest income; on Slide 14, you can see that our liquidity position is still very strong. The ratio of our loans to deposits moved up to 52.4% in this quarter, compared with 49% as of December 31, as a result of two things combined: total deposits fell by $1.8 billion, while loan balances grew by $469 million during the quarter. Because we hold substantial liquidity on our balance sheet, we are in a very strong position to satisfy the growing loan demand from customers in the future. On the capital side, we also remain solid, posting a common equity Tier 1 ratio of 11.3%, which sits comfortably above the regulatory thresholds. Given those robust capital levels, we were once again active in repurchasing shares, taking the opportunity to buy back 476,000 shares in the open market at an average price of $101.02 each. Moving to Slide 15. Total expenses on a linked quarter basis fell by $22 million, mostly because of lower personnel expense in this quarter and a $5 million contribution we made to our foundation in the prior quarter. Personnel expense dropped $15 million on a linked quarter basis, as cash-based incentive compensation came down $11 million from the elevated levels seen in the fourth quarter. Deferred compensation expense, which is largely offset by a decline in the value of related investments recorded in other gains and losses, net, was down $4.2 million. Share-based incentive compensation fell $3.8 million, driven by changes in vesting assumptions tied to performance relative to our peer group. Partially offsetting these decreases was a $3.2 million net rise in employee benefits expense, reflecting a seasonal uptick in payroll taxes and retirement plan costs, partly offset by a seasonal drop in medical expense costs. Regular compensation expense is still running fairly flat, as it has over the last 4 quarters. Looking ahead, we anticipate continuing to manage personnel costs effectively, though we recognize that inflation in a tight labor market presents a risk. Non-personnel expense declined $6.6 million in this quarter, with $5 million of that tied to the fourth quarter contribution to the foundation. Most expense categories saw comparable spending levels across both quarters. The exception was higher occupancy and equipment, which was offset by decreases in professional fees and recruiting expenses. On Slide 16, I'll give guidance on a few key areas for the rest of 2022. Loan growth picked up momentum this quarter, in line with what we expected. And we still see solid loan pipelines overall along with better line utilization, and both of those support point-to-point growth in the upper single-digit range. We expect that growth to come from every one of our regional markets as well as continued growth in our wealth division. Since interest rates are likely to be much higher during 2022 than we initially assumed, we expect some reduction in deposit balances. Deposits might fall point-to-point by mid-single digits by year-end; however, even with loan growth speeding up and some deposit runoff, our liquidity position should stay strong. If we model a 200 basis point rise in interest rates for the rest of 2022, and factor in how flat the forward curve is, deposit beta assumptions comparable to prior rate cycles, our loan growth guidance, and keeping the available-for-sale securities portfolio unchanged, then we anticipate core net interest income on a year-over-year basis will be up 9%, and that figure leaves out a $40 million PPP revenue difference between the 2 years. Under that modeling, our net interest margin ought to move to approximately 3% by year-end. The market interest rate increase we expect has hurt, and will continue to hurt, our mortgage and brokerage and trading activities in a meaningful way. Conversely, higher interest rates benefit part of our money management and fiduciary fees. Because of market uncertainty, I will give guidance for each of our diversified fee revenue line items. Even so, I will note that in aggregate, fee revenues might come in somewhat under 35% of total revenues, at least during 2022. With fee revenues falling and variable expenses tied to them declining, we aim to keep total operating expenses roughly level in 2022. At present, our loan loss reserve equals 1.37% of loan balances. By the end of 2022, we anticipate that figure will move toward 1.2%, which is very near day 1 CECL levels; we also expect to keep making opportunistic quarterly share repurchases within the total dollar ranges used across the last several quarters. Now I'll hand the call back to Stacy Kymes for closing commentary.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#6

Thank you, Steven. Results for this quarter, taken as a whole, fell short of what we had anticipated, because the market went through remarkable interest rate volatility. High inflation had to be absorbed by the markets, along with shifting sentiment regarding how large interest rate hikes would be and the first significant geopolitical conflict in Europe since World War 2. Our business lines focused on mortgages took a material hit as the markets seemed to reset. Setting that reset aside, our core operating business model turned in a solid performance this quarter. Looking forward, we feel we are well positioned for this new environment. We have strong momentum growing our loan portfolio, with both actual results and loan pipeline strong. We've been intentional about positioning our balance sheet to benefit from rising interest rates, with evidence this quarter as core loan and available-for-sale securities yields improved. As the Federal Reserve moves aggressively to increase short-term interest rates, we will see expanding margins and revenue. Credit quality has long been a differentiator for BOK Financial. And we are well positioned should the credit markets begin to show weakness, though there is no sign of that today. We operate in a fast-growing regional footprint that we expect to provide stronger growth than the national economy over time. Looking ahead, I'm excited about the outlook for BOK Financial. With that, we are pleased to take your questions. Operator?

Jared Shaw

analyst
#7

Perhaps we could begin briefly with the outlook and the rate expectations. Has there been any significant revision to what you assume for deposit beta compared with the close of last year, given the revised guidance we're now considering?

Steven Nell

executive
#8

Slightly; for the initial 100 basis points, my sense is that it would closely match what we provided in the first quarter, and then clearly, for the subsequent 100 basis points of increases, roughly a 30% beta on average across the year is what our model incorporates.

Jared Shaw

analyst
#9

So we're looking at 30%, more or less, once that cumulative beta of 200 basis points is fully in place?

Steven Nell

executive
#10

That's right.

Jared Shaw

analyst
#11

All right. Then regarding the securities portfolio — the AFS portfolio — what is its duration as of March 31? Also, what monthly cash flow do you anticipate from it?

Steven Nell

executive
#12

Sure. The effective duration, as I recall, comes to roughly 3.6 years. And across most interest rate scenarios, we're getting approximately $1.8 billion per year in cash flow. So from there, you can calculate it on a quarterly basis.

Jared Shaw

analyst
#13

All right; then regarding expansion on the loan side, I found the information about the normalized utilization rate and its potential effect on balances helpful. For that loan growth, do you assume a return to a completely normal utilization rate in order to achieve it? Or if that happened, would more upside remain?

Marc Maun

executive
#14

Marc Maun here. We aren't really assuming we will return to growth at full utilization. Our commitments have remained at quite a steady level; and utilization has risen only a little. Thus a great deal of the growth has resulted from acquiring new customers. We anticipate bringing in additional customers all through the year; and anticipate that if we receive a boost from higher utilization, it will aid our overall growth rate.

Jared Shaw

analyst
#15

All right. That sounds excellent. Then last, just personally, regarding fees on deposits. Do you have any views about altering policy or the way things are done when it comes to NSF along with other retail deposit charges? Or might that be something that sits potentially further off in the future?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#16

Absolutely. Jared, it's Stacy speaking; we keep examining that; roughly $5 million each quarter comes from consumer-related NSF fees. And we keep taking a very serious look at it as time passes. And I believe you should expect as time goes on that, that line item for consumer will face some pressure in terms of shrinking; yet measured as a relative percent of our fee revenue, it's an extremely, extremely tiny percent. So it's something we believe we can substitute as time goes on. We rolled out a new deposit product during this quarter, a bank on product that carries no overdraft fees tied to it; and we're monitoring how that gets adopted too, which might likewise affect that line item. But we see as you do the regulatory pressure on that. It isn't a major line item for us. We've already implemented other changes before this. So we feel we're well positioned there. But there will be pressure on that item moving forward.

Peter Winter

analyst
#17

It's clear the diversified business model brings advantages. Still, I want to ask: given the strain on fee income during this year, do you believe positive operating leverage is achievable in this year, or perhaps during the second half?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#18

As for the efficiency ratio, our expectation is definitely that it gets better over the course of the year. Consider this — that, I believe, was essentially the key point here, which is that we are moving away from — we enjoyed an excellent 2 years in the fee business, both on trading and on the mortgage side. And truly, we gained from that to a degree that other regional banks did not, thanks to the investment we've made in the fee businesses. Yet as the market moves toward revenue generated more by net interest and conditions become harder for certain of those businesses tied to mortgages, that revenue stream is a more efficient one for the company. Therefore, we think a shift will become apparent, toward more positive operating leverage and a reduced efficiency ratio, by the time we reach the end of the year.

Peter Winter

analyst
#19

All right, that's useful. And then I noticed the trading portfolio got smaller. I'm just curious about how you're thinking about it moving forward. Is it going to keep contracting?

Scott Grauer

executive
#20

Yeah. Scott Grauer here. So, as things stand right now, when it comes to how big the mortgage-backed securities trading portfolio is — as of today, we've brought it down by more than 70% versus our peak. And so, regarding that portfolio's size, it's clear we've cut back the basis point exposure we previously had. So we're pleased with the scale of our activity and the portfolio we have in place as of today. So, assuming some of the market volatility and uncertainty eases, we're comfortable with where things stand right now on that front.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#21

Peter, consider it in terms of inventory — honestly, that's going to expand or contract depending on how much selling is happening. So if selling activity drops, that trading portfolio is going to shrink. And if trading activity speeds up, it could get bigger; though on the whole, we're likely fairly near the level we'll stay at.

Peter Winter

analyst
#22

Okay. And that's my last question. Stacy, you've spent many years at BOK; but now that you're the new CEO, are there particular areas you may be concentrating on more than Steve Bradshaw did? Or is it basically the same as always?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#23

Well, if you wanted big changes, you probably wouldn't have chosen someone who's been with the company for 25 years. What you'll notice from us, I believe, largely reflects the shifting environment. We've made it through 2 years of pandemic, and 2022 is the first year that's sort of post-pandemic. So we're very focused on top line revenue growth, being visible with our clients, being out front and visible, being in their offices, being active calling. Top line revenue growth is our #1 priority for this year; and that's really just a result of a different sales environment we're entering after a really tough couple of years from a sales perspective. You can sell deeper into an existing relationship virtually, and we've done that successfully; but it's hard to bring new relationships across if you don't have a previous relationship. And so we think that's the opportunity. You're seeing the early fruits of that, I think, here in 2022. But our sales teams are very active. They're in front of customers, and we're seeing the benefit of that.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#24

Scott or Steven, could one of you assist us in breaking down the brokerage and trading line a little, simply so we can grasp what is happening beneath it? Clearly, you mentioned a loss previously, but just aid us in comprehending what lies under that.

Scott Grauer

executive
#25

Truly, it ties back to the basis point exposure we carried in our mortgage-backed securities at the time we observed our run rate of trading activity for mortgage-backed securities, and when we moved into the fourth quarter, as activities decelerated, especially right at the close of the year, they experienced some pickup during the initial couple of weeks of January. However, then with what seemed an accelerated shift from the Fed, we had inflation figures, energy cost — energy level spikes, and then Ukraine, that activity came to a stop; and therefore our inventory, as Stacy referenced, was suitable considering our volume and activity rates leading up to that moment. Consequently, as we witnessed activity subdued amid uncertainty in the marketplace, that basis point risk, we chose we wished to lower that exposure, and we did so; and we feel as though we have tackled it and believe it is mostly behind us right now.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#26

However, Jon, when you look at the individual components that usually comprise it — whether that's revenue generated by investment activity on the syndication side, retail brokerage, energy derivatives trading — those other core areas performed very solidly, or very strongly, during this quarter. It was essentially what we refer to as mortgage trading activity that pushed that revenue category lower. Still, the remaining parts of that line item did well this quarter. We're witnessing unusually robust activity from our energy customers who want to hedge in this environment. Retail brokerage has remained quite stable. And in — investment banking revenue declined somewhat in the first quarter, though that's a seasonal decline. As a result, we have a very strong syndication pipeline and anticipate that the second and third quarter will be very strong for that category.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#27

That big difference, though — did it come to $50 million? I'm basically attempting to circle back to whatever you'd consider closer to typical...

Steven Nell

executive
#28

Right. And honestly, that figure was $50 million. What I mean is, it came in just under $49 million. That's why we included $50 million in the 8-K, without question, since positions remained open at that point. A handful are still sitting there, and we had no idea how the market would move. I simply wanted to be certain we addressed what the potential downside might look like. Yet when everything settled, we didn't record any losses on that. It came in lower.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#29

Yeah, that answers my question. Then, Steven, regarding what you show on Slide 13, I'd like to confirm my understanding of that disclosure. In the second scenario — up 200 grams during months 13 through 24 — the assumption is a 200 basis point increase over the first 12 months, and then for months 13 to 24, I'm not sure of the term, residual with nothing further added.

Steven Nell

executive
#30

Right, right. That's the second year. So you rise gradually during months 1 through 12, then you remain at up 200 on a parallel basis throughout the following year. That gives you the net interest income, or revenue, that you'd capture under such a scenario on a parallel shift. What I'm attempting to point out is that a forward curve exists which is flatter than a parallel shift, and should that forward curve and its flatness materialize, it would reduce that figure somewhat. That's roughly the way to read it.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#31

But it's the second...

Steven Nell

executive
#32

Right, so that's year two of the complete 200 increase, and after that it holds steady there. That's the sort of lift you'd see in that second year.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#33

All right. So perhaps Marc or Stacy, could you weigh in on commercial real estate, and on the way the permanent market alternatives have loosened up somewhat? Would you call that a lasting shift or a passing one? And could you also offer some thoughts on what we should expect from CRE overall now that rates are higher?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#34

Sure. When it comes to commercial real estate, lumpiness between one quarter and the next is simply built in. My habit has been to view CRE across a 12-month continuum, since a single quarter can bring unusually strong growth, while another can bring unusually large paydowns. That said, the sharper paydown headwind we experienced, I believe, is mostly in the rearview. In my view, that stemmed largely from the pandemic and what you might call the economic freeze that accompanied it. Consequently, a great deal that qualified to shift into the permanent market did so; we will continue to hold a sound portfolio. So some loans will keep migrating there as time passes. Relative to fresh activity, though, I expect things to be far steadier going forward.

Jennifer Demba

analyst
#35

Steven, thanks so much for walking us through all that thorough fundamental guidance for '22. It's genuinely useful. Regarding the loan loss reserve, which is likely to decline back to roughly 120 basis points, do you view that as the largest risk embedded in the outlook you provided, since none of us can say for certain how the macro picture will play out across the coming several quarters, what with all these rate hikes and the geopolitical risk?

Marc Maun

executive
#36

Yes. Jennifer, Marc here. No, in my view that isn't a major risk for us when it comes to the guidance, and the reason is straightforward: our starting point today is arguably the strongest we've had since before the Great Recession — and I don't just mean before the pandemic — when it comes to asset quality. And should we see the loan growth, managing that reserve down to 1.2 will help us offset that loan growth. So my sense is loan growth, along with asset quality, will underpin that decrease. And whether it translates into provisions will hinge heavily on what that loan growth figure turns out to be.

Brady Gailey

analyst
#37

Yes, this is Brady. So I suppose I just wanted to get some clarity regarding the trading portfolio, overall, from an average standpoint, which moved from $9 billion in the prior quarter to roughly $8.5 billion in this one. During the period, it ended at just under $5 billion. So are you saying, more or less on a forward-looking basis, that volume ought to be relatively flat versus where it closed the quarter, near $5 billion?

Scott Grauer

executive
#38

Well, I believe — Scott here. I believe, as Stacy noted, that will really be more indicative of what opportunity exists in the market, where flows stand, and where volumes are from a client activity perspective. And we have truly witnessed enormous lethargy in the market when it comes to people being willing to commit anywhere along the curve, given how much uncertainty we've had regarding the Fed's speed and magnitude, combined with all the other macroeconomic factors; so I'm not implying it will remain at that level. It will reflect simply the overall demand from our customer base in the marketplace. And our mix already reflects — is reflecting some shift, as we've observed the arrival of a bit of yield availability, with tax exempt and municipal yields pushing through taxable equivalents; so we're seeing stronger demand and improved activity in other segments of the fixed income markets, though not specifically in the mortgage-backed securities area.

Brady Gailey

analyst
#39

All right. And I believe I caught you folks mentioning that you'd pre-announced the $50 million loss there. But in the quarter, it actually landed lower than that. What did that loss really total for 1Q?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#40

On page 3 of the press release, in the highlights, I believe the figure was $41.9 million.

Brady Gailey

analyst
#41

Understood. Okay. And last thing—there's a different Oklahoma Bank, much smaller than you folks; on their call yesterday evening, though, they said ESG was truly pushing many capital providers away from the energy sector; and they were getting improved terms. Improved rates were showing up; it was genuinely an excellent moment to become more active in energy lending. Are all of you observing that trend, with ESG driving some folks off, and perhaps now is an excellent moment to increase involvement in the energy business and possibly expand that portfolio for your team?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#42

Yeah. This is Stacy. I believe obviously, our results across the past truly 2 cycles during the past 6 years have set us apart; and I believe we are witnessing that; we had 19 new customer deals in the first quarter by itself. During 2022 — during 2021, we ranked third in the league tables, and energy deals we led had deal size under $750 million. So it was BofA; it was JPMorgan, Wells Fargo. And it was BOK Financial. During the first quarter, we ranked second in the league tables for deals we ran in the energy space; so we are seeing opportunity there. Clearly, we have plenty of cash flow. So some of that new deal flow exists; they have plenty of cash flow and might not require debt to drill with. But we are seeing growth there; and we're seeing truly strong opportunities and real meaningful recognition of our consistency in this space. We haven't gotten in and gotten out depending on the environment; we understand it. And we're in it in good times and bad times.

Brady Gailey

analyst
#43

Okay, and then, Stacy, just one more thing, going back to what I asked before. Regarding that trading loss, you mentioned it came to $41.9 million, and that's actually on the first page. It appears brokerage and trading revenue fell from $41.9 million. So, are these the same item we're discussing?

Steven Nell

executive
#44

Slightly different. He cited the $41.9 million drop in brokerage and trading. That includes some other pieces, such as the investment banking revenue brought up earlier. The actual loss, or what we lost on those specific bonds, came to slightly under $40 million.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#45

Also, returning to what Steven mentioned, those are particular securities we pinpointed at those price points. Therefore, if you consider the overall picture of what was done, it's obviously lower than that figure once we account for the entire quarter's total.

Steven Nell

executive
#46

Yes. We really kind of isolating the bonds.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#47

We're separating out the <<inaudible>> securities and the bonds we had interest in, and where we showed unfavorable market moves. So when you add up institutional trading and sales, that figure came to minus $15 million across the whole first quarter.

Gary Tenner

analyst
#48

I'd like to pose one more question regarding energy. For 2 consecutive quarters, that segment has expanded. People have speculated about whether the sharp rise in commodity prices stemming from events in Ukraine might spur more activity in this area. So, are you genuinely observing a pickup? Or would you say those 2 quarters—or the expansion seen this quarter—aren't clearly attributable to that rise, including in the fourth quarter?

Marc Maun

executive
#49

What I'd point to is a mix of fresh drilling work. On top of that, expectations around capital returns play a role. Because prices are elevated, several owners across these different businesses want to give back some capital from what they've invested. That blend, I believe, will—yet as months go by and drilling becomes necessary to keep their collateral and reserves at the same level, activity should pick up as we progress through the year. That, in our view, ought to support growth in this portfolio over time across this year, provided prices remain firm and demand stays at the levels we anticipate.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#50

Remember, across the country, the number of active rigs remains lower than it was before the pandemic, even with prices at current levels. So at this point, output is nearer to what it was before the pandemic, yet the rig tally itself is still under that. Therefore we believe that — especially if they're able to lock in hedges looking out 2 or 3 years at $75 or above — I mean, honestly, natural gas prices are very high at the moment; so should they hedge ahead at such levels, I think you'll see additional drilling in the second half of the year. But much of our expansion has come from bringing on new customers and the deal flow generated by that; drilling, though, is still to come, and I think that represents part of the upside.

Gary Tenner

analyst
#51

Okay, and I've got a follow-up question for Steven about rates, sensitivity, and the outlook for deposit beta. Since this tightening cycle will probably happen so quickly, and considering what's coming in Q2 and Q3, do you figure that cumulative beta will mostly show up in the numbers fast, before this year wraps up, and then we'd just see a slight creep higher in funding costs during 2023? Or is your view that you folks will manage to keep those betas suppressed on the front end?

Steven Nell

executive
#52

So, during that initial 100 basis points, it's obvious we have the ability to keep them down. My honest view is that they do speed up somewhat once the second 100 basis point hike arrives. When you take an average of the two, I'd say it comes to roughly 30. The other side of this, though, is that I believe there's sort of a turning point once you get to 100 basis points higher, where activity picks up more. And you'll observe that we need to raise prices somewhat further. Still, on the whole, my sense is that we can maintain things through this 200 basis point shift we're anticipating, landing near that 30 figure for the average beta throughout the entire range of products.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#53

There's another aspect we really haven't discussed much, which relates to our money management business. On the fee side, higher rates are going to help us somewhat, since we've been forgoing fees of roughly $5 million each quarter — right, Scott? And yes, that means waiving them or simply not collecting. So once we've climbed around 50 basis points, that turns into a gain for us; therefore, it's an advantage going forward as well. You'll likely see it completely reflected by the third quarter, though the second quarter should show some of that upside too.

Scott Grauer

executive
#54

On top of that, there's simply a combined lift for overall AUMA, since at the close of the quarter, cash made up 14% of the allocation dollars across our total assets, out of the $101 billion we hold in AUM.

Matt Olney

analyst
#55

I'd like to return to the trading securities portfolio on the balance sheet. My recollection is that it accounted for roughly 20% of running assets during the first quarter. I suppose the end-of-period figure, near $5 billion, implies it's closer to about 12% of earning assets by late 1Q. I'm just trying to understand, Steven, with regard to the NII guidance, what assumption you're making for that trading securities portfolio?

Steven Nell

executive
#56

It's sitting at a level comparable to where it stood at quarter-end. I don't believe we have it increasing; it comes back to what these guys discussed regarding the inventory and the opportunity — I think we're holding it fairly near where we finished the quarter. When we examined our modeling ahead for the remainder of the year, it could turn out better. But that's essentially what we relied on.

Matt Olney

analyst
#57

Then I suppose I'll ask something that builds on that. Regarding the outlook you provided for this year, Steven, what level of total average earning assets does it factor in?

Steven Nell

executive
#58

Honestly, I don't currently have those figures with me. However, take our projection for loan growth — it sits in the upper single digits — and assume AFS stays level. Keep trading securities essentially unchanged as well. Next, consider the funding side: the mix barely shifts, though our model does include a modest drop in deposits prior to year-end. Those are the variables feeding the model that produces the NII outlook I shared.

Matt Olney

analyst
#59

All right. All right. So if we revisit the trading inventory, could you walk me through the way it has been financed on the liabilities side over the past 2 years? And then, given the contraction in average balance we anticipate for that trading inventory, how should we think about what that implies for the other side of the balance sheet?

Steven Nell

executive
#60

Sure, it comes from every one of our funding sources together. What I mean is, we don't really carve out a single one and match it against another. Liquidity has been so abundant for us that there's no need to separate things and claim a particular piece of the balance sheet is backed by X; at least, that's how it works in my head.

Matt Olney

analyst
#61

All right. And then finally, I believe, Nell, you said that certain trading positions remained open back in March at the time you filed the 8-K. Do any positions still remain open that might lead to additional losses going forward?

Steven Nell

executive
#62

Well, I suppose that possibility always exists. Some of the securities we were working with during the first quarter are still on our books. We continue to hold an inventory of them. But as Scott said, more than 70% of that basket of securities has been sold; and actually, by now, we've sold even more. So yes, some securities could present that opportunity, but we don't see that — we don't anticipate it occurring.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#63

Because of the inventory decrease and the write-down we recorded, any subsequent adjustment probably wouldn't be significant going forward. What I'm saying is, it definitely wouldn't come anywhere close to the size of what showed up in Q1.

Taylor Brodarick

analyst
#64

I've got a few big-picture questions. Regarding fiduciary and asset management, that line was only off 1%, though equity markets clearly got weaker. I'm wondering whether there's anything else you can share regarding customer acquisitions, or perhaps assets per customer climbing once more, which might have cushioned that drop this quarter.

Scott Grauer

executive
#65

Yeah, Scott here. During Q1, the decline we recorded in AUMA on a net basis stemmed from moves and decreases in market value. Sales activity was in fact solid pretty much everywhere. So when it comes to our fiduciary assets, safekeeping assets, brokerage, and assets under administration, we're feeling positive. Pipelines have been robust, and a new asset acquisition has delivered really strong outcomes across the Board. So the decrease essentially mirrors market adjustment.

Taylor Brodarick

analyst
#66

Great. You may have addressed this already, but regarding the repurchase program, plainly, does anything shift considering the current share price, especially since capital remains quite strong? Or is there perhaps a greater preference to reserve that for other inorganic possibilities?

Steven Nell

executive
#67

No. I believe you can — you will observe us active in the market at the price point we're at right now compared with what we acquired during the prior couple of quarters. I believe the dollar amount we'll deploy for buybacks will be quite close to sort of the average you've witnessed over the past year. That sort of aligns with our capital allocation toward repurchases; therefore you should anticipate us being in the market.

Steven Nell

executive
#68

All right, once more, I appreciate all of you being here with us. Should any additional questions come up, feel free to reach out by phone. My number is (918) 595 to 3030, and e-mail works too at ir@bokf.com. Thanks once more, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#69

That brings us to the end of today's call. You're free to hang up now, and we appreciate your joining us.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete BOK Financial Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to BOK Financial Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in BOK Financial Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.