BOK Financial Corporation (BOKF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 25, 2023

NASDAQ US Financials Banks earnings 44 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Steven Nell

executive
#1

Hello, everyone, and thank you for being with us this morning. Our Chief Executive Officer, Stacy Kymes, is going to start things off with some opening remarks. After that, Marc Maun, who serves as Executive Vice President for Regional Banking, will walk through the loan portfolio along with the credit metrics tied to it. Scott Grauer, Executive Vice President of Wealth Management, will then discuss the results we generate from fees. I'll follow with the specifics on the key metrics that measure financial performance, and Martin Grunst, the incoming CFO we recently named, will share our guidance looking forward. You can find a PDF of the slide presentation as well as the Q4 press release on our website, bokf.com. Please take note of the disclaimers shown on slide 2, which address the forward-looking statements we make during the call. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Stacy Kymes.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#2

Hello, and welcome. We appreciate you being here as we go over BOK Financial's results for the fourth quarter and the entire 2022 fiscal year. If you look at slide 4, net income for Q4 came to $168 million, which works out to $2.51 per diluted share. Those robust Q4 figures extended the positive earnings trajectory that has been building all through 2022. During this quarter, we recorded the largest pre-provision net revenue ever in our company's history. With Q4 now behind us, that makes five consecutive quarters of healthy core loan expansion, and the annualized rate for core loan growth reached 13%. Fee-based operations stayed resilient in both the quarter and the full year, even as equity and fixed income markets together posted their weakest performance since the late 1960s. Because short-term rates kept climbing over the quarter, our asset-sensitive balance sheet combined with rising earning assets produced a $36 million gain in net interest revenue, along with a linked quarter bump of 30 basis points in net interest margin. Credit is also due to our varied fee sources, since linked quarter fees held steady even with a full quarter's worth of impact from the previously announced customer overdraft program changes, plus the ongoing slump in mortgage origination activity. We did see linked quarter net charge-offs go up. The quality of our assets continues to trend at levels that are unsustainably favorable. Acknowledging the considerable expansion in loans and unfunded commitments over the quarter, we did increase our credit loss reserve. Economic outlook uncertainty stayed elevated, and key economic factors were marginally less positive this quarter. Let's move to slide 5. Core loan balances at period end rose $773 million, or 3.5% linked quarter, with gains distributed among C&I and commercial real estate. Unfunded loan commitments climbed $839 million linked quarter and are up $2.9 billion across the past 12 months. Utilization rates are still a bit under historical norms, meaning there's room for further expansion in outstanding balances. Average deposit volumes remain elevated relative to pre-pandemic levels. We did see a decline of $1.6 billion, or 4%, this quarter, with runoff in both interest-bearing and non-interest-bearing balances. Such decreases matched what the industry experienced as the Federal Reserve kept pushing short-term rates up in its effort to cool inflation. Assets under management or administration rose $4.3 billion, or 4.5% linked quarter, but fell $5.2 billion, or 4.9%, versus a year ago. The equity market's effect this year, with equities making up roughly one third of the total, was partly offset by new sales that fueled the results. Before we begin the Q&A session, I'll share some further insight into these results. Now Marc Maun is going to walk through the loan portfolio and our credit metrics in greater depth. I'll hand things over to Marc.

Marc Maun

executive
#3

Appreciate that, Stacy. Now if you’ll move with me to slide 7, at period end our core loan portfolio held $22.5 billion in loans, which was a 3.5% rise from the prior quarter. Within that, total C&I loans rose $591 million, or 4.3%, quarter over quarter, and for the year they’re up $1.7 billion, or 13.5%, with gains seen in every sector. Unfunded C&I commitments were up 7.4% from the previous quarter. Commercial real estate loans grew $133 million, or 3%, from the linked quarter, and over the year they’ve risen $775 million, or 20%. That essentially brings those balances back to where they stood in 2020, following a lot of paydown activity during 2021. The yearly gain came mostly from loans backed by multifamily residential properties and industrial facilities. Unfunded commercial real estate commitments rose 4.9% quarter over quarter. Our approach to CRE lending stays disciplined — we allocate 185% of Tier 1 capital and reserves against total CRE commitments; right now we’re at the top end of that range, though we do anticipate outstanding CRE balances rising in 2023 as construction loans fund up. Healthcare balances were up modestly this quarter, rising $18 million, or 0.5%, while for the year they’re up $430 million, or 12.6%, largely due to our senior housing sector. Healthcare unfunded commitments rose 16% from the linked quarter, and we expect that to drive further balance growth. Energy balances grew $53 million, or 1.6%, quarter over quarter, and are up $418 million, or 13.9%, year-over-year. Unfunded commitments there rose 9.6% from the prior quarter, leaving an average utilization rate of roughly 49%, which gives us more room for continued balance sheet growth. General business loans had a solid quarter, with balances rising $368 million, or 11.8%, from the linked quarter. Most loans in that general business category come from our wholesale and retail sectors. Our services sector also saw loan growth, with balances up $151 million, or 4.6%, quarter over quarter. Service sector loans are made up of a large number of loans across many kinds of businesses, including Native American, tribal, and state and local governments, plus tribal casino operations, foundations, not-for-profit organizations, educational services, and specialty trade contractors. Taken together, services and general business loans are up $844 million, or 13.9%, year-over-year. Unfunded commitments across those combined services and general business categories rose 4.4% from the linked quarter, which nudged utilization rates a bit lower. Utilization rates are still running under where they were before COVID. We’re still well positioned to grow outstanding loan balances without needing any new customer acquisition to do it. Over the past 12 months, core loans have increased $2.6 billion, or 13% — the biggest annual dollar gain in our history, if you exclude acquisitions in PPP loans. While we don’t anticipate loan growth staying at that pace, we think the momentum from the last five quarters will carry into 2023 as customers raise their line utilizations. Moving to slide 8, credit quality across the loan portfolio remains exceptionally strong. Non-performing assets, excluding those guaranteed by US government agencies, were down $22 million this quarter. Non-accrual loans fell $9 million, and repossessed assets dropped $15 million. Because loan balances still outstanding grew robustly and unfunded commitments rose during this quarter, we put an additional $15 million into our provision for expected credit losses. Uncertainty stayed elevated in the economic outlook behind our reasonable and supportable forecast, and across every scenario the key economic factors had turned slightly less supportive of growth. Our probability weighting for the downside forecast was 40%, the same as the prior quarter. Given where our credit stands today, a commercial real estate capital allocation ratio well under that of our peers, and a track record of beating expectations through earlier credit cycles, we feel we are positioned favorably if an economic downturn shows up in upcoming quarters. During the Q4 we had a net charge-off of $15.5 million, and essentially all of it came from one single credit. Across the full year, net charge-offs came to an average of 10 basis points, well under the 30 to 40 basis points range that marks our historical losses. Going forward, we anticipate net charge-offs will stay low. At quarter end, our combined Allowance for Credit Losses stood at $297 million, equal to 1.31% of loans outstanding. We anticipate holding that ratio steady or drifting modestly higher, since we expect robust loan growth to persist along with ongoing economic uncertainty tied to market conditions while the Fed works toward its objective of bringing inflation down. Both of those conditions lend support to credit provisions ahead. At this point I'll hand the call to Scott.

Scott Grauer

executive
#4

Appreciate that, Marc. Moving on to slide 10. For Q4, total fees and commissions came in at $194 million, which is fairly consistent with what we saw the prior quarter. During Q3, we had record-breaking performance in commodity and hedging activities, plus investment banking activities across the entire bank. Linked quarter, trading fees rose by $9 million as we capitalized on advantageous market conditions and heightened market volatility. Compared to last quarter's record high, our commodity and hedging activities dropped by $4.7 million, with quarter-over-quarter decreases in both energy and interest rate derivatives. Investment banking activities bank-wide decreased by $2.4 million versus last quarter's record high. Commercial loan syndication fees were up $2.3 million on a linked quarter basis, but this was offset by a $4.7 million drop in other investment banking fees, mostly from fees in our municipal investment banking segment. For the year, combining our investment banking and customer hedging activities from the wealth and commercial segments produced $91 million in fee income, which is $36 million or 67% more than 2021. Fiduciary and asset management fees totaled $50 million in Q4, essentially flat from the previous quarter; over the full year, these fees grew by $18 million or 10%, largely because of lower fund fee waivers resulting from rising short-term interest rates, along with market-driven gains in our oil and gas fees. Our assets under management or administration ended the year at $99.7 billion, up $4.3 billion or 4.5% from the prior quarter, with increases in every category. This quarter, our asset mix for assets under management or administration stayed about the same, at 45% fixed income, 32% equities, 14% cash, and 9% alternatives. Deposit service charges were down $2.3 million in the quarter, mainly because of adjustments we made to our overdraft program during that period. Commercial service charges dipped a bit too, as we raised the earnings credit rate for our customers. Mortgage banking revenue reached $10 million this quarter, a modest decline from the previous quarter, with production revenues falling $1.6 million owing to a $119 million drop in production volumes along with tighter margins. Mortgage servicing fees ticked up this quarter and stand 25% above Q4 of last year. Over the last 18 months, we've made strategic acquisitions of servicing for roughly $6 billion in unpaid principal balances, which will contribute $15 million in annual servicing revenue. At this point, I'll hand the call to Steven so he can walk through our Net Interest Margin dynamics and the key balance sheet items for the quarter. Steven?

Steven Nell

executive
#5

Thank you, Scott. If you’ll look at slide 12, our Net Interest Revenue for the fourth quarter came in at $353 million, which is up $36 million from the prior quarter. Because rates moved up quickly, along with robust growth in our loans and our asset-sensitive positioning, Net Interest Margin rose on a linked-quarter basis from 3.24% to 3.54%. That improvement was partly counterbalanced by growth in our securities portfolio, which has a modest margin-dilutive effect even as it lifts Net Interest Revenue. Interest-bearing deposits saw their average effective rate rise by 59 basis points during the quarter, which brought our Deposit Beta for the full year to 32%. Average earning assets were up $757 million versus the prior quarter. The average Available-for-Sale securities portfolio grew $648 million in the quarter, as we added $1.5 billion to that portfolio on a linked-quarter basis to move back toward a more neutral interest rate posture. Average loans rose $377 million, while cash and cash equivalents declined $180 million. If you turn to slide 13, you’ll see that our liquidity remains quite robust. Our Loan-to-Deposit Ratio moved up to 65.4% this quarter, compared with 59.8% as of September 30th. Total deposits were down $1.9 billion, while loan balances grew $767 million during the quarter. Even though it is rising, our Loan-to-Deposit Ratio is still comfortably under the 78.7% pre-pandemic level we had at year-end 2019, which gives us ample on-balance sheet liquidity to satisfy future customer loan demand. Our capital position is also solid, with a Common Equity Tier 1 ratio of 11.7%, which is comfortably above regulatory thresholds; it’s worth noting that despite strong loan growth and meaningful unrealized losses in our Available-for-Sale securities portfolio, our Tangible Common Equity ratio is still a healthy 7.63%. The holding company and the bank both carry investment grade ratings from all three major rating agencies. Given these strong capital levels, we were active again with share repurchase, taking advantage of opportunities to buy back 314,000 shares in the open market at an average price of $103.14 per share; we expect to remain active in repurchasing shares over the next 4 quarters. Now on slide 14, total expenses on a linked-quarter basis rose $24 million, with $16 million coming from personnel and $8 million from non-personnel expense. Of the personnel expense, $10 million relates to cash-based compensation tied to higher sales activity, together with a one-time employee incentive. Deferred compensation expense, which market valuations directly affect, rose $5 million. The linked-quarter rise in non-personnel expense was mostly due to higher professional fees and business promotion spend, along with a contribution to the BOKF Charitable Foundation. I’ll now hand the call over to Marty Grunst, our incoming CFO, who will give our forward guidance. Marty?

Martin Grunst

executive
#6

Appreciate that, Steven. Moving on to slide 16, I want to walk through what we're anticipating for 2023; on an annualized basis, we're looking at loan growth somewhere in the mid to upper single digits. Our geographic footprint's economy is still quite robust and could outpace others in this cycle, thanks to the significant amount of business relocating from other markets. Meaningful growth in unfunded commitments across 2022, combined with low line utilization, ought to provide another tailwind for loan growth. In Q4 of 2022, we put an additional $1.5 billion into our Available-for-Sale securities portfolio, which brought us nearer to an interest rate neutral stance. Our plan is to keep the portfolio at that elevated level in 2023; given a solid foundation of core deposits, we anticipate slight attrition in interest-bearing and demand deposits, which should push our Loan-to-Deposit Ratio up somewhat while it stays under historical levels. Right now, our assumption is 25 basis point hikes in February and March, after which the Federal Reserve takes a pause. We think the margin will drift slightly lower during the first half of 2023 as interest-bearing Deposit Betas rise, demand deposit balance attrition plays out, and our interest rate position becomes more balanced. For December, Net Interest Margin came in at 3.57%. We expect Net Interest Income to reach close to $1.4 billion overall in 2023; taken together, total fees and commissions revenue should come in near $750 million for 2023. Over the near term, we anticipate expenses below Q4 2022 levels, then drifting back up toward that level as 2023 progresses. Our expectation remains that revenue growth exceeds expense growth, keeping the Efficiency Ratio under 60% and getting close to 57% by the end of 2023. Our allowance sits a bit above the peer median, and we intend to keep a robust credit reserve. Based on our loan growth outlook and the strength of our credit quality, we're expecting quarterly provisions in line with the second half of 2022. Asset quality right now is quite strong and doesn't point to any meaningful deterioration. Shifts in the economic outlook will naturally affect our provision expense; as Steven mentioned earlier, we plan to keep up our quarterly share repurchases. At this point I'll hand the call back to Stacy Kymes for some closing remarks.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#7

Thanks, Marty. Those solid Q4 numbers — and really, the full-year earnings — show just how well this bank was set up to grow profits while rates were climbing. Because of the unusual circumstances that sent rates falling so sharply, we deliberately moved toward greater asset sensitivity. That was a choice we made, and we've since shifted back to a more balanced interest rate risk stance. Our asset-sensitive balance sheet paid off handsomely in 2022, and so did our push for top-line revenue gains. We posted the biggest yearly loan growth ever recorded at this company, spread across our entire geographic footprint and every business line sector. Thanks to our varied fee streams, we nearly offset the 53% drop in mortgage banking fees versus a year earlier, while commodities and investment banking each set fresh records. Last year brought $100 million in loan loss reserve releases, against an actual provision of $30 million in 2022. The wide array of products we offer our clients delivered the top-line revenue growth we'd targeted when the year began, and it leaves us in a strong spot entering the new year. Credit quality remains quite steady and above pre-pandemic levels, even if that probably can't last. Our combined allowance still sits above the median for our peer group. We're at a point where putting money into strong banks, rather than trading the sector, is likely to be what counts. Institutions with disciplined growth, a varied business mix, substantial core deposits, and a track record of credit discipline ought to come out ahead. No matter which way the economy turns — better or worse — we're ready as we head into the coming year. I'm proud of my colleagues at BOK Financial, who put in tremendous effort to produce these excellent results. Before we finish, I'd be remiss if I didn't recognize my friend and our longtime CFO, Steven Nell, since this marks his final earnings call. Steven has been a real asset to this company and served with tremendous character. His contributions will be missed. We're lucky to have such deep talent, with Marty Grunst stepping in to take on the CFO role. A lot of you know Marty from when he served as our treasurer, before becoming our chief risk officer. With that, we're happy to take your questions. Operator?

Jared Shaw

analyst
#8

Good morning.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#9

Good morning, Jared.

Jared Shaw

analyst
#10

Let me start by saying I share what Stacy expressed. Steve, my congratulations to you on the retirement you have coming up. Marty, congratulations on taking on this new position, and I'm eager to collaborate with you as you move forward in it.

Martin Grunst

executive
#11

Thanks.

Jared Shaw

analyst
#12

Right. Perhaps, considering the asset sensitivity and the actions taken during this quarter, do you feel you've reached the point of being more fully neutral now? Or might there be further adjustments to the securities portfolio needed to achieve that? Regarding how that's funded, did it involve match funding, or what is the duration of the funding for that positioning?

Martin Grunst

executive
#13

Yes. Jared, we're quite content with the neutral stance we achieved from that increase. We'll keep monitoring that stance as the year goes on. I mean, that's something we review constantly; it's entirely funded through variable rate funding; that's necessary to produce the effect of the rate risk position. That's how it turned out.

Jared Shaw

analyst
#14

All right. Regarding that trade, as rates begin declining afterward, we might anticipate some spread widening, correct? How long is the duration for the securities being bought?

Martin Grunst

executive
#15

Yes. Those are our standard Mortgage-Backed Securities. Duration falls roughly around 3 years, perhaps slightly beyond that range.

Jared Shaw

analyst
#16

All right, thank you. Setting aside the increase in loans, it appears there is, as you mentioned, solid momentum as we head into the year. Are spreads on loans improving at this point? And also, what would need to occur, I suppose, for clients to return and engage again, and for that utilization rate to climb as we move ahead?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#17

Yes. All right, Jared, this is Marc Maun. I wouldn't describe the spread as having widened, though it certainly hasn't narrowed. It has simply followed along throughout the entire year and remained pretty steady. We haven't truly observed any meaningful movement there. Regarding utilization rates, I mean, looking at the C&I segment, CRE will rise on its own simply because of construction loans. On the C&I side, it's more a matter, I believe, of our customers having grown commitments more quickly than they've drawn down. I think that comes from their cash positions and liquidity positions.

Steven Nell

executive
#18

A portion of that is going to get used up first, prior to us witnessing an increase in utilization. As time moves forward, our expectation is that this will keep happening. There remains some of it that simply needs to be consumed within the operation.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#19

All right, thank you. So last thing, regarding capital — what's your main area of attention when it comes to the TCE ratio, in terms of how you intend to manage surplus capital? Should that be what we're concentrating on, and where do you expect it will eventually be deployed or settle out?

Steven Nell

executive
#20

Okay, Steven here. Our Tangible Common Equity has been sitting in the 11.5% to 12% band, and honestly, that's a zone we're comfortable with. It's the main metric we focus on. At times, total capital ends up being the binding constraint, but as you've observed across the past few quarters, we've maintained a solid amount of buybacks. Our plan is to keep doing those when the opportunity arises, deploying capital that way, and paying a strong dividend. During the quarter, we nudged that up slightly. Whatever remains will go toward expanding loans and growing the balance sheet so our businesses are supported; that's basically our framework.

Jared Shaw

analyst
#21

Great. Thank you.

Brady Gailey

analyst
#22

Hey, thank you. Good morning, guys.

Steven Nell

executive
#23

Morning. Morning.

Brady Gailey

analyst
#24

I'd like to pose the buyback matter in another way. Looking back at 2022, you bought back roughly 2.5% of the company, which came to about $155 million in shares. For 2023, ought we to anticipate roughly the same? Obviously, you have surplus capital on hand, so it seems you might potentially go beyond that level.

Steven Nell

executive
#25

My guess is it'll look pretty much the same. That quarterly band you've been seeing — somewhere between $30 million and $50 million — seems to match the capital profile well. We believe we have that amount of money available for repurchasing shares, though it varies by quarter. Scott handles that on our behalf, and when we spot a favorable price, we tend to act more aggressively. Should the price climb, we'll ease off somewhat. That's the reason it fluctuates quarter to quarter. For 2023, I'd expect a comparable volume of buybacks to what we did in 2022. Once again, everything hinges on market conditions.

Brady Gailey

analyst
#26

Alright, so BOKF has been involved in energy and healthcare lending for many years and has a lot of experience in both, and those areas make up a significant portion of the loans on your books. With the way pricing looks right now, I realize energy is performing very well. You're beginning to pick up on a bit of softness in healthcare. At this point, nothing like that is showing up in your figures, but perhaps you could just give us an update on what your expectations are regarding credit quality over the coming couple of years when it comes to the healthcare borrowers you have.

Steven Nell

executive
#27

Mark here, Brady. We're definitely watching the healthcare portfolios closely — largely because of the pressures there involving labor expenses in the senior housing sector, which is the main space we concentrate on, plus the lagging Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement rates that still haven't fully caught up. We're noticing some problems in that area, though it's something we'll continue monitoring. For a long while now, we have been. We've operated in this field for many years. We've been extremely careful regarding whom we target. The industry benefits from demographic trends. Our focus has been on regional operators rather than big chains and large-scale operators — folks who grasp this business. We've weathered downturns previously, and we feel good about the customers we've chosen, yet that's certainly the area we'll devote probably our closest scrutiny to during 2023.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#28

Sure. From where I sit, looking back across the past two decades, that segment is likely the one with the smallest net charge-offs anywhere in our loan book. It's true that we carry criticized classified risk, since the timing of cash flows can be off — operating expenses get incurred at one point, while reimbursement from private or public payers may arrive at another — and those mismatches can push some short-term criticized or classified levels up. But when you look at a longer horizon, the loss rates attached to this portfolio are extraordinarily low. In fact, across the last 20 years, it has probably been the strongest asset quality segment in our whole portfolio.

Brady Gailey

analyst
#29

Okay, that's useful. Last thing from my side: BOKF has clearly excelled when it comes to expanding fiduciary and asset management fees. When I view it across several years, that segment has simply delivered tremendous revenue growth for your team. Not that it has to be the coming quarter, or even the coming year, but when we think about the next 2 years, ought we to keep anticipating that BOKF will generate this attractive revenue growth within that segment?

Steven Nell

executive
#30

Alright, this is Scott speaking. We're genuinely encouraged by the fact that, beyond our asset mix — which is quite well diversified across fixed income, equity, and alternatives — we're holding a solid percentage in the mid-teens in cash, which at this point clearly benefits us when it comes to generating fees from money market funds, including both our own proprietary offerings and the others we use. It's been good to see that momentum return, along with the revenue it brings.

Martin Grunst

executive
#31

Across every one of the business lines within Wealth Management, plus each of the customer segments we serve, we're genuinely seeing meaningful strides when it comes to growing assets. We stay optimistic and feel good about where we stand to keep that segment expanding, since our accounts are attracting assets with likely less exposure to the market and less decline than a lot of others experience who have an asset mix more skewed than ours. About that, we're quite optimistic. Yes.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#32

Another element that sets us apart somewhat is when you consider the pandemic as well as the drop in asset values throughout that stretch, plus the prior year when both fixed income and equity markets fell for the first time since 1969. Our method of serving that segment, via a highly personalized approach, is something people appreciate. While certain competitors in the market shift toward more automated methods or similar things, having the capacity for a touch point, for speaking with an advisor, for discussing strategy, and for reassuring individuals during tough market conditions — that value is far greater now than maybe in earlier times, given the volatility that has been experienced. In our view, that's a differentiator for us over the long term to assist us in expanding this asset base.

Brady Gailey

analyst
#33

Okay, that sounds good. Thanks for the update. Steven, it has been a pleasure collaborating with you. Best wishes for your retirement.

Scott Grauer

executive
#34

Thanks a lot, Brady.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#35

Hey, morning.

Scott Grauer

executive
#36

Morning.

Martin Grunst

executive
#37

Good morning there, Jon.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#38

Steven, congratulations.

Scott Grauer

executive
#39

I appreciate that.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#40

Jon Arfstrom here. Marty, it has been some time, though I'm eager for what's ahead.

Martin Grunst

executive
#41

Correct. Yes. Same here for me.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#42

All right, let's circle back to the Midwest, I suppose. Could you two give us a hand with how the margin will trend? I realize your attention is more on NII, yet you're indicating a slight decrease until things like deposit rates and flow pressures let up somewhat. What level of erosion are we discussing in the early part of the year? Do you figure it might level off and then drift upward as the year goes on?

Martin Grunst

executive
#43

Yes. Jon, it's Marty here, and I'll handle that question. Our interest rate risk posture is currently fairly balanced relative to a rate hike. We believe we will see one or 2 rate increases in the early part of the year. That could be slightly positive, at least in the beginning. The securities portfolio is going to keep repricing upward. Those are among the favorable elements. The shift in deposit mix is, naturally, the offsetting factor, as that unfolds. Loan growth will provide support for Net Interest Revenue, though it's only marginally dilutive to margin. It remains quite unclear precisely how that plays out in terms of timing, yet it ought to lead to a slight drop in margin, and nothing particularly meaningful in either direction.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#44

All right. Understood; that helps. Nothing significant changed. Perhaps Marc or Stacy — I jotted down a few quotes. Marc, you mentioned, "Should an economic slowdown materialize," and Stacy, you said, "Credit is unsustainably good." Give us a sense of where your thinking stands regarding what you're observing in credit; it doesn't seem like you're pointing to any major deceleration in loan growth, or am I mistaken about that?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#45

Stacy here. I find it fascinating to hear market commentators across the past six months shift from a deep recession on the way, to, uh, a mild recession, to now a soft landing. Yeah, I doubt any of us can say with real precision what lies ahead. We have a deeply inverted yield curve, yet we're also emerging from a pandemic unlike anything before. Every economic metric folks typically rely on when attempting to forecast those sorts of, uh, economic results is likely less dependable. Our stance is, if you believe we'll get a soft landing and we'll expand, we've shown we can expand. We increased loans organically 13% this year, $2.6 billion. We sit in a great footprint and we're nicely positioned to grow should the economy reach a soft landing. Our footprint beats most others. If your, if your outlook is that a recession will come and credit deterioration becomes more probable, then we rank among the top-performing credit banks within the regional bank space. The largest bank in the United States that didn't participate in TARP. Our credit results during the last meaningful downturn substantially beat our peers. Credit is difficult to predict. We usually say the coming six months are fairly simple to see. Beyond roughly six months, the view becomes quite murky. Looking ahead from this point, our classified loans have declined, our potential problem loans have declined, and our accrual loans have declined. We're beginning from an extraordinarily low level. Even a bit of migration upward wouldn't necessarily signal a real worsening in long-term credit trends — really just movement away from abnormally low levels. I'm not sure any of us wish to forecast precisely what we believe will occur, since nobody truly knows. In a growth scenario, we'll do well. If it's a credit event that worries people, then I believe our credit track record and our discipline surrounding it will benefit us greatly should that be the scenario causing concern.

Scott Grauer

executive
#46

The view from Tulsa is not Armageddon. It's just-

Stacy Kymes

executive
#47

Not in the least.

Scott Grauer

executive
#48

Yeah.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#49

Well, I'd say our perspective — even back when a downturn was being predicted — was that it was quite probable our geographic footprint would help us. Consider Dallas, Houston, Denver, Phoenix — what's going on in those cities — there could be a degree of meaningful outperformance in our primary markets compared to what might occur elsewhere in the nation if a recession hits, since the amount of people moving into these areas is considerable. The economic expansion taking place is greatly exceeding the broader national economy. Even at times when the widespread belief was that a downturn was coming, we believed we'd be sitting in a far stronger spot simply due to that footprint. Nothing we're observing right now — whether in conversations with our borrowers or in our own data — suggests to us that we think a recession is about to happen.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#50

Alright, thanks a lot, everyone. I appreciate it. Best of luck, Steven. Thank you.

Matt Olney

analyst
#51

Thanks. Good morning. Regarding the brokerage and trading line, I believe the slide deck linked increased trading activity to higher margins. Could you give us additional detail on what's behind that improved margin, and how much of it can carry over into 2023?

Scott Grauer

executive
#52

Okay, this is Scott speaking. Given the market swings that Stacy mentioned, we witnessed volatility in every fixed income market during Q4 that was unlike anything seen before. With the amount of rate uncertainty present out there in the marketplace, we keep seeing solid spread capability; our team is nimble, and within the fixed income space we hold a product mix that's fairly well diversified. Our view is that we will keep benefiting from improved margins in that area until the uncertainty and market volatility let up.

Matt Olney

analyst
#53

All right, thanks for that. Turning back to deposits and funding — Q4 saw a fairly significant outflow of demand deposits, and this is happening industry-wide; your guidance seems to presume that pressure will persist. I'd like to know what you're anticipating, and where within that guidance do you see things leveling off?

Martin Grunst

executive
#54

Yes, Marty here. I'll add a bit of detail on that. Our guidance does assume that our Loan-to-Deposit Ratio rises somewhat above 23, and it assumes that our cumulative beta on deposits keeps climbing a bit beyond 23 to support keeping our interest-bearing deposits. As for DDA attrition, we're seeing that mostly early in the year. With any of these attrition factors, they either fade away or circumstances shift and they stop mattering. That's roughly how we view the outlook on that front.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#55

Matt, it's Stacy here. I believe there's been talk in the markets regarding deposit attrition across the industry at large. A few things set us apart that I think deserve highlighting. First, our Loan-to-Deposit Ratio starting point is far lower than that of most peers in this area. We closed Q4 with a Loan-to-Deposit Ratio in the low 60% range. Steven and I were chatting, and for a long stretch we ran this bank in the upper 70s to low 80s. That's usually far more typical. That initial position gave us room to handle both liquidity and margin, and we're actively doing so. We also hold substantial stored liquidity that sits effectively off balance sheet via our broker-dealer and our wealth group, where money that has exited our balance sheet has moved into other channels controlled by our broker-dealer or wealth group, which, should we require liquidity down the road, could be returned at the appropriate price. We don't view this as necessarily an issue; it's actually something we're actively managing and monitoring to optimize for our shareholders.

Matt Olney

analyst
#56

Yeah. All right. Thanks for that, Stacy. I suppose I'll just remain on this subject; during Q4, the financing approach clearly involved certain borrowings to sort of fill the gap. Stacy, you brought up a portion of the reserved liquidity that might be tapped at some point, yet it didn't seem as though that would happen soon. What's the strategy, I suppose, when it comes to funding, at minimum across the initial half of the year?

Martin Grunst

executive
#57

Right. We'd expect deposit patterns overall to level out, plus we'd draw on wholesale funding across all four quarters. Where wholesale is concerned, nearly all of the securities we hold are US government agencies, and those work perfectly as collateral for FHLB. Having FHLB advances sit at the center of how we fund ourselves is genuinely standard for us. That stretches back 25, 30 years. What's actually unusual is just the last couple of years. At some point, every one of us will land on normal balance sheet profiles.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#58

Matt, if you look back to before the pandemic, our thinking was always that deposits paid for the loan book, while the securities book took care of itself via other channels — FHLB, repo, or whatever else we used. That approach guided how we operated this bank across 25 years. We're essentially returning to it now. In the past, deposits weren't what financed loans and securities. That only started happening during the last couple, three years or so. Even now, our deposits stand $6 billion above where they sat in December of 2019. Some of this needs to be seen through a long-term lens, rather than purely through the lens of the pandemic.

Matt Olney

analyst
#59

Yes. Yes. Fully agree. Okay. Thanks, guys.

Martin Grunst

executive
#60

Thanks.

Steven Nell

executive
#61

Once more, we appreciate all of you being with us here today. Should anything else come to mind, feel free to reach out by phone at 918 to 595 to 3030, or send a message to ir@bokf.com. Enjoy the rest of your day. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#62

Thanks. That wraps up the call for today. At this point you're free to hang up, and we appreciate your joining us.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete BOK Financial Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to BOK Financial Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in BOK Financial Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.