BOK Financial Corporation (BOKF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 26, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Martin Grunst
executiveHello, everyone, and welcome. Stacy Kymes, our CEO, is going to start us off with some opening remarks. After that, I'll walk through where we stand right now in terms of capital and liquidity strength. Marc Maun, who serves as Executive Vice President for Regional Banking, will discuss our loan portfolio along with the credit metrics tied to it. Scott Grauer, Executive Vice President of Wealth Management, will then address the results we generate from fees. Following that, I'll share specifics on the financial performance metrics for the quarter and offer remarks about our forward guidance. You can find PDFs of both the slide presentation and the first quarter press release on our website, bokf.com. We'd also point you to the disclaimers on Slide 2, which cover any forward-looking statements we make during this call. At this point, I'll hand things over to Stacy Kymes.
Stacy Kymes
executiveHello, everyone, and thank you for being here as we go over BOK Financial's results for the first quarter. I'll begin on Slide 4. We posted net income of $162 million, which works out to $2.43 per diluted share. Those solid first quarter figures carried forward the earnings momentum we built up across 2022. Pre-provision net revenue for this quarter ranked as the second highest we've ever recorded, and it would have taken the top spot if not for the exceptional market volatility that weighed on net mortgage servicing results. Our robust first quarter performance speaks to a diversified business model, strong operating geographies and a disciplined approach to risk management that has long been essential to sustaining our success. Our peer-leading tangible capital ratio, together with balance sheet liquidity, has served us well through the sector disruption of the last 45 days. The disruptions and the nearly unprecedented rate volatility seen this quarter showed that we can both manage critical risk effectively and keep delivering strong financial results for our shareholders. During the first quarter, we saw sustained revenue in our noninterest income businesses, continued loan growth and an efficiency ratio under 57%. While no bank can be completely insulated from the macro economy, we believe this is exactly the kind of environment that sets our diversified business model, robust risk management framework and strong financial performance apart in a positive way. Our management of interest rate, liquidity and credit risk is strong, and we stay focused on growing top line revenue in the exceptional growth markets. We turned in very strong first quarter financial results that we're proud to discuss, but today we'll divide our prepared comments into 2 sections. In the first section, we'll cover many of the key metrics around capital, liquidity and deposit diversity that the markets have been watching closely over the last 45 days. In the second section, we'll cover the core results for the quarter, which was the second best pre-provisioned net revenue quarter in BOKF's history. We want to tackle the issues that are top of mind early so the good financial results don't get lost in the noise of the recent market disruptions. Before Martin takes us through the metrics that are top of mind for you, I'd like to offer a few broader comments. The failures of Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank were idiosyncratic and do not represent broad weakness in the banking sector. Banks are better capitalized than at any time in my banking career. Regional banks specifically play an important role in our communities and play a broad role in our business and economic activity that cannot be filled by the largest U.S. banks. At BOK Financial, we take managing interest rate, liquidity and credit risk seriously, and those in risk management roles rightfully create natural tension with those in risk-taking roles to ensure the proper balance exists. We closed out the quarter carrying a neutral stance on interest rate risk, with loans to deposits below 70% — versus an average in the 80% range before the pandemic — and strong capital levels. As a matter of fact, on December 31, our tangible common equity, including unrealized securities net losses on a tax-affected basis, put us among the top 17% of publicly traded banks holding assets above $25 billion. On that basis, we finished the first quarter at an adjusted ratio of 8.2%, up against 7.4% in the prior quarter. Although liquidity and rate risk have moved to the forefront, credit risk management is likewise a core competency. We are the biggest traditional bank that stayed out of TARP through the financial crisis, thanks to how disciplined we are about managing credit risk. During good times, we have kept to the same credit fairway that let us meaningfully outperform the last time a credit cycle occurred. For commercial real estate exposure, we hold ourselves to an internal cap of 185% of Tier 1 capital and reserves, and we take it seriously. Even though our asset quality measures, such as net charge-offs, potential problem loans and nonperforming loans, are still close to historic lows, we are building a strong combined reserve for credit losses at 1.37%. Our earnings performance looks even more impressive when you consider that our current earnings include meaningful provision expense. Last, our diverse business model stands out for a bank our size. Even as the market concentrated on net interest revenue and related margins, our operating revenue is very diverse, which is a big reason for both the resiliency of our earnings and a key driver of growth for the company. I will now hand the call over to Marty to discuss key aspects of our liquidity and capital before we review the first quarter results.
Martin Grunst
executiveThank you, Stacy. A few particular capital and liquidity measurements have become the market's focus following recent developments, and I'll address where we stand on every one of them. On the capital side, the measurement in question is tangible common equity, adjusted so that unrealized net losses on held-to-maturity securities are included. Add that to the unrealized net losses on available-for-sale securities, which the TCE ratio already reflects. Slide 6's chart sets our December '22 adjusted TCE against the identical measurement for the 20 biggest banks in the U.S. BOKF's 7.4% level exceeded that of 18 among those 20 largest banks and stood notably above all four of the largest banks; because this degree of capital strength is plain for investors and depositors to see, our conversations lately with clients and prospects have been comparatively easy. As of March 31, '23, that identical measurement for BOKF came to 8.2%, a figure that will stack up well against peers' and very large banks' March 31 levels. Our robust TCE levels stem from the disciplined way we approach risk management throughout the organization, and especially inside the investment portfolio; we watch and cap TCE exposure to market rate increases. We keep a securities portfolio of relatively short duration, which adds flexibility when rates rise. Slide 7 displays the duration for our AFS and HTM securities along with the modest level of extension risk; during 2020 and 2021, we recognized that some of the deposit growth from the COVID era would not last, and our portfolio's size reflected that understanding. U.S. government agency mortgage-backed securities make up the overwhelming majority of our holdings, and 96% are pledgeable to secured borrowing sources, which provides liquidity support. I should point out that within our AFS portfolio we in fact hold $1.8 billion of securities carrying an unrealized gain, largely because we repositioned the balance sheet in Q4 of '22. Turning to liquidity. Our loan-to-deposit ratio finished the quarter at 69.8%, a solid figure next to peers and next to our own history. What stands behind that ratio is a diversified deposit franchise, as Slide 8 illustrates. Even in our bigger industry vertical, energy is the largest single industry concentration at just 7% of total deposits. Corporate Banking spans many industries, every one of them more granular than that. The uninsured deposit metric has drawn fresh attention throughout the industry, and Slide 8 provides important context around our level. On its face, uninsured deposits came to 57% as of March 31. To make that metric more meaningful, though, one important adjustment is needed. Adjusting for collateralized deposits makes sense, since they are effectively the same as insured deposits. Collateralization is mandatory for municipalities, native American tribes and certain trust-related deposits. All three are large business segments for us relative to our asset size, producing aggregate collateralized deposit balances of $4.5 billion, or 14% of total deposits. Once that adjustment is applied, our effectively uninsured level comes to $14.2 billion, or 44% of total deposits. The following liquidity test people typically apply involves stacking our accessible liquidity sources against that net effectively uninsured deposit figure. On Slide 9, you can see our available liquidity from collateralized sources listed as a subtotal of $23.7 billion, and then a grand total of $27.6 billion once Fed funds lines are included. Each of those amounts is greater than the $14.2 billion effectively uninsured deposit total, giving us yet another reason to say our liquidity standing is genuinely solid. Three points of context regarding that slide. First, what we present under the Federal Reserve's new BTFP program reflects the extra secured borrowing capacity we could generate thanks to those favorable collateral haircuts, assuming we shifted security collateral out of FHLB and into the BTFP program. Second, the secured borrowing capacity shown for unpledged loans represents what we would net after collateral haircuts are applied to those particular loan categories; and third, within our Wealth Management business, $17 billion of customer investments sit in money market mutual funds, and those aren't carried on our balance sheet. Our view is that a substantial share of that could be drawn onto our balance sheet, though at a market rate and sometimes with some form of insurance enhancement. When it comes to our deposit portfolio, the disruptive March events produced no meaningful net effect. Deposit attrition for Q1 of 2023 totaled the same figure as Q4 of 2022 and was broadly in line with the guidance we gave in January; as for the subset of customers asking how well prepared BOKF is for the present circumstances, the strong message we have to share made those conversations quite easy. When I discuss our outlook, you'll see that our forward-looking guidance on the late '23 loan-to-deposit ratio remains unchanged. Finally, I'd point out that our wholesale borrowing activity this quarter was entirely business as usual for us. No usage of the Federal Reserve, whether the new program or anything else; we have increased usage of FHLB, though it remains below what is historically normal for us. Let's now turn to our performance in the quarter. We delivered solid financial results, with earnings per share of $2.43 and net income of $162 million. Period-end loan growth came in at $193 million, and asset quality remains very strong and well positioned for potential headwinds. I'll now hand the call over to Marc to discuss loan growth and credit trends in more detail.
Marc Maun
executiveAppreciate that, Marty. Moving on to Slide 11. At period end, loans stood at $22.8 billion, which works out to a 0.9% rise from the prior quarter. Total C&I loans came in roughly unchanged, with the mix tilting toward healthcare and sources. On a year-over-year basis, total C&I loans are up $1.2 billion, or 9.2%, with gains seen in every sector. Commercial real estate loans rose $209 million, or 4.5%, from the linked quarter, and are up $714 million, or 17%, year-over-year. That essentially brings those balances back to where they were in 2020, following a lot of pay-down activity during 2021. The yearly increase came mostly from loans backed by multifamily residential properties and industrial facilities. Unfunded commercial real estate commitments dropped 13% from the linked quarter. Our internal cap is 185% of Tier 1 capital in reserves relative to total CRE commitment, and we're currently sitting near the top of that range. We do anticipate outstanding CRE balances will keep growing as construction loans fund up. As of March 31, CRE balances made up 21% of total outstanding loan balances, a ratio that's well under what our peers show. Healthcare balances rose $54 million, or 1.4%, linked quarter and are up $458 million, or 13%, year-over-year, driven mainly by our senior housing sector. At quarter end, healthcare sector loans accounted for 17% of total loans. Energy balances declined $27 million, or 0.8%, from the linked quarter, and have grown $200 million, or 6%, year-over-year, with period-end balances making up 15% of total period-end loans. Taking services and general business loans together, our core C&I loans were roughly flat versus the linked quarter, with year-over-year growth of $539 million, or 8.4%. These combined categories account for 30% of our total loan portfolio. Unfunded commitments in these categories dipped slightly from the linked quarter, while utilization rates edged up a bit. And utilization rates are still running under pre-COVID levels, so aside from any new customer acquisition, we have room to generate balanced growth. Year-over-year, loans are up $2.1 billion, or 10%. Setting aside PPP loans, Q1 2023 marks six straight quarters of linked quarter loan growth. While we don't anticipate loan growth continuing at this rate, we do think we have the momentum to keep driving growth in the loan portfolio through 2023, in line with our guidance, unless the macro economy weighs on borrower sentiment. Moving to Slide 12, you can see credit quality remains exceptionally strong throughout the loan portfolio and well under historical norms and pre-pandemic levels. Nonperforming assets, excluding those guaranteed by U.S. government agencies, were down $2.5 million this quarter, nonaccrual loans fell $1.5 million, and repossessed assets dropped $1.7 million. Now, with uncertainty around the economic outlook remaining elevated in our reasonable and supportable forecast, and key economic factors less favorable to economic growth across all scenarios, including WTI oil prices and projected commercial real estate vacancy rates, those combined economic factors supported the $16 million credit loss provision for the quarter. Given how much smaller the share of capital we've put toward commercial real estate is compared to others in our industry, plus our track record of beating expectations through earlier periods of tight credit, we feel we're in a strong position if the economy does slow down over the coming quarters. Following recent shifts in where people prefer to work, the market's attention is mostly on the office portion of real estate, even though it's still unclear whether that focus will hold as employers keep asking for more days spent in the office itself. Our maturities are mostly spread evenly across the coming 3 to 4 years, and there's always a mini-perm alternative available to us when market conditions don't favor permanent long-term financing. In office, average loan-to-value ratios come in under 65%, and average cash flow coverage sits above 1.4x, per the semi-annual review we most recently completed at the close of 2022. First quarter net charge-offs came to under $1 million, averaging 7 basis points across the last 12 months, which is well beneath the 30 to 40 basis points we've historically seen as our loss range. Going forward, we anticipate net charge-offs staying at low levels. At quarter end, the combined allowance for credit losses totaled $312 million, equal to 1.37% of loans outstanding; we've observed that a lot of analysts leave the combined allowance out when they assess how strong loan loss reserves are. That total combined allowance can be used against losses, and industry practice regarding unfunded versus funded reserves varies. For any true apples-to-apples comparison, the combined reserves need to be included. We anticipate holding this ratio steady or letting it drift somewhat higher, since we look for loan growth to keep up along with ongoing economic uncertainty tied to today's market conditions. Both factors argue for continued credit provisions ahead. At this point I'll hand the call to Scott.
Scott Grauer
executiveThanks, Marc. I'll move on to Slide 14. Fees and commissions came in at $186 million in Q1, which was a linked-quarter drop of $7.6 million, or 3.9%. The main reasons for that sequential decrease were trading and syndication fees, which fell $8.3 million and $4.7 million, respectively. Partly offsetting those declines was a $4.3 million linked-quarter rise in mortgage banking fees. The drop in trading fees was mostly the result of a $7.4 million decrease in our MBS trading activities, since mortgage originations are still at historically low levels, as are our trading volumes for both originations and sales. Trading activity has also been held back by market volatility tied to recent bank failures. Commercial loan syndication fees were down $4.7 million linked quarter, mainly because the fourth quarter had significant activity in energy and CRE. Fees from our municipal investment banking segment rose $2.1 million linked quarter. The $4.3 million gain in mortgage banking fees comes from higher servicing revenue and better mortgage origination pipeline volumes after the seasonally weak fourth quarter. Fiduciary and asset management fees totaled $50.7 million in the first quarter, up 1.5% linked quarter. Assets under management or administration stood at $102.3 billion, a linked-quarter increase of $2.6 billion, or 2.6%, with growth in every category. The mix of our assets under management or administration was fairly steady this quarter: 45% fixed income, 32% equities, 14% cash and 9% alternatives. We see our diversified mix of fee income as a strategic differentiator versus our peers, particularly when the economy is uncertain; we regularly rank in the top decile for fee income as a percent of total net interest revenue and noninterest fee income. Over the last 12 months, that revenue mix has averaged a bit more than 36%. That reliably supports a revenue stream that can be sustained through most economic cycles. I'll now hand the call to Marty to walk through our net interest margin dynamics and the key balance sheet items for the quarter. Marty?
Martin Grunst
executiveThank you, Scott. Let's move to Slide 16. Net interest revenue for the first quarter came in at $352 million, which matched the previous quarter even though there were 2 fewer days in the period. As we anticipated, the net interest margin fell 9 basis points from the prior quarter to 3.45%, driven by slightly higher deposit betas and reduced demand deposit balances stemming from the rate environment. The average effective rate paid on interest-bearing deposits rose 61 basis points during this quarter, which brings our cumulative deposit beta to 39% since the Fed started tightening. Average earning assets grew by $1.5 billion from the prior quarter. Our average available-for-sale portfolio grew by $785 million this quarter, which captures the full quarter effect of purchases completed in Q4. Average loans rose $500 million, with increases in both commercial and commercial real estate loans. Let's turn to Slide 18. We want to highlight our relatively neutral interest rate risk posture. If rates gradually rise 100 basis points over 12 months, net interest revenue would decline by just 0.2%, or roughly $2.8 million. If rates gradually fall 100 basis points over 12 months, net interest revenue would drop by approximately 1.9%. For the near term, we anticipate keeping a position that is neither materially asset nor liability sensitive. Moving to Slide 19. Total expenses on a linked quarter basis declined to $12.6 million, consisting of $4.3 million from personnel and $8.4 million from other operating expense. The drop in personnel expense resulted from a $12.6 million decrease in cash-based compensation, partly offset by a $6.1 million seasonal rise in employee benefits, mainly payroll taxes, and a $2.3 million increase in staffing costs from annual merit raises. The linked quarter reduction in other operating expense was mostly due to lower professional fees and accruals for mortgage loss mitigation costs, along with a contribution to the BOKF Charitable Foundation that was made in the fourth quarter. Now Slide 20. I'll go over our outlook for 2023. We still expect mid-to-upper single-digit annualized loan growth. Economic conditions across our geographic footprint remain quite strong and continue to benefit from business in migration from other markets. Robust growth in unfunded commitments during 2022 and today's low levels of line utilization should provide an extra tailwind for loan growth. Shifting borrower sentiment tied to the macro economy could affect our assumption if they pull back anticipating a slower economic environment. We plan to keep our available-for-sale securities portfolio flat in 2023 and to maintain a neutral interest rate risk position; we have a solid base of core deposits and expect attrition in total deposits to taper off, pushing our loan-to-deposit ratio somewhat higher while it stays below historical levels. At present, we are assuming one more 25 basis point increase in May before the Federal Reserve deposits. We think the margin will drift lower throughout 2023, as interest-bearing deposit betas rise and demand deposit balance attrition plays out. Net interest income should land in the range of $1.35 billion to $1.4 billion for 2023. All told, we anticipate that revenue from fees and commissions will come close to $750 million during 2023. Our projection is that costs will land at or a bit under the level seen in Q4 2022, while the efficiency ratio should stay around 57% or 58% for the rest of 2023. When it comes to our allowance, it sits a little higher than the midpoint for our peer group, and we intend to keep a robust credit reserve in place. Because of what we foresee for loan growth along with how solid our credit quality is, we look for provision expense each quarter to be comparable to what we recorded in Q1 of 2023. Any shifts in the economic outlook would have an effect on that provision expense. Additionally, we plan to keep buying back shares on a quarterly basis. At this point I'll hand the call back to Stacy, who will offer closing commentary.
Stacy Kymes
executiveThank you, Marty. This quarter has made clear that disciplined risk-taking and solid bottom-line performance can go hand in hand; doing both at a high level is what we aim for. Our skilled colleagues work together effectively so that expansion happens the correct way — one that holds up across every kind of economic cycle. Although attention in the market leans toward capital and liquidity — areas where we post robust figures — please keep in mind how strong our earnings were during Q1; across the past 2 quarters, I wrapped up my prepared comments by noting that we've entered a phase in which putting money into well-run banks, rather than trading the industry, ought to make a difference. Institutions featuring prudent expansion, a varied set of business lines, substantial core deposits, and demonstrated credit restraint ought to deliver better results. That is exactly what happened in Q1. Ours is a company built on organic growth, possessing a superb geographic footprint, and we think our positioning is excellent for beating the field both right now and over the years ahead; having said that, we're happy to open the floor. Operator?
Jon Arfstrom
analystSome of this might already have come up and gotten a response, but could you discuss how deposits moved before versus after the middle of March — did anything shift on your end?
Martin Grunst
executiveThat's right, Jon, Marty here. Honestly, when we compare the periods before and after, there wasn't much movement to speak of. Truthfully, spotting any real deviation in that pattern is difficult; we managed to distribute talking points to our customer base on that very day, with additional details going out the next day, and what we communicated was persuasive. As a result, there was definitely some money coming in and some going out, yet for us the effect simply isn't noticeable.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAlright, that's reasonable. I'll accept that. Marty, you mentioned deposit attrition working through its cycle — can you shed some light on that for us? Ultimately, where do those balances end up going, and what's the timeline for it to fully play out?
Martin Grunst
executiveSure. I believe what you'll observe is the demand deposit runoff essentially finishing its course. With demand deposits specifically, it's really a matter of movement between demand accounts and interest bearing ones. So my sense is that this will play out across the coming couple of quarters; however, when it comes to overall deposits, we anticipate that things will stabilize in Q2, and we'll end up with a loan-to-deposit ratio sitting in the low 70s.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAll right, that's helpful. And now a question for you, Marc. Regarding the commitment figures you're providing, what should we understand? And in terms of your loan pipeline, what areas are expanding and which ones might be shrinking or losing momentum?
Marc Maun
executiveSure, we're consistently out there engaging with both clients and potential clients. Our goal is to bring in more lending activity. We're receptive to new business. Our credit quality remains solid, and our approach to credit is something we aim to keep steady—we don't aim to ease up or make things stricter, but instead assess every transaction as it comes. The economies in the areas we serve have remained quite robust, so we continue to observe pipeline expansion; there are current possibilities we feel good about, and this aligns with the guidance we're receiving on loan growth; we've reduced the pace of adding commercial real estate commitments since we're nearing our ceiling in terms of capital, though we anticipate outstanding balances will increase as our construction loans get disbursed. Our other verticals and business lines, along with general C&I, continue to move ahead. The energy sector is still performing well, and the prospects there look favorable. And as I mentioned, with our C&I, we'll be selective, but we'll keep seeking out opportunities.
Stacy Kymes
executiveJon, it's Stacy here. I believe a key message we're sharing with our teams is that conditions like these are precisely when we can stand apart the most, thanks to how solid our capital and liquidity positions are. We aren't forced to turn inward and fixate on matters that are largely about appearances. That frees us to keep our attention outward, staying committed to bringing in customers and pursuing new business development. And I'd say having that outward focus during a moment like this serves our long-term interests best. I also think it's fair to say that, looking back at our track record, this is typically the period when we're able to set ourselves apart from competitors more than at any other time.
Brady Gailey
analystSo looking back, the repurchase program has stayed fairly steady; however, during the first quarter you bought shares back at roughly $100 apiece. Today the stock sits at $80, which works out to around 1/4 of tangible book value; that makes your shares look like a more attractive value. Given where the stock is trading from here on, are you considering making the buyback larger?
Martin Grunst
executiveYes. Brady, our view matches that. So we're excited about the chance to repurchase shares here in the second quarter.
Stacy Kymes
executiveDisappointed to get the opportunity, but we see it the same way you do.
Brady Gailey
analystYeah, yeah. And maybe real quick, I mean, two of your lending segments stand out. Healthcare makes up 17% of loans, energy accounts for 15% of loans; combined, those two represent roughly 1/3 of your loan portfolio. Could you give a quick update on credit quality in each of those segments?
Marc Maun
executiveSure, I'll handle this — Marc. Let me start with energy. Energy credit quality is essentially as strong as it gets; given oil prices, and even with gas prices at current levels, our customers have solid borrowing base support. Another factor is that hedging activity across our energy portfolio is very robust. So the majority of our gas-weighted customers are hedged through 2024 at $3.5 compared to the spot rate. And looking at it, you can hedge gas today at almost $4.20 going out to $2.25; so gas producers have good visibility looking forward, and oil remains on a very flat curve, down slightly, but — on the whole, it's in good shape. So for the foreseeable future, we anticipate no credit issues in that portfolio. On the healthcare side, it remains a solid portfolio for us. The only significant problems in that industry appear to relate to Medicare and Medicaid reimbursements, which simply need time to catch up. But we are seeing staffing-related challenges ease somewhat, and we see growth there, an opportunity in the Senior Housing segment, which is the main portion of our healthcare portfolio, and no material systemic credit quality concerns.
Stacy Kymes
executiveBrady, it's Stacy here. When it comes to healthcare, I'd say the market has gotten things a bit wrong by examining how certain healthcare REITs have done — and similar vehicles — then attempting to draw a line from that to the banks and figure out what it might mean for them. My view is simply that the permanent financing space operates in a completely different way from bank lending. Who you choose as a customer matters enormously, and for us this is a portfolio that has delivered outstanding results across a very extended stretch, so we have zero short-term worries whatsoever; and looking further out, it's likely been the strongest asset quality segment on our books today, at minimum across the past 20 years.
Brady Gailey
analystOkay, that's useful. Then last thing from my side: starting next year, TLAC takes partial effect for banks, specifically those above $50 billion. I realize you're currently just a bit below that $50 billion mark. However, if you do expand past $50 billion and thereby fall under TLAC rules, would there be any consequences? Would it be necessary to issue debt or secure additional liquidity sources in order to comply with TLAC?
Martin Grunst
executiveYes. This is Marty speaking. What I'd say is that it remains uncertain precisely which pieces of those regulations for systemically important banks will trickle down from $700 billion to $250 billion to $100 billion to $50 billion. That question is still unresolved. Moreover, I'd argue TLAC is likely the least probable piece of that to reach $50 billion. In my view, AOCI is in fact more apt to impact the $50 billion to $100 billion group. As for us, given how we already handle our common equity, any AOCI effect would be quite minimal for us; therefore, at this stage, we don't view that regulatory waterfall as something particularly troublesome. Still, we'll gain further clarity on this during the coming period — well, we'll get a bit more insight in May, and then considerably more throughout the following year, regarding how this will ultimately unfold.
Brett Rabatin
analystBrian here, filling in for Brett. Okay. I just want to briefly revisit deposits. You're nearing a cumulative beta of 40%. I'd like to hear your perspective on the pace of funding costs and where the terminal beta might land across the cycle, or whether you expect it to climb well beyond 40% from this point?
Martin Grunst
executiveRight. We're sitting at exactly 39%. And our view is that it will rise further over the remainder of the year. In fact, our assumption set incorporates a figure of roughly 50% by year-end. So that's already accounted for; it encompasses both the upcoming rate increase in May and a certain degree of gradual upward drift afterward, which is simply what would happen naturally within the portfolio.
Timur Braziler
analystTimur Braziler here, sitting in for Jared. So once more, going back to the topic of deposits. I do value what you shared regarding the attrition we expect to keep seeing, even if it happens more gradually. If we zero in on demand deposits in particular, we're getting close to where things stood before the pandemic. What I'd like to know is how much the rate increases matter. Could we actually end up under that 34% mark from before the pandemic? Or can you confidently say that level acts as a solid floor for demand deposits at this point?
Martin Grunst
executiveMy honest view is that it will dip somewhat beneath that, since the ultimate rate level you're dealing with is simply higher than what existed before the pandemic. For that reason alone, my sense is — and this is how we're looking at it internally — that it does drop a bit under 34%, though it stays within the low 30s. That's what we see as our base case.
Stacy Kymes
executiveEvery one of those assumptions we discussed is in fact baked into the net interest revenue guidance we gave for this quarter too.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right. Regarding those deposit outflows we've been observing, what portion is heading into that money market account tied to the mutual funds? And when it comes to getting those funds back, is there any case for us to actively pursue that? Or do you feel confident that a lot of that money will gradually return to the balance sheet once rates begin moving the opposite way?
Martin Grunst
executiveYes. I'll kick things off, and Scott might chime in. However, a meaningful share of that attrition leaving the balance sheet has actually landed on the balance sheet at our own broker-dealer, within the different market-based alternatives we provide there. So really, this has simply been driven by price. That means it's something we can halt or turn around fairly easily, as long as we ensure our pricing levels and our focus on that specific part of the business are aimed at keeping those funds and pulling them back onto the balance sheet.
Scott Grauer
executiveYeah, so Scott here. What I'd tack onto that, focused just on the balances that have shifted into different pockets within our Wealth Management business: it isn't only institutional money market funds making that up — we've also witnessed a lot of activity, notably high, in treasuries, and short-term T-bills in particular. And that sizable wave of liquid dollars that occurred in late Q4 of last year and all through Q1 of this year is now beginning to mature. As a result, we've got a meaningful multi-billion — a few billion dollars — in treasury volumes that have moved off our balance sheet. Those sit with us inside the broker-dealer. On top of that, there are substantial balances adding up to $17 billion across institutional and other varieties of money market funds. So, going back to what Marty said, once we reach a price point and can price those at a level we want, and when we need those balances, we're confident we can pull values and amounts back that we'd be interested in returning to the balance sheet.
Stacy Kymes
executiveYet regarding what you mentioned before, most of the cash that has departed the balance sheet moved via the wealth and broker-dealer platform we oversee and assist our clients in overseeing. That is precisely why it becomes simpler, should the price be appropriate, for us to draw it back in.
Timur Braziler
analystGreat. That's helpful context. Then, only one more item from me. When it comes to the unfunded commitments, I suppose, what portion of that follows a set formula, and what begins to draw down during this year? Are you beginning to notice certain construction deals being delayed, simply because of some of the wider macroeconomic uncertainty? And I suppose, looking at the flip side, what is your willingness at present to move step by step into funding some of those construction deals under these conditions?
Stacy Kymes
executiveThis is Stacy; we have made a pledge that we will provide funding for the commitments we extend no matter what conditions look like. Our growth that remains outstanding, really, if you review the prior several years, has truly centered on multifamily and industrial. Those represent 2 segments that continue to deliver strong results and are expected to keep delivering strong results. We have kept retail and office under-weighted. That shows up in the absence of growth within those segments. And as a matter of fact, those areas have also fallen off across the prior several periods. So I don't — obviously, there is worry regarding that. In the end, 21% of our total loans sit in commercial real estate; so the reality that we have, from an institutional standpoint, truly kept that segment under-weighted compared with other regional banks, we believe will benefit us, along with the reality that we believe we have performed well with our underwriting and customer selection too. But I think, in the end, having diversity within our lending portfolio will turn out to be extremely valuable for us as time goes on.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right, so are any customers sort of resisting that timeline for the funding? Or does it mostly match what was initially planned?
Stacy Kymes
executiveAt this stage, we haven't observed any shifts in how borrowers are acting.
Analyst
analystLet's return to the brokerage and trading fees, which were primarily fueled by trading fees in the prior quarter. Could you provide some insight into the components at play going forward? Should we anticipate growth, and possibly some challenges ahead?
Scott Grauer
executiveSure. This is Scott. When we examine the pattern, during the latter six months of last year, while rates were steadily climbing, we definitely encountered uncertainty along with volatility and some spread widening in fixed income markets. Consequently, our desks managed risk positions well while remaining engaged in the market and providing liquidity to our clients. We believe that entering Q1 of this year, we had returned to a more steady and sustainable growth trajectory for our balances and our mortgage-backed activities. Obviously, the latter portion of March brought market disruption and dislocation. Nevertheless, we've observed consistent outcomes from that activity. We've noted rising flows and revenues tied to municipal bond activity, which in certain aspects of revenue generation have now overtaken our mortgage-backed securities revenues. Thus, we believe that as mortgage rates settle — as mortgage borrowers adjust to the present rate environment — and we aren't confronting a continuous series of rate hikes, those flows will shift upward, and that activity and volume levels will return to normal. So we're hopeful regarding the activity in that space.
Stacy Kymes
executiveAlso, Stacy, just to note — that particular line item tends to swing quite a bit. Yet when you take fees and commissions as a whole, which we've laid out separately on Slide 14 of the deck, they represent, across time, a highly dependable driver of earnings. What that means is that one category on its own might shift somewhat between quarters, while the aggregate remains quite steady. And as a matter of fact, our guidance for this area for the entire year is unchanged.
Scott Grauer
executiveAs Stacy pointed out, when you examine what our broker-dealer actually brought in overall, those combined revenues rose a bit in Q1 compared with Q4. That said — and this factors in that we're pulling in bigger revenue streams from money market funds and elsewhere as balances have shifted.
Peter Winter
analystI'd like to ask something — that was a really strong presentation. Given the healthy balance sheet and the credit trends, do you see chances to gain share in your markets? And second, with everything that's happening, are you noticing some competitors stepping back?
Stacy Kymes
executiveOn the first one, it may be a bit too soon to state with certainty that we're finding chances to gain share. Still, we are definitely hearing about chances in the market anecdotally, when it comes to talent as well as customer prospects. We have two avenues for growth — bringing skilled team members into our core operation here, and bringing in customers and prospects too; so I believe we're seeing both. Being definitive on that is a little premature; but anecdotally, that is plainly what's happening. Looking ahead as we try to get a sense of the environment, how long the market keeps perceiving weakness in the sector will really be the determining factor. I believe that so long as it lasts, our strength will keep letting us generate some outsized chances that we are working very hard to seize, even right now.
Peter Winter
analystPeter, thanks. Next, Marty, I wanted to ask about the outlook for net interest income. The forecast assumes the Fed holds steady on rates. Yet when we examine the forward curve, it does build in 2 or 3 rate cuts. Should that happen, would that put pressure on the net interest income range to fall under the low end of that range if those cuts occur?
Martin Grunst
executiveYes. Peter, our rate risk position is fairly balanced. So with the guidance ranges we provided, even if that scenario played out, I believe we would still anticipate staying within that range.
Stacy Kymes
executiveCorrect — rate reductions aren't baked into what we project internally. On Slide 18, though, we laid out for the market what a downward 100 ramp would bring about. That way you're able to observe what we anticipate net interest revenue would do if that scenario unfolded across time. On either a quarterly or an annual basis, it simply isn't material. Keep in mind that during the fourth quarter we shifted back to a stance built around being more neutral on rates. Since you've tracked us across many years, you're aware that when it comes to handling interest rate risk, neutrality has been our customary approach. At one point we tilted asset sensitive so we could gain from rates moving higher, yet as autumn arrived, our thinking started to change — the risks appeared more evenly split between upward and downward moves — so we acted sooner rather than later to reduce any interest rate risk. As a result, we now sit in a far more neutral place, essentially returning to where we've stood for the bulk of my time with this company.
Peter Winter
analystOkay. A solid quarter despite a difficult backdrop.
Brandon King
analystCould you help us put a figure on how much deposit runoff you anticipate during this year, and also give us a feeling for how that decline will trend and roughly when you think deposit balances will level off?
Martin Grunst
executiveSure, Brandon. What we foresee is that total deposit balances will decline over the course of Q2, and after that we land at a loan-to-deposit ratio in the low 70s. And of course, it's — difficult to specify the precise decimal point. But I believe that provides a fairly clear picture of how we expect the remaining months of the year to unfold.
Brandon King
analystUnderstood. So things level out during the second half of the year? Is that right?
Martin Grunst
executiveCorrect. Exactly. Yes.
Brandon King
analystThen, regarding what you said about brokerage and trading, one more question. Given those patterns, is it reasonable to expect the inventory trading securities to increase gradually over the course of the year?
Scott Grauer
executiveMuch of that, I believe, hinges on mortgage originations. It hinges on overall flows. And beyond that, the demand from downstream customers for mortgage-backed securities; yet as things settle down and there's clarity from the Fed along with the rate outlook, we'd anticipate restoring those balances and levels to figures closer to what we've seen historically.
Martin Grunst
executiveOkay, once more, thank you all for being here with us. Should anything else come to mind, feel free to reach out by phone or send a message to ir@bokf.com. Everyone, enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that brings today's conference call to a close. You're free to hang up now. Thanks for joining us, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete BOK Financial Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to BOK Financial Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in BOK Financial Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.