BOK Financial Corporation (BOKF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 25, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Martin Grunst
executiveHello, and thanks for being with us this morning. Our Chief Executive Officer, Stacy Kymes, is going to start things off with some opening remarks. After that, Marc Maun, who serves as Executive Vice President for Regional Banking, will walk through the loan portfolio and the credit metrics tied to it. Then Scott Grauer, Executive Vice President of Wealth Management, will go over what we saw in fee-based results. Following that, I'll talk about how we performed financially during the quarter and what our guidance looks like going forward. You can find PDFs of both the slide presentation and the third quarter press release on our website, bokf.com. We'd also point you to the disclaimers shown on Slide 2, which address any forward-looking statements made on this call. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Stacy Kymes.
Stacy Kymes
executiveHello everyone, and thank you for being here as we go over BOK Financial's results for the third quarter. If you look at Slide 4, net income for the quarter came in at $134 million, which works out to $2.04 per diluted share. The team delivered yet another strong quarter of earnings, powered by our diversified business model, which carefully balances interest revenue against non-interest revenues and enables us to do well across many different business environments. Fee and commission revenues made up 40% of total revenue during the quarter. In this quarter, our Public and Corporate Finance group set a fresh record for investment banking fees, which substantially offset the record-high derivative fees from the prior quarter. On top of that, we keep concentrating on growth opportunities, thanks to the economic strength of our core geographic footprint, while we leverage our strong capital and liquidity position. Total loans are up nearly 9% versus last year, and core commercial and industrial loans rose 8%. We are getting ready to bring our full-service banking model to the San Antonio market, along with adding a fixed income sales and trading office in Memphis. We believe both moves will create long-term shareholder value. Now let's move to Slide 5. Period-end loan balances grew $486 million, or 2.1% linked quarter, with gains in both C&I and commercial real estate. Both period-end and average deposits kept growing throughout the quarter. Our loan-to-deposit ratio ticked up only slightly, to 70.5% at quarter end, since loan growth was faster than deposit growth. Our deposit cost did rise during the quarter; even so, the pace of that increase slowed. As Marty will explain in more detail later, our reported net interest margin is still being diluted by the expanding trading activity this quarter, with our core margin, excluding trading activities, at 3.14%. Though it will take a few quarters to be unclear, we are already seeing early indications that loan spreads are widening in our footprint as credit tightens and deposit costs stay elevated. The strain on our net interest margin from higher funding costs led to a $21 million linked quarter drop in net interest revenue, pushing our efficiency ratio above 60%, which is more normal for us considering our mix of non-interest revenue. Credit quality remains solid, and we hold a combined reserve of $325 million, or 1.37% of outstanding loans at quarter end, which is well above the median for our peer group. Lastly, we bought back 700,500 shares this quarter, reflecting our long-term confidence in the company and the attractive repurchase valuations. I'll share some further perspective on the results before we begin the Q&A session, but right now Marc Maun will go through the loan portfolio and our credit metrics in greater detail. I'll hand the call over to him.
Marc Maun
executiveAppreciate that, Stacy. Moving on to Slide 7. At period end, loans stood at $23.7 billion, which is a 2.1% rise from the prior quarter. Within that, total C&I loans climbed $185 million, or 1.3%, quarter over quarter, and compared with a year earlier they were up $1.1 billion, or 8%. Commercial real estate loans rose $270 million, or 5.4%, from the previous quarter, and versus a year ago they are higher by $767 million, or 17%. Measured against December 31, 2020, CRE balances have expanded at a modest 3.8% annualized pace, while commitments rose 5.8% over that same stretch. The growth in this quarter came mainly from multifamily properties, which rose $232 million, or 13.4%, from the prior quarter. Loans for industrial facilities were up $83 million, or 6.1%, quarter over quarter, but that gain was offset by a $24 million, or 2.4%, linked-quarter drop in loans backed by office facilities. Outstanding office loans total $982 million, the smallest amount since June 2020, and they make up just 4% of the total outstanding loan balance. The $767 million of year-over-year CRE growth came mostly from multifamily and industrial lending. Our internal cap for total CRE commitment is 185% of Tier 1 capital and reserves, and right now we sit at the high end of that cap. We do anticipate ongoing modest expansion in outstanding CRE balances as construction loans are drawn down. At September 30, CRE balances accounted for 22% of total outstanding loan balances, a ratio that sits nicely beneath our peers. For our core C&I loans, meaning combined services and general business loans, the increase was $112 million, or 1.6%, linked quarter, with year-over-year growth of $716 million, or 11%. Together these categories make up 30% of our total loan portfolio. Health care balances were up $92 million, or 2.3%, linked quarter, and have risen $257 million, or 6.7%, year-over-year, mostly because of our Senior Housing sector. At quarter end, healthcare sector loans made up 17% of total loans. Energy balances fell $18 million from the prior quarter and are up $119 million, or 3.5%, year-over-year, with period-end balances equal to 15% of total period-end loans. On a year-over-year basis, loans are higher by $1.9 billion, or 8.9%. Setting aside BBB loans, Q3 2023 marks the eighth straight quarter of linked-quarter loan growth. Our pipeline right now is strong, and we're confident the momentum is there to generate further growth in our loan portfolio well into next year. Now to Slide 8, where you can see credit quality remains exceptionally good throughout the loan portfolio, and sits well below historical norms and pre-pandemic levels. Non-performing assets, leaving out those guaranteed by U.S. government agencies, were down $12 million this quarter. Non-accruing loans fell $13 million linked quarter, mostly because of a decline in commercial real estate loans. The $7 million provision for credit losses in the third quarter mirrors strong asset quality, continued loan growth and modest shifts in our economic forecast. We're still in a solid credit position today. Given a ratio of capital allocated to commercial real estate that is substantially lower than our peers, plus our history of outperformance through past credit cycles, we believe we're well positioned should an economic slowdown materialize in the quarters ahead. Given shifts in what workers prefer, the market's attention remains fixed on the Office portion of real estate. That said, no final answer exists on whether this lasts, since momentum appears to be swinging back toward spending more hours at a physical workplace. Our Office segment maturities tend to come due evenly across the coming 3 to 4 years, and should long-term permanent financing conditions prove unfavorable, we hold a mini-perm option. Based on our latest review at the close of 2022, the typical loan-to-value ratio for Office sits under 65%, while average cash flow coverage is above 1.3x. For the third quarter, net charge-offs came to $6.5 million, equal to 11 basis points annualized, and across the trailing 12 months they have averaged 13 basis points — well under our historical loss range of 30 to 40 basis points. Going forward, we anticipate net charge-offs staying low. At quarter end, the combined allowance for credit losses stood at $325 million, which is 1.37% of outstanding loans. This total combined allowance can absorb losses, and any industry comparison on an apples-to-apples basis ought to factor in the combined reserves; we anticipate this ratio holding steady as loans keep growing and economic conditions continue. Scott, I'll hand the call over to you.
Scott Grauer
executiveAppreciate that, Marc. Moving on to Slide 10. For the third quarter, total fees and commissions came in at $198 million, a modest decline from the prior quarter. In our Wealth segment, fees and commissions once again reached new quarterly records, hitting $123.6 million this quarter and surpassing the high watermark established just last quarter. The second quarter's fees and commissions had benefited from record outcomes in energy customer hedging along with annual tax service fees. While both energy hedging customer fees and tax service fees declined from the prior quarter, record performance this quarter in our Public and Corporate Finance groups helped make up for much of that, producing a $5.3 million gain in other investment banking fees. Trading fees fell $2.5 million quarter over quarter, driven mainly by fees tied to our municipal bond trading portfolio, which dropped $3.5 million from the prior quarter amid a rising interest rate backdrop and shifting market expectations throughout the third quarter. Partially countering that was a $1.1 million rise in our MBS trading activities. Fiduciary and asset management fees totaled $52 million in the third quarter, a 1.4% decrease from the prior quarter, attributable to the second quarter's annual tax service fees. At quarter end, our assets under management and administration stood at $99 billion. The composition of our assets under management or administration shifted modestly this quarter, landing at 43% fixed income, 32% equities, 16% cash and 9% alternatives. We take pride in our diversified fee income mix, which we view as a strategic differentiator relative to our peers, particularly when economic uncertainty arises. We have consistently placed in the top decile for fee income as a percentage of total net interest revenue and non-interest fee income. Over the last 12 months, our revenue mix averaged 37%, which reliably underpins a revenue stream that remains sustainable across a broad range of economic cycles. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Marty Grunst.
Martin Grunst
executiveThanks, Scott. Now let's look at Slide 12. For the third quarter, net interest revenue came in at $301 million, which is down $21 million from the prior quarter. Net interest margin stood at 2.69%, representing a decline of 31 basis points compared to Q2. I want to point out that out of that 31 basis point drop in margin, 8 basis points resulted from expansion in trading securities. When trading securities expand, it dilutes net interest margin because it adds earning assets at a tighter spread than the rest of the balance sheet. Once you exclude the 8 basis point effect from trading, the other 23 basis points of decline came from the competitive deposit environment, since average interest-bearing deposit costs rose 61 basis points from one quarter to the next. Our cumulative interest-bearing deposit beta climbed to 58% in the third quarter, and non-interest DDA kept migrating into interest bearing. As of September 30, DDA represented 29.6% of total deposits. On this slide, we present net interest margin and net interest revenue both with and without the trading business impact, so trends and comparability are clearer; for Q3 2023, net interest margin excluding the effect of trading assets was 3.14%, compared with 3.36% in Q2. This quarter, growth in earning assets was driven by loans and trading securities, though that was partially counterbalanced by a decline in the fair value option securities we hold to hedge our mortgage servicing asset. Let's turn now to Slide 13. Both on an absolute basis and when measured against peers, our liquidity and capital positions are still quite robust. Period-end total deposits increased by $358 million, and the ratio of loans to deposits reached 70.5%, which represents a slight uptick versus the prior quarter. Average total deposits climbed $918 million compared with the previous quarter, as average interest-bearing deposits grew $1.8 billion, offset in part by demand deposits falling $840 million. Brokered CDs came up as an industry topic lately. We know we've historically leaned on that funding source only lightly, though it isn't zero. Those CDs stood at $688 million when the quarter closed. That's less than 2% of total funding, and it fell $72 million versus the previous quarter's end. Our tangible common equity ratio came in at 7.74%. That's a 5 basis point drop from the prior quarter, driven by balance sheet growth and rising interest rates, yet it's 11 basis points above where we finished 2022. Adjusted TCE, which factors in unrealized losses on held to maturity securities, sits at 7.35%, matching year-end as well. Our CET1 ratio stands at 12.1%, which would come to 9.7% once adjusted for AOCI. Because the capital rules recently proposed by regulators mostly apply to institutions with more than $100 billion in assets, our capital position is more than sufficient to finance further organic growth and keep up our existing buyback program. During Q3, we repurchased 700,500 shares, paying an average of $84.17 per share. Turning to Slide 14, overall expenses were up $5.6 million, a 1.8% increase versus the previous quarter. Personnel costs stayed flat compared with the prior quarter, since increased spending related to our expansions in San Antonio and Memphis was almost entirely offset by reduced employee benefits. Non-personnel operating costs increased $5.5 million. Occupancy and equipment expenses were up $2.5 million, and that increase came from retiring some ATMs as we upgraded our network. Our FDIC insurance expense climbed $1 million. When you add it all up, the remaining expense categories increased $3.3 million, largely because of an accrual related to some disputed matters. Looking year over year, total operating expense grew $3 million, which is 10%. Personnel expense was up $20 million, or 12%. But $3 million of that year-over-year growth came from a onetime benefit in the second quarter of '22 related to our pension plan dissolution, along with linked quarter market adjustments for deferred compensation. In the third quarter of 2023, we also had $2.6 million in personnel costs related to expansion. Compensation on a cash basis linked to new business production went up by $6.8 million. The other $8 million of the year-over-year increase came mostly from regular salaries and benefits, which are directly connected to annual merit raises and a significantly reduced number of open roles. On a year-over-year basis, other operating expense increased by $9 million, or 7.3%. Occupancy and equipment were up $3.3 million, with $2.5 million of that attributable to the ATM retirements; FDIC insurance climbed $3.7 million because both the assessment base and the rate went up; and data processing grew $3.9 million, largely reflecting ongoing technology investments. These were partly offset by a $1.1 million reduction in mortgage banking costs as MSR amortization flow. Let's move to Slide 15. I should mention that our 2024 financial planning process is currently underway. Because of that, we aren't in a position to offer forward-looking assumptions at the same level of detail we've given over the past few quarters. That said, I can share these higher level expectations covering the next 15 months. On loan growth, our expectation remains upper single-digit annualized growth. Conditions in the economy across our geographic footprint are still favorable, and business activity plus migration from other markets continue to support them. When it comes to loans, the competitive environment ought to work in our favor. We also expect to keep our available-for-sale securities portfolio unchanged and to hold a neutral interest rate risk position. Our outlook is that overall deposits will either hold steady or increase slightly, and that the ratio of loans to deposits will stay in the low 70s. At this point, our assumption is that the Federal Reserve will make no further rate moves during 2023 or 2024. As interest-bearing deposit betas stop rising and the runoff of demand deposit balances plays out, we think the margin will drift somewhat lower across the coming two quarters. Taken together, we anticipate that total fees and commissions revenue will post a mid-single-digit increase compared with the prior year, and that our strategic expansion initiatives will give a lift to growth rates in 2024. We're anticipating a modest rise in expenses as we keep putting money into strategic growth and technology initiatives, with revenue growth coming in a bit behind that. As net interest margin shifts, we'd expect the efficiency ratio to climb, and then it should trend lower once revenue growth materializes; that outlook leaves out the FDIC special assessment's effect, which may get settled in the fourth quarter of 2023. If you consider our overall reserve position, it's above the midpoint for peer banks, and our plan is to keep that reserve strong. With the loan growth we're projecting and how solid our credit quality remains, we see quarterly provision expense staying around where it's been lately, then gradually shifting toward more typical credit costs at some point later in 2024. Should the economic outlook shift, that would move our provision expense as well. On top of that, we plan to keep buying back shares when opportunities arise. At this point I'll hand things back to Stacy Kymes, who will offer some closing remarks.
Stacy Kymes
executiveMarty, thank you. During this quarter, you can see what our varied revenue streams and solid risk management approach deliver, since both we and others in the sector felt margin strain caused by higher funding expenses. Although tighter margins affect us along with our competitors, the strength of our core revenue comes from our many fee-generating operations, which is what distinguishes us. If you set aside the unpredictable mortgage refinance fee from Q2 and Q3 of 2020, the past 5 straight quarters represent the greatest fee income levels ever recorded by this company. We keep expanding and putting money into our fee operations, as our latest move into Memphis demonstrates, and our skilled teams work together effectively so that we scale this company properly — in a manner that can endure across every economic cycle. Even though capital, liquidity, and credit remain the market's focus, I view this moment as a rare chance to leverage our advantages in those very areas to expand organically and commit resources to new territories while rival financial institutions might be looking inward; our attention is on harnessing our geographic footprint's power to grow in the current environment and beyond. Having said that, we're happy to hear your questions. Operator?
Brady Gailey
analystYes, this is Brady. I just had a question about your guidance for additional net interest margin pressure — we saw quite a large movement in the third quarter. How are you thinking about how big the decline in margin might be across the coming quarter or 2?
Martin Grunst
executiveYes. That's a good question, Brady. I think when considering the upcoming quarter or 2, perhaps I can offer a bit of context. First, I'm essentially excluding the trading impacts. There's genuinely no basis for expecting that those would change. They'll respond to market conditions. And even if they do change, those are really denominator effects and they don't actually move the numerator that much. So excluding trading, the Q3 margin decline came to 23 basis points; the positive factors there were the bond portfolio repricing upward, the fixed rate portion of the loan book repricing upward, and loan growth. The negative factors were the DDA mix shift and the deposit beta component. So Q4 ought to show essentially the same positives at a very similar magnitude, while the negatives taken together will be less significant. So compared with that 23 basis points, we anticipate a smaller decrease in the core margin from Q3 to Q4, though it will probably still be in the low double digits to basis points; and really it's the beta decelerating. That's the piece that will provide the help there. As we move into Q1, we continue to believe the positives are roughly the same in magnitude, but the negatives will still exceed those positives, though by less, and we'll see another margin decline that is probably smaller. And after that point, it becomes increasingly likely that the balance is — the positives offset or exceed the negatives. But we'll provide you with additional color on that in January.
Brady Gailey
analystAll right. And loan growth running at a high single-digit rate is quite strong right now. I mean, compared with your peers, not a lot of banks are expanding at that pace. So what enables you to grow at that elevated rate versus others in the industry these days?
Marc Maun
executiveYes, Brady, Marc Maun here. At the core, our balance sheet is positioned well to let us expand given the liquidity — a loan-to-deposit ratio of 70%; we have both the liquidity and the capacity for growth. Our credit metrics are the best they have ever been. I mean, with criticized levels at half of what they were before the pandemic; and we see no major problems ahead; so we've managed to concentrate on our sales efforts and getting our teams out into the field, working with companies to produce loan growth. And while certain peers are retreating in that space. That has let us grow not only in 1 particular area, but fairly broadly across our C&I portfolio, health care, and energy — real estate, we anticipate some modest growth simply due to our own internal limits. But we have no reason to stop that effort, and we will be very focused on it this quarter and in 2024.
Stacy Kymes
executiveBrady, it's Stacy here. Let me also mention something. I believe Marc captured the key point, and this has been a major area of emphasis for us as we've watched disruption hit the industry, with competitors forced to deal with both liquidity and capital limitations. That isn't our situation; we have an uncommon chance — one that might come along only about once in 15 years — to clearly capture market share and expand while rivals are less capable of doing so; and that has been a truly major priority for us; and what pleases me regarding the expansion is that it has come from core C&I growth. Over the past year, Energy plays a very significant role in our business, yet Energy is not what propelled that. In the past, frequently when we've posted robust C&I growth, Energy was the primary force. We've seen enormous growth in commitments there, but outstandings haven't followed. So when you look at it by market, it has truly been spread across our footprint. Every one of the markets has enjoyed a solid year when it comes to C&I growth, especially, and it's been something we concentrate on; and so I'd say we feel good about our ability to sustain that.
Brady Gailey
analystOkay. All right. And then the last thing I have relates to fee income; for BOK this year that's been a fantastic narrative, with fee income expanding. Are there any components of your fee income that, in your view, are earning above a sustainable level at present and might come down toward normal? Or is this entire increase genuine, and is mid-single-digit fee growth excellent for this year? Should we essentially view fee income growth over a longer horizon for BOK as being at that mid-single-digit mark?
Martin Grunst
executiveYes, Brady, Marty here. Yes, our view is that this represents strong franchise growth of the sort we've managed to produce. And when you consider any period of roughly 12 months, we can consistently expand it at that mid-single-digit rate, and our feeling on that now matches what it was one quarter back.
Scott Grauer
executiveBrady, it's Scott here. One more thing I'd mention — when you break it down by component, comparing the second quarter with the third, a few different lines hit all-time peaks during the second quarter. Take our energy business: several of its parts ranked at the very top during the second quarter, and then in the third quarter that shifted, with investment banking and some other areas taking the lead. So this isn't originating from any single segment or component. That gives you diversification across those sources of fee and commission revenue, much the same way we have it at the firmwide level when you look at revenue. So we take comfort in the fact that these different business lines can produce fees and commissions — really every kind of fee revenue — no matter which part of the cycle we happen to be in.
Peter Winter
analystI'd like to ask, Marty, whether you could share some outlook on how you're viewing net interest income for Q4? There are just so many shifting pieces, plus how are you approaching the trading portfolio, and where do you expect net interest income to reach its low point? Do you figure it's possibly Q2 when we hit that floor?
Martin Grunst
executiveSure; Peter, allow me to offer a bit of detail regarding net interest revenue and its various components. Starting with loan growth, that contributes roughly — we saw loan growth of approximately $450 million, and it's coming in at a spread of $250 million. That's one of your positive factors. On the bond portfolio reprice, that runs about $450 million per quarter on average, and you basically see a runoff rate of around 275 basis points along with a reinvestment yield matching what prevailing market rates were. However, during Q3, we managed to accomplish that at $550 million. As for fixed-rate loan reprice, that's roughly another $350 million repricing upward every quarter, at 300 basis points. So those are the favorable items. Deposit betas still had a fairly significant effect in Q3. We observed a good deceleration in the pace of growth during September. As a result, we closed the quarter at a 58% cumulative beta. So we might see that easing. Consequently, that easing will help Q4 and going forward. Then regarding the DDA mix shift, we continue to expect that to be a larger figure in Q4, with a probable deceleration afterward.
Stacy Kymes
executivePeter, it's Stacy here. To give you a precise response, I believe Marty has essentially laid out the components; however, from our perspective, you're going to see greater margin compression during Q4, and a smaller amount in Q1. As we currently see it, it's probable that during the first quarter, both margin and net interest revenue will more or less hit their low point, after which we start rebuilding from that level, give or take, without much precision regarding the exact figures, though directionally speaking, we do think we probably reach the bottom at some point around the first quarter.
Peter Winter
analystPeter, thanks. On the expense side, if you look at the company and our strategy — and I get it, with competitors pulling back and us seizing the chance and putting money to work — should we consider dialing back some of that investment spend in the coming year, given that revenue conditions are a bit tough?
Stacy Kymes
executiveNo. Look, Peter, you've tracked us for the bulk of my career, it seems. Our mindset is that we're building this company not for the coming quarter or the coming year, but for the coming 5 years, 10 years, or 15 years. So when chances like this come along, you've got to seize them. I get how it looks, but given the makeup of our fee revenue, we aren't a business with an efficiency ratio under 60%, and we never have been. So sitting in the low 60s on efficiency ratio doesn't trouble us one bit, since 40% to 50% of our revenues come from fee-based businesses that carry a higher efficiency ratio. So we'll be disciplined on expenses. We won't do anything reckless there, but we will grow the company, and we'll approach things with a long-term lens, not a short-term one. That may be the single most distinctive advantage we hold as a financial institution, and we intend to make the most of it.
Peter Winter
analystAlright, and for my final question, regarding deposit betas — I believe the guidance was 64% by the time the year ends. Could you give us an update on that, and also share your thoughts for next year?
Martin Grunst
executiveSure. Our current view remains 64% to 65% for the close of this year, and beyond that, we anticipate a notable deceleration next year.
Peter Winter
analystDo you have any sense of where it eventually levels off?
Martin Grunst
executiveYeah. It's likely a bit soon to say for sure, though it will be significantly reduced. We noticed a decent deceleration in September, and we anticipate that easing will keep going.
Jon Arfstrom
analystMarc, this one might be for you. During your prepared remarks, you mentioned there are certain caps on commercial real estate concentrations. I'd like to know how that affects commercial real estate growth overall. My specific interest is in multifamily and industrial, since those two have driven so much of your growth.
Marc Maun
executiveSure. What I referenced is that we make an effort to keep our real estate exposure at a particular share of capital, and we're sitting near the top of that band. So growth has occurred — much of what we've recorded this year came from funding up of existing deals and construction loans, plus payoffs have slowed because of what's happening in long-term markets. As a result, we think there's still space for modest growth next year, though it won't reach the double-digit rate we've posted year-over-year in CRE up to now; multifamily and industrial are where we're putting our attention. That's where growth has come from. We don't expect those markets to slow down too much. Retail isn't a focus for us, and the office piece certainly isn't either. So once more, it will be modest. It won't match the growth rate we had overall this year.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAll right. And on that slide as well, could you discuss your office activities? I realize your exposure there isn't large, yet I notice a decline. You mentioned — you said something regarding a mini-perm choice to address certain possible problems. Could you elaborate on that a bit?
Marc Maun
executiveSure, at present, from a credit perspective, our office portfolio remains quite solid. Should 1 of the office loans come to maturity, right now every one of them is in fine condition, and we'd be able to prolong that loan briefly until longer-term markets possibly become available; however, at this moment we truly have no meaningful credit concerns whatsoever within the office portfolio.
Stacy Kymes
executiveAlright, Jon, what a mini perm means in our world is an amortization schedule stretching over 20 years paired with a 3-year term, meaning maturity lands at 3 years, provided the property keeps performing the way we agreed. That way, the borrower avoids needing to locate a permanent refinancing source — we're able to offer a short maturity alongside a longer amortization that lines up with the permanent markets, bridging them across until those permanent markets recover.
Jon Arfstrom
analystYeah. All right. That tracks. Then your shares are taking a bit of a hit this morning, and I believe that's mostly tied to the NII and margin guidance, but you've been busy with the buyback. I'm just wondering — and honestly, you paid quite a bit more. So I'm just wondering, what's your appetite and capacity for buybacks, particularly at the current share price?
Stacy Kymes
executiveYeah, I think it's fair to assume that considering where the stock sits today and considering the level at which we purchased in the third quarter, our appetite for repurchasing shares would be very high.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAnd what about capacity more broadly?
Martin Grunst
executiveYes — our capital ratios are very strong, and to do that, we have the capacity required.
Brandon King
analystMorning. Yes. I was hoping to gain additional background regarding your perspective on where the efficiency ratio is headed across the coming year, or perhaps even further out, considering both your initiatives and the way income from those initiatives is performing within fee income. At what point do you expect that efficiency ratio to reach its high point, after which we might finally observe some steadiness or perhaps a decline?
Stacy Kymes
executiveBrandon, we have never treated the efficiency ratio as a metric we manage toward. Clearly, right now we are in the midst of preparing our budget for the coming year. As a result, we won't offer guidance on that subject today; however, what I can share is that each of our businesses has a target efficiency ratio of sorts that we keep in mind. Consequently, what shifts our efficiency ratio over time more than anything else is the composition of fee businesses. When fee businesses represent a larger share of total revenue, the efficiency ratio rises. And when net interest revenue accounts for a greater percentage, the efficiency ratio will fall. Still, we will keep examining that by line of business and oversee each line of business within our sort of implied expectations for efficiency; we will keep seeking opportunities throughout this fall season to find chances for efficiency. But that is not the way we operate our company, because the revenue mix plays such a large role in guiding that efficiency ratio. So that is neither how we think about it nor how we run the company.
Brandon King
analystAll right, and to build on that point regarding these programs and what you anticipate for the point at which that top-line increase will come through; I realize many variables are in play there; but might you offer additional detail on your thinking around the schedule for that, which rests on initial blueprints?
Martin Grunst
executiveSure. To offer a handful of illustrations, Brandon. Consider our Memphis expansion as 1 of them, which involves sales and trading producers. That means a pretty quick ramp, simply because of how that business works. With our San Antonio investment, it's mainly commercial and wealth. As a result, those come with longer sales cycles; so ramping that will require somewhat more time relative to the Memphis expansion. Thus it really depends on each individual investment. So with luck, that is useful.
Brandon King
analystAll right. All right. Turning to the tech projects, can you share a bit more detail about the sorts of things you intend to pursue that aren't part of what you do today? And how should we think about that scaling up as you work to run this business across the coming 5 years?
Stacy Kymes
executiveBrandon, during the past several years, we've put substantial money into our treasury platform, plus our customer interface that connects to our commercial and corporate interface and into the technology systems we already have. We also have sizable commitments tied to our wealth platform that are in progress and that we keep pushing forward. So, as I said earlier, we're managing this company with a focus on the long term rather than the short term. That means we keep investing so that our technology platforms stay competitive and give our customers a genuinely good experience whenever they interact with us.
Matt Olney
analystLet's revisit the topic of loan growth. It's encouraging to hear all of you mention that the bank is capitalizing as certain competitors step back while they handle their capital and liquidity. Could you share any thoughts on what portion of that expansion comes from bigger transactions or syndications? I'd simply like to understand how much of the increase stems from larger deals and current syndications, as opposed to bringing aboard new clients?
Marc Maun
executiveHonestly, those are all part of the picture. In fact, we haven't seen any meaningful rise — like during the third quarter — in how many SNCs we participate in. Our leveraged loans are in fact declining. Therefore, our attention is on enterprises where a broad-based relationship can be built; as a result, we're bringing in a blend of new clients while also entering certain club deals, and so on, but nothing — simply purchasing participations in syndicated deals without a real chance for relationships is not our focus.
Matt Olney
analystThat's the heart of the middle market, right in the center of the fairway, just as we've always been across time.
Martin Grunst
executiveYes. Like Marc said, regarding the SNC — the count of SNCs for us is the same in the second quarter and the third quarter. If we happen to be part of a Shared National Credit, we have a direct tie to the borrower; usually we hold other business connected to them. The expansion we're witnessing, and the reason it makes me enthusiastic, is that it's truly core, it's direct relationships, individuals we've been reaching out to, and opportunities are emerging; so that matters greatly to us, and it builds the franchise over the long run.
Matt Olney
analystAll right, that's useful, folks. I've got nothing further on my remaining items.
Timur Braziler
analystTo build on what was just said in that final remark, can you share the aggregate amount of Shared National Credits and participations for the quarter?
Marc Maun
executiveSure. Shared National Credit volumes represent roughly 24% of what we hold overall. And those are largely concentrated in Energy and C&I, with those 2 segments accounting for approximately 80% of all Shared National Credits. We participate in about 1/4 of them, and close to 80% of those sit within our local markets. So when pursuing loans of that type, we stay inside our footprint.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right, moving over to deposits. Both the sequential drop and demand deposits remain quite high. Demand now accounts for under 30% of the overall base, which puts it beneath pandemic-era figures. So from a liquidity perspective, what are you hearing from your borrowers? You mentioned that the pressure appears to be easing. What's the expectation for demand deposits as we head through Q4 and into '24?
Martin Grunst
executiveYeah. DDA average balances fell $840 million from Q2 to Q3, and when that occurs, it represents a move out of DDA into an interest-bearing category inside the company. So looking at Q3 to Q4, we anticipate a decrease close to that same amount. Then in Q1, we think that pace of decline will moderate considerably. When we examine the portfolio more closely and break it down by size cohorts, the rate of change is visibly decelerating, and that's what gives us some confidence we'll see a slowdown over the coming 6 months. Q4 will still be a larger number.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right. So I suppose, when you consider how you'll finance that loan growth in the high single digits next year, and combine it with what was said about deposits being stable or perhaps rising a bit, what's your plan for covering that expansion? And from what I can tell, it seems like the margins you earn on that loan growth compared with where the money comes from are getting tighter. And I'm simply asking — clearly you've got the longer-term view — but what's the reason to expand loans so quickly when that margin is going to keep narrowing, especially with greater economic uncertainty present at the moment?
Martin Grunst
executiveRight. If you examine the added loan growth, the margin on that added loan volume is in fact getting wider. So we have observed spreads on new production expanding, and the economics of that new production are solid. On top of that, it arrives with complete relationships, meaning deposits and so on. Yet that added loan growth carries incrementally favorable and broader spreads. As for the funding question, it will involve a combination of a certain amount of deposit growth, and there could be a somewhat smaller portion of wholesale funding included too; regardless, it makes no difference which route — whether wholesale or deposits provide the funding — that is incrementally profitable, without a doubt.
Martin Grunst
executiveOnce more, I appreciate all of you being here with us today. Should anything else come to mind, feel free to reach out by sending an e-mail to ir@bokf.com. Enjoy the rest of your day, everybody.
Operator
operatorThanks so much. That brings today's teleconference to a close. At this point, feel free to drop off your lines. We appreciate you taking part.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete BOK Financial Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to BOK Financial Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in BOK Financial Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.