BOK Financial Corporation (BOKF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 24, 2024

NASDAQ US Financials Banks earnings 48 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Martin Grunst

executive
#1

Hello, everyone, and thanks for being here as we go over BOK Financial's results for the fourth quarter. Stacy Kymes, our CEO, is going to start us off with some remarks. Our loan portfolio and the credit metrics tied to it will be presented by Marc Maun, Executive Vice President for Regional Banking, while Scott Grauer, Executive Vice President of Wealth Management, will walk through the results we saw from fees. After that, I'll go over how we performed financially this quarter and what we're guiding toward going forward. You can find a PDF of the slide deck along with the fourth quarter press release on our site, bokf.com. Please take note of the disclaimers shown on Slide 2, which apply to any forward-looking statements made on this call. At this point, I'll hand things over to Stacy Kymes.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#2

Thank you, Marty, and good morning to all of you. Starting with Slide 4, for the fourth quarter we posted net income totaling $82.6 million, equivalent to $1.26 per diluted share, and that figure includes a $0.52 per share hit tied to the FDIC special assessment. I could not be more proud of the BOKF team and what we accomplished this year. At BOKF, our focus has consistently been on delivering long-term shareholder value, powered by our diversified business model and our skilled team, and together these allow us to perform strongly relative to our industry no matter what the economy does. We saw that play out once more when the sector came under pressure in the opening six months of the year, and we had positioned ourselves ahead of time. Risk management done the disciplined way — and not just the credit side, which has been a strength for a long while — gave us solid capital and liquidity when it mattered most. Because of that standing, we could grow deliberately while competitors were scaling back; we put genuine money into expanding our core C&I and into hiring talent in new markets such as Central Texas. The fourth quarter carried a lot of noise from many one-time items, yet our underlying performance was extremely solid, which leaves us with an excellent launching pad for 2024. We keep making strategic choices about where to put our capital so it lands in the places with the strongest growth and returns. You can see that in the call we made during the fourth quarter to get out of the insurance brokerage and consulting business. After transaction expense, that produced a pretax gain of $28 million, and we took that opportunity to restructure a small piece of our available-for-sale securities portfolio, which will add to interest revenue and the margin in the months ahead. Still on this slide: our efficiency ratio came in at 72% for the quarter. That number drops to 67% once you take out the FDIC special assessment and the activity tied to selling our insurance brokerage and consulting business, which Marty will walk through later. I want to take a quick detour here and talk about the FDIC special assessment. My sense is that most people will treat it as a one-time item and strip it out when looking at the quarter. The way the FDIC went about this was flawed — it didn't focus on what actually caused the problem, which was thin levels of fully loaded tangible capital resulting from bad decisions around asset liability risk management. I found the final rule disappointing, because a lot of thoughtful comment letters, ours included, were essentially disregarded. They said there would be a public hearing, then scrapped that hearing, and afterward voted 3 to 2 along partisan lines to put the final rule in place. That fits an unsettling pattern of banking regulation becoming more and more partisan. The U.S. stands alone in letting partisanship work its way into how banks are regulated. Serving in banking is a worthy line of work; we share strong alignment with the people we serve, and cooperation across our sector is essential yet currently lacking. Turning to what comes next, the choices and capital we've deployed over this year leave us, in our view, positioned to win over the long haul, and our varied mix of businesses will keep performing well regardless of whatever conditions the market brings. Let's shift to Slide 5 now. When the period ended, loan volume had climbed $181 million, an increase of about 1% from the quarter before, fueled by improvements in both C&I and commercial real estate. Although loan expansion slowed somewhat in the fourth quarter, our teams remain optimistic regarding our pipelines ahead. Average deposits and period-end deposits both kept expanding during this quarter. At 70.3%, our ratio of loans to deposits held steady, which is still far under that of our peers and gives us substantial on-balance-sheet liquidity to satisfy upcoming loan demand or <<inaudible>> liquidity needs. Although our deposit cost kept climbing this quarter, the rate of increase came in at under half of what we saw across the prior 3 quarters, which let our net interest margin level off. Marty will say more regarding net interest revenues, but we think we're quite near the bottom. Credit performance is still very strong for us. When the quarter closed, our total reserve stood at $326 million, which works out to 1.36% of loans outstanding — a level that sits comfortably above where our peers typically land. On top of that, we repurchased 700,237 shares over the quarter, a move that shows how confident we are in this company over the long haul and that lets us take advantage of attractive buyback prices. Before we open things up for questions, I'll share a bit more color on how the results came together, but first Marc Maun is going to walk everyone through the loan book and our credit numbers in more depth. Over to him.

Marc Maun

executive
#3

Appreciate that, Stacy. Moving on to Slide 7. At period end, loans stood at $23.9 billion, which was up $181 million, or just about 1%, from the prior quarter. Total C&I loans rose $84 million, or 0.6%, quarter over quarter, and on a year-over-year basis they were up $591 million, or 4.2%. Commercial real estate loans were up $96 million, or 1.8%, from the linked quarter, and compared with a year earlier they've risen $731 million, or 15.9%. Relative to December 31, 2020, CRE balances have expanded at a modest annualized rate of 4.1%. The main drivers of this quarter's growth were multifamily properties, which rose $138 million, and industrial facility loans, which rose $43 million. Partly offsetting that was a $72 million decline in office loans, which pushed the total office loan portfolio down to its lowest level since 2018. The $731 million of year-over-year CRE growth was likewise fueled by multifamily and industrial loans and, once again, partly offset by a drop in office loans. We maintain an internal cap of 185% of Tier 1 capital and reserves relative to total CRE commitments, and right now we sit at 172%. Because that cap is measured against total commitments, we do have plenty of capacity for ongoing modest expansion in outstanding CRE balances as construction loans fund up. At December 31, CRE balances made up 22% of total loans, unchanged from the previous quarter and a ratio that is well under what our peers show. For combined services and general business loans — our core C&I loans — the increase was $77 million, or 1.1%, with year-over-year growth of $281 million, or 4%. Those combined categories account for 30% of our total loan portfolio. Health care balances rose $60 million, or 1.5%, from the linked quarter and are up $298 million, or 7.8%, year-over-year, mainly because of our senior housing sector. Health care loans made up 17% of the total. Energy loan balances fell $53.5 million from the linked quarter and are up $12 million, or 0.4%, year-over-year, with period-end balances at 14% of total period-end loans. On a year-over-year basis, loans are up $1.3 billion, or 6%, excluding PPP loans, and Q4 2023 marks the 9th consecutive quarter of linked-quarter loan growth. Our pipeline right now is strong, and combined C&I and CRE commitments were up 2% from the linked quarter; we anticipate that continued strong momentum will generate additional loan growth in 2024. Now to Slide 8. As you can see, credit quality remains exceptionally good throughout the loan portfolio, with credit metrics far below historical norms and pre-pandemic levels. Nonperforming assets, excluding those guaranteed by U.S. government agencies, rose $26 million this quarter. As a result, nonperforming assets to period-end loans and repossessed assets did climb 10 basis points, to 0.62%. Nonaccrual loans were up $26 million from the linked quarter, mainly because of an increase in health care loans. That increase aligns with the nonaccrual fluctuations in a narrow range we've seen over the past 2 years, with nothing pointing to systemic issues. At year-end 2023, committed criticized assets came to 10.2% of Tier 1 capital and reserves — the second straight year under 10.5% and the third under 13%, versus an 18% ratio before the pandemic. Our fourth-quarter credit loss provision came to $6 million, which mirrors a steady economic outlook along with ongoing expansion in our loan book and persistently low net charge-offs. For Q4, net charge-offs totaled $4.1 million, equal to 7 basis points annualized, and across the past 12 months they have averaged 8 basis points — a continuation of results that sit well under the 30 to 40 basis points we've seen historically. Going forward, we anticipate that net charge-offs will stay beneath our historical norms. Given shifting patterns in where people prefer to work, market attention remains fixed on the office portion of real estate. As we deliberately shrink that segment, our loans backed by office CRE keep decreasing, and they now account for under 4% of the entire loan portfolio. Office maturities are largely spread evenly across the coming 3 to 4 years, and should market conditions prove unfavorable for long-term financials, a mini-perm option is available to us. At quarter end, our combined allowance for credit losses stood at $326 million, which equals 1.36% of loans outstanding. That reserve covers our nonperforming assets 2.2x over. Since the total combined allowance can absorb any losses, any like-for-like comparison across the industry ought to factor in the combined reserves; we intend to keep an adequate reserve that backs loan growth and mirrors economic conditions. On the whole, we sit in a strong credit position right now with a steady economic forecast, and although today's credit metrics might not be sustainable if the economy weakens, we've historically outperformed through prior credit cycles and are well set up should an economic downturn arrive in upcoming quarters. I'll hand the call to Scott.

Scott Grauer

executive
#4

Appreciate that, Marc. Moving on to Slide 10. Fees and commissions came in at $196.8 million altogether, which was fairly in line with what we saw the quarter before. That said, the prior quarter had delivered record-breaking results for our Wealth Management segment, and even so, the wealth figures for the fourth quarter still stand as their third-highest fee income quarter on record. Trading fees rose by $1.1 million, reflecting continued gains in sales activities tied to our institutional customers, with a bit of a boost from our recent Memphis expansion, though that was partly offset by a quarter-over-quarter drop in our MBS trading activities. Investment banking activities across the bank declined by $2.4 million compared to the prior quarter, since the third quarter had the benefit of a record quarter for Wealth Public and Corporate Finance Group. Even though it was below the record high set in the third quarter, the Publican Corporate Finance Group notched its biggest single transaction ever during the fourth quarter. Wealth Management posted a record year in 2023, with total revenue reaching $656 million, surpassing the prior record from 2020 by $140 million, which works out to an annualized 3-year growth rate of 8.4%. This came from record 2023 revenue in most of our business units, among them Corporate Trust, retirement plan and asset services, private wealth, customer hedging and investment banking. Transaction card revenue climbed $2.5 million, while all other fee-generating categories stayed roughly flat versus the previous quarter, which shows the steady positive results we get from these business lines. Our assets under management or administration stood at $104.8 billion at year-end, with an asset mix of 43% fixed income, 33% equities, 16% cash and 8% alternatives. This varied mix of fee income remains a strategic differentiator for us and helps us do well across a range of economic environments. We regularly place in the top decile for fee income as a percentage of total net interest revenue and noninterest fee income. Over the last 12 months, our revenue mix has averaged 38%. With that, I'll hand the call over to Marty.

Martin Grunst

executive
#5

Thanks, Scott. To kick things off, I want to walk through a handful of items this quarter that were out of the ordinary, since several of them hit more than one line. When we sold our insurance brokerage and consulting business, that generated a onetime pretax gain of $31 million, and it sits in the other gains net line on the income statement. On top of that, transaction-related expenses showed up in NIE across 2 components: $2.5 million in professional fees and services, plus $925,000 in personnel expense, which nets out to a gain of $28 million. We used that chance to reposition the available-for-sale portfolio, and that produced pretax losses of $28 million, reported in the loss on available-for-sale securities line. The $40.5 million total in the other gains net line is made up of the $31 million gain from the insurance sale and $5.9 million tied to market value increases on deferred compensation assets, which is effectively offset by $5.4 million of higher personnel expense this quarter. Q4 also carried $3.1 million of accelerated tax expense recognition stemming from our exit of 3 low income housing tax credit investments. Excluding that, the effective tax rate this quarter would have been 23.1%. Moving to Slide 12. Net interest revenue for the fourth quarter came in at $296.7 million, down $4.2 million from the linked quarter. Net interest margin was 2.64%, a decline of 5 basis points versus Q3; deposit pricing pressure eased considerably this quarter relative to recent ones. Costs on interest-bearing deposits rose 26 basis points this quarter; even so, that's the slowest rate of increase we've seen since the Federal Reserve began lifting the Fed funds rate in early '23. Our cumulative interest-bearing deposit beta rose to 63% in the fourth quarter. DDA as a percentage of total deposits fell to 27% as of December 31. This slide presents net interest margin and net interest revenue both with and without the trading business impact, to better show trends and comparability. In the fourth quarter, net interest margin excluding the effect of trading assets was 3.03%, compared with 3.14% in the third quarter. Going into Q1, I expect a modest decrease in net interest margin, with relative stability thereafter. Earning asset growth this quarter was mainly driven by C&I and CRE loans. Now to Slide 13. On both an absolute basis and relative to peers, liquidity and capital remain very strong. Total deposits rose $367 million on a period-end basis, and the loan-to-deposit ratio dipped only slightly, to 70.3%. That's above where we stood pre-pandemic, far under the median among our peer banks, and it leaves us well positioned for loan growth ahead. Average total deposits were up $388 million from the linked quarter. Average interest-bearing deposits rose $1.2 billion, partly offset by a $779 million drop in demand deposits. Brokered CDs are still an insignificant slice of our funding and edged down in the fourth quarter. Our tangible common equity ratio came in at 8.29%, which is an increase of 55 basis points, mostly because term interest rates declined late in the fourth quarter. When we adjust TCE to include the effect of unrealized losses on held to maturity securities, it stands at 8.02%. CET1 sits at 12.1%, and on an AOCI-adjusted basis it would be 10.5%. We hold enough capital to fund ongoing organic growth as well as opportunistic share buyback with a great deal of confidence, since we know the recent regulatory capital proposal mainly targets banks above $100 billion. Moving to Slide 14. Expenses on a linked quarter basis rose $59.8 million, or 18.4%, primarily as a result of the $43.8 million FDIC special assessment. Personnel expense was up $12.2 million, reflecting 4 main factors. Regular compensation rose $3.2 million because of salaries tied to business expansion plus expenses tied to the sale of the insurance business. Sales-related activities produced a $4.0 million rise in cash-based incentive compensation. Deferred compensation expense, which market valuations drive, rose $5.4 million on a linked quarter basis; and finally, employee benefits were up $1.1 million linked quarter because of seasonal increases in health insurance costs. Non-personnel operating expenses rose $3.3 million; stripping out the increase in FDIC insurance expense, that figure was $2.5 million tied to expenses on the sale of our insurance brokerage and consulting business; we also contributed $1.5 million to the BOKF Foundation as part of our ongoing efforts to support the communities we serve. Moving to Slide 15. I'll walk through our expectations for 2024. We anticipate annualized loan growth in the mid- to upper single-digit range. Economic conditions across our geographic footprint remain favorable and continue to get support from business in migration from other markets. The competitive environment for loans ought to serve as a tailwind for us. We expect to keep our available-for-sale securities portfolio flat and to hold a neutral interest rate risk position; we anticipate total deposits will grow modestly and the loan-to-deposit ratio will stay near 70%. At present, we are assuming no additional rate changes by the Federal Reserve in 2024. We believe the margin will drift slightly lower in Q1 of 2024 and expect net interest income to come in near $1.2 billion for full year '24. Taken together, we expect total fees and commissions revenue in a range of $825 million to $850 million for 2024. Excluding the FDIC special assessment, we expect expenses to rise at a mid-single-digit growth rate as we keep investing in strategic growth and technology initiatives, with revenue growth trailing at a slight lag. As revenue growth is realized in 2024, we expect the efficiency ratio to drift downward to approximately 65%. Our combined allowance level sits above the median of our peers, and we expect to keep a strong credit reserve. Given our expectations for loan growth and the strength of our credit quality, we expect near-term provision expense to stay low and trend toward our normal credit costs in the second half of 2024. Changes in the economic outlook will affect our provision expense. In addition, we expect to continue opportunistic share repurchase activity. Stacy Kymes will now take the call once more to offer some final remarks.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#6

Thanks, Marty. Our results for this quarter, which wraps up the year, came in as the second-highest earnings BOK Financial has ever posted. While plenty of banks had a tough time amid the turbulent economic environment, we showed once more that our revenue mix, diverse by design, can weather any storm. Other banks might be scaling back, but we've put ourselves in a great spot on liquidity and capital, which lets us grow the business organically and do very well in 2024. We're heading into 2024 with strong pipelines. Our market reach has grown. Credit quality is still very strong, and our fee income businesses are set up for solid growth. I want to express how much admiration I have for everyone across BOK Financial who put in such dedicated effort to achieve these impressive outcomes. Now we'd be glad to address any questions you may have. Operator?

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#7

Jon Arfstrom here with a question for Marty. This morning I've heard this asked a handful of times regarding your figures. Certain banks are working off the assumption of zero rate cuts, while others figure 2 to 4, and still others mention 6. How would your net interest income and margin outlook appear under a scenario with a few cuts, and then potentially as many as 6 cuts? I'd also like to circle back on fees, but let's start with net interest income.

Martin Grunst

executive
#8

Absolutely, Jon, that's an excellent question. Our sensitivity to falling rates is in fact quite limited — truly de minimis. More significantly, though, should you take the forward curve showing 4 or 6 cuts within that range, the result is a steeper curve, which works to our advantage; therefore under those scenarios where the Fed is cutting this year, it would be slightly beneficial for us.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#9

All right, so — you're talking about that $1.2 billion guidance. What you're basically saying is that if additional cuts come through, that figure might climb. All right, that's encouraging to hear. Then, I suppose, a question for Scott too. If I'm right that a portion of the fee guidance you're providing assumes rates stay flat, what effect would lower — what effect would a drop in short-term rates have on a few of your trading businesses and other fee income businesses?

Scott Grauer

executive
#10

Correct. The 2 big winners from such a decline would be our mortgage entity itself, through our mortgage originations within the mortgage group, and then a fairly quick pickup in our mortgage trading, our MBS activity — both of which, as they always have, have delivered notably stronger results when rates are lower. So we'd see considerable upside from both under that market backdrop if rates were to rise — I mean, to decrease, sorry.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#11

All right. Honestly, you folks would be glad to see some reductions happening at the short end.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#12

Absolutely, without question. In this climate, mortgages are doing quite nicely, yet from a production standpoint, where we currently sit is essentially an unprecedented trough. As a result, even a slight decline in rates would truly provide a boost there. Beyond that, that same shift would likewise assist in generating additional inventory, so to speak, for the mortgage trading side of what we do too.

Scott Grauer

executive
#13

That amount of output and the money coming in from the institutional trading group has stayed roughly flat, while other categories have picked up. So the drop in MBS has been made up for by what we're doing in municipal trading; even so, we'd expect MBS to improve, and we believe that would raise us up on the whole.

Peter Winter

analyst
#14

I wanted to ask about the lending side of things. Could you discuss how borrowers are feeling now compared with 90 days back? And then, if you would, go a bit deeper on your comment that the competitive landscape ought to actually work in your favor.

Marc Maun

executive
#15

Sure. Marc here. You're completely correct that it works to our advantage. With where we stand on liquidity and capital, plus strong credit quality, we have a lot of confidence that we're actively seeking lending opportunities throughout our footprint and in every one of our business lines. And we're attempting to capitalize on certain peer banks that are scaling back somewhat or retreating for their own assortment of reasons. So that's the push and the priority for every one of our sales teams. And I don't believe there's any specific segment we're avoiding at this moment. When it comes to how borrowers are feeling, that's — customer selection has always been our emphasis. So our attention will be on those that are well situated to grow or to expand over this period, and we'll back those companies as we deem suitable.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#16

Also, Peter, our geographic reach provides a substantial boost as well. Consider the economic growth occurring throughout Texas—generally speaking, the fresh market we launched involving San Antonio and Austin, while Phoenix is performing extremely strongly. Denver continues to hold up quite nicely. Thus, simply because the states within our footprint enjoy stronger economic performance, that reach will deliver additional momentum for us, and my belief is you'll see that across the country too. The sole significant worry I have regarding the danger to the loan growth guidance we've given is really commercial real estate. There's a possibility that, as the year progresses, we encounter a more elevated amount of payoffs, which might dampen overall loan growth somewhat. Yet on the whole, we feel quite confident about the guidance we offered, considering our footprint.

Peter Winter

analyst
#17

Understood. Then regarding credit, Marc, you brought up health care. Might you provide a bit more detail on that $40 million rise in health care nonperforming loans?

Marc Maun

executive
#18

Sure. What I'd say is health care loans represent 17% of our total loan portfolio at this point. Every so often we get a loan that has received solid management backing within it, yet circumstances didn't unfold the way they'd anticipated, so we needed to move those into a workout scenario. One involves a continuing senior housing facility. Another falls under a private pay arrangement. So these aren't even from the same segment of the business. It's simply that one-off nonperforming credits like these will pop up, and they don't indicate anything systemic that we're seeing in the health care sector. If there's anything else I'd mention, when you examine our nonperforming loans across time, they've moved within a very tight band for the past many quarters. Looking back, in certain quarters it's a different portfolio of ours contributing to the total. In another quarter, a separate portfolio does. This quarter it simply turned out to be a few one-off transactions in health care, and we'll work through those and handle them, we think, on a continuing basis within a very tight band alongside low charge-offs, just as we've experienced for quite a few years now.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#19

Peter, on a broad level, credit really is one of our strengths. If you consider our current position relative to where things stood before the pandemic, our criticized and classified levels are not even at half of what they were, and nonperforming levels remain solid. Charge-offs for this quarter came in at $4 million. Clearly, that figure isn't something we can sustain. Still, given where we stand and how we've performed over time, it's quite clear that credit is a real strength at the moment. Looking ahead, we continue to feel — as reflected in the guidance Marty gave — that we're in good shape, and at least for the coming couple of quarters, we don't anticipate charge-offs rising to a material degree.

Ben Gerlinger

analyst
#20

I was wondering — the growth side seems fairly strong. It's a touch better than what I'd anticipated. But are you noticing that people are pulling back, or that risk-adjusted spreads have become somewhat more suitable, making you willing to pursue growth more aggressively? Any insight on the rates you're receiving would be helpful too.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#21

No, I'd put it this way — broadly speaking, it really hinges on which segment you're examining when it comes to spreads. On bigger corporate transactions, I'd note there's a degree of spread improvement occurring, possibly driven by a liquidity premium in the market that the larger banks are demanding. From that angle, on the commercial banking side at the lower end, there likely isn't much spread improvement taking place. Competition remains stronger in that space. Some of this comes down to mix. As the mix evolves over time, that can shift our spreads slightly, since specialty lines of business carry higher spreads compared to traditional C&I. But I believe what we've observed is that being not merely open for business, but actively seeking out new customers and attempting to leverage this moment to expand very deliberately is generating opportunities for us. And truly, we had a number of deals that sort of spilled into the first quarter. We had hoped they'd close in the fourth quarter; so we feel good about our loan pipelines and the feedback we're getting from our customers and prospects as we consider loan growth in 2024.

Ben Gerlinger

analyst
#22

Understood. That gives me a useful picture. Next, from what I understand, the trading segment largely sits at the front end of the curve. For that to begin paying off, is a steady series of Fed reductions required? Or is it more about what the market is pricing in — do you have any view on what sort of pace you'd anticipate, assuming the forward curve holds?

Martin Grunst

executive
#23

In my view, within trading, even if rates stay where they are, there's already momentum in that segment because of the money we've put into growing in Memphis, among other places. So should the forward curve unfold as expected, that would come on top of the growth trajectory we're already anticipating.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#24

Ben, were you talking about NIR or the fee businesses?

Ben Gerlinger

analyst
#25

The fee. The fee businesses.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#26

Yes. I believe Marty already addressed that, and certainly in regard to the fee businesses.

Matt Olney

analyst
#27

Great. Let's revisit the fee conversation — I believe Scott mentioned this briefly when answering Jon. But stepping back, could you walk us through what's behind that $24 million projection for fees and commissions? Break down the pieces across each of your fee-based businesses. That outlook, as I read it, suggests something like high single-digit expansion in '24. What are the key forces driving that forecast?

Martin Grunst

executive
#28

Yes. Let me take that one, Matt; the areas with the biggest upside, I'd say, are brokerage and trading, where we've put money to work and momentum is strong. In fiduciary asset management, we should see normal growth, and on top of that, we believe asset valuations will provide a slight tailwind on the AUM side, which then feeds into improved growth rates. Mortgage also presents an opening, on both the production and servicing sides. So from a percentage growth standpoint, we anticipate solid results from that business line.

Scott Grauer

executive
#29

Matt, Scott here. When you take a look at that overall category, as I said earlier on this call, what makes us happy is that no single piece is bearing the burden. Looking across several quarters at this point and the full year, we're observing elevated and record amounts of revenue being produced in every area of Wealth Management, which, as you're aware, is quite well diversified across products, customers, and the geographies where we serve the international market in a lot of those operating units. So it's wide-ranging across the board, where we've witnessed investment — prior investments in our Corporate Trust business, in our Asset Management business, the trading components, as Marty said, yet all of those collectively and in combination are what generate the outcome that leaves us optimistic that we aren't reliant on those Fed rate cuts to keep seeing momentum and growth in the business lines. Certainly if we see — and it's less about the rate cuts. It's more that some steepness to the curve helps the trading businesses, since we've been operating now for a decade where there was no slope to the curve, which in a sense left no one to go out. So should we see some steepness in the curve, we'll see, but I believe we're extremely well positioned if that were to take shape.

Matt Olney

analyst
#30

All right. Thanks for sharing your perspective on that, Scott. Now I suppose we move back to the topic of rate sensitivity. You gave us useful input, essentially neutral when it comes to NII. What's your initial take regarding deposit betas if rates are declining, whether that happens in the latter half of this year or during the next one, whichever it turns out to be? And in your view, how would those betas stack up during a downward move against what we recently witnessed during the upward move here at the bank?

Martin Grunst

executive
#31

Sure. Because betas have come in on the higher side across the past 2 quarters, you're going to observe an almost mirror reflection of that when rates decline in that sort of setting. As you're aware, these things don't move in a straight line, so each rate increase won't produce an identical beta. Even so, on the way down you'll witness fairly elevated betas, since a substantial portion of that beta on the upside came from the bigger corporate and wealth balances.

Matt Olney

analyst
#32

All right. Hoping for the best there. And finally, turning to costs. I realize those can swing around from one quarter to the next. I believe you brought up a handful of items that pushed them up somewhat in Q4. I can see the guidance for the entire year, but is there anything you can share about how we might come out of the gates in Q1 on the cost line?

Martin Grunst

executive
#33

Sure. Take that Q4 figure, $384 million, and once you strip out the FDIC special assessment, that leaves you with $340 million; so as we begin the next quarter, our expectation is to land somewhat under that.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#34

Right, and as I already mentioned, Matt, I believe this matters. In the fourth quarter, certain BOKF transaction costs are sitting inside a few of those line items — especially those tied to personnel expense and professional fees. You also need to keep in mind that these really belong to the sale of that business, and aren't genuinely part of the company's core run rate.

Martin Grunst

executive
#35

Yeah, so when you look at a few of those one-off items and take some of them out, you'll see payroll taxes show up during the first quarter, though that'll end up netting down to just a bit low.

Will Jones

analyst
#36

Marty, I was hoping you might assist us in breaking down the margin narrative. How does it appear within this unchanged-rate setting that your forecast is essentially built upon? Then perhaps what happens to the margin should we actually witness 2, 3, 4, or even 6 reductions in rates during the upcoming year. I realize you mentioned tightening next quarter, yet possibly a steady NIM under this unchanged-rate setting, but might you envision enlargement in such a case? And I suppose just verify, all of you will definitely observe NIM enlargement should we receive reductions in rates?

Martin Grunst

executive
#37

Yes. Thus the fundamental path we anticipate is margins essentially flattening somewhat lower at the initial quarter's level and afterward truly merely somewhat higher by the close of the year — that is our view for an unchanged-rate situation, naturally, give or take the typical factors and disturbance surrounding such a pattern. And afterward if you have a forward curve type of situation unfolding, that would provide modest backing for the margin percentage across those subsequent quarters once that unfolds — when the steepness would begin to unfold.

Will Jones

analyst
#38

Understood, that's useful. So where would you say we stand regarding the noninterest-bearing remix situation? I realize balances dropped again this quarter, but does it feel like we're nearing some sort of stabilization? Or what's your thinking on noninterest-bearing deposits for this year?

Martin Grunst

executive
#39

Yeah. The decrease in Q4 came in mostly in line with what we anticipated, and we discussed it during our Q3 call; thus in Q1, we're expecting a further decrease somewhat less than Q4's, yet still fairly significant, quite near that magnitude since you get a mix of certain rate-driven shifts plus some seasonal drops that are typical for us as we move into Q1. So Q1 will show another step down, and following that, we anticipate considerably smaller volumes of migration out of noninterest-bearing and into interest-bearing over the coming 2 quarters. We're simply entering the tail end of it as it runs its natural course.

Will Jones

analyst
#40

All right, that's helpful. It seems as though it may have been some time since we last heard your perspective on bank M&A. Looking ahead to next year, there appear to be forces that could both encourage and discourage deals. Would you bring us up to speed on your current view, or your usual way of approaching M&A when it comes to in-market deals, out-of-market deals, or scale? Any context along those lines would be appreciated.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#41

Sure; there are 2 things. My belief is that rates will need to decline before bank M&A can become more of a reality. Purchase accounting problems will persist until certain securities portfolios and the banks that are hoping to be bought are in stronger shape. That will produce some drag until it gets worked out. Speaking for us, in general, a big bank purchase would be tough for us to pull off. Very little out there matches the profile we seek; our preference would be to remain mostly within the geographic footprint we currently occupy; we're quite fond of it. We intend to keep expanding, especially in fast-growing markets such as Texas, and to keep putting money to work there. Any target would need enough scale to make a real difference for us, yet very few opportunities meet that bar. Our greater interest lies in acquiring technology or products that could bolt on and add incrementally, far faster and without pulling the entire company into a regulatory approval and conversion effort. Therefore, I'd say the chance that we complete an acquisition of an entire bank within the next 12 months is quite low. Meanwhile, we keep searching for product or technology opportunities that might prove accretive and valuable to us over the long term, even though nothing is currently in sight on that front.

Timur Braziler

analyst
#42

To begin with deposits — can you tell us where the deposit spot rate stood when the year closed?

Martin Grunst

executive
#43

There isn't truly a deposit spot rate as such, though our cumulative beta came in at 63% for the quarter, and for December it was 64%; so that's honestly not much of a change from the average across the whole quarter.

Timur Braziler

analyst
#44

All right. Then when we consider costs and factor in a few of those remarks regarding the fee income side, should rate cuts occur. In a scenario with somewhat greater fee-based revenues, is the assumption that expenses rise? And should that happen, does the 65% efficiency ratio remain a solid baseline when rates are falling? Or might you in fact witness a bit of enhancement as a number of these fee income operations gain further traction?

Martin Grunst

executive
#45

Generally, I would say the 65% is fine, though a modest gain could emerge simply from a larger overall revenue lift, which would only speed up that movement.

Stacy Kymes

executive
#46

When you look at mortgage specifically, that business is likely operating at an efficiency level above 90% right now. So any improvement in that area would translate into a stronger efficiency ratio for that particular line of business. So Marty's point stands — I'd say we feel quite good about the forward guidance we've given on that. But whatever upside comes our way from a lower rate environment ought to push our efficiency ratio in a favorable direction.

Brandon King

analyst
#47

I'd like to ask a follow-up about trading NIR. What sort of level is baked into your NII guidance? And could you walk us through the puts and takes for how that might unfold, particularly since there's a chance of better rate cuts happening this year?

Martin Grunst

executive
#48

Sure. In our guide, we simply assume that it stays approximately flat across the year, and if you do see some steepening, that would certainly be a plus for that line item.

Brandon King

analyst
#49

All right. And one more question related to credit as a follow-up. In the outlook you provided, you're anticipating that credit costs will rise, with more of that happening later in 2024, and you also referenced a normalized range between 30 and 40 basis points. So would it be reasonable to think that perhaps in the second half of 2024, we get close to that 30 basis points for net charge-offs? Is that the way you're looking at it?

Stacy Kymes

executive
#50

No. What we're actually attempting to do is anchor our guidance on provision levels rather than charge-off levels. I do believe that simply due to some reversion, it's possible charge-off levels tick up somewhat during the back half of the year. But Marc did discuss our historical charge-offs a bit; we consistently guide to 30 to 40 basis points, though it has been quite a while since 40 basis points has occurred.

Marc Maun

executive
#51

Sure. If you look back at our track record, net charge-offs have stayed under 30 basis points going all the way back to 2013. That was the final time we reached 30 basis points. So for the past 10 to 11 years, we've generally run somewhere between under 10 and 20; so at this point, based on where our credit stands, we aren't anticipating a higher level of net charge-offs ahead. That said, as we expand, and as economic conditions shift, that's going to affect the provision we need to carry and the reserve we need to hold; and we're going to keep — make certain we maintain that suitable level of reserve, mirroring those 2 factors. But those 2 things will be the bigger driver of it rather than net charge-offs.

Martin Grunst

executive
#52

We appreciate all of you being with us today. Should you have any inquiries, feel free to send them to ir@bokf.com. Enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#53

Appreciate it. That brings today's call to a close. At this point you're free to drop off your lines, and thanks for joining us.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete BOK Financial Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to BOK Financial Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in BOK Financial Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.