BOK Financial Corporation (BOKF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 24, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Heather Worley
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks for being here as we go over BOK Financial's results for the first quarter of 2024. Stacy Kymes, our CEO, is going to start us off with some opening remarks. Our loan portfolio and the credit metrics tied to it will be presented by Marc Maun, Executive Vice President for Regional Banking. Scott Grauer, Executive Vice President of Wealth Management, will then walk through the results we saw from fees. After that, Marty Grunst, our CFO, will talk about how we performed financially this quarter and what we're guiding toward going forward. You can find the slide presentation and the press release on our site, bokf.com. We'd point you to the disclaimers shown on Slide 2, which address any forward-looking statements we make on this call. At this point, I'll hand things over to Stacy Kymes, starting on Slide 4.
Stacy Kymes
executiveI want to thank Heather, and we're glad to have her join the team. For the first quarter, we're happy to announce earnings of $83.7 million, which works out to EPS of $1.29 per diluted share. If you set aside notable items like the AFS repositioning and the FDIC special assessment, Net income would have come in at $123.2 million, with EPS of $1.91 per share. Before getting into the first quarter highlights, I'd like to cover our strategy. Here at BOKF, we take a long-term view. Our focus is on generating profitability and performance that delivers sustainable value to shareholders. BOK Financial is a full-service financial services company, with a diversified loan portfolio, unwavering discipline when it comes to credit quality, top-tier fee income businesses generating attractive returns, and a solid core deposit franchise. We operate in dynamic, high-growth markets, and our strong risk management culture keeps us open for business, growing our portfolio actively when others are retreating. Our management team is seasoned, with deep bench strength. On average, our executive leadership team brings 34 years of industry experience, including 24 years at this organization. Across market cycles, we keep investing in the company's growth. With ample capital and liquidity, we're able to deepen client relationships and capture market share while others pull back. A clear illustration is our investment in the San Antonio market, which is going better than we expected; we've added 13 employees there and are already generating meaningful new business. As another piece of our Central Texas expansion, we have 12 wealth employees and 7 mortgage employees in Austin. We've also brought on 13 team members for our institutional sales team through our Memphis expansion, which will complement our existing fixed income trading activities. Bringing in talent is a core part of our strategy. We recruit proactively for the future, understanding that our people are our greatest asset. I'm delighted to share that we were one of just 60 organizations to earn a 2024 Gallup Exceptional Workplace Award. That's independent confirmation of our culture of inspiration, ambition, collaboration and tenacity. Discipline is essential to creating value. One differentiator I want to point out is our credit culture. If you go back to the great financial crisis, our credit costs were well above our own average, yet we materially outperformed our peers. That, along with our holistic risk management focus, helped make us the largest traditional bank not to participate in TRID. Credit costs across the industry have been very low for the last several years, but as concerns grow in the regional banking space, there's renewed attention on credit and especially commercial real estate; we never stopped managing credit prudently and believe this is somewhere we'll keep outperforming on a relative basis. Our credit standards have stayed exactly the same, and a persistent credit management group has produced improved credit losses relative to competitors over time. A slide has been added to our presentation displaying our credit performance across business lines historically, so our strong long-term results stand out. When you pair that solid historical credit record with a continuing dedication to concentration limits, investors ought to feel more assured about how we will do in this area going forward. Our commercial real estate concentration limit sits at 185% of total commitments against Tier 1 capital plus reserves. As of today, roughly 22% of outstanding balances fall within commercial real estate. Through the years, our attention has gone toward expanding specialty business lines such as energy and health care, and that has grown our core commercial and industrial relationships. Investments in our core commercial businesses were made across the past several years, and those returns show up clearly in the first quarter through 9% annualized growth in commercial loans. Retention of our VISA Class B stock is another sign of how we take the long view. Since 2008, plenty of holders have fully monetized their shares at a hefty discount. We kept this position instead, and now anticipate getting full value for the shares in our possession. Turning to Slide 5. Period-end loan balances rose $268 million, or 1% linked quarter, with commercial loans fueling that growth, and our teams stay confident about our pipelines going forward. Period end and average deposits both kept growing during this quarter. Our loan-to-deposit ratio dipped a bit to 68%, still far under our peers and delivering substantial on balance sheet liquidity for future loans or other liquidity needs; two consecutive quarters have now shown a slowing pace of net interest margin decline, and we think the trough has arrived. Credit remains quite strong, and at quarter end we hold a combined reserve of $329 million, or 1.36% of outstanding loans, which sits above the median for our peer group. Last, we bought back over 616,000 shares during this quarter, reflecting our long-term confidence in the company and capturing attractive repurchase valuations. This team's quarter makes me proud, and I appreciate the time to walk through it with you this morning. With that, I'll hand the call to Marc.
Marc Maun
executiveThank you, Stacy. I'd like to briefly turn everyone's attention to Slide 7 and build on what Stacy said about credit. The way we approach credit is at the very core of how we operate; our underwriting standards are rigorous and tailored to what we've learned across each line of business, and that means not just a baseline credit review but also stress testing as part of underwriting, with every loan run through interest rate shock scenarios. Ours is a steady, disciplined process built so that standards don't swing around with economic conditions. Roughly 81% of our commercial and CRE loans carry floating rates or will reprice within the next year. That variable has therefore always been a key consideration for us. The credit performance you're currently seeing in our loan book already reflects the impact of higher borrowing rates. We aren't significantly worried about repayment shocks. Because we actively manage the book, we keep an eye on credit in order to spot problems. Any loan that concerns us gets downgraded quickly, and that can sometimes cause our criticized ratios to appear elevated relative to peers; in our view, this proactive approach produces better results over the long term. If a credit problem does arise, our approach is to partner with the customer—whether that means helping them get back on their feet, arranging a full-payoff exit, or limiting our losses by working together with management, the line bankers, and our special assets group. This combination of disciplined underwriting standards on the front end and hands-on oversight throughout the loan's life has, over time, produced quite small credit losses, which you can see on Slide 7. Let's turn to Slide 8. Overall, loans were up 1.1% from the prior quarter, with commercial loans increasing 2.2% and CRE declining 1.9%. For the quarter, portfolio yields improved by 4 basis points. Energy business loan balances grew 0.2% quarter over quarter. Just a reminder: about 70% of our energy portfolio is made up of borrowers weighted toward oil, and 30% is borrowers weighted toward natural gas. On the book, first lien senior secured production accounts for 92%. Our internal engineering team — 17 full-time staffers — handles the lending assessment and stress testing. For at least the next twelve months, our energy borrowers are pretty well hedged, and that takes a lot of the commodity price risk off the collateral. If you combine services with general business loans, our core C&I loans grew 3% from the prior quarter. Given the current market, we're centered on creating complete banking relationships through cash flow lending, and we build our credits with adequate secondary repayment sources to keep risk as low as possible. Healthcare business loans rose 2.5% quarter over quarter. About 2/3 of the portfolio sits in senior housing, bringing together a diversified mix of skilled nursing facilities that are Medicare, Medicaid-based stabilized private pay senior living, integrated health systems mostly carrying investment-grade equivalent ratings, and other specialized providers. The healthcare line of business has a national footprint but is focused on regional operators with multiple locations for diversity and deep knowledge of their markets. We have a long history of strong underwriting in this space. Commercial real estate lending slipped 1.9% from the prior quarter. Stacy noted that we kept a tight rein on concentration. When we underwrite, each loan faces multiple stress tests, including scenarios that shock interest rates and payments. Alongside the rigorous criteria we use in underwriting, two factors stand out as what will distinguish our credit performance this cycle. Guarantor backing comes first. Over 90% of our CRE loans have meaningful support, provided by counterparties with whom we've built long-standing relationships and who have demonstrated dedication to honoring their deals. Geographic location is the second factor. This portfolio is spread across geographies, and, just as importantly, most of the exposure sits in strong economies within our footprint, while very little sits in the parts of the country that have experienced the biggest price declines, like New York City and Los Angeles, as the next slide shows. Turning to Slide 9, what you'll find is that the credit quality of our loan portfolio remains outstanding and sits well below where it stood both in historical learnings and before the pandemic. Nonperforming assets — leaving out the ones backed by U.S. government agencies — declined by $25 million during the quarter. So as a result, nonperforming assets relative to period-end loans plus repossessed assets declined by 11 basis points, landing at 51 basis points. Compared with the previous quarter, nonaccruing loans fell by $26 million. If you measure committed criticized assets against capital, they remain far below where they stood before the pandemic. Net charge-offs for Q1 added up to $5.5 million, which works out to 9 basis points annualized. On a trailing 12-month average, that number comes to 10 basis points. That really demonstrates how much stronger our performance is than the 30 to 40 basis points we've historically recorded. Going forward, we anticipate net charge-offs will stay under those historical levels. Our reserves are still in good shape: at quarter end, the combined allowance for credit losses stood at $329 million, which is 1.36% of outstanding loans. The $8 million provision reflects both a steady operating environment and our expectation for loan growth. When you look at that reserve, it's covering our nonperforming assets three times over. If what you're after is the full picture of how our credit reserve levels compare with others, we believe the combined reserve is the best measure to use. Our plan is to maintain a reserve at an appropriate level — one that backs loan growth while also taking economic conditions into account. During my opening remarks I mentioned that through tough credit cycles, we've consistently come out ahead of peers, and should an economic slowdown occur, we're in a strong position. With that, I'll turn things over to Scott.
Scott Grauer
executiveThanks, Marc. Now let's look at Slide 11. I'm glad to talk about our wealth management, mortgage and TransFund operations. These are areas we've dedicated ourselves to for many years and they're central to who we are. Back in 1918, we started Oklahoma's very first trust company, and in 1949 we brought asset management into the mix, which shows how dedicated we are to delivering creative financial services for our clients. These days, BOKF offers a very solid base of stability, knowledge and experience that people, families and institutions can count on. We run these fee income businesses at scale, and that gives us great operational leverage and the capacity to compete effectively with bigger companies. We made the strategic choice to put money into these and other high ROE fee income businesses that deliver revenue diversity, and that's worked out nicely for us. Fee income businesses account for 41% of BOKF's revenue, which is a peer-leading contribution to earnings and delivers stability, particularly when net interest income is volatile. To share a few figures showing the scale and strength of these operations, we rank in the top 10 dealers of agency mortgage-backed securities. We were the #1 underwriter and financial adviser of Texas Independent School District bonds for 2023. We're the eighth largest corporate trustee bank ranked by number of trusteeships, a top 10 electronic funds transfer processor in the United States through our TransFund business, which handles debit and credit issuing processing or EFT for almost 500 banks and credit unions throughout the U.S., representing close to 1 billion transactions last year alone. And last, we're a top 50 U.S. mortgage originator and service over $21 billion in mortgage loans, representing more than 122,000 accounts. Now for this quarter. Total fee income brought in $200.6 million of revenue, which is 41% of total revenue. I'll start with the details of our markets and securities businesses, again on Slide 11. Our trading fees, which come mostly from fixed income trading, rose by 5.4% to $37.5 million during the quarter, driven by slightly higher trading volumes and spreads compared to the prior quarter. Mortgage banking revenue grew 48% to $19 million. This came from improvement in the mortgage origination market and positive seasonal trends, which led to increased volume. Margins have gone up too as the pooling of COVID-19 forbearance loans we previously repurchased keeps migrating lower, now hitting some of their lowest historical levels. As a reminder, brokerage and insurance was down 24% to $4.7 million; this was due to the exit of BOK Financial Insurance in the fourth quarter last year. Now let's turn to Slide 12. To cover our asset management and transaction businesses. Asset management revenue has also risen 8% to $55.3 million, driven by an increase in AUMA of just under $800 million with spreads increasing slightly. Transaction card revenue fell by 11.6% to $25.5 million, driven by normalized activity following elevated levels experienced in Q4. Companies driven by fees usually generate better returns on capital than those built around conventional net interest income; however, their efficiency ratio also runs higher, since achieving scale and an effective cost structure is necessary to run them well. So when you observe the share of fee income rising, anticipate both an elevated efficiency ratio and stronger returns on capital; with that, I'll pass the call to Martin, who will walk through the financials.
Martin Grunst
executiveThank you, Scott. I'll begin by addressing a couple of things from the quarter. To start, we recorded an accrual of $6.5 million representing our estimate of the extra special assessment we anticipate receiving from the FDIC this June. Next, as we noted before, during March we repositioned part of our securities portfolio, which resulted in a $45 million pretax charge for the quarter, and this repositioning will enhance net interest income moving forward. We own VISA B shares that right now equate to 400,420 common shares. VISA's exchange program launched on April 8 and ought to let us monetize 50% of RB shares during the second quarter. In the second quarter, we expect the benefit from this transaction to be greater than the $45 million loss on securities we took in the first quarter, plus whatever additional sum we plan to contribute to our charitable foundation during Q2. That's the last thing I'll say about that. As for restructuring the portfolio, our focus is on generating added economic value, and we aim for the earn-back period to fall short of the weighted average life of the securities in question. With the Q1 transaction, it took roughly 2 years to earn back, versus a weighted average life of 3.4 years on the securities we sold, which points to a very favorable economic result. Let's move on to Slide 14. We continue to be in a strong position when it comes to capital and liquidity. That strength rests on how we manage risk, and our framework recognizes that capital, liquidity, and interest rate risk are disciplines that connect with one another. When we include every loss in our securities portfolio, our adjusted tangible common equity ratio is 7.92%. Measured against the 20 largest U.S. banks as of Q4 '23, that puts us third highest. Beyond that, we hold strong capital ratios across all regulatory capital metrics. Right now our loan-to-deposit ratio is 68%. Coverage of uninsured and non-collateralized deposits remained robust at 179%, and deposits grew $1.4 billion this quarter. Our strong capital and liquidity position has enabled us to actively chase organic growth opportunities and buy back shares. During Q1, we bought back slightly more than 616,000 shares of common stock, paying an average of $83.89 per share. Going forward, we'll remain opportunistic when it comes to repurchasing shares. Turning to Slide 15. Net interest income for the first quarter reached $293.6 million, and the rate of decline kept easing as we had anticipated. The drop from the prior quarter was $3.1 million, $1 million of which stemmed from day count. Our net interest margin landed at 2.61%, down 3 basis points from Q4, mainly because of DDA migration and, to a smaller degree, deposit repricing. When we closed out the first quarter, the deposit beta across the full cycle stood at 68%, while DDA made up 24% of all deposits. Turning now to Slide 16. On a linked-quarter basis, total expenses came down by $43.7 million, which works out to 11.4%, and that decline was largely driven by the FDIC special assessment recorded in the earlier quarter. During Q4 we booked the initial estimate of $43.8 million, and then in Q1 we added another $6.5 million on top of that. The result is a $37.3 million sequential reduction, which explains most of the drop in total expenses for the quarter. Aside from that, expense items were largely consistent with the previous quarter. Let's go ahead to Slide 17. There you'll see our guidance for 2024. Commercial loan growth has solid momentum, and on a period-end basis we're looking for total loans to grow 5% to 7%. We've given a numeric range for that line item, though our view is essentially unchanged from a quarter ago. Our sense is that net interest margin has bottomed out, and net interest income for the full year 2024 should come in a bit above $1.2 billion. We baked in 2 rate reductions from the Federal Reserve for 2024, which matches the forward curve from a couple of weeks back. For 2024, we anticipate provision expense roughly in line with 2023, and the ratio of combined reserves to total loans should hold stable as outstandings increase and economic conditions continue. With that said, I'll turn things back to the operator for the Q&A portion, and after that Stacy will offer some closing comments.
Jon Arfstrom
analystIs the audio coming through okay on your end?
Stacy Kymes
executiveYes, Jon, we've got you now. It's nice to hear from you.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAll right. That sounds good. Regarding Slide 8, I'm not sure whether this one's directed at you, Stacy, or at Marc, but could you speak briefly about the overall business trends you're observing when it comes to pipelines? Marc, I realize you merged services together with general business, but I'm simply wondering what you're noticing on the pipeline front and whether any of that is shifting?
Marc Maun
executiveSure. Up to this point, in terms of our C&I pipelines, the strength we're seeing remains quite solid. What I mean is, our push has been aimed at seizing opportunities, because of where we sit with liquidity, with our credit metrics and the like, so that we stay open for business and keep up active calling efforts. And while a number of our competitors eased off somewhat, we managed to develop that pipeline rather effectively. If you turn to healthcare, that area has likewise been expanding quite nicely. Energy simply mirrors more of what's taking place in the economy at present; so on the whole, on the commercial side we anticipate carrying on seeing the same sort of growth that showed up during the first quarter.
Stacy Kymes
executiveJon, it's Stacy here. What I'd say is, when you look at the way we approach this, take commercial growth in general — with the footprint we have, and with the liquidity and capital position we have — we feel genuinely good about it. The business lines are quite enthusiastic about their pipelines and about what they expect to see develop as time goes on. The one genuine headwind where our forecasting ability is limited is the question of how commercial real estate will perform, and whether pay downs come through there. If they do, replacing them takes time — we have ample capacity in commercial real estate to originate loans right now, but it does take a while; and so that — I believe I said this on last quarter's call, that was really the single wildcard in our guidance, as I saw it; and I'd still say the same thing today. We feel quite good about commercial. On commercial real estate, we feel good about our capacity to grow the commitments there, but when those commitments actually fund is the wildcard, relative to the payoffs there.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAll right, that's useful. Then I've got just one more for you, Marty. There isn't much to criticize here, but you brought up DDA migration, and I'm wondering what your take is on it. Also, has that pressure started to fade? Any particular patterns regarding DDA migration that you'd want to highlight?
Martin Grunst
executiveAbsolutely. Yes. We believe that pressure is indeed fading, like you mentioned. Looking only at the quarter, almost all of the decreases happened in January. February and March essentially flattened out, and even when you check April, we observed a slight increase during the April pretax season, and then on April 16, that came out and how everything settled was still in line with February and March. That gives us fairly strong confidence that a burnout point is being reached. I still think there's a bit further to go. So I wouldn't say it's completely finished, but we're feeling quite positive about the outlook.
Peter Winter
analystThe way your credit has been performing is really impressive. In my view, your institution is among a small set of banks that have posted a drop in nonperforming assets. Would you mind giving us a bit more detail regarding criticized and problem loans? Then, second, my assumption from the provision expense guidance is that you still anticipate elevated net charge-offs during the latter half of the year.
Marc Maun
executiveOkay, I'll address the second one first. On the provision side, we aren't actually expecting greater net charge-offs across the remainder of the year. What we're seeing points to criticized and classified levels, along with nonperforming improvement, producing an outcome closer to what the prior few quarters have shown us. Any increase in provision would be driven by loan growth; that's what would cause it, together with the aim of holding our percentage reserve roughly level relative to the total loan portfolio; as for specific criticized assets and similar items, nothing we see is systemic within any given portfolio. Actually, our — a portion of our CRE has declined, and we've managed to get out of quite a few nonperforming loans, which contributed to why we recorded a reduction last quarter rather than charge-offs. So we've handled our criticized and classified assets well. And we simply believe that will keep showing up going forward, judging by what we observe right now.
Stacy Kymes
executivePeter, credit quality is something we tend to feel pretty optimistic about, and you're right to highlight it as a major element of what happened this quarter. I believe we've set ourselves apart in the way we underwrite and the way we approach it. Strong asset quality and solid growth can coexist, and I think we're achieving both right now. Our ability to forecast and our asset quality hold up for roughly 6 months, after which the picture becomes quite murky. So the reason we mentioned possibly the back half of the year comes down mainly to an expectation that sooner or later there will be a reversion to the mean and conditions will resemble what they looked like pre-COVID; we figured maybe we were moving that way in the fourth quarter. Criticized and classified loans showed modest deterioration, so we were beginning that migration, but it didn't materialize in the first quarter. Our outlook at this point is quite positive, given what we know about the book and how the current criticized and classified nonperforming loans are behaving today. So we feel really good. Just understand that eventually — I get teased about this a lot internally, but I keep saying it's unsustainably good. It is, yet it seems like it will remain that way for at least the next 6 months or so.
Peter Winter
analystUnderstood, and that's quite useful. Then, turning to something else: even with the revised projection calling for 2 rate cuts, you kept the fee income guidance unchanged. Previously, the guidance had been for no rate cuts. You also noted that lower rates would in fact be a positive for fee income. So, now that some rate cuts are included in your forecast, would you favor perhaps the top end of that range?
Martin Grunst
executiveYes, Peter, I would say we feel good about how that business is trending. Mortgages in particular — we even saw an increase there, and that should hold up. That clearly gave it a boost. Trading operations benefit from that sort of backdrop; and the fiduciary businesses likewise benefit from that backdrop, simply because of the asset — the effect on asset valuation; so yes, we feel great about that line item.
Peter Winter
analystIs there any way to gauge, if it lands nearer the top of that range, especially considering a few of the advantages from rate cuts?
Martin Grunst
executiveYeah, I'm not sure. I'd rather not attach a precise figure to any specific spot within that range, but those businesses definitely have solid momentum right now, and we anticipate that continuing across the year.
Scott Grauer
executiveOne more point from my side, Scott here, is that when it comes to trading, we've moved into something of a wait-and-see stretch regarding whether rate cuts are coming or not; and the first quarter shows that activity and business volumes are still running a bit high even in the absence of a cut; so no matter which way the Fed ends up going there, we're feeling good about our positioning.
Ben Gerlinger
analystWhat I'm really wondering about is the growth — sort of the numerical fine-tuning of it, I suppose. A number of your rivals have suggested the second half of the year, while others operating in that same footprint have talked about something closer to linearity. And if we set aside the CRE noise and the potential paydowns, should growth be expected to come in fairly linear from this point through year-end? Or does it lean somewhat more heavily toward the back half?
Stacy Kymes
executiveAnswering that is not easy. Broadly, my expectation is that it will be linear, or at least more so than tilted toward the back half. Loan growth, as you're aware, comes in lumps. One month it's flat, another month it's larger. Yet as time passes, that path ought to be fairly consistent and, from where I sit, more linear than backloaded.
Ben Gerlinger
analystUnderstood, that clears things up. Then, from what I gather, you've now lowered the guidance twice. Early in the year, we discussed how this quarter would likely mark the lowest point for margin, and that does appear to be the case, yet when you consider the somewhat mixed picture regarding possible rate cuts — if none actually happen, do you have a view on where margin could stand by year-end, given the usual mix shift or the flows you expect?
Martin Grunst
executiveRight, Ben, so regardless of whether those 2 rate cuts materialize, we continue to believe margin bottoms out at this point, with some steadiness around midyear, followed by an improvement afterward. The advantage we gain from rate reductions stems more from a steeper curve, which accumulates gradually — you won't see an enormous gain within 1 quarter because of it. So in either scenario, we expect margin to rise as the year draws to a close.
Stacy Kymes
executiveWhat I'd say is this is really the key takeaway: when you look at us going forward, don't focus so much on how rate changes affect net interest revenue or margin in absolute terms, since from a rate risk standpoint we're generally pretty neutral. Instead, focus more on the yield curve steepening. If a steepening occurs, over time we'll benefit from it in a material way. So for us, that steepening effect matters far more than whether rates move up or down at the short end.
Will Jones
analystGreat. I'd like to discuss the increase in deposits that you recorded during this quarter. Obviously, it was quite significant. I was hoping you might be able to explain what went your way over those three months. I'm aware that you also mentioned an effort to perhaps exchange certain borrowings and then substitute them with deposits. Could you walk us through a few of the movements you observed in the quarter and possibly what produced that strong expansion?
Martin Grunst
executiveYes; so Will, what happened there was we extended proposals to the customers we already have. And like we've discussed previously, a sizable share of our clientele holds a mix of liquid assets, with a portion kept on our balance sheet and another portion sitting in our broker-dealer or the wealth operation, and we can shift those holdings between the two through outreach campaigns; so we simply engaged in a bit of that, and the results were highly productive. And it turned out precisely the way we had planned.
Will Jones
analystAll right. And regarding the guidance for deposit growth, it seems as though a significant portion of that increase may simply have been pulled forward during the earlier part of this year. So is the expectation that deposit balances might essentially stabilize and remain unchanged through the rest of the year?
Martin Grunst
executiveCorrect. Generally speaking, our aim is for deposit growth and loan growth to be roughly matched. That's something we're quite comfortable with. Around a 70% loan-to-deposit ratio, which we define as a wider range; so yes, it makes sense to expect those will be more or less aligned for the remainder of the year.
Will Jones
analystAll right, that's helpful. Turning back to what we discussed regarding margin — so perhaps this quarter the margin holds steady, and by the end of the year it moves higher. Would that suggest deposit costs might top out around the third quarter, or possibly late in the second quarter?
Executive
executiveYeah. I'm not sure I'd frame it as deposit costs topping out specifically, but a few things are working in the margin's favor: the fixed rate securities portfolio. Every quarter, roughly $500 million, maybe a bit more, reprices from the lower rate it currently carries up to today's rate. That same pattern shows up in the loan book. The dollar amount is somewhat smaller, yet the identical effect applies — the fixed rate piece of the loan book reprices upward. And those keep going for some time, across several quarters. Then where deposits are concerned, what you're seeing is that quarter by quarter, the pressure on deposits simply keeps easing. So that becomes considerably smaller. It may not reach exactly 0, but our belief is that the lines cross this quarter.
Timur Braziler
analystTo pick up where that last comment left off, when I look at time deposits, the average rate during the quarter came to $4.85. Where does that eventually settle? Also, what promotion are you running right now across your markets?
Martin Grunst
executiveSure. If we take our top offer, it varies by term, but the peak would fall somewhere between $4.85 and $5.10, and not all markets carry an identical offer, though that represents the ceiling. Compared with a quarter earlier, we've actually reduced those by 5 or 10 basis points, which should give you some indication of the modest easing pressure we're observing. Pinpointing the exact endpoint is difficult, since not all deposits reach that top offer, as that specific term comes with specific specials. So the final level is definitely below that, and it will simply come down to the mix inside that portfolio. That said, you're correct that this does tend to slow down asymptotically, so to speak, as time passes.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right. Now perhaps regarding your wider willingness to take on time deposits. With the loan-to-deposit ratio sitting under 70% at this point, and given that you hold ample liquidity on the balance sheet, does your willingness remain unchanged when it comes to time deposits? Or might we see a portion of those maturities potentially run off at some point within the year?
Martin Grunst
executiveEvery one of those represents a core customer. What I'm saying is nothing there falls into the brokered category or anything along those lines. So there isn't a chunk that will simply mature and disappear. Whatever our customers are seeking, we will provide it; a good portion of that sits within the consumer book. And that's simply the organic way a consumer book ages across this segment of the rate cycle; therefore we'd anticipate gradual expansion continuing as the consumer book follows that pattern on its own.
Stacy Kymes
executiveAlso, if your worry is that we're growing certificates of deposit right as the market starts to anticipate falling rates, does that mean you get stuck with a pricier funding cost because of that expansion? Through our treasury group, we're positioned to convert those into floating rate, once we form a view on it, which means a fixed rate isn't necessarily a trap for us. In our eyes, that's an essential deposit gathering engine, and it needs to keep running steadily. So when we think it through, we'll adjust based on our interest rate risk profile whether we switch it back to floating, and how we approach that; still, this has to be considered more broadly, not simply as that one line item.
Martin Grunst
executiveThose maturities, by the way, fall due in under 12 months, though a handful stretch slightly past that 12-month mark — yet they match up nicely against the fixed-rate piece of the loan book. And as Stacy mentioned, whenever that matching isn't quite perfect, swapping them out is no trouble for us at all. So the outcome there should be a good one.
Timur Braziler
analystGreat. That's helpful context. Then perhaps just a few items on the credit side. So if we zero in on healthcare, and I'm talking about that slide, we're noticing wider problems sort of emerging throughout the industry in that sector; and then when you examine your healthcare portfolio, before the pandemic and after it, the numbers are quite striking. I suppose what shifted in your underwriting, perhaps, or whatever else is producing that kind of outperformance after the pandemic in that portfolio compared with the greater charge-off activity in '17, '18 and '19.
Stacy Kymes
executiveYes. I'm not sure that our — I don't view our results as significantly different in this case. What I mean is healthcare across a wide span of time has served as a very strong asset quality portfolio for us. It has consistently carried more volatility at the criticized and classified level since the risk we perceive in that portfolio tends to be classification risk rather than loss risk; and so from a loss standpoint our historical results in the health care book have been very strong; roughly 7, 8 years back we had a few noncore type healthcare loans where we took some losses. But today the portfolio is built around senior housing and healthcare systems and doctor practice groups and similar things; that portfolio has existed for quite a while, and for us it's been a very strong credit performer, and the way we underwrite it doesn't change, and we feel really good about that. I don't think you can ever avoid being exposed to some classification risk in the healthcare book simply given its nature; but the loss history, which is truly what we concentrate on, has remained very stable in the core businesses we're in now.
Marc Maun
executiveWhat I'd mention as well is that we once participated in a portion of the health care sector, starting around early or mid 2010, and we got out of it in roughly '17 or '18, and that piece isn't in the portfolio anymore. Senior housing has consistently been the heart of the portfolio, and it's been steady.
Timur Braziler
analystAnd then one final item for me — I realize this is only a minor piece — perhaps the nonperforming loan additions tied to commercial real estate, which asset classes did those fall into? And is there any sort of common factor linking a few of those migrations?
Stacy Kymes
executiveWould you mind repeating the question? We lost you for a moment there.
Timur Braziler
analystOkay, regarding the migration in nonperforming loans for commercial real estate during this quarter, which sectors did those involve? And was there any common factor connecting those loans?
Stacy Kymes
executiveRight. If you examine nonperforming loans in commercial real estate, it's actually a slight rise. That's primarily driven by one office facility; we recorded a small charge-off related to it in this quarter, and we anticipate it will be sold with no further loss content before the quarter ends. So as of now, we have no particular worries about loss content. It was truly a single — mostly made up of one loan, and that accounts for the uptick.
Matt Olney
analystHere's a broad question. I'd like to get your take on how intense the rivalry is right now in the lending operations that sit at the heart of your business. My recollection is that during the past several quarters, we discussed how some rivals were stepping back, which opened the door for the bank to bring in additional clients. I'm simply wondering whether anything has shifted on that front. Do those competitors remain somewhat off balance? Beyond that, any news you can share regarding loan spreads would be helpful.
Stacy Kymes
executiveMatt, in my view, what you actually observed was certain regional banks — including the bigger ones in that group — attempting to keep their capital positions and liquidity positions under control. So we've pulled back somewhat, especially with bigger corporate clients, and that's helped us. Broadly, I'd say they're beginning to dip a toe back in — maybe not at the level they were at before last spring, but they are re-entering the market somewhat. My view is that spreads on the larger corporate side will likely hold steady. Once there's more clarity on Basel III being implemented, they might widen slightly as people work out what the capital structure needs to be. Broadly, though, what I'd note is that spreads on corporates haven't moved much either way. That lines up with what we're anticipating right now, even if certain players are maybe not being as forceful as they used to be.
Matt Olney
analystAlright, I appreciate that, Stacy. Turning to costs, thanks for the guidance you provided — essentially unchanged. Still, could you walk me through how much that cost base can move around? And if we went with the upper end of fees for the year, would it make sense to also model the upper end of the cost guidance?
Martin Grunst
executiveYes. Take two businesses specifically — mortgage, plus brokerage and trading — each ties quite directly into the cost base. Those really are the two where you can see that close connection. More broadly on costs, we'll keep investing in IT. So seasonality — third-party fees and data processing costs — you could see movement there. And as you probably are aware, mortgage costs run seasonally low in Q1, and they're predictably somewhat higher across the remaining 3 quarters; those are the only items I'd call out.
Brandon King
analystI saw that unfunded commitments decreased during the quarter, so could you give us some background on that?
Marc Maun
executiveWhat we've really observed is that we've managed to bring in new business, and much of it isn't being drawn on yet. There's the construction portion, which needs to fund gradually, plus the commercial side. Utilization has simply remained level even as we've brought on new customers. So what the unfunded commitments show is basically higher commitments in total alongside steady utilization rates.
Martin Grunst
executiveApart from commercial real estate, where they're drawing on it gradually, and that's one area where you notice a factor behind the drop.
Brandon King
analystAll right, that's useful. And finally from my side, on the topic of commercial real estate: could you update us on what you're observing when it comes to extensions for loans approaching maturity, and where borrowers stand regarding their asks?
Stacy Kymes
executiveSure. For the most part, I'd say it's largely business as usual. What I mean is, when loans reach maturity or get near it, we handle that the same way we would in any standard cycle. At least so far, it simply doesn't look much different from an ordinary course of business. Borrowers can choose to have us provide some form of mini-perm financing. So you'd place it on an amortization schedule if it's going through the construction phase; and should the permanent market not be accepting at that moment, they're able to do what we refer to as a mini perm with us. The loan amortizes, usually with a 3-year type term, and then they can essentially wait for the capital markets or the permanent financing markets to improve. But really, what we've observed — we have a very healthy portfolio. In the first quarter, we saw really good payoffs in the commercial real estate book, which we largely attribute to having a healthy portfolio. And so it doesn't — nothing we're seeing there is out of the ordinary.
Martin Grunst
executiveYeah, the prepayment speeds we observed in this quarter came in significantly above what we'd seen over the prior two quarters; it nearly seemed as though it was simply the typical, everyday pattern of prepayments for that portfolio, which, as Stacy mentioned, points to an underlying portfolio that's quite healthy.
Stacy Kymes
executiveRight from the start, we made clear that in commercial real estate, two factors are what count: geographies and recourse. I believe that point is truly proving itself. So the fact that 90% of our commercial real estate loans carry some type of guarantor support and recourse sets us apart here, and we're genuinely seeing that reflected in our portfolio.
Timur Braziler
analystJust a brief follow-up regarding those remarks. Who's actually stepping in to handle the payoff activity? Was it rival banks, insurers, I suppose, where exactly were those paydowns headed?
Stacy Kymes
executiveRight, mostly permanent financing sources. So Lifeco is, any place you'd generally find longer-term nonrecourse financing within commercial real estate is basically where those takeouts originate. They aren't originating from rival banks.
Stacy Kymes
executiveI appreciate all of you for your questions, your discussion, and for taking the time this morning to hear about what we see as a distinctive story we have to share. Our decisions have always been grounded in creating value for our shareholders over the long term while handling our risk effectively, and I believe that showed clearly during this quarter. Those core values continue to be our focus, and we're enthusiastic about what lies in front of us; thank you for your interest in BOK Financial. If any questions come up, I'd urge you to get in touch with Heather at hworley@bokf.com.
Operator
operatorThanks. That brings today's presentation to a close. I appreciate everyone joining us today, and you're free to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete BOK Financial Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to BOK Financial Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in BOK Financial Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.