Brown & Brown, Inc. (BRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 28, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Insurance earnings 74 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

J. Powell Brown

executive
#1

Thank you, Cecilia. Good morning to all of you, and I appreciate you being here for our call covering the fourth quarter of 2019. I want to spend a few minutes offering some general thoughts on the way we view our business. Back in 2018, we passed an interim milestone of $2 billion in revenue. During 2019, we brought in just under $2.4 billion in revenue. A lot of you probably already know that our following financial target is $4 billion in revenue. No timeline has been set for reaching it. We'll arrive there by bringing on gifted colleagues, expanding through organic growth, and purchasing companies that are a cultural fit and financially sound. Had our only aim been to hit that next interim milestone, we could have accomplished it last week, last month, or last year. Buying companies and operating companies are two very different skill sets. On top of that, paying too much for a big acquisition doesn't generate value for our teammates or our investors. As we've said before, roughly 25% of our company is owned by teammates. When I walk into an office and teammates ask me, "Powell, what's going on with the stock?" I know those teammates hold Brown & Brown shares and want our company to succeed; we think that demonstrates excellent alignment within the company, and that will eventually produce positive outcomes for all shareholders. Hitting our divisional and local goals overall isn't achievable without outstanding teammates devoted to bringing solutions to our customers. We're constantly looking for creative ideas that help our customers thrive. Our team numbers more than 10,000 people. They represent the single most important element behind our success. These teammates, equipped with fresh capabilities, are continually working to enhance the customer experience at Brown & Brown. How are we going to accomplish that going forward? One path will involve making better use of data and digital tools, along with teaming up with the right technology companies to help us push innovation within our company. Technology ranks as a very high priority for Brown & Brown and for me personally in 2020. Private equity is extremely aggressive in our sector. They're wagering that interest rates remain flat or decline toward zero. Every owner sponsor is hoping to grow the business organically and then flip it at a higher exit multiple. Things are frothy out there. When PE acquires PE on the basis of inflated EBITDA and anticipated synergies, there's little margin for error, if any at all. Our investment thesis is forever. We concentrate on capital allocation, return on invested capital, and cash flow from operations, which let us put our earnings back into the business annually. While a lot of people fixate on quarterly results, our eyes are on next year, three years out, and five years out. We're a customer-focused solutions business that takes a disciplined approach to capital allocation. We treat cash flow as a crucial yardstick alongside total shareholder return against big indices and our publicly traded competitors; over the last 5 years, we've beaten the average total shareholder return of the other public brokers by over 50% and the S&P 500 by over 125%. The reason I bring this up is that everyone here at Brown & Brown takes pride in what we've achieved. Not merely during 2019 or across the last 5 years, but from the very beginning. We're a disciplined provider of solutions that deploys capital wisely. We're happy with how we've performed historically and we're excited about what lies ahead. Now I'll turn to slide number 3. In Q4, we brought in $578 million of revenue, up 13.8% overall, with organic growth of 5.2%. We're quite happy with that robust organic revenue growth, and in a few minutes I'll go into greater depth regarding organic revenue growth for every segment. Our EBITDAC margin came in at 27%, a decline of 110 basis points from the fourth quarter of 2018. Net income per share in Q4 was $0.27, up 3.8% from the equivalent period a year earlier. Adjusted, and leaving out the change in acquisition earn-out payables, we produced $0.28 of net income per share, a rise of 7.7% over Q4 of 2018. In that quarter, we bought 5 businesses whose annual revenues totaled roughly $19 million. I'm now on slide 4. Across the year, revenues rose 18.8% and organic revenue growth came to 3.6%. That one-time non-cash $8 million adjustment we booked in last year's third quarter inside our National Programs segment hurt our 2019 organic revenue growth for the year by 50 basis points; we're quite happy with the ongoing enhancement in organic revenue growth that we achieved in 2019. Our EBITDAC margin stood at 30%, a drop of 60 basis points versus 2018, driven mainly by bringing in the Hays business. Net income per share for the entirety of 2019 climbed 14.8% to $1.40, up from $1.22 in 2018; adjusted, which leaves out the change in acquisition earn-outs, net income per share rose 13.8%. Andy will go through our financial results in greater depth later on in the presentation. Across the year, we completed 23 transactions representing roughly $105 million of annual revenue. We enjoyed yet another solid year of M&A activity, adding numerous outstanding businesses and teammates who are a cultural fit with Brown & Brown. I'm on slide 5. In Q4, premium rates kept climbing or, as we've put it before, are firming. Although we saw some speed-up in premium pricing relative to the prior few quarters, we don't think this amounts to a broad-based hard market. As we talked about during the year, risk bearers are after rate increases, and these are taking hold in some areas while failing to take hold in others. We've observed larger increases among large accounts. These probably won't affect the growth we generate organically, since a lot of the bigger accounts are billed on a fee basis. Broadly speaking, most lines keep trending upward. How much they rise is still a function of the loss experience tied to the account or to particular classes of business. Among the lines posting the biggest jumps are transportation, habitational, coastal property, wind and quake alike, and excess liability, also referred to as umbrellas — though that list isn't exhaustive. As noted previously, accounts that have losses tend to face rate hikes far beyond what accounts with little or no loss history see. Commercial auto stands alone as the coverage line that has reliably delivered a 5%-10% rate increase; nearly every carrier is putting through hikes like these. In most states, workers' compensation rates are still down 2%-5%, while other lines generally rise 2%-5%. Turning to E&S placement for properties exposed to catastrophes, wind and quake included, we saw increases ranging from 5%-20%, though outliers can occur. For private companies, most professional liability lines came in flat to down 10%. D&O and E&O for public companies usually run up 5%-10% or more. On the casualty pricing side, the unfavorable loss development showing up throughout the industry is pushing carriers to examine whether their pricing is adequate. Should that loss development trend keep climbing, our view is that added pressure to raise casualty pricing will emerge over the quarters ahead.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#2

We keep seeing the E&S market as the place where quite a few carriers are getting pickier about particular lines or regions, and because of that, the effect on E&S rates is stronger than what we're seeing in admitted markets. Broadly speaking, even though risk bearers have managed to secure rate increases, for most lines there's been an upward shift compared with where things stood twelve months ago. A great deal of capital is still sitting in the market, and competition persists for accounts that have favorable loss histories. Given today's conditions, our view is that these dynamics won't ease until at minimum the opening six months of 2020; we're happy, in fact extremely happy, with how far we've come on numerous initiatives across the whole company during 2019, and we believe our position is excellent for keeping the business growing in 2020. I've moved on to slide 6 now. Let's turn to how each of our four segments performed. Within retail, organic revenue growth came in at 7% for Q4; we want to congratulate every one of our teammates in that division for producing the best organic revenue growth we've recorded in a number of years. Good new business, better retention, and a bit of rate improvement powered our fourth-quarter growth; looking at the entire year, organic revenue growth of 4.7% marks ongoing incremental gains relative to the 3% organic revenue growth achieved across full-year 2018. Last but not least, we're happy with how Hays performed in its initial complete year. Our national program segment posted 10.7% organic growth during the fourth quarter, which made for yet another very strong quarter. Setting aside the effect of flood claims, the organic revenue growth recorded this quarter also ranks among the best we've achieved in a number of years. Continued strong results from our earthquake programs, our lender-placed program, and a great showing from many of our other programs fueled that growth. Across the full year, our national program segment achieved 3% organic growth. The one-time $8 million non-cash adjustment booked during last year's third quarter in our lender-placed business dragged down full-year organic revenue growth by roughly 180 basis points. All in all, the quarter and the year were excellent. Thanks to Chris Walker and the entire national programs team. Our wholesale brokerage segment turned in yet another solid quarter, with organic revenue growth of 7.9%, powered by strong results in our brokerage business along with rising rates, capping another excellent year with 7.4% organic revenue growth in 2019. Many thanks to Tony Strianese and everyone in wholesale for another terrific year. Organic revenue for our services segment fell 19.4% during the quarter. As we noted last quarter, we anticipated that revenues and margins for the services segment would drop by 5%-10% in Q4, due to our Social Security advocacy business and a customer contract that was terminated in one of our claims processing businesses. On top of that, during the quarter, the services segment's organic revenue growth took a further hit from fewer weather-related claims as well as reduced general property claims. Our services segment, as we've observed previously, tends to show greater revenue swings depending on claims activity across several of our businesses. Although we saw solid growth across the prior few years, 2019 turned out to be a year in which claims activity contributed very little, which drove the services segment down 6.3% on an organic basis; with that, I'll hand things over to Andy so he can walk through our financial performance in greater depth.

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#3

Thanks, Kyle. Morning, everyone. As in prior quarters, we'll cover our GAAP results, some non-GAAP financial highlights, and then our adjusted results that exclude the effects of changes in acquisition earn-outs. I'm on slide 7. In Q4, total revenue grew by $70 million, or 13.8%, while organic revenue rose 5.2%. Income before income tax and EBITDA were up 1.3% and 9.2%, respectively. The slower growth in pre-tax income came from higher interest and amortization expense tied to our acquisition activity, plus a $5 million increase in the change in acquisition earn-out payables, since several businesses performed better than expected. In a bit, we'll go through the detailed movement of our EBITDAC margin and what Hays contributed. Net income rose $3 million, or 4.1%, and diluted net income per share went up by $0.01, or 3.8%, to $0.27. For Q4 2019, our effective tax rate was 25%, versus 27% in Q4 2018. That lower effective tax rate stemmed from our state tax footprint and related apportionment, together with a tax rate change in Florida. Our weighted average share count was basically flat year over year, as we bought shares to offset the effect of our stock incentive plan. Finally, dividends per share climbed to $0.085, or 6.3%, compared with Q4 2018. Now to slide 8. This slide shows our results once the change in acquisition earn-out payables is removed for both years; we think this presentation gives a more comparable year-over-year view. On an adjusted basis, our income before income taxes grew 6.2%, or slower than EBITDA, because of the added interest and amortization expense from acquisitions we closed since 2018. Now to slide 9. This slide lays out the key components of our revenue performance. For the quarter, total commissions and fees rose 13.6%. Contingent commissions and guaranteed supplemental commissions, or GSCs, were up $2.5 million versus Q4 2018, partly because of our acquisition activity. Once we isolate the net effect of M&A activity, organic revenues rose 5.2% in Q4. Over to slide 10. To give a bit more visibility into the main drivers of our EBITDAC margin, we've included a walkthrough from 2018 to 2019. During the quarter, we had a couple of disposals that produced a gain, which helped our EBITDAC margin by 90 basis points. As we expected, Hays hurt our margins by roughly 150 basis points in the quarter, due to the phasing of revenues and profit under the new revenue standard. I'll say more about Hays' financial performance in a few minutes. Other captures the margin change we saw across the rest of our business. The primary factors behind this were increased non-cash stock compensation expense along with dilution from a 2019 acquisition that books nearly all of its revenue during the first quarter every year. Once you strip those out, margins improved during the quarter. Looking at the full year, and setting aside what Hays contributed, we grew margins thanks to stronger organic growth, more contingents within GSCs, keeping a handle on costs, and capturing returns on investments made earlier — all of which outweighed the drag from rising non-cash stock compensation expense. Let's turn to slide 11. Our retail segment posted total revenue growth above 22%, fueled by acquisitions made during the last 12 months plus 7% organic revenue growth that came from gains across the majority of our lines of business. EBITDAC margin for the quarter fell 140 basis points, reflecting how profit from Hays was phased, the margin effect tied to an acquisition closed in last year's third quarter, 2019, and greater non-cash stock-based compensation cost. Every one of those factors outweighed the gains from disposals made in the current quarter. If we set all of these items aside, margins improved during the quarter. Our income before income tax margin dropped 530 basis points, attributed to elevated intercompany interest expense, amortization, and additional acquisition earn-out expense, plus the same EBITDAC drivers described earlier. Let's turn to slide 12. Our national program segment grew total revenues by $14.2 million, or 11.8%, with organic revenue up 10.7%, reflecting strong results from several programs — commercial and residential earthquake, lender-placed, and our sports and entertainment offerings — along with higher contingent commissions. Income before income taxes rose by $11.9 million, or 46.5%, largely from revenue leverage and reduced intercompany interest expense. EBITDAC climbed by $9.9 million, or 24.9%, on the strength of higher revenues and ongoing expense discipline. Let's turn to slide 13. Our wholesale brokerage segment achieved total revenue growth of 5.9% and organic revenue growth of 7.9%. Contingent commissions for the quarter came in lower because of a prior-year adjustment that didn't repeat in 2019. EBITDAC margin contracted 80 basis points, caused by reduced contingent commissions and GSCs, which outweighed the margin expansion coming from higher organic revenue and expense management. Our income before income tax margin declined 20 basis points from the same forces behind the EBITDAC margin, partly offset by lower intercompany interest and amortization expense. Over to slide 14. Total revenues in our services segment decreased because organic revenue fell, though acquisition activity partly offset that. The decline in organic revenue growth stemmed from our Social Security advocacy businesses, reduced weather-related and property claims, and a customer contract termination we discussed last quarter. On the margin side, the EBITDAC decline came from lower revenues. We expect that revenue for this segment is going to keep declining by roughly 5% during the first half of 2020, as it remains affected by our Social Security advocacy businesses along with that customer contract that got terminated in the third quarter of 2019. Let's move to slide 15. On this slide, you'll see our GAAP results for the full years of 2019 and 2018. During 2019, we brought in $2.4 billion of revenue, which grew 18.8%, and earnings per share came in at $1.40. EBITDAC rose 16.5%, while the EBITDAC margin fell by 60 basis points. If we exclude the impact of Hays, we saw margin improvement for the full year, and that's something we're very pleased about. Our effective tax rate for the full year was 24.2%, which is a decrease of 140 basis points compared to 2018. Throughout the year, our share count stayed relatively flat, dropping by 30 basis points from the previous year. Now let's go to slide number 16; here we present our results with the change in estimated acquisition earn-out payables excluded for both years. Adjusted income before income taxes went up by 12.7%, which trails the growth in EBITDAC because of higher interest and amortization tied to acquisitions we closed since 2018. Adjusted net income rose by 14.7%, and adjusted earnings per share climbed 13.8% to $1.40 versus 2018. Lastly, one remark about how efficiently we turn revenues into cash.

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#4

Looking at the entire year, 28.4% of revenues turned into cash flow from operations, and that figure sits 20 basis points above what we saw last year. For the full year, cash flow from operating activities rose 19.5%, while total revenue growth came to 18.8%. If you turn to slide 17, we want to share a bit more detail on how Hays performed quarterly and annually; during Q4, Hays brought in revenues of $52 million, roughly $4 million beyond the upper bound of what was expected for that quarter. EBITDAC for Q4 landed at approximately $8 million, placing it at the bottom of the range. Looking at the full year, revenues reached $221 million, slightly topping the high end of our original guidance of $210 million-$220 million. Full-year EBITDAC was $50 million, putting it in the middle of our estimated range. Diluted net income per share, after excluding the incremental change in estimated acquisition earn-out payable, came to $0.02 for the full year, matching our expectations. Before turning to closing comments, we have further guidance on a few line items for 2020. We'd like to offer guidance on the third quarter acquisition mentioned earlier, which will recognize substantially all of its estimated $20 million-$22 million in revenue during Q1, aligning with the effective dates of the policies it places. Because of the new revenue standard, this acquisition will affect our quarterly profits in 2020. The favorable effect on our EBITDAC margin in Q1 should fall within 100 to 150 basis points. We're expecting roughly 30 to 40 basis points of compression in Q2, followed by roughly 15 to 20 basis points of compression in Q3, in each case measured against the equivalent periods a year earlier. We anticipate GSCs will decline by $8 million-$10 million in 2020 relative to 2019, mainly driven by the one-time GSC of approximately $9 million that we realized in the National Programs segment during Q2 of 2019. As previously discussed, our stock compensation cost has been climbing thanks to improved performance. We expect stock compensation cost to rise in 2020 by roughly $6 million-$8 million compared with 2019. Based on our current rate outlook, interest expense should stay relatively flat year-over-year. Amortization expense ought to land in the range of $100 million-$105 million for 2020. Bear in mind that both the estimated interest expense and amortization exclude any further acquisitions or borrowings that might take place in 2020. You'll need to form your own assumptions about those items. We expect our effective tax rate for 2020 to resemble that of 2019. Even though the yearly rate we expect will be comparable, for Q3 we do expect an effective rate between 14% and 17%, and every remaining quarter should rise compared with the earlier year of 2019. What causes that expected difference in Q3 is the tax benefit tied to stock incentive awards vesting; having said that, I'll hand things back to Powell for his closing remarks.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#5

Thank you, Andy, for that excellent update. To wrap things up, I'd like to offer a few thoughts on several subjects and share where our heads are at concerning the business and the opportunities ahead of us in 2020 and past that. When it comes to the economy, we're anticipating that the growth rate, along with the related effect on exposure units, will look fairly comparable in 2020 to what we saw in 2019 — assuming there aren't any significant adverse shifts in trade relations or some other development that might shake the broader economy. Looking at rates, we believe premium rates will keep climbing modestly through at minimum the opening six months of 2020. That said, let me stress once more: we wouldn't characterize the current environment as a hard market. What we're seeing instead is a firming of rates across numerous lines, which is pushing some risk bearers to either limit their capital or exit particular lines or regions altogether. Turning to M&A, our expectation is that competition will stay fierce until interest rates rise substantially. We think PE will, in all likelihood, keep pushing leverage on deals to a greater degree than strategic buyers do. Our approach will stay disciplined, since that's proven highly effective across the years; we'll acquire companies that are financially sound and a good cultural match. There's no shortage of opportunities meeting those criteria. We've spoken before about how technology and data usage are growing in significance. It's our strong conviction that both will significantly shape how insurance gets delivered in the years ahead. Let me be direct — I'm not suggesting technology will make it less important for a customer to speak with their broker about transferring risk. What I'm referring to is the way we'll engage with customers throughout the buying and renewal process, eliminating friction from straightforward transactions, and also how data will be used to help build new products alongside our carrier partners. Beyond that, we'll be concentrating on becoming more efficient so that we can channel more hours toward acquiring and keeping additional customers. Given that we aren't a technology firm and don't claim to hold every answer, we'll most likely team up with insurtech companies, allowing us to combine their innovation with our sector knowledge and data. For every one of our leaders, putting capital to work in the best possible manner stays a leading concern. We're lucky enough to produce more than $600 million in cash, and we expect that figure to rise further down the road. As we've said previously, our aim is to put every dollar of available capital to work — and beyond that — whenever the right opportunities present themselves, so we can keep delivering industry-leading financial metrics, cash flow conversion, and ultimately shareholder value. Growing and investing in our teammates continues to be a central priority for our company, because it's through our skilled team that we're able to serve our customers; we're confident we possess the right operating framework and culture to spark further profitable growth in 2020 and beyond. With all that said, I'll hand things back to Celia so we can begin the Q&A.

C. Gregory Peters

analyst
#6

All right. Morning, everybody. I'd like to revisit something. There are a few things I'd like to ask about, but Powell, technology came up when you were speaking, and given that you don't consider yourselves a tech company, I'm curious whether you expect to increase spending during 2020 on tech-related efforts throughout the franchise compared with 2019, or how should we frame that as far as pressure on expenses?

J. Powell Brown

executive
#7

Morning, Greg. What I'd say is that, as you're aware, we appointed Stephen Boyd last year to lead Technology, Innovation, Data, and Digital Strategy. We keep assessing matters such as security, plus we discuss how we operate internally day to day. We can't yet state precisely what that looks like. What I'd say is that we are confident there will be additional investment, and we'll approach it carefully. Nobody listening should misinterpret this as us simply tossing $25 million into a bucket. That's not our mindset; we're approaching technology from multiple angles. Some of it involves keeping things up and running, the way you'd treat electricity, and then there's defending against the bad guys, to use my phrasing. Innovation also has two sides. One involves adopting something that's genuinely emerging, which resembles a fast follower approach; the other piece could sit at the leading edge, and that represents the smallest bucket. I have a lot of confidence in our team and in some of the newcomers who've come aboard or are about to come aboard in the technology space to help us think through operating more efficiently so our teammates can devote more time to taking care of our customers. It's something I'm enthusiastic about.

C. Gregory Peters

analyst
#8

Sure, Andy, please go ahead.

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#9

Response from R. Andrew Watts: Hi, Greg. This is Andy speaking. Perhaps one more item worth considering, comparable to actions we took during 2016's first quarter. Should a significant multi-year technology outlay arise, we'd discuss it with every one of our investors, yet nothing of that kind appears to be coming up at present.

C. Gregory Peters

analyst
#10

I appreciate the answer. We're here evaluating what your EBITDA margin might look like for 2020, and I understand you provided certain guidance about the impact the acquisition will have. For the entire 2019 fiscal year, that figure declined by 60 basis points relative to 2018, and Hays factors into that number. In your view, has the situation more or less settled? Are you expecting improvement in 2020? From a directional standpoint, could you offer any perspective on what you're anticipating there?

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#11

Yes. Greg, let's take another quick look back at 2019. Regarding the company's margins, you're correct that they've fallen. However, if you were to strip out Hays on a standalone basis, then our margins on an underlying basis actually rose. At the start of 2019, we set out to slightly improve the business's margins. And that is precisely what we achieved. We're quite pleased with our current position. One key point: when you exclude Hays, there are numerous other elements at play beneath the surface, and they essentially offset one another in both directions. Our underlying margins went up, so once again, we're very happy with 2019. Looking ahead to 2020, we aren't aware of any significant challenges on the horizon at this moment. Of course, circumstances could always shift, but as of right now, no, nothing is on our radar, and we feel very confident about the business's direction.

C. Gregory Peters

analyst
#12

Excellent. I appreciate that response. Let's shift our focus to the top line. Powell, I'm aware you made remarks regarding exposures and the forecast for those exposures. As you mentioned, retail performed very well. Could you provide some sense of how much of it — not just in Q4 but for the whole year — came from exposure as opposed to rates? Given the success achieved in 2019, should we anticipate some rather tough comparisons throughout 2020 when it comes to organic growth?

J. Powell Brown

executive
#13

The precise figure for organic revenue growth attributable to rate and exposures isn't something we disclose. As I've mentioned to you, it's somewhat of a balancing act — from the exposure side, we'd say anecdotally that our customers are generally performing better across the board, which comes as no surprise to you, first of all. You heard what I said earlier regarding rates in the market. I believe, and will continue to believe, that our message has been very consistent. The retail business, similar to the overall business, delivers low to mid-single-digit organic growth in a steady state economy, and that could get a slight positive bump from other factors, such as rates rising in the area where we find ourselves today. Guidance on organic growth is not something we're providing, as you're aware. That said, I will tell you this: I could not be more pleased with the progress achieved in our retail business, and for that matter, across the entire business over the past three to four years.

C. Gregory Peters

analyst
#14

Great. That last item, regarding free cash flow and the conversion rate. Should we be worried about any headwinds when considering what the conversion rate will be for 2020? That is my final question.

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#15

Let me make this clear. Greg, cash flow from operations is among the key metrics we track. We are not aware of any major items. One element that can swing either way is movement in fiduciary cash, since that eventually flows into cash flow from operations. That movement is the sole thing capable of creating fluctuations, up or down, in certain years. Apart from that, no, there is nothing.

C. Gregory Peters

analyst
#16

Excellent, thanks for the responses.

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#17

Response from R. Andrew Watts: Thanks.

Elyse Greenspan

analyst
#18

Hi there, and thanks. Good morning. For my first question: we keep hearing that pricing conditions in Florida are improving as 2020 progresses. Since you have exposure there, Powell, I was hoping you could discuss what you expect to see in Florida this year, and then how that might affect your organic revenue growth and possibly act as a tailwind, maybe even past the first half of the year.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#19

All right. Let me address Florida from a couple of angles. As you're aware, Florida has the largest amount of coastal-exposed building construction in the U.S., which means cat exposed within a single county, outside of New York State. Texas would rank second. The last time I looked at that figure, it was $1,300 billion or thereabouts. That's an enormous number. It's almost staggering. First, we discussed the E&S market's impact and how it would affect the potentially residential and commercial accounts we're seeing. We noted earlier that, broadly speaking, the rates we're seeing fall in that 5%-20% range. That's one piece. Second, I'd point out that within the state of Florida, there are many takeout companies, and those takeout companies are depopulating the Citizens, as many of you are aware. As we understand it, a number of those companies are currently being watched by Demotech and others. We don't yet know exactly what that will mean for that space, but some of the losses that have happened over the past couple of years are developing in a way, or may have reached their reinsurance layers in a manner, that wasn't otherwise expected. That said, when we went public in 1993, the vast majority of our business was in Florida. Now, at just roughly $2.4 billion of revenue, our Florida exposure is far smaller. I mention that because, remember, in a business that in retail, which is roughly — these are all rough figures — of $1.4 billion, maybe $180 million of it is in retail; we don't break out how much property we have. We also have some sizable wholesale in Florida too, but they're writing business across the entire country in cat-prone areas. Elyse, I'd caution you by saying that we're going to get some enormous lift from the so-called Florida effect. We're all very happy to live in Florida for a whole host of reasons and to run our business from here. I'd just tell you that I think I would want you to view the Florida effect as similar to around the country, with a slight upside to it, but nothing where you need to go adjust something substantially. I'd caution you about that.

Elyse Greenspan

analyst
#20

That's a big help. Regarding retail, I realize you folks prefer not to provide guidance, but if my memory serves, didn't you indicate earlier this year that Q2 2019 would be the standout period for that business, because of revenue recognition and the way things fell between the first and second quarters? Q4 turned out quite robust — your best showing in quite a while, as you mentioned. So I'm wondering, was it new business, renewals, or some one-time item that produced the 7% for the quarter and perhaps pushed that figure above what you'd previously anticipated?

J. Powell Brown

executive
#21

All right. First, to clear up what you said earlier, I believe the quarter we discussed was the first, not the second. Second, Andy is seated right beside me, and you all will laugh, but in my view 606 obscures the picture rather than clarifying it. I'm neither a CPA nor with the PCAOB. That said, what I'd tell you is we simply had a damn good quarter. What that means is we wrote plenty of new business; among our clients, some occasionally get acquired, but we had clients acquiring businesses. We saw exposure increases; we had various items. It was simply a really strong quarter. I'd also add, Elyse, so you can calibrate expectations, the following. A single quarter does not establish a trend, and we've stated that. My view is, if you review retail's organic growth over the past 4 years — and I could be mistaken about the 4 years ago figure — I believe it runs roughly like this: 1.8%, 2.7%, 3.0%, 4.7. We're quite pleased with that. We believe that's a major factor in why the stock price has responded as it has, along with our acquisitions, our carrying out the plan in our other divisions, and all these other things. Once again, we're very happy with it.

Elyse Greenspan

analyst
#22

That helps. One final item, on the margin front. Assuming my math is right — apologies for throwing a figure out there — it looks as though you lifted margins roughly 20 basis points during 2019, excluding Hays. Could you weigh in on 2020: is that the appropriate magnitude of gain to assume across all of Brown & Brown? Andy, when it comes to those quarterly effects in 2020 stemming from that single acquisition, they apply to the entire company, correct? And in retail, wouldn't the effect be considerably bigger?

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#23

Let's handle the final portion of your question initially, and afterward we'll circle back. Yes, you've got it right. What we're talking about is the change at the company-wide level. One way to approach it might be: after you've built into your model whatever you expect the physics to produce, setting that aside, then place those possible adjustments into it. Carry that through to retail on a proportional basis. Regarding the underlying companies we mentioned before, we were higher by roughly 20 to 30 basis points, excluding Hays.

Elyse Greenspan

analyst
#24

When we look at 2020, does that appear to be roughly the correct amount of margin gain?

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#25

As you're aware, we don't provide public guidance, yet at this point we aren't seeing any significant headwinds heading our way for 2020. There's nothing that would lead us to believe they'd decline.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#26

Allow me to jump in on that point, Elyse. The truth is, this won't do anything for your model, so what I'd say to you is this: we're putting in serious effort, and we're enjoying ourselves quite a bit. Our plan is to put money into companies that we believe are a cultural match and financially sound, and that covers bringing aboard strong talent who would grow those companies, plus all sorts of other things. I simply want to be certain I understand that you're attempting to arrive at a hard figure, this is what the result will be, it will emerge on the far side of your model. We get that. I only want you to grasp that our top line and our bottom line are both expanding. Whether you examine how things went across the past 12 months, the past 3 years, or the past 5 years, carrying on in that way is what we're aiming for. I mention it only because that doesn't mean you can simply drop a single number into the model and have it emerge on the far side. I just want you to grasp that we'll attempt to deploy the capital in whatever manner we judge best in order to produce the strongest long-term outcomes; that might not be a single quarter, nor even a single year, for that matter. Occasionally 606, as Andy brought up before, changes the timing of when we purchase something, and suddenly it changes the whole company when it comes to an acquisition. That's okay; we'll get through it. All we're doing is attempting to complete solid acquisitions and bring on additional strong talent. In order to reach $4 billion.

Elyse Greenspan

analyst
#27

Okay, many thanks. I appreciate all of that detail.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#28

Yeah, thanks.

Mark Hughes

analyst
#29

Thank you, and good morning. Since Hays was acquired during the same quarter last year, did that acquisition end up inside organic for this quarter?

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#30

Yes, good morning, Mark. It was part of the figure, covering just those 45 days. From a weighting perspective within the quarter, it simply didn't carry much of an overall effect.

Mark Hughes

analyst
#31

When we consider that having a larger effect in Q1, could you tell us what kind of growth path Hays has been following?

J. Powell Brown

executive
#32

What I can say is that discussing how individual businesses are growing isn't something we do. Hays has performed in a way that makes us quite happy, and we're also happy about how we expect Hays to do going forward, though we won't be offering any remarks on it. Everything I said regarding organic growth in the low to mid-single-digit range, assuming a steady state economy, covers that.

Mark Hughes

analyst
#33

Regarding the margin impact at Hays, that reduced contribution during Q4 — did an earn-out adjustment alone account for it, or were other things at play?

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#34

Nothing out of the ordinary, Mark. As we wrapped up Q3, we had expected — we told everyone — that Q4 would quite possibly contain some noise. Our projection was a $0.01 loss for Q4. The actual figure was $0.02. Incremental acquisition earn-out accounts for $0.01 of that, so we essentially ended up exactly where we'd predicted. Our attention wasn't really on per-quarter margins for that business. The total was what truly held our focus, since when we began, we gave the quarterlies our best estimate, and looking back at the full year, we came in at the high end on revenues and more or less right on target with margins. Hays' performance this year leaves us feeling really, really good.

Mark Hughes

analyst
#35

On the stock compensation, you mentioned, as I recall, an increase of $6 million-$8 million. If I'm reading it right, based just on the cash flow, it seems like that's roughly half the rate of growth seen in 2019. Is that right?

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#36

Yes.

Mark Hughes

analyst
#37

Okay. Very good. Thank you.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#38

Thanks, Mark.

Yaron Kinar

analyst
#39

Hello, and good morning to everyone. My initial question, I suppose, concerns the market overall. You mentioned various business lines, with certain ones showing somewhat stronger firming than others. At this point, are there any areas where you're noticing disruption, or where placing a program is proving difficult?

J. Powell Brown

executive
#40

By difficult, do you mean that you can't secure coverage — is that what you're getting at?

Yaron Kinar

analyst
#41

Yeah. Maybe the whole program is bigger than it needs to be.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#42

That's right. Two scenarios pop into my head immediately, and I'll give you one example. Over the years, some carriers that write big property risks—engineered ones in particular—have been pulling back their capacity. Once they do that, you have to begin layering, so say they were offering $1 billion or $2 billion, and all at once they shrink, that property ends up split into layers. Costs are going up. I wouldn't claim this happens in every instance, where you simply can't place it, but there are times when, due to pricing pressure or things like that, they may choose not to buy as much coverage. That would be one case, and it would be the first. Consider engineered risk, particularly in the high-limit space. The next area that stands out is umbrella coverage, particularly when it involves sectors like transportation or exposures tied to very heavy products. Suppose you're handling a transportation account and, purely for illustration, one carrier provides a primary umbrella of $25 million while a second carrier contributes an additional $25 million, bringing the total umbrella to $50 million. Based on what I know, I'd say very few players in the transportation market today would be willing to commit more than 10. All at once, what you'd pay for a 10 could end up matching or exceeding what a 25 cost a year ago. That's point one. We could reach a situation where rates are set so high that no one is willing to quote at those elevated tiers, simply because they feel the return isn't adequate — or whatever they'd offer or price out wouldn't find a buyer, since folks don't believe it's worth that amount. I know of a handful of cases where accounts are hard to place, yet generally speaking, from what I can tell, we do quite well on behalf of our clients, though we keep a very close eye on this.

Yaron Kinar

analyst
#43

That's useful detail. For my second question, on National Programs and organic growth, it looks as though the past 2 quarters have marked a turning point. The trend has been quite favorable. The challenges you ran into earlier in this year and toward the end of last year — are they basically behind you now?

J. Powell Brown

executive
#44

Keep in mind, I believe you're right when you say, first, that National Programs and its team have things in a genuinely strong spot. That's point one. Point two, don't forget that a carrier's underwriting appetite can affect National Programs. As of now, we aren't aware of any major shifts among our carriers that would force a program to move or anything of that sort. That's a good thing. Whenever a key carrier partner in programs undergoes a leadership transition, appetite might shift, or the way they see things might shift. We think about this especially with certain underwriting programs where we're bringing capacity online — that might be wind, it might be quake, it might be other associated perils. Much of it comes down to how we secure additional capacity to meet those needs down the road; we might hold a certain amount of capacity, and once it's sold, if no further capacity comes in, then expansion gets held back. We won't name any specific program of that kind, but there are some capacity situations where that could happen. We are constantly searching for capacity to expand our programs, especially during periods of disruption.

Yaron Kinar

analyst
#45

All right, that's clear. Just one question about modeling. I believe you mentioned services revenues would see a 5% decline during the first half of 2020. Does that figure stand on its own, or is it measured against 2019?

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#46

Yaron, regarding that item. At this point our guidance is 5% lower for Q1, and that's compared with 2019.

Yaron Kinar

analyst
#47

All right, thanks.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#48

Regarding those identical time frames. When it comes to organic, there's one thing I want to be certain everyone understands — contingent commissions and GSCs are left out of how we figure organic. I'm aware that a few competitors may add them, then remove them, going back and forth. Those items are not part of our organic figure, all right.

Yaron Kinar

analyst
#49

Understood. Many thanks.

Josh Shanker

analyst
#50

Thanks. Andy, I really don't want to ask you to go over this again, but when you were reviewing slide 10 a bit earlier, the explanation about margin expansion didn't fully land with me. Could you take us through it once more — why did underlying margins grow in the quarter?

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#51

Going back to it, taking a look at the quarter, okay; the starting point was 28.1%, and this year we ended at 27%. That's a decline of 110 basis points. Gains and losses on our disposals contributed 90 basis points of pickup. Naturally, that won't happen again. Right. Hays cost us 150 basis points, and beyond that we were 50 basis points lower. What we've been pointing out there for the quarter is our non-cash stock compensation expense, plus the dilution from the acquisition completed in the third quarter. Those two things more than offset the underlying margin expansion we saw in the quarter.

Josh Shanker

analyst
#52

When I go through the numbers one by one, and I look at ex Hays, what I see is 140 basis points of normalized margin compression. That's covered by the — is it wrong for me to think about it in those terms?

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#53

Yeah. Take us through how you arrive at that, since I don't believe we're following that.

Josh Shanker

analyst
#54

If that disposal gain weren't there, wouldn't you land at 26.1 rather than 27? Hays, naturally, is recurring. Let's include it. That's the reason my sense was that. Setting Hays aside, I figure you'd sit around 26.1 plus 1.5, meaning 27.6, I suppose. No. With Hays excluded, you'd be at 26.7 without Hays, I guess, is where I'm. Would I be mistaken to believe the underlying got compressed across the quarter, I suppose? I'm attempting to track this. My apologies.

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#55

If you're. No, that isn't how we view it, I'd say — it's simply that when you take and you carve out the gains from the disposals and Hays, correct? That amounts to 60 basis points. Those figures are net, right?

Josh Shanker

analyst
#56

Yes.

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#57

All right, understood. So that means the remaining side has 50.

Josh Shanker

analyst
#58

Correct. Hays keeps coming back, but the profit from that sale does not. That 150 bucks, I'm moving it into 4Q20 so it happens once more, I suppose.

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#59

What would make you do that?

Josh Shanker

analyst
#60

Hays-

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#61

No, wait a moment. The lap on that was already made by us, though, Josh. That's perhaps something you need to keep in mind, I think. The full impact of it was being felt by us in this past quarter. Now that we're heading into next year, the comparison is more even. Well, an extra 150 basis points of margin compression isn't something I think Hays can deliver, but in 4Q20 you're going to have the fourth quarter Hays effect with you. Yeah. Assume the business changes nothing. It's net. Versus the fourth quarter of 2019, there is then no margin increase or decrease in the fourth quarter of 2020.

Josh Shanker

analyst
#62

Wouldn't that put you at 26.1? Am I mistaken there?

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#63

You mean 26.1 for Q4? Yes.

Josh Shanker

analyst
#64

Turning to 2020. Assuming nothing changes other than removing the gain from that disposal, your fourth-quarter 2020 EBITDA margin would come in at 26.1.

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#65

Correct. There's also a bit of an effect from the acquisition made in the third quarter, which is creating some drag. As I said, that's something you'll only see during this year.

Josh Shanker

analyst
#66

Alright, fine. I'd like to dig into the way those margins recover, I suppose, when we get to next year. Let's discuss it away from this call. I guess I'm not bright enough, and we'll sort it out. Appreciate it, Andy.

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#67

Of course. But hold on one moment, since you're heading off this call. Do you mean that your expectation is that the business's margins are going to decline in the coming year?

Josh Shanker

analyst
#68

I'm not sure at this point. My calculations aren't finished yet — my understanding is that I should begin with 26.1, then work out how the third quarter affects that and so on. For putting together a forecast for 4Q 2020, it seems like the starting base sits a bit below where 4Q 2019 landed.

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#69

Once more, what we'd put forward is this — in the end, whatever you choose to do is up to you. Begin with the whole year, all right? Take the full-year guidance we provided about how we view the business. From there, it will assist you on a quarterly basis.

Josh Shanker

analyst
#70

Okay. Obviously, to start with, what counts isn't merely a single year — it's a lot of years regardless. We can pick this conversation back up after the call. Thanks for all the assistance.

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#71

Of course. Thanks.

Josh Shanker

analyst
#72

Thank you.

Mike Zaremski

analyst
#73

Hey, I appreciate you squeezing me in. I suppose, Powell, during your prepared comments, you mentioned something to the effect that the large account segment is experiencing additional rates; that line of business is fee-based. My understanding is you're hinting at receiving less of a revenue upside, compared to a commission structure. I'm wondering, does hard pricing within the large account segment, or really solid pricing, act as a tailwind? Or is every single account truly handled through individual negotiation and might it become a headwind in some situations? I'm just attempting to grasp the dynamics better there.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#74

Correct. Simply consider, with large accounts, clearly the figures are significantly bigger. Should there be a rise, in those cases, a lot of those accounts employ risk managers, whose role is to secure the broadest coverage at the most aggressive rate. That creates extra strain on that objective, if you want to label it that way, when their pricing increases. I'd say it's largely dependent on the individual situation and how that insurance purchaser perceives the hard market or hardening market, I should clarify. Firming, like I mentioned, not hard market. They perceive it as a hard market, but our view differs. I'd simply say to you, I believe it's more on an individual basis.

Mike Zaremski

analyst
#75

All right, that's useful. So perhaps this one's for Andy — I take it you aren't seeing any significant margin pressures, which would suggest the outlook for contingent commissions is holding steady?

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#76

Not exactly. Keep in mind, we indicated our expectation that the GSCs would decline by $8 million to $10 million during 2020. The reason for that was the one-time GSC worth $9 million we received in the second quarter of 2019. Beyond that, as things stand, we aren't aware of any significant items.

Mike Zaremski

analyst
#77

All right. Do those contingents lean more toward casualty or toward property, or can you give us any detail on that?

R. Andrew Watts

executive
#78

No. I suppose we've never separated them out or examined them from that angle, but they're evenly weighted between casualty and property on a cost basis.

Mike Zaremski

analyst
#79

And finally, the deck included some fresh remarks regarding anticipated rivalry and price competition when it comes to acquisition candidates. Powell, you provided solid detail on that point. If that turns out to be accurate, does it suggest that stock repurchases might become a bigger item under consideration?

J. Powell Brown

executive
#80

Mike, like we've mentioned previously, our approach is to weigh the possible upside of every investment option available to us. Periodically, the board and I discuss a buyback, and we compare that against putting the funds into acquisitions and other uses; no formal repurchase program has been announced by us. I realize this frustrates a lot of you, yet going forward we'll keep assessing it. Please don't interpret this to mean that, well, should that happen, then stock will certainly be repurchased by them. Don't reach that conclusion. When we compare the company's intrinsic worth with the stock's actual price at the given moment, that's when we'll act.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#81

Okay, I appreciate the perspective.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#82

You're welcome.

Meyer Shields

analyst
#83

Thanks. Building on what Mike asked, if I may. You said that with large accounts there's, I suppose, less of an automatic revenue bump, because the arrangement is fee-based. Given that this is probably where the marketplace is currently showing the most distortion, what happens to the extra costs associated with placing business when it gets more expensive or takes more work? Do you get paid more for that?

J. Powell Brown

executive
#84

No. That would be nice, but no. Though I'll note that 26.1% shows up in that dynamic.

Meyer Shields

analyst
#85

All right.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#86

There are occasions when the compensation comes in lower. If they are revisiting the fee due to rivals or another factor, the amount can be reduced. That keeps things quite lively for the folks handling placements — perhaps that's the best way to put it.

Meyer Shields

analyst
#87

Sounds like a kind of excitement we'd rather skip. Question two. Now that you've made acquisitions up in Canada, I was hoping you could give us some sense of how we ought to view M&A outside the U.S.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#88

Absolutely. Opportunities that might come up in nations where we think Brown & Brown could find potential have been and will keep being things we examine. Broadly speaking, if you consider where our operations sit right now, there's a Canadian business at present, plus operations—or an operation—in London. Bermuda holds one as well. What ties each of those nations together? First off, they belong to the Commonwealth. Within those Commonwealth nations, the rule of law prevails. I won't state as an absolute that those are the only spots we'd ever pursue a deal. Statements like always, never, or can't bother me. Those words really rub me the wrong way. Up to now, that's where our thinking has centered, and should it prove sensible, we'd weigh that moving forward. It's curious, Meyer, that this question came from you, since the competitive environment for deals in a number of those nations is at times even more intense than what exists in the U.S., believe it or not. Somewhat curious.

Meyer Shields

analyst
#89

All right. No, I appreciate that. That's quite useful.

Mark Hughes

analyst
#90

Yeah, real quick, you said in the retail segment that one of the factors was bigger rises in employee benefits. Can you explain what's causing that?

J. Powell Brown

executive
#91

I don't recall saying anything about a bigger rise in employee benefits, even though employee benefit healthcare expenses are rising, but I don't recall saying that in the

Mark Hughes

analyst
#92

I'm looking at the retail segment here. You mention that as one of the factors, along with commercial auto and employee benefits.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#93

Answer from J. Powell Brown: Yes. Oh, yes. Mark, that relates only to what our customers pay, not to what we pay — not to our own expense on that. Broadly speaking, my sense is that everybody observes this out in the market.

Mark Hughes

analyst
#94

Okay, got it.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#95

That seems to me like it backs up the organic figure, so I was basically wondering whether anything fresh or unusual is happening on the benefits side— Answer (J. Powell Brown): Nope.

Mark Hughes

analyst
#96

That was one factor pushing growth forward.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#97

Yeah, no, nothing at all. It keeps going pretty much at the same speed as before, so there's nothing fresh or changed on that front.

Mark Hughes

analyst
#98

Thanks.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#99

If there are any, Cecilia, we'll take one final question. If not, we'll go ahead and wrap up for today, please.

Yaron Kinar

analyst
#100

Thank you. One more short question about modeling, if I may. Regarding how the margin was affected by the acquisition we completed in the third quarter — I believe your comment was that it added 100 to 150 basis points in the first quarter, and then became a drag during the second and third quarters. Do the figures you gave reflect the consolidated company, or just the retail segment?

J. Powell Brown

executive
#101

That's right — the whole company, Yaron.

Yaron Kinar

analyst
#102

All right, thank you.

J. Powell Brown

executive
#103

Cecilia, before we finish up, I'd like to share a thought with everyone. First of all, thanks for spending part of your day with us. Should anything be unclear, Andy would be glad to walk you through it in detail, and so would others on our team. One thing I want everyone to be clear on: from where we sit, the Hays acquisition is a fantastic one, and the main reason is the outstanding people it brings. Thinking back to deals such as Arrowhead and other big ones where we brought aboard so many truly talented individuals, those transactions played a major role in our company's history. In my view, the Hays team includes quite a few people of that caliber. My reason for saying so is that Mike Egan and Jim Hays have built a tremendous business, and that team holds plenty of other exceptional individuals as well. Let my final remark today be this: our entire business has us feeling very good; the Hays acquisition has us feeling very good, and we anticipate wonderful results from that portion of our operations in the years ahead. As I mentioned, broadly speaking, we aren't seeing many headwinds as we head into 2020, and all of us are genuinely excited about what that means for us and the company both now and down the road as we progress toward $4 billion. We appreciate the time you've given us, and we can't wait to speak with everyone again next quarter. Thank you. Enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#104

Thank you; that concludes today's conference call. Thank you for your participation.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Brown & Brown, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Brown & Brown, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Brown & Brown, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.