Brown & Brown, Inc. (BRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 28, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
J. Powell Brown
executiveAppreciate that, Lisa. Hello everybody, and we're glad you could be with us for the call covering our first quarter of 2020. Ahead of reviewing those results, everyone here at Brown & Brown wants to express that our prayers and thoughts go out to each person touched, whether directly or indirectly, by COVID-19. We'd also like to extend our thanks to everyone working on the front lines for all they are doing in these difficult times. And last, my gratitude goes out to every one of our more than 10,000 teammates for what they're accomplishing on behalf of our customers and for making the shift to working from home go so well. On today's call, we'll go over how we did in Q1 and share our perspective regarding the coming quarters. I want to leave you with a few things worth remembering. To start, the quarter turned out really well for us. On top of that, our balance sheet is in great shape — among companies trading publicly that we compete with, none convert cash better than we do, and we can tap roughly $1 billion in liquidity. Running the business conservatively is how we've always operated and how we'll keep operating; our eyes are on the long haul, we don't carry heavy assets, and every day we aim to deliver distinctive solutions for the people we serve. The first quarter felt like two different stories stitched together. Things were expanding at a healthy clip through January and February, and then came the start of March, when the effects began showing up among our customers in the Pacific Northwest. Our position, which we've communicated previously, is that this company serves as an economic bellwether, particularly for those in the middle and upper-middle income brackets. Starting in the middle of March, we started noticing how this was affecting our clients across the nation. Among the numerous challenging factors to evaluate right now is the question of what effect mitigation measures undertaken by the U.S. government will have on our customers via its support programs. In this highly extraordinary period, our priority is the well-being and protection of our colleagues and the people they care for. Thanks to numerous technology investments we'd made in the past, we were able to move more than 10,000 team members into a remote work setup within an extremely brief window. People keep coming to us looking for answers—whether it's about the CARES Act, SBA loans, what furloughs and layoffs mean for them, or even things like using their own car to make restaurant deliveries or finding specific supplies. We launched our B&B Relief Center so that customers and the broader public could get deals on particular supplies. Along with sending out weekly updates to both customers and prospects, these efforts have landed well with the people we're trying to reach. On top of that, I feel truly humbled watching how resolute, devoted, and committed our teammates are—and what they bring to our customers. Let's now shift over to how we did this quarter. I'm looking at Slide 4. Turning to the first quarter, we generated $698.5 million in revenue. That works out to 12.8% growth overall and 5.6% growth on an organic basis. That organic number is a strong one, and we feel good about it. Shortly, I'll take you through how each segment did in more detail. Our EBITDAC margin was 34.6%, which is 280 basis points higher than what we saw in Q1 of '19. For the quarter, net income per share came to $0.54, a 35% improvement over the same period last year. Adjusted, meaning we exclude the movement in acquisition earnout payables, net income per share was $0.51, representing 24.4% growth against adjusted net income per share in 2019 Q1. We picked up 5 additional companies this quarter as well, bringing in about $39 million of yearly revenue. All in all, we're thrilled about the way we grew revenue and profit during this quarter. Coming off a really solid 2019, this was an excellent quarter. Later on in the presentation, Andy will dig further into our financial numbers. I've turned to Slide 5 at this point. The first quarter was a curious one. Up through the beginning of March, the U.S. economy continued to expand, and the majority of firms continued adding workers and putting money into their operations, which in the end fueled growth in exposure units. And then, halfway through March, the situation shifted completely. Due to the numerous orders requiring people to remain at home or stay in place, we are observing businesses either letting workers go or putting them on temporary leave, which is pushing first-quarter GDP down and will keep affecting it afterward. As we've mentioned previously, one of the main factors behind our organic growth is exposure units. Therefore, we anticipate an effect in the quarters ahead — I'll share more details on that when we discuss outlook. When it comes to rates, we're still seeing slight upticks on — increases in rates across the majority of coverage lines, since carriers keep making their underwriting standards stricter. Those increases ended up largely matching our expectations for the first quarter and resembled what we saw in the prior few quarters. In the end, what mostly determined how much rates went up was how large a loss a particular account had. For accounts with few losses in the admitted market, premiums typically rose between 1% and 5%, apart from auto, where the increase reached 5% to 10%. On the E&S side, rates for coastal property climbed 5% to 15% compared with the year before. General property rates came in at 5% to 10%. Professional liability saw a 5% to 10% rise, while cyber went up roughly 10% to 15%. How the pandemic will affect rates, both now and going forward, remains uncertain. As for the M&A landscape, it stayed highly competitive. In Q1, we completed five more deals, which we estimate will bring in $39 million yearly. We're still in discussions with many businesses, though things have slowed down as sellers try to figure out how the pandemic might hit their operations and, as a result, the value they'd get. I'm now on Slide 6. Let's move on to how our four segments did. On the retail side, we had another strong quarter, with organic revenue up 5.7% in Q1. If not for a $10.5 million adjustment to our estimate for future revenues related to the economic turbulence from COVID-19, retail's organic revenue growth would have been about 300 basis points higher. Andy will cover that more thoroughly in a moment. Our Q1 growth was driven by better retention, more exposure units with current customers, new business, and improved rates. We'd like to congratulate all of our retail segment teammates on yet another outstanding quarter. National programs delivered 11.8% organic growth — another great quarter. If you exclude the impact of flood claims, the organic revenue growth this quarter is one of the strongest we've ever achieved. Our growth was fueled by continued strong performance across quite a few programs, including lender placed, earthquake, personal and commercial property, along with many others. At the start of January, we completed our first deal in Canada by acquiring Special Risk Insurance Managers. We're quite pleased with this transaction and believe it will create opportunities for us in the coming quarters and years. Overall, National Programs delivered an outstanding quarter, and I'd like to thank each and every member of that team. Our Wholesale Brokerage segment posted yet another solid quarter, achieving 8.2% organic revenue growth, driven by robust performance in both our Brokerage and Binding Authority operations, and this occurred despite some carriers reducing their writing of California personal lines due to wildfire losses incurred last year. My gratitude goes out to the whole team for another excellent quarter. During this quarter, organic revenue in our Services segment dropped 13.1%. When we looked at the Services segment at the start of the year, our expectation had been a 5% decline in organic revenue for the first six months, and that was because of our Social Security Advocacy business plus a customer contract that was terminated at one of our claims processing businesses. But as the quarter went on, we saw fewer weather-related claims and social security advocacy claims, which made the hit to organic revenue growth in the Services segment even worse. This isn't new for us — claim volume and claim timing can cause revenues in the Services segment to swing more widely. With that, I'll turn it over to Andy, who will walk through our financial performance in more detail.
R. Watts
executiveThanks, Powell, and good morning to all of you. Just like in prior quarters, our plan is to go over our GAAP results, some non-GAAP financial highlights, and after that our adjusted results, which exclude the effect of the change in acquisition earn-outs. I'm on Slide #7. In the first quarter, we achieved total revenue growth of $79.2 million, or 12.8%, along with organic revenue growth of 5.6%. Our EBITDAC rose by 22.8%, expanding more quickly than revenues thanks to leverage on our expense base from greater organic revenue growth, increased contingent commissions, and the results from one acquisition we made in the past year that books substantially all of its revenue in each year's first quarter. Our income before income tax climbed by 38.2%, outpacing EBITDAC because of the change in acquisition earn-out payables, which fell by $12.2 million compared with a year earlier, based on our latest projections. Our net income rose by $38.5 million, or 33.8%, and diluted net income per share went up by $0.14, or 35%, reaching $0.54. For the first quarter, our effective tax rate came in at 25.7%, versus 23.3% in the first quarter of 2019. That higher effective tax rate resulted from lower state tax rates and prior-year adjustments, plus the shift in market valuation of our company-owned life insurance tied to our deferred compensation plan. Our weighted average share count was essentially unchanged from the prior year, and dividend per share rose to $0.085, or 6.3%, compared with the first quarter of 2019. Now to Slide #8. This slide shows our results once the change in estimated acquisition earn-outs payable is removed for both years. We think this presentation gives a more comparable year-on-year basis. In the first quarter, we revised our estimated future financial performance and the corresponding estimated earn-out payables by $11 million for certain acquisitions completed within the last 3 years, and $6 million of that adjustment was tied to the potential impact from COVID-19. Isolating the change in acquisition earn-outs for both years, our income before income taxes grew $44.6 million, or 29.8%. Net income on an adjusted basis rose by $29.5 million, or 25.7%. And our adjusted diluted net income per share was $0.51, up $0.10, or 24.4%. All in all, it was a really good quarter. Over to Slide #9. This slide lays out the key components of our revenue performance. For the quarter, our total commissions and fees rose 12.8%. Our contingent commissions and guaranteed supplemental commissions, or GSCs, went up by $8.9 million compared with the first quarter of 2019, since the cash received during the first quarter of 2020 for contingents accrued as of December 31, 2019, was higher than expected, as we qualify for certain contingents that we did not qualify for in the past. Our organic revenues, which isolate the net impact of M&A activity, rose by 5.6% for the quarter. Over to Slide #10. In our Retail business, overall revenue rose 15%, helped by acquisitions made during the last 12 months along with organic growth of 5.7%, which came from gains in every line of business. Under ASC 606, we reduced the estimates of revenue we anticipate collecting from existing employee benefits and workers' compensation policies, which cut revenue by $10.5 million. We revised those estimates after evaluating how COVID-19 is expected to affect future employment levels and payrolls for our customers over the rest of their present policy terms. That adjustment reduced retail organic growth for the quarter by nearly 300 basis points. EBITDAC margin for the quarter rose 220 basis points, and EBITDAC was up 22.3%, reflecting the timing of profit from an acquisition closed in last year's third quarter, greater contingent commissions and expense base leverage from stronger organic growth. Partly offsetting that margin gain were increased noncash stock-based compensation cost, intercompany IT costs and margin flow-through tied to the $10.5 million revenue adjustment noted above. Our EBITDAC expanded more quickly than total revenues even after excluding the effect of the acquisition that booked nearly all of its revenue in this year's first quarter. Income before income tax margin climbed 470 basis points, mainly from a higher EBITDAC margin, $7.1 million of year-over-year adjustments to earn-out liabilities and slower percentage growth in intercompany interest charges. Those earn-out liability adjustments stemmed largely from COVID-19's possible effect on future results of acquisitions closed within the last 3 years. Turning to Slide #11. National Programs total revenues rose $18.8 million, or 17.2%, while organic revenue rose 11.8%, thanks to strong results from several programs. EBITDAC climbed 25.2%, and margin rose 210 basis points on higher revenues, greater contingent commissions and ongoing expense base leverage. Partly offsetting the margin gain were larger intercompany IT charges. National Programs had another very strong quarter, with EBITDAC rising much faster than total revenues. Income before income taxes rose $10.3 million, or 53.4%, and expanded 550 basis points on EBITDAC margin expansion, reduced intercompany interest expense and lower estimated earnout payables affected by the possibility of weaker future performance tied to COVID-19. Now to Slide #12. Wholesale Brokerage posted total revenue growth of 10.2% and organic growth of 8.2%. Total revenues outpaced organic because of acquisitions closed during the last 12 months, partly offset by reduced contingent commissions. EBITDAC rose 8.5%, while margin fell 40 basis points from larger intercompany IT charges and lower contingent commissions that outweighed underlying margin expansion. Income before income taxes rose 13.5%, and margin rose 70 basis points on lower amortization and a change in acquisition earn-out payables. Moving on to Slide #13. Our Services segment saw total revenues fall 10.1%, while organic revenue dropped 13.1%, though total revenues got a lift from an acquisition made earlier. Because organic revenue fell by a larger amount than we had expected during the first quarter, we now think organic growth across the first half of the year may land nearer to a negative 10%, setting aside any possible COVID-19 effect. During the quarter, EBITDAC was down 16.9% and margin fell 180 basis points, which came from reduced organic revenues along with greater intercompany IT charges. Income before income taxes rose 9.8%, and our margin on income before income taxes went up 410 basis points. That gain resulted from reducing our estimated acquisition earn-out payables. Turning to Slide #14; we'd like to offer a few remarks about capital and liquidity. Our aim has been, and will keep being, to stay disciplined in how we allocate capital, seeking to optimize shareholder returns while keeping leverage at a conservative level. We've noted before how important it is to carry low leverage and a balanced debt maturity ladder so we have strength when the economy is uncertain. We believe holding the lowest leverage among the major public or PE-backed insurance brokers gives us robust financial security and flexibility.
R. Watts
executiveA really solid balance sheet plus our liquidity gives us the ability to navigate the unknowns created by this pandemic, and it also lets us keep making investments. As of the end of March, cash and cash equivalents stood at more than $385 million, alongside $700 million of capacity we can draw on our revolver. We expect to draw roughly $250 million on that revolving line of credit prior to May 1. Some of that money is slated to fund the payment tied to our previously announced purchase of Loan Protector Insurance Services, which we expect to finalize in early May. The rest of what we borrow goes toward making our financial footing even stronger so we can soften possible COVID-19 pandemic impacts stemming from late payments by customers or carriers. Now on to Slide #15. Among the metrics that make us proud is how well we turn revenues into free cash flow. Thanks to strong margins and disciplined working capital management, we reliably convert 22% to 26% of revenues into available capital. Our free cash flow conversion ratio leads the industry and sits roughly 100% above the average among the other public brokers; in other words, the cash we produce is about equal to what a company twice our size generates. That leaves us with substantial capital to put back into the business. Depending on how much M&A activity occurs, we throw off considerable capital beyond our committed expenditures, which cover dividends, CapEx and debt service. Right now, we feel our position is truly strong. Keep in mind that Q1 typically shows a lower free cash flow conversion ratio because of ASC 606, since we accrue revenue mostly tied to employee benefits policies whose cash comes in across the year. On top of that, during the first quarter we paid out most of the annual performance bonuses employees had earned the year before. For the first quarter of 2020, our free cash flow conversion ratio came in at about 2.5%, versus negative 2.9% in the first quarter of 2019. A factor that could impact free cash flow conversion is customers holding back payments, whether that's something carriers offer or states require. In our view, that kind of scenario would push back our cash receipts, which explains why we plan to pull more capital on our revolver later this month; with that said, I'll hand things back to Powell for the closing remarks.
J. Powell Brown
executiveThanks, Andy. That was a solid report. Now let me walk through how we're viewing things for the quarters ahead. Our expectation is that both the economy and employment will shrink across at least the next 2 quarters, and then could rise modestly as we move into the fourth quarter. That view comes from reports by numerous economists at our banking partners, who are forecasting an unemployment rate of 15% to 20% during the second quarter. Keep in mind, under the CARES Act, people who are self-employed and gig workers can now apply for unemployment. Since these individuals typically aren't covered by sponsored plans, chances are they won't affect our employee benefits or workers' compensation lines of business. Also remember, a lot of employees are being furloughed and filing for unemployment even though they remain benefit eligible. Those situations illustrate just how complex it is to compare today's unemployment figures with prior years and to estimate what the potential impact on our business might be. Those same economists expect GDP to fall 20% to 30% in the second quarter, with growth beginning to rebound in the third quarter, though they don't see a recovery until mid- to late 2021. Given those assumptions, we think the greatest effect on our financial performance will land in the third quarter, while our organic growth could turn negative in the second quarter. That's because it takes roughly 60 days before higher unemployment shows up in our numbers. We believe the heaviest impact will hit our employee benefits and workers' compensation lines of coverage, since employment and payrolls are the primary drivers for those. Beyond that, we expect our overall P&C business to feel the effects once companies lower their exposure units. One more dynamic tied to the work from home mandate: we anticipate new business will slow while retention rises. Whether those two offset one another, we don't know. What remains unknown right now is how severe and how prolonged the impact of COVID will be. Our hope is that the CARES Act and the Fed's actions begin to take effect within the next month or 2. On rates, we expect most to tick up slightly in the second quarter, but what happens during the second half of the year is unclear until we know more about how COVID-19 is affecting things. Weighing all of these factors, our best estimate is that full year organic growth could be slightly positive or down low to mid-single digits. That range is truly uncertain, since our assumptions rest on limited actual data. Over the next quarter, we'll have a clearer picture of the depth and duration. Here's what we do know. We're a solutions provider. So we'll keep our focus on delivering risk management solutions for our customers and prospects, and on developing new and creative ways of generating new business remotely. Discussions with potential acquisition targets are still ongoing, and it's possible we'll finalize a handful of transactions during Q2. At minimum over the coming months, we anticipate a deceleration in M&A dealings stemming from the lack of clarity regarding how businesses will perform going forward and the implications that could hold for the valuations sellers expect; we remain — my apologies, I noted before that we keep pursuing innovation and providing service to our customers through these uncertain times. Great creativity emerges when necessity demands it. At Brown & Brown, our constant aim is to bring forth the greatest possible number of new solutions to benefit our customers, our teammates, our carrier partners and our shareholders. Finally, just as I opened by speaking about our teammates and their families, I'd like to end with that same emphasis. Ours is an organization of committed, diligent teammates devoted to taking care of our customers. So our objective is to always make certain they stay safe and well. Doing so enables them to excel as spouses, parents and teammates who concentrate on providing innovative risk management solutions. With that, I'll hand things back to Lisa for the Q&A.
Greg Peters
analystThanks for the outlook guidance for the year — we really appreciate it. I was hoping you might expand on it by talking about what exposure you have to sectors such as restaurants, energy, and so on? Then, second, I'm aware that a few of your competitors have talked about pledges not to lay anyone off. So I'm just wondering, if you see the possibility of organic revenue shrinking, how do you plan to handle your cost structure through this crisis?
J. Powell Brown
executiveAll right. Greg, a few points. To begin with, as you're aware, our book of business is fairly diversified; that isn't to say we don't have plenty of plenty of lines, but it's simply a wide spectrum spanning the United States. So what I'd say is, there are sectors, as you know, getting hit dramatically — gaming, hospitality, restaurants, movie theaters, sporting events, you mentioned oil and gas, anything involving theme parks, gyms, some construction, transportation; and frankly, figuring out the effect on every one of those sectors is very hard at this moment, we can make assumptions, and at present that would be our best estimate. So for instance, you might ask, we do substantial business in the automobile space and automobile could involve dealerships, new, both — plus RV. We do F&I business. We do plenty of things. So based on where you are in the country, that business has been affected in widely differing ways; so for instance, I mean in the Northeast, it's been hit far harder than in the Mountain States, as an example; and so I think it's genuinely too soon to say, Greg. But from a sector perspective, there isn't any single sector where our exposure is so enormous that we need to single it out. As I said, I just used the auto industry because it's a distinctive one, and you read plenty about it, but we have lots of governmental entities and we have lots of nonprofits and we have lots of construction and we have — so that's the first point. The second point relates to the $64,000 question, which I figured everyone would raise, and let's address that briefly. First, at Brown & Brown, we have teammates; we don't have employees. And we belong to one big high-performing, as we call it, athletic team; and every team at the local level is led by a leadership group that assesses how to invest in that business on a daily, monthly, quarterly, yearly basis; so our customers, our capabilities and our carrier relationships define us both as an organization and locally. So when I say that, it is not our intention to have teammates leave the team during this period; that would be the very last thing we'd want. Let me say this: any such evaluations, should they take place, would be made very locally rather than handed down as a sweeping order — we wouldn't be issuing directives from on high. Choosing how best to serve our customers would be a decision made at the local level. So at this moment we're quite attuned to that subject, just as we always are, since we've got a bunch of great teammates. And our belief is that as these changes unfold and whatever that turns out to mean, since your guess is as good as ours, we'll emerge on the other side as a stronger organization.
Greg Peters
analystThat's a thorough response, and I'm grateful for it. Alright, regarding the point you brought up — it also appeared in the press release — about the danger that money coming in from policyholders could be postponed. Could you address whether you've observed anything suggesting that so far? And then maybe take that and expand on what you said regarding the acquisition, plus how you're putting money into the company right now and moving ahead?
J. Powell Brown
executiveAlright. First off, keep in mind, this is definitely taking place, Greg, since certain states are requiring it; as you're aware, there are states mandating something like a 60-day premium holiday. That's the first thing. Second, we have, in a restricted way, some customers — especially the smaller ones, though not only them — who are asking for rate relief as a result of exposure units declining. In certain cases, and a few carriers permit us to lower exposure units partway through the term, expecting the effect on their business overall. Now you raised a question regarding acquisitions and how we view our company. Let's discuss how life actually works. How life actually works is, first, we made an announcement about a loan protector, which we believe is a really solid business, and we were awaiting DOJ approval. We expect that to close at some point in the second quarter. And we completed, as you're aware, a number of other deals in Q1. And so — we're a company that is constantly in conversations with people. Right? And ultimately, companies are led by gifted individuals. So they might have the finest revenue stream or earnings stream you could imagine, but if it — if the culture doesn't match, then it fails. And that's not something we want. So the notion of completing a deal through a video call where we've never encountered the people involved — I simply find that extremely, extremely, extremely difficult to picture; that said, we've been reaching out to many people over very, very long stretches of time. So the rationale Andy mentioned, and Andy and I have discussed this extensively, is — the rationale Andy mentioned regarding our liquidity is, I believe, that's genuinely very important. And for those of you who joined the call 10 years back, prior to the downturn 10 years back, some folks would get a bit — they would fault us for being conservative. And then we made our way through that stretch of time, and today we remain conservative and I believe we're well positioned to put money into our company whenever we choose; that doesn't mean we're attempting to head out and purchase a slew of companies amid the downturn. It means we possess the flexibility to invest whenever we wish.
Greg Peters
analystAll right. For the last question: during earlier quarters, both you and Andy were ready to give us some insight into how profit sharing and guaranteed supplemental commissions would play out across the year. So I'd like to know whether you could take this chance, given a genuinely unpredictable view for the rest of the year, to explain how that might flow through and impact those 2 revenue lines?
J. Powell Brown
executiveAll right, once more, Greg, this is nothing but a guess. So I'll give that 2 shots. First, looking at it, one could argue you might see fewer losses since automobiles and similar things haven't been on the road for some stretch. So one could argue perhaps it rises a bit. Yet with some of these, as you're aware, growth elements are built in. That means you must — the business has to expand and deliver a particular performance; that's point one. Second, I believe a lot of our big carrier partners, along with other carriers, are exploring methods to assist their distribution partners. What I mean is, once more, the way we operate our business versus how a smaller independent agency operates theirs could differ somewhat when it comes to cash flow and other matters of that sort. Therefore I genuinely think carriers will examine carefully how they can factor in these extraordinary circumstances and reduce the possible downside of that — meaning, say, if a growth element exists, will they choose to waive it for the year? I don't know. I haven't heard of anyone doing that so far. I'm only speculating. So it's quite difficult to say, Greg; yet if you push me, I'd essentially say I believe it would be down a bit.
R. Watts
executiveRight. Greg, this is Andy. Since we now accrue for these on a go-forward basis under ASC 606, that adds another layer of complexity. You noticed in our first quarter that we picked up additional contingents tied to those we didn't qualify for last year; we wouldn't — at least as of right now, we would not expect that going forward. Hopefully that will happen, but at this stage that probably wouldn't be our expectation. We're going to have to watch this really closely over the next quarter or 2 and just see how trends look. Feedback we're getting from carriers. Again, the lost comment is spot on. The other side of it, but if premium is down for them, it impacts their profitability, which impacts the contingents. So there are a lot of factors we're going to need to kind of monitor on the way through.
Greg Peters
analystUnderstood. Now, regarding those ASC 606 adjustments you mentioned at the beginning — did any portion of that touch the profit sharing and guaranteed supplemental commission piece of your revenue, or did none of it pass through there?
R. Watts
executiveNo, it was extremely minimal; we didn’t have a — no basis.
Mike Zaremski
analystStarting off with the revenue recognition question. I just want to get a sense of whether the effect during this quarter had a material impact on margins?
R. Watts
executiveHonestly, Mike, I'm not sure I'd call it material. What we told everyone was that we took that $10.5 million revenue adjustment, and the hit to profit came to roughly $5.8 million. And like you've observed before, the changes we typically record related to ASC 606 tend to carry better margins than the business as a whole. So that's fairly consistent with how it plays out.
Mike Zaremski
analystAll right, Andy, just to make sure I've got that straight — was the benefit to the margin somewhere around $5 million to $6 million?
R. Watts
executiveNo, it actually hurt the margin. What happened is it came through at roughly a 58% margin. Our EBITDAC margin isn't 58%.
Mike Zaremski
analystAll right, understood. And based on what you've said, is it reasonable for us to think this could carry on through 2Q and 3Q?
R. Watts
executiveNo. Let me walk through an example to clarify how this played out, since what we needed to do was review every policy currently active, or in force, as of March 31, and perform a look-back on each one. Out of that $10.5 million adjustment, roughly $7.5 million ties to policies we wrote during the first quarter, while the remainder comes from policies written back in 2019. Here's the way to frame it — take worker's compensation. Suppose we bound a policy and its projected payrolls indicated we'd earn $100 across the following 12 months; at this point, if we now believe payrolls will drop and we'll only earn $80, then we have to reverse the $20 we booked at the time we bound that policy. In this case, that's what we did during January. Then we reversed course and added the $20 back in March, all right? So that ought to capture every policy still outstanding. What it leaves out, Mike, is the part we can't predict and what we addressed in our commentary — namely, what will actually occur with renewal business across the quarters ahead and how that hits the organic; that element, at this moment, we simply have no visibility into.
Mike Zaremski
analystGot it, that's useful. One final thing from me — around possible business interruption claims. There's a ton of talk going around. I'm not talking about the regulatory side. That, I think, unless you've got a view — which I'd be glad to hear — is probably beyond our hands. What I'm curious about is what your clients — what are you hearing from them, and from the carriers, about whether there's room for — do you figure some business interruption claims will get paid for your clients, or will most of them be excluded?
J. Powell Brown
executiveAlright, Mike, this is Powell. A few points. First off, I want to note that, as you're aware, pandemic is usually the reason business interruption gets excluded, or generally excluded. And beyond that, a physical damage loss provision applies. So keep that in mind. What I'd say is that a very small number of policies out there carry certain sublimits. And I mean very small as a share — under 1%, if I had to guess. That said, once again, we — you'd need to examine each individual policy for each individual customer. But if we're talking broadly, across the industry, and our customers make up a pretty broad cross-section of what the industry writes, then as I mentioned, generally speaking, business interruption carries a pandemic exclusion and it also requires physical damage loss — that's the first point. That's all.
R. Watts
executiveMike, let me circle back and clear up one point regarding what you raised, just to be sure we've addressed it for everyone, since you were asking whether there would be an impact going forward. That $10.5 million adjustment we recorded — once more, it reflects our best estimate, based on what we believe could occur with unemployment and payroll for those policies still outstanding. Should that somehow play out differently from what we expect, might we record yet another adjustment, an incremental one, in the second or third quarter? Yes, that's possible. At this point we simply don't know. Once again, what we've made at this stage is our best estimate.
Elyse Greenspan
analystTo kick things off, I've got a pair of quick items regarding the quarter, and after that a broader question. Roughly $6.4 million in EBITDAC didn't flow through the segments and possibly went through corporate instead — is that right? And if so, what drove that corporate benefit during the quarter?
R. Watts
executiveThat's right, Elyse, a couple of factors were at play. During our commentary we flagged the incremental — the increased IT costs within the divisions. Really, that was simply a reclassification from corporate into the divisions compared with how we reported it a year ago. So that accounted for part of it. Beyond that, in the first quarter we adjusted our SIP according to the projected payout for those — the 3 grants still outstanding; those were the main items at corporate adding up to the $6 million. Regarding SIP, as you're aware, we review it consistently, and we'll adjust it upward or downward in the quarters ahead depending on what we expect the payouts to be, on both organic and the earnings per share.
Elyse Greenspan
analystAll right, that's useful. And in the remarks you prepared, you folks mentioned some solid expansion in the lender-placed operation. Was that simply strong performance from clients holding up against COVID-19's recessionary strain, or would that increase have occurred no matter what took place with COVID?
R. Watts
executiveRight, Elyse, there were a handful of separate forces at play in that. Nearly all of it came from new business, and we've worked that out. They enjoyed a strong 2018 and a solid '19. We had lost a few accounts during the previous year because of M&A, though we brought them in and made up the bulk of that via new business; that same pattern keeps going. What's happening in that area at present — and you're seeing quite a few mandates tied to the inability to foreclose on properties — means we aren't getting many additional placements at the moment; however, what we appreciate about that segment is the way it provides a pleasant cushion for organic growth, since when the economy declines, those operations surge, and that's genuinely positive.
Elyse Greenspan
analystAll right, that's useful. And I do appreciate the outlook, and of course, all of us get that there's a great deal of uncertainty when it comes to GDP and unemployment projections, plus how long these stay-at-home orders will last. But when you consider that roughly flat to somewhat declining organic figure for the year, how do you view the various segments? And I realize this is extremely fluid. Still, as you work through various scenarios, it appears programs might continue to do fairly well even if things trend downward. Could you give us a high-level walkthrough of the segments and which ones might do better and which could face greater pressure as the economy moves lower?
J. Powell Brown
executiveElyse, this is Powell. The answer is, as you're aware, we historically haven't provided guidance, and this time we won't be providing guidance on the divisions. We've tried our hardest to give you a broad picture based on our best estimate as of today. And if and when we get better information, we'd be in a position to give you a better answer. However, right now, we've stated what we intend to state regarding that.
R. Watts
executiveRegarding the additional color we provided this quarter, Elyse, that was solely for the Services segment, and it stems from what we are observing in terms of underlying claims activity.
Elyse Greenspan
analystAll right, that helps. And previously you mentioned something like two-thirds to three-quarters, correct, of organic growth came from exposure units, while the rest came from price. Does that rough estimate still hold today, given some of the shifts we've observed in your book of business?
J. Powell Brown
executiveI believe that's right, Elyse. Here's what I think matters a great deal for everyone on this call to keep in mind. During 2008 through 2011, there was a stretch when exposure units declined and rates declined too. Now the situation is different. Exposure units are declining while rates are climbing. Right? So there are a few things you need to consider. First, that dynamic when folks are short on cash, and if you're in a survival mindset, which means I simply want to make it to another day, I have to get through this, then would you purchase — and we haven't observed this yet, but I'm asking, would you purchase a somewhat smaller umbrella, would you purchase a reduced limit for your earthquake coverage, would you purchase a lesser wind limit? What would you do out of necessity to allow yourself to reach that next day. So let's keep that in mind. That's truly significant; and I don't know of any method for you or anyone else on this call to model that, since we don't know. We're only sharing our impression of it and speaking with customers ourselves and speaking with folks in our organization; that's a major thing for me. I want to understand how our customers are faring financially and how we can assist them. We want them to remain a going concern.
R. Watts
executiveRight, Elyse — as we discussed during the past two or three calls, a direct link isn't something you can count on. Take property rates climbing 5%: that doesn't mean organic growth lands at 5%, since it depends on how companies approach deductibles. And once more, 5% may not be the point that sets things off — yet should you happen to impose 10%, 15%, or 20% on a client owing to their loss history, their deductibles could shift. So those are a few of the forces that feed into the real revenues, and after that, the weightings.
Mark Hughes
analystAndy, suppose organic ends up roughly in the middle — basically flat, maybe slightly negative — how would that affect EBITDAC profitability across the whole year?
R. Watts
executiveMark, my sense is that remains one of the things we simply don't know yet at this point. You've observed before that our organic growth and our margins don't necessarily track one another directly; some quarters have seen those 2 things rise or fall together. Other quarters have seen them diverge. We — as you're aware, our approach is to run and guide this business over the long haul, rather than quarter to quarter. Could there be some margin effect in the interim? Possibly, given how fast all of this hit everyone throughout every part of it; but we make a real effort to keep a close handle on all of it daily; that's the reason our business enjoys the margins it does; still, it wouldn't shock us to see a bit of downward pressure on margins for the full year. Turning to the quarters, honestly, we lack a solid read at this point simply because we're finding it hard to pin down the revenues, to be candid, and there's very little hard data available to us right now on which to build any of our assumptions — that's where the difficulty lies.
Mark Hughes
analystWhat about the gap between smaller accounts and those that are mid-sized or large? In terms of how they're acting, what kind of divergence are you observing?
J. Powell Brown
executiveSure, Mark — this is Powell. What I'd say is that we lend across every category. Consequently, many of our smaller clients, quite a few of them lack the money needed to ride out 6 weeks of working from home, or as I put it, when I head home and witness the creativity that has emerged and the shift or metamorphosis of especially certain small companies toward a different way of delivering value, whatever that may be for them — whether it's takeout at a restaurant or something different — I believe there are folks who are barely scraping by, in certain cases, more so among small companies, or if they've gotten some form of financial help or it's on the way. They're simply aiming to reach the point where we ramp back up. A lot of the medium and bigger companies, except for those carrying heavy debt — so — and plenty of those exist as well, but generally they're in better shape. And a typical reply would be, when we entered this — into this aspect of it, we can sustain it for a couple of months, but we need this thing to ramp back up in the first part of the summer or midway through the summer, since they had kept their balance sheet and cash position fairly conservative; so it's sort of all over the map.
Yaron Kinar
analystFirst off, let's revisit the margin topic once more. If organic growth does end up going negative for the year and reducing staff isn't really something you want to do, could you discuss what other options you have available to hold margins fairly steady? And on a wider note, how much of your cost base is variable?
R. Watts
executiveYaron, as you're aware, we have quite a few levers within the company when it comes to variable cost, and those will simply rise and fall in line with whatever we spend on commissions, and anything we can review when the moment is right regarding compensation, we'll act on. That said, we'll determine how to move through that when the timing makes sense; and like we mentioned in our remarks, it will truly be up to the leaders of those individual businesses, since the way each of our businesses handles this uncertainty will differ, and we're going to lean heavily on our local leaders to make the correct decisions in there; they do a fantastic job running their businesses now. They have before. We're fully confident they'll keep doing so going forward to balance what our customers and carrier partners need alongside all of our teammates.
Yaron Kinar
analystAlright. Then when I think back to the global financial crisis, my sense is that the company's organic growth stayed under pressure for a fairly extended stretch during the recovery. A big part of that, I believe, stemmed from simply having more of a focus on smaller businesses. Could you perhaps discuss what's different now compared with 2009 to 2012? Maybe you could give us some idea of the typical account size, typical commissions, or anything else you're able to share regarding how you view the effect both during the present crisis and afterward?
J. Powell Brown
executiveYaron, this is Powell. First, I'd urge you and everyone else not to try drawing comparisons between what's happening now and any later event that has taken place — anything that happened in history, since doing so is nothing but speculation. I want that clear right at the start. Second, when you consider our business, at a very broad level, think about it briefly. We've brought in Arrowhead, Beecher Carlson, Wright. We've brought in Hays; we've brought in all sorts of other truly top-tier organizations covering the whole range of sizes, and much of that has been upper middle market and even some large accounts operations. That said, another key difference, I think, is that if we focus only on retail for a second, how much we depend on the state of Florida as a share of revenue now versus back then. As a whole company, roughly 20% of total revenue comes out of Florida, yet that figure can mislead since, say, close to 6% of that revenue sits in a program largely located outside Florida. So suddenly you've got what Andy might call a more diversified portfolio of companies. Honestly, I'd tell you we aren't economists. And incidentally, we're optimists by nature; we're just salespeople who live by the sea. We know our numbers and we plow them back in for the long haul; so what I'd say is that this isn't a V, but whether it's a U or an L or whatever shape, we can't say. What we do know, given all of that, is that I want everyone to realize we're extremely happy with the first quarter. And that's — our 3 biggest divisions posted excellent quarters, and we're writing plenty of new business. And we'll be there for our customers, so I genuinely believe it's — I'd be very wary of attempting to draw a parallel between then and now, because in my view there are no similarities. That was a short — that was a long downward slide lasting, let's say, 16 to 18 months, followed by a very slow crawl out. It was a steep elevator decline, and for a lot of folks that brought financial panic along with it. So what you saw was a fall in demand for services and consumable goods, while the financial institutions were in a much stronger position. I wish we could tell you more about that, Yaron, since it would benefit us as well, but what I'm saying is that I believe this situation is different. And if the customer accounts for 68% of GDP — and that's going to hit demand — then how is the customer feeling if they've lost their job, are collecting an unemployment check, or have been furloughed for what? We don't know. They aren't feeling good. That much I know.
R. Watts
executiveYaron, one more thing to keep in mind — you likely remember this — there was that entire citizens effect we experienced over that stretch; so that dynamic is in play.
J. Powell Brown
executive2007.
R. Watts
executivePrecisely; therefore that effect is present. That is what pushed it lower; however, when you examine rates in commercial lines, and you likely, once more, went back and reviewed this, yet during that stretch you have '06, '07, '08, '09 and '10, every commercial line also declined. So those represent a few of the dynamics at play. Construction got hit hard. That is the reason we believe this comes across to us as a very, very different kind of event. Perhaps in certain ways, it resembles sort of taking that '08 through '10 stretch and squeezing it into roughly a 3- or 4-week span, or at least that is how it seems at this moment. That is among the unknowns for us.
Yaron Kinar
analystAll right, I'm grateful for that. And this is precisely about attempting to grasp what the distinction is. So that's where I stood. And then perhaps one last item. On pricing, could you perhaps discuss the momentum you observed in April when it comes to pricing?
J. Powell Brown
executiveIt's more or less the same. I mean, as I mentioned, I don't want you getting overly fixated on whether it will rise further or fall. The carriers, clearly, are quite sensitive about the limits they set and particular coverage lines where they believe some potential exposure exists, and I'm not referring to a BI claim. I'm simply referring to other coverage lines that could carry an exposure and the way they underwrite that, D&O, professional liabilities, et cetera.
Ronald Bobman
analystYour health and safety is something we never stop thinking about. That's why we genuinely hope neither one of you appeared in those photos from the beach that we all saw 2 weeks back.
J. Powell Brown
executiveWe did not.
Ronald Bobman
analystFantastic. Fantastic. I wanted to ask you something regarding your wholesale operation, which clearly just posted a truly impressive quarter. And I'm wondering — I realize it's extremely, extremely early — but I'd love to know what you're observing when it comes to the pace of things, the conventional wholesale side recently, carriers putting out quotes, steering additional volume toward that channel, or is that not showing up yet, or is nothing different?
J. Powell Brown
executiveAlright, let's revisit Q1 once more, and the response is that I believe it looks much like the earlier quarters. That said, I'd say there's still plenty going on. So activity levels are unchanged, I'd say, from Q4 into Q1, yet wholesale simply has a great deal happening. And keep in mind, based on which agent we happen to be working with, a number of those agents haven't managed to shift into a work from home setup as smoothly as, say, we did, or perhaps somebody else.
Ronald Bobman
analystSo what you're saying is that even with that in mind, it remains pretty active. Is that what you're stressing?
J. Powell Brown
executiveYeah. Yeah, exactly; you've got it; that's the way I'd like you to view it.
Meyer Shields
analystAndy, could you assist us in putting the $10.5 million ASC 606 adjustment into context — perhaps what proportion of yearly revenues serves as the denominator, or what level of payroll or employment reduction is envisioned within that in-and-out?
R. Watts
executiveSure, Meyer. A few approaches to consider: once more, we examined policies that were still active. It's not being applied to every policy across the whole year. The reason it carries greater weight early in the year is that any policies we wrote last year would have as many as 11 months where that prior exposure was already sitting beneath them. As we said in our remarks, we tried to draw heavily on what economists are projecting — whether through our banking partners or other sources we can access — and use that to at least estimate how unemployment might look. The variable here is that furloughing's effect remains unclear, so that's an unknown. The available data dates back roughly 3 weeks, so that's one factor. We also can't be sure what COBRA's impact will be on the employee benefits business, which is another unknown. Then there's the matter of how many of those prior individuals can now seek unemployment claims — meaning independent contractors or gig workers. That will drive up the reported figure, yet it will likely have virtually no effect on our employee benefits or work comp operations. Those are the dynamics we were weighing as we worked to produce an estimate.
Meyer Shields
analystAll right, I see. That clears things up quite a bit. When it comes to ASC 606, if your estimate turns out to be right, does that mean the past effect of premium audits won't appear in the segment?
R. Watts
executiveLet me think about this — when we're talking about work comp and employee benefits, yes, your statement would hold. Assuming every single thing played out flawlessly, which, by the way, isn't how it's going to play out. Still, yes, that would be true. What remains uncertain to us at this point concerns other policies that we write. Should it begin to look like there's a chance of meaningful return premiums in out periods, then yes, we will definitely have to examine those; but once more, at this stage we have no data offering any signal that such a thing exists. So that's another one we have to keep an eye on. I wish we could give you something more precise. There are just so many unknowns right now in this environment at this stage.
Meyer Shields
analystNo. Got it. And I really do appreciate all of the assistance. If I could, just one final question. There's a great deal of chatter out there, especially among smaller businesses, regarding carriers that are taken aback to learn that their business interruption claims are not covered. Could you possibly walk us through what Brown & Brown does in terms of policies, procedures, and perhaps no coverage when it comes to claims from folks who experienced that letdown?
J. Powell Brown
executiveWell, keep in mind, like I mentioned earlier, broadly speaking, business interruption typically includes a pandemic exclusion, and it generally requires a loss involving physical damage; so we're having conversations with our clients, of course, about how their policies are worded. And where some clarification is needed, we might obviously be in discussions with our carrier partners about that; and there have actually been claims submitted in certain cases. So it really hinges on the individual customer and the specific policy.
Elyse Greenspan
analystI've got just one more thing to ask. A single brief extra question. Has there been any comment from you folks regarding what portion of your costs transportation and entertainment represent, since my guess is that with travel ban restrictions in place, there might be a gain from reduced total spending in the second quarter and possibly the third?
J. Powell Brown
executiveThe response is — Elyse, you were cutting out on us there. So in case I don't address your question precisely, you might need to put it another way. What I took from it, though, was the possible upside from a decrease in T&E costs within the company, and yes, that's right. In our view, a modest gain could come in Q2 and Q3 when it comes to travel. Clearly, we're urging our teammates to speak with our clients, and the ideal option would be video conference, exactly like all those other millions of folks out there attempting the same thing, or else by telephone. After that, once states reopen and we feel it would be safe for teammates to head out and meet our customers, we would — they'll be making those trips. From our perspective, I do think the reopening will be a careful one; by that I mean I figure there's going to be plenty of driving in cars rather than getting on planes immediately. Still, yes, we do think a modest favorable effect could occur in Q2 and Q3.
Elyse Greenspan
analystDid you mention what portion of your expenses T&E represents?
J. Powell Brown
executiveElyse, no — historically we have not made that figure public.
Mark Hughes
analystPowell, you said we're selling quite a bit of new business. Could you talk about how April looked for new business, thinking about April versus what it might have been in January or February, just in terms of run rate?
J. Powell Brown
executiveYeah, so let me — keep in mind, this is entirely speculative and anecdotal, since I don't — we aren't providing forward-looking information. And what I'd say is, remember, we operate 60, 80, 120, 150 days ahead. So keep in mind, we had inventory in the pipeline for April, May, June, work we're engaged in; so what I'd say, and I think this distinction matters, I think when you begin to see the possible effect on new business and the drop in exposure units for our current customer base, that's May. So I'd like you to consider that point briefly. If someone has made it through April, and we're working with them, and they tell us, we figure, say their annual revenues are $12 million a year, $1 million a month, and, say, for 3 months the revenues were close to 0 or 10% of the usual and they revise that downward, then that would carry through in May and June and on into July and all of it. And that's the reason we think Q3 will see a potentially larger downdraft, because you'll get 3 full months of exposure changes instead of potentially 2 months.
R. Watts
executiveMark, one more point on that: another factor is that right now carriers are likely more open to adjustments of midterm exposure units than they might typically be — normally they'd say, we'll handle it at audit. So that's an additional factor that will likely unfold over this stretch. It varies by carrier. It varies by how they — but our preference is to make those adjustments so the exposure units are best reflected as they stand now, and to do so alongside the customer.
Mark Hughes
analystOn that note, how reliable do you figure your — not how reliable is the data you have, but how current is it? What kind of delay exists within this process? It stands to reason that many business owners are busy with other things and might not have yet gotten around to making changes or considering how insurance factors in — do you believe there's simply some inherent lag? Or how current is the...
J. Powell Brown
executiveLike I mentioned, that will vary by customer, but I want you to be certain that essentially all business owners gave insurance some thought; that's the first thing. And the second thing, cash flow has also been on their minds. So what I refer to as the going concern theory — which is, when you think about it, if the carrier decides to simply continue making the standard payments and we'll settle up with you at the audit — I would urge — I would say that isn't so great, because in certain cases the client is wondering whether they'll still be operating when the audit arrives. So I must control my cash flow today, next week, next month, and next quarter to make it there. So in my view there's a minor lag, Mark, though not a big one. Therefore, insofar as our carrier partners permit us to make those changes midterm, we're promoting that and collaborating with our customers on it to assist them in getting through this stretch of time.
R. Watts
executiveLisa, since we've hit roughly 1 hour and 20 minutes, I believe we'll just move forward. Should anyone have an additional follow-up call, they're welcome to give us a ring. We'll go ahead and close out today's call. Powell has a few closing remarks.
J. Powell Brown
executiveThanks, Andy. Before we wrap up, I'd like to leave everyone with a few important points. It was a genuinely strong quarter for us. Some folks might overlook that given what's happened lately, but I want to be clear that we certainly aren't overlooking it. We're extremely proud of our team and the way they've come through for customers repeatedly in what I'd describe as tough conditions — that's point one. Point two, and this isn't something we treat casually, our balance sheet is solid, and that's a point of pride. No other company among our publicly traded peers converts cash at a higher rate, and we can tap more than $1 billion in liquidity. So our mindset is long term; could things get somewhat uneven over the coming quarter or 2 and further out? Absolutely, yes. But here's what I can tell you — our hands are on the wheel, we're steering our way through this, and we're striving to provide business solutions for our customers so they can get back to running their operations. With that, I wish all of you good health, and we can't wait to speak with you again next quarter. Take care, and best of luck.
Operator
operatorThis concludes today's call. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Brown & Brown, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Brown & Brown, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Brown & Brown, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.