Brown & Brown, Inc. (BRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 24, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
J. Powell Brown
executiveThanks, Norma. Morning, everyone, and I appreciate you being with us for the call covering our fourth quarter of 2022. Before diving into specifics, I'd like to offer some thoughts about how we performed during 2022. With the fourth quarter, we wrapped up yet another outstanding year — one in which we produced robust organic growth while largely holding our margins steady, despite higher variable operating costs and the financial effects of Hurricane Ian. 2022 also marked a milestone when it came to activity — specifically acquisition activity — since we expanded our international capabilities considerably by bringing in GRP and BdB in the U.K. Results as consistently strong as ours come about only because of the effort and commitment of our roughly 15,000 teammates. Let's now shift to the quarter's results. I'm looking at Slide #4. Revenue came in at $900 million, up 22% overall and 7.8% organically. For the quarter, our adjusted EBITDAC margin rose by almost 300 basis points, reaching 31.4%. Adjusted net income per share landed at $0.50, an increase of 28%; during the quarter we also closed 9 acquisitions carrying annual revenues of roughly $17 million. On the whole, we're happy with how the quarter turned out. I'm now on Slide 5. This year brought another milestone, as we generated more than $3.5 billion in revenue, with total growth of 17% and organic growth of 8%. For the year, our adjusted EBITDAC margin stayed strong at 32.8%. On an adjusted basis, net income per share rose almost 7%, to $2.28. Finally, M&A activity hit a record, with 30 acquisitions completed representing approximately $435 million in annual revenue. Whether large or small, the businesses we acquire are doing well. Thanks to our disciplined approach of buying top quality companies that are a cultural fit and financially sensible, we've demonstrated a proven ability to successfully acquire, integrate and grow businesses of every size that become part of the Brown & Brown team. Andy will go deeper into our financial results later in the presentation. I'm on Slide 6. Let's begin with the economy; we keep seeing many businesses expand and continue hiring, though at a slower rate than in earlier quarters. Companies are generally looking to fill fewer open positions than before. Although interest rates have risen substantially over the last year, we have yet to observe a broad-based effect on our customers from the economy. Looking at insurance, some markets have experienced and continue to experience major turmoil. Pricing for CAT property — commercial as well as residential — faced pressure throughout the third quarter, and then Ian struck Florida. That led 1/1 reinsurance treaties to be bound with higher attachment points and significantly higher rates. Consequently, we observed additional price increases and reduced limits offered for placements during late Q4 of last year and early this year. Placing CAT property in Q4 of last year and in January of this year proved to be among the hardest placements we've dealt with in decades, with rates climbing 20% to 40% or more. But for properties with poorer build quality or those that have sustained damage, the numbers can be significantly greater — and by that I mean far beyond this band. Consequently, some clients couldn't obtain or pay for their full coverage, so they wound up raising deductibles or buying reduced loss limits to keep their insurance expenses under control; in some situations that wasn't an option, since banks or condo boards refused to permit smaller limits or much larger deductibles. Rate hikes in the admitted market looked much like earlier quarters, rising 3% to 7% across the majority of lines, with workers' compensation standing out as the exception, still declining 1% to 3%. Professional liability and excess liability placements stayed competitive, with pricing ranging from down 5% to up 5%, while public company D&O pricing fell 5% to 20% or more. Turning to cyber, the pattern mirrors recent quarters, with pricing and deductibles still climbing, though we observed a bit of easing over the period. Near the close of Q4, Florida enacted insurance legal and regulatory reforms, among them ending one-way attorney fees and assignment of benefit, creating a reinsurance backstop for select carriers, and mandating arbitration ahead of litigation. Buyers of insurance ought to benefit from these shifts, though that will take time. On the M&A side, we're happy about the 9 deals we closed. We keep bringing in firms that are a cultural fit and financially sound, and we're buying a number of businesses, with GRP's integration proceeding quite well and financial results matching what we anticipated. Industry-wide, deal volume decelerated sharply from earlier quarters. As was true last quarter, when a business qualifies as a platform or a must have, pricing in the market remains aggressive. I'm now on Slide 5. Let's move — pardon me, Slide 7, let's move to — and talk about how the 4 segments performed; during the quarter, our Retail segment posted 2.7% organic growth, with solid gains seen across most lines of business. Slower specialty lines activity, caused by weaker auto and RV sales, plus reduced growth in a couple of our employee benefits operations facing an exceptionally difficult comparison against the prior year's fourth quarter, held back our organic growth. Our Retail segment turned in yet another robust year, with organic revenue growth of 6.5%. We feel great about our business's positioning and our ability to serve customers of every size, and we believe 2023 ought to be another solid year. Our National Programs segment once again produced outstanding results, with 22% organic growth for the quarter. Solid new business and retention throughout most of our programs, along with exposure unit expansion and rate increases, fueled this outcome. The National Programs team is doing really well — they provide a wide array of offerings and come through with top-tier solutions for the people we serve, which fueled close to 16% organic growth across the entire year. Our Wholesale Brokerage segment posted yet another solid quarter, with 8% organic growth, powered by higher rates and fresh business, and that happened even though personal lines has proven difficult through much of the year. For 2022, organic growth in our Wholesale Brokerage segment reached 7.6%, and the team is positioned nicely to keep that momentum going in '23. Turning to the quarter, our Services segment saw a slight rise in organic revenue, thanks to landing new clients and more storm claims, though that gain was largely canceled out by fewer claims in some businesses. Taking everything together, we're pleased with what we can do and the value we bring to our customers. At this point, I'll hand things over to Andy, who will walk you through our financial performance in greater detail.
R. Watts
executiveThanks, Powell. Good morning, everybody. We're on Slide #8 now. Just like we've done in previous quarters, we'll review GAAP results first, then move on to chosen non-GAAP financial highlights. Total revenue growth for Q4 was 22.1%. Organic revenue growth came to 7.8%, while our EBITDAC margin increased 220 basis points. Net income rose 43%, and diluted net income per share was up 42%, reaching $0.51. A change in estimated acquisition earn-out payables impacted both numbers — a $5.8 million credit in 2022 against a $19.8 million charge the year before. The effective tax rate dropped to 25.2% this fourth quarter, down from 27.8% during the same period a year ago, largely due to lower statutory rates for our international businesses and the effect of deductibility for acquisition earn-out payable adjustments. Our weighted average share count stayed basically flat versus the prior year, and our dividends per share for the quarter increased to $0.115, or 11.7% compared to the fourth quarter of 2021. Now we're on Slide #9. This slide presents our results on an adjusted basis, which removes the impact of foreign currency movements on revenues and expenses, the net gain or loss on disposals, the onetime acquisition and integration costs tied to GRP, Orchid and BdB, and the change in earn-out payables. Slides 18 through 26 contain reconciliations to the most comparable GAAP measures. On an adjusted basis, our EBITDAC margin expanded 290 basis points against the prior year. EBITDAC rose 34.9%, and income before income taxes was up 22.6%. This margin expansion stemmed from another solid quarter of revenue growth, increased contingent incentive commissions and leverage of our expense base, even with higher year-over-year variable operating cost. The incremental growth rate of adjusted EBITDAC relative to adjusted income before income taxes was driven by higher year-over-year interest cost of $29 million and higher amortization of $7 million, both largely attributable to the GRP, Orchid and BdB acquisitions. Our adjusted net income for the quarter rose 26.9%, and adjusted diluted net income per share was $0.50, up 28.2%. We're at Slide #10. Our Retail segment posted adjusted total revenue growth of 19.8%, driven primarily by acquisition activity and organic revenue growth of 2.7% for the quarter. Adjusted EBITDAC grew 25.1%, with our adjusted EBITDAC margin up 120 basis points for the quarter, primarily driven by lower year-over-year performance incentives but partially offset by higher variable operating cost. We're at Slide #11. Our National Programs segment posted adjusted total revenue growth of 34.1%, driven by organic revenue growth of 21.9%, acquisition activity and higher contingent commissions. Organic growth got a positive boost of roughly $7 million from the finalization of a growth bonus for one of our programs, which we don't expect to recur in 2023. When it comes to the revenue we get from processing flood claims tied to Hurricane Ian, our expectation remains unchanged: somewhere between $12 million and $15 million. During Q4, we booked roughly $8 million of that. We saw contingent commissions rise, driven by premium growth and profitable underwriting throughout our CAT programs, along with loss development from Hurricane Ian that came in better than we had initially expected. Compared with the same period last year, adjusted EBITDAC increased 53%, and our adjusted margin climbed 540 basis points to reach 44.1%, mainly because of overall revenue growth, leverage on our expense base, higher contingent commissions, and that growth bonus I referenced earlier. Let's move to Slide #12. Within our Wholesale Brokerage segment, adjusted total revenue grew 17.1%, driven by recent acquisitions, strong organic revenue growth of 8.1%, and additional contingent commissions. Adjusted EBITDAC increased 19.9%, while the related margin improved 70 basis points, largely reflecting larger contingent commissions and healthy organic growth, although higher variable operating expenses partially offset that. Now to Slide #13. In our Services segment, adjusted total revenues and organic revenue growth were broadly in line with the prior-year period; during the quarter, adjusted EBITDAC increased by $1.6 million, or 23.9%, as we continued to manage expenses tightly; moving on to Slide #14. This slide presents our GAAP results for both years. In 2022, revenues exceeded $3.5 billion, an increase of 17.1%, while earnings per share hit $2.37, up 14.5%. EBITDAC grew 14% to approximately $1.2 billion; throughout the year, our share count remained essentially unchanged, and dividends paid during 2022 rose 11.3%. Also, our dividends per share for the quarter increased to $11.5, or 11.7%, compared with the fourth quarter of 2021. On Slide #15 now; here you can see our results for both years on an adjusted basis. Income before income taxes rose 6.6%, and net income per share was $2.28, up 6.5%, versus total revenue growth of 17.3%. That difference came from higher interest and amortization associated with GRP, Orchid and BdB. Our adjusted EBITDAC margin remained solid at 32.8%, declining modestly by 40 basis points from the prior year due to higher variable cost. Overall, we're very pleased with how 2022 turned out; now on Slide #16. As part of evaluating the year's performance and given that our captives are relatively new, we wanted to provide a little more detail. We participate in 2 CAT property captives, seeking to enhance capacity, support further organic growth, share in strong underwriting results much as we do through contingent commissions, and produce solid returns on our invested capital. 1 captive writes on a quota share basis for certain wind and quake programs, while the second occupies an excess of loss, or reinsurance, layer for our personal lines wind program. On the whole, we're extremely pleased with both top and bottom line performance, recognizing that individual quarters can swing when CAT events occur. You have to remember that you can't judge how we're doing based on a single quarter — looking at a whole year gives you a much better picture. During 2022, we booked roughly $25 million in additional revenue, and the Orchid acquisition accounted for around $5 million of that; when it comes to 2023, our expectation is revenue somewhere between $30 million and $35 million. When it comes to risk, those two captives expose us to as much as $13 million on any one occurrence, and $25 million in the aggregate. We've always stuck to a disciplined approach, balancing possible upside and potential losses against the capital we've committed, and we believe these programs are built well to accomplish what we've set out to do. A few quick notes on liquidity and the way cash turns over; cash flow from operations for 2022 totaled $881 million. Measured against total revenues, cash flow from operations equaled 24.7%, compared with 26.5% the prior year; that drop stemmed from earn-out payments on some acquisitions that beat our original expectations, plus greater interest expense and larger incentive bonuses handed to our teammates for their outstanding 2021 performance. All in all, we're producing healthy cash and remain in a strong capital position, finishing the year with $650 million of available cash. Beyond that, we repaid the final $150 million left on the revolver, which had been drawn to fund the purchases of GRP, BdB and Orchid. Going forward, we expect to keep bringing leverage down over the coming quarters, exactly as we've done previously after larger capital deployments. We ended the year with solid liquidity. With this capital, the cash we'll generate in 2023, and the capacity on our revolver, we're well positioned to continue funding investments in our business. Now a few thoughts on what 2023 will bring. First, contingent commissions ought to remain roughly flat versus last year, though loss experience will be the ultimate determinant. As for taxes, our effective tax rate should come in between 24% and 25%, a slight increase over 2022, driven by a higher estimated U.K. tax rate, a reduced year-over-year tax benefit from stock grants vesting, and limits on deductions for certain compensation benefits. Interest expense should be somewhere in the range of $185 million to $195 million. Interest income is improving quite well, and we estimate roughly $14 million to $17 million, contingent on the Fed's rate decisions. Amortization expense should be about $162 million to $166 million. That number excludes amortization from any deals we may complete in 2023. As for margins, we don't foresee any major headwinds or tailwinds entering 2023 that would shift them in a meaningful way. And our dividends per share for the quarter rose to $11.5, or 11.7%, against the fourth quarter of 2021. With that, I'll turn it back to Powell for closing remarks.
J. Powell Brown
executiveAppreciate that, Andy — strong update. Wrapping up 2022 and turning our attention to 2023, a few things stand out. To start, Brown & Brown enjoyed yet another highly rewarding year. Revenue came in above $3.5 billion, up 17%, and we completed more acquisitions than in any prior year, all while broadening both our reach and our service offerings across the U.K. In the market, we put money into technology to make things better for our customers and teammates, achieved more than 8% organic growth, and once again produced solid margins despite increased variable costs and the effects of Hurricane Ian, while also bringing in over $880 million of cash flow from operations. From a capital perspective, we're in a robust position too, and we'll keep investing in what we're capable of doing so we can serve our customers' needs as well as possible. As for how the economy looks in 2023, although there is considerable uncertainty around inflation and labor shortages, we anticipate additional economic moderation once higher interest rates start to have an impact. When it comes to insurance, we think rate hikes from admitted markets will look a lot like they did a year ago. For CAT property, we're looking at increases of 10% to 40% or more during at least the first six months, and capacity could get tight — actually, scratch "could," it will get tight, since the market still has to absorb the full effect of Hurricane Ian along with other insured losses. On top of that, rates for professional liability ought to keep easing downward. As for the deals we closed recently, they're doing well, and we anticipate solid, profitable growth over the next year. Regarding mergers and acquisitions, our pipeline looks solid, and we'll keep applying the same disciplined method to identify excellent businesses that are a strong cultural match and financially sound. To wrap up, we're very pleased with our business, how varied our capabilities are, and how well we can support customers with risk management solutions tailored to what they need most. Our nearly 15,000-person team carries solid momentum, and we anticipate yet another robust year ahead. With that said, I'll hand things back to Norma so we can begin the Q&A portion.
Greg Peters
analystI know you don't like to provide organic revenue growth projections, but two things catch my attention. First, you brought up catastrophe pricing in your commentary. Second, when it comes to your retail segment, you mentioned some employee benefit headwinds or a tough comparison. So looking at '23, Powell and Andy, how will those factors — such as the June 1 renewals on property CAT and what's happening with employee benefits — how will that shape your organic results for this year, this coming year?
J. Powell Brown
executiveAll right. Let's take the second part first. Let's discuss employee benefits. Across the board, our employee benefits segment turned in a strong performance this year, and those operations leave us feeling very pleased. As we noted in the prepared remarks, only one or two of those businesses actually ran into trouble. That said, my expectation is that EV will continue to deliver solid results within the system; we don't offer organic guidance on that piece, and we don't disclose results by line of business. Still, when it comes to employee benefits, we feel really good. Regarding CAT property pricing, Greg, the key factor isn't really our side — well, actually it is — in certain cases there are constraints on our capacity to offer limits, but from where I sit, the bigger driver is affordability. So think about it this way: imagine you've been hit with rate hikes on your own personal lines, your homeowners coverage, say a 10% bump annually, four or five years running. Then all at once, in year five, we hand you a 25% increase. Buyers are simply worn out by that. With that being said, the amount of capacity out there right now is beyond anything I've witnessed. I've spent 33 years in insurance, so there's plenty of road ahead of me, yet nothing compares to what we're seeing. We'll continue delivering solutions to our customers. However, take the illustration I believe we shared previously, and I'd bring it up again: suppose an entity currently pays $800,000 for its property coverage, and at renewal the price becomes $1.8 million. If they ask what $1 million could get them, the answer is that there's simply no additional insurance available to purchase. It's beyond what they can afford. Greg, that pattern is showing up more and more. So with CAT — CAT pricing specifically — that piece is becoming a bigger question mark. The other development we're noticing involves CAT capacity and how you get to it. In certain cases, there's now downward commission pressure on some of those placements. A lot of people just take it for granted that if rates go up by x, then your commission — assuming you're paid commission instead of a fee — goes up by x as well, and sometimes that's exactly what happens. But in this situation, they might cut your commission by 1 or 2 points. We're seeing that as well. So that one's harder to tackle, Greg.
Greg Peters
analystAll right, those make sense to me. It's certainly a shifting target, particularly down in the Southeast. For my follow-up, let me shift gears, Andy — during your remarks, you offered some guidance. Then regarding adjusted EBITDAC margins, you indicated there would be neither tailwinds nor headwinds for '23. So could you give a bit of context on whether, as far as setting expectations for the Street goes, this means we should simply anticipate margins holding flat compared with last year? Or perhaps share some detail that helps us interpret what your remarks are really getting at.
R. Watts
executiveOf course. What I believe we're attempting to convey there, Greg, is that we aren't seeing any significant headwinds or tailwinds as we head into the year. Like nearly everyone else, we have unknowns regarding how inflation and T&E will play out, but we'll navigate our way through those items. I'm not aware of any sizable incremental investments being made in the business that would need to be flagged publicly. Investments in our business happen all the time, but that occurs annually across everything we do. We do expect T&E to rise compared with a year earlier, just not to the degree that we're currently seeing with '22 against '21. So — and that's really the reason we issued guidance entering 2022, since that was such a large variable. As things stand now, though, nothing specific stands out that would affect margins in '23 relative to '22.
Greg Peters
analystJust one more thing to add there. As you consider organic for '23, is there any kind of guideline — I realize a few of your competitors give a guideline that if organic reaches a particular level, margins can grow, and if organic doesn't, I mean, do you have any metric in mind regarding organic and how it affects margins?
R. Watts
executiveNo.
Rob Cox
analystRegarding retail specifically — you mentioned a few headwinds. My question is really about group benefits: did that difficult comparison come from a true-up in exposure expectations during the same quarter a year earlier, or was it driven more by slower growth in the current quarter?
R. Watts
executiveNo, Rob, I'd frame it this way: a handful of our businesses simply delivered exceptionally strong results in Q4 of last year. One was a newer operation that was just getting off the ground, so it was expanding. That's the reason the year-over-year comparison for Q4 is tough. Still, as Powell noted when he spoke, we're quite confident about where our businesses stand and how they'll perform in 2022. We aren't reading anything further into Q4. There's no justification for that.
Rob Cox
analystUnderstood, that helps. Perhaps we can shift to a few of the legislative modifications in Florida. Do you have any thoughts on what effect those could have on Brown & Brown in the short term and, maybe, over a longer horizon?
J. Powell Brown
executiveRob, to begin with, from everything we observe, we view them as favorable for the operating environment for risk bearers and for insureds in Florida. I want to note that we expect the trial bar will contest them; therefore I doubt they will be implemented without difficulty; so I can't say what that implies regarding timing and adoption in relation to the marketplace. What our governor and the state of Florida are fundamentally attempting to achieve is a marketplace that is, one, viable; two, competitive; three, sustainable. And the state of Florida doesn't truly wish to be, as it were, in the insurance business. Yet given this disruption, they will need to be larger in the insurance business over the coming several years. So I believe — we believe that the — this is a transition spanning multiple years to return the Florida marketplace, particularly personal lines in Florida, to that sort of environment. So it will likely require 3 to 5 years for somewhat more involvement by the state of Florida, meaning what they are proposing here. And it might require additional steps down the road, but the governor's intention is not to grow their involvement, that is, as a state risk bearer; so it's difficult to say since there are challenges ahead, there are other factors. But what we truly want and need in Florida is, comparatively affordable homeowners prices for homes of every size, with a coverage A home of $200,000 versus one exceeding $1 million and all points between. And so that's — there is considerable disruption across those — every one of those sizes.
Rob Cox
analystUnderstood. And then perhaps as a final point, might you put a figure on the yearly growth bonus within National Programs and perhaps, more precisely, for programs, where do you expect contingents to land in 2023?
R. Watts
executiveWell, Rob, I believe there are two components in that. One item we discussed regarding the growth bonus came to roughly $7 million; and at this moment, we do not anticipate that repeating in 2023. And once more, that sits within the organic computation, not within contingent commissions. And beyond that, we provided no guidance on contingents broken out by the separate segments. What we said was only at the total company level that, at least at present, we expect it to be comparatively flat in 2023, though naturally everything hinges on loss experience across the year along with total growth and profitability.
Weston Bloomer
analystTo start, I'd like to piggyback on what was said regarding employee benefits. Could you refresh our memory about how that segment's seasonality works? Also, should we anticipate any significant challenges during the first quarter?
R. Watts
executiveSure, there is indeed a seasonal pattern in the EB segment, and typically it's somewhat — when you examine each quarter, as a rule, Q1 tends to carry a bit more weight, which stems from how revenue gets recognized in that line of business; after that, you see the usual pattern. Q4 is usually among the softer periods, and that's simply the natural rhythm of how that segment operates. Regarding the — certain headwinds we mentioned during the fourth quarter, a portion of those could spill into Q1, though over the entire year I don't anticipate any problems, consistent with what we said about our approach to this business for 2022.
Weston Bloomer
analystUnderstood. Then a somewhat comparable inquiry regarding the professional lines. You mentioned a deceleration in D&O pricing — does seasonality play any role there? And what's the right way to frame how reduced rates affect that business, in both retail and wholesale?
J. Powell Brown
executiveThe simplest way for me to frame it is this: consider a setting where rate pressure has been climbing for multiple years, and in certain instances far more sharply within the public markets. Those rates are now falling significantly, since competition there is intense. Weston, one could theorize that those cutting back their catastrophic property exposure would seek to place business somewhere else — and where would that be? Possibly casualty, or perhaps professional lines. So it matters to view that as a headwind — modest, yet still a headwind — for that portion of our operations, since my expectation is that it will decline, and in certain cases, decline quite a bit.
Weston Bloomer
analystExcellent. Then for the final question, regarding the margin: I realize you pointed out there are no significant headwinds or tailwinds, and perhaps we shouldn't get too detailed, but that March '22 M&A — it arrived with a higher overall margin. Does that operation continue to perform at a higher overall level compared to the core Brown & Brown?
R. Watts
executiveWhen you mention March, are you referring to...
Weston Bloomer
analystYeah, regarding the margin outlook you provided...
R. Watts
executiveOh, for those 3 — right, all 3 deals taken together?
Weston Bloomer
analystYes.
R. Watts
executiveYes, every one of the businesses is doing just as we anticipated; we mentioned a bit about certain seasonal patterns on the earnings call for the prior quarter. But no, each of them is pretty much exactly where we figured they would be.
Elyse Greenspan
analystFirst thing I want to ask about is those contingent commissions, Andy. I'm aware that you had lender-placed contingents where you weren't certain they'd show up again the following year. Is it baked in that they return? What's your assumption regarding the lender-placed program?
R. Watts
executiveYeah, so one thing we observed in the third — actually in Q4, we recognized roughly $3 million to $4 million that we'd figured we wouldn't be able to recognize during Q4. If you recall, on that call we mentioned that we'd pulled out $15 million year-to-date as of the Q3 call, and stated we likely wouldn't be recording anything in Q4 as a result. Development didn't reach the level we'd expected at that point, and that's a good thing. So we recognized that 3 to 4. Then when we think about 2023, we'd expect to earn a portion in '23, though not returning to typical levels, since some carryover remains in the calculation. But that's been factored in when we provided guidance at the total company level, essentially flat.
Elyse Greenspan
analystAll right. Turning to interest income — I realize you previously indicated that fiduciary income might not amount to much, yet it seems you're noticing something of an uptick there, correct? You mentioned a range of $14 million to $17 million. Would that not boost your margins in '23?
R. Watts
executiveYeah. Taken on its own, that would be accurate. It would boost margins.
Elyse Greenspan
analystSo in theory, perhaps the income from interest helps us, and something different is canceling that out? Since it seems like what you're describing is an absence of negatives, positives. Perhaps margins end up level on the whole. Yet it does seem as though that figure on its own would provide a boost for the year ahead.
R. Watts
executiveYes. Once more, I believe taken alone, I'd say that's likely reasonable at minimum. However, there's — inside what we do, as with a lot of companies, but at least we'll discuss ours in particular, there are constantly numerous pieces in motion and you've constantly got items shifting to and fro; and that was truly the reason we're attempting to provide guidance through any significant positives or negatives that exist.
Elyse Greenspan
analystAnd finally, one more item. You mentioned that employee benefits are weighted heavily toward the early months of the year. But it really does seem like what occurred in Q4 might have simply been a very difficult comparison against the prior year. So regarding retail, and I realize you prefer not to provide guidance, is there anything notable as we begin the year that would cause the early portion of '23 to face harder comparisons than the later portion?
R. Watts
executiveAt a high level, nothing. I believe, referring back to Weston's question from before, there could perhaps be a slight headwind during Q1 stemming from what we observed in Q4, just a bit; however, we feel very confident about our business and its positioning, along with the capabilities we possess to serve customers of every size within that business. And we believe we will deliver strong results throughout 2023.
Mike Zaremski
analystPerhaps we could return to what's happening with the disruption in certain areas of the real estate sector. At a broad level, I'd just like to know if your thinking has shifted, and whether this situation is, on balance, a plus for growth or margins, roughly neutral, or possibly even a minus. Obviously, many factors are in play. You mentioned some pressure on commissions, yet interest rates are climbing significantly. So I'm simply wondering whether you regard all these variables, taken together, as roughly a wash, or whether your perspective has evolved?
J. Powell Brown
executiveRight. Michael, I'd characterize it as likely a net gain, though only a modest one; the word "slight" is my hedge, and that's due to shifts in the marketplace we can't yet observe, meaning carriers cutting limits, or the chance of some commission pressure, or things along those lines. And beyond that, clients are essentially putting up their hands and crying uncle. I realize that's a hard thing to say, but it's accurate, since we're the ones who bring the bad news when conditions turn like this. So my answer is that it will be marginally favorable, and that's how I'd like you to frame it.
Mike Zaremski
analystAll right, that's useful. Let's maybe pivot to how inflation is hitting Brown's income statement. I believe somebody whose identity wasn't clear said something about inflation and T&E. When I consider Brown's commission structure, my sense is that it's relatively shielded from pressure on wages, given the way frontline sales staff get compensated. Though perhaps that's incorrect, and perhaps you could explain what you meant regarding T&E and inflation.
J. Powell Brown
executiveLet's address what you said about pressure on wages; immune to it we are not. That point matters a great deal, I believe. One thing we observe, same as anyone else in this industry, is that competition for talent is fierce. And employers want people — not only sales staff, but also service staff, marketing staff, or administrative staff handling claims and similar work. So the marketplace is extremely competitive. So please don't assume we're shielded from this, because we are nowhere near that. That's the first point. Second, when we mention T&E pressure, we don't believe there will be a huge increase in travel and entertainment; our view is that — if you keep doing the same amount, there's simply considerable pressure on, say, a plane ticket or a hotel room, depending on your destination. That's where that pressure shows up; and so — our company resembles many other companies you're familiar with, track, or whatever else. This is an inflationary climate. The pressure in this case, even though it's elevated, isn't as elevated as in England and Ireland, where wage pressure appears greater. Still, we're navigating that too; so that's roughly what we meant, Michael.
Mike Zaremski
analystThat's useful. And perhaps I could slip in one fast question. Could the flooding in California have any effect on the flood program you run — something that might be material?
J. Powell Brown
executiveNo. Interestingly, we have not observed anything in California. As you're aware, they receive little rain to start with; therefore, when a great deal of rain does come, they experience serious flooding. And few individuals in the state of California purchase flood insurance. So it's — no, that isn't something we see.
Yaron Kinar
analystSo, for my first question—and I believe this may connect to a few other questions that have already come your way. When you consider the property cat rate landscape, where do you think—which segments do you believe would gain the most? And which ones do you think might be up against more pressure from the different elements you mentioned, such as lower commissions, perhaps tougher placement of business.
J. Powell Brown
executiveYaron, I'd like to be certain I've got that right—could you either say the question again or expand on it a bit. What you're asking is, in your view, what gets harder. And then what gets simpler. Did I catch that correctly?
Yaron Kinar
analystOut of your 4 segments — or really 3, I suppose, meaning Retail, National Programs, and Wholesale — which one do you figure stands to gain the most, and which one might be under the heaviest strain?
J. Powell Brown
executiveAll right, so to start, my view on this is a bit different from framing it as gaining more or not — you didn't say this word, or enduring more, that might be the word I'd use for it. Take Retail for a second. Retail is lucky. Our dealings are straight with the customer. That means a great deal of hard work goes into delivering those specific increases. And as I mentioned, in certain cases you might see commission reductions, but rates will rise, and I'd describe it as slightly favorable when it comes to organic growth in that business. Over in Wholesale, it makes things considerably harder for property brokers as they attempt to complete lines of business. So suppose you had a line worth $100 million handled by 1 or 2 markets; and then that market taking 80% of it starts pulling back or reducing its participation, you now need 6 or 7 markets to reach your $100 million. Even so, strain will persist there too. And I think there's more — the biggest conflict, if that's the word you want, in placements will show up in retail and wholesale; when it comes to National Programs, what matters is CAT capacity availability. So as you're aware, a number of carriers exist that have let their capacity be underwritten by various kinds of MGAs and MGUs, and many of those weren't profitable, not only last year but across many years prior. That gives rise to what we call a flight to quality. And regarding our underwriting facilities, we're quite happy with the results delivered before last year and including last year with the losses and Ian and Nicole; so I'd say with programs, it's a different matter. Availability caps their growth potential. It isn't the conflict of. With the other 2, there's hand-to-hand combat involved in getting people to actually raise limits and follow through; with the underwriting facilities, that authority sits with us and we can do what we can do, yet capacity constrains us. So if, in fact, a market or market decides to reduce the capacity they give us, that will affect our ability to grow. And on the flip side, if they decide to alter their commission level, that too would affect our ability to grow. One thing I do want to bring up, I think it matters for everyone to consider this. Things are never as good as they seem or as bad as they seem. So what I'm getting at is this: the CAT market is really struggling at the moment, but a future point will come when things get better. I'm not trying to predict anything here, since none of us has a crystal ball. I'm not suggesting that 12 months from now we'll have X or Y or Z — that isn't my point. Still, some markets are approaching this in a manner where they're viewing it very opportunistically. Meanwhile, other markets are treating it like a long-term partnership. Naturally, the latter is what we'd prefer over the former, but we are out there seeking capacity, globally. So I simply want everyone to sort of understand that this pressure, too, will pass at some point.
Yaron Kinar
analystThat's useful context. Let me pivot to M&A briefly. I believe you mentioned the pipeline is still strong; however, you're observing a slowdown in M&A activity. Is that simply because the bid-ask spread is too wide? Or are other factors at play?
J. Powell Brown
executiveNo. No. When you note that M&A activity is decelerating, keep in mind, we're discussing the entire industry. As you're aware, private equity has played a huge role, and the count of private equity deals announced in Q4 dropped considerably compared to earlier quarters and/or Q4 of the previous year. I believe there's this intriguing kind of — we're sort of at this strange collision point, if you will, where the market, with higher interest rates, and buyers want to see a modest reduction in the multiples they pay. Yet there are companies, some owned by private equity, that want to cash out at what were historical levels or multiples, anticipating other chances for themselves. Or perhaps put better, maybe they believe multiples will face downward pressure ahead, so they aim to exit at a higher multiple, if they can, than they might expect a year from now. I'm merely offering that as an illustration; so I think we'll witness plenty of activity over the next 12 months. The positive aspect of our business is, we concentrate on the long term, and for us long term isn't 1 year or 3 years. It's an extremely long period; and so — we seek companies that align culturally and are financially sensible. And we're confident such companies will exist. But during this meantime, as Andy mentioned, we're actively reducing our debt. We're putting resources into teammates and prioritizing organic growth for our business.
Mark Hughes
analystPowell, you spoke quite a bit about your pursuit of capacity. Were there any constraints you encountered? Have you noticed this amid a tougher reinsurance marketplace? Any reductions to your programs? And you're considering flood or quake, for example. Is there anything worth noting that might affect organic growth?
J. Powell Brown
executiveYes; thanks for asking; that's kind of a shifting target. However, as of right now, we believe a solid result is flat, meaning no capacity reduction. There might be certain entities or businesses where they'd perhaps be exchanging some capacity or debt — net down slightly on a net basis. But at this moment, we consider it fairly neutral, and from where we sit, we see that as a victory. So nothing comes to mind. And you specifically mentioned flood or quake, but that could also include our wind facilities. But what we discussed last year and have discussed in earlier years, yet it's even more pronounced this year. Our growth chances in national programs will be directly — not solely, but directly tied to how much new capacity we can obtain. And so if, in fact, we cannot procure any new capacity, that will be a minor constraint on organic growth. That doesn't mean we can't grow organically. It simply means we'll grow more organically if we can secure additional capacity, which we're pursuing globally.
Mark Hughes
analystGot it. Then regarding the captives, you brought up some of the financials involved — $30 million to $35 million in revenue — yet there's loss retention of $13 million per event. It seems like you'd require a fairly strong margin on those revenues to feel confident about earning a return across multiple years given that level of retention. Is that the right way to look at it?
J. Powell Brown
executiveOkay, I'll address your question in two parts. First, consider what a captive actually is. A captive really has 3 components. One is the loss — the retention amount you keep on any single loss. That's purely losses. Second is the reinstatement premium, meaning you restore the program for a later event. And third would be any profits during that time within the captive, before they get distributed. So here's what I'd say: we pay very close attention to how we deploy our capital. We're seeking returns that support growing the business. Therefore, if we didn't believe those were sensible long-term investments, we wouldn't pursue them. And should the economics shift against us — say cost inputs or other factors render them unworkable — we simply won't proceed with them.
R. Watts
executiveMark, I just want to ask you something. Could you say more about — when you mentioned it, you brought up delivering sufficient returns. What's your — take us through what you actually mean by that? Since, I suppose, I believe we might not be looking at it the way you do, but if what you're telling us is — we're keeping third...
Mark Hughes
analystI believe you're indicating something. Right. Right, supposing you bring in $30 million of revenue and, let's say, the margin is 50%, that's $15 million, yet suppose your retention for each event comes to $13 million. And perhaps a hurricane strikes Florida 1 out of 3 years, so that shapes how the economics look. That was the — just basic arithmetic I had in mind.
R. Watts
executiveAll right. So the chance probably exists there to shed more light on these matters. The approach we'd like everyone to adopt when considering these is this: what we're doing is taking part in the underwriting profits from these captives. What happens with contingent commissions? We take part in the underwriting profits. So this isn't a situation where they arrive and we're handing out commissions and all the rest on the business. So I think that's simply part of the element that perhaps — you're contemplating, it's traditional, let's call it, operating profit. It arrives as — presuming it's a typical operating profit rather than underwriting profit in there; therefore we're extremely, extremely happy with how things went this year, echoing Powell's remark; we're eager to deploy our capital into these unless we believed we couldn't obtain a suitable return.
J. Powell Brown
executiveAlso, that $13 million figure Mark mentioned is a ceiling — it's not a guarantee that the amount will land at $13 million. That's a key difference to keep in mind. The actual number could come in below that, or even considerably below it.
Mike Ward
analystMaybe just one more. Could you give us any detail on the profit commissions within programs? And was any portion of that tied to potential Hurricane Ian true-ups?
R. Watts
executiveMike, Andy speaking. Regarding that — I wouldn't characterize anything as connected to Hurricane Ian true-ups, correct. At the close of the third quarter, we had reversed out the $15 million, as we discussed previously. And at that time, we had also stated that, given our expectations for losses, we would refrain from recording $3 million to $4 million under one of our programs; that development didn't materialize at the level we anticipated, which, once again, is a favorable outcome. So we proceeded to record that $3 million or $4 million during the fourth quarter. As for all the other contingents booked in the fourth quarter, those were entirely driven by the profitable growth we produced for our carrier partners, and we simply perform year-end calculations, and at times you qualify, at times you don't. That's the reason we typically observe the greatest volatility in our national programs, as they fluctuate.
Mike Ward
analystThat's really useful. Perhaps just one final quick item. Regarding the strain in specialty — I believe you mentioned auto — softer auto and RV sales. Is there anything additional in that area we ought to be considering?
J. Powell Brown
executiveNo, I don't believe so. I mean, keep in mind, if you look a bit further out, maybe hypothesize about what's ahead for that sector, my sense is likely that inventory levels will rise somewhat during the third quarter and later in the year. Also, given the economic climate, there will likely be additional incentives. I'm not certain of that, but incentives introduced to help move units. So if inventory exists, and I use the key point is, I cannot — we cannot completely forecast that. Our view is you'll observe a bit of an increase there, though modest. Let's take one more question, Norma. That would be wonderful.
Derek Han
analystMy question concerns the programs business. Andy, I believe you said before that you expected organic growth in programs to be sort of moderate. Yet even if we set aside that $7 million you identified, organic growth came in really strong. And sequentially, it actually sped up. So could you provide a bit more detail about what caused that outperformance versus what you had expected internally?
R. Watts
executiveYes. One of the other things in there — we discussed this — we said we brought in $25 million of revenue from the captives, and roughly $5 million of that arrived via the Orchid acquisition. The rest of it, then, sits on the organic side. In '23 we'll keep seeing growth, though not at that same level, Derek.
Derek Han
analystUnderstood. Alright, that helps. Then just a single fast question. The integration of GRP and BdB is going well, as I understand it. Could you provide a bit of detail regarding your economic view for Europe and what effect you expect that to have on organic growth at those operations?
J. Powell Brown
executiveCertainly. Keep in mind, GRP covers England and Ireland — the Republic of Ireland as well — and we already have operations within the Republic of Ireland plus Northern Ireland. As for BdB, our activity spans Italy — specifically, we place the most Italian business into Lloyd's of anyone; that accounts for more than 50% of it. After that — our operations extend to France and Belgium. And clearly we also operate in England, writing into the London market. So here's what I'd say: conditions in England aren't that different from what you're seeing over here, with considerable strain on wages and the expense of living, meaning gasoline and similar items; even so — looking at it from the client's perspective, we haven't observed any meaningful pullback in how they spend. So my take is that we believe the economy there appears to be progressing reasonably well. Regarding our footprint, even though it's considerably smaller, across Western Europe we likewise aren't detecting any odd patterns. Keep in mind, Lloyd's is a major marketplace on a global scale. My understanding is roughly 50% of what they underwrite comes from the United States, while the remaining 50% is spread around the world; therefore we keep achieving solid expansion within our Lloyd's brokers, of which we currently have 3. Consequently, we're quite happy with Decus, Lonmar and BdB.
J. Powell Brown
executiveNorma, thanks. I really appreciate everyone being here. We're grateful for the time and effort you've given us. In our view, the past year went quite well. And the future has us enthusiastic. Here's what I'd say in closing, when it comes to trends: a single quarter doesn't make a trend, in our view. And we don't judge how the business is doing based on 1 quarter. Our lens is years, and multiple years. So when it comes to each of our 3 biggest segments, we're feeling positive about heading into the coming year. Certain constraints exist, that is, due to limits in the market and limits in the economy, but we'll find our way past them. So we're eager to speak with you again in 3 months, and enjoy the rest of your day. Thanks.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's conference call. We appreciate everyone for joining. You're free to disconnect at this point. Wishing all of you a great day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Brown & Brown, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Brown & Brown, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Brown & Brown, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.