Brown & Brown, Inc. (BRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 29, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
J. Powell Brown
executiveThanks, Kevin. Morning, everyone, and thanks for joining our Q3 earnings call. First off, our thoughts go out to all those impacted by Hurricanes Helene and Milton. Back-to-back storms of that kind were unprecedented on many levels, causing significant loss of life and devastation throughout the Southeastern U.S. We're committed to helping the communities struck by these events recover and return to normal over the coming weeks, months, and years. With that said, let's turn to our results for the quarter; both our top and bottom lines were outstanding. The team continues to deliver for customers, driving solid net new business, organic growth, and margin improvement. I'll give a few high-level comments on how we did, plus updates on the insurance market and M&A activity. Andy will then walk through the financials in more detail. And last, I'll share some closing remarks before we open it up to Q&A; so let's dive into the results. I'm on Slide 4. Revenue came in at just under $1.2 billion, up 11% overall and 9.5% organically versus Q3 2023. Our adjusted EBITDAC margin increased 30 basis points to 34.9%, and adjusted EPS was up 12.3% to $0.91. On the M&A front, we completed 4 deals with projected annual revenues of $8 million. Overall, another great quarter, with the team staying focused on delivering the best solutions for our customers and strong results. I'm on Slide #5; in our main operating countries, economic conditions were largely unchanged from the first half of this year. Consumers are still spending and fueling demand. As a result, businesses continue to hire and invest, though at a slower pace than in recent years. Here in the U.S., we're seeing a bit more caution due to uncertainty around the presidential election. When it comes to insurance pricing, rates are still climbing across many lines, but a little more slowly than in the first half of this year and in Q3 of last year. The line that shifted the most this quarter was E&S property, which we'll get into more shortly. Employee benefits pricing looked similar to previous quarters, with medical and primary cost trends rising 7% and 9% for commission-based accounts. Ongoing rate pressure and the complexity of health care are driving strong demand for our employee benefits consulting businesses. Thanks to our past and continued investments to grow our capabilities, we're well positioned to help companies of all sizes navigate this tough market. Rates in the admitted P&C markets were up 2% to 7% for most lines. The decline in workers' compensation continued, but it moderated, with decreases of down 1% to 5% in most states; given the high employment level, we expect this range to persist in the quarters ahead. Looking at Q3, rate increases for non-CAT property eased and finished in a range from flat to a 5% increase; for properties located in convective storm zones, the upticks we observed were less robust than those obtained across the initial half of the year. Moving to casualty, primary layers continue to experience rising rates, driven by the ongoing magnitude of legal judgments within the U.S. and, to a lesser extent, by heightened inflation. As has occurred across the prior few quarters, excess casualty pricing continues to increase within a 1% to 10% range, and at times past that. Regarding professional liability, rates were flat to up 5%. Shifting now to the E&S markets. As all of you know, throughout this year some carriers and facilities have demonstrated a readiness to offer additional limits on existing insurers and new business. Despite CAT property rates continuing to edge upward somewhat in Q1 of this year, we started to see reductions later in Q2 and carrying on through Q3. On average, rates dropped in a range of 10% to 20% relative to Q3 of the prior year. As a result, quite a few customers increased their limits or modified deductibles, while others just kept the savings. As we have noted before, small pricing shifts in either direction for one line of business generally won't materially affect our company's overall results. To deliver consistently strong and industry-leading financial performance, we focus on diversification across lines of coverage, geography, industry and customer segment. Regarding M&A, the intensity of competition for high-quality businesses remained consistent with the first half of the year. Though private equity-backed acquisitions declined in number as interest rates rose, we are now starting to see more activity as interest rates begin to fall. During the quarter, we continued building relationships with a great many companies and remained dedicated to our disciplined M&A approach of seeking outstanding organizations that are culturally compatible and financially sound. I'm now on Slide 6. Let's proceed to how our 3 segments performed. Retail generated 3.9% organic growth in the quarter, with most business lines performing well. We had yet another strong quarter for net new business, but we are observing the impact of rates softening across most lines along with somewhat weaker growth in exposure units; additionally, our organic growth was reduced by over 100 bps owing to the year-to-date true-up on certain incentive commissions, plus quarterly fluctuations in bond or nonrecurring revenue. Our team is performing at a very high level and carries solid momentum into Q4. Programs delivered a fantastic result, recording 22.8% organic growth. Multiple programs drove this growth through new business and expansion among existing customers. Our lender-placed business and captives performed extremely well, and our CAT programs continue to grow; because of the diversity across our programs, it was another excellent quarter, with $34.9 million. Turning to wholesale brokerage, we delivered another strong quarter, with organic revenue growth reaching 8.4%. That performance was driven by net new business and rate increases together. Our open brokerage business continued to grow at a healthy pace, albeit more slowly, since CAT property rates have declined. Delegated authority delivered another strong quarter. Personal lines saw solid growth, led by California and Texas, and we're very pleased that the balance we've achieved between brokerage and delegated authority continues to generate results that are both strong and consistent. At this point, I'll turn it over to Andy so he can discuss additional results — our financial results.
R. Watts
executiveThanks, Powell, and good morning to all of you. I'll walk through our financial results with a bit more granularity. Whenever we mention EBITDAC, EBITDAC margin, income before income taxes, or diluted net income per share, those figures are on an adjusted basis. You can locate the reconciliation of our GAAP to non-GAAP financial measures either in the appendix of this presentation or in the press release we put out yesterday. Let's turn to Slide #7; total revenues came in at $1.186 billion, which represents 11% growth versus the third quarter of 2023. Income before income taxes rose by 13.1%, while EBITDAC was up by 11.9%. EBITDAC margin reached 34.9%, a 30 basis point expansion compared with the third quarter of the prior year. Our effective tax rate for the quarter fell to 24.6%, compared with 25.6% in the third quarter of the prior year. That decline came mainly from certain onetime items in the prior year along with the impact of changes in the market value of our company-owned life insurance. Diluted net income per share climbed to $0.91, or 12.3%. Our weighted average shares outstanding rose slightly versus last year, as we keep prioritizing paying down our floating rate debt. Dividends paid per share were up by 13% versus the third quarter of 2023. Last week, our Board of Directors approved a 15% increase to our projected dividend payments for the fourth quarter of 2024. That marks our 31st consecutive annual increase. All in all, we're quite pleased with how we performed this quarter and with the strong results our team delivered. Now let's move to Slide #8. The Retail segment saw total revenues rise by 6.5%, with organic growth of 3.9%. The gap between total revenues and organic revenue came largely from acquisition activity over the past year. EBITDAC declined as a result of lower contingent and incentive commissions, higher noncash stock-based compensation, and investments in teammates to drive and support our current and future growth. We're now on Slide #9. Programs posted another excellent quarter, with total revenues up 15.7% and organic growth of 22.8%. Our organic growth got a benefit of roughly $15 million tied to onboarding of new customers within our lender-placed business. That revenue will be recognized more evenly throughout 2025. Growth in total revenues trailed organic due to net acquisition and disposition activity as well as lower contingent commissions. Our EBITDAC margin expanded by 360 basis points to 48.2%, driven by leveraging of our expense base and the sale of certain claims administration and adjusting services businesses in the fourth quarter of 2023. As for the impact of the hurricanes, there remain a lot of unknowns, primarily associated with Hurricane Milton. We think we'll book about $12 million to $15 million in flood claims processing revenue tied to the recent hurricanes during the fourth quarter, and then $18 million to $22 million across the first half of 2025, with most of that falling in the first quarter. Right now, we expect claims costs of $5 million to $10 million inside our captives related to Hurricane Milton; let's move ahead to Slide #10. Wholesale Brokerage turned in yet another strong quarter, with total revenues up 14% and organic growth at 8.4%. That extra growth in total revenues beyond organic came from acquisitions closed during the last 12 months, along with higher contingent commissions as we finalized the estimates booked in the prior year. Our EBITDAC margin rose 130 basis points to 38.6%, largely on the back of higher contingent commissions and leverage on our expense base. A few points on our capital structure, cash generation and outlook: during the third quarter, we retired $500 million of our inaugural 10-year bonds using proceeds from the issuance we completed in this year's second quarter. Thanks to continued deleveraging, our balance sheet sits in a great spot, since our gross debt-to-EBITDA ratio on a trailing 12-month basis matches our 10-year average; through the first 9 months of this year, cash generation was strong at more than $810 million, lifting our ratio of cash flow from operations as a percentage of revenue to 22.4%. On full year cash generation, we feel really good; we want to point out that U.S. federal tax relief exists tied to the recent hurricanes. Because of that, payments for this year's third and fourth quarters can be deferred until the second quarter of next year. So our full year ratio of cash flow from operations as a percentage of total revenue for 2024 ought to land between 24% and 26%. Given our strong year-to-date performance and factoring in possible effects from Hurricane Helene and Milton, we expect our full year EBITDAC margin for 2024 to be up at least 100 basis points versus 2023. With that, I'll hand things back to Powell for closing comments.
J. Powell Brown
executiveAppreciate that, Andy. That was an excellent report. Looking at things economically, we don't expect any significant shifts compared to what we saw during the opening 9 months of this year. The main uncertainties that business leaders across the states appear to be focused on — ones that could affect how much they invest — are how the U.S. presidential election turns out, geopolitical developments, and when and how much future interest rate cuts and inflation will occur. Appreciate that, Andy. That was an excellent report. Looking at things economically, we don't expect any significant shifts compared to what we saw during the opening 9 months of this year. The main uncertainties that business leaders across the states appear to be focused on — ones that could affect how much they invest — are how the U.S. presidential election turns out, geopolitical developments, and when and how much future interest rate cuts and inflation will occur. Speaking from an admitted lines rate viewpoint, we expect rates during the fourth quarter and early '25 to look fairly close to, or perhaps ease somewhat compared with, the third quarter of this year. Within the E&S market, casualty and professional liability ought to resemble what we saw in the third quarter of 2024. When it comes to cat property, everything hinges on the final paid losses tied to Helene and Milton. We expect rate decreases ranging from flat to down 10% as we move into the fourth quarter. Regarding M&A, our pipeline continues to give us confidence, both here at home and abroad. We're constantly cultivating relationships with plenty of companies, and our capital position is strong; we'll keep applying the same disciplined approach, since it has served us well in acquiring excellent companies that boost our capabilities and fuel profitable growth. Finally, we're thrilled that the Quintes team is joining Brown & Brown, and we expect the deal to close in the fourth quarter. As we move into the fourth quarter, our team remains well positioned and is harnessing the power of we to capture more net new business. Momentum is strong throughout the company, and we're optimistic about our prospects for the fourth quarter and about closing out the year on a high note. With that, we'll hand things back to Kevin and begin the Q&A.
Greg Peters
analystThe instructions apparently limited me to a single question, so I'll direct that one question toward the Retail segment. Powell and Andy walked us through a number of factors that had an impact on organic in Q3. I'd like to know whether you can give us additional detail on that, and whether there's anything we ought to keep in mind as a read-through going forward.
J. Powell Brown
executiveGreg, we're glad to have your one question. The truth is, we won't drill down into the specifics; but here's what I'd say: as we mentioned regarding organic growth, incentives really are a factor — incentive commissions have come down, and we discussed somewhat the nonrecurring onetime revenue that didn't show up, such as bonds and other related items; so from the perspective of how we feel about our Retail business, we feel good about it, and I think that's what matters. My view is that a single quarter doesn't establish a trend; so take from that whatever you'd like, but our Retail business feels really good to us.
R. Watts
executiveAlso, Greg, here's another point I want everyone to remember. We've mentioned before that typically, our Retail business expands at a quicker pace during the first half of the year compared to the second half. The previous year was somewhat unusual, and that was due to when certain bonds and some surety work landed within it. However, looking back across history, growth is usually quicker in the first half, mainly because of how much employee benefits business gets recorded in the first quarter.
Rob Cox
analystThanks for that outlook calling for property CAT rates to be either unchanged or as much as 10% lower. I'm simply wondering whether the wholesale book's product mix is positioned to deliver solid expansion under those conditions. Or should we expect more of that to begin appearing within the organic side?
J. Powell Brown
executiveFine, and allow me to add one further point of clarification regarding my earlier remark. My sense is that risk bearers, especially those here in the U.S., have a strong desire to keep pricing nearer to unchanged. That being said, fresh entrants have arrived. Additional markets exist, London in particular, and it is behaving quite aggressively, which will only add more pressure there. With that noted, what's interesting is that our Q3 isn't an especially property-heavy quarter. Property usually falls in Q1 and Q2, ahead of hurricane season. So once more, it comes down to the mix, though our brokerage and binding authority operations are fairly well balanced. And the discussion here concerns brokerage, not really binding; so my take would be that whenever rates decline, that can happen. Still, from the angle of how much discipline the markets will show, we'll find out in Q4, and what I'm about to say is entirely speculative — keep in mind that before the storms, we were observing declines of 20% and 30%. So we don't expect that, yet nothing can be ruled out. In my view, a far more likely outcome is 0 to 10.
Elyse Greenspan
analystI'd like to circle back to the Retail segment. That incentive compensation, from what I understand, is a supplemental commission, and my recollection is you folks began including it in organic roughly 2 years back. So I just want to verify that; and since the one-time item came to 100 basis points — I realize you typically prefer not to provide guidance, but Powell, you did remark that a single quarter doesn't establish a trend. Should we think about it this way: that growth of approximately 5% is more or less the baseline for Q4 and afterward?
J. Powell Brown
executiveAndy, do you want to handle that?
R. Watts
executiveSure, I’ll start with the first one, since that’s fairly straightforward. Right — regarding GSCs, both guaranteed supplemental commissions and incentive commissions sit within organic growth, and, as you’re aware, they can rise or fall from quarter to quarter, much the way contingent commissions can shift within that same figure. As you know, we don’t provide guidance on organic growth for the business. Still, I think as we look at least toward the fourth quarter, we would at least expect that — first, we feel very good about our business, our net performance, and how we’re generating new business. A great deal will depend on what happens with rates and then exposure units in the economy; so absent anything unusual there, we would anticipate those 2 would be quite comparable to the third quarter.
Yaron Kinar
analystMy question concerns the programs business. I believe a portion of the captives was sold to a third party, and that portion is now returning to consolidation via noncontrolling interests, via NCI. Could you perhaps take us through what this means for the programs segment itself — specifically that NCI within the programs business — namely, what would adjusted margin come out to? And what would organic growth for that segment come out to?
R. Watts
executiveYaron, neither organic growth nor margins are affected at all. Keep in mind that the noncontrolling interest applies only as a pretax basis allocation; thus we book the entire gross up above and subsequently remove the minority interest below.
Yaron Kinar
analystOK, so what I'd like to ask is this — if we had made that NCI adjustment down at the segment level, what effect would the segment have seen?
R. Watts
executiveWhat I'd probably tell you is that it doesn't really matter, since the accounting rules won't permit you to do that in any case. The rules are what we're abiding by. It has to come in on a gross basis.
Mike Zaremski
analystI only have one question, and it concerns the programs segment. For three consecutive years, that segment has delivered remarkable growth. You also mentioned, I think, that catastrophe programs may have been the source of this quarter's exceptionally strong growth. Still, I want to ask: whenever we look at the wholesale marketplace, we tend to think about it over longer time frames, and typically it grows a bit faster than the standard market thanks to particular secular forces underneath. So I'm curious whether anything structural or secular is driving your programs business, or whether you simply see it as something that should, over time, expand at a multiple of the standard markets.
J. Powell Brown
executiveOkay, let's give that some thought. A lot of what we do — actually, I shouldn't say a lot, since many of them are admitted — right? So picture those as an outgrowth of the specialty admitted sector rather than the conventional wholesale or non-admitted sector. I think it's worth flagging that difference right at the start. That's the first point. Second, my sense is that interest in and focus on the programs business will keep building down the road. Based on whatever you happen to be reading and whatever you choose to believe, premium in the U.S. program space falls somewhere in the range of $85 billion to $100 billion. And so we expect to keep watching that expand at a healthy pace in the years ahead. We have plenty of highly skilled underwriters who are interested in coming aboard — some currently working as risk bearers, others arriving from different programs — since this is an energetic setting in which we've built strong ties with the insurance companies we partner with. And keep in mind, we write business on their behalf; as far as we know, no other delegated underwriting authority organization in the United States is bigger than ours. Consequently, those carriers hand us tremendous decision-making power, and we treat that responsibility with the utmost seriousness. So will that expansion keep running at roughly twenty percent? Sustained across a lengthy stretch, that figure is pretty elevated, correct? Let's be honest about that. What I'd say, though, is that in our view, the programs area grows quite steadily and attractively across a long stretch, and the numbers we've posted bear that out. What's curious is — and Mike, I realize this doesn't apply to you — certain folks seem to me to lack a real grasp of, or at least don't credit us for, the portion of our business that isn't Retail, and that portion accounts for 40% of revenue. And, as you're aware, it's doing quite well. So, if you'd like to consider it from a somewhat different angle — and I realize you've likely already considered this — when you combine the results of wholesale and programs, that 40% figure rose 17.7% during Q3. Quite remarkable.
Mike Zaremski
analystI do believe that when folks evaluate programs and wholesale operations, they tend to use Orion as a benchmark. But if I may — I'll keep to my single question, though it's a follow-up on what you said regarding that same subject. Would it be reasonable to assume that underwriters joining Brown, or simply a programs business owned by a broker, might be paid at a higher level than a carrier is able to offer, given how valuations work?
J. Powell Brown
executiveYou're referring to the person's pay? Well, in my view, pay usually looks different since it may include cash, a salary plus a bonus in many cases, and equity as well. So on the whole, I think as a general statement, you could likely answer yes.
Mark Hughes
analystAndy, you said you brought in $15 million in revenue from onboarding new customers and programs, and that it would be distributed more evenly across 2025. Is any portion of that $15 million nonrecurring? And when you say spread more evenly, can you help us understand whether there are any bumps or tough comps to consider for 2025 in the lender-placed business?
R. Watts
executiveThe way it works is that when we take on a new account or a customer purchases a portfolio, there's typically a delay of 90 to 180 days before the prior servicer actually sends out notifications. What happens is you'll usually get 2 to 3 quarters of revenue in roughly the first quarter after we onboard them. Then when renewal or the ex date comes around, that revenue will drop off accordingly. That's essentially what we're saying — next year, in the third quarter, we wouldn't expect to see that $15 million, but it will be spread out during '25, with the majority coming in the first half of the year. Does that help clarify how it works?
Mark Hughes
analystThat answers it. For the remaining part of what I wanted to ask, is there any update regarding the advocacy side? Has the Social Security Administration become somewhat more engaged when it comes to deciding claims?
R. Watts
executiveNot really. Things have stayed largely the same as what we've observed across the past several years. Inflows into our business are solid, yet just a limited amount emerges from the rear of the funnel.
Alex Scott
analystCould you give us additional detail on the M&A pipeline — especially those remarks about rates starting to decline and growing interest from private equity firms? Also, what might the size of those opportunities be, and where are you aiming to expand through acquisitions?
J. Powell Brown
executiveAbsolutely. Regarding the first portion of your question: before rates climbed, you would usually see a large number of PE shops showing interest. Clearly, their perspective differs somewhat when it comes to how they account for these things and evaluate such investments. So, just to illustrate, perhaps 10 firms were initially engaged. Then, once rates rose, the count of those participating could have dropped to 3 firms. These are entirely hypothetical scenarios. Fast forward to now, and maybe 6 or 7 firms would be involved. What I'm attempting to convey is that when rates decline, a greater number of interested parties emerge — ones with a shorter-term orientation in how they see things, meaning private equity. As for our approach, we keep evaluating opportunities both at home — where we believe some quite attractive prospects lie ahead for us — and in the overseas markets where we already have operations. That's demonstrated by our expectation to complete the Quintes deal in the Netherlands during this quarter; that represents yet another market we're eager to take part in moving forward. So neither takes priority over the other. We emphasize how important cultural alignment is; we consider capabilities; we consider whether we're strengthening what we already do, bringing in something new, or perhaps entering a new geography — provided it aligns with our core principles: first, it must be a cultural fit and financially sound. Second, we prefer doing business in nations whose governments we grasp. Normally there's rule of law, and generally a stable economy. We're quite happy with the conditions in which we presently function.
Meyer Shields
analystI'd like to return to the topic of lender-placed insurance in the program. Regarding that $15 million — I believe you mentioned a lag of 90 to 120 days — so would the $15 million amount to roughly 3/4 of revenue? Or does it represent a full year? And did it have any effect on margins within the segment?
J. Powell Brown
executiveLet's take a look. It accounts for a bit more than 6 months of revenue, Meyer, once again, mostly during the first half of 2025. A portion of it will extend into the fourth quarter as it cycles through, which is simply the usual delay in processing, transitioning it over from the prior processor. As for full year margin, no, it has no effect on full year margins. It's only a matter of timing between the quarters.
Grace Carter
analystThe 10-Q referred to certain strain on contingents and retail stemming from elevated loss ratios among carrier partners. My sense is that marks the second straight quarter where that has shown up. Might you share more detail about the specific lines that drove the pressure during 3Q, and what that looks like relative to 2Q? Also, any perspective on whether you expect this to keep coming back over the coming few quarters?
R. Watts
executiveGrace, sure — this is something we've discussed across, I'd say, the prior few quarters at minimum. The beginning of it appeared in '23. Auto is the main area, covering both personal and commercial. As you're well aware, carriers in that segment have sought rate increases purely because of claim frequency and severity in the market, and that is weighing on profitability overall. That's really the primary factor. What I'd say at present is that nothing we're seeing in the marketplace is yet reversing that pattern. Therefore, we'd anticipate continued pressure there.
Scott Heleniak
analystI'd like to hear more about the employee benefits operation. You touched on it earlier, and it seems like health care is trending in a good direction. Could you walk through how Q3 compared with the first half, and then what the outlook looks like for 2025 — both organically and via M&A — plus what you're observing in that unit?
J. Powell Brown
executiveSure, Scott. Here's my take: think back — this takes us a bit into the past — over the past 10 years, we've deliberately put money into added capabilities, and that has positioned us as a company to serve essentially any customer, whatever their size, in employee benefits. What that translates to is this: we're able to take on a start-up. Should that start-up eventually reach 100,000 employees, we're genuinely capable of serving them at that 100,000-employee scale. Keep in mind, too, that middle market and upper middle market make up our core business. Given the capabilities we offer, plenty of opportunities exist for us right now and going forward, and we're quite enthusiastic about the growth prospects ahead. On top of that, health care is a subject every CFO wants to discuss — specifically what it costs them. There's a great deal we can deliver to our customers and prospects that helps them approach things from a new angle and possibly achieve different results — in certain cases, performance that beats what they've known by a wide margin. So we're actively seeking more firms to bring onto the team. That said, even if we completed no acquisition bringing employee benefit capabilities within the coming 12 months, I don't believe that would alter, in any respect, how we view the existing business and employee benefits. Andy, myself, and the whole operating team feel very, very good — and frankly, quite thrilled — about our capacity to write and service customers regardless of size.
Brian Meredith
analystI have one quick question. Are you expecting Milton and Helene to affect contingent commissions at all during Q4?
R. Watts
executiveBrian, I'd say that's still somewhat up in the air. During our remarks earlier, we mentioned that with Milton there remain numerous moving pieces. For Helene, we recorded certain adjustments in Q3, comparable to what happened back in '22 with Ian; we use the most accurate estimate available given what is known at that moment. So, would adjustments be anticipated from us in Q4? Yeah, that will likely happen; but remember, adjustments were recorded by us on the positive side in Q4 of the prior year owing to low claim activity, and that's mostly within the program space. Consequently, a fairly significant year-over-year swing will likely show up there. The size of it is unknown to me at this point; we simply require some claims development to take place.
J. Powell Brown
executiveBrian, there are a couple of points I want to highlight that may not be the first things you'd think of. First, we observed — and are still observing — a significant number of auto losses during the storms, especially Helene, and Milton too. Picture a vehicle sitting in a garage when floodwaters rise, and the car is ruined, right? It stops functioning; and I'm not referring to electric vehicles at all, I'm simply describing that situation. That's the first point. Second, based on your location, there's a quite pronounced link between buildings — both commercial and residential — constructed after 2005 and the scale of damage. As you're aware, new codes came into effect, honestly, dating back to 1992 with Hurricane Andrew; and then roughly every 2 years, it appears they've been tightened. But if you ask folks in the market about property losses, those losses tend to involve structures from the '90s, the '80s, the '70s and the '60s. When you get to older homes from the 30s and the 40s, those aren't the ones suffering losses; they're actually very — they're very sturdy structures; it's that middle category where the building codes perhaps weren't as strict. So just a brief aside, just to provide a bit of color regarding your question.
Greg Peters
analystAll right. Now I'll ask what I wanted to ask next. During what you said about free cash flow, you mentioned certain deferred tax payments that are going to provide a boost to the '24 free cash flow figure. Given that there will be extra tax payments coming from both '24 and '25, not only '25, should we expect the conversion rate on '25 free cash flow to come in lower?
R. Watts
executiveThat's right, Greg. At present, according to IRS rules, payment has to happen during the second quarter. So as you put together your projections, and you're able to form a fairly solid sense of what our taxes will be, those taxes come to roughly $90 million to $100 million each quarter. So be certain to include them in the second quarter. That's going to drag down our conversion for '25. That's the reason we said what we did about lifting the conversion ratio for '24, since that deferral made it possible.
Greg Peters
analystAlso, regarding the conversion rate for '24, it's been increased — could you refresh my memory?
R. Watts
executiveSure, previously we gave a figure of 22% to 24%. So this raises it by 2 percentage points or so. However, as we examine the company, and if you remember some time ago when discussion turned to the conversion ratio, and we brought up 2025, we indicated that a quite obvious route back to the 24% to 26% range was visible to us. That was before the storm arrived; yet as we assess the entire operation, along with how we expand it, the margins we produce and the conversion of our free cash flow, our confidence in the company and its trajectory is extremely high. It merely comes down to the timing of various items shifting around, occasionally across years. Still, the fundamental business remains exceptionally robust.
Elyse Greenspan
analystFor my follow-up, I want to ask about investment income, since it rose quite a bit this quarter. Andy, what was behind that increase? And as rates shift, how should we think about, I suppose, the NII level you anticipate for Q4 and beyond?
R. Watts
executiveOkay. One point to remember is the $600 million in bonds we issued during the second quarter. We held onto those funds until the September bonds were repaid, which generated an additional $6 million to $7 million in interest income for the quarter. So the roughly $31 million we recorded this quarter shouldn't be treated as a run rate; it will certainly decline in the second quarter and then — sorry, in the fourth quarter...
J. Powell Brown
executiveLet me clear up one thing. Elyse, I want to address a point you raised before, and you're right that, as you're aware, we don't provide guidance on organic growth. But here's what happened: you had asked about a figure for Q4. What Andy and I meant, or were attempting to convey, was that if you examine how Q3 performed and take into account the adjustments we implemented, we think that serves as a solid baseline for Q4. I just wanted to ensure that came across clearly. Is that understandable?
Elyse Greenspan
analystYes. So for Retail, the Q4 starting point is the 3.9% plus the 100 basis points, or roughly 5%.
J. Powell Brown
executiveI was going to let you work that out, and while we don't provide guidance, I simply wanted to make that clear.
Elyse Greenspan
analystAll right, understood.
R. Watts
executiveThen Elyse, to finish up regarding net investment income, since I believe it's likely also crucial that we discuss the flip side of that. And once more, you can sort of get a sense for — when modeling, if there's a 1% drop in rates, an idea as to what that might mean for net investment income. Now again, bear in mind that as our organization keeps expanding, fiduciary cash increases. So doing that won't give you an exact ratio, right? The reason being you must assume fiduciary assets will keep growing. But then also remember the opposite side of that is our floating rate debt. So as an organization, we designed our capital structure so that roughly 25% of our debt would be floating rate. For creating shareholder value over many years, it's been extremely, extremely beneficial. And so when we — at the end of 9/30, on floating rate debt we had just under $800 million. So if you're doing your ups and downs on interest, just be sure you grab that on the other side of the equation, okay?
Mark Hughes
analystYou brought up how investing in teammates affects margin. Since M&A activity, at least during Q3, was somewhat softer for you. Is spending more on teammates something you planned on purpose? Or did it come about more opportunistically?
J. Powell Brown
executiveI'd call it opportunistic, Mark. The way I see it, whenever we come across the right people, we're going to put money behind them; that's why I keep saying one quarter or — isn't a trend; and when those investments get made, our full expectation is that we'll grow into them over the quarters and years to come. So if it were something really big in terms of a number, we'd flag it and discuss it with you; but looking at it this way, we — to me this is just ordinary opportunistic investing. We won't go around pounding a drum about having some program. That's not what this is; good people are always on our radar. Our belief is that, culturally, a certain group of people will be drawn to us who want to work for a sales and service organization that's competitive, collaborative, and high-performing. But there isn't anything — there isn't some hidden initiative happening. That's — I don't want you walking away with that impression.
Mike Zaremski
analystThanks. I'd like to dig a little deeper, as a follow-up, into what all of you are observing or forecasting regarding pricing power trends on the casualty side? From what I recall — I believe it was last quarter — you and possibly plenty of other folks expected pricing to tick upward somewhat. Has that shifted in any way? Also, I'm not sure whether you'd want to split things out between E&S and admitted versus non-admitted.
J. Powell Brown
executiveAbsolutely. Okay, Mike, first thing: as you may recall, I've previously mentioned that throughout my career — and I've only been in the insurance business since 1990 — there's consistently been an underlying sense that casualty has been underpriced, yet I don't believe carriers have shown much discipline when it comes to how they price it. Right now, things appear to be different. There seems to be discipline in that area. Therefore, in my view, it applies to both primary and excess, and I also believe it applies to admitted and non-admitted alike. So this isn't a matter of us splitting it apart in a way where you're seeing it more in one category than the other. That isn't what's happening; and so I think we will keep seeing rate pressure on casualty, meaning general liability, excess liability and, as Andy mentioned earlier, in automobile, both commercial and personal auto. At this point in time, I don't anticipate that shifting. Depending on which carrier you ask, they'll describe various trends they're observing in their books; but yes, pressure persists across all of those segments.
J. Powell Brown
executiveAbsolutely. Kevin, thank you — we're grateful that all of you could join us today. Q3's results make us quite happy. We're eager for Q4, finishing the year on a high note and heading into 2025. Have a great day, everyone. Thanks for spending your time with us.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that brings today's presentation to a close. You're welcome to disconnect at this point, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Brown & Brown, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Brown & Brown, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Brown & Brown, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.