Business First Bancshares, Inc. (BFST) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 24, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, everyone, and welcome to the Business First Bancshares Q3 2024 Earnings Call. Just a reminder that today's call is being recorded. At this time, I would like to hand things over to Mr. Matt Sealy, Senior Vice President, Director of Corporate Strategy and FP&A. Please go ahead, sir.
Matthew Sealy
executiveGood afternoon, and thank you everyone for joining. Earlier today, we issued our Third Quarter 2024 earnings press release, a copy of which is available on our website, along with the slide presentation that we'll refer to during today's call. Please refer to Slide 3 of our presentation, which includes our safe harbor statements regarding forward-looking statements and these non-GAAP financial measures. For those of you joining by phone, please note the slide presentation is available on our website at www.b1bank.com. Please also note our safe harbor statements are available on Page 7 of our earnings press release that was filed with the SEC today. All comments made during today's call are subject to the safe harbor statements in our slide presentation and earnings release. I'm joined this afternoon by Business First Bancshares' Chairman, President and CEO; Jude Melville; Chief Financial Officer; Greg Robertson; Chief Banking Officer, Philip Jordan; and President of b1BANK, Jerry Vascocu. After the presentation, we'll be happy to address any questions you may have. And with that, I'll turn the call over to you, Jude.
David Melville
executiveOkay. Thanks, Matt, and good afternoon, everybody. To begin, I want to make sure to say thank you to everyone currently on the call or listening to it or rereading the transcripts at some point in the future. We know you have choices to make, and we appreciate you making us a priority today. I can be relatively brief as the quarter was straightforward and generally positive. Primary theme I'd like to highlight is the improvement in operating leverage achieved through a combination of continued expansion of our net interest margin and expense control. [indiscernible] expenses were down about $1 million linked quarter, even while we continue to make the technological investments that we detailed in previous quarterly calls. Our core margin expanded 12 basis points linked quarter to 3.46% driven by roughly flat deposit costs down 1 basis point linked quarter faired with increased aggregate portfolio loan yields as new and renewed loans pricing held steady at 8.46%. Secondary thing I'd like to highlight is the continued diversification of revenue from the investments we've made over the past couple of years and sources of noninterest income, including SSW our asset management company. Waterstone, our SBA loan service provider, our big group and our nascent internal swap desk. A new chart on Page 15 explains the primary sources of that increased income. And while we expect the components of that income to shift quarter-to-quarter. We're pleased that the aggregate impact is incrementally positive income and has been consistently over the course of 2024. Third, we demonstrated discipline in the management of our balance sheet, again, growing deposits at a rate faster than loans while also growing risk assets appropriately in line with retained earnings leading to increased capital levels and tangible book value growth even outside of the impact of positive AOCI movement. We believe we've positioned the loan and deposit portfolios favorably considered in the current rate outlook and anticipate continued incremental improvement in our NIM due to this positioning and the hard on the groundwork of our banking teams. Finally, on a broader topic of adding value to the franchise beyond just the numbers. We are pleased to successfully closed the Oakwood transaction on October 1, bringing the percentage of our asset exposure in the Dallas and Houston markets to the mid-40s as a percentage of the overall loan book. Thank you to the Oakwood team for their positivity and their energy and thank you also to our regulatory partners for reviewing the merger in a professional and timely manner. We also recently announced a promotion to Jerry Vascocu to the position of President of the bank [indiscernible] main Chair and CEO. Jerry has made an impact serving with us for a couple of years already and had an extensive career with growing regional banks before joining our team. We believe we'll have many opportunities before us in the coming years, and we want to be sure that we are positioning our internal operations to continue coordinated performance even while we expand interaction with our external constituencies. This is especially important as we move closer to the $10 billion asset level, a transition that we want to be certain we approach proactively. With that, I again thank you for calling in. And I'd like to close by congratulating our team and our [ loyal ] finance on another successful quarter. I'll now turn the call over to Greg for further detail. .
Gregory Robertson
executiveThank you, Jude, and good afternoon, everyone. The Third Quarter GAAP net income and EPS available to common shareholders was $16.5 million and $0.65 per share and included a $13,000 pretax loss on sale of securities. $319,000 pretax acquisition-related expense on a $511,000 pretax conversion-related expense. Excluding this noncore item, non-GAAP core net income and EPS available to common shareholders was $17.2 million, and $0.68 per share. As Jude mentioned, while expenses did come in lower than we had expected, we feel like Q3 represents an overall solid run rate going forward. I'll start on the balance sheet for moving to the margin and then conclude with the income statement. Total loans held for investment increased by $57.3 million or 4.4% annualized during the third quarter. I should note, our production pipeline remains very strong as we sold approximately $30 million in loans to participating banks during the third quarter. Loan growth from linked quarter was largely attributable to the net growth in the commercial real estate portfolio of $58.2 million and $16.9 million net growth in the C&D portfolio. Production was led by our North Louisiana region and our New Orleans region, which accounted for approximately 3 quarters of net loan growth from the linked quarter. Based on unpaid principal balances, Texas-based loans represent approximately 35% of the overall portfolio as of September 30. And as Jude mentioned, as we expect Oakwood to contribute $690 million in net loans, bringing the total Texas loan balances to approximately 42%. Total deposits increased $77.3 million or 5.5% annualized quarter-over-quarter. During the quarter ended September 30, interest-bearing accounts drove the increase of $196.5 million in growth, offset by $119 million and reduction in noninterest-bearing accounts compared to the linked quarter. The reduction in the noninterest-bearing accounts is isolated to 7 clients with production-related accounts that make up approximately $75 million in deposits. In spite of that, new production remained strong with approximately $25 million in new deposits generated during the quarter. The increase in interest-bearing was largely attributable to $161 million increase in our money market accounts. The weighted average money market portfolio rate declined by 35 basis points in the linked quarter from 4.22% to 3.87%. Total noninterest-bearing deposits represent 21.1% of total deposits as of September 30, down from 23.5% in the linked quarter that remains in line with our expectations at the beginning of the year to end the year of 2024 in the low 20% range. Our GAAP reported third quarter net interest margin of 3.51% benefited from $705,000 in discount loan accretion, which was in line with our consensus expectations. Third quarter core NIM, excluding accretion of 3.46% came in higher than we expected, the 12 basis point linked quarter expansion in the core NIM and it continued strong and renewed loan yield repricing tailwinds and moderated funding pressures. A little context there. Our weighted average new and renewed loan yields for the third quarter was approximately 3.46% with a spot rate at the end of September at 8.49%. While quarter-over-quarter total deposits declined 1 basis point with the September cut in interest rates, we do expect deposit costs to continue to decline in the near term, but will be affected by our ability to retain and attract lower cost funding and noninterest-bearing deposit accounts. This is a good opportunity to direct your attention to a new slide we created in our earnings presentation, with a reference slide on Page 21 for a summary of our deposit beta assumptions in an easing interest rate environment. We expect overall total deposit betas to be in the 45% to 55% range, which should translate into low single-digit expansion in the core NIM assuming a static balance sheet. There could be additional upside to margin expansion should we assume some normal organic growth. We feel like this new beta slide is a good complement to the following slide on Page 22, which depicts the repricing opportunities within the loan portfolio. As you'll see on Page 22, we have approximately $2 billion in floating rate loans at approximately 8.15% weighted average, but we also have approximately $500 million in fixed rate loans maturing over the next 12 months at a weighted average of 6.28%, which we would expect to reprice in the low 8% range. Last thing I would add is just the impact of the addition of the good balance sheet, which we have a full quarter impact during the fourth quarter. We continue to expect Oakwood to be a couple of basis points accretive to our overall core margin, and we also expect loan discount accretion to average and approximately $700,000 to $800,000 order range going forward, including Oakwood addition. Moving on to the income statement. Our GAAP noninterest expense was $42.4 million and included $319,000 in acquisition-related expense of $511,000 in conversion-related expense. Core net interest expense for the third quarter of $41.6 million declined approximately $1.1 million linked quarter and benefited from timing of salaries, [ several ] rules and certain investments not hitting during the quarter. We'd expect this to reverse trend somewhat during the fourth quarter and with the full impact of Oakwood, we view the current consensus estimate for the noninterest expense of approximately $50 million to be a fair estimate and a good run rate going forward. Third quarter GAAP and core noninterest income was $10.8 million, but GAAP did include a $13,000 loss of sale on securities. Noninterest income results for the third quarter did come in slightly better than we had expected and was driven our contribution from our newly formed customer swap business, which generated approximately $900,000 in revenue during the quarter. We view Q3 of core noninterest interest income as a good run rate going forward and expect our noninterest income to continue to trend with an upward trajectory that will be bumpy as our investments continue to season. As Jude mentioned, we did add a new noninterest income slide on Page 15 in our earnings presentation that summarizes those investments and provide additional color. Lastly, the addition of Oakwood will be additive to the overall noninterest income, that increase will be modest in the near term as they get used to our product offerings. And that concludes my remarks for today, and I'll hand it back over to Jude.
David Melville
executiveThanks, Greg. Again, just a good, solid working day quarter, and we're pleased with the incremental improvement, and we think we're positioned well to continue that over the coming quarters. So with that, I'll look for any questions that we might have and look forward to the conversation. .
Operator
operator[Operator Instructions] We'll take our first question from Michael Rose, Raymond James.
Michael Rose
analystNice expansion on the margin and good to see the deposit costs come down. I think as I recall, last quarter, you guys had a bunch of brokered CDs that are expected to mature by the end of the year. I think it was $450 million last quarter. Just wanted to see how much of a tailwind is there. And I think you had previously talked about the core margin reaching kind of around 350 by the end of the second quarter. I just wanted to see if there were any updates and then just embedded in that, it seems like the accretion might be a little bit lower -- do you have the amount of expected accretion that you expect to realize from Oakwood, what the addition would be to the kind of the $9 million that was remaining at the end of the third quarter.
Gregory Robertson
executiveYes, I'll start off answering the first part. The -- as far as the CD brokered and the maturities go, that was what we had -- the last time we talked to you, we had -- we're isolating on about $400 million in retail CD renewals in the near term. We have been pulling through with a fairly solid above 50% retention rate on that CD book and repricing. So we feel pretty confident there are some tailwinds. And we do feel like that, that will be instrumental in helping us achieve that 350 margin by the second quarter like you spoke of.
David Melville
executiveMichael, I'll jump in kind of give you a little bit of color in terms of the 350 target in the second quarter. I think you're referring to the second quarter of 25 core margin run rate. So obviously, a little bit ahead of schedule is what it would appear service level. There's a couple of things that I would call out that I'm not sure how much could be sustained within that core margin currently. So within our business manager factoring product set that we have, there's about 7-ish basis points within the core margin attributed to that business line and really no direct balances on balance sheet balances associated with that interest income that we have. There's a couple of larger clients that are currently reflected in that number. And the past quarter or so, we've been uncertain if they're going to stick around. And fortunately, they have. That is a bit of a wildcard. So while we are currently ahead of schedule to hit that 350 core margin, by Q2 of next year. I would just caveat it with that. There's a couple of clients that account for a few basis points, maybe about 3 basis points of that 7-related to those folks. Now that is also pre-Oakwood. So if you layer in Oakwood there another couple of basis points accretive, so I'd say, all in all, still very confident that we can hit that core margin run rate by Q2 of next year and potentially a little bit sooner, but that's kind of the context around that piece of it. And then lastly, on the kind of Greg's point about the CD repricing and maturing. We do have, on our new Slide 21 in the presentation, the last bullet point, which depicts the upcoming maturities within the CD portfolio in Q4 and Q1 to the tune of about $300 million. So we'll try to keep updating that and rolling that forward. So you can see kind of the context going forward in the next couple of quarters.
Gregory Robertson
executiveYes. And then Michael, your last question in regards to the gain with the Oakwood closing. From the time we announced the transaction, the interest rate environment has changed. So we're in the process of finalizing the marks and the accretion and all that on that. So a little bit too early to tell on that, but we're still working on that. It will be additive, but our echo's [indiscernible].
Michael Rose
analystBut $700,000 to $800,000 a quarter with Oakwood is what you're still expecting is, I think what I heard.
Gregory Robertson
executiveYes, that's right.
Michael Rose
analystOkay. Perfect. Sorry for the 3-part question in the first question. Just as one follow-up. Saw the provision came in a little bit lower than I was expecting. But looking at Slide 31, I did notice that the special mention was up and NPLs did go up a little bit as well. Can you just give some context there, anything to worry about and just any general overall thoughts on credit?
Gregory Robertson
executiveI will say -- I'll start with NPLs. So the increase in NPLs is really attributable to one loan that's SBA guaranteed loan that we should have resolution with that within the next month or so. So that I think what we're seeing within the credit book is just the impact of normalized credit performance with, for example, the past due loans, the increase in that -- 2 of the 3 loans that make up most of the increase, we should have some resolution on those as well. So still seeing some one-off things. I think as far as the watchlist goes, that is an impact or a direct reflection of the interest rate environment, probably majority of the movement with that. But I think it would be foolish not to say that they -- we're in a more normal credit environment. So we're seeing no major degradation in the credit portfolio, just one of examples here and there.
Operator
operatorNext up is Matt Olney, Stephens Inc. .
Matt Olney
analystWant to ask about loan growth. A little bit slower than what we've seen at the bank more recently, but still quite a bit above what we've seen from peers over the last week or two. Would love to kind of hear what your borrowers are saying, specifically the C&I borrowers looks like utilization rates moved down a little bit. I would love to hear just kind of what you're hearing from your customers. .
Gregory Robertson
executiveI'll talk about the impact of the balance sheet and then I'll let Philip or Jerry kind of chime in on what they're seeing with the customers. The 4.4% is kind of in line with what we've been talking about lately in being understanding the impacts of capital growth and profitability. So I think that's right in line. And as I mentioned, we did sell $30 million worth of loans in the quarter to participating banks in our network. So we still feel like the pipeline is strong and in a good place, but I'll let these guys talk a little bit about that.
Unknown Executive
executiveYes. I would say I don't know that there's necessarily an outlier from that perspective too and the customer feedback. I think this is kind of a timing for us. We don't see it -- it's just kind of normal on a year-over-year basis as far as how our clients are utilizing the lines. Also, it's a point of the year where a lot of our loans are paying down. So we're seeing some of that. But I didn't mean necessarily outliers. . Well, and I would offer to kind of my second year through the process. We're seeing some pretty nice growth embedded in there from some core customers that are really kind of having a successful season. It's been nice to see that this -- over the last couple of -- particularly the last few months. It's manifest some additional good [indiscernible].
Matt Olney
analystOkay. Great. Thanks for all the commentary on the loan growth and I guess, going over to the fee side, another nice quarter on the fees. I think it was the swap fees that maybe drove the strong trends this quarter. I think these can be a little volatile quarter-to-quarter, but it sounds like based off the prepared remarks, you don't expect any kind of step back in the near term. You think you can continue to grow it from this run rate that we saw in the third quarter. Is that right?
Gregory Robertson
executiveThat's right. And if you think about our production in that noninterest income in the second quarter, that was really driven by a $1.9 million kind of outlier fee from a USDA gain on sale. So for us to really build from there shows the continued investment in those different business lines that we've been and we're highlighting in the slide deck this quarter. We do think it will be bumpy, like you said, but we do expect it to continue to incrementally grow over time.
David Melville
executiveGo ahead Jerry.
Unknown Executive
executiveI was going to add. It was a good question. One of the things I think we've been most pleased about, particularly with the swap business is it's become more granular. We've got a good rhythm with that product and applying it to the right clients, good clients. If you look at the slide that breaks out the swap some detail there, it's 20 trades in the quarter. So I think what we've been most pleased about is it's not as lumpy in the third quarter, and we can kind of see it leveling out over time in a good way with a good gradual ramp, good response from our bankers and our clients.
David Melville
executiveI think I would also add just that we don't expect for swaps to necessarily be the leader in every quarter. One of the reasons that we've chosen to invest in multiple sources of revenue, so we know that, that can be a little more volatile than our traditional spread income. And so we wanted to be sure we had 3 or 4 choices. And I think today, we're probably feeling like in the fourth quarter, the SBA income, probably the stronger pipeline than swap income, not that the swaps won't continue to accrete, but we wanted to be sure that we had multiple sources of revenue so that as we experienced some fluctuation in and the individual components, the overall aggregate results should be incrementally positive .
Operator
operatorThe next question comes from Feddie Strickland of the Hovde Group.
Feddie Strickland
analystJust want to ask, as you integrate, how should we think about the expense growth kind of later in '25. Are there any major initiatives? I mean I know you maybe have some cost saves here and there or they're in the year. But anything major we should look out for is kind of past years premerger like a piece of history to look at for that?
Gregory Robertson
executiveI would say past year's premerger is a good indicator of how we think about it. I think the overarching we're going to grow or we want to grow loans in the mid-single-digit range next year. And so keeping expense -- that expense base in line with that asset growth is really what we're thinking about from an overall strategy standpoint. So -- and do remember, it's worth noting that because of the later in the year, core conversion with them that we're not pulling through a lot of cost savings in 2025. Those will be showing towards the [indiscernible].
Unknown Executive
executiveBut one thing that I'd add. Greg hit on this in his prepared remarks. All in Oakwood in the fourth quarter kind of a good launching point going into 2025 it is kind of the current consensus number out there. I believe is right at $50-ish million all in, and that includes fully-loaded impact of Oakwood. That's kind of a good launching point.
Feddie Strickland
analystGot you. And then you said the cost saves are probably later in the year. I wouldn't see as many of those initially right?
Gregory Robertson
executiveWe're probably not going to see any of those until the Q4 of next year and then pulling through into '26
David Melville
executiveWhich is what our expectation was when we cut the deal as we model. So it's not a delay. It's just a sequence of events with our own internal work, including a core conversion of legacy prior to doing the Oakwood conversion.
Feddie Strickland
analystUnderstood. And then just one more question for me is just kind of still on Oakwood a little bit, but -- how do you think about the geographic expansion or is growth going forward? I mean, does M&A remain a part of the playbook in the medium term here? Would you look at doing team lift-outs? Or do you just still feel like there's a good bit of runway with the current footprint in terms of, I guess, low hanging fruit for additional loan and [indiscernible] growth.
David Melville
executiveYes. I think as always, we want to be prepared to take advantage of opportunity when it presents itself, and we believe that we could be successful on multiple fronts. I do -- I would say that our current priority remains organic growth and making sure that we're maximizing the team that we have, and we do have a really good track record of enabling teams that we've partnered with to grow beyond where they were before we partnered with them. And so that certainly will be -- the first priority would be our current footprint, continuing to gain operating leverage. Certainly, the team lift-outs or a great way to grow, and we've done that successfully, and we'll begin look for some opportunities. And we prepare -- we feel prepared to take on M&A should the right partner, so I would say from a footprint standpoint, #1 priority is our current footprint. Number 2 priority is filling in some of the gaps in our current footprint, Dallas and Houston as a possible area that might be [indiscernible]. We have still have plenty of room to grow in Louisiana as well as continue to build our core franchise. Secondarily, I would say that we, over time, will look for opportunities looks sideways to the East, but that's -- if we think about our footprint and what we wanted to look like 5, 7, 10 years from now, I would imagine more widespread in the face or the order of how we do that will be determined by who we can partner with. And our location choices have always been about the bankers more than the specific geography, and so we'll continue to do that. But we do think we have plenty of take rates over in our current footprint, and that will be our whether that's through organic growth or through partnership, that will be our priority for the near term.
Unknown Executive
executiveWould like to mention to you that we had a couple of bankers retire in our Houston footprint, and we're back to those who [indiscernible], for that addition.
Gregory Robertson
executiveWe're excited about that. And again, some incremental addition to our current talent base I think will produce positive earnings results.
David Melville
executiveI think it is worth pointing out that -- and Greg mentioned before, but our 2 biggest growth areas this year or this quarter were both Louisiana and New Orleans. So I know -- we're excited about Dallas and Houston, and those are things that tend to get the headlines. But we also feel really good about our competitive posture within our core Louisiana franchise and with each quarter and each year that passes, I think we build credibility, we build brand power, and we accumulate additional talent. And so while Texas certainly is a key part of our future, we believe we have plenty of opportunities throughout our footprint. And I think third quarter was a really good example of the different constituent elements of our footprint or together to serve the greater hole and you can paint a picture over '24 and '23, which some of our Southwest Louisiana portion of our footprint, for example, provided the most deposit growth. So one of the things that we've tried to do over time is to say that we have an opportunity to combine the best of both worlds, which is the more kind of community bankers slightly rural locations that we might have in our Louisiana footprint with the slightly more commercial metro banking that we might do in other areas. And I think when you really kind of parse out the results over the course of this year, we've had good evolution of leadership from [indiscernible] footprint and very excited about opportunities across the sector.
Operator
operatorAnd we'll take our next question today from Manuel Navas, D.A. Davidson.
Manuel Navas
analystThe low single-digit core NIM expansion under the 50 basis point reduction, that's only so far. What's the future rate cut improvement. And is that slide only on the balance sheet as of 3Q. Can you just kind of talk through some of the assumptions behind that slide?
Gregory Robertson
executiveYes, that would be on a static balance sheet as of 3Q, and then that would be an assumption for every 50 basis points, that would be what we would realize.
Unknown Executive
executiveYes. And a little bit more color there, Manuel. So that's the incremental and kind of additive expansion on top of our current trajectory, assuming flat rates. So we've got a scenario where if rates were not cut, we would still see some expansion and lift. So that couple of basis point pickup is not off of the current Q3 figure or current Q3 ending figure. There's already some inherent expansion in there in just a flat rate environment. So that's really the additive expansion on top of already some modest expansion over the next 12 months. So that's not a 3-month outlook expansion from the recent cut plus ordinary course of business expansion from growth and margin improvement. If that makes sense.
Gregory Robertson
executiveManuel really, I think the last time we saw we talked about the work we have done to restructure the liability side of the balance sheet. And I think this really paints a picture and shows the work that we put in to become more neutral and position the balance sheet where we can be reactive to interest rate movements. This is just a snapshot that shows indication of what that work has proves out to give us a little bit of lift to be able to do.
Manuel Navas
analystSo if that low single digits, let's say, is 2 to 3 basis points, and we -- the forward curve contemplates another 150 basis point cut in Fed funds by middle of next year. Is this saying almost like another 6 basis point improvement in core NIM under these assumptions.
Gregory Robertson
executiveI think that would be reasonable to expect.
Manuel Navas
analystOkay. And then you add in layer in the Oakwood core NIM improvement, Oakwood purchase accounting accretion on top of that. So there's a couple of other pieces as well.
Gregory Robertson
executiveI think the NIM [indiscernible] from Oakwood is correct. I think the accretion lift on Oakwood, we're still trying to finalize the numbers on that. But I think there will be slightly some lift on that.
Manuel Navas
analystSure, sure. So the money markets stepped down pretty nicely this quarter. They are expected to have pretty strong betas through the cycle. You're about a month since the Fed cut rates, how is the acceptance of those cuts progressed from your customers.
Gregory Robertson
executiveNot a lot of volatility in that account. We've had slight growth since the Fed cuts, no run out. So we feel pretty good about the decision we made so far.
Manuel Navas
analystThat's great. That's great to hear. Any other updates on Oakwood now that it's closed? It seems like there's a little bit more loan growth there. Did they use up some of the cash you were going to have about $100 million in cash deployed pretty quickly. Kind of just walk me through that any other...
Gregory Robertson
executiveI'll give you an update. They did have loan growth since the deal was announced. And so their loan-to-deposit ratio to [ tick ] higher. And so that's where some of the cash went. And then we'll continue to evaluate opportunities from their funding base as we move to ours. They have a little more of a structured time deposit funding base that as renewal opportunity is coming up. So we'll deal with that on a one-off basis and hopefully be able to see some improvement in that. But everything is going as planned for sure.
Operator
operator[Operator Instructions] We'll go to Christopher Marinac, Janney Montgomery Scott.
Christopher Marinac
analystI wanted to ask about the lower interest rates and the impact on credit upgrades in future quarters. Is that possible? And what would that looks like?
Unknown Executive
executiveYes. It's a good question. We're in the process right now of kind of going through at a pretty granular level on our risk ratings across the portfolio and we do feel like there's some opportunities to see some benefits and some improvements in risk rating. So we're looking at it across the board, across the portfolio and implying that factor and going about it in a pretty disciplined fashion. It's been a good phase.
David Melville
executiveMost of our increase in the watch list has been due to higher debt service requirements based on rising in rates. So we would expect that they reverse with hold true to some degree. And it is a little bit of a question of timing and how quickly the rates actually move? And how does that feed into whatever stress clients might have been under previously. And then also, from our perspective, just make that decisions, should we require documentation and updated financials and all those things will take a little time. But I do think we expect that the change in rate environment should be a net positive for -- to counter some of the watchlist growth that we've experienced over the past couple of quarters in particular.
Christopher Marinac
analystIs there any kind of, I guess, separation between watchlist that is CRE related versus pure C&I would the C&I have its own separate behavior these next few quarters. .
Gregory Robertson
executiveI think there is a pretty good distinct. This is Greg, Chris. There is a pretty good distinction between -- on the makeup of the watchlist. I would say it's probably 60% CRE, 40% C&I, something in that range. I think the overarching fact kind of play out what Jude said is about 90% of that watchlist is paying as agreed, but does have financial performance impacted if you're looking at from a ratio standpoint. So and that's prior to the rate cut. So we feel like that it will naturally probably help those customers, but as far as having the granularity on the performance in each group, we can probably get you some of that data that we don't have it right now.
Christopher Marinac
analystNo problem. That's helpful. And then just last question just goes back to the beta slide on #21. Would you see that mix changing if we think prospectively 12, 18 months? Or should we think of business versus kind of the same mix in this environment?
Gregory Robertson
executiveI would say we worked real hard over the last 12 to 18 months to move the mix into this position to give us a little more balanced -- neutral balance sheet. So I would say going out in the future, say for some dramatic change from an M&A standpoint, and I think that's realistic that this would be what we could expect. .
Unknown Executive
executiveYes. I'd say that big range is probably a good assumption to use not just in the recent 50 basis point cut we got, but foreseeable future, any rates we might get in the future in the near term.
Operator
operatorAt this time, there are no further questions. I apologize. I'll hand it back to you Jude Melville. .
David Melville
executiveAll right. I'm ready. Thank you, and I appreciate everybody's participation and questions. it's been an unexpected event for a couple of years, and I'm just really proud of the work that we've done to position ourselves coming out of this cycle to maximize 2025 and 2026 and beyond. And really proud of just community banking in general. There were an awful lot of dark clouds hanging over the industry in general over the past couple of years. And I think we're going to find the community banks in particular have exceeded expectations and are well prepared to continue to play a critical role in our country's future in the coming quarters and years, and we're proud to be a part of it. Thank you for your interest, and I look forward to next quarter being our first quarter with our Oakwood teammates numbers incorporated in ours and look forward to seeing what we can do together. Thank you.
Operator
operatorOnce again, everyone, that does conclude today's conference. We would like to thank you all for your participation. You may now disconnect.
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Business First Bancshares, Inc. earnings transcripts and 32,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $24.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.