Caledonia Investments Plc (CLDN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 21, 2023

London Stock Exchange GB Financials Capital Markets earnings 57 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Mat Masters

executive
#1

Alright, welcome everyone, whether you're joining us online or here in the room, to the presentation of our half year results. I'm Mat Masters, Chief Executive of Caledonia. During this presentation we'll be joined by Tom Leader, who runs our private capital portfolio, and then by Rob Memmott, who has just joined us as finance director. What we're going to do is take you through the strategy a little bit. I'll give some highlights on the half year, and then we'll go through the portfolio. There's been some activity in the private capital portfolio, which is why Tom is joining us, and after that Rob will take us through the finance section. So moving through the cautionary statement and onto an overview and just a reminder of Caledonia, which is a self-managed investment trust. I'll come on to explain why that's special a bit later on, and our net assets are GBP 2.9 billion. We're focused on delivering our shareholders real returns over the longer term. And you can see on the chart that we compare ourselves really against inflation. So we're aiming to beat consumer price CPIH inflation over the medium and longer term. And then there's a reference point over the 10-year periods; we're looking to outperform against the FTSE All-Share Index.

Mat Masters

executive
#2

But our main goals are really about safeguarding and increasing the actual worth of the money our shareholders have put in, and likewise the actual worth of the dividend as time goes on — those are our chief aims. And this chart also lets you see our dividend track record, demonstrating how we've moved that forward across the years. That's 56 years of dividend growth, and as a matter of fact, during the last 10 years, through ordinary dividends plus two special dividends, we've paid out GBP 460 million to our shareholders — which kind of shows that returning cash to shareholders is something we're not at all against, and we believe the fairest method for doing so is via the dividend mechanism. The company came into being on the foundation of the businesses of the Cayzer family. That history stretches back to the late 1800s, and having the Cayzer family as such a long-standing and supportive shareholder is a great piece of fortune for us. It is a total cornerstone of the investing culture in this place, and it forms a significant element of the ecosystem. So we invest for the long term, and to give you a slightly better sense of how we go about our investing: I reckon there's little that beats putting money into a company across a lengthy stretch of time.

Mat Masters

executive
#3

The problem is, well, you have to figure out which one is worth putting money into, and that's why we hold a portfolio of companies we invest in. It's even better when you're able to single out top-quality businesses and top-quality investment opportunities within those businesses, and that is exactly what Caledonia is about. It's about investing in companies. We run focused strategies, which we'll get to shortly, and those teams devote all their time to research and to building relationships, so that within those strategies we can choose from the very best opportunities that come our way. So we are highly selective when picking from what we regard as a high-quality opportunity set. We have a robust selection process. Every single pound that's invested or committed goes through a central investment committee, which I chair, staffed by the heads of the pools, the finance director and company secretary. Every investment, every pound that leaves the door is carefully thought through. Part of that is what we'd call being a responsible investor, and what everyone else is kind of calling ESG, which is that we consider just how sustainable are the things that we're investing in. Because as a long-term investor, there's a strong correlation between investing in sustainable things and developing, delivering good long-term returns.

Mat Masters

executive
#4

That has always been part of the DNA here, and it's built into how we invest. We're self-managed. We invest the money ourselves. We are fully aligned with shareholders against absolute metrics rather than relative metrics. And what does that mean? So the investment teams here are only working for our shareholders, our present shareholders. We're not raising money. We're not working for separate funds elsewhere. We're only working for Caledonia. So we have a lot of control over what they're thinking about, how the time is directed, and all the learning is shared across the business. And there's very little time from the investment team spent selling Caledonia to try and drive AUM. In fact, there's none at all, really, and we're really just focused on investing as best we can for our shareholders. And I think those ingredients are what's behind, you know, delivering a very strong performance over time. This next slide gives you a snapshot of the three different strategies. We invest in public companies, and that is 30%-40% of the net assets. We have quite a broad range for that. And that's a global portfolio, but it's mostly North America, Northern European-headquartered companies, where we're investing in companies that we understand, which are predictable and have pricing power.

Mat Masters

executive
#5

These are strong businesses, and we run two portfolios: a capital portfolio and an income portfolio. The capital portfolio has no income constraint, and our return target there is 10%; the income pool, meanwhile, targets 7%, and we seek a three and a half percent yield on cost — on cost, not on valuation — which keeps us behaving as investors in companies rather than as traders. Both portfolios are concentrated: roughly 15 companies sit in each one. So they are very well... a great deal of thought goes into those investments, and I'll walk you through one of them a bit later so you get some insight into it. We also have private capital — Tom will cover that in more detail later. This means investing directly into companies headquartered in the UK. Our aim is to hold 6 to 8 significant UK companies that we're invested in, and we partner over the longer term with management and, at times, other shareholders, to improve these businesses and grow them over time. The return target there is 14.5%, and they have a 2.5% yield on cost. You can see that, over 10 years, they've actually performed beyond the top — at the top end of their range — so we're pleased about that.

Mat Masters

executive
#6

Then there are our private equity funds, which put money behind managers with a proven track record, concentrating on North America and the low and mid-market, while also giving us appealing exposure to newer economies in Asia. That carries a target return of 12.5%, and against that target they are doing very well indeed, so all of that leaves us quite happy. On this slide you get some high-level detail on how the portfolio is split by geography and by sector. So I just want you to appreciate that even though Caledonia is constructed from the ground up — we back high-quality companies and funds — this kind of sector allocation really emerges from all of that rather than from an investment committee declaring, "We want 10% in this one, that one, or another." It is genuinely a bottom-up process, with people chasing where the quality sits. It also gives you a window into our appetite for risk and the things we favour and the things we don't. As you'll see, within financials these are mostly investments in platforms and investment managers — 7IM and Stonehage Fleming, I'd note — so we aren't taking balance sheet risk within our financials, meaning we hold no banks there, for instance.

Mat Masters

executive
#7

Moving on to energy — our exposure there is quite small. I'm a bit reluctant to make this comparison, since I don't really like measuring ourselves against an index, but for context: energy makes up 12% of the FTSE All-Share, essentially BP and Shell, and we hold neither. We aren't fans of capital-intensive companies that are cyclical, so that should give you a feel for how we invest. Next, performance. Our main focus is the net asset total return, measured against inflation. We definitely wouldn't assess it over six months, which is why we haven't shown that figure. Our real lens is three years, then five and 10, and the longer term is where our attention sits, because you have to give things time to play out. And we're glad that over that 10-year stretch we've kept net asset value ahead of inflation. People often ask about discounts and similar topics, and what I'd highlight is that across 10 years we've paid shareholders GBP 460 million in dividends. At the start of that stretch, a share in the company would have set you back GBP 18.39.

Mat Masters

executive
#8

You've received GBP 8.55 back through dividends. Over that stretch, that amounts to just under half of your money returned via dividends. I'd argue we're a long-term investment house. My encouragement to people is to invest with us for the longer term, and paying dividends plus special dividends across a longer horizon genuinely helps shareholders through this journey, as discounts shift around over time. So turning to the half year results. During the half year, we delivered 3.7%, and we're pleased that every pool contributed to that performance. I think we ought to highlight the private capital pool, where we sold 7IM, and that proved a good driver of performance for us. 7IM was sold at a 29% premium to what it was held at in our books a year ago, and at a 23% premium to the carrying value at the time. So we've got a nice uplift on the sale. Over the period, foreign exchange had little impact on returns, and today we're announcing a dividend of GBP 0.1893 per share, which is up 4% over last year. On the people side of things, we're delighted to be joined by Rob Memmott as finance director, and we'll hear more from him later on.

Mat Masters

executive
#9

We also want to send our best to Tim Livett, who I'm certain is watching, and we're looking forward to getting together with him at his leaving party. So many thanks to Tim. And fresh off the press, Caledonia was named Investment Trust of the Year in the Flexible Investment sector at the Investment Week Investment Company Awards. That makes it, I believe, the second year running that we've taken that award, I think. So naturally we're delighted with that. I'll now pass things over to Tom Leader, who'll walk us through private capital.

Tom Leader

executive
#10

Thanks, Mat. So, as mentioned, I'm Tom Leader. I head up the private capital team here, and I'll give you a somewhat deeper look at what we do. Altogether, we're a team of 11. Our strategic allocation is 25%-35% of the Caledonia balance sheet, targeting, as Mat mentioned, a 14% return, along with a reasonably well-balanced portfolio of six to eight investments of similar size. What we're after is high quality, well-established businesses centred on the UK. Our focus is the mid-market. That phrase means different things to different people, but in our case, we try to buy businesses when their profits are at GBP 7 to 10 million of EBITDA, and then take them on the journey to GBP 20 to 30. So that's the part of the mid-market where we operate, and it means we're typically putting equity to work in check sizes of roughly GBP 100 to 120 million, and we're acquiring businesses whose enterprise value is GBP 150 to 250 million. So that's the kind of deal size we concentrate on. We steer clear of turnarounds and carve-outs, and all of that sort of thing. We're a low volume investor — one, perhaps two deals per annum.

Tom Leader

executive
#11

We’re quite far from Lloyds Development Capital and the other high-volume shops. There are a few ways what we do differs from Main Street private equity. Our philosophy is buy-to-own, not buy-to-sell. As a balance sheet investor, we hold permanent capital, and we aren’t pushed by the fundraising cycle and the deployment timetables that typical PE firms work to. That, in our view, produces a far stronger level of engagement with our management teams. It isn’t that we never sell assets—of course we do—but we have a lot of flexibility to choose the moment, working alongside our management partners to optimize the exit, so we can hold things for seven, eight, nine years, and we do. I’ll come to 7IM in a moment, which is a good case in point. Our partnership approach with management shows up in two particular ways that are very different from Main Street private equity. First, we have a very high degree of economic alignment with our management teams. We don’t use loan notes, which are endemic in the private equity community, and we do use, you know, the reward of dividends, even from our private capital portfolio companies, some of which get shared with management teams.

Tom Leader

executive
#12

The second aspect is that our appetite for leverage is quite modest. You know, we'd normally employ gearing of two, three, occasionally slightly above that, times EBITDA, while Main Street private equity sits at five or six. Clearly, things are a little different right now given where interest rates stand, but our appetite for leverage is usually substantially lower than what you'd find elsewhere in the market. So that's just some background on what we're doing. At the half year, 30 September, we held a portfolio of 9 companies, 6 large ones, and 3, relatively speaking, minnows. Total NAV of just over GBP 1 billion, and the top 6 account for 95% of the value in the pool. Two major events took place during the first six months. The first, back in April, was acquiring a majority stake in AIR-serv Europe. And the second, at the start of September, was that we exchanged contracts to sell 7IM to Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan, and I'll return to that in a bit more detail. Trading across the portfolio has been reasonably solid, despite the headwinds of inflation and interest rates, and consumer confidence. And you know, after the sale of 7IM, you know, while we're roughly 36% of the group's NAV at the moment, we will drop back to the mid-20s.

Tom Leader

executive
#13

So we’re going to be somewhat underweight—not by a lot, but somewhat underweight once that deal transaction closes. As a result, over the next several years we’ll be aiming to add 1 or 2 new high-quality investments. Let me go deeper on 7IM, which is a strong illustration of what we do and how we do it. That investment was first made in 2015, and it captured, you know, all five of the critical things we typically look for when appraising a new investment. First, we want the businesses to be operating in a growing market. And at 7IM, you know, with rising U.K. household wealth, with an aging population, with a very significant advice gap in financial advice, and with all sorts of pension freedoms opening up, this was a market where there were lots of tailwinds and lots of growth opportunities to be had for agile firms. A good growing market. 7IM was very well positioned in that market. It was a pioneer in multi-manager risk profile funds, and at the heart of its intermediary offering was an award-winning tech platform that helped independent financial advisors, frankly, make their lives simpler. So it was well positioned in this growing market with a good management team—with a caveat.

Tom Leader

executive
#14

All of 7IM's founders were reaching the age of retirement, so we understood a fairly intricate succession plan had to be implemented, and doing that in an orderly fashion required multiple years. Yet a solid team — something else we prioritize — plus robust financial indicators when it comes to operating margins and cash flow generation. That, then, is item four on our checklist. And last, plenty of distinct avenues for growth. There was a chance for us to pull the organic growth lever, with considerable white space available in the market for 7IM to pursue. We completed several acquisitions — 4 here — to assist in pivoting 7IM away from being essentially a pure asset management operation toward a platform-led wealth management operation, along with ample growth CapEx opportunities, especially on the platform side. So it matched all 5 of the criteria we seek. On the chart at the bottom right, you'll notice that across our entire holding period, AUM almost trebled. We moved from slightly above GBP 7 billion to roughly GBP 21 billion by the moment we concluded that journey. So it's a terrific story. And I'm glad to report that on returns, it panned out too, yes, quite pleasingly.

Tom Leader

executive
#15

Sure, so over the course of this, we've gotten roughly GBP 44 million in dividends from 7IM. And we've handled all the turbulence of management change and integrating four acquisitions, COVID, you know, a regulatory environment which gets more complex every day. But we've pulled out nearly GBP 50 million in dividends, and our expected returns when this deal closes, which we expect to be in calendar Q1 next year, we should make an IRR of about 15% over an 8-year period, and 2.3x of our investment cost. So, and it is- it will be our single biggest cash gain at Caledonia. So a great story. Very different, I hope you will agree from what you will see from most private equity firms out there, who don't have the term flexibility that we do. Picking up some of our other investments, the other big ones, ranked pretty much in order, are Stonehage Fleming, will become our biggest operating company. We have a 35% stake, just under, in Stonehage. It's a multifamily office focused on the ultra-high net worth market. Within Stonehage, there is a big investment management business, and just to give that some scale, it's about GBP 17 billion in AUM.

Tom Leader

executive
#16

So that's roughly a third of the business when you look at revenues and profits, and the remainder consists of an array of fiduciary and family office services. We've also been growing this business through acquisitions. Over the four years during which we've held a stake in it, we've completed three acquisitions. And the main issue we're addressing right now is a planned succession of our CEO. AIR-serv is our newest investment, GBP 142.5 million invested in April this year. So we're seven months in. The key achievements have been successfully separating it from its parent, CSC ServiceWorks, which was a U.S. corporation. We've brought in a new non-exec chairman, Justin Tydeman, and I'm pleased to say that it has been trading ahead of plan every month since we bought it. So, lots of good, lots of good news there, and plenty of encouragement from lots of incremental value creation opportunities, which were outside the original investment case. So that's going very nicely. Liberation obviously, and as a sector, which has been affected by the challenges of COVID and Brexit and consumer confidence and what have you, but you know, the key focus at Liberation is on raising the standard and operating performance of the Cirrus pubs.

Tom Leader

executive
#17

At the close of last year, we acquired 21 pubs from Cirrus, brought up to the same standard we hold the rest of the group to. That's the crucial thing, the central mission for the management team here. The sector overall is clearly bouncing back. You might have noticed that Young's agreed just last week to buy City Pub Group. So animal spirits are coming back into the sector, which I think is a good sign for the future when we look to realize Liberation. Next up is Cooke. Cooke makes high-end cinematography lenses. The Hollywood strikes have hit it very hard. You'll have seen in the press that the writers' strike began at the start of May, and the actors' strike, which began at the start of July, have pretty much paralyzed film and movie production in the U.S., and in fact it's had a knock-on effect across plenty of other non-U.S. markets too. So this has weighed heavily on revenues and profits at Cooke. And the team has done a really good job managing through it, and I'm pleased to say both strikes are now finished. And in the meantime, they have actually launched a very new range of prosumer cinematography lenses, which are flying off the shelves.

Tom Leader

executive
#18

We do anticipate that Cooke will bounce back. How steep that recovery curve will be is still unclear. But Cooke carries virtually no borrowings from outside lenders, so its balance sheet is strong, and I'm confident it will come back in time. That leads us to our last major holding, which differs somewhat from the other four operating businesses. Cobepa is a private equity investment vehicle headquartered in Belgium. Because it is private, it has no stock exchange listing, unlike Caledonia. Its total NAV stands at roughly EUR 4.5 billion, and its investment portfolio contains close to 20 separate companies. Its investments are made in Europe and the U.S. It has no operations in the U.K. For us, this has been a very long-term holding. Our first investment was made back in 2004, and it has been extremely successful. As you know, it typically delivers a return of between 11% and 13% per annum and pays us a dividend. We enjoy a very close relationship with Cobepa and frequently examine deals together, investment opportunities, both in the U.S. and in Europe, including, for those who've been shareholders for a while, our very successful investment in BioAgilytix. So Cobepa is a bit different from the rest of the portfolio, but it has been an interesting and very profitable partnership over the years.

Tom Leader

executive
#19

That covers everything on my side. Now I'll pass things back to Mat, who will walk you through the quoted portfolio and what we hold in public companies.

Mat Masters

executive
#20

Thanks, Tom. Now turning to the strategy for our public companies, where our goal is to put money into high-quality businesses in which owning them over the long term is likely to pay off. I have an example coming up that will illustrate what all of that means. As I said earlier, each portfolio holds roughly 15 companies, so these are very concentrated portfolios, and that means the investment team knows the companies extremely well, and they also know their investment opportunity set incredibly well. Our culture here means we're not engaged in short-interval management of them, so things are given time to play through. I'll get to why that's all very interesting in a second. Over the six months, we had a positive return in the capital portfolio and a slightly negative return in the income portfolio. There was a little of what we call top slicing and bottom slicing of positions, so we have core holdings. When things get expensive, rating-wise, we'll sell a bit of them, and when they get cheaper, rating-wise, we'll buy a bit of them, and that just augments returns over time, and it also instills a sort of value-oriented investment discipline within the team, which I think is very healthy. We added one new position in RELX, which is an information and analytics business, UK-listed business, and increased our holding in a couple of other positions.

Mat Masters

executive
#21

Take Oracle as the example — we put money into it in 2014, and that was actually the period when I was running the portfolio. So I ought to know a fair amount about it, though please don't quiz me too hard. We bought in at $40 in 2014, and once we'd worked through the analysis, what we found was a very persistent level of profit at Oracle. We spent time with the company and came to know it well, and we could see that the recurring level of profit was in fact considerably higher than the recurring level of revenue, which made it an incredibly stable cashflow. But it had gotten tangled up in the legacy tech story — had they missed the boat on cloud and SaaS, that sort of narrative — and so the rating was quite cheap, and so we got in at, the way we framed it, roughly a 7% sort of yield on the earnings. Not dividend yield — just on the earnings. So we felt we'd got into a really good, stable company at a good price, with an amazing position, a potential position, in cloud and SaaS, which they were telling people about, but it was very early days, and so nobody was rewarding them for it, rating-wise.

Mat Masters

executive
#22

And you know, for a long stretch it didn't really do much for us, because you've gone from 2014 to 2017 and the share price has barely budged. That's okay, though, since we're tracking the company's fundamentals. On a fundamental basis, we're quite pleased with how it's performing; we're not concerned about the share price, and we could see progress being made, so we felt completely at ease with that journey. Then, as time went on and the cloud and SaaS portions of the business grew more prominent — and, to be fair, the company got a bit better at communicating that to people — folks could see the benefits of it, and profit and cash flow increased, and the share price has performed magnificently. And so far it's delivered a 16% annualized return for us across a long stretch, nearly 10 years. The extra upside was that over the last 10 years they repurchased — Oracle, an S&P 500 company, a massive company — repurchased half of its shares, and that sort of supercharged the company's progress through to the share price. We were fairly confident that would occur, because when a large shareholder in a company tells you what they intend to do, then, you know, it's worth paying attention to them.

Mat Masters

executive
#23

So we entered a business that was stable, one we believed we could value accurately, and we could allow it time for both the investment thesis and the value thesis to unfold. We were extremely pleased with that one, and it simply illustrates how we approach investing in the capital portfolio as well as the income portfolio at Caledonia. The share price lately went, as I believe people say, parabolic — meaning it shoots up — because they've succeeded in capitalizing on artificial intelligence. We sold a handful of shares since it became quite expensive, or the rating rose, and it grew fairly large within the portfolio. As a matter of risk management and, you might say, good housekeeping, we trimmed part of our holding, though we continue to keep our core position in it. Turning to our private equity funds. As I said earlier, we're putting money behind proven managers across North America and Asia. Now, in contrast to our other strategies, this contains a great many companies. It's highly fragmented. So there are 600 companies in what amounts to the underlying exposure here, and that excludes the investments in the fund of funds portfolio, which is more difficult to tally.

Mat Masters

executive
#24

There are a lot of companies in the portfolio, so idiosyncratic risk is quite low. Slightly below 60% of net assets sit in the U.S. lower mid-market, and I'll walk through an example shortly that makes this concrete. These North American lower mid-market funds usually come in at around $500 million as limited partner LP funds. Typically — though not always — we are the sole European investor or limited partner in them, which means they're hard to reach from the U.K. We also serve on the advisory board, giving us a close relationship with 80% of these funds. That access and exposure is something we're very lucky to have, and it has shown itself to be a strong asset class. I'll give you an example of that in a moment. Our Asian portfolio accounts for 48%. Within Asia, it's roughly a 50/50 split between buyout-style private equity on one side and growth and venture capital on the other, concentrated on the new economy — growth areas like healthcare, consumer, and technology. In both regions we are extremely selective. Each market offers a large, visible opportunity set that we can readily choose from. In North America, for instance, the aim is typically to identify two new funds for investment annually, and then they generally re-up with two existing funds every year.

Mat Masters

executive
#25

A fair amount of time goes into doing research and working out what to do, and after that we simply choose which ones we'll act on. Across the six months, this approach delivered a 4.6% return for us. In local terms, North America accounted for 4%, while Asia was softer at 1%. As you can see, distributions have come down relative to the last few years. Both markets are experiencing some of that, which reflects the liquidity issues they're facing right now. But we're clearly very close to those markets, and we're being told, particularly in North America, that the managers there can see things improving. So here's an example that helps bring it to life. It's an American lower mid-market company by the name of CenterOak. We've put money into two of their funds, fund one and fund two, and we've committed $30 million to each of those funds. U.S. lower mid-market is a core part of the investment strategy. We'd been watching the CenterOak team for a little while. They worked together at a previous house for 15 years, and then they departed that house to establish CenterOak. So this is a well-established team with a good track record behind them.

Mat Masters

executive
#26

This wasn't a situation where a fund was starting completely from scratch, then. And we appreciated the fact that Randall Fojtasek was the one leading the team. He was an intriguing person. He'd served as CEO of a family business that had passed through a couple of private equity owners, and after that he set up a private equity house of his own. So he'd built a track record as an investor too. So here's a great illustration of a great businessman turning into a great investor, and so we were delighted to get the chance to back him along with his colleagues, whom we hold in high regard. And as I said, they've been working together for a long time. They have what the Americans call a playbook of operational and strategic improvement, which they apply to smaller companies. They make those companies more efficient. They make them more capable, so they can do more. They do bolt-ons. You'll see in a minute that they add quite a few companies to each of the businesses. And then there's this enormous home market in America for these companies to grow into. So let's look at some of their holdings.

Mat Masters

executive
#27

These are just standard businesses, right—plumbing, collision repair, lawn care, pest control. What they'd do is acquire smaller companies as a starting platform, then complete a number of add-ons to those, and you can see the kinds of figures there. In America, that's an extremely potent model. It performs really well. The approach is about partnering to enhance and expand these small enterprises within this enormous domestic market, and then capitalizing on that, and everything is essentially set up for it. So it's a solid model for producing returns. It doesn't depend on debt. Debt does get used, but it's not—they aren't pushing it to the maximum. The focus is more on operational enhancement, sharpening the strategy, and bettering the way these companies are operated, and then selling them on. And with that, I'll pass things over to Rob, who will walk you through the financial review.

Rob Memmott

executive
#28

Thank you, Mat. Good morning, everyone. Before I walk you through the figures, I wanted to share a few reasons why I decided to join Caledonia. First, there's the track record. Caledonia has produced excellent returns for shareholders: 56 years of dividend growth, GBP 460 million given back to shareholders across the past 10 years through both ordinary and special dividends. Annualized NAV growth over that same 10-year stretch came in at 11%. Second, the people and the culture — transparent and non-hierarchical, with an exceptionally skilled and capable team, something that has been reaffirmed for me every day since I arrived. What I especially appreciate is that the team and the people stay focused on the existing balance sheet and on future opportunities, rather than being distracted by any need to raise fresh funds. Then there's the long-term investment philosophy, centered on operating cash flows and business improvement with modest levels of leverage. Caledonia develops a deep understanding of the companies and the funds in which we invest, building strong relationships, and that is what underpins the investment discipline when we assess new opportunities and manage the existing portfolio. Fourth is a robust balance sheet. Capital gets allocated centrally, investing across a diverse range of quality businesses and funds.

Rob Memmott

executive
#29

When it comes to valuing assets, we take a careful stance. I'll get to that shortly. At the Caledonia balance sheet level, there is no structural debt, and we hold a healthy amount of liquidity, which lets us put money to work when we choose to pursue quality investments. So I'm very pleased to be joining Mat and the rest of the team to help drive long-term shareholder value. Now, IR has been one of my main areas of focus up to this point, making sure our investment proposition is properly understood and also rated by the market. And hopefully, in the presentation you've seen some increased disclosure and found some of the case studies informative about how we do what we do at Caledonia. We'll keep including this in future releases as we go forward. So on to the numbers, which is what you've all been waiting for. NAV at the end of the six-month period, so thirtieth of September, has grown to GBP 2.9 billion, generating a total return of 3.7%. We're 100% invested in a diversified portfolio of listed, privately held companies, private equity funds that have global reach. And as I said, we have zero structural leverage at the balance sheet level. The portfolio has delivered 4.1% return, and this compares favorably to the FTSE All-Share, which was 1.4% over the same period.

Rob Memmott

executive
#30

So, as Tom walked everyone through, we recently reached an agreement to sell 7IM. When you add that to the facilities we already have in place, it comes to GBP 485 million in pro forma liquidity. Then there's our interim dividend — we've announced an increase of 4%, taking it to 18.93p. That works out to GBP 10.3 million, and it gets paid to shareholders on the fourth of January, which happens to be my birthday. So that's an important date to put in the diary. You'll notice over the next few slides that I really do enjoy a waterfall chart and a bridge, so I'm going to walk you through three of them. The first shows how the portfolio moved. If you begin on the left-hand side, at the start of the period, it stood at £2.5 billion, with net cash invested into the portfolio of £223 million — that includes £143 million going into AIR-serv, as Tom mentioned, within the portfolio in the private capital pool. Then £50 million in net inflows, or investments, into the funds pool, plus £60 million into the public companies, which took in that new position in RELX. We received cash yield from investments of £23 during the period, and then a total return of £120. That's 4.1%, and it includes £51 million pounds worth of uplift following the sale — the agreed sale — of 7IM, and then a little bit of FX, £18 million.

Rob Memmott

executive
#31

Over on the right-hand side, that small pie chart illustrates how the assets break down. Private capital sits at just above GBP 1 billion. That represents 36%. It's a touch above where we want it strategically. As Tom mentioned, that will come down once 7IM closes in the early part of the new year. Since coming into the business, I've devoted a fair amount of time to reviewing how we value the portfolio, particularly the private capital holdings. We adhere to the IPEV guidelines. As a result, we carry these at fair value. These assets generate cash and are conservatively levered. Valuation multiples generally fall in the 9%-14% range, a bit lower than in earlier periods, and on the whole, I'm at ease that we sit toward the cautious end of the valuation range. The evidence for that is really the 7IM sale, which gave us a GBP 51 million uplift to carrying value immediately prior to disposal. In the table at the bottom right of the slide, you can see returns and yields broken out by pool. In total, 4.1% return, 3.5% yield, and every one of the pools added positively. The following small chart covers total net assets. Starting on the left, GBP 2.8 billion at the beginning of the period, net investment gains of GBP 120 million, and management expenses of GBP 17 million.

Rob Memmott

executive
#32

So that brings us to GBP 2.9 billion, and then the dividend was paid last — the prior year's final dividend — which takes us back to just under GBP 2.9 billion. The pie chart on the right-hand side breaks down our net assets by currency. Heavily weighted at 51% to the US dollar and 39% sterling, so movements in the sterling-dollar exchange rate are going to have an impact on our in-year results. In the period, GBP 18 million benefit. Net cash at the start of the period was GBP 222 million, and we've effectively net invested the whole lot during this period — GBP 223 million net invested. There's a cash yield coming from the assets of GBP 23 million, management expenses, and a little bit of working capital in that number too of GBP 15 million, and then dividends paid, and that takes us to GBP 20 million of net debt at the end of the period. At the end of September, we had cash on balance sheet of GBP 15 million within that GBP 20 million, an undrawn revolving credit facility of GBP 215 million, and we expect to receive in early 2024 calendar GBP 255 million from 7IM, meaning we've got pro forma liquidity of GBP 485 million, and this gives us the capital to invest in new assets and act quickly to invest in attractive opportunities that meet our criteria.

Rob Memmott

executive
#33

Turning to share price performance. If you look at the charts covering 3, 5, and 10 years, it's clear that performance compares well with the FTSE All-Share total return. Over the 6 months, the discount has gone from 32.8% to 35.4%. I suppose if someone joined the organization and considered that discount — you know, it gets described as a liquidity discount — and when you consider the pools that made up the organization's assets, the public companies where we invest, that pool gets marked to market every single day. Then you think, well, we've agreed the sale of 7IM for GBP 255 million. So putting those two together, we have GBP 1.1 billion of net asset value, which is currently marked to market within the balance sheet. And so the private company assets are effectively trading at a 60% discount, which to me seems pretty excessive, particularly given, as I said in my earlier comment, that on valuation we're towards the conservative end of the range. I suppose one of the areas we've been thinking about is the IR project, which I've spoken about, and that's very much about making sure Caledonia is understood by the market and that it's rated by the market.

Rob Memmott

executive
#34

Beyond that, we’re working closely with our broker advisors to broaden the shareholder register, with the goal of bringing in more marginal buyers. So, to sum up, Caledonia has assembled a diverse portfolio that is well positioned to deliver returns over the long term. We put money into quality businesses that focus on free cashflow, which means the portfolio is very much able to meet the challenges currently posed by the macro.

Tom Leader

executive
#35

Our balance sheet is strong, with assets carried at the cautious end of the range, and pro forma liquidity of GBP 485 million, which gives us the firepower to act and invest in an attractive asset should we wish to. The seasoned team is 100% dedicated to continuing to invest in and manage the portfolio of high-quality companies and private equity funds. Thank you. We'll now take some questions. At first, we'll take them from the room, and after that we'll go remotely, and Richard will help deliver those to us. Laura, I believe, has a microphone, so if you'd like to ask a question, please raise your hand, and Mat will join me up here to cover those. So, any questions?

Analyst

analyst
#36

Hi there. Regarding the 7IM sale, I was just wondering what the sort of trigger point was for the sale and the reassessment of that? The trigger point for the sale on 7IM, what—

Tom Leader

executive
#37

Let me just confirm that I've got your question right. First, the conditionality around the 7IM sale is only FCA approval of the change of control. That process is now underway. As for why we sold it — well, financial services is a highly fragmented space. 7IM had completed four acquisitions. There are lots of further opportunities for 7IM to grow through acquisition and put considerably more capital to work. And we felt the timing was right, and so did the team, to hand the baton to a larger investor with more resources. OTPP has NAV of more than CAD 250 billion, so a balance sheet that's much, much bigger than ours. And they have a highly ambitious team who intend to tap into that.

Analyst

analyst
#38

Appreciate it.

Analyst

analyst
#39

Mat, could you give us a bit more color on the Asian VC exposure? What's the size of it, and which parts of the VC market are you exposed to?

Mat Masters

executive
#40

Sure, Alan — thanks for asking. The Asian portfolio makes up roughly 14% of Caledonia's NAV. Within that 14%, we'd describe around half as buyout. So PAG, a fairly large buyout firm, is one of the funds in that portion of the portfolio. You're backing businesses generating billions of dollars in revenue and hundreds of millions in EBITDA — so buyout-style opportunities. The remaining half sits in growth and more venture-oriented investments, though not at the very earliest venture stage. That part concentrates on newer, expanding sectors: healthcare, technology, and consumer. So that's essentially the buyout versus venture breakdown. Of that 14%, about half is deployed in China, while the rest is spread more broadly across Asia. That gives you a sense of the geographic mix. Does that answer your question?

Analyst

analyst
#41

Yes, thank you.

Tom Leader

executive
#42

Richard, would you like to take it from here?

Richard Webster

executive
#43

Yeah. So, first question: are you looking at any steps to narrow that discount we're seeing right now?

Mat Masters

executive
#44

On the discount question — yeah, so I think the first thing regarding the discount is sticking to the knitting of focusing on investing well, so that we can grow, keep growing, net asset value and dividends and, and keeping the real value of those, moving over time. So that's the primary focus of the organization. I think we've recognized that we can do a little more with investor relations activity, which Rob has talked about, and being, as I term it, a better partner to the secondary market. We're not looking to do any primary issuance at Caledonia, but we could help the secondary market understand us better and perhaps find a few more shareholders who are more who can help with the discount through that process. And also, you know, we do have this track record of giving shareholders money back through dividends over time, and reminding people about that.

Richard Webster

executive
#45

Thanks. And regarding the equity interest in Stonehage Fleming, this may be one for Tom. Are you comfortable keeping minority positions in privately held businesses?

Tom Leader

executive
#46

Sure, we have the flexibility to structure investments across both minority and majority stakes. Stonehage Fleming is hardly the only minority position we hold. We clearly have stakes in Cobepa, in Bloom, and in SIS, and a couple of our smaller investments are all minority positions. So we do operate in both control and non-control investments, and in fact, we always have.

Richard Webster

executive
#47

Thanks. And then we have a couple of questions that are similar in nature, about how the proceeds from 7IM might be deployed.

Mat Masters

executive
#48

The cash returns to Bank of Caledonia and stays there, and we don't always alter how fast we invest or operate. We'll simply watch for whatever the next strongest opportunity turns out to be, whether that's in private capital, in secondaries somewhere, or in listed markets offering us a chance.

Richard Webster

executive
#49

When it comes to the public equity holdings, is there a typical range of multiples that we look at, or when we're looking to trim or add to those holdings?

Mat Masters

executive
#50

I guess my answer to that would be that since we tend to invest in highly predictable businesses, their rating histories are also pretty predictable or consistent. So by putting in the work — and there's a great deal of work involved — we're able to look back and see when prices are high and when they're lower relative to each company's own rating track record. What we're doing here is all about purchasing a strong business at a sensible price. And we'll adjust that for where interest rates stand. So if rates are elevated, that will shape how that river operates for us, and we'll factor that in. So when prices sit toward the bottom of what we call the Rating River, we'll consider adding, and when they're toward the top, and they're large relative to their risk profile in the portfolio, we'll go ahead and sell, sell, sell a portion of it. That's the method we use to determine whether something is expensive or cheap.

Richard Webster

executive
#51

Thanks. That wraps up the Q&A.

Tom Leader

executive
#52

All right, thanks. And thank you all for those questions. Appreciate everyone joining, and we'll see you at the full year.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Caledonia Investments Plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Caledonia Investments Plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Caledonia Investments Plc or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.